# Comedy Bang! Bang!

Comedy Bang! Bang! (formerly Comedy Death-Ray Radio) is a weekly comedy audio podcast, which originally began airing as a radio show on May 1, 2009. Popularly known as Humanity and the Animal Kingdom's Podcast, it is hosted by writer and comedian Scott Aukerman, best known for his work on the 1990s HBO sketch comedy program Mr. Show with Bob and David, creating and hosting the Comedy Bang! Bang! TV series, and co-founding the weekly Comedy Death-Ray stage show at the Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre in Hollywood.
Comedy Death-Ray Radio was formerly broadcast from Southern California's Indie 103 studios, but since the summer of 2010 has been broadcast as part of the Earwolf comedy podcasting network, being recorded in studios owned by the company.
Comedy Bang! Bang! was also a television series on IFC hosted by Scott Aukerman and featuring in different seasons bandleaders Reggie Watts, Kid Cudi, and "Weird Al" Yankovic.
In 2021, Aukerman and producer Brett Morris launched Comedy Bang Bang World, a website and subscription platform offering the back catalog of the podcast alongside dozens of new spin-off shows and related content.

## History

Comedy Death-Ray Radio first aired May 1, 2009, after Aukerman gained permission from Indie 103 to conduct a "one-month tryout". The first episode's guests were Rob Huebel and Thomas Lennon. During occasions when Aukerman has been unable to host, Paul F. Tompkins, Chris Hardwick, Jimmy Pardo or Jerry Minor (in character as "Cyberthug") have guest hosted. Although normally produced in Los Angeles, the show has also been taped in Vancouver, Seattle, New York City, Chicago and Austin.

### Name change

On the May 15, 2011 "Two-year Anniversary" podcast, Aukerman announced that the show's name was changing to Comedy Bang Bang: The Podcast. He went on to say that the show had evolved a great deal in its first two years, and he credited his wife Kulap Vilaysack with coming up with the new name.

### Red Hot Chili Peppers parody

In episode 204 (which aired on March 4, 2013), "The Pepper Men," guests Jon Daly and Zach Galifianakis professed their love for the rock band Red Hot Chili Peppers. Both claimed to be "huge Pepper Men" and had written a song in tribute to the band titled "Abracadabralifornia", which Daly sang using his best Anthony Kiedis imitation.
On January 29, 2014, a very official-looking website called www.RHCP2014.com appeared online claiming to have the brand-new Chili Peppers song, "Abracadabralifornia". The song even featured a layout for the band's upcoming Super Bowl appearance, complete with sponsors' logos. Various people through websites including Twitter and Facebook at first were fooled by the song, although many quickly realized that it was a parody. The song was written and performed by Daly and musician Cyrus Ghahremani. Chili Peppers drummer Chad Smith Tweeted his approval of the song.

### Comedy Bang Bang World

In 2021, Aukerman tapped Brett Morris, longtime engineer, creative, and senior production manager of Earwolf to help create a new independent platform for the Comedy Bang Bang archive as well as launch new like-minded podcasts with their comedy friends.
On October 1, 2021 they launched Comedy Bang Bang World, offering exclusive Discord access, ad-free back episodes of CBB, CBB Live, and fan favorite Earwolf podcasts like Affirmation Nation with Bob Ducca, Mike Detective, and Bonanas For Bonanza. Premium "Maximus" subscribers got brand new shows like Scott Hasn't Seen, The Andy Daly Podcast Project, CBB-FM, College Town, We Have To Stop Talkin’ TMNT On CBB, and the rotating concept feed of CBB Presents, where comedy friends and recurring CBB characters host their own spin-off podcasts.
CBB Presents recurring podcasts have included Hey Randy (Tim Baltz), WHO ME? An Extremely True Crime Podcast with The Batmin (Bobby Moynihan), This Book Changed My Life (Lily Sullivan), Full Throttle with Bob Ducca (Seth Morris), Eat Pray Dunk with Bill Walton (Dan Lippert), Hi(Nes)! I’m Prov To Meet You (Will Hines), Entreè PeeE Neur's Entrepreneur Tour (Ego Nwodim), and various one-offs and specials.
Since launching, Andy Daly took his podcasts to his own Patreon channel, and CBB World has expanded its lineup to include the popular podcasts Threedom, The Neighborhood Listen, Womp It Up!, Going Deep, and The Gino Lombardo Show.

## Format and features

The podcast begins with a theme song composed and performed by Reggie Watts, followed by the reading of a listener-submitted catchphrase, under the pretense that one will eventually replace the show's original catchphrase, "What's up, hot dog?"
The show's format mixes conversation between the host and guests with comedy songs and occasionally game segments. Some guests play characters or impersonate certain celebrities, sometimes for the entirety of the episode.
For the first few months of the program, comedian Doug Benson would semi-regularly call the program and give several "8 Words or Less Movie Reviews".
Occasionally the podcast is taped with a live audience, usually at comedy shows or at festival events.
In the last third of the show, Aukerman and his guests will sometimes play one of several improv-style games. Examples of games played include:
* "Would You Rather?", in which the guests are presented with two typically absurd scenarios; following a brief question-and-answer session with answers made up on the spot by Aukerman, the contestants are asked to choose one of the options, with points given after each round.
* "Riddle Me This", in which one person comes up with a question that is the setup for a joke. An example would be "What's brown and is often spotted near a fast-food restaurant?". The other contestants then come up with answers and vote whose answer was the funniest.
* "Freestyle Rap Battle/Contest", in which the guests take turns performing a freestyle rap.
* "What Am I Thinking?", in which two guests (or Scott) count down together from three and attempt to use word association to say the same word.
The following games have been played on the podcast in the past, but not recently:
* "Jukebox Jury", in which Scott and the guests rate songs sent in by listeners as either "mustard" or "pants", although the meanings of the ratings is unknown.
* "Alive or Dead", in which Scott gives the guests the name of a celebrity and they must determine if that celebrity is alive or dead. The people in question are usually alive but their fictional deaths are described in a humorous way.
* "Who Said It?", in which guests name the person to whom a given quote is attributed.
* "Hollywood Facts", in which Scott and guests list fake celebrity gossip news. This game has largely been discontinued, however the game's theme music is regularly played when guest Andy Samberg appears on the podcast because Samberg recorded it.
Occasionally, guests will present their own features on the show. Examples include:
* "Harris' Foam/Phone Corner", in which Harris Wittels recited jokes, text-messaged to himself, which were deemed unworthy of his stand-up performances, and was ridiculed for his efforts.
* "New No-Nos", in which Paul Rust makes up new rules for life and the world, which he refers to as New No-Nos. Nearly every new rule is a ridiculous idea that does not solve any problem.
* "The Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge", in which Ben Schwartz and Scott sing a myriad of different songs, jingles, and show-tunes, attempting to seamlessly transition between songs that have some sort of connection to one another. These connections can include being by the same artist, including the same word or having a similar style, rhythm or melody.

## Episodes
### Recurring guests

* Paul F. Tompkins (240 episodes)
* Jason Mantzoukas (66 episodes)
* Lauren Lapkus (58 episodes)
* James Adomian (54 episodes)
* Will Hines (54 episodes)
* Andy Daly (52 episodes)
* Jon Gabrus (47 episodes)
* Neil Campbell (46 episodes)
* Carl Tart (44 episodes)
* Nick Kroll (42 episodes)
* Lily Sullivan (42 episodes)
* Drew Tarver (39 episodes)
* Tim Baltz (38 episodes)
* Shaun Diston (38 episodes)
* Ben Schwartz (38 episodes)
* Mike Hanford (37 episodes)
* Dan Lippert (32 episodes)
* Jon Daly (31 episodes)
* Ryan Gaul (31 episodes)
* Paul Rust (30 episodes)
* Horatio Sanz (30 episodes)
* Seth Morris (28 episodes)
* Ego Nwodim (28 episodes)
* Matt Besser (27 episodes)
* Mary Holland (27 episodes)
* Jessica McKenna (27 episodes)
* Tawny Newsome (22 episodes)
* Jessica St. Clair (22 episodes)
* Doug Benson (21 episodes)
* Reggie Watts (21 episodes)
* Brett Gelman (20 episodes)
* Harris Wittels (20 episodes)
* Matt Apodaca (19 episodes)
* "Weird Al" Yankovic (19 episodes)
* Zeke Nicholson (18 episodes)
* Paul Scheer (18 episodes)
* Matt Gourley (17 episodes)
* Vic Michaelis (17 episodes)
* Thomas Middleditch (17 episodes)
* Ben Rodgers (17 episodes)
* Brendon Small (17 episodes)
* Joe Wengert (17 episodes)
* Lisa Gilroy (16 episodes)
* Gil Ozeri (16 episodes)
* John Gemberling (15 episodes)
* Bobby Moynihan (15 episodes)
* Bob Odenkirk (15 episodes)
* Jimmy Pardo (15 episodes)
* Lennon Parham (15 episodes)
* Andy Richter (15 episodes)
* Ryan Rosenberg (15 episodes)
* Patton Oswalt (14 episodes)
* Paul Brittain (13 episodes)
* Zach Galifianakis (13 episodes)
* Rob Huebel (13 episodes)
* Gillian Jacobs (13 episodes)
* Edi Patterson (13 episodes)
* Chelsea Peretti (13 episodes)
* Adam Scott (13 episodes)
* David Wain (13 episodes)
* Madeline Walter (13 episodes)
* Thomas Lennon (12 episodes)
* Nick Thune (12 episodes)
* Kristian Bruun (11 episodes)
* Todd Glass (11 episodes)
* Jon Hamm (11 episodes)
* Tig Notaro (11 episodes)
* Andy Samberg (11 episodes)
* Sarah Silverman (11 episodes)
* Betsy Sodaro (11 episodes)
* Erin Whitehead (11 episodes)
* Nick Wiger (11 episodes)
* Casey Feigh (10 episodes)
* Tim Heidecker (10 episodes)
* Taran Killam (10 episodes)
* Natasha Leggero (10 episodes)
* Kumail Nanjiani (10 episodes)
* Claudia O'Doherty (10 episodes)
* Zac Oyama (10 episodes)
* Jeremy Rowley (10 episodes)
* Dave Theune (10 episodes)
* Matt Walsh (10 episodes)
* Jacob Wysocki (10 episodes)
* Brian Huskey (9 episodes)
* Tim Kalpakis (9 episodes)
* Erin Keif (9 episodes)
* Griffin Newman (9 episodes)
* Zach Reino (9 episodes)
* Casey Wilson (9 episodes)
* Eugene Cordero (8 episodes)
* David Cross (8 episodes)
* Tatiana Maslany (8 episodes)
* Adam Pally (8 episodes)
* Mookie Blaiklock (7 episodes)
* D'Arcy Carden (7 episodes)
* Cameron Esposito (7 episodes)
* Greg Hess (7 episodes)
* John Hodgman (7 episodes)
* Howard Kremer (7 episodes)
* James Mannion (7 episodes)
* Jerry Minor (7 episodes)
* Pamela Murphy (7 episodes)
* Holly Prazoff (7 episodes)
* Martin Starr (7 episodes)
* Kulap Vilaysack (7 episodes)
* Suzi Barrett (6 episodes)
* Matt Braunger (6 episodes)
* Christine Bullen (6 episodes)
* Michael Cassady (6 episodes)
* Sean Clements (6 episodes)
* Jefferson Dutton (6 episodes)
* Devin Field (6 episodes)
* Riki Lindhome (6 episodes)
* Allan McLeod (6 episodes)
* John Mulaney (6 episodes)
* Jacquis Neal (6 episodes)
* Kevin Nealon (6 episodes)
* Jack Quaid (6 episodes)
* Jonah Ray (6 episodes)
* Alison Rich (6 episodes)
* Katie Rich (6 episodes)
* Rory Scovel (6 episodes)
* Max Silvestri (6 episodes)
* Edgar Wright (6 episodes)
* Ronnie Adrian (5 episodes)
* Dan Ahdoot (5 episodes)
* Caroline Anderson (5 episodes)
* Ike Barinholtz (5 episodes)
* Todd Barry (5 episodes)
* River Butcher (5 episodes)
* Adam Cayton-Holland (5 episodes)
* Rob Corddry (5 episodes)
* Hayes Davenport (5 episodes)
* Colin Hanks (5 episodes)
* Mitra Jouhari (5 episodes)
* Langston Kerman (5 episodes)
* Holly Laurent (5 episodes)
* Charlie McCrackin (5 episodes)
* Mike Mitchell (5 episodes)
* Haley Joel Osment (5 episodes)
* Natalie Palamides (5 episodes)
* Hannah Pilkes (5 episodes)
* Connor Ratliff (5 episodes)
* The Sklar Brothers (5 episodes)
* Mary Sohn (5 episodes)
* Brendon Walsh (5 episodes)
* Ele Woods (5 episodes)
* Stephanie Allynne (4 episodes)
* Maria Bamford (4 episodes)
* Michael Ian Black (4 episodes)
* Flula Borg (4 episodes)
* Heather Anne Campbell (4 episodes)
* Jerrod Carmichael (4 episodes)
* Jocelyn DeBoer (4 episodes)
* Adam DeVine (4 episodes)
* Sean Dickerson (4 episodes)
* Dave Ferguson (4 episodes)
* Alex Fernie (4 episodes)
* Nathan Fielder (4 episodes)
* Fran Gillespie (4 episodes)
* Chris Hardwick (4 episodes)
* Erinn Hayes (4 episodes)
* Moshe Kasher (4 episodes)
* Jon Mackey (4 episodes)
* Dan Mangan (4 episodes)
* Aimee Mann (4 episodes)
* Ken Marino (4 episodes)
* Edgar Momplaisir (4 episodes)
* Mike O'Brien (4 episodes)
* Eddie Pepitone (4 episodes)
* Amy Phillips (4 episodes)
* Mary Lynn Rajskub (4 episodes)
* Andrea Savage (4 episodes)
* Danielle Schneider (4 episodes)
* Rekha Shankar (4 episodes)
* Dhruv Uday Singh (4 episodes)
* Monika Smith (4 episodes)
* Nick Swardson (4 episodes)
* Lamar Woods (4 episodes)
* Aziz Ansari (3 episodes)
* Anthony Atamanuik (3 episodes)
* Kate Berlant (3 episodes)
* Mike Birbiglia (3 episodes)
* The Birthday Boys (3 episodes)
* Kyle Bornheimer (3 episodes)
* Jordan Black (3 episodes)
* Molly Bretthauer (3 episodes)
* Nick Ciarelli (3 episodes)
* Jackie Clarke (3 episodes)
* Brad Evans (3 episodes)
* Chris Gethard (3 episodes)
* Anthony Jeselnik (3 episodes)
* James Austin Johnson (3 episodes)
* Alana Johnston (3 episodes)
* Myq Kaplan (3 episodes)
* Kyle Kinane (3 episodes)
* Ted Leo (3 episodes)
* Amanda Lund (3 episodes)
* Manchester Orchestra (3 episodes)
* Mandell Maughan (3 episodes)
* Kate Micucci (3 episodes)
* Eugene Mirman (3 episodes)
* Ify Nwadiwe (3 episodes)
* Nicole Parker (3 episodes)
* Amy Poehler (3 episodes)
* June Diane Raphael (3 episodes)
* Eliza Skinner (3 episodes)
* Jenny Slate (3 episodes)
* Chris Tallman (3 episodes)
* Gregg Turkington (3 episodes)
* Brent Weinbach (3 episodes)
* Dan Wilson (3 episodes)

### 2009

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 1: Welcome To Comedy Bang Bang | 5/1/09 | Rob Huebel Thomas Lennon Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies: X-Men Origins: Wolverine | "Turn My Swag On" (Theme Song) by Soulja Boy "Buy You Clothes, Do You In 'em, Take 'em Back" by Dragon Boy Suede "Ladyboy" by R.O. Manse "We Can Count" by Cracked Out "In My Life" by Sean Connery |
| Episode 2: Reggaeton Soundboard | 5/8/09 | Aziz Ansari Kevin Nealon Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies: Star Trek | "Short Pants For Fatty" by The Reigning Monarchs "Sax Man" by The Lonely Island (featuring Jack Black) "Business Time" by Flight of the Conchords "Eat It" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Wiseguy" by Joe Pesci "Pi" by Hard 'N Phirm (featuring Dragon Boy Suede) "Nut Valet" by Dragon Boy Suede |
| Episode 3: Never Date A "Brown" | 5/15/09 | Jackie Clarke Greg Behrendt Nick Thune Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies: Angels & Demons | "The Life Of Brian" by Monty Python "Austin Powers" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Wonderboy" by Tenacious D "Blaine" by The New Sheridans "Fanfare For The Well Dressed Man" by The Reigning Monarchs "Punch You In The Jeans" by The Lonely Island "I Wanna Be A Hulkamaniac" by Hulk Hogan & The Wrestling Boot Band |
| Episode 4: Special Nerdist Edition | 5/22/09 | Chris Hardwick (guest host) Matt Mira Mike Phirman Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies: Terminator Salvation | "New Math" by Tom Lehrer "You Make Me" by "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Episode 5: Guest Host Jimmy Pardo | 5/29/09 | Jimmy Pardo (guest host) Matt Belknap Maria Bamford as Jazz Martin Paul Gilmartin as Congressman Richard Martin Pat Francis as Paul Stanley Garfunkel and Oates Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies: Drag Me to Hell | "Broken Hearts Are for Assholes" by Frank Zappa "17" by Kings of Leon "You Make Me" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "New Cassette" by Tinted Windows "Pregnant Women are Smug" by Garfunkel and Oates "Sex With Ducks" by Garfunkel and Oates |
| Episode 6: Doing Laundry with Sarah | 6/5/09 | Howard Kremer Brett Gelman as James Gandolfini and Billy Crystal Sarah Silverman calls in Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies (8 Words or Less): Land of the Lost and The Hangover | "MTV Movie Awards Medley" by The Lonely Island (featuring LeAnn Rimes, Chris Isaak and Forest Whitaker) "Love Slaves" by Tim and Eric "You Won't Sass Me Like That When I Can Summon Wolves" by Dragon Boy Suede "Jug Town" by Neil Hamburger "Kick It" by The Vandals (featuring Bob Odenkirk and David Cross) "I Heal With My Steel" by Dragon Boy Suede (featuring Rapzilla) "I Got a Perm for Our Camping Trip" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "I'm on Fire" "The Curly Shuffle" by The Jump in the Saddle Band "Buy You Clothes, Do You In 'Em, Take 'Em Back" by Dragon Boy Suede (featuring Rapzilla) "Tonight You Belong to Me" by Steve Martin and Bernadette Peters |
| Episode 7: Double Co-Hosts | 6/12/09 | The Sklar Brothers Paul Rust as Cal Shipsby and Jerry Jimson Paul F. Tompkins calls in Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies (8 Words or Less): Imagine That and The Taking of Pelham 123 | "Big Bottom" by Spinal Tap "Who Said We’re Wack?" by The Lonely Island "I'm Never Gonna Wipe My Butt" by The Shins "The Metal" by Tenacious D "Whatever You Like" by Weird Al Yankovic "You Look Marvelous" by Billy Crystal "Zitty Van Zitties" by Adam Sandler "Hawaii" by The Glass Beef |
| Episode 8: The New Doctor Demento | 6/19/09 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul Scheer as Jim Pipe and Richard Dalton Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies (8 Words or Less): The Proposal and Year One | "The Weird Al Show Theme" by Weird Al Yankovic "Amish Paradise" by Weird Al Yankovic "It's Still Billy Joel To Me" by Weird Al Yankovic "Craigslist" by Weird Al Yankovic "Alternative Polka" by Weird Al Yankovic "My Bologna" by Weird Al Yankovic "Pancreas" by Weird Al Yankovic "One More Minute" by Weird Al Yankovic |
| Episode 9: R.I.P. Michael Jackson | 6/26/09 | Dax Shepard Chip Pope as R.O. Mance Paul F. Tompkins as Michael Jackson's Ghost calls in Gregg Turkington as Neil Hamburger calls in | | |
| Episode 10: Comedy Vs. Music | 7/3/09 | Aimee Mann Morgan Murphy Seth Morris as Todd Wickey Doug Benson calls in | Doug Loves Movies (8 Words or Less): Tom Cruise Edition | "Street Legal" by Dragon Boy Suede "Nobody's Perfect" by Sarah Silverman "Low Voice" by R. O. Manse "31 Today" by Aimee Mann "Anything" by Hard N Phirm "Three Piece Chicken Dinner" by Neil Hamburger "Birthday Checks" by Scott Aukerman "Central Park" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Hearts" by Tim & Eric feat. Aimee Mann |
| Episode 11: Birthday Checks! | 7/10/09 | Doug Benson Rob Huebel The Sklar Brothers | Doug Loves Movies (8 Words or Less): I Love You, Beth Cooper and Brüno | "Take Off" by Bob and Doug McKenzie "Jizz In My Pants" by The Lonely Island "You Be My Wife" by Borat "Driving A Truck With My High Heels On" by Weird Al Yankovic "Birthday Checks" by Scott Aukerman "Open Up Your Window" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Tonight I'm Gonna Rock You Tonight" by Spinal Tap "Always Look On The Bright Side Of Life" by Monty Python |
| Episode 12: The Baby's Sunglasses | 7/17/09 | Jon Hamm Howard Kremer Nick Kroll as himself, Bobby Bottleservice and El Chupacabra Doug Benson | Doug Loves Movie (8 Words or Less): Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince | "You Won't Sass Me Like That When I Can Summon Wolves" by Dragon Boy Suede "The Most Beautiful Girl (In the Room)" by Flight of the Conchords "Let's Duet" by Dewey Cox "Champagne" by Chris Rock "Happiness Pie" by Bruce McCulloch "Boogie in Your Butt" by Eddie Murphy "Love Me Sexy" by Will Ferrell "I'm So Ronery" by Trey Parker and Matt Stone |
| Episode 13: Jimmy Pardo's Back | 7/24/09 | Jimmy Pardo (guest host) Jason Nash as The Shaman Jimmy Dore Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T Doug Benson calls in | | "The Self-Proclaimed Critic" by Daver "Mexican Joe" by Jim Reeves "Bimbo" by Jim Reeves "Simple As That" by Ben Wise "Fish Out Of Water" by Simon Scardanelli "My Pants" by Dr. Pants "Mad At The World' by Daver |
| Episode 14: An Old Fashioned Dinner | 7/31/09 | Andy Samberg Zach Galifianakis Andy Daly as Danny Mahoney, Shooter, and himself Doug Benson calls in | Games: Would You Rather? | "Space Olympics" by The Lonely Island "Ka-Blamo!" by The Lonely Island "Come On and Get It (Up in 'Dem Guts)" by Zach Galifianakis (featuring Fiona Apple) "Stork Patrol" by The Lonely Island "I Think I Might Have Killed the President" by The Lonely Island "Boombox" by The Lonely Island (featuring Julian Casablancas) "Ardy Party" by The Lonely Island "Metaphor" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 15: Four Douche Episode | 8/7/09 | Steve Agee Natasha Leggero Matt Besser as himself and Björk | Games: Would You Rather? | "So Great" by Sarah Silverman "Sugalumps" by Flight Of The Conchords "I Love Rock 'N Roll' by Joe Piscopo "Boats 'N' Hoes" by Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly "When You're Fat" by Bruce McCulloch "Let Me Borrow That Top" by Kelly "Super Heroes" by Barry Bostwick and Susan Sarandon |
| Episode 16: Bob Odenkirk's Death Bed | 8/14/09 | Andy Dick Bob Odenkirk Chelsea Peretti | Games: Would You Rather? | "Dip Your Cock In Vodka" by Andy Dick "We're Number One" by Bob Odenkirk "Surfin' Bird" by Pee Wee Herman "Mr. Roboto" by Styx "Sausage Party" by Pink Steel "Here She Comes" by Tim & Eric featuring Bob Odenkirk "Kick It" by The Vandals featuring Bob Odenkirk and David Cross |
| Episode 17: Live From Downtown Franklin | 8/21/09 | Thomas Lennon as Little Gary and himself Matt Walsh Matt Braunger | Games: Would You Rather? | "Friendship" by Tenacious D "Bennigan'z" by Cracked Out "Anthem" by Chip Pope "Me, You and Steve" by Garfunkel and Oates |
| Episode 18: Poppin' Bottles | 8/28/09 | Andy Kindler Jerry Minor Brendon Walsh | Games: Would You Rather? | "Jazzbot Xtreme" by JP Incorporated "Think About It" by Flight Of The Conchords "Shaddap You Face" by Joe Dolce "America (Fuck Yeah)" by Matt Stone and Trey Parker "CNR" by Weird Al Yankovic "Eric The Half-a-Bee" by Monty Python "Dracula's Lament" by Jason Segel |
| Episode 19: SNL Reunion | 9/4/09 | Kevin Nealon Laraine Newman Casey Wilson | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 20: World Premiere of Tangelo | 9/11/09 | Mary Lynn Rajskub Reggie Watts Rory Scovel | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 21: Morning Becomes Oddly Racist | 9/18/09 | Chris Hardwick Charlyne Yi Seth Morris as Nathan Brantley | | |
| Episode 22: Yet Another Pardo-sode | 9/25/09 | Jimmy Pardo (guest host) Dana Gould Matt Belknap Pat Francis as Paul Stanley Mike Toomey as Kirk Rocker | | "Question Song" by Tom Wilson "The Fonz Song" by the Heyettes (Pardo introduces this as "the worst song ever recorded") "The Curly Shuffle" by Jump in the Saddle "Star Trekkin'" by The Firm "Funky Man" by Dee Dee Ramone |
| Bonus Episode: Live from Vancouver Comedy Fest | 9/25/09 | Reggie Watts Nick Thune Todd Barry Paul F. Tompkins Garfunkel and Oates | | |
| Episode 23: Guest Host Paul F. Tompkins | 10/2/09 | Paul F. Tompkins (guest host) "Weird Al" Yankovic Tig Notaro | | |
| Episode 24: No Such Thing As Shirter! | 10/9/09 | Nick Swardson Matt Walsh James Adomian as Gary Busey Paul F. Tompkins | | |
| Episode 25: We're Down For Whatewers | 10/16/09 | Gregg Turkington as Neil Hamburger Mike O'Connell Brent Weinbach | | |
| Episode 26: What Do You Say To Your Dog? | 10/23/09 | Sarah Silverman Andy Richter | | |
| Episode 27: A Cyberthug Take-Over! | 10/30/09 | Jerry Minor as Cyber Thug (guest host) Jerry O'Connell Nick Kroll Sean Dickerson as Miles Archer | | |
| Episode 28: Did Somebody Sit on a Duck? | 11/6/09 | Paul F. Tompkins Todd Glass Jon Daly | | |
| Episode 29: Introducing Huell Howser | 11/13/09 | Ben Schwartz Chip Pope James Adomian as Huell Howser | | |
| Episode 30: Yerr An Egghead! | 11/20/09 | Matt Walsh Howard Kremer as himself, Sloppy Timmy Slotsman, Big Jim Slotsman, and Bobby Jensen Dave Holmes | | "Pi" by Hard 'n Phirm "Gymnastics Dad" by JP Hasson "Me Mother Became a Werewolf" by The Mighty Regis "I'm Not Paying Five-Hundred Dollars to Watch Douchebags Eat Turkey" by Dragon Boy Suede "I Must Be in Love" by The Rutles |
| Episode 31: Happy Black Friday! | 11/27/09 | Michael Cera Harris Wittels James Adomian as Huell Howser Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T calls in Jimmy Pardo Nick Kroll as Bobby Bottleservice calls in | Games: Harris' Phone Corner, Would You Rather? | "The Thanksgiving Song" by Adam Sandler "Cold Turkey" by John Lennon (briefly) "I'm Not Paying 500 Dollars to Watch Douchebags Eat Turkey" by Dragon Boy Suede Do They Know It's Christmas? by The Comedy Death-Ray Xmas Nativity Choir "Christmas is for Fucking" by Reggie Watts "You've Got to Follow Your Balloon" by Mr. Show "Gay Ray, the Reggae Gay (The Homosexual Rasta)" by Eli Braden "Skipper Dan" by Weird Al Yankovic |
| Episode 32: Raaaaaaaandy! | 12/4/09 | Aziz Ansari Brendon Small as himself, Captain Moustache, Fat Albert, and Louis Armstrong Hal Rudnick as Stan Lee | | "Bloodlines" by Dethklok "I'm On a Boat" by The Lonely Island "Give the Jew Girl Toys" by Sarah Silverman |
| Episode 33: Welcome To Jamrock | 12/11/09 | Kyle Kinane Paul F. Tompkins | | |
| Episode 34: Have A Merry Christmas... | 12/18/09 | Jon Hamm Doug Benson Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Paul F. Tompkins as John C. Reilly James Adomian as Jesse Ventura Kulap Vilaysack | | |
| The Best of 2009 | 12/27/09 | Nick Kroll as Bobby Bottleservice Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T James Adomian as Huell Howser | | |

### 2010

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 35: And A Happy New Year! | 1/8/10 | Thomas Lennon as Little Gary and Chris Mindy Patton Oswalt Brett Gelman | | "eBay" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Cool Guys Don't Look at Explosions" by Andy Samberg, Will Ferrell and J. J. Abrams "Stu's Song" by Ed Helms "Police & Thieves" by The Clash |
| Episode 36: Another Cyberthug Take-Over! | 1/15/10 | Jerry Minor as Cyber Thug (guest host) Matt Besser as Kanye East and Taylor Slow Sean Dickerson as Miles Archer | | |
| Bonus Episode: Live from San Francisco Sketch Fest | 1/18/10 | Doug Benson Michael Ian Black Paul F. Tompkins Dana Gould Reggie Watts | | |
| Episode 37: Exclusive Prince Interview | 1/22/10 | Sarah Silverman Todd Glass Hannibal Buress | | |
| Episode 38: Paul F. Tompkins Steps In | 1/29/10 | Paul F. Tompkins (guest host) Kaitlin Olson Matt Gourley Jeremy Carter Mark McConville | | |
| Bonus Episode: Live from UCB Theatre New York | 2/2/10 | Zach Galifianakis David Cross Todd Barry John Gemberling Ted Leo | | |
| Episode 39: The Premiere of Bob Ducca | 2/5/10 | Garfunkel and Oates Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Brendon Walsh | | |
| Episode 40: Happy Valentine's Day | 2/12/10 | Doug Benson James Adomian as Christopher Hitchens Harris Wittels Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall | Games: Harris' Phone Corner, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 41: Winter Olympic Fever | 2/19/10 | Aimee Mann Kumail Nanjiani Drew Droege as Maya Angelou | | |
| Episode 42: Winter Olympic Fever: Deux! | 2/26/10 | Nick Thune Matt Walsh as Stash Polinyac Ian Roberts as Boris Darchinian Danielle Schneider as Irena Stinchen James Pumphrey | | |
| Episode 43: Good One! | 3/5/10 | Tig Notaro Casey Wilson as Julie Penzmere Rory Scovel | | |
| Episode 44: We Got A Caller on the Line | 3/12/10 | Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Paul F. Tompkins as Dame Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber Jason Woliner | Games: Would You Rather? | "Lasagne" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Bitch School" by Spinal Tap "I'm Saving My Hymen for Jesus"* by Broad Comedy |
| Episode 45: Cyberthug Take-Over Pt. Three | 3/19/10 | Jerry Minor as Cyber Thug (guest host) James Adomian as Jesse Ventura Craig Robinson David Sitek Dave Cousin Brandon Johnson | | |
| Episode 46: Curb Your Suicide Attempts | 3/26/10 | Ben Stiller Jeff Garlin Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T Andy Daly as Ben Alterman | | |
| Episode 47: Happy Chap | 4/2/10 | Greg Proops Jon Daly as Barry R. | Games: Would You Rather? | "Uncle Fucka" by Trey Parker and Matt Stone "Hamburgers and Hot Dogs" by Tim and Eric "One Night"* by Stephen Bowcom "Poisoning Pigeons in the Park" by Tom Lehrer |
| Episode 48: In The Thicke of the Night | 4/9/10 | The Sklar Brothers Paul Scheer as J. Montgomery Scott | | "That's What I Wish" by Sarah Silverman "Will We Eat Each Other's Doodies" by Sarah Silverman "Hey Aunt Jemima"* by Jeff Ellingson "Glad You Hurt Your Hand" by Steve Agee and Brian Posehn "Halo" by Weirder Scott Aukerman (Parody of "Hello" by Lionel Richie) "Glad I Hurt My Hand" by Brian Posehn |
| Episode 49: Family Counseling | 4/16/10 | Adam Scott Matt Walsh as Jerry McDowell June Diane Raphael as Kathy McDowell James Pumphrey as Damian Vast Chris Fairbanks | | "Baby" by Tenacious D "Penis Song (Not the Noel Coward Song)" by Monty Python "My Retarded Girlfriend"* by Phillipe Simondet "Get Me to the Toilet"* by Bloody Anal Leakage "Midnight Party"* by Shoddy Radio |
| Episode 50: A Thrilling Hour or So | 4/23/10 | Paul Gilmartin Mookie Blaiklock The cast of The Thrilling Adventure Hour | | "Asian Baby" by Mike O'Connell "Colonel Tick Tock's Theme" by the cast of the Thrilling Adventure Hour "Here's to Us" by Paul F. Tompkins and Paget Brewster "Fish Heads" by Dr. Demento "Gangsta Dinosaurs"* by Humungo Ginormous "Man-Made Vagina"* by Beaver and Phone "Takin' a Shit"* by John Gardner "When I'm Done" by Dragon Boy Suede |
| Episode 51: One Year Anniversary Party | 4/30/10 | Tig Notaro Paul F. Tompkins as John C. Reilly, Ice-T and Dame Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber calls in James Adomian as Jesse Ventura and Huell Howser Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Thomas Lennon as Little Gary Rich Fulcher Nick Kroll as Bobby Bottleservice and El Chupacabra Jerry Minor | Games: Would You Rather? | "Love Will Lead You Back" by Taylor Dayne "Tell It To My Heart" by Taylor Dayne "I'll Be Your Shelter" by Taylor Dayne "Heart of Stone" by Taylor Dayne "Original Sin" by Taylor Dayne "Champion" by Kristen Wiig "Birthday Checks" by Weirder Scott "Pico and Sepulveda" by Felix Figuero and His Orchestra |
| Episode 52: Introducing: The Japan Dogs | 5/7/10 | Sarah Silverman Harris Wittels Ben Schwartz | Games: Harris' Phone Corner | |
| Episode 53: A Cover of a Parody | 5/14/10 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Garfunkel and Oates | | |
| Episode 54: The Wacky Ding Dongs | 5/21/10 | Marc Maron The Birthday Boys | | |
| Episode 55: Go Rent Delgo! | 5/28/10 | Natasha Leggero Jason Mantzoukas Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | Games: Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 56: Is Dave Foley Here? | 6/4/10 | David Anthony Higgins Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | | |
| Episode 57: A Buttery, Juicy Episode | 6/11/10 | Brian Posehn James Adomian as Merrill Shindler | | |
| Episode 58: I Want It That Way | 6/19/10 | Rob Huebel Steel Panther | | |
| Episode 59: Free Subarus for Moms! | 6/25/10 | Paul F. Tompkins Todd Glass Andy Daly as August Lindt | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 60: Now Hiring Interns! | 7/2/10 | Donald Glover Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Brendon Walsh | | |
| Episode 61: Palin 2012 | 7/9/10 | Jimmy Pardo Rory Scovel | | |
| Episode 62: Serious or Sarcastic? | 7/16/10 | Andy Richter Matt Besser as Bennett Stevens Paul F. Tompkins as Danny Glover Don't Stop Or We'll Die (Paul Rust, Michael Cassady, Harris Wittels) | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 63: Harry's World: Mad Men | 7/23/10 | Jon Hamm Rich Sommer David Koechner as Gerald "T-Bones" Tibbons | | |
| Episode 64: Harrison Ford Approved | 7/30/10 | Sarah Silverman Mary Lynn Rajskub James Adomian as Merrill Shindler | | |
| Episode 65: Welcome To Earwolf! | 8/5/10 | The Sklar Brothers Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | Games: Jukebox Jury | "A Kiss is Not a Contract" by Flight of the Conchords "Darling" by John C. Reilly "Japanese Cowboy" by Ween "Bob" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Give Peace a Chance" by Mitch Miller and the Gang |
| Episode 66.1: Where Do Babies Come From? | 8/12/10 | Bob Odenkirk Brett Gelman | | |
| Episode 66.2: Cool Whip Play Challenge | 8/16/10 | Bob Odenkirk Brett Gelman | | |
| Episode 67: What Happens In Vegas | 8/19/10 | Rob Corddry Lake Bell Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 68: Live From LA it's Comedy Bang Bang! | 8/26/10 | Fred Armisen Howard Kremer Trainwreck | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 69: I Am Not Food | 9/1/10 | Thomas Lennon as Little Gary Kumail Nanjiani Loch and Key | Games: Entourage re-cap; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 70: Rock 'n Roll Dreams | 9/8/10 | Ted Leo Aimee Mann Jon Wurster Paul F. Tompkins as Mr. Brainwash | Games: Jukebox Jury; Fortunately, Unfortunately | |
| Episode 71: Comedy Death Scott | 9/15/10 | Paul Scheer as himself and J. Montgomery Scott Nick Kroll as himself, El Chupacabra, and Vinnie from Port Washington | | |
| Episode 72: History In The Making | 9/22/10 | Janeane Garofalo Andy Dick James Adomian as Paul Giamatti, Huell Howser, and Mr. Hairslice | | |
| Episode 73: Featuring Betty White! | 9/29/10 | Nick Swardson as himself and Betty White Jon Daly as Bill Cosby-Bukowski | Games: UnGames Question of the Week; Jukebox Jury; Would You Rather | |
| Episode 74: Introducing Rocky! | 10/6/10 | Andy Daly as Bill Carter and Patrick McMahon Jason Mantzoukas | | "Running With Chicken" by Garfunkel and Oates |
| Episode 75: The Farting Fuck Faces | 10/13/10 | Mike Birbiglia Matt Besser as Mark Zuckerberg Henry Phillips | Games: Fortunately Unfortunately | |
| Episode 76.1: Can He Sing, Jeremy Piven? | 10/15/10 | Zach Galifianakis Paul F. Tompkins as Dame Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber Dillon Campbell | Part 1 | |
| Episode 76.2: Don't Cry Rolling Skate Train | 10/20/10 | Zach Galifianakis Paul F. Tompkins as Dame Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber Dillon Campbell | Part 2 Games: What Am I Thinking?; Jukebox Jury; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 77: Crappy Howl-o-ween! | 10/27/10 | Jerry Minor as Cyber Thug Sean Dickerson as Miles Archer Allan McLeod as Ghost Boy Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron Brett Gelman as Messmore le Barron Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi | Halloween episode Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 78: Poundin' Puss in Heaven | 11/3/10 | Doug Benson John Gemberling as Pastor Rhe Holner | Games: The Leonard Maltin Games; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 79: Who'd Fuck Tom Brady? | 11/10/10 | Eugene Mirman Jackie Clarke as Claire Woodruff Mookie Blaiklock as Carl McCarthy | Games: What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 80: Enigma Force Five Reunion | 11/17/10 | Adam Scott Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T James Adomian as Jesse Ventura and Huell Howser | | |
| Episode 81: Todd Barry Vs. Borders | 11/24/10 | Todd Barry Paul Rust as Leo Carnell Neil Campbell as Nathan Morrow | Games: What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 82: Dammit That Was a Hot Jam | 11/29/10 | Kevin Nealon Sarah Silverman Tig Notaro Jon Daly as Barry R. Jerry Minor as Cyberthug Sean Dickerson as Miles Archer | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 83: Family Matters | 12/6/10 | Michael Ian Black Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 84: Impotent Teamsters Unite | 12/13/10 | Harris Wittels Reggie Watts Eddie Pepitone as Tommy Malone | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 85: That's One Way of Doing It | 12/20/10 | Colin Hanks Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Andy Daly as Don Dimello Brett Gelman as himself and James Gandolfini Neil Campbell as Pimsy the Elf, Jerry, and Ebesneezer Scrooge | Christmas episode | |
| The Best of 2010 | 12/26/10 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself, Ice-T, Danny Glover, Garry Marshall, and Andrew Lloyd Webber Andy Daly as August Lindt Brett Gelman James Adomian as Huell Howser and Christopher Hitchens Jon Daly as Bill Cosby-Bukowski and Frasier Fonzie Nick Kroll as himself and El Chupacabra Reggie Watts Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Thomas Lennon as himself and Little Gary Tig Notaro as herself, Good One Robot, and Molly's Mother | | |

### 2011

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 86: The New Year Attack of 2011 | 1/3/11 | Patton Oswalt Rob Huebel | Games: Alive or Dead; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 87: Droppin' Wallets! | 1/10/11 | Nick Thune Chelsea Peretti | Games: Sports Results; Jukebox Jury; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 88: Impression Off | 1/17/11 | Chris Hardwick Matt Braunger | Games: Guess the Misheard Lyrics; The WTF? Question of the Week; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 89: Great Big Hill of Hope | 1/24/11 | Nick Kroll as Fabrice Fabrice and Bobby Bottleservice Harris Wittels | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 90: Is This Sexual Harassment? | 1/31/11 | Brett Gelman Michael Gladis Maria Thayer | Games: Is This News Story True or False?; What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 91: Garry Marshall Presents | 2/7/11 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Tom Scharpling Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall | Games: Who Said It?; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 92: How's Your Boner? | 2/14/11 | Andy Richter Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: Guess the Celebrities’ Real Name; What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 93: And The Oscar Goes To... | 2/21/11 | Reggie Watts James Adomian as Paul Giamatti | Games: Oscar Trivia; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 94: Dip Didda Dip Dow! | 2/28/11 | Ben Schwartz Andy Daly as Hot Dog | Games: Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 95: Phishing For Compliments | 3/7/11 | Natasha Leggero Harris Wittels Matt Besser as King George VI | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; Jukebox Jury; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 96: Live from SXSW! | 3/13/11 | Paul Reubens Dave Foley Thomas Lennon as Little Gary | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 97: Can I Catch A Ride? | 3/21/11 | Jon Hamm Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | Games: Who Said It?; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 98: A Worthy Uhhh | 3/28/11 | Adam Scott James Adomian as Alan Rickman | Games: Guess The Misheard Lyric; Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 99: Somethin' For Daddy! | 4/4/11 | Patton Oswalt Andy Daly as Don Dimello | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 100: The Big One-Oh-Oh | 4/11/11 | Susanna Hoffs Matthew Sweet Rob Huebel Thomas Lennon as himself and Little Gary Doug Benson calls in | Games: Who Said It? | |
| Episode 101: Booked It! | 4/18/11 | Joe Lo Truglio Casey Wilson Matt Besser as Fred Phelps | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 102: Behind the Music | 4/25/11 | Tim Heidecker as himself and Elton John Gregg Turkington as Neil Hamburger and Bernie Taupin | Games: Alive or Dead? | "Life On The Road" by Heidecker & Wood |
| Episode 103: These Times They Are A-Changin' | 5/2/11 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself, Huell Howser, and Yogi Bear Reggie Watts Andy Daly as Clive Dundee Paul Scheer as Truck Bastien Tig Notaro Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra James Adomian as Huell Howser, Jesse Ventura, and Paul F. Tompkins | | |
| Episode 104: Shut Up Dracula! | 5/9/11 | Paul Feig The Birthday Boys | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 105: Comedy is Honey | 5/16/11 | Matt Walsh Scot Armstrong Jon Daly as Sappity Tappity | Games: Alive or Dead?; What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 106: It's a Fucking Podcast: Pt. 1 | 5/23/11 | Andy Richter Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Who Said It? | "I'm back" by Randy Savage "Rocket Experience" by Buzz Aldrin |
| Episode 106.5: It's a Fucking Podcast: Pt. 2 | 5/30/11 | Andy Richter Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Would You Rather? | "The Crimson Permanent Assurance" by Monty Python "A Kiss is not a Contract" by Flight of the Conchords |
| Episode 107: Maybe It's Maybelline | 6/6/11 | John Mulaney as himself and George St Geegland Nick Kroll as Gil Faizon, Fabrice Fabrice, and Don Pardo as Marv Albert | | |
| Episode 108: Pussy CPR | 6/13/11 | Rob Corddry Erinn Hayes James Adomian as Dov Charney | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 109: The Andy Samberg Special | 6/20/11 | Andy Samberg Adam Pally as Bro | Games: Hollywood Facts; Would You Rather? | "Reba (Two Worlds Collide)" by The Lonely Island feat. Kenan Thompson "Japan" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 110: Thumbs Yes! | 6/27/11 | Colin Hanks Myq Kaplan Paul Scheer as Kylie Bloom | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "Having No Friends" by Sarah Silverman |
| Episode 111: Hi, How Are You? | 7/1/11 | David Guy Levy Harris Wittels Brett Gelman | Games: Harris' Foam Corner | "I Can Make You A Man (Reprise)" by Tim Curry "The Camping Song" by Hard 'n Phirm |
| Episode 112: Since You've Been Gone | 7/5/11 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber | Games: Word Association; Would You Rather? | "If That Isn't Love" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Since You've Been Gone" by "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Episode 113: Skanking Hayride | 7/11/11 | Bobby Moynihan Seth Morris as Ozzie Patinkin | Games: Hollywood Facts; Would You Rather? | "The Government Totally Sucks" by Tenacious D "My Sister's Cute" by Tim and Eric "Dry Sheets, Ice Cream, Jellybeans" by Sarah Silverman & Sydney Park |
| Episode 114: Hats Off to Caruso | 7/18/11 | Edgar Wright Joe Cornish Matt Besser as Martin Riley | Games: Hollywood Facts; Would You Rather? | "With A Girl Like You" by The Rutles "You're Gonna Die Soon" by Sarah Silverman |
| Episode 115: The Plug-In Drug | 7/25/11 | Paul Rudd David Wain Ken Marino | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle; What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "No Homo" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 116: When I Go To Queens... | 8/1/11 | Todd Glass Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "Lee" by Tenacious D "Hamburgers and Hot Dogs" by Tim and Eric |
| Episode 117: Can't Never Did Nothing | 8/8/11 | David Cross Ruben Fleischer Chad Carter as Sam Darling | Games: Hollywood Facts; Would You Rather? | "Pizza Boy" by David Cross "You've Got To Follow Your Balloon" by Bob Odenkirk & David Cross |
| Episode 118: Hologram Toes | 8/15/11 | Patton Oswalt Eddie Pepitone as The Diner Marshal | | "I'm Glad You Hurt Your Hand" by Steve Agee & Brian Posehn "I Sit On You" by Tim and Eric |
| Episode 119: Andi Callahan, RN | 8/22/11 | Gillian Jacobs Andy Daly as Andi Callahan | | "The Mulatto Song" by Dewey Cox |
| Episode 120: Farts and Procreation | 8/29/11 | Adam Scott Harris Wittels Chelsea Peretti | Games: Harris' Foam Corner | "Mama" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 121: Bro-ing Out | 9/5/11 | Jimmy Pardo Paul Rust Rob Delaney | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Hot Topics; Jukebox Jury | |
| Episode 122: Shanghaied by Irene | 9/12/11 | Zach Galifianakis Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog Yo La Tengo | Games: Would You Rather? | "Let's Save Tony Orlando's House" by Yo La Tengo "Sugarcube" by Yo La Tengo "Periodically Double or Triple" by Yo La Tengo "Tom Courtenay" by Yo La Tengo |
| Episode 123: No Scoop For You | 9/19/11 | Amy Poehler The Bangles Adam Pally as David Fiene | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle; Would You Rather? | "Manic Monday" by The Bangles "Hazy Shade of Winter" by The Bangles "Ride The Ride" by The Bangles |
| Episode 124: Bro-ing Out Pt. Deux | 9/26/11 | Todd Barry Nick Thune Matthew Sweet | Games: Hot Topics; What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "She Walks The Night" by Matthew Sweet "Baltimore" by Matthew Sweet "I've Been Waiting" by Matthew Sweet "Byrdgirl" by Matthew Sweet |
| Episode 125: Wine in the Whirlpool | 10/3/11 | Sarah Silverman Nick Kroll as himself, Bobby Bottleservice, and Erma Dan Mangan | Games: Would You Rather? | "Oh Fortune" by Dan Mangan "Leaves, Trees, Forest" by Dan Mangan "Post-War Blues" by Dan Mangan "Sold" by Dan Mangan |
| Episode 126: Suicide is Painless | 10/10/11 | Jon Hamm Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall Nick Lowe | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle; Would You Rather? | "Stoplight Roses" by Nick Lowe "Sensitive Man" by Nick Lowe "All Men Are Liars" by Nick Lowe "(What's So Funny 'Bout) Peace, Love, and Understanding" by Nick Lowe |
| Episode 127: National Pleasure | 10/17/11 | Paul Scheer as Bob Cage Nick Swardson Brody Stevens | Games: Guess The Misheard Lyrics; Would You Rather? | "Todd Barry Is An Idiot" by Aimee Mann, Tim Heidecker & Michael Penn "My Little Buttercup" by Steve Martin, Martin Short & Chevy Chase "Like A G6" by Richard Cheese |
| Episode 128: Coach? Coach? Coach? | 10/24/11 | Jon Heder Harris Wittels Seth Morris as Hank Williams Jr. | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; What Am I Thinking?; Alive or Dead?; Freestyle Rap Battle | "Humanitarian Song" by Sarah Silverman "Der Guten Tag Hop-Clop" by Will Ferrell |
| Episode 129: Comedy Fang Fang | 10/31/11 | Brett Gelman as Messmore le Barron Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron Allan McLeod as Ghost Boy Neil Campbell | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | "Halloween (E.T. Please Phone Home)" by "Weirder Scott" Aukerman featuring Aimee Mann "Batman, Wolfman, Frankenstein, or Dracula" by The Diamonds |
| Episode 130: Tall Napoleon | 11/7/11 | Bobby Moynihan as Charles Barkley and Fagin Platt Jenny Slate Elizabeth Laime | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Who Said It?; Would You Rather? | "My Dead Dog Rover" by Hank, Stu, Dave & Hank "Jesus Ranch" by Tenacious D |
| Episode 131: Mayor of Hollywood | 11/14/11 | Andy Daly as Chip Gardner Jason Mantzoukas | | "Spaceballs" by The Spinners "Heartbreak Hotel" by Stan Freberg |
| Episode 132: Occupy Thanksgiving | 11/21/11 | David Wain Margaret Cho James Adomian as Dov Charney Grant-Lee Phillips | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "Your Favorite Thing" by Margaret Cho & Grant-Lee Phillips "Asian Adjacent" by Margaret Cho & Grant-Lee Phillips "Eat Shit and Die" by Margaret Cho & Grant-Lee Phillips "Wave of Mutilation" by Grant-Lee Phillips, David Wain, Margaret Cho & Scott Aukerman |
| Episode 133: Fortunately Unfortunately | 11/28/11 | Patton Oswalt Chris Tallman as Leslie Schecter | Games: Fortunately Unfortunately; Would You Rather? | "I'm Not Going To Pay $500 To Watch Douchebags Eat Turkey" by Dragon Boy Suede "Cain Mutiny" by Tim Heidecker "That's Been Done" by Sarah Silverman |
| Episode 134: Bride of Chucky | 12/5/11 | Kevin Nealon Ben Schwartz Amy Phillips as Jennifer Tilly | Games: Subjective Holiday Quiz; Would You Rather? | "Do They Know It's Christmas?" by Comedy Bang Bang "Christmas Is For Fucking" by Reggie Watts |
| Episode 135: Scavenge and the Wisemen | 12/12/11 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Cake Boss Erinn Hayes Dan Telfer | Games: Would You Rather? | "Christopher Bell Rock" by The Birthday Boys "Christmas Wrapping" by Doug Benson |
| Episode 136: 2011 Holiday Spectacular | 12/19/11 | Harris Wittels Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber Brett Gelman as Billy Crystal Thomas Lennon as Little Gary Jon Daly as Kelsey Grammer and Bill Cosby-Bukowski Adam Pally Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Seth Morris as Bob Ducca James Adomian as Jesse Ventura and Huell Howser | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; Freestyle Rap Battle NOTE: No Plugs segment. | "If It Doesn't Snow On Christmas" by Joe Pesci "I'm A Christmas Tree" by Wild Man Fischer & Dr. Demento "Santa's Packin'" by R.O. Manse (feat. Dukey) "What Can You Get a Wookiee for Christmas (When He Already Owns a Comb?)" by The Intergalactic Droid Choir and Chorale "Another Christmas Song" by Stephen Colbert |
| Episode 137: Best of 2011 Pt. 1 | 12/26/11 | Paul F. Tompkins | 10. Bro (Episode 109: The Andy Samberg Special) 9. Boner Jamz (Episode 92: How's Your Boner?) BONUS CLIP: Summertime Freestyle Rap (Episode 115: The Plug-In Drug) 8. Would You Rather? (Episode 126: Suicide is Painless) BONUS CLIP: Zach's Q&A (Episode 122: Shanghaied By Irene) 7. Chip Gardner's Campaign Strategy (Episode 131: Mayor of Hollywood) BONUS CLIP: Alive or Dead? (Episode 86: The New Year Attack of 2011) 6. Don Dimello (Episode 85: That's One Way of Doing It) | |
| Episode 137.5: Best of 2011 Pt. 2 | 12/29/11 | Paul F. Tompkins Andy Richter | 5. Cake Boss Contacts Chewbacca (Episode 106.5: It's A Fucking Podcast: Pt. 2) BONUS CLIP: What Am I Thinking? (Episode 121: Bro-ing Out) 4. Huell Howser and the Hadron Collider (Episode 103: These Times They Are A-Changin') BONUS CLIP: A Worthy Uhhh (Episode 98: A Worthy Uhhh) 3. Hot Dog (Episode 94: Dip Didda Dip Dow!) BONUS CLIP: Back To School Freestyle Rap (Episode 123: No Scoop For You) 2. Don Dimello's Beauty and the Beast (Episode 99: Somethin' For Daddy!) 1. Jack Sjunior and Brian Pieces (Episode 120: Farts and Procreation) | |

### 2012

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 138: Ghost Protocol | 1/2/12 | Andy Richter Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog | Games: Would You Rather? | "Charlene II (I'm Over You)" by Stephen Colbert with The Black Belles "The Getaway Grandmothers Club" by Don't Stop or We'll Die |
| Episode 139: Win a Farmhouse | 1/9/12 | Bob Odenkirk Brian Huskey as Paul Luzak | Games: Would You Rather? | "I'm Glad You Hurt Your Hand" by Steve Agee & Brian Posehn "Dio" by Tenacious D |
| Episode 140: Ron Swanson Off | 1/16/12 | Nick Offerman James Adomian as Paul Giamatti | | "Hulkster in Heaven" by Hulk Hogan and The Wrestling Boot Band |
| Episode 141: Ladies Night | 1/23/12 | Tig Notaro Jamie Denbo as Beverly Ginsberg Jessica Chaffin as Ronna Glickman | Games: Jukebox Jury | "One Night In Bangkok" by Mike Tyson "Trouble On Dookie Island" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 142: Popcorn.com | 1/30/12 | Tim Heidecker Eric Wareheim James Adomian as Dr. Bronner | Games: Would You Rather? | "Rolo Tony" by Tim and Eric "Long Legs" by Tim and Eric |
| Episode 143: Grammy Spectacular | 2/6/12 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Todd Glass Amy Phillips as Liza Minnelli | Games: Would You Rather? | "Rappin' Rodney" by Rodney Dangerfield |
| Episode 144: Clones and Oliver Stones | 2/13/12 | Don't Stop Or We'll Die: (Harris Wittels as himself and Steven Spielberg Paul Rust as himself and Melvin Pelvin Michael Cassady as himself and Mark Hamill) | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | "Deep Down (In The Dusty Meadow)" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "Once In Awhile" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "'Lectric Roller Skates" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "Austin and Ace" by Don't Stop or We'll Die |
| Episode 145: A Family Affair | 2/20/12 | David Wain James Adomian as Gary Busey | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | "Pencil Neck Geek" by Freddie Blassie |
| Episode 146: Climbing the Ladder | 2/27/12 | Reggie Watts Ben Schwartz Matt Besser as Björk | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 147: Raisin Norman Bates | 3/5/12 | Paul F. Tompkins as Ice T Greg Proops James Adomian as Jesse Ventura | Games: Would You Rather? | "Baby Penis In Your Mind" by Sarah Silverman & Laura Silverman "Highly Illogical" by Leonard Nimoy |
| Episode 148: Wipeout! | 3/12/12 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox, Don Dimello, Hot Dog, August Lindt, Danny Mahoney, Bill Carter, Patrick McMahon, Clive Dundee, and himself | | "Baby, Let Me Be" by The Rutles |
| Episode 149: Live from SXSW 2012 | 3/19/12 | Tim Heidecker James Adomian as Merrill Shindler Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Reggie Watts | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 150: Time Bobby | 3/26/12 | Bobby Moynihan as Fourvel Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber | | "Cerise" by Ken Nordine |
| Episode 151: Fan Fiction | 4/2/12 | Fred Savage Jackie Clarke as Pam Bicell Gil Ozeri as Len Bicell | Games: Would You Rather? | "Does Your Chewing Gum Lose Its Flavor (On the Bedpost Overnight)?" by Lonnie Donegan |
| Episode 152: Behind the Irony Curtain | 4/9/12 | Ed Helms as Dale Seth Morris | Games: Would You Rather? | "Stu's Song" by Ed Helms "Allentown" by Ed Helms |
| Episode 153: Jing It Or Ding It! | 4/12/12 | Will Forte Leo Allen | Games: Jing It Or Ding It; Would You Rather? | "MacGruber's Theme" by Cornbread Compton & The Silver Lake Chorus "The Perfect Number" by Vicki St. Elmo |
| Episode 154: Finger Guns | 4/16/12 | Lennon Parham as Miss Listler Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: Jukebox Jury; What Am I Thinking? | "Friends" by Flight of the Conchords |
| Episode 155: Fingerbang Lindbergh | 4/23/12 | Patton Oswalt Chris Tallman as Mark Van Driel | Games: Fart, Marry/Mary, Kiss | "The Getaway Grandmothers Club" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Watch Me Do Me" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 156: Anniversary Party! | 4/30/12 | St. Vincent Zach Galifianakis Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss Harris Wittels James Adomian as Christopher Hitchens Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra and Toph Shay Brett Gelman Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: Harris' Foam Corner | "Surgeon" by St. Vincent "Cheerleader" by St. Vincent "Cruel" by St. Vincent |
| Episode 157: God Bless America | 5/7/12 | Bobcat Goldthwait Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall | Games: Fart, Marry/Mary, Kiss | "America, Fuck Yeah (Bummer Remix)" by Trey Parker "Chicken Monkey Duck" by Mike Phirman |
| Episode 158: Words with Friends | 5/14/12 | Gillian Jacobs Jordan Peele as Jermaine Jones | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 159: Apicklelypse | 5/21/12 | Alison Brie Jason Mantzoukas Bob Odenkirk as Saul Goodman | Games: What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 160: Slow Dance Boner | 5/28/12 | Sarah Silverman Kyle Dunnigan as Del LaRue and Craig | Games: Shorts or Jeans? | "Poop Song" by Sarah Silverman & Laura Marano "Aids Ballad" by Sarah Silverman |
| Episode 161: Highly Illogical | 6/4/12 | Reggie Watts Tim Heidecker Andy Daly as Don Dimello Jon Daly as Barry R. | | |
| Episode 162: Best Bro Hang | 6/11/12 | Andy Samberg Adam Pally as Bro | Games: Would You Rather? | "Mama" by The Lonely Island "My Mic (Interlude)" by The Lonely Island |
| Episode 163: Burning Love | 6/18/12 | Steve Agee Ken Marino as Mark Orlando Janet Varney as Carly Deanna Russo as Tamara G | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 164: Clifton Was Here | 6/25/12 | Bob Zmuda as Tony Clifton Ben Schwartz | Games: What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 165: Hoo-ah! | 7/2/12 | Andy Kindler Loudon Wainwright III Amy Phillips as Gwyneth Paltrow | Games: Who Said It? | "Double Lifetime" by Loudon Wainwright III "Man and Dog" by Loudon Wainwright III "The Days That We Die" by Loudon Wainwright III |
| Episode 166: Farts and Procreation 2 | 7/9/12 | Adam Scott Harris Wittels Chelsea Peretti | | |
| Episode 167: New No-Nos | 7/16/12 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Paul Rust Jerrod Carmichael | Games: New No-Nos; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 168: Breaking Bread | 7/23/12 | Bob Odenkirk Matt Besser as The Pope | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 169: Immortal Mustache | 7/30/12 | Jay Chandrasekhar Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 170: New Scoop | 8/6/12 | Martin Starr Lennon Parham as Ethel Branscome Neil Campbell | Games: Would You Rather? | "Lost Boy/Friend" by Laura Silverman |
| Episode 171: Scrog Secretions | 8/13/12 | Megan Mullally Nick Kroll as David Eros and El Chupacabra Stephanie Hunt | | "Jack, You're Dead" by Nancy and Beth "The Cool of the Day" by Nancy and Beth "Poop Song" by Sarah Silverman and Laura Marano "It's The Girl" by Nancy and Beth |
| Episode 172: This is a Safe Zone | 8/20/12 | Todd Glass Brian Huskey as Glenn Maxx | | |
| Episode 173: Ride Like Hell | 8/27/12 | Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog Paul Scheer as Scott Jeffries Brent Weinbach | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 174: Series Regulars | 9/3/12 | Lizzy Caplan John Mulaney as himself and George St Geegland Nick Kroll as himself and Gil Faizon | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 175: Mop Water | 9/10/12 | Justin Kirk Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber | Start of the fall spectacular of having television stars show up, the first being Justin Kirk who joins host Scott Aukerman to help Andrew Lloyd Webber (Tompkins) regain his memory. | |
| Episode 176: Out of Bleeps | 9/17/12 | Amy Poehler Jason Mantzoukas James Adomian as Tom Leykis | Games: Speed Round; Freestyle Rap Battle; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 177: Penises Abounding | 9/24/12 | B. J. Novak Wyatt Cenac Keegan-Michael Key as Van Davion Jordan Peele as Mike Smith | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 178: Motor Boating Around Town | 10/1/12 | Rob Corddry Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 179: Pitch Slapped | 10/9/12 | Adam DeVine Paul Scheer as Scott Jeffries Kay Cannon Hana Mae Lee | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 180: Friends Without Words | 10/15/12 | Gillian Jacobs Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall Lauren Lapkus as Tracy | The third in the ongoing saga of Gillian Jacobs and Scott Aukerman's argument over Words with Friends. Garry Marshall (Tompkins) marries Gillian Jacobs, and college student Tracy stops by to tell tales of her time abroad. Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 181: Happy Endings | 10/22/12 | Casey Wilson Adam Pally | Games: Fortunately Unfortunately; Freestyle Rap Battle; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 182: Repeat Your Keyword | 10/24/12 | Tim Heidecker Joe Wengert as Arthur Steinborn Lauren Lapkus as Diane | | |
| Episode 183: Return to Suicide House | 10/29/12 | Brett Gelman as Messmore le Barron, James Gandolfini, Snagglepuss, David Koresh, and Billy Crystal Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron, Shaggy, Christopher Walken, Santa Claus, Jim Belushi, and Chris Rock Allan McLeod as Caine Sherman, Ghost Boy, Robert De Niro, and Stephen Hawking James Adomian as Maximillian Blanc, Ralph Macklevaney, Christopher Hitchens, Jim Jones, and Frank Calliendo | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 184: Pop and Politics | 11/5/12 | Aziz Ansari Bob Odenkirk Neil Campbell Mike Hanford James Adomian as Pat Buchanan | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 185: Cum Scanners | 11/7/12 | Chris Hardwick Ike Barinholtz as JT McDowell | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 186: New York Mainstays | 11/12/12 | Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall Julie Klausner Jake Fogelnest | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 187: Finger Chimes | 11/19/12 | Nat Faxon Lennon Parham as Forsythia | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 188: Attack of the Shits | 11/26/12 | Judd Apatow Graham Parker Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | Games: Would You Rather? | "Stop Cryin' About the Rain" by Graham Parker |
| Episode 189: The Pancake Man | 12/3/12 | Chris Fairbanks Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 190: You Know What I Mean? | 12/10/12 | Demetri Martin James Adomian as Orson Welles Pamela Murphy as Nancy Cooper | | |
| Episode 191: 2012 Holiday Spectacular | 12/17/12 | Harris Wittels Matt Besser as Björk, Neil Young, and Billy Braggart Paul Rust Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T Jon Daly as Bill Cosby-Bukowski Nick Kroll as Liz | Games: Harris' Foam Corner; New No-Nos (referred to as New Ho Ho Hos). | |
| Best of 2012 Pt. 1 | 12/24/12 | Paul F. Tompkins | 10. George St. Geegland & Gil Faizon (Episode 174: Series Regulars) 9. Tracy (Episode 180: Friends Without Words) BONUS: Arthur Steinborn's Memory System (Episode 182: Repeat Your Keyword) 8. Harris' Foam Corner (Episode 156: Anniversary Party!) BONUS: Off the Top (Episode 146: Climbing the Ladder) 7. Woody Allen on Entourage (Episode 162: Best Bro Hang) 6. Miss Listler (Episode 154: Finger Guns) | |
| Best of 2012 Pt. 2 | 12/31/12 | Paul F. Tompkins "Weird Al" Yankovic | 5. New No-Nos (Episode 167: New No-Nos) 4. Dalton Wilcox (Episode 148: Wipeout!) BONUS: Ching Chong Matinee (Episode 161: Highly Illogical) 3. Tom Leykis (Episode 176: Out of Bleeps) BONUS: The Washington Monugents (Episode 184: Pop and Politics) 2. Blaze and Rod Ogg (Episode 166: Farts and Procreation 2) 1. Fourvel (Episode 150: Time Bobby) | |

### 2013

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 192: GoodFelines | 1/7/13 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 193: What Else? What Else? | 1/10/13 | Kristen Schaal Neil Campbell as Rick Faber Pamela Murphy as Nancy Cooper | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 194: Me Gusta Characters! | 1/14/13 | Nick Kroll as himself, Chance, El Chupacabra & Fabrice Fabrice Chelsea Peretti as herself and Tootie | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 195: Making the Snow Angel | 1/21/13 | Billy Eichner Reggie Watts Matt Besser as Frosty the Snowman | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 196: A Different Huelliverse | 1/24/13 | Jeff Garlin James Adomian as Huell Howser and Christopher Hitchens | | |
| Episode 197: Please Claire-ify | 1/28/13 | Tim Heidecker Paul Rust Jon Daly as Bill Cosby-Bukowski | Games: New No-Nos; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 198: Aren't You Glad | 2/4/13 | Jeffrey Ross Ron Sexsmith Amy Phillips as Sarah Silverman Neil Campbell as Cam Bilmoth | Games: Would You Rather? | "Sneak Out the Back Door" by Ron Sexsmith |
| Episode 199: Garry Unmarried | 2/6/13 | Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall Gillian Jacobs | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 200: Halfway To China | 2/11/13 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Cactus Tony and Don Dimello | | |
| Episode 201: End Scene | 2/18/13 | Jon Glaser Matt Besser as Pope Benedict XVI | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 202: Philip Traumatic Seymour Disorder | 2/21/13 | Nick Thune James Adomian as Philip Seymour Hoffman and Paul Giamatti Lauren Lapkus as Todd | Games: Fortunately, Unfortunately | |
| Episode 203: The Vicar of Yanks | 2/25/13 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 204: The Pepper Men | 3/4/13 | Zach Galifianakis Jon Daly Neil Campbell | | |
| Episode 205: Titans of Comedy | 3/7/13 | Anthony Jeselnik Eugene Mirman Nathan Fielder Eugene Cordero as Jazz Jazz | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 206: Live from SXSW 2013 | 3/11/13 | Michael Cera Sarah Silverman Tim & Eric Reggie Watts Brett Gelman (cameo) | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 207: Live from SXSW 2013 II | 3/14/13 | Ken Marino Rob Huebel Natasha Leggero Martin Starr Reggie Watts James Adomian as Jesse Ventura | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 208: Zombie Candles | 3/18/13 | Steven Yeun Doug Benson Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 209: The Bisco Boys | 3/22/13 | Don't Stop Or We'll Die (Paul Rust, Harris Wittels, Michael Cassady) Howard Kremer | Games: Fortunately, Unfortunately; Would You Rather? | "Bullfrog" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Lisa" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Sunrise"/"Little Boys" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "The Good Old Boys" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Newborn Baby Colt" by Dragon Boy Suede |
| Episode 210: A Spiritual Journey | 3/25/13 | Adam Brody Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Joe Wengert as Shelby Orangina | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 211: April Fools! | 4/1/13 | Jon Hamm as himself and El Chupacabro Nick Kroll as himself, El Chupacabra, and Chilly Willy | | |
| Episode 212: Comedy Bleep Bleep | 4/8/13 | Brendon Walsh James Adomian as Gordon Ramsay Neil Campbell | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 213: Star Graves | 4/15/13 | Jerrod Carmichael Horatio Sanz as Joe France's | | |
| Episode 214: You Have To Take Action | 4/18/13 | Jen Kirkman Pamela Murphy as Karen Porter | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 215: Time Bobby 2 | 4/22/13 | Bobby Moynihan as Fourvel and Fryvault Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber | | |
| Episode 216: Top of the Schaal To You! | 4/29/13 | Kristen Schaal Neil Campbell as Buford Dorsey Michaela Watkins as Dr. Sherri Levine | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 217: The WTF Hour | 5/2/13 | Marc Maron | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 218: The 4th Anniversary Extravaganza! | 5/6/13 | David Wain Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Paul F. Tompkins as Mike the Janitor Jason Mantzoukas Paul Rust as Benny Bachelor Neil Campbell as Barrett Bachelor | | |
| Episode 219: Farts and Procreation 3 | 5/13/13 | Adam Scott as himself, Bus Guy #1, Jason Vorges, Edwin and Window Loving Dog #1 Harris Wittels as himself, Bus Guy #2, Clark Griswald, Vince and Window Loving Dog #2 Chelsea Peretti as herself, Coslita, Cheri Oteri and Cheri Oteri | NOTE: No Plugs segment. | |
| Episode 220: 4 PayDays & A Baby | 5/20/13 | Lennon Parham as Miss Listler Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | | |
| Episode 221: The Cake Council | 5/28/13 | Andy Richter Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 222: A Peanut In The Rain | 6/3/13 | Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall Gillian Jacobs Mike Hanford as Ducky Powell | | |
| Episode 223: Roll Over, Seth Rogen | 6/10/13 | Seth Rogen | Games: Fart, Marry, Kiss; What Am I Thinking?; Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 224: Live from Austin | 6/13/13 | Paul Scheer as Bill Diesel Martin Starr Brandon Johnson Neil Campbell as Rick Faber | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 225: Super Chums | 6/17/13 | Taran Killam as himself and Mark Johnson Sr. Paul Brittain as himself and Lon Smudge | | |
| Episode 226: ¡Aspira! | 6/24/13 | Paul Feig Horatio Sanz as Victor Ramos | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 227: All Farted Out | 6/27/13 | Brian Posehn Jon Daly as Mall McCartney | | |
| Episode 228: Acapella Cuddle Puddle | 7/1/13 | John Hodgman Paul F. Tompkins as Ice-T and Garry Marshall | | |
| Episode 229: Two Thumbs & Not Much Else | 7/8/13 | Ben Schwartz Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog | | |
| Episode 230: Something for Everything | 7/11/13 | Reggie Watts Neil Campbell | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 231: This Is Not Me, This Is Them | 7/15/13 | Kumail Nanjiani James Adomian as Paul Giamatti & Jesse Ventura | | |
| Episode 232: LIVE from San Diego Comic-Con | 7/18/13 | Andy Daly as Hot Dog Paul Rust | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 233: Royal Watching | 7/22/13 | Bob Odenkirk Andy Daly as Byron Denniston David Cross calls in | | |
| Episode 234: Changing the Bandage | 7/25/13 | Bill Hader Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 235: Concert Buddies | 7/29/13 | Doug Benson Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 236: Murderer Heaven | 8/5/13 | Rob Corddry Paul F. Tompkins as The Ghost of Richard Harrow | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 237: Filipino Blockbuster | 8/8/13 | Jonah Ray Nick Thune Eugene Cordero as Tito Ben | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 238: Marissa Wompler's Birthday Pool Party LIVE | 8/12/13 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler and Kimmy Jason Mantzoukas as Eric “Gutterballs” Gutterman and Kareem Brian Huskey as Dr. Seth Wompler Melissa Rauch as Danielle Bartiromo and Katie Wong | | |
| Episode 239: New Dad | 8/19/13 | Jay Mohr Matt Besser as New Dad | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 240: #TheWorldsEnd | 8/23/13 | Edgar Wright Simon Pegg as himself, Michael Caine, and Sean Connery Nick Frost as himself, Sean Connery, and Michael Caine | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 241: The Stallone Bros. | 8/26/13 | Paul Scheer as himself and Frank Stallone Nick Kroll as himself and Sylvester Stallone | | |
| Episode 242: Veggie Dongs | 9/2/13 | Thomas Lennon as himself and Little Gary Rob Huebel Neko Case | Games: Would You Rather? | "Local Girl" by Neko Case "Calling Cards" by Neko Case |
| Episode 243: Blow Me Up Tom! | 9/9/13 | Maria Bamford James Adomian as Tom Leykis, Merrill Shindler, and Jesse Ventura | | |
| Episode 244: An Ode to New York! | 9/16/13 | Andy Samberg Eddie Pepitone as Eddie Floatley | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 245: Poehler Ice Caps | 9/23/13 | Amy Poehler Neil Campbell Paul F. Tompkins as Alan Thicke | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 246: Butthole Baby | 9/30/13 | Casey Wilson as herself and Janelle Johnson June Diane Raphael as herself and Jolene Johnson | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 247: Half a Score | 10/7/13 | Tim Meadows Horatio Sanz as Chico Davis | | |
| Episode 248: Todd's Life 2.0 | 10/10/13 | Eric André Lauren Lapkus as Todd | | |
| Episode 249: Ice Cold STaB | 10/14/13 | Bob Odenkirk The Birthday Boys as themselves and Coke/Pepsi/Tab secret formula holders | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 250: Podcast Silence | 10/21/13 | Pete Holmes Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Pamela Murphy as Lisa Bartin | | |
| Episode 251: The Bed Spoiler | 10/24/13 | Amber Tamblyn Todd Glass | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 252: The Creeeeeeepy Halloween Special | 10/28/13 | Steven Yeun Paul Rust as Dr. Traygo Molly Bretthauer as Dykula Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi Eva Anderson and Caroline Anderson as The Hauntettes | | |
| Episode 253: Fieri Fight | 11/4/13 | Tim Heidecker Jon Daly as himself and Bill Cosby-Bukowski | Games: Tic-Tac-Toe, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 254: LIVE from Comedy Gives Back | 11/7/13 | Zach Galifianakis David Wain Andy Daly as Jack Fitzgerald | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 255: A Visit from Hee Hee-ll | 11/11/13 | Rob Delaney Mookie Blaiklock as Michael Jackson | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 256: Raw Copera | 11/18/13 | Brendon Small Cameron Esposito James Adomian as Jesse Ventura | | "The Birth / Fata Sidus Oritur / One of Us Must Die" by Dethklok (Brendon Small) "The Duel" by Dethklok (Brendon Small) |
| Episode 257: Nuts As A Pile Of Nuts | 11/21/13 | Will Forte as himself and Texter Paul F. Tompkins as The Ghost of Richard Harrow | | |
| Episode 258: Yoke Jams | 11/25/13 | Jimmy Pardo Bill Callahan Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | | "The Sing" by Bill Callahan "Wrecking Ball" by Miley Cyrus (Performed by Bob Ducca) "Small Plane" by Bill Callahan "Ride My Arrow" by Bill Callahan |
| Episode 259: Charlotte's Website | 12/2/13 | David Alan Grier Lauren Lapkus as Regina Crimp Joe Wengert as Mr. G | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 260: Tiny Cheeseburger Story | 12/5/13 | Mike Birbiglia Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo | | |
| Episode 261: Nubile Agape | 12/9/13 | Kulap Vilaysack Shelby Fero Horatio Sanz as Aaron Neville | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 262: 2013 Holiday Spectacular | 12/16/13 | Nick Lowe Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox Paul F. Tompkins as Alan Thicke James Adomian as Merrill Shindler Jon Daly as Bill Cosby-Bukowski Neil Campbell as Barrett Bachelor Paul Rust as Benny Bachelor Paul Scheer as Frank Stallone | | "Christmas at the Airport" by Nick Lowe "The North Pole Express" by Nick Lowe "A Dollar Short of Happy" by Nick Lowe |
| Best of 2013 Pt. 1 | 12/23/13 | Paul F. Tompkins | 15. The Vicar of Yanks (Episode 203: The Vicar of Yanks) 14. The Pepper Men (Episode 204: The Pepper Men) BONUS: New No-Nos 2013 (Episode 197: Please Claire-ify) 13. El Chupacabra y El Chupacabro (Episode 211: April Fools!) BONUS: Werner Herzog's Yelp Hotel Review (Comedy Bang! Bang! 2013 Tour: LIVE from San Francisco with Paul F. Tompkins and Doug Benson) 12. Garry, Gilly, and the Butthole-less Baby (Episode 222: A Peanut In The Rain) BONUS: What A Thrashable Slope (Episode 222: A Peanut In The Rain) | |
| Best of 2013 Pt. 2 | 12/26/13 | Paul F. Tompkins | 11. Frank and Sylvester Stallone (Episode 241: The Stallone Bros.) BONUS: Breaking Bad Finale Spoilers (Episode 249: Ice Cold STaB) 10. The Return of the Tom Leykis Show (Episode 243: Blow Me Up Tom!) 9. Reardon and Wompler and The Bachelor Brothers (Episode 218: The 4th Anniversary Extravaganza!) BONUS: Tito Ben's Karaoke (Episode 237: Filipino Blockbuster) 8. Werner Herzog in Jack Reacher (Episode 229: Two Thumbs & Not Much Else) BONUS: Silent Night by Bjork (Episode 191: 2012 Holiday Spectacular) 7. Richard Harrow (Episode 236: Murderer Heaven) | |
| Best of 2013 Pt. 3 | 12/30/13 | Paul F. Tompkins | 6. Bel-Air Marriage and Divorce (Episode 199: Garry Unmarried) BONUS: Freestyle Rap Battle (Episode 230: Something for Everything) 5. Harris' Foam Corner and Some Characters (Episode 219: Farts and Procreation 3) BONUS: Sean Connery and Michael Caine (Episode 240: #TheWorldsEnd) 4. Poehler vs Campbell vs Thicke Freestyle Rap Battle (Episode 245: Poehler Ice Caps) | |

### 2014

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Best of 2013 Pt. 4 | 1/2/14 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. Cactus Tony (Episode 200: Halfway to China) 2. The Platform is Shifting (Episode 238: Marissa Wompler's Birthday Pool Party LIVE) 1. Fourvel and Fryvault (Episode 215: Time Bobby 2) | |
| Episode 263: Hollywild | 1/6/14 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as Coco Marx | Games: Would You Rather?, Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 264: Creating A Krolliverse | 1/13/14 | Nick Kroll as himself, Liz, C-Czar, Sylvester Stallone, and El Chupacabra Jenny Slate as herself and Pretty Liz | | |
| Episode 265: LIVE from RIOT LA | 1/16/14 | Paul F. Tompkins as JW Stillwater Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Harris Wittels | Games: Harris' Foam Corner, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 266: The Calvins Twins | 1/20/14 | Taran Killam as himself and Smith "Bever Hopox" Calvins Paul Brittain as himself and Jones "Chico Hands" Calvins | | |
| Episode 267: That Wasn't It (I'm Back) [Hee Hee] | 1/27/14 | Jerrod Carmichael Neil Campbell Mookie Blaiklock as Michael Jackson | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 268: What Does the Fonz Say? | 1/30/14 | Jimmy Pardo Betsy Sodaro as Voda Gaipsy the Romanian Gypsy | Games: Riddle Me This, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 269: Smaug's Kickstarter | 2/3/14 | Doug Benson Paul Hornschemeier Matt Besser as Smaug | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 270: Off The Grid | 2/10/14 | Jon Daly James Adomian as Jesse Ventura | | "Abracadabralifornia" by Jon Daly |
| Episode 271: Tiny Little Boy Parts | 2/13/14 | Nick Thune Molly Bretthauer as Meredith Coldwell | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 272: Sex Party Season | 2/17/14 | Gillian Jacobs Paul F. Tompkins as Garry Marshall and Len Wiseman | | |
| Episode 273: Vape Cod | 2/24/14 | Jim O'Heir Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood | | |
| Episode 274: Oh, Golly! | 3/3/14 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Gil & Golly and Dalton Wilcox | | |
| Episode 275: LIVE from SXSW 2014 | 3/10/14 | Jonah Ray Adam Cayton-Holland James Adomian as The Sheriff of Nottingham | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 276: LIVE from SXSW 2014 II | 3/14/14 | Matt Braunger Matt Besser as Hooch the Mooch Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 277: Comedy Bang Me! | 3/17/14 | Chelsea Peretti Paul Rust as Benny Bachelor Neil Campbell as Barrett Bachelor | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 278: Only Tones | 3/24/14 | Old 97's Matt Berninger James Adomian as George Zimmer and Russell Crowe | Games: Would You Rather? | "Longer Than You've Been Alive" by Old 97's "Let's Get Drunk and Get It On" by Old 97's "Nashville" by Old 97's |
| Episode 279: Reverse April Fools | 3/31/14 | Patton Oswalt Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Will Hines as Qthor | | |
| Episode 280: DuALity | 4/7/14 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul F. Tompkins as Alan Thicke | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 281: Bro Boarders | 4/14/14 | Matt Walsh as himself and XJR& Timothy Simons | Games: Name A Bread, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 282: Wompster's University | 4/21/14 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler | | |
| Episode 283: The 5th Anniversary Show! | 4/28/14 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler Jason Mantzoukas Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Matt Besser as Mattilda Besserina Ay Der Bong Boy Retired Pope Smith Paul F. Tompkins as Mike the Janitor and JW Stillwater Paul Rust as Benny Bachelor Neil Campbell as Barrett Bachelor | | |
| Episode 284: A Thrilling CBB Adventure Hour | 5/5/14 | Marc Evan Jackson Mark Gagliardi as Croach the Tracker Paul F. Tompkins as K of the Cosmos and himself | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 285: Solo Bolo | 5/8/14 | Ben Schwartz | | |
| Episode 286: Time Bobby 3 | 5/12/14 | Bobby Moynihan as Fourvel and Fryvault Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber and Werner Herzog | | |
| Episode 287: Stinky Chips | 5/19/14 | Shane Torres Lauren Lapkus as Mizz Chips | | |
| Episode 288: Back to Barz, Back to Reality | 5/22/14 | The Sklar Brothers Horatio Sanz as Barzelona Marriott | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 289: The Exorcism of Cake Boss | 5/26/14 | Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss and Reverend Robert Parcimonie Matt Gourley as H. R. Giger | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 290: Shed Busting | 6/2/14 | Todd Glass James Adomian as himself, George W. Bush, Jesse Ventura, Merrill Shindler, and Paul Giamatti | | |
| Episode 291: Summer Haunted House | 6/5/14 | Bob Odenkirk as himself and Thor Silverblatt Adam Resnick Neil Casey as Earl Bixby Fran Gillespie as Pammy Bixby | | |
| Episode 292: DJs Are Sleaze Js | 6/9/14 | Jenny Slate Merrill Garbus Jon Daly as himself and Sappity Tappity | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 293: Monster Muscles | 6/12/14 | Phil Lord Chris Miller Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Eugene Cordero as R.J. Rise | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 294: Honk Shoo | 6/16/14 | Ian Edwards Brendon Small as Bernie Fretts Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | | |
| Episode 295: I Turned It On For The Dog Penis | 6/19/14 | Alex Anfanger Dan Schimp Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 296: Taking The Bladder Out | 6/23/14 | David Wain as himself and Phineas T. Johnson Michael Showalter Neil Campbell as Percy Perryweather | | |
| Episode 297: Canadian Apparel | 6/30/14 | Nathan Fielder Joe Wengert as Brad Hammerstone James Adomian as Dov Charney | | |
| Episode 298: The Hotwives of Orlando | 7/7/14 | Paul Scheer Danielle Schneider as Shauna Maducci Tymberlee Hill as Phe Phe Reed Andrea Savage as Veronica Von Vandervon Dannah Phirman as Alli | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 299: Don't Hack the SAC | 7/15/14 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Claudia O'Doherty | | "Handy" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Foil" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "My Own Eyes" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Mission Statement" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Lame Claim to Fame" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "NOW That's What I Call Polka!" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "First World Problems" by "Weird Al" Yankovic "Sports Song" by "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Episode 300: Oh, Golly! You Devil | 7/21/14 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Golly, Dalton Wilcox, Danny Mahoney, Ben Alterman, August Lindt, Bill Carter, Patrick McMahon, Hot Dog, Clive Dundee, Andi Callahan, Chip Gardner, Cactus Tony, Byron Denniston, and Don Dimello | | |
| Episode 301: They're Twins Jonah | 7/28/14 | Jonah Ray Kumail Nanjiani Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 302: Milkshake Movies | 7/31/14 | Mary Lynn Rajskub Twin Shadow Eddie Pepitone as Howard Amethyst | | "The One" by Twin Shadow "Locked and Loaded" by Twin Shadow "To the Top" by Twin Shadow |
| Episode 303: Puttering Around | 8/04/14 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself, Andrew Lloyd Webber, and Cake Boss Loudon Wainwright III | | "Haven't Got the Blues (Yet)" by Loudon Wainwright III "Here Come the Choppers" by Loudon Wainwright III "Spaced" by Loudon Wainwright III |
| Episode 304: Marissa Wompler's Six Flags Birthday Womptacular | 8/11/14 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler, Kimmy, and Philippe Jason Mantzoukas as Eric “Gutterballs” Gutterman and Kareem Brian Huskey as Dr. Seth Wompler Melissa Rauch as Danielle Bartiromo and Katie Wong Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon and Liz Andy Daly as Don Dimello | NOTE: also featuring Scott Aukerman as Dabney and Andy Daly's daughter as Birthday Girl | |
| Episode 305: CattleLickItUp | 8/18/14 | Kulap Vilaysack Howard Kremer Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 306: Project Funway | 8/21/14 | Don't Stop Or We'll Die (Paul Rust, Harris Wittels, Michael Cassady) | Games: Harris' Foam Corner, New No-Nos, Riddle Me This | "Blood" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Central Park" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "For the Revolution" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die "Alfred E. Neuman/Sylvester P. Smith" by Don't Stop Or We'll Die |
| Episode 307: Ruth's Ross Dress For Loss | 8/25/14 | Tenacious D (Jack Black and Kyle Gass) Lauren Lapkus as Regina Crimp Joe Wengert as Russ | Games: The Guessing Game | |
| Episode 308: Superego: Loose Beginnings, Tight Ends | 9/1/14 | Matt Gourley as himself and H. R. Giger Mark McConville as himself and Trevor Jeremy Carter as himself and Bryson Tyson Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Reverend Robert Parcimonie | | |
| Episode 309: Tony Macaroni | 9/08/14 | Nick Kroll as himself and R. Schrift Jimmy Pardo Claudia O'Doherty | | |
| Episode 310: Little Button Puss | 9/15/14 | Kevin Allison Pamela Murphy as Bridgette Murphy John Gemberling as HP-DP-69B | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 311: Denny's Boys | 9/18/14 | Joe Lo Truglio Beth Dover as Saman Thughgh | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 312: Grounded Me@ | 9/22/14 | Andy Samberg Lauren Lapkus as Todd | Games: What Am I Thinking?, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 313: Gumbo Challenge | 9/29/14 | Ben Schwartz Paul Banks Horatio Sanz as Dante and Aaron Neville | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 314: Y’all Heard Any of These Names Before? | 10/6/14 | Cameron Esposito Paul F. Tompkins as JW Stillwater | Games: Y’all Heard Any of These Names Before? | |
| Episode 315: Sandwich Therapy | 10/13/14 | Ken Marino Casey Wilson Joe Wengert as Dr. Jerry Pensacola | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 316: In the Larp Run | 10/16/14 | Dane Cook Reggie Watts Neil Campbell as Rick Faber | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 317: Tash.2 | 10/20/14 | Natasha Lyonne Paul F. Tompkins Mary Holland as Dreama Peaches | | |
| Episode 318: Lumber Hack | 10/27/14 | Wyatt Cenac Matt Besser as Paul Funyuns Jocelyn DeBoer as Bitsy Boo-Carmichael | | |
| Episode 319: Return to Suicide House Part Gore | 10/30/14 | Brett Gelman as Messmore le Barron Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron Allan McLeod as Ghost Boy Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi Caroline Anderson as Scaroline | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 320: Charging Kids | 11/3/14 | Alex Borstein Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny Molly Bretthauer as Miss D. | | |
| Episode 321: Big Fat Voice | 11/10/14 | Ana Gasteyer Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Mookie Blaiklock as Officer Jay Gutwill | Games: Riddle Me This | "A Proper Cup of Coffee" by Ana Gasteyer "One Mint Julep" by Ana Gasteyer |
| Episode 322: YouTube Phenomahna | 11/17/14 | Chelsea Peretti Seth Morris as Lou Ciello | | |
| Episode 323: Pie Quiz with Tears for Fears | 11/24/14 | Tears For Fears Reggie Watts Paul F. Tompkins as Barnaby Valastrok, the Pie Minister | | |
| Episode 324: Golden Duchess Cruise Lines | 12/1/14 | Colin Hanks Lauren Lapkus as Marla Charles Stephanie Allynne as Pam John Mary Holland as Margie Donk Erin Whitehead as Carol Sheldon | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 325: Musical Organs | 12/8/14 | Skylar Astin Rory Scovel Pamela Murphy as Jewel's Will Hines as Markis Campbell | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 326: 2014 Holiday Spectacular | 12/15/14 | Aimee Mann Ted Leo Paul F. Tompkins as Len Wiseman Matt Gourley as Ian Fleming Matt Besser as Björk Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho James Adomian as Orson Welles Neil Campbell as Logan Conley | | "You Can't Help Me Now" by The Both "Volunteers of America" by The Both "Nothing Left to Do (Let's Make This Christmas Blue)" by The Both |
| Best of 2014 Pt. 1 | 12/22/14 | Paul F. Tompkins | 15. HP-DP-69B (Episode 310: Little Button Puss) 14. The Victor Podcast (Episode 301: They're Twins Jonah) 13. JW Stillwater (Episode 265: LIVE From RIOT LA) 12. Bever Hopox and Chico Hands (Episode 266: The Calvins Twins) | |
| Best of 2014 Pt. 2 | 12/25/14 | Paul F. Tompkins | 11. R. Shrift (Episode 309: Tony Macaroni) 10. Len Wiseman (Episode 272: Sex Party Season) 9. Coco Marx (Episode 263: Hollywild) 8. Mike the Janitor and Traci Reardon (Episode 283: The 5th Anniversary Show!) | |
| Best of 2014 Pt. 3 | 12/29/14 | Paul F. Tompkins | 7. Hollywood Facts (Episode 312: Grounded Me@) 6. Benny Schwaz (Episode 285: Solo Bolo) 5. Dabney! (Episode 304: Marissa Wompler's Six Flags Birthday Womptacular) 4. Fourvel Returns (Episode 286: Time Bobby 3) | |

### 2015

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Best of 2014 Pt. 4 | 1/1/15 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. Giger Possesses Cake Boss (Episode 289: The Exorcism of Cake Boss) 2. Gil & Golly (Episode 274: Oh, Golly!) 1. The Battle Between Good and Evil (Episode 300: Oh, Golly! You Devil) | |
| Episode 327: Bang! Bang! Into Your Mouth! | 1/5/15 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself and Uncle Stoney | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 328: Beatle Heaven | 1/8/15 | American Football Anders Holm Mike Hanford as John Lennon | Games: Would You Rather? | "Never Meant" by American Football "The Summer Ends" by American Football "For Sure" by American Football |
| Episode 329: Too Much Tuna Tour | 1/12/15 | Nick Kroll as himself and Gil Faizon John Mulaney as George St Geegland | Games: Get To The Gifts | |
| Episode 330: Peruvian Pullovers | 1/19/15 | Jim Rash Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 331: Secret Superlatives | 1/26/15 | Patton Oswalt Lauren Lapkus as Benjamin Susix III Mary Holland as Trabitha Tarteen | | |
| Episode 332: What Winsome Said | 2/2/15 | Kyle Kinane Matt Braunger Neil Campbell as Winsome Prejudice Fran Gillespie as Missy Prejudice | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 333: Pit Stop | 2/9/15 | Jack Antonoff Horatio Sanz as Jacob Brooks Miriam Tolan as Susan Brooks | | |
| Episode 334: The Dream Team | 2/12/15 | David Cross James Adomian as himself and Slavoj Žižek Matt Walsh as himself and Corny Grandpa | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 335: The Wedding of Gilli and Garry | 2/16/15 | Colin Hay Paul F. Tompkins as Len Wiseman, Garry Marshall, Reverend Robert Parcimonie, and Alan Thicke Gillian Jacobs | | "Did You Just Take the Long Way Home" by Colin Hay "I Want You Back" by Colin Hay "Next Year People" by Colin Hay |
| Episode 336: NOT Farts and Procreation 4 | 2/23/15 | Adam Scott Harris Wittels Chelsea Peretti | Opens and closes with two separate tributes to Harris Wittels, who died eight days after this episode was recorded. Games: Harris' Foam Corner | |
| Episode 337: The Ying and the Yankovic | 3/2/15 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber Joe Wengert as Doug Doyzoice | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 338: Be My Guest, Literally! | 3/9/15 | Michael Ableson Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog and Santa Claus Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho Andy Daly as Jean Claude Pepi | Games: Name French Actors, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 339: LIVE from SXSW 2015 | 3/16/15 | Lauren Lapkus as Todd Colin Hanks Nick Kroll as himself, El Chupacabra, and Sylvester Stallone Horatio Sanz as Kanye West | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 340: LIVE from SXSW 2015 II | 3/19/15 | Tig Notaro Stephanie Allynne as Hannah Harpie Mary Holland as Helen Harpie Lauren Lapkus as Hortense Harpie James Adomian as Tom Leykis | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 341: Banging the Table with Stars | 3/23/15 | Stars Claudia O'Doherty Neil Campbell as Brian Barber | Games: Would You Rather? | "This Is the Last Time" by Stars "Elevator Love Letter" by Stars |
| Episode 342: A Silicon Valley P-Cast | 3/30/15 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Joey Tortellini, and China Kumail Nanjiani Martin Starr Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 343: Athlete's Head | 4/6/15 | Alicia Witt Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny | | |
| Episode 344: Classic Switcheroo | 4/9/15 | Ryan Hansen Jamie Chung Horatio Sanz Jocelyn DeBoer as Bitsy Boo-Carmichael Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 345: Shifting Bouncy | 4/13/15 | Kyle Bornheimer Paul Brittain as himself, Michael Explosione, Jr., Michael Explosione, Sr., and Steve Explosione Roman Sklar | | |
| Episode 346: That Is Wild | 4/20/15 | Tom Green Mary Holland as Trabitha Tarteen Erin Whitehead as Gale Burbiglia | | |
| Episode 347: Foley Slumber Party | 4/23/15 | Kevin Pollak Seth Morris as Andy Pappage Nick Kroll calls in | Games: One Word Impressions | |
| Episode 348: Is Y'all My Daddy? | 4/27/15 | Cameron Esposito Paul F. Tompkins as J.W. Stillwater Matt Gourley as Jim Chambers/Professor Stillwater | | |
| Episode 349: The 6th Anniversary Show! | 5/4/15 | Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss, Alan Thicke, and Santa Claus Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho Thomas Middleditch as Klaus Schneider Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Mike Hanford as John Lennon Joe Wengert as Brad Hammerstone Paul Scheer as The Rickster Erin Whitehead as Chad Warren | | |
| Episode 350: Helmets, Aqueduct, Crucifixion, and Boobs | 5/11/15 | Andy Richter Andy Daly as Byron Denniston | | |
| Episode 351: CBB: The Movie | 5/18/15 | Sean Clements Hayes Davenport Ben Rodgers as Bang Rodgers Hayley Huntley as Hayley Shields | | |
| Episode 352: Scrunchy Face | 5/25/15 | Nick Swardson James Adomian as Bernie Sanders Will Hines as Jacob Cloudy | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 353: Goodbye Reggie! | 6/1/15 | Reggie Watts Neil Campbell Mike Mitchell as BB-8 | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 354: Solo Bolo: Dos Lo | 6/4/15 | Ben Schwartz | Games: Riddle Me This, Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge | |
| Episode 355: Kid Detectives | 6/8/15 | Lauren Lapkus as herself and Murphy O’Malaman Thomas Middleditch as himself and JJ O’Malaman | | |
| Episode 356: Heynong Man | 6/15/15 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Mike the Janitor | | |
| Episode 357: Modern Anti-Comedy | 6/22/15 | Natasha Leggero Jeremy Konner Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny Betsy Sodaro as Mrs. Potts | | |
| Episode 358: Freddie Mercury To Me | 6/25/15 | Beck Bennett Mike Hanford as Alfie Kangas Neil Campbell as Denver Coward | | |
| Episode 359: TofuPeople | 6/29/15 | Jonah Ray Kumail Nanjiani Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood Erin Whitehead as Elaine the Dragon | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 360: Snow Dome | 7/6/15 | Jimmy Pardo Paul Brittain as himself and Fitch Pender | | |
| Episode 361: Waiting for Infinnerty | 7/9/15 | Dan Finnerty Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo John Gemberling as Ton Limen | | |
| Episode 362: RomanTig | 7/13/15 | Tig Notaro Stephanie Allynne as herself and Dorothea Shirley Mookie Blaiklock as Vin Diesel | | |
| Episode 363: Wet Hot Crew | 7/20/15 | David Wain Molly Shannon Rich Sommer Marguerite Moreau | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 364: The Marm of Smarm Returns | 7/23/15 | Michael Ian Black Lauren Lapkus as Todd | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 365: Bongo vs. Bongos | 7/27/15 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Joe Bongo Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 366: Cafeteriapalooza | 8/3/15 | Bobcat Goldthwait Joe Wengert as Frank Frank Will Hines as Dusty Stevens | | |
| Episode 367: Bits, Riffs, and Friendships | 8/6/15 | Brett Gelman Jon Daly Tim Heidecker | | |
| Episode 368: Rick Bic For President | 8/10/15 | Paul Scheer as himself and Rick Bic Rob Huebel as himself and Dick Butterfield | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 369: The Hotwives of Las Vegas | 8/13/15 | Andrea Savage as herself and Ivanka Silversan Casey Wilson as herself and Jenfer Beudon Dannah Phirman as herself and Leona Carpeze Danielle Schneider as herself and Denise Funt | | |
| Episode 370: The Brochelor | 8/17/15 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Chin Dollhouse Matt Gourley as himself and Danielle Steel | | |
| Episode 371: You Got PreDICted! | 8/24/15 | Jemaine Clement Lauren Lapkus as Juniper Flagen Mary Holland as Peony Flagen Stephanie Allynne as Shrub Flagen Erin Whitehead as Hyacinth Flagen | | |
| Episode 372: Motown Tea | 8/31/15 | Diane Coffee Mike Hanford as John Lennon Horatio Sanz as Skip Garcia | | "Not That Easy" by Diane Coffee "Mayflower" by Diane Coffee |
| Episode 373: Vocal Fry | 9/7/15 | Eric Stonestreet Brendon Small as Victor Diamond, Tiny, and Willard “Willy” Mapleton | | |
| Episode 374: Tick Tock Clawk | 9/10/15 | Neil Campbell as Maxwell Keeper/The Time Keeper Paul Rust Fran Gillespie as Marco | Games: New No-Nos, Old Yes-Yeses, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 375: Wompler's REAL 17th B-Day Womptacular | 9/14/15 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler Brian Huskey as Dr. Seth Wompler and Queth Wompler Seth Morris as Dr. Lionel Drioche Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Jason Mantzoukas as Eric "Gutterballs" Gutterman and Kareem | NOTE: also featuring Scott Aukerman as Dabney | |
| Episode 376: Romantic Tommy D | 9/17/15 | Peaches Claudia O'Doherty Will Hines as Clayton Purdy | | "Dick in the Air" by Peaches "Rub" by Peaches |
| Episode 377: Good Night in the Morning | 9/21/15 | Tatiana Maslany as herself and Belissima Kristian Bruun as himself and Phil Collins Paul F. Tompkins as Chazmin and Scarsdale Lauren Lapkus as Sunny, Salantame, and Scarsdale | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 378: Mailer Daemon | 9/28/15 | Jason Mantzoukas as himself and Jeffrey Characterwheaties Nick Kroll as himself, the Mailer Daemon, Dr. Conrad Murray, Live Taylor, and Fabrice Fabrice | | |
| Episode 379: Realies and Fictionals | 10/5/15 | Alia Shawkat Angela Trimbur Adam DeVine Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Pamela Murphy as Cutie Cake | | |
| Episode 380: A Colinary Journey | 10/8/15 | Colin Hanks Eagles of Death Metal Matt Walsh as Maximilian Lugner Brian Huskey as Dr. Hiro Tokyo, Tommy, and Boys | | |
| Episode 381: Kitchen Stand-Up | 10/12/15 | Nathan Fielder Anthony Jeselnik Drew Tarver as Terry Burkhalter | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 382: Doing It the Savage Way | 10/19/15 | Fred Savage Wayne Federman Matt Gourley as H. R. Giger | | |
| Episode 383: Return to Suicide House Part Boo | 10/26/15 | Brett Gelman as Messmore le Barron Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron, Bill Cosby, and Bill Cosby 2 Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi Paul Rust as Dr. Traygo Caroline Anderson as Scaroline | Games: Freestyle Rap Battle | |
| Episode 384: Numbers Cannot Lie | 11/2/15 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Atherton Witherflower | | |
| Episode 385: The Beatles of Cults | 11/9/15 | John Mulaney Lauren Lapkus as Big Sue Betsy Sodaro as Nancy K | | |
| Episode 386: Titbit for Tatbit | 11/16/15 | Bob Odenkirk David Cross Mike O'Brien as Zin Bradley Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Reverend Robert Parcimonie | | |
| Episode 387: Most Multiple Personalities | 11/19/15 | John Grant John Gemberling as Tom Jimson Jocelyn DeBoer as Delna | | "Grey Tickles, Black Pressure" by John Grant "Global Warming" by John Grant |
| Episode 388: Breath Before Death | 11/23/15 | Neko Case Mike Hanford as John Lennon Mookie Blaiklock as himself and Michael Jackson | | |
| Episode 389: Travel Agent-Si! | 11/30/15 | Mary Elizabeth Ellis Drew Tarver as Randy Travels Dan Lippert as Dr. Frankie Beans | | |
| Episode 390: The Oh, Hello Show | 12/7/15 | Eugene Mirman John Mulaney as George St. Geegland Nick Kroll as Gil Faizon | | |
| Episode 391: 2015 Holiday Spectacular | 12/14/15 | Paul F. Tompkins as Andrew Lloyd Webber Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Mike Hanford as John Lennon Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Will Hines as David Bunting | | |
| Episode 392: The Holiday Womptacular | 12/17/15 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler and Barbra Streisand Brian Huskey as Dr. Seth Wompler Jason Mantzoukas as Eric "Gutterballs" Gutterman Seth Morris as Ms. Anderson and Dr. Lionel Drioche Danielle Schneider as Rhonda DeLuce Jon Daly as Matt Yanni | NOTE: also featuring Scott Aukerman as Dabney Coleperson | |
| Best of 2015 Pt. 1 | 12/21/15 | Paul F. Tompkins | 14. George & Gil's Eulogies for the Passed (Episode 329: Too Much Tuna Tour) 13. Benny Schwaz and Uncle Stoney (Episode 327: Bang! Bang! Into Your Mouth!) 12. Live Reading the Script (Episode 351: CBB: The Movie) 11. The Ceremony Begins (Episode 335: The Wedding of Gilli and Garry) | |
| Best of 2015 Pt. 2 | 12/24/15 | Paul F. Tompkins | 10. Talkin' Tang with Joe Bongo (Episode 365: Bongo vs. Bongos) 9. Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge (Episode 354: Solo Bolo: Dos Lo) 8. Scarsdale! (Episode 377: Good Night in the Morning) 7. Jeffrey Characterwheaties (Episode 378: Mailer Daemon) | |
| Best of 2015 Pt. 3 | 12/28/15 | Paul F. Tompkins | 6. Time, Drums, and Ducks (Episode 349: The 6th Anniversary Show!) 5. Joey Tortellini (Episode 342: A Silicon Valley P-Cast) BONUS: Gino Lombardo montage 4. Santa vs. Scott (Episode 338: Be My Guest, Literally!) | |
| Best of 2015 Pt. 4 | 12/31/15 | Paul F. Tompkins Jason Mantzoukas calls in | 3. Four Washington Lane! (Episode 355: Kid Detectives) 2. In Memory of Harris (Episode 336: NOT Farts and Procreation 4) 1. Birth of a Catchphrase (Episode 356: Heynong Man) | |

### 2016

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 393: Peanuts Awareness | 1/4/16 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself and Ted Ronson | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 394: Wisconsin Sugar Babies | 1/11/16 | Zach Galifianakis Lauren Lapkus as Todd Tim Baltz as Don Darling | | |
| Episode 395: Yupparently | 1/18/16 | Whitney Cummings John Gemberling as Gene Rottenberry Mary Holland as Linda Gravel | | |
| Episode 396: The Intern Challenge | 1/21/16 | Rob Huebel Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler | | |
| Episode 397: My Silly Moss Man | 1/25/16 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Lauren Lapkus as Dimples and Mrs. Blarrr Joe Wengert as Cody Calavera | | |
| Episode 398: Prayer Orgy | 2/1/16 | Samantha Bee Drew Tarver as Craig Bieber Ryan Gaul as Ron Bieber | | |
| Episode 399: Trump vs. Bernie | 2/4/16 | Gilbert Gottfried James Adomian as Bernie Sanders and Jesse Ventura Anthony Atamanuik as Donald Trump | | |
| Episode 400: The War on Surfing | 2/8/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Hot Dog | | |
| Episode 401: LOVE Is Thicker Than Water | 2/15/16 | Paul Rust Gillian Jacobs Paul F. Tompkins as Alan Thicke and Garry Marshall | Games: New No-Nos | |
| Episode 402: Solo Bolo Trolo | 2/18/16 | Ben Schwartz | Games: Riddle Me This, Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge, What Am I Thinking? | |
| Episode 403: This Ain’t Now, This is Then | 2/22/16 | Adam Scott Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Dan Ahdoot as Tebow Lebow | | |
| Episode 404: The Timeys Leap Year Celebration | 2/29/16 | Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Jessica Jean Jardine as The Sun Dialer Ronnie Adrian as The Clock Facer Betsy Sodaro as The Watch Maker Carl Tart as The Old Timer Tim Kalpakis as The Time Master | NOTE: There is a segment after the post-episode ad and Earwolf credits with Paul F. Tompkins as JW Stillwater. | |
| Episode 405: Space Chemistry | 3/3/16 | Jillian Bell Charlotte Newhouse Matt Gourley as Irvin Kershner James Bladon as Sir Alec Guinness | | |
| Episode 406: Kid Detectives II | 3/7/16 | Thomas Middleditch as J.J. O'Malaman Lauren Lapkus as Murphy O'Malaman and Todd | | |
| Episode 407: Shut the Fuck Door! | 3/14/16 | Paul F. Tompkins Dan Ahdoot as himself and Felix Heist Drew Tarver as himself and Wiliger Wronge Mandell Maughan as herself and Stacey Keeks Ryan Gaul as himself and Dean Unda Tawny Newsome as herself and Margita Chelco Tim Baltz as himself and Olivier Wronge | | |
| Episode 408: LIVE at SXSW 2016 | 3/17/16 | Ben Schwartz Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Nick Kroll as Sylvester Stallone Paul F. Tompkins as Len Wiseman | | |
| Episode 409: Man Brats | 3/21/16 | Taran Killam as Bryce Cripple Paul Brittain as Tob Handlez | | |
| Episode 410: You Know John Leguizamo | 3/28/16 | Jerrod Carmichael Joe Wengert as Angel Coliciwo Neil Campbell as Pam Steensma | | |
| Episode 411: The Phony Marony Show with The Thermals | 3/31/16 | The Thermals Mike Hanford as John Lennon Tim Kalpakis as Tony B. | | "My Heart Went Cold" by The Thermals "Thinking of You" by The Thermals "The Walls" by The Thermals |
| Episode 412: Little Whittle Whistle | 4/4/16 | Cameron Esposito Paul F. Tompkins as J.W. Stillwater and Richard Harrow Matt Gourley as Professor Stillwater | | |
| Episode 413: Cranking It To Coldplay | 4/7/16 | Tom Scharpling Jon Daly as John Daly | | |
| Episode 414: Hollywood Handbook Comedy! (Hollywood Edition) | 4/11/16 | Sean Clements Hayes Davenport | Games: Would You Rather?, Riddle Me This! (Dragon Edition), Fart, Mary, Kiss | |
| Episode 415: The Longest Pig Pile | 4/14/16 | Rob Corddry Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Brian Huskey as himself and Gustav Dudamel Erinn Hayes | | |
| Episode 416: Silicone Bralley Poo Crew | 4/18/16 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Turd Dunkweed, and China Kumail Nanjiani Martin Starr | | |
| Episode 417: The 3 Year Diet | 4/25/16 | Shane Torres Tim Baltz as Ron Petty Ryan Gaul as Dr. Peter Fash | | |
| Episode 418: Paul Reiser and The Apple Tree | 4/28/16 | Paul Reiser Brendon Small as Victor Diamond, Tiny, and Willard “Willy” Mapleton | | |
| Episode 419: The 7th Anniversary Show! | 5/2/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Thomas Lennon Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Mike Hanford as John Lennon Tim Baltz as Olivier Wronge Drew Tarver as Wiliger Wronge | | |
| Episode 420: Todd Is Too High with Rogue Wave | 5/9/16 | Rogue Wave Haley Joel Osment Lauren Lapkus as Todd | | "Look At Me" by Rogue Wave "Falling" by Rogue Wave "Ocean" by Rogue Wave "Plug Up the Toilet" by Ghetto Astronauts "Endless Supply" by Rogue Wave |
| Episode 421: I Got Your Results | 5/16/16 | Maria Bamford Will Hines as Brock Stone | | |
| Episode 422: The WoodyVerse | 5/19/16 | Chris Gethard Anthony Atamanuik as Woody Allen Connor Ratliff as George Lucas Shannon O'Neill as Renalda | | |
| Episode 423: Time Bobby 4 | 5/23/16 | Bobby Moynihan as Fourvel and Fourandahalfvel Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber | | |
| Episode 424: Almost Parasites | 5/30/16 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Kate Berlant as Greg Kerns Drew Tarver as Crap Pollo | | |
| Episode 425: Sunday Afternoon Taped | 6/2/16 | Andy Samberg Claudia O'Doherty Nick Kroll as R. Schrift, the Mailer Daemon, Fabrice Fabrice, himself, Sylvester Stallone, El Chupacabra, Mrs. Doubtfire, Bill Maher, Creaky Gate, and Gil Faizon | | |
| Episode 426: Schwartz & Schwarts | 6/6/16 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself and Barney Schwarts | | |
| Episode 427: True Russian Facts | 6/13/16 | Natasha Leggero Riki Lindhome Dan Mangan Craig Cackowski as Mikhail Titscoffski | Games: Would You Rather? | "Mouthpiece" by Dan Mangan "Basket" by Dan Mangan "New Skies" by Dan Mangan |
| Episode 428: Get Donk’d | 6/16/16 | Rhys Darby Mary Holland as Margie Donk Londale Theus Jr. as Reggie Tote | | |
| Episode 429: Almost Mandatory | 6/20/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Thomas Middleditch as himself and Edmond Carlyle | | |
| Episode 430: Man Veils | 6/27/16 | Kristian Bruun Jessica McKenna as Beth Zeke Nicholson as B.Q. | Games: How Dumb Are You As A Canadian?, Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 431: Ghost Pets Are Liars | 6/30/16 | Brett Gelman Mike O'Brien as Chris Dante Tawny Newsome as Ydeda Elaine Brown | | |
| Episode 432: Dana Carvey's Micro-Impressions | 7/4/16 | Dana Carvey John Gemberling as HP-DP-69B Drew Tarver as Little Dammit Man | | |
| Episode 433: Government Pizza | 7/11/16 | Aparna Nancherla Jeremy Rowley as Ming Ryan Gaul as Doug Gropes | | |
| Episode 434: Doubt About That | 7/14/16 | Brent Weinbach Brendon Small as Victor Diamond, Tiny, and Willard “Willy” Mapleton Erin Whitehead as Patty Pecker | | |
| Episode 435: Jim Gaffigan Says No | 7/18/16 | Jim Gaffigan Eugene Cordero as Tito Ben Will Hines as Matt Knight | | |
| Episode 436: Rich Mind Vain | 7/25/16 | Sean Clements as himself and Rich Mind Vain Chris Tallman as Nick Nolte Eliza Skinner as Angelica Trashmouth | | |
| Episode 437: Fart Face Fuckers 2 | 8/1/16 | Mike Birbiglia Horatio Sanz as himself and Dr. Bill Phil Mary Holland as herself and Lisa Taco | | |
| Episode 438: Hair Take It | 8/8/16 | Cameron Esposito River Butcher Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson | | |
| Episode 439: It's Great (An Improv Team) | 8/11/16 | Adam Pally as himself and Bro Nick Kroll as himself and R. Schrift | | |
| Episode 440: Pop-TarTender | 8/15/16 | Todd Glass Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Matt Besser as LaMary | | |
| Episode 441: Your Cousin Marvin | 8/22/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Carl Tart as Marvin Phelps Neil Campbell as Larry the Loner | | |
| Episode 442: Atlantis Dire Warning | 8/29/16 | Andy Daly as Neptuna and Dalton Wilcox Jeremy Rowley as Ming | | |
| Episode 443: This Is Your Boy Troy | 9/5/16 | Adam Scott Will Hines as Jack Sparks Jessica McKenna as This Is Your Boy Troy | | |
| Episode 444: Mind Your Please and Questions | 9/12/16 | Tig Notaro Mike Hanford as John Lennon Drew Tarver as Mr. Manners | | |
| Episode 445: Sully Goose | 9/15/16 | Michelle Biloon Paul F. Tompkins as Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger | | |
| Episode 446: Scrounging and Lounging | 9/19/16 | Tatiana Maslany Kristian Bruun Mary Holland as Janice Cramps Paul F. Tompkins as Big Chunky Bubbles | | |
| Episode 447: These Are the Worst | 9/26/16 | Aya Cash Kether Donohue Zeke Nicholson as Bone Queef Kate Berlant as Daniel | | |
| Episode 448: Master of Horror | 10/3/16 | Robert Kirkman Ryan Gaul as Doug Gropes John Gemberling as Mart | | |
| Episode 449: Nasty Lyrics | 10/10/16 | Paul F. Tompkins Drew Tarver as Trish Trasch Ryan Gaul as Beverly Gunt Mandell Maughan as Janice Bullhorn Dan Ahdoot as Juan | | |
| Episode 450: Throw It On the Floor | 10/13/16 | Kyle Kinane Horatio Sanz as Dr. Julius Jackson | | |
| Episode 451: Wishing with The Grawlix | 10/17/16 | Ben Roy Andrew Orvedahl Lauren Lapkus as Frank Dorito Brendon Small as Victor Diamond, Tiny, and Willard "Willy" Mapleton Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 452: Pow! Pow! Power Wheels! | 10/24/16 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Claudia O'Doherty Jessica McKenna as Beth | | |
| Episode 453: Unblocked and Unlocked | 10/27/16 | Johnny Pemberton as himself and Dicker Troy Eden Sher Londale Theus Jr. as Reverend T.P. Stain | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 454: Return to Suicide House Part Tricks-or-Treats | 10/31/16 | Jon Daly as Beuford le Barron Allan McLeod as Ghost Boy Paul Rust as Dr. Traygo Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi Caroline Anderson as Scaroline | Games: Hallowscream Freestyle Rap Contest | |
| Episode 455: The Washington Monugents Reunite | 11/3/16 | Bob Odenkirk River Butcher Tim Kalpakis Dave Ferguson Mike Hanford Eban Schletter | | |
| Episode 456: The Historic Rap | 11/7/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon | | |
| Episode 457: Prepare for the Quake | 11/14/16 | Michael Showalter Paul Brittain as Dr. Brian Blouse Jeremy Rowley as Mark | | |
| Episode 458: Solo Bolo Cuatrolo | 11/17/16 | Ben Schwartz Lin-Manuel Miranda calls in | Games: Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge | |
| Episode 459: Giamatti Gives Thanks | 11/21/16 | Maria Thayer James Adomian as Paul Giamatti Tawny Newsome as Gary Urbansky | | |
| Episode 460: Persons of Interest | 11/28/16 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Ryan Gaul as Detective James P. Garetty Jeremy Rowley as Kole Kringle Drew Tarver as David | | |
| Episode 461: Tragedy Boom! Boom! with The Magic Tavern | 12/1/16 | Adal Rifai as Chunt, King of the Badgers Arnie Niekamp Matt Young as Usidore the Blue | Games: Honesty or Challenge | |
| Episode 462: Breakin' Since the 30s | 12/5/16 | Nick Thune Moshe Kasher Lauren Lapkus as Wendy Quote The Worm Unquote Widelman and The Dell Guy | | |
| Episode 463: 2016 Holiday Spectacular | 12/12/16 | Jason Mantzoukas Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Mike Hanford as John Lennon Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson Tawny Newsome as Gary Urbansky Tim Baltz as Ron Urbansky Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper River Butcher Will Hines as Frosty the Snowman Ryan Gaul as Norm Hamer Jeremy Rowley as Ming Drew Tarver as Keith Jones James Adomian as Jesse Ventura Zeke Nicholson as Dr. Green Brendon Small as Victor Diamond, Tiny, and Willy Mapleton | | |
| Best of 2016 Pt. 1 | 12/19/16 | Paul F. Tompkins | 15. Benny Shwaz and Ted Ronson (Episode 393: Peanuts Awareness) 14. Droppin’ Deuces and Pizza Raps (Episode 456: The Historic Rap) 13. Rapping Beth and Text Death (Episode 452: Pow! Pow! Power Wheels!) 4. Gil, George, and Pamela from Big Bear (Live Episode: Just For Laughs in Montreal) 12. Catching up with Hot Dog (Episode 400: The War on Surfing) | |
| Best of 2016 Pt. 2 | 12/22/16 | Paul F. Tompkins | 11. New No-Nos and Theme Songs (Episode 401: LOVE Is Thicker Than Water) 10. D.A.B.D.A. (Episode 423: Time Bobby 4) 9. Another Olympic Song Challenge (Episode 402: Solo Bolo Trolo) 3. Claudia O'Doherty and Calvin Redding (Live Episode: Sydney, NSW, Australia) 8. Exposing R. Schrift (Episode 425: Sunday Afternoon Taped) | "Please Don't Joke About 'I, Robot' This Christmas" by Scott Aukerman and Paul F. Tompkins |
| Best of 2016 Pt. 3 | 12/26/16 | Paul F. Tompkins | 7. You Know What? (Episode 390: The Oh, Hello Show) 2. Kid Detectives 2.5 (Live Episode: Live from Comic-Con) 6. Broken Feet and Janice Cramps (Episode 446: Scrounging and Lounging) 5. Amateur Barrister Sex Parties (Episode 429: Almost Mandatory) 4. The Time Keeper's Rap (Episode 419: The 7th Anniversary Show!) | |
| Best of 2016 Pt. 4 | 12/29/16 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. Everyone but David Bunting (Episode 391: 2015 Holiday Spectacular) BONUS: The Apple Tree Song (Episode 418: Paul Reiser and The Apple Tree) 2. Turd Dunkweed (Episode 416: Silicone Bralley Poo Crew) 1. Ho Ho, The Contraptionaire, and Donny Gary (Live Episode: Atlanta, The Tabernacle) 1. Two Words! We Gotta Go to Alaska! (Episode 406: Kid Detectives II) | "Olympic Song Challenge Remix" by Scott Aukerman and Ben Schwartz (featuring Lin-Manuel Miranda) |

### 2017

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 464: A Ton More Sexy | 1/4/17 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as Shelly Driftwood and Gringo Starr | | |
| Episode 465: Harsh Joe Pinions | 1/9/17 | Matt Besser Jessica McKenna as Margery Kershaw Gil Ozeri as Joe "Pinions" Rudolph | | |
| Episode 466: Gossip Guy | 1/16/17 | Brendon Walsh as himself and Rene Faberge Randy Liedtke Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon and Ross Geller | | |
| Episode 467: TruLife TV | 1/23/17 | Paul Scheer as himself and Tyren Bigsby Michelle Biloon Mike O'Brien as Kelly Burton | | |
| Episode 468: The Dream Method | 1/30/17 | Rachel Bloom Jeremy Rowley as Ming Anthony Atamanuik as Chief Inspector Yoplait and Ringo Starr Mike Hanford as Peter Finn | | |
| Episode 469: Quiznos What QuizDid | 2/6/17 | John Hodgman Zeke Nicholson as Dr. Green Carl Tart as The Chief | | |
| Episode 470: Electric Guest Are Masculine | 2/13/17 | Electric Guest Mary Holland as Brandon Potter Erin Whitehead as Janelle Jinx | | "Glorious Warrior" by Electric Guest "Dear To Me" by Electric Guest |
| Episode 471: Shy By Nature, Outgoing By Nurture | 2/20/17 | Jason Mantzoukas John Early as Tricia R. Kate Berlant as Tricia L. | | |
| Episode 472: Pleats, Please! | 2/23/17 | Kurt Braunohler Will Hines as Johnny Bikes Holly Prazoff as Susan Greenberg | | |
| Episode 473: Tight Tort | 2/27/17 | Ben Schwartz as himself and Markis Quiddlebit Thomas Middleditch as himself and Alan Buchanan | | |
| Episode 474: Liquid Meal Spheres | 3/6/17 | Gillian Jacobs Paul Rust Paul F. Tompkins as Big Chunky Bubbles | Games: New No-Nos, Comedy Bang Bang Dating Game | |
| Episode 475: Prince and John Popper | 3/13/17 | Andy Daly as August Lindt Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo | | |
| Episode 476: The Evigan Way | 3/20/17 | Ryan Gaul as Dr. Martinia Johansson Heidi Gardner as Tracy Evigan Jordan Black as Toluca Graves | | |
| Episode 477: Two Fingers Wide | 3/23/17 | American Football Mike Hanford as John Lennon Mary Holland as Gwendolyn Speck Tim Baltz as Jonathan Woodley | | "I've Been So Lost For So Long" by American Football "Home Is Where The Haunt Is" by American Football "Everyone Is Dressed Up" by American Football |
| Episode 478: Spank Me With A Feather! | 3/27/17 | Kristian Bruun Tatiana Maslany Paul F. Tompkins as Chazmin Lauren Lapkus as Sunny Mary Holland as Janice Cramps | | |
| Episode 479: The Bunn Process | 4/3/17 | Gerry Duggan Paul Brittain as Richard Bunn Kirby Howell-Baptiste as Angeylinaaa | | |
| Episode 480: Tooth of the Sea | 4/6/17 | Jane Lynch Kate Mines Paul Witten Drew Tarver as Curtis Korn Madeline Walter as Wanda Dumps | | |
| Episode 481: Silly Con Valley Poo Crew 3 | 4/10/17 | Thomas Middleditch as himself and Don Donaldson Kumail Nanjiani Martin Starr | | |
| Episode 482: Streahemoth | 4/17/17 | Joel Hodgson Baron Vaughn Jonah Ray Horatio Sanz as Johnny "Delta" Johnson Alison Rich as Inés Blarfi | | |
| Episode 483: The 420 Show | 4/20/17 | Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Zeke Nicholson as Dr. Green Matt Besser as Colin Ramsey | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 484: Pre Chowder | 4/24/17 | Jason Mantzoukas Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 485: The 8th Anniversary Show! | 5/1/17 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss, Garry Marshall and Alan Thicke Lauren Lapkus as Regina Crimp and P'Nut Zeke Nicholson as Bone Queef Carl Tart as The Chief Mary Holland as Chucky Spliff Mike Hanford as John Lennon Jessica McKenna as Dagmar the Small Tawny Newsome as Rauro Riley Tim Baltz as Burt Riley Ryan Gaul as Norm Hamer Drew Tarver as Keith Jones Jeremy Rowley as Ming Nick Kroll as R. Schrift | | |
| Episode 486: Schwimm On In | 5/8/17 | Ron Funches Nick Thune Jon Daly as Papa Johns Misty Jordan Black as Vernita Wyatt | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 487: Genie Awareness | 5/15/17 | Haley Joel Osment Ryan Gaul as Doug Gropes Lauren Lapkus as Bunty Pickles Shaun Diston as Carl Smart | | |
| Episode 488: 3 Kidnapped Boys | 5/22/17 | Al Madrigal Alana Johnston as Cam Paxton Alison Rich as Brian Credit Natalie Palamides as Billy Neville | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 489: The Bajillion Dollar Propertie$ Elevator Pitch | 5/29/17 | Kulap Vilaysack as herself and Gishel Bergentrack Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Orph Bergentrack Tim Baltz as himself and Jackenzie Bergentrack Dan Ahdoot as himself and Gobo Bergentrack Drew Tarver as himself and Trey Bergentrack Eugene Cordero as himself and D'artagnan Bergentrack Mandell Maughan as herself and Mackenzie Bergentrack Tawny Newsome as herself and Kim Bega | | |
| Episode 490: Coma Pants | 6/5/17 | Lucia Aniello Paul W. Downs Zeke Nicholson as Pants the Rapper Carl Tart as MC Sugar Butt Lamar Woods as Carl Coaster | | |
| Episode 491: Goo It | 6/12/17 | Rory Scovel Mike Hanford as Justin Hoffman D'Arcy Carden as Caroline BelindaCarlisle | | |
| Episode 492: Dashiki Fever | 6/19/17 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Miss Listler | | |
| Episode 493: King Garbage Dick | 6/22/17 | Nick Kroll Anthony King as Liberty DeVito Seth Morris as Josh Yadegar | | |
| Episode 494: Face Fox | 6/26/17 | Jon Hamm Edgar Wright Paul F. Tompkins as J.W. Stillwater Jessica McKenna as Beth | | |
| Episode 495: Who CBBeefed? | 6/29/17 | Jason Mantzoukas Mary Holland as Jennifer Spot Tim Baltz as Jason Turley | | |
| Episode 496: The Dream Lords | 7/3/17 | Andrea Savage Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Will Hines as Morpheus, The Dream Lord Holly Prazoff as Mary Lisa | | |
| Episode 497: Wait Awhile | 7/10/17 | Kumail Nanjiani Emily V. Gordon Horatio Sanz as Cooper F. Worthington-Tompkins Eliza Skinner as Lindsey Cumdrop | | |
| Episode 498: What That DOS | 7/13/17 | Flula Borg Jeremy Rowley as Ming Brendon Small as Willard "Willy" Mapleton and Captain Mustache Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 499: The Freak | 7/17/17 | Kyle Mooney as himself and Chris Fitzpatrick Paul Rust as Benny Bachelor Neil Campbell as Barrett Bachelor Fran Gillespie as Rosie Jipps | | |
| Episode 500: The 500th Episode | 7/24/17 | Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Jason Mantzoukas Lauren Lapkus as Todd Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon Mary Holland as Tommy Scuzz | | |
| Episode 501: Manchester Orchestra's Kith and Kin | 7/31/17 | Manchester Orchestra (Andy Hull and Robert McDowell) Jessica McKenna as Sissy Montgomery Zach Reino as Lord Dingle | | "The Gold" by Manchester Orchestra "The Alien" by Manchester Orchestra |
| Episode 502: Error 502 | 8/7/17 | Joe Mande James Adomian as Jesse Ventura and Falkor Will Hines as Morpheus | | |
| Episode 503: Reese's Feces | 8/14/17 | Andy Richter Alison Rich as Tina Danish John Gemberling as Patricia Primm | | |
| Episode 504: The Bigger the Percent the Better | 8/17/17 | Brett Gelman | | |
| Episode 505: Grass-Fed Bits | 8/21/17 | David Wain Dan Wilson Jordan Black as Testarossa Manigault Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz | | "When the Stars Come Out" by Dan Wilson "Someone Like You" by Dan Wilson "Closing Time" by Dan Wilson |
| Episode 506: Hot Tub Diarrhea | 8/28/17 | Chris Gethard Mike Hanford as John Lennon Madeline Walter as Pam Carton | | |
| Episode 507: Popcorn Costume | 9/4/17 | Cameron Esposito River Butcher Paul F. Tompkins as Mike the Janitor Tawny Newsome as Gary Urbansky | | |
| Episode 508: Beach Cheese | 9/11/17 | Nathan Fielder Betsy Sodaro as Cherry the C.H.U.D. Will Hines as Bones McGrill | | |
| Episode 509: 3 Witches and a Baby | 9/18/17 | Tig Notaro Lauren Lapkus as Dump Dump Mary Holland as Frida Corpse Erin Whitehead as Girdle | | |
| Episode 510: Pound Foolish | 9/25/17 | Andy Samberg Paul F. Tompkins as Mayor Junius Bobbledoonary Drew Tarver as Derek Contrera | | |
| Episode 511: Morzouksnick Interruption | 10/2/17 | Nick Kroll Jason Mantzoukas Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | | |
| Episode 512: What's Your AIM? | 10/9/17 | Bobby Moynihan as Slow Pesci and Fourvel Paul F. Tompkins as Werner Herzog | | |
| Episode 513: Hobo Code | 10/12/17 | Patton Oswalt Drew Tarver as Randy Travels Betsy Sodaro as Charlotte | | |
| Episode 514: The Calvins Twins Return | 10/16/17 | Taran Killam as Bever Hopox Paul Brittain as Chico Hands Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock | | |
| Episode 515: Return to Suicide House Part 666 | 10/23/17 | Brett Gelman as Messmore LeBaron Jon Daly as Bueford LeBaron Allan McLeod as Ghost Boy Natalie Palamides as Ghost Mother Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi Caroline Anderson as Scaroline | Games: Hallowscream Freestyle Rap Competition | |
| Episode 516: Solo Bolo Cincolo | 10/26/17 | Ben Schwartz | Games: Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge | |
| Episode 517: Aha Moments with The National | 10/30/17 | The National Brendon Small as Victor Diamond and Tiny Jessica McKenna as Dagmar the Small | | "Walk It Back" by The National "Guilty Party" by The National "Carin at the Liquor Store" by The National |
| Episode 518: Corn Dog Horndog | 11/6/17 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Cameron McGonigle | | |
| Episode 519: Law O Ver Everything | 11/13/17 | John Early Carl Tart as The Chief Zeke Nicholson as Bone Queef | | |
| Episode 520: Dead Body Rap | 11/16/17 | Rob Huebel Will Hines as Joe Squib Alana Johnston as Chandeline Jean | | |
| Episode 521: Bing Bong Goodbye | 11/20/17 | John Hodgman Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lauren Lapkus as Todd D'Arcy Carden as Caroline BelindaCarlisle | | |
| Episode 522: Charlie's Bucket List | 11/27/17 | Sarah Silverman Madeline Walter as Charles Manson Ego Nwodim as Prince Chinedu Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 523: Chekhov's Phone | 12/4/17 | Jimmy Pardo Drew Tarver as Jake Ryan Rosenberg as David Jon Mackey as Lou Dan Lippert as Carl | Games: Charades By Proxy | |
| Episode 524: Merry Chunky Christmas with Neil Patrick Harris | 12/11/17 | Neil Patrick Harris Paul F. Tompkins as Big Chunky Bubbles Shaun Diston as Rudi North | | |
| Episode 525: 2017 Holiday Spectacular | 12/18/17 | Mister Heavenly Jason Mantzoukas Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Mike Hanford as John Lennon Paul F. Tompkins as Mayor Junius Bobbledoonary and Old Woman James Adomian as Chris Matthews Carl Tart as MC Sugar Butt Tawny Newsome as Gary Urbansky Drew Tarver as Keith Jones Jeremy Rowley as Ming Neil Campbell as Ernie Bread | | "Makin' Excuses" by Mister Heavenly "Beat Down" by Mister Heavenly "Blue Lines" by Mister Heavenly "Hammer Drop" by Mister Heavenly |
| Best of 2017 Pt. 1 - Nagada: A Star Wars Story | 12/25/17 | Paul F. Tompkins | 16. New No-Nos and Big Chunky Bubbles (Episode 474: Liquid Meal Spheres) 15. The Chief's Debut (Episode 469: Quiznos What Quiz Did) 14. The Bergentrack Family Familial Band (Episode 489: The Bajillion Dollar Propertie$ Elevator Pitch) 13. Buchanan and Quiddlebit (Episode 473: Tight Tort) | "Please Don't Joke About 'I, Tonya' This Christmas" by Scott Aukerman and Paul F. Tompkins |
| Best of 2017 Pt. 2 | 12/28/17 | Paul F. Tompkins | 12. CG Me Eyes (Episode 521: Bing Bong Goodbye) 11. The Horse-Off (Episode 514: The Calvins Twins Return) 10. Ghost Tours (Episode 518: Corn Dog Horndog) 9. Meeting the Mayor (Episode 510: Pound Foolish) | "Freestyle Rap Remix" by Ben Schwartz and Scott Aukerman |

### 2018

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Best of 2017 Pt. 3 | 1/1/18 | Paul F. Tompkins | 8. Chazmin and Sunny Return (Episode 478: Spank Me With A Feather!) 7. Don & Dong (Episode 481: Silly Con Valley Poo Crew 3) 6. Slow Pesci (Episode 512: What's Your AIM?) 5. Scott's Breakfast Bukkake (Episode 484: Pre Chowder) | "The Monster Fuck Part 6 (Scary Love)" by Nick Wiger and Caroline Anderson |
| Best of 2017 Pt. 4 | 1/4/18 | Paul F. Tompkins | 4. The Return of Bob Ducca (Episode 511: Morzouksnick Interruption) 3. The Smooth Criminal, The Time Keeper, and The Hammer Nissan Holiday Naughty Or Nice Nissan Sentra Car Giveaway Contest (Episode 463: 2016 Holiday Spectacular) 2. Garry Marshall, Bone Chief, and Chucky Spliff (Episode 485: The 8th Anniversary Show!) 1. Breaking Off Another Hundo (Episode 500: The 500th Episode) | "Olympic Song Challenge Remix" by Scott Aukerman and Ben Schwartz |
| Episode 526: Air Lift Me Out | 1/8/18 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself and Shelly Driftwood | | |
| Episode 527: Hootie Hoo | 1/15/18 | Ego Nwodim as Dorothy Charlessss Shaun Diston as Leo Williams Alison Rich as Will Crowe | | |
| Episode 528: This Is The Story of My Life | 1/22/18 | Natasha Leggero Riki Lindhome Zeke Nicholson as Kiwi Kris Drew Tarver as Josh Fox | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 529: Am I The What? | 1/29/18 | Patton Oswalt Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox Mary Sohn as Pam Tran | | |
| Episode 530: Zoom Zoom | 2/5/18 | Whitney Cummings Jessica McKenna as Barry Big Marques Ray as Danny Trejo Jr. | | |
| Episode 531: Atmosphere Bully | 2/12/18 | Todd Glass James Adomian as Winston Churchill Nicole Byer as Becky | | |
| Episode 532: Everything is Horrible and Wonderful | 2/19/18 | Stephanie Wittels Wachs Will Hines as Morpheus the Dream Lord Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett Tawny Newsome as The Rum Tum Tugger | | |
| Episode 533: Is That Chocolate, Or What? | 2/26/18 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Mary Holland as Debbie Creepy Mano Agapion as Jergen Tavikya | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 534: Solid As A Rock | 3/5/18 | Paul Rust Claudia O'Doherty Carl Tart as Bashford Ego Nwodim as Franklin | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 535: Niles Per Hour | 3/12/18 | Peter Serafinowicz Griffin Newman Shaun Diston as Rudi North Natalie Palamides as Shaliyah Courtney Pauroso as Conchneee | | |
| Episode 536: Live from SXSW 2018 | 3/15/18 | Tatiana Maslany Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lauren Lapkus as Todd Paul Scheer as Scott Jeffries James Adomian as Sebastian Gorka | | |
| Episode 537: Silly Cone Valley Poo Crew Minus One | 3/19/18 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Janine Blackwell, and Kumail Nanjiani Martin Starr | | |
| Episode 538: Ro...ller Co...aster O...ne | 3/26/18 | Chelsea Peretti Matt Besser as Mick 4D Dhruv Uday Singh as Samir Chakraborty | | |
| Episode 539: The Pointing Sisters | 4/2/18 | Adam Cayton-Holland Neil Campbell as Larry the Loner D'Arcy Carden as Dino & Shame | | |
| Episode 540: Low Five | 4/9/18 | Jon Hamm Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson Jessica McKenna as Margery Kershaw Zach Reino as Dash Grabum | | |
| Episode 541: Is That A Joke? | 4/16/18 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Mitch Slocum, and Slippy Daniels Ben Schwartz as himself, Leonard Stooltap, and Jack Pot | | |
| Episode 542: Big Ben Minus Ten | 4/23/18 | Phoebe Robinson Madeline Walter as Mary Berry Ronnie Adrian as Bertrand "Sweet Sauce" Gilmore | | |
| Episode 543: The 9th Anniversary Show! | 4/30/18 | Sean Clements Hayes Davenport Lauren Lapkus as Dirk Thirsty Paul F. Tompkins as Emily Grandchildren Shaun Diston as Rudi North Zeke Nicholson as Kiwi Kris Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur Madeline Walter as Charles Manson | | |
| Episode 544: On Script | 5/7/18 | Michael Ian Black Nick Thune Zac Oyama as Kenny Takahashi Holly Prazoff as Melissa | | |
| Episode 545: Casual High Technology with Wajatta | 5/14/18 | Reggie Watts John Tejada Jeremy Rowley as Ming Alison Rich as Margarite Shoes | | "Let Me Come To Your Party" by Wajatta "Get Down (with Ya Bad Self)" by Wajatta "Je Wa Soto" by Wajatta "Runnin'" by Wajatta |
| Episode 546: 69 Show Pitches | 5/17/18 | Sean Clements Hayes Davenport | | |
| Episode 547: Johnny Pacquiao | 5/21/18 | John Mulaney Seth Morris as Clovis Mandrake Betsy Sodaro as Mrs. Potts | | |
| Episode 548: Know What I'm Saying? | 5/28/18 | Gillian Jacobs Paul F. Tompkins as Lavinia Marsh Caruthers Lamar Woods as Carmine Tawny Newsome as eDream Vignette | | |
| Episode 549: Prom Womptacular | 6/4/18 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Lennon Parham as Charlotte Listler Brian Huskey as Dr. Seth Wompler and Vance H. Paul Scheer as C.S. Steers | NOTE: also featuring Scott Aukerman as Dabney Coleperson | |
| Episode 550: Cheesing Out the Wave D-Hole | 6/11/18 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Hot Dog | | |
| Episode 551: New to the Wax with The Sloppy Boys | 6/18/18 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Mike Hanford as himself and John Lennon Tim Kalpakis Jefferson Dutton Shaun Diston as Devin O'Shea | | "Here for the Beer" by The Sloppy Boys "I'm One Hell of a Dude" by The Sloppy Boys "Hee Hee Hee" by The Sloppy Boys |
| Episode 552: Hey, Keep Readin' | 6/25/18 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Ryan Gaul as Dr. Peter Fash Edi Patterson as Bean Dip | | |
| Episode 553: Let's Write on the White | 7/2/18 | Lakeith Stanfield Ego Nwodim as Darlington Cassel/Meryl Stanfield Mary Sohn as Nancy Yi and Bob Cat | | |
| Episode 554: Educainment Squad | 7/9/18 | Horatio Sanz as himself, Peppers McGilly, and Big One Thomas Middleditch as Lyle Cummings | | |
| Episode 555: What A Wonderful WaterWorld | 7/16/18 | Cameron Esposito Paul F. Tompkins as JW Stillwater Matt Gourley as Cal Buckley/Professor Stillwater | | |
| Episode 556: Tips 'n' Tricks | 7/23/18 | Kristian Bruun John Gemberling as Erupt Gil Ozeri as Sweatch Zeke Nicholson as Raul DeLaMancha | | |
| Episode 557: Word Down | 7/23/18 | Carl Tart as Larry Blackmon Madeline Walter as Nance | | |
| Episode 558: Ship of Love | 7/29/18 | Casey Wilson Drew Tarver as Martin Sheffield Lickly Zac Oyama as Chase Varner | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 559: Jen and Berry's Frozen Ice | 8/6/18 | Bobby Moynihan as Jen Eugene Cordero as Berry | | |
| Episode 560: 1-800 Jingles | 8/13/18 | Ben Schwartz Jessica McKenna as Phil Shorts Will Hines as Hypnoto the Mesmerist and Morpheus the Dream Lord | | |
| Episode 561: Poke Mitzvah | 8/20/18 | Andy Richter Zach Reino as Dash Grabum Tawny Newsome as Hekla Jonsdottir | | |
| Episode 562: They'ven't Yet | 8/27/18 | Max Silvestri Matt Besser as Daniel Faraway Joe Wengert as Roman D'O'Grots | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 563: Where You Come From with CHVRCHES | 9/2/18 | CHVRCHES Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Holly Prazoff as Mary Lisa | | "Miracle" by CHVRCHES "Graffiti" by CHVRCHES |
| Episode 564: Svelte Scale | 9/10/18 | Zach Galifianakis Andy Daly as Byron Denniston Nicole Parker as Celine Dion | | |
| Episode 565: C'mon Bake Bake | 9/17/18 | Jason Mantzoukas Mary Holland as Eugenia Wobbles D'Arcy Carden as Augie Augerman | | |
| Episode 566: The Calvins Triplets | 9/24/18 | Taran Killam as Bever Hopox and Marinka Oligarch Paul Brittain as Chico Hands Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock | | |
| Episode 567: Midnight Junket | 10/1/18 | Lennon Parham as Forsythia Nick Kroll as Sergei, himself, and Timmy Gil Ozeri as Bane | | |
| Episode 568: Literal Web | 10/8/18 | Ike Barinholtz Dhruv Uday Singh as Lin-Manuel Miranda Mary Sohn as Nadine Funts | | |
| Episode 569: Dull Knives Sturdy Eyes | 10/15/18 | Emily Heller Drew Tarver as Matthew Dan Lippert as Luke Ryan Rosenberg as Chris Jon Mackey as Billy | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 570: The Dirty 27 | 10/22/18 | David Wain Thomas Middleditch as himself and Brody Broderson Shaun Diston as Rudi North | | |
| Episode 571: Rope Beats Rock | 10/29/18 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Betsy Sodaro as Queen Cleopatra Will Hines as Idaho | | |
| Episode 572: Changerous | 11/5/18 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Buttonwillow McKittrick | | |
| Episode 573: Alfred Molina Flair | 11/12/18 | Adam Cayton-Holland Alana Johnston as Diane Templeton Ben Rodgers as Jack Furz | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 574: Conan Never Goes Outside | 11/19/18 | Conan O'Brien Paul F. Tompkins as Pat Hamptoncrat Lauren Lapkus as Scat Hamptoncrat Mary Holland as Prudence Farth | | |
| Episode 575: That Dazzles Me Already | 11/26/18 | Don't Stop or We'll Die (Paul Rust, Michael Cassady) Mike Hanford as John Lennon Zac Oyama as Keantwo Reeves | | "That's Right I'm Five" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "Lily Pad On Your Doorstep" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "Taco Night"/"Waving Through A Window" by Don't Stop or We'll Die & Scott Aukerman |
| Episode 576: What the Sound Made | 12/3/18 | Andy Daly as Joe Bongo Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz | | |
| Episode 577: Miss-pered | 12/10/18 | Flula Borg Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Lily Sullivan as Kayla Dickie | | |
| Episode 578: Right Off The Batman | 12/13/18 | Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon Bobby Moynihan as Batman | | |
| Episode 579: 2018 Holiday Spectacular | 12/17/18 | Jason Mantzoukas Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Paul F. Tompkins as Santa Claus Lauren Lapkus as Big Sue Claus Shaun Diston as Rudi North Zeke Nicholson as Peter Griffin Jessica McKenna as Beth and Killiam Mike Hanford as John Lennon Will Hines as Morpheus, The Dream Lord Ryan Gaul as Deanas Croc Tim Baltz as Daenas Croc Thomas Middleditch as Big Dog Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi | | |
| Best of 2018 Pt. 1 | 12/24/18 | Paul F. Tompkins | 14. The Songs of Martin Sheffield Lickly (Episode 558: Ship of Love) 13. Brock Lovett, Treasure Hunter (Episode 532: Everything is Horrible and Wonderful) 12. Eugenia Wobbles (Episode 565: C'mon Bake Bake) 11. Debut of a Fan Favorite (Episode 524: Merry Chunky Christmas with Neil Patrick Harris) | "Blue Lines" by Mister Heavenly |
| Best of 2018 Pt. 2 | 12/27/18 | Paul F. Tompkins | 10. Bever, Chico, and Bisby (Episode 566: The Calvins Triplets) 9. Godfather vs. Queen (Episode 572: Changerous) 8. Stooltap and Slocum (Episode 541: Is That A Joke?) 7. Conan and the Hamptoncrats (Episode 574: Conan Never Goes Outside) | |
| Best of 2018 Pt. 3 | 12/31/18 | Paul F. Tompkins | 6. What's Up, Hot Dog? (Episode 550: Cheesing Out the Wave D-Hole) 5. Calling the Superintendent (Episode 554: Educainment Squad) 4. Gotta Catch 'Em All! (Episode 540: Low Five) | |

### 2019

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Best of 2018 Pt. 4 | 1/03/19 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. New No-No's and Bashford & Franklin (Episode 534: Solid As A Rock) 2. A Fan Favorite is Back and Entrée PeeE Neur (Episode 543: The 9th Anniversary Show!) 1. Mayor Bobbledoonary and Chris Matthews (Episode 525: 2017 Holiday Spectacular) | |
| Episode 580: Legend of Mr. Met | 1/7/19 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself, Johnny Salese, and Chris Grezlik | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 581: Thickest Oompa Loompa | 1/14/19 | Matt Ingebretson Jake Weisman Ego Nwodim as Willamina Wonka Mary Scheer as Doreen Blachly | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 582: Practice Sacks | 1/17/19 | Sam Richardson Joe Wengert as Coach Joel GanVundi Mary Sohn as Deb | | |
| Episode 583: Batman Nine-Nine | 1/21/19 | Chelsea Peretti Drew Tarver as Martin Sheffield Lickly John Gemberling as Chitter Chitter Cluck Click | | |
| Episode 584: Weirdamony Alimony Tony | 1/28/19 | John Hodgman Paul F. Tompkins as Alimony Tony Will Hines as Rupert Sharp | | |
| Episode 585: Lemons is the New Black | 2/4/19 | Matt Walsh Lauren Lapkus as Traci Reardon Dhruv Uday Singh as Allen Woody, Louis C.K., and Roman Polanski | Games: Riddle Me This | |
| Episode 586: Butt First | 2/11/19 | River Butcher Colton Dunn as Devon Westinghouse Ryan Gaul as James P. Garity | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 587: No Relation | 2/18/19 | Maya Erskine Anna Konkle Dan Lippert as Seth Berkowitz Ronnie Adrian as Perry Gordon | | |
| Episode 588: Lil' Choices | 2/25/19 | Jason Mantzoukas Thomas Middleditch as Kaitlin | | |
| Episode 589: Werewolfwithal | 3/4/19 | Patton Oswalt Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox | | |
| Episode 590: Bread Mop | 3/11/19 | Andrea Savage Matt Besser as Jackson Maine Madeline Walter as Linda Watermark | | |
| Episode 591: UnbeWiebebeble: Kayla Dickie Returns | 3/14/19 | Flula Borg Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Lily Sullivan as Kayla Dickie Tim Baltz as Jud Wiebe | | |
| Episode 592: The PeeE Neurs | 3/18/19 | Langston Kerman Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur Carl Tart as Appetizer PeeE Neur Paul F. Tompkins as Jarles | | |
| Episode 593: Get In The Way Gremlin | 3/25/19 | Natalie Morales Jessica McKenna as Get In The Way Gremlin Zeke Nicholson as Peter Griffin | | |
| Episode 594: Now It's Time For A Breakdown | 3/28/19 | Dan Mangan Will Hines as Randy Useless Jon Mackey as Jimmy-Bug Brickhouse | | "Peaks & Valleys" by Dan Mangan "Troubled Mind" by Dan Mangan "Cold in the Summer" by Dan Mangan |
| Episode 595: Mother's Olive Oil | 4/1/19 | Demi Adejuyigbe Carl Tart as The Chief and Cleveland Columbus Alyssa Limperis as Mother | | |
| Episode 596: Mr. Met and the Legitimate Witch | 4/8/19 | Griffin Newman Paul F. Tompkins as Mr. Met Alison Rich as Mathilda Primble | | |
| Episode 597: Simpson and Smith: Selling Stories | 4/15/19 | Baron Vaughn Zac Oyama as Denny Simpson Ify Nwadiwe as Gregory Smith | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 598: Secret Shopping with Mötley Crüe | 4/22/19 | Tim Robinson Ryan Rosenberg as The Super Secret Shopper Natalie Palamides as Nikki Sixx Courtney Pauroso as Nikki Seven | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 599: 10th Anniversary Part 1 | 4/29/19 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Hot Dog and Dalton Wilcox Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Jon Hamm Lauren Lapkus as Todd Jessica McKenna as Beth Zach Reino as Dash Grabum Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur and Prince Chinedu Zeke Nicholson as Bone Queef and Kiwi Kris Carl Tart as MC Sugar Butt and The Chief Rob Huebel Thomas Lennon as himself and Little Gary Matt Besser as Björk Paul Scheer as Chip Garvey Tawny Newsome as Gary Urbansky and Rum Tum Tugger Madeline Walter as Charles Manson Taran Killam as Bever Hopox Paul Brittain as Chico Hands Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock and Jisby | | |
| Episode 599.5: 10th Anniversary Part 2 | 4/29/19 | Thomas Middleditch as Joey Tortellini Adam Scott Chelsea Peretti Nick Kroll as Fabrice Fabrice Drew Tarver as Martin Sheffield Lickly "Weird Al" Yankovic Paul Rust as himself and Mama Bread Neil Campbell as Ernie Bread and Mr. Bread Bobby Moynihan as Fourvel and Batman Mary Holland as Eugenia Wobbles Horatio Sanz Ben Schwartz Jon Daly as Mall McCartney Shaun Diston as Rudi North and Judy North Mike Hanford as John Lennon Will Hines as Randy Useless Brendon Small as Captain Mustache Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler calls in Lennon Parham as Charlotte Listler calls in James Adomian as Jesse Ventura and Huell Howser | Games: New No-Nos | |
| Episode 600: Patrick McMahon Returns: A Story About Johnny McGory | 5/6/19 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Patrick McMahon | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 601: 20th Anniversary Special | 5/13/19 | Kulap Vilaysack Lily Sullivan as Becky Ryan Gaul as Randy H. Over | | |
| Episode 602: Four...Dollars Hundred | 5/20/19 | David Cross Will Hines as Louis Green Ele Woods as Dina Dennis | | |
| Episode 603: Fastidious Makeover with The Sloppy Boys | 5/27/19 | Mike Hanford as himself, John Lennon, and Ralph Slodge Tim Kalpakis as himself and Dr. Olivia Slodge Jefferson Dutton Neil Campbell as Mr. Fastidious/Dan Slodge | | "Santa Ana Winds" by The Sloppy Boys "Radio Dayze" by The Sloppy Boys "The Bands" by The Sloppy Boys |
| Episode 604: Hashtag Song Goals with Seth Green | 6/3/19 | Seth Green Carl Tart as Trombone Shitty Jon Daly as Stephen Road Gil Ozeri as Jonathan Track | | |
| Episode 605: Full Ninja Rights | 6/10/19 | Max Silvestri Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Dan Lippert as Conroy | | |
| Episode 606: Treasure Hunting with Silversun Pickups | 6/17/19 | Silversun Pickups Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett Jessica McKenna as Margery Kershaw | | "It Doesn't Matter Why" by Silversun Pickups "Panic Switch" by Silversun Pickups "Freakazoid" by Silversun Pickups |
| Episode 607: Are You A Heaux? | 6/24/19 | Beth Stelling Ego Nwodim as Judge Heaux Brown Betsy Sodaro as Icky Spice | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 608: Major League Bees | 7/1/19 | Tim Heidecker Will Hines as Lester Gayle Ben Rodgers as Jack Furz | | |
| Episode 609: Donna Sticks Catering Experience | 7/8/19 | Andy Richter Lily Sullivan as Donna Sticks Oscar Montoya as Sam Poppers | | |
| Episode 610: NutsStalgia | 7/15/19 | Alan Tudyk Holly Prazoff as Mary Lisa Ryan Rosenberg as Petey Tweety | | |
| Episode 611: TindTeacher | 7/22/19 | Bryan Safi Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Zac Oyama as Mr. Camp Edgar Momplaisir as Dr. Chet Mariongello | | |
| Episode 612: The Juice Is Loose | 7/29/19 | Jimmy Pardo Carl Tart as O. J. Simpson Lauren Ashley Smith as Liza Farrington | | |
| Episode 613: Driving Beauty Queens | 8/6/19 | Moshe Kasher Natasha Leggero Drew Tarver as Fred Head Ele Woods as Sophie Purell | | |
| Episode 614: Bean Dip & Randy Snutz Return: That's What I Said | 8/12/19 | Adam DeVine Edi Patterson as herself and Bean Dip Tim Baltz as himself and Randy Snutz | | |
| Episode 615: The Chastman Family | 8/19/19 | Tatiana Maslany as herself, Chastity Aspen, and Madildabelle Chastaman Kristian Bruun as himself and Branston Chastman Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Robert Chastman Kirby Howell-Baptiste as herself and Cicilia Chastaman | | |
| Episode 616: Memphis Kansas Breeze with YACHT | 8/26/19 | YACHT Shaun Diston as Little Tony Diamonds Drew Tarver as Brantley Aldean Carl Tart as Harland Haywood and Danny Diamonds/Jim Parsons | | "(Downtown) Dancing" by YACHT "SCATTERHEAD" by YACHT "Blue On Blue" by YACHT |
| Episode 617: Modern Nursery Rhymes | 9/2/19 | Anthony Jeselnik Dan Lippert as Maximilian McSillystein Dhruv Uday Singh as Art Ketel One | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 618: Hot Yogurt | 9/9/19 | Kevin Nealon Joe Wengert as Joe Kupso Lily Sullivan as Yogi Gussy | | |
| Episode 619: The Stars of Between Two Ferns: The Movie | 9/15/19 | Zach Galifianakis Lauren Lapkus as herself and Clint Screams Ryan Gaul as himself and Ichabod Gordy Bradbury Jiavani Linayao as herself and The Artful Dodger | | |
| Episode 620: Burbank is The Good Place | 9/23/19 | D'Arcy Carden Anthony King as Phil Wiggins John Gemberling as Robert Whistler | | |
| Episode 621: Untitled Wachs Project | 9/30/19 | Stephanie Wittels Wachs Dan Lippert as Shemp A. and James Drew Tarver as Tater, John, and Mayor Ron Ryan Rosenberg as Corey A. and Jingleheimer | | |
| Episode 622: Pillow Coffin: Rudi North Returns | 10/7/19 | Jason Mantzoukas Shaun Diston as Rudi North Lily Sullivan as Virginia Patricia Tim Baltz as Darren Matichek | | |
| Episode 623: The Pragmatic Jokers | 10/14/19 | Sarah Baker Matt Gourley as himself, Ted Kemper, and Jed Kemper Paul F. Tompkins as himself, Ned Kemper, and Red Kemper | | |
| Episode 624: Clinkity Clank | 10/21/19 | Jocelyn DeBoer Dawn Luebbe Griffin Newman as Skints McGlinty Laci Mosley as Tayleigh Lopez | | |
| Episode 625: Petite Modeling | 10/28/19 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Claudia O'Doherty Will Hines as Stanley Chamberlin Ben Rodgers as Chuck Plyman | | |
| Episode 626: Trickery and Rhythm | 11/4/19 | Max Silvestri Edgar Momplaisir as Leonard Jonas Zeke Nicholson as Étouffée | | |
| Episode 627: How Bout That? | 11/11/19 | Allen Strickland Williams Holly Prazoff as Mary Lisa Jiavani Linayao as Carter Meza | | |
| Episode 628: Floating Bus Reform | 11/18/19 | Joel Kim Booster Mitra Jouhari Dan Lippert as Burgey Sullenberger Zac Oyama as Topher Schmidty | | |
| Episode 629: Pimp My Site | 11/25/19 | Demi Adejuyigbe Gabe Gundacker Ryan Rosenberg as Chef Spaghetti Capellini Ify Nwadiwe as Xzibit | | |
| Episode 630: Tattoos Clues | 12/2/19 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Chauncey Pippins, and Joey Tortellini Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo | | |
| Episode 631: What Are the Coordinates? | 12/9/19 | Rekha Shankar as herself and Giuseppe Spaghetti Mary Holland as Sarah Lastnum Jimmy Fowlie as Chris Creen | | |
| Episode 632: 2019 Holiday Spectacular | 12/16/19 | Electric Guest Jason Mantzoukas Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lauren Lapkus as Todd Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Tim Baltz as Darren Matichek Lily Sullivan as Tracy M. Will Hines as Stanley Chamberlin Zeke Nicholson as Étouffée Paul F. Tompkins as Santa Claus Zach Reino as Dash Grabum Carl Tart as Harland Haywood Drew Tarver as Brantley Aldean | | "Dollar" by Electric Guest "Oh Devil" by Electric Guest "More" by Electric Guest |
| Best of 2019 Pt. 1 | 12/23/19 | Paul F. Tompkins | 15. Hunters and Rangers (Episode 606: Treasure Hunting with Silversun Pickups) 14. Dip/Snutz (Episode 614: Bean Dip and Randy Snutz Return: That's What I Said) 13. O. J. (Episode 612: The Juice Is Loose) 12. Birds, Bees, Trees, Letters (Episode 615: The Chastman Family) | |
| Best of 2019 Pt. 2 | 12/26/19 | Paul F. Tompkins | 11. Return of the Poet Laureate of the West (Episode 589: Werewolfwithal) 10. Stanley Never Gets To His Bit (Episode 625: Petite Modeling) 9. Entrée and Appetizer (Episode 592: The PeeE Neurs) 1. The Dink Dink Man (Live Episode: Chicago 2019) | |
| Best of 2019 Pt. 3 | 12/30/19 | Paul F. Tompkins Brad Evans Nick Ciarelli | 8. Seamus McMahon's Less Famous Brother (Episode 600: Patrick McMahon Returns: A Story About Johnny McGory) 7. From Catchphrase to Character (Episode 584: Weirdamony Alimony Tony) 6. Rise of the North, a Retiree, and Bobbleheads (Episode 622: Pillow Coffin: Rudi North Returns) 5. Martin Sheffield Lickly Returns (Episode 583: Batman Nine-Nine) | "Love Gym" by Drew Tarver "Love Eggs" by Drew Tarver "Love Restaurant" by Drew Tarver "Existence is Emptiness" by Drew Tarver |

### 2020

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Best of 2019 Pt. 4 | 1/2/20 | Paul F. Tompkins | 4. Gino, Santa, Big Sue, Big Dog, and Leo Carpazzi (Episode 579: 2018 Holiday Spectacular) 3. The Dark Knight and Cal Solomon (Episode 578: Right Off The Batman) 2. Kaitlin and The Mole Man Portal (Episode 588: Lil' Choices) 1. Songs About Trucks (Episode 616: Memphis Kansas Breeze with YACHT) | "The Monster Fuck Part 7 (Haunted-kah)" by Nick Wiger and Jessica McKenna "Pick-Up Truck Birthday" by Drew Tarver and Carl Tart "Truck Prom Dance" by Drew Tarver and Carl Tart "Human Skin Truck Baby" by Drew Tarver and Carl Tart |
| Episode 633: Forky On Top, Porky On The Bottom | 1/6/20 | Ben Schwartz Horatio Sanz as himself, Piggy Sorebacks, and Coco Marx | | |
| Episode 634: Wainscotting, Entree P. Neur & Italiano Jones | 1/13/20 | David Wain Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur and Sharon Carl Tart as Italiano Jones | | |
| Episode 635: Peanut Time Machine | 1/16/20 | Rob Huebel Erinn Hayes Jonathan Braylock as George Washington Carver Jerah Milligan as Lusciously James III as Marcus Tanner | | |
| Episode 636: Hamburger Spider | 1/20/20 | Kristian Bruun as himself and Mary Ford Ben Rodgers as Rusell Karate Lisa Gilroy as Nana Aukerman | | |
| Episode 637: Moshe Rock, Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber & Jim the Shim | 1/27/20 | Moshe Kasher Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber, Alimony Tony, and Dame Judi Dench Tawny Newsome as Jim the Shim/Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber and Rum Tum Tugger | | |
| Episode 638: One Last Heist | 2/3/20 | Jason Mantzoukas Shaun Diston as Bullets Jackson Tim Baltz as Antonio Lambrinidis | | |
| Episode 639: The Becky Button | 2/10/20 | Andy Samberg Nick Kroll Lily Sullivan as Becky and Shannon | | |
| Episode 640: Solo Bolo Sonicolo | 2/13/20 | Ben Schwartz | Games: Riddle Me This, Pitch a Sitsong, Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge | |
| Episode 641: Not My Aunt | 2/17/20 | Adam Cayton-Holland Jessica McKenna as Sherry Barrels Zach Reino as Dash Grabum | | |
| Episode 642: Chicago Chaperone | 2/24/20 | Jimmy Pardo Niccole Thurman as Crystal Del Rey Jenner Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe | | |
| Episode 643: The Order of the Keepers | 3/2/20 | Neil Campbell as The Time Keeper Paul F. Tompkins as JW Stillwater | | |
| Episode 644: Fall Olympics | 3/9/20 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo D'Arcy Carden as Chris Starbo Brandon Scott Jones as Chris Starbo Dan Lippert as Bill Walton | | |
| Episode 645: Jack FM Bumpers | 3/16/20 | Matt Braunger Will Hines as Lester Brads Brad Evans as Murf Nick Ciarelli as Dirt | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 646: Ninja Nordstrom | 3/23/20 | Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Lily Sullivan as Sabrina Jacob Wysocki as Griff Hedgley | | |
| Episode 647: Steak My Day | 3/30/20 | Paul F. Tompkins as Burnt Millipede Nicole Parker as Joan Pedestrian Ryan Gaul as Dickie Caroline's | | |
| Episode 648: Door-to-door Doors | 4/6/20 | Alan Yang Lauren Lapkus as Todd Mike Castle as Gigantic Dan | | |
| Episode 649: Goose Tycoon | 4/9/20 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur Carl Tart as O. J. Simpson Drew Tarver as Roger Peculiar | | |
| Episode 650: Bun Gun and a Hot Dog Bullet | 4/13/20 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox, August Lindt, and Hot Dog | | |
| Episode 651: Pirates Never Lie | 4/20/20 | Thomas Middleditch as himself, Captain Littlemember, and Still Tantin Ben Schwartz as himself, Squawks, and Bill Rantin | | |
| Episode 652: Virtual Styling | 4/27/20 | Jonathan Van Ness Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Tawny Newsome as Auntie Renee Tim Baltz as Joel Spanaducci | | |
| Episode 653: The 11th Anniversary Show! | 5/4/20 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Carl Tart as Roland Gift Ego Nwodim as Dairy Queen | | |
| Episode 654: LasSie is Benji | 5/11/20 | Rhys Darby Paul F. Tompkins as Alimony Tony Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe | | |
| Episode 655: Zoom Gloom | 5/18/20 | David Spade Lauren Lapkus as Big Sue Seth Morris as Bob Ducca | | |
| Episode 656: A Bonanas for Bonanza Takeover | 5/21/20 | Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox Maria Bamford as Amy Sleeverson Matt Gourley as Mutt Taylor | | |
| Episode 657: Space Forts, Baby! | 5/25/20 | Ben Schwartz as himself and Genzer Smartz Tawny Newsome as herself and Genevieve Smartz Dan Lippert as Seth Berkowitz | | |
| Episode 658: AcroBATics | 6/1/20 | Myq Kaplan Mike Hanford as John Lennon Jessica McKenna as Dagmar the Small | | |
| Episode 659: Hubba Hubba Punch Up | 6/8/20 | Judd Apatow Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Ego Nwodim as Tony Wyoming Ben Rodgers as Dar the Beast Master | | |
| Episode 660: Beer with Judy Greer Award | 6/15/20 | Judy Greer Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Will Hines as Buck Reilly | | |
| Episode 661: The Moser Trio | 6/22/20 | Paul F. Tompkins as Chejff Moser Carl Tart as Heepe Moser Tim Baltz as Pastor Peter Pool Boy | | |
| Episode 662: The Robbies | 6/29/20 | Rory Scovel as himself and Chester Tumphrie Sasheer Zamata as herself and Tyler Wiffle Mary Holland as herself and Francis Stork | | |
| Episode 663: P.A.I.G.E. Is Magic | 7/6/20 | John Hodgman David Rees Paul F. Tompkins as Jill Noll the Magic Doll Matt Gourley as P.A.I.G.E. | | |
| Episode 664: YouTube, Show Me Haircut | 7/13/20 | Langston Kerman Heidi Gardner as Erica Zac Oyama as Douglas Speaker | | |
| Episode 665: Half a Hartnett | 7/20/20 | Jim Gaffigan Lily Sullivan as Amber Lee Tots Ego Nwodim as QuaranTina Turner | | |
| Episode 666: You Get It? | 7/27/20 | Yassir Lester Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Ryan Gaul as Douglas Gropes Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi | | |
| Episode 667: Andy Samberg Is Not Family | 8/3/20 | Andy Samberg Mike Hanford as himself and John Lennon Tim Kalpakis Jefferson Dutton Will Hines as Barry Sams | | "The Mastah Bong Rippah" by The Sloppy Boys "Out on the Town" by The Sloppy Boys "Little Miss Socialite" by The Sloppy Boys |
| Episode 668: Four Siblings | 8/10/20 | June Diane Raphael Paul F. Tompkins as Charlie "Burgey" Sullenberger Jacquis Neal as Bishop R.L. Bakes | | |
| Episode 669: Star Trek: Upper Decker | 8/17/20 | Jack Quaid as himself, Dash Griswold, and Jeff Eugene Cordero as himself and Jazz Jazz Tawny Newsome as herself and Cast Iron | | |
| Episode 670: The Meet Heads | 8/24/20 | Kyle Bornheimer Carl Tart as Jerone Buckethat Lily Sullivan as Trish Maxwell | | |
| Episode 671: Married Thespians | 8/31/20 | Patton Oswalt Mike O'Brien as himself and Bob Wessex Mary Sohn as herself and Cherilyn Wessex | | |
| Episode 672: Busy Burgeys | 9/7/20 | Busy Philipps Ego Nwodim as Tricia Seawater Paul F. Tompkins as Charlie "Burgey" Sullenberger Dan Lippert as Burgey Sullenberger | | |
| Episode 673: The Grax Apology Tour | 9/14/20 | Eliza Skinner Joe Wengert as Grax, Eater of Worlds Matt Apodaca as Jefferson Milkyway | | |
| Episode 674: Canon Relapse | 9/21/20 | Shaun Diston as Rudi North Tim Baltz as Darren Matichek Edgar Momplaisir as Jerry Major Paul F. Tompkins as Cake Boss calls in | | |
| Episode 675: Clothing Sausages | 9/28/20 | Arden Myrin Lauren Lapkus as Shaden Gallbreath Brian Jordan Alvarez as Emil | | |
| Episode 676: Juice on Juice | 10/5/20 | Nick Thune Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Ben Rodgers as Dale Creamy | | |
| Episode 677: The Calvins Family Telethon Extravaganza | 10/12/20 | Taran Killam as Bever Hopox, Dylan Preeches, Michael Cera, Bronx Girl, Minnesota Guy, Surfer Dude, Coroner, and The Taffy God Paul Brittain as Chico Hands, Brian Fun, Bronx Guy, and Minnesota Girl Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock | | |
| Episode 678: The Heimlich Remix | 10/19/20 | Steve Byrne Jimmy O. Yang Drew Tarver as Henry Heimlich Katie Rich as JoJo Benassi | | |
| Episode 679: Popcorn World | 10/26/20 | Gillian Jacobs Paul F. Tompkins as Alimony Tony Carl Tart as Orville Redenbacher | | |
| Episode 680: Small Claims Cyborg | 11/2/20 | Jason Mantzoukas Thomas Middleditch as himself and Gino Carpuzzi | | |
| Episode 681: Bard and Switch with Aunty Donna | 11/9/20 | Broden Kelly as himself and Mr. Monroe Zachary Ruane as himself and Mario Mark Bonanno as himself and Salvatore Michelangelo | | |
| Episode 682: Colin Quinn's Dream Presentation | 11/16/20 | Colin Quinn Jessica McKenna as Margery Kershaw Will Hines as Morpheus the Dream Lord | | |
| Episode 683: Sidewalk in the Desert | 11/23/20 | Kulap Vilaysack SuChin Pak Ego Nwodim as Ana Conda Madeline Walter as Mary Berry | | |
| Episode 684: Road Toad | 11/30/20 | Natalie Palamides as herself, Alex, and Luke Walton Drew Tarver as Jeff Ryan Rosenberg as Mike Dan Lippert as Bill Walton Jon Mackey as Wade Boggs | | |
| Episode 685: The Fix-It Guys | 12/7/20 | Paul Rust as himself and Clev Neil Campbell as himself and Gary | | |
| Episode 686: 2020 Holiday Spectacular | 12/14/20 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Santa Claus Andy Daly as August Lindt Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho the Naughty Elf Ego Nwodim as The Kid Who Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus Carl Tart as The Chief Lily Sullivan as Nookie Tim Baltz as Tootie Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Dan Lippert as Frankenstein | | |
| Best of 2020 Part 1 | 12/21/20 | Paul F. Tompkins | 16. Two Burgeys (Episode 672: Busy Burgeys) 15. We've Got To Stop Talking About TMNT On CBB (Episode 646: Ninja Nordstrom) 14. Rectangular Things (Episode 634: Wainscotting, Entree P. Neur & Italiano Jones) 13. The Starbos (Episode 644: Fall Olympics) | |
| Best of 2020 Part 2 | 12/24/20 | Paul F. Tompkins | 12. The Mosers (Episode 661: The Moser Trio) 11. Rudi's Recap, Cake Boss, and Bobbleheads (Episode 674: Canon Relapse) 10. The Magic of Podcasts (Episode 663: P.A.I.G.E. Is Magic) 9. Gino Carpuzzi (Episode 680: Small Claims Cyborg) | |
| Best of 2020 Part 3 | 12/28/20 | Paul F. Tompkins | 8. Gillian Goes Gold-Digging (Episode 679: Popcorn World) 7. Treasure Hunting & Social Media (Episode 653: The 11th Anniversary Show) 6. Bee Honey & Taffy Tins (Episode 677: The Calvins Family Telethon Extravaganza) 5. Roger Peculiar (Episode 649: Goose Tycoon) | |
| Best of 2020 Part 4 | 12/31/20 | Paul F. Tompkins | 4. Death of a Water Skier (Episode 650: Bun Gun and a Hot Dog Bullet) 3. No Time To Die (Episode 643: The Order of the Keepers) 2. Bullets Jackson (Episode 638: One Last Heist) 1. Omaha Steaks, Physical Therapy, and Memphis Kansas Breeze (Episode 632: 2019 Holiday Spectacular) | |

### 2021

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 687: Full Grown Grogu | 1/4/21 | Ben Schwartz as himself, Chaniel Leftrowbottom, and Bobby Knuts Horatio Sanz as himself, Skip Weller, and Shelly Driftwood | | |
| Episode 688: The Sugarhill Gang Museum | 1/11/21 | Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon | | |
| Episode 689: Marketing Mine Own Selfowitz | 1/18/21 | Jake Fogelnest Dan Lippert as Seth Berkowitz Lyric Lewis as 'Shell | | |
| Episode 690: Spices On Your Meat | 1/25/21 | Mary Lynn Rajskub Ego Nwodim as Mrs. Dash Carl Tart as Mr. Dash Ben Rodgers as Bud Frakely | | |
| Episode 691: #NoStank | 2/1/21 | Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Shaun Diston as Mike Ruby Lily Sullivan as Diana Deep | | |
| Episode 692: Chalke Talk, Structure-A-Stuffy & Tunt | 2/8/21 | Sarah Chalke Paul F. Tompkins as Bill Eikenberry Katie Rich as Deb Tunt | | |
| Episode 693: Kissy's Prime | 2/15/21 | London Hughes Will Hines as Ruben Stone Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe | | |
| Episode 694: Thunder Bucket | 2/22/21 | Adam Brody Ryan Gaul as Gary Candles Madeline Walter as Tina | | |
| Episode 695: Spinning Fidgets & Hunting Bounties with Teen #2 | 3/1/21 | Kelly Marie Tran Kulap Vilaysack Jessica McKenna as Chrysanthemum Tummers Zach Reino as Eli Fuseli | | |
| Episode 696: Rather Good | 3/8/21 | Gillian Jacobs Diona Reasonover Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson Neil Campbell as Alister Brown | | |
| Episode 697: Good News for Boobs | 3/15/21 | Fortune Feimster Dan Lippert as Bill Walton Jacquis Neal as Jacquis Robinson | | |
| Episode 698: Horse Meat Paninis | 3/22/21 | Thomas Lennon Rob Huebel Lily Sullivan as Lindsay McMulligan Jay Pichardo as Carmella Areola | | |
| Episode 699: Avatar 2: ACABatar | 3/29/21 | Dulcé Sloan Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Connor Ratliff as James Cameron Griffin Newman as Jake Sully | | |
| Episode 700: Plan One: The Scrooge Gang | 4/5/21 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston, Dalton Wilcox, August Lindt, and Hot Dog | | |
| Episode 701: Promo Code SPORTS | 4/12/21 | Jamie Lee Carl Tart as Italiano Jones Ego Nwodim as Entrée PeeE Neur Jon Gabrus as Geoff Ben Rodgers as Jeoff | | |
| Episode 702: Electric Toilet with Don't Stop or We'll Die | 4/19/21 | Paul Rust Michael Cassady Matt Gourley as H.R. Giger Kaitlyn Tanimoto as Mary Jane Kim | | "Flower in My Garden" by Don't Stop or We'll Die "Baby Gets (What Baby Wants)" by Don't Stop or We'll Die |
| Episode 703: Gaines and Gaines | 4/26/21 | Langston Kerman Paul F. Tompkins as Original Fig James Austin Johnson as Donald Trump | | |
| Episode 704: The 12th Anniversary Show! | 5/3/21 | Jason Mantzoukas Manchester Orchestra Andy Daly as Byron Denniston and Dalton Wilcox Paul F. Tompkins as The Griz Jessica McKenna as Margery Kershaw Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Lily Sullivan as Carissa Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Carl Tart as Charles Barkley Dan Lippert as Rabbi Bill Walton Ego Nwodim as Charlotte Hornette | | "Bed Head" by Manchester Orchestra "Keel Timing" by Manchester Orchestra "Telepath" by Manchester Orchestra |
| Episode 705: Better Call Bed Bath & Beyond | 5/10/21 | Bob Odenkirk Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Griffin Newman as Skints McGlinty | | |
| Episode 706: Mind Google | 5/17/21 | J. B. Smoove Carl Tart as O. J. Simpson Will Hines as Gary the Robot | | |
| Episode 707: 6 Foot Long Sticks | 5/24/21 | Paul F. Tompkins as Lavinia Marsh Caruthers aka Shevel Knievel, Little Joe Bardi, The Big Dammit Man, and Gavin's Friend Dan Lippert as Mark Patsy and Big Charlie Bardi Monika Smith as Bob Parks | | |
| Episode 708: Common Slaw | 5/31/21 | Nikki Glaser Zach Reino as Gareth Cloakman Zac Oyama as Mr. Camp | | |
| Episode 709: Sprague's Survivor | 6/7/21 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Will Hines as Andy Manders and Morpheus the Dream Lord Mike Hanford as Zoobi Condarino and John Lennon | | |
| Episode 710: A Trio of Duos | 6/14/21 | Sparks Edgar Wright Ben Rodgers as Jack Furz Matt Apodaca as Buck Tango | | |
| Episode 711: The Heimlich B-Side | 6/21/21 | Patton Oswalt Meredith Salenger Drew Tarver as Henry Heimlich Betsy Sodaro as Little Debbie | | |
| Episode 712: Tides Anonymous | 6/28/21 | Max Silvestri Paul F. Tompkins as Burnt Millipede Nicole Parker as Joan Pedestrian Jacquis Neal as Bishop R.L. Bakes | | |
| Episode 713: 3 Time Pizzas and Goose Liver Pate | 7/5/21 | Mike Mitchell Neil Campbell as Maxwell Keeper Carl Tart as Cleotis Martholobew Jessica Jean Jardine as Wolfgang Puck | | |
| Episode 714: Twilight 2: Top Chef | 7/12/21 | Ziwe Ryan Rosenberg as Coach Billips Jessica McKenna as Chrysanthemum Trummers | | |
| Episode 715: Ho No Dew Didn't | 7/19/21 | Haley Joel Osment Shaun Diston as Mike Ruby Joe Wengert as JP Fossord Raiza Licea as Juslani Marilyn | | |
| Episode 716: Meemaw and Them | 7/26/21 | Casey Wilson Paul F. Tompkins as Eddie Lee Capers Katie Rich as Connie Depandi | | |
| Episode 717: Tighten Those Nuts | 8/2/21 | Felicia Day Janet Varney Matt Apodaca as The Great Magna Holly Prazoff as Mary Lisa | | |
| Episode 718: Hey, Where is Everybody? | 8/9/21 | Tawny Newsome as herself and Billa Beth Jack Quaid as himself and Thurl Ravenscroft Ryan Gaul as Darryl Who | | |
| Episode 719: Give It To Gilli! | 8/16/21 | Gillian Jacobs Will Hines as Henry Sames Dan Lippert as Bill Walton and R. L. Stine | | |
| Episode 720: Rita Rasvegas | 8/23/21 | Hannah Einbinder Monika Smith as Baby Boy Boy Jacob Wysocki as Tommy the Green Power Ranger | | |
| Episode 721: Passion of the Pasta | 8/30/21 | Phoebe Bridgers Ego Nwodim as Pastor Pasta Drew Tarver as Fred Head | | |
| Episode 722: Cowdy Partner | 9/6/21 | Andy Samberg Ryan Rosenberg as Dusty Neil Campbell as The Answer Seeker | | |
| Episode 723: Bell Biv DeVito | 9/13/21 | Kristian Bruun Paul F. Tompkins as Lorenzo Borgia and The Ghost of Stan Lee Suzi Barrett as Lane Driver | | |
| Episode 724: Four Super Producers | 9/20/21 | Ike Barinholtz as himself and Gary Filipowski Katie Rich as herself and Marge Filipowski Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer | | |
| Episode 725: Blitzen D'Onofrio | 9/27/21 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox Tim Baltz as Darren Matichek | | |
| Episode 726: Church of Commercials | 10/4/21 | Sasheer Zamata as herself and Dina the Dinosaur Lily Sullivan as Harper L. Cosmopolitan Carl Tart as Reverend Good Feeling | | |
| Episode 727: Zig Zag Lights | 10/11/21 | Vanessa Bayer Will Hines as Brent Finley Edgar Momplaisir as Mack Attack | | |
| Episode 728: Phoebing for Some Phoebes | 10/18/21 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Phoebe Robinson Paul F. Tompkins as Kevin Attenborough Casey Feigh as Officer Dreary | | |
| Episode 729: Beethoven's 5th: F*ck the Fourth | 10/25/21 | Edgar Wright Bobby Moynihan as Jonathan Biting Dan Lippert as Ian Appaloosa | | |
| Episode 730: Solo Bolo Hallowolo | 10/28/21 | Ben Schwartz Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi | Games: Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge | |
| Episode 731: Nutshell Yourself | 11/1/21 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston, Hot Dog, and Dalton Wilcox | | |
| Episode 732: Pause and Respond | 11/8/21 | Laurie Kilmartin Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe Lily Sullivan as Sammy Samantha Jacquis Neal as Justin the Pickup Artist | | |
| Episode 733: City Limit Beans | 11/15/21 | "Weird Al" Yankovic Tim Baltz as Maurice Flatbottom Vic Michaelis as Morgan Weeston-Smythe | | |
| Episode 734: Elderly Whisperer | 11/22/21 | Aisling Bea Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber Madeline Walter as Brenda Tattletale | | |
| Episode 735: The Calvins Triplets vs. The Baxter Triplets | 11/29/21 | Taran Killam as Bever Hopox and Quita Baxter Paul Brittain as Chico Hands and Tanya Baxter Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock and Candide Baxter | | |
| Episode 736: Potato Fambly | 12/6/21 | Jimmy Pardo Danielle Koenig Suzi Barrett as Uggams the Potato Joey Greer as Mickey Babyboy | | |
| Episode 737: 2021 Holiday Spectacular | 12/13/21 | Paul F. Tompkins as Mike the Janitor Shaun Diston as Mike Ruby Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Jessica McKenna as Dagmar the Small Will Hines as Bennett Quints Carl Tart as Chief Dan Lippert as Michael Lindsay-Hogg Mary Holland as Crapy the Reindeer Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe | | |
| Best of 2021 Part 1 | 12/20/21 | Paul F. Tompkins | 15. A Concerned Citizen (Episode 716: Meemaw and Them) 14. Italiano & Entree (Episode 701: Promo Code SPORTS) 13. One Of The Great Cartographers! (Episode 719: Give It To Gilli!) 12. What's Up, Hot Dog? (Episode 731: Nutshell Yourself) | |
| Best of 2021 Part 2 | 12/23/21 | Paul F. Tompkins | 11. Smashing Guitars (Episode 721: Passion of the Pasta) 10. Cal's Legacy (Episode 688: The Sugarhill Gang Museum) 9. Nobody & Bolognese (Episode 705: Better Call Bed Bath & Beyond) 8. Bonanas For Bobbleheads (Episode 725: Blitzen D'Onofrio) | |
| Best of 2021 Part 3 | 12/27/21 | Paul F. Tompkins | 7. Narrated by Kevin Attenborough (Episode 728: Phoebing for Some Phoebes) 6. Winning The Best-Of's (Episode 709: Sprague's Survivor) 5. Santa's Got Nothing (Episode 686: 2020 Holiday Spectacular) 4. Being Prince Phillip (Episode 700: Plan One: The Scrooge Gang) | |
| Best of 2021 Part 4 | 12/30/21 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. Randy's Deal and Mike's Steps (Episode 691: #NoStank) 2. The Griz! (Episode 704: The 12th Anniversary Show!) 1. NCIS, Smooth Criminals, and Art Criticism (Episode 696: Rather Good) | |

### 2022

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 738: Three Doctors...Oh No | 1/3/22 | Ben Schwartz as himself and Dr. Sturgeon the Rock n Roll Surgeon Katie Dippold as Dr. Yvette Victor Gil Ozeri as Dr. Sweetchat the Small Talk Robot | | |
| Episode 739: Oi Noi, BB Bridgers! | 1/10/22 | Lily Sullivan as Bicky Carl Tart as MC Sugar Butt and Italiano Jones Ego Nwodim as Pastor Pasta | | |
| Episode 740: A Bar Mangled Manor | 1/17/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as Alimony Tony Dave Theune as Robby Delmuda Toni Charline as Max the Dog | | |
| Episode 741: Podcast Rescue | 1/24/22 | Roy Wood Jr. Devin Field as Ron Snapper Zeke Nicholson as Bone Queef Vic Michaelis as Willadeene Marie Bates | | |
| Episode 742: Wain Packaged Foods | 1/31/22 | David Wain Dan Lippert as Bill Walton Ele Woods as Amber Bolt | | |
| Episode 743: Over/Under | 2/7/22 | David Cross Tim Baltz as Antonio Lambrinidis Lisa Gilroy as Dickie Donnelly | | |
| Episode 744: The Three White Amigos and Dart | 2/14/22 | Ego Nwodim as Scapegoat Smith Will Hines as Jonas Kings Matt Apodaca as Dude Fiero | | |
| Episode 745: McGruff the Grind Dog | 2/21/22 | Anders Holm Shaun Diston as McGruff the Crime Dog Jacquis Neal as Justin | | |
| Episode 746: James Bond Dolls for Sale | 2/28/22 | Langston Kerman Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson Matt Gourley as himself and P.A.I.G.E. Townland | Andy Daly and Mark McConville appear in a post-credits scene as Joe Bongo and Joe Walsh, respectively. | "Gin Atomic" by Townland "War" by Townland |
| Episode 747: Honky Tonk Badonkalonk Weekend | 3/7/22 | John Gemberling as Winston Carmel Joe Wengert as Dr. Kevin Kenwait Raiza Licea as Phoebe Chi Chi Roo | | |
| Episode 748: Twink Christ | 3/14/22 | Lennon Parham as Dr. Helma Plinkton Jacob Wysocki as Barry Bunbuster Barryball Madeline Walter as Eileen Dogg | | |
| Episode 749: Time Loop | 3/21/22 | D'Arcy Carden Vic Michaelis as Emma Simon Knee-Keller Matt Apodaca as Ricky Johnson | | |
| Episode 750: The Pool Duel-Over: Part Duel | 3/28/22 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston, Hot Dog, and Dalton Wilcox Paul F. Tompkins as The Griz, Brock Lovett, Al A. Peterson, JW Stillwater, and Shimmy | | |
| Episode 751: From Candy Boy to TV Boy | 4/4/22 | Adam Scott Will Hines as Thomas Mashed-Potatoes Suzi Barrett as Mariska Beenaboutta | | |
| Episode 752: Wet Day Special | 4/10/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Spike Minksalmon Drew Tarver as Ike Minksalmon Ryan Gaul as Doug Gropes | | |
| Episode 753: Grilling with the Zouks | 4/17/22 | Natasha Leggero Lily Sullivan as Kayla Dickie Mike Hanford as Adjacent Mantzoukas Peter Banifaz as Dr. Anthony Fauci | | |
| Episode 754: Top Letterboxd Reviews | 4/24/22 | Claudia O'Doherty Carl Tart as O.J. Simpson Brad Evans as Kelvin Nick Ciarelli as Travis | | |
| Episode 755: The 13th Anniversary Show! | 5/1/22 | Dan Lippert as Bill Walton Stars Paul F. Tompkins as Big Chunky Bubbles Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Tim Baltz as Richie Castlebaum Ego Nwodim as Pastor Pasta Shaun Diston as Garry the Gardener Will Hines as Keith Stanley | | "Build a Fire" by Stars "Capelton Hill" by Stars "Pretenders" by Stars |
| Episode 756: Water Ghost Rules | 5/9/22 | Jonah Ray Zac Oyama as Tim Bullock Ego Nwodim as Bathina Salts Heather Anne Campbell as Cynthia Blake | | |
| Episode 757: Warning Jeans | 5/16/22 | Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Ben Rodgers as Brooke Flagstaff Devin Field as Jack Persimmons | | |
| Episode 758: Previous Partons | 5/23/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon Lisa Gilroy as Peanut Parton James Mannion as Alan Stubbs | | |
| Episode 759: Hot Sauce Reunion | 5/30/22 | Ben Schwartz Gil Ozeri as himself, Irving Sardinas, and Gabriel Sardinas Adam Pally as himself and Bro | | |
| Episode 760: The Four Questions | 6/6/22 | Andy Richter Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Vic Michaelis as Susie Tewman Casey Feigh as Young Scott | | |
| Episode 761: Plumbing Wars | 6/13/22 | Shaun Diston as Franky Flush Lily Sullivan as Lena Dunne Homme Ronnie Adrian as Jack Lusty | | |
| Episode 762: Beef Bank | 6/20/22 | Ryan Rosenberg as Craig Zlist aka Fishy Monika Smith as Ethel B. Dumphrey Dave Theune as Ernie Schrempf and Mick Hall | | |
| Episode 763: Star Toon Cartoon | 6/27/22 | Jack Quaid as himself and Dr. John Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett and Shimmy Tawny Newsome as Tierna and Lisa | | |
| Episode 764: iFrasier | 7/4/22 | Jon Daly as Kelsey Grammer Dan Lippert as Superman Ryan Gaul as Tobias Boothby | | |
| Episode 765: Pirate Ship Energy | 7/11/22 | Adam Pally as himself and Johnny Depp Jon Gabrus as himself and Gino Lombardo Ben Rodgers as Jack Furz Lisa Gilroy as Bethany Waterbottle | | |
| Episode 766: Kushtopia | 7/18/22 | Howard Kremer Brett Morris Will Hines as Hughie Chism Jacob Wysocki as Mr. Toots | | |
| Episode 767: Fourdom | 7/25/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Jarles Lauren Lapkus as herself and Carmine DeLonge Mary Holland as Haney Dilf | | |
| Episode 768: Scatch a Rising Star | 8/1/22 | Patton Oswalt Suzi Barrett as Ellen Norton-Simon Harris-Finley Finister Dave Theune as Dean Hormel Peter Banifaz as Johnny Scat | | |
| Episode 769: Cowbell Saul | 8/8/22 | Bob Odenkirk James Austin Johnson as Bobby Flay Carl Tart as Italiano Jones | | |
| Episode 770: She-Garbage People | 8/15/22 | Tatiana Maslany Paul F. Tompkins as Obi Ron Kenobi Caitlin Reilly as Lucy Bukater | | |
| Episode 771: Bean Time with Silversun Pickups | 8/22/22 | Silversun Pickups Will Hines as Keith Keith Matt Apodaca as Officer Marshal Sergeant Ele Woods as Maximo Tootie | | "Scared Together" by Silversun Pickups "Sticks and Stones" by Silversun Pickups "Lazy Eye" by Silversun Pickups |
| Episode 772: Half-Wonka/Half-Loompa | 8/29/22 | Bridger Winegar Paul F. Tompkins as The Pie Minister and Shimmy Lamar Woods as Dre Wonka | | |
| Episode 773: Olafer Only | 9/5/22 | Adam Scott Matt Besser as Olaf's Middle Part Monika Smith as Harvey the Truth Seeker Toni Charline as Martha the Medium | | |
| Episode 774: InFletchtion | 9/12/22 | Jon Hamm Lily Sullivan as Bridget Jones Devin Field as Steve Spinx | | |
| Episode 775: Operation Double Decoy | 9/19/22 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston Paul F. Tompkins as The Griz | | |
| Episode 776: Live from The Paramount Theatre, Austin TX 08/06/2022 | 9/22/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger Carl Tart as MC Sugar Butt Dan Lippert as Todd Padre | | |
| Episode 777: Postal Opposites | 9/26/22 | Rachel Bloom James Mannion as Chris Orchard Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe | | |
| Episode 778: Celebrity Auction List | 10/3/22 | Dan Wilson Paul Rust as Cecil Sotheby Christine Bullen as Myrtle McGee Charlie McCrackin as Cordwood Pete Bunyan | | "Dancing on the Moon" by Dan Wilson "Closing Time" by Dan Wilson |
| Episode 779: He Did It His Way | 10/10/22 | Kyle Bornheimer Dan Lippert as Lloyd Garterbelt Erin Keif as Matilda Gravyman | | |
| Episode 780: Bong Hugs | 10/17/22 | Sharon Horgan Paul F. Tompkins as Original Fig Casey Feigh as Weed Seinfeld | | |
| Episode 781: Ump-and-coming Umps | 10/24/22 | Kevin Nealon Ryan Rosenberg as Donald Ump Dave Theune as Robby Delmuda | | |
| Episode 782: Unique Stuff | 10/31/22 | Kurt Braunohler Mike Hanford as John Lennon Jacob Wysocki as COOTER the supercomputer Nick Wiger as Leo Carpazzi | | |
| Episode 783: YouTube Review | 11/7/22 | Natalie Morales Jillian Bell Griffin Newman as CJTETHEMAN9888_UNLIMITED and Calvin Ward Christine Bullen as Piper Adoggy | | |
| Episode 784: The Princess Sprite | 11/14/22 | Nick Kroll John Gemberling as Mutty Brickford Gil Ozeri as Ned Belanela | | |
| Episode 785: Buzzyear Headlines | 11/21/22 | Jason Mantzoukas Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Erin Whitehead as Stacy Buzzaba Paul F. Tompkins as Shimmy and Jarles | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 786: Ford Rock Hard Eve | 11/28/22 | Max Silvestri Tim Baltz as Harry Footman Lily Sullivan as Kayla Dickie | | |
| Episode 787: Nature, Nurture, Nietzche | 12/5/22 | Kristian Bruun Paul F. Tompkins as Major Bob Driver and Shimmy Matt Gourley as Teen Giger Lisa Gilroy as Peonis Pilates | | "Christmas on the Rocks" by Townland |
| Episode 788: 2022 Holiday Spectacular | 12/12/22 | Paul F. Tompkins as Obi Ron Kenobi Shaun Diston as McGruff the Crime Dog Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Carl Tart as Charles Barkley Jessica McKenna as Harry Styles Will Hines as Henry Vic Michaelis as Susie Tewman Lisa Gilroy as Dickie Donnelly Gil Ozeri as Dr. Sweetchat | | |
| Best of 2022 Part 1 | 12/19/22 | Paul F. Tompkins | 17. Bridget Jones’ Diarrhea (Episode 774: InFletchtion) 16. Help Me, Obi-Ron (Episode 770: She-Garbage People) 15. The Return of Bob Ducca (Episode 785: Buzzyear Headlines) 14. Baba Booey (Episode 746: James Bond Dolls for Sale) 13. Holiday Madness! (Episode 737: 2021 Holiday Spectacular) | |
| Best of 2022 Part 2 | 12/22/22 | Paul F. Tompkins | 12. The Baxter FKA Decker Triplets Pig Wrestling And Caramel Country Maaaart (Episode 735: The Calvins Triplets vs. The Baxter Triplets) 11. Carmine's Memory (Episode 767: Fourdom) BONUS CLIP: Jack Can't Talk Today (Episode 763: Star Toon Cartoon) 10. Vigilantes & Bullies (Episode 765: Pirate Ship Energy) 9. One Of The Great Anniversaries! (Episode 755: The 13th Anniversary Show!) | |
| Best of 2022 Part 3 | 12/26/22 | Paul F. Tompkins | 8. A Pastor, An MC, & An Australian Actress (Episode 739: Oi Noi, BB Bridgers!) 7. The Peanut Prototype (Episode 758: Previous Partons) 6. The Busiest Man In The World (Episode 784: The Princess Sprite) 5. Denniston Vs. Griz II (Episode 750: The Pool Duel-Over: Part Duel) | |
| Best of 2022 Part 4 | 12/29/22 | Paul F. Tompkins | 4. The Zerg & Noryb (Episode 775: Operation Double Decoy) 3. The Tapes Of Gabriel Sardinas (Episode 759: Hot Sauce Reunion) 2. Stay Away From Their Granddaughter (Episode 752: Wet Day Special) 1. Dr. Sweetchat, The Small Talk Robot (Episode 738: Three Doctors... Oh No) | |

### 2023

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments | Featured songs |
| Episode 789: Oh My God, Becky | 1/2/23 | Ben Schwartz as himself and Yohan Breitbark Drew Tarver as Henry Heimlich Mary Holland as Barb Nuts | | |
| Episode 790: Mannequin Skywalker | 1/9/23 | Allison Williams Dan Lippert as Bill Walton Erin Keif as Macy Hannigan | | |
| Episode 791: She Splashy She Splishy Cruise Ship | 1/16/23 | Jason Woliner Lily Sullivan as Chippy Dipps Will Hines as Bill Smither Casey Feigh as Joey Salsa | | |
| Episode 792: Murder Was Wrote | 1/23/23 | Paul F. Tompkins as Ted Newguy Ego Nwodim as Stormy Kirkland and Fred Matt Apodaca as Ricky Johnson and Maya Newguy | | |
| Episode 793: Coca-Cola Loaded | 1/30/23 | Reggie Watts Vic Michaelis as Oopsie Spider-Man Dave Theune as Tam Pasture | | |
| Episode 794: Sloppy Firsts | 2/6/23 | Dan Mangan Lauren Lapkus as Cabin Fevver Ryan Rosenberg as Dr. Crack | Games: Would You Rather? | "Just Know It" by Dan Mangan "All Roads" by Dan Mangan "Fire Escape" by Dan Mangan |
| Episode 795: Dr. Skeleton's Celebrity Toilet | 2/13/23 | John Hodgman Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett Lisa Gilroy as Elvis Presley | | |
| Episode 796: Hans's Opus | 2/20/23 | Zach Galifianakis Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Andy Daly as August Lindt | Games: Would You Rather? | |
| Episode 797: Hold for Room Tone | 2/27/23 | Jason Alexander Peter Tilden Shaun Diston as Tony Nails Jessica McKenna as Filomena Trappp | | |
| Episode 798: Hostage Forecast | 3/1/23 | David Cross James Mannion as Ryan Headboard Holly Laurent as Sherry Pie Greg Hess as Jim Bolt | | |
| Episode 799: Bruba Go Do | 3/6/23 | Nick Kroll Ike Barinholtz Mitra Jouhari as Andi Gil Ozeri as Ned Belanela | | |
| Episode 800: Operation Golden Orb | 3/13/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston and Hot Dog Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber, The Griz, and Shimmy | | |
| Episode 801: WiFi For A Wife Guy | 3/20/23 | Andy Samberg Neil Campbell as Himself and Dirty Dog Lily Sullivan as Sister Margaret | | |
| Episode 802: Crown Prince of Slime | 3/27/23 | Jay Pharoah Bobby Moynihan as Batman Tim Baltz as Darren Matichek | | |
| Episode 803: John Wick: My Eyes Are Up Here | 4/3/23 | David Wain Katie Rich as Leia Hannah Pilkes as Susan Christmas | | |
| Episode 804: Wet Day Special 2023 | 4/10/23 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Spike Minksalmon Drew Tarver as Ike Minksalmon Ryan Gaul as Pudge | | |
| Episode 805: Wet Work Nurse | 4/17/23 | Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Dave Theune as Robby Delmuda Ben Rodgers as Ernest Taylor | | |
| Episode 806: Swiwwy Boys with Aunty Donna | 4/20/23 | Broden Kelly as himself and Australian Dad on a Holiday Zachary Ruane as himself and Jimmy/A Slice of Lime Mark Bonanno as himself and Silly Boy | | |
| Episode 807: Live at Largo | 4/24/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Drew L. Barrymore Andy Daly as Dalton Wilcox Carl Tart as The Chief Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese Gil Ozeri as Dr. Sweetchat | | |
| Episode 808: Live at the Bell House #1 | 4/26/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Adam Scott Paul F. Tompkins as Big Chunky Bubbles Mike Hanford as John Lennon Griffin Newman as Silver Screen Sammy | | |
| Episode 809: Live at the Bell House #2 | 4/28/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Cal Solomon Ego Nwodim as Pastor Pasta Connor Ratliff as Mr. Books | | |
| Episode 810: The 14th Anniversary Show! | 5/1/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Hot Dog Paul F. Tompkins as Fred Guinness and Shimmy Jessica McKenna as Dagmar the Small Shaun Diston as Rudi North Drew Tarver as Clam Lisa Gilroy as Pearl Lily Sullivan as Bicky Tim Baltz as Harry Footman Carl Tart as Snake Eyes and The Chief Will Hines as Anniversary Man the Demon Dan Lippert as Bill Walton | | |
| Episode 811: We Bought An Oil Rig | 5/8/23 | Dan Ahdoot Vic Michaelis as Taylor Stephanie Casey Feigh as Weed Foxworthy | | |
| Episode 812: Oops I Dropped This | 5/15/23 | Sean Clements Hayes Davenport Will Hines as Kenny Kicks Christine Bullen as Fifinella | | |
| Episode 813: Winkers and Blinkers | 5/22/23 | Jena Friedman Heather Anne Campbell as Grance Prebs Jacob Wysocki as Marty Motorcycle | | |
| Episode 814: The Institute | 5/29/23 | Sarah Silverman Suzi Barrett as Destiny Shaun Diston as Crenshaw | | |
| Episode 815: Fantom of the Phorest | 6/5/23 | Fortune Feimster Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber Matt Apodaca as Mr. Monster | | |
| Episode 816: Love, Bridge | 6/12/23 | Jack Quaid as himself and Dr. John Lily Sullivan as Bridget Jones Carl Tart as The Crypt Keeper, Italiano Jones and O.J. Simpson | | |
| Episode 817: Nostalgia Bombs | 6/19/23 | Nick Kroll John Gemberling as Korbato Krim Gil Ozeri as Yargo Lamento | | |
| Episode 818: Thumb No. 3, 4, 5 | 6/26/23 | Myq Kaplan Greg Hess as Glen Plapinger Erin Keif as Candle St. Louis | | |
| Episode 819: Man's Laughter In the First Degree | 7/3/23 | Paul F. Tompkins as Fred Guinness Lisa Gilroy as Kyle Chutney Neil Campbell as Noel | | |
| Episode 820: Limo Karaoke | 7/10/23 | Vera Drew Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Casey Feigh as Joey Salsa | | |
| Episode 821: Smooth Denim | 7/17/23 | Adam DeVine Ryan Rosenberg as Mr. Sing Ify Nwadiwe as Shadow Vision | | |
| Episode 822: Honey, I Shrunk Her | 7/24/23 | Anna Konkle Mitra Jouhari as Leila Christine Bullen as Myrtle McGee | | |
| Episode 823: Hand Friends with Manchester Orchestra | 7/31/23 | Andy Hull Robert McDowell Tawny Newsome as herself and Tierna Smarg Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Dave Theune as Mirk | | "Capital Karma" by Manchester Orchestra "The Way" by Manchester Orchestra |
| Episode 824: Toe Show | 8/7/23 | Mike Hanford as Chef Adjacent Mantzoukas James Austin Johnson as VAAMM Ele Woods as Young Miss Willow Panloose | | |
| Episode 825: Any Questions, Poindexter? | 8/14/23 | Ellie Kemper Matt Apodaca as Ronnie Little Jacob Wysocki as Gunk Little Hannah Pilkes as Brett | | |
| Episode 826: Viral Beatdown | 8/21/23 | Andy Richter Vic Michaelis as Susie Tewman Alex Fernie as Daniel Kolodjiez | | |
| Episode 827: Sea Witch Six | 8/28/23 | Paul F. Tompkins as Abernathy Combs Erin Whitehead as Ursula John Hartman as Ken Lunch | | |
| Episode 828: Conversation Referee | 9/4/23 | Jack Quaid as himself and Greg Tawny Newsome as herself and Brigadoon James Mannion as Robert Canasta | | |
| Episode 829: Love is Truck | 9/11/23 | Flula Borg Shaun Diston as Sprague the Whisperer Lily Sullivan as Kayla Dickie | | |
| Episode 830: Being Bi-Brainial | 9/18/23 | Gary Gulman Dan Lippert as Rick Rubin Dan O'Connor as Ian Chiswick | | |
| Episode 831: Hugs Between Friends | 9/25/23 | Aparna Nancherla Will Hines as Kurt Slammer Holly Laurent as Ruth Debevoise | | |
| Episode 832: Cockroach Hell | 10/2/23 | Paul F. Tompkins as Dolores Brainwater Mitra Jouhari as Casey Lisa Gilroy as Cockroach Rick | | |
| Episode 833: Abraham LinkedIn | 10/9/23 | Bob Odenkirk Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Tim Baltz as Tom Boreman Heather Anne Campbell as Telli Charcuterie | | |
| Episode 834: Mouse Mingle | 10/16/23 | Reggie Watts Matt Gourley as Cody Amanda Lund as Codi Katie Rich as Janet Holly Laurent as Leanne | | |
| Episode 835: Oh, Hell Maybe! | 10/23/23 | Sam Jay Gil Ozeri as Bane Greg Hess as Benny Sands | | |
| Episode 836: Twins by Blood | 10/30/23 | Felicia Day Betsy Sodaro as Selma Mano Agapion as Blair Devin Field as David Lynch | | |
| Episode 837: The Scrounger | 11/6/23 | Dan Wilson Paul Rust as AJ Zap Erin Keif as Criss Angel Casey Feigh as Donk Poop | | "You're Not Alone" by Dan Wilson "Little Bit of Sun" by Dan Wilson |
| Episode 838: Peter Pogdanovich | 11/13/23 | Edgar Wright Paul F. Tompkins as Brock Lovett Vic Michaelis as Quiet the Mime Matt Apodaca as Marcus Green | | |
| Episode 839: O.B.Have | 11/20/23 | Jon Hamm Drew Tarver as Jesse Ryan Gaul as Doug Gropes | | |
| Episode 840: Little Pepper Makes Four | 11/27/23 | Chelsea Peretti James Mannion as Micah Fellows Ben Rodgers as Uncle Jellyfish | | |
| Episode 841: Diagnosis What? | 12/4/23 | John Early Mitra Jouhari as Angelina Leviosa Amanda Lund as Marabel May | | |
| Episode 842: Two Straws and a Goldshlåger | 12/11/23 | Edi Patterson as Bean Dip and Deeana Bermuda Dave Theune as Robby Delmuda Jacob Wysocki as RJ Dudley and Jack UCLA Allison Dunbar as Rhonda Batuchi | | |
| Episode 843: 2023 Holiday Spectacular | 12/18/23 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Fred Guinness Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Lily Sullivan as Carissa Shaun Diston as Room Tone Tony Vic Michaelis as Terry Alamander Carl Tart as Shohei Ohtani Drew Tarver as Clam Lisa Gilroy as Pearl Dan Lippert as Dr. Marty Goldstein Gil Ozeri as Ned Belanela Will Hines as Harvey the Devil | | |
| Best of 2023 Part 1 | 12/25/23 | Paul F. Tompkins | 16. He Blew It. (Episode 839: O.B.Have) 15. Mythical Beings (Episode 787: Nature, Nurture, Nietzche) 14. Heimlich & Nuts (Episode 789: Oh My God, Becky) 13. Scott Needs Tech Support (Episode 796: Hans's Opus) | |
| Best of 2023 Part 2 | 12/28/23 | Paul F. Tompkins | 12. bark bark. (Episode 801: WiFi For A Wife Guy) 11. Quite The Mime, Ouah! (Episode 838: Peter Pogdanovich) 10. Remember This (Episode 817: Nostalgia Bombs) 9. Scott's Tension With Guests (Episode 788: 2022 Holiday Spectacular) | |

### 2024

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments |
| Best of 2023 Part 3 | 1/1/24 | Paul F. Tompkins | 8. Bridget Bones’ DIE-ary! (Episode 816: Love, Bridge) 7. “You Tried To Kill Me, Scott!” (Episode 832: Cockroach Hell) 6. Hot Dog, Guinness, and Pig Shit (Episode 810: The 14th Anniversary Show!) 5. Griz v. LAW (Episode 800: Operation Golden Orb) |
| Best of 2023 Part 4 | 1/4/24 | Paul F. Tompkins | 4. Boys Being Boys (Episode 819: Man's Laughter In the First Degree) 3. Shroomami (Episode 799: Bruba Go Do) 2. Avoidable Granddaughters & Missing Dogs (Episode 804: Wet Day Special 2023) 1. Little Baby Momma (Episode 795: Dr. Skeleton's Celebrity Toilet) |
| Episode 844: Full Stilts, Full Tilt | 1/8/24 | Ben Schwartz as himself, Sean Lantern-Phil, George Lucas, and Lucas Foster Mary Holland as Delia Totebag Eugene Cordero as Veronica | |
| Episode 845: So New York | 1/15/24 | Jake Johnson Paul F. Tompkins as Alimony Tony Lily Sullivan as Bridget Jones | |
| Episode 846: Doug Can Do It Too | 1/22/24 | Natasha Lyonne Jacqueline Novak Alex Fernie as Doug Sandy Honig as Jenny Power | |
| Episode 847: Benmont Bologna’s Meat Flavored Cologne | 1/25/24 | Adam Cayton-Holland Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Erin Keif as Matilda Gravyman Greg Hess as Benmont Bologna | |
| Episode 848: Raisin Kids | 1/29/24 | Zach Woods Lisa Gilroy as Margo Tits Charlie McCrackin as Mr. Gunlock | |
| Episode 849: One Capful, 14 Buckets | 2/5/24 | Moshe Kasher Carl Tart as The Pine-Sol Lady Vic Michaelis as Tinselina the Green Fairy | |
| Episode 850: The Exorcism of Hot Dog | 2/12/24 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as Byron Denniston, Hot Dog, August Lindt, Don DiMello, Dalton Wilcox, and Golly Paul F. Tompkins as Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber, Fred Guinness, The Griz, Greg Nicotero, Cal Solomon, Padre Davide Benvenuto, and Shimmy | |
| Episode 851: The Avatar Do-Si-Do | 2/19/24 | Todd Barry Jessica McKenna as Liz Feigh Casey Feigh as Bob Feigh Connor Ratliff as James Cameron Griffin Newman as Jake Sully | |
| Episode 852: The Paninis Press | 2/26/24 | Chris Gethard Lily Sullivan as Tony Sony Dan Lippert as Matthew Zimmerman Hannah Pilkes as Chutney C. Rabbits | |
| Episode 853: The Calvins Triplets Court Case | 3/4/24 | Jason Mantzoukas Taran Killam as Bever Hopox Paul Brittain as Chico Hands Ryan Gaul as Bisby St. Hancock | |
| Episode 854: Snip Snip Sanskrit | 3/11/24 | Haley Joel Osment Ryan Rosenberg as Mr. Body Holly Laurent as Day LaBont | |
| Episode 855: Crow Court | 3/18/24 | Jermaine Fowler Mike Hanford as John Lennon Ben Rodgers as Magnus Nootropic | |
| Episode 856: SHAZAM (Stephen Hawking As Zeus And Miss Piggy) | 3/25/24 | Jon Cryer Paul F. Tompkins as Al A. Peterson and Fred Guinness Lamar Woods as Carmine Backontour | |
| Episode 857: The CBB Roundtable | 4/1/24 | Ego Nwodim as Pastor Pasta Matt Apodaca as Albert Roe Payam Banifaz as Michael Police | |
| Episode 858: Kink or No Kink | 4/4/24 | Alex Edelman Christine Bullen as Misty Civic Matt Besser as Roger Matthews | |
| Episode 859: Wet Day Special 2024 | 4/8/24 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Brock Lovett Erin Whitehead as Ursula Ryan Gaul as Bernie Cutch | |
| Episode 860: The Letter D | 4/15/24 | Tatiana Maslany Edi Patterson as Bean Dip Carl Tart as Lothario Lewis | Games: Would You Rather? |
| Episode 861: KWFZZ: The Fuzz | 4/22/24 | Todd Glass Mike Hanford as Dominic Weiss Gil Ozeri as Mike Stacker | |
| Episode 862: Cloud Slam | 4/29/24 | Hannah Einbinder Bobby Moynihan as The Batmin Lisa Gilroy as God | |
| Episode 863: The 15th Anniversary Show! | 5/6/24 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Original Fig and Shimmy Andy Daly as Neptuna and August Lindt Lily Sullivan as Francesca Bolognese and Carissa Tim Baltz as Randy Snutz Shaun Diston as Jeffy McSaturday Vic Michaelis as Quiet the Mime Lisa Gilroy as Scott's Nana Will Hines as The Bronze Boogie Boarder | |
| Episode 864: Live at the Belasco | 5/13/24 | Lily Sullivan as Tony Sony Paul F. Tompkins as Fred Guinness Claudia O'Doherty Andy Daly as Chip Gardner Carl Tart as O.J. Simpson Tim Baltz as Harry Footman | |
| Episode 865: Night Night | 5/20/24 | Nikki Glaser Paul Scheer as Bartholomew Richard Fitzgerald-Smythe aka Mr. Peanut Hannah Pilkes as Chase Sapphire | |
| Episode 866: Buffalo Suede | 5/27/24 | Natasha Leggero Seth Morris as Bob Ducca Jacob Wysocki as The Executioner | |
| Episode 867: Dork Pranks | 6/3/24 | Jessica St. Clair as Marissa Wompler Devin Field as Ron Snapper Rekha Shankar as Becky Girardi | |
| Episode 868: Life Is An Opera | 6/10/24 | Greg Hess as Glen Plapinger Will Hines as Paul Dudley Caitlin Reilly as Leanne Lee | |
| Episode 869: Ganz Stan | 6/17/24 | Kathleen Madigan Charlie McCrackin as Detective Jack Cates James Mannion as Robert Canasta | |
| Episode 870: E.T. Bikini | 6/24/24 | Mike Hanford as John Lennon Vic Michaelis as Jack the Ripper Zeke Nicholson as Dr. Green | |
| Episode 871: Good Weddings | 7/1/24 | Poppy Liu Suzi Barrett as Donna Matt Apodaca as Ray Good | |
| Episode 872: Wolfarangs | 7/8/24 | Jack Quaid as himself and Janice Dickinson Tawny Newsome as herself and Escrow Philanthropa Ben Rodgers as Jack Furz | |
| Episode 873: You Bet Your Life Twice | 7/15/24 | Andy Richter Maria Blasucci as Brand Rollbrone Amanda Lund as Brock Palmesprings Jordan Morris as EPT Grizzly | |
| Episode 874: A Long Time Ago (Downton Abbey Time) | 7/22/24 | Tony Hale Paul F. Tompkins as Woolly Doorgosh Erin Keif as Shirley Macadamia | |
| Episode 875: Minnie Rifferton | 7/29/24 | Reggie Watts Jacob Wysocki as Mr. Toots Casey Feigh as Weed Seinfeld and Andrew Dice Weed | |
| Episode 876: The Bear Minimum | 8/5/24 | Alex Fernie as Robert Caro Lily Sullivan as The Bear Hannah Pilkes as Simone | |
| Episode 877: Impossiblood | 8/12/24 | Langston Kerman Will Hines as Alan Freeman Ronnie Adrian as Kilgorious Van Helsing | |
| Episode 878: Munich Style | 8/19/24 | Paul Feig Christine Bullen as Myrtle McGee Devin Field as Johnny Manicotti | |
| Episode 879: Side Duck | 8/26/24 | Haley Joel Osment Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Vic Michaelis as Ember Chuckit | |
| Episode 880: Rhythem Rhythwe | 9/2/24 | David Wain Dave Theune as Alex Rhythms Rekha Shankar as Barbara | |
| Episode 881: Two Longlegs Up | 9/9/24 | Kumail Nanjiani Taran Killam as Longlegs | Games: Would You Rather? |
| Episode 882: It's A.I. All Good | 9/16/24 | Matt Braunger Dan Lippert as Seth Berkowitz Carl Tart as The Pine-Sol Lady | |
| Episode 883: Goblin Con | 9/23/24 | Zac Oyama as Crunchkin the Goblin Erin Keif as Pip Whistle Will Hines as Billy Sly Car Guy | |
| Episode 884: The Littlest Wayne | 9/30/24 | Chuck Bryant Bobby Moynihan as The Batmin Holly Laurent as Luanne Lewis | |
| Episode 885: Badge Off | 10/7/24 | Max Silvestri Charlie McCrackin as Inspector Jack Cates Ryan Rosenberg as Big Mike | |
| Episode 886: Fyre Can Be Fun | 10/14/24 | Kristian Bruun Paul F. Tompkins as Bing Lujo Vic Michaelis as Hannah Burn | |
| Episode 887: Bidi Bidi Bugle Boy Bumbalee-Bee | 10/21/24 | Tatiana Maslany Kristian Bruun Paul F. Tompkins as Dr. Bill Blondie Vic Michaelis as Luzi Brockheimer | |
| Episode 888: Return to Suicide House: Dom Parasol | 10/28/24 | Jimmy Pardo Jon Daly as Buford LeBaron Ben Rodgers as Raven Maze Nick Wiger as Satanick Carpazzi | |
| Episode 889: Every Rock is Gray | 11/4/24 | Zach Reino as Branessa Whaleslay Lisa Gilroy as Rockly Mountainrock Jacquis Neal as Big Momma | |
| Episode 890: Old Money | 11/11/24 | James Acaster Lily Sullivan as Mrs. Lyndhurst Matt Apodaca as Ricky Johnson | |
| Episode 891: Pelican Briefcase | 11/18/24 | Jim O'Heir Paul Rust as Cecil Sotheby James Mannion as Chris Orchard | |
| Episode 892: Cloak of Brown | 11/25/24 | Mary Elizabeth Ellis Greg Hess as Glen Plapinger Madeline Walter as Stephen King | |
| Episode 893: No Tuxedos | 12/2/24 | Kyle Mooney as himself and Ian Vanchuri Will Hines as Bags MK.gee | |
| Episode 894: Train Perverts | 12/9/24 | Mekki Leeper Jon Gabrus as Gino Lombardo Erin Keif as The Little Engine That Might Dave Theune as Robby Delmuda | |
| Episode 895: 2024 Holiday Spectacular | 12/16/24 | Jason Mantzoukas Paul F. Tompkins as Hoover Personae Lauren Lapkus as Ho Ho the Elf Lily Sullivan as Tony Sony Shaun Diston as Tony Nails Vic Michaelis as Terry Alamander Dan Lippert as Papa Mia Jessica McKenna as Elsbeth Connors Will Hines as Glen Gil Ozeri as DeLuca's Chophouse | |
| Episode 896: Solo Bolo Ho Ho Holo | 12/19/24 | Ben Schwartz | Games: Solo Bolo Olympic Song Challenge |
| Best of 2024 Part 1 | 12/23/24 | Paul F. Tompkins | 14. A Nite-Wolf In Love (Episode 872: Wolfarangs) 13. Don’t Step Where Your Cat Done Shit (Episode 860: The Letter D) 12. Tits & Gunlock (Episode 848: Raisin Kids) 11. The Monster Fuck Part 10: The End (Episode 888: Return to Suicide House: Dom Parasol) |
| Best of 2024 Part 2 | 12/26/24 | Paul F. Tompkins | 10. Ember Knows Dash For Sure! (Episode 879: Side Duck) 9. The Music Man Saga Begins (Episode 886: Fyre Can Be Fun) 8. The Movie's Based On His Life (Episode 881: Two Longlegs Up) 7. Reasons For The Season (Episode 859: Wet Day Special 2024) |
| Best of 2024 Part 3 | 12/30/24 | Paul F. Tompkins | 6. Records, Gifts, Twins, & Calls (Episode 843: 2023 Holiday Spectacular) 5. Trial Flashbacks (Episode 853: The Calvins Triplets Court Case) 4. The Music Man Saga Continues (Episode 887: Bidi Bidi Bugle Boy Bumbalee-bee) |

### 2025

| Episode number | Date | Guests | Synopsis and segments |
| Best of 2024 Part 4 | 1/2/25 | Paul F. Tompkins | 3. Fig & Neptuna (Episode 863: The 15th Anniversary Show!) 2. Tony SoNY (Episode 845: So New York) 1. Dread Zeppelin (Episode 850: The Exorcism of Hot Dog) |
| Episode 897: I Understand | 1/6/25 | Ben Schwartz Bobby Moynihan as Slow Pesci Ryan Gaul as Darryl Day | |
| Episode 898: Everything's a Hot Dog | 1/13/25 | Stephanie Hsu Zosia Mamet Heather Anne Campbell as Alexa Melrose Casey Feigh as Joey Salsa | |
| Episode 899: CBB Presents: The Music Man Watchalong | 1/20/25 | Paul F. Tompkins as Bing Lujo and Dr. Bill Blondie | |
| Episode 900: What's Up Cool Cat? | 1/27/25 | Jason Mantzoukas Andy Daly as August Lindt, Hot Dog, Cool Cat, and Phil Collins Paul F. Tompkins as Mason I. Clodge, Ernie Rocks, Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber, Shimmy, Lillian Clodge, Food Court Bailiff, and Studio Bailiff | |
| Episode 901: Shout Out Shaboozey | 2/3/25 | Mo Welch Carl Tart as Coach Prime Greg Hess as James "Juvenille Booterie" Armentrout | |
| Episode 902: Gelsons Ganz | 2/10/25 | Zach Galifianakis Charlie McCrackin as Jack Cates Lisa Gilroy as Shrunkenhead Babywitch, IQ Lady, and Megan Ganz | |
| Episode 903: That is All | 2/17/25 | John Hodgman Connor Ratliff as James Cameron Griffin Newman as Jake Sully Patty Guggenheim as Kitty Sea-Joy Sage | |
| Episode 904: Dr. Hospital, MD: Syringe | 2/24/25 | Ike Barinholtz Drew Tarver as Henry Heimlich Erin Keif as Louie Pantano | |
| Episode 905: Crumpet Rat | 3/3/25 | Ione Skye Alex Fernie as Travis Skin Rekha Shankar as Doctor Scrumptious | |
| Episode 906: More Cushion for the Pushin' | 3/10/25 | Paul F. Tompkins as himself and Ben Jammin Will Hines as Guy Foreman | |
| Episode 907: Nasty Boys | 3/17/25 | Asif Ali Lily Sullivan as Miss Lacy Dan Lippert as Russ Saguaro | |

## Reception

"Often strange, consistently hilarious, always unpredictable." – Entertainment Weekly
"One of the 10 Best Comedy Podcasts Of The Moment...never strays far from a laugh." – Rolling Stone
GQ has praised the show, calling it in 2010 "one of the preeminent places to hear not only the stalwarts of stand-up... but also lesser known comics, like Natasha Leggero, Chelsea Peretti, and Brett Gelman."
The A.V. Club says "The guests are routinely top-notch, the show has a de facto company of ace improvisers enlivening each episode, and Scott Aukerman is a gleefully indulgent host", also saying "For comedy fans, Comedy Bang Bang is essential listening." It frequently appears in the Podmass column, highlighting the best podcasts of each week, and the website named Comedy Bang! Bang! the best podcast of 2013.
"It's perhaps the easiest show to single out as a juggernaut; the podcast is ten years in with over 600 episodes, a testament to creator Scott Aukerman's unparalleled collaboration prowess." — Vulture
The show won in the Comedy category at the 2015 and 2017 Academy of Podcasters Awards.