# List of The Challenge (TV series) contestants

The Challenge is an American reality television show, which was spun off from the reality shows The Real World and Road Rules. Contestants compete against one another individually, in pairs, or in teams to win cash prizes. First airing in 1998, there have been a total of 40 seasons aired in addition to 12 spin-off seasons, and the show has been filmed on six different continents. The Challenge airs on MTV and is hosted by T. J. Lavin.
Contestants on the show are a combination of alumni from seasons of various reality televisions shows, including The Real World, Road Rules, Are You the One?, Big Brother, and Ex on the Beach, contestants who debuted directly on The Challenge, professional athletes, as well as other celebrities. Prior to the twelfth season, Fresh Meat, contestants had only been from The Real World and Road Rules. The 26th season was the first to feature contestants from Are You the One? Since the 31st season, casting has expanded to feature alumni from several reality television shows, including Big Brother, Ex on the Beach, and Geordie Shore. There has also been one contestant who originated from a special mini-series that aired during MTV's Spring Break programming block in 2010, titled Spring Break Challenge. Contestants are regularly brought back for multiple seasons and use their veteran status along with relationships with other returnees to their advantage.

## Table key

* The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras established that for every ten seasons (1-10, 11-20, etc.), they make up an "Era" of The Challenge, excluding the spin-offs.

## Seasons 1–10

* Eric Nies, Road Rules: All Stars, Battle of the Sexes and Battle of the Sexes 2
* Rachel Campos, Road Rules: All Stars
* Sean Duffy, Road Rules: All Stars, and Battle of the Seasons
* Heather B. Gardner, Challenge 2000
* Julie Stoffer, Extreme Challenge, Battle of the Sexes, The Inferno, The Inferno II and The Gauntlet 2
* Mike Mizanin, Battle of the Seasons, The Gauntlet, The Inferno, Battle of the Sexes 2 and The Inferno II
* Christina Pazsitzky, Battle of the Sexes
* Blair Herter, Battle of the Sexes
* Theo Vonkurnatowski, Battle of the Seasons, The Gauntlet, Battle of the Sexes 2 and Fresh Meat
* Chris "CT" Tamburello, 20 times contestant
* David Giuntoli, The Gauntlet
| Name | Original Show | Season | Finish |
| Jon Brennan | The Real World: Los Angeles | 1. Road Rules: All Stars | Winner |
| Rachel Campos | The Real World: San Francisco | 1. Road Rules: All Stars | Winner |
| Sean Duffy | The Real World: Boston | 1. Road Rules: All Stars | Winner |
| Eric Nies | The Real World: New York | 1. Road Rules: All Stars | Winner |
| Cynthia Roberts | The Real World: Miami | 1. Road Rules: All Stars | Winner |
| Kalle Dedolph | Road Rules: Islands | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Kefla Hare | Road Rules: Down Under | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Roni Martin | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Noah Rickun | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Anne Wharton | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Winner |
| Nathan Blackburn | The Real World: Seattle | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Janet Choi | The Real World: Seattle | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Jason Cornwell | The Real World: Boston | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Neil Forrester | The Real World: London | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Montana McGlynn | The Real World: Boston | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 2. Real World vs. Road Rules | Runner-up |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Carlos "Los" Jackson | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Dan Setzler | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Holly Shand | Road Rules: Latin America | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Bronwen "Piggy" Thomas | Road Rules: Down Under | 3. Challenge 2000 | Winner |
| Amaya Brecher | The Real World: Hawaii | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| David Burns | The Real World: Seattle | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| Heather B. Gardner | The Real World: New York | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| Tecumshea "Teck" Holmes III | The Real World: Hawaii | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| Mike Lambert | The Real World: Miami | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| Kat Ogden | The Real World: London | 3. Challenge 2000 | Runner-up |
| Rebecca Lord | The Real World: Seattle | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Jamie Murray | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Kameelah Phillips | The Real World: Boston | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Dan Renzi | The Real World: Miami | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Julie Stoffer | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 4. Extreme Challenge | Winner |
| Emily Bailey | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| Christian Breivik | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| Susie Meister | Road Rules: Down Under | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| James Orlando | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| Michelle Parma † | Road Rules: Europe | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 4. Extreme Challenge | Runner-up |
| Ayanna Mackins | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 4. Extreme Challenge | Disqualified |
| Sean Duffy | The Real World: Boston | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner (2) |
| Elka Walker | The Real World: Boston | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner |
| Mike Mizanin | The Real World: Back to New York | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner |
| Danny Roberts | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner |
| Kelley Limp | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Winner |
| Timmy Beggy | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Emily Bailey | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Dan Setzler | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Tara McDaniel | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Theo Vonkurnatowski | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Holly Brenston | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Runner-up |
| Norman Korpi | The Real World: New York | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Rebecca Blasband | The Real World: New York | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Josh Florence | Road Rules: Latin America | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Holly Shand | Road Rules: Latin America | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Mike Lambert | The Real World: Miami | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Flora Alekseyeun | The Real World: Miami | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Adam Larson | Road Rules: The Quest | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Jisela Delgado | Road Rules: The Quest | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Stephen Williams IV | The Real World: Seattle | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Lindsay Brien | The Real World: Seattle | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Chris Melling | Road Rules: Europe | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Belou Den Tex | Road Rules: Europe | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Mike Johnson | The Real World: London | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Sharon Gitau | The Real World: London | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Chadwick Pelletier | Road Rules: Down Under | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Bronwen "Piggy" Thomas | Road Rules: Down Under | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Jon Brennan | The Real World: Los Angeles | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 5. Battle of the Seasons | Eliminated |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Winner (2) |
| Colin Mortensen | The Real World: Hawaii | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Winner |
| Jamie Murray | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Winner (2) |
| Ruthie Alcaide | The Real World: Hawaii | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Runner-up |
| Ellen Cho | Road Rules: The Quest | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Runner-up |
| Lori Trespicio | The Real World: Back to New York | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Runner-up |
| Antoine de Bouverie | Road Rules: Europe | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Melissa Howard | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Genesis Moss | The Real World: Boston | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| James Orlando | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Emily Bailey | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Eric Nies | The Real World: New York | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Anne Wharton | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Blair Herter | Road Rules: The Quest | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Ayanna Mackins | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Theo Gantt III | The Real World: Chicago | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Christina Pazsitzky | Road Rules: Down Under | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Jake Bronstein | Road Rules: Islands | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Dan Renzi | The Real World: Miami | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| David "Puck" Rainey | The Real World: San Francisco | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Amaya Brecher | The Real World: Hawaii | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| David Broom | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Jisela Delgado | Road Rules: The Quest | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Eric Jones | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Gladys Sanabria | Road Rules: Latin America | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| David Edwards | The Real World: Los Angeles | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Julie Stoffer | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 6. Battle of the Sexes | Eliminated |
| Dave Giuntoli | Road Rules: South Pacific | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Sarah Greyson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Adam Larson | Road Rules: The Quest | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Roni Martin | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner (2) |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner (2) |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Theo Vonkurnatowski | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Cara Zavaleta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 7. The Gauntlet | Winner |
| Nathan Blackburn | The Real World: Seattle | 7. The Gauntlet | Runner-up |
| Norman Korpi | The Real World: New York | 7. The Gauntlet | Runner-up |
| Mike Mizanin | The Real World: Back to New York | 7. The Gauntlet | Runner-up |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 7. The Gauntlet | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Alton Williams | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 7. The Gauntlet | Runner-up |
| Theo Gantt III | The Real World: Chicago | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Irulan Wilson | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Rachel Braband | The Real World: Back to New York | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Trishelle Cannatella | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Steve Meinke | Road Rules: The Quest | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Elka Walker | The Real World: Boston | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Matt Smith | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Montana McGlynn | The Real World: Boston | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| David Broom | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 7. The Gauntlet | Eliminated |
| Timmy Beggy | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 8. The Inferno | Winner |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 8. The Inferno | Winner |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 8. The Inferno | Winner |
| Christena Pyle | Road Rules: South Pacific | 8. The Inferno | Winner |
| Holly Shand | Road Rules: Latin America | 8. The Inferno | Winner (2) |
| Kendal Sheppard | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 8. The Inferno | Winner |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 8. The Inferno | Winner (2) |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 8. The Inferno | Winner (3) |
| Mike Mizanin | The Real World: Back to New York | 8. The Inferno | Runner-up |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 8. The Inferno | Runner-up |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 8. The Inferno | Runner-up |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 8. The Inferno | Runner-up |
| David Burns | The Real World: Seattle | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Leah Gillingwater | The Real World: Paris | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Julie Stoffer | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Mallory Snyder | The Real World: Paris | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Jeremy Blossom | Road Rules: South Pacific | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Trishelle Cannatella | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 8. The Inferno | Eliminated |
| Eric Nies | The Real World: New York | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Winner (2) |
| Dan Setzler | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Winner (2) |
| Theo Vonkurnatowski | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Winner (2) |
| Arissa Hill | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Runner-up |
| Sophia Pasquis | Road Rules: The Quest | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Runner-up |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Runner-up |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Ruthie Alcaide | The Real World: Hawaii | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Steven Hill | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Randy Barry | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Ibis Nieves | Road Rules: X-Treme | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Frank Roessler | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Nick Haggart | Road Rules: X-Treme | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Chris Graebe | Road Rules: South Pacific | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Mike Mizanin | The Real World: Back to New York | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Shawn Sealy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Angela Trimbur | Road Rules: X-Treme | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Cynthia Roberts | The Real World: Miami | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Ayanna Mackins | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Kina Dean | Road Rules: X-Treme | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Cameran Eubanks | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Jacquese Smith | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Genesis Moss | The Real World: Boston | 9. Battle of the Sexes 2 | Eliminated |
| Jamie Chung | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 10. The Inferno II | Winner |
| Landon Lueck | The Real World: Philadelphia | 10. The Inferno II | Winner |
| Mike Mizanin | The Real World: Back to New York | 10. The Inferno II | Winner (2) |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 10. The Inferno II | Winner (3) |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 10. The Inferno II | Runner-up |
| Shavonda Billingslea | The Real World: Philadelphia | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Dan Renzi | The Real World: Miami | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Julie Stoffer | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Karamo Brown | The Real World: Philadelphia | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 10. The Inferno II | Quit |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |
| Jon Brennan | The Real World: Los Angeles | 10. The Inferno II | Eliminated |

## Seasons 11–20

* Derrick Kosinski, 11 times contestant
* Kenny Santucci, 8 times contestant
* Brianna Taylor, The Ruins
* Sarah Rice, 9 times contestant
* Laurel Stucky, 7 times contestant
| Name | Original Show | Season | Finish |
| Randy Barry | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Kina Dean | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| MJ Garrett | The Real World: Philadelphia | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Landon Lueck | The Real World: Philadelphia | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner (2) |
| Susie Meister | Road Rules: Down Under | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Jamie Murray | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner (3) |
| Ibis Nieves | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Alton Williams | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Winner |
| Timmy Beggy | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| David Burns | The Real World: Seattle | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Julie Stoffer | The Real World: New Orleans (2000) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Runner-up |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Jillian Zoboroski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Quit |
| Jeremy Blossom | Road Rules: South Pacific | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Cara Zavaleta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Montana McGlynn | The Real World: Boston | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Ruthie Alcaide | The Real World: Hawaii | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Jisela Delgado | Road Rules: The Quest | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Danny Dias † | Road Rules: X-Treme | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Adam Larson | Road Rules: The Quest | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Eliminated |
| Cameran Eubanks | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Quit |
| Jo Rhodes | The Real World: San Francisco | 11. The Gauntlet 2 | Quit |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 12. Fresh Meat | Winner (4) |
| Aviv Melmed | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Winner |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 12. Fresh Meat | Runner-up |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Runner-up |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 12. Fresh Meat | Third place |
| Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Third place |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Theo Vonkurnatowski | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Chanda Sneed | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Linette Gallo | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 12. Fresh Meat | Injured |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Injured |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Eric Banks | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Johnnie McBride | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Jesse Stark | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Melinda Stolp | The Real World: Austin | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 12. Fresh Meat | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 13. The Duel | Winner |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 13. The Duel | Winner (2) |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 13. The Duel | Runner-up |
| Svetlana Shusterman | The Real World: Key West | 13. The Duel | Runner-up |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Kina Dean | Road Rules: X-Treme | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Eric Banks | Fresh Meat | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 13. The Duel | Disqualified |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 13. The Duel | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner (2) |
| Janelle Casanave | The Real World: Key West | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 14. The Inferno 3 | Winner |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Susie Meister | Road Rules: Down Under | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Alton Williams | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Cara Zavaleta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 14. The Inferno 3 | Runner-up |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Davis Mallory | The Real World: Denver | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Timmy Beggy | Road Rules: USA - The Second Adventure | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Colie Edison | The Real World: Denver | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Rachel Moyal | The Real World: Austin | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 14. The Inferno 3 | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 14. The Inferno 3 | Disqualified |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Tori Hall | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Rachel Moyal | The Real World: Austin | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Frank Roessler | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Jillian Zoboroski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 15. The Gauntlet III | Winner |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up |
| Eric Banks | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Coral Smith | The Real World: Back to New York | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| MJ Garrett | The Real World: Philadelphia | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Melinda Stolp | The Real World: Austin | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Derek McCray | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Zach Mann | The Real World: Key West | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Janelle Casanave | The Real World: Key West | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Brooke LaBarbera | The Real World: Denver | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Angel Turlington | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Alex Smith | The Real World: Denver | 15. The Gauntlet III | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 16. The Island | Winner |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 16. The Island | Winner (2) |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 16. The Island | Winner (2) |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 16. The Island | Winner (2) |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 16. The Island | Runner-up |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 16. The Island | Runner-up |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 16. The Island | Runner-up |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 16. The Island | Runner-up |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Dan Walsh | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Colie Edison | The Real World: Denver | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Ashli Robson | The Real World: Sydney | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Dave Malinosky | The Real World: Hollywood | 16. The Island | Quit |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 16. The Island | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 17. The Duel II | Winner (2) |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 17. The Duel II | Winner |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 17. The Duel II | Runner-up |
| Brittini Sherrod | The Real World: Hollywood | 17. The Duel II | Runner-up |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 17. The Duel II | Third place |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 17. The Duel II | Third place |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Landon Lueck | The Real World: Philadelphia | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| MJ Garrett | The Real World: Philadelphia | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Tori Hall | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Derek McCray | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Kimberly Alexander | The Real World: Hollywood | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Eric Banks | Fresh Meat | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Ruthie Alcaide | The Real World: Hawaii | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Isaac Stout | The Real World: Sydney | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Brooke LaBarbera | The Real World: Denver | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Davis Mallory | The Real World: Denver | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Shauvon Torres | The Real World: Sydney | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Nick Brown | The Real World: Hollywood | 17. The Duel II | Eliminated |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 17. The Duel II | Disqualified |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 17. The Duel II | Disqualified |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 18. The Ruins | Winner (2) |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 18. The Ruins | Winner (3) |
| Susie Meister | Road Rules: Down Under | 18. The Ruins | Winner (2) |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 18. The Ruins | Winner (3) |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 18. The Ruins | Winner (2) |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 18. The Ruins | Runner-up |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 18. The Ruins | Runner-up |
| Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Kimberly Alexander | The Real World: Hollywood | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 18. The Ruins | Disqualified |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 18. The Ruins | Disqualified |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Ibis Nieves | Road Rules: X-Treme | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | 18. The Ruins | Disqualified |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Brianna Taylor | The Real World: Hollywood | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Nick Brown | The Real World: Hollywood | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Shauvon Torres | The Real World: Sydney | 18. The Ruins | Injured |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Chet Cannon | The Real World: Brooklyn | 18. The Ruins | Eliminated |
| Landon Lueck | The Real World: Philadelphia | 19. Fresh Meat II | Winner (3) |
| Carley Johnson | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Winner |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 19. Fresh Meat II | Runner-up |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Runner-up |
| Jillian Zoboroski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 19. Fresh Meat II | Third place |
| Pete Connolly | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Third place |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 19. Fresh Meat II | Fourth place |
| Noor Jehangir | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Fourth place |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Luke Wolfe | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Mandi Moyer | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| CJ Koegel | The Real World: Cancun | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Sydney Walker | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Sandy Kang | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Katelynn Cusanelli | The Real World: Brooklyn | 19. Fresh Meat II | Disqualified |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Disqualified |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Jeff Barr | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Vinny Foti | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 19. Fresh Meat II | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 20. Cutthroat | Winner |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 20. Cutthroat | Winner |
| Tori Hall | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 20. Cutthroat | Winner (2) |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 20. Cutthroat | Winner |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Runner-up |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Runner-up |
| Luke Wolfe | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Runner-up |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 20. Cutthroat | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 20. Cutthroat | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 20. Cutthroat | Third place |
| Emily Schromm | The Real World: D.C. | 20. Cutthroat | Third place |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Johnny Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Dan Walsh | Road Rules: Viewers' Revenge | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Melinda Stolp | The Real World: Austin | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Chet Cannon | The Real World: Brooklyn | 20. Cutthroat | Injured |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Ty Ruff | The Real World: D.C. | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Eric "Big Easy" Banks | Fresh Meat | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Ayiiia Elizarraras | The Real World: Cancun | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Vinny Foti | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Shauvon Torres | The Real World: Sydney | 20. Cutthroat | Injured |
| Mandi Moyer | Fresh Meat II | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| JD Ordoñez | The Real World: Brooklyn | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |
| Emilee Fitzpatrick | The Real World: Cancun | 20. Cutthroat | Eliminated |

## Seasons 21–30

| Name | Original Show | Season | Finish |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 21. Rivals | Winner (3) |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 21. Rivals | Winner (2) |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 21. Rivals | Winner |
| Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | 21. Rivals | Winner (3) |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 21. Rivals | Runner-up |
| Kenny Santucci | Fresh Meat | 21. Rivals | Runner-up |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 21. Rivals | Runner-up |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 21. Rivals | Runner-up |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 21. Rivals | Third place (DNF) |
| Michael Ross | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 21. Rivals | Third place (DNF) |
| Mandi Moyer | Fresh Meat II | 21. Rivals | Third place (DNF) |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | 21. Rivals | Third place (DNF) |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Evan Starkman | Fresh Meat | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Katelynn Cusanelli | The Real World: Brooklyn | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Ty Ruff | The Real World: D.C. | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Davis Mallory | The Real World: Denver | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 21. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Adam Royer | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 21. Rivals | Disqualified |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 22. Battle of the Exes | Winner (4) |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 22. Battle of the Exes | Winner |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 22. Battle of the Exes | Runner-up |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 22. Battle of the Exes | Runner-up |
| Ty Ruff | The Real World: D.C. | 22. Battle of the Exes | Third place |
| Emily Schromm | The Real World: D.C. | 22. Battle of the Exes | Third place |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Naomi Defensor | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Heather Marter | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Disqualified |
| Dustin Zito | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Injured |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Mandi Moyer | Fresh Meat II | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Vinny Foti | Fresh Meat II | 22. Battle of the Exes | Disqualified |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 22. Battle of the Exes | Disqualified |
| Priscilla Mendez | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Nate Stodghill | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 22. Battle of the Exes | Eliminated |
| Ashley Kelsey | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Winner |
| Sam McGinn | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Winner |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Winner |
| Frank Sweeney | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Winner |
| Trishelle Cannatella | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Runner-up |
| Dustin Zito | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Runner-up |
| Chet Cannon | The Real World: Brooklyn | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Third place |
| JD Ordoñez | The Real World: Brooklyn | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Third place |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Third place |
| Devyn Simone | The Real World: Brooklyn | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Third place |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Marie Roda | The Real World: St. Thomas | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Robb Schreiber | The Real World: St. Thomas | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Alton Williams | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| CJ Koegel | The Real World: Cancun | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Ryan Knight † | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Laura Waller | The Real World: St. Thomas | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Trey Weatherholtz | The Real World: St. Thomas | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Preston Roberson-Charles | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| McKenzie Coburn | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Eric "Big Easy" Banks | Fresh Meat | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Melinda Stolp | The Real World: Austin | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Lacey Buehler | The Real World: Austin | 23. Battle of the Seasons (2012) | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 24. Rivals II | Winner (2) |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 24. Rivals II | Winner |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | 24. Rivals II | Winner (2) |
| Emily Schromm | The Real World: D.C. | 24. Rivals II | Winner |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 24. Rivals II | Runner-up |
| Frank Sweeney | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Runner-up |
| Heather Cooke | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Runner-up |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 24. Rivals II | Runner-up |
| Marlon Williams | The Real World: Portland | 24. Rivals II | Third place |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 24. Rivals II | Third place |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 24. Rivals II | Third place |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 24. Rivals II | Third place |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Ryan Knight † | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Preston Roberson-Charles | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Ty Ruff | The Real World: D.C. | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Trey Weatherholtz | The Real World: St. Thomas | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Robb Schreiber | The Real World: St. Thomas | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Trishelle Cannatella | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 24. Rivals II | Quit |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 24. Rivals II | Disqualified |
| Jessica McCain | The Real World: Portland | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Anastasia Miller | The Real World: Portland | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | 24. Rivals II | Eliminated |
| Naomi Defensor | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 24. Rivals II | Quit |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 25. Free Agents | Winner (5) |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 25. Free Agents | Winner |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 25. Free Agents | Runner-up |
| Johnny Reilly | The Real World: Portland | 25. Free Agents | Runner-up |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 25. Free Agents | Third place |
| Devyn Simone | The Real World: Brooklyn | 25. Free Agents | Third place |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Jessica McCain | The Real World: Portland | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Preston Roberson-Charles | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Brandon Swift | The Real World: St. Thomas | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Isaac Stout | The Real World: Sydney | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| LaToya Jackson | The Real World: St. Thomas | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Nia Moore | The Real World: Portland | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Frank Sweeney | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 25. Free Agents | Injured |
| Emilee Fitzpatrick | The Real World: Cancun | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Dustin Zito | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Chet Cannon | The Real World: Brooklyn | 25. Free Agents | Injured |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 25. Free Agents | Eliminated |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Winner |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Winner |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Runner-up |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Runner-up |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Third place (DNF) |
| Jay Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Third place (DNF) |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Nia Moore | The Real World: Portland | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Disqualified |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Johnny Reilly | The Real World: Portland | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Averey Tressler | The Real World: Portland | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Brittany Baldassari | Are You the One? 1 | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Adam Kuhn | Are You the One? 1 | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Disqualified |
| Ryan Knight † | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Injured |
| John "JJ" Jacobs | Are You the One? 1 | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Simone Kelly | Are You the One? 1 | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Diem Brown † | Fresh Meat | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Injured |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Left |
| Thomas Buell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Hailey Chivers | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Jessica McCain | The Real World: Portland | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Dustin Zito | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 26. Battle of the Exes II | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Winner |
| Jamie Banks | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Winner |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Runner-up |
| Mitch Reid | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Runner-up |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Third place |
| Brianna Julig | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Third place |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Rianna Polin | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Vince Gliatta | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Mike Boise | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Anthony Cuomo | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Thomas Buell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Stephen Buell | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Nicole Ramos | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Dario Medrano | Are You the One? 2 | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Raphy Medrano | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Injured |
| Shane Raines | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Disqualified |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Larissa Nakagawa | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Disqualified |
| Candice Fowler | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Injured |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Jill Tuttle | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Christina LeBlanc | Are You the One? 2 | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Emily Reese | Battle of the Bloodlines | 27. Battle of the Bloodlines | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 28. Rivals III | Winner (6) |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | 28. Rivals III | Winner (2) |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 28. Rivals III | Runner-up |
| Vince Gliatta | Battle of the Bloodlines | 28. Rivals III | Runner-up |
| Cheyenne Floyd | Are You the One? 3 | 28. Rivals III | Third place |
| Devin Walker | Are You the One? 3 | 28. Rivals III | Third place |
| Dario Medrano | Are You the One? 2 | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Nicole Ramos | Battle of the Bloodlines | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Christina LeBlanc | Are You the One? 2 | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Nate Siebenmark | Are You the One? 2 | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Jamie Banks | Battle of the Bloodlines | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 28. Rivals III | Disqualified |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 28. Rivals III | Disqualified |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Thomas Buell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 28. Rivals III | Quit |
| Simone Kelly | Are You the One? 1 | 28. Rivals III | Quit |
| Jessica McCain | The Real World: Portland | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Johnny Reilly | The Real World: Portland | 28. Rivals III | Eliminated |
| Briana LaCuesta | Are You the One? 2 | 28. Rivals III | Disqualified |
| Brandon Tindel | Are You the One? 2 | 28. Rivals III | Quit |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 28. Rivals III | Injured |
| Averey Tressler | The Real World: Portland | 28. Rivals III | Disqualified |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Winner |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Winner (2) |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Runner-up |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Runner-up |
| Nicole Zanatta | Real World: Skeletons | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Third place |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Third place |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Hunter Barfield | Are You the One? 3 | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Sylvia Elsrode | Real World: Skeletons | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Dario Medrano | Are You the One? 2 | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Ashley Kelsey | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Anthony Bartolotte | Are You the One? 2 | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| LaToya Jackson | The Real World: St. Thomas | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Theo Bradley | Real World Seattle: Bad Blood | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Quit |
| Anika Rashaun | Real World Seattle: Bad Blood | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Marie Roda | The Real World: St. Thomas | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Bruno Bettencourt | Real World: Skeletons | 29. Invasion of the Champions | Eliminated |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Winner (2) |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Winner (2) |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Runner-up |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Runner-up |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Third place |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Third place |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Hunter Barfield | Are You the One? 3 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Dario Medrano | Are You the One? 2 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Britni Thornton | Are You the One? 3 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Disqualified |
| Nicole Ramos | Battle of the Bloodlines | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Marie Roda | The Real World: St. Thomas | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Chris "Ammo" Ammon Hall | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Briana LaCuesta | Are You the One? 2 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Derrick Henry | Are You the One? 5 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| LaToya Jackson | The Real World: St. Thomas | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker | Are You the One? 3 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Eliminated |
| Simone Kelly | Are You the One? 1 | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Disqualified |
| Shane Raines | Battle of the Bloodlines | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Disqualified |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 30. XXX: Dirty 30 | Quit |

## Seasons 31–40

| Name | Original Show | Season | Finish |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 31. Vendettas | Winner (2) |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 31. Vendettas | Runner-up |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 31. Vendettas | Third place |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 31. Vendettas | Fourth place |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 31. Vendettas | Fifth place |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 31. Vendettas | Sixth place |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 31. Vendettas | Seventh place |
| Nicole Zanatta | Real World: Skeletons | 31. Vendettas | Eighth place (DNF) |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Natalie Negrotti | Big Brother 18 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Britni Thornton | Are You the One? 3 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Kayleigh Morris | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 31. Vendettas | Quit |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Marie Roda | The Real World: St. Thomas | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Joss Mooney | Ex on the Beach UK 1 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 31. Vendettas | Injured |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Victor Arroyo | Big Brother 18 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Sylvia Elsrode | Real World: Skeletons | 31. Vendettas | Injured |
| Melissa Reeves | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Alicia Wright | Are You the One? 5 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Eddie Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 31. Vendettas | Removed |
| Rogan O'Connor | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Nicole Ramos | Battle of the Bloodlines | 31. Vendettas | Eliminated |
| Hunter Barfield | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Winner |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 32. Final Reckoning | Winner (2) |
| Sylvia Elsrode | Real World: Skeletons | 32. Final Reckoning | Runner-up |
| Joss Mooney | Ex on the Beach UK 1 | 32. Final Reckoning | Runner-up |
| Paulie Calafiore | Big Brother 18 | 32. Final Reckoning | Third place |
| Natalie Negrotti | Big Brother 18 | 32. Final Reckoning | Third place |
| Marie Roda | The Real World: St. Thomas | 32. Final Reckoning | Fourth place |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 32. Final Reckoning | Fourth place |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Kayleigh Morris | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Disqualified |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 32. Final Reckoning | Disqualified |
| Jozea Flores | Big Brother 18 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Disqualified |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 32. Final Reckoning | Injured |
| Da'Vonne Rogers | Big Brother 17 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Angela Babicz | Bad Girls Club: Twisted Sisters | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Faith Stowers | Vanderpump Rules | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Derrick Henry | Are You the One? 5 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Chuck Mowery | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Britni Thornton | Are You the One? 3 | 32. Final Reckoning | Eliminated |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 32. Final Reckoning | Disqualified |
| Melissa Reeves | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 32. Final Reckoning | Disqualified |
| Turabi "Turbo" Çamkıran | Survivor Turkey 8 | 33. War of the Worlds | Winner |
| Theo Campbell | Love Island UK 3 | 33. War of the Worlds | Runner-up |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 33. War of the Worlds | Third place |
| Natalie Duran | American Ninja Warrior | 33. War of the Worlds | Fourth place |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 33. War of the Worlds | Fifth place |
| Hunter Barfield | Are You the One? 3 | 33. War of the Worlds | Sixth place |
| Mattie Lynn Breaux | Party Down South | 33. War of the Worlds | Seventh place (DNF) |
| Georgia Harrison | Love Island UK 3 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eighth place (DNF) |
| Paulie Calafiore | Big Brother 18 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Da'Vonne Rogers | Big Brother 17 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Dee Nguyen | Geordie Shore | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Stephen Bear | Celebrity Big Brother UK 18 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Ashley Cain | Ex on the Beach UK 1 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Gus Smyrnios | Floribama Shore | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Shaleen Sutherland | The Bachelor Canada 3 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Zahida Allen | Ex on the Beach UK 6 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Julia Nolan | Big Brother 17 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Natalie Negrotti | Big Brother 18 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| João Paulo "JP" Andreade | Ex on the Beach Brazil 2 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Morgan Willett | Big Brother: Over The Top | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Chase McNary | The Bachelorette 12 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Liz Nolan | Big Brother 17 | 33. War of the Worlds | Eliminated |
| Alan Valdez | Telemundo | 33. War of the Worlds | Injured |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Winner (3) |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Winner (3) |
| Dee Nguyen | Geordie Shore | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Winner |
| Rogan O'Connor | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Winner |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Runner-up |
| Natalie Duran | American Ninja Warrior | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Runner-up |
| Paulie Calafiore | Big Brother 18 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Runner-up |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Runner-up |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Finalist |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Finalist |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Finalist |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Finalist |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Joss Mooney | Ex on the Beach UK 1 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Kayleigh Morris | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Jenny West | Survival of the Fittest | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Theo Campbell | Love Island UK 3 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Georgia Harrison | Love Island UK 3 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Turabi "Turbo" Çamkıran | Survivor Turkey 8 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Disqualified |
| Idris Virgo | Love Island UK 4 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Esther Falana | BKCHAT LDN | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Stephen Bear | Celebrity Big Brother UK 18 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Nicole Bass | Ex on the Beach UK 6 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Faith Stowers | Vanderpump Rules | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Quit |
| Zahida Allen | Ex on the Beach UK 6 | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Quit |
| Sean Lineker | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 34. War of the Worlds 2 | Eliminated |
| Jenny West | Survival of the Fittest | 35. Total Madness | Winner |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 35. Total Madness | Winner (7) |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 35. Total Madness | Runner-up |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 35. Total Madness | Runner-up |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 35. Total Madness | Third place |
| Bayleigh Dayton | Big Brother 20 | 35. Total Madness | Third place (DNF) |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 35. Total Madness | Fourth place |
| Melissa Reeves | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 35. Total Madness | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Rogan O'Connor | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 35. Total Madness | Fifth place |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Dee Nguyen | Geordie Shore 17 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Christopher "Swaggy C" Williams | Big Brother 20 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Mattie Lynn Breaux | Party Down South | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 35. Total Madness | Injured |
| Stephen Bear | Celebrity Big Brother UK 18 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Justin "Jay" Starrett | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 35. Total Madness | Injured |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Jenn Lee | The Amazing Race 29 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Asaf Goren | So You Think You Can Dance 12 | 35. Total Madness | Eliminated |
| Amber Borzotra | Big Brother 16 | 36. Double Agents | Winner |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 36. Double Agents | Winner (4) |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 36. Double Agents | Runner-up |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 36. Double Agents | Runner-up |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 36. Double Agents | Third place |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 36. Double Agents | Third place |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 36. Double Agents | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 36. Double Agents | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 36. Double Agents | Injured |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Gabby Allen | Love Island UK 3 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Nam Vo | Ultimate Beastmaster 1 | 36. Double Agents | Injured |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Lolo Jones | Olympic Games | 36. Double Agents | Quit |
| Amber Martinez | Are You the One? 8 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Theresa Gonzalez | Fresh Meat II | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Demetrius "Mechie" Harris | Ex on the Beach US 3 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Justin "Jay" Starrett | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Lio Rush | WWE NXT | 36. Double Agents | Quit |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Natalie Anderson | The Amazing Race 21 | 36. Double Agents | Injured |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Olivia "Liv" Jawando | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 36. Double Agents | Injured |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Nicole Zanatta | Real World: Skeletons | 36. Double Agents | Injured |
| Joseph Allen | America's Got Talent 14 | 36. Double Agents | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Winner (5) |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Winner |
| Kyle Christie | Geordie Shore | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Runner-up |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Runner-up |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Third place |
| Emy Alupei | Survivor Romania 1 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Third place |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Fourth place |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Fourth place |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Emanuel Neagu | Survivor Romania 1 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Logan Sampedro | Survivor Spain 13 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Disqualified |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Bettina Buchanan | Paradise Hotel Sweden 8 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Ed Eason | The Circle US 1 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Priscilla Anyabu | Love Island UK 6 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Amber Borzotra | Big Brother 16 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Jeremiah White | Love Island USA 2 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Berna Canbeldek | Survivor Turkey 8 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Hughie Maughan | Big Brother UK 17 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Esther Agunbiade | Big Brother Nigeria 4 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Disqualified |
| Gábor "Gabo" Szabó | Warsaw Shore 12 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Injured |
| Corey Lay | 12 Dates of Christmas | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Michele Fitzgerald | Survivor: Kaôh Rōng | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Natacha "Tacha" Akide | Big Brother Nigeria 4 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Tommy Sheehan | Survivor: Island of the Idols | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Injured |
| Kelechi "Kelz" Dyke | Too Hot to Handle 1 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Tracy Candela | Love Island Germany 2 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Lauren Coogan | Love Island USA 2 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Removed |
| Michaela Bradshaw | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Renan Hellemans | Ex on the Beach: Double Dutch 4 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Eliminated |
| Nam Vo | Ultimate Beastmaster 1 | 37. Spies, Lies & Allies | Removed |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 38. Ride or Dies | Winner |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 38. Ride or Dies | Winner |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 38. Ride or Dies | Runner-up |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 38. Ride or Dies | Runner-up |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 38. Ride or Dies | Third place |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 38. Ride or Dies | Third place |
| Horacio Gutiérrez | Exatlón Estados Unidos 5 | 38. Ride or Dies | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Olivia Kaiser | Love Island USA 3 | 38. Ride or Dies | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Moriah Jadea | Ride or Dies | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Amber Borzotra | Big Brother 16 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Chauncey Palmer | Ride or Dies | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Kenny Clark | Ride or Dies | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Nurys Mateo | Are You the One? 6 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Justin "Jay" Starrett | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Michele Fitzgerald | Survivor: Kaôh Rōng | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Jakk Maddox | Ex on the Beach: Peak of Love | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Colleen Schneider | The Mole Germany | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Kim Tränka | Prince Charming 3 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Analyse Talavera | Big Brother 21 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Tommy Bracco | Big Brother 21 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Johnny Middlebrooks | Love Island USA 2 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Ravyn Rochelle | Ride or Dies | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Tamara Alfaro | Ride or Dies | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Turabi "Turbo" Çamkıran | Survivor Turkey 8 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Nam Vo | Ultimate Beastmaster 1 | 38. Ride or Dies | Disqualified |
| Emmy Russ | Beauty & The Nerd 2 | 38. Ride or Dies | Quit |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Sam Bird | Love Island UK 4 | 38. Ride or Dies | Eliminated |
| Emanuel Neagu | Survivor Romania 1 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Winner |
| Nurys Mateo | Are You the One? 6 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Runner-up |
| Colleen Schneider | The Mole Germany | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Third place |
| Corey Lay | 12 Dates of Christmas | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Fourth place |
| Berna Canbeldek | Survivor Turkey 8 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Fifth place |
| Moriah Jadea | Ride or Dies | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Sixth place |
| Justin "Jay" Starrett | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Seventh place |
| James Lock | The Only Way Is Essex 24 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Olivia Kaiser | Love Island USA 3 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Michele Fitzgerald | Survivor: Kaôh Rōng | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Horacio Gutiérrez | Exatlón Estados Unidos 5 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Kyland Young | Big Brother 23 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Ed Eason | The Circle US 1 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Zara Zoffany | The Royal World | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Ravyn Rochelle | Ride or Dies | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Asaf Goren | So You Think You Can Dance 12 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Melissa Reeves | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Callum Izzard | Ibiza Weekender 7 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Ciarran Stott | The Bachelorette Australia 5 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Hughie Maughan | Big Brother UK 17 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Sofia "Jujuy" Jiménez | Dancing with the Stars Argentina 2018 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Chauncey Palmer | Ride or Dies | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Jessica Brody | The Bachelor Australia 7 | 39. Battle for a New Champion | Eliminated |
| Jenny West | Survival of the Fittest | 40. Battle of the Eras | Winner (2) |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 40. Battle of the Eras | Winner (5) |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 40. Battle of the Eras | Winner (3) |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 40. Battle of the Eras | Runner-up |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 40. Battle of the Eras | Third place |
| Michele Fitzgerald | Survivor: Kaôh Rōng | 40. Battle of the Eras | Third place |
| Kyland Young | Big Brother 23 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Fourth place |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Fourth place |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Aviv Melmed | Fresh Meat | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Olivia Kaiser | Love Island USA 3 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Theo Campbell | Love Island UK 3 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Nia Moore | The Real World: Portland | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Averey Tressler | The Real World: Portland | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Emily Schromm | The Real World: D.C. | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Horacio Gutiérrez | Exatlón Estados Unidos 5 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Nurys Mateo | Are You the One? 6 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Paulie Calafiore | Big Brother 18 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Katie Cooley | Road Rules: The Quest | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 40. Battle of the Eras | Eliminated |

## Spin-offs

Camila Nakagawa debuted on the Spring Break Challenge and was on the winning team, and later became the only player to compete on the main series. The show's production officially counts All Stars and the World Championship series to a contestant's total appearances and records, but excludes Spring Break Challenge and Champs vs. Stars. The international seasons are numbered based on the order they aired.

### Champs vs. Stars

| Name | Known for | Season | Finish |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | The Challenge: Fresh Meat II | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Winner |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Winner |
| Kamerion Wimbley | Retired NFL linebacker | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Runner-up |
| Lindsey Jacobellis | Snowboarder and Olympic Medalist | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Runner-up |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Third place |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Third place |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Gus Kenworthy | Skier and Olympic medalist | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Louise Hazel | Heptathlete and Olympian | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Lolo Jones | Olympic hurdler and bobsledder | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Louie Vito | Snowboarder and Olympian | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| CM Punk | UFC Fighter/Former Pro Wrestler | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Tia Blanco | Surfer and World Champion | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Ashley Kelsey | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Shawne Merriman | Retired NFL linebacker | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Candice Wiggins | Retired WNBA Player | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 1. Champs vs. Pros | Eliminated |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Winner |
| Emily Schromm | The Real World: D.C. | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Winner |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Winner |
| Josh Murray | The Bachelorette US 10 | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Runner-up |
| Justina Valentine | Rapper / Wild 'n Out | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Runner-up |
| Michelle Waterson | UFC | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Runner-up |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Zach Nichols | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Ariane Andrew | Former WWE pro wrestler | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Kim Glass | Olympic Volleyballer | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Matt Rife | Wild 'n Out / TRL | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Riff Raff | Hip Hop Artist / From G's to Gents | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Shawn Johnson | Olympic Gymnast | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Romeo Miller | Rapper / Actor | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Quit |
| Terrell Owens | NFL wide receiver | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Quit |
| Jenna Compono | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Injured |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Eliminated |
| Camilla Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | 2. Champs vs. Stars 1 | Disqualified |
| Chris "CT" Tamburello | The Real World: Paris | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Winner (2) |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Winner |
| Casper Smart | Dancer | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Louise Hazel | Olympian | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Daniel Gibson | Former NBA guard | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Third place |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Third place |
| Drake Bell | Actor and singer | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Lil Mama | Rapper | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Brooke Hogan | TV personality | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Jozea Flores | Big Brother 18 | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Selita Ebanks | Model | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker | Are You the One? 3 | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Injured |
| Hennessy Carolina | Social media personality | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Quit |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Arian Foster | NFL running back | 3. Champs vs. Stars 2 | Eliminated |

### All Stars

| Name | Original Show | Season | Finish |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 1. All Stars | Winner (2) |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 1. All Stars | Runner-up |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 1. All Stars | Third place |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 1. All Stars | Third place |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 1. All Stars | Fifth place |
| Alton Williams | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 1. All Stars | Sixth place |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 1. All Stars | Seventh place |
| Ruthie Alcaide | The Real World: Hawaii | 1. All Stars | Seventh place |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 1. All Stars | Ninth place |
| Eric "Big Easy" Banks | Fresh Meat | 1. All Stars | Tenth place |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 1. All Stars | Eleventh place |
| Jisela Delgado | Road Rules: The Quest | 1. All Stars | Eleventh place |
| Kendal Darnell | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Katie Cooley | Road Rules: The Quest | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Arissa Hill | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 1. All Stars | Quit |
| Tecumshea "Teck" Holmes | The Real World: Hawaii | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Trishelle Cannatella | The Real World: Las Vegas (2002) | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 1. All Stars | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 2. All Stars 2 | Winner |
| MJ Garrett | The Real World: Philadelphia | 2. All Stars 2 | Winner (2) |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 2. All Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Janelle Casanave | The Real World: Key West | 2. All Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Melinda Collins | The Real World: Austin | 2. All Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 2. All Stars 2 | Runner-up |
| Ayanna Mackins | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 2. All Stars 2 | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Tecumshea "Teck" Holmes | The Real World: Hawaii | 2. All Stars 2 | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | 2. All Stars 2 | Disqualified |
| Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | 2. All Stars 2 | Injured |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Kendal Darnell | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 2. All Stars 2 | Injured |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Steve Meinke | Road Rules: The Quest | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Katie Cooley | Road Rules: The Quest | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Sophia Pasquis | Road Rules: The Quest | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Leah Gillingwater | The Real World: Paris | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 2. All Stars 2 | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 3. All Stars 3 | Winner (2) |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 3. All Stars 3 | Winner (3) |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 3. All Stars 3 | Runner-up |
| Kailah Casillas | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | 3. All Stars 3 | Runner-up |
| Nehemiah Clark | The Real World: Austin | 3. All Stars 3 | Third place |
| Nia Moore | The Real World: Portland | 3. All Stars 3 | Third place |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 3. All Stars 3 | Fourth place |
| Mark Long | Road Rules: USA - The First Adventure | 3. All Stars 3 | Fourth place |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 3. All Stars 3 | Injured |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Roni Martin | Road Rules: Northern Trail | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| MJ Garrett | The Real World: Philadelphia | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Sylvia Elsrode | Real World: Skeletons | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 3. All Stars 3 | Quit |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Kendal Darnell | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Jemmye Carroll | The Real World: New Orleans (2010) | 3. All Stars 3 | Quit |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 3. All Stars 3 | Injured |
| Laterrian Wallace | Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Melinda Collins | The Real World: Austin | 3. All Stars 3 | Quit |
| Tyler Duckworth | The Real World: Key West | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Cynthia Roberts | The Real World: Miami | 3. All Stars 3 | Eliminated |
| Laurel Stucky | Fresh Meat II | 4. All Stars 4 | Winner (2) |
| Cara Maria Sorbello | Fresh Meat II | 4. All Stars 4 | Runner-up |
| Steve Meinke | Road Rules: The Quest | 4. All Stars 4 | Third place |
| Ace Amerson | The Real World: Paris | 4. All Stars 4 | Fourth place |
| Nicole Zanatta | Real World: Skeletons | 4. All Stars 4 | Fifth place |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 4. All Stars 4 | Fifth place |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 4. All Stars 4 | Seventh place |
| Derek Chavez | The Real World: Cancun | 4. All Stars 4 | Eighth place |
| Adam Larson | Road Rules: The Quest | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Averey Tressler | The Real World: Portland | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Ryan Kehoe | Fresh Meat | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Flora Alekseyeun | The Real World: Miami | 4. All Stars 4 | Quit |
| Jay Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Kam Williams | Are You the One? 5 | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Tina Barta | Road Rules: South Pacific | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Jasmine Reynaud | The Real World: Cancun | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Kefla Hare | Road Rules: Down Under | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Brandon Nelson | Fresh Meat II | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Ayanna Mackins | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | 4. All Stars 4 | Quit |
| Janelle Casanave | The Real World: Key West | 4. All Stars 4 | Quit |
| Tyri Ballard | The Real World: Denver | 4. All Stars 4 | Eliminated |
| Adam Larson | Road Rules: The Quest | 5. Rivals | |
| Ashley Kelsey | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 5. Rivals | |
| Da'Vonne Rogers | Big Brother 17 | 5. Rivals | |
| Dario Medrano | Are You the One? 2 | 5. Rivals | |
| Frank Sweeney | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 5. Rivals | |
| Katie Cooley | Road Rules: The Quest | 5. Rivals | |
| Melissa Reeves | Ex on the Beach UK 2 | 5. Rivals | |
| Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 5. Rivals | |
| Nicole Zanatta | Real World: Skeletons | 5. Rivals | |
| Sam McGinn | The Real World: San Diego (2011) | 5. Rivals | |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 5. Rivals | |
| Steve Meinke | Road Rules: The Quest | 5. Rivals | |
| Turabi "Turbo" Çamkıran | Survivor Turkey 8 | 5. Rivals | |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 5. Rivals | |
| Amber Borzotra | Big Brother 16 | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Corey Lay | 12 Dates of Christmas | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Tula "Big T" Fazakerley | Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Devin Walker-Molaghan | Are You the One? 3 | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Leroy Garrett | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Aneesa Ferreira | The Real World: Chicago | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Sylvia Elsrode | Real World: Skeletons | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Beth Stolarczyk | The Real World: Los Angeles | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 5. Rivals | Eliminated |

### World Championship & International series

| Name | Known for | Season | Finish |
| Danny McCray | Survivor 41 | 1. USA | Winner |
| Sarah Lacina | Survivor: Cagayan | 1. USA | Winner |
| Cayla Platt | The Amazing Race 33 | 1. USA | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Domenick Abbate | Survivor: Ghost Island | 1. USA | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Justine Ndiba | Love Island 2 | 1. USA | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Tyson Apostol | Survivor: Tocantins | 1. USA | Runner-up (DNF) |
| Angela Rummans | Big Brother 20 | 1. USA | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Enzo Palumbo | Big Brother 12 | 1. USA | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Desi Williams | Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers | 1. USA | Fifth place (DNF) |
| Ben Driebergen | Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers | 1. USA | Fifth place (DNF) |
| Alyssa Lopez | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| David Alexander | Big Brother 21 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Cashay Proudfoot | Love Island 3 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Leo Temory | The Amazing Race 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Kyland Young | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Kyra Green | Love Island 1 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Derek Xiao | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Shannon St. Clair | Love Island 3 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Azah Awasum | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Melvin "Cinco" Holland Jr. | Love Island 3 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Shan Smith | Survivor 41 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Xavier Prather | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| James Wallington | The Amazing Race 32 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Tasha Fox | Survivor: Cagayan | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Cashel Barnett | Love Island 1 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Tiffany Mitchell | Big Brother 23 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Cely Vazquez | Love Island 2 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Javonny Vega | Love Island 3 | 1. USA | Eliminated |
| Troy Cullen | Australian Ninja Warrior 4 | 2. Australia | Winner |
| Kiki Morris | The Bachelor Australia 4 | 2. Australia | Winner |
| Brooke Jowett | Australian Survivor 3 | 2. Australia | Runner-up |
| Ciarran Stott | The Bachelorette Australia 5 | 2. Australia | Runner-up |
| Brittany Hockley | The Bachelor Australia 6 | 2. Australia | Third place |
| Conor Curran | Masterchef Australia 13 | 2. Australia | Third place |
| Brooke Blurton | The Bachelor Australia 6 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Konrad Bién-Stephen | The Bachelorette Australia 7 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Grant Crapp | Love Island Australia 1 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Megan Marx | The Bachelor Australia 4 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Emily Seebohm | Olympian | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Marley Biyendolo | Big Brother Australia 13 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Ryan Gallagher | Married at First Sight Australia 5 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Cherneka "Sugar" Johnson | Professional boxer | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Cyrell Paule | Married at First Sight Australia 6 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Johnny Eastoe | Australian Survivor: Champions vs. Contenders 2 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| David Subritzky | I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here! Australia 8 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Jessica Brody | The Bachelor Australia 7 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Audrey Kanongara | Love Island Australia 3 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Jack Vidgen | Australia's Got Talent 5 | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Billy Dib | Professional boxer | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Suzan Mutesi | Actress & Influencer | 2. Australia | Eliminated |
| Sol Pérez | Model and presenter | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Winner |
| Oky Appo | YouTuber | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Runner-up |
| Stéfano "Yeyo" de Gregorio | Actor | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Third place |
| Rodrigo "Rodri" Cascón | Celebrity chef | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Fourth place |
| Eva Bargiela | Model | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Fifth place |
| Claudia Albertario | Model and actress | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Sixth place |
| Lionel "Lio" Ferro | Influencer | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Seventh place |
| Julieta "Juli" de la Puente | Influencer | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eighth place |
| Adrián "Adro" Cormillot | Celebrity physician | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| María Fernanda Callejón | Actress | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Virginia "Virgie" Elizalde | Former model | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Benjamín "Benja" Alfonso | Actor | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Sofia "Jujuy" Jiménez | Model | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Rodrigo "Morita" Mora | Former football player | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Florencia "Floppy" Tesouro | Model and vedette | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Lizardo Ponce | Influencer | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Fernando Burlando | Celebrity lawyer | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Carolina Duer | Professional boxer | 3. Argentina: El Desafio | Eliminated |
| Kaz Crossley | Love Island 4 | 4. UK | Winner |
| Tristan Phipps | Made in Chelsea 16 | 4. UK | Winner |
| Nathan Henry | Geordie Shore 10 | 4. UK | Runner-up |
| Zara Zoffany | The Royal World | 4. UK | Runner-up |
| Callum Izzard | Ibiza Weekender 7 | 4. UK | Third place |
| Courtney Veale | Below Deck Mediterranean 6 | 4. UK | Third place |
| AJ Pritchard | Strictly Come Dancing 14 | 4. UK | Fourth place |
| Arabella Chi | Love Island 5 | 4. UK | Fourth place |
| Ashley McKenzie | Celebrity Big Brother 10 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Ella Wise | The Only Way Is Essex 24 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Danni Menzies | A Place in the Sun | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Marcel Somerville | Love Island 3 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Curtis Pritchard | Love Island 5 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Kaz Kamwi | Love Island 7 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Aisleyne Horgan-Wallace | Big Brother 7 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| James Lock | The Only Way Is Essex 24 | 4. UK | Eliminated |
| Jordan Wiseley | The Real World: Portland | 5. World Championship | Winner (4) |
| Kaz Crossley | Love Island 4 | 5. World Championship | Winner (2) |
| Danny McCray | Survivor 41 | 5. World Championship | Runner-up |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 5. World Championship | Runner-up |
| Kaycee Clark | Big Brother 20 | 5. World Championship | Third place |
| Troy Cullen | Australian Ninja Warrior 4 | 5. World Championship | Third place |
| Sarah Lacina | Survivor: Cagayan | 5. World Championship | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Theo Campbell | Love Island UK 3 | 5. World Championship | Fourth place (DNF) |
| Emily Seebohm | Olympian | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Yes Duffy | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Kiki Morris | The Bachelor Australia 4 | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Tristan Phipps | Made in Chelsea 16 | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Benjamín "Benja" Alfonso | Actor | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Jodi Weatherton | Road Rules: X-Treme | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Amber Borzotra | Big Brother 16 | 5. World Championship | Quit |
| Ben Driebergen | Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers | 5. World Championship | Injured |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Justine Ndiba | Love Island 2 | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Grant Crapp | Love Island Australia 1 | 5. World Championship | Injured |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 5. World Championship | Disqualified |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Zara Zoffany | The Royal World | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Nia Moore | The Real World: Portland | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Rodrigo "Rodri" Cascón | Celebrity chef | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Sofia "Jujuy" Jiménez | Model | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Nelson Thomas | Are You the One? 3 | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Claudia Albertario | Model and actress | 5. World Championship | Eliminated |
| Nathan Henry | Geordie Shore 10 | 5. World Championship | Injured |
| Chris Underwood | Survivor: Edge of Extinction | 6. USA 2 | Winner |
| Desi Williams | Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers | 6. USA 2 | Winner |
| Chanelle Howell | Survivor 42 | 6. USA 2 | Runner-up |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | 6. USA 2 | Runner-up |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | 6. USA 2 | Third place |
| Michaela Bradshaw | Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X | 6. USA 2 | Third place (DNF) |
| Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat | Big Brother 20 | 6. USA 2 | Fourth place |
| Tori Deal | Are You the One? 4 | 6. USA 2 | Fourth place |
| Josh Martinez | Big Brother 19 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Cassidy Clark | Survivor 43 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Michele Fitzgerald | Survivor: Kaôh Rōng | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Tyler Crispen | Big Brother 20 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Alyssa Snider | Big Brother 24 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Sebastian Noel | Survivor: Ghost Island | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Monte Taylor | Big Brother 24 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Tiffany Mitchell | Big Brother 23 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Dusty Harris | The Amazing Race 33 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Alyssa Lopez | Big Brother 23 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Amanda Garcia | Are You the One? 3 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Luis Colón | The Amazing Race 34 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Paulie Calafiore | Big Brother 18 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Jonna Mannion | The Real World: Cancun | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Ameerah Jones | Big Brother 24 | 6. USA 2 | Eliminated |
| Jens Thomas Rönnqvist | The Farm 2020 | 7. Sverige | Winner |
| Sandra Cucarano | Robinson 2022 | 7. Sverige | Winner |
| Jennifer Schill | The Farm 2021 | 7. Sverige | Runner-up |
| Viktor Bergström | The Farm 2023 | 7. Sverige | Runner-up |
| Anthony Yigit | SAS: Who Dares Wins Sweden 2021 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Elvira Svensson | The Bachelor Sweden 2021 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Robin Johansen | The Farm 2018 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Matilda Borgström | The Bachelor Sweden 2021 | 7. Sverige | Quit |
| Alexander Segerström | The Farm 2022 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Joanna Swica | Robinson 2021 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Helené Fransson | The Farm 2022 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Homayon Sytes | Robinson: Malaysia | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Cruise Ferreira | Robinson 2020 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Elin Härkönen | SAS: Who Dares Wins Sweden 2021 | 7. Sverige | Quit |
| Phillip-Lloyd Rochester | The Farm 2021 | 7. Sverige | Injured |
| Emmy Rönning | The Bachelor Sweden 2019 | 7. Sverige | Quit |
| Fabian Thingwall | Robinson 2020 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Izabella Anderson | The Farm 2022 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Joshua Akena | The Bachelorette Sweden 2022 | 7. Sverige | Quit |
| Isabella Resmark | Robinson 2022 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Carl Bengtsson | The Bachelorette Sweden 2021 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Olivia Baldwin | Robinson 2021 | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Greta Pierre | Robinson: Malaysia | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |
| Valentino Demina | Robinson: Malaysia | 7. Sverige | Eliminated |