# The Markenmore Mystery/Chapter 4

pp. 46–58.
CHAPTER IV
MARKENMORE HOLLOW
About half a mile to the north-east of Markenmore Court, flanked by a narrow, deep-set lane that ran up from the main road of the village to the overhanging downs, and backed by the woods and coverts which lay between the foot of those downs and the level lands beneath, stood a small, comfortable, picturesque old house called The Warren. It had been built in the middle of the eighteenth century by the fifth baronet, Sir Geoffrey Markenmore, as a residence for his steward, and had been occupied by successive stewards until recent years, when they were relegated to a more convenient house in the centre of the village. Since then The Warren had been let to tenants; its position, its fine outlook over park, meadows, and sea made it a desirable property for any man of quiet tastes. Its present occupant was Mr. Samuel Fransemmery, a middle-aged bachelor, by profession a barrister-at-law, who, once taking a holiday in these regions, had found The Warren to let and had immediately snapped it up on a twenty-one years' lease. It was, indeed, the very place for which Mr. Fransemmery had been looking for some time; barrister though he was (of the Middle Temple) he had scarcely ever held a brief in his life, and the law had no particular attraction for him. Nor was he in any way dependent upon it: he possessed very ample private means, which enabled him to gratify his particular tastes to the full. Those tastes were simple. Mr. Fransemmery's days were passed in collecting books and antiquities, doing a little flower-cultivation in his charming gardens, and taking long walks in the country. He was a bit of a botanist, and a bit of a geologist: what with one thing and another his time went pleasantly—and uneventfully.
In outward appearance, Mr. Fransemmery was a cheerful little person. Somewhat under medium height, he was inclined to portliness; like many little men, he carried himself very erect, and was proud of the fact that he was as straight of back and square of shoulder at fifty as he had been at twenty-five. His clean-shaven face was round and rosy; his eyes were bright behind his big gold-mounted spectacles; he had beautiful teeth and plentiful light-brown hair; scrupulous to a fault about his personal appearance, he always looked, said the village folk, as if he had just come out of a band-box, by which they meant that he was perfectly groomed. There was, indeed, an air of perpetual youth and freshness about Mr. Fransemmery: each spring seemed to find him younger than the last. People chaffed him about his juvenility; if he ever troubled himself to explain it, he did so by solemnly repeating the old saying—"Early to bed and early to rise makes a man healthy, wealthy, and wise." Mr. Fransemmery, since his arrival at The Warren, and his beginning of a truly rural existence, had always gone to bed at half-past nine o'clock and risen with the lark.
He was up with the lark on this particular morning; was rising, as a matter of fact, at the very moment wherein, half a mile away at Markenmore Court, Harry Markenmore was quietly telling his sister Valencia that their father had died in his sleep. Mr. Fransemmery, of course, knew nothing of that; his thoughts were not of death but of life. He, too, drew his blinds and saw the red dawn, and heard the thrushes and blackbirds in the neighbouring plantations; he smelled the scent of the spring-tide, and longed to be out of doors. It was his custom to go for a long walk every morning before his nine-o'clock breakfast; he was going to keep to it this morning. But first there were things to be done. His servants were never up before six: Mr. Fransemmery did things for himself. He was a great man for labour-saving devices; in his house at any hour of the day or night, hot water was ready in any sleeping chamber. Accordingly Mr. Fransemmery could get his bath and his shaving water by merely twisting a tap; he had a patent stove, too, in his own bedroom whereon he would make tea or coffee in a few minutes. So now, long before his housekeeper, his parlourmaid, and his housemaid had opened their eyes, he was bathing, shaving, dressing, and in due time sipping his fragrant Mocha and nibbling digestive biscuits. At precisely six o'clock, clad in a smart suit of grey tweed, and shod in stout shooting boots, strong enough to meet the searching morning dews, he went downstairs, picked up an ash-plant stick in his hall, and putting a rakish-looking cap on his head, set out across the high lands across The Warren.
Mr. Fransemmery's first steps took him out of his own trim surroundings and across a little well-stocked orchard—planted by himself—to the lane which ran up from Markenmore to the crest of the downs. This was one of those lanes peculiar to the south of England, and rarely found elsewhere. It was deep-set in the land; high banks on either side shut it in; each bank was topped by an equally high hedgerow of hawthorne, holly, and elder-bush, liberally mixed with bramble, gorse, and honeysuckle. The road-surface, rough and rutty, lay deep down beneath these prodigalities of vegetation; in winter it was usually a mass of mud; in summer it was ankle-deep in dust. But Mr. Fransemmery did not propose to follow the lane: he descended into it by a rustic stair way of logs, set in the bank, crossed the ruts at the bottom, and ascended the opposite bank by a similar series of steps. There he climbed a stile and be took himself along a narrow footpath hedged in on either side by laurel shrubs; this led him to the palings of a smart little garden at the back of which stood a commodious dwelling house, Woodland Cottage, the residence of Mrs. Braxfield. And there, on a bit of open ground at the side of the garden, flinging corn to her fowls, Mr. Fransemmery saw Mrs. Braxfield herself.
Mr. Fransemmery had known Mrs. Braxfield for some years. He had once or twice stayed at the Sceptre Inn before he came to live at The Warren. In those days Mrs. Braxfield was Mrs. Wrenne, relict of Peter Wrenne, deceased. She was a clever, bustling, managing woman, who knew how to do things. Peter had left her money and one child—a girl named Poppy, who from the days of short frocks bade fair to be a beauty, and had made good her promise. Mrs. Wrenne continued to make money at the Sceptre; folks said she was putting by a fortune for Poppy—certainly Poppy was being brought up like a lady, sent to smart boarding schools, and such like. And then, all of a sudden, Mrs. Wrenne retired from business, took Woodland Cottage, and married Braxfield. Why she married him, nobody ever knew; Braxfield continued to live in his accustomed fashion at Markenmore Court, and if he ever visited his spouse, it was only for an hour or two of an afternoon or evening, or for a very occasional week-end. But, as people of the neighbourhood said, Braxfield, too, would retire sometime, probably when Sir Anthony died—and then, no doubt, he would go home to Woodland Cottage and his wife for good.
Mr. Fransemmery looked approvingly at Mrs. Braxfield as he drew near to her and her chickens. He admired her. Being a little man himself, he had a keen eye for women of the somewhat massive order. Mrs. Braxfield was a big, strong, handsome woman of forty-seven or so, who looked quite five years younger—she had an excellent figure, fine hair, teeth, and colouring, and a pair of quick, shrewd, hazel eyes, in which there was still a spice of roguishness. She smiled at Mr. Fransemmery as he put his fingers to his rakish shepherd's-plaid cap, and Mr. Fransemmery smiled back.
"The top of the morning to you, ma'am!" exclaimed Mr. Fransemmery. "Many of 'em, too! Ah, Mrs. Braxfield, you and I are the only sensible people about here, I think. Here we are, fresh and rosy—and in your case, beautiful as the day itself—enjoying fresh air and these delightful country sights and sounds while most of our neighbours—forgetful of Dr. Watts and his little hymn—are snoring in their beds. You're a wise woman, ma'am!"
Mrs. Braxfield laughed, showing her white teeth, and bringing a dimpled chin into play.
"Why that's as may be, Mr. Fransemmery," she retorted, coquettishly. "But perhaps I'd lie snoring—not that I ever do snore that I know of—in my bed, if I'd the chance. You get up early because you like it—I get up because I've things to do. If I'd three strong women servants, as you have, I'd not get up at five o'clock of a morning, nor yet at six, I'd promise you—not I! I could do with more bed than I get."
"In that case, ma'am," said Mr. Fransemmery, "I should do one of two things. Either I should get a stout serving-lass into the house, or I should request Miss Poppy to rise and feed the fowls."
Mrs. Braxfield emptied her sieve of corn amongst the chickens and drew nearer to the hedge.
"Oh well," she said. "Poppy's not a bad one for getting up and doing her bit. But she's away just now, visiting one of her old school friends, so I'm alone. And as to having a girl, Mr. Fransemmery, I'd rather not be bothered with one—they're more bother than they're worth. Of course, I've a woman comes every day to do the rough work—what else there is to do, Poppy and me can manage well enough. I don't know how it'll be though, when Braxfield comes to live here—a man makes a difference, and I suppose we shall have to keep a servant or two when he retires."
"He's expecting to retire, then?" asked Mr. Fransemmery, who had a weakness for village gossip. "Had enough of it, eh?"
"He'll not retire while Sir Anthony lives," answered Mrs. Braxfield.
"From what I hear that won't be long," observed Mr. Fransemmery. "When I called at the Court, yesterday morning, to enquire, as I do every day, ma'am, I understood from Miss Markenmore that according to the doctors her father might go any time."
"He's a very old man, Mr. Fransemmery," said Mrs. Braxfield. "He was near sixty when he married the second time. However, whether he lasts long or little, Braxfield'll stop with him till the end."
"Good old faithful servant, Braxfield," observed Mr. Fransemmery. "Well—when he does retire, ma'am, you've got a very cozy nest for him to come to! Lucky man!—pleasant home, delightful surroundings, and—the handsomest woman in the South Country! Eh, ma'am?"
"Lord, Mr. Fransemmery, what a flatterer you are!" said Mrs. Braxfield with a conscious laugh. "Go away with you!—you'll be turning my head."
Mr. Fransemmery laughed too, and went. He had a trick of teasing people, and derived great pleasure from it; its exercise kept him in good spirits. He was in high good spirits now, and he began to whistle when he had passed Woodland Cottage and had stepped out on the open downs beyond. But before he had gone far across the springy turf his whistling stopped abruptly. Rounding a corner of the undulating surface Mr. Fransemmery suddenly saw that which made him pause. A hundred yards or so in front, a little to the left of the broad grass-covered foot-track which led from Markenmore Court to Mitbourne, a village on the further side of the downs, lay a deep depression in the land, locally known as Markenmore Hollow. It was, in reality, a long-disused chalk pit of unusual extent, but since its workings had been given up, a hundred years previously, thick under-growth of gorse and bramble had accumulated there beneath a cluster of old Scotch fir, and the place was now a wilderness as lonely as it was wild. But it was not lonely at that moment. Standing by one of the Scotch firs, in close proximity to a great clump of gorse, were men—one of them, from his uniform, Mr. Fransemmery immediately recognized as the Markenmore village policeman; another, from his velveteen coat, as Sir Anthony Markenmore's gamekeeper; the third was a farm-labourer whom Mr. Fransemmery often met of a morning as the man crossed the downs on his way to work in the village.
But it was not the sight of these three men that made Mr. Fransemmery suddenly halt and stop his blithe whistle and catch his breath. He was familiar with the three men—to his eyes they were known. But as they moved, he saw that at their feet there was lying something that was unknown. That something looked like the figure of a man, supine, motionless, covered by some wrap, a coat or overcoat, thrown carefully across its immobility. And it was with a sudden sense of he scarcely knew what, that Mr. Fransemmery, grave and silent enough by that time, went down into the Hollow.
The village policeman, a sharp-eyed fellow, who had once confided to Mr. Fransemmery that he had ambitions and meant to rise in the force, came towards him. His face betokened a good deal, and he shook his head slightly as he put his fingers to his, peaked cap.
"What's all this?" asked Mr. Fransemmery in a hushed voice. "Something wrong?"
"Something very wrong, sir," replied the policeman. He drew nearer, and turning, pointed to the shrouded figure. "Gentleman lying there dead, sir. Shot through the head!—but whether its murder or suicide, I can't say, sir. Murder I think—anyhow, there's no revolver lying near. And it's been a revolver."
"Good heavens!" exclaimed Mr. Fransemmery. "Why—who was he?"
The policeman gave him a sharp look.
"I couldn't have said, sir," he replied. I've only been here three years, so of course I don't know him. But these other two men, they do: Mr. Guy Markenmore, sir."
Mr. Fransemmery started.
"What!" he exclaimed. "Sir Anthony's elder son? You don't mean it."
"They say so, sir, and they know him well enough," answered the policeman. "That man, Hobbs, the ploughman, found him. He ran down to the keeper's cottage, and to me, and we came up at once. But before coming I telephoned to Selcaster, and the Chief Constable himself is coming along—they said he was starting out then, with the doctor. Come and look at him, sir."
Mr. Fransemmery nerved himself to this sad task, and went nearer. The keeper and the labourer touched their caps: the policeman drew aside the cloak which the labourer had taken from his shoulders and laid over the dead man. And Mr. Fransemmery, wandering what all this meant, bent down.
Dead enough, he thought. And peaceful enough. A calm, bloodless face, neither smile nor frown on it—nothing but a little drawing together of the finely marked eyebrows, a slightly puzzled expression. Otherwise, so still. …
"It must have been murder, sir," whispered the policeman, "and at close quarters. Look there!—the skin over his temples slightly burnt. And——"
"They're coming," said the keeper suddenly. "Two or three of them."
Mr. Fransemmery straightened himself and looked across the downs. A dog-cart, driven at considerable speed, was coming along the grass-track from the direction of Selcaster, the tall spire of whose cathedral showed above the woods which lay between the downs and the old city. In the gleam of the rapidly rising sun he caught the glint of the silver and blue uniform of the county police, and as the keeper had said, the dog-cart, driven by a policeman, seemed filled with men. And presently it raced up the sward to the lip of the hollow, and the Chief Constable, a military-looking man of middle age, jumped out and followed by two other men, one the police-surgeon, the other obviously a plain-clothes officer, came hurrying down to the little group beneath the Scotch firs. He nodded to Mr. Fransemmery, whom everybody in the district knew, and turned sharply on the village constable.
"Who found this man?" he asked quickly.
The ploughman came forward, with evident distaste.
"I did, sir!" he answered. "James Hobbs—work at Mr. Marrow's."
"When—and how?" asked the Chief Constable.
"About an hour ago, sir—maybe a bit more," replied Hobbs. "I come this way to my work every morning. I caught sight of him as I was passing the top there, and I came down to take a look at him. Then I saw he was dead, so I covered him up with my coat and ran along to the village to tell the policeman there."
"He was dead when you found him?" asked the Chief Constable.
"Made out he was dead enough, sir! I touched his hand and his face—stone cold they was, both of 'em."
The Chief Constable turned to the police-surgeon, who went forward and removed the cloak. He stooped down and made a hasty examination; then rose and spoke with decision.
"He's been dead from, I should say, two to three hours—perhaps a little longer," he said. "Shot dead—a revolver, presumably."
"Found anything of that sort?" asked the Chief Constable of the policeman.
"Nothing, sir. I've looked carefully all round. There's nothing."
"Murder then!" muttered the Chief Constable. He went nearer and looked intently at the dead man. "I suppose this is Mr. Guy Markenmore?" he said, glancing at the keeper and the policeman. "I've never seen him, you know—he'd left before I came to Selcaster."
"This is Guy Markenmore, without a doubt," said the police-surgeon. "I knew him well enough. He's very little altered, either. You knew him, too, of course," he continued, with a look at the keeper. "You can recognize him?"
"Oh, I know him, sir," exclaimed the keeper. "That's Mr. Guy, right enough, that is! I'd know him anywhere—poor gentleman!"
The Chief Constable looked round. Markenmore Court caught his eye, lying amongst its elms and beeches three-quarters of a mile away across the shelving hill-side. He shook his head.
"This is a bad business," he muttered. "Who on earth should want to murder him? Been away for—seven years, isn't it? Well, he'll have to be removed, and we shall have to inform the coroner at once. Blick," he continued, turning to the plain-clothes man, "you take charge of this. Send down to the village for help—have the body brought down to the Court; the inquest can be held there. Let Hobbs there run down to the village—send Walshaw back in the dog-cart to Selcaster for the other policeman—and have all round here thoroughly examined for footmarks, and so on. Doctor, will you stay by and come down with them to the Court when they're ready to remove him?—you'll no doubt want to make a more careful examination. Now then—we've got to break the news to the family. Mr. Fransemmery, I think you know them all pretty well—will you walk down with me? A painful duty, but it's got to be done."
Mr. Fransemmery bowed his head, and he and the Chief Constable set off at a smart pace across the downs. For awhile they walked in silence: the Chief Constable broke it.
"I understand that Sir Anthony's about at his last end," he said. "This—hello, what's that?"
The two men stopped, staring at each other. Then, with a mutual understanding, they turned sharply towards the valley. From the tower of Markenmore Church came the deep, booming note of a bell; a moment passed and it was repeated.
"The minute bell!" muttered the Chief Constable. "Then—Sir Anthony Markenmore's gone!"