# New York Yankees award winners and league leaders

This is a list of award winners and league leaders for the New York Yankees of Major League Baseball.

## Baseball Hall of Famers

(Affiliation according to National Baseball Hall of Fame; Reggie Jackson is affiliated with the Athletics, but wears a New York Yankees cap )

## Major League Baseball awards
### Most Valuable Player

* 1923 – Babe Ruth
* 1927 – Lou Gehrig
* 1936 – Lou Gehrig (2)
* 1939 – Joe DiMaggio
* 1941 – Joe DiMaggio (2)
* 1942 – Joe Gordon
* 1943 – Spud Chandler
* 1947 – Joe DiMaggio (3)
* 1950 – Phil Rizzuto
* 1951 – Yogi Berra
* 1954 – Yogi Berra (2)
* 1955 – Yogi Berra (3)
* 1956 – Mickey Mantle
* 1957 – Mickey Mantle (2)
* 1960 – Roger Maris
* 1961 – Roger Maris (2)
* 1962 – Mickey Mantle (3)
* 1963 – Elston Howard
* 1976 – Thurman Munson
* 1985 – Don Mattingly
* 2005 – Alex Rodriguez (2)
* 2007 – Alex Rodriguez (3)
* 2022 – Aaron Judge
* 2024 – Aaron Judge (2)

### Cy Young

* 1958 – Bob Turley (MLB)
* 1961 – Whitey Ford (MLB)
* 1977 – Sparky Lyle (AL)
* 1978 – Ron Guidry (AL)
* 2001 – Roger Clemens (AL)
* 2023 – Gerrit Cole (AL)

### Rookie of the Year

* 1951 – Gil McDougald
* 1954 – Bob Grim
* 1957 – Tony Kubek
* 1962 – Tom Tresh
* 1968 – Stan Bahnsen
* 1970 – Thurman Munson
* 1981 – Dave Righetti
* 1996 – Derek Jeter
* 2017 - Aaron Judge
* 2024 - Luis Gil

### Manager of the Year

    See footnote
* Buck Showalter (1994)
* Joe Torre [2] (1996, tied with Johnny Oates, Texas; 1998)

### Gold Glove Award

Key :
| † | Elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame |
| Player | Position | Times Won | Years |
| Ron Guidry | P | 5 | 1982–86 |
| Bobby Shantz | P | 4 | 1957–60 |
| Mike Mussina$^†$ | P | 3 | 2001, 2003, 2008 |
| Thurman Munson | C | 3 | 1973–75 |
| Elston Howard | C | 2 | 1963–64 |
| Don Mattingly | 1B | 9 | 1985–89, 1991–94 |
| Joe Pepitone | 1B | 3 | 1965–66, 1969 |
| Mark Teixeira | 1B | 3 | 2009–10, 2012 |
| Chris Chambliss | 1B | 1 | 1978 |
| Bobby Richardson | 2B | 5 | 1961–65 |
| Robinson Canó | 2B | 2 | 2010, 2012 |
| Wade Boggs$^†$ | 3B | 2 | 1994–95 |
| Graig Nettles | 3B | 2 | 1977–78 |
| Scott Brosius | 3B | 1 | 1999 |
| Derek Jeter$^†$ | SS | 5 | 2004–06, 2009–10 |
| Anthony Volpe | SS | 1 | 2023 |
| Bernie Williams | OF | 4 | 1997–2000 |
| Dave Winfield$^†$ | OF | 5 | 1982–85, 1987 |
| Brett Gardner | OF | 1 | 2016 |
| Mickey Mantle$^†$ | OF | 1 | 1962 |
| Roger Maris | OF | 1 | 1960 |
| Bobby Murcer | OF | 1 | 1972 |
| Norm Siebern | OF | 1 | 1958 |
| Tom Tresh | OF | 1 | 1965 |
| Jose Trevino | C | 1 | 2022 |
| DJ LeMahieu | UTIL | 1 | 2022 |

### Platinum Glove Award

Awarded to the best defensive player in each league, as selected by fans from the year's Gold Glove winners.
* Jose Trevino (2022)

### Wilson Defensive Player of the Year Award

    Note: In its first two years, the award was given to a player on each MLB team; one awardee was then named the Overall Defensive Player of the Year for the American League and another for the National League. Starting in 2014, the award is now given to one player at each position for all of Major League Baseball; one of the nine awardees is then named the Overall Defensive Player of the Year for all of Major League Baseball.

#### Team (all positions)

* Robinson Canó (2012, 2013)

#### Left fielder (in MLB)

* Brett Gardner (2016)

### Silver Slugger Award

| Player | Position | Times Won | Years |
| Don Baylor | DH | 2 | 1983, 1985 |
| Reggie Jackson$^†$ | DH | 1 | 1980 |
| Jorge Posada | C | 5 | 2000–03, 2007 |
| Mike Stanley | C | 1 | 1993 |
| Gary Sánchez | C | 1 | 2017 |
| Don Mattingly | 1B | 3 | 1985–87 |
| Jason Giambi | 1B | 1 | 2002 |
| Tino Martinez | 1B | 1 | 1997 |
| Mark Teixeira | 1B | 1 | 2009 |
| Robinson Canó | 2B | 5 | 2006, 2010–13 |
| Willie Randolph | 2B | 1 | 1980 |
| Alfonso Soriano | 2B | 1 | 2002 |
| DJ LeMahieu | 2B | 2 | 2019–2020 |
| Alex Rodriguez | 3B | 3 | 2005, 2007–2008 |
| Wade Boggs$^†$ | 3B | 2 | 1993–94 |
| Derek Jeter$^†$ | SS | 5 | 2006–2009, 2012 |
| Dave Winfield$^†$ | OF | 4 | 1981–82, 1984–85 |
| Gary Sheffield | OF | 2 | 2004–05 |
| Rickey Henderson$^†$ | OF | 1 | 1985 |
| Bernie Williams | OF | 1 | 2002 |
| Curtis Granderson | OF | 1 | 2011 |
| Aaron Judge | OF | 4 | 2017, 2021–2022, 2024 |
| Juan Soto | OF | 1 | 2024 |

### Comeback Player of the Year Award

* 2005 – Jason Giambi
* 2013 – Mariano Rivera

### Hank Aaron Award (top hitter)

* Derek Jeter [2] (2006, 2009)
* Alex Rodriguez (2007)
* Aaron Judge (2022)

### Edgar Martínez Award

* Don Baylor (1985)

### All-MLB Team

| Player | Position | Times Won | Years |
| DJ LeMahieu | 2B | 2 | 2019 (1st), 2020 (1st) |
| Aaron Judge | OF | 4 | 2021 (1st), 2022 (1st), 2023 (2nd), 2024 (1st) |
| Juan Soto | OF | 1 | 2024 (1st) |
| Gerrit Cole | SP | 3 | 2020 (2nd), 2021 (1st), 2023 (1st) |
| Aroldis Chapman | RP | 1 | 2019 (2nd) |

### DHL Hometown Heroes (2006)

* Babe Ruth — voted by MLB fans as the most outstanding player in the history of the franchise, based on on-field performance, leadership quality and character value

### MLB All-Time Team (1997; Baseball Writers' Association of America)

* First base
** Lou Gehrig
* Right field
** Babe Ruth
* Manager
** Casey Stengel

### Sporting News All-Decade Team

    See: Sporting News#Major-league baseball awards
* Alex Rodriguez, 3B (2009) (also played with Seattle and Texas (2000-2003))
* Derek Jeter, SS (2009)
* Randy Johnson, SP (2009) (Played with the Yankees from 2005–2006. Also played with Arizona (1999–2004; 2007–2008) and San Francisco (2009))
* Mariano Rivera, CP (2009)
* Joe Torre, Manager (2009) (Managed the Yankees from 1996–2007. Also managed the Los Angeles Dodgers (2008-2009))

### Sports Illustrated MLB All-Decade Team

* Alex Rodriguez, 3B (2009) (also played with Seattle and Texas (2000-2003))
* Derek Jeter, SS (2009)
* Randy Johnson, SP (2009) (Played with the Yankees from 2005–2006. Also played with Arizona (1999–2004; 2007–2008) and San Francisco (2009))
* Mariano Rivera, CP (2009)
* Joe Torre, Manager (2009) (Managed the Yankees from 1996–2007. Also managed the Los Angeles Dodgers (2008-2009))

### USA Today Cy Young

* 2005 – Mariano Rivera
* 2010 – CC Sabathia

### Baseball America All-Rookie Team

    See: Baseball America#Baseball America All-Rookie Team
* 2011 – Iván Nova (SP; one of five)

### World Series Most Valuable Player Award

* Don Larsen (1956)
* Bob Turley (1958)
* Bobby Richardson (1960)
* Whitey Ford (1961)
* Ralph Terry (1962)
* Reggie Jackson (1977)
* Bucky Dent (1978)
* John Wetteland (1996)
* Scott Brosius (1998)
* Mariano Rivera (1999)
* Derek Jeter (2000)
* Hideki Matsui (2009)

### Babe Ruth Award (postseason MVP)

    Note: Before 2007, the award was exclusively for performances in the World Series.
* Joe Page (1949)
* Jerry Coleman (1950)
* Phil Rizzuto (1951)
* Johnny Mize (1952)
* Billy Martin (1953)
* Don Larsen (1956)
* Elston Howard (1958)
* Whitey Ford (1961)
* Ralph Terry (1962)
* Reggie Jackson (1977)
* Bucky Dent (1978)
* Cecil Fielder (1996)
* Scott Brosius (1998)
* Mariano Rivera (1999, 2003)
* Derek Jeter (2000)
* Alex Rodriguez (2009)

### MLB Insiders Club Magazine All-Postseason Team

* 2011 – Robinson Canó (2B)

### Lou Gehrig Memorial Award

* Gil McDougald (1958)
* Bobby Richardson (1963)
* Tommy John (1981)
* Don Mattingly (1993)
* Derek Jeter (2010)

### MLB All-Time Manager

    See: Major League Baseball All-Time Team (1997; BBWAA)
* Casey Stengel

### Sporting News Manager of the Decade

    See: Sporting News § Major League Baseball
* Joe Torre (2009) (also managed the Los Angeles Dodgers, 2008-09)

### Sports Illustrated MLB Manager of the Decade

* Joe Torre (2009) (also managed the Los Angeles Dodgers, 2008-09)

### The Sporting News Manager of the Year

    Note: Established in 1936, this award was given annually to one manager in Major League Baseball. In 1986 it was expanded to honor one manager from each league.
    See footnote
* 1936 – Joe McCarthy
* 1938 – Joe McCarthy
* 1943 – Joe McCarthy
* 1947 – Bucky Harris
* 1949 – Casey Stengel
* 1953 – Casey Stengel
* 1958 – Casey Stengel
* 1961 – Ralph Houk
* 1974 – Bill Virdon
* 1994 – Buck Showalter
* 1998 – Joe Torre

### Associated Press Manager of the Year Award

    See: Associated Press#AP sports awards
    Note: Discontinued in 2001. From 1959 to 1983, the award was given annually to one manager in each league. From 1984 to 2000, the award was given to one manager in all of Major League Baseball.
    See footnote
* 1963 – Ralph Houk
* 1970 – Ralph Houk
* 1976 – Billy Martin
* 1978 – Bob Lemon (Also managed the Chicago White Sox in 1978)
* 1998 – Joe Torre

### Ford C. Frick Award recipients (broadcasters)

    See "Ford C. Frick Award recipients" at New York Yankees § Hall of Famers

## Team awards
### Team championships and recognitions

* 1976 – William Harridge Trophy (American League champion)
* 1977 – World Series Trophy
* 1978 – World Series Trophy
* 1981 – William Harridge Trophy (American League champion)
* 1996 – Commissioner's Trophy (World Series)
* 1997 (1996 New York Yankees) – Outstanding Team ESPY Award
* 1998 – Commissioner's Trophy (World Series)
* 1998 – Baseball America Organization of the Year
* 1999 – Commissioner's Trophy (World Series)
* 1999 (1998 New York Yankees) – Outstanding Team ESPY Award
* 1999 – Sporting News Sportsman of the Year
* 1999 (1927 Yankees) – "ESPN" Number 1 greatest sports team (in 20th century, of the 4 major North American sports leagues)
* 1999 (1939 Yankees) – "ESPN" Number 6 greatest sports team (in 20th century, of the 4 major North American sports leagues)
* 2000 – Commissioner's Trophy (World Series)
* 2001 (2000 New York Yankees) – Outstanding Team ESPY Award
* 2001 – William Harridge Trophy (American League champion)
* 2003 – William Harridge Trophy (American League champion)
* 2009 – Commissioner's Trophy (World Series)
* 2009 – Sports Illustrated MLB Top Single-Season Team of the Decade (2009 Yankees)
* 2009 – Sports Illustrated Best MLB Franchise of the Decade

## Other achievements
### Monument Park
### Retired numbers

    See New York Yankees#Retired numbers

### James P. Dawson Award

The James P. Dawson Award is given at the end of spring training to the best rookie.
* 1956 – Norm Siebern, OF
* 1957 – Tony Kubek, SS
* 1958 – Johnny Blanchard, C
* 1959 – Gordie Windhorn, OF
* 1960 – Johnny James, P
* 1961 – Rollie Sheldon, P
* 1962 – Tom Tresh, SS
* 1963 – Pedro González, 2B
* 1964 – Pete Mikkelsen, P
* 1965 – Arturo López, OF
* 1966 – Roy White, OF
* 1967 – Bill Robinson, OF
* 1968 – Mike Ferraro, 3B
* 1969 – Jerry Kenney, OF, and Bill Burbach, P
* 1970 – John Ellis, 1B / C
* 1971 – None selected
* 1972 – Rusty Torres, OF
* 1973 – Otto Vélez, OF
* 1974 – Tom Buskey, P
* 1975 – Tippy Martinez, P
* 1976 – Willie Randolph, 2B
* 1977 – George Zeber, IF
* 1978 – Jim Beattie, P
* 1979 – Paul Mirabella, P
* 1980 – Mike Griffin, P
* 1981 – Gene Nelson, P
* 1982 – Andre Robertson, SS
* 1983 – Don Mattingly, 1B / OF
* 1984 – José Rijo, P
* 1985 – Scott Bradley, C
* 1986 – Bob Tewksbury, P
* 1987 – Keith Hughes, OF
* 1988 – Al Leiter, P
* 1989 – None selected
* 1990 – Alan Mills, P
* 1991 – Hensley Meulens, OF
* 1992 – Gerald Williams, OF
* 1993 – Mike Humphreys, OF
* 1994 – Sterling Hitchcock, P
* 1995 – None selected
* 1996 – Mark Hutton, P
* 1997 – Jorge Posada, C
* 1998 – Homer Bush, IF
* 1999 – None selected
* 2000 – None selected
* 2001 – Alfonso Soriano, 2B
* 2002 – Nick Johnson, 1B
* 2003 – Hideki Matsui, OF
* 2004 – Bubba Crosby, OF
* 2005 – Andy Phillips, IF
* 2006 – Eric Duncan, IF
* 2007 – Kei Igawa, P
* 2008 – Shelley Duncan, IF / OF
* 2009 – Brett Gardner, OF
* 2010 – Jon Weber, OF
* 2011 – Manny Bañuelos, P
* 2012 – David Phelps, P
* 2013 – Vidal Nuño, P
* 2014 – Masahiro Tanaka, P
* 2015 – Slade Heathcott, OF
* 2016 – Johnny Barbato, P
* 2017 – Gleyber Torres, IF
* 2018 – Miguel Andújar, 3B
* 2019 – Stephen Tarpley, P
* 2020 – Clarke Schmidt, P
* 2021 – Deivi García, P
* 2022 – Clarke Schmidt, P
* 2023 – Anthony Volpe, SS

### New York BBWAA chapter awards

    See: New York BBWAA chapter awards

#### Joan Payson Award

    Note: The award is for excellence in community service.

#### Casey Stengel "You Can Look It Up" Award

    Note: The award is to honor career achievement for those who went home empty-handed at previous dinners.

#### Joe DiMaggio "Toast of the Town" Award

    The awards is for a player who has become a New York favorite.

#### William J. Slocum–Jack Lang Award

    Note: The award is for long and meritorious service.

#### Ben Epstein–Dan Castellano "Good Guy" Award

    Note: The award is for candor and accessibility to writers.

#### Willie, Mickey and the Duke Award

    Note: The award is given to a group of players forever linked in baseball history.

### World Baseball Classic MVP

* 2013 – Robinson Canó (2B) (2013 World Baseball Classic § All-WBC team)

### Associated Press Athlete of the Year

* 1941 – Joe DiMaggio
* 1956 – Mickey Mantle
* 1961 – Roger Maris
* 1978 – Ron Guidry

### Hickok Belt

    Note: The Hickok Belt trophy was originally awarded to the top professional athlete of the year in the U.S., from 1950 to 1976. It was then revived and has been awarded since 2012.
* 1950 – Phil Rizzuto
* 1951 – Allie Reynolds
* 1956 – Mickey Mantle
* 1958 – Bob Turley
* 1961 – Roger Maris

### Sporting News Sportsman of the Year

    See: Sporting News#Sportsman of the Year
* 1978 – Ron Guidry
* 1996 – Joe Torre
* 1999 – New York Yankees

### Sporting News Pro Athlete of the Year

    See: Sporting News#Pro Athlete of the Year
* 2009 – Mariano Rivera

### Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year

* 2009 – Derek Jeter

### Sports Illustrated Top 20 Male Athletes of the Decade

    See: List of 2009 all-decade Sports Illustrated awards and honors#Top 20 Male Athletes of the Decade
* 2009 – Mariano Rivera (#11)
* 2009 – Derek Jeter (#18)
* 2009 – Alex Rodriguez (#20)

### Sports Illustrated Top 10 Coaches/Managers of the Decade (2009)

    See: List of 2009 all-decade Sports Illustrated awards and honors#Top 10 Coaches/Managers of the Decade
* No. 3 – Joe Torre, Yankees–Dodgers (the list's only other MLB manager was Boston's Terry Francona, No. 4)

### Best Coach/Manager ESPY Award

* Joe Torre (1997, 1999, 2000, 2001)

## Minor-league system
### Baseball America Minor League Player of the Year Award

* Derek Jeter, 1994

### MiLB George M. Trautman Award / Topps Player of the Year

* 2009 – Shelley Duncan (International League; Scranton/Wilkes-Barre; OF) & Austin Romine (Florida State League; Tampa; C)

### Kevin Lawn Awards

The Kevin Lawn Awards are given annually to the best minor league baseball player and pitcher in the Yankees' organization.
Player of the Year :
| Year | Player | Position | Team(s) |
| 1980 | Steve Balboni | 1B | Nashville Sounds |
| 1981 | Don Mattingly | 1B | Nashville Sounds |
| 1982 | Matt Winters | OF | Greensboro Bats/Nashville Sounds |
| 1983 | Brian Dayett | OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1984 | Scott Bradley | C/OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1985 | Dan Pasqua | OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1986 | Chris Alvarez | 3B | Fort Lauderdale Yankees |
| 1987 | Darren Reed | OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1988 | Kevin Maas | 1B | Prince William Yankees/Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1989 | Hal Morris | 1B | Columbus Clippers |
| 1990 | Hensley Meulens | OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1991 | Kiki Hernandez | C | Greensboro Bats/Prince William Cannons |
| 1991 | Dave Silvestri | SS | Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1992 | J. T. Snow | 1B | Columbus Clippers |
| 1993 | Billy Masse | OF | Columbus Clippers |
| 1994 | Derek Jeter | SS | Tampa Yankees/Albany-Colonie Yankees/Columbus Clippers |
| 1995 | Derek Jeter | SS | Columbus Clippers |
| 1996 | Ricky Ledee | OF | Columbus Clippers/Norwich Navigators |
| 1997 | Mike Lowell | 3B | Columbus Clippers/Norwich Navigators |
| 1998 | Nick Johnson | 1B | Tampa Yankees |
| 1999 | Nick Johnson | 1B | Norwich Navigators |
| 1999 | D'Angelo Jiménez | 2B | Columbus Clippers |
| 2000 | Scott Seabol | 3B | Norwich Navigators |
| 2001 | Juan Rivera | OF | Columbus Clippers/Norwich Navigators |
| 2001 | Marcus Thames | OF | Norwich Navigators |
| 2002 | Andy Phillips | 2B | Columbus Clippers/Norwich Navigators |
| 2003 | Dioner Navarro | C | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2004 | Andy Phillips | 1B | Columbus Clippers/Trenton Thunder |
| 2005 | Kevin Thompson | OF | Columbus Clippers/Trenton Thunder |
| 2006 | Cody Ehlers | 1B | Tampa Yankees |
| 2007 | Austin Jackson | OF | Charleston RiverDogs/Tampa Yankees/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2008 | Brett Gardner | OF | Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2009 | Austin Romine | C | Tampa Yankees |
| 2010 | Eduardo Núñez | SS | Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2011 | Austin Romine | C | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2012 | Tyler Austin | OF | Gulf Coast Yankees/Charleston RiverDogs/Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2013 | Greg Bird | 1B | Charleston RiverDogs |
| 2014 | Rob Refsnyder | 2B | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2015 | Gary Sánchez | C | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2016 | Aaron Judge | OF | Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2017 | Miguel Andújar | 3B | Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2018 | Brandon Wagner | INF | Tampa Tarpons/Trenton Thunder |
| 2019 | Chris Gittens | 1B | Trenton Thunder |
| 2020 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 |
| 2021 | Anthony Volpe | SS | Tampa Tarpons/Hudson Valley Renegades |
Pitcher of the Year :
| Year | Pitcher | Handedness | Team(s) |
| 1980 | Gene Nelson | RHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees |
| 1981 | Pete Filson | LHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees/Nashville Sounds |
| 1982 | Bob Tewksbury | RHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees |
| 1983 | José Rijo | RHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees/Nashville Sounds |
| 1984 | Jim Deshaies | LHP | Nashville Sounds/Columbus Clippers |
| 1985 | Brad Arnsberg | RHP | Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1986 | Logan Easley | RHP | Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1987 | Dana Ridenour | RHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees |
| 1988 | Todd Malone | RHP | Gulf Coast Yankees |
| 1989 | Steve Adkins | LHP | Fort Lauderdale Yankees/Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1990 | Dave Eiland | RHP | Columbus Clippers |
| 1991 | Ed Martel | RHP | Albany-Colonie Yankees/Columbus Clippers |
| 1991 | Sam Militello | RHP | Prince William Cannons/Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1992 | Sam Militello | RHP | Columbus Clippers |
| 1993 | Ryan Karp | LHP | Albany-Colonie Yankees/Prince William Yankees/Greensboro Bats |
| 1994 | Andy Pettitte | LHP | Columbus Clippers/Albany-Colonie Yankees |
| 1995 | Matt Drews | RHP | Tampa Yankees |
| 1996 | Jay Tessmer | RHP | Tampa Yankees |
| 1997 | Eric Milton | LHP | Norwich Navigators/Tampa Yankees |
| 1998 | Ryan Bradley | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Norwich Navigators/Columbus Clippers |
| 1999 | Ed Yarnall | RHP | Columbus Clippers |
| 2000 | Randy Keisler | RHP | Columbus Clippers |
| 2001 | Brandon Claussen | LHP | Norwich Navigators/Tampa Yankees |
| 2002 | Jorge DePaula | RHP | Norwich Navigators |
| 2002 | Danny Borrell | LHP | Norwich Navigators/Tampa Yankees |
| 2003 | Jorge DePaula | RHP | Columbus Clippers |
| 2004 | Chien-Ming Wang | RHP | Trenton Thunder/Columbus Clippers |
| 2005 | Matt DeSalvo | RHP | Trenton Thunder |
| 2006 | Phil Hughes | RHP | Trenton Thunder |
| 2007 | Ian Kennedy | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2008 | Phil Coke | LHP | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2009 | Zach McAllister | RHP | Trenton Thunder |
| 2010 | David Phelps | RHP | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2011 | D. J. Mitchell | RHP | Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees |
| 2012 | Mark Montgomery | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2013 | Shane Greene | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2014 | Luis Severino | RHP | Charleston RiverDogs/Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2015 | Luis Severino | RHP | Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2016 | Chance Adams | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder |
| 2017 | Domingo Acevedo | RHP | Tampa Yankees/Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2018 | Michael King | RHP | Tampa Tarpons/Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2019 | Deivi García | RHP | Tampa Tarpons/Trenton Thunder/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
| 2020 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 |
| 2021 | Hayden Wesneski | RHP | Hudson Valley Renegades/Somerset Patriots/Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |