# Harlon Hill Trophy

The Harlon Hill Trophy is an award in American college football given to the individual selected as the most valuable player in NCAA Division II. The award is named for former University of North Alabama and National Football League player Harlon Hill. It was first given in 1986 to Jeff Bentrim of North Dakota State University. It is often considered to be the Division II equivalent of the Heisman Trophy.

## Selection process

Nominations for the trophy are made by sports information directors (SIDs) from the 156 schools that participate in NCAA Division II football. All of the nominees are then presented to a four-member regional Advisory Committee, one for each competition region (Northeast, South, Midwest, and West). Each committee is composed of four SIDs familiar with the process, who select up to six players who they deem worthy of the award, and give their results to the Voting Coordinator.
The 24 players selected in the regional committees are referred to as "Candidates". The regional candidates are then presented to the regions' SIDs, who vote for a first, second, and third place. Each first place vote earns the player three points, while second place votes earn two, and third place votes one point. The top two players selected in each region are the "Finalists" and are placed on a national ballot.
The national ballot is open to all of the SIDs, who vote for first, second, and third place amongst the eight finalists. The top three finishers are invited to the awards presentation held during the Division II Championship weekend on the North Alabama campus in Florence, Alabama. Even though the D-II title game moved to Kansas City, Kansas in 2016, the award ceremony continues to be held in Florence.

## Trophy

The Harlon Hill Trophy is 30 inches (76 cm) and weighs 63 pounds (29 kg). The football on top is a life-size replica of an actual game football and sits on a solid walnut base. The approximate value of the trophy is $2,300. It was created by Herff Jones of Indianapolis, Indiana, which also makes such notable awards as the Heisman Trophy and the Medal of Honor. Each year's winner of the Hill Trophy is awarded a trophy to keep. The original Hill Trophy remains on display in something or somewhere called 'the Shoals' year-round and bears the names of each year's recipient. The award was first presented in 1986.
Replicas of the Harlon Hill Trophy are on display at:
* The College Football Hall of Fame in Atlanta, Georgia.
* The Alabama Sports Hall of Fame in Birmingham, Alabama.

## History

The trophy is named after Harlon Hill, who played at Florence State Teachers College (now the University of North Alabama) from 1950 to 1953, where he was named an NAIA All-American in his senior year. Hill was drafted by the Chicago Bears in the 15th round of the 1954 NFL draft. He played for the Chicago Bears (1954–61), Pittsburgh Steelers (1962), and Detroit Lions (1962). Hill was the NFL's Rookie of the Year in 1954 and its most valuable player in 1955, both voted by the Newspaper Enterprise Association. He was a three-time All-Pro selection between 1954 and 1956.
Through 2009, only three winners have been selected in the NFL Draft. Three-time winner Johnny Bailey was selected by the Chicago Bears in the ninth round of the 1990 draft. Bailey played six seasons in the NFL and was selected to the 1993 Pro Bowl. Ronald Moore was taken by the Phoenix Cardinals in the fourth round in 1993 and played six seasons. Bernard Scott was selected by the Cincinnati Bengals in the sixth round in 2009 and debuted during his rookie season in 2010.
Others were signed in the NFL as undrafted free agents. Two-time winner Danny Woodhead made his NFL debut with New York Jets in 2009. Ronald McKinnon signed with the Arizona Cardinals, where he played from 1996 to 2004. He played an additional season for the New Orleans Saints for a total of ten seasons in the league, recording over 1,000 tackles.
As of 2009, three winners—Johnny Bailey, Jeff Bentrim, and Ronald McKinnon—have been inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame.
Five players have won the award multiple times: Johnny Bailey in 1987, 1988, and 1989, Dusty Bonner in 2000 and 2001, Danny Woodhead in 2006 and 2007, Jason Vander Laan in 2014 and 2015, and Zach Zebrowski in 2023 and 2024. All but one winner (Ronald McKinnon, 1995) have been offensive positions.

## Winners

| Year | Player | School | Position |
| 1986 | Jeff Bentrim | North Dakota State | QB |
| 1987 | Johnny Bailey | Texas A&M–Kingsville | RB |
| 1988 | Johnny Bailey | Texas A&M–Kingsville | RB |
| 1989 | Johnny Bailey | Texas A&M–Kingsville | RB |
| 1990 | Chris Simdorn | North Dakota State | QB |
| 1991 | Ronnie West | Pittsburg State | WR |
| 1992 | Ronald Moore | Pittsburg State | RB |
| 1993 | Roger Graham | New Haven | RB |
| 1994 | Chris Hatcher | Valdosta State | QB |
| 1995 | Ronald McKinnon | North Alabama | LB |
| 1996 | Jarrett Anderson | Truman | RB |
| 1997 | Irvin Sigler | Bloomsburg | RB |
| 1998 | Brian Shay | Emporia State | RB |
| 1999 | Corte McGuffey | Northern Colorado | QB |
| 2000 | Dusty Bonner | Valdosta State | QB |
| 2001 | Dusty Bonner | Valdosta State | QB |
| 2002 | Curt Anes | Grand Valley State | QB |
| 2003 | Will Hall | North Alabama | QB |
| 2004 | Chad Friehauf | Colorado School of Mines | QB |
| 2005 | Jimmy Terwilliger | East Stroudsburg | QB |
| 2006 | Danny Woodhead | Chadron State | RB |
| 2007 | Danny Woodhead | Chadron State | RB |
| 2008 | Bernard Scott | Abilene Christian | RB |
| 2009 | Joique Bell | Wayne State (MI) | RB |
| 2010 | Eric Czerniewski | Central Missouri | QB |
| 2011 | Jonas Randolph | Mars Hill | RB |
| 2012 | Zach Zulli | Shippensburg | QB |
| 2013 | Franklyn Quiteh | Bloomsburg | RB |
| 2014 | Jason Vander Laan | Ferris State | QB |
| 2015 | Jason Vander Laan | Ferris State | QB |
| 2016 | Justin Dvorak | Colorado School of Mines | QB |
| 2017 | Luis Perez | Texas A&M–Commerce | QB |
| 2018 | Jayru Campbell | Ferris State | QB |
| 2019 | Roland Rivers III | Slippery Rock | QB |
| 2020 | Not awarded due to the COVID-19 pandemic. | Not awarded due to the COVID-19 pandemic. | Not awarded due to the COVID-19 pandemic. |
| 2021 | Tyson Bagent | Shepherd | QB |
| 2022 | John Matocha | Colorado School of Mines | QB |
| 2023 | Zach Zebrowski | Central Missouri | QB |
| 2024 | Zach Zebrowski | Central Missouri | QB |

## Trophies won by school

This is a list of the colleges and universities who have had a player win a Hill trophy: Central Missouri, Colorado Mines, Texas A&M–Kingsville, Valdosta State, and Ferris State are tied for the most trophies at 3 each. Eight schools have had two different players claim the award—Bloomsburg, Central Missouri, Ferris State, North Alabama, North Dakota State, Pittsburg State, and Valdosta State. Texas A&M–Kingsville boasts the only three-time winner, Johnny Bailey. Mines is the only program to have three different winners. In total, players from 20 different schools have won a Harlon Hill, while ten schools have more than one trophy.
| School | Trophies held |
| Central Missouri | 3 |
| Colorado Mines | 3 |
| Texas A&M–Kingsville† | 3 |
| Ferris State | 3 |
| Valdosta State | 3 |
| Bloomsburg | 2 |
| Chadron State | 2 |
| North Alabama§ | 2 |
| North Dakota State§ | 2 |
| Pittsburg State | 2 |
| Abilene Christian§ | 1 |
| East Stroudsburg | 1 |
| Emporia State | 1 |
| Grand Valley State | 1 |
| Mars Hill | 1 |
| New Haven | 1 |
| Northern Colorado§ | 1 |
| Shepherd | 1 |
| Shippensburg | 1 |
| Truman | 1 |
| Wayne State (MI) | 1 |
| Colorado Mesa | 1 |
| East Texas A&M‡§ | 1 |
| Slippery Rock | 1 |
†previously known as Texas A&I ‡previously known as Texas A&M–Commerce §currently an NCAA Division I FCS program

## Sponsors

* City of Florence
* Herff-Jones
* Marriott Shoals Hotel & Spa
* OptiNet
* Florence-Lauderdale Tourism