PMC20201221pmc.key4888278CC BYno0010.1186/s12900-016-0059-3488827827246200597RORγ Agonist Inverse Agonist Activation Function 2 Helix (AF2) TH17cells IL-17 Autoimmune Disease
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.surname:Marcotte;given-names:Douglas J.surname:Liu;given-names:YuTingsurname:Little;given-names:Kevinsurname:Jones;given-names:John H.surname:Powell;given-names:Noel A.surname:Wildes;given-names:Craig P.surname:Silvian;given-names:Laura F.surname:Chodaparambil;given-names:Jayanth V.TITLEKeywordsfront1620160Structural determinant for inducing RORgamma specific inverse agonism triggered by a synthetic benzoxazinone ligand0.9996841proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:51ZPR:RORgamma0.9997347chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinoneABSTRACTabstract_title_1116BackgroundABSTRACTabstract127The nuclear hormone receptor RORγ regulates transcriptional genes involved in the production of the pro-inflammatory interleukin IL-17 which has been linked to autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis and inflammatory bowel disease. This transcriptional activity of RORγ is modulated through a protein-protein interaction involving the activation function 2 (AF2) helix on the ligand binding domain of RORγ and a conserved LXXLL helix motif on coactivator proteins. Our goal was to develop a RORγ specific inverse agonist that would help down regulate pro-inflammatory gene transcription by disrupting the protein protein interaction with coactivator proteins as a therapeutic agent.0.9994586protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:12:34ZMESH:nuclear hormone receptor0.9995332proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:44ZPR:RORγprotein_typeMESH:cleaner02023-07-19T15:55:50Zinterleukinprotein_typeMESH:cleaner02023-07-19T15:55:24ZIL-170.99969506proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγstructure_elementSO:cleaner02023-07-19T15:13:36Zactivation function 2 (AF2) helix0.9996891structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:07ZSO:ligand binding domain0.9997353proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9995486protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:59:12ZDUMMY:conserved0.99966925structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:54:48ZSO:LXXLL helix motif0.99968076proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonistABSTRACTabstract_title_1855ResultsABSTRACTabstract863We identified a novel series of synthetic benzoxazinone ligands having an agonist (BIO592) and inverse agonist (BIO399) mode of action in a FRET based assay. We show that the AF2 helix of RORγ is proteolytically sensitive when inverse agonist BIO399 binds. Using x-ray crystallography we show how small modifications on the benzoxazinone agonist BIO592 trigger inverse agonism of RORγ. Using an in vivo reporter assay, we show that the inverse agonist BIO399 displayed specificity for RORγ over ROR sub-family members α and β.0.99951196chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:55ZCHEBI:benzoxazinoneprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9995297chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9994516chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:08ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9995902experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:47ZMESH:FRET based assay0.9997276structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:25ZSO:AF2 helix0.99978596proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.7023409protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:59:28ZDUMMY:proteolytically sensitiveprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9991371chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9995466experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:51ZMESH:x-ray crystallography0.9994616chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinoneprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9995976chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.99979097proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9995693experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:56ZMESH:in vivo reporter assayprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99939096chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9997814proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99713814protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZMESH:ROR0.99299026proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:12ZPR:α0.9972766proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:15ZPR:βABSTRACTabstract_title_11409ConclusionABSTRACTabstract1420The synthetic benzoxazinone ligands identified in our FRET assay have an agonist (BIO592) or inverse agonist (BIO399) effect by stabilizing or destabilizing the agonist conformation of RORγ. The proteolytic sensitivity of the AF2 helix of RORγ demonstrates that it destabilizes upon BIO399 inverse agonist binding perturbing the coactivator protein binding site. Our structural investigation of the BIO592 agonist and BIO399 inverse agonist structures identified residue Met358 on RORγ as the trigger for RORγ specific inverse agonism.0.9997489chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.99962234experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:15:18ZMESH:FRET assayprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.999524chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9993519chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9997969proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9997283structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99979514proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9988256chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99966204sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:15:29ZSO:coactivator protein binding site0.9996029experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:15:07ZMESH:structural investigation0.99946314chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9992617chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9992576evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:19ZDUMMY:structures0.9998889residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9997987proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99973875proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγABSTRACTabstract_title_11972Electronic supplementary materialABSTRACTabstract2006The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12900-016-0059-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.INTROtitle_12146BackgroundINTROparagraph2157Retinoid-related orphan receptor gamma (RORγ) is a transcription factor belonging to a sub-family of nuclear receptors that includes two closely related members RORα and RORβ. Even though a high degree of sequence similarity exists between the RORs, their functional roles in regulation for physiological processes involved in development and immunity are distinct. During development, RORγ regulates the transcriptional genes involved in the functioning of multiple pro-inflammatory lymphocyte lineages including T helper cells (TH17cells) which are necessary for IL-17 production. IL-17 is a pro-inflammatory interleukin linked to autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis and inflammatory bowel disease; making its transcriptional regulation through RORγ an attractive therapeutic target.proteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:15:55ZRetinoid-related orphan receptor gamma0.99976176proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.96197236protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:16:22ZMESH:transcription factor0.9992901protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:16:28ZMESH:nuclear receptors0.9998398proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:01ZPR:RORα0.99984014proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:06ZPR:RORβ0.99961334protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:16:33ZMESH:RORs0.99953103proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9956913protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:55:24ZMESH:IL-170.99601126protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:55:24ZMESH:IL-17protein_typeMESH:cleaner02023-07-19T15:55:50Zinterleukin0.9997352proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγINTROparagraph2995RORγ consists of an N-terminal DNA binding domain (DBD) connected to a C-terminal ligand binding domain (LBD) via a flexible hinge region. The DBD is composed of two zinc fingers that allow it to interact with specifically encoded regions on the DNA called the nuclear receptor response elements. The LBD consists of a coactivator protein binding pocket and a hydrophobic ligand binding site (LBS) which are responsible for regulating transcription. The coactivator binding pocket of RORγ recognizes a conserved helix motif LXXLL (where X can be any amino acid) on transcriptional coactivator complexes and recruits it to activate transcription. Like other nuclear hormone receptors, RORγ’s helix12 which makes up the C-termini of the LBD is an essential part of the coactivator binding pocket and is commonly referred to as the activation function helix 2 (AF2). In RORγ, the conformation of the AF2 helix required to form the coactivator binding pocket is mediated by a salt bridge between His479 and Tyr502 in addition to π- π interactions between Tyr502 and Phe506. The conformation of the AF2 helix can be modulated through targeted ligands which bind the LBS and increase the binding of the coactivator protein (agonists) or disrupt binding (inverse agonists) thereby enhancing or inhibiting transcription. Since RORγ has been demonstrated to play an important role in pro-inflammatory gene expression patterns implicated in several major autoimmune diseases, our aim was to develop RORγ inverse agonists that would help down regulate pro-inflammatory gene transcription.0.9995522proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99970484structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:16:52ZSO:DNA binding domain0.9998134structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:16:57ZSO:DBD0.999716structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:08ZSO:ligand binding domain0.9998136structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:06ZSO:LBD0.9997424structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:15ZSO:hinge region0.9998217structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:16:57ZSO:DBD0.99940574structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:20ZSO:zinc fingersstructure_elementSO:cleaner02023-07-19T15:17:55Znuclear receptor response elements0.99982005structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:06ZSO:LBD0.9995779sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:17:29ZSO:coactivator protein binding pocket0.99728817sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:04ZSO:hydrophobic ligand binding site0.97560805sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.9996037sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:21ZSO:coactivator binding pocket0.99960774proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9993538protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:23ZDUMMY:conservedstructure_elementSO:cleaner02023-07-19T15:58:57Zhelix motif LXXLL0.99955034protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:38ZMESH:nuclear hormone receptors0.99942905proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9998221structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:18:45ZSO:helix120.99983406structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:06ZSO:LBD0.9996125sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:21ZSO:coactivator binding pocket0.9996948structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:18:49ZSO:activation function helix 20.99982625structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:18:51ZSO:AF20.9995863proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99973696structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99961215sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:21ZSO:coactivator binding pocketbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zsalt bridge0.9999027residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.99989915residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:56ZDUMMY:Tyr502bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zπ- π interactions0.99990165residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:56ZDUMMY:Tyr5020.99990034residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:19:01ZDUMMY:Phe5060.9997456structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99979895sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.9995858proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9994648proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ12900_2016_59_Fig1_HTML.jpgFig1FIGfig_caption4599FRET results for agonist BIO592 (a) and Inverse Agonist BIO399 (b)evidenceDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:20:05ZFRET resultsprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9992667chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20ZInverse Agonist0.99943894chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399INTROparagraph4666Here we present the identification of two synthetic benzoxazinone RORγ ligands, a weak agonist BIO592 (Fig. 1a) and an inverse agonist BIO399 (Fig. 1b) which were identified using a Fluorescence Resonance Energy transfer (FRET) based assay that monitored coactivator peptide recruitment. Using partial proteolysis in combination with mass spectrometry analysis we demonstrate that the AF2 helix of RORγ destabilizes upon BIO399 (inverse agonist) binding. Finally, comparing binding modes of our benzoxazinone RORγ crystal structures to other ROR structures, we hypothesize a new mode of action for achieving inverse agonism and selectivity.0.9993067chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.99667335proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9994783chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99941254chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399experimental_methodMESH:cleaner02023-07-19T15:19:33ZFluorescence Resonance Energy transfer (FRET) based assay0.99953055experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:19:44ZMESH:partial proteolysis0.99952245experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:19:46ZMESH:mass spectrometry0.9997479structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.999608proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9987185chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9855926evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:30ZDUMMY:binding modes0.99849415chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.99864763proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99943864evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:34ZDUMMY:crystal structures0.99912757protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZMESH:ROR0.9982961evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:20:17ZDUMMY:structuresMETHODStitle_15319MethodsMETHODStitle_25327Cloning, protein expression and purification of RORγ518METHODSparagraph5387GST-RORγ518 was constructed by sub-cloning residues 259 to 518 of a human RORγ cDNA into a pGEX-6P vector with a cleavable N-terminal GST fusion tag. BL21 (DE3) Escherichia coli cells were transformed with the plasmid encoding the GST-PreScission-hRORgamma 259–518 protein (GST-RORγ518) and were grown at 37 °C in LB media supplemented with ampicillin to an OD of 1. The temperature was reduced to 18 °C and protein expression was induced by adding 1 mM IPTG and was shaking for an additional 16 h. The cells were harvested and resuspended in lysis buffer (25 mM TRIS pH 8.0, 250 mM NaCl, 10 % Glycerol, 5 mM DTT and Roche EDTA-free protease inhibitor cocktail) and were lysed using a microfluidizer. The lysate was clarified by centrifugation at 20,000 × g for 1 h at 4 °C and GST-RORγ518 was captured by batch binding to Glutathione Sepharose resin overnight at 4 °C. The resin was washed with buffer A (25 mM TRIS pH 8.0, 250 mM NaCl, 10 % glycerol, 5 mM DTT) and loaded onto a XK column and washed until no non-specific unbound protein was detected. GST- RORγ518 was eluted from the column using buffer A supplemented with 10 mM Glutathione pH 8.0 and analyzed by SDS-PAGE. The eluate was then treated with PreScission Protease (10units/mg of protein) and further purified on a Superdex 75 column equilibrated in buffer B (25 mM TRIS pH 8.0, 250 mM NaCl, 5 % glycerol and 2 mM DTT). RORγ518 eluted as a monomer and was approximately 95 % pure as observed by SDS-PAGE.METHODSparagraph6901Additional constructs including c-terminal truncations, surface entropy reduction and cysteine scrubbed mutations were also expressed and purified in the same manner as RORγ518 if an expression level of >1 mg/L was achieved.METHODStitle_27130RORγ FRET based assay and GAL4 reporter assayMETHODSparagraph7180FRET-based (Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer) assay and the GAL4 Reporter assay were performed as described previously. BIO592 and BIO399 were synthesized (Additional file 1) and belonged to a proprietary library where they were identified as RORγ activity modulators using the FRET-based assay.METHODStitle_27486Partial proteolysis of RORγ518METHODSparagraph7521RORγ518 at 8 mg/ml or in complex with 1 mM BIO399 or 1 mM BIO592 and 0.5 mM coactivator peptide EBI96 EFPYLLSLLGEVSPQ (New England Peptide) were treated with Actinase E (Hampton Research) added at a ratio of 1.25ugs of protease/1 mg of RORγ518 for 6 h at 4 °C. The reactions were quenched using 1X Protease inhibitor cocktail (Roche) + 1 mM EDTA and subjected to mass spectrometry analysis.METHODStitle_27927Mass spectrometry of partially proteolyzed RORγ518METHODSparagraph7982Proteolyzed RORγ518 samples were reduced with 50 mM dithiothreitol in 50 mM Tris pH 8.0, 150 mM NaCl containing 4 M urea and 5 mM EDTA. The sample was then analyzed on a LC-MS system comprised of a UPLC (ACQUITY, Waters Corp.), a TUV dual-wavelength UV detector (Waters Corp.), and a ZQ mass spectrometer (Waters Corp.). A Vydac C4 cartridge was used for desalting. Molecular masses for the Actinase E treated RORγ518 samples were obtained by deconvoluting the raw mass spectra using MaxLynx 4.1 software (Waters Corp.).METHODStitle_28511Crystallization of RORγ518 with agonist BIO592 and inverse agonist BIO399METHODSparagraph8589RORγ518 was concentrated to 8 mg/ml and EBI96 was added to a final concentration of 0.5 mM and agonist BIO592 to 1 mM and incubated on ice for 1 h. The coactivator peptide EBI96 which was identified by phage display was chosen for crystallization because of its strong interaction with RORγ in a mammalian two-hybrid analysis system that assessed the transactivation of RORγ. Diffraction quality crystals were grown through vapor diffusion in a buffer containing 0.1 M HEPES pH 8.0, 25 % PEG3350 and 0.2 M NaCl at 18 °C. Crystals were cryoprotected in the mother liquor containing 20 % glycerol as cryoprotectant prior to being frozen in liquid nitrogen for data collection.METHODSparagraph9278Actinase E proteolyzed RORγ518 BIO399 concentrated to 8 mg/ml was crystallized using vapor diffusion in a buffer containing 0.1 M BisTRIS pH 5.5, 0.2 M ammonium acetate and 15 % PEG3350 at 18 °C. Crystals were cryoprotected for data collection by transferring them to a mother liquor containing 15 % PEG400 prior to being frozen in liquid nitrogen.METHODStitle_29636Data collection and structure determination for RORγ518 BIO592 and BIO399 complexesMETHODSparagraph9724X-ray diffraction data for all the crystals were measured at beam line ID31 at the Argonne Photon Source. The data were processed with Mosflm in case of the RORγ518-BIO592-EBI96 ternary complex and with HKL2000 in the case of the Actinase E treated aeRORγ518/BIO399 complex. For both datasets, PDB ID: 3LOL was used as the search model, and the molecular replacement solutions were determined using MOLREP. The refinement was carried out using Refmac5 and model building was carried out in Coot. The data processing and refinement statistics are provided in Additional file 2.METHODSparagraph10309RORγ518-BIO592-EBI96 ternary complex:METHODSparagraph10351The data for the ternary complex were measured to 2.63 Å. It crystallized in a P21 space group with four molecules of the ternary complex in the asymmetric unit. The final model was refined to a Rcryst of 19.9 % and Rfree of 25.5 %.METHODSparagraph10588aeRORγ518/BIO399 complex:METHODSparagraph10618Diffraction data for the aeRORγ518-BIO399 complex were measured to 2.35 Å. It crystallized in C2 space group with two molecules in the asymmetric unit. The final model was refined to a Rcryst of 21.1 % and Rfree of 26.3 %.RESULTStitle_110846Results and discussionRESULTStitle_210869Identification of BIO592 and BIO399 as ligands that modulate RORγ coactivator peptide recruitmentRESULTSparagraph10971Using a FRET based assay we discovered agonist BIO592 (Fig. 1a) which increased the coactivator peptide TRAP220 recruitment to RORγ (EC50 0f 58nM and Emax of 130 %) and a potent inverse agonist BIO399 (Fig. 1b) which inhibited coactivator recruitment (IC50: 4.7nM). Interestingly, the structural difference between the agonist BIO592 and inverse agonist BIO399 was minor; with the 2,3-dihydrobenzo[1,4]oxazepin-4-one ring system of BIO399 being 3 atoms larger than the benzo[1,4]oxazine-3-one ring system of BIO592. In order to understand how small changes in the core ring system leads to inverse agonism, we wanted to structurally determine the binding mode of both BIO592 and BIO399 in the LBS of RORγ using x-ray crystallography.0.99959534experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:47ZMESH:FRET based assayprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9988141chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.48274022chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T16:06:11ZCHEBI:TRAP2200.99982065proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99535024evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:20:56ZDUMMY:EC500.9963708evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:21:01ZDUMMY:Emaxprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9961767chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9992803evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:45ZDUMMY:IC50protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9986708chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9949522chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9993613chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:21:29ZCHEBI:2,3-dihydrobenzo[1,4]oxazepin-4-one0.9886368chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99949chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:21:40ZCHEBI:benzo[1,4]oxazine-3-one0.9971795chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9968554chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9926582chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9996377sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.99981266proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99956167experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:52ZMESH:x-ray crystallographyRESULTStitle_211713Structure of the RORγ518-BIO592-EBI96 ternary complex is in a transcriptionally active conformation0.71792406evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:51ZDUMMY:Structure0.9997385complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:21:15ZGO:RORγ518-BIO592-EBI960.6499308protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:21:52ZDUMMY:active12900_2016_59_Fig2_HTML.jpgFig2FIGfig_caption11817
a The ternary structure of RORγ518 BIO592 and EBI96. b RORγ AF2 helix in the agonist conformation. c EBI96 coactivator peptide bound in the coactivator pocket of RORγ0.88747376evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:50:58ZDUMMY:ternary structure0.99852496proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.97716755chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.99978215chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:28ZCHEBI:EBI960.9997538proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99961114structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helixprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9998048chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:28ZCHEBI:EBI96protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:24:07Zbound in0.9995923sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:23:47ZSO:coactivator pocket0.9994972proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγRESULTSparagraph11997RORγ518 bound to agonist BIO592 was crystallized with a truncated form of the coactivator peptide EBI96 to a resolution of 2.6 Å (Fig. 2a). The structure of the ternary complex had features similar to other ROR agonist coactivator structures in a transcriptionally active canonical three layer helix fold with the AF2 helix in the agonist conformation. The agonist conformation is stabilized by a hydrogen bond between His479 and Tyr502, in addition to π-π interactions between His479, Tyr502 and Phe506 (Fig. 2b). The hydrogen bond between His479 and Tyr502 has been reported to be critical for RORγ agonist activity. Disrupting this interaction through mutagenesis reduced transcriptional activity of RORγ. This reduced transcriptional activity has been attributed to the inability of the AF2 helix to complete the formation of the coactivator binding pocket necessary for coactivator proteins to bind.0.9997739proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.9995284protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:24:12ZDUMMY:bound toprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99953663chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9996308experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:52:21ZMESH:crystallized0.9987739protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:29ZDUMMY:truncated0.96395886chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:27ZCHEBI:EBI960.9991172evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:51:05ZDUMMY:structure0.99873656protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZMESH:RORprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9898212evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:51:13ZDUMMY:structures0.99713844protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:25:01ZDUMMY:transcriptionally active0.99960726protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:25:14ZDUMMY:canonical three layer helix fold0.9997512structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9995945protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:34ZDUMMY:agonist0.9995764protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:38ZDUMMY:agonistbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bond0.99990356residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.9998977residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr502bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zπ-π interactions0.99989974residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.9998951residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr5020.9998956residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:19:02ZDUMMY:Phe506bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bond0.99989986residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.99989367residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr5020.83831507proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9996239experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:25:38ZMESH:mutagenesis0.99961555proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99976134structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99962956sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:21ZSO:coactivator binding pocketRESULTSparagraph12916Electron density for the coactivator peptide EBI96 was observed for residues EFPYLLSLLG which formed a α-helix stabilized through hydrophobic interactions with the coactivator binding pocket on RORγ (Fig. 2c). This interaction is further stabilized through a conserved charged clamp wherein the backbone amide of Tyr7 and carbonyl of Leu11 of EBI96 form hydrogen bonds with Glu504 (helix12) and Lys336 (helix3) of RORγ. Formation of this charged clamp is essential for RORγ’s function for playing a role in transcriptional activation and this has been corroborated through mutagenic studies in this region.0.99952424evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:25:47ZDUMMY:Electron density0.9981281chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:28ZCHEBI:EBI960.7580885structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:25:52ZSO:EFPYLLSLLG0.99970657structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:25:58ZSO:α-helixbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrophobic interactions0.999589sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:21ZSO:coactivator binding pocket0.9997904proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99953485protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:26:40ZDUMMY:conserved0.9152874structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:26:31ZSO:charged clamp0.9999007residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:26:12ZDUMMY:Tyr70.99990094residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:26:17ZDUMMY:Leu110.99767834chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:28ZCHEBI:EBI96bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bonds0.9999043residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:26:23ZDUMMY:Glu5040.9997838structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:18:45ZSO:helix120.9999033residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:26:27ZDUMMY:Lys3360.9997806structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:26:49ZSO:helix30.9997863proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.85428715structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:26:32ZSO:charged clamp0.999788proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9995812experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:26:37ZMESH:mutagenic studiesRESULTStitle_213539BIO592 binds in a collapsed conformation stabilizing the agonist conformation of RORγ0.9965342chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.999559protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:27:02ZDUMMY:collapsed0.6351255protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:27:05ZDUMMY:agonist0.99970454proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ12900_2016_59_Fig3_HTML.jpgFig3FIGfig_caption13629
a Collapsed binding mode of agonist BIO592 in the hydrophobic LBS of RORγ. b Benzoxazinone ring system of agonist BIO592 packing against His479 of RORγ stabilizing agonist conformation of the AF2 helixprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9995141chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.6673667sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.999788proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγchemicalCHEBI:cleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZBenzoxazinoneprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99953103chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9998983residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.9997874proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99967206structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helixRESULTSparagraph13840BIO592 bound in a collapsed conformational state in the LBS of RORγ with the xylene ring positioned at the bottom of the pocket making hydrophobic interactions with Val376, Phe378, Phe388 and Phe401, with the ethyl-benzoxazinone ring making several hydrophobic interactions with Trp317, Leu324, Met358, Leu391, Ile 400 and His479 (Fig. 3a, Additional file 3). The sulfonyl group faces the entrance of the pocket, while the CF3 makes a hydrophobic contact with Ala327. Hydrophobic interaction between the ethyl group of the benzoxazinone and His479 reinforce the His479 sidechain position for making the hydrogen bond with Tyr502 thereby stabilizing the agonist conformation (Fig. 3b).0.9990957chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9857471protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:24:08ZDUMMY:bound inprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:27:48Zcollapsed0.99963737sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.99978584proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99809307chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:29:29ZCHEBI:xylene0.99882764sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:54:20ZSO:pocketbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrophobic interactions0.9999033residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:06ZDUMMY:Val3760.9998995residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:10ZDUMMY:Phe3780.99989617residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:14ZDUMMY:Phe3880.9998977residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:19ZDUMMY:Phe4010.9988957chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:29:27ZCHEBI:ethyl-benzoxazinonebond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrophobic interactions0.9999012residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:25ZDUMMY:Trp3170.999899residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:29ZDUMMY:Leu3240.9999006residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9999014residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:37ZDUMMY:Leu391residue_name_numberDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:28:56ZIle 4000.9999039residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.97242635chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:29:34ZCHEBI:sulfonyl0.9925991sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:54:25ZSO:pocketbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrophobic contact0.99990606residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:29:06ZDUMMY:Ala327bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02ZHydrophobic interaction0.9993363chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.9999043residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.999907residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His479bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bond0.99990344residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr502protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38ZagonistRESULTStitle_214529RORγ AF2 helix is sensitive to proteolysis in the presence of Inverse Agonist BIO3990.999711proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99974036structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9675162protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:29:49ZDUMMY:presence ofprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20ZInverse Agonist0.9995938chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399RESULTSparagraph14618Next, we attempted co-crystallization with the inverse agonist BIO399. However, extensive crystallization efforts with BIO399 and RORγ518 or other AF2 intact constructs did not produce crystals. We hypothesized that the RORγ518 coactivator peptide interaction in the FRET assay was disrupted upon BIO399 binding and that a conformational rearrangement of the AF2 helix could have occurred, hindering crystallization.0.999572experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:30:01ZMESH:co-crystallizationprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9988544chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99946946experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:29:54ZMESH:crystallization0.9979844chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9996563proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.9412052structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:59:05ZSO:AF20.9938573protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:30:12ZDUMMY:intact0.9034121evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:30:17ZDUMMY:crystals0.9997154proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.9995203experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:15:19ZMESH:FRET assay0.99598217chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9997167structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9927527experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:30:05ZMESH:crystallization12900_2016_59_Fig4_HTML.jpgFig4FIGfig_caption15043Specific proteolytic positions on RORγ518 when treated with Actinase E alone (Green) or in the presence of BIO399 (Red) and shared proteolytic sites (Yellow)0.99923706proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.9101149experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:52:27ZMESH:treated with0.9971443proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:53:23ZPR:Actinase E0.99917436protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:29:49ZDUMMY:presence of0.999374chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99941564sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:54:37ZSO:proteolytic sitesRESULTSparagraph15205The unfolding of the AF2 helix has been observed for other nuclear hormone receptors when bound to an inverse agonist or antagonist. We used partial proteolysis in combination with mass spectrometry to determine if BIO399 was causing the AF2 helix to unfold. Results of the Actinase E proteolysis experiments on RORγ518, the ternary complex of RORγ518 with agonist BIO592 and coactivator EBI96, or in the presence of inverse agonist BIO399 supported our hypothesis. Analysis of the fragmentation pattern showed minimal proteolytic removal of the AF2 helix by Actinase E on RORγ518 alone (ending at 504 to 506) and the ternary complex remained primarily intact (ending at 515/518) (Additional file 4). However, in the presence of inverse agonist BIO399, the proteolytic pattern showed significantly less protection, albeit the products were more heterogeneous (majority ending at 494/495), indicating the destabilization of the AF2 helix compared to either the APO or ternary agonist complex (Fig. 4, Additional file 5).0.9997374structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9996216protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:39ZMESH:nuclear hormone receptors0.99951684protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:24:12ZDUMMY:bound toprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99952674experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:31:34ZMESH:partial proteolysis0.9995297experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:31:30ZMESH:mass spectrometry0.99214536chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9997202structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.7968726experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:31:25ZMESH:Actinase E proteolysis0.9997969proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.99978536proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ518protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9989819chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9997379chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:23:28ZCHEBI:EBI960.99913347protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:29:49ZDUMMY:presence ofprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99921584chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99508756evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:31:16ZDUMMY:fragmentation pattern0.9997283structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9967369proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:53:23ZPR:Actinase E0.99980134proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ518residue_rangeDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:48:58Z504 to 5060.80447483protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:48ZDUMMY:ternary complex0.43031177residue_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:49:44ZDUMMY:515residue_numberDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:49:25Z5180.999481protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:29:49ZDUMMY:presence ofprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99928194chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9842393evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:31:19ZDUMMY:proteolytic pattern0.49895975residue_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:49:48ZDUMMY:494residue_numberDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:49:40Z4950.9997306structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99967384protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:00:53ZDUMMY:APO0.7635996protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:01ZDUMMY:ternary agonist complexRESULTSparagraph16237Several rounds of cocrystallization attempts with RORγ518 or other RORγ AF2 helix containing constructs complexed with BIO399 had not produced crystals. We attributed the inability to form crystals to the unfolding of the AF2 helix induced by BIO399. We reasoned that if we could remove the unfolded AF2 helix using proteolysis we could produce a binary complex more amenable to crystallization.0.999603experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:32:05ZMESH:cocrystallization0.9997676proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:23:34ZPR:RORγ5180.9812258proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99960935structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99924374protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:31:42ZDUMMY:complexed with0.88344735chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.97513825evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:18ZDUMMY:crystals0.8911621evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:16ZDUMMY:crystals0.9997282structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.96908194chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99956316protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:14ZDUMMY:unfolded0.99973404structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99730253experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:32:09ZMESH:proteolysis0.99929774experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:32:11ZMESH:crystallizationRESULTStitle_216641AF2 truncated RORγ BIO399 complex is more amenable to crystallization0.99842143protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:36ZDUMMY:AF2 truncated0.99530745complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:32:42ZGO:RORγ BIO3990.9996778experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:32:39ZMESH:crystallization12900_2016_59_Fig5_HTML.jpgFig5FIGfig_caption16715
a The binary structure of AF2-truncated RORγ and BIO399. b The superposition of inverse agonist BIO399 (Cyan) and agonist BIO592 (Green). c Movement of Met358 and His479 in the BIO399 (Cyan) and BIO592 (Green) structures0.9753916evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:53ZDUMMY:structure0.99942464protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:07ZDUMMY:AF2-truncated0.9997619proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9949635chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9996861experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:32:49ZMESH:superpositionprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9971846chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99816895chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9998957residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.99989843residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.9886769chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9916482chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.99948066evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:32:55ZDUMMY:structuresRESULTSparagraph16941The Actinase E treated RORγ518 BIO399 ternary complex (aeRORγ493/4) co-crystallized readily in several PEG based conditions. The structure of aeRORγ493/4 BIO399 complex was solved to 2.3 Å and adopted a similar core fold to the BIO592 agonist crystal structure (Fig. 5a, Additional file 3). The aeRORγ493/4 BIO399 structure diverged at the c-terminal end of Helix 11 from the RORγ518 BIO592 EBI96 structure, where helix 11 unwinds into a random coil after residue L475.proteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:53:22ZActinase E0.99942446complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:33:06ZGO:RORγ518 BIO3990.99912286complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:33:12ZGO:aeRORγ493/40.99949425experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:34:49ZMESH:co-crystallized0.99952996evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:34:46ZDUMMY:structure0.9994172complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:33:28ZGO:aeRORγ493/4 BIO3990.84812504experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:34:51ZMESH:solved0.98904616chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.999605evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:34:41ZDUMMY:crystal structure0.9969038complex_assemblycleaner02023-07-19T15:33:29ZGO:aeRORγ493/4 BIO3990.99960536evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:34:38ZDUMMY:structure0.99971807structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:34:34ZSO:Helix 11complex_assemblyGO:cleaner02023-07-19T15:34:27ZRORγ518 BIO592 EBI960.9993129evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:34:43ZDUMMY:structure0.99970734structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:34:33ZSO:helix 110.99849415residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:33:49ZDUMMY:L475RESULTStitle_217431Inverse agonist BIO399 uses Met358 as a trigger for inverse agonismprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20ZInverse agonist0.9986848chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9999069residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met358RESULTSparagraph17499BIO399 binds to the ligand binding site of RORγ adopting a collapsed conformation as seen with BIO592 where the two compounds superimpose with an RMSD of 0.72 Å (Fig. 5b). The majority of the side chains within 4 Å of BIO399 and BIO592 adopt similar rotomer conformations with the exceptions of Met358 and His479 (Fig. 5c). The difference density map showed clear positive density for Met358 in an alternate rotomer conformation compared to the one observed in the molecular replacement model or the other agonist containing models (Additional file 6). We tried to refine Met358 in the same conformation as the molecular replacement model or the other agonist containing models, but the results clearly indicated that this was not possible, thus confirming the new rotamer conformation for the Met358 sidechain in the inverse agonist bound structure. The change in rotomer conformation of Met358 between the agonist and inverse agonist structures is attributed to the gem-dimethyl group on the larger 7 membered benzoxazinone ring system of BIO399. The comparison of the two structures shows that the agonist conformation observed in the BIO592 structure would be perturbed by BIO399 pushing Met358 into Phe506 of the AF2 helix indicating that Met358 is a trigger for inducing inverse agonism in RORγ (Fig. 5c).0.9960114chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99961sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:34:59ZSO:ligand binding site0.99980706proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:35:15Zcollapsed0.9943234chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.998801experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:53:32ZMESH:superimpose0.99946564evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:35:28ZDUMMY:RMSD0.9960063chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99231964chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9998167residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9998622residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.9993809evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:35:33ZDUMMY:difference density map0.9976566evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:35:38ZDUMMY:positive density0.99972934residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.99948543experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:35:43ZMESH:molecular replacement modelprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99954575residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9995101experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:35:43ZMESH:molecular replacement modelprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99965596residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.99805737protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:14ZDUMMY:inverse agonist bound0.9991708evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:35:59ZDUMMY:structure0.999673residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9903914protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:37ZDUMMY:agonist0.9016677protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:19ZDUMMY:inverse agonist0.9906707evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:01ZDUMMY:structures0.99437535chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.99684626chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.8270343experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:53:36ZMESH:comparison0.74309015evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:04ZDUMMY:structures0.88217115protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38ZDUMMY:agonist0.53165466chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9989053evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:06ZDUMMY:structure0.80424184chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9997873residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9998599residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:19:02ZDUMMY:Phe5060.99969506structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.9998171residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9997954proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγRESULTStitle_218820BIO399 and Inverse agonist T0901317 bind in a collapsed conformation distinct from other RORγ Inverse Agonists Cocrystal structures0.9986603chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20ZInverse agonist0.9993025chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:21ZCHEBI:T09013170.9996755protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:15ZDUMMY:collapsed0.6189321proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99943864evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:12ZDUMMY:Cocrystal structures12900_2016_59_Fig6_HTML.jpgFig6FIGfig_caption18956
a Overlay of RORγ structures bound to BIO596 (Green), BIO399 (Cyan) and T0901317 (Pink). b Overlay of M358 in RORγ structure BIO596 (Green), BIO399 (Cyan), Digoxin (Yellow), Compound 2 (Grey), Compound 48 (Salmon) and Compound 4j (Orange)0.99830246experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:34ZMESH:Overlay0.99475783proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9991398evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:36ZDUMMY:structures0.9994433protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:24:12ZDUMMY:bound to0.9967662chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T16:06:49ZCHEBI:BIO5960.9978752chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.96408117chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:22ZCHEBI:T09013170.99945694experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:42ZMESH:Overlay0.99989235residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:50:13ZDUMMY:M3580.99910957proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9986027evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:36:44ZDUMMY:structure0.997511chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T16:07:00ZCHEBI:BIO5960.99866104chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9995783chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:55ZCHEBI:DigoxinRESULTSparagraph19204The co-crystal structure of RORγ with T0901317 (PDB code: 4NB6), an inverse agonist of RORγ (IC50 of 54nM in an SRC1 displacement FRET assay and an IC50 of 59nM in our FRET assay (Additional file 7)) shows that it adopts a collapsed conformation similar to the structure of BIO399 described here. The two compounds superimpose with an RMSD of 0.81 Å (Fig. 6a). The CF3 group on the hexafluoropropanol group of T0901317 was reported to fit the electron density in two conformations one of which pushes Met358 into the vicinity of Phe506 in the RORγ BIO592 agonist structure. We hypothesize that since the Met358 sidechain conformation in the T0901317 RORγ structure is not in the BIO399 conformation, this difference could account for the 10-fold reduction in the inverse agonism for T0901317 compared to BIO399 in the FRET assay.0.9994807evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:12ZDUMMY:co-crystal structure0.99975437proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9983985chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:22ZCHEBI:T0901317protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9997485proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9804152evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:51:33ZDUMMY:IC500.99956346experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:37:06ZMESH:SRC1 displacement FRET assay0.9948265evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:51:37ZDUMMY:IC500.99950325experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:15:19ZMESH:FRET assayprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T15:37:44Zcollapsed0.63860226evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:51:41ZDUMMY:structure0.9829714chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9992175experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:37:15ZMESH:superimpose0.99965835evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:35:28ZDUMMY:RMSD0.99770904chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:37:28ZCHEBI:hexafluoropropanol0.9959305chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:22ZCHEBI:T09013170.9994836evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:25:47ZDUMMY:electron density0.99987984residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9998841residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:19:02ZDUMMY:Phe5060.9995697proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.8003477chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO592protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.9993617evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:20ZDUMMY:structure0.99987173residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9912252chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:22ZCHEBI:T09013170.99891305proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99936765evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:23ZDUMMY:structure0.86961484chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99782795chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:36:22ZCHEBI:T09013170.9925011chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99927664experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:15:19ZMESH:FRET assayRESULTSparagraph20050Co-crystal structures of RORγ have been generated with several potent inverse agonists adopting a linear conformation distinct from the collapsed conformations seen for BIO399 and T090131718. The inverse agonist activity for these compounds has been attributed to orientating Trp317 to clash with Tyr502 or a direct inverse agonist hydrogen bonding event with His479, both of which would perturb the agonist conformation of RORγ. BIO399 neither orients the sidechain of Trp317 toward Tyr502 nor forms a hydrogen bond with His479 suggesting its mode of action is distinct from linear inverse agonists (Additional file 8). In the linear inverse agonist crystal structures the side chain of Met358 resides in a similar position as the rotomer observed in RORγ agonist structures with BIO592 described here or as observed in the hydroxycholesterol derivatives and therefore would not trigger inverse agonism with these ligands (Fig. 6b).0.9995247evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:57ZDUMMY:Co-crystal structures0.9997024proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9989466protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:52ZDUMMY:linear0.9995504protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T15:37:54ZDUMMY:collapsed0.9995369chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9996209chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T16:07:05ZCHEBI:T090131718protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.99989784residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:25ZDUMMY:Trp3170.99989426residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr502protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonistbond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bonding0.9999031residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His4790.99489343protein_statecleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38ZDUMMY:agonist0.9996356proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9995697chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9999018residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:28:25ZDUMMY:Trp3170.9998988residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:18:57ZDUMMY:Tyr502bond_interactionMESH:melaniev@ebi.ac.uk2023-07-28T14:18:02Zhydrogen bond0.9999014residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:25:24ZDUMMY:His479protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9996216evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:38:08ZDUMMY:crystal structures0.9999008residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9991548proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.7199689evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:38:11ZDUMMY:structures0.99945503chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.99954826chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:38:05ZCHEBI:hydroxycholesterolRESULTStitle_220996BIO399 shows selectivity for RORγ over RORα and RORβ in a GAL4 Cellular Reporter Assay0.9948939chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9997609proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99983096proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.99983597proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:06ZPR:RORβ0.9995607experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:38:17ZMESH:GAL4 Cellular Reporter AssayTab1.xmlTab1TABLEtable_caption21094GAL4 cell assay selectivity profile for BIO399 toward RORα and RORβ in GAL40.9994817experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:38:20ZMESH:GAL4 cell assay0.9978909chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.9998468proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.9998485proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:06ZPR:RORβ0.98739153proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:57:30ZPR:GAL4Tab1.xmlTab1TABLEtable<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<table frame="hsides" rules="groups"><thead><tr><th>ROR</th><th>γ</th><th>α</th><th>β</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>IC50 (uM)</td><td>0.043 (+/− 0.01uM; N = 6)</td><td>>10 (N = 2)</td><td>>1.2 (N = 2)</td></tr><tr><td>Selectivity (X)</td><td>-</td><td>>235</td><td>>28.2</td></tr></tbody></table>
21177ROR γ α β IC50 (uM) 0.043 (+/− 0.01uM; N = 6) >10 (N = 2) >1.2 (N = 2) Selectivity (X) - >235 >28.2 12900_2016_59_Fig7_HTML.jpgFig7FIGfig_caption21301
a Overlay of RORα (yellow), β (pink) and γ (cyan) showing side chain differences at Met358 inverse agonism trigger position and (b) around the benzoxazinone ring system of BIO3990.9992525experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:38:33ZMESH:Overlay0.99982053proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.9997744proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:38:36ZPR:β0.999747proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:38:39ZPR:γ0.9998907residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met358chemicalCHEBI:cleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56Zbenzoxazinone0.99398804chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399RESULTSparagraph21492In order to assess the in vivo selectivity profile of BIO399 a cellular reporter assay was implemented where the ligand binding domains of ROR α, β and γ were fused to the DNA binding domain of the transcriptional factor GAL4. The ROR-GAL4 fusion proteins were expressed in cells with the luciferase reporter gene under the control of a GAL4 promoter. BIO399 inhibited the luciferase activity when added to the cells expressing the RORγ-GAL4 fusion with an in vivo IC50 of 42.5nM while showing >235 and 28 fold selectivity over cells expressing GAL4 fused to the LBD of ROR α or β, respectively (Table 1). The LBS of RORs share a high degree of similarity. However, the inverse agonism trigger of BIO399, residue Met358, is a leucine in both RORα and β. This selectivity profile for BIO399 is attributed to the shorter leucine side chain in RORα and β which would not reach the phenylalanine on the AF2 helix further underscoring the role of Met358 as a trigger for RORγ specific inverse agonism (Fig. 7a). Furthermore, RORα contains two phenylalanine residues in its LBS whereas RORβ and γ have a leucine in the same position (Fig. 6b). We hypothesize that the two phenylalanine residues in the LBS of RORα occlude the dihydrobenzoxazepinone ring system of BIO399 from binding it and responsible for the increase in selectivity for RORα over β.0.99780947chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99894136experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:39:38ZMESH:cellular reporter assay0.9995373structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:39:40ZSO:ligand binding domains0.9841285protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZMESH:ROR0.9995415proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:39:27ZPR:α0.9996561proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:39:30ZPR:β0.9997303proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:39:33ZPR:γ0.774799experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:39:35ZMESH:fused to0.99931574structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:16:53ZSO:DNA binding domain0.96916354protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:39:49ZMESH:transcriptional factor0.8299078proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:39:52ZPR:GAL4protein_typeMESH:cleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZRORproteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:57:30ZGAL4proteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:57:30ZGAL40.99855095chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO399proteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZRORγproteinPR:cleaner02023-07-19T15:57:30ZGAL40.99954826evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:52:08ZDUMMY:IC500.34280136proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:57:30ZPR:GAL40.9998186structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:17:06ZSO:LBD0.6574821protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:14:21ZMESH:ROR0.9995084proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:40:06ZPR:α0.9996867proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:40:09ZPR:β0.99981755sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.9994504protein_typecleaner02023-07-19T15:16:33ZMESH:RORs0.99703026chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99989223residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9991722residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:17ZSO:leucine0.9998022proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.9997577proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:56:20ZPR:β0.99747974chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99865365residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:17ZSO:leucine0.9997924proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.99976355proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:40:25ZPR:β0.9991916residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:21ZSO:phenylalanine0.9997171structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99989223residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met3580.9997229proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9998173proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.9992132residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:21ZSO:phenylalanine0.9998124sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.9997999proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:06ZPR:RORβ0.9997799proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:40:28ZPR:γ0.99925333residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:17ZSO:leucine0.99922276residue_namecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:21ZSO:phenylalanine0.99981564sitecleaner02023-07-19T15:18:14ZSO:LBS0.999821proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.99927276chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:40:31ZCHEBI:dihydrobenzoxazepinone0.99807584chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.999803proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:16:02ZPR:RORα0.999731proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:56:26ZPR:βCONCLtitle_122900ConclusionsCONCLparagraph22912We have identified a novel series of synthetic benzoxazinone ligands which modulate the transcriptional activity of RORγ in a FRET based assay. Using partial proteolysis we show a conformational change which destabilizes the AF2 helix of RORγ when the inverse agonist BIO399 binds. The two RORγ co-crystal structures reported here show how a small change to the core ring system can modulate the mode of action from agonist (BIO592) to inverse agonism (BIO399). Finally, we are reporting a newly identified trigger for achieving RORγ specific inverse agonism in an in vivo setting through Met358 which perturbs the agonist conformation of the AF2 helix and prevents coactivator protein binding.0.9997615chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:13:56ZCHEBI:benzoxazinone0.9997459proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99949485experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:47ZMESH:FRET based assay0.9995538experimental_methodcleaner02023-07-19T15:40:50ZMESH:partial proteolysis0.9997312structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helix0.99975103proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:20Zinverse agonist0.9993443chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99973184proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.99941427evidencecleaner02023-07-19T15:40:53ZDUMMY:co-crystal structuresprotein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99953425chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:02ZCHEBI:BIO5920.9995059chemicalcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:09ZCHEBI:BIO3990.99942756proteincleaner02023-07-19T15:12:45ZPR:RORγ0.9998945residue_name_numbercleaner02023-07-19T15:15:13ZDUMMY:Met358protein_stateDUMMY:cleaner02023-07-19T16:01:38Zagonist0.99972713structure_elementcleaner02023-07-19T15:14:26ZSO:AF2 helixABBRtitle_123623AbbreviationsABBRparagraph23637AF2, activation function 2; BisTRIS, 2-[Bis(2-hydroxyethyl)amino]-a-(hydroxymethyl)propane-1,3-diol; DND, DNA binding domain; DTT, 1,4-Dithiothreitol; EDTA, 2-({2-[Bis(carboxymethyl)amino]ethyl}(carboxymethyl)amino)acetic acid; FRET, fluorescence resonance energy transfer; GST, Glutathione-S-Transferase; HEPES, 2-[4(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid; IC50, half maximal inhibitory concentration; IL-17, Interleukin-17; IPTG, isopropyl β-D-1-thiogalactopyranoside; LBD, Ligand Binding Domain; LBS, ligand binding site; LC-MS, liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry; PDB, Protein Data Bank; ROR, retinoid orphan receptor; SRC-1, steroid receptor coactivator-1; TH17 Cells, T helper cells; TRIS, 2-amino-2-hydroxymethyl-propane-1,3,diol.ABBRtitle_124392Additional filesCOMP_INTtitle_124409Competing interestsCOMP_INTparagraph24429The authors declare that they have no competing interests.COMP_INTtitle_124488Consent to publishCOMP_INTparagraph24507Not applicable.COMP_INTtitle_124523EthicsCOMP_INTparagraph24530Not applicable.REFtitle24546ReferencesREFref24557Jetten AM. Retinoid-related orphan receptors (RORs): critical roles in development, immunity, circadian rhythm, and cellular metabolism. Nuclear Receptor Signaingl. 2007;4:e003.112133surname:Ivanov;given-names:IIsurname:McKenzie;given-names:BSsurname:Zhou;given-names:Lsurname:Tadokoro;given-names:CEsurname:Lepelley;given-names:Asurname:Lafaille;given-names:JJsurname:Cua;given-names:DJsurname:Littman;given-names:DR10.1016/j.cell.2006.07.03516990136REFCellref126200624735The Orphan Nuclear Receptor RORγt Directs the Differentiation Program of Proinflammatory IL-17+ T Helper Cells96370surname:Chabaud;given-names:Msurname:Durand;given-names:JMsurname:Buchs;given-names:Nsurname:Fossiez;given-names:Fsurname:Page;given-names:Gsurname:Frappart;given-names:Lsurname:Miossec;given-names:P10.1002/1529-0131(199905)42:5<963::AID-ANR15>3.0.CO;2-E10323452REFArthritis Rheumref42199924850Human interleukin-17: A T cell-derived proinflammatory cytokine produced by the rheumatoid synovium5008surname:Lock;given-names:Csurname:Hermans;given-names:Gsurname:Klonowski;given-names:Psurname:Austin;given-names:Asurname:Lad;given-names:Nsurname:Kaminski;given-names:Nsurname:Galli;given-names:SJsurname:Oksenberg;given-names:JRsurname:Raine;given-names:CSsurname:Heller;given-names:Rsurname:Steinman;given-names:Lsurname:Pedotti;given-names:Rsurname:Brendolan;given-names:Asurname:Schadt;given-names:Esurname:Garren;given-names:Hsurname:Langer-Gould;given-names:Asurname:Strober;given-names:Ssurname:Cannella;given-names:Bsurname:Allard;given-names:J10.1038/nm0502-50011984595REFNat Medref8200224950Gene-microarray analysis of multiple sclerosis lesions yields new targets validated in autoimmune encephalomyelitis6570surname:Fujino;given-names:Ssurname:Andoh;given-names:Asurname:Bamba;given-names:Ssurname:Ogawa;given-names:Asurname:Hata;given-names:Ksurname:Araki;given-names:Ysurname:Bamba;given-names:Tsurname:Fujiyama;given-names:Y10.1136/gut.52.1.6512477762REFGutref52200325066Increased expression of interleukin 17 in inflammatory bowel disease38006surname:Xie;given-names:Hsurname:Sadim;given-names:MSsurname:Sun;given-names:Z10.4049/jimmunol.175.6.380016148126REFJ Immunolref175200525135RORgammat recruits steroid receptor coactivators to ensure thymocyte survival102533surname:Danielian;given-names:PSsurname:White;given-names:Rsurname:Lees;given-names:JAsurname:Parker;given-names:MG1372244REFEMBO Jref11199225213Identification of a conserved region required for hormone dependent transcriptional activation by steroid hormone receptors1697707surname:Kallen;given-names:JAsurname:Schlaeppi;given-names:JMsurname:Bitsch;given-names:Fsurname:Geisse;given-names:Ssurname:Geiser;given-names:Msurname:Delhon;given-names:Isurname:Fournier;given-names:B10.1016/S0969-2126(02)00912-712467577REFStructureref10200225337X-ray structure of the hRORalpha LBD at 1.63 A: structural and functional data that cholesterol or a cholesterol derivative is the natural ligand of RORalpha5293302surname:Wang;given-names:Ysurname:Tang;given-names:Tsurname:Zhang;given-names:Wsurname:Wu;given-names:Qsurname:Zhang;given-names:Ksurname:Li;given-names:Ysurname:Xiang;given-names:JNsurname:Elliot;given-names:JDsurname:Leung;given-names:Ssurname:Ren;given-names:Fsurname:Lin;given-names:Xsurname:Liu;given-names:Qsurname:Ma;given-names:Ysurname:Yang;given-names:Lsurname:Zhou;given-names:Lsurname:Xiang;given-names:Zsurname:Cheng;given-names:Zsurname:Lu;given-names:Ssurname:Orband-Miller;given-names:LA10.1016/j.bmc.2015.07.06826277758REFBioorg Med Chemref23201525495Discovery of N-(4-aryl-5-aryloxy-thiazol-2-yl)-amides as potent RORγt inverse agonistsREFref25586Wang Y, Cai W, Cheng Y, Yang T, Liu Q, Zhang G, Meng Q, Han F, Huang Y, Zhou L2 Xiang Z, Zhao YG, Xu Y, Cheng Z, Lu S, Wu Q, Xiang JN, Elliott JD, Leung S, Ren F, Lin X. Discovery of Biaryl Amides as Potent, Orally Bioavailable, and CNS Penetrant RORγt Inhibitors. ACS Med Chem Lett. 2015;26:787–92.REFref25890Fauber BP, René O, Deng Y, DeVoss J, Eidenschenk C, Everett C, Ganguli A1, Gobbi A, Hawkins J1, Johnson AR, La H, Lesch J, Lockey P1, Norman M1, Ouyang W, Summerhill S1, Wong H. Discovery of 1-{4-[3-fluoro-4-((3s,6r)-3-methyl-1,1-dioxo-6-phenyl-[1,2]thiazinan-2-ylmethyl)-phenyl]-piperazin-1-yl}-ethanone (GNE-3500): a potent, selective, and orally bioavailable retinoic acid receptor-related orphan receptor C (RORc or RORγ) inverse agonist. J Med Chem. 2015;58:5308–22.43141surname:Zhang;given-names:Ysurname:Xue;given-names:Xsurname:Jin;given-names:Xsurname:Song;given-names:Ysurname:Li;given-names:Jsurname:Luo;given-names:Xsurname:Song;given-names:Msurname:Yan;given-names:Wsurname:Song;given-names:Hsurname:Xu;given-names:Y10.1016/j.ejmech.2014.03.06524704616REFEur J Med Chemref78201426366Discovery of 2-oxo-1,2-dihydrobenzo[cd]indole-6-sulfonamide derivatives as new RORγ inhibitors using virtual screening, synthesis and biological evaluationREFref26526Chao J, Enyedy IJ, Hutchings RH, Jones HJ, Powell NA, Vanvloten KD. Biaryl-containing compounds as inverse agonists of ror-gamma receptors. PCT Int Appl. 2014, WO2014008214 A1.91927surname:Kurebayashi;given-names:Ssurname:Nakajima;given-names:Tsurname:Kim;given-names:SCsurname:Chang;given-names:CYsurname:McDonnell;given-names:DPsurname:Renaud;given-names:JPsurname:Jetten;given-names:AM10.1016/j.bbrc.2004.01.13114985100REFBiochem Biophys Res Communref315200426703Selective LXXLL peptides antagonize transcriptional activation by the retinoid-related orphan receptor RORγ27181surname:Battye;given-names:TGGsurname:Kontogiannis;given-names:Lsurname:Johnson;given-names:Osurname:Powell;given-names:HRsurname:Leslie;given-names:AGW10.1107/S090744491004867521460445REFActa Crystallogr Sect D: Biol Crystallogrref67201126815iMOSFLM : a new graphical interface for diffraction-image processing with MOSFLMREFref26896Otwinowski Z, Minor W. Processing of X-ray diffraction data collected in oscillation mode. Methods Enzymol. 1997;276:307–269239surname:Jin;given-names:Lsurname:Martynowski;given-names:Dsurname:Zheng;given-names:Ssurname:Wada;given-names:Tsurname:Xie;given-names:Wsurname:Li;given-names:Y10.1210/me.2009-050720203100REFMol Endocrinolref24201027022Structural basis for hydroxycholesterols as natural ligands of orphan nuclear receptor RORgamma225surname:Vagin;given-names:Asurname:Teplyakov;given-names:A10.1107/S090744490904258920057045REFActa Crystallogr Sect D: Biol Crystallogrref66201027118Molecular replacement with MOLREP24755surname:Murshudov;given-names:GNsurname:Vagin;given-names:Asurname:Lebedev;given-names:Asurname:Wilson;given-names:KSsurname:Dodson;given-names:EJ10.1107/S090744499801405X10089417REFActa Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogrref55199927152Efficient anisotropic refinement of macromolecular structures using FFT212632surname:Emsley;given-names:Psurname:Cowtan;given-names:K10.1107/S090744490401915815572765REFActa Crystallogr Sect D: Biol Crystallogrref60200427224Coot: Model-building tools for molecular graphics7187surname:Zhang;given-names:Ysurname:Luo;given-names:Xsurname:Wu;given-names:Dsurname:Xu;given-names:Y10.1038/aps.2014.12025500868REFActa Pharmacol Sinref36201527274ROR nuclear receptors: structures, related diseases, and drug discovery92737surname:Shiau;given-names:AKsurname:Barstad;given-names:Dsurname:Loria;given-names:PMsurname:Cheng;given-names:Lsurname:Kushner;given-names:PJsurname:Agard;given-names:DAsurname:Greene;given-names:GL10.1016/S0092-8674(00)81717-19875847REFCellref95199827346The structural basis of estrogen receptor/coactivator recognition and the antagonism of this interaction by tamoxifen6146surname:Nahoum;given-names:Vsurname:Lipski;given-names:Asurname:Quillard;given-names:Fsurname:Guichou;given-names:JFsurname:Boublik;given-names:Ysurname:Pérez;given-names:Esurname:Germain;given-names:Psurname:de Lera;given-names:ARsurname:Bourguet;given-names:W10.1107/S1744309108015492REFActa Crystallogr Sect F: Struct Biol Cryst Communref64200827464Nuclear receptor ligand-binding domains: reduction of helix H12 dynamics to favor crystallization1102533surname:Singarapu;given-names:KKsurname:Zhu;given-names:Jsurname:Tonelli;given-names:Msurname:Rao;given-names:Hsurname:Assadi-Porter;given-names:FMsurname:Westler;given-names:WMsurname:DeLuca;given-names:HFsurname:Markley;given-names:JL10.1021/bi201637p22112050REFBiochemistryref50201127562Ligand-specific structural changes in the vitamin D receptor in solution7784surname:Koth;given-names:CMsurname:Orlicky;given-names:SMsurname:Larson;given-names:SMsurname:Edwards;given-names:AM10.1016/S0076-6879(03)68005-5REFMethods Enzymref368200327635Use of limited proteolysis to identify protein domains suitable for structural analysis66049surname:Fauber;given-names:BPsurname:de Leon;given-names:BGsurname:Norman;given-names:Msurname:Ouyang;given-names:Wsurname:René;given-names:Osurname:Wong;given-names:Hsurname:Burton;given-names:Bsurname:Eidenschenk;given-names:Csurname:Everett;given-names:Csurname:Gobbi;given-names:Asurname:Hymowitz;given-names:SGsurname:Johnson;given-names:ARsurname:Liimatta;given-names:Msurname:Lockey;given-names:P10.1016/j.bmcl.2013.10.05424239186REFBioorg Med Chem Lettref23201327723Structure-based design of substituted hexafluoroisopropanol-arylsulfonamides as modulators of RORc3140917surname:Fujita-Sato;given-names:Ssurname:Ito;given-names:Ssurname:Isobe;given-names:Tsurname:Ohyama;given-names:Tsurname:Wakabayashi;given-names:Ksurname:Morishita;given-names:Ksurname:Ando;given-names:Osurname:Isono;given-names:F10.1074/jbc.M111.25400321733845REFJ Biol Chemref286201127822Structural basis of digoxin that antagonizes RORγt receptor activity and suppresses Th17 cell differentiation and interleukin (IL)-17 production18925surname:Muegge;given-names:Isurname:Collin;given-names:Dsurname:Cook;given-names:Bsurname:Hill-Drzewi;given-names:Msurname:Horan;given-names:Jsurname:Kugler;given-names:Ssurname:Labadia;given-names:Msurname:Li;given-names:Xsurname:Smith;given-names:Lsurname:Zhang;given-names:Y10.1016/j.bmcl.2015.03.04225840886REFBioorg Med Chem Lettref25201527971Discovery of 1,3-dihydro-2,1,3-benzothiadiazole 2,2-dioxide analogs as new RORC modulators27681surname:René;given-names:Osurname:Fauber;given-names:BPsurname:Liimatta;given-names:Msurname:Lockey;given-names:Psurname:Norman;given-names:Msurname:Ouyang;given-names:Wsurname:Wallweber;given-names:HAsurname:Wong;given-names:Hsurname:de Boenig;given-names:GLsurname:Burton;given-names:Bsurname:Eidenschenk;given-names:Csurname:Everett;given-names:Csurname:Gobbi;given-names:Asurname:Hymowitz;given-names:SGsurname:Johnson;given-names:ARsurname:Kiefer;given-names:JR10.1021/ml500420y25815138REFACS Med Chem Lettref6201528062Minor Structural Change to Tertiary Sulfonamide RORc Ligands Led to Opposite Mechanisms of Action298590surname:Wang;given-names:Tsurname:Banerjee;given-names:Dsurname:Talreja;given-names:Tsurname:Van Vloten;given-names:Ksurname:Bohnert;given-names:Tsurname:Chao;given-names:Jsurname:Enyedy;given-names:Isurname:Fontenot;given-names:Jsurname:Guertin;given-names:Ksurname:Jones;given-names:Hsurname:Lin;given-names:EYsurname:Marcotte;given-names:D10.1016/j.bmcl.2015.05.02826048789REFBioorg Med Chem Lettref25201528160Discovery of novel pyrazole-containing benzamides as potent RORγ inverse agonists29917surname:Chao;given-names:Jsurname:Enyedy;given-names:Isurname:Silvian;given-names:Lsurname:Hong;given-names:VSsurname:Little;given-names:Ksurname:Banerjee;given-names:Dsurname:Peng;given-names:Lsurname:Taveras;given-names:Asurname:Viney;given-names:JLsurname:Fontenot;given-names:Jsurname:Van Vloten;given-names:Ksurname:Marcotte;given-names:Dsurname:Guertin;given-names:Ksurname:Hutchings;given-names:Rsurname:Powell;given-names:Nsurname:Jones;given-names:Hsurname:Bohnert;given-names:Tsurname:Peng;given-names:C-C10.1016/j.bmcl.2015.05.02626048806REFBioorg Med Chem Lettref25201528246Discovery of biaryl carboxylamides as potent RORγ inverse agonists