Assuming good faith only goes so far. When an admin indef blocks someone they are not assuming good faith, because the blocked editor is blatant in his actions, just as I do not assume good faith when I make a 3RR report - same logic applies to my comments regarding Melonbarmonster.  As for personal remarks, I do not see how they are relevant, I could not care less about any personal aspects of anyone who edits wikipedia, I care about their edits.

 But anyway Ed, nice to meet you - sure we are gonna get along just fine.