It is not quite the same thing, firstly I write my own replies, and secondly I have participated in discussion about BJCP on this page, quite clearly giving my reasons for wanting the BJCP link to be retained.  24.8.16.209 has never posted here until very recently and has given no reason for not wanting the BJCP link.  It will be interesting to see if I get a reply from 24.8.16.209.