# Five Esquisses

The Five Esquisses (in Finnish: Viisi luonnosta; in German: Fünf Skizzen), Op. 114, is a collection of compositions for piano written in February 1929 by the Finnish composer Jean Sibelius. The Five Esquisses represent—along with the Suite for Violin and String Orchestra in D minor (JS 185), as well as the Op. 115 and Op. 116 seven duos for violin and piano—the dawn of a "radical new stylistic period" for Sibelius. Indeed, these compositions could provide the best clues as to the "sound world" Sibelius's never-realized (and likely destroyed) Symphony No. 8 may have inhabited.

## History

The Five Esquisses have a tortuous publication history. On 5 October 1928, the New York-based publisher Carl Fischer expressing an interest in publishing "works for piano, voice and piano, and violin and piano ..." Sibelius responded to Fischer on 15 February 1929 that it was his "pleasure" to offer four collections of his latest miniatures: the Op. 114 Five Esquisses, as well as the Op. 115 Four Pieces for violin and piano, the Op. 116 Three Pieces for violin and piano, and the Op. 117 (later demoted from Sibelius's opus list) Suite for Violin and String Orchestra. However, Fischer rejected all four compositions:
   We must reluctantly inform you that in view of the extremely unfortunate constellation in the music publishing field in the United States, it seems to us inadvisable at the present time to publish compositions of the high standard which you have submitted to us. The market is very unfavorable for this class of music and we are compelled to return them to you with our regrets.
Shortly thereafter, Sibelius sent the pieces to Leipzig's Breitkopf & Härtel, and although they accepted the offer, Sibelius requested the manuscripts be returned to him so that he could revise Metsälaulu; after making the changes, however, he never mailed them back to Germany—likely due to the ever-worsening self-criticism that marred his later career. In 1945, the Helsinki-based published R. E. Westerlund [fi] inquired about the Five Esquisses: as with fifteen years prior, Sibelius initially agreed but changed his mind when preparing the manuscripts for publication. Westerlund's second attempt in 1950 was similarly unsuccessful. In the end, the pieces were published posthumously from 1973 to 1974 by Fazer Music [fi].

## Structure and music
### No. 1: Landscape

Landscape (in Finnish: Maisema) is marked Andantino.

### No. 2: Winter Scene

Winter Scene (in Finnish: Talvikuva) is marked Allegretto.

### No. 3: Forest Lake

Forest Lake (in Finnish: Metsälampi) is marked Con moto.

### No. 4: Song in the Forest

Song in the Forest (in Finnish: Metsälaulu) is marked Animato.

### No. 5: Spring Vision

Spring Vision (in Finnish: Kevätnäky) is without tempo marking.

## Discography

The Finnish pianist Liisa Karhilo made the world premiere studio recording of the Five Esquisses c. 1976 for the Musical Heritage Society. The sortable table below lists this and other commercially available recordings:
| No. | Pianist | Runtimes | Runtimes | Runtimes | Runtimes | Runtimes | Runtimes | Rec. | Recording venue | Label | Ref. |
| No. | Pianist | Op. 114/1 | Op. 114/2 | Op. 114/3 | Op. 114/4 | Op. 114/5 | Total | Rec. | Recording venue | Label | Ref. |
| 1 | Liisa Karhilo | | | | | | | c. 1976 | | Musical Heritage Society | |
| 2 | Tapani Valsta | 3:24 | 2:48 | 2:11 | 3:17 | 1:22 | 13:02 | 1975 | | Finlandia | |
| 3 | Erik T. Tawaststjerna | 2:34 | 2:16 | 1:37 | 2:22 | 1:34 | 10:40 | 1984 | Studio BIS, Djursholm | BIS | |
| 4 | Izumi Tateno | 2:15 | 2:04 | 1:06 | 1:39 | 1:35 | 8:39 | 1994 | Ainola | Canyon Classics | |
| 5 | Annette Servadei [ja] | 2:28 | 2:26 | 2:25 | 2:39 | 1:37 | 11:32 | 1994 | St George's Church, Brandon Hill | Olympia | |
| 6 | Ralf Gothoni | 1:57 | 2:10 | 2:03 | 2:06 | 2:25 | 10:34 | 1995 | Järvenpää Hall [fi] | Ondine | |
| 7 | Eero Heinonen [fi] | 2:52 | 2:07 | 1:32 | 2:23 | 1:33 | 10:27 | 1999 | YLE M2 Studio, Helsinki | Finlandia | |
| 8 | Kyoko Tabe [ja] | 2:24 | 2:18 | 1:38 | 2:04 | 1:57 | 10:29 | 1999 | New Broadcasting House, Manchester | Chandos | |
| 9 | Katriina Korte | 2:23 | 2:07 | 1:26 | 1:46 | 1:24 | 9:09 | 2001 | Järvenpää Hall [fi] | Alba [fi] | |
| 10 | Håvard Gimse | 2:21 | 2:58 | 1:23 | 2:16 | 1:44 | 10:44 | 2001 | St Martin's Church, East Woodhay | Naxos | |
| 11 | Kikuo Watanabe | 2:18 | 2:12 | 1:36 | 1:47 | 1:55 | 9:48 | 2003 | Tokyo Bunka Kaikan | Exton | |
| 12 | Vladimir Ashkenazy | 2:24 | 2:03 | 1:16 | 1:54 | 1:31 | 9:08 | 2007 | Järvenpää Hall [fi] | Exton | |
| 13 | Tuija Hakkila | 2:36 | 2:00 | 1:26 | 1:44 | 1:42 | 9:28 | 2008 | Nya Paviljongen | Alba [fi] | |
| 14 | Folke Gräsbeck [fi] | 2:35 | 2:28 | 1:27 | 2:46 | 1:53 | 11:25 | 2009 | Kuusankoski Hall [fi] | BIS | |
| 15 | Rudi Spring | 2:45 | 1:51 | 1:36 | 1:52 | 1:47 | 9:51 | 2009 | Sounddesign Peter Guschelbauer, Hagenberg | Alessa | |
| 16 | Joseph Tong | 2:24 | 2:22 | 1:23 | 2:05 | 1:37 | 9:51 | 2014 | Jacqueline Du Pré Music Building | Quartz | |
| 17 | Janne Mertanen | 2:09 | 2:24 | 1:54 | 1:57 | 2:13 | 10:37 | 2015 | [Unknown], Helsinki | Sony Classical | |
| 18 | Leif Ove Andsnes | 1:48 | 1:55 | 1:40 | 1:49 | 2:05 | 9:17 | 2016 | Teldex Studio | Sony Classical | |
| 19 | Yi Zhong | 2:53 | 2:19 | 2:16 | 2:34 | 2:00 | 12:02 | 2023 | [unknown] | TYXArt | |

## Notes, references, and sources
### Notes

* ↑ All runtimes are official, as printed on CD or LP liner notes.
* ↑ Refers to the year in which the performers recorded the work; this may not be the same as the year in which the recording was first released to the general public.
* ↑ L. Karhilo–Musical Heritage (MHS 3596) 1976
* ↑ T. Valsta–Finlandia (FACD 811) 1991
* ↑ E. Tawaststjerna–BIS (CD–278) 1987
* ↑ I. Tateno–Canyon Classics (PCCL–00243) 1994
* ↑ A. Servadei–Olympia (OCD 635) 1997
* ↑ R. Gothóni–Ondine (ODE 847–2) 1995
* ↑ E. Heinonen–Finlandia (8573–80776–2) 2000
* ↑ K. Tabe–Chandos (CHAN 9833) 2000
* ↑ K. Korte–Alba (ABCA 159) 2001
* ↑ H. Gimse–Naxos (8.555853) 2004
* ↑ K. Watanabe–Exton (OVCX–00009) 2004
* ↑ V. Ashkenazy–Exton (EXCL–00017) 2008
* ↑ T. Hakkila–Alba (ABCD 297) 2010
* ↑ F. Gräsbeck–BIS (CD–1927/29) 2010
* ↑ R. Spring–Alessa (ALC 2001) 2010
* ↑ J. Tong–Quartz (QTZ 2111) 2015
* ↑ J. Mertanen–Sony Classics (888751614222) 2015
* ↑ L. Andsnes–Sony Classics (886446267067) 2017
* ↑ Y. Zhong–TYXArt (TXA24187) 2023

### References

* 1 2 Dahlström 2003, pp. 485–487.
* ↑ Dahlström 2003, pp. 484, 486–487.
* 1 2 Dahlström 2003, p. 484.
* ↑ Barnett 2007, pp. 329–331.
* ↑ Dahlström 2003, pp. 484–485.
* 1 2 Dahlström 2003, p. 485.

### Sources

* Barnett, Andrew (2007). Sibelius. New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-16397-1.
* Dahlström, Fabian [in Swedish] (2003). Jean Sibelius: Thematisch-bibliographisches Verzeichnis seiner Werke [Jean Sibelius: A Thematic Bibliographic Index of His Works] (in German). Wiesbaden: Breitkopf & Härtel. ISBN 3-7651-0333-0.