# Ladies Stakes

The Ladies Stakes is a historic American Thoroughbred horse race for Fillies and Mares four years of age and older held annually at Aqueduct Racetrack in Queens, New York. Inaugurated at the Jerome Park Racetrack in 1868, it is the oldest stakes race in the United States exclusively for fillies and mares. An unlisted stakes race, it is currently run on or about New Year's Day and offers a purse of $100,000.
From its beginnings in 1868 through 1912 the race was restricted to three-year-old fillies then from 1913 through 1938, it was made open to fillies of any age. Since 1939, it has been open to older fillies and mares. There was no race in 1895 and also none in 1911 and 1912, as a result of the New York State Legislature passage of the Hart–Agnew Law in 1908 which banned wagering and led to the shut down of all racing in the state. In 2006, the race was not run due to the shortage of entrants and as a result of NYRA financial reorganization, neither was it run in 2009.
The Ladies Handicap has been won by some notable females in American racing history including Hall of Fame inductees Firenze, Miss Woodford, Beldame, Maskette, Top Flight and Shuvee.
The Ladies Handicap has also been run at:
* Jerome Park Racetrack: 1868–1890
* Morris Park Racecourse: 1890–1904
* Belmont Park: 1905–1958, 1960

## Records

Speed record
* 1:49.78 @ 1-1/8 miles: Teen Pauline (2014)
* 1:36.40 @ 1 mile: Red Eye (1939)
* 2:01.40 @ 1-1/4 miles: Bastonera II (1976), Transient Trend (1995)
* 2:29.40 @ 1-1/2 miles: Goofed (1963)
* 2:58.25 @ 1-5/8 miles: Katie Pease 1873)
Most wins
* Black Maria (1926, 1927)
* Strolling Belle (1999, 2000)
Most wins by a jockey
* 6 – Ángel Cordero Jr. (1968, 1970, 1973, 1976, 1981, 1988)
Most wins by a trainer
* 4 – Jacob Pincus (1872, 1875, 1876, 1880)
* 4 – R. Wyndham Walden (1877, 1879, 1881, 1894)
* 4 – John C. Kimmel (1998, 1999, 2000, 2004)
Most wins by an owner
* 5 – August Belmont (1872, 1875, 1876, 1880, 1889)

## Winners

| Year | Winner | Age | Jockey | Trainer | Owner | Dist. (Miles) | Time | Win $ | Gr. |
| 2025 | Tizzy in the Sky | 6 | Kendrick Carmouche | Todd Pletcher | KimDon Racing LLC | 1-1/8 m | 1:52.56 | $82,500 | B/T |
| 2024 | Comparative | 4 | Manuel Franco | Brad H. Cox | Godolphin | 1-1/8 m | 1:55.83 | $82,500 | B/T |
| 2023 | Falconet | 4 | Jose Lezcano | Todd Pletcher | WinStar Farm & China Horse Club | 1-1/8 m | 1:52.15 | $82,500 | B/T |
| 2022 | Battle Bling | 4 | Trevor McCarthy | Rob Atras | Michael Dubb & Gandharvi Racing Stables | 1-1/8 m | 1:57.11 | $55,000 | B/T |
| 2021 | Thankful | 4 | Kendrick Carmouche | Todd Pletcher | Bass Stables LLC | 1-1/8 m | 1:53.51 | $55,000 | B/T |
| 2020 | Bellera | 4 | Jose Lezcano | Todd Pletcher | Mathis Stable LLC (Bill & Terry Mathis) | 1-1/8 m | 1:54.87 | $55,000 | B/T |
| 2019 | Forever Liesl | 5 | Eric Cancel | Michelle Nevin | Kallenberg Farms | 1-1/8 m | 1:54.12 | $55,000 | L/R |
| 2018 | Just Got Out | 7 | Manuel Franco | Linda Rice | Linda Rice & Sacandaga Stable | 1-1/8 m | 1:55.32 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2017 | Wonder Gal | 5 | Kendrick Carmouche | Leah Gyarmati | Clearview Stable | 1 m, 70 yds | 1:42.45 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2016 | Saythreehailmary's | 5 | Manuel Franco | John Morrison | Very Un Stable | 1 m, 70 yds | 1:44.91 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2015 | Divided Attention | 4 | Dylan Davis | Kiaran McLaughlin | Godolphin | 1-1/8 m | 1:55.00 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2014 | Teen Pauline | 4 | Irad Ortiz Jr. | Todd Pletcher | Stonestreet Stables | 1-1/8 m | 1:49.78 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2013 | Arena Elvira | 6 | Junior Alvarado | William Mott | Carolyn Wilson | 1-1/8 m | 1:51.53 | $45,000 | L/R |
| 2012 | C C's Pal | 5 | Junior Alvarado | Richard E. Dutrow Jr. | Eric Fein | 1-1/8 m | 1:52.85 | $45,000 | L/R |
| 2011 | R Betty Graybull | 5 | Eddie Castro | Linda Ann White | Fantasy Lane Stable & Stronach Stables | 1-1/8 m | 1:50.56 | $98,000 | L/R |
| 2010 | Tidal Dance | 5 | Channing Hill | Michael Hushion | Marc C. Ferrell | 1-1/8 m | 1:53.59 | $60,000 | L/R |
| 2009 | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held |
| 2008 | Borrowing Base | 5 | Javier Castellano | Patrick Quick | Daddie's Girl Stable, LLC | 1-1/4 m | 2:07.30 | $49,260 | L/R |
| 2007 | Wow Me Free | 5 | Alan Garcia | Kiaran McLaughlin | Edward A. Seltzer | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.63 | $47,730 | L/R |
| 2006 | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held |
| 2005 | India Halo | 5 | Jose Espinoza | James Ferraro | Blue Sky Farm | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.20 | $49,650 | L/R |
| 2004 | Rare Gift | 3 | Richard Migliore | John C. Kimmel | George Bolton, David Dipietro, Roger Honour | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.40 | $65,640 | G3 |
| 2003 | Savedbythelight | 3 | Richard Migliore | Richard Violette Jr. | Earle I. Mack | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.80 | $67,260 | G3 |
| 2002 | Critical Eye | 5 | Mike Luzzi | Scott Schwartz | Herbert Schwartz | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.00 | $64,440 | G3 |
| 2001 | Summer Colony | 3 | John Velazquez | Mark A. Hennig | Edward P. Evans | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.80 | $66,660 | G3 |
| 2000 | Strolling Belle | 4 | Heberto Castillo Jr. | John C. Kimmel | Red Oak Stable (John Brunetti) | 1-1/4 m | 2:06.60 | $66,000 | G3 |
| 1999 | Strolling Belle | 3 | Heberto Castillo Jr. | John C. Kimmel | Red Oak Stable (John Brunetti) | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.60 | $65,640 | G3 |
| 1998 | Unbridled Hope | 4 | Richard Migliore | John C. Kimmel | Martin J. Wygod | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.40 | $51,150 | G3 |
| 1997 | Prophet's Warning | 4 | Jorge Chavez | Joe Orseno | Jane Lyon | 1-1/4 m | 2:06.20 | $60,000 | G2 |
| 1996 | Miss Slewpy | 5 | Larry Reynolds | Ronald Cartwright | Oliver C. Goldsmith | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.20 | $66,660 | G2 |
| 1995 | Transient Trend | 3 | Jean-Luc Samyn | Patrick J. Kelly | Live Oak Racing (Charlotte Weber) | 1-1/4 m | 2:01.40 | $67,800 | G2 |
| 1994 | Tara Roma | 4 | Frank Alvarado | C. R. McGaughey III | Emory A. Hamilton | 1-1/4 m | 2:06.60 | $84,300 | G2 |
| 1993 | Groovy Feeling | 4 | Herb McCauley | Peter Ferriola | Robert P. Donaldson | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.80 | $120,000 | G2 |
| 1992 | Brilliant Brass | 5 | Edgar Prado | Carlos A. Garcia | Elaine L. Bassford | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.40 | $150,000 | G2 |
| 1991 | Wortheroatsingold | 4 | Eddie Maple | Patrick J. Kelly | Fox Ridge Farm (Peter G. Schiff) | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.40 | $150,000 | G2 |
| 1990 | Colonial Waters | 5 | José Santos | LeRoy Jolley | Carl Icahn | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.80 | $104,400 | G2 |
| 1989 | Dance Teacher | 4 | José Santos | Philip G. Johnson | Edward P. Evans | 1-1/4 m | 2:05.80 | $141,120 | G1 |
| 1988 | Banker's Lady | 3 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | Philip Hauswald | Edward A. Cox Jr. | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.00 | $138,960 | G1 |
| 1987 | Nastique | 3 | Robbie Davis | Stephen A. DiMauro | Bernard Chaus | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.40 | $146,880 | G1 |
| 1986 | Life At The Top | 3 | Randy Romero | D. Wayne Lukas | Eugene V. Klein | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.80 | $167,160 | G1 |
| 1985 | Videogenic | 3 | Robbie Davis | Gasper S. Moschera | Albert Davis | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.00 | $67,800 | G1 |
| 1984 | Heatherten | 5 | Randy Romero | William I. Mott | John A. Franks | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.00 | $71,400 | G1 |
| 1983 | Mademoiselle Forli | 4 | Gregg McCarron | Mitchell C. Preger | Leonard P. Sasso | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.40 | $67,320 | G1 |
| 1982 | Tina Tina Too | 4 | Don MacBeth | Richard DeStasio | Albert Fried, Jr. | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.00 | $65,520 | G1 |
| 1981 | Jameela | 5 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | Hyman M. Ravich | Peter M. Brant | 1-1/4 m | 2:01.80 | $66,240 | G1 |
| 1980 | Plankton | 4 | Cash Asmussen | Howard M. Tesher | Frederick K. Tesher | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.00 | $65,400 | G1 |
| 1979 | Spark Of Life | 4 | Jean Cruguet | MacKenzie Miller | Rokeby Stables | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.80 | $64,740 | G1 |
| 1978 | Ida Delia | 4 | Angel Santiago | Laz Barrera | Aaron U. Jones | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.40 | $65,820 | G1 |
| 1977 | Sensational | 3 | Michael Venezia | Woody Stephens | Mill House Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.80 | $65,820 | G1 |
| 1976 | Bastonera II | 5 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | Henry M. Moreno | Ann K. Elmore | 1-1/4 m | 2:01.40 | $65,220 | G1 |
| 1975 | Tizna | 6 | Fernando Alvarez | Henry M. Moreno | Victor Zemborian | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.60 | $51,390 | G1 |
| 1974 | Coraggioso | 4 | Eddie Maple | Anthony Basile | Bwamazon Farm (Millard Waldheim) | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.00 | $33,300 | G1 |
| 1973 | Wakefield Miss | 5 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | H. Allen Jerkens | Hobeau Farm | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.80 | $33,180 | G1 |
| 1972 | Grafitti | 4 | Michael Venezia | Horatio Luro | Louisa d'A Carpenter | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.80 | $32,250 |
| 1971 | Sea Saga | 3 | Carlos H. Marquez Sr. | Herbert W. Jones | Buckland Farm | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.60 | $34,680 |
| 1970 | Cathy Honey | 3 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | Evan S. Jackson | Frances M. Harcourt | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.20 | $36,010 |
| 1969 | Shuvee | 3 | Jesse Davidson | Willard C. Freeman | Anne Minor Stone | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.00 | $37,830 |
| 1968 | Politely | 5 | Ángel Cordero Jr. | George M. Baker | Bohemia Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.60 | $36,335 |
| 1967 | Sweet Folly | 3 | Heliodoro Gustines | John M. Gaver, Sr. | Greentree Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:04.60 | $38,090 |
| 1966 | Destro | 3 | Braulio Baeza | Edward A. Neloy | Ogden Phipps | 1-1/4 m | 2:02.40 | $36,725 |
| 1965 | Straight Deal | 3 | Johnny Sellers | Hirsch Jacobs | Ethel D. Jacobs | 1-1/4 m | 2:03.60 | $36,336 |
| 1964 | Steeple Jill | 3 | John Ruane | Bert Mulholland | George D. Widener Jr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.60 | $38,415 |
| 1963 | Goofed | 3 | John L. Rotz | Oleg Dubassoff | John M. Schiff | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.40 | $38,765 |
| 1962 | Royal Patrice | 3 | Howard Grant | Burley Parke | Harbor View Farm | 1-5/16 | 2:10.60 | $37,245 |
| 1961 | Mighty Fair | 3 | Paul J. Bailey | Edward A. Neloy | Andrew J. Crevolin | 1-5/16 | 2:11.80 | $37,050 |
| 1960 | Berlo | 3 | Eric Guerin | Richard E. Handlen | Foxcatcher Farm | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.60 | $38,205 |
| 1959 | Tempted | 4 | Eldon Nelson | Henry S. Clark | Mooring Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:09.00 | $36,580 |
| 1958 | Endine | 4 | Eldon Nelson | Henry S. Clark | Christiana Stable | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.40 | $37,165 |
| 1957 | Rare Treat | 5 | Paul J. Bailey | Bert Mulholland | George D. Widener Jr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.60 | $40,800 |
| 1956 | Flower Bowl | 4 | Bill Shoemaker | Preston M. Burch | Brookmeade Stable | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.80 | $40,100 |
| 1955 | Manotick | 3 | Angel Valenzuela | Casey Hayes | Christopher Chenery | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.40 | $43,900 |
| 1954 | Lavender Hill | 5 | Stanley Small | Thomas W. Kelley | Mrs. Charles Silver | 1-1/2 m | 2:32.20 | $43,400 |
| 1953 | La Corredora | 4 | Ira Hanford | Carl Hanford | Marian W. O'Connor | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.40 | $40,900 |
| 1952 | How | 4 | Nick Shuk | Horatio Luro | Herman B. Delman | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.40 | $40,900 |
| 1951 | Marta | 4 | Conn McCreary | Woody Stephens | Woodvale Farm | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.20 | $21,250 |
| 1950 | Next Move | 3 | Eric Guerin | William C. Winfrey | Alfred G. Vanderbilt Jr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.40 | $20,700 |
| 1949 | Gaffery | 3 | Eric Guerin | Richard E. Handlen | Foxcatcher Farm | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.80 | $24,800 |
| 1948 | Miss Request | 3 | Ted Atkinson | James P. Conway | Florence D. Whitaker | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.00 | $40,600 |
| 1947 | Snow Goose | 3 | Ted Atkinson | Oscar White | Walter M. Jeffords Sr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:29.60 | $42,600 |
| 1946 | Athenia | 3 | Ted Atkinson | E. Leigh Cotton | Hal Price Headley | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.60 | $16,700 |
| 1945 | War Date | 3 | Arnold Kirkland | Tom Smith | Maine Chance Farm | 1-1/2 m | 2:34.40 | $11,730 |
| 1944 | Donitas First | 3 | Ted Atkinson | Preston M. Burch | Longchamps Farms | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.20 | $11,040 |
| 1943 | Stefanita | 3 | Conn McCreary | Bert Mulholland | George D. Widener Jr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.80 | $11,025 |
| 1942 | Vagrancy | 3 | James Stout | James E. Fitzsimmons | Belair Stud | 1-1/2 m | 2:31.20 | $11,175 |
| 1941 | Up The Hill | 3 | Conn McCreary | George M. Odom | Marshall Field III | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.00 | $11,800 |
| 1940 | Salamania | 3 | Don Meade | Duval A. Headley | Hal Price Headley | 1-1/2 m | 2:30.00 | $12,250 |
| 1939 | Red Eye | 3 | Basil James | J. P. "Sammy" Smith | Falaise Stable | 1 m | 1:36.40 | $5,900 |
| 1938 | Idle Miss | 4 | Alfred M. Robertson | B. Frank Christmas | B. Frank Christmas | 1 m | 1:37.60 | $5,400 |
| 1937 | Genie Palatine | 4 | Charley Kurtsinger | Bert S. Michell | Jean Denemark | 1 m | 1:38.00 | $2,405 |
| 1936 | Rust | 4 | Eddie Yager | Louis Strube | Louis Strube | 1 m | 1:38.40 | $2,395 |
| 1935 | Vicaress | 3 | Eddie Arcaro | James E. Fitzsimmons | Belair Stud | 1 m | 1:37.40 | $2,325 |
| 1934 | Coequel | 3 | Eddie Litzenberger | George E. Phillips | Maemere Farm (DeWitt Page) | 1 m | 1:37.40 | $2,030 |
| 1933 | White Lies | 3 | Mack Garner | Henry McDaniel | Gertrude T. Widener | 1 m | 1:38.40 | $1,030 |
| 1932 | Top Flight | 3 | Raymond Workman | Thomas J. Healey | C. V. Whitney | 1 m | 1:37.80 | $2,275 |
| 1931 | Valenciennes | 4 | Charley Kurtsinger | William Knapp | Fannie Hertz | 1 m | 1:37.40 | $2,725 |
| 1930 | Snowflake | 3 | Louis Schaefer | Jack R. Pryce | Walter J. Salmon Sr. | 1 m | 1:40.00 | $4,375 |
| 1929 | Lace | 4 | Laverne Fator | John W. May | Mendham Stable (R. H. Williams) | 1 m | 1:38.20 | $3,750 |
| 1928 | Twitter | 3 | Raymond Workman | James G. Rowe Jr. | Harry Payne Whitney | 1 m | 1:40.40 | $3,275 |
| 1927 | Black Maria | 4 | Frank Colitelli | William H. Karrick | William R. Coe | 1 m | 1:39.80 | $3,500 |
| 1926 | Black Maria | 3 | Laverne Fator | William H. Karrick | William R. Coe | 1 m | 1:38.80 | $3,175 |
| 1925 | Whetstone | 4 | Albert M. Johnson | Gwyn R. Tompkins | Glen Riddle Farm | 1 m | 1:37.80 | $3,400 |
| 1924 | Relentless | 3 | John Maiben | Matthew P. Brady | Joseph E. Davis | 1 m | 1:38.00 | $3,725 |
| 1923 | Solisa | 3 | Benny Marinelli | Scott P. Harlan | Greentree Stable | 1 m | 1:38.80 | $3,325 |
| 1922 | Many Smiles | 3 | Charles Fairbrother | William H. Karrick | William R. Coe | 1 m | 1:37.20 | $2,475 |
| 1921 | Pen Rose | 5 | Laverne Fator | Dan Kearney | Triple Spring Farm | 1 m | 1:40.60 | $1,745 |
| 1920 | Milkmaid | 4 | Earl Sande | H. Guy Bedwell | J. K. L. Ross | 1 m | 1:38.20 | $3,175 |
| 1919 | Salvestra | 4 | Edward Taplin | Frank M. Taylor | John J. Hallenbeck | 1 m | 1:37.60 | $1,955 |
| 1918 | Eyelid | 3 | Morris Rowan | Richard O. Miller | Anthony L. Aste | 1 m | 1:40.00 | $2,130 |
| 1917 | Rhine Maiden | 5 | Raymond Ball | Frank Devers | Edward F. Whitney | 1 m | 1:41.00 | $2,060 |
| 1916 | Celandria | 3 | Mack Garner | James A. McLaughlin | Elkwood Park Stable (Frederick Lewisohn) | 1 m | 1:41.00 | $1,610 |
| 1915 | Addie M. | 4 | George Byrne | George W. Langdon | John W. Messervy | 1 m | 1:39.20 | $1,450 |
| 1914 | Flying Fairy | 4 | Tommy Davies | J. Simon Healy | Edward B. Cassatt | 1 m | 1:38.00 | $2,110 |
| 1913 | Flamma | 4 | Herman Radtke | Paul Maderia | E. F. Condran | 1 m | 1:39.60 | $1,720 |
| 1912 | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. |
| 1911 | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. | No races held due to the Hart–Agnew Law. |
| 1910 | Ocean Bound | 3 | Guy Garner | French Brooks | Woodford Clay | 1 m | 1:43.00 | $1,520 |
| 1909 | Maskette | 3 | James Butwell | James G. Rowe Sr. | James R. Keene | 1 m | 1:39.00 | $6,630 |
| 1908 | Stamina | 3 | Eddie Dugan | A. Jack Joyner | Harry P. Whitney | 1 m | 1:40.60 | $6,385 |
| 1907 | Yankee Girl | 3 | Herman Radtke | George P. Brazier | Charles R. Ellison | 1 m | 1:40.60 | $5,405 |
| 1906 | Perverse | 3 | Lucien Lyne | John W. Rogers | Harry P. Whitney | 1 m | 1:39.80 | $5,000 |
| 1905 | Flinders | 3 | Lucien Lyne | John Allen | Chelsea Stable (Ernest La Montagne & Russell Tucker) | 1 m | 1:42.40 | $5,345 |
| 1904 | Beldame | 3 | Gene Hildebrand | Fred Burlew | Newton Bennington | 1 m | 1:41.20 | $4,870 |
| 1903 | Girdle | 3 | Tommy Burns | John W. Rogers | William Collins Whitney | 1 m | 1:42.20 | $3,445 |
| 1902 | Blue Girl | 3 | Tommy Burns | John W. Rogers | William Collins Whitney | 1 m | 1:42.00 | $2,395 |
| 1901 | Janice | 3 | Joe Piggott | Green B. Morris | Green B. Morris | 1 m | 1:45.25 | $2,485 |
| 1900 | Oneck Queen | 3 | Danny Maher | Walter C. Rollins | Oneck Stable | 1 m | 1:40.75 | $2,600 |
| 1899 | Prestidigitatrice | 3 | Fred Littlefield | Robert J. Walden | Alfred H. & Dave H. Morris | 1 m | 1:43.00 | $2,340 |
| 1898 | Geisha | 3 | Tod Sloan | William H. Karrick | Arthur White | 1 m | 1:43.00 | $2,240 |
| 1897 | Divide | 3 | Fred Taral | Edward F. Hughes | Kensico Stable (J. P. Kramer & Anthony L. Aste) | 1 m | 1:44.00 | $2,550 |
| 1896 | Intermission | 3 | Fred Littlefield | Ed Wall | John E. McDonald | 1 m | 1:43.50 | $1,425 |
| 1895 | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held | Race not held |
| 1894 | Nahma | 3 | Fred Littlefield | R. Wyndham Walden | John A. & Alfred H. & Dave H. Morris | 1-1/16 m | 1:49.00 | $4,600 |
| 1893 | Naptha | 3 | Willie Simms | William J. Speirs | William James Speirs | 1-1/16 m | 1:49.00 | $2,930 |
| 1892 | Yorkville Belle | 3 | Isaac Murphy | Matthew M. Allen | Frank A. Ehret | 1 m, 1 f | 1:56.50 | $3,530 |
| 1891 | Castalia | 3 | Fred Taral | William H. McCarthy | David D. Withers | 6.36 f | 1:20.50 | $3,420 |
| 1890 | Sinaloa II | 3 | Shelby Barnes | Robert E. Campbell | Santa Anita Stable | 6.36 f | 1:19.00 | $5,670 |
| 1889 | Fides | 3 | Edward Garrison | James G. Rowe Sr. | August Belmont Sr. | 1 m, 1 f | 2:00.50 | $4,040 |
| 1888 | Bella B. | 3 | Jim McLaughlin | Frank McCabe | Dwyer Brothers Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:14.50 | $2,970 |
| 1887 | Firenze | 3 | Fred Littlefield | Matthew Byrnes | James B. A. Haggin | 1-1/4 m | 2:14.75 | $2,670 |
| 1886 | Bandala | 3 | Jim McLaughlin | Charles S. Littlefield | Richmond Stable | 1-1/4 m | 2:12.50 | $2,270 |
| 1885 | Miss Palmer | 3 | Jim McLaughlin | Andrew Thompson | John E. McDonald | 1-1/2 m | 2:47.50 | $2,120 |
| 1884 | Duchess | 3 | William Donohue | Evert V. Snedecker | E. V. Snedeker & Co. | 1-1/2 m | 2:46.00 | $2,360 |
| 1883 | Miss Woodford | 3 | Jim McLaughlin | James G. Rowe Sr. | Dwyer Brothers Stable | 1-1/2 m | 2:43.50 | $3,040 |
| 1882 | Hiawasse | 3 | Matthew Feakes | Matthew Byrnes | Pierre Lorillard IV | 1-1/2 m | 2:44.00 | $2,800 |
| 1881 | Aella | 3 | Tom Costello | R. Wyndham Walden | George L. Lorillard | 1-1/2 m | 2:51.00 | $2,400 |
| 1880 | Carita | 3 | William Hayward | Jacob Pincus | August Belmont Sr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:44.50 | $2,350 |
| 1879 | Ferida | 3 | Tom Costello | R. Wyndham Walden | George L. Lorillard | 1-1/2 m | 2:47.00 | $2,900 |
| 1878 | Invermoor | 3 | John Sparling | Barney Riley | David D. Withers | 1-1/2 m | 2:46.75 | $3,000 |
| 1877 | Idalia | 3 | George Barbee | R. Wyndham Walden | George L. Lorillard | 1-1/2 m | 2:41.00 | $3,300 |
| 1876 | Sultana | 3 | William Hayward | Jacob Pincus | August Belmont Sr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:46.00 | $2,950 |
| 1875 | Olitipa | 3 | George Evans | Jacob Pincus | August Belmont Sr. | 1-1/2 m | 2:42.75 | $2,850 |
| 1874 | Bonaventure | 3 | William Lakeland | | William Cottrill | 1-1/2 m | 2:42.25 | $2,850 |
| 1873 | Katie Pease | 3 | James G. Rowe Sr. | Col. David McDaniel | Col. David McDaniel | 1-5/8 m | 2:58.25 | $3,150 |
| 1872 | Victoria | 3 | Gradwell | Jacob Pincus | August Belmont Sr. | 1-5/8 m | 3:11.00 | $2,800 |
| 1871 | Nellie Gray | 3 | Robert Swim | | Miles Kelley | 1-5/8 m | 3:03.00 | $3,400 |
| 1870 | Annette | 3 | Wilson | Rollie Colston | Daniel Swigert | 1-5/8 m | 3:02.00 | $2,800 |
| 1869 | Tasmania | 3 | C. Miller | | David D. Withers & John F. Purdy | 1-5/8 m | 3:07.75 | $2,150 |
| 1868 | Bonnie Braes | 3 | Hennessey | | J. Eckerson | 1-5/8 m | 3:06.75 | $1,850 |
* In 1974, Poker Night won the race, but was disqualified and set back to second.
* In 1970, Manta won the race, but was disqualified and set back to second.