# And That's Why We Drink

And That's Why We Drink (ATWWD) is a comedy true crime and paranormal podcast created by Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz.
The show has been in production since February 2017. It updates every Sunday on a variety of podcast platforms as well as a YouTube channel where video recordings of the podcast's audio recording sessions have been uploaded since October 2019. Since its launch, the show has seen over eighty million downloads and has spawned two live tours through the United States and Canada.
In May 2019, and again in 2021, the podcast won People's Voice for Best Comedy Podcast at the 23rd and 25th Annual Webby Awards.
In March 2022, Schiefer and Schultz launched a second podcast, Rituals, produced by the Parcast podcasting network and streaming only on Spotify, which focuses on aspects of the occult, mystical and new age beliefs.
In late May 2022, Schiefer and Schulz published their first book, A Haunted Road Atlas, which debuted at #6 on the New York Times Best Sellers list for Advice, How-To and Miscellaneous works. A follow up, A Haunted Road Atlas: Next Stop, was released in September 2024.

## Format and production

The podcast is formatted into two sections. The first is the paranormal section, in which Schulz discusses a paranormal story, often dealing with suspected haunted locations, alien or UFO sightings, cryptids, and occasionally conspiracy theories or creepypastas. This is followed by Schiefer's true crime portion of the show in which she covers murders, serial killers, unsolved crimes, and abductions. The two friends, both Boston University graduates, often tell stories about their lives as well, occasionally adding personal anecdotes to the stories.
The original name of the show was "Eerie and Theory", but was changed later in the conception phase to "And That's Why We Drink", after it was jokingly exclaimed during a moment of exasperation.
Originally, the two hosts also divided themselves into "Team Wine" and "Team Milkshake," as Schiefer often imbibes alcoholic drinks during the recording sessions, while Schulz, a teetotaler, would drink a variety of milkshakes, and the two would list the reasons (both good and bad) they were drinking that episode. While this is still a way for the hosts to identify their respective fan bases (more recently including a Team Lemon), in later episodes of the show, the practice of drinking milkshakes was mostly abandoned.
On the first day of every month, the show features a special episode of "Listener Stories", in which the hosts read and react to stories of crimes and the paranormal submitted by fans, often with a theme requested by one of the hosts.
ATWWD occasionally features special guests, including the hosts' family and friends as well as comedian Lisa Lampanelli, who is Schiefer's aunt-in-law, and the podcast has done several crossover episodes with podcasts such as Wine and Crime, Morbid, and Sinisterhood, among others.
In October 2021, Schiefer took maternity leave after giving birth to her first child. During that time, Schulz continued to host the show along with a series of guest hosts, including Eva Gross and Schulz' girlfriend, Allison Goforth. Schiefer returned to the show in mid-February 2022.

## Episodes
### Regular show episodes

Regular show episodes :
| | Episode title | Paranormal topic | True Crime topic | Release date |
| 1. | Frances Ford "Cupola" and the Off-Brand Kool-Aid | Winchester Mystery House | Jonestown Cult Suicide | 9 February 2017 |
| 2. | Clothesline Cookies and the Lone Band-Aid | Whaley House | Robert Durst | 15 February 2017 |
| 3. | Paranormal Bitchslaps and the Body Examiners | The Bell Witch | Black Dahlia | 19 February 2017 |
| 4. | Demon Pigs and a Call from Tamara | Amityville Haunting | Sodder Children | 26 February 2017 |
| 5. | The "Creepy Little Thing" and a Journey of Self-Destruction | Smurl Poltergeist | John Wayne Gacy | 5 March 2017 |
| 6. | The Human Hair Version and the Worst Social Studies Class Ever | Robert the Doll | Elizabeth Smart Kidnapping | 12 March 2017 |
| 7. | A Menorah Made of Lava and the Jerry Springer of Germany | Eastern State Penitentiary | Hinterkaifeck Massacre | 19 March 2017 |
| 8. | Our First Fight and Franzia Stains... or Blood | Queen Mary Ship | Maura Murray Disappearance | 26 March 2017 |
| 9. | The Wandering Cowboy and the Pregnancy Pact, but for Boys | The Sallie House | Michael Malloy | 2 April 2017 |
| 10. | Annabelle the Doll-y Parton Impersonator and the Tap Water Scammer | Annabelle the Doll | H. H. Holmes | 9 April 2017 |
| 11. | A Drunk Pandora's Box and How to Play the Elevator Game | The Dybbuk Box | Elisa Lam Death | 16 April 2017 |
| 12. | The 300-Year-Old Drama Queen and the Bitchy 7th Grader | Busby's Stoop Chair | Carl Tanzler | 23 April 2017 |
| 13. | The Cincinnati Mobsters and a PSA for Samsung | Bobby Mackey's Music World | Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers | 30 April 2017 |
| 14. | The Old School House of Pies and Freud's Field Day | Hotel Monte Vista | Josef Fritzl | 7 May 2017 |
| 15. | A Sample of Our Outhouse and Catfished by Lucifer | St. Alban's Sanatorium | Gypsy Rose Blanchard | 14 May 2017 |
| 16. | Horse Grunts and the 1900s Policeman Who Was Also a Scarf Person | Lemp Mansion | Papin Sisters | 21 May 2017 |
| 17. | Flo & Frankenstein and Christine Has Another Stroke | Stanley Hotel | Katherine Mary Knight | 28 May 2017 |
| 18. | An Even Worse Eyeball Story and the Adventures of Captain Midnight | LaLaurie Mansion | Craigslist Killer | 4 June 2017 |
| 19. | A Great View of the DMV and There's No Such Thing as a Fun Best Friend Murder * | Hilltop House Hotel | Christine Paolilla | 11 June 2017 |
| 20. | Fun Times in the Body Chute and Em's Hairy Torso | Waverly Hills Sanitorium | Gregory Scott Hale | 18 June 2017 |
| 21. | Four Pounds of Uneaten Bacon and A Deeply Holy-Some Blonde | Villisca Axe Murders | Robert William Fisher | 25 June 2017 |
| 22. | Vicious Vices and a "Shaved Off" Shotgun | Trans Allegheny Lunatic Asylum | Robert Reldan | 2 July 2017 |
| 23. | A Demon Named Adelle and Oceans 11:06 | Roland Doe | George Joseph Smith | 9 July 2017 |
| 24. | A Ouija Board PSA and Lessons on Limes | Zozo | Xavier Dupont de Ligonnes | 16 July 2017 |
| 25. | Ghostly Frenemies and Alcala-ism | White House Ghosts | Rodney Alcala | 23 July 2017 |
| 26. | Homo-cidal Birdman and the Confessions of Shauna K. | Alcatraz | Mark Twitchell | 30 July 2017 |
| 27. | Mr. Carbunkle and A Science Class Murder | Monte Cristo Homestead | Skylar Neese | 6 August 2017 |
| 28. | Fannie and the Floppy Disk | Myrtles Plantation | Rebecca Schaeffer | 13 August 2017 |
| 29. | Seasonally Employed Ghosts and the Scottish Tim McGraw | Jefferson Hotel | Peter Thomas Anthony Manuel | 20 August 2017 |
| 30. | Slagpot Wormwood and Em's Nomadic Clown Life | Sloss Furnaces | Sylvia Likens | 27 August 2017 |
| 31. | Pretty Woman Status and the Paranormal Pirate | Driskill Hotel | The Bloody Benders | 3 September 2017 |
| 32. | Father Beelzebub and 4,000 Salutes | Anna Ecklund | Luka Magnotta | 10 September 2017 |
| 33. | Coughin' on Coffins and #WereTheBride ** | Rolling Hills Asylum | Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka | 17 September 2017 |
| 34. | A 200-lb Rat and the Dollar Store Plunger | San Pedro Haunting | Jack Unterweger | 24 September 2017 |
| 35. | A Popcorn Fortune and a Friend Named Squirrel | Summerwind Mansion | Rampart Street Murder House | 1 October 2017 |
| 36. | A German Socialist Airbnb and a Myspace Lesbian Porno | Franklin Castle | Bathtub Girls of Ontario | 8 October 2017 |
| 37. | Kyle Columbus and The Napoleon Complex but with Cannibalism | St. Augustine Lighthouse | Issei Sagawa | 14 October 2017 |
| 38. | An Alli-Ghost and the Gilded Eleventh Ballroom | Menger Hotel | John List | 21 October 2017 |
| 39. | A Girl Named German and La La Land 1 1/2 | Anneliese Michel | The Axeman of New Orleans | 29 October 2017 |
| 40. | A Fashion-Forward Victorian Ghost and Workplace Triangulation | Crescent Hotel | Edmund Kemper | 5 November 2017 |
| 41. | Dr. Carrot and the Score of Yore | Great Amherst Mystery | Herb Baumeister | 12 November 2017 |
| 42. | The Eternal Bromance and Pretty Little Liars 3:16 | Harvard Exit Theater | Ed Gein | 19 November 2017 |
| 43. | A Hell-Roaring Camp and a Chick-en-Training | Bullock Hotel | Wineville Chicken Coop Murders | 26 November 2017 |
| 44. | Turtle Tortoise and Frogger: IRL | Ashley's of Rockledge | Ursula and Sabina Eriksson | 3 December 2017 |
| 45. | Excessive Murder and Miss Vatican | June and Jennifer Gibbons | Joyce McKinney | 10 December 2017 |
| 46. | Cinnamontown (TM) and Pastor Detective | St. James Hotel | Pedro Lopez | 17 December 2017 |
| 47. | A Boozy, Goat-Horned Menace and an Unwashed Cup | Krampus | Tamara Samsanova | 24 December 2017 |
| 48 | The Island of Misfit Priests and the Easter Egg Rapist | George Lukins | East Area Rapist | 31 December 2017 |
| 49. | Bananas in Pajamas and Your Friendly Local Kioskman | Barney and Betty Hill | Lake Bodom murders | 7 January 2018 |
| 50. | Luvs 'N Laffs and an Alt-Right Turn | Loftus Hall | Jamison Family | 14 January 2018 |
| 51. | The One Where Ross Gets a Pager and a Moment of Silence for Google | South Shield Poltergeist | Ted Bundy | 21 January 2018 |
| 52. | A Reverse Pickpocket and There Goes Melinda | Fairmont Banff Springs Hotel | Michael Alig | 28 January 2018 |
| 53. | The Perm of the Century and A Call to the Apron Factory | Black Eyed Kids | Dolly Oesterrich | 4 February 2018 |
| 54. | THE ANNIVERSARY EPISODE *** | Jack the Ripper | Past Life Experiences | 11 February 2018 |
| 55. | Big (Frat) Brother and a Dixie Cup Stethoscope | Congress Plaza Hotel | Ward Weaver III | 18 February 2018 |
| 56. | Hell's Carpet and McDonald's Airbnb | Enfield Haunting | McStay Family Murders | 25 February 2018 |
| 57. | Harry Potter and the Chamber of Zombies and an Em-vis Impersonator | Russian Sleep Experiment | David and Louise Turpin | 4 March 2018 |
| 58. | Wicca-How.com and the Return of RicePudding9 **** | The House of 200 Demons | Richardson Family Murder | 11 March 2018 |
| 59. | The Spirit of AOL and Granola Silly Putto | Joshua Ward House | Slenderman Stabbings | 18 March 2018 |
| 60. | A Brief History of the Indianapolis Urgent Care and A Distorted View of Ice Cream | Central Indiana State Hospital for the Insane | Yorkshire Ripper | 25 March 2018 |
| 61. | A Human Lazy Susan and the Bloody Brunch | Squirrel Cage Jail | Leonarda Cianciulli | 6 April 2018 |
| 62. | The Musical History Algebra Podcast and Emvis Returns | Morris-Jumel Mansion | Barbara and Patricia Grimes | 8 April 2018 |
| 63. | A Good Old Canadian Gaol and the Summer of Like | Ottawa Jail | Robinson Family Murders | 15 April 2018 |
| 64. | Father Bob and Wrong Answers | Borley Rectory | Locked Room Mysteries | 22 April 2018 |
| 65. | A Gender-Neutral Wolf and Satan's Center Mouth | Dante's Inferno | Golden State Killer and Mandy Steingasser | 29 April 2018 |
| 66. | Snowflake Forest and the Bacon Society | Travis Walton Abduction | Robert Pickton | 5 May 2018 |
| 67. | The UK Office Alien and Too Much Mutton | Mothman | Lizzie Borden | 13 May 2018 |
| 68. | A Lazy River Cellar and a Buffett Tattoo | Barnstable House | Brian Shaffer | 20 May 2018 |
| 69. | The John Wick Effect and Funky Politics | Spontaneous Combustion | Wallace Souza | 27 May 2018 |
| 70. | Fall Out Walt and a Child Called Murder | Doris Bither Poltergeist | Belle Gunness | 3 June 2018 |
| 71. | Spicy Highways and the New Brazilian Evangelical Gay Church of Murderers | Yuma Territorial Prison | Suzane von Richtofen | 10 June 2018 |
| 72. | A Bonanza of Coal and the Wrong Way to Impress a Girl | Black Star Canyon | Daniel Wozniak | 17 June 2018 |
| 73. | Catholic Goosebumps and the Masked Blank | St. Louis Cathedral | Beast of Jersey | 23 June 2018 |
| 74. | A Polite Shadowman and a Phony Film School | Pantages Theater | Clara Phillips | 1 July 2018 |
| 75. | Pickled Bodies and the Grim Repo Woman | Payton Randolph House | Marlene Warren Murder | 8 July 2018 |
| 76. | A Venn DiagRUM and Detective Constable Christine | Savannah Pirate House | Shannon Matthews Kidnapping | 15 July 2018 |
| 77. | A Baptized Wonton and Spiral Notebook-ing | Children of Woolpit | Jennifer Pan | 22 July 2018 |
| 78. | Paranormal Toontown and 40,001 Mystery Experiments | Skinwalker Ranch | Joseph Kallinger | 29 July 2018 |
| 79. | A Demonic Cold Sore and the World's Smallest Violin | Peggy the Doll | Mary Vincent | 4 August 2018 |
| 80. | Paranormal Justice and a Depressing High School Reunion | Rotherwood Mansion | Paula Herring | 12 August 2018 |
| 81. | Little Pilgrims and Astrological Issues | Flannan Isles Lighthouse | Charles Cullen | 19 August 2018 |
| 82. | Everyone's Ghostly Stepdad and a Tattoo of Frosted Tips | Lizzie Borden House | Amy Lynn Bradley Disappearance | 26 August 2018 |
| 83. | Ghost Goats and Horror-scopes | Goatman's Bridge | Donald Henry Gaskins | 2 September 2018 |
| 84. | A Powerful Chicken and a Techno Haunting | Aswang | Henry Lee Lucas | 8 September 2018 |
| 85. | Transgender Lemonade and Old Ass Bowling Balls | Ed Gein's Cauldron and Bela Lugosi's Mirror | David Edward Maust | 16 September 2018 |
| 86. | The Haunted Doll Market and 420 Zodiac | Harold the Doll | Zodiac Killer | 23 September 2018 |
| 87. | Paranormal Fun Facts and Your Sister's Pony | Casper the Friendly Ghost | Jack Gilbert Graham | 30 September 2018 |
| 88. | A Low Key Brothel and a Japanese Skater Boy | Cary Hotel | Setagaya Family Murders | 7 October 2018 |
| 89. | Violent Tickling and a Hollywood Bonfire | Cecil Hotel | William Desmond Taylor | 13 October 2018 |
| 90. | High Quality Excitement and a Serial Killer Crossover | Bloody Mary | Joel Rifkin | 21 October 2018 |
| 91. | Mad Lib Disease and an Everlasting Faint | Scary Linda Stories | Ouija Board Murders | 28 October 2018 |
| 92. | Twin Theybies and a Phone Call to the Mayor | La Llorona | Scary Renate Stories | 4 November 2018 |
| 93. | The Broad of Broadcast and a Love Rhombus | Rose Hall Manor | Lauren Giddings | 10 November 2018 |
| 94. | Cocoa Pebbles County and the Cannibal Cafe | Byberry Mental Hospital | Armin Meiwes | 18 November 2018 |
| 95. | A Wendigo Named Megan and a Winnebago in the Woods | Wendigo | Hannah Graham and Morgan Harrington | 25 November 2018 |
| 96. | A Garden in the Rear and a Rejection from ISIS | Octagon House | Selfie Killer (Amanda Taylor) | 2 December 2018 |
| 97. | A Rogue Cork and The Millennium Special | Popper the Poltergeist | Katy Harris and Krystal Surles | 9 December 2018 |
| 98. | Exorcism Colonics and a Hot Sauce Love Potion | Exorcist of the Vatican | Tina Watson | 16 December 2018 |
| 99. | Paranormal Swirl and Aura Imprinting | The Ramms Inn of Gloucestershire | Yogurt Shop Murders of Austin, TX | 22 December 2018 |
| 100. | Cryptids for 400 and a Best-Friend-Elope | Mary Celeste Ghost Ship | Andras Pandy | 29 December 2018 |
| 101. | A Ghost in the Nude and a Pasta Peddler | General Wayne Inn | The Philly Poison Ring | 6 January 2019 |
| 102. | Quantum Madness and an Abundance of Icicles | Time travel and Project Pegasus Part 1 | Paul Michael Stephani | 13 January 2019 |
| 103. | Martian Beer Pong and Sweat Glands of the Hand | Time travel Project Pegasus Part 2 | Altemio Anchez | 19 January 2019 |
| 104. | The Golden Girls Horror Crossover and a Cousin Cat | Borgvattnet Vicarage | Leslie Allen Williams | 27 January 2019 |
| 105. | The Great Non-Binary Owl and Kronk's Evil Twin | Elizabeth Bathory | Medieval Falling Sickness | 2 February 2019 |
| 106. | The Worst Toy Story and an Empty Wine Stockpile | Sleep Paralysis | John Frank Hickey | 10 February 2019 |
| 107. | Ghostly Cat Toes and A Box-in-a-Box-in-a-Box | Jerome Grand Hotel | Wendi Andriano | 17 February 2019 |
| 108. | The Kings of Banter and a Mummified Lemon | Dear David (story by Adam Ellis) | Viola Drath | 24 February 2019 |
| 109. | A Tornado of Cuddles and an Extra Ab | The Beast of Gevaudan | Evelyn Dick | 3 March 2019 |
| 110. | A Pretty Little Monster and a Planetary Enzyme | The Goatman of Maryland and The Pope Lick Monster | Ira Einhorn | 10 March 2019 |
| 111. | A Ghost Tour by Em and a Mother of Pearl Pie Tin | Shanghai Tunnels | D. B. Cooper | 16 March 2019 |
| 112. | The Age of Flurida and a Florida Man Floriscope | Fort Gary Hotel | Judy Buenoano | 24 March 2019 |
| 113. | Millennial Pink and Spanish Moss Red Bug Crayons | Flagler College | Diane Downs | 30 March 2019 |
| 114. | A Gnarly Rumor and Hysterical Historians | Pascagoula Abduction | John Christie | 7 April 2019 |
| 115. | A Digital Butler and Walls Full of Secrets | Pfister Hotel | The Watcher House | 14 April 2019 |
| 116. | The Pancake Witching Hour and the Ghost of Burritos Past | Ben Lomond Hotel | Lori Hacking | 21 April 2019 |
| 117. | The Buddy system Til Death and Sprinkles of Light in the Chicago Suburbs | Spooky Food Stories | Tylenol Murders | 28 April 2019 |
| 118. | A Demon in the Drain and Pentagrams on the Golf Course | Biltmore Estate | Dana Sue Gray | 5 May 2019 |
| 119. | A Shadow Figure Selfie and Inappropriate Dream Journaling | Salem Ghosts | Jane Toppan | 12 May 2019 |
| 120. | Burial Physics and the Troll of Jackass Hill | Gore Orphanage | Cleveland Torso Murders | 19 May 2019 |
| 121. | The Plumbing Dutchman and a Murderous Glow Down | The Flying Dutchman | Jake Bird | 26 May 2019 |
| 122. | Alien Bumper Cars and MTV Crypts | Navy UFO Reports | Susan Snow | 2 June 2019 |
| 123. | The Ignoramus of Nevada and a Poisoned Prune Cake | Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program | Nannie Doss | 9 June 2019 |
| 124. | A Birdless Penguin and The Wink Face Emoji | Tic-Tac Incident | Casey Anthony | 16 June 2019 |
| 125. | A Neighborhood of Haunted Houses and Codename Vanilla Lunch | Yesteryear Village | Isdal Woman | 23 June 2019 |
| 126. | Summer Camp at the Occult Vault and A Flintstone Motorcade | Edinburgh Vaults | Bryce Laspisa | 30 June 2019 |
| 127. | Human Wine and the Postal Service Bank | Poveglia Island | Alyssa Bustamante | 7 July 2019 |
| 128. | A Lasagna House and Scrapbooks of Destruction | The McRaven House | Michael Swango | 14 July 2019 |
| 129. | A Tipsy Alien and Your Least Favorite Word | Flatwoods Monster | Shari Faye Smith and Debra May Helmick | 21 July 2019 |
| 130. | A Creature's Femur and Giovani 3:16 | Varginha UFAO | Kristen Costas | 28 July 2019 |
| 131. | A Pretzel Worm and the 'That Was Easy' Button | Tatzelwurm | Tara Grant Murder | 4 August 2019 |
| 132. | A Lost Bitch and the Weirdest Thing Said in an Interview | Eloise Asylum | Karina Holmer Murder | 11 August 2019 |
| 133. | A Dumpy Tunnel and Dungeon Lite TM | Dover Castle | Max Gufler | 18 August 2019 |
| 134. | A "Quicker Than You Look" Trophy and a Threddit RabbitHole | Haunted Toys-R-Us Locations | Kristen Modafferi Disappearance | 25 August 2019 |
| 135. | The Ghost of Lamps Past and a Pumpkin Stealing Cryptid | Bridgewater Triangle | Mary Ashford and Barbara Forrest | 1 September 2019 |
| 136. | A French Toast Ghost and the Pepper Spray Squad | Hillview Mannor | Kate Stoffel and the Biddle Brothers | 7 September 2019 |
| 137. | Satan's Little Helper and the Year of the Microwave | Pukwudgie | Elizabeth Thomas Abduction | 15 September 2019 |
| 138. | Five-Dollar Geodes and Our Neverending Awkward Phase *****] | Hodag | Edward Wayne Edwards | 22 September 2019 |
| 139. | Lemon's Cousin and the Alien Frog Vendetta | Pier Fortunato Zanfretta | Stephen Peter Morin | 29 September 2019 |
| 140. | Psychedelic Conversations and the Frogman's Lazy River | Loveland Frogman | Rotherham Shoe Rapist | 6 October 2019 |
| 141. | Alligator Neck Looping and A Casual Last Minute Seance | Moon River Brewing Company | Sara Ambrusko Murder | 13 October 2019 |
| 142. | The Buffalo Plaid Anniversary and a Sweaty, Sweaty Witch | Grace Sherwood, The Witch of Pungo | Bruce McArthur | 20 October 2019 |
| 143. | Portal Ripping Muscles and Vampire Rumors | Ghosts of the Alamo | The Carter Brothers | 27 October 2019 |
| 144. | A Baby with Teeth and Another Pillar of the Community | Pittock Mansion | Jeanne Ann Childs Murder | 3 November 2019 |
| 145. | Octo-Puns and the Goose CamTM | Beattie Mansion | Helle Crafts | 10 November 2019 |
| 146. | Iceberg Feet and Valuable Skittles | James Dean Death Car | Durham Family Murders | 17 November 2019 |
| 147. | Catsgiving and a Sleeping Tuxedo | @gr3gory88 Twitter Feed | Lindbergh Kidnapping | 24 November 2019 |
| 148. | Fro-Yo Fridays and 15,000 Slices of Dirty Meatloaf | Kay's Cross | Franklin Bradshaw Murder | 30 November 2019 |
| 149. | An Unidentified Naked Object and the Girl Who Cried Jude Law | Ogopogo | Erika and Benjamin Sifrit | 8 December 2019 |
| 150. | Soul Stealing Otters and a Detector Inspector | Kushtaka | Shannon Siders | 15 December 2019 |
| 151. | The Penultimate Sisyphean Nightmare and Cursed Raisins | Kallikanzaros | Lawson Family Massacre | 21 December 2019 |
| 152. | A Cute Bread and Breakfast and Emotional Grilled Cheese Sandwiches | Sauer Castle | Susan Cox Powell | 29 December 2019 |
| 153. | An Ego Snack and a Lemon-napping | Hotel Galvez | Mary Morris Murders | 5 January 2020 |
| 154. | An Opera About Bread and A Fake Monogrammed Private Jet for Dogs | Omni Parker Hotel | Christian Gerhartsreiter | 12 January 2020 |
| 155. | A Teatime Seance and Lin-Manuel Miranda's Next Big Hit | Houdini Part 1 | Tweed Morris Murders | 19 January 2020 |
| 156. | The Chairman of the Haunted House Committee and Too Many Walters | Houdini Part 2 | Sharon Kinne | 26 January 2020 |
| 157. | A Hollywood Alien Correspondent and an Outer Space Lemon | The Akroyd Family | Kyle Fleischmann | 2 February 2020 |
| 158. | A Vodka Blanket and Radioactive Snow Angels | Dyatlov Pass | Kevin Bacon Murder | 9 February 2020 |
| 159. | A Sinister Vibe Check and the Governor of Noodletown | Ohio State Reformatory | Donald Harvey | 15 February 2020 |
| 160. | Parry Hotter and a Choose Your Own Sad-venture | Minnesota Iceman | Dorothea Puente | 23 February 2020 |
| 161. | Bald Anchovies and the Golden Birds | Thunderbird | Dorothy Jane Scott | 1 March 2020 |
| 162. | A Gaga-Damn Delight and Sense of Crohdar | Mandela Effect | Corey Breininger | 8 March 2020 |
| 163. | The Valedictorian of Space Camp and an Alien Princess | Poltergeist movie franchise | Jesse Pomeroy | 15 March 2020 |
| 164. | A Cold-Toed Ghost and an Impromptu Ski Waxing | Langham Hotel | Sherri Rasmussen | 22 March 2020 |
| 165. | Chaotic Riffing and Noodles All The Way To The Top | Hilary Porter | Anthonette Cayedito | 29 March 2020 |
| 166. | Banjo-less Banjo Lessons and Toddlers Learning How to Podcast | Thornton Heath Poltergeist | Lindsay Buziak | 5 April 2020 |
| 167. | The 69th Chakra and a Paranormal Insurance Family Plan Bundle | Mount Shasta | Heaven's Gate Cult | 12 April 2020 |
| 168. | Lemuria Studios and a Tarantula Millionaire | Lemurians | Nancy Moyer | 19 April 2020 |
| 169. | An Uncooked Goose and a B-Side Conspiracy | Omm Sety | Mitrice Richardson | 26 April 2020 |
| 170. | A La Croix Lobotomy and a Big Golden Eye | Aradale Mental Hospital | Bain Family Murders | 5 May 2020 |
| 171. | A Vegetarian Lake Monster and a Proud Consumptive | Pepie, the Lake Pepin Monster | Murder of Kitty Ging | 10 May 2020 |
| 172. | The Paranormal Cinematic Universe and a Cosmopolitan Globetrotter | Harry Price Part 1 | Lululemon Murder | 17 May 2020 |
| 173. | Mongoose Cam and a New Gemini Icon | Harry Price Part 2 | Smiley Face Killings | 24 May 2020 |
| 174. | A Diamond in the Wall and Untarnished Vibes | Harry Price Part 3 | Michelle Knotek | 31 May 2020 |
| 175. | A Ruined Candy Crush Score and a Birthday Jimmy Buffett | Anonymous (group) | Murder of April Kauffman | 14 June 2020 |
| 176. | A Cheesecake Business Meeting and a Pop Up Seance Nightclub | The Watseka Wonder | Kendrick Johnson | 21 June 2020 |
| 177. | Gio's Burner Phone and a Very Slow Steamship Tour | Congelier House | Sherri Dally abduction | 28 June 2020 |
| 178. | Christine's News Network and a Confused Conflagration | Cornelio Closa, The Invisible Boy | Murder of Dominique Fells | 5 July 2020 |
| 179. | Gio's Quantum Point and How to Spell Meghan Backwards | Radonautica App | Murder of Rhia Milton | 12 July 2020 |
| 180. | An Alien Silver Fox and Skeleton ASMR | Elizabeth Klarer | Jeffrey Dahmer | 19 July 2020 |
| 181. | Upside Down Eyes and Tiny Doll Hand Shaped Bruises | The Island of the Dolls | Rey Rivera Murder | 26 July 2020 |
| 182. | Meghan's Ghost Writer and a Glitter TikTok Box | Leap Castle | Kyron Horman | 2 August 2020 |
| 183. | A Deeply Warped Tour and Random Dan | The Fire Spook of Caledonia Mills | Whitaker Family Murders | 9 August 2020 |
| 184. | Cheesecake Drunk and Dog Fashion Swimming | Preston Castle | Angela Diaz | 16 August 2020 |
| 185. | The Presence of Emothy and a Wine Glass Planchette | Chupacabra | Tamla Horsford | 22 August 2020 |
| 186. | The Patron Saint of Podcasters and the Age of the Spinster | Poogan's Porch | Missy Bevers | 30 August 2020 |
| 187. | Lydia Chlamydia and Father Macaroni | Eleonora Zugun | Laurie Bembenek | 6 September 2020 |
| 188. | A Ouija Board Lemon and Poetized Martinis | Legend of Sleepy Hollow | Disappearance of Joshua Guimond | 13 September 2020 |
| 189. | A Poultry Ghost and a Manasshole | SS Ourang Medan | Lorena Bobbitt | 20 September 2020 |
| 190. | An After-Life Reality Show and a Hypnosis Session Spec Script | Nelly Butler, America's First Ghost | Keddie Cabin Murders | 27 September 2020 |
| 191. | Modern Trash And The Pantsless Burrito | Mercy Lena Brown, The Last American Vampire | Juana Barraza | 4 October 2020 |
| 192. | Comfy Chic and a Full Ass Exorcism | Snedeker Haunting | Bible John | 11 October 2020 |
| 193. | An Afterlife Guard and a Rose Colored Flag | The Night Marchers of Hawaii | Israel Keyes | 18 October 2020 |
| 194. | A Lisa Frank Ouja Board and Spider Egg Gum | Zak Bagans | Ronald O'Bryan | 25 October 2020 |
| 195. | Frankenstein's Ding Dong and Haphazardly Fermented Kraut | Frankenstein | East Coast Rapist | 1 November 2020 |
| 196. | Pop Icon Werewolves and Christine's Trash Can Cocktail | Werewolves Part 1 | Cindy Song Disappearance | 8 November 2020 |
| 197. | Satan's Sourdough Starter and a Fainting Couch | Werewolves Part 2 | Neil Stonechild and the Saskatoon Starlight Tours | 14 November 2020 |
| 198. | The Chef's Kiss of Death and Some Juice Covered News | Charleston Old City Jail | Watts family murders | 21 November 2020 |
| 199. | The Surgeon Sturgeon Named Spurgeon and Big Bert in the Million Acre Wood | Loch Ness Monster | Joshua Maddux | 29 November 2020 |
| 200. | The Burbank Fish-Flopper and a Homicidal Rhombus | Winchester Mystery House | Jonestown Cult Suicide | 6 December 2020 |
| 201. | Pi Day Advent Season and a Ouija Planchette Flasher | The Fox Sisters | Phoebe Handsjuk | 13 December 2020 |
| 202. | Spiritualist Chippendales and The Murder Situation Show | Davenport Brothers | Death of JonBenét Ramsey | 20 December 2020 |
| 203. | The Abdominal Snowman and Christmas on an Embered Ash | Abominable Snowman | The Grinch | 27 December 2020 |
| 204. | This Year's Sandwich Predictions and the Old Synaprague | Golem | Son of Sam | 3 January 2021 |
| 205. | A Zero Gravity Wine Bra and a Coffee Date with Slenderman | The Simpsons Predictions | Miriam Rodriguez Martinez | 10 January 2021 |
| 206. | A Vengeful Lady Fish and Biscuits with Bear | Pyramid Lake | Cleveland Kidnappings | 17 January 2021 |
| 207. | The Return of the Plunger Fort and the Paranormal Gossip Mill | Cheltenham Ghost | Betsy Faria | 24 January 2021 |
| 208. | Creepy Coats and a Party Lemon | Japan Airlines Flight 1628 Incident | Trang Ho | 31 January 2021 |
| 209. | A Ghost's Recliner and the PTA of Covens | Bettis House | Sean Vincent Gillis | 7 February 2021 |
| 210. | The Golden Plunger Award and the London Fog Cult | QAnon Part 1 | Rajneesh Movement | 14 February 2021 |
| 211. | The Echelon Twins and a Rotary Butt Dial | QAnon Part 2 | Kitty Genovese | 21 February 2021 |
| 212. | Conspiracy Theory Lasagna and the Migraine Episode | QAnon Part 3 | The Snowtown Murders | 28 February 2021 |
| 213. | A Trashy Bunny and the Podcast Built on a Thousand Demons | Arne Cheyenne Johnson | White House Farm Murders | 7 March 2021 |
| 214. | Em's Sleep Skin and Christine's Day Skin | Headless Nun of New Brunswick | Savannah LaFontaine-Greywind | 14 March 2021 |
| 215. | Bigfoot Geometry and Tin Can Fingerprints | Sasquatch | George Weyerhaeuser Kidnapping | 21 March 2021 |
| 216. | The Opposite of a Meet Cute and a Half-Sister in Space | Laura Clarke Alien Abductions | Anthony Sowell | 28 March 2021 |
| 217. | A Mantis Manifesto and a Serial Killer's Dentist | Mantis Alien | Richard Ramirez Part 1 | 4 April 2021 |
| 218. | A Skeleton's Waiting Room and Christine's New Screen Name | Bohemian Grove | Richard Ramirez Part 2 | 11 April 2021 |
| 219. | A Papier-Mache Nose Doll and Mothman's Grandchildren | Helen Duncan | The Somerton Man/Taman Shud Case | 18 April 2021 |
| 220. | Astrophysics Improv and the Owl Queen | Back Door theory | Joe Exotic | 25 April 2021 |
| 221. | Family Nuts and the Hitchhikers Guide to the Backrooms | Backrooms Theory | Abraham Shakespeare murder | 2 May 2021 |
| 222. | The Wine Kill Switch and the Paranormal Vagina Monologues | Eva Carriere | Lin Family murders | 9 May 2021 |
| 223. | Schiefesaurus and Balonatoons | The Kracken | Ted Kaczynski | 16 May 2021 |
| 224. | The Hogwarts of Prisons and Two Generations of Cringeworthy Screen Names | Mansfield Reformatory | The Circleville Letter Writer | 23 May 2021 |
| 225. | A Baby Barcalounger and the Water Tumbler of Doom | The Black Shuck | Harold Shipman | 30 May 2021 |
| 226. | Poisonous Sharks and the Patchsquatch | America's Hircine Shifter | The Wichita Massacre | 6 June 2021 |
| 227. | The Ghouls Next Door and the Criminal Pickle Barrell | Miss Molly's Hotel | Kayla Berg | 13 June 2021 |
| 228. | Goat Cheese Marshmallows and Bougie Gators | St. Augustine Old Jail | Icebox Murders | 20 June 2021 |
| 229. | Team Aliens and the Opposite of a Jolly Rancher | Westall UFO Sightings | Ronnie Long | 27 June 2021 |
| 230. | A Cauldron of Mac and Chees and Sugar Free Gummy Bear Consumption | Agnes Sampson | Jayme Closs | 4 July 2021 |
| 231. | A Royal Jalapeño Crib and The Worst Quilt Ever Quilted | The Brown Lady of Raynham Hall | Shanda Sharer | 11 July 2021 |
| 232. | Paranormal Anxiety and a Seat in the Barking Room | Sorrel-Weed House | Charles Allen Jr. Disappearance | 18 July 2021 |
| 233. | Cryptid Smut and a Boy Boss Summer | Dover Demon | The Colts Neck Mansion Murders | 25 July 2021 |
| 234. | An Anxious Tooth Mouse and an Amateur Alligator Charmer | The Tooth Fairy | Lena Clarke | 1 August 2021 |
| 235. | Space Cowboys and Semantics Champions | The Rozwell Incident | Terrence Williams and Felipe Santos | 8 August 2021 |
| 236. | Ghostly Dog Breath and a Sardine and Sadness Sandwich | Pluckley Village | Magdalena Solis | 15 August 2021 |
| 237. | The Ghost With No Pants and a Matchmaking Serial Killer | Falcon Lake Incident | Glennon Engleman | 22 August 2021 |
| 238. | Bagelbites with Italian Seasoning and a Summer Camp Forensics Degree | Azzurrina | The Yoga Twins Murder | 29 August 2021 |
| 239. | A Trash Pile of Ghostly Magazines and the Paranormal DARE Program | Ed & Lorraine Warren Part 1 | Amanda Knox Part 1 | 5 September 2021 |
| 240. | A Haunted Hotline and a Vegan Doc Marten Sized Baby | Ed & Lorraine Warren Part 2 | Amanda Knox Part 2 | 12 September 2021 |
| 241. | Time Travel Art and Cubed Wombat Poop | Rudolph Fentz | Ivan Milat aka The Backpack Murders | 19 September 2021 |
| 242. | Ufo Potholes and Our Collective Eyebrow | Ariel School UFO Encounter | Laci and Scott Peterson Part 1 | 26 September 2021 |
| 243. | A Baker's Dozen No One Invited To The Party and A Bad Donut | Friday The 13th | Laci and Scott Peterson Part 2 | 3 October 2021 |
| 244. | A Demonic Cricut Cutter and Mercury's Mindflight | The Peabody-Whitehead Mansion | Michael and Suzan Carons aka The witch Killers | 10 October 2021 |
| 245. | Napkin Hating Ghosts and An Immortal Portal | The Ringcroft Poltergeist | Moses Sithole | 17 October 2021 |
| 246. | A Wall of Lava Lamps and Christine the Cackle Burger Witch | Hellfire Farm | Burger Chef Murders | 24 October 2021 |
| 247. | Roach Milk and Em-Raphobia | Perron Family Haunting Part 1 | Killer Clowns | 31 October 2021 |
| 248. | Paranormal Preschool Gossip and June's Podcast Calendar Models | Perron Family Haunting Part 2 | Joachim Kroll | 7 November 2021 |
| 249. | The Devil's Timeshare and Sleepwalking Mouths | Elizabeth Knapp Haunting | Trick or Treat Murder | 14 November 2021 |
| 250. | An Engineer of Good Times and Witches on Speed Dial | The Glenluce Devil | The Pillow Pyro | 21 November 2021 |
| 251. | Mercury in the Microwave and a Ghost's Attic Speakeasy | The Glenn Tavern Inn Part 1 | Susan Hamlin | 28 November 2021 |
| 252. | B-List Ghosts and French Diamond Thief Girlboss Energy | The Glenn Tavern Inn Part 2 and the Philip experiment | Jeanne De Valois-Saint Remi | 5 December 2021 |
| 253. | The Funcle Takeover and The Crime of Christine | Bunnyman Bridge Part 1 | Jurgen Bartsch | 12 December 2021 |
| 254. | The Bunnyman Bridge 5K and Pre-Halloween Santa Hats | Bunnyman Bridge Part 2 | Bathsheba Spooner | 19 December 2021 |
| 255. | Holiday Cryptid Friends and a Very Merry Christmas | Belsnickel | Santa Crimes | 26 December 2021 |
| 256. | The Quest for Vegan Fried Chicken And Waffles and a Ghost's Nightcap | The Olde Pink House | Fritz Haarman | 2 January 2022 |
| 257. | Xandy's Castle Roommate and Spicy Lighthouse Decor | Point Lookout Lighthouse | The Little Ross Lighthouse Murder | 9 January 2022 |
| 258. | One Titty Out History and Eternal Skinny Dipping | Castle of Good Hope | The Old Charleston Jail and Lavinia Fisher | 16 January 2022 |
| 259. | Ectoplasm Happy Hour and A Haunted Lawnmower | Ten Cent Beer Night | Pete the Poltergeist | 23 January 2022 |
| 260. | Detective Spatula and Beard Forensics | Old Baraboo Inn | Teresita Basa | 30 January 2022 |
| 261. | Supernatural Roaches and Ghost Potatoes | Curtis House Inn aka the 1754 House | Oscar Pistorius | 6 February 2022 |
| 262. | The Quadratic Formula for Our Crushes and AIM Screen Name Numerology | Numerology | Disappearance of Patti Adkins | 13 February 2022 |
| 263. | Best Friend TV Show Betrayal and the Era of Frappuccinos | Korner's Folly | Joyce Chiang | 20 February 2022 |
| 264. | Our Newfound Noodles and Christine's Quantum Thoughts | Urban legend of stairs in the woods that lead to nowhere | Élan School Part 1 | 27 February 2022 |
| 265. | Generation Xiinön and Intergalactic Instant Messages | Fermi paradox | Élan School Part 2 | 6 March 2022 |
| 266. | Em's Condemned Troll Hole and a Ouija Related Genital Bridge | History of Ouija boards | Nikko Jenkins | 13 March 2022 |
| 267. | Wooing Tactics and the Emothy Sunrise | Anansi's Goatman | Ramsay Scrivo | 20 March 2022 |
| 268. | A Sea Shanty for Christine and Paranormal FaceTime | Stone Lion Inn | Angel Makers of Nagyrév | 27 March 2022 |
| 269. | Cardiologically Speaking and a Magical Scarf Swoosh | Twin Bridges Orphanage | The Chess Board Killer Part 1 | 3 April 2022 |
| 270. | A Gold-Dipped Pickle and the Empurrress | The Palmer House | The Chess Board Killer Part 2 | 10 April 2022 |
| 271. | A Top-Heavy Brain and a Beer Can Easter | Barbro Karlén | Disappearance of Mekayla Bali | 17 April 2022 |
| 272. | The Most Emo Cryptid and the Emcyclopedia | Squonk | Hybristophilia | 24 April 2022 |
| 273. | The Jim Halpert of Ghosts and the People Pleasing Outlaw | Missouri State Penitentiary | Milton Sharp | 1 May 2022 |
| 274. | Psychic Clouds and a Literal Goldmine | Stone tape theory | 1976 Chowchilla kidnapping | 8 May 2022 |
| 275. | The Thneed of Kentucky and the Stigmata of Squidward Tentacles | Glamis Castle | Teresita Basa | 15 May 2022 |
| 276. | Christine Junior and Our Flatlined Sanity | Wyoming Frontier Prison | The Lego Murder | 22 May 2022 |
| 277. | A Grass-Fed Cryptid and Trash Snacks | Fresno Nightcrawler | Mantell UFO Incident | 29 May 2022 |
| 278. | A Birthday Demon and a Lunar Lemon | Alma Fielding/The Croyden Poltergeist | Cletus Hehmz | 5 June 2022 |
| 279. | Burnt Microphones and the Hauntland | Becker 1971 televised exorcism Part 1 | Richard Chase | 12 June 2022 |
| 280. | Emothy Phantom and the Walt Disney of Ghosts | Becker 1971 televised exorcism Part 2 | Bertha Gifford | 19 June 2022 |
| 281. | A Gossip Corner Dinner Trap and Facts Served Up on a Celery Dish | Emlen Physick Estate | Springfield Three | 26 June 2022 |
| 282. | A Sleep Zoo and a Big Gay Bathroom | Maringa Abduction aka AGRIPO Experiment | Belle Siddons aka Madame Vestal | 3 July 2022 |
| 283. | A Psychic Wordle Turtle and a Tangent Lasagna | Mirassol Abductions | Oklahoma Girl Scout murders Part 1 | 10 July 2022 |
| 284. | The Troll Hole Emporium and the Time Traveling Wedgie Patrol | Tizzie Whizie | Oklahoma Girl Scout murders Part 2 | 17 July 2022 |
| 285. | An Emergency Bag Escape Room and a Pantsless Recording | Afanc and the Lavellan | Lisa McVey | 24 July 2022 |
| 286. | A Middle Finger Lemon Manicure and the Devil's Night-Time Corn Walk | Devil's Tramping Ground (North Carolina) | Nicholas Barclay | 31 July 2022 |
| 287. | The Gay Bathroom Invite Revisited and a Selection of Mothman Mugs | Tarrare | Texarkana Moonlight Murders | 7 August 2022 |
| 288. | A Podcast Done via Ouija Board and a Bewitched Cow | Trial of Mary Webster (Witch of Hadley) | Van Breda Family Murder | 14 August 2022 |
| 289. | Jewish Deli Chocolate Milk and Microsoft PowerPoint Dissolve Ghosts | Spring-heeled Jack | Lake Oconee murders | 21 August 2022 |
| | Special Episode: 2nd Annual Cryptids Unscripted Poetry Slam and Charity Auction | | | 21 August 2022 |
| 290. | Psychic Surgery Dreams and Christine's Principle's of Magic | Moundsville Penitentiary | Children of Thunder Part 1 | 28 August 2022 |
| 291. | Router Hauntings and Our Weekly World News Broadcasting Voices | Batsquatch | Children of Thunder Part 2 | 4 September 2022 |
| 292. | Hellhound Belly Rubs and Caveman Ghost Tchotchkes | U.S. Route 66 | Angela Hammond | 11 September 2022 |
| 293. | A Hottie Without a Body and the Fun Factory | Enfield Monster | Alferd Packer | 18 September 2022 |
| 294. | Strawberry Eyeballs and Our Wildest Autumnal Dreams | Crosswick Snake/Monster | The Scarlet Letter murder | 25 September 2022 |
| 295. | A Yak Attack and a Kidnapper's SoundCloud | Ghosts of Port Townsend | Abduction of Denise Huskins | 2 October 2022 |
| 296. | A Lemon Planchette Read-a-Long Graphic and a Material Girl Coffin | Manresa Castle | Alexander family and the Lorber Cult | 9 October 2022 |
| 297. | A Halloween Holiday Gift and Justice for Book | Selkie | Abduction of Shawn Hornbeck | 16 October 2022 |
| 298. | A Merch Bag of Dirt and the Latest Sensation for Jaded Lovers of Uncanny Things | Haunted coal mines | Pamela Smart | 23 October 2022 |
| 299. | A Lesson in Filaments and a Future Ghost Prank | Hotel del Coronado | Jane Marie Prichard | 30 October 2022 |
| 300. | Bougie Ghost Hunting and Wafts of Fog Friends | Winchester Mystery House, in person | Listener stories, paranormal equipment, EVPs | 6 November 2022 |
| 301. | Jack-o-lantern Moths and Spooky Smiles | History of Halloween traditions | Susan Kuhnhausen | 13 November 2022 |
| 302. | An Elbow Eyebrow and an Asparagus Salad | Berry Pomeroy Castle | Stacey Castor | 20 November 2022 |
| 303. | A Pumpkin Head and a Biased Bisexual | Disappearance of Frederick Valentich | Murder of Mandy Stavik | 27 November 2022 |
| 304. | Hand Paws and Wisconsinners | Beast of Bray Road | Athalia Ponsell Lindsley | 4 December 2022 |
| 305. | An Onion of a Drink and a Real Life Fish Flop | Greenbrier Ghost | Stalking of Laura Black | 11 December 2022 |
| 306. | Mailed Stale French Fries and Rogue Eyebrows | Greyfriars Kirkyard | Napa Valley Halloween Murders | 18 December 2022 |
| 307. | Secret Krampus and Creepy Cake | Perchta, Mari Lwyd, and Hans Trapp | Murders of Ed and Minnie Maurin | 25 December 2022 |
| 308. | Trenchfoot Animation and Ballhootin' Through the Holler | Dullahan | Murders along the Appalachian trail | 1 January 2023 |
| 309. | A Haunted Doll Book Club and a Murder Comic | Terrell Copeland UFO sightings | Cordelia Botkin | 8 January 2023 |
| 310. | The Town Shrieker and the Grape Escape | Banshee | Case that Stockholm Syndrome originated from Part 1 | 15 January 2023 |
| 311. | Vaudeville Canes and Hand-Clap Games | Tower of London | Case that Stockholm Syndrome originated from Part 2 | 22 January 2023 |
| 312. | Our AIM Renaissance and Our Cryptid Festival Year | Van Meter Visitor | Connecticut River Valley Killer | 29 January 2023 |
| 313. | Tommy Pickles Voice and Milkshake Throat | Haunted dorm rooms | Murder of Carole Garton | 5 February 2023 |
| 314. | Haircuts for Haunted Dolls and Christine's October Elf on the Shelf | Six haunted dolls | Christa Pike | 12 February 2023 |
| 315. | A Compendium on the Birds of Kentucky and a Celebrity Opossum | Torsåker witch trials of Sweden | Murder of Connie Dabate | 19 February 2023 |
| 316. | Em's Apothecary and a Tincture of Frenzy | The Seven Deadly Sins | Alice and Gerald Uden | 26 February 2023 |
| 317. | An Emergency Snuggie and a Vitaminute | Tallman House in Horicon, Wisconsin | Abduction of Katie Poirier | 5 March 2023 |
| 318. | Collateral Damage to Everyone's Misdeeds and Thor Peanut Butter Schiefer Schultz | Crossroads | Murder of Molly Watson | 13 March 2023 |
| 319. | Synchronicity Sandwiches and Long Lost Mustard Friends | Liminal spaces, Hecate | Murder of Janet Abaroa | 19 March 2023 |
| 320. | A Lucid Dreaming Banana Experience and the Famous Saint Jack-in-the-Box Ley Line | Ley lines | Disappearance of Lauren Spierer | 26 March 2023 |
| 321. | A Coffee Unboxing and a Boiling Milk Cocktail | Mollie Fancher aka the Brooklyn Enigma aka the Fasting Girl | Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Part 1 | 2 April 2023 |
| 322. | The Halloween House and the Woolper News | Mammoth Cave in Kentucky | Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Part 2 | 9 April 2023 |
| 323. | Em's Galactic Bartending and Christine's Grog Shoppe | The Scottish play | Burke and Hare | 16 April 2023 |
| 324. | Foot Pimples and Chicken Pox Parties | Stigmatized property law aka the Ghostbuster Ruling | Kathleen Peterson aka the Staircase Murder | 23 April 2023 |
| 325. | Last Minute Lasik and Nonsense for Your Mind | The Union Screaming House in Missouri | Jared Fogle | 30 April 2023 |
| 326. | Step-Stud Muffins and Microphone Kisses | Abductions in the story of Brian Scott | Murder of Angie Dodge | 7 May 2023 |
| 327. | Consensual Foot Blister Pics and the Speaking Your Mind Dance | Moffitt Family haunting | Lewis–Clark Valley murders | 14 May 2023 |
| 328. | A Wicked Birthday Card and a Vampirarchy | Highgate Vampire | Murder of Ellen Sherman | 21 May 2023 |
| 329. | Sad Happy Hour and Night Nuts | Doppelgänger | Red Barn Murder | 28 May 2023 |
| 330. | Psychic Grandma and Swimming in Jeans | Kinsella twins UFO encounters | Duggar family | 4 June 2023 |
| 331. | A Milky Way Martini and a Naughty Gaudy Party | Ghost stories of the University of Toronto | The Porco family murders | 11 June 2023 |
| 332. | The Mysterious Bisexual and the Sauce of Time | Time traveler Sergei Ponomarenko | Murder of Nona Dirksmeyer | 18 June 2023 |
| 333. | Glowing Green Spaghetti Bolognese and a Teeny Tiny Apothecary | David Grusch UFO whistleblower claims | Case of Ryan Waller | 25 June 2023 |
| 334. | Macarena of Veins and Casper's Foil | Hotel Alex Johnson | Murder of Grace Millane | 2 July 2023 |
| 335. | The Gospel of Chillax and a Plot Tornado | Sister Magdalena of the Cross | Lady of the Dunes | 9 July 2023 |
| 336. | An Armoire of Brandy Snifters and Mug Madness | UFO encounter of Snippy the horse | Hall–Mills murder case | 16 July 2023 |
| 337. | An Empire of Ems and a Sitcom about a Wizard's Origin Story | Dudleytown, Connecticut | eBay stalking scandal | 23 July 2023 |
| 338. | Caramel Apple Eating Ghosts and Moist Brains | Franz Mesmer | Malaysian Airlines Flight 370 | 30 July 2023 |
| 339. | A Time Capsule Era and a Weasel Break-In | 2012 doomsday prophecy | Viktoria Nasyrova | 6 August 2023 |
| 340. | Midnight Moon Bounces and Moody Away Messages | The Demon of Brownsville Road | Kelly Cochran | 13 August 2023 |
| 341. | Conversations with Fake Allison and Cast Iron Skeletons | Shaker's Cigar Bar in Milwaukee | Sherri Papini kidnapping hoax | 20 August 2023 |
| 342. | A Soft Launched Haunting and a Paranormal Rat King | Madison Seminary | Lori Arnold AKA the Queen of Meth | 27 August 2023 |
| 343. | Cute Mishaps and Emoticon Etiquette | Ghosts of Yosemite National Park | Costa Concordia disaster | 3 September 2023 |
| 344. | A Neon Parrot Beacon and a Hootenanny of Birds with Pigtails | La Lechuza aka the witch owl | Malcolm MacArthur | 10 September 2023 |
| 345. | Baba Yaga Barbie and Emergency Needlepoint | Baba Yaga | Lost Boys of Bucks County | 17 September 2023 |
| 346. | A Witch's Rap Battle and a Cursed Fart | John Darrell | Lucie Blackman | 24 September 2023 |
| 347. | A Lovely Villain Era and a Lasagna Horror | Hauntings of Lake Lanier | Billy the Kid | 1 October 2023 |
| 348. | Stolen Meditation Journals and Fun, Fruity Pond Water | The Catskills Crone | Barnes Mystery aka the murder of Julia Martha Thomas | 8 October 2023 |
| | 3rd Annual Cryptids Unscripted Poetry Slam | | | 13 October 2023 |
| 349. | A Haunted Podcast Studio and a Space Boat | Project Blue Book | Disappearance of Susan Wolff | 15 October 2023 |
| 350. | Eyelid Licking Demons and Black Cat Broomsticks | Black cat lore | Heather Mayer | 22 October 2023 |
| 351. | Mongoose Sound-Waves and Halloween Caroling | Seven princes of Hell | Halloween pranks and crimes | 29 October 2023 |
| | BONUS EPISODE: A Halloween Surprise with Roz Hernandez! | | | 31 October 2023 |
| 352. | A Vampire Castle Gift Shop and Millennial Secret Passageway Dreams | Vlad the Impaler and the hauntings of Bran Castle | Murder of Martha Moxley | 5 November 2023 |
| 353. | A Weird Date Agent and a Ghost Go Bag | Black Monk of Pontefract | The George Brothers | 12 November 2023 |
| 354. | A Tarot Therapy Session and a Ghost Cat Pawty | Old Idaho State Penitentiary | Disappearance of Kimberly Avila | 19 November 2023 |
| 355. | Ghouls, Gays, Theys and Cottage Core Lesbian Hauntings | Alton Towers | The Amityville Horror House | 26 November 2023 |
| 356. | Spam Artists and Interplanetary Gossip | Superstitions on mirrors | Case of Darlie Routier | 3 December 2023 |
| 357. | A Millennial Pause and a Scythe Tsunami | Psychopomps | Disappearance of Steven Kuback | 10 December 2023 |
| 358. | The Frenaissance and the Poopmonger | Mary King's Close | Dennis Rader - BTK Part 1 | 17 December 2023 |
| 359. | Secret Society Bullshit and Paranormal Rejection at the Front Desk | The Augustine Steward House | Dennis Rader - BTK Part 2 | 24 December 2023G |
| 360. | A Vampiric Stage Lipstick and a Nap Episode | Third man factor Syndrome | Murders of Dean and Tina Clouse | 31 December 2023 |
| 361. | Troll Hole To-Go and Naming Our ADHD | Possession of Clarita Villanueva | Murder of Brenda Powell | 7 January 2024 |
| 362. | An Identi-Tea Crisis and Wobbly Mountain | The Bennington Triangle | Harvey Glatman AKA the Glamour Girl Slayer | 14 January 2024 |
| 363. | A Failed Handstand and an Infestation of Prairie Dogs | Cheesman Park | The Spider Man of Denver | 21 January 2024 |
| 364. | A Boulder of Salt and a Shot Put of Horseradish | Acid Bridge and the 7 Gates of Hell | The Death of Natalie Wood | 28 January 2024 |
| 365. | Podcasting in Dog Years and Collecting Crows Feet | The Nodolf Incident | The Lipstick Killer Part 1 | 4 February 2024 |
| 366. | Troll Butter and Moon Spit | Kentucky Meat Shower | The Lipstick Killer Part 2 | 11 February 2024 |
| 367. | Millennial Road Signs and Yappucinos | Baba Vanga Prophecies | Case of Natalia Grace | 18 February 2024 |
| 368. | Whodunnit Hauntings and Three Lollipops in a Trench Coat | Haunting of Isabell Binnington | Murder of Sharron Prior | 25 February 2024 |
| 369. | Frankenstein's Monster's Ghost and Grunge Justice | The Dakota Apartments | Murder of Mia Zapata | 3 March 2024 |
| 370. | Therapy Book Club and Satan's Church Fonts | Rougarou | Malcolm Naden | 10 March 2024 |
| 371. | Warnings About File Organizing and Smooth Coffee Shop Compliments | Twin Flames Universe Cult | Holly K. Dunn | 17 March 2024 |
| 372. | A Trash Nap and a Clumsy Girl Ghost | King's Tavern | Murder of Seath Jackson | 24 March 2024 |
| 373. | The Thirsty Little Rat Inn and the Coowoo Girls | Longfellow's Wayside Inn | Anthony Broadwater and Alice Sebold | 31 March 2024 |
| 374. | A Big Queer Door and The Mulberry Bush of the Year | Dark side of nursery rhymes | Krystian Bala | 7 April 2024 |
| 375. | Joann's Haberdashery and Ghost Logic | The Merchant's House Museum | Ruby Franke/8 Passengers Part 1 | 14 April 2024 |
| 376. | Vintage Honks and Zoomies Screams | The Char Man of the Ojai Valley | Ruby Franke/8 Passengers Part 2 | 21 April 2024 |
| 377. | Carnival Cobblers and Time Travelling Text Messages | The Pollock Twins aka The Hexham Rebirth | Terry Rasmussen aka The Chameleon Killer | 28 April 2024 |
| 378. | The Butter Bar Lore and the Glass Peacock Yappers | Capitol Theatre Building (Flint, Michigan) | Murder of Cara Lea Farver | 5 May 2024 |
| 379. | A Never-ending Slumber Party and an ATWWD Bowling League (Live Show at Houston Improv, 2019) | The Spaghetti Warehouse (Haunted) and The Old Spaghetti Factory | Ana Trujillo aka The Stiletto Killer | 12 May 2024 |
| 380. | The Spookyeasy and the Crime Travelers, Partners in Time | The Hannah House | Disappearance of the Klein Brothers | 19 May 2024 |
| 381. | Drunk on Leaves and Resurrecting the Information SuperHighway | The Mongolian Death Worm | Murder of Greg Fleniken aka The Body in Room 348 | 26 May 2024 |
| 382. | Birthday Bummers and Haunted Emo Cowboys | The O.K. Corral and Boothill Cemetery | Murders of Kylen Schulte and Crystal Turner | 2 June 2024 |
| 383. | Pseudo Armchair Ear Experts and Flower Pot London Fogs | Ogden Union Station | Murder of Travis Alexander by Jodi Arias | 9 June 2024 |
| 384. | A Raccoon Bagel Infestation and a Birthday Shot in the Butt | Elias Henry Jones and Cedric Waters Hill | Inna Budnytska | 16 June 2024 |
| 385. | Dinosaur Spiritualism and Mediumship Advisors | Mediums of the Lily Dale Spiritualist Assembly | Nicholas Alahverdian | 23 June 2024 |
| 386. | A Telegram to our Exes and a Hell of a Case of Swamp Gas | The Allagash Four | Disappearance of Blanche Monnier | 30 June 2024 |
| 387. | Adulting Cheat Codes and Dramatic Readings of the Cha Cha Slide | The Old Licking County Jail | The Claypool Hotel | 7 July 2024 |
| 388. | Stress Rashes and Deranged Camera Angles | The Cock Lane Haunting | Suzanne Sevakis Part 1 | 14 July 2024 |
| 389. | Intriguing Event Schedules and Lukewarm Cans of Sparkling Water | The Gilcrease House | Suzanne Sevakis Part 2 | 21 July 2024 |
| 390. | A Noodle Room and a Doodle Competition | Sturdivant Hall | Wrongful Conviction of Juan Catalan and Murder of Martha Puebla | 28 July 2024 |
| 391. | A Penultimate Show and a Bonus Drinking Game Round (Live Show in Albany, 2019) | Fort William Henry at Lake George | Murder of Peter Porco | 4 August 2024 |
| 392. | Rat Girl Summer and Weepy Hollow | Buffalo Bill's Irma Hotel | Disappearance of Heather Teague | 11 August 2024 |
| 393. | A Feral Rat Summer and A Trench Coat Full of Snakes | Stepp Cemetery | Sally McNeil | 18 August 2024 |
| 394. | A Glitching Sim and a Yappy Hour | Black Hope Cemetery | Murders of Julie Williams and Lollie Winans | 25 August 2024 |
| 395. | Dessert Waters and Gullah, Gullah Island Medical Degrees | Exorcism of Gottliebin Dittus | Murder of Molly Bish | 1 September 2024 |
| 396. | A Curtain Fiesta and a Ghost's Fan Mail | Red Onion Saloon | Steven Stayner Part 1 | 8 September 2024 |
| 397. | A Poultrygeist and an En-gay-gement | The Highgate Hill Chicken | Steven Stayner Part 2 | 15 September 2024 |
| 398. | A Pink Panther Ghost and The Great Disappointment | Tomb of Colonel Jonathan Buck | Branch Davidians and the Siege of Mount Carmel | 22 September 2024 |
| 399. | Em’s Day O' Fun and a Ghost Renovator | Sylvester K. Pierce House | Case update from episode 15 on Gypsy-Rose Blanchard | 29 September 2024 |
| 400. | Dry Spaghetti Psychics and Gay Gasps | Dancing plague of 1518 | Alice Mitchell and her murder of Freda Ward | 6 October 2024 |

### Listener stories volumes

Listener stories vol. :
| | Topic/theme | Release date |
| 1. | | 1 March 2017 |
| 2. | | 1 April 2017 |
| 3. | | 1 May 2017 |
| 4. | | 1 June 2017 |
| 5. | | 1 July 2017 |
| 6. | | 1 August 2017 |
| 7. | | 1 September 2017 |
| 8. | | 1 October 2017 |
| 9. | | 2 November 2017 |
| 10. | | 1 December 2017 |
| 11. | | 1 January 2018 |
| 12. | | 1 February 2018 |
| 13. | | 1 March 2018 |
| 14. | | 1 April 2018 |
| 15. | | 1 May 2018 |
| 17. | | 1 June 2018 |
| 18. | | 1 July 2018 |
| 19. | | 1 August 2018 |
| 20. | | 1 September 2018 |
| 21. | Friendly ghosts. | 1 October 2018 |
| 22. | | 1 November 2018 |
| 23. | Holiday. | 1 December 2018 |
| 24. | | 1 January 2019 |
| 25. | | 1 February 2019 |
| 26. | | 1 March 2019 |
| 27. | 90s themed. | 1 April 2019 |
| 28. | | 1 May 2019 |
| 29. | | 1 June 2019 |
| 30. | | 1 July 2019 |
| 31. | Cowboys. | 1 August 2019 |
| 32. | Mirrors. | 1 September 2019 |
| 33. | Scariest thing that's every happened. | 1 October 2019 |
| 34. | Doppelgänger. | 1 November 2019 |
| 35. | Creepy twin tales. | 1 December 2019 |
| 36. | Badass grandparent stories. | 1 January 2020 |
| 37. | Soul mate, romance, other-worldly connection stories. | 1 February 2020 |
| 38. | | 1 March 2020 |
| 39. | | 1 April 2020 |
| 40. | Past life and ghost stories. | 1 May 2020 |
| 41. | Birthday themed. | 1 June 2020 |
| 42. | Astral projection. | 1 July 2020 |
| 43. | Synchronicities. | 1 August 2020 |
| 44. | Spooky real life stories. | 1 September 2020 |
| 45. | | 1 October 2020 |
| 46. | Bonus special. Hauntings and true crime. | 15 October 2020 |
| 47. | Black Eyed Kids. | 1 November 2020 |
| 48. | Bonus special. Potato themed. | 15 November 2020 |
| 49. | Full moon stories. | 1 December 2020 |
| 50. | Bonus special. "How ATWWD Cursed Me". | 15 December 2020 |
| 51. | | 1 January 2021 |
| 52. | | 1 February 2021 |
| 53. | Cryptid Poetry Slam. | 1 March 2021 |
| 54. | | 1 April 2021 |
| 55. | | 1 May 2021 |
| 56. | Recent topics, unusual hauntings, birthday themed stories. | 1 June 2021 |
| 57. | | 1 July 2021 |
| 58. | Pregnancy stories. | 1 August 2021 |
| 59. | | 1 September 2021 |
| 60. | Halloween. | 1 October 2021 |
| 61. | ****** | 1 November 2021 |
| 62. | Holiday. ****** | 1 December 2021 |
| 63. | Themeless. | 1 January 2022 |
| 64. | | 1 February 2022 |
| 65. | | 1 March 2022 |
| 66. | Beach Too Sandy, Water Too Wet setup. **** | 1 April 2022 |
| 67. | | 1 May 2022 |
| 68 | Scorpio Stories | 1 June 2022 |
| 69. | Themeless. | 1 July 2022 |
| 70. | Armchair Hauntings | 1 August 2022 |
| 71. | Spooky scandals. | 1 September 2022 |
| 72. | Halloween/spooky/autumnal. | 1 October 2022 |
| 73. | Trucker stories. | 1 November 2022 |
| 74. | "Home for the holidays" stories. | 1 December 2022 |
| 75. | Themeless. | 1 January 2023 |
| 76. | "Stories for another day", and Valentine's Day stories. | 1 February 2023 |
| 77. | Synchronicities. | 1 March 2023 |
| 78. | Poltergeists and pranks. | 1 April 2023 |
| 79. | True crime, family drama, and Ancestry.com-related stories. | 1 May 2023 |
| 80. | Gemini themed stories for birthday month (redemption for last year). | 1 June 2023 |
| 81. | Themeless. | 1 July 2023 |
| 82. | Haunted dolls. | 1 August 2023 |
| 83. | Travel. | 1 September 2023 |
| 84. | Doppelgängers, black eyed kids, hauntings, past lives. | 1 October 2023 |
| 85. | Dia de los Muertos, dowsing rods, and ghost hunting stories. | 1 November 2023 |
| 86. | Christine's mysteriously mailed tintype photos, a Duggars-adjacent story, and an overall festive theme. | 1 December 2023 |
| 87. | Stories with remote connections to previous episodes. | 1 January 2024 |
| 88. | Themeless | 1 February 2024 |
| 89. | Themeless******* | 1 March 2024 |
| 90. | Two truths and a lie. | 1 April 2024 |
| 91. | Mysteries. | 1 May 2024 |
| 92. | Hosts's favorite themes for their birthdays. | 1 June 2024 |
| 93. | Whaley House. | 1 July 2024 |
| 94. | True crime. | 1 August 2024 |
| 95. | Fate. | 1 September 2024 |
| 96. | Spooky Halloween stories. | 1 October 2024 |

### Key

* Special Guest Deirdre Klima
** Special Guest Lisa Lampanelli
*** For this episode, Schulz and Schiefer switched roles, with Schulz telling a crime story and Schiefer telling a paranormal one.
**** Special Guest Alexander Schiefer
***** First episode to be video-recorded and uploaded to YouTube.
****** Special Guest Allison Goforth
******* Special Guests Trevin and Amanda from Live, Laugh, Larceny