# NCAA Division I men's ice hockey All-Tournament team

NCAA All-Tournament team is an honor bestowed at the conclusion of the NCAA Division I ice hockey tournament to the players judged to have performed the best during the championship. The team is currently composed of three forwards, two defensemen and one goaltender with additional players named in the event of a tie. Voting for the honor was conducted by the head coaches of each member team once the tournament has completed and any player regardless of their team's finish is eligible.
The All-Tournament Team began being awarded after the first championship in 1948 along with an All-Tournament Second-Team. The second team was dropped after the 1969 tournament and it has remained a single team ever since except for 1976 when no team was selected. In recent years the regional tournaments have begun to name all-tournament teams of their own, making the NCAA All-Tournament team draw only from the teams and performances in the Frozen Four.
In two years (1973 and 1992) some players who were voted onto the All-Tournament team played for schools that had their participation in the championship vacated and are no longer officially recognized with the honor but have been included here for historical reference. Vacated appearances are not included in team totals.

## All-Tournament teams
### 1940s

1948 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernie Burke | G | Boston College |
| Connie Hill | D | Michigan |
| Ron Newson | D | Colorado College |
| Wally Grant | F | Michigan |
| Bill Riley | F | Dartmouth |
| Joe Riley | F | Dartmouth |
1949 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dick Desmond | G | Dartmouth |
| Ed Songin | D | Boston College |
| Mike Thayer | D | Dartmouth |
| Wally Grant | F | Michigan |
| Jack Mulhern | F | Boston College |
| Joe Riley | F | Dartmouth |

### 1950s

1950 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ralph Bevins | G | Boston University |
| Ross Smith | D | Michigan |
| Jim Starrak | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Anderson | F | Boston University |
| Tony Frasca | F | Colorado College |
| Jack Garrity | F | Boston University |
1951 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Donald Whiston | G | Brown |
| Bob Heathcott | D | Michigan |
| Jim Starrak | D | Colorado College |
| Gil Burford | F | Michigan |
| Neil Celley | F | Michigan |
| John Matchefts | F | Michigan |
1952 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Kinsley | G | Colorado College |
| Jim Haas | D | Michigan |
| Len Maccini | D | Colorado College |
| George Chin | F | Michigan |
| John McKennell | F | Michigan |
| Doug Philpott | F | Michigan |
1953 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mattson | G | Minnesota |
| Alex MacLellan | D | Michigan |
| Tom Wegleitner | D | Minnesota |
| John Matchefts | F | Michigan |
| Dick Meredith | F | Minnesota |
| Abbie Moore | F | Rensselaer |
1954 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Fox | G | Rensselaer |
| Jim Pope | D | Rensselaer |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Frank Chiarelli | F | Rensselaer |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| Gordie Peterkin | F | Rensselaer |
1955 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lorne Howes | G | Michigan |
| Phil Hilton | D | Colorado College |
| Doug Silverberg | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Cleary | F | Harvard |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Tom Rendall | F | Michigan |
1956 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lorne Howes | G | Michigan |
| Bob Pitts | D | Michigan |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Pete Aubry | F | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Rendall | F | Michigan |
| Ed Switzer | F | Michigan |
1957 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie MacDonald | G | Clarkson |
| Bob Pitts | D | Michigan |
| Don Wishart | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Hay | F | Colorado College |
| Bob McCusker | F | Colorado College |
| Tom Rendall | F | Michigan |
1958 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rodney Schneck | G | Denver |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Ed Zemrau | D | Denver |
| Murray Massier | F | Denver |
| Bob Van Lammers | F | Clarkson |
| Jim Brown | F | Denver |
1959 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Selinger | G | Michigan State |
| Joe Jangro | D | Boston College |
| Pat Presley | D | St. Lawrence |
| Reg Morelli | F | North Dakota |
| Bill MacKenzie | F | Michigan State |
| Ed Thomlinson | F | North Dakota |

### 1960s

1960 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Barry Urbanski | G | Boston University |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| George Konik | D | Denver |
| Lou Angotti | F | Michigan Tech |
| Paul Coppo | F | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Marquis | F | Boston University |
1961 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Larson | G | Minnesota |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| Grant Munro | D | Denver |
| Trent Beatty | F | Denver |
| Bill Masterton | F | Denver |
| Jerry Walker | F | Denver |
1962 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richie Broadbelt | G | St. Lawrence |
| Henry Åkervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Elov Seger | D | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Angotti | F | Michigan Tech |
| Red Berenson | F | Michigan |
| John Ivanitz | F | Michigan Tech |
1963 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Apprille | G | Boston College |
| George Goodacre | D | North Dakota |
| Don Ross | D | North Dakota |
| Al McLean | F | North Dakota |
| Dave Merrifield | F | North Dakota |
| Don Stokaluk | F | North Dakota |
1964 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Gray | G | Michigan |
| Tom Polanic | D | Michigan |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Andy Herrebout | F | Denver |
| Bill Staub | F | Denver |
| Gordon Wilkie | F | Michigan |
1965 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Dennis Huculak | D | Michigan Tech |
| Pete Leiman | D | Michigan Tech |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Gary Milroy | F | Michigan Tech |
| Wayne Weller | F | Michigan Tech |
1966 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gaye Cooley | G | Michigan State |
| Don Heaphy | D | Michigan State |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Mike Coppo | F | Michigan State |
| Tom Hurley | F | Clarkson |
| Brian McAndrew | F | Michigan State |
1967 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Harry Orr | D | Cornell |
| Skip Stanowski | D | Cornell |
| Mike Doran | F | Cornell |
| Tom Mikkola | F | Michigan State |
| Jim Quinn | F | Boston University |
1968 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gerry Powers | G | Denver |
| Terry Abram | D | North Dakota |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Bob Munro | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Trembecky | F | Denver |
1969 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gerry Powers | G | Denver |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Bruce Pattison | D | Cornell |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Tom Miller | F | Denver |
| Bob Trembecky | F | Denver |

### 1970s

1970 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Bullock | G | Clarkson |
| Steve Giuliani | D | Cornell |
| Dan Lodboa | D | Cornell |
| John Hughes | F | Cornell |
| Rick Magnusson | F | Clarkson |
| Bob Poffenroth | F | Wisconsin |
1971 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Brady | G | Boston University |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Bruce McIntosh | D | Minnesota |
| Dean Blais | F | Minnesota |
| Don Cahoon | F | Boston University |
| Steve Stirling | F | Boston University |
1972 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Regan | G | Boston University |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Ric Jordan | D | Boston University |
| John Danby | F | Boston University |
| Dave Westner | F | Cornell |
| Gary Winchester | F | Wisconsin |
1973 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Makey | G | Wisconsin |
| Bruce Affleck* | D | Denver |
| John Taft | D | Wisconsin |
| Stan Hinkley | F | Wisconsin |
| Peter McNab* | F | Denver |
| Dean Talafous | F | Wisconsin |
1974 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Shelstad | G | Minnesota |
| Les Auge | D | Minnesota |
| Jim Nahrgang | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Jensen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Jim McMahon | F | Harvard |
| Mike Polich | F | Minnesota |
1975 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Warden | G | Michigan Tech |
| Reed Larson | D | Minnesota |
| Bob Lorimer | D | Michigan Tech |
| Bob D'Alvise | F | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Jensen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Warren Miller | F | Minnesota |
1976 :
* No Team Selected ||
1977 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Julian Baretta | G | Wisconsin |
| Craig Norwich | D | Wisconsin |
| John Taft | D | Wisconsin |
| Dave Debol | F | Michigan |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Dave Silk | F | Boston University |
1978 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Skidmore | G | Boston College |
| Dick Lamby | D | Boston University |
| Jack O'Callahan | D | Boston University |
| Mark Fidler | F | Boston University |
| Joe Mullen | F | Boston College |
| Dave Silk | F | Boston University |
1979 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Janaszak | G | Minnesota |
| Mike Ramsey | D | Minnesota |
| Howard Walker | D | North Dakota |
| Steve Christoff | F | Minnesota |
| Eric Strobel | F | Minnesota |
| Mark Taylor | F | North Dakota |

### 1980s

1980 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Weeks | G | Northern Michigan |
| Marc Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Tom Laidlaw | D | Northern Michigan |
| Roy Kerling | F | Cornell |
| Doug Smail | F | North Dakota |
| Phil Sykes | F | North Dakota |
1981 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Behrend | G | Wisconsin |
| Mike Knoke | D | Minnesota |
| Tim Watters | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Bozek | F | Northern Michigan |
| Aaron Broten | F | Minnesota |
| John Newbery | F | Wisconsin |
1982 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darren Jensen | G | North Dakota |
| Bruce Driver | D | Wisconsin |
| James Patrick | D | North Dakota |
| Cary Eades | F | North Dakota |
| John Newbery | F | Wisconsin |
| Phil Sykes | F | North Dakota |
1983 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Behrend | G | Wisconsin |
| Chris Chelios | D | Wisconsin |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Patrick Flatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Paul Houck | F | Wisconsin |
1984 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Kosti | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Gary Kruzich | G | Bowling Green |
| David Ellett | D | Bowling Green |
| Garry Galley | D | Bowling Green |
| Dean Barsness | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Lakso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Lyle Phair | F | Michigan State |
1985 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Terreri | G | Providence |
| Tim Friday | D | Rensselaer |
| Ken Hammond | D | Rensselaer |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer |
| George Servinis | F | Rensselaer |
| Bill Watson | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1986 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Norm Foster | G | Michigan State |
| Mark Benning | D | Harvard |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Allen Bourbeau | F | Harvard |
| Mike Donnelly | F | Michigan State |
| Jeff Parker | F | Michigan State |
1987 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ed Belfour | G | North Dakota |
| Ian Kidd | D | North Dakota |
| Chris Luongo | D | Michigan State |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Tony Hrkac | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Joyce | F | North Dakota |
| Corey Millen | F | Minnesota |
1988 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Hoffort | G | Lake Superior State |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Brian McColgan | D | St. Lawrence |
| Dave Capuano | F | Maine |
| Mike de Carle | F | Lake Superior State |
| Pete Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
1989 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Allain Roy | G | Harvard |
| Todd Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Kevin Sneddon | D | Harvard |
| Jon Anderson | F | Minnesota |
| Ted Donato | F | Harvard |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard |

### 1990s

1990 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Duane Derksen | G | Wisconsin |
| Rob Andringa | D | Wisconsin |
| Mark Osiecki | D | Wisconsin |
| John Byce | F | Wisconsin |
| Joel Gardner | F | Colgate |
| Chris Tancill | F | Wisconsin |
1991 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Pye | G | Northern Michigan |
| Lou Melone | D | Northern Michigan |
| Brad Werenka | D | Northern Michigan |
| Tony Amonte | F | Boston University |
| Scott Beattie | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | Maine |
1992 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Mark Astley | D | Lake Superior State |
| Barry Richter* | D | Wisconsin |
| Paul Constantin | F | Lake Superior State |
| Brian Rolston | F | Lake Superior State |
| Jason Zent* | F | Wisconsin |
1993 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garth Snow | G | Maine |
| Chris Imes | D | Maine |
| Michael Smith | D | Lake Superior State |
| Paul Kariya | F | Maine |
| Jim Montgomery | F | Maine |
| Brian Rolston | F | Lake Superior State |
1994 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blaine Lacher | G | Lake Superior State |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Steven Barnes | D | Lake Superior State |
| Clayton Beddoes | F | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Pomichter | F | Boston University |
| Sean Tallaire | F | Lake Superior State |
1995 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blair Allison | G | Maine |
| Chris Imes | D | Maine |
| Kaj Linna | D | Boston University |
| Shawn Bates | F | Boston University |
| Chris O'Sullivan | F | Boston University |
| Dan Shermerhorn | F | Maine |
1996 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Steven Halko | D | Michigan |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Peter Geronazzo | F | Colorado College |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
1997 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aaron Schweitzer | G | North Dakota |
| Curtis Murphy | D | North Dakota |
| Tom Poti | D | Boston University |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University |
| Matt Henderson | F | North Dakota |
| David Hoogsteen | F | North Dakota |
1998 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Bubba Berenzweig | D | Michigan |
| Mike Mottau | D | Boston College |
| Mark Kosick | F | Michigan |
| Josh Langfeld | F | Michigan |
| Marty Reasoner | F | Boston College |
1999 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alfie Michaud | G | Maine |
| David Cullen | D | Maine |
| Jayme Filipowicz | D | New Hampshire |
| Niko Dimitrakos | F | Maine |
| Jason Krog | F | New Hampshire |
| Michael Souza | F | New Hampshire |

### 2000s

2000 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Mike Commodore | D | North Dakota |
| Mike Mottau | D | Boston College |
| Jeff Farkas | F | Boston College |
| Lee Goren | F | North Dakota |
| Bryan Lundbohm | F | North Dakota |
2001 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Clemmensen | G | Boston College |
| Travis Roche | D | North Dakota |
| Rob Scuderi | D | Boston College |
| Chuck Kobasew | F | Boston College |
| Krys Kolanos | F | Boston College |
| Bryan Lundbohm | F | North Dakota |
2002 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Hauser | G | Minnesota |
| Michael Schutte | D | Maine |
| Peter Metcalf | D | Maine |
| John Pohl | F | Minnesota |
| Grant Potulny | F | Minnesota |
| Róbert Liščák | F | Maine |
2003 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Travis Weber | G | Minnesota |
| Paul Martin | D | Minnesota |
| Matt DeMarchi | D | Minnesota |
| Steve Saviano | F | New Hampshire |
| Thomas Vanek | F | Minnesota |
| Nathan Martz | F | New Hampshire |
2004 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Berkhoel | G | Denver |
| Ryan Caldwell | D | Denver |
| Prestin Ryan | D | Maine |
| Junior Lessard | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Dustin Penner | F | Maine |
| Connor James | F | Denver |
2005 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Peter Mannino | G | Denver |
| Brett Skinner | D | Denver |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Paul Stastny | F | Denver |
| Travis Zajac | F | North Dakota |
| Gabe Gauthier | F | Denver |
2006 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Elliott | G | Wisconsin |
| Tom Gilbert | D | Wisconsin |
| Brett Motherwell | D | Boston College |
| Adam Burish | F | Wisconsin |
| Chris Collins | F | Boston College |
| Robbie Earl | F | Wisconsin |
2007 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State |
| Tyler Howells | D | Michigan State |
| Brian Boyle | D | Boston College |
| Tim Kennedy | F | Michigan State |
| Nathan Gerbe | F | Boston College |
| Justin Abdelkader | F | Michigan State |
2008 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Muse | G | Boston College |
| Michael Brennan | D | Boston College |
| Kyle Lawson | D | Notre Dame |
| Kevin Deeth | F | Notre Dame |
| Nathan Gerbe | F | Boston College |
| Ben Smith | F | Boston College |
2009 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kieran Millan | G | Boston University |
| Colby Cohen | D | Boston University |
| Kevin Roeder | D | Miami |
| Nick Bonino | F | Boston University |
| Colin Wilson | F | Boston University |
| Tommy Wingels | F | Miami |

### 2010s

2010 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Muse | G | Boston College |
| Brian Dumoulin | D | Boston College |
| Brendan Smith | D | Wisconsin |
| Cam Atkinson | F | Boston College |
| Ben Smith | F | Boston College |
| Joe Whitney | F | Boston College |
2011 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shawn Hunwick | G | Michigan |
| Justin Faulk | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jon Merrill | D | Michigan |
| Kyle Schmidt | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| J. T. Brown | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ben Winnett | F | Michigan |
2012 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Parker Milner | G | Boston College |
| Brian Dumoulin | D | Boston College |
| Chad Billins | D | Ferris State |
| Kyle Bonis | F | Ferris State |
| Paul Carey | F | Boston College |
| Steven Whitney | F | Boston College |
2013 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Malcom | G | Yale |
| Zach Davies | D | Quinnipiac |
| Gus Young | D | Yale |
| Clinton Bourbonais | F | Yale |
| Andrew Miller | F | Yale |
| Jordan Samuels-Thomas | F | Quinnipiac |
2014 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Colin Stevens | G | Union |
| Mat Bodie | D | Union |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| Daniel Ciampini | F | Union |
| Kyle Rau | F | Minnesota |
| Sam Warning | F | Minnesota |
2015 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Gillies | G | Providence |
| Anthony Florentino | D | Providence |
| Matt Grzelcyk | D | Boston University |
| Ahti Oskanen | F | Boston University |
| Mark Jankowski | F | Providence |
| Jack Eichel | F | Boston University |
2016 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cam Johnson | G | North Dakota |
| Troy Stecher | D | North Dakota |
| Connor Clifton | D | Quinnipiac |
| Drake Caggiula | F | North Dakota |
| Brock Boeser | F | North Dakota |
| Travis St. Denis | F | Quinnipiac |
2017 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tanner Jaillet | G | Denver |
| Will Butcher | D | Denver |
| Neal Pionk | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Alex Iafallo | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jarid Lukosevicius | F | Denver |
| Troy Terry | F | Denver |
2018 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Hunter Shepard | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Scott Perunovich | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jordan Gross | D | Notre Dame |
| Karson Kuhlman | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jared Thomas | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Andrew Oglevie | F | Notre Dame |
2019 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Hunter Shepard | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mikey Anderson | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Marc Del Gaizo | D | Massachusetts |
| Parker Mackay | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Justin Richards | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Billy Exell | F | Minnesota-Duluth |

### 2020s

2020 :
* Not awarded due to the coronavirus pandemic ||
2021 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Filip Lindberg | G | Massachusetts |
| Zac Jones | D | Massachusetts |
| Matthew Kessel | D | Massachusetts |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State |
| Bobby Trivigno | F | Massachusetts |
| Nolan Walker | F | St. Cloud State |
2022 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Magnus Chrona | G | Denver |
| Mike Benning | D | Denver |
| Jack McNeely | D | Minnesota State |
| Carter Savoie | F | Denver |
| Ryan Barrow | F | Denver |
| Sam Morton | F | Minnesota State |
2023 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Luke Mittelstadt | D | Minnesota |
| Logan Cooley | F | Minnesota |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac |
| Jacob Quillan | F | Quinnipiac |
2024 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Davis | G | Denver |
| Sean Behrens | D | Denver |
| Zeev Buium | D | Denver |
| Tristan Broz | F | Denver |
| Rieger Lorenz | F | Denver |
| Will Smith | F | Boston College |
* Player is no longer officially considered as part of the All-Tournament Team

## Second Teams
### 1940s

1948 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dick Desmond | G | Dartmouth |
| Ross Smith | D | Michigan |
| Ed Songin | D | Boston College |
| Wally Gacek | F | Michigan |
| Bruce Stewart | F | Colorado College |
| Joe Slattery | F | Colorado College |
1949 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernie Burke | G | Boston College |
| Ron Newson | D | Colorado College |
| Lew Meier | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Riley | F | Dartmouth |
| Wally Gacek | F | Michigan |
| Connie Hill | F | Michigan |

### 1950s

1950 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Roy Ikola | G | Colorado College |
| Ed Songin | D | Boston College |
| Joe Foligno | D | Boston University |
| Jack Mulhern | F | Boston College |
| Wally Grant | F | Michigan |
| Ron Hartwell | F | Colorado College |
1951 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Hal Downes | G | Michigan |
| Jim Sutherland | D | Brown |
| John Murphy | D | Brown |
| Jack Garrity | F | Boston University |
| Al Gubbins | F | Brown |
| Omer Brandt | F | Colorado College |
1952 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Cruikshank | G | Yale |
| Steve Leolich | D | Colorado College |
| Reggie Shave | D | Michigan |
| Earl Keyes | F | Michigan |
| Wally Kilrea Jr. | F | Yale |
| Omer Brandt | F | Colorado College |
1953 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Willard Ikola | G | Michigan |
| Herb LaFontaine | D | Rensselaer |
| Reggie Shave | D | Michigan |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| George Chin | F | Michigan |
| Frank Chiarelli | F | Rensselaer |
1954 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mattson | G | Minnesota |
| Jim Haas | D | Michigan |
| Bob Siblo | D | Boston College |
| Abbie Moore | F | Rensselaer |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Richard Dougherty | F | Minnesota |
1955 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Sloan | G | St. Lawrence |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Mike Buchanan | D | Michigan |
| Clare Smith | F | Colorado College |
| Ken Smith | F | Colorado College |
| Dick Dunnigan | F | Michigan |
1956 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Sarge Whittier | G | St. Lawrence |
| Bill Renner | D | St. Lawrence |
| Willie Tattersall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Cliff Wylie | F | Michigan Tech |
| Ron Stenlund | F | Michigan Tech |
| Joe McLean | F | St. Lawrence |
1957 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ross Childs | G | Michigan |
| Dick McGhee | D | Colorado College |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Bob McVey | F | Harvard |
| Dick Dunnigan | F | Michigan |
| John Andrews | F | Colorado College |
1958 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie MacDonald | G | Clarkson |
| Blair Livingstone | D | Denver |
| Ralph Lyndon | D | North Dakota |
| Barry Sharp | F | Denver |
| Ron King | F | North Dakota |
| John MacMillan | F | Denver |
1959 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Logue | G | Boston College |
| Ralph Lyndon | D | North Dakota |
| Ed Pollesel | D | Michigan State |
| Larry Langill | F | St. Lawrence |
| Tom Mustonen | F | Michigan State |
| Joe Poole | F | North Dakota |

### 1960s

1960 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Kirkwood | G | Denver |
| Henry Akervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Pat Enright | D | Boston University |
| Terry Slater | F | St. Lawrence |
| John MacMillan | F | Denver |
| John Kosiancic | F | Michigan Tech |
1961 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Kirkwood | G | Denver |
| George Konik | D | Denver |
| Arlie Parker | D | St. Lawrence |
| Terry Slater | F | St. Lawrence |
| Jim Josephson | F | Rensselaer |
| Ron Constantine | F | Minnesota |
1962 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Cal Wagner | D | Clarkson |
| Don Rodgers | D | Michigan |
| Jerry Sullivan | F | Michigan Tech |
| Larry Babcock | F | Michigan |
| Hal Pettersen | F | Clarkson |
1963 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wayne Gibbons | G | Clarkson |
| Jim Kenning | D | Denver |
| Maurice Roberge | D | North Dakota |
| Jack Leetch | F | Boston College |
| Corby Adams | F | Clarkson |
| Bob Hamill | F | Denver |
1964 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Bellemore | G | Providence |
| Jim Kenning | D | Denver |
| Larry Kish | D | Providence |
| Barry MacDonald | D | Michigan |
| Mel Wakabayashi | F | Michigan |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
| Jack Cole | F | Michigan |
1965 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Murphy | G | Boston College |
| Roy Davidson | D | North Dakota |
| Ralph Toran | D | Boston College |
| Gerry Kell | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Stoyko | F | North Dakota |
| Dennis Macks | F | Brown |
1966 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Yurkiewicz | G | Clarkson |
| Pete McLachlan | D | Boston University |
| Bob Brawley | D | Michigan State |
| Tom Mikkola | F | Michigan State |
| John McLennan | F | Clarkson |
| Lyle Bradley | F | Denver |
1967 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wayne Ryan | G | Boston University |
| Pete McLachlan | D | Boston University |
| Brian Gilmour | D | Boston University |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| Dave Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| Brian McAndrew | F | Michigan State |
1968 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Tim Gould | D | Denver |
| Terry Ogden | D | North Dakota |
| Dave Kartio | F | North Dakota |
| Jim Wiste | F | Denver |
| Tom Gilmour | F | Denver |
1969 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Tim Gould | D | Denver |
| Steve Giuliani | D | Cornell |
| Al Karlander | F | Michigan Tech |
| Ron Mark | F | Harvard |
| Peter Tufford | F | Cornell |