Huh? 

You page protected Amanda Knox.  The previous editor was redirecting it because they said the article was a copy of the murder article.  But the article has been up only 2 hours and already it has changes.  The previous editor before that was John Carter, who is an administrator.

What you should do is not to listen to the pro-redirect editor and let many editors improve the article so that it is not a copy of the murder article.  Then it can be judged on its own.  If people add biographical details to the murder article, those will probably be removed because they are unrelated to the murder.  So we are stunning the growth due to inflexible rules.

There is already a consensus, about 5 editors have edited the article and 1 changed it to a redirect and demanded page protection.  5:1 is consensus.  You should unprotect it and ask for opinions on the Amanda Knox talk page.  Then see what the real consensus is. 

I came here and typed Amanda Knox.  This is because she is the key article.  I did not type in Murder of Kirscher.