# List of All-Atlantic Hockey Teams

The All-Atlantic Hockey Teams were composed of players at all positions from teams that are members of the Atlantic Hockey Association, an NCAA Division I hockey-only conference. Each year, at the conclusion of the Atlantic Hockey regular season, the head coaches of each member team voted for players to be placed on each all-conference team. The First Team, Second Team and Rookie Teams were named from 2003–04 (the inaugural year of Atlantic Hockey) and a Third Team was added starting in 2006–07.
The all-conference teams were composed of one goaltender, two defencemen and three forwards. Should a tie occur for the final selection at any position, both players were included as part of the superior team with no reduction in the number of players appearing on any succeeding teams (as happened in 2004–05 and 2008–09). Players may only appear once per year on any of the first, second, or third teams but freshman may appear on both the rookie team and one of the other all-conference teams.
Due to the conference playing in two separate pods (East and West) for the 2020–21 season, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, Atlantic Hockey named two all-conference and an all-Rookie team for each pod. No Third team was named.
After the conference merged with College Hockey America in 2024, Atlantic Hockey America began naming [[all-conference teams under a new banner.

## All-Conference Teams

Source:

### First Team

Source:

#### 2000s

2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Holden | G | Quinnipiac |
| T. J. Kemp | D | Mercyhurst |
| Eric Nelson | D | Connecticut |
| Jeff Dams | F | Holy Cross |
| Tim Olsen | F | Connecticut |
| Guillaume Caron | F | American International |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Novello | G | American International |
| Bryan Woroz | G | Canisius |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| T. J. Kemp | D | Mercyhurst |
| Tyler McGregor | F | Holy Cross |
| Pierre-Luc O'Brien | F | Sacred Heart |
| Tim Olsen | F | Connecticut |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Smith | G | Sacred Heart |
| Jamie Hunt | D | Mercyhurst |
| Jon Landry | D | Holy Cross |
| Tyler McGregor | F | Holy Cross |
| Dave Borrelli | F | Mercyhurst |
| Pierre-Luc O'Brien | F | Sacred Heart |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Smith | G | Sacred Heart |
| Jon Landry | D | Holy Cross |
| Scott Marchesi | D | Sacred Heart |
| Eric Ehn | F | Air Force |
| Pierre-Luc O'Brien | F | Sacred Heart |
| James Sixsmith | F | Holy Cross |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Kassel | G | Army |
| Zach McKelvie | D | Army |
| Dan Ringwald | D | RIT |
| Simon Lambert | F | RIT |
| Alexandre Parent | F | Sacred Heart |
| Luke Flicek | F | Army |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andrew Volkening | G | Air Force |
| Greg Flynn | D | Air Force |
| Zach McKelvie | D | Army |
| Dan Ringwald | D | RIT |
| Jacques Lamoureux | F | Air Force |
| Owen Meyer | F | Army |
| Brennan Sarazin | F | RIT |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jared DeMichiel | G | RIT |
| Tim Kirby | D | Air Force |
| Dan Ringwald | D | RIT |
| Cory Conacher | F | Canisius |
| Nick Johnson | F | Sacred Heart |
| Jacques Lamoureux | F | Air Force |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shane Madolora | G | RIT |
| Scott Mathis | D | Air Force |
| Denny Urban | D | Robert Morris |
| Bryan Haczyk | F | Niagara |
| Nathan Longpre | F | Robert Morris |
| Paul Zanette | F | Niagara |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shane Madolora | G | RIT |
| Tim Kirby | D | Air Force |
| Scott Mathis | D | Air Force |
| Kyle De Laurell | F | Air Force |
| Brett Gensler | F | Bentley |
| Cole Schneider | F | Connecticut |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Carsen Chubak | G | Niagara |
| Adam McKenzie | D | Air Force |
| Nick Jones | D | Mercyhurst |
| Chris Saracino | D | RIT |
| Kyle De Laurell | F | Air Force |
| Giancarlo Iuorio | F | Niagara |
| Brett Gensler | F | Bentley |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jimmy Sarjeant | G | Mercyhurst |
| Steven Weinstein | D | Bentley |
| Nick Jones | D | Mercyhurst |
| Brett Gensler | F | Bentley |
| Cody Wydo | F | Robert Morris |
| Matthew Zay | F | Mercyhurst |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Ginn | G | Holy Cross |
| Chris Rumble | D | Canisius |
| Steven Weinstein | D | Bentley |
| Matt Garbowsky | F | RIT |
| Andrew Gladiuk | F | Bentley |
| Cody Wydo | F | Robert Morris |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shane Starrett | G | Air Force |
| Lester Lancaster | D | Mercyhurst |
| Chase Norrish | D | RIT |
| Greg Gibson | F | Robert Morris |
| Zac Lynch | F | Robert Morris |
| Shane Conacher | F | Canisius |
| Max French | F | Bentley |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charles Williams | G | Canisius |
| Phil Boje | D | Air Force |
| Lester Lancaster | D | Mercyhurst |
| Brady Ferguson | F | Robert Morris |
| Max French | F | Bentley |
| Justin Danforth | F | Sacred Heart |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Berrafto | G | Holy Cross |
| Alexander Wilkinson | D | Army |
| Cameron Heath | D | Canisius |
| Dylan McLaughlin | F | Canisius |
| Brady Ferguson | F | Robert Morris |
| Erik Brown | F | RIT |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Billy Christopoulos | G | Air Force |
| Joseph Duszak | D | Mercyhurst |
| Brennan Kapcheck | D | American International |
| Derek Barach | F | Mercyhurst |
| Blake Christensen | F | American International |
| Dylan McLaughlin | F | Cansius |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zackarias Skog | G | American International |
| Mike Lee | D | Sacred Heart |
| Brennan Kapcheck | D | American International |
| Blake Christensen | F | American International |
| Jason Cotton | F | Sacred Heart |
| Austin McIlmurray | F | Sacred Heart |
| Jakov Novak | F | Bentley |
2020–21 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Trevin Kozlowski | G | Army |
| Brennan Kapcheck | D | American International |
| Thomas Farrell | D | Army |
| Colin Bilek | F | Army |
| Tobias Fladeby | F | American International |
| Marc Johnstone | F | Sacred Heart |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jacob Barczewski | G | Cansius |
| Nick Jenny | D | Robert Morris |
| Dan Willett | D | RIT |
| Will Calverley | F | Robert Morris |
| Nick Prkusic | F | RIT |
| Keaton Mastrodonato | F | Cansius |
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jacob Barczewski | G | Canisius |
| Zak Galambos | D | American International |
| Drew Bavaro | D | Bentley |
| Chris Theodore | F | American International |
| Colin Bilek | F | Army |
| Will Calverley | F | RIT |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tommy Scarfone | G | RIT |
| Gianfranco Cassaro | D | RIT |
| Aiden Hansen-Bukata | D | RIT |
| Carter Wilkie | F | RIT |
| Neil Shea | F | Sacred Heart |
| Blake Bennett | F | American International |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tommy Scarfone | G | RIT |
| Gianfranco Cassaro | D | RIT |
| Brian Kramer | D | American International |
| Liam McLinskey | F | Holy Cross |
| Carter Wilkie | F | RIT |
| Will Gavin | F | Air Force |
| Cody Laskosky | F | RIT |

### Second Team

Source:

#### 2000s

2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Quesada | G | Holy Cross |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Konn Hawkes | D | Sacred Heart |
| Garrett Larson | F | Sacred Heart |
| Mike Carter | F | Mercyhurst |
| David Wrigley | F | Mercyhurst |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Holden | G | Quinnipiac |
| Conrad Martin | D | Mercyhurst |
| Kalen Wright | D | Sacred Heart |
| Matt Craig | F | Quinnipiac |
| Pierre Napert-Frenette | F | Holy Cross |
| David Wrigley | F | Mercyhurst |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Roberts | G | Army |
| Tony Quesada | G | Holy Cross |
| Josh Chase | D | Bentley |
| Tim Manthey | D | Army |
| Pierre Napert-Frenette | F | Holy Cross |
| Ben Cottreau | F | Mercyhurst |
| Alexandre Parent | F | Sacred Heart |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Kassel | G | Army |
| Tim Manthey | D | Army |
| Brent Patry | D | RIT |
| Simon Lambert | F | RIT |
| Andrew Ramsey | F | Air Force |
| Matt Scherer | F | Connecticut |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Beau Erickson | G | Connecticut |
| Scott Marchesi | D | Sacred Heart |
| Greg Flynn | D | Air Force |
| Owen Meyer | F | Army |
| Ben Cottreau | F | Mercyhurst |
| Bear Trapp | F | Sacred Heart |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Zapolski | G | Mercyhurst |
| Bobby Raymond | D | RIT |
| Sean Erickson | D | Connecticut |
| Dain Prewitt | F | Bentley |
| Steve Cameron | F | Mercyhurst |
| Matt Pierce | F | Mercyhurst |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andrew Volkening | G | Air Force |
| Marcel Alvarez | D | Army |
| Carl Hudson | D | Canisius |
| Brandon Coccimigilo | F | Mercyhurst |
| Andrew Favot | F | RIT |
| Cody Omilusik | F | Army |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Zapolski | G | Mercyhurst |
| Marcel Alvarez | D | Army |
| Chris Saracino | D | RIT |
| Tyler Brenner | F | RIT |
| Cory Conacher | F | Canisius |
| Jacques Lamoureux | F | Air Force |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Noonan | G | Niagara |
| Alex Gerke | D | Connecticut |
| Chris Haltigin | D | RIT |
| Michael Colavecchia | F | RIT |
| John Kruse | F | Air Force |
| Adam Schmidt | F | Holy Cross |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ben Meisner | G | American International |
| Dan Weiss | D | Niagara |
| Steve Weinstein | D | Bentley |
| Ryan Misiak | F | Mercyhurst |
| Adam Pleskach | F | American International |
| Adam Brace | F | Robert Morris |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Branden Komm | G | Bentley |
| Adam McKenzie | D | Air Force |
| Matthew Blomquist | D | Bentley |
| Alex Grieve | F | Bentley |
| Dan O'Donoghue | F | Mercyhurst |
| Cole Gunner | F | Air Force |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keegan Asmundson | G | Canisius |
| Brady Norrish | D | RIT |
| Josh Mitchell | D | RIT |
| Ryan Misiak | F | Mercyhurst |
| Ralph Cuddemi | F | Canisius |
| Cole Gunner | F | Air Force |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Parker Gahagen | G | Army |
| Johnny Hrabovsky | D | Air Force |
| Tyson Wilson | D | Robert Morris |
| Andrew Gladiuk | F | Bentley |
| Ralph Cuddemi | F | Canisius |
| Justin Danforth | F | Sacred Heart |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Parker Gahagen | G | Army |
| Brady Norrish | D | RIT |
| Cameron Heath | D | Canisius |
| Ryan Schmelzer | F | Canisius |
| Derek Barach | F | Mercyhurst |
| Jordan Himley | F | Air Force |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brandon Wildung | G | Mercyhurst |
| Joseph Duszak | D | Mercyhurst |
| Lester Lancaster | D | Canisius |
| Jack Riley | F | Mercyhurst |
| Derek Barach | F | Mercyhurst |
| Michael Wilson | F | Army |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aidan Pelino | G | Bentley |
| Tanner Jago | D | Bentley |
| Dalton MacAfee | D | Army |
| Abbott Girduckis | F | RIT |
| Luke Santerno | F | Bentley |
| Alex Tonge | F | Robert Morris |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Justin Kapelmaster | G | Robert Morris |
| Adam Brubacher | D | RIT |
| Patrik Demel | D | American International |
| Dominic Franco | F | Army |
| Matt Hoover | F | Cansius |
| Nick Hutchison | F | Cansius |
2020–21 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Stefano Durante | G | American International |
| John Zimmerman | D | Army |
| Matt Slick | D | Holy Cross |
| Elijah Barriga | F | American International |
| Chris Dodero | F | American International |
| Braeden Tuck | F | Sacred Heart |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Noah West | G | Robert Morris |
| Zach LaRocque | G | Air Force |
| Joseph Maziarz | D | Mercyhurst |
| Brendan Michaelian | D | Robert Morris |
| Randy Hernández | F | Robert Morris |
| Jon Bendorf | F | Mercyhurst |
| Carson Brière | F | Mercyhurst |
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gavin Abric | G | Army |
| Anthony Firriolo | D | Army |
| Logan Britt | D | Sacred Heart |
| Keaton Mastrodonato | F | Canisius |
| Neil Shea | F | Sacred Heart |
| Jake Stella | F | American International |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jarrett Fiske | G | American International |
| Luke Rowe | D | Air Force |
| Brian Kramer | D | American International |
| Jack Ricketts | F | Holy Cross |
| Eric Esposito | F | Mercyhurst |
| Joey Baez | F | Army |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Grande | G | Holy Cross |
| Chris Hedden | D | Air Force |
| Aiden Hansen-Bukata | D | RIT |
| Matteo Giampa | F | Canisius |
| Jack Ricketts | F | Holy Cross |
| Joey Baez | F | Army |

### Third Team

Source:

#### 2000s

2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Louis Menard | G | RIT |
| Sean Erickson | D | Connecticut |
| Al Mazur | D | RIT |
| Luke Flicek | F | Army |
| Jeff Gumaer | F | Bentley |
| Jereme Tendler | F | American International |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Calvi | G | Bentley |
| Bobby Raymond | D | RIT |
| Matt Burke | D | Holy Cross |
| Eric Ehn | F | Air Force |
| Brodie Sheahan | F | Holy Cross |
| Jereme Tendler | F | American International |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Rank | G | Bentley |
| Al Mazur | D | RIT |
| Carl Hudson | D | Canisius |
| Matt Fairchild | F | Bentley |
| Jason Weeks | F | Canisius |
| Scott Pitt | F | Mercyhurst |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Zapolski | G | Mercyhurst |
| Paul Ferraro | D | Sacred Heart |
| Christopher Tanev | D | RIT |
| Cameron Burt | F | RIT |
| Dave Jarman | F | Sacred Heart |
| Vincent Scarcella | F | Canisius |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brooks Ostergard | G | Robert Morris |
| Tim Kirby | D | Air Force |
| Ryan Annesley | D | Niagara |
| Jeff Terminesi | D | Mercyhurst |
| Andrew Favot | F | RIT |
| Cody Omilusik | F | Army |
| Scott Pitt | F | Mercyhurst |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Branden Komm | G | Bentley |
| Trent Bonnett | D | Bentley |
| Nick Jones | D | Mercyhurst |
| Matt Gingera | F | Sacred Heart |
| Adam Pleskach | F | American International |
| Cody Crichton | F | Robert Morris |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Grogan | G | Connecticut |
| Kevin Ryan | D | Niagara |
| Jeff Ceccacci | D | American International |
| Matthew Zay | F | Mercyhurst |
| Kyle Gibbons | F | Canisius |
| Eric Delong | F | Sacred Heart |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Shafer | G | Robert Morris |
| Ben Danforth | D | Canisius |
| Kevin Ryan | D | Niagara |
| John Puskar | F | American International |
| Andrew Gladiuk | F | Bentley |
| Brant Harris | F | Connecticut |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dalton Izyk | G | Robert Morris |
| Jayson Argue | G | Bentley |
| Chase Golightly | D | Robert Morris |
| Alexander Kuqali | D | RIT |
| Zac Lynch | F | Robert Morris |
| Brad McGowan | F | RIT |
| Daniel Bahntge | F | Mercyhurst |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Shafer | G | Robert Morris |
| Brady Norrish | D | RIT |
| Chase Golightly | D | Robert Morris |
| Josh Mitchell | F | RIT |
| Derek Barach | F | Mercyhurst |
| Brandon Denham | F | Robert Morris |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shane Starrett | G | Air Force |
| Eric Israel | D | Robert Morris |
| Spencer Trapp | D | Holy Cross |
| Daniel Leavens | F | Robert Morris |
| Dylan McLaughlin | F | Canisius |
| Danny Lopez | F | Holy Cross |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Billy Christopoulos | G | Air Force |
| Chase Norrish | D | RIT |
| Jānis Jaks | D | American International |
| Derian Plouffe | F | Niagara |
| Ryan Schmelzer | F | Canisius |
| Alex Tonge | F | Robert Morris |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Marotte | G | Robert Morris |
| Adam Brubacher | D | RIT |
| Noah Delmas | D | Niagara |
| Erik Brown | F | RIT |
| Jonathan Desbiens | F | Bentley |
| Austin Magera | F | Sacred Heart |
| Ludwig Stenlund | F | Niagara |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Benson | G | Sacred Heart |
| Logan Drackett | G | RIT |
| Brandon Koch | D | Air Force |
| Matt Stief | D | Cansius |
| Jack Billings | F | Niagara |
| Martin Mellberg | F | American International |
| Hugo Reinhardt | F | American International |
2020–21 :
* Not awarded ||
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jake Kucharski | G | American International |
| Brandon Koch | D | Air Force |
| David Melaragni | D | Canisius |
| Braeden Tuck | F | Sacred Heart |
| Carson Brière | F | Mercyhurst |
| Ryan Leibold | F | Holy Cross |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jacob Barczewski | G | Canisius |
| Nick Hale | D | Holy Cross |
| Hunter Sansbury | D | Sacred Heart |
| Keaton Mastrodonato | F | Canisius |
| John Keranen | F | Army |
| Jordan Biro | F | American International |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Owen Say | G | Mercyhurst |
| Luke Rowe | D | Air Force |
| Nick Bochen | D | Bentley |
| Ethan Leyh | F | Bentley |
| John Jaworski | F | Sacred Heart |
| Elijah Gonsalves | F | RIT |

### Rookie Team

Source:

#### 2000s

2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Tomes | G | Connecticut |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Jamie Hunt | D | Mercyhurst |
| Pierre-Luc O'Brien | F | Sacred Heart |
| Matt Scherer | F | Connecticut |
| James Sixsmith | F | Holy Cross |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Smith | G | Connecticut |
| Matt Sorteberg | D | Quinnipiac |
| Scott Marchesi | D | Sacred Heart |
| Ben Cottreau | F | Mercyhurst |
| Ben Nelson | F | Quinnipiac |
| Alexandre Parent | F | Sacred Heart |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Giffin | G | Canisius |
| Sean Erickson | D | Connecticut |
| Tim Manthey | D | Army |
| Bear Trapp | F | Sacred Heart |
| Anthont Canzoneri | F | Bentley |
| Jeff Gumear | F | Bentley |
| Chris Trafford | F | Mercyhurst |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Louis Menard | G | RIT |
| Cullen Eddy | D | Mercyhurst |
| Al Mazur | D | RIT |
| Anton Kharin | F | RIT |
| Josh Heidinger | F | Canisius |
| Owen Meyer | F | Army |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Calvi | G | Bentley |
| Jeff Terminesi | D | Mercyhurst |
| Mark Znutas | D | Holy Cross |
| Everett Sheen | F | Holy Cross |
| Vincent Scarsella | F | Canisius |
| Erik Peterson | F | Bentley |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Rank | G | Bentley |
| Marcel Alvarez | D | Army |
| Scott Mathis | D | Air Force |
| David Kostuch | F | Canisius |
| Phil Ginand | F | Mercyhurst |
| Tyler Brenner | F | RIT |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steven Legato | G | Sacred Heart |
| Alex Greke | D | Connecticut |
| Christopher Tanev | D | RIT |
| Joe Campanelli | F | Bentley |
| Eric Delong | F | Sacred Heart |
| Adam Pleskach | F | American International |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Torf | G | Air Force |
| Jeffrey Reppucci | D | Holy Cross |
| Adam McKenzie | D | Air Force |
| Taylor Holstrom | F | Mercyhurst |
| Ryan Rashid | F | Niagara |
| Cole Schneider | F | Connecticut |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Ginn | G | Holy Cross |
| Tyson Wilson | D | Robert Morris |
| Tyler Shiplo | D | Mercyhurst |
| Alex Grieve | F | Bentley |
| Dan Bahntge | F | Mercyhurst |
| Brett Switzer | F | Bentley |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| | G | |
| Matt Blomquist | D | Bentley |
| Karl Beckman | D | Holy Cross |
| Andrew Gladiuk | F | Bentley |
| Joe Kozlak | F | Army |
| Chris Porter | F | American International |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Truehl | G | Air Force |
| Vinny Muto | D | Niagara |
| Mitch Nylen | D | Sacred Heart |
| C. J. Reuschlein | F | Army |
| David Norris | F | American International |
| Justin Danforth | F | Sacred Heart |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jayson Argue | G | Bentley |
| Keegan Harper | D | Niagara |
| Brady Norrish | D | RIT |
| Tyler Pham | F | Army |
| Jack Riley | F | Mercyhurst |
| Brady Ferguson | F | Robert Morris |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shane Starrett | G | Air Force |
| Tanner Jago | D | Bentley |
| Lester Lancaster | D | Mercyhurst |
| Gabriel Valenzuela | F | RIT |
| Derek Barach | F | Mercyhurst |
| Matt Serratore | F | Air Force |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Marotte | G | Robert Morris |
| Adam Brubacher | D | RIT |
| Alexander Wilkinson | D | Army |
| Nick Hutchinson | F | Canisius |
| Ryner Gorowsky | F | Bentley |
| Dominic Franco | F | Army |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Stefano Durante | G | American International |
| Brennan Kapcheck | D | American International |
| Jon Zimmerman | D | Army |
| Luke Santerno | F | Bentley |
| Grant Meyer | F | Canisius |
| Marc Johnstone | F | Sacred Heart |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Benson | G | Sacred Heart |
| Josh McDougall | D | Mercyhurst |
| Matt Slick | D | Holy Cross |
| Austin Magera | F | Sacred Heart |
| Ludwig Stenlund | F | Niagara |
| Anthony Vincent | F | Holy Cross |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Veltri | G | Niagara |
| Anthony Firriolo | D | Army |
| Brandon Koch | D | Air Force |
| Elijiah Gonsalves | F | RIT |
| Matt Gosiewski | F | Bentley |
| Braeden Tuck | F | Sacred Heart |
2020–21 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nick Grabko | G | Bentley |
| Nico Somerville | D | American International |
| Drew Bavaro | D | Bentley |
| Lincoln Hatten | F | Army |
| Aaron Grounds | F | American International |
| Eric Otto | F | American International |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Noah West | G | Robert Morris |
| Brian Kramer | D | Robert Morris |
| Josef Mysak | D | Niagara |
| Randy Hernández | F | Robert Morris |
| Carson Brière | F | Mercyhurst |
| Austin Heidemann | F | Mercyhurst |
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tommy Scarfone | G | RIT |
| Luis Lindner | D | American International |
| Mitchell Digby | D | Air Force |
| Carter Wilkie | F | RIT |
| Clayton Cosentino | F | Air Force |
| Shane Ott | F | Niagara |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Owen Say | G | Mercyhurst |
| Chris Hedden | D | Air Force |
| Mack Oliphant | D | Holy Cross |
| Max Itagaki | F | Army |
| Nicholas Niemo | F | Bentley |
| Marcus Joughin | F | Sacred Heart |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nils Wallstrom | G | American International |
| Mac Gadowsky | D | Army |
| Trent Sambrook | D | Mercyhurst |
| Matteo Giampa | F | Canisius |
| Boris Skalos | F | Mercyhurst |
| Jack Stockfish | F | Holy Cross |
Rookie Team All-Stars by school
SchoolWinners
Bentley18
Mercyhurst18
Sacred Heart13
Army13
RIT11
Air Force10
American International10
Holy Cross10
Canisius7
Niagara7
Connecticut6
Robert Morris6
Quinnipiac3 :