# Butch (lesbian slang)

Part of a series on :
Lesbian feminism :
Women's liberation movement :
People
Paula Gunn Allen
Dorothy Allison
Ti-Grace Atkinson
Alison Bechdel
Evelyn Torton Beck
Miriam Ben-Shalom
Julie Bindel
Ivy Bottini
Charlotte Bunch
Cheryl Clarke
Michelle Cliff
Kate Clinton
Jeanne Córdova
Mary Daly
Max Dashu
Stormé DeLarverie
Diane DiMassa
Alix Dobkin
Andrea Dworkin
Elana Dykewomon
Lillian Faderman
Ferron
Marilyn Frye
Michiyo Fukaya
Carolyn Gage
Donna Gottschalk
Sarah Hoagland
Karla Jay
Sheila Jeffreys
Jill Johnston
Melanie Kaye/Kantrowitz
Joan Larkin
Anna Livia
Audre Lorde
Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon
Cherríe Moraga
Bonnie J. Morris
Ruth Mountaingrove
Jean O'Leary
Pat Parker
Julia Penelope
Janice Raymond
Adrienne Rich
Margaret Sloan-Hunter
Barbara Smith
Cris Williamson
Monique Wittig
Bonnie Zimmerman :
Groups
AMASONG
Amazon Bookstore Cooperative
Anjaree
Artemis Singers
Atlanta Lesbian Feminist Alliance
Bi-National Lesbian Conference
Chicago Lesbian Liberation
Combahee River Collective
Connexxus Women's Center/Centro de Mujeres
Daughters of Bilitis
Daughters of Bilitis (Australia)
The Feminists
First Black Lesbian Conference
The Furies Collective
Gay Women's Alternative
Gouines rouges
June L. Mazer Lesbian Archives
Lavender Menace
Leeds Revolutionary Feminist Group
Lesbian Art Project
Lesbian Avengers
Lesbian Feminist Liberation
Lesbian Herstory Archives
Lesbian Movement (Denmark)
Lesbian Organization of Toronto
Lesbians Against Pit Closures
Lincoln Legion of Lesbians
Mujeres Creando
Oregon Women's Land Trust
Salsa Soul Sisters
Sister Spit
Sisters for Homophile Equality
Van Dykes :
Key issues
Butch
Butch and femme
Compulsory heterosexuality
Corrective rape
Dyke
Feminist separatism
Femme
Gender-critical feminism
Lesbian bed death
Lesbian erasure
Lesbians in Francoist Spain
Lesbians in the Spanish Second Republic
Lesbophobia
Lipstick lesbian
Political lesbianism
Radical lesbianism
Separatist feminism
Soft butch
Stone butch
Stone femme
U-Haul lesbian
Womyn-born womyn
Womyn's land :
Media
Books
Les Guérillères (1969)
Le Corps Lesbien (1973)
Lesbian Nation (1973)
Lover (1976)
The Wanderground (1979)
Zami: A New Spelling of My Name (1982)
Lesbian/Woman (1991)
The Straight Mind and Other Essays (1992)
Boots of Leather, Slippers of Gold (1993)
Your Silence Will Not Protect You (2017)
Other
Die Freundin (1924–1933)
Vice Versa (1947–1948)
The Ladder (1956–1972)
Arena Three (1963-1972)
The Woman-Identified Woman (1970)
Off Our Backs (1970–2008)
Lavender Woman (1971–1976)
Lesbian Tide (1971–1980)
Dykes & Gorgons (1973–1976)
Lesbian Feminist Circle (1973–1986)
WomanSpirit (1974–1984)
Lesbian Connection (1974–present)
Conditions (1976–1990)
Sinister Wisdom (1976–present)
Azalea: A Magazine by Third World Lesbians (1977–1983)
Common Lives/Lesbian Lives (1980–1996)
Onyx: Black Lesbian Newsletter (1982–1984)
Amazones d'Hier, Lesbiennes d'Aujourd'hui (1982–present)
Dykes to Watch Out For (1983–2008)
Hothead Paisan (1991–1998)
Diva (1994–present)
Journal of Lesbian Studies (1997–present)
Jane's World (1998–2018)
Curve (2000–present)
AfterEllen (2002–present)
Velvetpark (2007–present)
Hannah Gadsby: Nanette (2017) :
Actions and ideas
Cineffable
Dyke march
Lesbian bar
Lesbian flags
Lesbian literature
Lesbian pulp fiction
Maud's (bar)
Michigan Womyn's Music Festival
Motherpeace Tarot
Mountain Moving Coffeehouse
Olivia Records
Paris Lesbian and Feminist Film Festival
Peg's Place (bar)
Some Prefer Cake
Women's music
Women's Week Provincetown :
Feminism portal :
vte :
Butch is a lesbian who exhibits a masculine identity or gender presentation. Although the term originated in the lesbian community, it is also used by persons who identify as queer in the larger LGBTQIA+ subculture today.
Since the lesbian subculture of 1940s America, "butch" has been present as a way for lesbians to circumvent traditional gender roles of women in society and distinguish their masculine attributes and characteristics from feminine women.

## History

Starting in the 1940s and 1950s, butch became a central identity in the lesbian community. It was often understood in conjunction with femme identity, and butch–femme relations have been studied at great length. As a result, butch identity on its own remains somewhat ill-defined. Butch people are often described as sexually dominant lesbians who are interested in having sex with femmes. The Queen's Vernacular claimed a butch was "a lesbian with masculine characteristics." In Of Catamites and Kings, Gayle Rubin describes a butch as those lesbians who use masculine mannerisms, and/or who wear traditionally male clothing, and/or who experience gender dysphoria. The defining characteristic that most scholars agree on is that butch people are lesbians who are to some degree aligned with masculine traits.
In the US during the mid 20th century, butch people were usually limited to a few jobs, such as factory work and cab driving, that had no dress codes for women. During the 1950s, with the anti-gay politics of the McCarthy era and the Lavender Scare, homophobic violence was common, especially through raids on gay and lesbian bars. Although femmes also fought back, it became primarily the role of butches to defend against attacks and hold the bars as gay women's space. The prevailing butch image was severe but gentle, while it became increasingly tough and aggressive as violent confrontation became a fact of life. Black lesbians, especially vulnerable to police brutality and racial segregation, often socialised in private parties instead of bars, and often dressed formally, compared to the typical working-class attire of T-shirts and jeans that white butches adopted. Leslie Feinberg's novel Stone Butch Blues is a predominant piece of butch literature, and offers a window into butch bar culture, police brutality towards transvestites (both drag queens and butch people), and butch eroticism in the 1970s.

## Transgender butch identity

One of the subcategories of the butch identity was and is people who experience gender dysphoria. In the mid 20th century, butch was a group that included most lesbians who identified with masculine characteristics; unsurprisingly, this was a space that included many transmasculine identities. In the words of butch, transgender man S. Bear Bergman, "butch and transgender are the same thing with different names, except that butch is not a trans identity, unless it is." However, there is something of a "border war" between butch and FTM identities, as renowned butch scholar Jack Halberstam put it in Transgender Butch. Some butch people identify as women and undergo some amount of medical transition, and some FTM individuals identify as butch men. The difference between the two groups is nuanced and has as many interpretations as there are butch people. Halberstam argues that in "making concrete distinctions between butch women and transsexual males, all too often such distinctions serve the cause of heteronormativity."