# Jenn Colella

Jennifer Lin Colella is an American actress and singer. She is best known for her work in musical theatre.
She received a Tony Award nomination and won the Drama Desk Award, Outer Critics Circle Award, and three regional theater awards for her portrayal of Annette/Beverley Bass in Come from Away. She reprised her roles in the 2021 filmed recording of the musical.
Colella was in the original Broadway casts of Urban Cowboy, High Fidelity (2006), Chaplin: The Musical (2012), If/Then (2014) and Suffs (2024), and Off-Broadway original productions of Slut (2005) and Lucky Guy (2011). Her Off-Broadway work includes the title character in the Beebo Brinker Chronicles (2008), Closer Than Ever (2012), and a staged reading of Twelve Angry Men (2018) with an all-female cast.
In 2008, Colella performed in abridged versions of Girl Crazy and Side Show, two of the parts of Broadway: Three Generations at the Kennedy Center. The production celebrated the reopening of the renovated Eisenhower Theater. She also appeared in The Full Monty (2009) at the Paper Mill Playhouse in Millburn, New Jersey, and the American premiere of Take Flight (2010), her first pilot role, at the McCarter Theatre in Princeton, New Jersey.
Colella has performed in over a half-dozen world premiere musicals in the United States, including three at the La Jolla Playhouse in San Diego. She has appeared in four productions of Peter Pan. Additionally, she has been in multiple productions at the New York Musical Theatre Festival.
Colella has also done some television work; she appeared on the game show Can You Tell? in 2003 and An Evening with Lerner and Loewe, the initial Broadway in Concert Series installment on PBS in 2022.

## Early life

Colella was born to Lindy Crawford and Mick Colella, and grew up in Summerville, South Carolina Starting at eight, she sang in church and school concert and show choirs, which were where she learned to harmonize. In church, she also played handbells. She refers to herself as a choir nerd. Her mother has said of the eight year old, singing as an auctioneer in a school play, "She took the microphone in her hand, looked right at the audience, and this voice came out." People wondered where all the sound came from.
A local woman gave theatre lessons in her garage, and to earn money to take the classes, Colella did odd jobs about the woman's house, including painting the exterior. Her first role was Gertie in Oklahoma!. In seventh grade, she had a hunter education class, which she says helped make it comfortable to handle guns when she performed in Annie Get Your Gun. When, as part of a school group, she saw Phantom of the Opera in New York, she decided that she was going to be on stage.
While an undergraduate at Columbia College, she played basketball, tennis and flag football. During her senior year, she quarterbacked. She graduated in 1996 with a dual degree in speech and drama. Her family had moved to Hilton Head Island and had a golf store there. While working at the shop one summer during college, she taught herself to juggle. She stayed in the area for three years and worked at an insurance company call center. In April 1997, she attended a Comet Carnival in Aiken, SC to observe Comet Hale–Bopp through a telescope. From 1997 to 1999 she was a member of The Sol Divers (initially The Gib Cats) rock 'n' roll band.
Colella served as a company member of the Trustus Theatre beginning in her senior year. At Trustus, starting in the fall of 1995 and running through the spring of 1999, she played Kitty in Taking Steps, The Angel in Angels in America (both parts), the title role in Sylvia (twice), Launcelot Gobbo in The Merchant of Venice, Amy in Company, Marta in Kiss of the Spider Woman, Teenage Greek Chorus in How I Learned to Drive, and Vivian in Free Will and Wanton Lust.
Colella went on to attend the University of California, Irvine, where she earned a Master of Fine Arts in Acting in 2002. While at UCI, she played Miss Jane in Floyd Collins, Puck in A Midsummer Night's Dream, Caterpillar in Alice in Wonderland, Princess Ninetta in The Love of Three Oranges, and Victoria Grant in Victor/Victoria at the Barclay Theatre. In 2000 and 2001, she did summer stock at the Santa Rosa Summer Repertory Theatre, playing Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz, Peter in Peter Pan, and Val in A Chorus Line.

## Career
### Theatre

As a UCI graduate, Colella participated in a showcase in New York, along with NYU and Yale, and auditioned for a part. After going back to California for a few months, she got a call to come back to New York to audition for Sissy in the original production of Urban Cowboy, and was cast in her Broadway debut role. She had not yet gotten her Equity card. The world premiere was at the Coconut Grove Playhouse, in Miami, Florida. Then it moved to the Broadhurst Theatre for its seven and a half week New York run. When the show closed, she returned to California and co-hosted a game show.
Her Off-Broadway original cast credits include a six-week run as Delia in Slut in 2005, two weeks in 2011 as Chicky Lay in Lucky Guy at the Little Shubert Theater, and a seven week long engagement in the 2022 world premiere of Suffs at the Public Theater. Colella's Off-Broadway work also includes the butch title character in the Beebo Brinker Chronicles for seven weeks in early 2008, a four-week review, Closer Than Ever, during the summer of 2012, and a single performance, all-female cast staged reading of Twelve Angry Men in September 2018.
After being in the original staged reading in Connecticut in 2006, she appeared in Kiki Baby, as an "utterly believable" four year old singer "you will fall in love with," who becomes a celebrity—and a spoiled brat. This titular characterization won Colella a 2011 NYMF Award for Outstanding Individual Performance. Other New York Musical Theatre Festival appearances include The Great American Trailer Park Musical in 2004 and 2009's All Fall Down. In 2006 she starred in the world premiere of Twyla Tharp's The Times They Are A-Changin' at the Old Globe Theatre. An additional role was as Laura in High Fidelity. Colella played the world premiere in Boston in October 2006, and the original Broadway production in December of that year.
For her New York debut in Urban Cowboy, she earned a 2003 Outer Critics Circle Award nomination.
In Fall 2010, she also originated the role of Hedda Hopper in the world premiere of Limelight: The Story of Charlie Chaplin at the La Jolla Playhouse. It was renamed Chaplin: The Musical and she performed the role on Broadway from September 2012 to January 2013.
After the December 2013 world premiere run at the National Theatre in Washington, D.C., in March 2014, she started a year-long appearance in If/Then at the Richard Rodgers Theatre. Colella played Anne, a woman in a same-sex relationship with Kate. She had worked with the Kate role through development, but it was decided to cast LaChanze for the part. The role of Anne was then written in for her.
Among original Broadway productions, her longest run, starting in March 2017, was two and a half years in Come from Away. In the summer of 2015 Colella originated the role of Annette/Beverley Bass in the La Jolla Playhouse's world premiere production, which transferred later in the year to the Seattle Repertory Theatre. It then played Washington D.C. at Ford's Theatre, a concert presentation in Gander, Newfoundland, and at the Royal Alex in Toronto in 2016 before transferring to Broadway at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre. The show received positive reviews and she was nominated for a Tony Award, along with winning both a Drama Desk Award and an Outer Critics Circle Award for her performance. After three years of performing the role over a 4+1⁄2 year span, she left the production on November 10, 2019. During the summer of 2022, she returned as a replacement for seven weeks. She also returned for the final weeks of the production, in late September 2022, and performed in the last Broadway showing on October 2, 2022, to a sold out crowd.

### Regional theatre

Colella has had multiple regional theater appearances. In addition to those listed above that moved on to New York, they have included her favorite role, Peter Pan, which she has done four times. Along with the 2001 California summer stock appearance, she has been cast in 2008 at the Sondheim Center in Fairfield, IA, the Music Circus in Sacramento, CA in 2015, and a 2019 Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera in Pennsylvania.
Also in Pittsburgh, she played Annie Oakley in Annie Get Your Gun in 2008. In 2009 she appeared, along with Elaine Stritch, in Paper Mill Playhouse's The Full Monty in Millburn, NJ. 2010 found her in Princeton, NJ at the McCarter Theatre in the American premiere of Take Flight as aviator Amelia Earhart. Another world premiere occurred in December 2003 for Madison Repertory in Wisconsin as Jenny in Heartland: The Musical, followed by a January 2004 appearance in the show for the Broadway Contemporary Series in Dallas, TX.

### Comedy, film, and television

In the hopes of breaking into television, Colella began her career as a comedian as a way to get noticed. That, as well as the rock band, helped build her on stage confidence. She started doing observational humor stand-up in Southern California while pursuing her MFA. During that time, she performed in places such as the Laugh Factory and The Comedy Store in Hollywood. She has said that success and failure are equally valuable instructors.
She had her television debut in 2003 co-hosting the game show Can You Tell? with Tony Rock on Oxygen. Her next appearance was on the ABC series Cashmere Mafia, where she was in a same-sex relationship and discussed their starting a family. That show aired January 2008, six weeks before she opened in Beebo Brinker. Since then she has guest starred in several other television shows. In 2019, the year she left Come From Away, there were three for CBS, The Code, Madam Secretary, and Evil. Colella was also part of the PBS Tribute to Stephen Sondheim with the New York Philharmonic at Lincoln Center in 2010, and the initial Broadway in Concert: An Evening with Lerner and Loewe, again for PBS, in March 2022.
Her film credits are found in Uncertainty, Lay It Down for Good, the live filmed version of Come From Away, and Chocolate Milk.

### Additional work

Colella has performed for online web shows. These include 2012's Pzazz 101 in the "Jenn Colella" episode and Hedda's Headlines: Backstage at 'Chaplin' with Jenn Colella where she reported from backstage over eight episodes of the Broadway.com Series. In 2014 she played Sarah Jeffreys in Submissions Only for two episodes titled "Chapter 2" and "Reason to Stay." 2017 saw her in another Broadway.com series over the eight episodes of Welcome to the Rock: Backstage at COME FROM AWAY with Jenn Colella. In 2021 she played Jo in all eight episodes of The Flame: A Podcast Musical.
In between other appearances, she teaches master classes, has a cabaret act, and does benefit performances. She sang the National Anthem at a New York Yankees game in October 2021. Colella has also co-written a song with Tom Kitt that was included in his album Reflect: Tom Kitt & The Collective.

### Process

When Colella works on a project, she says she treats it as a hit and believes in it completely. But whether it is a hit is not the point, for her as an actor, it is to do her best work for as long as the show runs. She believes actors get hired not only because of talent, but because of their energy. She feels the energy that an actor brings into the room must be practiced throughout the day, working toward the foundation of present moment awareness. To her, "acting is the easy part, staying in the present moment in her work is harder and requires focus." She believes that acting is the same whether on Broadway or in a local theater.
She says there are only two things over which an actor has control—preparation and attitude. Her work ethic is to arrive at rehearsal with lines memorized and music learned. She works to understand what is going on and to develop ideas about her character. She thinks a production staff wants to trust that the actor will do the work and not appear for rehearsal unprepared. They also want to know the actor will be a team player, someone they will want to work with during a development cycle that may take several years.
Colella says she enjoys rehearsing more than performing. She has indicated she feels sad after opening night, when the creative team is not there anymore, as it is like mom and dad are gone. They are no longer there to guide and approve the work being done. She loves the energy and approval received from an audience, but the safety, community, and feeling of family within rehearsal is not the same.
She treats signing-in at the theater as a contract between herself and the others in the company to be her best self while there, and knows practicing kindness requires attention. She does not mark in rehearsal, and has spent her career singing like it's the last time she'll sing.

## Personal life

Colella refers to kindness as her religion and believes in its practice. She tries to be respectful and pleasant to each person she meets. A podcast host has said, "(she) might literally be the nicest person I've ever met," a former artistic director, "I've never seen her be cruel," and a composer/lyricist, "the most fun-loving, open-hearted, life-affirming person working in the theatre."
She identifies as mostly gay. Colella became engaged to Mo Mullen in June 2022 and they married October 4, 2022. On October 30, 2023, the couple announced that they were expecting their first child together. Their daughter, Morrison Caroline Colella, was born on February 14, 2024.
Coming to New York, she was told by people she respected to stay in the closet, as it might cause casting problems. After playing a lesbian in Beebo Brinker, though, she was getting more attention and media questions, and finally felt it was time to come out. Colella has said, "being a queer woman in the Broadway community is something I'm very proud of."
Manoel Felciano, a co-star of Colella's in the movie Uncertainty, wrote the song "Jenn Colella" about her. The second line reads, "But I suspect, Jenn Colella, if my name were Isabella, then my clumsy overtures might stand a chance."
After having seen Phantom of the Opera on Broadway, she got a mask tattooed on her right arm to show her dedication to the craft. Her first Broadway show, Urban Cowboy, was in the theater next to the Phantom theater. Colella then got a star tattooed to represent Urban Cowboy and to cover the mask. A star represented guidance and light to her. Two other visible tattoos, on the backs of her upper arms, are "Kindness" and "Gratitude," which she got while in Come From Away.
While working on Come From Away, Colella became friends with Beverley Bass, the airline captain she portrayed in the show. They first met in San Diego at James' Place, a restaurant across from the La Jolla Playhouse, after the last preview performance. They had an immediate kinship. At closing night for the Seattle tryout run, Bass presented her with the flight jacket, wings, and service pin that she wore on September 11, to be worn on Broadway.

## Credits
### Stage

| Year | Production | Role | Notes |
| 2002 | Urban Cowboy | Sissy | World Premiere Performances: Coconut Grove Playhouse, Miami, FL (Regional), Nov. 16–Dec. 1 |
| 2003 | Urban Cowboy | Sissy | Original Broadway Production Performances: Broadhurst Theatre, Mar. 27–May 18 |
| 2003 | Heartland: A Musical | Jenny | World Premiere Madison Repertory Theatre, Madison, WI (Regional) Performances: UW Vilas Hall • Mitchell Theatre, December 5–28 |
| 2004 | Heartland: A Musical | Jenny | Broadway Contemporary Series, Dallas, TX (Regional) Performances: Majestic Theatre, January 16–25 |
| 2004 | The Great American Trailer Park Musical | Pippi | New York Musical Theatre Festival Performances(6): Revelation Theatre, Sep. 28–Oct. 3 |
| 2005 | Slut | Delia | Original Off-Broadway Production Performances: American Theatre of Actors • Chernuchin, Oct. 1–Nov. 13 |
| 2006 | The Times They Are A-Changin' | Cleo | World Premiere La Jolla Playhouse, San Diego, CA (Regional) Performances: Old Globe Theatre, Feb. 9–Mar. 12 |
| 2006 | Kiki Baby | Kiki | Original staged reading Eugene O'Neill Theater Center Music Theatre Conference, Waterford, CT Performances: Rose Barn Theater, July 15–21 |
| 2006 | High Fidelity | Laura | World Premiere Emerson, Boston, MA (Regional) Performances: Colonial Theatre, October 6–22 |
| 2006 | High Fidelity | Laura | Original Broadway Production Performances: Imperial Theatre, December 7–17 |
| 2007 | The Becky Show | Performer | Readings, New York Performances: Ars Nova, February 11, 12 |
| 2007 | Don't Quit Your Night Job | Improve Player | Off-Broadway Improv Performances: HA! Comedy Club, May 17–June 4 |
| 2007 | Beautiful Girls: A Tribute to Sondheim | Performer | World Premiere Review The Colorado Festival of World Theatre Performances: Colorado College, September 22–23 |
| 2008 | Beebo Brinker Chronicles | Beebo Brinker | Off-Broadway Production Performances: 37 Arts Theatre B, Mar. 5–Apr. 27 |
| 2008 | Annie Get Your Gun | Annie Oakley | Pittsburgh CLO, Pittsburgh, PA (Regional) Performances: Benedum Center, July 22–Aug. 3 |
| 2008 | Girl Crazy (abridged) Side Show (abridged) | Molly Gray Daisy Hilton | Broadway: Three Generations, as Act 1 and Act 3, respectively Kennedy Center, Washington, D.C. Performances: Eisenhower Theater, October 2–5 (reopening after a 16-month renovation) |
| 2008 | Peter Pan | Peter | Way Off Broadway Musical Theatre, Fairfield, IA (Regional) Performances: Sondheim Center for the Performing Arts, November 6–16 |
| 2009 | The Full Monty | Georgie Bukatinsky | Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ (Regional) Performances (with Elaine Stritch as Jeanette): June 10–July 12 |
| 2009 | All Fall Down | Sarah Little | New York Musical Theatre Festival Performances(6): 45th Street Theatre, October 9–18 |
| 2010 | Beautiful Girls: A Tribute to Sondheim | Performer | Review Manhattan School of Music Performance: January 18 |
| 2010 | Take Flight | Amelia Earhart | American Premiere McCarter Theatre Center, Princeton, NJ (Regional) Performances: Berlind Theatre, May 13–June 6 |
| 2010 | Limelight: The Story of Charlie Chaplin | Hedda Hopper | World Premiere La Jolla Playhouse, San Diego, CA (Regional) Performances: Mandell Weiss Theatre, Sep. 7–Oct. 17 |
| 2011 | Lucky Guy | Chicky Lay | Original Off-Broadway Production Performances: Little Shubert Theatre, May 19–29 |
| 2011 | I'm Getting My Act Together and Taking It on the Road | Heather | Off-Broadway Production, staged concert performance Performances: York Theatre Company at St Peter's Church, June 19–26 |
| 2011 | Piece of My Heart | Jessie | Workshop with performances New York Stage and Film and Vassar College Powerhouse Theater Performances(3): Martel Theater, July 29–31 |
| 2011 | Kiki Baby | Kiki | New York Musical Theatre Festival Performances(6): Theatre at St. Clement's Church, October 5–16 |
| 2012 | Closer Than Ever | Performer | Off-Broadway Revue Performances: York Theatre Company at St Peter's Church, June 20–July 14 |
| 2012 | Chaplin: The Musical | Hedda Hopper | Original Broadway Production Performances: Ethel Barrymore Theatre, Sep. 10, 2012 – Jan. 6, 2013 |
| 2013 | If/Then | Anne | World Premiere Performances: National Theatre, Washington, D.C. Nov. 5–Dec. 8 |
| 2014 | If/Then | Anne | Original Broadway Production Performances: Richard Rodgers Theatre, Mar. 30, 2014 – Mar. 22, 2015 |
| 2015 | If/Then | Anne | Original Broadway Production Performances: Richard Rodgers Theatre, Mar. 30, 2014 – Mar. 22, 2015 |
| 2015 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | World Premiere La Jolla Playhouse, San Diego, CA (Regional) Performances: Sheila and Hughes Potiker Theatre, June 11–July 12 |
| 2015 | Peter Pan | Peter | Broadway Sacramento at Music Circus, Sacramento, CA (Regional) Performances: Wells Fargo Pavilion, July 21–26 |
| 2015 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Second out-of-town tryout Seattle Repertory Theatre, Seattle, WA (Regional) Performances: Bagley Wright Theater, Nov. 18 – Dec. 20 |
| 2016 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Third out-of-town tryout Performances: Ford's Theatre, Washington, D.C. (Regional), Sep. 8–Oct. 9 |
| 2016 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Concert presentation Performances: Steele Community Centre, Gander, Nfld, October 29 |
| 2016 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Fourth out-of-town tryout Performances: Royal Alex, Toronto, ON (Regional), Nov. 24, 2016–Jan. 8, 2017 |
| 2016 | Dear Evan Hansen | Virtual Community Voice | Recorded voice only |
| 2017–2019; 2022 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Original Broadway Production Performances: Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre, Mar. 12, 2017–Nov. 10, 2019; Jun. 21–Aug. 7, 2022 (limited run replacement) |
| 2018 | Twelve Angry Men | Juror 12 | Off-Broadway staged reading, all-female cast Performance: Theatre Row • Acorn, September 16 |
| 2019 | Camelot | Sir Lionel | Benefit Concert for Lincoln Center Theater Performance: Vivian Beaumont Theater, March 4 |
| 2019 | Peter Pan | Peter | Pittsburgh CLO, Pittsburgh, PA (Regional) Performances: Benedum Center, July 12–21 |
| 2019 | Fun Home | Alison | Immersive, site specific reading Quintessence of Dust Theatre Company Performance: Plaza Jewish Community Chapel, December 19 |
| 2022 | Suffs | Carrie Catt | World Premiere Performances: The Public Theater • Newman, Apr. 6–May 29 |
| 2024 | Suffs | Carrie Catt | Original Broadway Production Performances: Music Box Theatre, Mar. 26–present |

### Television

| Year | Title | Role | Notes |
| 2003 | Can You Tell? | Self | Co-host [Oxygen] |
| 2008 | Cashmere Mafia | Erika | Episode: "The Deciders" [ABC] |
| 2009 | Rescue Me | Singing Nurse #5 | Episode: "Mickey" [FX] |
| 2010 | All My Children | TV Reporter | Episode #10300 [ABC] |
| 2010 | The Good Wife | Julie | Episode: "Bad" [CBS] |
| 2010 | Sondheim! The Birthday Concert | Self | Great Performances on PBS |
| 2015 | Elementary | Blonde Group Wife | Episode: "All My Exes Live in Essex" [CBS] |
| 2016 | Feed the Beast | Val | 6 episodes [AMC] |
| 2019 | The Code | Lt. Col. Judge Jette | Episode: "Lioness" [CBS] |
| 2019 | Madam Secretary | Valerie Guillen | Episode: "Daisy" [CBS] |
| 2019 | Evil | Cori | Episode: "2 Fathers" [CBS] |
| 2022 | An Evening with Lerner and Loewe | Self | Broadway in Concert Series [PBS] – March 6 |
| 2022 | FBI: Most Wanted | DEA Agent Vanessa Ritchie | Episode: "Succession" [CBS] |
| 2025 | Elsbeth | Captain Kershaw | Episode "Unalive and Well" [CBS] |

### Film

| Year | Title | Role | Notes |
| 2008 | Uncertainty | Emily | |
| 2009 | Lay It Down For Good | Rebecca | Short film |
| 2021 | Come from Away | Annette, Beverley Bass and others | Live film recording of the musical |
| 2021 | Chocolate Milk | Sue | Short film |

### Webcast

| Year | Title | Role | Notes |
| 2012 | Pzazz 101 | Jenn | Episode: "Jenn Colella" |
| 2012 | Hedda's Headlines: Backstage at Chaplin with Jenn Colella | Self | 8 episodes, Broadway.com Series |
| 2014 | Submissions Only | Sarah Jeffreys | Episodes: "Chapter 2" and "Reason to Stay" |
| 2017 | Welcome to the Rock: Backstage at Come from Away with Jenn Colella | Self | 8 episodes, Broadway.com Series |
| 2021 | The Flame: A Podcast Musical | Jo | 8 episodes, series regular |

## Partial discography

These include cast albums and collections with a Colella solo track.
| Year | Album | Performer | Label |
| 1998 | The Gib Cat Sessions | The Gib Cats (original name of Sol Divers) | Pin Up Records |
| 1999 | Ink | The Sol Divers | Pin Up Records |
| 2007 | High Fidelity: A Musical | Original Broadway cast | Sh-K-Boom Records |
| 2007 | This Ordinary Thursday: The Songs of Georgia Stitt | Various artists | PS Classics |
| 2009 | Lost Broadway and More, Vol. 2 | Various artists | Original Cast Records |
| 2012 | Chaplin: The Musical | Original Broadway cast | Masterworks Broadway |
| 2012 | Closer Than Ever | Off-Broadway cast | Jay Records |
| 2014 | If/Then | Original Broadway cast | Masterworks Broadway |
| 2017 | Bare Naked: Lynne Shankel | Various artists | Yellow Sound Label |
| 2017 | Come From Away | Original Broadway cast | Concord Records |
| 2019 | Beau | World premiere recording | Masterworks Broadway |
| 2021 | Reflect: Tom Kitt & The Collective | Various artists | Masterworks Broadway |

## Awards and nominations

| Year | Award | Category | Work | Result |
| 2003 | Outer Critics Circle Award | Outstanding Actress in a Musical | Urban Cowboy | Nominated |
| 2011 | New York Musical Theatre Festival Award | Outstanding Individual Performance | Kiki Baby | Awarded |
| 2015 | Craig Noel Award | Outstanding Featured Performance in a Musical, Female | Come From Away. San Diego, CA | Won |
| 2017 | Helen Hayes Award | Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical – Hayes Production | Come From Away. Washington, D.C. | Won |
| 2017 | Dora Mavor Moore Award | Outstanding Performance – Female | Come From Away, Toronto | Won |
| 2017 | Tony Award | Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Musical | Come From Away | Nominated |
| 2017 | Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Come From Away | Won |
| 2017 | Outer Critics Circle Award | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Come From Away | Won |
| 2017 | Broadway.com Audience Choice Award | Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical | Come From Away | Nominated |
| 2018 | Grammy Award | Best Musical Theater Album | Come From Away | Nominated |
| 2018 | Grammy Award | Best Musical Theater Album | Dear Evan Hansen (for participation as Virtual Community Voice) | Won |
| 2022 | Outer Critics Circle Award | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Suffs | Nominated |