# Killing of Michael Ovsjannikov

On 19 August 2023, 28-year-old Michael Ovsjannikov was murdered in Wittlich, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany, during the Säubrennerkirmes [de] folk festival. A few hours later, 26-year-old Grant Harrison and 25-year-old Robert Cain II, U.S. airmen stationed at nearby Spangdahlem Air Base, were arrested. Harrison confessed to fatally stabbing Ovsjannikov.
The arrest, interrogation, and investigation was undertaken by the German Federal Police and the American Air Force Office of Special Investigation (OSI), but per the NATO Status of Forces Agreement, Harrison was tried by a U.S. military court, which dismissed the confession as inadmissible evidence. During the court-martial the following year, Harrison's defense argued that Cain had killed Ovsjannikov. The subsequent acquittal of Harrison, immunity from prosecution for Cain, and the accusation by the court that Federal Police had obtained the confession under pressure caused protests across the state.

## Background

Since the end of World War II, the United States maintained a strong military presence in Germany, with around 14.000 U.S. soldiers stationed at 25 military bases in Rhineland-Palatinate as of 2024. Wittlich has a population of under 20,000 and is one of the closest towns to Spangdahlem Air Base, which houses 5,000 active duty personnel and 7,000 military dependents. The Säubrennerkirmes, called "Pig Fest" by the American residents, hosts around 100,000 visitors from all over the state each year.

### Victim

Michael "Micha" Ovsjannikov was born on 13 July 1995 in Wittlich. He won several local and state youth-level judo championships as a child and since 2015, he co-managed a private security company, regularly contracted with SV Eintracht Trier 05. Ovsjannikov was active as an a MMA athlete in the lightweight class, both amateur and professional leagues, until 2021 and since 2022, he ran a judo school, where he acted as a fighting instructor.

### Accused

Grant D. Harrison was born in the United States. He has the rank of airman first class and was a transient aircraft journeyman as part of the 726th Air Mobility Squadron. Harrison had been in Germany since 2021 and lived off-base in Wittlich.
Robert Cain II was born in the United States. He has the rank of staff sergeant and served in the same squadron as Harrison.

## Murder

On the night of 13 August 2023, at 2:40 a.m., Ovsjannikov was hanging out with two friends on Trierer Strasse, a block away from his apartment, when he encountered a group of four, consisting of Harrison, Cain, Cain's then-fiancée, and the wife of another airman. The group had attended the carnival in the town square since around 1:00 a.m. and were heading home as the event was nearing its end. All involved were under the influence of alcohol. A confrontation ensued between the men, which ended with Ovsjannikov being fatally stabbed and bleeding to death on the street. Ovsjannikov's last words were reported as "It's going to be fine" ("Alles wird gut"). A passerby recalled seeing the American group quickly walking from the scene, visibly shocked with one of the men bleeding around the face. After the act, the weapon was dropped into the Lieser river and found the following day by a police officer under the Wittlicher Römerbrücke, near Harrison's home.
Ovsjannikov was identified on scene by witnesses. Despite security concerns, the Säubrennerkirmes continued under increased police presence, and after a talk between Wittlich mayor Joachim Rodenkirch and Ovsjannikov's father, it ran as planned in the following days.

## Investigation

Ovsjannikov was stabbed four times, three times in the back and once in the side of the stomach. There were no other defensive wounds such as bruises, bloody nose, or busted lip.
A few hours later, an airman called police and told them about Harrison's involvement in the stabbing. Harrison had allegedly confessed to him shortly after fleeing the scene, but the airman was unable to remember the details. Harrison was taken into custody alongside Cain, the two women in their company the previous night, and another male American national. Both Harrison and Cain were found to have Ovsjannikov's blood on their clothes, shoes, and jewelry. Before the questioning, the arrestees were read their rights by officers for German law, and Harrison was also told his rights under the Uniform Code of Military Justice by a special agent and a special investigator of the Air Force Office of Special Investigation. Cain claimed that he was hit in the head and sat on by the victim, blacked out, and regained consciousness to see Harrison standing over Ovsjannikov's prone body with a knife. Cain also stated that Harrison had written him text messages stating "I stabbed [Ovsjannikov] twice" after returning home. Harrison corroborated Cain's statements, admitted to carrying the knife in his pocket, stabbing Ovsjannikov "once, maybe twice" and disposing of it in the river, reasoning that he "flipped out" and wanted to protect Cain. Harrison stated that he did not remember the events of the night as he was drunk and taking a new prescription medication, claiming he had depression and attempted suicide in the past over his desire to leave the air force. Cain and Harrison claimed that the altercation lasted less than a minute. Cain's later wife, a German national, initially stated that neither her husband or Harrison had carried a knife during the night, but would later testify in court that she had seen the knife in Harrison's apartment. She attributed the incorrect statement to memory loss.
Cain and his wife claimed the fight occurred after Ovsjannikov spat at one of the women and attacked the group when she returned the gesture, stating they did not know each other. Harrison, eyewitnesses or surveillance footage did not corroborate the claim, which was further contested during the trial. Harrison's lawyer asserted that the fight was due to a pre-existing personal dispute, citing the owner and patrons a shisha bar, who claimed that they saw the three men, along with a woman and another airman, engaged in a verbal argument at the establishment a day before the killing.
Cain's version of events was initially believed by the state prosecutor's office and he was released, receiving a minor disciplinary infraction by the air force. Harrison stayed in jail and had a hearing at the Trier Higher Regional Court, where he repeated his confession. On 24 August, he was handed to U.S. military authorities, in accordance with the NATO SOFA [de], thus terminating the legal case against Harrison by the Rhineland-Palatinate's prosecutor's office. The handover is not mandatory, however, and not preferred by both German authorities and American arrestees due to harsher punishment in the United States, including capital punishment for murder convictions, which, under regular circumstances, is punishable by a life sentence with the possibility of parole in 15 years by German courts. Germany may also choose to have the defendant returned when the case concerns "interests of the German judiciary", which includes homicide cases, but this can only occur if U.S. authorities believe that the case may be mishandled by their courts. Harrison was held at United States Army Corrections Facility-Europe in Sembach until court proceedings.

## Trial

Harrison's court-martial began on 28 May 2024, while the murder trial started on 30 September of the same year. Harrison was represented by three attorneys and entered a not guilty plea, asserting that evidence implicated Robert Cain in the murder. If convicted, Harrison faced life imprisonment and a dishonorable discharge. Unlike in German judicial proceedings, co-plaintiffs were not accepted in the trial. Ovsjannikov's family still attended, but had problems following the trial as there was no translation. An interpreter, Denise W., was provided only after relatives complained in a local SWR interview; W. was one of the special agents that handled Harrison's interrogation.
The tribunal's judge, Colonel Jennifer Powell, refused to enter the confession made in German custody, alleging that it had been obtained "involuntarily". Specifically, Powell stated that Harrison was "confused" about his rights, not informed that a homicide had occurred, and that he was threatened with an overnight jail stay if he did not confess. The investigators in charge and the state prosecutor's office denied using coercion or force, but did state that in accordance with article 112 of the German Code of Criminal Procedure (StPo), remand is a valid and typical option in homicide investigations. It was clarified by the court that Harrison was not actively threatened, but that he still "felt pressured" and believed there would be punishment in case of non-cooperation. The source of Powell's information was not revealed and German authorities do not have access to the U.S. military court files.
The confession had been separately recorded in two ways, in audio and on video. The initial transcript was created using an dictation machine, and contained a translation of the entire confession, but the remainder of the interrogation was only partial and also in German, thus the original English exchange was not recorded. In the video confession, made just after the initial statement, the lead investigator told Harrison "So he [the other officer] will repeat the advisement as subject. And the allegation is, allegation of homicide." and "Last night, at the event, a person passed away during the incident, and we are going to ask some questions about this", both of which were answered with "yes" by Harrison. Harrison's lawyer claimed that the contents of either the transcript or video were irrelevant and insisted that his client had been misinformed about his rights at the very beginning of his interrogation. The video did reveal that despite earlier mention of homicide, one of the American investigators, Angelo M., had mistakenly read Harrison the rights for aggravated assault during this second time. Similarly, in the notice of suspect rights signed by Harrison, there were instances were the English language fields had been left blank, such as the "criminal provisions/charges" field, which read "Verdacht Tötungsdelikt" ("suspicion of homicide") in the German line, but lacked and English translation.
The trial featured the testimony of the involved Americans and their spouses, as well as that of three Germans. Dmytro Mynka, a friend of Ovsjannikov, claimed that he was close-up during the stabbing and gave a description consisted with Cain's clothing. However, he was dismissed by prosecutor Christie Jones as "hysteric". Adelheid Steffen, a local woman, stated that she saw two men in a physical struggle for several minutes before both fell to the ground. She did not see the start of the altercation, but corroborated that Ovsjannikov had sat on his opponent. Only one of the men got back up and ran off. According to Steffen, the scene was watched by "two Ukrainians and one American [man]". Marius Schäfer, Ovsjannikov's business partner, was not present at the scene, but tentatively supported the notion that Harrison killed the victim, but also did not rule out Cain. The OSI agents were not called to the witness stand and Ovsjannikov's family was not told that their interpreter had handled Harrison's interrogation.
On 11 October 2024, Harrison was found not guilty by a jury, which consisted of an eight-person panel of enlisted U.S. military personnel from Spangdahlem Air Base. Contrary to German court proceedings, no reason was provided for the verdict. Cain was given criminal immunity for cooperating with authorities and acting as a witness during the trial.

## Aftermath

On 29 August 2023, Ovsjannikov's funeral service was held at St. Peter Church and attended by 1,000 visitors, including mayor Joachim Rodenkirch and Spangdahlem Air Base Commander Kevin Crofton.
Prosecutor of Trier Higher Regional Court Peter Fritzen denied the allegations levied by Harrison's defense. Harrison's attorney Grover Baxley claimed that only "German Polizei" had handled the interrogation of Harrison, that officers told him that he was held for aggravated assault rather than homicide, and that the confession was coerced. Fritzen stated that American investigators were present and talked with the suspects, that police disclosed the homicide investigation to Harrison and that no force was used by police. The parents of Ovsjannikov accused Harrison's attorney of establishing the defense on a false basis. Rhineland-Palatinate Minister of Justice Herbert Mertin has ordered a re-examination of the validity of handover of Harrison and Cain to NATO custody. Ovjannikov's family is seeking to abolish the status of forces agreement in Germany through state and federal courts, as well as the European Court of Justice.
For over a month, there were regular protests outside the Spangdahlem Air Base and the Landtag of Rhineland-Palatinate by hundreds of locals who criticised the verdict. Harrison was still working at the air base as of November 2024, but the U.S. Air Force were in the process of discharging him.