# List of All Stars Awards winners (football)

This is a list of all past winners of the official GAA GPA All Stars Awards in Gaelic football since the first awards in 1971. As an insight to the prominent players of the 1960s, it also includes the unofficial "Cuchulainn" awards presented from 1963 to 1967 under the auspices of Gaelic Weekly magazine.
For each year since 1995, when the official award began, the All Stars Footballer of the Year is highlighted with $^{FOTY}$. If the footballer of the year did not win an All Star Award, his name is added to the list as FOTY. The unofficial Texaco Footballer of the Year, awarded since 1958, is a guide to the leading players of the past.

## Overview

By the end of 2013, 387 different footballers had received awards. For those with the highest numbers of awards, see GAA GPA All Stars Awards.
As of 2024, the players are from the following teams:
    Given as • Team, team's overall total/number of different players to have won while representing this team:
* Kerry, 159/64 (list)
* Dublin, 146/67 (list)
* Cork, 64/42 (list)
* Mayo, 54/33 (list)
* Tyrone, 58/33 (list)
* Meath, 48/26 (list)
* Galway, 48/34 (list)
* Donegal, 36/24 (list)
* Offaly, 30/19 (list)
* Armagh, 30/21 (list)
* Derry, 29/19 (list)
* Down, 23/18 (list)
* Roscommon, 16/12 (list)
* Kildare, 15/12 (list)
* Monaghan, 14/10 (list)
* Cavan, 5/5
* Laois, 5/5
* Westmeath, 5/4
* Sligo, 4/4
* Fermanagh, 4/3
* Tipperary, 4/3
* Leitrim, 2/2
* Louth, 2?
* Antrim, 1
* Clare, 1
* Wexford, 1
* Wicklow, 1
No player has received an All Star while representing Carlow, Kilkenny**, Limerick, Longford, Waterford, or the overseas county teams of London and New York in football.
** Kilkenny no longer competes in the All-Ireland Senior Football Championship.

## 1970s
### 1971

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | P. J. Smyth | Galway | 1 |
| RCB | Johnny Carey | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Jack Cosgrove | Galway | 1 |
| LCB | Donie O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| RWB | Eugene Mulligan | Offaly | 1 |
| CB | Nicholas Clavin | Offaly | 1 |
| LWB | Patrick Reynolds | Meath | 1 |
| MD | Liam Sammon | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Willie Bryan | Offaly | 1 |
| RWF | Tony McTague | Offaly | 1 |
| CF | Ray Cummins | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Mickey Kearins | Sligo | 1 |
| RCF | Andy McCallin | Antrim | 1 |
| FF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 1 |
| LCF | Seamus Leydon | Galway | 1 |

#### County breakdown

* Galway = 4
* Offaly = 4
* Mayo = 1
* Kerry = 1
* Meath = 1
* Cork = 1
* Sligo = 1
* Antrim = 1
* Down = 1

### 1972

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Martin Furlong | Offaly | 1 |
| RCB | Mick Ryan | Offaly | 1 |
| FB | Paddy McCormack | Offaly | 1 |
| LCB | Donie O'Sullivan | Kerry | 2 |
| RWB | Brian McEniff | Donegal | 1 |
| CB | Tommy Joe Gilmore | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Kevin Jer O'Sullivan | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Willie Bryan | Offaly | 2 |
| MD | Mick O'Connell | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Johnny Cooney | Offaly | 1 |
| CF | Kevin Kilmurray | Offaly | 1 |
| LWF | Tony McTague | Offaly | 2 |
| RCF | Mickey Freyne | Roscommon | 1 |
| FF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 2 |
| LCF | Paddy Moriarty | Armagh | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Offaly = 7
* Kerry = 2
* Donegal = 1
* Galway = 1
* Cork = 1
* Roscommon = 1
* Down = 1
* Armagh = 1

### 1973

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Billy Morgan | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Frank Cogan | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Mick Ryan | Offaly | 2 |
| LCB | Brian Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Liam O'Neill | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Tommy Joe Gilmore | Galway | 2 |
| LWB | Kevin Jer O'Sullivan | Cork | 2 |
| MD | John O'Keeffe | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Dinny Long | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Johnny Cooney | Offaly | 2 |
| CF | Kevin Kilmurray | Offaly | 2 |
| LWF | Liam Sammon | Galway | 2 |
| RCF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Ray Cummins | Cork | 2 |
| LCF | Anthony McGurk | Derry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Cork = 7
* Offaly = 3
* Galway = 3
* Kerry = 1
* Derry = 1

### 1974

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paddy Cullen | Dublin | 1 |
| RCB | Donal Monaghan | Donegal | 1 |
| FB | Seán Doherty | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Robbie Kelleher | Dublin | 1 |
| RWB | Paddy Reilly | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Barnes Murphy | Sligo | 1 |
| LWB | Johnny Hughes | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Dermot Earley | Roscommon | 1 |
| MD | Paudie Lynch | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Tom Naughton | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Declan Barron | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | David Hickey | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 2 |
| FF | Jimmy Keaveney | Dublin | 1 |
| LCF | John Tobin | Galway | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 6
* Galway = 3
* Cork = 2
* Donegal = 1
* Sligo = 1
* Roscommon = 1
* Kerry = 1

### 1975

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paudie O'Mahony | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Gay O'Driscoll | Dublin | 1 |
| FB | John O'Keeffe | Kerry | 2 |
| LCB | Robbie Kelleher | Dublin | 2 |
| RWB | Peter Stevenson | Derry | 1 |
| CB | Anthony McGurk | Derry | 2 |
| LWB | Ger Power | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Dinny Long | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Colm McAlarney | Down | 1 |
| RWF | Gerry McElhinney | Derry | 1 |
| CF | Ken Rennicks | Meath | 1 |
| LWF | Mickey O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| RCF | John Egan | Kerry | 1 |
| FF | Mattie Kerrigan | Meath | 1 |
| LCF | Anton O'Toole | Dublin | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 5
* Dublin = 3
* Derry = 3
* Meath = 2
* Cork = 1
* Down = 1

### 1976

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paddy Cullen | Dublin | 2 |
| RCB | Ger O'Keeffe | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | John O'Keeffe | Kerry | 3 |
| LCB | Brian Murphy | Cork | 2 |
| RWB | Johnny Hughes | Galway | 2 |
| CB | Kevin Moran | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Ger Power | Kerry | 2 |
| MD | Brian Mullins | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Dave McCarthy | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Anton O'Toole | Dublin | 2 |
| CF | Tony Hanahoe | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | David Hickey | Dublin | 2 |
| RCF | Bobby Doyle | Dublin | 1 |
| FF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 1 |
| LCF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 7
* Kerry = 5
* Cork = 2
* Galway = 1

### 1977

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paddy Cullen | Dublin | 3 |
| RCB | Gay O'Driscoll | Dublin | 2 |
| FB | Pat Lindsay | Roscommon | 1 |
| LCB | Robbie Kelleher | Dublin | 3 |
| RWB | Tommy Drumm | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Paddy Moriarty | Armagh | 2 |
| LWB | Pat O'Neill | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Brian Mullins | Dublin | 2 |
| MD | Joe Kernan | Armagh | 1 |
| RWF | Anton O'Toole | Dublin | 3 |
| CF | Jimmy Smyth | Armagh | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 2 |
| RCF | Bobby Doyle | Dublin | 2 |
| FF | Jimmy Keaveney | Dublin | 2 |
| LCF | John Egan | Kerry | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 9
* Armagh = 3
* Kerry = 2
* Roscommon = 1

### 1978

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ollie Crinnigan | Kildare | 1 |
| RCB | Harry Keegan | Roscommon | 1 |
| FB | John O'Keeffe | Kerry | 4 |
| LCB | Robbie Kelleher | Dublin | 4 |
| RWB | Tommy Drumm | Dublin | 2 |
| CB | Ollie Brady | Cavan | 1 |
| LWB | Paudie Lynch | Kerry | 2 |
| MD | Colm McAlarney | Down | 2 |
| MD | Tomás O'Connor | Offaly | 1 |
| RWF | Ger Power | Kerry | 3 |
| CF | Declan Barron | Cork | 2 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 3 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 2 |
| FF | Jimmy Keaveney | Dublin | 3 |
| LCF | John Egan | Kerry | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Dublin = 3
* Kildare = 1
* Roscommon = 1
* Cavan = 1
* Down = 1
* Offaly = 1
* Cork = 1

### 1979

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paddy Cullen | Dublin | 4 |
| RCB | Eugene Hughes | Monaghan | 1 |
| FB | John O'Keeffe | Kerry | 5 |
| LCB | Tom Heneghan | Roscommon | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Drumm | Dublin | 3 |
| CB | Tim Kennelly | Kerry | 1 |
| LWB | Danny Murray | Roscommon | 1 |
| MD | Dermot Earley | Roscommon | 2 |
| MD | Bernard Brogan | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Ger Power | Kerry | 4 |
| CF | Seán Walsh | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 4 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 3 |
| FF | Seán Lowry | Offaly | 1 |
| LCF | Joe McGrath | Mayo | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Dublin = 3
* Roscommon = 3
* Monaghan = 1
* Offaly = 1
* Mayo = 1

## 1980s
### 1980

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Charlie Nelligan | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Harry Keegan | Roscommon | 2 |
| FB | Kevin Kehilly | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Gerry Connellan | Roscommon | 1 |
| RWB | Kevin McCabe | Tyrone | 1 |
| CB | Tim Kennelly | Kerry | 2 |
| LWB | Danny Murray | Roscommon | 2 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Colum McKinstry | Armagh | 1 |
| RWF | Ger Power | Kerry | 5 |
| CF | Dinny Allen | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 5 |
| RCF | Matt Connor | Offaly | 1 |
| FF | Eoin Liston | Kerry | 1 |
| LCF | John Egan | Kerry | 4 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 7
* Roscommon = 3
* Cork = 2
* Tyrone = 1
* Armagh = 1
* Offaly = 1

### 1981

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Martin Furlong | Offaly | 2 |
| RCB | Jimmy Deenihan | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | Paddy Kennedy | Down | 1 |
| LCB | Paudie Lynch | Kerry | 3 |
| RWB | Páidí Ó Sé | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Richie Connor | Offaly | 1 |
| LWB | Séamus McHugh | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 2 |
| MD | Seán Walsh | Kerry | 2 |
| RWF | Barry Brennan | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Denis 'Ogie' Moran | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 6 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 4 |
| FF | Eoin Liston | Kerry | 2 |
| LCF | Brendan Lowry | Offaly | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 9
* Offaly = 3
* Galway = 2
* Down = 1

### 1982

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Martin Furlong | Offaly | 3 |
| RCB | Mick Fitzgerald | Offaly | 1 |
| FB | Liam O'Connor | Offaly | 1 |
| LCB | Kevin Kehilly | Cork | 2 |
| RWB | Páidí Ó Sé | Kerry | 2 |
| CB | Seán Lowry | Offaly | 2 |
| LWB | Liam Currams | Offaly | 1 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 3 |
| MD | Pádraig Dunne | Offaly | 1 |
| RWF | Peter McGinnity | Fermanagh | 1 |
| CF | Joe Kernan | Armagh | 2 |
| LWF | Matt Connor | Offaly | 2 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 5 |
| FF | Eoin Liston | Kerry | 3 |
| LCF | John Egan | Kerry | 5 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Offaly = 7
* Kerry = 5
* Cork = 1
* Fermanagh = 1
* Armagh = 1

### 1983

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Martin Furlong | Offaly | 4 |
| RCB | Páidí Ó Sé | Kerry | 3 |
| FB | Stephen Kinneavy | Galway | 1 |
| LCB | John Evans | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Pat Canavan | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Tommy Drumm | Dublin | 4 |
| LWB | Jimmy Kerrigan | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 4 |
| MD | Liam Austin | Down | 1 |
| RWF | Barney Rock | Dublin | 1 |
| CF | Matt Connor | Offaly | 3 |
| LWF | Greg Blaney | Down | 1 |
| RCF | Martin McHugh | Donegal | 1 |
| FF | Colm O'Rourke | Meath | 1 |
| LCF | Joe McNally | Dublin | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 4
* Kerry = 2
* Offaly = 2
* Cork = 2
* Down = 2
* Galway = 1
* Donegal = 1
* Meath = 1

### 1984

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John O'Leary | Dublin | 1 |
| RCB | Páidí Ó Sé | Kerry | 4 |
| FB | Mick Lyons | Meath | 1 |
| LCB | Séamus McHugh | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Tommy Doyle | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Tom Spillane | Kerry | 1 |
| LWB | P. J. Buckley | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 5 |
| MD | Eugene McKenna | Tyrone | 1 |
| RWF | Barney Rock | Dublin | 2 |
| CF | Eoin Liston | Kerry | 4 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 7 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 6 |
| FF | Frank McGuigan | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCF | Dermot McNicholl | Derry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 7
* Dublin = 3
* Tyrone = 2
* Meath = 1
* Galway = 1
* Derry = 1

### 1985

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John O'Leary | Dublin | 2 |
| RCB | Páidí Ó Sé | Kerry | 5 |
| FB | Gerry Hargan | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Mick Spillane | Kerry | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Doyle | Kerry | 2 |
| CB | Ciarán Murray | Monaghan | 1 |
| LWB | Dermot Flanagan | Mayo | 1 |
| MD | Jack O'Shea | Kerry | 6 |
| MD | Willie Joe Padden | Mayo | 1 |
| RWF | Barney Rock | Dublin | 3 |
| CF | Tommy Conroy | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 8 |
| RCF | Kevin McStay | Mayo | 1 |
| FF | Paul Earley | Roscommon | 1 |
| LCF | Eugene Hughes | Monaghan | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 5
* Dublin = 4
* Mayo = 3
* Monaghan = 1
* Roscommon = 1

### 1986

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Charlie Nelligan | Kerry | 2 |
| RCB | Harry Keegan | Roscommon | 3 |
| FB | Mick Lyons | Meath | 2 |
| LCB | John Lynch | Tyrone | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Doyle | Kerry | 3 |
| CB | Tom Spillane | Kerry | 2 |
| LWB | Colm Browne | Laois | 1 |
| MD | Plunkett Donaghy | Tyrone | 1 |
| MD | Liam Irwin | Laois | 1 |
| RWF | Ray McCarron | Monaghan | 1 |
| CF | Eugene McKenna | Tyrone | 2 |
| LWF | Pat Spillane | Kerry | 9 |
| RCF | Mikey Sheehy | Kerry | 7 |
| FF | Damien O'Hagan | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCF | Ger Power | Kerry | 6 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Tyrone = 4
* Laois = 2
* Roscommon = 1
* Meath = 1
* Monaghan = 1

### 1987

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John Kerins | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Robbie O'Malley | Meath | 1 |
| FB | Colman Corrigan | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Tony Scullion | Derry | 1 |
| RWB | Niall Cahalane | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Tom Spillane | Kerry | 3 |
| LWB | Ger Lynch | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Gerry McEntee | Meath | 1 |
| MD | Brian McGilligan | Derry | 1 |
| RWF | David Beggy | Meath | 1 |
| CF | Larry Tompkins | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Kieran Duff | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Val Daly | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Brian Stafford | Meath | 1 |
| LCF | Bernard Flynn | Meath | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Meath = 5
* Cork = 4
* Derry = 2
* Kerry = 2
* Dublin = 1
* Galway = 1

### 1988

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paddy Linden | Monaghan | 1 |
| RCB | Robbie O'Malley | Meath | 2 |
| FB | Colman Corrigan | Cork | 2 |
| LCB | Mick Kennedy | Dublin | 1 |
| RWB | Niall Cahalane | Cork | 2 |
| CB | Noel McCaffrey | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Martin O'Connell | Meath | 1 |
| MD | Shea Fahy | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Liam Hayes | Meath | 1 |
| RWF | Maurice Fitzgerald | Kerry | 1 |
| CF | Larry Tompkins | Cork | 2 |
| LWF | Kieran Duff | Dublin | 2 |
| RCF | Colm O'Rourke | Meath | 2 |
| FF | Brian Stafford | Meath | 2 |
| LCF | Eugene Hughes | Monaghan | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Meath = 5
* Cork = 4
* Dublin = 3
* Monaghan = 2
* Kerry = 1

### 1989

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Gabriel Irwin | Mayo | 1 |
| RCB | Jimmy Browne | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Gerry Hargan | Dublin | 2 |
| LCB | Dermot Flanagan | Mayo | 2 |
| RWB | Connie Murphy | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Conor Counihan | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Tony Davis | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Teddy McCarthy | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Willie Joe Padden | Mayo | 2 |
| RWF | Dave Barry | Cork | 1 |
| CF | Larry Tompkins | Cork | 3 |
| LWF | Noel Durkin | Mayo | 1 |
| RCF | Paul McGrath | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Eugene McKenna | Tyrone | 3 |
| LCF | Tony McManus | Roscommon | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Cork = 6
* Mayo = 5
* Dublin = 1
* Kerry = 1
* Tyrone = 1
* Roscommon = 1

## 1990s
### 1990

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John Kerins | Cork | 2 |
| RCB | Robbie O'Malley | Meath | 3 |
| FB | Steven O'Brien | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Terry Ferguson | Meath | 1 |
| RWB | Michael Slocum | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Conor Counihan | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | Martin O'Connell | Meath | 2 |
| MD | Shea Fahy | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Mickey Quinn | Leitrim | 1 |
| RWF | David Beggy | Meath | 2 |
| CF | Val Daly | Galway | 2 |
| LWF | Joyce McMullan | Donegal | 1 |
| RCF | Paul McGrath | Cork | 2 |
| FF | Kevin O'Brien | Wicklow | 1 |
| LCF | James McCartan Jnr | Down | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Cork = 6
* Meath = 4
* Leitrim = 1
* Galway = 1
* Donegal = 1
* Wicklow = 1
* Down = 1

### 1991

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Michael McQuillan | Meath | 1 |
| RCB | Mick Deegan | Dublin | 1 |
| FB | Conor Deegan | Down | 1 |
| LCB | Enon Gavin | Roscommon | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Carr | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Keith Barr | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Martin O'Connell | Meath | 3 |
| MD | Barry Breen | Down | 1 |
| MD | Martin Lynch | Kildare | 1 |
| RWF | Ross Carr | Down | 1 |
| CF | Greg Blaney | Down | 2 |
| LWF | Tommy Dowd | Meath | 1 |
| RCF | Colm O'Rourke | Meath | 3 |
| FF | Brian Stafford | Meath | 3 |
| LCF | Bernard Flynn | Meath | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Meath = 6
* Down = 4
* Dublin = 3
* Roscommon = 1
* Kildare = 1

### 1992

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Gary Walsh | Donegal | 1 |
| RCB | Seamus Clancy | Clare | 1 |
| FB | Matt Gallagher | Donegal | 1 |
| LCB | Tony Scullion | Derry | 2 |
| RWB | Paul Curran | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Martin Gavigan | Donegal | 1 |
| LWB | Eamon Heery | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Anthony Molloy | Donegal | 1 |
| MD | T. J. Kilgallon | Mayo | 1 |
| RWF | Anthony Tohill | Derry | 1 |
| CF | Martin McHugh | Donegal | 2 |
| LWF | James McHugh | Donegal | 1 |
| RCF | Tony Boyle | Donegal | 1 |
| FF | Vinny Murphy | Dublin | 1 |
| LCF | Enda Gormley | Derry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Donegal = 7
* Derry = 3
* Dublin = 3
* Clare = 1
* Mayo = 1

### 1993

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John O'Leary | Dublin | 3 |
| RCB | John Joe Doherty | Donegal | 1 |
| FB | Dermot Deasy | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Tony Scullion | Derry | 3 |
| RWB | Johnny McGurk | Derry | 1 |
| CB | Henry Downey | Derry | 1 |
| LWB | Gary Coleman | Derry | 1 |
| MD | Anthony Tohill | Derry | 2 |
| MD | Brian McGilligan | Derry | 2 |
| RWF | Kevin O'Neill | Mayo | 1 |
| CF | Joe Kavanagh | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Charlie Redmond | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Colin Corkery | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Ger Houlahan | Armagh | 1 |
| LCF | Enda Gormley | Derry | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Derry = 7
* Dublin = 3
* Cork = 2
* Donegal = 1
* Mayo = 1
* Armagh = 1

### 1994

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John O'Leary | Dublin | 4 |
| RCB | Miceal Magill | Down | 1 |
| FB | Seamus Quinn | Leitrim | 1 |
| LCB | Paul Higgins | Down | 1 |
| RWB | Graham Geraghty | Meath | 1 |
| CB | Steven O'Brien | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | D. J. Kane | Down | 1 |
| MD | Jack Sheedy | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Gregory McCartan | Down | 1 |
| RWF | Peter Canavan | Tyrone | 1 |
| CF | Greg Blaney | Down | 3 |
| LWF | James McCartan Jnr | Down | 2 |
| RCF | Mickey Linden | Down | 1 |
| FF | Tommy Dowd | Meath | 2 |
| LCF | Charlie Redmond | Dublin | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Down = 7
* Dublin = 3
* Meath = 2
* Leitrim = 1
* Cork = 1
* Tyrone = 1

### 1995

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John O'Leary | Dublin | 5 |
| RCB | Tony Scullion | Derry | 4 |
| FB | Mark O'Connor | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Fay Devlin | Tyrone | 1 |
| RWB | Paul Curran | Dublin | 2 |
| CB | Keith Barr | Dublin | 2 |
| LWB | Steven O'Brien | Cork | 3 |
| MD | Brian Stynes | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Anthony Tohill | Derry | 3 |
| RWF | Jarlath Fallon | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Dessie Farrell | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | Paul Clarke | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Tommy Dowd | Meath | 3 |
| FF | Peter Canavan$^{FOTY}$ | Tyrone | 2 |
| LCF | Charlie Redmond | Dublin | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 7
* Derry = 2
* Cork = 2
* Tyrone = 2
* Galway = 1
* Meath = 1

### 1996

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Finbar McConnell | Tyrone | 1 |
| RCB | Kenneth Mortimer | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Darren Fay | Meath | 1 |
| LCB | Martin O'Connell | Meath | 4 |
| RWB | Pat Holmes | Mayo | 1 |
| CB | James Nallen | Mayo | 1 |
| LWB | Paul Curran | Dublin | 3 |
| MD | John McDermott | Meath | 1 |
| MD | Liam McHale | Mayo | 1 |
| RWF | Trevor Giles$^{FOTY}$ | Meath | 1 |
| CF | Tommy Dowd | Meath | 4 |
| LWF | James Horan | Mayo | 1 |
| RCF | Joe Brolly | Derry | 1 |
| FF | Peter Canavan | Tyrone | 3 |
| LCF | Maurice Fitzgerald | Kerry | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Meath = 5
* Mayo = 5
* Tyrone = 2
* Dublin = 1
* Derry = 1
* Kerry = 1

### 1997

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Declan O'Keeffe | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Kenneth Mortimer | Mayo | 2 |
| FB | Davy Dalton | Kildare | 1 |
| LCB | Cathal Daly | Offaly | 1 |
| RWB | Séamus Moynihan | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Glenn Ryan | Kildare | 1 |
| LWB | Eamonn Breen | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Pat Fallon | Mayo | 1 |
| MD | Niall Buckley | Kildare | 1 |
| RWF | Pa Laide | Kerry | 1 |
| CF | Trevor Giles | Meath | 2 |
| LWF | Dermot McCabe | Cavan | 1 |
| RCF | Joe Brolly | Derry | 2 |
| FF | Brendan Reilly | Meath | 1 |
| LCF | Maurice Fitzgerald$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 5
* Kildare = 3
* Mayo = 2
* Meath = 2
* Offaly = 1
* Cavan = 1
* Derry = 1
List of nominees

### 1998

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Martin McNamara | Galway | 1 |
| RCB | Brian Lacey | Kildare | 1 |
| FB | Seán Marty Lockhart | Derry | 1 |
| LCB | Tomás Mannion | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | John Finn | Kildare | 1 |
| CB | Glenn Ryan | Kildare | 2 |
| LWB | Seán Óg de Paor | Galway | 1 |
| MD | John McDermott | Meath | 2 |
| MD | Kevin Walsh | Galway | 1 |
| RWF | Michael Donnellan | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Jarlath Fallon$^{FOTY}$ | Galway | 2 |
| LWF | Dermot Earley | Kildare | 1 |
| RCF | Karl O'Dwyer | Kildare | 1 |
| FF | Pádraic Joyce | Galway | 1 |
| LCF | Declan Browne | Tipperary | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Galway = 7
* Kildare = 5
* Derry = 1
* Meath = 1
* Tipperary = 1
List of nominees

### 1999

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Kevin O'Dwyer | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Mark O'Reilly | Meath | 1 |
| FB | Darren Fay | Meath | 2 |
| LCB | Anthony Lynch | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Ciarán O'Sullivan | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Kieran McGeeney | Armagh | 1 |
| LWB | Paddy Reynolds | Meath | 1 |
| MD | John McDermott | Meath | 3 |
| MD | Ciarán Whelan | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Diarmaid Marsden | Armagh | 1 |
| CF | Trevor Giles$^{FOTY}$ | Meath | 3 |
| LWF | James Horan | Mayo | 2 |
| RCF | Philip Clifford | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Graham Geraghty | Meath | 2 |
| LCF | Ollie Murphy | Meath | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Meath = 7
* Cork = 4
* Armagh = 2
* Dublin = 1
* Mayo = 1
List of nominees

## 2000s
### 2000

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Declan O'Keeffe | Kerry | 2 |
| RCB | Kieran McKeever | Derry | 1 |
| FB | Séamus Moynihan$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 2 |
| LCB | Mike McCarthy | Kerry | 1 |
| RWB | Declan Meehan | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Kieran McGeeney | Armagh | 2 |
| LWB | Anthony Rainbow | Kildare | 1 |
| MD | Anthony Tohill | Derry | 4 |
| MD | Darragh Ó Sé | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Michael Donnellan | Galway | 2 |
| CF | Liam Hassett | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Oisín McConville | Armagh | 1 |
| RCF | Mike Frank Russell | Kerry | 1 |
| FF | Pádraic Joyce | Galway | 2 |
| LCF | Derek Savage | Galway | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Galway = 4
* Derry = 2
* Armagh = 2
* Kildare = 1
List of nominees

### 2001

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Cormac Sullivan | Meath | 1 |
| RCB | Kieran Fitzgerald | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Darren Fay | Meath | 3 |
| LCB | Coman Goggins | Dublin | 1 |
| RWB | Declan Meehan$^{FOTY}$ | Galway | 2 |
| CB | Francie Grehan | Roscommon | 1 |
| LWB | Seán Óg de Paor | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Kevin Walsh | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Rory O'Connell | Westmeath | 1 |
| RWF | Evan Kelly | Meath | 1 |
| CF | Stephen O'Neill | Tyrone | 1 |
| LWF | Michael Donnellan | Galway | 3 |
| RCF | Ollie Murphy | Meath | 2 |
| FF | Pádraic Joyce | Galway | 3 |
| LCF | Johnny Crowley | Kerry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Galway = 6
* Meath = 4
* Dublin = 1
* Roscommon = 1
* Westmeath = 1
* Tyrone = 1
* Kerry = 1
List of nominees

### 2002

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 1 |
| RCB | Enda McNulty | Armagh | 1 |
| FB | Paddy Christie | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Anthony Lynch | Cork | 2 |
| RWB | Aidan O'Rourke | Armagh | 1 |
| CB | Kieran McGeeney$^{FOTY}$ | Armagh | 3 |
| LWB | Kevin Cassidy | Donegal | 1 |
| MD | Darragh Ó Sé | Kerry | 2 |
| MD | Paul McGrane | Armagh | 1 |
| RWF | Steven McDonnell | Armagh | 1 |
| CF | Eamonn O'Hara | Sligo | 1 |
| LWF | Oisín McConville | Armagh | 2 |
| RCF | Peter Canavan | Tyrone | 4 |
| FF | Ray Cosgrove | Dublin | 1 |
| LCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Armagh = 6
* Dublin = 3
* Kerry = 2
* Cork = 1
* Donegal = 1
* Sligo = 1
* Tyrone = 1
List of nominees

### 2003

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Fergal Byron | Laois | 1 |
| RCB | Francie Bellew | Armagh | 1 |
| FB | Cormac McAnallen | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCB | Joe Higgins | Laois | 1 |
| RWB | Conor Gormley | Tyrone | 1 |
| CB | Tom Kelly | Laois | 1 |
| LWB | Philip Jordan | Tyrone | 1 |
| MD | Kevin Walsh | Galway | 3 |
| MD | Seán Cavanagh | Tyrone | 1 |
| RWF | Brian Dooher | Tyrone | 1 |
| CF | Brian McGuigan | Tyrone | 1 |
| LWF | Declan Browne | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCF | Steven McDonnell$^{FOTY}$ | Armagh | 2 |
| FF | Peter Canavan | Tyrone | 4 |
| LCF | Adrian Sweeney | Donegal | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Tyrone = 7
* Laois = 3
* Armagh = 2
* Galway = 1
* Tipperary = 1
* Donegal = 1
List of nominees

### 2004

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Diarmuid Murphy | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Tom O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | Barry Owens | Fermanagh | 1 |
| LCB | Mike McCarthy | Kerry | 2 |
| RWB | Tomás Ó Sé$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | James Nallen | Mayo | 2 |
| LWB | John Keane | Westmeath | 1 |
| MD | Martin McGrath | Fermanagh | 1 |
| MD | Seán Cavanagh | Tyrone | 2 |
| RWF | Paul Galvin | Kerry | 1 |
| CF | Ciarán McDonald | Mayo | 1 |
| LWF | Dessie Dolan | Westmeath | 1 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 2 |
| FF | Enda Muldoon | Derry | 1 |
| LCF | Matty Forde | Wexford | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Fermanagh = 2
* Mayo = 2
* Westmeath = 2
* Tyrone = 1
* Derry = 1
* Wexford = 1
List of nominees

### 2005

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Diarmuid Murphy | Kerry | 2 |
| RCB | Ryan McMenamin | Tyrone | 1 |
| FB | Mike McCarthy | Kerry | 3 |
| LCB | Andy Mallon | Armagh | 1 |
| RWB | Tomás Ó Sé | Kerry | 2 |
| CB | Conor Gormley | Tyrone | 2 |
| LWB | Philip Jordan | Tyrone | 2 |
| MD | Seán Cavanagh | Tyrone | 3 |
| MD | Paul McGrane | Armagh | 2 |
| RWF | Brian Dooher | Tyrone | 2 |
| CF | Peter Canavan | Tyrone | 6 |
| LWF | Owen Mulligan | Tyrone | 1 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 3 |
| FF | Stephen O'Neill$^{FOTY}$ | Tyrone | 2 |
| LCF | Steven McDonnell | Armagh | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Tyrone = 8
* Kerry = 4
* Armagh = 3
List of nominees

### 2006

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 2 |
| RCB | Marc Ó Sé | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | Barry Owens | Fermanagh | 2 |
| LCB | Karl Lacey | Donegal | 1 |
| RWB | Séamus Moynihan | Kerry | 3 |
| CB | Ger Spillane | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Aidan O'Mahony | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Darragh Ó Sé | Kerry | 3 |
| MD | Nicholas Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Paul Galvin | Kerry | 2 |
| CF | Alan Brogan | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | Alan Dillon | Mayo | 1 |
| RCF | Conor Mortimer | Mayo | 1 |
| FF | Kieran Donaghy$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 1 |
| LCF | Rónán Clarke | Armagh | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Dublin = 2
* Cork = 2
* Mayo = 2
* Fermanagh = 1
* Donegal = 1
* Armagh = 1
List of nominees

### 2007

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 3 |
| RCB | Marc Ó Sé$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 2 |
| FB | Kevin McCloy | Derry | 1 |
| LCB | Graham Canty | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Tomás Ó Sé | Kerry | 3 |
| CB | Aidan O'Mahony | Kerry | 2 |
| LWB | Barry Cahill | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Ciarán Whelan | Dublin | 2 |
| MD | Darragh Ó Sé | Kerry | 4 |
| RWF | Stephen Bray | Meath | 1 |
| CF | Declan O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Alan Brogan | Dublin | 2 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 4 |
| FF | Paddy Bradley | Derry | 1 |
| LCF | Tomás Freeman | Monaghan | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 6
* Dublin = 4
* Derry = 2
* Cork = 1
* Meath = 1
* Monaghan = 1
List of nominees

### 2008

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Gary Connaughton | Westmeath | 1 |
| RCB | Conor Gormley | Tyrone | 3 |
| FB | Justin McMahon | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCB | John Keane | Westmeath | 2 |
| RWB | Davy Harte | Tyrone | 1 |
| CB | Tomás Ó Sé | Kerry | 4 |
| LWB | Philip Jordan | Tyrone | 3 |
| MD | Enda McGinley | Tyrone | 1 |
| MD | Shane Ryan | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Brian Dooher | Tyrone | 3 |
| CF | Declan O'Sullivan | Kerry | 2 |
| LWF | Seán Cavanagh$^{FOTY}$ | Tyrone | 4 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 5 |
| FF | Kieran Donaghy | Kerry | 2 |
| LCF | Rónán Clarke | Armagh | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Tyrone = 7
* Kerry = 4
* Westmeath = 2
* Dublin = 1
* Armagh = 1
List of nominees

### 2009

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Diarmuid Murphy | Kerry | 3 |
| RCB | Karl Lacey | Donegal | 2 |
| FB | Michael Shields | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Tom O'Sullivan | Kerry | 2 |
| RWB | Tomás Ó Sé | Kerry | 5 |
| CB | Graham Canty | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | John Miskella | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Dermot Earley | Kildare | 2 |
| MD | Séamus Scanlon | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Paul Galvin$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 3 |
| CF | Pearse O'Neill | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Tadhg Kennelly | Kerry | 1 |
| RCF | Daniel Goulding | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Declan O'Sullivan | Kerry | 3 |
| LCF | Stephen O'Neill | Tyrone | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 7
* Cork = 5
* Donegal = 1
* Kildare = 1
* Tyrone = 1
List of nominees

## 2010s
### 2010

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan McVeigh | Down | 1 |
| RCB | Peter Kelly | Kildare | 1 |
| FB | Michael Shields | Cork | 2 |
| LCB | Charlie Harrison | Sligo | 1 |
| RWB | Paudie Kissane | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Graham Canty | Cork | 3 |
| LWB | Philip Jordan | Tyrone | 4 |
| MD | Paddy Keenan | Louth | 1 |
| MD | Aidan Walsh | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Daniel Hughes | Down | 1 |
| CF | Martin Clarke | Down | 1 |
| LWF | Johnny Doyle | Kildare | 1 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 6 |
| FF | Bernard Brogan$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 1 |
| LCF | Benny Coulter | Down | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Cork = 4
* Down = 4
* Kildare = 2
* Sligo = 1
* Louth = 1
* Tyrone = 1
* Kerry = 1
* Dublin = 1
List of nominations

### 2011

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 4 |
| RCB | Marc Ó Sé | Kerry | 3 |
| FB | Neil McGee | Donegal | 1 |
| LCB | Michael Foley | Kildare | 1 |
| RWB | Kevin Cassidy | Donegal | 2 |
| CB | Karl Lacey | Donegal | 3 |
| LWB | Kevin Nolan | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Bryan Sheehan | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Michael Darragh MacAuley | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Darran O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| CF | Alan Brogan$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 3 |
| LWF | Paul Flynn | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 7 |
| FF | Andy Moran | Mayo | 1 |
| LCF | Bernard Brogan | Dublin | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 6
* Kerry = 4
* Donegal = 3
* Mayo = 1
* Kildare = 1
List of nominees

### 2012

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paul Durcan | Donegal | 1 |
| RCB | Neil McGee | Donegal | 2 |
| FB | Ger Cafferkey | Mayo | 1 |
| LCB | Keith Higgins | Mayo | 1 |
| RWB | Lee Keegan | Mayo | 1 |
| CB | Karl Lacey$^{FOTY}$ | Donegal | 4 |
| LWB | Frank McGlynn | Donegal | 1 |
| MD | Neil Gallagher | Donegal | 1 |
| MD | Aidan Walsh | Cork | 2 |
| RWF | Paul Flynn | Dublin | 2 |
| CF | Alan Dillon | Mayo | 2 |
| LWF | Mark McHugh | Donegal | 1 |
| RCF | Colm O'Neill | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Michael Murphy | Donegal | 1 |
| LCF | Colm McFadden | Donegal | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Donegal = 8
* Mayo = 4
* Cork = 2
* Dublin = 1
List of nominees

### 2013

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 5 |
| RCB | Colin Walshe | Monaghan | 1 |
| FB | Rory O'Carroll | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Keith Higgins | Mayo | 2 |
| RWB | Lee Keegan | Mayo | 2 |
| CB | Cian O'Sullivan | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Colm Boyle | Mayo | 1 |
| MD | Michael Darragh MacAuley$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 2 |
| MD | Aidan O'Shea | Mayo | 1 |
| RWF | Paul Flynn | Dublin | 3 |
| CF | Colm Cooper | Kerry | 8 |
| LWF | Seán Cavanagh | Tyrone | 5 |
| RCF | James O'Donoghue | Kerry | 1 |
| FF | Bernard Brogan | Dublin | 3 |
| LCF | Conor McManus | Monaghan | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 6
* Mayo = 4
* Monaghan = 2
* Kerry = 2
* Tyrone = 1
List of nominees

### 2014

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Paul Durcan | Donegal | 2 |
| RCB | Paul Murphy | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | Neil McGee | Donegal | 3 |
| LCB | Keith Higgins | Mayo | 3 |
| RWB | James McCarthy | Dublin | 1 |
| CB | Peter Crowley | Kerry | 1 |
| LWB | Colm Boyle | Mayo | 2 |
| MD | Neil Gallagher | Donegal | 2 |
| MD | David Moran | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Paul Flynn | Dublin | 4 |
| CF | Michael Murphy | Donegal | 2 |
| LWF | Diarmuid Connolly | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Cillian O'Connor | Mayo | 1 |
| FF | Kieran Donaghy | Kerry | 3 |
| LCF | James O'Donoghue$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry= 5
* Donegal= 4
* Dublin= 3
* Mayo= 3
List of nominees

### 2015

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Kealy | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Shane Enright | Kerry | 1 |
| FB | Rory O'Carroll | Dublin | 2 |
| LCB | Philly McMahon | Dublin | 1 |
| RWB | Lee Keegan | Mayo | 3 |
| CB | Cian O'Sullivan | Dublin | 2 |
| LWB | Jack McCaffrey$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Brian Fenton | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Anthony Maher | Kerry | 1 |
| RWF | Mattie Donnelly | Tyrone | 1 |
| CF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | Donnchadh Walsh | Kerry | 1 |
| RCF | Conor McManus | Monaghan | 2 |
| FF | Aidan O'Shea | Mayo | 2 |
| LCF | Bernard Brogan | Dublin | 4 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin= 7
* Kerry= 4
* Mayo= 2
* Tyrone= 1
* Monaghan= 1
List of nominees

### 2016

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | David Clarke | Mayo | 1 |
| RCB | Brendan Harrison | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Jonny Cooper | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Philly McMahon | Dublin | 2 |
| RWB | Lee Keegan$^{FOTY}$ | Mayo | 4 |
| CB | Colm Boyle | Mayo | 3 |
| LWB | Ryan McHugh | Donegal | 1 |
| MD | Brian Fenton | Dublin | 2 |
| MD | Mattie Donnelly | Tyrone | 2 |
| RWF | Peter Harte | Tyrone | 1 |
| CF | Diarmuid Connolly | Dublin | 2 |
| LWF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 2 |
| RCF | Dean Rock | Dublin | 1 |
| FF | Michael Quinlivan | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCF | Paul Geaney | Kerry | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 6
* Mayo = 4
* Tyrone = 2
* Donegal = 1
* Kerry = 1
* Tipperary = 1
List of nominees

### 2017

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | David Clarke | Mayo | 2 |
| RCB | Chris Barrett | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Michael Fitzsimons | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | Keith Higgins | Mayo | 4 |
| RWB | Colm Boyle | Mayo | 4 |
| CB | Cian O'Sullivan | Dublin | 3 |
| LWB | Jack McCaffrey | Dublin | 2 |
| MD | Colm Cavanagh | Tyrone | 1 |
| MD | James McCarthy | Dublin | 2 |
| RWF | Dean Rock | Dublin | 2 |
| CF | Aidan O'Shea | Mayo | 3 |
| LWF | Con O'Callaghan | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Paul Mannion | Dublin | 1 |
| FF | Paul Geaney | Kerry | 2 |
| LCF | Andy Moran$^{FOTY}$ | Mayo | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 7
* Mayo = 6
* Kerry = 1
* Tyrone = 1
List of nominees

### 2018

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Rory Beggan | Monaghan | 1 |
| RCB | Jonny Cooper | Dublin | 2 |
| FB | Colm Cavanagh | Tyrone | 2 |
| LCB | Pádraig Hampsey | Tyrone | 1 |
| RWB | Karl O'Connell | Monaghan | 1 |
| CB | James McCarthy | Dublin | 3 |
| LWB | Jack McCaffrey | Dublin | 3 |
| MD | Brian Fenton$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 3 |
| MD | Brian Howard | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Paul Mannion | Dublin | 2 |
| CF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 3 |
| LWF | Ryan McHugh | Donegal | 2 |
| RCF | David Clifford | Kerry | 1 |
| FF | Conor McManus | Monaghan | 3 |
| LCF | Ian Burke | Galway | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 7
* Monaghan = 3
* Tyrone = 2
* Kerry = 1
* Donegal = 1
* Galway = 1
List of nominees

### 2019

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 6 |
| RCB | Michael Fitzsimons | Dublin | 2 |
| FB | Ronan McNamee | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCB | Tom O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| RWB | Patrick Durcan | Mayo | 1 |
| CB | Brian Howard | Dublin | 2 |
| LWB | Jack McCaffrey | Dublin | 4 |
| MD | Brian Fenton | Dublin | 4 |
| MD | David Moran | Kerry | 2 |
| RWF | Paul Mannion | Dublin | 3 |
| CF | Seán O'Shea | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Michael Murphy | Donegal | 3 |
| RCF | David Clifford | Kerry | 2 |
| FF | Cathal McShane | Tyrone | 1 |
| LCF | Con O'Callaghan | Dublin | 2 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 7
* Kerry = 4
* Tyrone = 2
* Mayo = 1
* Donegal = 1
List of nominees

## 2020s
### 2020

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Raymond Galligan | Cavan | 1 |
| RCB | Oisín Mullin | Mayo | 1 |
| FB | Padraig Faulkner | Cavan | 1 |
| LCB | Michael Fitzsimons | Dublin | 3 |
| RWB | James McCarthy | Dublin | 4 |
| CB | John Small | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Eoin Murchan | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Brian Fenton$^{FOTY}$ | Dublin | 5 |
| MD | Thomas Galligan | Cavan | 1 |
| RWF | Niall Scully | Dublin | 1 |
| CF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 4 |
| LWF | Con O'Callaghan | Dublin | 3 |
| RCF | Cillian O'Connor | Mayo | 2 |
| FF | Conor Sweeney | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCF | Dean Rock | Dublin | 3 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 9
* Cavan = 3
* Mayo = 2
* Tipperary = 1

### 2021

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Niall Morgan | Tyrone | 1 |
| RCB | Pádraig Hampsey | Tyrone | 2 |
| FB | Lee Keegan | Mayo | 5 |
| LCB | Tom O'Sullivan | Kerry | 2 |
| RWB | Conor Meyler | Tyrone | 1 |
| CB | Kieran McGeary$^{FOTY}$ | Tyrone | 1 |
| LWB | Peter Harte | Tyrone | 2 |
| MD | Brian Kennedy | Tyrone | 1 |
| MD | Matthew Ruane | Mayo | 1 |
| RWF | Niall Sludden | Tyrone | 1 |
| CF | Paudie Clifford | Kerry | 1 |
| LWF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 5 |
| RCF | Darren McCurry | Tyrone | 1 |
| FF | David Clifford | Kerry | 3 |
| LCF | Ryan O'Donoghue | Mayo | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Tyrone = 8
* Mayo = 3
* Kerry = 3
* Dublin = 1

### 2022

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Shane Ryan | Kerry | 1 |
| RCB | Chrissy McKaigue | Derry | 1 |
| FB | Jason Foley | Kerry | 1 |
| LCB | Liam Silke | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Tadhg Morley | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | John Daly | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Gavin White | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Conor Glass | Derry | 1 |
| MD | Cillian McDaid | Galway | 1 |
| RWF | Paudie Clifford | Kerry | 2 |
| CF | Seán O'Shea | Kerry | 2 |
| LWF | Ciarán Kilkenny | Dublin | 6 |
| RCF | David Clifford$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 4 |
| FF | Damien Comer | Galway | 1 |
| LCF | Shane Walsh | Galway | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Kerry = 7
* Galway = 5
* Derry = 2
* Dublin = 1

### 2023

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Cluxton | Dublin | 7 |
| RCB | Conor McCluskey | Derry | 1 |
| FB | Michael Fitzsimons | Dublin | 4 |
| LCB | Tom O'Sullivan | Kerry | 3 |
| RWB | James McCarthy | Dublin | 5 |
| CB | Gareth McKinless | Derry | 1 |
| LWB | Conor McCarthy | Monaghan | 1 |
| MD | Brian Fenton | Dublin | 6 |
| MD | Brendan Rogers | Derry | 1 |
| RWF | Paudie Clifford | Kerry | 3 |
| CF | Seán O'Shea | Kerry | 3 |
| LWF | Enda Smith | Roscommon | 1 |
| RCF | David Clifford$^{FOTY}$ | Kerry | 5 |
| FF | Shane McGuigan | Derry | 1 |
| LCF | Colm Basquel | Dublin | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Dublin = 5
* Kerry = 4
* Derry = 4
* Monaghan = 1
* Roscommon = 1

### 2024

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Niall Morgan | Tyrone | 2 |
| RCB | Johnny McGrath | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Barry McCambridge | Armagh | 1 |
| LCB | Peadar Mogan | Donegal | 1 |
| RWB | Dylan McHugh | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Aidan Forker | Armagh | 1 |
| LWB | Craig Lennon | Louth | 1 |
| MD | Paul Conroy$^{FOTY}$ | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Ben Crealey | Armagh | 1 |
| RWF | Rian O'Neill | Armagh | 1 |
| CF | John Maher | Galway | 1 |
| LWF | Oisín Conaty | Armagh | 1 |
| RCF | Robert Finnerty | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Oisín Gallen | Donegal | 1 |
| LCF | Conor Turbitt | Armagh | 1 |
Player has previously been selected.

#### County breakdown

* Armagh = 6
* Galway = 5
* Donegal = 2
* Tyrone = 1
* Louth = 1

## All Star Awards listed by team
### Armagh

Armagh has 30 All Stars, as of 2024. 21 different players have won, as of 2024. No player has won more than three All Stars.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1972: Paddy Moriarty 1977: Joe Kernan, Jimmy Smyth, Paddy Moriarty$^{2nd}$ 1980: Colum McKinstry 1982: Joe Kernan$^{2nd}$ 1993: Ger Houlahan 1999: Kieran McGeeney, Diarmaid Marsden 2000: Kieran McGeeney$^{2nd}$, Oisín McConville 2002: Enda McNulty, Aidan O'Rourke, Kieran McGeeney $^{3rd}$, Paul McGrane, Stevie McDonnell, Oisín McConville$^{2nd}$ 2003: Francie Bellew, Stevie McDonnell $^{2nd}$ 2005: Andy Mallon, Paul McGrane$^{2nd}$, Stevie McDonnell$^{3rd}$ 2006: Rónán Clarke 2008: Rónán Clarke$^{2nd}$ 2024: Barry McCambridge, Aidan Forker, Ben Crealey, Rian O'Neill, Oisín Conaty, Conor Turbitt

### Cork

Cork has 64 All Stars, as of 2012. 42 different players have won, as of 2012. Graham Canty, Steven O'Brien and Larry Tompkins each won three All Stars. No player has won more than three All Stars.
1971: Ray Cummins 1972: Kevin Jer O'Sullivan 1973: Billy Morgan, Frank Cogan, Brian Murphy, Kevin Jer O'Sullivan$^{2nd}$, Dinny Long, Jimmy Barry-Murphy, Ray Cummins$^{2nd}$ 1974: Declan Barron, Jimmy Barry-Murphy$^{2nd}$ 1975: Dinny Long$^{2nd}$ 1976: Brian Murphy$^{2nd}$, Dave McCarthy 1978: Declan Barron$^{2nd}$ 1980: Kevin Kehilly, Dinny Allen 1982: Kevin Kehilly$^{2nd}$ 1983: John Evans, Jimmy Kerrigan 1987: John Kerins, Colman Corrigan, Niall Cahalane, Larry Tompkins 1988: Colman Corrigan$^{2nd}$, Niall Cahalane$^{2nd}$, Shea Fahy, Larry Tompkins$^{2nd}$ 1989: Conor Counihan, Tony Davis, Teddy McCarthy, Dave Barry, Larry Tompkins$^{3rd}$, Paul McGrath 1990: John Kerins$^{2nd}$, Steven O'Brien, Mick Slocum, Conor Counihan$^{2nd}$, Shea Fahy$^{2nd}$, Paul McGrath$^{2nd}$ 1993: Joe Kavanagh, Colin Corkery 1994: Steven O'Brien$^{2nd}$ 1995: Mark O'Connor, Steven O'Brien$^{3rd}$ 1999: Kevin O'Dwyer, Anthony Lynch, Ciarán O'Sullivan, Philip Clifford 2002: Anthony Lynch$^{2nd}$ 2006: Ger Spillane, Nicholas Murphy 2007: Graham Canty 2009: Michael Shields, Graham Canty$^{2nd}$, John Miskella, Pearse O'Neill, Daniel Goulding 2010: Michael Shields$^{2nd}$, Paudie Kissane, Graham Canty$^{3rd}$, Aidan Walsh 2012: Aidan Walsh$^{2nd}$, Colm O'Neill

### Derry

Derry has 33 All Stars, as of 2023. 23 different players have won, as of 2023. No player has won more than four All Stars.
1973: Anthony McGurk 1975: Peter Stevenson, Anthony McGurk$^{2nd}$, Gerry McElhinney 1984: Dermot McNicholl 1987: Tony Scullion, Brian McGilligan 1992: Tony Scullion$^{2nd}$, Anthony Tohill, Enda Gormley 1993: Tony Scullion$^{3rd}$, Johnny McGurk, Henry Downey, Gary Coleman, Anthony Tohill$^{2nd}$, Brian McGilligan$^{2nd}$, Enda Gormley$^{2nd}$ 1995: Tony Scullion$^{4th}$, Anthony Tohill$^{3rd}$ 1996: Joe Brolly 1997: Joe Brolly$^{2nd}$ 1998: Seán Marty Lockhart 2000: Kieran McKeever, Anthony Tohill$^{4th}$ 2004: Enda Muldoon 2007: Kevin McCloy, Paddy Bradley 2022: Chrissy McKaigue, Conor Glass 2023: Conor McCluskey, Gareth McKinless, Brendan Rogers, Shane McGuigan

### Donegal

Donegal has 36 All Stars, as of 2024. 24 different players have won, as of 2024. No player has won more than four All Stars.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1972: Brian McEniff 1974: Donal Monaghan 1983: Martin McHugh 1990: Joyce McMullin 1992: Gary Walsh, Matt Gallagher, Martin Gavigan, Anthony Molloy, Martin McHugh$^{2nd}$, James McHugh, Tony Boyle 1993: John Joe Doherty 2002: Kevin Cassidy 2003: Adrian Sweeney 2006: Karl Lacey 2009: Karl Lacey$^{2nd}$ 2011: Karl Lacey$^{3rd}$, Kevin Cassidy$^{2nd}$, Neil McGee 2012: Paul Durcan, Neil McGee$^{2nd}$, Karl Lacey $^{4th}$, Frank McGlynn, Neil Gallagher, Mark McHugh, Michael Murphy, Colm McFadden 2014: Paul Durcan$^{2nd}$, Neil McGee$^{3rd}$, Neil Gallagher$^{2nd}$, Michael Murphy$^{2nd}$ 2016: Ryan McHugh 2018: Ryan McHugh$^{2nd}$ 2019: Michael Murphy$^{3rd}$ 2024: Peadar Mogan, Oisín Gallen

### Down

Down has 23 All Stars, as of 2010. 18 different players have won, as of 2010. Greg Blaney won three All Stars. No player has won more.
1971: Seán O'Neill 1972: Seán O'Neill$^{2nd}$ 1975: Colm McAlarney 1978: Colm McAlarney$^{2nd}$ 1981: Paddy Kennedy 1983: Liam Austin, Greg Blaney 1990: James McCartan Jnr 1991: Conor Deegan, Barry Breen, Ross Carr, Greg Blaney$^{2nd}$ 1994: Miceal Magill, Paul Higgins, DJ Kane, Gregory McCartan, Greg Blaney$^{3rd}$, James McCartan Jnr$^{2nd}$, Mickey Linden 2010: Brendan McVeigh, Daniel Hughes, Martin Clarke, Benny Coulter

### Dublin

Dublin has 146 All Stars, as of 2023. 67 different players have won, as of 2023. Stephen Cluxton has won seven All Stars, Brian Fenton and Ciarán Kilkenny have each won six. denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1974: Paddy Cullen, Seán Doherty, Robbie Kelleher, Paddy Reilly, David Hickey, Jimmy Keaveney 1975: Gay O'Driscoll, Robbie Kelleher$^{2nd}$, Anton O'Toole 1976: Paddy Cullen$^{2nd}$, Kevin Moran, Brian Mullins, Anton O'Toole$^{2nd}$, Tony Hanahoe, David Hickey$^{2nd}$, Bobby Doyle 1977: Paddy Cullen$^{3rd}$, Gay O'Driscoll$^{2nd}$, Robbie Kelleher$^{3rd}$, Tommy Drumm, Pat O'Neill, Brian Mullins$^{2nd}$, Anton O'Toole$^{3rd}$, Bobby Doyle$^{2nd}$, Jimmy Keaveney$^{2nd}$ 1978: Robbie Kelleher$^{4th}$, Tommy Drumm$^{2nd}$, Jimmy Keaveney$^{3rd}$ 1979: Paddy Cullen$^{4th}$, Tommy Drumm$^{3rd}$, Bernard Brogan Snr 1983: Pat Canavan, Tommy Drumm$^{4th}$, Barney Rock, Joe McNally 1984: John O'Leary, P. J. Buckley, Barney Rock$^{2nd}$ 1985: John O'Leary$^{2nd}$, Gerry Hargan, Barney Rock$^{3rd}$, Tommy Conroy 1987: Kieran Duff 1988: Mick Kennedy, Noel McCaffrey, Kieran Duff$^{2nd}$ 1989: Gerry Hargan$^{2nd}$ 1991: Mick Deegan, Tommy Carr, Keith Barr 1992: Paul Curran, Eamon Heery, Vinnie Murphy 1993: John O'Leary$^{3rd}$, Dermot Deasy, Charlie Redmond 1994: John O'Leary$^{4th}$, Jack Sheedy, Charlie Redmond$^{2nd}$ 1995: John O'Leary$^{5th}$, Paul Curran$^{2nd}$, Keith Barr$^{2nd}$, Brian Stynes, Dessie Farrell, Paul Clarke, Charlie Redmond$^{3rd}$ 1996: Paul Curran$^{3rd}$ 1999: Ciarán Whelan 2001: Coman Goggins 2002: Stephen Cluxton, Ray Cosgrove, Paddy Christie 2006: Stephen Cluxton$^{2nd}$, Alan Brogan 2007: Stephen Cluxton$^{3rd}$, Barry Cahill, Ciarán Whelan$^{2nd}$, Alan Brogan$^{2nd}$ 2008: Shane Ryan 2010: Bernard Brogan Jnr  2011: Stephen Cluxton$^{4th}$, Kevin Nolan, Michael Darragh MacAuley, Paul Flynn, Alan Brogan $^{3rd}$, Bernard Brogan Jnr$^{2nd}$ 2012: Paul Flynn$^{2nd}$ 2013: Stephen Cluxton$^{5th}$, Rory O'Carroll, Cian O'Sullivan, Michael Darragh MacAuley $^{2nd}$, Paul Flynn$^{3rd}$, Bernard Brogan Jnr$^{3rd}$ 2014: James McCarthy, Diarmuid Connolly, Paul Flynn$^{4th}$ 2015: Rory O'Carroll$^{2nd}$, Philly McMahon, Cian O'Sullivan$^{2nd}$, Jack McCaffrey , Brian Fenton, Ciarán Kilkenny, Bernard Brogan Jnr$^{4th}$ 2016: Jonny Cooper, Philly McMahon$^{2nd}$, Brian Fenton$^{2nd}$, Diarmuid Connolly$^{2nd}$, Ciarán Kilkenny$^{2nd}$, Dean Rock 2017: Michael Fitzsimons, Cian O'Sullivan$^{3rd}$, Jack McCaffrey$^{2nd}$, James McCarthy$^{2nd}$, Dean Rock$^{2nd}$, Con O'Callaghan, Paul Mannion 2018: Jonny Cooper$^{2nd}$, James McCarthy$^{3rd}$, Jack McCaffrey$^{3rd}$, Brian Fenton $^{3rd}$, Brian Howard, Paul Mannion$^{2nd}$, Ciarán Kilkenny$^{3rd}$ 2019: Stephen Cluxton $^{6th}$, Michael Fitzsimons$^{2nd}$, Brian Howard$^{2nd}$, Jack McCaffrey$^{4th}$, Brian Fenton$^{4th}$, Paul Mannion$^{3rd}$, Con O'Callaghan$^{2nd}$ 2020: Michael Fitzsimons$^{3rd}$, James McCarthy$^{4th}$, John Small, Eoin Murchan, Brian Fenton $^{5th}$, Niall Scully, Ciarán Kilkenny$^{4th}$, Con O'Callaghan$^{3rd}$, Dean Rock$^{3rd}$ 2021: Ciarán Kilkenny$^{5th}$ 2022: Ciarán Kilkenny$^{6th}$ 2023: Stephen Cluxton$^{7th}$, Michael Fitzsimons$^{4th}$, James McCarthy$^{5th}$, Brian Fenton$^{6th}$, Colm Basquel

### Galway

Galway has 48 All Stars, as of 2024. 34 different players have won, as of 2024. No player has won more than three All Stars.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1971: P. J. Smyth, Jack Cosgrove, Liam Sammon, Séamus Leydon 1972: Tommy Joe Gilmore 1973: Liam O'Neill, Tommy Joe Gilmore$^{2nd}$, Liam Sammon$^{2nd}$ 1974: Johnny Hughes, Tom Naughton, John Tobin 1976: Johnny Hughes$^{2nd}$ 1981: Séamus McHugh, Barry Brennan 1983: Stephen Kinneavy 1984: Séamus McHugh$^{2nd}$ 1987: Val Daly 1990: Val Daly$^{2nd}$ 1995: Jarlath Fallon 1998: Martin McNamara, Tomás Mannion, Seán Óg De Paor, Kevin Walsh, Michael Donnellan, Jarlath Fallon $^{2nd}$, Pádraic Joyce 2000: Declan Meehan, Michael Donnellan$^{2nd}$, Pádraic Joyce$^{2nd}$, Derek Savage 2001: Kieran Fitzgerald, Declan Meehan $^{2nd}$, Seán Óg De Paor$^{2nd}$, Kevin Walsh$^{2nd}$, Michael Donnellan$^{3rd}$, Pádraic Joyce$^{3rd}$ 2003: Kevin Walsh$^{3rd}$ 2018: Ian Burke 2022: Liam Silke, John Daly, Cillian McDaid, Damien Comer, Shane Walsh 2024: Johnny McGrath, Dylan McHugh, Paul Conroy , John Maher, Robert Finnerty

### Kerry

Kerry has 159 All Stars, as of 2023. 64 different players have won, as of 2023. Pat Spillane won nine All Stars, Colm Cooper won eight and Mikey Sheehy won seven.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1971: Donie O'Sullivan 1972: Donie O'Sullivan$^{2nd}$, Mick O'Connell 1973: John O'Keeffe 1974: Paudie Lynch 1975: Paudie O'Mahony, John O'Keeffe$^{2nd}$, Ger Power, Mickey "Ned" O'Sullivan, John Egan 1976: Ger O'Keeffe, John O'Keeffe$^{3rd}$, Ger Power$^{2nd}$, Mikey Sheehy, Pat Spillane 1977: Pat Spillane$^{2nd}$, John Egan$^{2nd}$ 1978: John O'Keeffe$^{4th}$, Paudie Lynch$^{2nd}$, Ger Power$^{3rd}$, Pat Spillane$^{3rd}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{2nd}$, John Egan$^{3rd}$ 1979: John O'Keeffe$^{5th}$, Tim Kennelly, Ger Power$^{4th}$, Seán Walsh, Pat Spillane$^{4th}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{3rd}$ 1980: Charlie Nelligan, Tim Kennelly$^{2nd}$, Jack O'Shea, Ger Power$^{5th}$, Pat Spillane$^{5th}$, Eoin Liston, John Egan$^{4th}$ 1981: Jimmy Deenihan, Paudie Lynch$^{3rd}$, Páidí Ó Sé, Jack O'Shea$^{2nd}$, Seán Walsh$^{2nd}$, Denis "Ogie" Moran, Pat Spillane$^{6th}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{4th}$, Eoin Liston$^{2nd}$ 1982: Páidí Ó Sé$^{2nd}$, Jack O'Shea$^{3rd}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{5th}$, Eoin Liston$^{3rd}$, John Egan$^{5th}$ 1983: Páidí Ó Sé$^{3rd}$, Jack O'Shea$^{4th}$ 1984: Páidí Ó Sé$^{4th}$, Tommy Doyle, Tom Spillane, Jack O'Shea$^{5th}$, Eoin Liston$^{4th}$, Pat Spillane$^{7th}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{6th}$ 1985: Páidí Ó Sé$^{5th}$, Mick Spillane, Tommy Doyle$^{2nd}$, Jack O'Shea$^{6th}$, Pat Spillane$^{8th}$ 1986: Charlie Nelligan$^{2nd}$, Tommy Doyle$^{3rd}$, Tom Spillane$^{2nd}$, Pat Spillane$^{9th}$, Mikey Sheehy$^{7th}$, Ger Power$^{6th}$ 1987: Tom Spillane$^{3rd}$, Ger Lynch 1988: Maurice Fitzgerald 1989: Connie Murphy 1996: Maurice Fitzgerald$^{2nd}$ 1997: Declan O'Keeffe, Séamus Moynihan, Eamonn Breen, Pa Laide, Maurice Fitzgerald $^{3rd}$ 2000: Declan O'Keeffe$^{2nd}$, Séamus Moynihan $^{2nd}$, Mike McCarthy, Darragh Ó Sé, Liam Hassett, Mike Frank Russell 2001: Johnny Crowley 2002: Darragh Ó Sé$^{2nd}$, Colm Cooper 2004: Diarmuid Murphy, Tom O'Sullivan (Rathmore), Mike McCarthy$^{2nd}$, Tomás Ó Sé , Paul Galvin, Colm Cooper$^{2nd}$ 2005: Diarmuid Murphy$^{2nd}$, Mike McCarthy$^{3rd}$, Tomás Ó Sé$^{2nd}$, Colm Cooper$^{3rd}$ 2006: Marc Ó Sé, Séamus Moynihan$^{3rd}$, Aidan O'Mahony, Darragh Ó Sé$^{3rd}$, Paul Galvin$^{2nd}$, Kieran Donaghy  2007: Marc Ó Sé $^{2nd}$, Tomás Ó Sé$^{3rd}$, Aidan O'Mahony$^{2nd}$, Darragh Ó Sé$^{4th}$, Declan O'Sullivan, Colm Cooper$^{4th}$ 2008: Tomás Ó Sé$^{4th}$, Declan O'Sullivan$^{2nd}$, Colm Cooper$^{5th}$, Kieran Donaghy$^{2nd}$ 2009: Diarmuid Murphy$^{3rd}$, Tom O'Sullivan (Rathmore)$^{2nd}$, Tomás Ó Sé$^{5th}$, Séamus Scanlon, Paul Galvin $^{3rd}$, Tadhg Kennelly, Declan O'Sullivan$^{3rd}$ 2010: Colm Cooper$^{6th}$ 2011: Marc Ó Sé$^{3rd}$, Bryan Sheehan, Darran O'Sullivan, Colm Cooper$^{7th}$ 2013: Colm Cooper$^{8th}$, James O'Donoghue 2014: Paul Murphy, Peter Crowley, David Moran, Kieran Donaghy$^{3rd}$, James O'Donoghue$^{2nd}$ 2015: Brendan Kealy, Shane Enright, Anthony Maher, Donnchadh Walsh 2016: Paul Geaney 2017: Paul Geaney$^{2nd}$ 2018: David Clifford 2019: Tom O'Sullivan (Dingle), David Moran$^{2nd}$, Seán O'Shea, David Clifford$^{2nd}$ 2021: Tom O'Sullivan (Dingle)$^{2nd}$, Paudie Clifford, David Clifford$^{3rd}$ 2022: Shane Ryan, Jason Foley, Tadhg Morley, Gavin White, Paudie Clifford$^{2nd}$, Seán O'Shea$^{2nd}$, David Clifford $^{4th}$ 2023: Tom O'Sullivan (Dingle)$^{3rd}$, Paudie Clifford$^{3rd}$, Seán O'Shea$^{3rd}$, David Clifford $^{5th}$

### Kildare

Kildare has 15 All Stars, as of 2011. 12 different players have won, as of 2011. No player has won more than two All Stars.
1978: Ollie Crinnigan 1991: Martin Lynch 1997: Niall Buckley, Davy Dalton, Glenn Ryan 1998: Dermot Earley, Karl O'Dwyer, Glenn Ryan$^{2nd}$, Brian Lacey, John Finn 2000: Anthony Rainbow 2009: Dermot Earley$^{2nd}$ 2010: Peter Kelly, Johnny Doyle 2011: Mick Foley

### Mayo

Mayo has 54 All Stars, as of 2021. 33 different players have won, as of 2021. Lee Keegan has won the most All-Stars with five.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1971: Johnny Carey 1979: Joe McGrath 1985: Dermot Flanagan, Willie Joe Padden, Kevin McStay 1989: Gabriel Irwin, Jimmy Browne, Dermot Flanagan$^{2nd}$, Willie Joe Padden$^{2nd}$, Noel Durkin 1992: T. J. Kilgallon 1993: Kevin O'Neill 1996: Kenneth Mortimer, Pat Holmes, James Nallen, Liam McHale, James Horan 1997: Kenneth Mortimer$^{2nd}$, Pat Fallon 1999: James Horan$^{2nd}$ 2004: James Nallen$^{2nd}$, Ciarán McDonald 2006: Alan Dillon, Conor Mortimer 2011: Andy Moran 2012: Ger Cafferkey, Keith Higgins, Lee Keegan, Alan Dillon$^{2nd}$ 2013: Keith Higgins$^{2nd}$, Lee Keegan$^{2nd}$, Colm Boyle, Aidan O'Shea 2014: Keith Higgins$^{3rd}$, Colm Boyle$^{2nd}$, Cillian O'Connor 2015: Lee Keegan$^{3rd}$, Aidan O'Shea$^{2nd}$ 2016: David Clarke, Brendan Harrison, Lee Keegan $^{4th}$, Colm Boyle$^{3rd}$ 2017: David Clarke$^{2nd}$, Chris Barrett, Keith Higgins$^{3rd}$ Colm Boyle$^{4th}$, Aidan O'Shea$^{3rd}$, Andy Moran $^{2nd}$ 2019: Paddy Durcan 2020: Oisín Mullin, Cillian O'Connor$^{2nd}$ 2021: Lee Keegan$^{5th}$, Matthew Ruane, Ryan O'Donoghue

### Meath

Meath has 48 All Stars, as of 2007. 26 different players have won, as of 2007. No player has won more than four All Stars.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1971: Pat Reynolds 1975: Ken Rennicks, Matt Kerrigan 1983: Colm O'Rourke 1984: Mick Lyons 1986: Mick Lyons$^{2nd}$ 1987: Robbie O'Malley, Gerry McEntee, David Beggy, Brian Stafford, Bernard Flynn 1988: Robbie O'Malley$^{2nd}$, Martin O'Connell, Liam Hayes, Colm O'Rourke$^{2nd}$, Brian Stafford$^{2nd}$ 1990: Robbie O'Malley$^{3rd}$, Terry Ferguson, Martin O'Connell$^{3rd}$, David Beggy$^{2nd}$ 1991: Michael McQuillan, Martin O'Connell$^{3rd}$, Tommy Dowd, Colm O'Rourke$^{3rd}$, Brian Stafford$^{3rd}$, Bernard Flynn$^{2nd}$ 1994: Graham Geraghty, Tommy Dowd$^{2nd}$ 1995: Tommy Dowd$^{3rd}$ 1996: Darren Fay, Martin O'Connell$^{4th}$, John McDermott, Trevor Giles , Tommy Dowd$^{4th}$ 1997: Trevor Giles$^{2nd}$, Brendan Reilly 1998: John McDermott$^{2nd}$ 1999: Mark O'Reilly, Darren Fay$^{2nd}$, Paddy Reynolds, John McDermott$^{3rd}$, Trevor Giles $^{3rd}$, Graham Geraghty$^{2nd}$, Ollie Murphy 2001: Cormac Sullivan, Evan Kelly, Ollie Murphy$^{2nd}$ 2007: Stephen Bray

### Monaghan

Monaghan has 14 All Stars, as of 2023. 10 different players have won, as of 2023. Eugene "Nudie" Hughes and Conor McManus each won three All Stars. No other player won more than one.
1979: Eugene "Nudie" Hughes 1985: Ciarán Murray, Eugene "Nudie" Hughes$^{2nd}$ 1986: Ray McCarron 1988: Paddy Linden, Eugene "Nudie" Hughes$^{3rd}$ 2007: Tomás Freeman 2013: Colin Walshe, Conor McManus 2015: Conor McManus$^{2nd}$ 2018: Rory Beggan, Karl O'Connell, Conor McManus$^{3rd}$ 2023: Conor McCarthy

### Offaly

Offaly has 30 All Stars, as of 1997. 19 different players have won, as of 1997. Martin Furlong won four All Stars, while Matt Connor won three. No one else won more than two.
1971: Eugene Mulligan, Nicholas Clavin, Willie Bryan, Tony McTague 1972: Martin Furlong, Mick Ryan, Paddy McCormack, Willie Bryan$^{2nd}$, Johnny Cooney, Kevin Kilmurray, Tony McTague$^{2nd}$ 1973: Mick Ryan$^{2nd}$, Johnny Cooney$^{2nd}$, Kevin Kilmurray$^{2nd}$ 1978: Tomás O'Connor 1979: Seán Lowry 1980: Matt Connor 1981: Martin Furlong$^{2nd}$, Richie Connor, Brendan Lowry 1982: Martin Furlong$^{3rd}$, Mick Fitzgerald, Liam O'Connor, Seán Lowry$^{2nd}$, Liam Currams, Pádraig Dunne, Matt Connor$^{2nd}$ 1983: Martin Furlong$^{4th}$, Matt Connor$^{3rd}$ 1997: Cathal Daly

### Roscommon

Roscommon has 16 All Stars, as of 2023. 12 different players have won, as of 2023. Harry Keegan won three All Stars. No other player won more than two.
1972: Mickey Freyne 1974: Dermot Earley Snr 1977: Pat Lindsay 1978: Harry Keegan 1979: Tom Heneghan, Danny Murray, Dermot Earley Snr$^{2nd}$ 1980: Harry Keegan$^{2nd}$, Ger Connellan, Danny Murray$^{2nd}$ 1985: Paul Earley 1986: Harry Keegan$^{3rd}$ 1989: Tony McManus 1991: Enon Gavin 2001: Francie Grehan 2023: Enda Smith

### Tyrone

Tyrone has 58 All Stars, as of 2024. 33 different players have won, as of 2024. Peter Canavan and Seán Cavanagh won eleven All Stars between them.  denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1980: Kevin McCabe 1984: Eugene McKenna, Frank McGuigan 1986: John Lynch, Plunkett Donaghy, Damien O'Hagan, Eugene McKenna$^{2nd}$ 1989: Eugene McKenna$^{3rd}$ 1994: Peter Canavan 1995: Fay Devlin, Peter Canavan $^{2nd}$ 1996: Finbar McConnell, Peter Canavan$^{3rd}$ 2001: Stephen O'Neill 2002: Peter Canavan$^{4th}$ 2003: Cormac McAnallen, Conor Gormley, Philip Jordan, Seán Cavanagh, Brian Dooher, Brian McGuigan, Peter Canavan$^{5th}$ 2004: Seán Cavanagh$^{2nd}$ 2005: Ryan McMenamin, Conor Gormley$^{2nd}$, Philip Jordan$^{2nd}$, Seán Cavanagh$^{3rd}$, Brian Dooher$^{2nd}$, Peter Canavan$^{6th}$, Owen Mulligan, Stephen O'Neill $^{2nd}$ 2008: Conor Gormley$^{3rd}$, Justin McMahon, David Harte, Philip Jordan$^{3rd}$, Enda McGinley, Brian Dooher$^{3rd}$, Seán Cavanagh $^{4th}$ 2009: Stephen O'Neill$^{3rd}$ 2010: Philip Jordan$^{4th}$ 2013: Seán Cavanagh$^{5th}$ 2015: Mattie Donnelly 2016: Mattie Donnelly$^{2nd}$, Peter Harte 2017: Colm Cavanagh 2018: Colm Cavanagh$^{2nd}$, Pádraig Hampsey 2019: Ronan McNamee, Cathal McShane 2021: Niall Morgan, Pádraig Hampsey$^{2nd}$, Conor Meyler, Kieran McGeary , Peter Harte$^{2nd}$, Brian Kennedy, Niall Sludden, Darren McCurry 2024: Niall Morgan$^{2nd}$

## Cú Chulainn Awards
### 1963

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Andy Phillips | Wicklow | 1 |
| RCB | Gabriel Kelly | Cavan | 1 |
| FB | Noel Tierney | Galway | 1 |
| LCB | Pa Connolly | Kildare | 1 |
| RWB | Seamus Murphy | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Paddy Holden | Dublin | 1 |
| LWB | Martin Newell | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Mick Garrett | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Des Foley | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 1 |
| CF | Mickey Whelan | Dublin | 1 |
| LWF | Tom Browne | Laois | 1 |
| RCF | Jimmy Whan | Armagh | 1 |
| FF | Tom Long | Kerry | 1 |
| LCF | Pat Donnellan | Galway | 1 |

### 1964

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Johnny Geraghty | Galway | 1 |
| RCB | Gabriel Kelly | Cavan | 2 |
| FB | Noel Tierney | Galway | 2 |
| LCB | Peter Darby | Meath | 1 |
| RWB | Enda Colleran | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Paddy Holden | Dublin | 2 |
| LWB | Frank Lynch | Louth | 1 |
| MD | Mick O'Connell | Kerry | 1 |
| MD | Mick Reynolds | Galway | 1 |
| RWF | Cyril Dunne | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Mattie McDonagh | Galway | 1 |
| LWF | Mickey Kearins | Sligo | 1 |
| RCF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 2 |
| FF | Charlie Gallagher | Cavan | 1 |
| LCF | Paddy Doherty | Down | 1 |

### 1965

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Johnny Geraghty | Galway | 2 |
| RCB | Enda Colleran | Galway | 2 |
| FB | Tom McCreesh | Armagh | 1 |
| LCB | Bosco McDermott | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Donie O'Sullivan | Kerry | 1 |
| CB | Paddy Holden | Dublin | 3 |
| LWB | Martin Newell | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Mick O'Connell | Kerry | 2 |
| MD | Des Foley | Dublin | 2 |
| RWF | Cyril Dunne | Galway | 2 |
| CF | Mickey Kearins | Sligo | 2 |
| LWF | Seamus Leydon | Galway | 1 |
| RCF | Sean Murray | Longford | 1 |
| FF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 3 |
| LCF | Paddy Doherty | Down | 2 |

### 1966

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Johnny Geraghty | Galway | 3 |
| RCB | Enda Colleran | Galway | 3 |
| FB | Jack Quinn | Meath | 1 |
| LCB | Peter Darby | Meath | 2 |
| RWB | Pat Collier | Meath | 1 |
| CB | Mick Carolan | Kildare | 1 |
| LWB | Brendan Barden | Longford | 1 |
| MD | Pat Donnellan | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Ray Carolan | Cavan | 1 |
| RWF | Mickey Kearins | Sligo | 3 |
| CF | Mattie McDonagh | Galway | 2 |
| LWF | Seamus Leydon | Galway | 2 |
| RCF | Pat Dunny | Kildare | 1 |
| FF | Con O'Sullivan | Cork | 1 |
| LCF | John Keenan | Galway | 1 |

### 1967

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Billy Morgan | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Gabriel Kelly | Cavan | 3 |
| FB | Jack Quinn | Meath | 2 |
| LCB | Seamus O'Connor | Mayo | 1 |
| RWB | Frank Cogan | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Bertie Cunningham | Meath | 1 |
| LWB | Pat Reynolds | Meath | 1 |
| MD | Mick Burke | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Ray Carolan | Cavan | 2 |
| RWF | Cyril Dunne | Galway | 3 |
| CF | Joe Langan | Mayo | 1 |
| LWF | Joe Corcoran | Mayo | 1 |
| RCF | Sean O'Connell | Derry | 1 |
| FF | Con O'Sullivan | Cork | 2 |
| LCF | Seán O'Neill | Down | 4 |