# 1957–58 Australia rugby union tour of Britain, Ireland and France

Between late 1957 and March 1958 the Australia national rugby union team – the Wallabies – conducted a world tour encompassing Britain, Ireland, France and Canada on which they played five Tests and thirty-one minor tour matches. The Wallabies won 17, lost 16 and drew three of their games in total. They lost all five Tests of the tour.

## The squad's leadership

Versatile back Dick Tooth had made 10 Test appearances for Australia before the tour and had captained the Wallabies well in two 1957 Tests against the All Blacks. Howell expresses a view that it was inexplicable that Tooth was not selected for the tour and partially blames this as cause of the disappointing tour result. However Howell writes that Bob Davidson possessed outstanding qualities to make him a natural touring captain. He was a born leader of men, was immensely popular, he met people well, was highly intelligent and spoke well in public. He played in 32 of the 41 tour games and did everything in his power to make the tour a success.
Veteran second-rower Alan Cameron had captained the Wallabies in 18 matches in 1955 and 1956 but was no longer supreme in his position nor guaranteed of Test selection. However he made a superb contribution to the tour playing in 22 matches including one Test and captained the side in seven mid-week matches
As per tradition, Assistant Manager Dave Cowper assumed the coaching duties. Howell writes that in spite of the mounting losses, Cowper "ever the gentleman, never criticised the players, even when he had every right to....he personified the true amateur, playing always to the rules with a strict code of ethics" Squad member Nicholas Shehadie was less complimentary in his published recollections suggesting Cowper had limited imagination as a coach with "our training devoid of variety which made it very tedious."

## Tour details

The squad was on tour for eight months in total and travelled to England by ship. Shehadie reports that the team issue consisted of " two blazers, a pair of grey slacks, four green ties with a hand-painted wallaby on each, a heavy pullover and a track suit. In addition, each player received one pair of boots – with another pair to be issued in England – sandshoes for training on the ship, a heavy woollen scarf and tablets to counteract sea-sickness, Vitamin C tablets to counteract colds in Britain and a packet of tranquiliser tablets to be used at the player's own discretion"' He recalls that the squad's pocket money was 10s a day, up from 5s a decade before.

## Matches of the Tour

    Scores and results list Australia's points tally first.
| | Date | Opponent | Location | Result | Score |
| 1 | 6 November | Southern Counties | Hove | Won | 29–5 |
| 2 | 10 November | Oxford University RFC | Iffley Road, Oxford | Lost | 6–12 |
| 3 | 13 November | Cambridge University R.U.F.C. | Grange Road, Cambridge | Lost | 3–13 |
| 4 | 16 November | London Counties | Twickenham | Draw | 9–9 |
| 5 | 20 November | Pontypool & Cross Keys | Pontypool Park, Pontypool | Won | 14–6 |
| 6 | 23 November | Newport | Rodney Parade, Newport | Lost | 0–11 |
| 7 | 27 November | Leinster | Lansdowne Road, Dublin | Won | 10–8 |
| 8 | 30 November | Ulster | Ravenhill, Belfast | Won | 9–0 |
| 9 | 4 December | Glasgow - Edinburgh | Old Anniesland, Glasgow | Won | 9–3 |
| 10 | 7 December | South of Scotland | Mansfield Park, Hawick | Won | 12–6 |
| 11 | 10 December | Llanelli | Stradey Park, Llanelli | Won | 9–5 |
| 12 | 14 December | Cardiff | Cardiff Arms Park, Cardiff | Lost | 11–14 |
| 13 | 18 December | Western Counties | Bristol | Lost | 8–9 |
| 14 | 21 December | Leicestershire & East Midlands | Welford Road Leicester | Won | 18–3 |
| 15 | 26 December | Combined Services | Twickenham | Won | 16–11 |
| 17 | 28 December | Aberavon & Neath | Talbot Athletic Ground, Port Talbot | Won | 5–3 |
| 18 | 4 January | Wales | Cardiff Arms Park | Lost | 3–9 |
| 19 | 8 January | Abertillery & Ebbw Vale | The Park, Abertillery | Lost | 5–6 |
| 20 | 11 January | Swansea | St Helen's Ground, Swansea | Won | 12–6 |
| 21 | 18 January | Ireland | Lansdowne Road | Lost | 6–9 |
| 22 | 21 January | Munster | Thomond Park, Limerick | Draw | 3–3 |
| 23 | 25 January | South West Counties | Home Park, Plymouth | Drew | 3–3 |
| 24 | 28 January | South East Counties | Portsmouth | Won | 6–0 |
| 25 | 1 February | England | Twickenham Stadium | Lost | 6–9 |
| 26 | 5 February | North Eastern Counties | County Ground, Gosforth | Won | 10–0 |
| 27 | 8 February | North Western Counties | County Ground, Blundellsands | lost | 3–6 |
| 28 | 11 February | North of Scotland | Aberdeen | Won | 6–3 |
| 29 | 15 February | Scotland | Murrayfield Stadium | Lost | 8–12 |
| 30 | 19 February | Midland Counties | Highfield Road, Coventry | Lost | 3–8 |
| 31 | 22 February | Barbarians | Cardiff Arms Park, Cardiff | Lost | 6–11 |
| 32 | 9 March | France | Stade de Columbes | Lost | 0–19 |
| 33 | 15 March | British Columbia | Vancouver | Lost | 3–15 |
| 34 | 20 March | University of BC | Vancouver | Won | 31–6 |
* ↑ Team billed as North of Scotland was a de facto combined North and Midlands side

## Test matches
### Wales

* 4 January 1958
| Wales | 9–3 | Australia |
| (3 −1t) Collins (3 – 1pg) TJ Davies (3 – 1dg) James | | Miller (3 – 1t) |
* Cardiff Arms Park, Cardiff Attendance: 55,000 Referee: AI Dickie (SRU)
AUSTRALIA: Terry Curley, Roderick Phelps, Kenneth Donald, Jim Lenehan, Jack Potts, Arthur Summons, Des Connor, Nicholas Shehadie, Norman Hughes, Peter Fenwicke, Tony Miller, Dave Emanuel, John Thornett, James Brown, Robert Davidson (captain)
WALES: Terry Davies, John Collins, Gordon Wells, Cyril Davies, Ray Williams, Carwyn James, Wynne Evans, Don Devereux, Bryn Meredith, Ray Prosser, Rhys Williams, Roddy Evans, Robin Davies, Clem Thomas (captain), John Faull

### Ireland

* 18 January 1958
| Ireland | 9–6 | Australia |
| Dawson (3 – 1t) Henderson (3 – 1t) Smith (3 – 1pg) | | Phelps (3 – 1t) Summons (3 – 1t) |
* Lansdowne Road, Dublin Attendance: 33,000 Referee: WJ Evans (WRU)
Shehadie writes in his memoirs that his response to Noel Murphy continually blocking his vision in the scrum was to deal him a punch in an ensuing scrum. He recalls that the Lansdowne Rd crowd booed the Australian team and that press afterwards singled out Shehadie for his brutal play. He suggests that Dave Cowper then determined to make an example of him and true to his word did not select him in another Test of the tour. It was therefore Shehadie's last Test match, as it would also be for Australia's other forward veteran Alan Cameron.
AUSTRALIA: Terry Curley, Kenneth Donald, Saxon White, Jack Potts, Roderick Phelps, Arthur Summons, Des Connor, Nicholas Shehadie, James Brown, Robert Davidson (captain), Alan Cameron, Dave Emanuel, John Thornett Norman Hughes, Peter Fenwicke
IRELAND: Paddy Berkery, Tony O'Reilly, Noel Henderson (c), Dave Hewitt, Cecil Pedlow, Jackie Kyle, Andy Mulligan, Patrick O'Donoghue, Ronnie Dawson, Gordon Wood, James Stevenson, Bill Mulcahy, James Donaldson, Noel Murphy, James Kavanagh Alan Cameron

### England

* 1 February 1958
| England | 9–6 | Australia |
| (3 – 1t) Phillips (3 – 1t) Jackson (3 – 1pg) Hetherington | | Curley (3 – 1fg) Lenehan (3 – 1pg) |
* Twickenham, London Attendance: 60,000 Referee: RC Williams (IRFU)
This was the day Twickenham booed, a rare sound at the august ground. But when big Jim Lenehan tackled Phil Horrocks-Taylor late and so heavily that he was taken off the field, the crowd were annoyed. Every time Lenehan touched the ball, the crowd booed.
The scores were 3–0 at half time, but soon Malcolm Phillips scored a great try and then the elegant Terry Curley gave the Wallabies the lead with a drop goal. When injury time came the score was 6-all. Then came the only try of the match by brilliant Peter Jackson. Jackson out on the wing, got a pass on the Wallaby 25. He was not the fastest of wings – but he was deceptive and knew sidestep, swerve and hand-off, and used them as deadly weapons. He swerved away from Rod Phelps and handed him off. He moved to cut in, plonking Terry Curley onto the wrong foot as he beat him on the outside. Phelps was gaining, the line was approaching, Phelps was faster and Jackson dived with Phelps on his back.
It was England's first post-war Test victory over one of the three Southern powers.
AUSTRALIA: Terry Curley, Rod Phelps, Ken Donald, Jim Lenehan, Saxon White, Arthur Summons, Des Connor, Kevin Ryan, Mac Hughes, Peter Fenwicke, Tony Miller, Dave Emanuel, Geoffrey Vaughan, James Brown, Robert Davidson (captain)
ENGLAND: Jim Hetherington, Peter Jackson, Malcolm Phillips, Jeff Butterfield, Peter Thompson, Phil Horrocks-Taylor, Dickie Jeeps, Alan Ashcroft, Ronald Syrett, Peter Robbins, David Marques, John Currie, Ron Jacobs, Eric Evans (captain), George Hastings

### Scotland

* 15 February 1958
| Scotland | 12–8 | Australia |
| Stevenson (3 – 1t) Weatherstone (3 – 1t) Smith (6 – 2pg) | | Donald (3 – 1t) Thornett (3 – 1t) Lenehan (2 – 1g) |
* Murrayfield, Edinburgh Attendance: 45,000 Referee: RC Williams (IRFU)
AUSTRALIA: Terry Curley, Kenneth Donald, Jim Lenehan, Saxon White, Roderick Phelps, Arthur Summons, Des Connor, Geoffrey Vaughan, James Brown, Robert Davidson (captain), Tony Miller, Dave Emanuel, Eddie Purkiss, John Thornett, Norman Hughes
SCOTLAND: Robin Chisholm, Arthur Smith (captain), George Stevenson, James Docherty, Thomas Weatherstone, Gordon Waddell, Tremayne Rodd, Hugh McLeod, Norman Bruce, Tom Elliot, Malcolm Swan, Hamish Kemp, Ken Smith, Adam Robson, Jim Greenwood

### France

* 9 March 1958
| France | 19–0 | Australia |
| (3 −1t) Crauste (3 −1t) Quaglio (3 −1t) Rancoule (3 – 1dg) Prat (7 – 2,g1dg) Labazuy | | |
* Stade Colombes, Paris Attendance: 14,236 Referee: NM Parkes (RFU)
AUSTRALIA: Terry Curley, Alan Morton, Jim Lenehan, Roderick Phelps, Otto Fox, Ron Harvey, Des Connor, Geoffrey Vaughan, James Brown, Robert Davidson (captain), Tony Miller, Dave Emanuel, Ken Yanz, John Thornett, Norman Hughes
FRANCE: Michel Vannier, Henir Rancolue, Maurice Prat, Roger Martine, Pierre Tarricq, Antoince Labazuy, Pierre Lacroix, Aldo Quaglio, Robert Vigier, Alfred Roques, Lucien Mias, Michel Celaya (captain), Michel Crauste, Henir Domec, Jean Barthe

## Touring party

* Manager: Terry McLenaughan
* Assistant manager (Coach) : Dave Cowper
* Captain: Bob Davidson
* Vice-captain : Alan Cameron

### Squad

| Name | Tests | Club | Career caps | Tour Apps | Position | Pts |
| Terry Curley | 5 | Newcastle Wanderers | | 34 | Full back | 3 |
| Ken Donald | 4 | Queensland University | 9 | | Three-quarter | 33 |
| Alan Morton | 1 | Randwick | 11 | | Three-quarter | |
| Rod Phelps | 5 | Northern Suburbs | | | Three-quarter | 3 |
| Saxon White | 3 | Sydney University | | | Three-quarter | |
| Jack Potts | 2 | Sydney University | | | Three-quarter | 0 |
| Jim Lenehan | 4 | Wagga Wagga | 24 | 32 | Three-quarter | 114 |
| Otto Fox | 1 | St George | 1 | 16 | Three-quarter | |
| Graham Bailey | 0 | | | 17 | Three-quarter | |
| Ron Harvey | 1 | Newcastle Waratahs | | | Half-back | |
| Arthur Summons | 4 | Gordon RFC | 10 | | Half-back | |
| Des Connor | 5 | Brisbane Brothers | 27 | 27 | Half-back | |
| Don Logan | 1 | Gordon RFC | 1 | | Half-back | |
| Bob Davidson (c) | 5 | Gordon RFC | 13 | 32 | Forward | |
| Kevin Ryan | 1 | Brisbane Brothers | 5 | | Forward | 0 |
| Alan Cameron | 1 | St George RUFC | 20 | 22 | Forward | |
| John Thornett | 4 | Sydney University | 37 | 18 | Forward | |
| Dave Emanuel | 5 | Eastern Suburbs | | | Forward | 0 |
| Norman Hughes | 5 | Sydney University | 14 | | Forward | 0 |
| Geoffrey Vaughan | 3 | Melbourne University Rugby Union | 6 | | Forward | |
| Peter Fenwicke | 2 | Walcha | 6 | 19 | Forward | |
| Ron Meadows | 0 | Newcastle Wanderers | | | Forward | |
| Jim Brown | 5 | Randwick | 9 | 24 | Forward | |
| Nicholas Shehadie | 2 | Randwick | 30 | 24 | Forward | |
| Tony Miller | 4 | Manly RUFC | 41 | | Forward | |
| Ken Yanz | 1 | Gordon RFC | 1 | | Forward | |
| Edwin Purkiss | 1 | Newcastle Wanderers | 3 | | Forward | |
| Bill Gunther | 0 | Molong | | 15 | Forward | |
| Stuart Scotts | | Eastern Suburbs | | | Forward | |
| Jim Phipps | | | 11 | 7 | Three-quarter | |
The team's most experienced centre three quarter Jim Phipps ( 11 caps prior to tour) played 7 of the first 9 games but broke his leg against Glasgow and Edinburgh and did not play again on tour.
The Wallabies played a match in Perth on the way to England during which lock Stuart Scotts broke a wrist and feared he would be left at home. Management decided the six weeks boat trip would give him sufficient time to recover, a decision vindicated by his playing several mid- week games during the tour.

## Sources
### Footnotes

* ↑ Howell p. 154
* ↑ Howell p. 158
* ↑ Howell p. 151
* ↑ Howell p. 104
* 1 2 3 Shehadie pp. 95–102
* 1 2 3 "Scrum.com November on this day". Scrum.com. Retrieved 14 August 2011.
* ↑ London Counties program
* ↑ "Pontypool program". Archived from the original on 27 September 2011. Retrieved 14 August 2011.
* ↑ Newport program
* ↑ Leinster program
* ↑ statistics
* ↑ Glasgow/Edinburgh program
* ↑ Sth of Scotland program
* ↑ "Scrum.com December on this day". Scrum.com. Retrieved 14 August 2011.
* ↑ "Western Counties (Eng) v Australia rugby match 1957".
* ↑ Combined Services program
* ↑ Aberavon program
* ↑ Abertillery program
* ↑ Sth West Counties program
* ↑ Nth East counties program
* ↑ Midland Counties program
* ↑ Barbarians program
* ↑ Planet-Rugby.com Archived 10 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine retrieved 17 September 2009.
* 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Howell