# Parade All-America Boys Basketball Team

The Parade All-America Boys Basketball Team was an annual selection by Parade that nationally honored the top high school boys' basketball players in the United States. It was part of the Parade All-American series that originated with boys basketball before branching to other sports. Started by the Sunday magazine in 1957, it had been the longest ongoing selection of high school basketball All-Americans in the country at the time of its final selections in 2015. Many of the honorees went on to star as college and professional basketball players. As of March 2011, there were 162 Parade All-Americans that were playing in the National Basketball Association (NBA).
At its onset, the selections were handled by a New York–based public relations firm, Publicity Enterprises, which was led by Haskell Cohen, who was a former sportswriter as well as the publicity director for the NBA at the time (1950–1969). The first All-America team in 1957 consisted of three five-player teams, and the first-team selections appeared on television on The Steve Allen Show. The following year, 20 players were selected and participated in the first annual Parade All-American high school game. The list later expanded to 40 of the nation's top players, divided into four teams of 10 each. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, known then as Lew Alcindor, became the first sophomore in 1963 to be named a Parade All-American. Fifteen years later, Earl Jones became the next sophomore to earn first-team honors, and subsequently joined Abdul-Jabbar as the first two players to be named to the first team on three occasions. "It was a real thrill for me to make it on the Parade list early, when I was just a sophomore. The recognition is a great thing for kids to shoot for," said Abdul-Jabbar as part of the announcement for the 2000 team.
Starting in 2011, the selections were compiled in conjunction with Sporting News and their writer, Brian McLaughlin. Candidates also began to be limited to players in their senior year. The selections went to a single-team format in 2012, and the size was reduced from 40- to a 20-player first team in 2014. McLaughlin described the selections as mostly Division I college-bound players that had a stellar senior year in high school. Additionally, Parade differentiated itself from most other All-American teams by not focusing solely on a player's standing among college recruiters. For example, some selectors might choose top recruits that had been injured much of their senior year. Parade discontinued its boys' basketball All-America selections after 2015.

## Selections
### 1957–1959

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 1957 | Terry Bethel | Collinsville (Collinsville, Ill.) | Charles Brandt | Elgin (Elgin, Ill.) | Bobby Lee Slusher | Lone Jack (Four Miles, Ky.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1957 | Tom Meschery | Lowell (San Francisco, Calif.) | Tom Stith | St. Francis (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | Johnny Kelso | Central (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1957 | Jerry Lucas | Middletown (Middletown, Ohio) | Bill McGill | Jefferson (Los Angeles, Calif.) | Bjarne Jensen | Franklin (Portland, Ore.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1957 | Al Butler | East (Rochester, N.Y.) | John Tidwell | Herrin Township (Herrin Township, Ill.) | Kay McFarland | Englewood (Englewood, Col.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1957 | Tony Jackson | Thomas Jefferson (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | John Egan | Weaver (Hartford, Conn) | Bob Heffner | Allentown (Allentown, Pa.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1958 | Bill McGill | Jefferson (Los Angeles, Calif.) | Norman Grow | Foley (Foley, Minn). | Wiliam LeFevre | Phillip Shuyler (Albany, Pa.) | Armand Reo | Catholic Central (Troy, N.Y.) | |
| 1958 | Sandy Pomerantz | University City (St. Louis, Mo.) | Terry Dischinger | Garfield (Terre Haute, Ind.) | Charles Hall | Gerstmeyer (Terre Haute, Ind.) | George Friedrich | Delhaas (Bristol, Pa.) | |
| 1958 | Jerry Lucas | Middletown (Middletown, Ohio) | Wayne Hightower | Overbrook (Philadelphia, Pa.) | Ralph Richardson | Russell Springs (Russell Springs, Ky.) | John Rudometkin | Santa Maria (Santa Maria, Calif.) | |
| 1958 | John Kelso | Fort Wayne Central (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | Doug Mills | Galesburg (Galesburg, Ill.) | Frank Pinchback | Christian Brothers Academy (Albany, N. Y.) | Dave DeBusschere | Austin (Detroit, Michigan) | |
| 1958 | John Foley | Assumption (Worcester, Mass.) | Robert McLoughlon | St. Joseph (West New York, N. J.) | Willis Thomas | Jefferson (Los Angeles, Ca.) | Tom Sizer | Middleton (Middleton, Ohio) | |
| 1959 | James Robinson | Crane Tech (Chicago, Ill.) | Matt Szykowny | North Catholic (Pittsburgh, Pa.) | Rodney Thorn | Princeton (Princeton, W Va.) | Bob Sommers | San Marino (San Marino, Ca.) | |
| 1959 | Art Heyman | Oceanside (Oceanside, N.Y.) | Ralph Heyward | Overbrook (Philadelphia, Pa.) | Roger Brown | Wingate (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | Pat Richter | Madison East (Madison, Wis.) | |
| 1959 | Tom Hoover | Archbishop Carroll (Washington D. C.) | Gordon Martin | Hawthorne (Los Angeles, Ca.) | George Wilson | Marshall (Chicago, Ill.) | Billy Galanti | James Madison (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | |
| 1959 | Bill Raftery | St. Cecilia's (Kearny, N. J.) | Lawrence "Bumpy" Nixon | Galesburg (Galesburg, Ill.) | Vinnie Ernst | St. Aloysius (Jersey City, N. J.) | Jimmy Rayl | Kokomo (Kokomo, Ind.) | |
| 1959 | Bernie Butts | Hialeah (Hialeah, Fla.) | Tom Bolyard | Fort Wayne South (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | Jim Chacko | Carleroi (Charleoi, Pa.) | Don Burks | Archbishop Molloy (Jamaica, N.Y.) | |

### 1960–1969

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 1960 | Ron Bonham | Muncie Central IN | Bill Bradley | Crystal City MO | Roger Brown | Brooklyn Wingate NY | Tom Baxley | North Miami FL | |
| 1960 | Connie Hawkins | Brooklyn Boys NY | Joe Caldwell | Los Angeles Fremont CA | Charles Hotetz | Greenwich CT | Buster Briley | Madison IN | |
| 1960 | Barry Kramer | Schenectady Linton NY | Art Roberts | Holyoke MA | Ricky Kaminsky | Bellaire TX | Bill Chmielewski | Detroit Holy Redeemer MI | |
| 1960 | Jeff Mullins | Lexington Lafayette KY | Paul Silas | Oakland McClymonds CA | Cotton Nash | Lake Charles LA | Bill Maphis | Romney WV | |
| 1960 | George Wilson | Chicago Marshall IL | John Thompson | Washington Carroll DC | Lawrence Nixon | Galesburg IL | Ron Smith | Camden NJ | |
| 1961 | Bill Bradley | Crystal City MO | Freddie Goss | Compton CA | Danny Farrell | Logansport IN | Luther Harper | Phoenix Union AZ | |
| 1961 | Reggie Harding | Detroit Eastern MI | Brent Kichting | Sharon Hills PA | George Lee | Trenton Central NJ | Fred Hetzel | Bethesda Landon MD | |
| 1961 | Jim Jarvis | Roseburg OR | Don Rolfes | Harrison OH | Skip Thoren | Rockford East IL | Dave Hicks | New Haven Wilbur Cross CT | |
| 1961 | Ron Krick | West Reading PA | L. C. Snow | Dayton Roosevelt OH | Dick Van Arsdale | Indianapolis Manual IN | Larry Sheffield | Troy LaSalle NY | |
| 1961 | Bryan Williams | Danville Schlarman IL | Haskell Tison | Geneva IL | Tom Van Arsdale | Indianapolis Manual IN | Marv Van Leeuwen | Canajoharie NY | |
| 1962 | John Austin | Hyattsville DeMatha MD | Henry Burlong | Dayton Roosevelt OH | Bob Bruggers | Danube MN | Larry Enos | Corvallis OR | |
| 1962 | Larry Conley | Ashland KY | Ed Griffin | Hartford Public CT | Myron Erickson | Orland CA | Ron Fahnstock | Seattle Roosevelt WA | |
| 1962 | Edgar Lacy | Los Angeles (Jefferson CA) | Tony Horton | Los Angeles University CA | Wilson Graham | Cleveland East Tech OH | Cazzie Russell | Chicago Carver IL | |
| 1962 | Jim Ligon | Kokomo IN | Riney Lochmann | Wichita North KS | Darrell Hardy | Houston Jefferson Davis TX | John Serbin | Hammond IN | |
| 1962 | Mike Silliman | Louisville St. Xavier KY | Bob McIntyre | New York City Holy Cross NY | Gary Keller | St. Petersburg Hollins FL | Jim Williams | Norristown PA | |
| 1963 | Edgar Lacey | Jefferson (Los Angeles, CA) | James Cummins | Cedar Rapids (Cedar Rapids, IA) | Bob Stuckey | Gilroy Union (Gilroy, CA) | Bill Soens | William Penn Charter (Philadelphia, PA) | |
| 1963 | Ronald Sepic | Uniontown (Uniontown, PA) | Paul Presthus | Rugby (Rugby, ND) | Vaughn Harper | Boys' (Brooklyn, NY) | Ed Hummer | Washington-Lee (Arlington, VA) | |
| 1963 | Lew Alcindor | Power Memorial Academy (New York, NY) | Robert King | Westfield (Westfield, NJ) | Nick Pino | St. Michael's (Santa Fe, NM) | Tom Niemeier | Rex Mundi (Evansville, IN) | |
| 1963 | Ian Morrison | St. Petersburg (St. Petersburg, FL) | Charles Coleman | Darby-Colwyn (Darby, PA) | Fred Hare | Omaha Tech (Omaha, NE) | Mike Gervasoni | Bishop O'Dowd (Oakland CA) | |
| 1963 | Bobby Lewis | St. John's College (Washington DC) | Mike Redd | Seneca (Louisville, KY) | Doug Hice | Cathedral (Trenton, NJ) | Doug Wardlaw | Wilbur L. Cross (New Haven, CT) | |
| 1964 | Wes Unseld | Seneca (Louisville, KY) | Rich Jones | Lester (Memphis, TN) | Glinder Torain | Central (Muncie, IN) | Bill Hosket Jr. | Belmont (Dayton, OH) | |
| 1964 | Mike Lewis | Missoula (Missoula, MT) | Rodger Bohnenstiehl | Collinsville (Collinsville, IL) | Don Chaney | McKinley (Baton Rouge, LA) | Ken Spain | Austin (Houston TX) | |
| 1964 | Lew Alcindor | Power Memorial Academy (New York, NY) | Butch Booker | Darby-Colwyn (Darby, PA) | Dave Newmark | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn, NY) | Manny Leaks | East (Cleveland OH) | |
| 1964 | Larry Miller | Catasauqua (Catasauqua, PA) | Ron Williams | Weirton (Weirton, WV) | Brendan McCarthy | DeMatha (Hyattsville, MD) | Jim Phillips | Bishop Barry (St. Petersburg, FL) | |
| 1964 | Jerry Sharman | Charter Oak (Charter Oak, CA) | Jack Bettridge | Power Memorial Academy (New York, NY) | Bob Tallent | Maytown (Maytown, KY) | Chris Ellis | Newport News (Newport News, VA) | |
| 1965 | Simmie Hill | Midlan (Midland, PA) | L. C. Bowen | Benton Harbor (Benton Harbor, MI) | Bernie Williams | DeMatha (Hyattsville, MD) | Dick Haucke | La Salle (Cincinnati, OH) | |
| 1965 | Don Ross | East (Waterloo, IA) | Howard Arndt | Republic (Republic, MO) | Walt Esdaile | Hillhouse (New Haven, CT) | Steve Vandenberg | Allegany (Cumberland, MD) | |
| 1965 | Lew Alcindor | Power Memorial Academy (New York, NY) | Melvin Bell | Clinton (Clinton, OK) | Sam Robinson | Jefferson (Los Angeles, CA) | Ted Wierman | Davis (Davis, WA) | |
| 1965 | Pete Maravich | Needham Broughton (Raleigh, NC) | Lucius Allen | Wyandotte (Kansas City, KS) | Dave Golden | Pekin (Pekin, IL) | Alan Goldfarb | Miami Beach (Miami Beach, FL) | |
| 1965 | Richard Braucher | Kutztown (Kutztown, PA) | Butch Beard | Breckinridge County (Hardinsburg, KY) | Charles Powell | McKinley (Baton Rouge, LA) | Larry Cannon | Abraham Lincoln (Philadelphia, PA) | |
| 1966 | Calvin Murphy | Norwalk (Norwalk, CT) | Perry Wallace | Pearl (Nashville, TN) | Mike Blevins | Springboro (Springboro, OH) | George Janky | St. Rita's (Chicago, IL) | |
| 1966 | Jim McMillian | Thomas Jefferson (Brooklyn, NY) | Richard Bradshaw | Marshall (Chicago, IL) | Doug Jackson | Shawnee Mission East (Shawnee Mission, KS) | Jerry Paluch | St. Mary's (Perth Amboy, NJ) | |
| 1966 | Joe Bergman | St. Mary's (Clinton, IA) | Bob Lienhard | Rice (New York, NY) | Sid Catlett | DeMatha (Hyattsville, MD) | Gregg Northington | Wood (Indianapolis, IN) | |
| 1966 | Sam Robinson | Jefferson (Los Angeles, CA) | Calvin Nicholson | Philip Schuyler (Albany, NY) | Nelson Isley | Reidsville (Reidsville, NC) | Eddie Fogler | Flushing (Flushing, NY) | |
| 1966 | Rick Mount | Lebanon (Lebanon, IN) | Pless Vann | Central (Tulsa, OK) | Marvin Winkler | Washington (Indianapolis, IN) | Jim Rose | Hazard (Hazard, KY) | |
| 1967| | Curtis Rowe | Fremont (Los Angeles, CA) | Ken Durrett | Schenley (Pittsburgh, PA) | Bart Johnson | Torrance (Torrance, CA) | Willie Long | South Side (Fort Wayne, IN) | |
| 1967| | Howard Porter | Booker (Sarasota, FL) | Craig Manwaring | Highland (Highland, IL) | Spencer Haywood | Pershing (Detroit, MI) | Lynn Howden | Waltrip (Houston, TX) | |
| 1967| | Jim McDaniels | Allen County (Allen County, KY) | Dana Lewis | Weequahic (Newark, NJ) | Artis Gilmore | Carver (Dothan, AL) | Gregg Northington | Wood (Indianapolis, IN) | |
| 1967| | Greg Starrick | Marion (Marion, IL) | Dana Pagett | El Segundo (El Segundo, CA) | Pierre Russell | Wyandotte (Kansas City, KS) | Austin Carr | Mackin (Washington DC) | |
| 1967| | Dick DeVenzio | Ambridge (Ambridge, PA) | Fred Hilton | McKinley (Baton Rouge, LA) | Dean Meminger | Rice (New York, NY) | Jim Rose | Hazard (Hazard. KY) | |
| 1968 | Dennis Wuycik | Ambridge (Ambridge, PA) | Tom Parker | Collinsville (Collinsville, IL) | Bob Zender | Edina (Edina, MN) | Chris Schweer | York (Elmhurst, IL) | |
| 1968 | Bob Ford | North (Evansville, IN) | James Speed | Valencia (Shreveport, LA) | Ron Riley | Jordan (Los Angeles, CA) | Cyril Baptiste | Archbishop Curley (Miami, FL) | |
| 1968 | Tom Riker | St. Dominic's (Oyster Bay, NY) | Steve Turner | Bartlett (Memphis, TN) | Ansley Truitt | Wilson (San Francisco, CA) | Bill Chamberlain | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | |
| 1968 | Ralph Simpson | Pershing (Detroit, MI) | John Fraley | Middletown (Middletown, OH) | Phil Chenier | Berkeley (Berkeley, CA) | Billy Shepherd | Carmel (Carmel, IN) | |
| 1968 | Bob Kivisto | East (Aurora, IL) | Milton Horne | Philip Schuyler (Albany, NY) | Henry Bacon | Male (Louisville KY) | Joby Wright | Johnson (Savannah, GA) | |
| 1969 | George McGinnis | Washington (Indianapolis, IN) | Mel Davis | Boys' (Brooklyn, NY) | Jim Horne | Philip Schuyler (Albany, NY) | Mike Fink | Central Valley (Central Valley, CA) | |
| 1969 | Johnny Neumann | Overton (Memphis, TN) | Jim Brewer | Proviso East (Maywood, IL) | Nick Weatherspoon | McKinley (Canton, OH) | Ernie Johnson | Ottawa Hills (Grand Rapids, MI) | |
| 1969 | Tom McMillen | Mansfield (Mansfield, PA) | Jim Chones | St. Catherine (Racine, WI) | Randy Canfield | Southeast (Wichita, KS) | Tom Payne | Shawnee (Louisville, KY) | |
| 1969 | Norm Stevenson | Gibbs (St. Petersburg, FL) | Allan Hornyak | St. John's (Bellaire, OH) | Dan Kirkland | Columbus (Columbus, GA) | Tyrone Collins | Kennedy (Paterson, NJ) | |
| 1969 | Kevin Joyce | Archbishop Molloy (Jamaica, NY) | Joe Wills | Vashon (St. Louis, MO) | Pete Harris | Dunbar (Baltimore, MD) | Walter Williams | Wyandotte (Kansas City, KS) | |

### 1970–1979

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 1970 | Tom McMillen | Mansfield (Mansfield, PA) | Dwight Jones | Wheatley (Houston, TX) | Bill Morris | Beaumont (St. Louis, MO) | Keith Bowman | Savannah (Savannah, GA) | |
| 1970 | Bill Walton | Helix (La Mesa, CA) | Jim Bradley | Roosevelt (East Chicago, IN) | Donald Washington | St. Anthony's (Washington DC) | Hal Sullinger | Camden (Camden, NJ) | |
| 1970 | Kris Berymon | Harper (Chicago, IL) | Tommy Burleson | Avery County (Avery, NC) | Les Cason | East Rutherford (East Rutherford, NJ) | Danny Moses | Williamson (Williamson, WV) | |
| 1970 | John Williamson | Wilbur L. Cross (New Haven, CT) | James Outlaw | Ballard-Hudson (Ballard, GA) | Don Smith | Roth (Dayton, OH) | Jeff Walker | Central (Detroit, MI) | |
| 1970 | Tom Gilbert | Speedway (Indianapolis, IN) | Sam Puckett | Hales Franciscan (Chicago, IL) | Bill Anderson | Skyline (Salt Lake City, UT) | Denton Jones | Central (Knoxville, TN) | |
| 1971 | Tom Roy | South Windsor (South Windsor, CT) | Rick Suttle | Assumption (East St. Louis, IL) | Kessem Grimes | West Side (Gary, Indiana) | Lindsay Hairston | Kettering (Detroit, MI) | |
| 1971 | Campy Russell | Central (Pontiac, MI) | Donald Washington | St. Anthony's (Washington, D.C.) | Owen Brown | Lyons (LaGrange, IL) | Carlos Mina | Central Union (El Centro, CA) | |
| 1971 | Les Cason | East Rutherford (East Rutherford, NJ) | David Vaughn | Cameron (Nashville, TN) | Ed Stahl | Walnut Ridge (Columbus, OH) | Fessor Leonard | Carver (Columbus, GA) | |
| 1971 | Andre McCarter | Overbrook (Philadelphia, PA) | Raymond Lewis | Verbum Dei (Los Angeles, CA) | Ricky Coleman | Schenley (Pittsburgh, PA) | Jimmy Dan Conner | Anderson County (Lawrenceburg, KY) | |
| 1971 | Mike Flynn | Jeffersonville (Jeffersonville, IN) | Gus Williams | Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon, NY) | Ernie Douse | Boys (Brooklyn, NY) | Lloyd Walton | Mt. Carmel (Chicago, IL) | |
| 1972 | Major Jones | Desha Central Rohwer, AR) | Casey Corliss | University West (Los Angeles, CA) | Phil Sellers | Jefferson (Brooklyn, NY) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Quinn Buckner | Thornridge (Dolton, IL) | John Engles | St. Peter's (Staten Island, NY) | Ira Terrell | Roosevelt (Dallas, TX) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Nino Samuel | Central (Salina, KS) | Jerry Thruston | Owensboro (Owensboro, KY) | Jeff Fosnes | Wheat Ridge (Wheat Ridge, CO) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Eugene Short | Hattiesburg (Hattiesburg, MS) | Ron Lee | Lexington (Lexington, MA) | Lamont Turner | Vashon (St. Louis, MO) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Ed Lawrence | Boston (Lake Charles, LA) | Greg Grady | Eastern District (Brooklyn, NY) | Merlin Wilson | St. Anthony's (Washington, D.C.) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Robert Parish | Woodlawn (Shreveport, LA) | Alvan Adams | Putnam City (War Acres, OK) | John Drew | Shields Beatrice, AL) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Leon Douglas | Leighton (Leighton, AL) | Mo Howard | St. Joseph's Prep (Philadelphia, PA) | Bill Cook | White Station (Memphis, TN) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Walter Luckett | Kolbe (Bridgeport, CT) | Mickey Heard | Wilbur L. Cross (New Haven, CT) | Dave O'Connell | McNicholas (Cincinnati, OH) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Bubbles Hawkins | Pershing (Detroit, MI) | Eddie Owens | Wheatley (Houston, TX) | John Lucas | Hillside (Durham, NC) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1972 | Chuckie Williams | East (Columbus, OH) | Larry Fogle | Cooley (Detroit, MI) | Roger Powell | Central (Joliet, IL) | None selected | None selected | |
| 1973 | Bo Ellis | Parker (Chicago, IL) | Eddie Owens | Wheatley (Houston, TX) | Jeff Randall | Castlemont (Oakland, CA) | Bill Paterno | Christian Brothers Academy (Lincroft, NJ) | |
| 1973 | Richard Washington | Benson Tech (Portland, OR) | Wesley Cox | Male (Louisville, KY) | Ernie Grunfeld | Forest Hills (Forest Hills, NY) | Moses Malone | Petersburg (Petersburg, VA) | |
| 1973 | Cliff Pondexter | San Joaquin Memorial (Fresno, CA) | Gavin Smith | Van Nuys (Van Nuys, CA) | Bob Siegel | Fairbury (Fairbury, NE) | Walter Actwood | Greenville (Greenville, MS) | |
| 1973 | Adrian Dantley | DeMatha (Hyattsville, MD) | Jackie Robinson | Morningside (Inglewood, CA) | Bob Manker | Valley (West Des Moines, IA) | Herman Harris | Chester (Chester, PA) | |
| 1973 | Melvin Baker | Gallup (Gallup, NM) | Geoff Crompton | Williams (Burlington, NC) | Kent Benson | Chrysler (New Castle, IN) | Jeff Wilkins | Elgin (Elgin, IL) | |
| 1973 | Tom LaGarde | Central Catholic (Detroit, MI) | Lewis Brown | Verbum Dei (Los Angeles, CA) | Steve Puidokas | St. Laurence (Burbank, IL) | Donnie Von Moore | Kenwood (Chicago, IL) | |
| 1973 | T. R. Dunn | West End (Birmingham, AL) | Ernie Kent | West (Rockford, IL) | Jim Webb | Adams (South Bend, IN) | David Moss | Ringgold (Ringgold, GA) | |
| 1973 | Jim Spillane | Palos Verdes (Palos Verdes, CA) | Jeep Kelley | Schenley (Pittsburgh, PA) | John Kuester | Benedictine (Richmond, VA) | Marty Giovacchini | Judge Memorial (Salt Lake City, UT) | |
| 1973 | Wayne Smalls | Camden (Camden, NJ) | Dexter Reed | Parkview (Little Rock, AR) | Jim Smith | Lake Worth (Lake Worth, FL) | Wayne Golden | Shawnee (Louisville, KY) | |
| 1973 | Larry Wright | Western (Washington, D.C.) | Joe Hassett | La Salle Academy (Providence, RI) | Brian Williams | South (Columbus, OH) | Ray Martin | Mater Christi (Astoria, NY) | |
| 1974 | Moses Malone | Petersburg (Petersburg, VA) | Mark Olberding | Melrose (Melrose, MN) | Myles Patrick | Southwest (Macon, GA) | Darryl Dawkins | Evans (Orlando, FL) | |
| 1974 | Mike Mitchell | Price (Atlanta, GA) | Bruce Campbell | Wilbur L. Cross (New Haven, CT) | Jack Givens | Bryan Station (Lexington, KY) | Winford Boynes | Capitol Hill (Oklahoma City, OK) | |
| 1974 | Audie Matthews | Bloom Township (Chicago Heights, IL) | Jacky Dorsey | Archer (Atlanta, GA) | Rick Robey | Brother Martin (New Orleans, LA) | Kim Stewart | Ballard (Seattle, WA) | |
| 1974 | Earl Evans | Lincoln (Port Arthur, TX) | Billy Lewis | Farragut (Chicago, IL) | Dave Winey | St. John's Prep (Danvers, MA) | Lawrence Boston | Kennedy (Cleveland, OH) | |
| 1974 | Kenny Carr | DeMatha (Hyattsville, MD) | Chris Patton | St. Francis (Athol Springs, NY) | Bill Cartwright | Elk Grove (Elk Grove, CA) | Lucius Foster | Savannah (Savannah, GA) | |
| 1974 | Brett Vroman | Provo (Provo, UT) | Tony Smith | Saginaw (Saginaw, MI) | Dave Batton | Springfield (Springfield, PA) | Chad Nelson | Yankton (Yankton, SD) | |
| 1974 | Phil Ford | Rocky Mount (Rocky Mount, NC) | Kenny Higgs | Owensboro (Owensboro, KY) | Tony Flannagan | Southwest (Atlanta, PA) | Jack Gilloon | Memorial (West New York, NJ) | |
| 1974 | Mark Wulfemeyer | Troy (Fullerton, CA) | Steve Collier | Southwestern (Hanover, IN) | Brad Davis | Monaca (Monaca, PA) | Wayne Bracy | Hayes (Birmingham, AL) | |
| 1974 | Skip Wise | Dunbar (Baltimore, MD) | James Jackson | Crane Tech (Chicago, IL) | Duck Williams | Mackin (Washington, D.C.) | Gary Rosenberger | Marquette (Milwaukee, WI) | |
| 1974 | Stan Rome | Valdosta (Valdosta, GA) | John Gunn | Melrose (Memphis, TN) | Al Green | Maine Central Institute (Pittsfield, ME) | Alex Eldridge | Taft (Bronx, NY) | |
| 1975 | Bill Cartwright | Elk Grove (Elk Grove, CA) | Larry Gibson | Dunbar (Baltimore, MD) | Ron Perry | Catholic Memorial (West Roxbury, MA) | Larry Harrison | Towson Catholic (Baltimore, MD) | |
| 1975 | Dave Greenwood | Verbum Dei (Los Angeles, CA) | Sam Drummer | Muncie North (Muncie, Indiana) | Pete Boesen | Maine South (Park Ridge, IL) | Jay Feltz | Monongah (Monongah, WV) | |
| 1975 | Kyle Macy | Peru (Peru, IN) | Stacey Robinson | Crossland (Camp Springs, MD) | Wayne McKoy | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | Mike Palma | St. Agnes (Rockville Centre, NY) | |
| 1975 | Bill Willoughby | Dwight Morrow (Englewood, NJ) | Reggie King | Jackson-Olin (Birmingham, AL) | Brad Holland | Crescenta Valley (La Crescenta, CA) | James Bradley | Melrose (Memphis, TN) | |
| 1975 | Roy Hamilton | Verbum Dei (Los Angeles, CA) | Glen Grunwald | East Leyden (Franklin Park, IL) | Jim Tillman | Eastern (Washington, D.C.) | Terry Crosby | DeVilbiss (Toledo, OH) | |
| 1975 | James Hardy | Jordan (Long Beach, CA) | Bob Bender | Bloomington (Bloomington, IL) | Chris Bennett | Catholic (Little Rock, AR) | Bernard Rencher | Mater Christi (Astoria, NY) | |
| 1975 | Bernard Toone | Gorton (Yonkers, NY) | Bill Laimbeer | Palos Verdes Estates (Palos Verdes, CA) | Jim Graziano | Farmingdale (Farmingdale, NY) | Pat Foschi | Virginia (Virginia, MN) | |
| 1975 | Darryl Dawkins | Evans (Orlando, FL) | Ernie Cobb | Stamford (Stamford, CT) | Larry Wilson | Central Lafourche (Mathews, LA) | Albert King | Fort Hamilton (Brooklyn, NY) | |
| 1975 | Bruce Flowers | Berkley (Berkley, MI) | Reggie Carter | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | Bob Roma | Christian Bros Academy (Lincroft, NJ) | Mickey Crowe | J.F. Kennedy Prep (St. Nazianz, WI) | |
| 1975 | Winford Boynes | Capitol Hill (Oklahoma City, OK) | Lynbert Johnson | Haaren (New York, NY) | Rich Valavicius | Hammond (Hammond, IN) | Cedrick Hordges | Robert E. Lee (Montgomery, AL) | |
| 1976 | Gene Banks | West Philadelphia (Philadelphia, PA) | Jim Graziano | Farmingdale (Farmingdale, NY) | Charles Whitney | DeMatha (Washington, D.C.) | Johnny Parker | Central (St. Louis, MO) | |
| 1976 | Albert King | Fort Hamilton (Brooklyn, NY) | Mike O'Koren | Hudson Catholic (Jersey City, NJ) | James Wilkes | Dorsey (Los Angeles, CA) | Kiki VanDeWeghe | Palisades (Pacific Palisades, CA) | |
| 1976 | LaVon Williams | Manuel (Denver, CO) | Greg Johnson | Lockland (Cincinnati, OH) | Butch Carter | Middletown (Middletown, OH) | John Virgil | Elm City (Elm City, NC) | |
| 1976 | Glen Grunwald | East Leyden (Franklin Park, IL) | Stan Matzen | Lincoln (Tacoma, WA) | Antonio Martin | Arsenal Technical (Indianapolis, IN) | Albert Jones | Worthing (Houston, TX) | |
| 1976 | Stuart House | Denby (Detroit, MI) | Derek Holcomb | Richwoods (Peoria, IL) | Jawann Oldham | Cleveland (Seattle, WA) | Gig Sims | Redondo Beach (Redondo Beach, CA) | |
| 1976 | Rickey Brown | Southwest (Atlanta, GA) | Wayne McKoy | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | LaVon Mercer | Metter (Metter, GA) | Larry Petty | Power Memorial (New York, NY) | |
| 1976 | Darrell Griffith | Male (Louisville, KY) | JoJo Hunter | Mackin (Washington, D.C.) | Jay Shidler | Lawrenceville (Lawrenceville, IL) | Bill Hanzlik | Beloit Memorial (Beloit, WI) | |
| 1976 | John Nash | Polytech (Long Beach, CA) | Brian Walker | Lebanon (Lebanon, IN) | Arnold Gaines | Lake Clifton (Baltimore, MD) | Tyrone Ladsdon | Carnarsie (Brooklyn, NY) | |
| 1976 | Ronnie Perry | Catholic Memorial (West Roxbury, MA) | James Daughtry | Berrien County (Nashville, GA) | Bob Turner | Male (Louisville, KY) | Baron Flenory | Valley (New Kensington, PA) | |
| 1976 | Rich Branning | Marina (Huntington Beach, CA) | Clyde Austin | Maggie Walker (Richmond, VA) | David Colescott | Marion (Marion, IN) | Lowes Moore | Mount Vernon (Mt. Vernon, NY) | |
| 1977 | Albert King | Fort Hamilton (Brooklyn, NY) | Bobby Cattage | J.O. Johnson (Huntsville, AL) | Gilberto Salinas | Burbank (San Antonio, TX) | Larry Petty | Power Memorial (New York, NY) | |
| 1977 | Gene Banks | West Philadelphia (Philadelphia, PA) | Jeff Ruland | Sachem (Lake Ronkonkoma, NY) | Pete Budko | Loyola (Towson, MD) | Brian Peterson | Prior Lake (Prior Lake, MN) | |
| 1977 | Earvin Johnson | Everett (Lansing, MI) | Danny Vranes | Skyline (Salt Lake City, UT) | Brian Allsmiller | Buffalo Grove (Buffalo Grove, IL) | Ray Tolbert | Madison Heights (Anderson, IN) | |
| 1977 | Wayne McKoy | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville, NY) | Steve Risley | Central (Lawrence, IN) | Kelly Tripucka | Bloomfield (Bloomfield, NJ) | Ken Matthews | Dunbar (Washington, D.C.) | |
| 1977 | Reggie Hannah | Titusville (Titusville, FL) | Eddie Johnson | Westinghouse (Chicago, IL) | Sam Clancy | Fifth Avenue (Pittsburgh, PA) | Wes Matthews | Warren Harding (Bridgeport, CT) | |
| 1977 | James Ratiff | Eastern (Washington, D.C.) | Oliver Lee | DeLand (DeLand, FL) | Tracy Jackson | Paint Branch (Burtonsville, MD) | Dwan Chandler | Main Central Institute (Boston, MA) | |
| 1977 | Herb Williams | Marion-Franklin (Columbus, OH) | Drake Morris | Washington (East Chicago, IN) | Felton Sealey | Don Bosco Prep (Boston, MA) | George Ratkovich | Alhambra (Alhambra, CA) | |
| 1977 | Al Wood | Jones County (Gray, GA) | Danny Ainge | North Eugene (Eugene, OR) | Willie Sims | Long Island City (Long Island City, NY) | James Crockett | Helena (Helena, AR) | |
| 1977 | Jeff Lamp | Ballard (Louisville, KY) | Tom Freeman | Lynwood (Lynwood, CA) | Greg Boyle | Mundelein (Mundelein, IL) | Wilbert Singleton | Sumter (Sumter, SC) | |
| 1977 | Darnell Valentine | Wichita Heights (Wichita, KS) | Wilmore Fowler | Palmetto (Palmetto, FL) | Ed Thurman | Lynn Classical (Lynn, MA) | Ken Page | McKee (Staten Island, NY) | |
| 1978 | Dwight Anderson | Roth (Dayton, OH) | Micah Blunt | East Jefferson (Metairie, LA) | Mark Aguirre | Westinghouse (Chicago, IL) | Thad Garner | Bishop Noll (Hammond, IN) | |
| 1978 | Greg Goorjian | Crescenta Valley (La Crescenta, CA) | Chris Brust | Babylon (Babylon, NY) | Lewis Card | Auburn (Auburn, AL) | Kevin Greaney | Nazareth (Brooklyn, NY) | |
| 1978 | Reggie Jackson | Roman Catholic (Philadelphia, PA) | Wallace Bryant | Emerson (Gary, IN) | Dwan Chandler | Maine Central (Pittsfield, MA) | Rick Harmon | Middle Township (Cape May, NJ) | |
| 1978 | Earl Jones | Mount Hope (Mount Hope, WV) | Darius Clemons | Phillips (Chicago, IL) | Ken McAlister | Oakland (Oakland, CA) | Gary Holmes | Central (Miami, FL) | |
| 1978 | Leonel Marquetti | Verbum Dei (Los Angeles, CA) | Jerry Eaves | Ballard (Louisville, KY) | Howard McNeill | Glassboro (Glassboro, NJ) | Anthony Lee | John Tyler (Tyler, TX) | |
| 1978 | Darryl Mitchell | North Shore (West Palm Beach, FL) | Tony Guy | Loyola (Towson, MD) | Guy Morgan | First Colonial (Virginia Bech, VA) | Dave Magley | LaSalle (South Bend, IN) | |
| 1978 | Corny Thompson | Middletown (Middletown, CT) | Derrick Hord | Tennessee (Bristol, TN) | Fred Roberts | Bingham (Riverton, UT) | Dean Marquardt | Washington (Milwaukee, WI) | |
| 1978 | Clarence Tillman | West Philadelphia (Philadelphia, PA) | Dan Larson | Ventura (Ventura, CA) | Walker Russell | Central (Pontiac, MI) | Raymond McCoy | Bloom (Chicago Heights, IL) | |
| 1978 | Landon Turner | Tech (Indianapolis, IN) | Vince Taylor | Tates Creek (Lexington, KY) | Mike Sanders | De Ridder (De Ridder, LA) | Scooter McCray | Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon, NY) | |
| 1978 | Terry White | Eastwood (El Paso, TX) | James Worthy | Ashbrook (Gastonia, NC) | Guy Williams | Bishop O'Dowd (Oakland, CA) | Dirk Minniefield | Lafayette (Lexington, KY) | |
| 1979 | Sam Bowie | Lebanon (Lebanon, PA) | Tim Andree | Brother Rice (Birmingham, MI) | Steve Bouchie | Washington (Washington, IN) | Jim Braddock | Baylor (Chattanooga, TN) | |
| 1979 | Derrick Hord | Tennessee (Bristol, TN) | Antoine Carr | Wichita Heights (Wichita, KS) | Howard Carter | Redemptorist (Baton Rouge, LA) | Randy Breuer | Lake City (Lake City, MN) | |
| 1979 | Earl Jones | Mount Hope (Mount Hope, WV) | Quintin Dailey | Cardinal Gibbons (Baltimore, MD) | Patrick Ewing | Rindge Latin (Cambridge, MA) | Tony Bruin | Mater Christi (Queens, NY) | |
| 1979 | Clark Kellogg | St. Joseph's (Cleveland, OH) | Darren Daye | Kennedy (Granada Hills, CA) | Terry Fair | Southwest (Macon, GA) | Mike Davis | Fayette County (Fayette, AL) | |
| 1979 | Ricky Ross | South (Wichita, KS) | Rod Foster | Aquinas (New Britain, CT) | Sidney Green | Jefferson (Brooklyn, NY) | Dale Ellis | Marietta (Marietta, GA) | |
| 1979 | Ralph Sampson | Harrisonburg (Harrisonburg, VA) | Teddy Grubbs | M.L. King (Chicago, IL) | Charles Hurt | Shelby County (Shelbyville, KY) | Michael Holton | Pasadena (Pasadena, CA) | |
| 1979 | Steve Stipanovich | DeSmet Jesuit (St. Louis, MO) | Greg Kite | Madison (Houston, TX) | Darrell Lockhart | Lee (Thomaston, GA) | Joe James | Rayen (Youngstown, OH) | |
| 1979 | Isiah Thomas | St. Joseph's (Westchester, IL) | Raymond McCoy | Bloom Township (Chicago Heights, IL) | John Paxson | Alter (Kettering, OH) | Paul Little | Latin (Boston, MA) | |
| 1979 | Dominique Wilkins | Washington (Washington, NC) | Dirk Minniefield | Lafayette (Lexington, KY) | Rob Williams | Milby (Houston, TX) | Rodney McCray | Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon, NY) | |
| 1979 | James Worthy | Ashbrook (Gastonia, NC) | Charlie Sitton | McMinnville (McMinnville, OR) | Leon Wood | Saint Monica (Saint Monica, CA) | Byron Scott | Morningside (Inglewood, CA) | |

### 1980–1989

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 1980 | Russell Cross | Manley | James Banks | Hoke Smith | Donnell Allen | Murrah | Anthony Brown | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 1980 | Patrick Ewing | Rindge & Latin | Bret Bearup | Harborfields | Mike Brooks | Melrose | Freddie Brown | Adlai E. Stevenson | |
| 1980 | Vern Fleming | Mater Christi | Clarke Bynum | Wilson Hall Academy | Manuel Forrest | Moore | Tony Costner | Overbrook | |
| 1980 | Derek Harper | North Shore | Matt Doherty | Holy Trinity Diocesan | Dean Hopson | Huron | Greg Dreiling | Kapaun Mt. Carmel | |
| 1980 | Ralph Jackson | Inglewood | Kenny Fields | Verbum Dei | Ray Jones | Union | Carl Hill | Princeton Day | |
| 1980 | Earl Jones | Spingarn | Joe Kleine | Slater | Mike LaFave | Scecina Memorial | Pete Holbert | W. T. Woodson | |
| 1980 | Sam Perkins | Shaker | Jim Master | Paul Harding | Leonard Mitchell | St. Martinville | Al Miller | Ballard | |
| 1980 | Doc Rivers | Proviso East | Tim McCormick | Clarkston | Clayton Olivier | Los Amigos | Tim O'Shea | Wayland | |
| 1980 | Charlie Sitton | McMinnville | Ken Perry | South Spencer (Reo, Indiana) | Jim Petersen | St. Louis Park | Tom Sluby | Gonzaga College HS | |
| 1980 | Gary Springer | Benjamin Franklin | Barry Spencer | Catholic Central | Mike Wacker | San Marcos | Ennis Whatley | Phillips | |
| 1981 | Walter Downing | Providence Catholic | Mark Acres | Palos Verdes | John Brownlee | Southwest | Jeff Adkins | Martinsville | |
| 1981 | Greg Dreiling | Kapaun Mt. Carmel | Bobby Lee Hurt | S. R. Butler | Gerald Crosby | Parker | Uwe Blab | Effingham | |
| 1981 | Patrick Ewing | Rindge & Latin | Dwayne Johnson | Mater Christi | Mandy Johnson | St. Anthony | Adrian Branch | DeMatha | |
| 1981 | John Flowers | South Side | Ken Johnson | La Jolla | Eugene McDowell | Dixie County | Greg Cavener | Parkview | |
| 1981 | Manuel Forrest | Moore | Bill Martin | McKinley | Nigel Miguel | Notre Dame | Jimmy Miller | Princeton | |
| 1981 | Stuart Gray | John F. Kennedy | Michael Payne | Quincy | Ken Patterson | Forest Hills | Buzz Peterson | Asheville | |
| 1981 | Anthony Jones | Dunbar | Jeff Robinson | Broad Ripple | Dwayne Polee | Manual Arts | Ed Pinckney | Adlai E. Stevenson | |
| 1981 | Michael Jordan | Laney | Aubrey Sherrod | Wichita Heights | Johnny Rogers | La Quinta | Blair Rasmussen | Auburn | |
| 1981 | Sam Vincent | Eastern | Eric Turner | Flint Central | Greg Stokes | Hamilton | Joe Ward | Griffin | |
| 1981 | Ennis Whatley | Phillips | Milt Wagner | Camden | Billy Thompson | Camden | Bill Wennington | Long Island Lutheran | |
| 1982 | Benoit Benjamin | Carroll | Ken Barlow | Cathedral | Winston Bennett | Male | Mark Alarie | Brophy Prep | |
| 1982 | Kerry Boagni | Junípero Serra (Gardena) | Mark Cline | Williamson | Johnny Dawkins | Mackin Catholic | Len Bias | Northwestern | |
| 1982 | Brad Daugherty | Charles D. Owen | Bruce Douglas | Quincy Senior | Pat Ford | Cass Tech | Dell Curry | Fort Defiance | |
| 1982 | Curtis Hunter | Southern | Mike Giomi | Newark | Roger Harden | Valparaiso | Willie Cutts | Bryant | |
| 1982 | Ernie Myers | St. Nicholas of Tolentine | Buck Johnson | Hayes | Eldridge Hudson | Carson | Bruce Dalrymple | St. Johnsbury | |
| 1982 | Harold Pressley | St. Bernard | Brad Lohaus | Greenway | Ron Kellogg | Northwest | Paul Jokisch | Brother Rice | |
| 1982 | Richard Rellford | Suncoast | Dwayne Washington | Boys and Girls | Dave Popson | Bishop O'Reilly | Tim Kempton | St. Dominic | |
| 1982 | Billy Thompson | Camden | David Wingate | Dunbar | Tom Sheehey | McQuaid Jesuit | Lloyd Moore | Clairton | |
| 1982 | Wayman Tisdale | Booker T. Washington | Rickie Winslow | Yates | Kenny Walker | Crawford County | Kerry Trotter | Creighton Prep | |
| 1982 | Efrem Winters | King College Prep | Steve Woodside | Parkrose | Chris Washburn | Hickory | Butch Wade | Tech | |
| 1983 | Winston Bennett | Male | Dallas Comegys | Roman Catholic | Tommy Amaker | W. T. Woodson | Curtis Aiken | Bennett | |
| 1983 | James Blackmon | Marion | Bruce Dalrymple | St. Johnsbury | Mark Cline | Williamson | Johnny Fort | Wallace | |
| 1983 | Tom Curry | Redemptorist | Corey Gaines | St. Bernard's | Frank Ford | Osceola Senior | Willie Glass | Atlantic City | |
| 1983 | Antoine Joubert | Southwestern | Keith Gatlin | Conley | Todd Meier | Lourdes | Michael Graham | Spingarn | |
| 1983 | Dave Popson | Bishop O'Reilly | Kenny Hutchinson | Martin Luther King | Martin Nessley | Whitehall-Yearling | Scott Hicks | Cathedral | |
| 1983 | Tom Sheehey | McQuaid Jesuit | Carl Pollard | Mountain View | Gerald Perry | Dreher | Harold Jensen | Trumbull | |
| 1983 | Dwayne Washington | Boys and Girls | Kenny Smith | Archbishop Molloy | Michael Rutledge | Bibb County | Terry Long | Hermitage | |
| 1983 | Reggie Williams | Dunbar | Michael Smith | Los Altos | Daryl Thomas | St. Joseph | Russell Pierre | North Babylon | |
| 1983 | Rickie Winslow | Yates | Barry Sumpter | Lovejoy | Lawrence West | Morse | Rico Washington | Benjamin Franklin | |
| 1983 | Joe Wolf | Kohler | Chris Washburn | Fork Union Military | Curtis Wilson | St. Vincent-St. Mary | Nikita Wilson | Leesville | |
| 1984 | Delray Brooks | Rogers | Matt Beeuwsaert | Mater Dei | Ed Davender | Boys & Girls | Mike Abram | Northside | |
| 1984 | Mike Brown | Dunbar | Duane Ferrell | Calvert Hall | Craig Jackson | Montbello | Derrick Chievous | Holy Cross | |
| 1984 | Gary Grant | McKinley | Danny Ferry | DeMatha | Cedric Jenkins | Terrell County | Herman Harried | Dunbar | |
| 1984 | Tony Kimbro | Seneca | Lowell Hamilton | Providence St. Mel | Tom Lewis | Mater Dei | Tyrone Jones | Dunbar | |
| 1984 | Al Lorenzen | John F. Kennedy | Jeff Lebo | Carlisle | Troy Lewis | Anderson | Wally Lancaster | Calvin Coolidge | |
| 1984 | Richard Madison | Northside | Derrick Lewis | Archbishop Carroll | Robert Lock | Reedley | Mitchell Lee | American | |
| 1984 | Danny Manning | Lawrence | Kevin Madden | Robert E. Lee | Craig McMillan | Cloverdale | Roger McClendon | Centennial | |
| 1984 | Charles Smith | Warren Harding | David Rivers | St. Anthony | Steve Miller | Henry Clay | Kenny Sanders | McKinley Tech | |
| 1984 | Chris Washburn | Laurinburg Institute | Chris Sandle | Long Beach Polytechnic | Kevin Strickland | North Surrey | Ranzino Smith | Chapel Hill | |
| 1984 | John Williams | Crenshaw | Kevin Walls | Camden | John Thompson | Brunswick | Leonard Taylor | St. Bernard | |
| 1985 | Danny Ferry | DeMatha | Steve Bucknall | Governor Dummer Academy | Lance Blanks | McCullough | Mike Christian | Mullen | |
| 1985 | Lowell Hamilton | Providence St. Mel | Rick Calloway | Withrow | David Butler | Calvin Coolidge | Terry Dozier | Dunbar | |
| 1985 | Tom Hammonds | Crestview | Ron Huery | Whitehaven | Jonathan Edwards | O. P. Walker | Terence Greene | Central | |
| 1985 | Tito Horford | Marian Christian | Tony Kimbro | Seneca | Ed Horton | Lanphier | Boo Harvey | Andrew Jackson | |
| 1985 | Mike Jones | Oak Hill Academy | Walker Lambiotte | Central | Jerome Lane | St. Vincent-St. Mary's | Fess Irvin | East Ascension | |
| 1985 | Jeff Lebo | Carlisle | Tom Lewis | Mater Dei | Toney Mack | Brandon | Darryl Prue | Dunbar | |
| 1985 | Kevin Madden | Robert E. Lee | Kenny Payne | Northeast Jones | Roy Marble | Beecher | Glen Rice | Northwestern | |
| 1985 | Terry Mills | Romulus | Pooh Richardson | Benjamin Franklin | Richard Morgan | Salem | Charles Shackleford | Kinston | |
| 1985 | J. R. Reid | Kempsville | Doug Roth | Karns | Jerry Pryor | Southeast Bulloch County | Anthony Sherrod | Jenkins County | |
| 1985 | Rod Strickland | Oak Hill Academy | Roland Shelton | Columbia | Dennis Scott | Flint Hill Prep | Rodney Walker | Cardinal Gibbons | |
| 1985 | Irving Thomas | Miami Carol City | Mark Stevenson | Roman Catholic | Trevor Wilson | Grover Cleveland | Doug West | Altoona | |
| 1986 | Dwayne Bryant | De La Salle | Nelison Anderson | Simeon | Sean Higgins | Fairfax | Alaa Abdelnaby | Bloomfield | |
| 1986 | Rex Chapman | Apollo | Barry Bekkedam | Archbishop Carroll | Ron Huery | Whitehaven | Pete Chilcutt | Tuscaloosa Academy | |
| 1986 | Lloyd Daniels | Andrew Jackson | Chris Brooks | Oak Hill Academy | Sam Jefferson | Flint Hill | Phil Henderson | Crete-Monee | |
| 1986 | Fess Irvin | East Ascension | Perry Carter | Gonzaga College HS | Treg Lee | St. Joseph | Shawn Kemp | Concord | |
| 1986 | Ricky Jones | Pendleton | Sylvester Gray | Bolton | Eric Manuel | Southwest | Andy Kennedy | Louisville | |
| 1986 | Marcus Liberty | Martin Luther King | Alonzo Mourning | Indian River | Derrick Miller | Bible Baptist | Jerrod Mustaf | DeMatha | |
| 1986 | Terry Mills | Romulus | Larry Rembert | Keith | Chris Munk | Riordan | King Rice | Binghamton | |
| 1986 | Anthony Pendleton | Northwestern | Dennis Scott | Flint Hill | James Munlyn | South Aiken | Keith Robinson | Grover Cleveland | |
| 1986 | J. R. Reid | Kempsville | Felton Spencer | Eastern | Brian Oliver | Wills | Dwayne Schintzius | Brandon | |
| 1986 | Rumeal Robinson | Rindge & Latin | Stephen Thompson | Crenshaw | Mark Randall | Cherry Creek | Larry Smith | Alton | |
| 1986 | LaBradford Smith | Bay City | Scott Williams | Glen A. Wilson | Brian Shorter | Simon Gratz | Mark Tillmon | Gonzaga College HS | |
| 1987 | Perry Carter | Maine Central Institute | Kenny Anderson | Archbishop Molloy | Richard Dumas | Booker T. Washington | Eric Anderson | St. Francis de Sales | |
| 1987 | LeRon Ellis | Mater Dei | Eli Brewster | Wehrle Memorial | Mark Georgeson | Marina | Vic Carstarphen | Camden | |
| 1987 | Larry Johnson | Skyline | John Crotty | Christian Brothers Academy | Christian Laettner | Nichols | Livingston Chatman | Kathleen | |
| 1987 | Marcus Liberty | Martin Luther King | Jay Edwards | Marion | Mike Maddox | Putnam City North | Chris Corchiani | Hialeah-Miami Lakes | |
| 1987 | Mark Macon | Buena Vista | Jerome Harmon | Lew Wallace | Bobby Martin | Atlantic City | Brian Garner | Booker T. Washington | |
| 1987 | Eric Manuel | Southwest | Sean Higgins | Fairfax | Jerrod Mustaf | DeMatha | Bill Heppner | Crystal Lake Central | |
| 1987 | Rodney Monroe | St. Maria Goretti | Chris Jackson | Gulfport | Billy Owens | Carlisle | Chris Jent | Sparta | |
| 1987 | Alonzo Mourning | Indian River | Shawn Kemp | Concord | John Pittman | Terry | Lyndon Jones | Marion | |
| 1987 | Dennis Scott | Flint Hill | Greg Koubek | Shenendehowa | Stanley Roberts | Lower Richland | César Portillo | Miami Senior | |
| 1987 | Brian Shorter | Oak Hill Academy | Treg Lee | St. Joseph | Everick Sullivan | Hillcrest | Doug Smith | Mackenzie | |
| 1987 | LaBradford Smith | Bay City | Chris Mills | Fairfax | David White | Boca Ciega | Elmore Spencer | Booker T. Washington | |
| 1987 | Anthony Tucker | McKinley Technical | King Rice | Binghamton | Brian Williams | Santa Monica | David Whitmore | St. Bernard | |
| 1988 | Kenny Anderson | Archbishop Molloy | Eric Anderson | St. Francis de Sales | Arron Bain | Flint Hill | Damon Bailey | Bedford-North Lawrence | |
| 1988 | LaPhonso Ellis | Lincoln | Milton Bell | John Marshall | Mark Baker | Dunbar | Harold Boudreaux | Cecilia | |
| 1988 | Chris Jackson | Gulfport | Christian Laettner | Nichols | Elmer Bennett | Bellaire | Antoine Davison | Collins | |
| 1988 | Jim Jackson | Macomber-Whitney | Don MacLean | Simi Valley | Todd Day | Hamilton | Jamal Faulkner | Christ the King | |
| 1988 | Shawn Kemp | Concord | Jerrod Mustaf | DeMatha | Marc Dowdell | Christian Brothers Academy | Robert Horry | Andalusia | |
| 1988 | Darrick Martin | St. Anthony | Anthony Peeler | Paseo | Litterial Green | Moss Point | Bobby Hurley | St. Anthony | |
| 1988 | Chris Mills | Fairfax | Stacey Poole | Forrest | Donald Hodge | Coolidge | Chris Jent | Sparta | |
| 1988 | Alonzo Mourning | Indian River | César Portillo | Miami Senior | Zan Mason | Westchester | Adam Keefe | Woodbridge | |
| 1988 | Billy Owens | Carlisle | Matt Steigenga | South Christian | Conrad McRae | Brooklyn Tech | Lee Mayberry | Will Rogers | |
| 1988 | Stanley Roberts | Lower Richland | Everick Sullivan | Hillcrest | Crawford Palmer | Washington Lee | Mike Peplowski | De La Salle | |
| 1988 | Malik Sealy | St. Nicholas of Tolentine | Robert Werdann | Archbishop Molloy | Chris Smith | Kolbe Cathedral | Orlando Vega | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 1988 | Kenny Williams | Northeastern | David Young | Greenville | Bryant Stith | Brunswick | Greg Woodward | McQuaid Jesuit | |
| 1989 | Kenny Anderson | Archbishop Molloy | Adrian Autry | St. Nicholas of Tolentine | Shawn Bradley | Emery County | Anthony Douglas | East | |
| 1989 | Arron Bain | Flint Hill Prep | Damon Bailey | Bedford-North Lawrence | Mitchell Butler | Oakwood | Mike Hughes | Peoria | |
| 1989 | Doug Edwards | Miami Senior | Darryl Barnes | Franklin K. Lane | Deryl Cunningham | St. Joseph | Lee Mayberry | Cheyenne East | |
| 1989 | Darrin Hancock | Griffin | Carroll Boudreaux | Cecilia | Travis Ford | Madisonville North Hopkins | Billy McCaffrey | Central Catholic | |
| 1989 | Allan Houston | Ballard | Jamie Brandon | Martin Luther King | Shaun Golden | Riverside | Eric Mobley | Salesian | |
| 1989 | Bobby Hurley | St. Anthony | Calvin Byrd | St. Joseph Notre Dame | Greg Graham | Warren Central | Dwayne Morton | Central | |
| 1989 | Jim Jackson | Macomber-Whitney | Jamal Faulkner | Christ the King | Orlando Lightfoot | Chattanooga | Lloyd Mumford | Lexington | |
| 1989 | Ed O'Bannon | Artesia | Michael Tate | Oxon Hill | Malcolm Mackey | Brainerd | Chris Reynolds | Peoria Central | |
| 1989 | Shaquille O'Neal | Robert G. Cole | Jeff Webster | Carl Albert | Zan Mason | Westchester | James Robinson | Murrah | |
| 1989 | Deon Thomas | Simeon | Matt Wenstrom | Mayde Creek | Conrad McRae | Brooklyn Tech | Tony Tolbert | St. Martin DePorres | |

### 1990–1999

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 1990 | Damon Bailey | Bedford-North Lawrence | Travis Best | Springfield Central | Adrian Autry | St. Nicholas of Tolentine | Fred Burley | Douglass | |
| 1990 | Penny Hardaway | Treadwell | Shawn Bradley | Emery County | Lee Green | Cheshire Academy | Brandon Cole | Bloom | |
| 1990 | Darrin Hancock | Griffin | Jamie Brandon | Martin Luther King | Grant Hill | South Lakes | Jevon Crudup | Raytown | |
| 1990 | Alan Henderson | Brebeuf Prep | Anthony Cade | Oak Hill Academy | Antonio Lang | LeFlore | Anthony Harris | Danbury | |
| 1990 | Eric Montross | Lawrence North | Bill Curley | Duxbury | Greg Minor | Washington County | Rodrick Rhodes | St. Anthony | |
| 1990 | Dwayne Morton | Central | Jamal Mashburn | Cardinal Hayes | Rodney Rogers | Hillside | Jalen Rose | Southwestern | |
| 1990 | Ed O'Bannon | Artesia | Derrick Phelps | Christ the King | Michael Smith | Dunbar | Melvin Simon | Archbishop Shaw | |
| 1990 | Cherokee Parks | Marina | Brian Reese | St. Nicholas of Tolentine | Pat Sullivan | Bogota | Kendrick Warren | Thomas Jefferson | |
| 1990 | Clifford Rozier | Southeast | Khalid Reeves | Christ the King | Shon Tarver | Santa Clara | Jamie Watson | Fike | |
| 1990 | Chris Webber | Detroit Country Day | Luther Wright | Elizabeth | Rodney Zimmerman | Air Academy | Thomas Wyatt | East Aurora | |
| 1991 | Cory Alexander | Oak Hill Academy | Orlando Antigua | St. Raymond | Percy Eberhart | Clarke Central | Derrick Carroll | Eau Claire | |
| 1991 | Travis Best | Springfield Central | Ben Davis | Oak Hill Academy | Othella Harrington | Murrah | Anthony Harris | Danbury | |
| 1991 | James Forrest | Southside | Jimmy King | Plano East | Keith LeGree | Statesboro | Donyell Marshall | Reading | |
| 1991 | Alan Henderson | Brebeuf Prep | Voshon Lenard | Southwestern | Loren Meyer | Ruthven-Ayrshire | Al Segova | Auburn | |
| 1991 | Juwan Howard | Chicago Vocational | Erik Meek | San Pasqual Escondido | Calvin Rayford | Washington | Duane Simpkins | DeMatha | |
| 1991 | Jason Kidd | St. Joseph Notre Dame | Howard Nathan | Manual | David Vaughn | Whites Creek | Greg Simpson | Lima Senior | |
| 1991 | Tom Kleinschmidt | Gordon Tech | Rodrick Rhodes | St. Anthony | Jayson Walton | Justin F. Kimball | Duane Spencer | Walter L. Cohen | |
| 1991 | Cherokee Parks | Marina | Jalen Rose | Southwestern | Antonio Watson | Eastmoor | Andre Riddick | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | |
| 1991 | Glenn Robinson | Roosevelt | Glen Whisby | Brookhaven | Corliss Williamson | Russellville | Donald Williams | Garner | |
| 1991 | Chris Webber | Detroit Country Day | Sharone Wright | Southwest | Bubba Wilson | Stone County | Julian Winfield | Cardinal Ritter Prep | |
| 1992 | Donta Bright | Dunbar | Damon Flint | Woodward | Joey Beard | South Lakes | Tony Delk | Haywood | |
| 1992 | Othella Harrington | Murrah | Ronnie Henderson | Murrah | Percy Eberhart | Clarke Central | Jerald Honeycutt | Grambling Laboratory | |
| 1992 | Jason Kidd | St. Joseph Notre Dame | Richard Keene | Collinsville | Steve Edwards | Miami Country Day | Chris Kingsbury | Hamilton | |
| 1992 | Randy Livingston | Isidore Newman School | Felipe López | Rice | Michael Evans | Booker T. Washington | Jason Lawson | Olney | |
| 1992 | Martice Moore | Oak Hill Academy | Charles Macon | Michigan City | Sylvester Ford | Fairley | Kenyon Murray | Central | |
| 1992 | Rodrick Rhodes | St. Anthony | Darnell Robinson | Emery | Rashard Griffith | King College Prep | Charles O'Bannon | Artesia | |
| 1992 | Jerry Stackhouse | Oak Hill Academy | Greg Simpson | Lima Senior | Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | Duane Simpkins | DeMatha | |
| 1992 | Carlos Strong | Cedar Shoals | Jacque Vaughn | John Muir | Chuck Kornegay | Southern Wayne | Duane Spencer | W. L. Cohen | |
| 1992 | Rasheed Wallace | Simon Gratz | John Wallace | Greece Athena | Walter McCarty | Harrison | Vandale Thomas | Lawrence County | |
| 1992 | Corliss Williamson | Russellville | Dontonio Wingfield | Westover | Serge Zwikker | Harker Preparatory School | DeJuan Wheat | Ballard | |
| 1993 | Bobby Crawford | Eisenhower | Joey Beard | South Lakes | Damon Flint | Woodward | Rayshard Allen | John B. Ehret | |
| 1993 | Ronnie Henderson | Murrah | Keith Booth | Dunbar | Kiwane Garris | Westinghouse Vocational | Marcus Camby | Hartford Public | |
| 1993 | Allen Iverson | Bethel | Rashard Griffith | King College Prep | Omm'A Givens | Aberdeen | Jeff Capel | South View | |
| 1993 | Randy Livingston | Isidore Newman School | Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | Cedric Henderson | Memphis East | James Collins | Andrew Jackson | |
| 1993 | Felipe López | Rice | Jason Lawson | Olney | Jerald Honeycutt | Grambling Laboratory | Dan Earl | Shawnee | |
| 1993 | Charles O'Bannon | Artesia | Antonio McDyess | Quitman | Avondre Jones | Artesia | Sylvester Ford | Fairley | |
| 1993 | Jerry Stackhouse | Oak Hill Academy | Jason Osborne | Louisville Male | Jeff McInnis | Oak Hill Academy | Charles Gelatt | Chenango Valley | |
| 1993 | Jacque Vaughn | John Muir | Andrae Patterson | Cooper | Scot Pollard | Torrey Pines | Willie Mitchell | Pershing | |
| 1993 | Rasheed Wallace | Simon Gratz | Terrance Roberson | Buena Vista | Joe Smith | Maury | Jess Settles | Winfield-Mount Union | |
| 1993 | Dontonio Wingfield | Westover | Darnell Robinson | Emery | Lee Wilson | Waco | Jeff Sheppard | McIntosh | |
| 1994 | Kevin Garnett | Farragut Career Academy | Jelani Gardner | St. John Bosco | Ronnie Fields | Farragut Career Academy | Ishua Benjamin | Concord | |
| 1994 | Zendon Hamilton | Sewanhaka | LaMarr Greer | Middle Township | Danny Fortson | Shaler Area | Chauncey Billups | George Washington | |
| 1994 | Felipe López | Rice | Chris Herren | Durfree | Adonal Foyle | Hamilton Central School | Mark Blount | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 1994 | Corey Louis | Miami Northwestern | Raef LaFrentz | MFL Mar-Mac | Omm'A Givens | Aberdeen | Luther Clay | Maine Central Institute | |
| 1994 | Stephon Marbury | Abraham Lincoln | Trajan Langdon | East Anchorage | Charlie Miller | South Miami | Lester Earl | Glen Oaks | |
| 1994 | Ron Mercer | Oak Hill Academy | Willie Mitchell | Pershing | Norman Nolan | Dunbar | Prince Fowler | Western | |
| 1994 | Bryant Notree | Simeon Career Academy | Tyrone Nesby | Cairo | Curtis Staples | Oak Hill Academy | Tremaine Fowlkes | Crenshaw | |
| 1994 | Andrae Patterson | Cooper | Terrance Roberson | Buena Vista | Mo Taylor | Henry Ford | Derek Hood | Central | |
| 1994 | Antoine Walker | Mount Carmel | Tim Thomas | Paterson Catholic | Samaki Walker | Whitehall | Ricky Price | Carson | |
| 1994 | Jerod Ward | Clinton | Lorenzen Wright | Booker T. Washington | Jahidi White | Cardinal Ritter College Prep | Kellii Taylor | Archbishop Carroll | |
| 1995 | Shareef Abdur-Rahim | Joseph Wheeler | Chauncey Billups | George Washington | Courtney Alexander | Charles E. Jordan | Lucas Barnes | South Miami | |
| 1995 | Ryan Blackwell | Sutherland | Rasheed Brokenborough | University City | Gary Bell | Joliet Township | Kobe Bryant | Lower Merion | |
| 1995 | Vince Carter | Mainland | Louis Bullock | Laurel Baptist Academy | Mark Blount | Oak Hill Academy | Chris Carrawell | Cardinal Ritter College Prep | |
| 1995 | Kevin Garnett | Farragut Career Academy | Taymon Domzalski | New Mexico Military Institute | Lester Earl | Glen Oaks | Luther Clay | Maine Central Institute | |
| 1995 | Stephon Marbury | Abraham Lincoln | Shaheen Holloway | St. Patrick | Ronnie Fields | Farragut Career Academy | Schea Cotton | St. Thomas More Prep | |
| 1995 | Ron Mercer | Oak Hill Academy | Derek Hood | Central | Tim James | Miami Northwestern | Bobby Joe Evans | McKinney | |
| 1995 | Tim Thomas | Paterson Catholic | Randell Jackson | The Winchendon School | Jermaine O'Neal | Eau Claire | Michael Gill | Dunbar | |
| 1995 | Robert Traylor | Murray-Wright | BJ McKie | Irmo | Sam Okey | Cassville | Melvin Levett | Euclid | |
| 1995 | Wayne Turner | Beaver Country Day | Paul Pierce | Inglewood | God Shammgod | La Salle Academy | Ricky Moore | Westside | |
| 1995 | Albert White | Inkster | Terrance Roberson | Buena Vista | Kenny Thomas | Albuquerque | Tyrone Washington | Mississippi State | |
| 1996 | Mike Bibby | Shadow Mountain | Lucas Barnes | South Miami | Jerald Brown | Aldine (Houston) | Malik Allen | Shawnee | |
| 1996 | Kobe Bryant | Lower Merion | Shane Battier | Detroit Country Day School | Mike Chappell | Southfield-Lathrup | Mike Babul | North Attleboro | |
| 1996 | Mateen Cleaves | Flint Northern | Corey Benjamin | Fontana | Jaraan Cornell | Clay | Nick Bradford | Fayetteville | |
| 1996 | Schea Cotton | St. Thomas More Prep | Jason Collier | Catholic Central | Ramel Lloyd | Cardinal Hayes | Ronald Curry | Hampton | |
| 1996 | Lester Earl | Glen Oaks | Ed Cota | St. Thomas More Prep | Olujimi Mann | Santa Ana Valley | Anthony Dent | Calhoun County | |
| 1996 | Ronnie Fields | Farragut Career Academy | Devonaire Deas | Albany | Doc Robinson | Selma | Willie Dersch | Holy Cross | |
| 1996 | Jermaine O'Neal | Eau Claire | Richard Hamilton | Coatesville Area | Mike Robinson | Richwoods | Vassil Evtimov | Long Island Lutheran | |
| 1996 | Lamar Odom | St. Thomas Aquinas Prep | Charles Hathaway | Hillwood | Jermaine Walker | Blanche Ely | David Jackson | Wilson | |
| 1996 | Tim Thomas | Paterson Catholic | Shaheen Holloway | St. Patrick | Vincent Whitt | Dudley | Derrick Thomas | Booker T. Washington | |
| 1996 | Winfred Walton | Pershing | Stephen Jackson | Oak Hill Academy | Loren Woods | Cardinal Ritter College Prep | Mohamed Woni | Prospect Hill | |
| 1997 | Shane Battier | Detroit Country Day School | Marcus Griffin | Manual | William Avery | Westside | Myron Anthony | Fletcher | |
| 1997 | Elton Brand | Peekskill | Larry Hughes | Christian Brothers College | Kenny Brunner | Dominguez | Charlie Bell | Flint Southwestern Academy | |
| 1997 | Chris Burgess | Woodbridge | Ryan Humphrey | Booker T. Washington | Khalid El-Amin | North Community | Eric Chenowith | Villa Park | |
| 1997 | Baron Davis | Crossroads School | Britton Johnsen | Murray | Marcus Fizer | Arcadia | Jarron Collins | Harvard-Westlake School | |
| 1997 | Melvin Ely | Thornton Township | Jumaine Jones | Mitchell-Baker | Tony Harris | Memphis East | Jason Collins | Harvard-Westlake School | |
| 1997 | Dion Glover | Cedar Grove | Corey Maggette | Fenwick | Brendan Haywood | James B. Dudley | Greedy Daniels | Cohen | |
| 1997 | Tracy McGrady | Mt. Zion Christian Academy | Chris Owens | Duncanville | Mark Karcher | St. Frances Academy | Ricky Davis | Iowa | |
| 1997 | Lamar Odom | St. Thomas Aquinas Prep | Anthony Perry | St. Anthony | Chris Mihm | Westlake | Kenny Gregory | Independence | |
| 1997 | JaRon Rush | The Pembroke Hill School | Luke Recker | DeKalb | Max Owens | Mt. Zion Christian Academy | Terence Morris | Governor Thomas Johnson | |
| 1997 | Korleone Young | Hargrave Military Academy | Ron Artest | La Salle Academy | Estaban Weaver | Independence | Edmund Saunders | Holy Cross | |
| 1998 | Ronald Curry | Hampton | Keith Bogans | DeMatha Catholic | Carlos Boozer | Juneau-Douglas | Jonathan Bender | Picayune | |
| 1998 | Dan Gadzuric | The Governor's Academy | Jason Capel | Saint John's Catholic Prep | Jeff Boschee | Valley City | Sam Clancy Jr. | St. Edward | |
| 1998 | Al Harrington | St. Patrick | Cory Hightower | Mt. Zion Christian Academy | Rasual Butler | Roman Catholic High School for Boys | Jason Gardner | North Central | |
| 1998 | DerMarr Johnson | Maine Central Institute | Kevin Lyde | Oak Hill Academy | Ajou Deng | Milford Academy | Donnell Harvey | Randolph-Clay | |
| 1998 | Rashard Lewis | Alief Elsik | Corey Maggette | Fenwick | Keyon Dooling | Dillard | Richard Jefferson | Moon Valley | |
| 1998 | Joel Przybilla | Monticello | Mike Miller | Mitchell | Teddy Dupay | Mariner | Kris Lang | Hunter Huss | |
| 1998 | JaRon Rush | The Pembroke Hill School | Tayshaun Prince | Dominguez | Dane Fife | Clarkston | Danny Miller | Rancocas Valley Regional | |
| 1998 | Stromile Swift | Fair Park | Quentin Richardson | Whitney Young | Adam Harrington | Pioneer Valley | Brett Nelson | St. Albans | |
| 1998 | Vincent Yarbrough | Cleveland | Frankie Williams | Manual | Marvin Stone | Virgil I. Grissom | J. R. VanHoose | Paintsville | |
| 1998 | Korleone Young | Hargrave Military Academy | Ray Young | St. Joseph Notre Dame | B. B. Waldon | Kathleen | Doug Wrenn | O'Dea | |
| 1999 | Jonathan Bender | Picayune | Nick Collison | Iowa Falls | Samuel Dalembert | St. Patrick | Matt Bonner | Concord | |
| 1999 | LaVell Blanchard | Ann Arbor Pioneer | Brian Cook | Lincoln Community | Mike Dunleavy Jr. | Jesuit | Marcus Cox | Kolbe Cathedral | |
| 1999 | Keith Bogans | DeMatha Catholic | Jamal Crawford | Rainier Beach | Chuck Eidson | Pinewood Preparatory School | Marquis Daniels | Mt. Zion Christian Academy | |
| 1999 | Carlos Boozer | Juneau-Douglas | Jason Gardner | North Central | Alton Ford | Milby | Kevin Gaines | Clark | |
| 1999 | Joseph Forte | DeMatha Catholic | Casey Jacobsen | Glendora | Drew Gooden | El Cerrito | Rod Grizzard | Central Park Christian | |
| 1999 | Donnell Harvey | Randolph-Clay | Brett Nelson | St. Albans | Majestic Mapp | St. Raymond High School for Boys | Donnell Knight | Corona del Sol | |
| 1999 | DerMarr Johnson | Maine Central Institute | Jason Richardson | Arthur Hill | Jason Parker | Memorial | Stéphane Pelle | Mercersburg Academy | |
| 1999 | Marvin Stone | Virgil I. Grissom | Marcus Taylor | Waverly | Leon Smith | King College Prep | Kareem Rush | The Pembroke Hill School | |
| 1999 | Jay Williams | St. Joseph | Damien Wilkins | Dr. Phillips | Travis Watson | Oak Hill Academy | Marshall Williams | Vincent | |

### 2000–2009

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 2000 | Omar Cook | Christ the King | Mario Austin | Sumter County | Nick Anderson | Louisiana State University Laboratory School | Cedrick Banks | Westinghouse Vocational | |
| 2000 | Chris Duhon | Salmen | Andre Barrett | Rice | Travon Bryant | Jordan | Brian Boddicker | Duncanville | |
| 2000 | Eddie Griffin | Roman Catholic High School for Boys | Andre Brown | Leo Catholic | Abdou Diame | Oak Hill Academy | Adam Boone | Minnetonka | |
| 2000 | Jerome Harper | Keenan | Taliek Brown | St. John's Preparatory School | Neil Fingleton | Holy Name Central Catholic | Cliff Hawkins | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 2000 | Jared Jeffries | Bloomington High School North | Tyson Chandler | Dominguez | Orien Greene | Gainesville | A. J. Moye | Westlake | |
| 2000 | Darius Miles | East St. Louis Senior | Eddy Curry | Thornwood | Hervé Lamizana | St. Patrick | Ricky Paulding | Renaissance | |
| 2000 | Zach Randolph | Marion | Alton Ford | Milby | Garner Meads | Bridgton Academy | Justin Reed | Provine | |
| 2000 | DeShawn Stevenson | Washington Union | Rolando Howell | Lower Richland | Darius Rice | Lanier | Luke Ridnour | Blaine | |
| 2000 | Marcus Taylor | Waverly | Imari Sawyer | King College Prep | Scooter Sherrill | West Rowan | Eddie Starks | Miami Northwest Christian Academy | |
| 2000 | Gerald Wallace | Childersburg | Dajuan Wagner | Camden | Kelvin Torbert | Northwestern | Marcus Toney-El | Seton Hall Prep | |
| 2001 | Kwame Brown | Glynn Academy | John Allen | Coatesville Area | Rashaad Carruth | Oak Hill Academy | Alan Anderson | De La Salle | |
| 2001 | Tyson Chandler | Dominguez | Cedric Bozeman | Mater Dei | Josh Childress | Mayfair | Travis Diener | Goodrich | |
| 2001 | Ousmane Cisse | St. Jude | T. J. Ford | Willowridge | Billy Edelin | Oak Hill Academy | Channing Frye | St. Mary's | |
| 2001 | Eddy Curry | Thornwood | Julius Hodge | St. Raymond | Raymond Felton | Latta | Quemont Greer | The Berkshire School | |
| 2001 | DeSagana Diop | Oak Hill Academy | LeBron James | St. Vincent St. Mary | Carlos Hurt | Moore | Chuck Hayes | Modesto Christian | |
| 2001 | David Harrison | Brentwood Academy | Aaron Miles | Jefferson | Pierre Pierce | Westmont | Rashad McCants | New Hampton School | |
| 2001 | David Lee | Chaminade College Preparatory School | Shavlik Randolph | Broughton | Anthony Richardson | Leesville | Earnest Shelton | White Station | |
| 2001 | Rick Rickert | Duluth East | Wayne Simien | Leavenworth | Anthony Roberson | Saginaw (Saginaw, Mich.) | Chris Thomas | Pike | |
| 2001 | Kelvin Torbert | Northwestern | James White | Hargrave Military Academy | Jamal Sampson | Mater Dei | Levi Watkins | Montrose Christian School | |
| 2001 | Dajuan Wagner | Camden | Jawad Williams | St. Edward | Mo Williams | Murrah | Shelden Williams | Midwest | |
| 2002 | Carmelo Anthony | Oak Hill Academy | Hassan Adams | Westchester | Mahmoud Abdul-Awwel | Woodrow Wilson | Derrick Byars | Ridgeway | |
| 2002 | Chris Bosh | Lincoln | Kevin Bookout | Stroud | Rashad Anderson | Kathleen | Alexander Johnson | Dougherty Comprehensive | |
| 2002 | Paul Davis | Rochester | Torin Francis | Tabor Academy | Brad Buckman | Westlake | Jimmy McKinney | Vashon | |
| 2002 | Raymond Felton | Latta | Jason Fraser | Amityville Memorial | Evan Burns | Fairfax | Gerry McNamara | Bishop Hannan | |
| 2002 | LeBron James | St. Vincent St. Mary | Daniel Horton | Cedar Hill | DeAngelo Collins | Inglewood | Steve Novak | Brown Deer | |
| 2002 | Sean May | Bloomington North | Andre Iguodala | Lanphier | Travis Garrison | DeMatha Catholic | Curtis Sumpter | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | |
| 2002 | Rashad McCants | New Hampton School | Elijah Ingram | St. Anthony | Jeff Horner | Mason City | Michael Thompson | Providence Catholic | |
| 2002 | Shavlik Randolph | Broughton | Kendrick Perkins | Ozen | Leon Powe | Oakland Technical | C. J. Watson | Bishop Gorman | |
| 2002 | Anthony Roberson | Saginaw (Saginaw, Mich.) | JJ Redick | Cave Spring | Eric Williams | Wake Forest-Rolesville | John Winchester | Milford | |
| 2002 | Amar'e Stoudemire | Cypress Creek | Bracey Wright | The Colony | Antoine Wright | Lawrence Academy at Groton | Kennedy Winston | Blount | |
| 2003 | Shannon Brown | Proviso East | Trevor Ariza | Westchester | Aaron Brooks | Benjamin Franklin | Ronnie Brewer | Fayetteville | |
| 2003 | Brian Butch | Appleton West | Brandon Bass | Capitol | J. R. Giddens | John Marshall | Olu Famutimi | Flint Northwestern | |
| 2003 | Luol Deng | Blair Academy | Jackie Butler | Coastal Christian Academy | Mike Jones | Thayer Academy | Daniel Gibson | Jesse H. Jones | |
| 2003 | Ndudi Ebi | Westbury Christian School | Brandon Cotton | Saint Martin de Porres | Linas Kleiza | Montrose Christian School | Ivan Harris | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 2003 | Kris Humphries | Hopkins | Dion Harris | Redford | Régis Koundjia | Laurinburg Institute | Shaun Livingston | Peoria Central | |
| 2003 | LeBron James | St. Vincent St. Mary | Ekene Ibekwe | Carson | Mike Nardi | St. Patrick | Cartier Martin | Aldine Nimitz | |
| 2003 | David Padgett | Reno | Drew Lavender | Brookhaven | Demetris Nichols | St. Andrew's | Rich McBride | Lanphier | |
| 2003 | Chris Paul | West Forsyth | Travis Outlaw | Starkville | Terrence Roberts | St. Anthony | Paul Millsap | Grambling Laboratory | |
| 2003 | Kendrick Perkins | Ozen | Sebastian Telfair | Abraham Lincoln | Rodrick Stewart | Rainier Beach | Ayinde Ubaka | Oakland Technical | |
| 2003 | Leon Powe | Oakland Technical | Von Wafer | Heritage Christian Academy | Chris Taft | Xaverian | Darius Washington | Edgewater | |
| 2004 | Glen Davis | Louisiana State University Laboratory School | LaMarcus Aldridge | Seagoville | Arron Afflalo | Centennial | Corey Brewer | Portland | |
| 2004 | Rudy Gay | Archbishop Spalding | Joe Crawford | Renaissance | Monta Ellis | Lanier | Toney Douglas | Jonesboro | |
| 2004 | Malik Hairston | Renaissance | Jordan Farmar | William Howard Taft | Richard Hendrix | Athens | Tasmin Mitchell | Denham Springs | |
| 2004 | Dwight Howard | Southwest Atlanta Christian Academy | Daniel Gibson | Jesse H. Jones | Jason Horton | Cedar Hill | Drew Neitzel | Wyoming Park (Wyoming, Mich.) | |
| 2004 | Al Jefferson | Prentiss | Jawann McClellan | Milby | Randolph Morris | Landmark Christian | Gabe Pruitt | Westchester | |
| 2004 | Shaun Livingston | Peoria Central | DeMarcus Nelson | Sheldon | Greg Oden | Lawrence North | A. J. Ratliff | North Central | |
| 2004 | Josh Smith | Oak Hill Academy | Rajon Rondo | Oak Hill Academy | Jason Rich | Dr. Phillips | Russell Robinson | Rice | |
| 2004 | Sebastian Telfair | Abraham Lincoln | J. R. Smith | Saint Benedict's Preparatory School | Josh Shipp | Fairfax | Cedric Simmons | West Brunswick | |
| 2004 | Darius Washington | Edgewater | Ronald Steele | John Carroll Catholic | Lou Williams | South Gwinnett | Robert Vaden | Bridgton Academy | |
| 2004 | Marvin Williams | Bremerton | Robert Swift | Bakersfield | Mike Williams | Wilcox Central | D. J. White | Hillcrest | |
| 2005 | Monta Ellis | Lanier | Jon Brockman | Snohomish Senior | Jamal Boykin | Fairfax | Korvotney Barber | Manchester | |
| 2005 | Tyler Hansbrough | Poplar Bluff | Kevin Durant | Montrose | Keith Brumbaugh | DeLand | Eric Boateng | St. Andrew's School | |
| 2005 | Richard Hendrix | Athens | Byron Eaton | Lincoln | Andrew Bynum | St. Joseph | Lewis Clinch | Crisp County | |
| 2005 | Josh McRoberts | Carmel | Jamont Gordon | Oak Hill Academy | Mario Chalmers | Bartlett | Darren Collison | Etiwanda | |
| 2005 | C. J. Miles | Skyline | Danny Green | St. Mary's | Wilson Chandler | Benton Harbor | Micah Downs | Juanita | |
| 2005 | Tasmin Mitchell | Denham Springs | Amir Johnson | Westchester | Brandon Costner | Seton Hall Preparatory School | Bobby Frasor | Brother Rice | |
| 2005 | Greg Oden | Lawrence North | James Keefe | Santa Margarita Catholic | Eric Devendorf | Oak Hill Academy | Dwight Lewis | Taylor | |
| 2005 | Martell Webster | Seattle Preparatory School | O. J. Mayo | North College Hill | Jerel McNeal | Hillcrest | Mike Mercer | South Gwinnett | |
| 2005 | Lou Williams | South Gwinnett | Greg Paulus | Christian Brothers Academy | J. P. Prince | White Station | Jon Scheyer | Glenbrook North | |
| 2005 | Brandan Wright | Brentwood Academy | Julian Wright | Homewood-Flossmoor | Derrick Rose | Simeon Career Academy | Kevin Swinton | James B. Dudley | |
| 2006 | Chase Budinger | La Costa Canyon | Michael Beasley | Notre Dame Preparatory | Darrell Arthur | South Oak Cliff | D. J. Augustin | Hightower | |
| 2006 | Kevin Durant | Montrose Christian School | Gerald Henderson | Episcopal Academy | Tweety Carter | Reserve Christian School | Jerryd Bayless | St. Mary's | |
| 2006 | Wayne Ellington | Episcopal Academy | Damion James | Nacogdoches | Sherron Collins | Crane | Earl Clark | Rahway | |
| 2006 | Spencer Hawes | Seattle Preparatory School | James Keefe | Santa Margarita Catholic | Mike Conley Jr. | Lawrence North | Eric Gordon | North Central | |
| 2006 | Ty Lawson | Oak Hill Academy | Vernon Macklin | Hargrave Military Academy | Daequan Cook | Dunbar | Raymar Morgan | Canton McKinley | |
| 2006 | Kevin Love | Lake Oswego | Stanley Robinson | Huffman | Duke Crews | Bethel | Derrick Rose | Simeon Career Academy | |
| 2006 | O. J. Mayo | North College Hill | Kyle Singler | South Medford | Javaris Crittenton | Southwest Atlanta Christian Academy | DeShawn Sims | Pershing | |
| 2006 | Greg Oden | Lawrence North | Lance Thomas | Saint Benedict's Preparatory School | Brook Lopez | San Joaquin Memorial | Jerry Smith | Wauwatosa East | |
| 2006 | Jon Scheyer | Glenbrook North | Henry Walker | North College Hill | Robin Lopez | San Joaquin Memorial | Alex Stepheson | Harvard-Westlake School | |
| 2006 | Brandan Wright | Brentwood Academy | Thaddeus Young | Mitchell | Scottie Reynolds | Herndon | Brian Zoubek | Haddonfield Memorial | |
| 2007 | Jerryd Bayless | St. Mary's | Cole Aldrich | Bloomington Jefferson | James Anderson | Junction City | Jon Diebler | Upper Sandusky | |
| 2007 | Nick Calathes | Lake Howell | Jonny Flynn | Niagara Falls | Blake Griffin | Oklahoma Christian | Tyreke Evans | American Christian Academy | |
| 2007 | Austin Freeman | DeMatha Catholic | James Harden | Artesia | Jrue Holiday | Campbell Hall School | Corey Fisher | St. Patrick | |
| 2007 | Eric Gordon | North Central | J. J. Hickson | Joseph Wheeler | Brandon Jennings | Oak Hill Academy | Senario Hillman | Wilkinson County | |
| 2007 | Donté Greene | Towson Catholic | Taylor King | Mater Dei | Gary Johnson | Aldine Nimitz | Rick Jackson | Neumann-Goretti | |
| 2007 | Kevin Love | Lake Oswego | Gani Lawal | Norcross | DeAndre Jordan | Christian Life Center | Alex Legion | Oak Hill Academy | |
| 2007 | O. J. Mayo | Huntington | Jai Lucas | Bellaire | Kosta Koufos | Glen Oak | Herb Pope | Aliquippa | |
| 2007 | Derrick Rose | Simeon Career Academy | Patrick Patterson | Huntington | Greg Monroe | Helen Cox | Anthony Randolph | Woodrow Wilson | |
| 2007 | Kyle Singler | South Medford | Corey Stokes | Saint Benedict's Preparatory School | E'Twaun Moore | East Chicago Central | Delvon Roe | St. Edward | |
| 2007 | Nolan Smith | Oak Hill Academy | Chris Wright | St. John's College | Dar Tucker | Arthur Hill | Durrell Summers | Redford | |
| 2008 | Brandon Jennings | Oak Hill Academy (Mouth of Wilson, Va.) | Ed Davis | Benedictine (Richmond, Va.) | Willie Warren | North Crowley (Fort Worth, Tex.) | Kenny Boynton | American Heritage (Plantation, Fla.) | |
| 2008 | Samardo Samuels | St. Benedict's (Newark, N. J.) | Derrick Favors | South Atlanta (Atlanta, Ga.) | Michael Dunigan | Farragut Academy (Chicago, Ill.) | DeQuan Jones | Wheeler (Marietta, Ga.) | |
| 2008 | Tyreke Evans | American Christian (Aston, Pa.) | Kemba Walker | Rice (New York, N. Y.) | JaMychal Green | St. Jude (Montgomery, Ala.) | Tony Woods | Rome (Rome, Ga.) | |
| 2008 | Jrue Holiday | Campbell Hall (North Hollywood, Calif.) | Lance Stephenson | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn, N. Y.) | Chris Singleton | Dunwoody (Dunwoody, Ga.) | Renardo Sidney | (Fairfax Los Angeles, Calif.) | |
| 2008 | Tyler Zeller | Washington (Washington, Ind.) | Luke Babbitt | Galena (Reno, Nev.) | Larry Drew | Taft (Woodland Hills, Calif.) | Terrelle Pryor | Jeannette (Jeannette, Pa.) | |
| 2008 | Al-Farouq Aminu | Norcross (Norcross, Ga.) | Elliot Williams | St. George's (Collierville, Tenn.) | Iman Shumpert | Oak Park & River Forest (Oak Park, Ill.) | Yancy Gates | Withrow (Cincinnati, Ohio) | |
| 2008 | B. J. Mullens | Canal Winchester (Canal Winchester, Ohio) | Sylven Landesberg | Holy Cross (Flushing, N. Y.) | Leslie McDonald | Briarcrest Christian (Eads, Tenn.) | Draymond Green | Saginaw (Saginaw, Mich.) | |
| 2008 | DeMar DeRozan | Compton (Compton, Calif.) | Scotty Hopson | University Heights (Hopkinsville, Ky.) | Dexter Strickland | St. Patrick (Elizabeth, N. J.) | Kevin Jones | Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon, N. Y.) | |
| 2008 | William Buford | Libbey (Toledo, Ohio) | Xavier Henry | Putnam City (Oklahoma City, Okla.) | Howard Thompkins | Wesleyan (Norcross, Ga.) | Malcolm Lee | J. W. North (Riverside, Calif.) | |
| 2008 | Greg Monroe | Helen Cox (Harvey, La.) | Mike Rosario | St. Anthony (Jersey City, N. J.) | Darius Miller | Mason County (Maysville, Ky.) | Henry Sims | Mount St. Joseph (Baltimore, Md.) | |
| 2009 | Derrick Favors | South Atlanta (Atlanta, Ga.) | Abdul Gaddy | Bellarmine Prep (Tacoma, Wash.) | Dominic Cheek | St. Anthony (Jersey City, N. J.) | David Wear | Mater Dei (Santa Ana, Calif.) | |
| 2009 | Xavier Henry | Putnam City (Oklahoma City, Okla.) | Jared Sullinger | Northland (Columbus, Ohio) | Mason Plumlee | Christ School (Arden, N. C.) | Travis Wear | Mater Dei (Santa Ana, Calif.) | |
| 2009 | John Henson | Sickles (Tampa, Fla.) | Alex Oriakhi | The Tilton School (Tilton, N. H.) | Mouphtaou Yarou | Montrose Christian (Rockville, Md.) | Terrell Vinson | St. Frances (Baltimore, Md.) | |
| 2009 | DeMarcus Cousins | John LeFlore (Mobile, Ala.) | Joshua Smith | Kentwood (Covington, Wash.) | Keith Gallon | Oak Hill Academy (Mouth of Wilson, Va.) | Deshaun Thomas | Bishop Luers (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | |
| 2009 | Renardo Sidney | Fairfax (Los Angeles, Calif.) | Dante Taylor | National Christian (Fort Washington, Md.) | Maalik Wayns | Roman Catholic (Philadelphia, Pa.) | Lorenzo Brown | Centennial (Roswell, Ga.) | |
| 2009 | Lance Stephenson | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn, N. Y.) | Jeremy Tyler | San Diego (San Diego, Calif.) | Tyler Honeycutt | Sylmar (Sylmar, Calif.) | Thomas Robinson | Brewster Academy (Wolfeboro, N.H.) | |
| 2009 | Kenny Boynton | American Heritage (Plantation, Fla.) | Wally Judge | Arlington Country Day (Jacksonville, Fla.) | John Jenkins | Station Camp (Gallatin, Tenn.) | Leslie McDonald | Briarcrest Christian (Eads, Tenn.) | |
| 2009 | Ryan Kelly | Ravenscroft (Raleigh, N.C.) | Harrison Barnes | Ames (Ames, Iowa) | Mfon Udofia | Miller Grove (Lithonia, Ga.) | Erik Murphy | St. Mark's (Southborough, Mass.) | |
| 2009 | Avery Bradley | Findlay College Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | Brandon Knight | Pine Crest (Fort Lauderdale, Fla.) | Peyton Siva | Franklin (Seattle, Wash.) | Roger Franklin | Duncanville (Duncanville, Tex.) | |
| 2009 | Dexter Strickland | St. Patrick (Elizabeth, N.J.) | Milton Jennings | Pinewood Prep (Summerville, S. C.) | Durand Scott | Rice (New York, N. Y.) | D. J. Richardson | Findlay College Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | |

### 2010–2015

| Season | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Fourth team | Fourth team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 2010 | Jared Sullinger | Northland (Columbus, Ohio) | Tristan Thompson | Findlay College Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | Ryan Harrow | Walton (Marietta, Ga.) | Allen Crabbe | Price (Los Angeles, Calif.) | |
| 2010 | Harrison Barnes | Ames (Ames, Iowa) | Michael Gilchrist | St. Patrick (Elizabeth, N. J.) | Kendall Marshall | Bishop O'Connell (Arlington, Va.) | Ian Miller | United Faith Christian Charlotte, N. C.) | |
| 2010 | Brandon Knight | Pine Crest (Fort Lauderdale, Fla.) | Doron Lamb | Oak Hill Academy (Mouth of Wilson, Va.) | Josh Hairston | Montrose Christian (Rockville, Md.) | Adreian Payne | Jefferson (Dayton, Ohio) | |
| 2010 | Kyrie Irving | St. Patrick (Elizabeth, N. J.) | Austin Rivers | Winter Park (Winter Park, Fla.) | Nate Lubick | St. Mark's (Southborough, Ma.) | James McAdoo | Norfolk Christian (Norfolk, Va.) | |
| 2010 | Deshaun Thomas | Bishop Luers (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | Josh Selby | Lake Clifton (Baltimore, Md.) | Fab Melo | Sagemont (Weston, Fla.) | Marquis Teague | Pike (Indianapolis, Ind.) | |
| 2010 | Tobias Harris | Half Hollow Hills West (Dix Hills, N. Y.) | C. J. Leslie | Word of God Christian (Raleigh, N .C.) | Keith Appling | Pershing (Detroit, Mich.) | Marcus Thornton | Westlake (Atlanta, Ga.) | |
| 2010 | Cory Joseph | Findlay College Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | Dion Waiters | Life Center Academy (Burlington, N. J.) | Jereme Richmond | Waukegan (Waukegan, Ill.) | James Bell | Montverde Academy (Montverde, Fla.) | |
| 2010 | Terrence Jones | Jefferson (Portland, Ore.) | Patric Young | Providence (Jacksonville, Fla.) | Jelan Kendrick | Wheeler (Marietta, Ga.) | Tyler Lamb | Mater Dei (Santa Ana, Calif.) | |
| 2010 | Reggie Bullock | Kinston (Kinston, N. C.) | JayVaughn Pinkston | Bishop Loughlin (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | Joe Young | Yates (Houston, Tex.) | Corey Hawkins | Estrella Foothills (Goodyear, Ariz.) | |
| 2010 | Joe Jackson | White Station (Memphis, Tenn). | Ray McCallum Jr. | Detroit County Day (Beverly Hills, Mich.) | Perry Jones | Duncanville (Duncanville, Tex.) | Noah Cottrill | Logan Logan, W. Va. | |
| 2011 | Austin Rivers | Winter Park (Fla.) | D'Angelo Harrison | Dulles (Tex.) | Wesley Saunders | Windward (Calif.) | Julien Lewis | La Marque (Tex.) | |
| 2011 | Bradley Beal | Chaminade (Mo.) | Adam Smith | Fayette County (Ga.) | Shelby Moats | Waconia (Minn.) | Jake White | Chaska (Minn.) | |
| 2011 | Anthony Davis | Perspectives (Ill.) | Tony Wroten | Garfield (Wash.) | Devonta Abron | Seagoville (Tex.) | Johnny O'Bryant | East Side (Miss.) | |
| 2011 | Chase Fischer | Ripley (W.Va.) | Chane Behanan | Bowling Green (Ky.) | Jarvis Threatt | Highland Springs (Va.) | Tanner Wozniak | Keswick Christian (Fla.) | |
| 2011 | Adonis Thomas | Melrose (Tenn.) | Cody Zeller | Washington (Ind.) | Amir Williams | Detroit C.D. (Mich.) | Myck Kabongo | Findlay Prep (Nev.) | |
| 2011 | Rodney Cooper | Russell County (Ala.) | Trey Burke | Northland (Ohio) | Jordan Baker | Tempe (Ariz.) | Reese Morgan | Palos Verdes Pen. (Calif.) | |
| 2011 | Dantley Walker | Lincoln County (Nev.) | Kyle Caudill | Brea Olinda (Calif.) | Branden Dawson | Wallace (Ind.) | Michael Gilchrist | St. Patrick (N.J.) | |
| 2011 | D. J. Gardner | Okolona (Miss.) | Jahii Carson | Mesa (Ariz.) | P. J. Hairston | Hargrave Military (Va.) | Colin Gruber | Harbor (Calif.) | |
| 2011 | Trevor Lacey | Butler (Ala.) | LeBryan Nash | Lincoln (Tex.) | James McAdoo | Norfolk Christian (Va.) | Ryan Spangler | Bridge Creek (Okla.) | |
| 2011 | Wayne Blackshear | Morgan Park (Ill.) | Angelo Chol | Hoover (Calif.) | Xavier Ford | Harrison (Colo.) | Marquis Teague | Pike (Ind.) | |
| Season | First team | First team | First team | First team | First team | First team | First team | First team | Ref |
| Season | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Player | High school | Ref |
| 2012 | Adolphus Washington | Taft (Cincinnati, Ohio) | Alex Poythress | Northeast (Clarksville, Tenn.) | Archie Goodwin | Sylvan (Sherwood, Ark) | Brandon Ashley | Findlay Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | |
| 2012 | Brice Johnson | Edisto (Cordova, S. C.) | Bruce Marshall | Fayette (Fayette, Mo.) | Cameron Biedscheid | Cardinal Ritter (St. Louis, Mo.) | Deandre Burnett | Carol City (Miami Gardens, Fla.) | |
| 2012 | Devonta Pollard | Kemper County (De Kalb, Miss.) | Dewayne Russell | Peoria (Peoria, Ariz.) | Gary Harris | Hamilton Southeastern (Fishers, Ind.) | Grant Jerrett | Lutheran (La Verne, Calif.) | |
| 2012 | Isaiah Cousins | Mount Vernon (Mount Vernon, N. Y.) | Javion Watson | San Ysidro (San Diego, Calif.) | Joe McDonald | Landon School (Bethesda, Md.) | John Ross Glover | Univ. School of Jackson (Jackson, Tenn.) | |
| 2012 | John Simons | Cadillac (Cadillac, Mich.) | Jordan Loveridge | West Jordan (West Jordan, Utah) | Josh Scott | Lewis-Palmer (Monument, Colo.) | Kaleb Tarczewski | St. Mark's (Southborough, Mass.) | |
| 2012 | Kenneth Gaines | Whitefield Academy (Mableton, Ga.) | Kris Dunn | New London (New London, Conn.) | Kyle Anderson | St. Anthony (Jersey City, N. J.) | Marcus Paige | Linn-Mar High (Marion, Iowa) | |
| 2012 | Matt Costello | Bay City Western (Auburn, Mich.) | Maurice Watson | Boys Latin Charter (Philadelphia, Penn.) | Mike Gesell | South Sioux City (South Sioux City, Neb.) | Mitch McGary | Brewster Academy (Wolfeboro, N. H.) | |
| 2012 | Nerlens Noel | Tilton School (Tilton, N. H.) | Omar Calhoun | Christ the King (Middle Village, N. Y.) | Perry Ellis | Heights (Wichita, Kan.) | Rasheed Sulaimon | Strake Jesuit (Houston, Texas) | |
| 2012 | Rodney Purvis | Upper Room Christian (Raleigh, N. C.) | Sam Dekker | Sheboygan Area Lutheran (Sheboygan, Wis.) | Savon Goodman | Constitution (Philadelphia, Penn.) | Shabazz Muhammad | Bishop Gorman (Las Vegas, Nev.) | |
| 2012 | Stefan Moody | Poinciana (Kissimmee, Fla.) | Tony Hicks | St. Rita (Chicago, Ill.) | Tony Parker | Miller Grove (Lithonia, Ga.) | Twymond Howard | Pearl High (Pearl, Miss.) | |
| 2013 | A. J. Jacobson | Shanley (Fargo, N.D.) | Aaron Gordon | Archbishop Mitty (San Jose, Calif.) | Aaron Harrison | Travis (Richmond, Texas) | Anders Broman | Lakeview Christian Academy (Duluth, Minn.) | |
| 2013 | Andrew Wiggins | Huntington Prep (Huntington, W.V.) | Austin Nichols | Briarcrest Christian (Eads, Tenn.) | Bobby Portis | Hall (Little Rock, Ark.) | Brannen Greene | Tift County (Tifton, Ga.) | |
| 2013 | Bryce Alford | La Cueva (Albuquerque, N.M.) | Chris Walker | Holmes County (Bonifay, Fla.) | Conner Frankamp | North (Wichita, Kan.) | Cullen Neal | Eldorado (Albuquerque, N.M.) | |
| 2013 | Derrick Walton Jr. | Chandler Park Academy (Harper Woods, Mich.) | De'Runnya Wilson | Wenonah (Birmingham, Ala.) | Dominique Hawkins | Madison Central (Richmond, Ky.) | Garet Beal | Jonesport-Beals (Jonesport, Maine) | |
| 2013 | Isaiah Hicks | J. F. Webb (Oxford, N.C.) | Jabari Parker | Simeon (Chicago, Ill.) | James Young | Rochester (Rochester Hills, Mich.) | Jarell Martin | Madison Prep Academy (Baton Rouge, La.) | |
| 2013 | Jon Severe | Christ The King (Queens, N. Y.) | Luke Fischer | Germantown (Wis.) | Mamadou N'Diaye | Brethren Christian (Huntington Beach, Calif.) | Marc Loving | St. John's (Toledo, Ohio) | |
| 2013 | Marcus Allen | Centennial (Las Vegas, Nev.) | Marcus Foster | Hirschi (Wichita Falls, Texas) | Marcus Lee | Deer Valley (Antioch, Calif.) | Monté Morris | Beecher (Flint, Mich.) | |
| 2013 | Nick King | Memphis East (Memphis, Tenn.) | Nigel Williams-Goss | Findlay Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | Peter Jok | Valley (West Des Moines, Iowa) | Ricky Seals-Jones | Sealy (Texas) | |
| 2013 | Roschon Prince | Poly (Long Beach, Calif.) | Rysheed Jordan | Vaux (Philadelphia) | Semi Ojeleye | Ottawa (Kan.) | Steve Vasturia | St. Joseph's (Philadelphia, Pa.) | |
| 2013 | Stevie Clark | Douglass (Oklahoma City) | Tyler Ennis | St. Benedict's Prep (Newark, N.J.) | Zach LaVine | Bothell (Wash.) | Zak Irvin | Hamilton Southeastern (Fishers, Ind.) | |
| 2014 | Cliff Alexander | Curie Metropolitan (Chicago, Ill.) | Joel Berry II | Lake Highland (Orlando, Fla.) | James Blackmon Jr. | Marion (Ind.) | Trevon Bluiett | Park Tudor School (Indianapolis) | |
| 2014 | Gabe DeVoe | Shelby (N.C.) | J. T. Escobar | FAMU High (Tallahassee, Fla.) | Daniel Hamilton | St. John Bosco (Bellflower, Calif.) | Justin Jackson | Homeschool Christian (Spring, Texas) | |
| 2014 | Stanley Johnson | Mater Dei (Santa Ana, Calif.) | Kevon Looney | Hamilton (Milwaukee, Wisc.) | Trey Lyles | Arsenal Tech (Indianapolis, Ind.) | Emmanuel Mudiay | Prime Prep Academy (Dallas, Texas) | |
| 2014 | Jahlil Okafor | Whitney Young (Chicago, Ill.) | Kelly Oubre | Findlay Prep (Henderson, Nev.) | Devin Robinson | Christchurch (Va.) | B. J. Taylor | Boone (Orlando, Fla.) | |
| 2014 | Karl-Anthony Towns | Saint Joseph (Metuchen, N.J.) | Myles Turner | Trinity (Euless, Texas) | Isaiah Whitehead | Lincoln (Brooklyn, N.Y.) | Justise Winslow | St. John's (Houston, Texas) | |
| 2015 | KeVaughn Allen | North Little Rock (Ark.) | Dwayne Bacon | Oak Hill (Mouth of Wilson, Va.) | Antonio Blakeney | Oak Ridge (Orlando, Fla.) | Isaiah Briscoe | Roselle Catholic (Newark, N.J.) | |
| 2015 | Bjorn Broman | Lakeview Christian (Duluth, Minn.) | Jaylen Brown | Wheeler (Marietta, Ga.) | Jalen Brunson | Stevenson (Lincolnshire, Ill.) | Deyonta Davis | Muskegon (Mich.) | |
| 2015 | Cheick Diallo | Our Savior (Centereach, N.Y.) | Tyler Dorsey | Maranatha (Pasadena, Calif.) | Henry Ellenson | Rice Lake (Wisc.) | Jawun Evans | Kimball (Dallas, Texas) | |
| 2015 | Admon Gilder | Madison (Dallas, Texas) | Brandon Ingram | Kinston (N.C.) | Camron Justice | Knott Co. Central (Hindman, Ky.) | Luke Kennard | Franklin (Ohio) | |
| 2015 | Skal Labissière | Reach Your Dream Prep (Memphis, Tenn.) | Dedric Lawson | Hamilton (Memphis, Tenn.) | Shake Milton | Owasso (Okla.) | Dejounte Murray | Rainier Beach (Seattle, Wash.) | |
| 2015 | Malik Newman | Callaway (Jackson, Miss.) | Ivan Rabb | Bishop O'Dowd (Oakland, Calif.) | Malachi Richardson | Trenton Catholic (Hamilton, N.J.) | Justin Robinson | Saint James (Hagerstown, Md.) | |
| 2015 | Matt Ryan | Iona Prep (Cortlandt Manor, N.Y.) | Ben Simmons | Montverde Academy (Montverde, Fla.) | Diamond Stone | Dominican (Milwaukee, Wisc.) | Caleb Swanigan | Homestead (Fort Wayne, Ind.) | |
| 2015 | Dean Wade | St. John (Kan.) | Jesse Wade | Davis (Kaysville, Utah) | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | |