# ABCA/Rawlings High School All-America Baseball Team

The ABCA/Rawlings High School All-America Baseball Team has been named by the American Baseball Coaches Association every year since 1969, with the exceptions of 1993 and 2020. Between 1971–1975 and in 2000, only one team was selected per year. In 1969–1970, 1976 and 1987, two teams were selected per year. Each team has consisted of between 10 and 25 players at various designated positions.
As of 2024, Farragut High School in Farragut, Tennessee has had nine selections to the team, most of any school. California has had more selections and more than twice as many First Team selections as any other state, with 327 and 146 respectively.
Thirty-four players have been named to the team twice. Bill McGuire of Creighton Preparatory School was the first to accomplish the feat in 1981 and 1982. As of 2024, Tripp MacKay, Joey Gallo, Jack Flaherty, Jace Bohrofen and Druw Jones are the only players to be named to the First Team twice.
In 2001, Casey Kotchman and John Killalea of Seminole High School became the first pair of high school teammates to be named to the First Team in the same year. Scott Kazmir and Clint Everts of Cypress Falls High School accomplished the same feat in the following year. Adrian Cárdenas and Chris Marrero of Monsignor Edward Pace High School followed in 2006 and Seth Hernandez and Ethan Schiefelbein of Corona High School followed in 2024.
Ten honorees have gone on to be enshrined in the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum while eight have been inducted into the National College Baseball Hall of Fame. John Elway of Granada Hills High School is enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame and Condredge Holloway of Lee High School is enshrined in the Canadian Football Hall of Fame.
Eighteen selectees have later won a Major League Baseball (MLB) Most Valuable Player Award, nine players have won a Cy Young Award. As highly touted prospects, 23 players have subsequently been selected first overall in the MLB draft and ten have won an MLB Rookie of the Year Award.
Eighteen players named to one of the three teams have played football professionally, including Josh Booty, Chad Hutchinson and Drew Henson who played in both the National Football League and MLB. Ryan Minor of Hammon High School in Hammon, Oklahoma played professional basketball and in MLB. Scott Burrell of Hamden High School is the only honoree to go on to play basketball in the National Basketball Association.
Before being sponsored by Rawlings, the team was sponsored by Converse.

## Key

| ‡ | Member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Major League Baseball All-Star |
| ^ | MLB Most Valuable Player or Cy Young Award-winner and All-Star |
| * | Major League Baseball All-Star |
| $^#$ | First overall Major League Baseball draft pick |
| $^G$ | Gatorade High School Baseball Player of the Year Award winner |
| $^B$ | Baseball America High School Player of the Year Award winner |
| ° | Player played a different sport professionally |

## Teams
### 1969–1979

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 1969 | Catcher | Terry McDermott | St. Agnes (NY) | Gene Holbert | Palmyra (PA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | First base | Mike Anderson | Timmonsville (SC) | Jim Baxley | Enterprise (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Second base | Fred Frazier | Hoover (CA) | Bill O'Connor | Mt. Miguel (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Third base | Ted Nicholson | Oak Park (MS) | Lester Spikes | Central Memorial (LA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Shortstop | Alan Bannister | Kennedy (CA) | Mike Phillips | MacArthur (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Outfield | Jeff Burroughs^$^#$ | Wilson (CA) | Jim Johnson | Brandywine (MI) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Outfield | Alvin McGrew | Parker (AL) | Kent Burdick | Parker (WI) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Outfield | Dave Chorley | Millikan (CA) | Richard Soriano | Hialeah (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Pitcher | Jim Richard* | Lincoln (LA) | Don Stanhouse* | DuQuoin (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1969 | Pitcher | Randall Sterling | Key West (FL) | Bob May | Merritt Island (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Catcher | Michael Ivie$^#$ | Walker (GA) | Barry Foote | Smithfield-Selma (NC) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | First base | Dan Briggs | Sonora (CA) | Kenneth Waiss | DePew (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Second base | Dale Holland | Riverview (FL) | Jerry Hairston | Gardendale (AL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Third base | Charles Maxwell | Miami Trace (OH) | Jimmie Hacker | Temple (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Shortstop | Kenneth Pape | MacArthur (TX) | Gary Polczynski | Hale (WI) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Outfield | Darnell Ford | Fremont (CA) | Art DeFilippis | Catholic (CT) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Outfield | Burnel Flowers | Courter Tech (OH) | Fred Wegner | Fresno (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Outfield | Ronald Kinner | Dunbar (TX) | Price Thomas | Shaw (AL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Pitcher | James Martin | Olympia (SC) | James Haller | Creighton Prep (NE) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1970 | Pitcher | Randy Scarbery | Roosevelt (CA) | David Cheadle, Jr. | Asheville (NC) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Catcher | Danny Goodwin$^#$ | Peoria Central (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | First base | Ed Kurpiel | Molloy (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Second base | Richard Puig | Hillsborough (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Third base | Thomas Bianco | Sewanhaka (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Shortstop | Condredge Holloway° | Lee (AL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Outfield | Terry Whitfield | Palo Verde (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Outfield | James Rice$^‡$^ | Hanna (SC) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Outfield | Ronald Williamson | Asher (OK) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Pitcher | Roy Branch | Beaumont (MO) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1971 | Pitcher | Roy Thomas | Lompoc (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Catcher | Bobbie D. Goodman | Bishop Byrne (TN) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Infield | Ellis C. Valentine* | Crenshaw (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Infield | Rickey D. White | Fresno (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Infield | Roy Lee Howell* | Lompoc (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Infield | Richard T. Manning | La Salle (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Outfield | Cleo H. Kilpatrick | Washington (OK) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Outfield | Mike Ondina | Cordova (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Outfield | Stephen Englishbey | S. Houston (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Pitcher | Larry Christenson | Marysville (WA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1972 | Pitcher | Scott H. McGregor* | El Segundo (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Catcher | Ted Farr | Shadle Park (WA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Infield | Mickey Reichenbach | Taylor (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Infield | Augie Juricic | Joliet (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Infield | Gary Roenicke | Edgewood (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Infield | Robin Yount$^‡$^ | Taft (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Outfield | Bill Taylor | Savannah (GA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Outfield | Bruce Tonascia | Napa (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Outfield | Lee Mazzilli* | Lincoln (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Pitcher | Dave Clyde$^#$ | Westchester (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1973 | Pitcher | George Kunkler | Lindbergh (MO) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Catcher | Dale Murphy^ | Wilson (OR) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Infield | James Del Vecchio | Warde (CT) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Infield | Lance Parrish* | Walnut (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Infield | Ron Sorey | Dayton (OH) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Infield | Rick Sutcliffe* | Van Horn (MO) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Outfield | Lonnie Smith* | Centennial (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Outfield | Kevin Drake | Cabrillo (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Outfield | Willie Wilson* | Summit (NJ) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Pitcher | Larry Monroe | Forest View (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Pitcher | Steve Reid | Wayne (IN) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1974 | Pitcher | Tom Boggs | Lanier (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Catcher | Al Benton | Godby (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Infield | Rocky Alburtis | Monterey (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Infield | Walter Podgurski | Union (NJ) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Infield | Arthur Miles | Crocket (TX) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Infield | Jim Anderson | Kennedy (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Outfield | Les Filkins | Washington (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Outfield | Brian Rosinski | Evanston (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Outfield | Clint Hurdle | Merritt Island (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Pitcher | Mike Lentz | Juanita (WA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1975 | Pitcher | Pat Gillie | Alhambra (AZ) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Catcher | Tim Glass | Springfield South (OH) | Osvaldo Virgil* | Moon Valley (AZ) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | First base | Leon Durham* | Woodward (OH) | Joe Keith Isaacs | Asher (OK) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Infield | Alan Trammell$^‡$ | Kearny (CA) | Roberto Alvarez | Miami Carol City (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Infield | Mark Kuecker | Brenham (TX) | D'Aloin James | Madison Township (NJ) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Infield | James Allen | Yakima Davis (WA) | Michael Allen Kopsky | Christian Brothers (MO) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Outfield | William Simpson | Lakewood (CA) | Jeff Kraus | Colerain (OH) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Outfield | Pat Tabler* | McNicholas (OH) | Paul Householder | North Haven (CT) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Outfield | Tom Thurberg | Weymouth South (MA) | Dana Drisko | North Syracuse (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Pitcher | Pat Underwood | Kokomo (IN) | Bruce Hurst* | Dixie (UT) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Pitcher | Bill Bordley | Bishop Montgomery (CA) | Ben Grzybek | Hialeah (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1976 | Pitcher | Steve Trout | Thornwood (IL) | William Scherrer | Cardinal O'Hara (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1977 | Catcher | Dave Hodgins | Buchser (CA) | Ray Corbett | Samuel Clemens (TX) | Gerry Groninger | Green Mountain (CO) | |
| 1977 | First base | Harold Baines$^‡$$^#$ | St. Michaels (MD) | Stan Davis | Halifax County (VA) | Bruce LaHay | Oakville (MO) | |
| 1977 | Second base | Walt Backman | Aloha (OR) | Tom Goffena | Sidney (OH) | Daryl Hill | Peterson (CA) | |
| 1977 | Third base | Tad Venger | Hart (CA) | Kyle Keahey | La Junta (CO) | Paul Gallagher | Pennsburg (PA) | |
| 1977 | Shortstop | Dave Hibner | Howell (MI) | Jose Castro | Miami Jackson (FL) | David Brooks | Blanchard (OK) | |
| 1977 | Outfield | Paul Croft | Morristown (NJ) | Brian Greer | Sonora (CA) | Leo Koralik | Weber (IL) | |
| 1977 | Outfield | Craig Landis | Vintage (CA) | Anthony Nicely | Meadowdale (OH) | Bill Kuchar | Hamden (CT) | |
| 1977 | Outfield | Kevin Bass* | Menlo (CA) | Bruce Compton | Norman (OK) | David Henderson* | Dos Palos (CA) | |
| 1977 | Pitcher | Andrew Madden | New Hartford (NY) | Tom Mullen | Central (IA) | Kevin Richardson | Roosevelt (MI) | |
| 1977 | Pitcher | William Gullickson | Joliet Catholic (IL) | Ricky Wright | Paris (TX) | Mike Jones | Sutherland (NY) | |
| 1977 | Pitcher | Richard Barnes | Lake Worth (FL) | Richard Dotson* | Anderson (OH) | David Flattery | St. Edmond (IA) | |
| 1978 | Catcher | Brian Milner | Southwest (TX) | Nick Hernandez | Hialeah (FL) | Dave Valle | Holy Cross (NY) | |
| 1978 | First base | Lloyd Moseby* | Oakland Tech (CA) | Mike Marshall* | Buffalo Grove (IL) | Harry Weaver | Eldorado (NM) | |
| 1978 | Second base | Mike Woodard | Proviso East (IL) | Rex Hudler | Bullard (CA) | Nick Esasky | Miami Carol City (FL) | |
| 1978 | Third base | Phil Lansford | Wilcox (CA) | Brian Giles | Kearny (CA) | Don Alcorn | Aurora Central (CO) | |
| 1978 | Shortstop | Bud Biancalana | Redwood (CA) | Kevin Martin | Falconer Central (NY) | Leonardo Faedo | Jefferson (FL) | |
| 1978 | Outfield | Tito Nanni | Chestnut Hill (PA) | Darryl Motley | Grant (OR) | Ruben Luna | Southwestern (MI) | |
| 1978 | Outfield | Mark Ryal | Dewar (OK) | Melvin Hall | Port Byron (NY) | David Leeper | Villa Park (CA) | |
| 1978 | Outfield | Tom Brunansky* | West Covina (CA) | Paul Summers | Oakville (MO) | Kean Rich | Washington (IA) | |
| 1978 | Pitcher | Mike Morgan* | Valley (NV) | Steve Raine | North Salinas (CA) | Johnny Moses | Bellaire (TX) | |
| 1978 | Pitcher | Melton Hawkins | Midway (TX) | Brian Ryder | Schrewsbury (MA) | Kevin Clinton | Wichita Southeast (KS) | |
| 1978 | Pitcher | Tim Conroy | Gateway (CA) | Mike Martinez | Pueblo East (CO) | Rip Rollins | Alleghany (NC) | |
| 1979 | Catcher | Jay Schroeder° | Palisades (CA) | John Mizerock | Punxsutawney (PA) | Ed Vosberg | Salpointe (AZ) | |
| 1979 | First base | Joe Lansford | Wilcox (CA) | Todd Demeter | U. S. Grant (OK) | Steve Chapman | Murray (UT) | |
| 1979 | Second base | Steve Buechele | Senite (CA) | Mike Kwiecinski | Cousino (MI) | Jim Heuring | St. Michael (MN) | |
| 1979 | Third base | Shane Allen | Palm Bay (FL) | John Brown | Crenshaw (CA) | Greg Gagne | Somerset (MA) | |
| 1979 | Shortstop | Juan Bustabad | Hialeah-Miami Lakes (FL) | Randy Kutcher | Palmdale (CA) | Jordan Berge | Pueblo East (CO) | |
| 1979 | Outfield | Albert Chambers$^#$ | John Harris (PA) | Kevin Brandt | Nekoosa (WI) | Chris Rehbaum | St. Joseph's (NY) | |
| 1979 | Outfield | Brad Komminsk | Shawnee (OH) | Chris Baker | Livonia Franklin (MI) | Ron Shepherd | Kilgore (TX) | |
| 1979 | Outfield | Andrew Van Slyke* | New Hartford (NY) | John Elway° | Granada Hills (CA) | Oscar Burnett | Moravia (NY) | |
| 1979 | Pitcher | John Bohnet | Hogan (CA) | Scott Garrelts* | Buckley-Loda (IL) | Lon Olejniczak | Decorah (IA) | |
| 1979 | Pitcher | Jeff Bettendorf | Cabrillo (CA) | Bob Gunnarsson | Lake Havasu (AZ) | Charles Crimm | Thousand Oaks (CA) | |
| 1979 | Pitcher | Richard Leucken | Spring Woods (TX) | Scott Glanz | Edison (OK) | Frank Osmulski | Summit (NJ) | |

### 1980–1989

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 1980 | Catcher | Jeff Reed | Joliet West (IL) | John Gibbons | MacArthur (TX) | Ross Kingsley | Janesville (WI) | |
| 1980 | First base | Ken Kinnard | Claremore (OK) | Jay Reid | Lynwood (CA) | Peter Yates | Newburport (MA) | |
| 1980 | Second base | Rhett Whisman | Fairfield (OH) | David Miley | Chamberlain (FL) | Tim Brecht | Norway (IA) | |
| 1980 | Third base | Roger Hansen | Rio Mesa (CA) | David Pagel | Sunside (AZ) | Bruce Seid | Oak Park (MI) | |
| 1980 | Shortstop | Darrell Coles | Eisenhower (CA) | Kelly Gruber* | Westlake (TX) | Doug Baylor | St. Mark's (DE) | |
| 1980 | Utility | Jay Tibbs | Huffman (AL) | Dion James | McClatchy (CA) | Chad Loupee | Washington (IA) | |
| 1980 | Outfield | Garry Harris | Hoover (CA) | Keith Lovellette | Taconic (MA) | John Schuessler | Thomas Jefferson (TX) | |
| 1980 | Outfield | Jeff Williams | Princeton (OH) | Andy Ponseigo | Arapahoe (CO) | Mark Reynolds | Wichita Southeast (KS) | |
| 1980 | Outfield | Cecil Espy | Point Loma (CA) | Orlando Villarreal | Wyoming Park (MI) | Ed McMillan | Xavier (CT) | |
| 1980 | Pitcher | Brian Fisher | Hinkley (CO) | Dan Collins | Newport News (VA) | Jeff Horne | White Oak (NC) | |
| 1980 | Pitcher | Tim Maki | Carroll (IN) | Pat Clements | Pleasant Valley (CA) | Ed Leuppe | Littleton (CO) | |
| 1980 | Pitcher | Don Schulze | Lake Park (IL) | Ron Robinson | Woodlake (CA) | Jody Johnson | Franklin (NY) | |
| 1981 | Catcher | Kevin Burrell | Poway (CA) | John Marzano | Central (PA) | David Lelievre | Waltham (MA) | |
| 1981 | First base | Todd Benzinger | New Richmond (OH) | Jeff Lauck | McLane (CA) | Steve Berlin | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 1981 | Second base | Chris Howard | Boone (FL) | Leon Roberts* | Skyline (CA) | John Kanter | Camelback (AZ) | |
| 1981 | Third base | David Cochrane | Troy (CA) | Brendan Hennessy | Bogota (NJ) | Greg McClain | Pasadena (CA) | |
| 1981 | Shortstop | Dick Schofield | Springfield Griffin (IL) | Randy Whisler | Klamath Union (OR) | Tom Duggan | Edison (CA) | |
| 1981 | Utility | Bill McGuire | Creighton Prep (NE) | Scott Fromwiller | Davison (MI) | W. Scott Pleis | Wentzville (MO) | |
| 1981 | Outfield | George Alpert | Livingston (NJ) | Jeff Bassett | South (OH) | Mike Land | Concord (DE) | |
| 1981 | Outfield | Darrin Jackson | Culver City (CA) | Stan Palmore | Chicago Vocational (IL) | Greg Morhardt | Gilbert (CT) | |
| 1981 | Outfield | Daryl Boston | Woodward (OH) | Jeff Koenigsman | Creighton Prep (NE) | Shawn Sullivan | Bowie (MD) | |
| 1981 | Pitcher | Mark Grant | Joliet Catholic (IL) | Bill Babock | Grosse Pointe North (MI) | Ricky Barlow | Woodville (TX) | |
| 1981 | Pitcher | Vance Lovelace | Hillsborough (FL) | Tony Ferreira | North Riverside (CA) | Mark Gubicza* | Penn Charter (PA) | |
| 1982 | Catcher | Ron Karkovice | Boone (FL) | Juan Velazquez | Hialeah-Miami Lakes (FL) | Bill McGuire (2) | Creighton Prep (NE) | |
| 1982 | First base | Sam Horn | Morse (CA) | Bill Clark* | Jesuit (LA) | Mike Hill | Lakewood (CO) | |
| 1982 | Second base | Shawon Dunston*$^#$ | Thomas Jefferson (NY) | Barry Larkin$^‡$^ | Moeller (OH) | Lance Lincoln | Pullman (WA) | |
| 1982 | Third base | Dale Sveum | Pinole Valley (CA) | Michael Greenwell* | North Fort Myers (FL) | Bob Witt | Canton (MA) | |
| 1982 | Shortstop | Sam Khalifa | Sahuaro (AZ) | Joe Dunlap | Haskell (OK) | Jeff Hamilton | Carman (MI) | |
| 1982 | Utility | Robert Jones | Proviso East (IL) | Dave Otto | Elk Grove (IL) | Chris Knabenshue | Smoky Hill (CO) | |
| 1982 | Outfield | Barry Bonds^ | Serra (CA) | Marc Washington | Northwestern (MI) | Jim Davins | Notre Dame (CT) | |
| 1982 | Outfield | Ken Williams | Mount Pleasant (CA) | Mark Davis | Hoover (CA) | Rodney Carter° | Elizabeth (NJ) | |
| 1982 | Outfield | Willie Boderick | Robinson (FL) | Steve Capell | Los Alamos (NM) | Steve Pollock | North Syracuse (NY) | |
| 1982 | Pitcher | Jimmy Jones | Thomas Jefferson (TX) | Richard Monteleone | Tampa Catholic (FL) | Robert Parkins | Cerritos (CA) | |
| 1982 | Pitcher | Robert Kipper | Aurora Central Catholic (IL) | David Wells* | Point Loma (CA) | Allan Anderson | Lancaster (OH) | |
| 1983 | Catcher | Matt Stark | Los Altos (CA) | Joe Oliver | Boone (FL) | Mark Machtolf | Gonzaga (WA) | |
| 1983 | First base | Paul Ricky Jordan | Grant (CA) | Boris King | Palm Springs (CA) | Psul Fuller | Leo (IL) | |
| 1983 | Second base | Todd Mabe | Edison (CA) | George Threadgill | Whiteville (NC) | Elanis Westbrooks | Bellaire (TX) | |
| 1983 | Third base | Eddie Williams | Hoover (CA) | Tim Zapolski | Boulder City (NV) | John Toale | Tarauella (FL) | |
| 1983 | Shortstop | Kurt Stillwell* | Thousand Oaks (CA) | Marcus Lawton | Harrison Central (MS) | Webster Garrison | Ehret (LA) | |
| 1983 | Utility | John Toale | Tarauella (FL) | Randall Strijek | Draper (NY) | Carl Jenkins | Yonkers (NY) | |
| 1983 | Outfield | Gary Thurman | North Central (IN) | Rex Blackwell | Colton (CA) | Chris Forgione | Salesianum (DE) | |
| 1983 | Outfield | Curt Parham | Thornridge (IL) | Paul Thoutsis | Worcester (MA) | Paul Murphy | Ardsley (NY) | |
| 1983 | Outfield | Ron DeLucchi | Campolindo (CA) | Geoff Petersen | Clovis West (CA) | Drew Stratton | Quabbin Regional (MA) | |
| 1983 | Pitcher | Brian Holman | Wichita North (KS) | Mike Greer | Valley (NV) | John Kuester | Norway (IA) | |
| 1983 | Pitcher | Jackie Davidson | Everman (TX) | Mike Pavelka | Hopkins (MN) | Wayne Dotson | Estacado (TX) | |
| 1983 | Pitcher | Joel Davis | Sandalwood (FL) | David West | Craigmont (TN) | Stan Fansler | Elkins (WV) | |
| 1984 | Catcher | Erik Pappas | Mount Carmel (IL) | Chris Olson | Medford (MA) | Dave Sturdivant | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 1984 | First base | Howard Freiling | Northeast (PA) | Rex Peters | Cherry Creek (CO) | Brandon Bailey | Hanna (SC) | |
| 1984 | Second base | Isaiah Clark | Crockett (TX) | Terry Green | Springtown (OK) | Ted Holcomb | Westchester (CA) | |
| 1984 | Third base | Luis De Los Santos | Newtown (NY) | Tim Scott | Hanford (CA) | Scott Livingstone | Lake Highlands (TX) | |
| 1984 | Shortstop | Jay Bell* | Tate (FL) | Darin Grimes | Wichita North (KS) | Greg Jefferies* | Serra (CA) | |
| 1984 | Utility | Thomas Glavine$^‡$^ | Billerica (MA) | Mark Kramer | Bremen (IL) | Chris Jones | Liverpool (NY) | |
| 1984 | Outfield | Tom Hartley | Hudson's Bay (WA) | Angelo Cuevas | Aviation (NY) | Robert Bell | Gardena (CA) | |
| 1984 | Outfield | Andrew Denson | Purcell Marian (OH) | Greg Selvera | Omaha Northwest (NE) | Tony Gray | Hopkins (MN) | |
| 1984 | Outfield | Shawn Abner$^#$ | Mechanicsburg (PA) | Marc Wolever | Lewis Central (IA) | Richard Leigh | DeSoto (TX) | |
| 1984 | Pitcher | Tony Menendez | American (FL) | Peter Smith | Burlington (MA) | Curt Krippner | Cypress Creek (TX) | |
| 1984 | Pitcher | Greg Maddux$^‡$^ | Valley (NV) | Kevin Garner | Brazoswood (TX) | David Haas | Truman (MO) | |
| 1984 | Pitcher | Al Leiter* | Central Regional (NJ) | Anthony Lee | Garner (NC) | Al Ashmont | Union Catholic (NJ) | |
| 1985 | Catcher | Kurt Brown | Glendora (CA) | Greg David | Barron Collier (FL) | Mark Harpenaw | St. Mary's (IA) | |
| 1985 | First base | Tino Martinez* | Jefferson (FL) | Al Martin | Rowland (CA) | Dan Didito | Waltham (MA) | |
| 1985 | Second base | Mark Cole | Kennedy (CA) | Rod Murrell | Skyline (TX) | Jeff Connors | Niwot (CO) | |
| 1985 | Third base | Bill St. Peter | Bay City Western (MI) | Bryn Kosco | Poland Seminary (OH) | Ed Toledo | Boulder (CO) | |
| 1985 | Shortstop | Greg Jefferies* (2) | Serra (CA) | Greg Smith | Glenelg (MD) | Brian McRae | Manatee (FL) | |
| 1985 | Utility | Gregg Olson* | Omaha Northwest (NE) | Anthony Balabon | Conestoga (PA) | Chris Bacon | New Trier (IL) | |
| 1985 | Outfield | Glen Braxton | Idabel (OK) | Kevin Batiste | Ball (TX) | Mike Moreland | Pascagoula (MS) | |
| 1985 | Outfield | Ricky Epps | Kildare (TX) | Brian Crowley | Newington (CT) | Brad Shoemaker | Prospect (IL) | |
| 1985 | Outfield | Steve Davis | Plano (TX) | John Viera | Miami Southridge (FL) | Shon Ashley | Meridian (ID) | |
| 1985 | Pitcher | Tommy Greene | Whiteville (NC) | Jeff Baumgarner | Hanford (WA) | Dan Johnston | Regis (IA) | |
| 1985 | Pitcher | Toby Nivens | McAllen (TX) | Dan Gabriele | Walled Lake Western (MI) | Clint Zavaras | Mullen Prep (CO) | |
| 1985 | Pitcher | Brian Dubois | Reed Custer (IL) | Ricky Rojas | Hialeah-Miami Lakes (FL) | Daniel McConaghy | La Salle (RI) | |
| 1986 | Catcher | Derek Parks | Montclair (CA) | Phil Clark | Crockett (TX) | Jeff Grey | Santana (CA) | |
| 1986 | First base | DeWain Stevens | Lawrence (KS) | Reggie Jefferson | Leon (FL) | Mike Bell | Newton (NJ) | |
| 1986 | Infield | Patrick Lennon | Whiteville (NC) | Brian Champion | Corvallis (OR) | Harvey Pullman | McAteer (CA) | |
| 1986 | Infield | Anthony Clements | Don Lugo (CA) | Kraig Washington | Diamond Bar (CA) | Darryl Robinson | Whitney Young (IL) | |
| 1986 | Infield | Gary Sheffield*$^G$ | Hillsborough (FL) | Bryan Foster | North Central (IN) | Pat Woods | Central (AL) | |
| 1986 | Utility | Brian Johnson | Skyline (CA) | Reggie Stalzer | Marshalltown (IA) | Darren Hidder | Washington (IA) | |
| 1986 | Outfield | Lee May Jr. | Purcell Marian (OH) | Mike White | Loudon (TN) | Chris Graves | Brenham (TX) | |
| 1986 | Outfield | Greg McMurtry° | Brockton (MA) | Terrence Carr | James Bennett (MD) | Carl Sullivan | Brenham (TX) | |
| 1986 | Outfield | Derrick May | Newark (DE) | William Taylor | Alexander (LA) | Manny Alvarez | George Washington (NY) | |
| 1986 | Outfield | Kevin Dean | Hogan (CA) | Karl Rhodes | Western Hill (OH) | Keith Thomas | Kenwood (IL) | |
| 1986 | Pitcher | Kent Mercer | Dublin (OH) | Mike Moscrey | Thomas Jefferson (TX) | Roger Pavlik* | Aldine (TX) | |
| 1986 | Pitcher | Daryl Green | Nacogdoches (TX) | Jamie McAndrew | Ponderosa (CO) | David Howell | Swampscott (MA) | |
| 1986 | Pitcher | Scott Scudder | Prairiland (TX) | Allen Rath | Highland (IA) | David Howell | Swampscott (MA) | |
| 1987 | Catcher | Mike Urman | Canoga Park (CA) | Bill Henderson | Westminster Christian (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | First base | Matt Franco | Westlake (CA) | Mark Healy | Creighton Prep (NE) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Infield | Jeremy Matthews | Sandalwood (FL) | Travis Fryman* | Tate (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Infield | Tom Redington | Esperanza (CA) | Delino Deshields | Seaford (DE) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Infield | Rick Lantrip | Golden West (CA) | Mike Wall | Norwood (MA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Utility | Brian Bohannon | North Shore (TX) | Chuck Ricci | Shawnee (NJ) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Outfield | Mark Merchant | Oviedo (FL) | Steve Pegues | Pontotoc (MS) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Outfield | Ken Griffey Jr.$^‡$^$^#$ | Moeller (OH) | Dave Zancanaro | Del Campo (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Outfield | Don Carroll | Granite Hills (CA) | Chris Threadgill | Whiteville (NC) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Outfield | Lee Tinsley | Shelbyville (KY) | Mike Seda | Shadow Mountain (AZ) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Pitcher | Willie Banks$^G$ | St. Anthony (NJ) | Brian Knackert | Ocean View (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Pitcher | Chris Myers | H.B. Plant (FL) | Dave Fleming | Mahopac (NY) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1987 | Pitcher | Chris Myers | H.B. Plant (FL) | Dan Wilson* | Barrington (IL) | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 1988 | Catcher | Troy Tallman | Napa (CA) | Tim Hodge | Callaway (MS) | Todd Winston | Marysville (MI) | |
| 1988 | First base | Joe Ciccarella | Mater Dei (CA) | Steve Dunn | Robinson (VA) | Nick Delvecchio | Natick (MA) | |
| 1988 | Second base | Doug Saunders | Esperanza (CA) | Brent Gates | Grandville (MI) | Rob White | Brewer (ME) | |
| 1988 | Third base | Roger Burnett | Broken Arrow (OK) | Scott Craven | Punahou (HI) | Jeff Caldara | Ardsley (NY) | |
| 1988 | Shortstop | Mark Lewis$^G$ | Hamilton (OH) | Bill Parese | Owasso (OK) | Ricky Gutierrez | American (FL) | |
| 1988 | Utility | Lawrence Gilligan | Lakeland Regional (NJ) | Hilly Hathaway | Sandalwood (FL) | Frank Mochak | Chicopee (MA) | |
| 1988 | Designated hitter | Jon Zuber | Campolindo (CA) | Ken Munoz | Suffern (NY) | Brad Cohen | Starkville (MS) | |
| 1988 | Outfield | Wendell Ansley | Plainview (TX) | Rex McMackin | Chatsworth (CA) | Luis Sierra | A.I. duPont (DE) | |
| 1988 | Outfield | Hugh Walker | Jacksonville (AR) | Chris Hart | Harrisonburg (VA) | Troy Bailey | T.C. Williams (VA) | |
| 1988 | Outfield | Derrick Warren | Washington (FL) | Bill Ashley | Belleville (MI) | Bob Scott | Mankato West (MN) | |
| 1988 | Pitcher | Alex Fernandez | Pace (FL) | Ben Howze | Washington (FL) | Jeff Juden | Salem (MA) | |
| 1988 | Pitcher | Steve Avery* | John F. Kennedy (MI) | Arthur Rhodes* | La Vega (TX) | Steve Worrell | Lower Cape May Regional (NJ) | |
| 1988 | Pitcher | Rico Brogna | Watertown (CT) | Scott Davison | Redondo Union (CA) | Doug Bennett | Hillcrest (MO) | |
| 1989 | Catcher | Tyler Houston | Valley (NV) | Charles Johnson | Westwood (FL) | Casey Burrill | Hart (CA) | |
| 1989 | First base | Bo Dodson | Christian Brothers (CA) | Scott Pugh | Abilene (TX) | Brian Sackinsky | South Park (PA) | |
| 1989 | Second base | George Virgilio | Elizabeth (NJ) | Chris Wimmer | Wichita East (KS) | Ted Corbin | Barron Collier (FL) | |
| 1989 | Third base | Rich Aude | Chatsworth (CA) | Calvin Murray | White (TX) | T.R. Lewis | Sandalwood (FL) | |
| 1989 | Shortstop | Scott Bream | Millard South (NE) | Willie Greene | Jones County (GA) | Chris Buzzi | Bethel Park (PA) | |
| 1989 | Utility | Earl Cunningham | Lancaster (SC) | Dan Melendez | St. Bernard (CA) | Doug Mirabelli | Valley (NV) | |
| 1989 | Designated hitter | Brook Fordyce | St. Bernard (CT) | Steve Hegan | South Pontotoc (MS) | Jim Wilke | Portage (IN) | |
| 1989 | Outfield | Greg Blosser | Sarasota (FL) | Bill Lott | Petal (MS) | Jason Robertson | Hillcrest (IL) | |
| 1989 | Outfield | Paul Coleman | Frankston (TX) | Jeff Hammonds* | Scotch Plains-Fanwood (NJ) | Brian Hunter | Fort Vancouver (WA) | |
| 1989 | Outfield | Jeff Jackson$^G$ | Simeon (IL) | Aaron Goins | Owasso (OK) | John Gumpf | Riverside Poly (CA) | |
| 1989 | Pitcher | Kiki Jones | Hillsborough (FL) | Scott Burrell° | Hamden (CT) | Thomas Taylor | Louisa County (VA) | |
| 1989 | Pitcher | Jeff Juden (2) | Salem (MA) | Chris Roberts | Middleburg (FL) | Jason Zimbauer | Andrew (IL) | |
| 1989 | Pitcher | Roger Salkeld | Saugus (CA) | Todd Johnson | Bullard (CA) | Tavo Alvarez | Tucson (AZ) | |

### 1990–1999

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 1990 | Catcher | Mike Lieberthal* | Westlake (CA) | Kevin Aubin | Drury (MN) | Willie Morales | Tucson (AZ) | |
| 1990 | First base | Chris Weinke° | Cretin-Derham Hall (MN) | Marc Newfield | Marina (CA) | Tim Green | Marlboro (NJ) | |
| 1990 | Second base | Bill Dunn | Mount St. Joseph (MD) | James Bonnici | Adams (MI) | Shannon Jones | Aurora Central (CO) | |
| 1990 | Third base | Jason Varitek* | Lake Brantley (FL) | Bob Osborne | Ben Davis (IN) | Tom Caldara | Ardsley (NY) | |
| 1990 | Shortstop | Chipper Jones$^‡$^$^#$ | Bolles (FL) | Tom Nevers | Edina (MN) | Shane Andrews | Carlsbad (NM) | |
| 1990 | Utility | Jeff Motuzas | Nashua (NH) | Mike Vogel | Cretin-Derham Hall (MN) | Creighton Gubanich | Phoenixville (PA) | |
| 1990 | Designated hitter | Mike Patrizi | Pennsauken (NJ) | John Lewallen | Wichita East (KS) | Trent Smith | South Newton (IN) | |
| 1990 | Outfield | Tony Clark* | Christian (CA) | Carl Everett* | Hillsborough (FL) | Greg Thomas | Lake Brantley (FL) | |
| 1990 | Outfield | Jamie Ogden | White Bear Lake (MN) | Vee Hightower | Mt. Lebanon (PA) | Duane Singleton | McKee Voc-Tech (NY) | |
| 1990 | Outfield | Michael Murphy | St. Pius X (NM) | Gary Hurst | Petal (MS) | Steve Money | Midland (MI) | |
| 1990 | Pitcher | Todd Van Poppel$^G$ | Martin (TX) | Mike Schiefelbein | Chatfield (CO) | Steve Karsay | Christ the King (NY) | |
| 1990 | Pitcher | Todd Ritchie | Duncanville (TX) | Ron Walden | Blanchard (OK) | Octavio Alvarez (2) | Tucson (AZ) | |
| 1990 | Pitcher | Aaron Knieper | Nouvel Catholic (MI) | Shawn Senior | Cherry Hill West (NJ) | Jose Prado | Coral Gables (FL) | |
| 1991 | Catcher | Ryan Luzinski | Holy Cross (NJ) | Shawn Curran | Corona (CA) | Eddie Williams | Miami Edison (FL) | |
| 1991 | First base | Cliff Floyd* | Thornwood (IL) | Mark O'Brien | Deering (ME) | Jeff Kiraly | La Cueva (NM) | |
| 1991 | Second base | Tripp MacKay | Mount Pleasant (TX) | Calvin Reese | Lower Richland (SC) | Ramon Diaz | Elizabeth (NJ) | |
| 1991 | Second base | Tripp MacKay | Mount Pleasant (TX) | Matt Mantei | Three Oaks (MI) | Ramon Diaz | Elizabeth (NJ) | |
| 1991 | Third base | Dmitri Young* | Rio Mesa (CA) | Eduardo Ramos | American (FL) | Davis Courter | Corona del Sol (AZ) | |
| 1991 | Shortstop | Dante Powell | Millikan (CA) | J.J. Johnson | Pine Plains (NY) | Alex Gonzalez | Miami Killian (FL) | |
| 1991 | Utility | Ron Hollis | Brighton (MI) | Benji Gil | Castle Park (CA) | Desi Relaford | Sandalwood (FL) | |
| 1991 | Designated hitter | Brandt Mathers | Sarasota (FL) | Nick Williams | Hastings (MI) | Erik Lane | Russelville (AR) | |
| 1991 | Designated hitter | Brandt Mathers | Sarasota (FL) | Maceo Houston | Galileo (CA) | Erik Lane | Russelville (AR) | |
| 1991 | Outfield | Al Shirley | Danville (VA) | Bruce Thompson | Brandon (FL) | John Curl | Logansport (IN) | |
| 1991 | Outfield | Shawn Green* | Tustin (CA) | Paul Ottavinia | Mount Olive (NJ) | McArthur McNabb | Ft. Walton Beach (FL) | |
| 1991 | Outfield | Basil Shabazz | Pine Bluff (AR) | Todd Hollandsworth | Newport (WA) | Vincent Moore | Elsik (TX) | |
| 1991 | Pitcher | Brien Taylor$^#$ | East Cateret (NC) | Justin Thompson* | Klein Oak (TX) | Trever Miller | Trinity (KY) | |
| 1991 | Pitcher | Shawn Estes* | Douglas (NV) | Ryan Kjos | Hopkins (MN) | Rich Gorecki | Oak Forest (IL) | |
| 1991 | Pitcher | Tyrone Hill | Yucaipa (CA) | Brian Barber$^G$ | Dr. Phillips (FL) | Kyle Kennedy | Quitman (MS) | |
| 1992 | Catcher | Jason Kendall* | Torrance (CA) | Andrew Jay Hinch$^G$ | Midwest City (OK) | Ryan Luzinski (2) | Holy Cross (NJ) | |
| 1992 | First base | Brandon Pico | Rogers (RI) | Steve Cox | Monache (CA) | Danny Kanell° | Westminster (FL) | |
| 1992 | First base | Brandon Pico | Rogers (RI) | Steve Cox | Monache (CA) | Craig McClure | Columbine (CO) | |
| 1992 | Second base | Tripp MacKay (2) | Mount Pleasant (TX) | Bobby Lee Coy | Mullen Prep (CO) | Jim Keefe | Spaulding (NH) | |
| 1992 | Third base | Chad Roper | Belton-Honea Path (SC) | Kris Bamberger | Gilbert (AZ) | Mark Pooschke | Madison (OR) | |
| 1992 | Shortstop | Derek Jeter$^‡$ | Kalamazoo Central (MI) | Preston Wilson*$^{BA}$ | Bamberg Ehrhardt (SC) | Yuri Sanchez | Lynn Tech (MA) | |
| 1992 | Utility | Greg Dean | Ada (OK) | Fred Koehne | Wheat Ridge (CO) | John Geis | Paul Moore (NY) | |
| 1992 | Designated hitter | T.R. Marcinczyk | St. Thomas Aquinas (CT) | Tom Knauss | Hersey (IL) | Ryan Minor° | Hammon (OK) | |
| 1992 | Outfield | VaShon Walker | Harrison County (KY) | Shannon Stewart | Miami Southridge (FL) | Shea Morenz | San Angelo Central (TX) | |
| 1992 | Outfield | Johnny Damon* | Dr. Phillips (FL) | Don Furtado | Carson (NV) | Clifford Trey Beamon | W.T. White (TX) | |
| 1992 | Outfield | Ryan Topham | Portage Central (MI) | Dwight Maness | William Penn (DE) | John David Hayman | Jackson (MS) | |
| 1992 | Pitcher | Jamie Arnold | Osceola (FL) | Peter N. Durkovic | Trinity-Pawling (NY) | Rich Ireland | Crater (OR) | |
| 1992 | Pitcher | Dan Serafini | Serra (CA) | Ben White | Salpointe (AZ) | David Spykstra | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 1992 | Pitcher | James Pittsley | DuBois (PA) | Keith Horn | Pine Bluff (AR) | Sean Runyan | Urbandale (IA) | |
| 1993 | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected |
| 1994 | Catcher | Paul Konerko* | Chaparral (AZ) | Corey Pointer | Waxahachie (TX) | Eric Schreimann | Jefferson City (MO) | |
| 1994 | Catcher | Mark Johnson | Warner Robins (GA) | Matt Treanor | Mater Dei (CA) | Damian Sapp | Pleasant Grove (UT) | |
| 1994 | Infield | Matt Smith | Grants Pass (OR) | Eddie Furniss | Nacogdoches (TX) | Andy Thompson | Sun Prairie (WI) | |
| 1994 | Infield | Josh Booty° | Evangel Christian (LA) | Jason Camilli | Thunderbird (AZ) | Mike Peeples | Clay (FL) | |
| 1994 | Infield | Terrence Long* | Stanhope Elmore (AL) | Troy Glaus* | Carlsbad (CA) | Ryan Freel | Englewood (FL) | |
| 1994 | Infield | Kevin Witt | Bishop Kenny (FL) | Bryon Gainey | Davidson (AL) | Sean McGrath | Drury (MA) | |
| 1994 | Outfield | McKay Christensen | Clovis West (CA) | Mike Darr | Corona (CA) | Scott Podsednik* | West (TX) | |
| 1994 | Outfield | Ben Grieve* | Martin (TX) | Tony Terry | Abbeville (SC) | Gordon Amerson | San Gorgonio (CA) | |
| 1994 | Outfield | Norm Hutchins | Lincoln (NY) | Mark Farris | Angleton (TX) | Mike Burrows | American Fork (UT) | |
| 1994 | Outfield | Norm Hutchins | Lincoln (NY) | Mark Farris | Angleton (TX) | Chris Sieger | Hackley (NY) | |
| 1994 | Pitcher | Jayson Peterson | East (CO) | Brian Rose | Dartmouth (MA) | Corey Avrard | Archbishop Rummel (LA) | |
| 1994 | Pitcher | Doug Million$^{GB}$ | Sarasota (FL) | Scott Elarton | Lamar (CO) | Roger Worley | Quartz Hill (CA) | |
| 1994 | Pitcher | Jacob Shumate | Hartsville (SC) | Larry Barnes | Englewood (FL) | Jaret Wright | Katella (CA) | |
| 1994 | Pitcher | Sean Johnston | Highland Park (IL) | Carl Pavano* | Southington (CT) | Jaret Wright | Katella (CA) | |
| 1995 | Catcher | Ben Davis$^B$ | Malvern (PA) | Charles Alley | Palm Beach Lakes (FL) | Ben Petrick | Glencoe (OR) | |
| 1995 | Catcher | Ben Davis$^B$ | Malvern (PA) | Josh Holliday | Stillwater (OK) | Craig Wilson | Marina (CA) | |
| 1995 | Infield | Michael Barrett | Pace (GA) | Jim Scharrer | Cathedral Prep (PA) | Joe Lawrence | Barbe (LA) | |
| 1995 | Infield | Ryan Jaroncyk | Orange Glen (CA) | Jay Hood | Germantown (TN) | Rob Quinlan | Hill-Murray (MN) | |
| 1995 | Infield | Chris Haas | St. Mary (KY) | Jason Woolf | American (FL) | Ken Miller | Providence Catholic (IL) | |
| 1995 | Infield | Chad Hermansen | Green Valley (NV) | Doug Blosser | Sarasota (FL) | Jeff Maloney | Ridge (NJ) | |
| 1995 | Outfield | Nate Rolison | Petal (MS) | Kevin McGlinchy | Malden (MA) | Derek Wallace | Neville (LA) | |
| 1995 | Outfield | Jaime Jones | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Ken James | Sebring (FL) | Jody Gerut | Willowbrook (IL) | |
| 1995 | Outfield | Corey Jenkins° | Dreher (SC) | Darrell Dent | Montclair (CA) | Brad Weber | DeKalb (IN) | |
| 1995 | Outfield | Reggie Taylor | Newberry (SC) | Darrell Dent | Montclair (CA) | Brad Weber | DeKalb (IN) | |
| 1995 | Pitcher | Roy Halladay$^‡$^ | Arvada West (CO) | Rob Bell | Marlboro (NY) | Phil Lowery | Casa Grande (CA) | |
| 1995 | Pitcher | Andy Yount | Kingwood (TX) | Dave Coggin | Upland (CA) | Ryan Mills | Horizon (AZ) | |
| 1995 | Pitcher | Kerry Wood* | Grand Prairie (TX) | Joe Fontenot | Acadiana (LA) | Jeff Yoder | Pottsville Area (PA) | |
| 1995 | Pitcher | Chad Hutchinson$^G$° | Torrey Pines (CA) | Tony McKnight | Arkansas (AR) | Mike Spnielli | Revere (MA) | |
| 1996 | Catcher | Eric Munson | Mt. Carmel (CA) | Josh Glassey | Mission Bay (CA) | Josh McAffee | Farmington (NM) | |
| 1996 | Infield | Joe Lawrence (2) | Barbe (LA) | Jimmy Rollins^ | Encinal (CA) | Nick Johnson | McClatchy (CA) | |
| 1996 | Infield | Brent Abernathy | Lovett (GA) | Damian Rolls | Schlagel (KS) | Grant Sharpe | Watkins (MS) | |
| 1996 | Infield | A.J. Zapp | Center Grove (IN) | Jim Terrell | Tri-City (MO) | Jason Moore | Westminster (FL) | |
| 1996 | Infield | Matt Halloran | Chancellor (VA) | Eric Chavez | Mt. Carmel (CA) | Mike Caruso | Stoneman Douglas (FL) | |
| 1996 | Infield | Brandon Byrd | Trinity Presbyterian (AL) | Eric Chavez | Mt. Carmel (CA) | Mike Caruso | Stoneman Douglas (FL) | |
| 1996 | Outfield | Robert Stratton | San Marcos (CA) | Milton Bradley* | Long Beach Poly (CA) | Darnell McDonald$^{GB}$ | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 1996 | Outfield | John Oliver | Lake-Lehman (PA) | Vernon Maxwell | Midwest City (OK) | Neal McCarthy | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | |
| 1996 | Outfield | Dermal Brown | Marlboro (NY) | Quincy Carter° | Southwest DeKalb (GA) | Cory Thurman | Texas (TX) | |
| 1996 | Outfield | Dermal Brown | Marlboro (NY) | Paul Wilder | Cary (NC) | Cory Thurman | Texas (TX) | |
| 1996 | Pitcher | Bobby Seay | Sarasota (FL) | Sam Marsonek | Jesuit (FL) | Todd Noel | North Vermillion (LA) | |
| 1996 | Pitcher | Matt White$^{GB}$ | Waynesboro (PA) | Jason Marquis* | Tottenville (NY) | Josh Garrett | South Spencer (IN) | |
| 1996 | Pitcher | Adam Eaton | Snohomish (WA) | Gil Meche* | Acadiana (LA) | Jake Westbrook* | Madison County (GA) | |
| 1996 | Pitcher | John Patterson | West Orange-Stark (TX) | Nick Bierbrodt | Millikan (CA) | K.O. Wiegandt | Westminster Christian (FL) | |
| 1997 | Catcher | Jayson Werth* | Glenwood (IL) | Dane Sardinha | Kamehameha (HI) | Will McCrotty | Russellville (AR) | |
| 1997 | Infield | J.J. Davis | Baldwin Park (CA) | Michael Restovich | Mayo (MN) | Chase Utley* | Long Beach Poly (CA) | |
| 1997 | Infield | Troy Cameron | St. Thomas Aquinas (FL) | Aaron Capista | Joliet Catholic (IL) | Ricky Bell | Moeller (OH) | |
| 1997 | Infield | Scott Hodges | Henry Clay (KY) | Jason Romano | Hillsborough (FL) | Keoni DeRenne | Iolani (HI) | |
| 1997 | Infield | Mike Cuddyer* | Great Bridge (VA) | Tom Pittman | East St. John (LA) | Chris Aguila | McQueen (NV) | |
| 1997 | Infield | Jack Cust | Immaculata (NJ) | Tom Pittman | East St. John (LA) | Chris Aguila | McQueen (NV) | |
| 1997 | Outfield | Darnell McDonald$^{GB}$ (2) | Cherry Creek (CO) | Tootie Myers | Petal (MS) | Kenny Kelly | Tampa Catholic (FL) | |
| 1997 | Outfield | Tyrell Goodwin | East Bladen (NC) | Jose Nicolas | Westminster Christian (FL) | Alvin Morrow | Kirkwood (MO) | |
| 1997 | Outfield | Vernon Wells* | Bowie (TX) | Nathan Haynes | Pinole Valley (CA) | Joey Nation | Putnam City (OK) | |
| 1997 | Outfield | Vernon Wells* | Bowie (TX) | Brett Caradonna | El Capitan (CA) | Joey Nation | Putnam City (OK) | |
| 1997 | Pitcher | Geoff Goetz | Jesuit (FL) | Mark Mangum | Kingwood (TX) | Shane Loux | Highland (AZ) | |
| 1997 | Pitcher | Jon Garland* | Kennedy (CA) | Tim Drew | Lowndes County (GA) | Jason Standridge | Hewitt-Trussville (AL) | |
| 1997 | Pitcher | John Curtice | Great Bridge (VA) | Donnie Bridges | Oak Grove (MS) | Sean Douglass | Antelope Valley (CA) | |
| 1997 | Pitcher | Rick Ankiel | Port St. Lucie (FL) | Chris Stowe | Chancellor (VA) | Shane Arthurs | Westmoore (OK) | |
| 1997 | Pitcher | Rick Ankiel | Port St. Lucie (FL) | Chris Stowe | Chancellor (VA) | T.J. Tucker | River Ridge (FL) | |
| 1998 | Catcher | Jeffrey Winchester | Archbishop Rummel (LA) | Todd Pratt | Tooele (UT) | Beau Craig | Grossmont (CA) | |
| 1998 | First base | Austin Kearns | Lafayette (KY) | Josh Pressley | Westminster (FL) | Ben Diggins | Bradshaw (AZ) | |
| 1998 | Infield | Felipe Lopez* | Lake Brantley (FL) | Anthony Torcato | Woodland (CA) | Gregory Porter | Keller (TX) | |
| 1998 | Infield | Sean Burroughs | Wilson (CA) | Drew Henson$^{GB}$° | Brighton (MI) | Kevin Bass | Fayette County (AL) | |
| 1998 | Infield | Josh McKinley | Malvern (PA) | David Kelton | Troup County (GA) | Kevin Kelly | Gloucester Catholic (NJ) | |
| 1998 | Utility | Gerald Laird | La Quinta (CA) | Alex Hart | Chambersburg (PA) | Christopher Jones | South Mecklenburg (NC) | |
| 1998 | Designated hitter | Mark Teixeira* | Mount St. Joseph (MD) | Ryan Langerhans | Round Rock (TX) | Andrew Good | Rochester (MI) | |
| 1998 | Outfield | Corey Patterson | Harrison (GA) | Raphael Freeman | Dallas Christian (TX) | Ben Cordova | Marian Catholic (CA) | |
| 1998 | Outfield | Andrew Brown | Richmond (IN) | Chip Ambres | West Brook (TX) | Jorge Padilla | Florida Air (FL) | |
| 1998 | Outfield | Rick Elder | Sprayberry (GA) | Arturo McDowell | Forest Hill (MS) | Mamon Tucker | S. F. Austin (TX) | |
| 1998 | Pitcher | J.M. Gold | Toms River North (NJ) | Patrick Strange | Springfield (MA) | Matt Belisle | McCallum (TX) | |
| 1998 | Pitcher | C.C. Sabathia^ | Vallejo (CA) | Christopher George | Klein (TX) | Jermaine Van Buren | Hattiesburg (MS) | |
| 1998 | Pitcher | Matt Roney | Edmond North (OK) | Nate Cornejo | Wellington (KS) | Mark Prior* | University (CA) | |
| 1999 | Catcher | Ryan Christianson | Arlington (CA) | Nick Trzesniak | Andrew (IL) | Jay Perez | Seymour (CT) | |
| 1999 | First base | Chris Duncan | Canyon del Oro (AZ) | Brian West | West Monroe (LA) | Brian Cardwell | Sapulpa (OK) | |
| 1999 | Infield | Corey Myers | Desert Vista (AZ) | Brandon Phillips* | Redan (GA) | Brandon Love | Viola (AR) | |
| 1999 | Infield | Josh Wilson | Mt. Lebanon (PA) | Brennan King | Oakland (TN) | Sheldon Fuse | George Jenkins (FL) | |
| 1999 | Infield | Drew Meyer | Bishop England (SC) | Pat Manning | Mater Dei (CA) | Pat Osborn | Bakersfield (CA) | |
| 1999 | Utility | B. J. Garbe$^G$ | Moses Lake (WA) | Jarrod Schmidt | Lassiter (GA) | Cody Ross | Carlsbad (NM) | |
| 1999 | Designated hitter | Neil Jenkins | William Dwyer (FL) | Brad Baker | Pioneer Valley Regional (MA) | Rob Bowen | Homestead (IN) | |
| 1999 | Outfield | Josh Hamilton^$^{#B}$ | Athens Drive (NC) | Alberto Concepcion | El Segundo (CA) | Mike Mallory | Dinwiddie (VA) | |
| 1999 | Outfield | Rick Asadoorian | Northbridge (MA) | Carl Crawford* | Jefferson Davis (TX) | Aron Weston | Solon (OH) | |
| 1999 | Outfield | Vince Faison | Toombs County (GA) | Jason Repko | Hanford (WA) | Jason Cooper | Moses Lake (WA) | |
| 1999 | Pitcher | Josh Beckett* | Spring (TX) | Richard Stahl | Newton (GA) | Ryan Gloger | Jesuit (FL) | |
| 1999 | Pitcher | Josh Girdley | Jasper (TX) | Ty Howington | Hudson's Bay (WA) | Josh Cenate | Jefferson (WV) | |
| 1999 | Pitcher | Bobby Bradley | Wellington (FL) | Jason Stumm | Centralia (WA) | Gerik Baxter | Edmonds Woodway (WA) | |

### 2000–2009

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 2000 | Catcher | Scott Heard | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | First base | Adrian Gonzalez*$^#$ | Eastlake (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Infield | Luis Montanez | Coral Park (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Infield | Corey Smith | Piscataway (NJ) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Infield | David Espinosa | Gulliver (FL) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Utility | Mike Stodolka | Centennial (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Outfield | Shaun Boyd | Vista (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Outfield | Rocco Baldelli | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Outfield | Dave Krynzel | Green Valley (NV) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Pitcher | Joseph Durbin | Coronado (AZ) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Pitcher | Matt Wheatland | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Pitcher | Mark Phillips | Hanover (PA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2000 | Pitcher | Matt Harrington$^B$ | Palmdale (CA) | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | No team selected | |
| 2001 | Catcher | Joe Mauer$^{‡^#B}$ | Cretin-Derham Hall (MN) | Jeff Mathis | Marianna (FL) | Jon Zeringue | E. D. White (LA) | |
| 2001 | First base | Casey Kotchman$^G$ | Seminole (FL) | Brad Nelson | Bishop Garrigan (IA) | Chamar McDonald | Madison Central (MS) | |
| 2001 | Infield | Dave Wright* | Hickory (VA) | B.J. Upton | Greenbrier Christian (VA) | Matt Ferrara | Westminster (FL) | |
| 2001 | Infield | Josh Burrus | Wheeler (GA) | Mike Garciaparra | Don Bosco (CA) | Joe Mather | Mountain Point (AZ) | |
| 2001 | Infield | Josh Burrus | Wheeler (GA) | Jayson Nix | Midland (TX) | Corey Ragsdale | Nettleton (AR) | |
| 2001 | Utility | John Killalea | Seminole (FL) | J.J. Hardy* | Sabino (AZ) | Jeff Hourigan | Masuk (CT) | |
| 2001 | Outfield | Mike Conroy | Boston College (MA) | Alhaji Turay | Auburn (WA) | Jay Mattox | Conway (AR) | |
| 2001 | Outfield | Roscoe Crosby° | Union (SC) | Alan Moye | Pine Tree (TX) | Bill Paganetti | Galena (NV) | |
| 2001 | Outfield | Mike Wilson | Washington (OK) | Chris Resop | Barron Collier (FL) | Jeff Francoeur | Parkview (GA) | |
| 2001 | Pitcher | Mike Jones | Thunderbird (AZ) | Andy Sisco | Eastlake (WA) | Dan Denham | Deer Valley (CA) | |
| 2001 | Pitcher | Gavin Floyd | Mount St. Joseph (MD) | Macay McBride | Screven County (GA) | J. P. Howell | Jesuit (CA) | |
| 2001 | Pitcher | Colt Griffin | Marshall (TX) | Alan Horne | Marianna (FL) | Garrett Berger | Carmel (IN) | |
| 2001 | Pitcher | Jeremy Sowers | Ballard (KY) | Jeremy Bonderman | Pasco (WA) | Scott Tyler | Downington (PA) | |
| 2002 | Catcher | Adam Donachie | Timber Creek (FL) | Justin Sullivan | Yukon (OK) | Mike Nixon | Sunnyslope (AZ) | |
| 2002 | First base | Prince Fielder* | Eau Gallie (FL) | James Loney | Elkins (TX) | John Fitzpatrick | Iona Prep (NY) | |
| 2002 | Infield | Scott Moore | Cypress (CA) | Sergio Santos | Mater Dei (CA) | Brett McMillan | Ponderosa (CA) | |
| 2002 | Infield | Micah Schilling | Silliman (LA) | Matt Whitney | Palm Beach Gardens (FL) | Brandon Weeden° | Edmond Santa Fe (OK) | |
| 2002 | Infield | B.J. Upton (2) | Greenbrier Christian (VA) | Josh Murray | Jesuit (FL) | Robert Andino | Miami Southridge (FL) | |
| 2002 | Designated hitter | Corey Shafer | Choctaw (OK) | Micah Owings | Gainesville (GA) | Dan Haigwood | Midland (AR) | |
| 2002 | Outfield | Jeff Francoeur (2) | Parkview (GA) | Mike Megrew | Chariho (RI) | Joe Hunter | Germantown (TN) | |
| 2002 | Outfield | Jason Pridie | Prescott (AZ) | Keiunta Span | Tampa Catholic (FL) | Jarrad Page° | San Leandro (CA) | |
| 2002 | Outfield | Jeremy Hermida | Wheeler (GA) | Brent Clevlen | Westwood (TX) | John Mayberry | Rockhurst (MO) | |
| 2002 | Pitcher | Clint Everts | Cypress Falls (TX) | Zack Greinke^$^{GB}$ | Apopka (FL) | Greg Miller | Esparanza (CA) | |
| 2002 | Pitcher | Chris Gruler | Liberty (CA) | Zach Segovia | Forney (TX) | Blair Johnson | Washburn (KS) | |
| 2002 | Pitcher | Jason Neighborgall | Riverside (NC) | Matt Cain* | Houston (TN) | Zach Hammes | Iowa City (IA) | |
| 2002 | Pitcher | Scott Kazmir* | Cypress Falls (TX) | Cole Hamels* | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Jon Lester* | Bellarmine Prep (WA) | |
| 2003 | Catcher | Daric Barton | Marina (CA) | Jarrod Saltalamacchia | Royal Palm Beach (FL) | C.J. Bressoud | North Cobb (GA) | |
| 2003 | Infield | Matt Moses | Mills Goodwin (VA) | Josh Darby | Marist (GA) | Charles Tiffany | Charter Oak (CA) | |
| 2003 | Infield | Eric Duncan | Seton Hall Prep (NJ) | Jonathan Fulton | George Washington (VA) | Alex Vitale | Severna Park (MD) | |
| 2003 | Infield | Ian Stewart | La Quinta (CA) | Sean Rodriguez | Braddock (FL) | Jeffrey Flaig | El Dorado (CA) | |
| 2003 | Infield | Brandon Wood | Horizon (AZ) | Adam Jones* | Morse (CA) | Robert Valido | Coral Park (FL) | |
| 2003 | Utility | James Houser | Sarasota (FL) | Kyle Waldrop | Farragut (TN) | Chad Barben | Taylorsville (UT) | |
| 2003 | Designated hitter | Ryan Harvey | Dunedin (FL) | Drew Stubbs | Atlanta (TX) | Tanner Rogers | Columbine (CO) | |
| 2003 | Outfield | Delmon Young$^#$ | Camarillo (CA) | Ryan Sweeney | Xavier (IA) | Xavier Paul | Slidell (LA) | |
| 2003 | Outfield | Chris Lubanski$^G$ | Kennedy-Kenrick (PA) | Estee Harris | Central Islip (NY) | Matt Kemp* | Midwest City (OK) | |
| 2003 | Outfield | Lastings Milledge | Lakewood Ranch (FL) | Michael Hall | Walton (GA) | Jordan Parraz | Green Valley (NV) | |
| 2003 | Pitcher | John Danks | Round Rock (TX) | Chad Billingsley* | Defiance (OH) | Jay Sborz | Langley (VA) | |
| 2003 | Pitcher | Jeff Allison$^B$ | Veterans Memorial (MA) | Adam Miller | McKinney (TX) | Anthony Whittington | Buffalo (WV) | |
| 2003 | Pitcher | Craig Whitaker | Lufkin (TX) | Andrew Miller* | Buchholz (FL) | Joe Reyes | Riverside Poly (CA) | |
| 2004 | Catcher | Neil Walker | Pine-Richland (PA) | Angel Salome | George Washington (NY) | Alex Garabedian | Columbus (FL) | |
| 2004 | Infield | Matt Bush$^#$ | Mission Bay (CA) | Eric Campbell | Gibson Southern (IN) | Matt Tuiasosopo | Woodinville (WA) | |
| 2004 | Infield | Chris Nelson | Redan (GA) | Justin Upton*$^{#GB}$ | Great Bridge (VA) | Ric Bishop | Columbus (GA) | |
| 2004 | Infield | Bill Butler* | Wolfson (FL) | Steve Marquardt | Kennewick (WA) | Ed Prasch | Milton (GA) | |
| 2004 | Infield | Blake DeWitt | Sikeston (MO) | Josh Horton | Orange (NC) | Yovani Gallardo* | Trimble (TX) | |
| 2004 | Utility | Trevor Plouffe | Crespi (CA) | Jay Rainville | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | James Parr | La Cueva (NM) | |
| 2004 | Designated hitter | Charles Creswell | Perryton (TX) | Jon Poterson | Chandler (AZ) | Billy Killian | Chippewa Hills (MI) | |
| 2004 | Outfield | Greg Golson | Connally (TX) | Dexter Fowler* | Milton (GA) | Patrick White° | Daphne (AL) | |
| 2004 | Outfield | Kyle Waldrop (2) | Farragut (TN) | Warren McFadden | Nova (FL) | Reid Brignac | St. Amant (LA) | |
| 2004 | Outfield | K. C. Herren | Auburn (WA) | Greg Burns | Walnut (CA) | Chuck Lofgren | Serra (CA) | |
| 2004 | Pitcher | Mark Rogers$^G$ | Mt. Ararat (ME) | Scott Elbert | Seneca (MO) | Troy Patton | Tomball (TX) | |
| 2004 | Pitcher | Homer Bailey$^B$ | La Grange (TX) | Phil Hughes* | Foothill (CA) | Erik Cordier | Southern Door (WI) | |
| 2004 | Pitcher | Eric Hurley | Wolfson (FL) | Nick Adenhart | Williamsport (MD) | Anthony Swarzak | Nova (FL) | |
| 2005 | Catcher | Brandon Snyder | Westfield (VA) | Preston Paramore | Allen (TX) | Jonathan Egan | Cross Creek (GA) | |
| 2005 | Infield | Justin Upton*$^{#GB}$ (2) | Great Bridge (VA) | Paul Kelly | Flower Mound (TX) | Justin Bristow | Mills Goodwin (VA) | |
| 2005 | Infield | C. J. Henry | Putnam City (OK) | Ryan Mount | Ayala (CA) | Reese Havens | Bishop England (SC) | |
| 2005 | Infield | Henry Sanchez | Mission Bay (CA) | John Whittleman | Kingwood (TX) | Justin Smoak* | Stratford (SC) | |
| 2005 | Infield | Jeff Bianchi | Lampeter-Strasburg (PA) | Drew Thompson | Jupiter (FL) | Justin Smoak* | Stratford (SC) | |
| 2005 | Utility | Chaz Roe | Lafayette (KY) | Iain Sebastian | Columbus (FL) | Trevor Bell | Crescenta Valley (CA) | |
| 2005 | Utility | Chaz Roe | Lafayette (KY) | Iain Sebastian | Columbus (FL) | Buster Posey^ | Lee County (GA) | |
| 2005 | Designated hitter | Colby Rasmus | Russell County (AL) | Isaac Davis | Chaparral (AZ) | Zach Putnam | Pioneer (MI) | |
| 2005 | Outfield | Cameron Maybin | T. C. Roberson (NC) | John Drennen | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Carlos Del Rosorio | George Washington (NY) | |
| 2005 | Outfield | Andrew McCutchen^ | Fort Meade (FL) | Reid Engel | Lewis-Palmer (CO) | Jordan Schafer | Winter Haven (FL) | |
| 2005 | Outfield | Jay Bruce* | Westbrook (TX) | Scott Van Slyke | Burroughs (MO) | Daryl Jones | Spring (TX) | |
| 2005 | Pitcher | Chris Volstad | Palm Beach Gardens (FL) | Ryan Tucker | Temple City (TX) | Beau Jones | Destrehan (LA) | |
| 2005 | Pitcher | Mark Pawelek | Springville (UT) | Tyler Herron | Wellington (FL) | Bryan Morris | Tullahoma (TN) | |
| 2005 | Pitcher | Aaron Thompson | Second Baptist (TX) | Michael Bowden | Waubonsie (IL) | Sean West | Captain Shreve (LA) | |
| 2006 | Catcher | Max Sapp | Bishop Moore (FL) | Hank Conger | Huntington Beach (CA) | Ryan Smith | Westlake (CA) | |
| 2006 | First base | Matt Sweeney | Magruder (MD) | Aaron Senne | Mayo (MN) | Brett Davis | Clackamas (OR) | |
| 2006 | Infield | Bill Rowell | Bishop Eustace (NJ) | Tyler Henson | Tuttle (OK) | Brett Sowers | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 2006 | Infield | Adrian Cardenas$^B$ | Monsignor Pace (FL) | Thomas Pham | Durango (NV) | Brent Brewer | Sandy Creek (GA) | |
| 2006 | Infield | Chris Marrero | Monsignor Pace (FL) | Marcus Lemon | Eustis (FL) | Zack Murry | Chanute (KS) | |
| 2006 | Utility | Daniel Stegall | Greenwood (AR) | Joey Mahalic | Wilson (OR) | Matt Packer | Christian Brothers (TN) | |
| 2006 | Utility | Daniel Stegall | Greenwood (AR) | Joey Mahalic | Wilson (OR) | Tyler Hibbs | Arundel (MD) | |
| 2006 | Designated hitter | Matt Sulentic | Hillcrest (TX) | Jake Locker° | Ferndale (WA) | Tyler Townsend | Cape Henlopen (DE) | |
| 2006 | Designated hitter | Matt Sulentic | Hillcrest (TX) | Jake Locker° | Ferndale (WA) | Will Musson | Wethersfield (CT) | |
| 2006 | Outfield | Travis Snider | Jackson (WA) | Cedric Hunter | King (GA) | Jason Place | Wren (SC) | |
| 2006 | Outfield | Kyler Burke | Ooltewah (TN) | Russell Moldenhauer | Boerne (TX) | Chris Parmelee | Chino Hills (CA) | |
| 2006 | Outfield | Cody Johnson | Mosley (FL) | Justin Reed | Hillcrest Christian (MS) | Mikal Garbarino | San Dimas (CA) | |
| 2006 | Outfield | Cody Johnson | Mosley (FL) | Justin Reed | Hillcrest Christian (MS) | Ronnie Welty | Mesquite (AZ) | |
| 2006 | Pitcher | Clayton Kershaw^$^G$ | Highland Park (TX) | Jeff Locke* | Kennett (NH) | Glen Witkowski | Flanagan (FL) | |
| 2006 | Pitcher | Kyle Drabek | The Woodlands (TX) | Alex White | Conley (NC) | Greg Peavey | Hudson's Bay (WA) | |
| 2006 | Pitcher | Brett Anderson | Stillwater (OK) | Bradley Boxberger* | Foothill (CA) | Cameron Nobles | Jackson (WA) | |
| 2006 | Pitcher | Brett Anderson | Stillwater (OK) | Bradley Boxberger* | Foothill (CA) | Anthony Butler | Oak Creek (WI) | |
| 2007 | Catcher | Devin Mesoraco* | Punxsutawney (PA) | Yasmani Grandal* | Miami Springs (FL) | Rafael Neda | Amphitheater (AZ) | |
| 2007 | Catcher | Devin Mesoraco* | Punxsutawney (PA) | Yasmani Grandal* | Miami Springs (FL) | Travis D'Arnaud | Lakewood (CA) | |
| 2007 | First base | Josh Garcia | Brophy Prep (AZ) | Iden Nazario | Miami Southridge (FL) | Freddie Freeman^ | El Modena (CA) | |
| 2007 | Second base | No player selected | No player selected | Andy Burns | Rocky Mountain (CO) | Tyler Hibbs (2) | Arundel (MD) | |
| 2007 | Third base | No player selected | No player selected | Kevin Ahrens | Memorial (TX) | Riccio Torrez | Brophy Prep (AZ) | |
| 2007 | Shortstop | No player selected | No player selected | No player selected | No player selected | Justin Jackson | T. C. Roberson (NC) | |
| 2007 | Infield | Josh Vitters | Cypress (CA) | Jon Gilmore | Iowa City (IA) | John Tolisano | Estero (FL) | |
| 2007 | Infield | Mike Moustakas*$^B$ | Chatsworth (CA) | Matt Dominguez | Chatsworth (CA) | John Tolisano | Estero (FL) | |
| 2007 | Infield | Peter Kozma | Owasso (OK) | Matt Dominguez | Chatsworth (CA) | John Tolisano | Estero (FL) | |
| 2007 | Designated hitter | Nick Noonan | Parker (CA) | Brett Oberholtzer | William Penn (DE) | Blake Forsythe | Christian Brothers (TN) | |
| 2007 | Outfield | Jason Heyward* | Henry County (GA) | Steve Blum | West Salem (OR) | Bobby Coyle | Chatsworth (CA) | |
| 2007 | Outfield | Ben Revere | Lexington Catholic (KY) | L.J. Hoes | St. John's (DC) | Mike Stanton^ | Notre Dame (CA) | |
| 2007 | Outfield | Wendell Fairley | George County (MS) | Matt Newman | Brophy Prep (AZ) | Kentrail Davis | Theodore (AL) | |
| 2007 | Pitcher | Rick Porcello^$^G$ | Seton Hall Prep (NJ) | Michael Main | DeLand (FL) | Jack McGeary | Roxbury Latin (MA) | |
| 2007 | Pitcher | Jarrod Parker | Norwell (IN) | Josh Smoker | Calhoun (GA) | Michael Watt | Capistrano Valley (CA) | |
| 2007 | Pitcher | Blake Beavan | Irving (TX) | Matt Harvey* | Fitch (CT) | Kyle Blair | Los Gatos (CA) | |
| 2007 | Pitcher | Tim Alderson | Horizon (AZ) | Chris Withrow | Midland Christian (TX) | Josh Osich | Bishop Kelly (ID) | |
| 2007 | Pitcher | Tim Alderson | Horizon (AZ) | Chris Withrow | Midland Christian (TX) | Madison Bumgarner* | South Caldwell (NC) | |
| 2008 | Catcher | Kyle Skipworth$^G$ | Patriot (CA) | Jean Carlos Rodriguez | George Washington (NY) | Anthony Angulo | Miami Southridge (FL) | |
| 2008 | First base | Eric Hosmer* | American Heritage (FL) | Clark Murphy | Fallbrook Union (FL) | Austin Stadler | James River (VA) | |
| 2008 | Infield | Timothy Beckham$^#$ | Griffin (GA) | Rolando Gomez | Flanagan (FL) | Matt Jensen | Clovis East (CA) | |
| 2008 | Infield | Derrik Gibson | Seaford (DE) | Matt Cerda | Oceanside (CA) | Tyler Hanover | North Davidson (NC) | |
| 2008 | Infield | Anthony Hewitt | Salisbury (CT) | Cam Schiller | Prescott (AZ) | Steve Proscia | Don Bosco Prep (NJ) | |
| 2008 | Utility | Jaff Decker | Sunrise Mountain (AZ) | Tyler Chatwood | Redlands East Valley (CA) | Ryan Westmoreland | Portsmouth (RI) | |
| 2008 | Designated hitter | Christopher Smith | Centennial (CA) | Jay Austin | North Atlanta (GA) | Bo Bigham | Arkansas (AR) | |
| 2008 | Designated hitter | Christopher Smith | Centennial (CA) | Jay Austin | North Atlanta (GA) | Joey DeMichele | Arcadia (AZ) | |
| 2008 | Outfield | Aaron Hicks | Wilson (CA) | L.J. Hoes (2) | St. John's (DC) | Herbie Romero | Santa Fe (NM) | |
| 2008 | Outfield | Zach Collier | Chino Hills (CA) | John Ruettinger | Joliet Catholic (IL) | Mike Planeta | Willow Canyon (AZ) | |
| 2008 | Outfield | Xavier Avery | Cedar Grove (GA) | Anthony Gose | Bellflower (CA) | Robert Grossman | Cypress-Fairbanks (TX) | |
| 2008 | Outfield | Xavier Avery | Cedar Grove (GA) | Anthony Gose | Bellflower (CA) | Michael Blake | Heritage (WA) | |
| 2008 | Pitcher | Ethan Martin$^B$ | Stephens County (GA) | Brett DeVall | Niceville (FL) | Mike Montgomery | William S. Hart (CA) | |
| 2008 | Pitcher | Gerrit Cole^$^#$ | Orange Lutheran (CA) | Tyler Stovall | Hokes Bluff (AL) | B.J. Hermsen | West Delaware (IA) | |
| 2008 | Pitcher | Jake Odorizzi* | Highland (IL) | Dan Hultzen | St. Albans (DC) | Danny Coulombe | Chaparral (AZ) | |
| 2009 | Catcher | Max Stassi | Yuba City (CA) | Luke Maile | Covington Catholic (KY) | William Myers* | Wesleyan Christian (NC) |
| 2009 | Catcher | Max Stassi | Yuba City (CA) | Luke Maile | Covington Catholic (KY) | Chad Fortenberry | Northshore (LA) | |
| 2009 | First base | Jeff Malm | Trinity (KY) | Giancarlo Brugnoni | De La Salle (MI) | Daniel Canela | Florida Christian (FL) | |
| 2009 | Infield | Stephen Bruno | Gloucester Catholic (NJ) | John Wooten | Eastern Wayne (NC) | Matt Davidson | Yucaipa (CA) | |
| 2009 | Infield | Bobby Borchering | Bishop Verot (FL) | Taylor Lindsey | Desert Mt. (AZ) | Jiovanni Mier | Bonita (CA) | |
| 2009 | Infield | Daniel Fields | University of Detroit Jesuit (MI) | Nolan Arenado* | El Toro (CA) | Billy Hamilton | Taylorsville (MS) | |
| 2009 | Infield | Daniel Fields | University of Detroit Jesuit (MI) | Nolan Arenado* | El Toro (CA) | Ryan Brett | Highline (WA) | |
| 2009 | Utility | Matt Hobgood$^G$ | Norco (CA) | Jake Barrett | Desert Ridge (AZ) | Nolan Gaige | Columbia (NY) | |
| 2009 | Designated hitter | Kris Hobson | Stockdale (CA) | Mike Schaaf | Arthur Hill (MI) | Jack Carey | St. Paul's (MD) | |
| 2009 | Outfield | Michael Trout^ | Millville (NJ) | Slade Heathcott | Texas (TX) | Marquise Cooper | Edison (CA) | |
| 2009 | Outfield | Donavan Tate | Cartersville (GA) | Max Walla | Albuquerque (NM) | Jacob Marisnick | Riverside Poly (CA) | |
| 2009 | Outfield | Randal Grichuk | Lamar (TX) | Jake Stewart | Rocky Mt. (CO) | Everett Williams | McCallum (TX) | |
| 2009 | Pitcher | Tyler Matzek | Capistrano Valley (CA) | Shelby Miller* | Brownwood (TX) | Steven Matz | Ward Melville (NY) | |
| 2009 | Pitcher | DJ Baxendale | Sylvan Hills (AR) | Jacob Turner | Westminster Christian (MO) | Garrett Gould | Maize (KS) | |
| 2009 | Pitcher | Zach Wheeler* | East Paulding (GA) | Patrick Schuster | Mitchell (FL) | Chad James | Yukon (OK) | |

### 2010–2014

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 2010 | Catcher | Greg Bird | Grandview (CO) | Ethan Bennett | Farragut (TN) | Matt Roberts | Graham (NC) | |
| 2010 | Catcher | Greg Bird | Grandview (CO) | Ethan Bennett | Farragut (TN) | Jake Rodriguez | Elk Grove (CA) | |
| 2010 | First base | Cole Gleason | Red Mountain (AZ) | Patrick Gallagher | Reno (NV) | Yordi Cabrera | Lakeland (FL) | |
| 2010 | Infield | Chris Culver | Irondequoit (NY) | Nicky Delmonico | Farragut (TN) | Sean Coyle | Germantown (TN) | |
| 2010 | Infield | Manny Machado* | Brito (FL) | Tyler Coughenor | Wichita Collegiate (KS) | Bobby Juan | LaCrosse (WI) | |
| 2010 | Infield | Delino Deshields Jr. | Woodward (GA) | Ryan Brett (2) | Highline (WA) | Angelo Gumbs | Torrance (CA) | |
| 2010 | Infield | Delino Deshields Jr. | Woodward (GA) | Ryan Brett (2) | Highline (WA) | Mike Antonio | George Washington (NY) | |
| 2010 | Utility | Kaleb Cowart$^{GB}$ | Cook (GA) | James Bradley | Nitro (WV) | Cody Buckel | Royal (CA) | |
| 2010 | Designated hitter | Jacob Realmuto* | Carl Albert (OK) | Brett Bass | Millard West (NE) | Kris Bryant^ | Bonanza (NV) | |
| 2010 | Designated hitter | Jacob Realmuto* | Carl Albert (OK) | Brett Bass | Millard West (NE) | Kevin Cron | Mountain Pointe (AZ) | |
| 2010 | Outfield | Josh Sale | Bishop Blanchet (WA) | Michael O'Neil | Olentangy Liberty (OH) | Ty Linton | Charlotte Christian (NC) | |
| 2010 | Outfield | Austin Wilson | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Aaron Shipman | Brooks County (GA) | Cory Hahn | Mater Dei (CA) | |
| 2010 | Outfield | Drew Vettleson | Central Kitsap (WA) | Chuckie Jones | Boonville (MO) | Brian Bolden | Madison Central (MS) | |
| 2010 | Pitcher | Jameson Taillon | The Woodlands (TX) | Stetson Allie | St. Edward (OH) | Mike Foltynewicz* | Minooka (IL) | |
| 2010 | Pitcher | Philip Pfeifer | Farragut (TN) | Zach Lee | McKinney (TX) | Dylan Covey | Maranatha (CA) | |
| 2010 | Pitcher | Kyle Crockett | Poquoson (VA) | Logan Ehlers | Nebraska City (NE) | Jesse Biddle | Germantown (PA) | |
| 2010 | Pitcher | Kyle Crockett | Poquoson (VA) | Logan Ehlers | Nebraska City (NE) | Adam Duke | Spanish Fork (UT) | |
| 2011 | Catcher | Christin Stewart | Providence Christian (GA) | Blake Swihart | Cleveland (NM) | Wayne Taylor | Memorial (TX) | |
| 2011 | First base | Daniel Vogelbach* | Bishop Verot (FL) | Trevor Mitsui | Shorewood (WA) | Jacob Anderson | Chino Hills (CA) | |
| 2011 | Infield | Jake Hager | Sierra Vista (NV) | Nick Johnson | Blue Ridge (AZ) | Travis Harrison | Tustin (CA) | |
| 2011 | Infield | Francisco Lindor* | Montverde (FL) | Alex Bregman* | Albuquerque (NM) | Branden Cogswell | Shenendehowa (NY) | |
| 2011 | Infield | Javier Baez* | Arlington Country (FL) | Joe Serrano | Salpointe (AZ) | Sam Travis | Providence Catholic (IL) | |
| 2011 | Infield | Javier Baez* | Arlington Country (FL) | Joe Serrano | Salpointe (AZ) | Trevor Story* | Irving (TX) | |
| 2011 | Utility | Hudson Boyd | Bishop Verot (FL) | Kevin Cron (2) | Mountain Pointe (AZ) | Zach Fish | Gull Lake (MI) | |
| 2011 | Utility | Hudson Boyd | Bishop Verot (FL) | Kevin Cron (2) | Mountain Pointe (AZ) | Jose Trevino | St. John Paul II (TX) | |
| 2011 | Designated hitter | Joey Gallo* | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Dante Bichette | Orangewood Christian (FL) | Bryce Greager | Fountain Hills (AZ) | |
| 2011 | Designated hitter | Joey Gallo* | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Dante Bichette | Orangewood Christian (FL) | Matt Bosse | Calvert Hall (MD) | |
| 2011 | Outfield | Josh Bell* | Jesuit College Prep (TX) | C.J. McElroy | Clear Creek (TX) | Jake Cave | Kecoughtan (VA) | |
| 2011 | Outfield | Larry Greene | Berrien County (GA) | Bubba Starling | Gardner Edgerton (KS) | Charlie Tilson | New Trier (IL) | |
| 2011 | Outfield | Williams Jerez | Grand Street (NY) | Kayden Porter | Spanish Fork (UT) | Cole Gleason (2) | Red Mountain (AZ) | |
| 2011 | Outfield | Williams Jerez | Grand Street (NY) | Kayden Porter | Spanish Fork (UT) | Granden Goetzman | Palmetto (FL) | |
| 2011 | Pitcher | José Fernández* | Alonso (FL) | Tyler Beede | Lawrence Academy (MA) | Jordan Cote | Winnisquam (NH) | |
| 2011 | Pitcher | Archie Bradley | Broken Arrow (OK) | Henry Owens | Edison (CA) | Sebastian Kessay | Blue Ridge (AZ) | |
| 2011 | Pitcher | Dylan Bundy$^{GB}$ | Owasso (OK) | Robert Stephenson | Alhambra (CA) | Blake Snell^ | Shorewood (WA) | |
| 2011 | Pitcher | Dylan Bundy$^{GB}$ | Owasso (OK) | Robert Stephenson | Alhambra (CA) | Cy Sneed | Twin Falls (ID) | |
| 2012 | Catcher | Brent Williams | Liberty (CO) | Stryker Trahan | Acadiana (LA) | Korey Dunbar | Nitro (WV) | |
| 2012 | First base | Matt Olson* | Parkview (GA) | Evan Walter | Thomas Jefferson (CO) | Jake Thompson | Rockwall-Heath (TX) | |
| 2012 | Infield | Corey Seager* | Northwest Cabarrus (NC) | Gavin Cecchini | Barbe (LA) | Austin Simcox | Farragut (TN) | |
| 2012 | Infield | Joey Gallo* (2) | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Austin Andrews | Wilson (OR) | Josh Advocate | River Valley (AZ) | |
| 2012 | Infield | Dan Robertson | Upland (CA) | Xavier Turner | Sandusky (OH) | Addison Russell* | Pace (FL) | |
| 2012 | Utility | Courtney Hawkins | Carroll (TX) | Adamy Schaly | Ashland (OH) | Nate Griep | Millard West (NE) | |
| 2012 | Utility | Courtney Hawkins | Carroll (TX) | Adamy Schaly | Ashland (OH) | Josh Sborz | McLean (VA) | |
| 2012 | Designated hitter | Taylor Hawkins | Carl Albert (OK) | Jamie Westbrook | Basha (AZ) | Luke Lowry | Cosby (VA) | |
| 2012 | Outfield | Byron Buxton$^B$ | Appling County (GA) | Chris Beall | Brophy Prep (AZ) | D'Vone McClure | Jacksonville (AR) | |
| 2012 | Outfield | Albert Almora | Mater (FL) | Dylan Cozens | Chaparral (AZ) | B.J. Boyd | Palo Alto (CA) | |
| 2012 | Outfield | Tate Matheny | Westminster Christian (MO) | David Dahl* | Oak Mountain (AZ) | Shilo McCall | Piedra Vista (NM) | |
| 2012 | Pitcher | Lance McCullers Jr.*$^G$ | Jesuit (FL) | Paul Blackburn | Heritage (CA) | Luke Eubank | Newbury Park (CA) | |
| 2012 | Pitcher | Collin Wiles | Blue Valley West (KS) | Brady Bramlett | Arlington (CA) | Kyle Funkhouser | Oak Forest (IL) | |
| 2012 | Pitcher | Trey Killian | Mountain Home (AR) | Robert Kaminsky | Saint Joseph Regional (NJ) | Kevin Hamann | Summit (OR) | |
| 2013 | Catcher | Tanner Murphy | Malden (MO) | Reese McGuire | Kentwood (WA) | Jonah Heim | Amherst Central (NY) | |
| 2013 | Catcher | Tanner Murphy | Malden (MO) | Reese McGuire | Kentwood (WA) | Nick Ciuffo | Lexington (SC) | |
| 2013 | First base | Dominic Smith | Serra (CA) | Drew Bridges | Carthage (MO) | Carmen Benedetti | Grosse Pointe North (MI) | |
| 2013 | Infield | Christian Arroyo | Hernando (FL) | Ryder Jones | Watauga (NC) | Ryan McMahon* | Mater Dei (CA) | |
| 2013 | Infield | Travis Demeritte | Winder-Barrow (GA) | Riley Unroe | Desert Ridge (AZ) | Drew Ward | Leedey (OK) | |
| 2013 | Infield | J. P. Crawford | Lakewood (CA) | Dustin Peterson | Gilbert (AZ) | Ronnie Dawson | Licking Heights (OH) | |
| 2013 | Outfield | Clint Frazier$^{GB}$ | Loganville (GA) | Ivan Wilson | Ruston (LA) | Thomas Milone | Masuk (CT) | |
| 2013 | Outfield | Austin Meadows* | Grayson (GA) | Silento Sayles | Port Gibson (MS) | Jackson Lamb | Bedford (MI) | |
| 2013 | Outfield | Andrew Benintendi | Madeira (OH) | Ryan Tellez | Elk Grove (CA) | Jordan Paroubeck | Serra (CA) | |
| 2013 | Outfield | Andrew Benintendi | Madeira (OH) | Ryan Tellez | Elk Grove (CA) | Matt McPhearson | Riverdale Baptist (MD) | |
| 2013 | Pitcher | Robert Kaminsky (2) | Saint Joseph Regional (NJ) | Mark Armstrong | Clarence (NY) | Devin Williams* | Hazelwood West (MO) | |
| 2013 | Pitcher | Phil Bickford | Oaks Christian (CA) | Kohl Stewart | St. Pius X (TX) | Ryan Burnett | The Woodlands (TX) | |
| 2013 | Pitcher | Jack Flaherty | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Ian Clarkin | Madison (CA) | Akeem Bostick | West Florence (SC) | |
| 2013 | Pitcher | Jack Flaherty | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Ian Clarkin | Madison (CA) | Keegan Thompson | Cullman (AL) | |
| 2013 | Pitcher | Jack Flaherty | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Ian Clarkin | Madison (CA) | Zach Farmer | Piketon (OH) | |
| 2013 | Utility | Tyler Danish | Durant (FL) | Will Crowe | Pigeon Forge (TN) | Griffin Jax | Cherry Creek (CO) | |
| 2013 | Utility | Tyler Danish | Durant (FL) | Carlos Salazar | Kerman (CA) | Kacy Clemens | Memorial (TX) | |
| 2013 | Designated hitter | Jonathan Denney | Yukon (OK) | Calvin Munson° | Francis Howell (MO) | Jake Hand | ThunderRidge (CO) | |
| 2013 | Designated hitter | Jonathan Denney | Yukon (OK) | Calvin Munson° | Francis Howell (MO) | Kevin Franklin | Gahr (CA) | |
| 2014 | Catcher | Chase Vallot | St. Thomas More (LA) | Alex Jackson$^B$ | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Nick Fortes | DeLand (FL) | |
| 2014 | Catcher | Chase Vallot | St. Thomas More (LA) | Alex Jackson$^B$ | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Jakson Reetz | Norris (NE) | |
| 2014 | First base | Michael Chavis | Sprayberry (GA) | Gavin LaValley | Carl Albert (OK) | T.J. Collett | Terre Haute North (IN) | |
| 2014 | Infield | Nick Gordon | Olympia (FL) | J. J. Matijevic | Norwin (PA) | Justin Yurchak | Shenendehowa (NY) | |
| 2014 | Infield | Trevor Ezell | Bryant (AR) | Jacob Gatewood | Clovis (CA) | Isan Diaz | Springfield Central (MA) | |
| 2014 | Infield | Cole Tucker | Mountain Pointe (AZ) | Tristan Hildebrandt | Esperanza (CA) | Ti'quan Forbes | Columbia (MS) | |
| 2014 | Infield | Cole Tucker | Mountain Pointe (AZ) | Tristan Hildebrandt | Esperanza (CA) | Justin Twine | Falls City (TX) | |
| 2014 | Outfield | Monte Harrison | Lee's Summit West (MO) | Jon Littell | Stillwater (OK) | Seth Beer | Lambert (GA) | |
| 2014 | Outfield | Derek Hill | Elk Grove (CA) | Braxton Davidson | T. C. Roberson (NC) | Cole Krzmarzick | Bishop Gorman (NV) | |
| 2014 | Outfield | Lane Thomas | Bearden (TN) | Sam Finnerty | Pelham (AL) | Marcus Wilson | Serra (CA) | |
| 2014 | Pitcher | Cameron Varga | Cincinnati Hills Christian (OH) | Brady Aiken$^#$ | Cathedral Catholic (CA) | Kodi Medeiros | Waiakea (HI) | |
| 2014 | Pitcher | Tyler Kolek | Shepherd (TX) | Cody Reed | Ardmore (AL) | Alex Lange | Lee's Summit West (MO) | |
| 2014 | Pitcher | Jack Flaherty (2) | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Justus Sheffield$^G$ | Tullahoma (TN) | Michael Kopech | Mount Pleasant (TX) | |
| 2014 | Pitcher | Jack Flaherty (2) | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Justus Sheffield$^G$ | Tullahoma (TN) | Tyler Frost | Greenway (AZ) | |
| 2014 | Utility | Brian Gonzalez | Archbishop McCarthy (FL) | Brendan McKay | Blackhawk (PA) | Nic Perkins | Francis Howell (MO) | |
| 2014 | Utility | Brian Gonzalez | Archbishop McCarthy (FL) | Brendan McKay | Blackhawk (PA) | Grant Hockin | Damien (CA) | |
| 2014 | Designated hitter | Brad Mathiowetz | Mayo (MN) | Alex Destino | North Buncombe (NC) | Blake Anderson | West Lauderdale (MS) | |

### 2015–2019

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 2015 | Catcher | Tyler Stephenson | Kennesaw Mountain (GA) | Corey Zangari | Carl Albert (OK) | Jacob Barnwell | Boyd County (KY) | |
| 2015 | First base | Devin Davis | Valencia (CA) | Alek Manoah* | South Dade (FL) | Breyden Varner | Collinsville (OK) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Brendan Rodgers | Lake Mary (FL) | Austin Riley | DeSoto Central (MS) | Travis Blankenhorn | Pottsville Area (PA) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Cornelius Randolph | Griffin (GA) | Charlie Donovan | Westmont (IL) | Ke'Bryan Hayes | Concordia Lutheran (TX) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Kody Clemens | Memorial (TX) | Cadyn Grenier | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Trey Cabbage | Grainger (TN) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Kody Clemens | Memorial (TX) | Cadyn Grenier | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Jeremy Eierman | Warsaw (MO) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Kody Clemens | Memorial (TX) | Cadyn Grenier | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Tyler Nevin | Poway (CA) | |
| 2015 | Infield | Kody Clemens | Memorial (TX) | Cadyn Grenier | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Nick Shumpert | Highlands Ranch (CO) | |
| 2015 | Outfield | Trent Clark | Richland (TX) | Garrett Whitley | Niskayuna (NY) | Ashton Bardzell | Ramsey (NJ) | |
| 2015 | Outfield | Dazmon Cameron | Eagle's Landing (GA) | Kyle Tucker*$^B$ | H.B. Plant (FL) | Isaiah White | Greenfield (NC) | |
| 2015 | Outfield | Nick Plummer | Brother Rice (MI) | Blake Perkins | Verrado (AZ) | Josh Magee | Franklinton (LA) | |
| 2015 | Outfield | Nick Plummer | Brother Rice (MI) | Blake Perkins | Verrado (AZ) | Brandon Wulff | Bishop Gorman (NV) | |
| 2015 | Outfield | Nick Plummer | Brother Rice (MI) | Blake Perkins | Verrado (AZ) | D. J. Wilson | Canton South (OH) | |
| 2015 | Designated hitter | Gene Wood | Jackson Prep (MS) | Cole Stobbe | Millard West (NE) | Daino Deas | Parkview (GA) | |
| 2015 | Designated hitter | Gene Wood | Jackson Prep (MS) | Cole Stobbe | Millard West (NE) | Ryan January | Swampscott (MA) | |
| 2015 | Utility | Bryce Denton | Ravenwood (TN) | Wesley Rodriguez | George Washington (NY) | Luken Baker$^G$ | Oak Ridge (TX) | |
| 2015 | Utility | Bryce Denton | Ravenwood (TN) | Wesley Rodriguez | George Washington (NY) | Joe DeMers | College Park (CA) | |
| 2015 | Pitcher | Max Wotell | Marvin Ridge (NC) | Triston McKenzie | Royal Palm Beach (FL) | Ian Anderson | Shenendehowa (NY) | |
| 2015 | Pitcher | Bryan Hudson | Alton (IL) | Jason Barber | Oxford (MS) | Mike Nikorak | Stroudsburg (PA) | |
| 2015 | Pitcher | Peter Lambert | San Dimas (CA) | Drew Finley | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Nolan Watson | Lawrence North (IN) | |
| 2015 | Pitcher | Peter Lambert | San Dimas (CA) | Drew Finley | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Ian Oxnevad | Shorewood (WA) | |
| 2016 | Catcher | Sam Huff | Arcadia (AZ) | Thomas Dillard | Oxford (MS) | Ben Rortvedt | Verona Area (WI) | |
| 2016 | First base | Dylan Carlson | Elk Grove (CA) | Zach Linginfelter | Sevier County (TN) | Walker Robbins | George County (MS) | |
| 2016 | Infield | Bo Bichette* | Lakewood (FL) | Nick Quintana | Arbor View (NV) | Nathaniel Garley | Eldorado (NM) | |
| 2016 | Infield | Joshua Lowe | Pope (GA) | Ryan Vilade | Frisco (TX) | Josh Jung* | MacArthur (TX) | |
| 2016 | Infield | Gavin Lux | Indian Trail (WI) | Cole Stobbe (2) | Millard West (NE) | Duncan Pence | Farragut (TN) | |
| 2016 | Infield | Gavin Lux | Indian Trail (WI) | Cole Stobbe (2) | Millard West (NE) | Nolan Jones | Holy Ghost Prep (PA) | |
| 2016 | Outfield | Mickey Moniak$^{#B}$ | La Costa Canyon (CA) | Blake Rutherford | Chaminade (CA) | Dante Baldelli | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | |
| 2016 | Outfield | Taylor Trammell | Mount Paran Christian (GA) | Khalil Lee | Flint Hill (VA) | Jack Duffy | Staley (MO) | |
| 2016 | Outfield | Alex Kirilloff | Plum (PA) | Conner Uselton | Southmoore (OK) | Nick Webre | Teurlings Catholic (LA) | |
| 2016 | Outfield | Alex Kirilloff | Plum (PA) | Conner Uselton | Southmoore (OK) | Quin Cotton | Regis Jesuit (CO) | |
| 2016 | Utility | Evan Lee | Bryant (AR) | Luca Dalatri | Christian Brothers (NJ) | Christian Camacho | Elk Grove (IL) | |
| 2016 | Utility | Evan Lee | Bryant (AR) | Luca Dalatri | Christian Brothers (NJ) | Connor Basler | Valle Catholic (MO) | |
| 2016 | Designated hitter | Zach Watson | West Ouachita (LA) | Zach Thompson | Wapahani (IN) | Pat DeMarco | Winder-Barrow (GA) | |
| 2016 | Pitcher | Joey Wentz | Shawnee Mission East (KS) | Grant Gambrell | Buchanan (CA) | Jared Horn | Vintage (CA) | |
| 2016 | Pitcher | Ian Anderson (2) | Shenendehowa (NY) | Sean Reynolds | Redondo Union (CA) | Jason Groome | Barnegat (NJ) | |
| 2016 | Pitcher | Bryse Wilson | Orange (NC) | Braxton Garrett | Florence (AL) | Cole Ragans* | North Florida Christian (FL) | |
| 2016 | Pitcher | Bryse Wilson | Orange (NC) | Braxton Garrett | Florence (AL) | Riley Pint | St. Thomas Aquinas (KS) | |
| 2016 | Pitcher | Bryse Wilson | Orange (NC) | Braxton Garrett | Florence (AL) | Jake Greenwalt | Windsor (CO) | |
| 2017 | Catcher | Luis Campusano | Cross Creek (GA) | Blake Hunt | Mater Dei (CA) | Casey Opitz | Heritage (CO) | |
| 2017 | First base | Nick Pratto | Huntington Beach (CA) | Bobby Seymour | Mount Carmel (IL) | Kody Milton | Severna Park (MD) | |
| 2017 | First base | Nick Pratto | Huntington Beach (CA) | Bobby Seymour | Mount Carmel (IL) | Terriez Fuller | Griffin (GA) | |
| 2017 | Infield | Jeter Downs | Pace (FL) | Buddy Kennedy | Millville (NJ) | Danny Hosley | Langley (VA) | |
| 2017 | Infield | Royce Lewis$^#$ | JSerra Catholic (CA) | Jacob Gonzalez | Chaparral (AZ) | Mark Vientos | American Heritage (FL) | |
| 2017 | Infield | Ryan Vilade (2) | Stillwater (OK) | Hunter Greene* | Notre Dame (CA) | Grant Wood | Jefferson City (MO) | |
| 2017 | Infield | Ryan Vilade (2) | Stillwater (OK) | Hunter Greene* | Notre Dame (CA) | Liam Eddy | Brighton (CO) | |
| 2017 | Outfield | Austin Beck | North Davidson (NC) | Bubba Thompson | McGill-Toolen (AL) | Quentin Holmes | Monsignor McClancy (NY) | |
| 2017 | Outfield | Drew Waters | Etowah (GA) | Jacob Pearson | West Monroe (LA) | Kyle Grantham | Francis Howell (MO) | |
| 2017 | Outfield | Jordon Adell | Ballard (KY) | Tristen Lutz | Martin (TX) | Calvin Mitchell | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | |
| 2017 | Outfield | Jordon Adell | Ballard (KY) | Tristen Lutz | Martin (TX) | Justin Bullock | South Granville (NC) | |
| 2017 | Designated hitter | Tyler Freeman | Etiwanda (CA) | Brett Owen | Blanchard (OK) | Hunter Gustafson | Webster (WI) | |
| 2017 | Utility | Christian Chamberlain | Reno (NV) | Nick Storz | Poly Prep Country Day (NY) | Conner VanCleave | Holcomb (KS) | |
| 2017 | Pitcher | MacKenzie Gore$^{GB}$ | Whiteville (NC) | D.L. Hall | Valdosta (GA) | Jake Jackson | El Toro (CA) | |
| 2017 | Pitcher | Trevor Rogers* | Carlsbad (NM) | Hagen Danner | Huntington Beach (CA) | Alex Scherff | Colleyville Heritage (TX) | |
| 2017 | Pitcher | Shane Baz | Concordia Lutheran (TX) | Sam Carlson | Burnsville (MN) | Charlie Neuweiler | Monsignor McClancy (NY) | |
| 2017 | Pitcher | Shane Baz | Concordia Lutheran (TX) | Sam Carlson | Burnsville (MN) | Cameron Cotter | Northern Guilford (NC) | |
| 2017 | Pitcher | Shane Baz | Concordia Lutheran (TX) | Sam Carlson | Burnsville (MN) | Jacob Heatherly | Cullman (AL) | |
| 2018 | Catcher | Will Banfield | Brookwood (GA) | Matt McCormick | St. Laurence (IL) | Andrew Cossetti | La Salle (PA) | |
| 2018 | First base | Grant Lavigne | Bedford (NH) | Justin Olson | Pine Creek (CO) | Kody Milton (2) | Severna Park (MD) | |
| 2018 | First base | Grant Lavigne | Bedford (NH) | Justin Olson | Pine Creek (CO) | Cade Beloso | John Curtis (LA) | |
| 2018 | Infield | Jeremiah Jackson | St. Luke's Episcopal (AL) | Brice Turang | Santiago (CA) | Matt McLain | Beckman (CA) | |
| 2018 | Infield | Triston Casas | American Heritage (FL) | Bobby Witt Jr.*$^{GB}$ | Colleyville Heritage (TX) | Jonathan Ornelas | Kellis (AZ) | |
| 2018 | Infield | Nolan Gorman | O'Connor (AZ) | Ryan Archibald | John Carroll (MD) | Cameron Chick | Hickman (MO) | |
| 2018 | Outfield | Jordyn Adams | Green Hope (NC) | Jack Washburn | Webster (WI) | Ryder Green | Karns (TN) | |
| 2018 | Outfield | Connor Scott | H.B. Plant (FL) | Kingston Liniak | Mission Hills (CA) | Alek Thomas | Mount Carmel (IL) | |
| 2018 | Outfield | Nicholas Schnell | Roncalli (IN) | Joe Gray | Hattiesburg (MS) | Brennen Davis | Basha (AZ) | |
| 2018 | Outfield | Nicholas Schnell | Roncalli (IN) | Joe Gray | Hattiesburg (MS) | Micah Bello | Hilo (HI) | |
| 2018 | Designated hitter | Jace Bohrofen | Westmoore (OK) | Austin Wells | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Haydn McGeary | Thunderbird (AZ) | |
| 2018 | Utility | Anthony Seigler | Cartersville (GA) | Luke Mann | St. John Vianney (MO) | Nick Decker | Seneca (NJ) | |
| 2018 | Utility | Anthony Seigler | Cartersville (GA) | Luke Mann | St. John Vianney (MO) | Connor Noland | Greenwood (AR) | |
| 2018 | Pitcher | Gunnar Hoglund | Fivay (FL) | Matt Liberatore | Mountain Ridge (AZ) | Lineras Torres Jr. | Beacon (NY) | |
| 2018 | Pitcher | Ryan Weathers$^G$ | Loretto (TN) | J. T. Ginn | Brandon (MS) | Owen White | Jesse Carson (NC) | |
| 2018 | Pitcher | Cole Winn$^B$ | Orange Lutheran (CA) | Mason Denaburg | Merritt Island (FL) | Joey Magrisi | Torrey Pines (CA) | |
| 2018 | Pitcher | Cole Winn$^B$ | Orange Lutheran (CA) | Mason Denaburg | Merritt Island (FL) | Carter Stewart | Eau Gallie (FL) | |
| 2018 | Pitcher | Cole Winn$^B$ | Orange Lutheran (CA) | Mason Denaburg | Merritt Island (FL) | Willie Weiss | Westview (OR) | |
| 2019 | Catcher | Jonathan French | Parkview (GA) | Kody Huff | Horizon (AZ) | Jack Bulger | DeMatha Catholic (MD) | |
| 2019 | Catcher | Jonathan French | Parkview (GA) | Kody Huff | Horizon (AZ) | Micah Yonamine | Iolani (HI) | |
| 2019 | First base | Jace Bohrofen (2) | Westmoore (OK) | Jordan Beck | Hazel Green (AL) | Joe Naranjo | Ayala (CA) | |
| 2019 | Infield | CJ Abrams* | Blessed Trinity Catholic (GA) | Anthony Volpe | Delbarton (NJ) | Luke Gold | Ballston Spa (NY) | |
| 2019 | Infield | Brett Baty | Lake Travis (TX) | Gunnar Henderson | John T. Morgan (AL) | Tyler Callihan | Providence (FL) | |
| 2019 | Infield | Bobby Witt Jr.*$^{GB}$ (2) | Colleyville Heritage (TX) | Keoni Cavaco | Eastlake (CA) | Parker Noland | Farragut (TN) | |
| 2019 | Infield | Bobby Witt Jr.*$^{GB}$ (2) | Colleyville Heritage (TX) | Keoni Cavaco | Eastlake (CA) | Will Duff | Springfield Catholic (MO) | |
| 2019 | Outfield | Sammy Siani | William Penn (PA) | Maurice Hampton Jr. | Memphis University (TN) | Joshua Mears | Federal Way (WA) | |
| 2019 | Outfield | Riley Greene* | Hagerty (FL) | Colin Barber | Pleasant Valley (CA) | Andre Tarver | Ringgold (GA) | |
| 2019 | Outfield | Corbin Carroll* | Lakeside (WA) | Stephen Paolini | St. Joseph (CT) | Ethan Vecrumba | Edgewood (IN) | |
| 2019 | Outfield | Corbin Carroll* | Lakeside (WA) | Stephen Paolini | St. Joseph (CT) | Jack Washburn (2) | Webster (WI) | |
| 2019 | Designated hitter | Aaron Roberts | Desert Oasis (NV) | Robert Hassell | Independence (TN) | Ethan Hearn | Mobile Christian (AL) | |
| 2019 | Designated hitter | Aaron Roberts | Desert Oasis (NV) | Robert Hassell | Independence (TN) | Brenden Dixon | Argyle (TX) | |
| 2019 | Utility | Jared Jones | La Mirada (CA) | Michael Doolin | Andrean (IN) | Ronan Kopp | Scottsdale Christian (AZ) | |
| 2019 | Utility | Jared Jones | La Mirada (CA) | Michael Doolin | Andrean (IN) | Blake Walston | New Hanover (NC) | |
| 2019 | Pitcher | Matthew Allan | Seminole (FL) | Jack Leiter | Delbarton (NJ) | Joe Clancy | Westfield (VA) | |
| 2019 | Pitcher | Chris McElvain | Summit (TN) | Matthew Thompson | Cypress Ranch (TX) | Ryan Hagenow | Farragut (TN) | |
| 2019 | Pitcher | JJ Goss | Cypress Ranch (TX) | Quinn Priester | Cary-Grove (IL) | Drew Gilbert | Stillwater (MN) | |
| 2019 | Pitcher | JJ Goss | Cypress Ranch (TX) | Quinn Priester | Cary-Grove (IL) | Kale Davis | Westmoore (OK) | |
| 2019 | Pitcher | JJ Goss | Cypress Ranch (TX) | Quinn Priester | Cary-Grove (IL) | Stephen Klenske | Sage Creek (CA) | |

### 2020–present

| Year | Position | First team | First team | Second team | Second team | Third team | Third team | Ref |
| Year | Position | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Player | High school (state) | Ref |
| 2020 | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic | No team selected due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | Catcher | Harry Ford | North Cobb (GA) | Joe Mack | Williamsville East (NY) | Carter Jensen | Park Hill (MO) | |
| 2021 | First base | Carson Benge | Yukon (OK) | Mike Kennedy | Troy (NY) | Greysen Carter | Fairview (CO) | |
| 2021 | First base | Carson Benge | Yukon (OK) | Mike Kennedy | Troy (NY) | Jared Everson | Aquinas (WI) | |
| 2021 | Infield | Jordan Lawlar | Jesuit College Prep (TX) | Max Muncy | Thousand Oaks (CA) | Cooper Kinney | Baylor (TN) | |
| 2021 | Infield | Marcelo Mayer | Eastlake (CA) | Noah Miller | Ozaukee (WI) | Cody Schrier | JSerra Catholic (CA) | |
| 2021 | Infield | Brady House | Winder-Barrow (GA) | Kahlil Watson | Wake Forest (NC) | Slate Alford | Bob Jones (AL) | |
| 2021 | Infield | Brady House | Winder-Barrow (GA) | Kahlil Watson | Wake Forest (NC) | Jackson Holliday$^{#B}$ | Stillwater (OK) | |
| 2021 | Infield | Brady House | Winder-Barrow (GA) | Kahlil Watson | Wake Forest (NC) | Colson Montgomery | Southridge (IN) | |
| 2021 | Outfield | Daylen Lile | Trinity (KY) | John Kramer | Lafayette (MO) | Lonnie White Jr. | Malvern (PA) | |
| 2021 | Outfield | Tyler Whitaker | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Brock Selvidge | Hamilton (AZ) | Chase Mason | Viborg-Hurley (SD) | |
| 2021 | Outfield | Druw Jones | Wesleyan (GA) | Jordan Viars | Reedy (TX) | Josh Baez | Dexter Southfield (MA) | |
| 2021 | Outfield | Druw Jones | Wesleyan (GA) | Jordan Viars | Reedy (TX) | Jay Allen | John Carroll (MD) | |
| 2021 | Outfield | Druw Jones | Wesleyan (GA) | Jordan Viars | Reedy (TX) | Braden Montgomery | Madison Central (MS) | |
| 2021 | Designated hitter | James Triantos | Madison (VA) | Sal Stewart | Westminster Christian (FL) | Roc Riggio | Thousand Oaks (CA) | |
| 2021 | Designated hitter | James Triantos | Madison (VA) | Sal Stewart | Westminster Christian (FL) | Collin Reuter | Magnolia Heights (MS) | |
| 2021 | Utility | Carson Williams | Torrey Pines (CA) | Owen Washburn | Webster (WI) | Bubba Chandler | North Oconee (GA) | |
| 2021 | Pitcher | Jackson Jobe$^B$ | Heritage Hall (OK) | Brock Porter$^G$ | St. Mary's Prep (MI) | Drew Christo | Elkhorn (NE) | |
| 2021 | Pitcher | Frank Mozzicato | East Catholic (CT) | Samuel Dutton | Westbrook Christian (AL) | Carson Liggett | Blue Valley (KS) | |
| 2021 | Pitcher | Gage Jump | JSerra Catholic (CA) | Josh Hartle | Reagan (NC) | Chase Petty | Mainland Regional (NJ) | |
| 2022 | Catcher | Malcolm Moore | McClatchy (CA) | Camden Ross | Broomfield (CO) | Ethan Frey | Rosepine (LA) | |
| 2022 | First base | Will Furniss | Nacogdoches (TX) | Xavier Issac | East Forsyth (NC) | Luke Anderson | Snow Canyon (UT) | |
| 2022 | First base | Will Furniss | Nacogdoches (TX) | Xavier Issac | East Forsyth (NC) | Brett Norfleet | Francis Howell (MO) | |
| 2022 | Infield | Jackson Holliday$^{#B}$ (2) | Stillwater (OK) | Cutter Coffey | Liberty (CA) | R. J. Austin | Pace (GA) | |
| 2022 | Infield | Blake Mitchell | Sinton (TX) | Patrick Forbes | Bowling Green (KY) | Cade Kurland | Berkeley Prep (FL) | |
| 2022 | Infield | Judd Utermark | Charlotte Christian (NC) | Jett Williams | Rockwall-Heath (TX) | Jackson Lovich | Blue Valley West (KS) | |
| 2022 | Infield | Judd Utermark | Charlotte Christian (NC) | Jett Williams | Rockwall-Heath (TX) | Grant MacArthur | Granite Hills (CA) | |
| 2022 | Outfield | Druw Jones (2) | Wesleyan (GA) | Nicholas Morabito | Gonzaga College (DC) | Harrison Didawick | Western Branch (VA) | |
| 2022 | Outfield | Justin Crawford | Bishop Gorman (NV) | Roman Anthony | Stoneman Douglas (FL) | Max Clark$^{GB}$ | Franklin (IN) | |
| 2022 | Outfield | Jace LaViolette | Tompkins (TX) | Dakota Jordan | Jackson (MS) | Korbyn Dickerson | Trinity (KY) | |
| 2022 | Outfield | Jace LaViolette | Tompkins (TX) | Dakota Jordan | Jackson (MS) | Dylan Dreiling | Hays (KS) | |
| 2022 | Outfield | Jace LaViolette | Tompkins (TX) | Dakota Jordan | Jackson (MS) | Henry Bolte | Palo Alto (CA) | |
| 2022 | Designated hitter | Dylan Carey | Ponderosa (CO) | Brendan Summerhill | Whitney Young (IL) | Matt Scott | Joel Barlow (CT) | |
| 2022 | Designated hitter | Dylan Carey | Ponderosa (CO) | Brendan Summerhill | Whitney Young (IL) | Sal Stewart (2) | Westminster Christian (FL) | |
| 2022 | Designated hitter | Dylan Carey | Ponderosa (CO) | Brendan Summerhill | Whitney Young (IL) | Anthony Martinez | De La Salle (CA) | |
| 2022 | Utility | Owen Murphy | Riverside Brookfield (IL) | Austin Charles | Stockdale (CA) | Ky Hoskinson | McMinnville (OR) | |
| 2022 | Utility | Owen Murphy | Riverside Brookfield (IL) | Austin Charles | Stockdale (CA) | Mitchell Voit | Whitefish Bay (WI) | |
| 2022 | Pitcher | Brock Porter$^G$ (2) | St. Mary's Prep (MI) | Justin Lamkin | Calallen (TX) | Nolan Perry | Carlsbad (NM) | |
| 2022 | Pitcher | Robby Snelling | McQueen (NV) | Riley Quick | Hewitt-Trussville (AL) | Thomas White | Phillips Andover (MA) | |
| 2022 | Pitcher | Eli Jerzembeck | Providence (NC) | Brennan Phillips | Owasso (OK) | Jaden Noot | Sierra Canyon (CA) | |
| 2022 | Pitcher | Eli Jerzembeck | Providence (NC) | Brennan Phillips | Owasso (OK) | Karson Milbrandt | Liberty (MO) | |
| 2022 | Pitcher | Eli Jerzembeck | Providence (NC) | Brennan Phillips | Owasso (OK) | Elliott Bray | Hartselle (AL) | |
| 2023 | Catcher | Blake Mitchell (2) | Sinton (TX) | Trever Baumler | Dowling Catholic (IA) | Ryder Helfrick | Clayton Valley Charter (CA) |
| 2023 | Catcher | Blake Mitchell (2) | Sinton (TX) | Trever Baumler | Dowling Catholic (IA) | Mark Gialluisi | St. Joseph (NJ) | |
| 2023 | First base | Dylan Cupp | Cedartown (GA) | Gage Gundy | Stillwater (OK) | Easton Shelton | Bishop Gorman (NV) | |
| 2023 | First base | Dylan Cupp | Cedartown (GA) | Gage Gundy | Stillwater (OK) | Joey McMannis$^G$ | Catoctin (MD) | |
| 2023 | Infield | Colin Houck | Parkview (GA) | Sam Stafura | Walter Panas (NY) | Arjun Nimmala | Strawberry Crest (FL) | |
| 2023 | Infield | Walker Martin | Eaton (CO) | Roch Cholowsky | Hamilton (AZ) | Trent Caraway | JSerra Catholic (CA) | |
| 2023 | Infield | Kevin Takeuchi | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Konnor Griffin$^{GB}$ (2) | Jackson Prep (MS) | Kevin McGonigle | Bonner-Prendergast (PA) | |
| 2023 | Infield | Kevin Takeuchi | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Konnor Griffin$^{GB}$ (2) | Jackson Prep (MS) | Steven Milam | Centennial (NM) | |
| 2023 | Infield | Kevin Takeuchi | Rancho Bernardo (CA) | Konnor Griffin$^{GB}$ (2) | Jackson Prep (MS) | Ethan Holliday | Stillwater (OK) | |
| 2023 | Outfield | Drew Burress | Houston County (GA) | Bristol Carter | Northwest Guilford (NC) | Slade Caldwell | Valley View (AR) | |
| 2023 | Outfield | Max Clark$^{GB}$ (2) | Franklin (IN) | Braxton Thomas | Central Catholic (CA) | Brady Ballinger | Green Valley (NV) | |
| 2023 | Outfield | Aidan Smith | Lovejoy (TX) | Walker Jenkins | South Brunswick (NC) | Tai Peete | Trinity Christian (GA) | |
| 2023 | Outfield | Aidan Smith | Lovejoy (TX) | Walker Jenkins | South Brunswick (NC) | Brock Eddy | Brighton (CO) | |
| 2023 | Designated hitter | Braden Holcomb | Foundation Academy (FL) | Ryder Robinson | American Fork (UT) | Adam Buerger | Lincoln (OH) | |
| 2023 | Designated hitter | Braden Holcomb | Foundation Academy (FL) | Ryder Robinson | American Fork (UT) | Jackson DiLorenzo | Walter Panas (NY) | |
| 2023 | Designated hitter | Braden Holcomb | Foundation Academy (FL) | Ryder Robinson | American Fork (UT) | Tyler August | Delaware Military Academy (DE) | |
| 2023 | Utility | Bryce Eldridge | James Madison (VA) | Dylan Loy | Pigeon Forge (TN) | Matt Thorsen | Chatham (NY) | |
| 2023 | Utility | Bryce Eldridge | James Madison (VA) | Dylan Loy | Pigeon Forge (TN) | Luke Dotson | Mount Paran Christian (GA) | |
| 2023 | Utility | Bryce Eldridge | James Madison (VA) | Dylan Loy | Pigeon Forge (TN) | Cooper Pratt | Magnolia Heights (MS) | |
| 2023 | Pitcher | Christian Rodriguez | Stoneman Douglas (FL) | Ross Felder | Har-Ber (AR) | Kash Mayfield | Elk City (OK) | |
| 2023 | Pitcher | Noble Meyer | Jesuit (OR) | Gabe Gaeckle | Aptos (CA) | Blake Wolters | Mahomet-Seymour (IL) | |
| 2023 | Pitcher | Tate McGuire | Liberty (MO) | Robert Satin | H.B. Plant (FL) | Steven Echavarria | Millburn (NJ) | |
| 2023 | Pitcher | Tate McGuire | Liberty (MO) | Robert Satin | H.B. Plant (FL) | Alex Clemmey | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | |
| 2023 | Pitcher | Tate McGuire | Liberty (MO) | Robert Satin | H.B. Plant (FL) | Destin Allen-Fox | Santana (CA) | |
| 2024 | Catcher | Cade Arrambide | Tomball (TX) | Hogan Denny | Mooresville (IN) | Taitn Gray | Dallas Center–Grimes (IA) | |
| 2024 | Catcher | Cade Arrambide | Tomball (TX) | Hogan Denny | Mooresville (IN) | Hunter Carns | First Coast (FL) | |
| 2024 | First base | AJ Evasco | Lincoln East (NE) | Braiden Reynolds | La Cueva (NM) | Tate Medicoff | Sacred Heart Cathedral (CA) | |
| 2024 | First base | AJ Evasco | Lincoln East (NE) | Braiden Reynolds | La Cueva (NM) | Parker Wright | Frank W. Cox (VA) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Cade Brown | Parkview (GA) | Devin Fitz-Gerald | Stoneman Douglas (FL) | Trey Snyder | Liberty North (MO) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Eli Evans | Farragut (TN) | Tyson Lewis | Millard West (NE) | Brock Thompson | Liberty (CA) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Bryce Rainer | Harvard-Westlake (CA) | Dalton Wentz | Amherst County (VA) | John Pearson | West Monroe (LA) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Boston Kellner | Hamilton (AZ) | Tomas Valincius | Baylor School (TN) | Tucker Swails | Patrick County (VA) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Boston Kellner | Hamilton (AZ) | Tomas Valincius | Baylor School (TN) | Gavin Smith | Basha (AZ) | |
| 2024 | Infield | Boston Kellner | Hamilton (AZ) | Tomas Valincius | Baylor School (TN) | Owen Paino | Roy C. Ketcham (NY) | |
| 2024 | Outfield | PJ Morlando | Summerville (SC) | Jaden Fauske | Nazareth Academy (IL) | Cole Pladson | Clay Center (KS) | |
| 2024 | Outfield | Isaac Sturgess | Powers Catholic (MI) | Tyler Paul Wentworth | Central Catholic (CA) | Michael Mullinax | North Cobb Christian (GA) | |
| 2024 | Outfield | Slade Caldwell (2) | Valley View (AR) | Jack Haferkamp | Santa Fe Christian (CA) | Jace Souza | Kamehameha Kapalama (HI) | |
| 2024 | Outfield | Jackson Kircher | Little Rock Christian (AR) | Griffin Crain | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | Ty Head | Windermere (FL) | |
| 2024 | Outfield | Jackson Kircher | Little Rock Christian (AR) | Griffin Crain | Bishop Hendricken (RI) | Sawyer Strosnider | Brock (TX) | |
| 2024 | Designated hitter | Joseph Parker | Purvis (MS) | Bryson Casto | Ripley (WV) | Matt Conte | Dexter Southfield (MA) | |
| 2024 | Utility | Konnor Griffin$^{GB}$ | Jackson Prep (MS) | Kruz Schoolcraft | Sunset (OR) | Perry Hargett | Metrolina Christian (NC) | |
| 2024 | Utility | Seth Hernandez | Corona (CA) | Johnny King | Naples (FL) | Colin Nowaczyk | Elkhorn North (NE) | |
| 2024 | Utility | Seth Hernandez | Corona (CA) | Johnny King | Naples (FL) | Jake Hanley | Mason (OH) | |
| 2024 | Pitcher | Kash Mayfield $^{(2)}$ | Elk City (OK) | Joey Oakie | Ankeny Centennial (IA) | Mateo Gray | North Broward Prep (FL) | |
| 2024 | Pitcher | Ethan Schiefelbein | Corona (CA) | Kyle DeGroat | Wallkill (NY) | Wade Walton | Newsome (FL) | |
| 2024 | Pitcher | Boston Bateman | Camarillo (CA) | Dax Whitney | Blackfoot (ID) | William Schmidt | Catholic (LA) | |
| 2024 | Pitcher | Cam Caminiti | Saguaro (AZ) | Lance Davis | Valley View (AR) | Camron Seagraves | Grace Christian (NC) | |
| 2024 | Pitcher | Cam Caminiti | Saguaro (AZ) | Lance Davis | Valley View (AR) | Mason Brassfield | Bakersfield Christian (CA) | |

## Selections by state

| State | First Team | Second Team | Third Team | Total |
| Alabama | 7 | 12 | 10 | 29 |
| Arkansas | 9 | 4 | 10 | 23 |
| Arizona | 19 | 28 | 28 | 75 |
| California | 146 | 95 | 86 | 327 |
| Colorado | 8 | 15 | 26 | 49 |
| Connecticut | 6 | 7 | 9 | 22 |
| Delaware | 2 | 3 | 6 | 11 |
| District of Columbia | 0 | 4 | 0 | 4 |
| Florida | 70 | 67 | 59 | 196 |
| Georgia | 47 | 17 | 18 | 82 |
| Hawaii | 0 | 2 | 5 | 7 |
| Idaho | 0 | 0 | 4 | 4 |
| Illinois | 24 | 18 | 18 | 60 |
| Indiana | 9 | 6 | 11 | 26 |
| Iowa | 0 | 9 | 13 | 22 |
| Kansas | 4 | 7 | 11 | 22 |
| Kentucky | 11 | 2 | 3 | 16 |
| Louisiana | 7 | 11 | 17 | 35 |
| Maine | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 |
| Maryland | 5 | 4 | 12 | 21 |
| Massachusetts | 7 | 11 | 19 | 37 |
| Michigan | 11 | 17 | 12 | 40 |
| Minnesota | 4 | 8 | 5 | 17 |
| Mississippi | 6 | 17 | 16 | 39 |
| Missouri | 8 | 11 | 21 | 40 |
| Nebraska | 4 | 9 | 5 | 18 |
| Nevada | 14 | 8 | 9 | 31 |
| New Hampshire | 2 | 1 | 2 | 5 |
| New Jersey | 19 | 11 | 17 | 47 |
| New Mexico | 2 | 5 | 11 | 18 |
| New York | 14 | 24 | 32 | 70 |
| North Carolina | 15 | 17 | 16 | 48 |
| Ohio | 18 | 13 | 8 | 39 |
| Oklahoma | 25 | 21 | 14 | 60 |
| Oregon | 4 | 7 | 7 | 18 |
| Pennsylvania | 17 | 9 | 14 | 40 |
| Rhode Island | 2 | 3 | 5 | 10 |
| South Carolina | 11 | 3 | 6 | 20 |
| South Dakota | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| Tennessee | 9 | 15 | 12 | 36 |
| Texas | 66 | 50 | 39 | 155 |
| Utah | 1 | 4 | 6 | 11 |
| Virginia | 12 | 10 | 13 | 35 |
| Washington | 12 | 13 | 14 | 39 |
| West Virginia | 0 | 2 | 4 | 6 |
| Wisconsin | 1 | 6 | 10 | 17 |