# List of All-CCHA Teams

The All-CCHA Teams are composed of players at all positions from teams that are members of the Central Collegiate Hockey Association, an NCAA Division I hockey-only conference that first existed from 1971 to 2013 and was revived in 2021. Each year, from 1972–73 through 2012–13 and since 2021–22, at the conclusion of the CCHA regular season the head coaches of each member team vote for players to be placed on each all-conference team. The First Team and Second Team were named in every CCHA season after the inaugural year while the Rookie Team was added starting in 1988–89. The all-CCHA teams were discontinued after the 2012–13 season when the original CCHA was dissolved as a consequence of the Big Ten Conference forming its men's ice hockey conference, and were revived along with the league in 2021–22.
In February 2020, seven schools that had announced in 2019 that they would leave the Western Collegiate Hockey Association after that league's 2020–21 season announced that they would revive the CCHA, with league play starting in 2021–22. Four of these seven schools—Bowling Green, Ferris State, Lake Superior State, and Northern Michigan—played in the final season of the original CCHA. A fifth member of the revived league, Michigan Tech, was briefly a CCHA member in the early 1980s.
The all-conference teams are composed of one goaltender, two defensemen and three forwards. If a tie occurs for the final selection at any position, both players are included as part of the all-conference team; if a tie results in an increase in the number of First Team all-stars, the Second Team is reduced in numbers accordingly (as happened in 1974–75 and 2010–11). Players may only appear once per year on any of the first or second teams but freshmen may appear on both the rookie team and one of the other all-conference teams.

## All-conference teams

Source:

### First Team
#### 1970s

1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ralph Kloiber | G | Saint Louis |
| Roger Archer | D | Bowling Green |
| Bill Slewidge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Rick Kennedy | F | Saint Louis |
| John Nestic | F | Saint Louis |
| Ray Meyers | F | Ohio State |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Tims | G | Lake Superior State |
| Roger Archer | D | Bowling Green |
| Tom Davies | D | Lake Superior State |
| Bob Dobek | F | Bowling Green |
| Kim Gellert | F | Lake Superior State |
| John Nestic | F | Saint Louis |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Liut | G | Bowling Green |
| Al Sarachman | G | Bowling Green |
| Lindsay Middlebrook | G | Saint Louis |
| Roger Archer | D | Bowling Green |
| Kevin O'Rear | D | Saint Louis |
| Bob Dobek | F | Bowling Green |
| Doug Ross | F | Bowling Green |
| Rick Kennedy | F | Saint Louis |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Al Sarachman | G | Bowling Green |
| John Mavity | D | Bowling Green |
| Ken Morrow | D | Bowling Green |
| Bruce Allworth | F | Ohio State |
| Gary Murphy | F | Saint Louis |
| Mike Ballanger | F | Saint Louis |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Liut | G | Bowling Green |
| John Mavity | D | Bowling Green |
| Kent Jackson | D | Saint Louis |
| Mark Wells | F | Bowling Green |
| John Markell | F | Bowling Green |
| Tim Dunlop | F | Western Michigan |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Stankiewicz | G | Bowling Green |
| Ken Morrow | D | Bowling Green |
| Don Waddell | D | Northern Michigan |
| John Markell | F | Bowling Green |
| Gary Murphy | F | Saint Louis |
| Bill Joyce | F | Northern Michigan |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wally Charko | G | Bowling Green |
| Ken Morrow | D | Bowling Green |
| Tom Laidlaw | D | Northern Michigan |
| Paul Tilley | F | Ohio State |
| John Markell | F | Bowling Green |
| Mark Wells | F | Bowling Green |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Weeks | G | Northern Michigan |
| Tom Laidlaw | D | Northern Michigan |
| Don Waddell | D | Northern Michigan |
| Steve Bozek | F | Northern Michigan |
| Bill Joyce | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jim Baker | F | Ferris State |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Blake | G | Ohio State |
| Dan Mandich | D | Ohio State |
| Jim File | D | Ferris State |
| George Harrison | D | Ferris State |
| Brent Morrow | D | Ohio State |
| Jeff Pyle | F | Northern Michigan |
| Steve Bozek | F | Northern Michigan |
| Ross Fitzpatrick | F | Western Michigan |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State |
| Brian MacLellan | D | Bowling Green |
| Jim File | D | Ferris State |
| George McPhee | F | Bowling Green |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green |
| Newell Brown | F | Michigan State |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State |
| Ken Leiter | D | Michigan State |
| Garry Galley | D | Bowling Green |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green |
| Andy Browne | F | Ohio State |
| Ted Speers | F | Michigan |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Dougan | G | Ohio State |
| Garry Galley | D | Bowling Green |
| Dan McFall | D | Michigan State |
| Paul Pooley | F | Ohio State |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan |
| Dan Kane | F | Bowling Green |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Essensa | G | Michigan State |
| Gary Haight | D | Michigan State |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Craig Simpson | F | Michigan State |
| Ray Staszak | F | Illinois-Chicago |
| Kelly Miller | F | Michigan State |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gary Kruzich | G | Bowling Green |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Wayne Gagné | D | Western Michigan |
| Mike Donnelly | F | Michigan State |
| Jamie Wansbrough | F | Bowling Green |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gary Kruzich | G | Bowling Green |
| Wayne Gagné | D | Western Michigan |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Mitch Messier | F | Michigan State |
| Brad Jones | F | Michigan |
| Iain Duncan | F | Bowling Green |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Hoffort | G | Lake Superior State |
| Tim Tilley | D | Michigan State |
| Scott Paluch | D | Bowling Green |
| Mark Vermette | F | Lake Superior State |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green |
| Paul Polillo | F | Western Michigan |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Hoffort | G | Lake Superior State |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Myles O'Connor | D | Michigan |
| Greg Parks | F | Bowling Green |
| Sheldon Gorski | F | Illinois-Chicago |
| Kip Miller | F | Michigan State |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Muzzatti | G | Michigan State |
| Rob Blake | D | Bowling Green |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Kip Miller | F | Michigan State |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green |
| Craig Fisher | F | Miami |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Karl Johnston | D | Lake Superior State |
| Jason Woolley | D | Michigan State |
| Jim Dowd | F | Lake Superior State |
| Denny Felsner | F | Michigan |
| Doug Weight | F | Lake Superior State |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Mark Astley | D | Lake Superior State |
| Joby Messier | D | Michigan State |
| Denny Felsner | F | Michigan |
| Dwayne Norris | F | Michigan State |
| Keith Jones | F | Western Michigan |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Shields | G | Michigan |
| Patrick Neaton | D | Michigan |
| Joe Cook | D | Miami |
| Brian Rolston | F | Lake Superior State |
| Brian Savage | F | Miami |
| Bryan Smolinski | F | Michigan State |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Shields | G | Michigan |
| John Gruden | D | Ferris State |
| Jeff Wells | D | Bowling Green |
| David Oliver | F | Michigan |
| Brian Wiseman | F | Michigan |
| Anson Carter | F | Michigan State |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chuck Thuss | G | Miami |
| Kelly Perrault | D | Bowling Green |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Brian Holzinger | F | Bowling Green |
| Anson Carter | F | Michigan State |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Magliarditi | G | Western Michigan |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| Sean Tallaire | F | Lake Superior State |
| Kevin Hilton | F | Michigan |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| Randy Robitaille | F | Miami |
| John Madden | F | Michigan |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Alban | G | Michigan State |
| Tyler Harlton | D | Michigan State |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami |
| Bill Muckalt | F | Michigan |
| Sean Berens | F | Michigan State |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Maund | G | Ohio State |
| Mike Weaver | D | Michigan State |
| Benoit Cotnoir | D | Notre Dame |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State |
| Adam Edinger | F | Bowling Green |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jayme Platt | G | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Weaver | D | Michigan State |
| Jeff Jillson | D | Michigan |
| Roger Trudeau | F | Northern Michigan |
| Shawn Horcoff | F | Michigan State |
| Mike Comrie | F | Michigan |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| Jeff Jillson | D | Michigan |
| Greg Zanon | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Andy Hilbert | F | Michigan |
| Mike Cammalleri | F | Michigan |
| David Brisson | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State |
| Mike Komisarek | D | Michigan |
| Jeff Hoggan | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Chris Kunitz | F | Ferris State |
| Rob Collins | F | Ferris State |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Brown | G | Ferris State |
| Brad Fast | D | Michigan State |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State |
| Chris Kunitz | F | Ferris State |
| Jim Slater | F | Michigan State |
| R. J. Umberger | F | Ohio State |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jordan Sigalet | G | Bowling Green |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| A. J. Thelen | D | Michigan State |
| Derek Edwardson | F | Miami |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Jim Slater | F | Michigan State |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tuomas Tarkki | G | Northern Michigan |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| Nathan Oystrick | D | Northern Michigan |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Scott Parse | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Jeff Tambellini | F | Michigan |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Jakaitis | G | Lake Superior State |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| Nathan Oystrick | D | Northern Michigan |
| Scott Parse | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Nathan Davis | F | Miami |
| Bill Thomas | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David Brown | G | Notre Dame |
| Jack Johnson | D | Michigan |
| Matt Hunwick | D | Michigan |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Mike Santorelli | F | Northern Michigan |
| Scott Parse | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State |
| Tyler Eckford | D | Alaska |
| Alec Martinez | D | Miami |
| Kevin Porter | F | Michigan |
| Ryan Jones | F | Miami |
| Chad Kolarik | F | Michigan |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Johnson | G | Alaska |
| Erik Gustafsson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Ian Cole | D | Notre Dame |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami |
| Aaron Palushaj | F | Michigan |
| Louie Caporusso | F | Michigan |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cody Reichard | G | Miami |
| Erik Gustafsson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Eddie DelGrosso | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Mark Olver | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jarod Palmer | F | Miami |
| Zac Dalpe | F | Ohio State |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Nagle | G | Ferris State |
| Zach Redmond | D | Ferris State |
| Torey Krug | D | Michigan State |
| Andy Miele | F | Miami |
| Carl Hagelin | F | Michigan |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami |
| Reilly Smith | F | Miami |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Taylor Nelson | G | Ferris State |
| Torey Krug | D | Michigan State |
| Chad Billins | D | Ferris State |
| Reilly Smith | F | Miami |
| Tyler Gron | F | Northern Michigan |
| T. J. Tynan | F | Notre Dame |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brady Hjelle | G | Ohio State |
| Jacob Trouba | D | Michigan |
| Danny DeKeyser | D | Western Michigan |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami |
| Anders Lee | F | Notre Dame |
| Riley Barber | F | Miami |

#### 2020s

2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Jake Livingstone | D | Minnesota State |
| Elias Rosén | D | Bemidji State |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State |
| Brian Halonen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Julian Napravnik | F | Minnesota State |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blake Pietila | G | Michigan Tech |
| Jake Livingstone | D | Minnesota State |
| Elias Rosén | D | Bemidji State |
| Ryland Mosley | F | Michigan Tech |
| David Silye | F | Minnesota State |
| Austen Swankler | F | Bowling Green |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mattias Sholl | G | Bemidji State |
| Kyle Looft | D | Bemidji State |
| Eric Pohlkamp | D | Bemidji State |
| Sam Morton | F | Minnesota State |
| Lleyton Roed | F | Bemidji State |
| Jared Westcott | F | Lake Superior State |
2024–25 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Tracy | G | Minnesota State |
| Evan Murr | D | Minnesota State |
| Chase Pietila | D | Michigan Tech |
| Liam Malmquist | F | St. Thomas |
| Rhett Pitlick | F | Minnesota State |
| Lucas Wahlin | F | St. Thomas |

### Second Team
#### 1970s

1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don Boyd | G | Bowling Green |
| Don Muio | G | Lake Superior State |
| Chuck Gyles | D | Bowling Green |
| Jim Witherspoon | D | Ohio State |
| Julio Francella | F | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Bartley | F | Bowling Green |
| Dave Davies | F | Saint Louis |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ralph Kloiber | G | Saint Louis |
| Mario Faubert | D | Saint Louis |
| Bill Slewidge | D | Lake Superior State |
| John Stewart | F | Bowling Green |
| Rick Kennedy | F | Saint Louis |
| Charlie Labelle | F | Saint Louis |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| | G | |
| Kent Jackson | D | Saint Louis |
| Marc Gaudreault | D | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Hartman | F | Bowling Green |
| Mike Gaba | F | Lake Superior State |
| Julio Francella | F | Lake Superior State |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Liut | G | Bowling Green |
| Kent Jackson | D | Saint Louis |
| George Kryzer | D | Saint Louis |
| Mike Hartman | F | Bowling Green |
| Mike Gaba | F | Lake Superior State |
| Kim Gellert | F | Lake Superior State |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Tims | G | Lake Superior State |
| Ken Morrow | D | Bowling Green |
| Doug Butler | D | Saint Louis |
| Gary Murphy | F | Saint Louis |
| Wayne Ormson | F | Saint Louis |
| Paul Tilley | F | Ohio State |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian O'Connell | G | Saint Louis |
| Doug Butler | D | Saint Louis |
| Kent Jackson | D | Saint Louis |
| Bernie Saunders | F | Western Michigan |
| Paul Cappuccio | F | Western Michigan |
| Byron Shutt | F | Bowling Green |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Jones | G | Ohio State |
| Murray Skinner | G | Lake Superior State |
| Steve Weeks | G | Northern Michigan |
| George Kryzer | D | Saint Louis |
| Doug Butler | D | Saint Louis |
| George McPhee | F | Bowling Green |
| Chris Valentine | F | Saint Louis |
| Ron Sandzik | F | Lake Superior State |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Jones | G | Ohio State |
| John Gibb | D | Bowling Green |
| Mike Cotter | D | Bowling Green |
| Brian Jenks | D | Ohio State |
| Greg Kostenko | D | Ohio State |
| Rod McNair | D | Ohio State |
| Paul Pickard | D | Ferris State |
| Larry Marson | F | Ohio State |
| Paul Tilley | F | Ohio State |
| Steve Mulholland | F | Lake Superior State |
| Bob Scurfield | F | Western Michigan |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Poeschl | G | Northern Michigan |
| | D | |
| | D | |
| Paul Pooley | F | Ohio State |
| George McPhee | F | Bowling Green |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Elliot | G | Michigan |
| Steve Richmond | D | Michigan |
| Gary Haight | D | Michigan State |
| John Schmidt | D | Notre Dame |
| Dave Poulin | F | Notre Dame |
| Mark Hamway | F | Michigan State |
| Larry Marson | F | Ohio State |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Dougan | G | Ohio State |
| Gary Haight | D | Michigan State |
| Kevin Beaton | D | Miami |
| Kirt Bjork | F | Notre Dame |
| Dan Kane | F | Bowling Green |
| Dave Kobryn | F | Ohio State |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Norm Foster | G | Michigan State |
| Dave Ellett | D | Bowling Green |
| Jim File | D | Ferris State |
| Perry Pooley | F | Ohio State |
| Randy Merrifield | F | Ferris State |
| John Samanski | F | Bowling Green |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Glenn Healy | G | Western Michigan |
| Dan McFall | D | Michigan State |
| Mike Rousseau | D | Ohio State |
| Jamie Wansbrough | F | Bowling Green |
| Allan Butler | F | Lake Superior State |
| Tom Anastos | F | Michigan State |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Essensa | G | Michigan State |
| Brian McKee | D | Bowling Green |
| Chris MacDonald | D | Western Michigan |
| Paul Ysebaert | F | Bowling Green |
| Brad Jones | F | Michigan |
| Stu Burnie | F | Western Michigan |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Horn | G | Western Michigan |
| Brian McKee | D | Bowling Green |
| Jeff Norton | D | Michigan |
| Paul Ysebaert | F | Bowling Green |
| Bill Shibicky | F | Michigan State |
| Rob Brynden | F | Western Michigan |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Muzzatti | G | Michigan State |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Posma | D | Western Michigan |
| Barry McKinlay | D | Illinois-Chicago |
| Mike de Carle | F | Lake Superior State |
| Bobby Reynolds | F | Michigan State |
| Ron Hoover | F | Western Michigan |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dave DePinto | G | Illinois-Chicago |
| Rob Blake | D | Bowling Green |
| Chris Luongo | D | Michigan State |
| Bobby Reynolds | F | Michigan State |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green |
| Todd Brost | F | Michigan |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Don Gibson | D | Michigan State |
| Dan Keczmer | D | Lake Superior State |
| Jim Dowd | F | Lake Superior State |
| Darryl Noren | F | Illinois-Chicago |
| Pat Murray | F | Michigan State |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Gilmore | G | Michigan State |
| Mark Astley | D | Lake Superior State |
| Patrick Neaton | D | Michigan |
| David Roberts | F | Michigan |
| Rod Taylor | F | Ferris State |
| Mike Eastwood | F | Western Michigan |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Hillebrandt | G | Illinois-Chicago |
| Joe Cook | D | Miami |
| Steven Barnes | D | Lake Superior State |
| Sandy Moger | F | Lake Superior State |
| Peter Homles | F | Bowling Green |
| Martin Jiranek | F | Bowling Green |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richard Shulmistra | G | Miami |
| Bob Marshall | D | Miami |
| Michael Smith | D | Lake Superior State |
| Brian Holzinger | F | Bowling Green |
| David Roberts | F | Michigan |
| David Oliver | F | Michigan |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Buzak | G | Michigan State |
| Bob Marshall | D | Miami |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Steve Guolla | F | Michigan State |
| Mike Knuble | F | Michigan |
| Clayton Beddoes | F | Lake Superior State |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Buzak | G | Michigan State |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Steven Halko | D | Michigan |
| Mike Knuble | F | Michigan |
| Kevyn Adams | F | Miami |
| Rem Murray | F | Michigan State |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Sakey | G | Ohio State |
| Steven Halko | D | Michigan |
| Kelly Perrault | D | Bowling Green |
| Jason Botterill | F | Michigan |
| Anson Carter | F | Michigan State |
| Jeremy Brown | F | Western Michigan |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Trevor Prior | G | Miami |
| Joe Corvo | D | Western Michigan |
| Harold Schock | D | Michigan |
| Sean Berens | F | Michigan State |
| Joe Blaznek | F | Lake Superior State |
| Jason Sessa | F | Lake Superior State |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Bubba Berenzweig | D | Michigan |
| Brett Colborne | D | Ferris State |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State |
| Terry Marchant | F | Lake Superior State |
| Bobby Hayes | F | Michigan |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Blackburn | G | Michigan State |
| Mike Jones | D | Bowling Green |
| Andrè Signoretti | D | Ohio State |
| Dan Price | F | Bowling Green |
| Ben Simon | F | Notre Dame |
| J. P. Vigier | F | Northern Michigan |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| Kevin Schmidt | D | Northern Michigan |
| Dave Huntzicker | D | Michigan |
| David Gove | F | Western Michigan |
| Adam Hall | F | Michigan State |
| Brian McCullough | F | Ferris State |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Blackburn | G | Michigan |
| Phil Osaer | G | Ferris State |
| Andrew Hutchinson | D | Michigan State |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State |
| Mike Bishai | F | Western Michigan |
| Jason Deskins | F | Miami |
| David Gove | F | Western Michigan |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Ellis | G | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Andrew Hutchinson | D | Michigan State |
| Greg Zanon | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Mike Cammalleri | F | Michigan |
| Bobby Andrews | F | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| John Shouneyia | F | Michigan |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Betz | G | Ohio State |
| Simon Mangos | D | Ferris State |
| Troy Milam | D | Ferris State |
| Mike Kompon | F | Miami |
| Jeff Legue | F | Ferris State |
| Jeff Tambellini | F | Michigan |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Al Montoya | G | Michigan |
| Brett Lebda | D | Notre Dame |
| Nathan Oystrick | D | Northern Michigan |
| Brandon Rogers | D | Michigan |
| Aaron Gill | F | Notre Dame |
| Rob Globke | F | Notre Dame |
| Greg Hogeboom | F | Miami |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jordan Sigalet | G | Bowling Green |
| Nate Guenin | D | Ohio State |
| Matt Hunwick | D | Michigan |
| Rod Pelley | F | Ohio State |
| Bill Thomas | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Brent Walton | F | Western Michigan |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charlie Effinger | G | Miami |
| Mitch Ganzak | D | Miami |
| Matt Hunwick | D | Michigan |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Alex Foster | F | Bowling Green |
| Ryan Jones | F | Miami |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Jakaitis | G | Lake Superior State |
| Sean Collins | D | Ohio State |
| Derek Smith | D | Lake Superior State |
| Nathan Davis | F | Miami |
| Kevin Porter | F | Michigan |
| Ryan Jones | F | Miami |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Zatkoff | G | Miami |
| Mitch Ganzak | D | Miami |
| Mark Mitera | D | Michigan |
| Bryan Marshall | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Derek Whitmore | F | Bowling Green |
| Tim Kennedy | F | Michigan State |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State |
| Kyle Lawson | D | Notre Dame |
| Eddie DelGrosso | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Erik Condra | F | Notre Dame |
| Christian Hanson | F | Notre Dame |
| Patrick Galivan | F | Western Michigan |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Drew Palmisano | G | Michigan State |
| Zach Redmond | D | Ferris State |
| Jeff Petry | D | Michigan State |
| Andy Miele | F | Miami |
| Tommy Wingels | F | Miami |
| Corey Tropp | F | Michigan State |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Greenham | G | Alaska |
| Chris Wideman | D | Miami |
| John Merrill | D | Michigan |
| T. J. Tynan | F | Notre Dame |
| Anders Lee | F | Notre Dame |
| | F | |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shawn Hunwick | G | Michigan |
| Danny DeKeyser | D | Western Michigan |
| Matt Tennyson | D | Western Michigan |
| Justin Florek | F | Northern Michigan |
| Cody Kunyk | F | Alaska |
| Jordie Johnston | F | Ferris State |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Slubowski | G | Western Michigan |
| Luke Witkowski | D | Western Michigan |
| Bobby Shea | D | Bowling Green |
| Tanner Fritz | F | Ohio State |
| Ryan Carpenter | F | Bowling Green |
| Andy Taranto | F | Alaska |

#### 2020s

2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blake Pietila | G | Michigan Tech |
| Colin Swoyer | D | Michigan Tech |
| Jacob Bengtsson | D | Lake Superior State |
| Owen Sillinger | F | Bemidji State |
| Louis Boudon | F | Lake Superior State |
| Trenton Bliss | F | Michigan Tech |
| AJ Vanderbeck | F | Northern Michigan |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mattias Sholl | G | Bemidji State |
| Akito Hirose | D | Minnesota State |
| Brett Thorne | D | Michigan Tech |
| Louis Boudon | F | Lake Superior State |
| Nathan Burke | F | Bowling Green |
| André Ghantous | F | Northern Michigan |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blake Pietila | G | Michigan Tech |
| Evan Murr | D | Minnesota State |
| Josh Zinger | D | Northern Michigan |
| Isaac Gordon | F | Michigan Tech |
| Connor Milburn | F | Lake Superior State |
| Lucas Wahlin | F | St. Thomas |
2024–25 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Kotai | G | Augustana |
| Chase Foley | D | St. Thomas |
| Travis Shoudy | D | Ferris State |
| Luke Mobley | F | Augustana |
| Ryan O'Hara (ice hockey)Ryan O'Hara | F | Bowling Green |
| Brody Waters | F | Bowling Green |

### Rookie Team
#### 1980s

1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| | G | |
| Jason Woolley | D | Michigan State |
| | D | |
| Rod Brind'Amour | F | Michigan State |
| Denny Felsner | F | Michigan |
| Craig Fisher | F | Miami |
| Ken House | F | Miami |
| Peter White | F | Michigan State |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Patrick Neaton | D | Michigan |
| Glenn Painter | D | Ohio State |
| Brett Harkins | F | Bowling Green |
| David Roberts | F | Michigan |
| Doug Weight | F | Lake Superior State |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Mazzoli | G | Ferris State |
| Steven Barnes | D | Lake Superior State |
| Aaron Ward | D | Michigan |
| Clayton Beddoes | F | Lake Superior State |
| David Oliver | F | Michigan |
| Brian Wiseman | F | Michigan |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Hillebrandt | G | Illinois-Chicago |
| Chris Belanger | D | Western Michigan |
| Daniel Daikawa | D | Miami |
| Brian Loney | F | Ohio State |
| Rem Murray | F | Michigan State |
| Steve Suk | F | Michigan State |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aaron Ellis | G | Bowling Green |
| Scott Chartier | D | Western Michigan |
| Justin Krall | D | Miami |
| Chris Brooks | F | Western Michigan |
| Jamie Ling | F | Notre Dame |
| Sean Tallaire | F | Lake Superior State |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Petrie | G | Bowling Green |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Harold Schock | D | Michigan |
| Blake Sloan | D | Michigan |
| Jason Botterill | F | Michigan |
| Curtis Fry | F | Bowling Green |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami |
| Steve Duke | D | Western Michigan |
| Bill Muckalt | F | Michigan |
| Robb Gordon | F | Michigan |
| Jason Blake | F | Ferris State |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Magliarditi | G | Western Michigan |
| Joe Corvo | D | Western Michigan |
| Chris Bogas | D | Michigan State |
| Tony Kolozsy | F | Illinois-Chicago |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State |
| Randy Robitaille | F | Miami |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Marvel | G | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Daryl Andrews | D | Western Michigan |
| Josh Mizerek | D | Miami |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State |
| Joe Dusbabek | F | Notre Dame |
| Adam Edinger | F | Bowling Green |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Maund | G | Ohio State |
| Mark Eaton | D | Notre Dame |
| Mike Van Ryn | D | Michigan |
| Rustyn Dolyny | F | Michigan State |
| Mark Kosick | F | Michigan |
| Kevin Swider | F | Ferris State |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Blackburn | G | Michigan |
| Jason Crain | D | Ohio State |
| Jeff Jillson | D | Michigan |
| Mike Comrie | F | Michigan |
| David Inman | F | Notre Dame |
| Adam Hall | F | Michigan State |
| Chad Theuer | F | Northern Michigan |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| Greg Zanon | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Jimmy Jackson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Andy Hilbert | F | Michigan |
| Chris Gobert | F | Northern Michigan |
| David Brisson | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Ellis | G | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Mike Komisarek | D | Michigan |
| Brett Lebda | D | Notre Dame |
| Jeff Campbell | F | Michigan |
| Dave Steckel | F | Ohio State |
| R. J. Umberger | F | Ohio State |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Brown | G | Ferris State |
| Eric Werner | D | Michigan |
| Matt York | D | Ferris State |
| Patrick Dwyer | F | Western Michigan |
| Eric Nystrom | F | Michigan |
| Jim Slater | F | Michigan State |
| Aaron Voros | F | Alaska-Fairbanks |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Al Montoya | G | Michigan |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| Danny Richmond | D | Michigan |
| Vince Bellissimo | F | Western Michigan |
| David Booth | F | Michigan State |
| Jeff Tambellini | F | Michigan |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dominic Vicari | G | Michigan State |
| Matt Hunwick | D | Michigan |
| A. J. Thelen | D | Michigan State |
| Matt Christie | F | Miami |
| Marty Guerin | F | Miami |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wylie Rogers | G | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Joe Grimaldi | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Mike Hodgson | D | Bowling Green |
| Tom Fritsche | F | Ohio State |
| Mike Santorelli | F | Northern Michigan |
| Bill Thomas | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State |
| Tyler Eckford | D | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Jack Johnson | D | Michigan |
| Andrew Cogliano | F | Michigan |
| Erik Condra | F | Notre Dame |
| Dan Riedel | F | Ferris State |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Riley Gill | G | Michigan |
| Eddie DelGrosso | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Kyle Lawson | D | Notre Dame |
| Kevin Deeth | F | Notre Dame |
| Mark Letestu | F | Western Michigan |
| Ryan Thang | F | Notre Dame |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nick Eno | G | Bowling Green |
| Erik Gustafsson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Jeff Petry | D | Michigan State |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami |
| Max Pacioretty | F | Michigan |
| Jacob Cepis | F | Bowling Green |
| Mark Olver | F | Northern Michigan |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Connor Knapp | G | Miami |
| Chris Wideman | D | Miami |
| Matt Bartkowski | D | Ohio State |
| Brandon Burlon | D | Michigan |
| Zac Dalpe | F | Ohio State |
| Billy Maday | F | Notre Dame |
| David Wohlberg | F | Michigan |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Johnson | G | Notre Dame |
| Joe Hartman | D | Miami |
| Torey Krug | D | Michigan State |
| Chris Brown | F | Michigan |
| Terry Broadhurst | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Andy Taranto | F | Alaska |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kevin Kapalka | G | Lake Superior State |
| Danny DeKeyser | D | Western Michigan |
| John Merrill | D | Michigan |
| Chase Balisy | F | Western Michigan |
| Anders Lee | F | Notre Dame |
| T. J. Tynan | F | Notre Dame |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Slubowski | G | Western Michigan |
| Garrett Haar | D | Western Michigan |
| Robbie Russo | D | Notre Dame |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami |
| Alex Guptill | F | Michigan |
| Max McCormick | F | Ohio State |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan McKay | G | Miami |
| Jacob Trouba | D | Michigan |
| Matthew Caito | D | Miami |
| Kenney Morrison | D | Western Michigan |
| Riley Barber | F | Miami |
| Mario Lucia | F | Notre Dame |
| Tyler Morley | F | Alaska |

#### 2020s

2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mattias Sholl | G | Bemidji State |
| Charlie Glockner | G | Northern Michigan |
| Eric Parker | D | Bowling Green |
| Bennett Zmolek | D | Minnesota State |
| Bradley Marek | F | Ferris State |
| Austin Swankler | F | Bowling Green |
| Josh Nixon | F | Lake Superior State |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Béni Halász | G | Northern Michigan |
| Dalton Norris | D | Bowling Green |
| Josh Zinger | D | Northern Michigan |
| Kyle Kukkonen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Joey Larson | F | Northern Michigan |
| Lleyton Roed | F | Bemidji State |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cole Moore | G | Bowling Green |
| Evan Murr | D | Minnesota State |
| Eric Pohlkamp | D | Bemidji State |
| Luigi Benincasa | F | Ferris State |
| Isaac Gordon | F | Michigan Tech |
| John Herrington | F | Lake Superior State |
2024–25 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rorke Applebee | G | Lake Superior State |
| Rylan Brown | D | Michigan Tech |
| Isa Parekh | D | Bemidji State |
| Jakub Altrichter | F | Northern Michigan |
| Elias Jansson | F | Michigan Tech |
| Logan Morrell | F | Michigan Tech |

#### Rookie Team players by school

| School | Winners |
| Bowling Green | 12 |
| Northern Michigan | 11 |
| Ferris State | 9 |
| Lake Superior State | 9 |
| Michigan Tech | 5 |
| Bemidji State | 4 |
| Minnesota State | 2 |
| School | Winners |
| Michigan | 38 |
| Miami | 18 |
| Michigan State | 15 |
| Notre Dame | 15 |
| Western Michigan | 15 |
| Ohio State | 11 |
| Nebraska-Omaha | 7 |
| Alaska | 6 |
| Illinois-Chicago | 2 |