# NIOSH Guide to the Selection and Use of Particulate Respirators Certified Under 42 CFR 84/II. DETAILED GUIDELINES FOR USE

II. DETAILED GUIDELINES FOR USE
A. PURPOSE
The purpose of this user's guide is (1) to familiarize respirator users with the new Part 84 certification regulations for particulate respirators, and (2) to provide guidance for the selection and use of the new particulate respirators. The new regulation became effective on July 10, 1995, and replaces the old Part 11 regulation under which NIOSH and the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) jointly certified respirators before that date.
These guidelines are written for those responsible for establishing and administering an acceptable respiratory protection program. These individuals should be knowledgeable about the basic elements of a respiratory protection program as required in the OSHA respiratory protection standard (29 CFR 1910.134) and as recommended in the NIOSH Guide to Industrial Respiratory Protection [NIOSH 1987], the American National Standard for Respiratory Protection (ANSI Z88.2-1992) [ANSI 1992], and the American Industrial Hygiene Association Respiratory Protection Manual [AIHA 1993].
B. BACKGROUND
The old Part 11 respirator certification regulation [30 CFR 11] was promulgated in 1972. Some of the particulate filter certification tests dated from Bureau of Mines procedures during the 1930s and were never significantly updated. New research, testing, and manufacturing technology have made the particulate filter certification procedures in Part 11 outdated.
Only certifications of nonpowered, air-purifying, particulate-filter respirators are affected by this change from Part 11 to Part 84. Powered, air-purifying, particulate-filter respirators will be addressed in a future revision to Part 84. The remaining portions of Part 11 are incorporated into Part 84 without change. This limited revision provides for certification tests using a worst-case penetrating aerosol (i.e., an aerosol that produces maximum filter penetration) so that the new certified filters can be used against any size of particulate in the workplace. Other respirator testing and certification procedures will be addressed through a series of future changes to Part 84.
On July 10, 1995, 30 CFR 11 was replaced by 42 CFR 84 as an active regulation. As of that date, NIOSH no longer accepts applications for new approvals or for extension of ​approvals under Part 11 regulations. All nonpowered, air-purifying, particulate-filter respirators approved under Part 84 must meet the new performance standard. However, the new regulation permits the manufacture and sale of nonpowered particulate respirators certified under Part 11 until July 10, 1998. This 3-year period will provide time for manufacturers to have new respirators approved and manufactured to meet demand. OSHA, MSHA, and other regulatory agencies have the authority to set a use deadline for 30 CFR 11 filters purchased before July 10, 1998.
A new sequence of approval numbers (TC-84A-xxxx) is used for nonpowered particulate respirators certified under Part 84. All other respirator types will continue to use the sequence of approval numbers previously used for Part 11 because the requirements for these other types have not changed. For example, the number series TC-13F-xxxx indicates an SCBA that is certified under the provisions of either the old Part 11 or the new Part 84. Similarly, PAPRs for particulates that are certified under the new Part 84 will continue to be numbered with the sequence TC-21C-xxxx (as they were numbered under Part 11) because the certification requirements have not yet changed. Appendix A shows examples of the old Part 11 and the new Part 84 certification labels.
All particulate respirators approved under Part 84-will have a certification label bearing the NIOSH and the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) emblems, whereas those approved under Part 11 have the emblems of NIOSH and MSHA. This allows the user to distinguish particulate respirators certified before July 10, 1995, under Part 11 from particulate respirators certified after that date under Part 84.
The revised testing requirements for particulate filters are much more demanding than the old Part 11 tests, and they provide much better evidence of the filter’s ability to remove airborne particles. The new requirements are consistent with 20 years of advances in respiratory protection technology.
C. 42 CFR 84 FILTER CLASSES
The Part 84 certification regulation provides for nine classes of filters (three levels of filter efficiency, with three categories of resistance to filter efficiency degradation). The three levels of filter efficiency are 95%, 99%, and 99.97%. The three categories of
Table 1.—Description of filter classes certified under 42 CFR 84 :
| Class of filter | Efficiency (%) | Test agent | Test maximum loading (mg) | Type of contaminant | Service time |
| N-series N100 N 99 N 95 | ― 99.97 99 95 | NaCl | 200 | Solid and water-based particulates (i.e, non- oil aerosols) | Nonspecific |
| R-series R100 R 99 R 95 | ― 99.97 99 95 | DOP oil | 200 | Any | One work shift |
| P-series P100 P 99 P 95 | ― 99.97 99 95 | DOP oil | Stabilized efficiency | Any | Nonspecific |
* ↑ NIOSH will be conducting and encouraging other researchers to conduct studies to assure that these service time recommendations are adequate. If research indicates the need, additional service time limitations may be recommended by NIOSH for specific workplace conditions.
* ↑ NaCl = sodium chloride
* ↑ Limited by considerations of hygiene, damage, and breathing resistance.
* ↑ High (200 mg) filter loading in the certification test is intended to address the potential for filter efficiency degradation by solid or water-based (i.e., non-oil) aerosols in the workplace. Accordingly, there is no recommended service time limit in most workplace settings. However, in dirty workplaces (high aerosol concentrations), service time should only be extended beyond 8 hours of use (continuous or intermittent) by performing an evaluation in specific workplace settings that demonstrates (a) that extended use will not degrade the filter efficiency below the certified efficiency level, or (b) that the total mass loading of the filter is less than 200 mg (100 mg per filter for dual-filter respirators).
* ↑ DOP oil = dioctyl phtalatate.
* ↑ No specific service time limit when oil aerosols are present. In the presence of oil aerosols, service time may be exteneded beyond 8 hours of use (continuous or intermittent) by demonstrating (a) that extended use will not degrade the filter efficiency below the certified efficiency level, or (b) that the total mass loading of the filter is less than 200 mg (100 mg per filter for dual-filter respirators).
* ↑ The P100 filter must be color-coded magenta. The Part 84 Subpart KK HEPA filter on a PAPR will also be magenta, but the label will be different from the P100 filter, and the two filters cannot be interchanged.
NIOSH established the new test criteria to simulate worst-case respirator use and very severe test conditions. These filters can be used without particle size analysis or filter penetration testing in the workplace. R- or P-series filters should be selected if there are oil (e.g., lubricants, cutting fluids, glycerine) or non-oil aerosols in the workplace. N-series filters should be used only for non-oil (i.e., solid and water-based) aerosols.
* Note: To help you remember the filter series, use the following guide:
* N for Not resistant to oil
* R for Resistant to oil
* P for oil Proof
The filter certification test is called worst-case (i.e., it produces maximum filter penetration) because the test conditions are the most severe that are likely to be encountered in a work environment. These conditions are:
The degradation categories (N-, R-, and P-series) will be determined by using either sodium chloride (NaCB or dioctyl phthalate (DOP) as the test aerosol. NaCl is only slightly degrading to filter efficiency, whereas DOP is very degrading. Respirators tested with NaCl (i.e., N-series filters) are not resistant to efficiency degradation by oils and ​should be used only in workplaces free of oil aerosols. Filters passing DOP oil tests (i-e., R- and P-series filters) are resistant to efficiency degradation and can be used for protection against any aerosols (including oil-based particulates) in the workplace.
D. USE LIMITATIONS
The service life of filters in all three categories of filter efficiency degradation (i.e., N-, R-, and P-series) is limited by considerations of hygiene, damage, and breathing resistance. All filters should be replaced whenever they are damaged, soiled, or causing noticeably increased breathing resistance (e.g., causing discomfort to the wearer).
R- or P-series filters can be used for protection against oil or non-oil aerosols. N-series filters should be used only for non-oil aerosols. Use and reuse of the P-series filters would be subject only to considerations of hygiene, damage, and increased breathing resistance. Generally, the use and reuse of N-series filters would also be subject only to considerations of hygiene, damage, and increased breathing resistance. However, for dirty workplaces that could result in high filter loading (i.e., 200 mg), service time for N-series filters should only be extended beyond 8 hours of use (continuous or intermittent) by performing an evaluation in specific workplace settings that demonstrates (a) that extended use will not degrade the filter efficiency below the efficiency level specified in Part 84, or (b) that the total mass loading of the filter(s) is less than 200 mg. The R-series filters should be used only for a single shift (or for 8 hours of continuous or intermittent use) when oil is present. However, service time for the R-series filters can be extended using the same two methods described above for N-series filters. These determinations would need to be repeated whenever conditions change or modifications are made to processes that could change the type of particulate generated in the user’s facility.
E. PARTICULATE RESPIRATOR SELECTION
To select the correct respirator for protection against particulates, the following conditions must be known:
* The hazard ratio (HR) (i.e., the airborne particulate concentration divided by the exposure limit) ​
* The APF for the class of respirator (the APF should be greater than the HR)
Multiplying the occupational exposure limit by the APF for a respirator gives the maximum workplace concentration in which that respirator can be used. For example, if the commonly accepted APF for a half-mask respirator is 10 and the PEL is 5 mg/m³, then 50 mg/m³ is the highest workplace concentration in which a half-mask respirator can be used against that contaminant. If the workplace concentration is greater than 50 mg/m³, a more protective respirator (with a higher APF) should be used. In no case should an air-purifying respirator be used in IDLH concentrations.
Appendix B presents a simplified guideline that can be used to identify an appropriate Part 84 particulate respirator when a properly selected Part 11 respirator is already in use.
Appendix C presents a flow chart that can be used to select the appropriate Part 84 particulate filters.
Appendix D presents some substance-specific examples of Part 84 respirator selection.
Appendix E answers questions commonly asked about Part 84 respirators.
Note Concerning Part 11 Particulate Filters
Note on Respirator Fit
OSHA requires that all respirators be properly fit-tested using a quantitative or qualitative fit test when initially assigned to a user and periodically thereafter. In addition to fit-testing, your respirator manufacturer has recommended fit-checking procedures that should be followed by the user each time the respirator is worn.
F. RESPIRATORY PROTECTION FOR TUBERCULOSIS
The only respirators certified by NIOSH under Part 11 that meet CDC filtration efficiency performance criteria for protection against tuberculosis (TB) are those with HEPA filters. All nine classes of nonpowered, air-purifying, particulate-filter respirators certified under Part 84 meet or exceed the CDC filtration efficiency performance criteria [CDC 1994]. Several of the Part 84 particulate-filter respirators will be less expensive and more comfortable than Part 11 HEPA-filter respirators, and they are likely to be more readily accepted by health care facilities and workers.
Health care delivery settings are generally free of oil aerosols that would be degrading to filter efficiency. Therefore, N-, R-, or P-series respirators are appropriate for protection against TB in health care settings and other workplaces in which oil aerosols are absent; these respirators are subject to replacement as necessary by considerations of hygiene, damage, and breathing resistance.
Current OSHA policy permits the use of a Part 11 HEPA filter or any Part 84 particulate filter for protection against TB [Miles 1995]. Pending completion of a final TB standard, respiratory protection against TB will be regulated by OSHA under the current unrevised respirator standard [29 CFR 1910.134] and compliance policy directives.
For additional information about respiratory protection for exposure to TB, refer to Guidelines for Preventing the Transmission of Mycobacterium Tuberculosis in Health-Care Facilities [CDC 1994] and Protect Yourself Against Tuberculosis—A Guide for Health Care Workers [NIOSH 1996].