# National Register of Historic Places listings in Mathews County, Virginia

This is a list of the National Register of Historic Places listings in Mathews County, Virginia.
This is intended to be a complete list of the properties and districts on the National Register of Historic Places in Mathews County, Virginia, United States. The locations of National Register properties and districts for which the latitude and longitude coordinates are included below, may be seen in an online map.
There are 16 properties and districts listed on the National Register in the county.
This National Park Service list is complete through NPS recent listings posted February 21, 2025.
Download coordinates as:
* KML
* GPX (all coordinates)
* GPX (primary coordinates)
* GPX (secondary coordinates)

## Current listings

| | Name on the Register | Image | Date listed | Location | City or town | Description |
| 1 | Billups House | Billups House | March 26, 1980 (#80004199) | East of Moon 37°26′31″N 76°17′11″W﻿ / ﻿37.441944°N 76.286389°W﻿ / 37.441944; -76.286389﻿ (Billups House) | Moon | |
| 2 | Fort Cricket Hill | Fort Cricket Hill | June 15, 1970 (#70000811) | East of the Gwynn's Island bridge 37°29′15″N 76°18′22″W﻿ / ﻿37.487500°N 76.306111°W﻿ / 37.487500; -76.306111﻿ (Fort Cricket Hill) | Hudgins | Revolutionary War fortifications |
| 3 | Gwynn's Island Historic District | Upload image | May 6, 2024 (#100010202) | Generally including Route 223 (Cricket Hill Rd.), Route 633 (Old Ferry Road, N. Bay Haven Road). Route 740 (Hill Plantation Road) 37°30′20″N 76°17′32″W﻿ / ﻿37.5055°N 76.2921°W﻿ / 37.5055; -76.2921﻿ (Gwynn's Island Historic District) | Gwynn | |
| 4 | Hesse | Hesse | February 12, 1974 (#74002137) | East of Cobbs Creek off Proctor Ln. 37°30′49″N 76°21′37″W﻿ / ﻿37.513611°N 76.360278°W﻿ / 37.513611; -76.360278﻿ (Hesse) | Blakes | |
| 5 | The Lane Hotel | The Lane Hotel | March 1, 2011 (#11000065) | 68 Church St. 37°26′03″N 76°19′19″W﻿ / ﻿37.434167°N 76.322083°W﻿ / 37.434167; -76.322083﻿ (The Lane Hotel) | Mathews | |
| 6 | Mathews County Courthouse Square | Mathews County Courthouse Square | August 18, 1977 (#77001491) | Church St. 37°26′00″N 76°19′20″W﻿ / ﻿37.433333°N 76.322222°W﻿ / 37.433333; -76.322222﻿ (Mathews County Courthouse Square) | Mathews | |
| 7 | Mathews Downtown Historic District | Mathews Downtown Historic District | September 18, 2017 (#100001642) | Mathews County Courthouse Square and vicinity 37°26′01″N 76°19′16″W﻿ / ﻿37.433611°N 76.321111°W﻿ / 37.433611; -76.321111﻿ (Mathews Downtown Historic District) | Mathews | |
| 8 | Methodist Tabernacle | Methodist Tabernacle | May 21, 1975 (#75002024) | Southeast of Mathews on Tabernacle Rd. at its junction with Salem Church Rd. 37°25′19″N 76°17′47″W﻿ / ﻿37.421944°N 76.296389°W﻿ / 37.421944; -76.296389﻿ (Methodist Tabernacle) | Mathews | |
| 9 | New Point Comfort Lighthouse | New Point Comfort Lighthouse More images | March 1, 1973 (#73002037) | Junction of Chesapeake Bay and Mobjack Bay 37°18′04″N 76°16′40″W﻿ / ﻿37.301111°N 76.277778°W﻿ / 37.301111; -76.277778﻿ (New Point Comfort Lighthouse) | New Point | |
| 10 | Old Thomas James Store | Old Thomas James Store | March 28, 2008 (#08000244) | Main and Maple Sts. 37°26′01″N 76°19′14″W﻿ / ﻿37.433611°N 76.320417°W﻿ / 37.433611; -76.320417﻿ (Old Thomas James Store) | Mathews Court House | |
| 11 | Poplar Grove Mill and House | Poplar Grove Mill and House | November 12, 1969 (#69000259) | Southwest of the junction of State Route 14 and Poplar Grove Ln. 37°23′54″N 76°20′07″W﻿ / ﻿37.398333°N 76.335278°W﻿ / 37.398333; -76.335278﻿ (Poplar Grove Mill and House) | Williams | |
| 12 | Riverlawn | Riverlawn | August 22, 2012 (#12000543) | 134 Williamsdale Lane 37°24′36″N 76°20′30″W﻿ / ﻿37.410000°N 76.341667°W﻿ / 37.410000; -76.341667﻿ (Riverlawn) | Mathews | |
| 13 | Sibley's and James Store Historic District | Sibley's and James Store Historic District | March 24, 2010 (#10000093) | 239 Main St. (Main and Maple Sts.) 37°26′01″N 76°19′15″W﻿ / ﻿37.433611°N 76.320833°W﻿ / 37.433611; -76.320833﻿ (Sibley's and James Store Historic District) | Mathews | |
| 14 | Springdale | Springdale | May 23, 2013 (#13000339) | 1108 State Route 14 37°25′20″N 76°19′41″W﻿ / ﻿37.422222°N 76.328056°W﻿ / 37.422222; -76.328056﻿ (Springdale) | Mathews | |
| 15 | B. Williams & Co. Store | B. Williams & Co. Store | June 3, 2009 (#09000394) | 1030 Williams Wharf Rd. 37°24′15″N 76°20′43″W﻿ / ﻿37.404167°N 76.345278°W﻿ / 37.404167; -76.345278﻿ (B. Williams & Co. Store) | Mathews | |
| 16 | Wolf Trap Light Station | Wolf Trap Light Station More images | December 2, 2002 (#02001434) | Southeast of New Point Comfort 37°13′49″N 76°11′24″W﻿ / ﻿37.230278°N 76.190000°W﻿ / 37.230278; -76.190000﻿ (Wolf Trap Light Station) | Poquoson East | |

## Former listings

| | Name on the Register | Image | Date listed | Date removed | Location | City or town | Description |
| 1 | Donk's Theatre | Donk's Theatre | January 28, 2011 (#10001185) | February 7, 2017 | 259 Buckley Hall Rd. 37°28′18″N 76°19′35″W﻿ / ﻿37.471528°N 76.326389°W﻿ / 37.471528; -76.326389﻿ (Donk's Theatre) | Hudgins | On January 22, 2016, the roof of Donk's collapsed due to heavy snowfall from a winter storm, as did several of the outside walls. Little survived, and what remained required demolition. |