"
 First, no, the passage states that Mustafa Zayd counted X instance of abrogation from some exegetesis, this is clear if you actually read (Mustafa Zayd, Al-Nasikh fi al-Qur'an al-Karim, vol2. pp.507-508), and again  ""pp. 115-116 and 120"" of Fatoohi book don't contain anything that states that Mustafa Zayd considered 140 verses to have been abrogated by Q.9:5. You distorted facts, I need explanations for that. Second, you keep referring to Iryna Harpy when she actually stated: ""My apologies, but I'm currently involved in other article disputes to the point of not knowing how to prioritise my time. More to the point, I am not in a position to engage in extensive reading in order to familiarise myself with the details of the subject matter in order to be able to give a reasonably qualified NPOV opinion. ""   "