# A Practical Commentary on Holy Scripture/Part 2/Chapter 20

Layout 2
Freiburg am Breisgau / London, W. C. / St. Louis, MO: B. Herder, pages 465–467
Chapter XX.
THE CURE OF THE PARALYTIC, AND FORGIVENESS OF SIN.
[Mark 2, 1 — 12. Mat. 9, 1 — 8. Luke 5, 17 — 26.]
JESUS returned to Capharnaum, and, as He was teaching in a private house, a great multitude of people, coming to hear Him, filled the house and crowded round it. But behold, four men brought a paralytic on a bed, and as they could not get near to Jesus on account of the throng, they went up on the roof of the house, and making an opening, let down the paralytic in his bed.
Jesus, seeing their faith, said: “Son, be of good heart, thy sins are forgiven thee.”
Now there were among the crowd some Scribes and Pharisees, who, hearing these words, thought within themselves: “He blasphemeth. Who can forgive sins but God alone?” Jesus, seeing their thoughts, said to them: “Why do you think evil in your hearts? Which is easier, to say: ‘Thy sins are forgiven thee?’ or to say: ‘Rise up, take thy bed and walk?’ But that you may know that the Son of Man hath power on earth to forgive sins, I say to thee: ‘Arise, take up thy bed, and go into thy house.’” ​Immediately the man arose, took up his bed and went forth in the sight of all. And all the people wondered and glorified God, saying: “We never saw the like!”
COMMENTARY.
Proofs of our Lord's Divinity. i. He saw the contrition, faith and hope which were in the soul of the paralysed man, in the same manner as He read the secret thoughts of the Pharisees: therefore He was Omniscient. God alone is Omniscient: therefore Jesus is God. 2. Jesus is Omnipotent; for by His will and word He instantaneously cured the lame man. Even as at the creation He said: “Let things be,” so now He said to the palsied man: “Arise!” 3. Jesus, by His own power, absolved the lame man of his sins. This, as the Pharisees very rightly judged, is the prerogative of God, who is offended by sins, and who knows the heart of the sinner: therefore Jesus is God. Had He not been God, He would have been assuming to Himself a divine right and power, and would have been a deceiver and a blasphemer.
Blasphemy. It was the Pharisees who were blasphemers, because, in spite of His miracles and holiness, they despised Jesus and accused Him of blasphemy. Their reason must have told them that God would not be with a blasphemer, and that therefore no blasphemer could work such mighty miracles. But their evil wills and evil hearts obscured their reason, and made them obstinate and defiant. Their unbelief was without excuse.
The dignity of the soul. Jesus first healed the palsied man’s soul, and then his body. He desired to teach us by this that He came to cure and save souls, that the soul is worth more than the body, and that the health of the body can only avail those whose soul is healthy. Our love of ourselves ought therefore to be bestowed first of all on our souls.
The necessity of contrition. The sick man possessed real contrition. His sins oppressed and tormented him more than his bodily infirmity; ​and with one beseeching glance he prayed to Jesus for forgiveness. Jesus saw that the state of his soul pained him more than that of his body, and that what he most craved for was pardon and peace; and therefore He said to him: “Son, be of good heart, thy sins are forgiven.” If the sick man had had no contrition, he would not have obtained pardon.
The Compassion of Jesus on repentant sinners. He lovingly addressed the sick man as “son”, and consoled him.
The object of sufferings. The severe malady of the lame man was perhaps a consequence or a punishment of his sins. God allowed this terrible infirmity to overtake this sinner and torment his body, so that he might learn to repent of his sins, and thus save his soul from everlasting perdition.
Sins of thought. The Pharisees sinned grievously by thought.
The forgiveness of sins by priests. You have just heard that God alone can forgive sins. But does not a priest forgive sins in the Sacrament of Penance? Yes, but he does so not in his own name and by his own authority as Jesus did, but in the name and by the authority received from God — our Lord having left to the apostles and their successors the office of forgiving sins. By the Sacrament of Penance our Lord gave to his Church a really divine power, for the comfort and salvation of sinful men. Let us too, then, “glorify God who has given such power to men”.
Indulgences. The palsied man receives first the forgiveness of his sins, then his temporal punishment (the palsy) is removed. This is exactly what is done by indulgences, which are granted for the purpose of removing temporal punishment. Only he who is cleansed from mortal sin and is in a state of grace, can gain an indulgence.
Application. Do you suppress all bad thoughts — such as envy, pride, impurity, unkindness — as quickly as possible? God sees into your heart. If a bad thought occurs to you, say at once: “Begone!” and turn your thoughts to something that is holy.
Do you make a good act of thanksgiving after you have been to confession?
* ↑ A paralytic, i. e. one who was wholly paralysed, so that he could use none of his limbs, but had to be carried about.
* ↑ The throng. The people being packed together as tightly as they could be in the passages and rooms, passing through was quite an impossibility.
* ↑ On the roof. A staircase on the outside of the house led directly to the roof.
* ↑ An opening. By removing a part of the roof, which was at the same time the ceiling of the room below.
* ↑ Their faith. The extraordinary amount of trouble they had taken to convey the sick man to Jesus as speedily as possible, proved both their faith and their desire for help.
* ↑ Thy sins. As the lame man lay before Jesus and raised his eyes to Him, he trembled before the Holy One of God, and, contrite and abashed, cast down his eyes. But Jesus beheld his contrition, and tenderly, addressing him as “Son”, comforted him and forgave him his sins.
* ↑ Scribes and Pharisees. Our Lord’s miracles and increasing fame in Galilee bad stirred up the Pharisees and Scribes throughout the whole land. They came to Capharnaum not only from Galilee, but also from Judaea and Jerusalem to watch Jesus (Luke 5, 17).
* ↑ Which is easier? It is easy enough to say the first, for nobody can look into a man’s soul, and see whether he be really cleansed from sin or not. Any deceiver or false prophet could say such words without his deception being proved; but to say to a lame man “Rise up and walk” is a very much harder thing, for it can be proved on the spot whether his words have any power or no.
* ↑ Took up his bed. Our Lord, by His word, cured the man so instantaneously that he was able to take up and carry off his bed without help. This should have proved to the Pharisees that our Lord’s former words: “Thy sins are forgiven thee,” had been equally powerful, and had remitted the man's sins. Jesus had proved that He was no blasphemer; and as his enemies could not deny His power, they remained silent.
* ↑ Glorified God. The people were seized with a holy awe, for they felt that only a divine power could have worked such a miracle: and the Gospel says that “they glorified God who gave such power to men”. For as Jesus, the Son of Man, stood before them in a lowly human form, they did not perceive that He was God, and had worked this miracle by His own power, but believed that God had given the power to Him, a man.
Footnotes