# Miracle Match (Australian rules football)

The "Miracle Match" is the unofficial title given to the Round 10, 1963 Victorian Football League home-and-away match played between Fitzroy and Geelong at Brunswick Street Oval in North Fitzroy on 6 July 1963. The game is most notable for winless Fitzroy defeating eventual premiers Geelong in an unfathomable upset, highlighting what would be Wally Clark's only game as coach. The performance remains held in such fondness that a book commemorating the win was released in 2014, shortly after the match's fiftieth anniversary.
Attended by 16,221 spectators at Fitzroy's home ground, the match was one of the major highlights of the 1960s, wherein the young, inexperienced (and, for the 1963 season, winless) Fitzroy team unexpectedly, comprehensively — and, for some, "miraculously" — beat the experienced and powerful Geelong team, 9.13 (67) to 3.13 (31). The Cats were a team that had finished second on the 1962 VFL ladder, had already won six, and drawn one, of its nine home-and-away matches, and would eventually go on to win the 1963 VFL grand final and premiership.
The game was remarkable for the extensive, detailed, and well-structured team strategies and player-against-player tactics devised by Clark (the stand-in coach-for-the-day), such that, in addition to Fitzroy playing an ideal game on a very muddy and waterlogged Brunswick Street Oval, the Fitzroy players played an inspired and tenacious game that completely nullified the experienced Geelong champions Polly Farmer and Bill Goggin, preventing them from combining their skills with one another and, in addition, kept Geelong's full-forward John Sharrock goalless for the match.
   Today's League game at Fitzroy will see a battle between two acting coaches — Wally Clark for the Maroons and Geelong's Neil Tresize. . . . Everything points to a win for Tresize and the Geelong team, which is after its seventh victory for the season. Fitzroy has yet to win a game this season, and it would be expecting too much of the young players to break through for their first win against a side as high on the ladder as Geelong. The Home side has lost its two most damaging players to the inter-State side, [Kevin] Murray and rover Graham Campbell. The Cats will be without key players in full-forward Doug Wade, and centreman Alistair Lord [both absent with the inter-State side], but they have players capable of filling the gaps adequately. Good Stand-ins New full-forward John Sharrock, in particular, should hold down the full-forward post adequately. He kicked five goals in the last [VFL] match against Richmond and six last week against [a combined Ovens and Murray team at] Albury. Sharper and more confident ball handling, plus strength in and around the packs, should be Geelong's main winning factors. Geelong’s ruckmen, Graham Farmer, John Watts, John Yeates and Fred Wooller, should have little trouble winning the knockouts and holding control in the air. The Age, Saturday, 6 July 1963 (emphasis in original).

## Background

Given that Fitzroy had lost the first nine home-and-away matches in the 1963 VFL season, and with its opponents being the powerful Geelong side that would go on to win the 1963 VFL premiership (14 of whom would play against Fitzroy on that day), nobody gave the Fitzroy team a chance.
The game was predicted to be such a one-sided affair that none of the Melbourne radio stations bothered to send a commentator to broadcast the match.

## Weather

Although the first half of the "split round" matches had been played under relatively good conditions at Victoria Park, Princes Park, and the Junction Oval on 29 June 1963, the heavy rainfall that Melbourne experienced over the ensuing week had seriously affected the condition of all of the VFL grounds on the day of the match.

### Postponement of Round 11

It is also significant that, on the following Saturday morning (13 July 1963) — based upon reports that the majority of the grounds upon which games were scheduled to be played that afternoon "were completely waterlogged" — the VFL’s adverse weather committee made the unanimous decision to postpone all of the Round 11 matches until the following Saturday and, in the process, move each of the season's scheduled rounds to a week later.
The weather that Melbourne experienced over that weekend proved that the committee's decision was well justified — not only did the storms and heavy rainfall cause widespread flooding in the Glenroy (Merlynston Creek) and Elsternwick-Gardenvale (Elwood Canal) areas, extensive power outages over a wide range of suburbs, and the postponement of the entire Grand National Steeple meeting at the low-lying and water-logged Flemington Racecourse, but also forced the closure of the Newport to Altona railway line for several days.

## Venue

In addition to the playing arena itself being rather low-lying and very poorly drained—a situation that meant that whenever there was heavy rain, the Brunswick Street Oval had a strong tendency to be very muddy and seriously waterlogged for weeks on end; the long, thin, and (comparatively) rectangular shape of Fitzroy's home ground, even when completely dry, always demanded significant tactical adjustments in visiting teams, especially those accustomed to playing their matches on wide, and (comparatively) circular-shaped oval football fields such as the Melbourne Cricket Ground.

## Teams

The Fitzroy selectors made eight changes to the previous round's team: five of which were "forced" upon them, and three which were not. The selected team was very inexperienced; it had seven teenagers, and only six members of the team had played more than 18 senior games.
The Geelong selectors made five changes to the previous round's team: two of which were "forced" upon them, and three which were not. The selected team was far more experienced than the Fitzroy team: eleven (including Polly Farmer, with a total of 190 WAFL and VFL games) had played more than 35 senior games over a number of seasons, and fourteen would later play in the 1963 VFL Grand Final and win the 1963 premiership.
The coaches for the day were Wally Clark, the captain-coach of the Fitzroy reserves, and Neil Trezise, the coach of the Geelong reserves. This was the only occasion that either of them ever coached a VFL senior team.
Fitzroy :
| B: | Brian Carroll 22yrs; 2 games | Allen Lynch 24yrs; 53 games | Norm Brown 19yrs; 12 games |
| HB: | Brian Pert 27yrs; 94 games | David Sykes 20yrs; 15 games | Bob Beattie 19yrs; 16 games |
| C: | Wayne Eastman 21yrs; 12 games | John Bahen 19yrs; 18 games | Colin Sleep 18yrs; 6 games |
| HF: | Tony Hirst 18yrs; 1 game | Ron Harvey (c) 27yrs; 118 games | Brian Beers 24yrs; 69 games |
| F: | Max Miers 22yrs; 17 games | Gary Lazarus 17yrs; 9 games | Ian McCrae 19yrs; 10 games |
| Foll: | Bryan Clements 20yrs; 11 games | Ron Fry 26yrs; 4 games | John Hayes 23yrs; 38 games |
| Res: | Barry Fitzgerald 24yrs; debut | Ray Slocum 25yrs; 83 games | |
| Coach: | Wally Clark: Debut as First XVIII coach. | Wally Clark: Debut as First XVIII coach. | Wally Clark: Debut as First XVIII coach. |
Geelong :
| B: | Terry Callan 24 yrs; 51 games | Roy West 22 yrs; 48 games | John Watts 26 yrs; 8 games |
| HB: | Stewart Lord 23 yrs; 43 games | Ken Goodland 22 yrs; 40 games | John Devine 23 yrs; 53 games |
| C: | Hugh Routley 23 yrs; 11 games | Bill Miller 27 yrs; 36 games | Peter Walker 21 yrs; 26 games |
| HF: | Garry Hamer 20 yrs; 30 games | Bill Ryan 18 yrs; 1 game | Ian Williams 21 yrs; 1 game |
| F: | Tony Polinelli 20 yrs; 16 games | John Sharrock 19 yrs; 9 games | John Yeates 24 yrs; 57 games |
| Foll: | Graham Farmer 28 yrs; 14 VFL games 176 WAFL games | Fred Wooller (c) 24 yrs; 104 games | Bill Goggin 22 yrs; 77 games |
| Res: | Brian Brushfield 19 yrs; 7 games | Paul Vinar 23 yrs; 73 games | |
| Coach: | Neil Trezise: Debut as First XVIII coach. | Neil Trezise: Debut as First XVIII coach. | Neil Trezise: Debut as First XVIII coach. |

## Lead-up

On the evening before the match, Wally Clark called all of the Fitzroy players together and quietly, thoroughly, and carefully explained — in very clear, precise, and simple terms — how all of them were to play (collectively) as a team, how each of them was to play as an individual and, in particular, how each of them was to play, on the day, against their specific opponent.
Clark methodically stressed the importance, regardless of the end to which the team was kicking, of attacking along the dryer (northern) grandstand side of the ground, and defending along the far more water-logged (southern) "outer" side of the ground. He demanded that they concentrate on tackling hard and keeping close to their opponents at all times, and that they continuously back each other up — and, as often as they could, use the handball directly to the team-mate that was backing up. In general play, he instructed them to keep their opponents between themselves and the boundary: see, for instance, the two-on-one tackle in the photograph at McFarlane (2014).
He spoke of the degree to which left-footed players such as Polly Farmer, Tony Pollinelli, Garry Hamer and John Sharrock could be destabilised by coming at them from their right side: see for example, the photograph of Norm Brown and John Hayes, coming in together from the centre of the ground, on the right side of the left-footer Garry Hamer, who is on the boundary side of the ground. In particular, he instructed the comparatively inexperienced ruckman, Bryan Clements — whose last 10 senior games, over three seasons (1961–1963) had been with losing Fitzroy teams, and who had been specifically promoted from the seconds for this special reason — to come in from the right side of Farmer at each bounce and boundary throw-in, bump him, and allow the other (even less experienced) Fitzroy ruckman, Ron Fry (in only his fourth VFL game), to go for the hit-out unimpeded and unchallenged.

## Match summary
### Curtain-raisers

On the day of the match Geelong's third XVIII (under-19s) and second XVIII (reserves) had already won their games against Fitzroy, 10.11 (71) to 6.10 (46), and 8.13 (61) to 4.8 (32), respectively.

### Pre-match

Prior to delivering his pre-game address to the team, Wally Clark made sure that each individual player clearly understood and could remember the instructions they had been given on the previous evening.
Clark took the unusual step of opening the Fitzroy rooms to as many of the supporters that could squeeze in — the regular coach, Kevin Murray, routinely excluded all except the players from the change-rooms before the matches and at half-time — and delivered an impressive, inspiring, and stirring speech, continuously interspersed by the ever more raucous cheers and encouragement of the assembled supporters, which sent the players out onto the field fully aroused, motivated, and eager to begin the contest.
       "A key factor in us winning the game was how (Clark) mentally prepared us. The frame of mind we were in was just incredible. We went out there to face Goliath, and they went out there to face David, and that was the difference in the two teams. And that was all because of Wally Clark. I don’t remember running onto the ground, he just had us so worked up. We all played roles on the field, but Wally Clark was the star that day." — Bryan Clements' 2014 recollection of the day.

### First quarter

The Fitzroy captain, Ron Harvey, won the toss and elected to kick, with the breeze, to the (northern) railway end, which also meant that the Fitzroy team's right-hand side was on the comparatively dryer grandstand side of the muddy and waterlogged ground.
"The young Lions . . . [who] were going in for the ball with a ton of determination . . . bewildered the Cats from the start and their marking, handball and teamwork shocked the Cats"; and Fitzroy scored 3.4 (22) — with full-forward Gary Lazarus scoring two goals and forward-pocket Max Miers one goal — with under-pressure Geelong scoring only 6 behinds from eight shots at goal.

### Second quarter

In the second quarter, and kicking against the breeze, "the Lions were hanging on to their [16-point] lead with a grim determination . . . [its] defenders were hurling themselves in for the ball and [Geelong] could not break through" While Fitzroy were able to score three behinds, Geelong, kicking to the scoring end, could only manage a single goal, and Fitzroy went in to the half-time break leading 3.7 (25) to Geelong’s 1.6 (12).

### Half-time

Once again, in a Fitzroy room filled with enthusiastic supporters, Clark delivered an inspiring speech.

### Third quarter

"Fitzroy led by 13 points at half time, and what looked like a possible win became a certainty in the third term as it piled on 5.4 to [Geelong’s] 1.3."

### Final quarter

Despite Geelong's efforts, kicking to the scoring end, the team was only able to reduce its third-quarter deficit of 38 points by two points — scoring 1.4 (10) to Fitzroy's 1.2 (8).

## Reception

According to the football correspondent of The Age, "with eight men in the side who had not played in the previous round, the eager Lions outplayed Geelong in every phase of the game . . . [and] as the game progressed they not only outmarked and outscored the Cats, but also beat them at their own fast, play-on game" — "Fitzroy, winning in nearly all positions, not only "broke the ice" against Geelong on Saturday . . . it shattered it" — and, moreover, he stressed, although the final score seemed to indicate that Geelong, which had "six shots fewer than Fitzroy", had "[fallen] down badly in attack", the real reason for "this inaccuracy" is that it had been "caused by the strong play of Fitzroy's defenders".
Brian Pert was declared the "best on ground" for his outstanding performance in the match.
Given Wally Clark's specific pre-match instructions, it is significant that, not only did "the Lions' plan to nullify star ruckman Polly Farmer . . . [with Clements] bumping Farmer at the throw-ins and bounces while teammate Fry went for the hit out . . . [prove to be] an outstanding success . . . [but also] Farmer's eclipse [not only] made hard work for the Geelong rovers Bill Goggin and Tony Polinelli [but], at the same time, turned Fitzroy rover John Hayes into a damaging player", and, as well, although they kicked a number of behinds (Hamer, one; Sharrock, three, and Polinelli, four), none of Geelong's left-footers scored a single goal during the game.

## Aftermath
### Fitzroy

This extraordinary performance, undoubtedly a consequence of Wally Clark’s meticulous planning, strongly contrasts with the fact that not only did Fitzroy fail to win another match during the entire 1963 home-and-away season and, as well, fail to win a single match in the 1964 season, it did not experience another victory until the second round of the 1965 season under its new non-playing coach, Bill Stephen, who had returned to Fitzroy after spending seven years as captain-coach and, later, non-playing coach of the Yarrawonga Football Club in the Ovens & Murray Football League — in other words, given that Kevin Murray did not coach the team on that day, the Fitzroy team was absolutely winless for Murray's entire two-season and 34-match captain-coach career (1963–1964).

### Geelong

The Geelong Football Club was so concerned about the comprehensive and overwhelming nature of the Fitzroy victory that, three days later, on Tuesday, 9 July 1963, the club convened a special 100-minute meeting between all of the club’s senior players and all of the members of the club's selection committee. Following this meeting, the team won nine of its next ten matches, including the 1963 grand final.

### Wally Clark

In the following season (1964), Wally Clark was appointed captain-coach of the Latrobe Football Club in the Tasmanian North West Football Union. He held the position for four seasons (1964–1967), winning the competition's best-and-fairest award, the Wander Medal, in 1964.