":::::: Here is what Lewis says on page 194; reader can judge whether Lewis has a condemning tone there for the two writters he mentions or not: ""Two other works, which emphasize the negative aspects of the Muslim record, are Bat Ye'or, ""name of a book"", and Karl Binswanger, ""name of a book"". The latter is very critical of what he calls the ""dogmatic Islamophilia"" of many orientalists."" I am sure Pecher is going to claim that Binswanger is also a reliable source.  

"