# List of All Stars Awards winners (hurling)

This is a list of all the past winners of the official GAA GPA All Stars Awards in hurling since the first awards in 1971. As an insight to the prominent players of the 1960s, it also includes the unofficial "Cuchulainn" awards presented from 1963 to 1967 under the auspices of Gaelic Weekly magazine.
Since 1971, the All Ordinaries Awards in hurling have been presented annually to a set of fifteen hurlers from that year's All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship, who are seen to be deserving of being named in a "Team of the Year". The shortlist is compiled by a selection committee steering group, while the overall winners are chosen by inter-county players themselves. The All Star is regarded by players as the highest individual award available to them, due to it being picked by their peers.
Limerick hold the record for most All-Star winners in one year with 12 players chosen in the hurling selection for 2021.

## Key

Positions :
| GK | Goalkeeper |
| RCB | Right corner-back |
| FB | Full-back |
| LCB | Left corner-back |
| RWB | Right wing-back |
| CB | Centre-back |
| LWB | Left wing-back |
| MD | Midfield |
| MD | Midfield |
| RWF | Right wing-forward |
| CF | Centre-forward |
| LWF | Left wing-forward |
| RCF | Right corner-forward |
| FF | Full-forward |
| LCF | Left corner-forward |
Key :
| Symbol | Meaning |
| | Had previously appeared on an All-Stars team |
| Pos. | Position |

## Cú Chulainn Awards
### 1963

| Pos. | Player | Winner | Team |
| GK | Ollie Walsh | 1 | Kilkenny |
| RCB | Tom Neville | 1 | Wexford |
| FB | Austin Flynn | 1 | Waterford |
| LCB | John Doyle | 1 | Tipperary |
| RWB | Séamus Cleere | 1 | Kilkenny |
| CB | Billy Rackard | 1 | Wexford |
| LWB | Larry Guinan | 1 | Waterford |
| MD | Theo English | 1 | Tipperary |
| MD | Des Foley | 1 | Dublin |
| RWF | Jimmy Doyle | 1 | Tipperary |
| CF | Mick Flannelly | 1 | Waterford |
| LWF | Eddie Keher | 1 | Kilkenny |
| RCF | Liam Devaney | 1 | Tipperary |
| FF | Jimmy Smyth | 1 | Clare |
| LCF | Phil Grimes | 1 | Waterford |

### 1964

| Pos. | Player | Winner | Team |
| GK | Ollie Walsh | 2 | Kilkenny |
| RCB | John Doyle | 2 | Tipperary |
| FB | Pa Dillon | 1 | Kilkenny |
| LCB | Tom Neville | 2 | Wexford |
| RWB | Séamus Cleere | 2 | Kilkenny |
| CB | Tony Wall | 1 | Tipperary |
| LWB | Pat Henderson | 1 | Kilkenny |
| MD | Mick Roche | 1 | Tipperary |
| MD | Paddy Moran | 1 | Kilkenny |
| RWF | Jimmy Doyle | 2 | Tipperary |
| CF | Michael 'Babs' Keating | 1 | Tipperary |
| LWF | Eddie Keher | 2 | Kilkenny |
| RCF | Tom Walsh | 1 | Kilkenny |
| FF | John McKenna | 1 | Tipperary |
| LCF | Donie Nealon | 1 | Tipperary |

### 1965

| Pos. | Player | Winner | Team |
| GK | John O'Donoghue | 1 | Tipperary |
| RCB | Tom Neville | 3 | Wexford |
| FB | Austin Flynn | 2 | Waterford |
| LCB | Kieran Carey | 1 | Tipperary |
| RWB | Denis O'Riordan | 1 | Cork |
| CB | Tony Wall | 2 | Tipperary |
| LWB | Jimmy Duggan | 1 | Galway |
| MD | Phil Wilson | 1 | Wexford |
| MD | Mick Roche | 2 | Tipperary |
| RWF | Jimmy Doyle | 3 | Tipperary |
| CF | Pat Carroll | 1 | Kilkenny |
| LWF | Pat Cronin | 1 | Clare |
| RCF | Donie Nealon | 2 | Tipperary |
| FF | John McKenna | 2 | Tipperary |
| LCF | Seán McLoughlin | 1 | Tipperary |

### 1966

| Pos. | Player | Winner | Team |
| GK | Paddy Barry | 1 | Cork |
| RCB | Pat Henderson | 2 | Kilkenny |
| FB | Austin Flynn | 3 | Waterford |
| LCB | Denis Murphy | 1 | Cork |
| RWB | Séamus Cleere | 3 | Kilkenny |
| CB | Kevin Long | 1 | Limerick |
| LWB | Martin Coogan | 1 | Kilkenny |
| MD | Bernie Hartigan | 1 | Limerick |
| MD | Theo English | 2 | Tipperary |
| RWF | Seánie Barry | 1 | Cork |
| CF | Eddie Keher | 3 | Kilkenny |
| LWF | Pat Cronin | 2 | Clare |
| RCF | Paddy Molloy | 1 | Offaly |
| FF | John McKenna | 3 | Tipperary |
| LCF | Mattie Fox | 1 | Galway |

### 1967

| Pos. | Player | Winner | Team |
| GK | Ollie Walsh | 3 | Kilkenny |
| RCB | Pat Henderson | 3 | Kilkenny |
| FB | Pa Dillon | 2 | Kilkenny |
| LCB | Jim Treacy | 1 | Kilkenny |
| RWB | Séamus Cleere | 4 | Kilkenny |
| CB | Jim Cullinan | 1 | Clare |
| LWB | Len Gaynor | 1 | Tipperary |
| MD | Mick Roche | 3 | Tipperary |
| MD | Paddy Moran | 2 | Kilkenny |
| RWF | Eddie Keher | 4 | Kilkenny |
| CF | Tony Wall | 3 | Tipperary |
| LWF | Pat Cronin | 3 | Clare |
| RCF | Donie Nealon | 3 | Tipperary |
| FF | Tony Doran | 1 | Wexford |
| LCF | Michael 'Babs' Keating | 2 | Tipperary |

## All Star awards listed by year 1970s
### 1971

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances | Rationale |
| GK | Damien Martin | Offaly | 1 | "For maintaining his very high level of brilliance in a position that invariably produced more than a few top class performances in any one year." |
| RCB | Tony Maher | Cork | 1 | "For his dependability. His unobtrusive but completely effective work in defence has always been the great quality of his hurling, particularly so this year." |
| FB | Pat Hartigan | Limerick | 1 | "For his contribution as one of the mainstays of Limerick's resurgence in 1971. At full back he showed unyielding stubbornness under the heaviest of pressure." |
| LCB | Jim Treacy | Kilkenny | 1 | "For maintaining his position as the outstanding left corner back in the country, for his sportsmanship and calm play in every situation." |
| RWB | Tadhg O'Connor | Tipperary | 1 | "For captaining Tipperary in their recapture of the All-Ireland championship. His qualities of leadership and great-hearted spirit were repeatedly in evidence throughout the season." |
| CB | Mick Roche | Tipperary | 1 | "For his memorable performances as one of the hurling perfectionists of his era, his true brilliance comes to the surface when the competition is at its hottest." |
| LWB | Martin Coogan | Kilkenny | 1 | "For bringing his judgement and experience out of retirement in 1971. His steadying influence was a major reason for the return of the Leinster title to Kilkenny." |
| MD | John Connolly | Galway | 1 | "For the admirable hurling style exemplified in his play. His crisp, deft striking of the ball was one but one of his many splendid skills." |
| MD | Frank Cummins | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his considerable role in recapturing the Leinster title for Kilkenny and Cork championship for Blackrock. All the promise of his early hurling years blossomed in 1971." |
| RWF | Francis Loughnane | Tipperary | 1 | "For his quick incisive forward play. His scoring ability was one of the factors enabling his County to become All-Ireland champions in 1971." |
| CF | Michael 'Babs' Keating | Tipperary | 1 | "For his exemplary performance in recovering his County team place and then becoming the inspiration of his team's many fine achievements during the year." |
| LWF | Eddie Keher | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his consummate artistry, the poise and grace he brings to his chosen sport. For a decade his play has delighted thousands of lovers of the game." |
| RCF | Mick Bermingham | Dublin | 1 | "For his stalwart contribution to the Dublin attack during the season. His skill, earnestness and unflagging enthusiasm made him the country's leading scorer in 1971." |
| FF | Ray Cummins | Cork | 1 | "For introducing a new degree of subtlety into full-forward play. His perfect coordination and the wide variety of his attacking play continually setting up scores." |
| LCF | Éamonn Cregan | Limerick | 1 | "For his speed, elusiveness and powerful shot which unite to make him one of the most successful score-getters of modern times. His effectiveness was strikingly emphasised during 1971." |

### 1972

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances | Rationale |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 1 | "For loyalty and devotion to his native county: for truly magnificent goalkeeping as he led Kilkenny to their 18th Championship." |
| RCB | Tony Maher | Cork | 2 | "For the courage he showed in overcoming injury and returning to demonstrate that his outstanding defensive qualities had not been diminished." |
| FB | Pat Hartigan | Limerick | 2 | "For consummate skill as a ball player: for consistency as a dependable defender even when fortune turned against his county." |
| LCB | Jim Treacy | Kilkenny | 2 | "For stubbornness and dependability under the sternest pressure and for proving yet again that he is the outstanding left corner back in the country." |
| RWB | Pat Lawlor | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his alertness and mobility in defence. His defensive ability contributing so much to his county's success in 1972." |
| CB | Mick Jacob | Wexford | 1 | "For his sparkling hurling style, his intelligent understanding of the game and his refusal to give up in the most difficult of situations." |
| LWB | Con Roche | Cork | 1 | "For the intensity of purpose and absolute determination which makes him an unshakeable defender: for his classic striking of the ball." |
| MD | Frank Cummins | Kilkenny | 2 | "For the self-assurance and poise which makes him a midfielder of highest stature: for another year of power in the middle for Kilkenny." |
| MD | Denis Coughlan | Cork | 1 | "For his hard work and devotion to the game and his county and for his dexterity and elegance in his play." |
| RWF | Francis Loughnane | Tipperary | 2 | "For his spirit and accuracy in attack and for the incisive forward play that always makes him a danger near the goal." |
| CF | Pat Delaney | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his straight-forward hard play which always commands the highest respect from the opposing defence." |
| LWF | Eddie Keher | Kilkenny | 2 | "For continuing to be the peerless marksman in the game from play and from frees: for his shrewd and brilliant use of the ball." |
| RCF | Charlie McCarthy | Cork | 1 | "For his great speed and sheer accuracy which gives him opportunities to score from the most unlikely situation." |
| FF | Ray Cummins | Cork | 2 | "For the supremely high standard he continues to set for full-forward play: for his utter unselfishness in bringing his team-mates into the game." |
| LCF | Éamonn Cregan | Limerick | 2 | "For his solo-running in attack which can split a defence: for his adaptability in other positions out the field." |

### 1973

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances | Rationale |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 2 | "For his courageous defiance, his agility and trustworthiness making him the kind of goalkeeper that any player would be happy to have behind him." |
| RCB | Phil "Fan" Larkin | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his dependability in defence, which combines with his natural hurling skill to establish him as one of the great corner backs of today." |
| FB | Pat Hartigan | Limerick | 3 | "For his undiminished skill and dependability in a very demanding position where quite often brawn is substituted for hurling artistry." |
| LCB | Jim O'Brien | Limerick | 1 | "For his rare bravery and mobility: for the all-round splender of his contribution to Limerick's much-delayed return to championship honours." |
| RWB | Colm Doran | Wexford | 1 | "For his alertness and sense of judgement, for the crispness of his stroke which played such a sizeable part in regaining the National League title for his county." |
| CB | Pat Henderson | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his sheer skill and obstinacy in defence, his tenacious approach and the devotion he continues to give to the game." |
| LWB | Seán Foley | Limerick | 1 | "For the fervour he brings to all facets of hurling, and particularly for his dedicated half-back play which contributed so much to Limerick's 1973 successes." |
| MD | Liam O'Brien | Kilkenny | 1 | "For his artistic stick-work which he has demonstrated with increasing regularity, and for establishing himself as one of the most elegant and energetic midfielders of recent times." |
| MD | Richie Bennis | Limerick | 1 | "For the level-headedness he has so frequently shown in the tightest of situations and for his exceptionally high rate of scoring." |
| RWF | Francis Loughnane | Tipperary | 3 | "For his incisive intelligent running which so often splits opposing defences: for the remarkable consistency and accuracy of his marksmanship." |
| CF | Pat Delaney | Kilkenny | 2 | "For highlighting just how vigorous play can be totally fair, particularly during his famous attacks towards the opposing goal." |
| LWF | Éamonn Grimes | Limerick | 1 | "For his seemingly limitless energy and his desire to work all over the field: qualities which have made him a natural leader and a high scorer." |
| RCF | Martin Quigley | Wexford | 1 | "For the wide range of his playing skills, his constancy of purpose and his obvious versatility." |
| FF | Kieran Purcell | Kilkenny | 1 | "For the out-and-out hard work he puts into the game. For his power of striking and his adaptability in attack." |
| LCF | Eddie Keher | Kilkenny | 3 | "For his enormously successful scoring record, his fluency of stroke and his accurate passing which create so many chances for his team mates." |

### 1974

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RCB | Phil 'Fan' Larkin | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FB | Pat Hartigan | Limerick | 4 |
| LCB | John Horgan | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Ger Loughnane | Clare | 1 |
| CB | Pat Henderson | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWB | Con Roche | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Liam 'Chunky' O'Brien | Kilkenny | 2 |
| MD | John Galvin | Waterford | 1 |
| RWF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 1 |
| CF | Martin Quigley | Wexford | 2 |
| LWF | Mick Crotty | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | John Quigley | Wexford | 1 |
| FF | Kieran Purcell | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LCF | Eddie Keher | Kilkenny | 4 |

### 1975

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RCB | Niall McInerney | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Pat Hartigan | Limerick | 5 |
| LCB | Brian Cody | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWB | Tadhg O'Connor | Tipperary | 1 |
| CB | Seán Silke | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Iggy Clarke | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Liam 'Chunky' O'Brien | Kilkenny | 3 |
| MD | Gerald McCarthy | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Martin Quigley | Wexford | 3 |
| CF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 2 |
| LWF | Éamonn Grimes | Limerick | 2 |
| RCF | Mick Brennan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FF | Kieran Purcell | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LCF | Eddie Keher | Kilkenny | 5 |

### 1976

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 5 |
| RCB | Phil 'Fan' Larkin | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FB | Willie Murphy | Wexford | 1 |
| LCB | John McMahon | Clare | 1 |
| RWB | Joe McDonagh | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Mick Jacob | Wexford | 2 |
| LWB | Denis Coughlan | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Frank Burke | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Pat Moylan | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Mick Malone | Cork | 1 |
| CF | Martin Quigley | Wexford | 4 |
| LWF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| RCF | Mick Brennan | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FF | Tony Doran | Wexford | 1 |
| LCF | Seánie O'Leary | Cork | 1 |

### 1977

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Séamus Durack | Clare | 1 |
| RCB | John McMahon | Clare | 2 |
| FB | Martin O'Doherty | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | John Horgan | Cork | 2 |
| RWB | Ger Loughnane | Clare | 2 |
| CB | Mick Jacob | Wexford | 3 |
| LWB | Denis Coughlan | Cork | 3 |
| MD | Tom Cashman | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Mick Moroney | Clare | 1 |
| RWF | Christy Keogh | Wexford | 1 |
| CF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 2 |
| LWF | P. J. Molloy | Galway | 1 |
| RCF | Charlie McCarthy | Cork | 2 |
| FF | Ray Cummins | Cork | 3 |
| LCF | Seánie O'Leary | Cork | 2 |

### 1978

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Séamus Durack | Clare | 2 |
| RCB | Phil 'Fan' Larkin | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FB | Martin O'Doherty | Cork | 2 |
| LCB | John Horgan | Cork | 3 |
| RWB | Joe Hennessy | Kilkenny | 1 |
| CB | Ger Henderson | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWB | Denis Coughlan | Cork | 4 |
| MD | Tom Cashman | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Iggy Clarke | Galway | 2 |
| RWF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 3 |
| CF | Noel Casey | Clare | 1 |
| LWF | Colm Honan | Clare | 1 |
| RCF | Charlie McCarthy | Cork | 2 |
| FF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 3 |
| LCF | Tommy Butler | Tipperary | 1 |

### 1979

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Pat McLoughney | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCB | Brian Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Martin O'Doherty | Cork | 3 |
| LCB | Tadhg O'Connor | Tipperary | 3 |
| RWB | Dermot McCurtain | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Ger Henderson | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWB | Iggy Clarke | Galway | 3 |
| MD | John Connolly | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Joe Hennessy | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWF | John Callinan | Clare | 1 |
| CF | Frank Burke | Galway | 2 |
| LWF | Liam 'Chunky' O'Brien | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RCF | Mick Brennan | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 4 |
| LCF | Ned Buggy | Wexford | 1 |

## 1980s
### 1980

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Pat McLoughney | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCB | Niall McInerney | Galway | 2 |
| FB | Leonard Enright | Limerick | 1 |
| LCB | Jimmy Cooney | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Dermot McCurtain | Cork | 2 |
| CB | Sean Silke | Galway | 2 |
| LWB | Iggy Clarke | Galway | 4 |
| MD | Joachim Kelly | Offaly | 1 |
| MD | Mossie Walsh | Waterford | 1 |
| RWF | Joe Connolly | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Pat Horgan | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Pat Carroll | Offaly | 1 |
| RCF | Bernie Forde | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 5 |
| LCF | Éamonn Cregan | Limerick | 3 |

### 1981

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Séamus Durack | Clare | 3 |
| RCB | Brian Murphy | Cork | 2 |
| FB | Leonard Enright | Limerick | 2 |
| LCB | Jimmy Cooney | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Liam O'Donoghue | Limerick | 1 |
| CB | Seán Stack | Clare | 1 |
| LWB | Ger Coughlan | Offaly | 1 |
| MD | Steve Mahon | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Liam Currams | Offaly | 1 |
| RWF | John Callinan | Clare | 2 |
| CF | George O'Connor | Wexford | 1 |
| LWF | Mark Corrigan | Offaly | 1 |
| RCF | Pat Carroll | Offaly | 2 |
| FF | Joe McKenna | Limerick | 6 |
| LCF | Johnny Flaherty | Offaly | 1 |

### 1982

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 6 |
| RCB | John Galvin | Waterford | 2 |
| FB | Brian Cody | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LCB | Pat Fleury | Offaly | 1 |
| RWB | Aidan Fogarty | Offaly | 1 |
| CB | Ger Henderson | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LWB | Paddy Prendergast | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Tim Crowley | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Frank Cummins | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RWF | Tony O'Sullivan | Cork | 1 |
| CF | Pat Horgan | Cork | 2 |
| LWF | Richie Power | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Billy Fitzpatrick | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FF | Christy Heffernan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCF | Jim Greene | Waterford | 1 |

### 1983

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Noel Skehan | Kilkenny | 7 |
| RCB | John Henderson | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Leonard Enright | Limerick | 3 |
| LCB | Dick O'Hara | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWB | Joe Hennessy | Kilkenny | 2 |
| CB | Ger Henderson | Kilkenny | 4 |
| LWB | Tom Cashman | Cork | 3 |
| MD | John Fenton | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Frank Cummins | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RWF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Ger Fennelly | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWF | Noel Lane | Galway | 1 |
| RCF | Billy Fitzpatrick | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 4 |
| LCF | Liam Fennelly | Kilkenny | 1 |

### 1984

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ger Cunningham | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Paudie Fitzmaurice | Limerick | 1 |
| FB | Eugene Coughlan | Offaly | 1 |
| LCB | Pat Fleury | Offaly | 2 |
| RWB | Joe Hennessy | Kilkenny | 3 |
| CB | Johnny Crowley | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Dermot McCurtain | Cork | 3 |
| MD | John Fenton | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Joachim Kelly | Offaly | 2 |
| RWF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 2 |
| CF | Kieran Brennan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWF | Paddy Kelly | Limerick | 1 |
| RCF | Tomás Mulcahy | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Noel Lane | Galway | 2 |
| LCF | Seánie O'Leary | Cork | 3 |

### 1985

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ger Cunningham | Cork | 2 |
| RCB | Séamus Coen | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Eugene Coughlan | Offaly | 2 |
| LCB | Sylvie Linnane | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Pete Finnerty | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Pat Delaney | Offaly | 1 |
| LWB | Ger Coughlan | Offaly | 2 |
| MD | John Fenton | Cork | 3 |
| MD | Pat Critchley | Laois | 1 |
| RWF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 3 |
| CF | Brendan Lynskey | Galway | 1 |
| LWF | Joe Cooney | Galway | 1 |
| RCF | Pat Cleary | Offaly | 1 |
| FF | Pádraig Horan | Offaly | 1 |
| LCF | Liam Fennelly | Kilkenny | 2 |

### 1986

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ger Cunningham | Cork | 3 |
| RCB | Denis Mulcahy | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Conor Hayes | Galway | 1 |
| LCB | Sylvie Linnane | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Pete Finnerty | Galway | 2 |
| CB | Tony Keady | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Bobby Ryan | Tipperary | 1 |
| MD | John Fenton | Cork | 4 |
| MD | Richie Power | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWF | Tony O'Sullivan | Cork | 2 |
| CF | Tomás Mulcahy | Cork | 2 |
| LWF | Joe Cooney | Galway | 2 |
| RCF | David Kilcoyne | Westmeath | 1 |
| FF | Jimmy Barry-Murphy | Cork | 5 |
| LCF | Kevin Hennessy | Cork | 1 |

### 1987

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ken Hogan | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCB | Joe Hennessy | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FB | Conor Hayes | Galway | 2 |
| LCB | Ollie Kilkenny | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Pete Finnerty | Galway | 3 |
| CB | Ger Henderson | Kilkenny | 5 |
| LWB | John Conran | Wexford | 1 |
| MD | Steve Mahon | Galway | 1 |
| MD | John Fenton | Cork | 5 |
| RWF | Michael McGrath | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Joe Cooney | Galway | 3 |
| LWF | Aidan Ryan | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCF | Pat Fox | Tipperary | 1 |
| FF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 4 |
| LCF | Liam Fennelly | Kilkenny | 3 |

### 1988

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John Commins | Galway | 1 |
| RCB | Sylvie Linnane | Galway | 3 |
| FB | Conor Hayes | Galway | 3 |
| LCB | Martin Hanamy | Offaly | 1 |
| RWB | Pete Finnerty | Galway | 4 |
| CB | Tony Keady | Galway | 2 |
| LWB | Bobby Ryan | Tipperary | 2 |
| MD | Colm Bonnar | Tipperary | 1 |
| MD | George O'Connor | Wexford | 2 |
| RWF | Declan Ryan | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Ciaran Barr | Antrim | 1 |
| LWF | Martin Naughton | Galway | 1 |
| RCF | Michael McGrath | Galway | 2 |
| FF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 5 |
| LCF | Tony O'Sullivan | Cork | 3 |

### 1989

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | John Commins | Galway | 2 |
| RCB | Aidan Fogarty | Offaly | 2 |
| FB | Éamonn Cleary | Wexford | 1 |
| LCB | Dessie Donnelly | Antrim | 1 |
| RWB | Conal Bonnar | Tipperary | 1 |
| CB | Bobby Ryan | Tipperary | 3 |
| LWB | Seán Treacy | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Michael Coleman | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Declan Carr | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Éanna Ryan | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Joe Cooney | Galway | 4 |
| LWF | Olcan McFetridge | Antrim | 1 |
| RCF | Pat Fox | Tipperary | 2 |
| FF | Cormac Bonnar | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCF | Nicky English | Tipperary | 6 |

## 1990s
### 1990

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Ger Cunningham | Cork | 4 |
| RCB | John Considine | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Noel Sheehy | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Seán O'Gorman | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Pete Finnerty | Galway | 5 |
| CB | Jim Cashman | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Liam Dunne | Wexford | 1 |
| MD | Michael Coleman | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Johnny Pilkington | Offaly | 1 |
| RWF | Michael Cleary | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Joe Cooney | Galway | 5 |
| LWF | Tony O'Sullivan | Cork | 4 |
| RCF | Eamon Morrissey | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FF | Brian McMahon | Dublin | 1 |
| LCF | John Fitzgibbon | Cork | 1 |

### 1991

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Michael Walsh | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Delaney | Tipperary | 1 |
| FB | Noel Sheehy | Tipperary | 2 |
| LCB | Seán Treacy | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Conal Bonnar | Tipperary | 2 |
| CB | Jim Cashman | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | Cathal Casey | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Terence McNaughton | Antrim | 1 |
| MD | John Leahy | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Michael Cleary | Tipperary | 2 |
| CF | Gary Kirby | Limerick | 1 |
| LWF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Pat Fox | Tipperary | 3 |
| FF | Cormac Bonnar | Tipperary | 2 |
| LCF | John Fitzgibbon | Cork | 2 |

### 1992

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Tommy Quaid | Limerick | 1 |
| RCB | Brian Corcoran | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Pat Dwyer | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCB | Liam Simpson | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWB | Brian Whelahan | Offaly | 1 |
| CB | Ciarán Carey | Limerick | 1 |
| LWB | Willie O'Connor | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Michael Phelan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Seánie McCarthy | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Gerard McGrattan | Down | 1 |
| CF | John Power | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWF | Tony O'Sullivan | Cork | 5 |
| RCF | Michael Cleary | Tipperary | 3 |
| FF | Liam Fennelly | Kilkenny | 4 |
| LCF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 2 |

### 1993

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Michael Walsh | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCB | Eddie O'Connor | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Seán O'Gorman | Cork | 2 |
| LCB | Liam Simpson | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWB | Liam Dunne | Wexford | 2 |
| CB | Pat O'Neill | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWB | Pádraig Kelly | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Pat Malone | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Paul McKillen | Antrim | 1 |
| RWF | Martin Storey | Wexford | 1 |
| CF | John Power | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RCF | Michael Cleary | Tipperary | 4 |
| FF | Joe Rabbitte | Galway | 1 |
| LCF | Barry Egan | Cork | 1 |

### 1994

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Joe Quaid | Limerick | 1 |
| RCB | Anthony Daly | Clare | 1 |
| FB | Kevin Kinahan | Offaly | 1 |
| LCB | Martin Hanamy | Offaly | 1 |
| RWB | Dave Clarke | Limerick | 1 |
| CB | Hubert Rigney | Offaly | 1 |
| LWB | Kevin Martin | Offaly | 1 |
| MD | Mike Houlihan | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Ciarán Carey | Limerick | 2 |
| RWF | Johnny Dooley | Offaly | 1 |
| CF | Gary Kirby | Limerick | 2 |
| LWF | John Leahy | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCF | Billy Dooley | Offaly | 1 |
| FF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 4 |
| LCF | Damien Quigley | Limerick | 1 |

### 1995

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Davy Fitzgerald | Clare | 1 |
| RCB | Kevin Kinahan | Offaly | 2 |
| FB | Brian Lohan$^{HOTY}$ | Clare | 1 |
| LCB | Liam Doyle | Clare | 1 |
| RWB | Brian Whelahan | Offaly | 2 |
| CB | Seánie McMahon | Clare | 1 |
| LWB | Anthony Daly | Clare | 2 |
| MD | Michael Coleman | Galway | 2 |
| MD | Ollie Baker | Clare | 1 |
| RWF | Johnny Dooley | Offaly | 2 |
| CF | Gary Kirby | Limerick | 3 |
| LWF | Jamesie O'Connor | Clare | 1 |
| RCF | Billy Dooley | Offaly | 2 |
| FF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 5 |
| LCF | Ger O'Loughlin | Clare | 1 |

### 1996

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Joe Quaid | Limerick | 2 |
| RCB | Tom Helebert | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Brian Lohan | Clare | 2 |
| LCB | Larry O'Gorman | Wexford | 1 |
| RWB | Liam Dunne | Wexford | 3 |
| CB | Ciarán Carey | Limerick | 3 |
| LWB | Mark Foley$^{YHOTY}$ | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Adrian Fenlon | Wexford | 1 |
| MD | Mike Houlihan | Limerick | 2 |
| RWF | Rory McCarthy | Wexford | 1 |
| CF | Martin Storey$^{HOTY}$ | Wexford | 2 |
| LWF | Larry Murphy | Wexford | 1 |
| RCF | Liam Cahill | Tipperary | 1 |
| FF | Gary Kirby | Limerick | 4 |
| LCF | Tom Dempsey | Wexford | 1 |

### 1997

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Damien Fitzhenry | Wexford | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Shelly | Tipperary | 1 |
| FB | Brian Lohan | Clare | 3 |
| LCB | Willie O'Connor | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWB | Liam Doyle | Clare | 2 |
| CB | Seánie McMahon | Clare | 2 |
| LWB | Liam Keoghan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Colin Lynch | Clare | 1 |
| MD | Tommy Dunne | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Jamesie O'Connor | Clare | 2 |
| CF | Declan Ryan | Tipperary | 2 |
| LWF | John Leahy | Tipperary | 3 |
| RCF | Kevin Broderick | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Ger O'Loughlin | Clare | 2 |
| LCF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 6 |
List of nominees

### 1998

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen Byrne | Offaly | 1 |
| RCB | Willie O'Connor | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FB | Kevin Kinahan | Offaly | 3 |
| LCB | Martin Hanamy | Offaly | 3 |
| RWB | Anthony Daly | Clare | 3 |
| CB | Seánie McMahon | Clare | 3 |
| LWB | Kevin Martin | Offaly | 2 |
| MD | Tony Browne | Waterford | 1 |
| MD | Ollie Baker | Clare | 2 |
| RWF | Michael Duignan | Offaly | 1 |
| CF | Martin Storey | Wexford | 3 |
| LWF | Jamesie O'Connor | Clare | 3 |
| RCF | Joe Dooley | Offaly | 1 |
| FF | Brian Whelahan | Offaly | 3 |
| LCF | Charlie Carter | Kilkenny | 1 |
List of nominees

### 1999

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Dónal Óg Cusack | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Fergal Ryan | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Diarmuid O'Sullivan | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Frank Lohan | Clare | 1 |
| RWB | Brian Whelahan | Offaly | 4 |
| CB | Brian Corcoran | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | Peter Barry | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Andy Comerford | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Tommy Dunne | Tipperary | 2 |
| RWF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 7 |
| CF | John Troy | Offaly | 1 |
| LWF | Brian McEvoy | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Seánie McGrath | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Joe Deane | Cork | 1 |
| LCF | Niall Gilligan | Clare | 1 |
List of nominees

## 2000s
### 2000

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Cummins | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCB | Noel Hickey | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Diarmuid O'Sullivan | Cork | 2 |
| LCB | Willie O'Connor | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RWB | John Carroll | Tipperary | 1 |
| CB | Eamonn Kennedy | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWB | Peter Barry | Kilkenny | 2 |
| MD | Johnny Dooley | Offaly | 3 |
| MD | Andy Comerford | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWF | Denis Byrne | Kilkenny | 1 |
| CF | Joe Rabbitte | Galway | 2 |
| LWF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Charlie Carter | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 8 |
| LCF | Joe Deane | Cork | 2 |
List of nominees

### 2001

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Cummins | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCB | Darragh Ryan | Wexford | 1 |
| FB | Philip Maher | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Ollie Canning | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Eamonn Corcoran | Tipperary | 1 |
| CB | Liam Hodgins | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Mark Foley | Limerick | 2 |
| MD | Tommy Dunne | Tipperary | 3 |
| MD | Eddie Enright | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Mark O'Leary | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Jamesie O'Connor | Clare | 4 |
| LWF | Kevin Broderick | Galway | 2 |
| RCF | Charlie Carter | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FF | Eugene Cloonan | Galway | 1 |
| LCF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2002

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Davy Fitzgerald | Clare | 2 |
| RCB | Michael Kavanagh | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Brian Lohan | Clare | 4 |
| LCB | Philly Larkin | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWB | Fergal Hartley | Waterford | 1 |
| CB | Peter Barry | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LWB | Paul Kelly | Tipperary | 1 |
| MD | Colin Lynch | Clare | 2 |
| MD | Derek Lyng | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWF | Eoin Kelly | Waterford | 1 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWF | Ken McGrath | Waterford | 1 |
| RCF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 2 |
| FF | Martin Comerford | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCF | D. J. Carey | Kilkenny | 9 |
List of nominees

### 2003

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Cummins | Tipperary | 3 |
| RCB | Michael Kavanagh | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FB | Noel Hickey | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LCB | Ollie Canning | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Seán Óg Ó hAilpín | Cork | 1 |
| CB | Ronan Curran | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Derek Lyng | Kilkenny | 2 |
| MD | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWF | John Mullane | Waterford | 1 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LWF | Eddie Brennan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Setanta Ó hAilpín | Cork | 1 |
| FF | Martin Comerford | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LCF | Joe Deane | Cork | 3 |
List of nominees

### 2004

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Damien Fitzhenry | Wexford | 2 |
| RCB | Wayne Sherlock | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Diarmuid O'Sullivan | Cork | 3 |
| LCB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 2 |
| CB | Ronan Curran | Cork | 2 |
| LWB | Seán Óg Ó hAilpín | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Ken McGrath | Waterford | 2 |
| MD | Jerry O'Connor | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Dan Shanahan | Waterford | 1 |
| CF | Niall McCarthy | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RCF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 3 |
| FF | Brian Corcoran | Cork | 3 |
| LCF | Paul Flynn | Waterford | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2005

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Davy Fitzgerald | Clare | 3 |
| RCB | Pat Mulcahy | Cork | 1 |
| FB | Diarmuid O'Sullivan | Cork | 4 |
| LCB | Ollie Canning | Galway | 3 |
| RWB | Derek Hardiman | Galway | 1 |
| CB | John Gardiner | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Seán Óg Ó hAilpín | Cork | 3 |
| MD | Jerry O'Connor | Cork | 2 |
| MD | Paul Kelly | Tipperary | 2 |
| RWF | Ben O'Connor | Cork | 1 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 5 |
| LWF | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RCF | Ger Farragher | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 4 |
| LCF | Damien Hayes | Galway | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2006

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Dónal Óg Cusack | Cork | 2 |
| RCB | Eoin Murphy | Waterford | 1 |
| FB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LCB | Brian Murphy | Cork | 1 |
| RWB | Tony Browne | Waterford | 2 |
| CB | Ronan Curran | Cork | 3 |
| LWB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 4 |
| MD | Jerry O'Connor | Cork | 3 |
| MD | James "Cha" Fitzpatrick | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWF | Dan Shanahan | Waterford | 2 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 6 |
| LWF | Eddie Brennan | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 5 |
| FF | Martin Comerford | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LCF | Tony Griffin | Clare | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2007

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brian Murray | Limerick | 1 |
| RCB | Michael Kavanagh | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FB | Declan Fanning | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Jackie Tyrrell | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 5 |
| CB | Ken McGrath | Waterford | 3 |
| LWB | Tony Browne | Waterford | 3 |
| MD | Michael Walsh | Waterford | 1 |
| MD | James 'Cha' Fitzpatrick | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWF | Dan Shanahan$^{HOTY}$ | Waterford | 3 |
| CF | Ollie Moran | Limerick | 1 |
| LWF | Stephen Molumphy | Waterford | 1 |
| RCF | Andrew O'Shaughnessy | Limerick | 1 |
| FF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 7 |
| LCF | Eddie Brennan | Kilkenny | 3 |
List of nominees

### 2008

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Cummins | Tipperary | 4 |
| RCB | Michael Kavanagh | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FB | Noel Hickey | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LCB | Jackie Tyrrell | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 6 |
| CB | Conor O'Mahony | Tipperary | 1 |
| LWB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 4 |
| MD | James 'Cha' Fitzpatrick | Kilkenny | 3 |
| MD | Shane McGrath | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Ben O'Connor | Cork | 2 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 8 |
| LWF | Eoin Larkin$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCF | Eddie Brennan | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FF | Eoin Kelly | Waterford | 2 |
| LCF | Joe Canning$^{YHOTY}$ | Galway | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2009

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | P. J. Ryan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCB | Ollie Canning | Galway | 4 |
| FB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Jackie Tyrrell | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RWB | Tommy Walsh$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 7 |
| CB | Michael Walsh | Waterford | 2 |
| LWB | Conor O'Mahony | Tipperary | 2 |
| MD | Michael Rice | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Alan McCrabbe | Dublin | 1 |
| RWF | Lar Corbett | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 9 |
| LWF | Eoin Larkin | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCF | Noel McGrath$^{YHOTY}$ | Tipperary | 1 |
| FF | Joe Canning | Galway | 2 |
| LCF | John Mullane | Waterford | 2 |
List of nominees

## 2010s
### 2010

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brendan Cummins | Tipperary | 5 |
| RCB | Noel Connors | Waterford | 1 |
| FB | Paul Curran | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Jackie Tyrrell | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RWB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 8 |
| CB | Michael Walsh | Waterford | 3 |
| LWB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 5 |
| MD | Michael Fennelly | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Brendan Maher$^{YHOTY}$ | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWF | Damien Hayes | Galway | 2 |
| CF | Noel McGrath | Tipperary | 2 |
| LWF | Lar Corbett$^{HOTY}$ | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCF | John Mullane | Waterford | 3 |
| FF | Richie Power | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCF | Eoin Kelly | Tipperary | 6 |
List of nominees

### 2011

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Gary Maguire | Dublin | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Murphy | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Paul Curran | Tipperary | 2 |
| LCB | Michael Cahill | Tipperary | 1 |
| RWB | Tommy Walsh | Kilkenny | 9 |
| CB | Brian Hogan | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LWB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 2 |
| MD | Liam Rushe | Dublin | 1 |
| MD | Michael Fennelly$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RWF | Michael Rice | Kilkenny | 2 |
| CF | Richie Power | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWF | Henry Shefflin | Kilkenny | 10 |
| RCF | John Mullane | Waterford | 4 |
| FF | Lar Corbett | Tipperary | 3 |
| LCF | Richie Hogan | Kilkenny | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2012

Details
| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Anthony Nash | Cork | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Murphy | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 6 |
| LCB | Fergal Moore | Galway | 1 |
| RWB | Brendan Bugler | Clare | 1 |
| CB | Brian Hogan | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWB | David Collins | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Iarla Tannian | Galway | 1 |
| MD | Kevin Moran | Waterford | 1 |
| RWF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 1 |
| CF | Henry Shefflin$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 11 |
| LWF | Damien Hayes | Galway | 3 |
| RCF | John Mullane | Waterford | 5 |
| FF | Joe Canning | Galway | 3 |
| LCF | David Burke | Galway | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2013

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Anthony Nash | Cork | 2 |
| RCB | Richie McCarthy | Limerick | 1 |
| FB | Peter Kelly | Dublin | 1 |
| LCB | David McInerney | Clare | 1 |
| RWB | Brendan Bugler | Clare | 2 |
| CB | Liam Rushe | Dublin | 2 |
| LWB | Patrick Donnellan | Clare | 1 |
| MD | Colm Galvin | Clare | 1 |
| MD | Conor Ryan | Clare | 1 |
| RWF | Séamus Harnedy | Cork | 1 |
| CF | Tony Kelly$^{HOTY,YHOTY}$ | Clare | 1 |
| LWF | Danny Sutcliffe | Dublin | 1 |
| RCF | Podge Collins | Clare | 1 |
| FF | Patrick Horgan | Cork | 1 |
| LCF | Conor McGrath | Clare | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2014

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Darren Gleeson | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Murphy | Kilkenny | 3 |
| FB | J. J. Delaney | Kilkenny | 7 |
| LCB | Séamus Hickey | Limerick | 1 |
| RWB | Brendan Maher | Tipperary | 2 |
| CB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 3 |
| LWB | Cillian Buckley | Kilkenny | 1 |
| MD | Richie Hogan$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 2 |
| MD | Shane McGrath | Tipperary | 2 |
| RWF | John O'Dwyer | Tipperary | 1 |
| CF | Patrick Maher | Tipperary | 1 |
| LWF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCF | Colin Fennelly | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FF | Séamus Callanan | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCF | Shane Dowling | Limerick | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2015

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Colm Callanan | Galway | 1 |
| RCB | Paul Murphy | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FB | Joey Holden | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCB | Noel Connors | Waterford | 2 |
| RWB | Daithí Burke | Galway | 1 |
| CB | Tadhg de Búrca$^{YHOTY}$ | Waterford | 1 |
| LWB | Cillian Buckley | Kilkenny | 2 |
| MD | Michael Fennelly | Kilkenny | 3 |
| MD | David Burke | Galway | 2 |
| RWF | Cathal Mannion | Galway | 1 |
| CF | Richie Hogan | Kilkenny | 3 |
| LWF | T. J. Reid$^{HOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RCF | Ger Aylward | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FF | Séamus Callanan | Tipperary | 2 |
| LCF | Maurice Shanahan | Waterford | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2016

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Eoin Murphy | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RCB | Cathal Barrett | Tipperary | 1 |
| FB | James Barry | Tipperary | 1 |
| LCB | Daithí Burke | Galway | 2 |
| RWB | Pádraig Walsh | Kilkenny | 1 |
| CB | Ronan Maher | Tipperary | 1 |
| LWB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 4 |
| MD | Jamie Barron | Waterford | 1 |
| MD | David Burke | Galway | 3 |
| RWF | Walter Walsh | Kilkenny | 1 |
| CF | Austin Gleeson$^{HOTY,YHOTY}$ | Waterford | 1 |
| LWF | Patrick Maher | Tipperary | 2 |
| RCF | Richie Hogan | Kilkenny | 4 |
| FF | Séamus Callanan | Tipperary | 3 |
| LCF | John McGrath | Tipperary | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2017

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Stephen O'Keeffe | Waterford | 1 |
| RCB | Pádraic Mannion | Galway | 1 |
| FB | Daithí Burke | Galway | 3 |
| LCB | Noel Connors | Waterford | 3 |
| RWB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 5 |
| CB | Gearóid McInerney | Galway | 1 |
| LWB | Mark Coleman | Cork | 1 |
| MD | Jamie Barron | Waterford | 2 |
| MD | David Burke | Galway | 4 |
| RWF | Kevin Moran | Waterford | 2 |
| CF | Joe Canning$^{HOTY}$ | Galway | 4 |
| LWF | Michael Walsh | Waterford | 4 |
| RCF | Conor Whelan$^{YHOTY}$ | Galway | 1 |
| FF | Conor Cooney | Galway | 1 |
| LCF | Patrick Horgan | Cork | 2 |
List of nominees

### 2018

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Eoin Murphy | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCB | Seán Finn | Limerick | 1 |
| FB | Daithí Burke | Galway | 4 |
| LCB | Richie English | Limerick | 1 |
| RWB | Pádraic Mannion | Galway | 2 |
| CB | Declan Hannon | Limerick | 1 |
| LWB | Dan Morrissey | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Cian Lynch$^{HOTY}$ | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Darragh Fitzgibbon | Cork | 1 |
| RWF | Peter Duggan | Clare | 1 |
| CF | Joe Canning | Galway | 5 |
| LWF | Séamus Harnedy | Cork | 2 |
| RCF | Patrick Horgan | Cork | 3 |
| FF | John Conlon | Clare | 1 |
| LCF | Graeme Mulcahy | Limerick | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2019

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Brian Hogan | Tipperary | 1 |
| RCB | Seán Finn | Limerick | 2 |
| FB | Ronan Maher | Tipperary | 2 |
| LCB | Cathal Barrett | Tipperary | 2 |
| RWB | Brendan Maher | Tipperary | 3 |
| CB | Pádraig Walsh | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LWB | Pádraic Maher | Tipperary | 6 |
| MD | Noel McGrath | Tipperary | 3 |
| MD | Diarmuid O'Keeffe | Wexford | 1 |
| RWF | Lee Chin | Wexford | 1 |
| CF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 4 |
| LWF | Colin Fennelly | Kilkenny | 2 |
| RCF | Aaron Gillane | Limerick | 1 |
| FF | Séamus Callanan$^{HOTY}$ | Tipperary | 4 |
| LCF | Patrick Horgan | Cork | 4 |
List of nominees

## 2020s
### 2020

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Nickie Quaid | Limerick | 1 |
| RCB | Seán Finn | Limerick | 3 |
| FB | Dan Morrissey | Limerick | 2 |
| LCB | Daithí Burke | Galway | 5 |
| RWB | Diarmaid Byrnes | Limerick | 1 |
| CB | Tadhg de Búrca | Waterford | 2 |
| LWB | Kyle Hayes | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Jamie Barron | Waterford | 3 |
| MD | Tony Kelly | Clare | 2 |
| RWF | Gearóid Hegarty$^{HOTY}$ | Limerick | 1 |
| CF | Cian Lynch | Limerick | 2 |
| LWF | Tom Morrissey | Limerick | 1 |
| RCF | Aaron Gillane | Limerick | 2 |
| FF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 5 |
| LCF | Stephen Bennett | Waterford | 1 |
Like of nominees

### 2021

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Eoin Murphy | Kilkenny | 3 |
| RCB | Seán Finn | Limerick | 4 |
| FB | Conor Prunty | Waterford | 1 |
| LCB | Barry Nash | Limerick | 1 |
| RWB | Diarmaid Byrnes | Limerick | 2 |
| CB | Declan Hannon | Limerick | 2 |
| LWB | Kyle Hayes | Limerick | 2 |
| MD | William O'Donoghue | Limerick | 1 |
| MD | Darragh O'Donovan | Limerick | 1 |
| RWF | Gearóid Hegarty | Limerick | 2 |
| CF | Cian Lynch$^{HOTY}$ | Limerick | 3 |
| LWF | Tom Morrissey | Limerick | 2 |
| RCF | Tony Kelly | Clare | 3 |
| FF | Séamus Flanagan | Limerick | 1 |
| LCF | Peter Casey | Limerick | 1 |
List of nominees

### 2022

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Nickie Quaid | Limerick | 2 |
| RCB | Mikey Butler$^{YHOTY}$ | Kilkenny | 1 |
| FB | Huw Lawlor | Kilkenny | 1 |
| LCB | Barry Nash | Limerick | 2 |
| RWB | Diarmaid Byrnes$^{HOTY}$ | Limerick | 3 |
| CB | Declan Hannon | Limerick | 3 |
| LWB | Pádraic Mannion | Galway | 3 |
| MD | David Fitzgerald | Clare | 1 |
| MD | Adrian Mullen | Kilkenny | 1 |
| RWF | Gearóid Hegarty | Limerick | 3 |
| CF | Kyle Hayes | Limerick | 3 |
| LWF | Shane O'Donnell | Clare | 1 |
| RCF | Aaron Gillane | Limerick | 3 |
| FF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 6 |
| LCF | Tony Kelly | Clare | 4 |
List of nominees

### 2023

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Eoin Murphy | Kilkenny | 4 |
| RCB | Mikey Butler | Kilkenny | 2 |
| FB | Huw Lawlor | Kilkenny | 2 |
| LCB | Dan Morrissey | Limerick | 3 |
| RWB | Diarmaid Byrnes | Limerick | 4 |
| CB | John Conlon | Clare | 2 |
| LWB | Kyle Hayes | Limerick | 4 |
| MD | Darragh O'Donovan | Limerick | 2 |
| MD | William O'Donoghue | Limerick | 2 |
| RWF | Shane O'Donnell | Clare | 2 |
| CF | T. J. Reid | Kilkenny | 7 |
| LWF | Tom Morrissey | Limerick | 3 |
| RCF | Conor Whelan | Galway | 2 |
| FF | Aaron Gillane$^{HOTY}$ | Limerick | 4 |
| LCF | Eoin Cody | Kilkenny | 1 |

### 2024

| Pos. | Player | Team | Appearances |
| GK | Nickie Quaid | Limerick | 3 |
| RCB | Adam Hogan$^{YHOTY}$ | Clare | 1 |
| FB | Eoin Downey | Cork | 1 |
| LCB | Dan Morrissey | Limerick | 4 |
| RWB | David McInerney | Clare | 2 |
| CB | Robert Downey | Cork | 1 |
| LWB | Kyle Hayes | Limerick | 5 |
| MD | Tony Kelly | Clare | 5 |
| MD | Darragh Fitzgibbon | Cork | 2 |
| RWF | David Fitzgerald | Clare | 2 |
| CF | Shane Barrett | Cork | 1 |
| LWF | Seamus Harnedy | Cork | 3 |
| RCF | Gearóid Hegarty | Limerick | 4 |
| FF | Shane O'Donnell$^{HOTY}$ | Clare | 3 |
| LCF | Mark Rodgers | Clare | 1 |

## Use of colours above

| Colour | Meaning |
| | Had previously appeared on an All-Stars team |