# 2012 Middlesbrough by-election

On 29 November 2012, a by-election was held for the UK House of Commons constituency of Middlesbrough. The by-election was caused by the death of its Member of Parliament, Sir Stuart Bell. It was held on the same day as by-elections in Croydon North and Rotherham.
The deadline for nominations was 14 November. The election returned a Labour member of parliament, with UKIP second and the Liberal Democrats third.

## Candidates

Labour selected Andy McDonald, a solicitor born in Middlesbrough and former councillor for Westbourne ward from 1995 to 1999, for the seat. At the time, McDonald was chairman of Middlesbrough Labour Party Local Government Committee.
UKIP selected Richard Elvin, chairman of the North East Regional Committee, as their candidate. He contested the Houghton and Sunderland South seat for UKIP in 2010.
The Liberal Democrats selected George Selmer, who works in employment services, as their candidate.
Stockton borough Councillor Ben Houchen was the Conservative candidate. He would later go on to become Tees Valley Mayor.
In November 2012, Councillor Imdad Hussain, who had been suspended from the Labour Party for two years after failing to disclose he had been banned as a company director, resigned from the party and announced he would be standing for the Peace Party in the by-election.
Campaigner Mark Heslehurst launched his candidacy as a self-styled 'independent Labour' candidate. He had no description on the ballot paper. He had previously organised events to raise awareness of an issue related to his estranged partner and son, which involved walking 500 miles to Downing Street.
The BNP candidate was Peter Foreman.
Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition candidate John Malcolm was the Tees, Esk & Wear Valley Health Unison branch representative.
Current independent Middlesbrough mayor Ray Mallon mooted the possibility of standing in the by-election, depending on the quality of other candidates, but did not submit his candidacy.

## Hustings

Hustings were held at St Barnabas' Church on 26 November 2012, hosted by Friends of the Earth. The lively proceedings went well, with members of the audience asking over 20 questions on topics ranging from education and services to employment and the environment. Six of the eight candidates were invited.

## Result

The Labour Party held the seat, with McDonald elected as the new MP. Along with other by-elections held on the same day, there were sharp declines in the vote for the governing coalition parties, although this was the only one of the three at which they both retained their deposit, and the only one at which the Liberal Democrats finished ahead of the Conservatives. UKIP finished in second place. Previously they had only come second in one other parliamentary election (the Barnsley Central by-election in 2011). They also came second in the Rotherham contest held on the same date as the Middlesbrough election.
The result was also notable as the first time the Peace Party had ever retained their deposit at a parliamentary election and their highest percentage of vote share in a single constituency.
| Election | Political result | Candidate | Party | Votes | % | ±% |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Andy McDonald | Labour | 10,201 | 60.5 | +14.6 |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Richard Elvin | UKIP | 1,990 | 11.8 | +8.1 |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | George Selmer | Liberal Democrats | 1,672 | 9.9 | −10.0 |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Ben Houchen | Conservative | 1,063 | 6.3 | −12.5 |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Imdad Hussain | Peace | 1,060 | 6.3 | New |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Peter Foreman | BNP | 328 | 1.9 | −3.9 |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | John Malcolm | TUSC | 277 | 1.6 | New |
| Middlesbrough by-election, 2012 Death of Sir Stuart Bell Turnout: 16,866 (25.91%) −25.5 | Labour hold Majority: 8,211 (47.7%) +21.7 Swing: 3.3% from UKIP to Lab | Mark Heslehurst | no description | 275 | 1.6 | New |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | Stuart Bell | Labour | 15,351 | 45.9 | −11.7 |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | Chris Foote-Wood | Liberal Democrats | 6,662 | 19.9 | +1.2 |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | John Walsh | Conservative | 6,283 | 18.8 | +2.3 |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | Joan McTigue | Independent | 1,969 | 5.9 | +5.9 |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | Michael Ferguson | BNP | 1,954 | 5.8 | +3.3 |
| General Election 2010 Turnout: 33,455 (51.4%) +2.7 | Labour hold Majority: 8,689 (26.0%) Swing: 6.4% from Lab to Lib Dem | Robert Parker | UKIP | 1,236 | 3.7 | +1.3 |