# Gene Kelly Awards

The Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musical Theater, named after the actor/director Gene Kelly, are given out yearly by the Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera. The award was founded in 1991 and celebrates excellence in the musicals of the Pittsburgh area's high schools. Technical/design awards and group awards including Best Musical are awarded in four levels based on production budget. The organization also offers scholarships to high school seniors involved in any aspect of their school's production. As of 2024, there are 33 participating schools. In 2009, the Gene Kelly Awards spawned the National High School Musical Theater Awards, nicknamed "The Jimmys", which Pittsburgh CLO co-produces with Nederlander Presentations. The Awards were cancelled in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Awards in 2021 were limited to individual awards only.

## Categories

* Outstanding Actor
* Outstanding Actress
* Outstanding Supporting Actor
* Outstanding Supporting Actress
* Outstanding Student Artist - Individual or Group
* Outstanding Student Orchestra
* Outstanding Vocal Ensemble*
* Outstanding Dance Ensemble*
* Outstanding Crew/Technical Execution*
* Outstanding Scenic Design*
* Outstanding Costume Design*
* Outstanding Lighting Design*
* Outstanding Musical*
*Awards given in four budget categories

## Participating schools

* Avonworth High School
* Baldwin High School
* Bishop Canevin High School
* Brentwood High School
* Carlynton Jr./Sr. High School
* Central Catholic / Oakland Catholic High Schools
* Chartiers Valley High School
* Deer Lakes High School
* Eden Christian Academy
* Elizabeth Forward High School
* Gateway High School
* Hampton High School
* Keystone Oaks High School
* McKeesport Area High School
* Montour High School
* North Hills High School
* Our Lady of the Sacred Heart High School
* Penn Hills High School
* Pine-Richland High School
* Pittsburgh Allderdice High School
* Pittsburgh CAPA 6-12
* Quaker Valley High School
* Redeemer Lutheran School
* Riverview Jr./Sr. High School
* Serra Catholic High School
* Seton-La Salle Catholic High School
* Sewickley Academy
* Shady Side Academy Senior School
* Springdale Jr./Sr. High School
* St. Joseph High School
* Thomas Jefferson High School
* Upper St. Clair High School
* West Allegheny High School
* Westinghouse Arts Academy
* Woodland Hills High School

## Former participants

* Brashear High School
* Bethel Park High School
* East Allegheny High School
* Fox Chapel Area High School
* Moon Area High School
* North Allegheny High School
* North Catholic High School
* Northgate Junior – Senior High School
* Peabody High School
* Perry Traditional Academy
* Plum Senior High School
* Propel Braddock Hills
* Robinson Township Christian School
* Schenley High School
* Shaler Area High School
* South Park High School
* South Allegheny High School
* South Fayette High School
* Steel Valley High School
* Vincentian Academy
* West Mifflin Area High School
* Winchester Thurston School

## Nominees and winners
### 2024 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Shady Side Academy | All Shook Up Oklahoma! Zombie Prom |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Quaker Valley West Allegheny | Into The Woods The Addams Family Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA | Big Fish The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Pine-Richland Thomas Jefferson | Tuck Everlasting Mamma Mia! Beauty And The Beast |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Saint Joseph Shady Side Academy | Oklahoma! Tarzan Zombie Prom |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Quaker Valley Serra Catholic | Into The Woods The Addams Family The Addams Family |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd Chicago |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Tuck Everlasting Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Saint Joseph Shady Side Academy | Oklahoma! Tarzan Zombie Prom |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Quaker Valley West Allegheny | Into The Woods The Addams Family Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd Chicago |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |
| Best Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Hills Pine-Richland Shady Side Academy Thomas Jefferson Westinghouse | Tuck Everlasting The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Mamma Mia! Zombie Prom Beauty and the Beast Chicago |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Shady Side Academy | All Shook Up Oklahoma! Zombie Prom |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Quaker Valley West Allegheny | Into The Woods The Addams Family Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd Chicago |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Tuck Everlasting Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Saint Joseph Shady Side Academy | Oklahoma! Tarzan Zombie Prom |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Quaker Valley Sewickley Academy West Allegheny | The Addams Family Singin' In The Rain Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd Chicago |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Tuck Everlasting Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Saint Joseph Shady Side Academy | All Shook Up Tarzan Zombie Prom |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Keystone Oaks McKeesport | Into The Woods Anything Goes Joseph... |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd Chicago |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |
| Outstanding Student Artist | Brady Bandik Bree Boyd Kennedy Edwards Sophie Feldhues Abigail Gindlesperger Bailey Linza | Lighting Designer Student Producer Stage Manager Dance Captain Student Director Choreographer | Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills Gateway Our Lady Of The Sacred Heart Elizabeth Forward Saint Joseph | Beauty and the Beast Wonderland Chicago Oklahoma! Big Fish Saint Joseph |
| Best Supporting Actor | Cole Johnston Jack Kelly Leo Matthews Eamonn McElfresh Jack Miller Javian Ortega-Rodriguez | Vice Principal Douglas Panch Chip Tolentino Jud Fry Tobias Ragg Fester Adams Beadle Bamford | North Hills North Hills Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley Pittsburgh CAPA | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Oklahoma! Sweeney Todd The Addams Famils Sweeney Todd |
| Best Supporting Actress | Sophia Burik Kelly Campion Addy Janicki Kayleigh Johnson Rissa Williams Jay Zhu | Rona Lisa Peretti Marie (The Fairy Godmother) Mama Morton Mrs. Potts Beggar Woman Delilah Strict | North Hills Baldwin Westinghouse Thomas Jefferson Pittsburgh CAPA Shady Side Academy | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Cinderella Chicago Beauty and the Beast Sweeney Todd Zombie Prom |
| Best Actor | Zachary Burkovich Mateo Carrasco Tyler Guinto-Brody Severin Harmon Max Peluso Kai Sachon | Shrek Gomez Addams Edward Bloom Cosmo Brown Don Lockwood Sweeney Todd | Penn Hills Carlynton Elizabeth Forward Sewickley Academy Sewickley Academy Pittsburgh CAPA | Shrek The Addams Family Big Fish Singin' In The Rain Singin' In The Rain Sweeney Todd |
| Best Actress | Emma Hopf Hope Johnson Mariana Mangual Lucy Myers Paulina Sanchez Olivia Virgin | William Barfee Mrs. Lovett Dorothy The Witch Roxie Hart Belle | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Seton LaSalle Avonworth Montour Thomas Jefferson | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Sweeney Todd The Wizard of Oz Into The Woods Chicago Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Saint Joseph | Oklahoma Tarzan |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Quaker Valley | Into The Woods The Addams Family |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Westinghouse | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Chicago |
| Best Musical   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Wonderland |

### 2023 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Serra Catholic | All Shook Up Big Fish Little Shop of Horrors |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton Quaker Valley Westinghouse | Disney's The Little Mermaid Anything Goes Joseph... |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Riverview | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Young Frankenstein |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Something Rotten! Anything Goes Seussical |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Redeemer Lutheran | All Shook Up Big Fish Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Carlynton Westinghouse | Grand Hotel Disney's The Little Mermaid Joseph... |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Riverview | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Young Frankenstein |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Something Rotten! Anything Goes Seussical |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Serra Catholic | All Shook Up Big Fish Little Shop of Horrors |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Westinghouse | Grand Hotel 9 to 5 Joseph... |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Riverview Shady Side Academy | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Young Frankenstein Chicago: Teen Edition |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Something Rotten! Anything Goes Seussical |
| Best Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Moon Pittsburgh CAPA Shady Side Academy Thomas Jefferson Westinghouse | Grand Hotel Something Rotten! The Prom Chicago: Teen Edition Anything Goes Joseph... |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Serra Catholic | All Shook Up Big Fish Little Shop of Horrors |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse | Grand Hotel The Prom Joseph... |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Riverview | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Young Frankenstein |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Plum Thomas Jefferson | Something Rotten! Fiddler On The Roof Anything Goes |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Sewickley Academy | All Shook Up Big Fish Big Fish: School Edition |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley Westinghouse | The Prom Anything Goes Joseph... |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Riverview | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Young Frankenstein |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Something Rotten! Anything Goes Seussical |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Mckeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Sewickley Academy | All Shook Up Big Fish Big Fish: School Edition |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Westinghouse | Grand Hotel Freaky Friday Joseph... |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Shady Side Academy | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Chicago: Teen Edition |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | Something Rotten! Anything Goes Seussical |
| Outstanding Student Artist | Anna Boothsby Charlotte Kinslow Linz Thomas David Poirier & Kulthoom Fatema Dinani Jack Cipriani Alexa Custer | Student Lighting Op/On-Stage Role Replacement Understudy for Judy Bernly, Also cast as Roz Keither Technical Lighting Designer Documentarians Advertisement Coordinator/Director Assistant Music Director | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Elizabeth Forward Hampton Moon Pittsburgh CAPA | Grand Hotel 9 to 5 The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Something Rotten! Something Rotten! The Prom |
| Best Supporting Actor | Brooks Brady Primo Brodt-Jenkins Avi Chetlin David Keller Hayden Krupp Eli Wynn | Thomas Nostradamus Harry Bright Trent Oliver Simeon Moonface Martin Thernardier | Hampton Gateway Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse Thomas Jefferson Pittsburgh Allderdice | Something Rotten! Mamma Mia! The Prom Joseph... Anything Goes Les Miserables: School Edition |
| Best Supporting Actress | Ashley Caldwell Annelise Hanson Kenzie Heidenreich Lila Kelley Lucia Palmer Natalie Whitfield | Erma Mayzie Labird Jan Zinnia Wormwood Portia Rosie | Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills West Allegheny Baldwin Moon Gateway | Anything Goes Seussical Grease Matilda Something Rotten! Mamma Mia! |
| Best Actor | Jack Cipriani Amerik Cirota Tyler Guinto-Brody Nathan Marks Ben Stolarz Kai Suyama | Nick Bottom Joseph Quasimodo Dom Claude Frollo Jean Valjean Nick Bottom | Moon Westinghouse Elizabeth Forward Elizabeth Forward Pittsburgh Allderdice Hampton | Something Rotten! Joseph... The Hunchback Of Notre Dame The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Les Miserables: School Edition Something Rotten! |
| Best Actress | Felicity Dicken Isabella Gricar Brylee Hendry Kaitlyn Majewski Rachael Parsons Ava Sandstrom | Judy Bernly Narrator Hodel Natalie Heller/Ed Hope Harcourt Eponine | North Hills Westinghouse Plum McKeesport Thomas Jefferson Pittsburgh Allderdice | 9 To 5 Joseph... Fiddler On The Roof All Shook Up Anything Goes Les Miserables: School Edition |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | McKeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart | All Shook Up Big Fish |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Westinghouse | Grand Hotel Joseph... |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Riverview | The Hunchback Of Notre Dame Young Frankenstein |
| Best Musical   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton Thomas Jefferson | Something Rotten! Anything Goes |

### 2022 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Plum Serra Catholic Westinghouse Arts Academy | The Addams Family Beauty and the Beast The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods Hairspray |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon North Hills Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family Once Upon A Mattress Legally Blonde |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Penn Hills Woodland Hills | How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Little Women Shrek |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Westinghouse Arts Academy | Mary Poppins Bye Bye Birdie The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | The Mystery Of Edwin Drood Into The Woods Hairspray |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon Riverview Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family The Little Mermaid Legally Blonde |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Shrek Shrek |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Plum Westinghouse Arts Academy | Mary Poppins The Addams Family The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Shady Side Academy | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods Pippin |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon Riverview Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family The Little Mermaid Legally Blonde |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Penn Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Little Women Shrek Shrek |
| Best Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Hills Pine-Richland Plum Sewickley Academy Westinghouse Arts Academy | Into The Woods Once Upon A Mattress Shrek The Addams Family Urinetown The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Serra Catholic Westinghouse Arts Academy | Mary Poppins Beauty And The Beast The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods Hairspray |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon North Hills Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family Once Upon A Mattress Legally Blonde |
| Best Vocal Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Shrek Legally Blonde Shrek |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Plum Westinghouse Arts Academy | Mary Poppins The Addams Family The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods Hairspray |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon Riverview Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family The Little Mermaid Legally Blonde |
| Best Dance Ensemble   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland West Allgeheny Woodland Hills | Shrek Legally Blonde Shrek |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Plum Serra Catholic | Mary Poppins The Addams Family Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods Hairspray |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Moon North Hills Thomas Jefferson | The Addams Family Once Upon A Mattress Legally Blonde |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Shrek Legally Blonde Shrek |
| Outstanding Student Artist | Maddie Casella Stella Christensen Jack Cipriani Olivia Holloway Alexander Victoria Thomas Bellows, Lindsey Linsenbigler, Grace Moon, Jaide Moses | Stage Manager Costume Designer Advertising/Video Student Director Stage Manager Dragon Puppeteers | North Hills Quaker Valley Moon Avonworth Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills | Once Upon A Mattress The Little Mermaid The Addams Family The Mystery Of Edwin Drood Hairspray Shrek |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jack Cipriani Andrew Kaehly Isaac McCloy Max Peluso Max Pratley Kai Sachon | Mel Beineke Cinderella's Prince/Wolf Leaf Coneybear Hot Blades Harry Bud Frump Seaweed Stubbs | Moon Hampton Westinghouse Arts Academy Sewickley Academy Baldwin Pittsburgh CAPA | The Addams Family Into The Woods The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Urinetown How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Hairspray |
| Best Supporting Actress | Camryn Hall Mackenzie Heidenreich Lucia Lazzara-Goodrich Teddy McClelland Beth Satariano Molly Virtue | Rona Lisa Peretti Enid Hoopes Amber von Tussle Dragon Lady Larkin Fairy Godmother | Westinghouse Arts Academy West Allegheny Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills North Hills Pittsburgh Allderdice | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Legally Blonde Hairspray Shrek Once Upon A Mattress Cinderella |
| Best Actor | Dominic Difuccia Jack Exline Tyler Guinto-Brody Logan Krushinski Quintin Michalski Nicolas Sperandeo | Shrek Donkey Seymour Krelborn Shrek J. Pierrepont Finch Bert | Woodland Hills Pine-Richland Elizabeth Forward Pine-Richland Baldwin Chartiers Valley | Shrek Shrek Little Shop Of Horrors Shrek How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Mary Poppins |
| Best Actress | Kylie Edwards Isabella Gricar Trisha Holmes Emma Hopf Kaitlyn Majewski Ellie Tongel | Janet Van De Graaf Olive Ostrovsky Fiona Winnifred Donna Sheridan Morticia Addams | Gateway Westinghouse Arts Academy Pine-Richland North Hills McKeesport Plum | The Drowsy Chaperone The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Shrek Once Upon A Mattress Mamma Mia! The Addams Family |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Westinghouse Arts Academy | Mary Poppins The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton | Little Shop Of Horrors Into The Woods |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Thomas Jefferson | Once Upon A Mattress Legally Blonde |
| Best Musical   Budget Category IV | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Legally Blonde Shrek |

### 2021 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | School |
| Best Supporting Actor | Broedy Geary Desmon Jackson Matthew Luckiewicz Maxwell Pratley Dennis Thompson Victor Williams | Westinghouse Arts Academy Woodland Hills Central/Oakland Catholic Baldwin' Woodland Hills Pine-Richland |
| Best Supporting Actress | Elaine Gombos Isabella Gricar Katarina Hudock Leah McConnell Jay Puff Ellie Tongel | Shady Side Academy Westinghouse Arts Academy Pine-Richland Hampton Baldwin Plum |
| Best Actor | Tyler Dumas Tyler Guinto-Brody Zach Kautter Logan Krushinski Jonathan Parker' Caedon Vogel | North Hills Elizabeth Forward Central/Oakland Catholic Pine-Richland Westinghouse Arts Academy Elizabeth Forward |
| Best Actress | Gracie Campbell Georgia Dale Angelina Guadalupe Audrey Logan Ellie Troiani Madison Vogel | West Allegheny Springdale Elizabeth Forward South Fayette Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Penn Hills |

### 2019 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Propel Braddock Hills | Mamma Mia! Once Upon a Mattress Once On This Island |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon North Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Mame The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Seton-LaSalle St. Joseph | Once Upon A Mattress Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat In The Heights |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Elizabeth Forward Hampton | Disney's The Little Mermaid Mamma Mia! Chicago |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Penn Hills West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Addams Family The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Propel Braddock Hills Seton-LaSalle | Once Upon A Mattress Once On This Island Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Hampton Moon | Sister Act Chicago Mamma Mia! |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Penn Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | The Addams Family Guys and Dolls Mamma Mia! |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Allderdice Pittsburgh CAPA Westinghouse Arts Academy | Chicago Tuck Everlasting Guys and Dolls Leader of the Pack Sister Act Footloose |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon Penn Hills West Allegheny Westinghouse Arts Academy Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! The Addams Family The Addams Family Footloose Mamma Mia! |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon North Hills Our Lady of Sacred Heart Westinghouse Arts Academy Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting Once Upona Mattress Footloose Mamma Mia! |
| Best Execution of Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central/Oakland Catholic Elizabeth Forward North Hills Westinghouse Arts Academy West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Chicago Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting Footloose The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |
| Best Execution of Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon North Hills Penn Hills West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting The Addams Family The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |
| Best Execution of Music Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon North Hills Penn Hills West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting The Addams Family The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |
| Best Supporting Actor | Declan Allwein Harrison Bash Tyler Dumas Samuel Kagle Noah Kendall Austin Peters | Nicely-Nicely Johnson Fester Addams Hugo Eddie Souther Willard Hewitt Mr. Mushnik | Pine-Richland Penn Hills North Hills Chartiers Valley Montour Pittsburgh Brashear | Guys and Dolls The Addams Family Tuck Everlasting Sister Act Footloose Little Shop of Horrors |
| Best Supporting Actress | Angelina Guadalupe Olivia Jesse Angel Palladini Rhiannon Passmore Lindsey Sabo Kaylee Skumburdes | Rosie Mulligan Daniela Dragon Sr. Mary Lazarus Alice Beineke Sr. Mary Patrick | Elizabeth Forward St. Joseph Quaker Valley Pittsburgh CAPA West Allegheny Chartiers Valley | Mamma Mia! In The Heights Shrek The Musical Sister Act The Addams Family Sister Act |
| Best Actor | Eric Dickey Trent Edwards Joseph Fish James Fedor Tyler Hepler Preston Proctor | Beast Ren McCormack Billy Flynn Scarecrow Sky Masterson Shrek | Sewickley Academy Westinghouse Arts Academy Hampton Serra Catholic Pine-Richland Riverview | Beauty and the Beast Footloose Chicago The Wizard of Oz Guys and Dolls Shrek The Musical |
| Best Actress | Alyssa Brinza Amariana Busa Diana Craycroft Annie Mihm Ruby Sevcik Morgan Traud | Princess Winnifred Miss Adelaide Maria Roxie Hart Fiona Mame Dennis | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Steel Valley Central/Oakland Catholic Quaker Valley Baldwin | Once Upon A Mattress Guys and Dolls The Sound of Music Chicago Shrek The Musical Mame |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Propel Braddock Hills Westinghouse Arts Academy | Once Upon A Mattress Once On This Island Footloose |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Moon North Hills | Mamma Mia! Mamma Mia! Tuck Everlasting |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Penn Hills West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Addams Family The Addams Family Mamma Mia! |

### 2018 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Redeemer Lutheran Sewickley Academy St. Joseph | Beauty and the Beast The Sound of Music Children of Eden |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Pittsburgh CAPA Plum | Legally Blonde Les Misérables Annie |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Redeemer Lutheran St. Joseph | The Little Mermaid Beauty and the Beast Children of Eden |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Les Miserables |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth West Allegheny Woodland Hills | 1776 The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Allderdice Propel Braddock Hills St. Joseph | The Addams Family Shrek the Musical Children of Eden |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Les Misérables |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Honeymoon In Vegas The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Allderdice Pittsburgh CAPA Plum Sewickley Academy | Nice Work If You Can Get It Oklahoma The Addams Family Les Misérables Annie The Sound of Music |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Plum Woodland Hills | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Oklahoma Les Miserables Annie The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Elizabeth Forward Pittsburgh CAPA Plum West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Legally Blonde Legally Blonde Les Miserables Annie The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Execution of Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central/Oakland Catholic Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA Plum West Allegheny Woodland Hills | A Chorus Line Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Les Miserables Annie The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Execution of Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA Plum West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Les Miserables Annie The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Execution of Music Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Redeemer Lutheran Woodland Hills | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Oklahoma Les Miserables Beauty and the Beast The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Supporting Actor | Joseph Fish Peter J. Kelly Stamerra AJ Prestogeorge Preston Proctor Matthew Thornton Kevin Tinsley | Cookie McGee Bela Zangler Adolpho Sir Dennis Galahad Callahan Robert Martin | Hampton Westingouse Arts Academy Woodland Hills Riverview Chartiers Valley Woodland Hills | Nice Work If You Can Get It Crazy For You The Drowsy Chaperone Spamalot Legally Blonde The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Supporting Actress | Katie Carlson Jane Fusco Angelina Guadalupe Liza Loebig Elena Orban Jenna Yezovich | Edward Rutledge Joan Enid Miss Hannigan Eileen Evergreen The Drowsy Chaperone | Avonworth North Hills Elizabeth Forward Plum Hampton Woodland Hills | 1776 Dames At Sea Legally Blonde Annie Nice Work If You Can Get It The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Actor | Tyler Anderson Michael Brawdy Nasir Butler Tyler Hepler Matthew Hommel Robbie Miller | Jimmy Winter Man In Chair Jean Valjean Will Parker Bobby Child Jack Singer | Hampton Woodland Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Pine-Richland Westinghouse Arts Academy Baldwin | Nice Work If You Can Get It The Drowsy Chaperone Les Misérables Oklahoma Crazy For You Honeymoon In Vegas |
| Best Actress | Chelsea Calfo Sydney Campbell Theresa Hall Johanna Loughran Zoey Myers Jenna Wood | Cosette Janet Van de Graff Elle Woods Cassie Eponine Elle Woods | Pittsburgh CAPA West Allegheny Elizabeth Forward Central/Oakland Catholic Pittsburgh CAPA Chartiers Valley | Les Miserables The Drowsy Chaperone Legally Blonde A Chorus Line Les Miserables Legally Blonde |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Allderdice Redeemer Lutheran Sewickley Academy | The Addams Family Beauty and the Beast The Sound of Music |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA | Legally Blonde Nice Work If You Can Get It Les Misérables |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Oklahoma The Drowsy Chaperone The Drowsy Chaperone |

### 2017 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh Perry | Anything Goes Sister Act You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Elizabeth Forward Hampton | In The Heights Anything Goes Big Fish |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | West Allegheny West Mifflin Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Anything Goes Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy St. Joseph | Little Shop Of Horrors Sister Act Hello Dolly! |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Quaker Valley | Anything Goes Big Fish The Sound of Plaid |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python’s Spamalot |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Our Lady of the Sacred Heart St. Joseph | Little Shop Of Horrors Footloose Hello, Dolly! |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Keystone Oaks | In The Heights Big Fish Footloose |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Hampton North Hills Pine Richland Pittsburgh Allderdice Pittsburgh CAPA | Zorro Big Fish Me and My Girl Joseph and The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Pippin Anything Goes |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Hampton Pittsburgh Barack Obama Quaker Valley West Allegheny | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Big Fish Sister Act The Sound of Plaid Thoroughly Modern Millie |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Elizabeth Forward Hampton West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Anything Goes Big Fish Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python’s Spamalot |
| Best Execution of Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Hampton Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Big Fish Sister Act Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Execution of Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Hampton Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Big Fish Sister Act Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python’s Spamalot |
| Best Execution of Music Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Hampton Pine Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Big Fish Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Anything Goes Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Supporting Actor | Robert Carr Samuel Kagle Zac McDowell Anders Ove Ethan Reed Sam Shadle | Sir Dennis Galahad Beadle Bamford Lefou Lumiere Eddie Souther Horace Vandergelder | Woodland Hills Chartiers Valley Avonworth Avonworth Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy St. Joseph | Monty Python's Spamalot Sweeney Todd Disney's Beauty & the Beast Disney's Beauty and the Beast Sister Act Hello, Dolly |
| Best Supporting Actress | Emma Sue Ewing Alayia Logan Marissa Randall Christina Trocchio Jenna Woods Katherine Zemaitis | Erma Latour Sister Mary Lazarus Sister Mary Patrick Rusty Beggar Woman Inez the Gypsy | Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Chartiers Valley Baldwin | Anything Goes Sister Act Sister Act Footloose Sweeney Todd Zorro: The Musical |
| Best Actor | Nick Cortazzo Tim Dougherty William Huffmyer Devin Moore Jake Pedersen Adam Walker | Zorro Benny Bill Snibson Sweeney Todd Joseph Sky Masterson | Baldwin Central Catholic North Hills Chartiers Valley Pine Richland Riverview | Zorro: The Musical In The Heights Me and My Girl Sweeney Todd Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Guys and Dolls |
| Best Actress | Chelsea Calfo Theresa Hall Chloe Rae Kehm Meredith Kocur Paige Nelson Morgan Traud | Reno Sweeney Reno Sweeney Millie Dillmount Sarah Brown Narrator Luisa Pulido | Pittsburgh CAPA Elizabeth Forward West Allegheny Riverview Pine Richland Baldwin | Anything Goes Anything Goes Thoroughly Modern Millie Guys and Dolls Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Zorro: The Musical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy St. Joseph | Footloose Sister Act Hello, Dolly! |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Elizabeth Forward Hampton | In The Heights Anything Goes Big Fish |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Zorro: The Musical Thoroughly Modern Millie Monty Python’s Spamalot |

### 2016 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | Thoroughly Modern Millie West Side Story Les Miserables |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Elizabeth Forward | Into The Woods Les Misérables 9 to 5 |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine Richland Woodland Hills | Big Fish The Music Man Peter Pan |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | Thoroughly Modern Millie West Side Story Les Miserables |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Hampton | Into The Woods Les Miserables Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine Richland Woodland Hills | Big Fish The Music Man Peter Pan |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | Thoroughly Modern Millie West Side Story Les Miserables |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Quaker Valley | Into The Woods Les Misérables 9 to 5 |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine Richland Woodland Hills | Big Fish The Music Man Peter Pan |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Deer Lakes Hampton North Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA | Big Fish Grease Monty Python's Spamalot Cinderella 9 to 5 West Side Story |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Chartiers Valley Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley | Into The Woods Big Fish Les Miserables 9 to 5 West Side Story 9 to 5 |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Chartiers Valley Elizabeth Forward North Hills Woodland Hills | Into The Woods Big Fish Les Miserables 9 to 5 Cinderella Peter Pan |
| Best Execution of Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Central Catholic Chartiers Valley Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills | Into The Woods Big Fish Fame Les Miserables West Side Story Peter Pan |
| Best Execution of Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Chartiers Valley North Hills Pine Richland Pittsburgh CAPA | Into The Woods Big Fish Les Miserables Cinderella The Music Man West Side Story |
| Best Execution of Music Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Chartiers Valley North Hills Pine Richland Pittsburgh CAPA | Into The Woods Big Fish Les Miserables Cinderella The Music Man West Side Story |
| Best Supporting Actor | Anthony Giancola Lance Joos Keaton Runco Logan Shiller Noah Skowron Alexander Wood | Enjorlas Action Smee Chino Zach Sir Dennis Galahad/Prince Herbert | St. Joseph Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills Pittsburgh CAPA West Allegheny Hampton | Les Miserables West Side Story Peter Pan West Side Story A Chorus Line Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Supporting Actress | Tessa Douglas Jayme Kefalas Meredith Kocur Elizabeth Manuel Ariel Squire Maura Ward | Tiger Lilly Madame Thenadier Beth Roz Keith Rosalia Miss Sherman | Woodland Hills St. Joseph Riverview Quaker Valley Pittsburgh CAPA Central Catholic | Peter Pan Les Miserables Little Women 9 to 5 West Side Story Fame |
| Best Actor | Dustin Butoryak Nick Cortazzo Jakob Hayes Rush Hodgin Devin Moore Paul Watt-Morse | Tony Edward Bloom Javert Harold Hill Jean Valjean Riff | Pittsburgh CAPA Baldwin St. Joseph Pine Richland Chartiers Valley Pittsburgh CAPA | West Side Story Big Fish Les Misérables The Music Man Les Misérables West Side Story |
| Best Actress | Bryce Chisom Elexa Hanner Maddie Kocur Leah Prestogeorge Marnie Quick Malynne Smith | Judy Bernley Anita Jo March Peter Pan Doralee Rhodes Maria | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh CAPA Riverview Woodland Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh CAPA | 9 to 5 West Side Story Little Women Peter Pan 9 to 5 West Side Story |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | Thoroughly Modern Millie West Side Story Les Miserables |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Hampton | Into The Woods Les Misérables Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine Richland Woodland Hills | Big Fish The Music Man Peter Pan |

### 2015 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Perry | SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida Annie |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Northgate Plum Quaker Valley | Mary Poppins Shrek the Musical The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Elizabeth Forward Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone Mary Poppins The Mystery of Edwin Drood |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA | The Addams Family SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Plum Quaker Valley Riverview | Shrek the Musical The Drowsy Chaperone The Addams Family |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Hampton Woodland Hills | Mary Poppins The Addams Family The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart | SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida The Addams Family |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Plum Quaker Valley | Footloose Shrek the Musical The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Mary Poppins Chicago The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Hampton Pittsburgh Allderdice Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA West Mifflin | The Drowsy Chaperone The Addams Family How To Succeed... SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida Shrek the Musical |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Plum Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone Footloose SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida Shrek the Musical The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone Footloose Aida The Drowsy Chaperone Chicago The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best Execution of Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Plum West Allegheny | The Drowsy Chaperone Footloose SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida Shrek the Musical Chicago |
| Best Execution of Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Pittsburgh Barack Obama Plum Quaker Valley West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone SHOUT! The Mod Musical Shrek the Musical The Drowsy Chaperone Chicago The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best Execution of Music Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Plum West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone Footloose SHOUT! The Mod Musical Shrek the Musical Chicago The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |
| Best Supporting Actor | Gavin Carnahan Alexander Conte Peter Heres Mitchell McDermott Robert Miller Dan Schall | Telly/Gavin Moonface Martin Man In Chair Lumiere Man In Chair Pontius Pilate | Bishop Canevin Springdale Quaker Valley Chartiers Valley Baldwin St. Joseph | Godspell Anything Goes The Drowsy Chaperone Beauty and the Beast The Drowsy Chaperone Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Supporting Actress | Erin Daly Susie George Campbell Kurlander Samantha Selleck Christina Trocchio Erin Witt | Alice Beineke Celisse/Susie Smitty Mrs. Tottendale Pugsley Addams Science Officer | Hampton Bishop Canevin Pittsburgh Allderdice Quaker Valley Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Keystone Oaks | The Addams Family Godspell How To Succeed... The Drowsy Chaperone The Addams Family Return To The Forbidden Planet |
| Best Actor | Justin McCord Larry McKay Noah Pepmeyer Adam Rayan Logan Smith Terry Terhune | John Jasper/Mr. Clive Paget J. Pierrepont Finch Ren McCormack Jonas Nightingale Shrek Lord Farquaad | Woodland Hills Pittsburgh Allderdice North Hills Penn Hills Plum Plum | The Mystery Of Edwin Drood How To Succeed... Footloose Leap Of Faith Shrek the Musical Shrek The Musical |
| Best Actress | Emily Matisko Leah Prestogeorge Marnie Quick Maria Scherer Kaylie Wallace Danielle Wolfson | Princess Fiona Edwin Drood/Miss Alice Nutting Orange Girl Wednesday Adams Roxie Hart Janet Van De Graaf | Plum Woodland Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Hampton West Allegheny Baldwin | Shrek The Musical The Mystery Of Edwin Drood SHOUT! The Mod Musical The Addams Family Chicago The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh CAPA | The Addams Family SHOUT! The Mod Musical Aida |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Plum Quaker Valley | Footloose Shrek The Musical The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Drowsy Chaperone Chicago The Mystery Of Edwin Drood |

### 2014 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Perry St. Joseph | The Wiz Seussical Shrek the Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Riverview | Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein Fiddler on the Roof |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Catch Me If You Can Sweeney Todd |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Quaker Valley St. Joseph | The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Shrek the Musical |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Central Catholic Hampton | The Drowsy Chaperone Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Shrek the Musical Thoroughly Modern Millie Sweeney Todd |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | The Wiz Footloose Shrek, The Musical |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Riverview | Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein Fiddler on the Roof |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Man of La Mancha Catch Me If You Can Sweeney Todd |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Hampton North Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Pittsburgh CAPA West Mifflin | Shrek the Musical Young Frankenstein 42nd Street The Wiz Footloose Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA West Allegheny | Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein Thoroughly Modern Millie The Wiz Footloose Catch Me If You Can |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Riverview Woodland Hills | Shrek the Musical Young Frankenstein Thoroughly Modern Millie The Wiz Fiddler On The Roof Sweeney Todd |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Quaker Valley St. Joseph West Allegheny | Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Shrek the Musical Catch Me If You Can |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Quaker Valley St. Joseph | Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein Thoroughly Modern Millie The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Shrek the Musical |
| Best Supporting Actor | Rush Hodgin Noah Baynes Lheureau Drew Praskovich Julius Ralph Quintin Reynolds Michael Zak | Trevor Graydon III Robert Martin Willard Hewitt The Wizard Cain/Japheth Patsy | Pine-Richland Bishop Canevin Pittsburgh CAPA Penn Hills CW North Catholic Central Catholic | Thoroughly Modern Millie The Drowsy Chaperone Footloose The Wiz Children of Eden Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Supporting Actress | Leah Prestogeorge Amanda Rulis Jillian Schmidt Mara Singleton Ashley Sitarik Brooke Taylor | Johanna Barker Inga Muzzy van Hossmere K.C. Downing Addaperle Beggar Woman/Lucy Barker | Woodland Hills Hampton Pine-Richland Plum Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Woodland Hills | Sweeney Todd Young Frankenstein Thoroughly Modern Millie My Favorite Year The Wiz Sweeney Todd |
| Best Actor | Ryan Borgo Connor Cook Tom Currey Peter Heres Adam Rayan Nathanial Yost | Frank Abignale Jr. Benjy Stone Carl Hanratty Pirate King Tinman King Arthur | West Allegheny Plum West Allegheny Quaker Valley Penn Hills Central Catholic | Catch Me If You Can My Favorite Year Catch Me If You Can Pirates of Penzance The Wiz Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Best Actress | Abby Dionise Alexandra Illescas Alexis Loiselle Mallory Millberger Marnie Quick Savannah Wiggins | Miss Dorothy Brown Rusty Millie Dillmount Princess Fiona Tinman Dorothy | Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Pine-Richland St. Joseph Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy Penn Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Footloose Thoroughly Modern Millie Shrek the Musical The Wiz The Wiz |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Quaker Valley St. Joseph | The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Shrek the Musical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Central Catholic Hampton | The Drowsy Chaperone Monty Python's Spamalot Young Frankenstein |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Penn Hills Pine-Richland West Allegheny | The Wiz Thoroughly Modern Millie Catch Me If You Can |

### 2013 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley | Once on This Island In the Heights Anything Goes |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley West Mifflin | In the Heights 9 to 5 Willy Wonka |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Plum Woodland Hills | Hairspray Seussical Young Frankenstein |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA St. Joseph | Honk! In the Heights Seussical |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton Keystone Oaks | Curtains Legally Blonde The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Plum Woodland Hills | The Pajama Game Seussical Young Frankenstein |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA | Honk! Once on This Island In the Heights |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley Keystone Oaks | In the Heights 9 to 5 The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Hairspray Big Young Frankenstein |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Plum Shady Side Academy | The Pajama Game Big Once on This Island In the Heights Seussical West Side Story |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Keystone Oaks Penn Hills Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley | 9 to 5 The Drowsy Chaperone All Shook Up Once on This Island In the Heights Anything Goes |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | Phantom of the Opera In the Heights 9 to 5 In the Heights Anything Goes Young Frankenstein |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Chartiers Valley Keystone Oaks Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Plum | Hairspray 9 to 5 The Drowsy Chaperone Once on This Island In the Heights Seussical |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Central Catholic Chartiers Valley Keystone Oaks Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley | Phantom of the Opera Curtains 9 to 5 The Drowsy Chaperone In the Heights Anything Goes |
| Best Supporting Actor | Greg Arcuri Benjamin Blinn Lucas Grasha Peter Heres Justin McCord Brandon Pent | Edna Turnblad Dennis Adolpho Lord Evelyn Oakleugh Igor Graffiti Pete | Baldwin Penn Hills Keystone Oaks Quaker Valley Woodland Hills Pittsburgh CAPA | Hairspray All Shook Up The Drowsy Chaperone Anything Goes Young Frankenstein In the Heights |
| Best Supporting Actress | Heather Catley Marika Countouris Katie Manuel Michala Williams Jennifer Yeager Molly Young | Sylvia Elizabeth Benning Erma Abuela Claudia Paulette The Drowsy Chaperone | Penn Hills Woodland Hills Quaker Valley Pittsburgh CAPA Hampton Keystone Oaks | All Shook Up Young Frankenstein Anything Goes In the Heights Legally Blonde The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Actor | Austin Adomitis Ryan Borgo Connor Cook Nathan Pool Angelo Ragghianti Michael Zak | Lt. Frank Cioffi Freddy Horton Phantom Usnavi Aaron Fox | Central Catholic West Allegheny Plum Avonworth Pittsburgh CAPA Central Catholic | Curtains Dirty Rotten Scoundrels Seussical Phantom of the Opera In the Heights Curtains |
| Best Actress | Emma Baker Maggie Brooks Rachael Houser Cassie Lombardo Maddie Kocur Katherine Rogers | Christine Daae Tracy Turnblad Reno Sweeney Elle Woods Annie Natalie/Ed | Avonworth Baldwin Quaker Valley Hampton Riverview Penn Hills | Phantom of the Opera Hairspray Anything Goes Legally Blonde Annie All Shook Up |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Barack Obama Pittsburgh CAPA Quaker Valley | Once on This Island In the Heights Anything Goes |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Keystone Oaks | Phantom of the Opera 9 to 5 The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Plum Woodland Hills | Hairspray Seussical Young Frankenstein |

### 2012 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Perry Quaker Valley | How to Succeed... Little Shop of Horrors Guys & Dolls |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Hampton | Sweeney Todd Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Woodland Hills | Curtains My Fair Lady Curtains |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Quaker Valley St. Joseph | How to Succeed... Guys & Dolls Once Upon a Mattress |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Hampton | Sweeney Todd Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | My Fair Lady Avenue Q Curtains |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Catholic Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Quaker Valley | Little Shop of Horrors How to Succeed... Guys & Dolls |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Hampton McKeesport | Sweeney Todd Damn Yankees Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Woodland Hills | Curtains My Fair Lady Curtains |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton Moon North Hills Pittsburgh Brashear Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Allderdice | Damn Yankees Guys & Dolls My Fair Lady Back to the '80s Oliver! 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Bishop Canevin Hampton Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | Sweeney Todd Curtains Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees Guys & Dolls Curtains |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin North Hills Penn Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Woodland Hills | Sweeney Todd Curtains My Fair Lady Beauty and the Beast Oliver! Curtains |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin Central Catholic Hampton Pittsburgh Perry Quaker Valley | Sweeney Todd Curtains Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees Little Shop of Horrors Guys & Dolls |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Sweeney Todd Bye Bye Birdie The Wedding Singer Guys & Dolls Avenue Q Curtains |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jonathan Andrew Zach Houston Adam Johnson Fletcher Jones Vinnie Smith Ben Torisky | Oscar Nicely Nicely Harry McAffee Willard Bud Frump Nathan Detroit | Plum Moon Central Catholic Pittsburgh Barack Obama Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Quaker Valley | Sweet Charity Guys & Dolls Bye Bye Birdie Footloose How to Succeed... Guys & Dolls |
| Best Supporting Actress | Emma Baker Maggie Brooks Elena Falgione Adrianne Knapp Katelyn Maurer Jennifer Yeager | Beggar Woman Carmen Bernstein Lucy Smitty Mae Peterson Gloria | Avonworth Baldwin Winchester Thurston Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Bishop Canevin Hampton | Sweeney Todd Curtains Avenue Q How to Succeed... Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees |
| Best Actor | Connor Doran Jonathan Hewitt Tal Kroser Zander Lyons Michael O'Brien Nathan Pool | Lt. Frank Cioffi Applegate Fagin J. Pierpont Finch Henry Higgins Sweeney Todd | Baldwin Hampton Pittsburgh CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart North Hills Avonworth | Curtains Damn Yankees Oliver! How to Succeed... My Fair Lady Sweeney Todd |
| Best Actress | Nia D'Emilio Abby Dionise Stephanie Higgins Rachael Houser Katie Rogers Brooke Tate | Kate Monster Julia Eliza Sarah Belle Mrs. Lovett | Winchester Thurston Pine-Richland North Hills Quaker Valley Penn Hills Avonworth | Avenue Q The Wedding Singer My Fair Lady Guys & Dolls Beauty and the Beast Sweeney Todd |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Barack Obama Quaker Valley | How to Succeed... Footloose Guys & Dolls |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin Hampton | Sweeney Todd Bye Bye Birdie Damn Yankees |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Hills Woodland Hills | Curtains My Fair Lady Curtains |

### 2011 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Northgate Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Schenley | All Shook Up Little Shop of Horrors Seussical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley McKeesport | Annie Get Your Gun Footloose Pippin |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | No, No, Nanette Les Miserables Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Schenley St. Joseph | Little Shop of Horrors Seussical Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Central Catholic McKeesport | Annie Get Your Gun Fiddler on the Roof Pippin |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Riverview Woodland Hills | Les Miserables Beauty and the Beast Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pittsburgh CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Schenley | Sweet Charity Little Shop of Horrors Seussical |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Central Catholic Chartiers Valley | Oklahoma! Fiddler on the Roof Footloose |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Children of Eden Les Miserables Phantom of the Opera |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Pittsburgh Allderdice Pittsburgh CAPA Plum North Hills Pine-Richland West Mifflin | Urinetown Sweet Charity Footloose No, No, Nanette Les Misérables Seussical |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton North Hills Riverview Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | Fiddler on the Roof West Side Story No, No, Nanette Beauty and the Beast Seussical Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Bishop Canevin North Hills Pine-Richland West Mifflin Woodland Hills | Oklahoma! Annie Get Your Gun No, No, Nanette Les Miserables Seussical Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Hills Pine-Richland Riverview Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | West Side Story No, No, Nanette Les Miserables Beauty and the Beast Seussical Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Hills Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | West Side Story No, No, Nanette Little Shop of Horrors Les Miserables Seussical Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Supporting Actor | Matt Augustyniak Ethan Butler Jake Chavara Peter Sorek Mike Trimm Harrison Wayne | Billy Early Oscar Thenardier Raoul Bernardo Willard Hewitt | North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Pine-Richland Woodland Hills Hampton Chartiers Valley | No, No, Nanette Sweet Charity Les Miserables Phantom of the Opera West Side Story Footloose |
| Best Supporting Actress | Mary Caparosa Nina Danchenko Stephanie Higgins Rehima Jordan Jennifer Rausch Keyanna Taylor-Thomas | Carlotta Mayzie Lucille Early Helene Mme. Thenardier Mayzie | Woodland Hills West Mifflin North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley | Phantom of the Opera Seussical No, No, Nanette Sweet Charity Les Miserables Seussical |
| Best Actor | Jonathan Andrew Patrick Bovo Luke Halferty Zander Lyons Connor McRory Eric Sciulli | Ren Finch Tevye Seymour Ren Phantom | Plum Penn Hills Central Catholic Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Chartiers Valley Woodland Hills | Footloose How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying Fiddler on the Roof Little Shop of Horrors Footloose Phantom of the Opera |
| Best Actress | Maggie Brooks Marika Countouris Megan Hawbaker Kirsten Hoover Adrianne Knapp Cassie Lombardo | Mama Noah Christine Eponine Nannette Audrey Maria | Baldwin Woodland Hills Pine-Richland North Hills Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Hampton | Children of Eden Phantom of the Opera Les Miserables No, No, Nanette Little Shop of Horrors West Side Story |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh Schenley St. Joseph | Little Shop of Horrors Seussical Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Central Catholic Hampton | Annie Get Your Gun Fiddler on the Roof West Side Story |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | No, No, Nanette Les Miserables Phantom of the Opera |

### 2010 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Chartiers Valley North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | Cats Seussical Beauty and the Beast Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Annie |
| Best Costume Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic McKeesport Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Penn Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley | The Wiz The Wizard of Oz Once On This Island Thoroughly Modern Millie Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown |
| Best Lighting Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Central Catholic Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | Cats The Wiz Once On This Island Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Annie |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley Plum West Mifflin | Cats Children of Eden Blood Brothers You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Anything Goes Annie |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Penn Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Riverview | Cats Once On This Island Thoroughly Modern Millie Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Hampton North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | Cats Guys and Dolls Beauty and the Beast Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Annie |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Central Catholic Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Riverview | Cats The Wiz Once On This Island Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall North Catholic Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | Cats Lucky Stiff Once On This Island Children of Eden You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Annie |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jonathan Andrew Connor Doran P.J. McMahon Michael O'Brien Mike Trimm Spencer Whale | Moonface Skimbleshanks Cain Cogsworth Nathan Detroit Lumiere | Plum Balwin-Whitehall Pine-Richland North Hills Hampton North Hills | Anything Goes Cats Children of Eden Beauty and the Beast Guys and Dolls Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Supporting Actress | Katie Colosimo Maddie Georgi Courtney Handlovich Jaslyn Hodge Shayla Mitrick Chelsea Stewart | Yonah Miss Adelaide Jellylorum Sally Rita LaPorta Agnes Gooch | Pine-Richland Hampton Baldwin-Whitehall Pittsburgh Schenley North Catholic Avonworth | Children of Eden Guys and Dolls Cats You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown Lucky Stiff Mame |
| Best Actor | Patrick Bovo Jeff Burgess Johnny Falconi Alex Field Connor McRory Donovan Smith | Jimmy Smith Father Cat In The Hat Tin Man Cat In The Hat Oliver Warbucks | Penn Hills Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Central Catholic Chartiers Valley Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Children of Eden Seussical The Wiz Seussical Annie |
| Best Actress | Jamie Bruno Kirsten Hoover Carly Otte Raychel Shipley Kyleigh Taylor Andrea Weinzierl | Gertrude Belle Millie Dillmount Eve Ti Moune Mame | Chartiers Valley North Hills Penn Hills Pine-Richland Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Avonworth | Seussical Beauty and the Beast Thoroughly Modern Millie Children of Eden Once On This Island Mame |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley | Once On This Island Blood Brothers You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Chartiers Valley Riverview | The Wiz Seussical Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Penn Hills Pine-Richland | Cats Thoroughly Modern Millie Children of Eden |

### 2009 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Chartiers Valley Hampton McKeesport West Mifflin Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz The Wedding Singer Anything Goes Once Upon A Mattress Oklahoma! The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Costume Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Keystone Oaks North Hills Pittsburgh CAPA Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Barnum Oliver! Anna Karenina The King and I The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Lighting Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Avonworth Baldwin-Whitehall Bishop Canevin Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Riverview Woodland Hills | Into the Woods The Wizard of Oz Anything Goes Hello, Dolly! Jesus Christ, Superstar The Wizard of Oz |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley Plum West Mifflin | Oliver! Carousel Anna Karenina Return to the Forbidden Planet 42nd Street Oklahoma! |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Chartiers Valley North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz The Wedding Singer Oliver! Carousel Return to the Forbidden Planet The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Chartiers Valley North Hills Penn Hills West Mifflin Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz The Wedding Singer Oliver! Oklahoma! Oklahoma! The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall North Hills Pine-Richland Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz Oliver! Carousel Anna Karenina Return to the Forbidden Planet The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall North Hills Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz Oliver! Hello, Dolly! Anna Karenina Return to the Forbidden Planet The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Supporting Actor | Luke Halferty Teddy McKenna Connor McRory Nick Ruffing Francesco Salpietro Justin Spittel | General Constantine George Ali Hakim Enoch Snow Cogsworth | Central Catholic Pittsburgh CAPA Chartiers Valley West Mifflin Pine-Richland Pittsburgh Allderdice | Kiss Me, Kate Anna Karenina The Wedding Singer Oklahoma! Carousel Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Supporting Actress | Loni Ben-Zvi Arielle Katcher Christine Lamendola Rachel Miller Marie Popovich Chelsea Stewart | Ariel Carrie Cousin Nettie Holly Wicked Witch Cinderella | Pittsburgh Schenley Pine-Richland Pine-Richland Chartiers Valley Baldwin-Whitehall Avonworth | Return to the Forbidden Planet Carousel Carousel The Wedding Singer The Wizard of Oz Into the Woods |
| Best Actor | Troy Beaudry Timothy DeVita Michael Ellwood Kian McCollum Bobby Podolinski Shawn Russman | Fagin Tin Man Cookie Robbie Hart Father Scarecrow | North Hills Woodland Hills Pittsburgh Schenley Chartiers Valley Vincentian Baldwin-Whitehall | Oliver! The Wizard of Oz Return to the Forbidden Planet The Wedding Singer Children of Eden The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actress | Elizabeth Bailey Kirsten Hoover Teressa LaGamba Caitlin O'Connor Andrea Weinzierl Erin Zarisnak | Anna Karenina Nancy Miranda Dolly Levi Witch Dorothy | Pittsburgh CAPA North Hills Pittsburgh Schenley Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Avonworth Baldwin-Whitehall | Anna Karenina Oliver! Return to the Forbidden Planet Hello, Dolly! Into the Woods The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Catholic Pittsburgh CAPA Pittsburgh Schenley | Anything Goes Anna Karenina Return to the Forbidden Planet |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Avonworth Chartiers Valley Our Lady of the Sacred Heart | Into the Woods The Wedding Singer Hello, Dolly! |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall North Hills Woodland Hills | The Wizard of Oz Oliver! The Wizard of Oz |

### 2008 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton North Catholic Pine-Richland St. Joseph Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Into the Woods Seussical Seussical Once on This Island Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Costume Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Eden Christian Academy North Catholic Perry Traditional Academy Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Narnia, the Musical Seussical Urinetown Seussical Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Lighting Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic North Catholic Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Riverview Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Seussical Seussical Footloose Aida Beauty and the Beast |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Hampton Pine-Richland Plum Taylor Allderdice West Mifflin | Children of Eden Into the Woods Seussical Singin' in the Rain Footloose The Wiz |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic North Catholic North Hills Pine-Richland Plum Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Seussical Dames at Sea Seussical Singin' in the Rain Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin-Whitehall Hampton Keystone Oaks North Catholic West Mifflin Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Into the Woods Brigadoon Seussical The Wiz Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic North Hills Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Schenley Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Dames at Sea Joseph and the Amazing   Technicolor Dreamcoat Seussical All Shook Up Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton North Catholic North Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Into the Woods Seussical Dames at Sea Seussical Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Supporting Actor | Michael Campayno Alex Cosentino Brad Pietryga Nicholas Rushe Ted Stevenson Shaun Umpleby | Gaston Mareb Cosmo Brown Lumiere Lumiere The Wiz | Central Catholic Riverview Plum Woodland Hills Central Catholic West Mifflin | Beauty and the Beast Aida Singin' in the Rain Beauty and the Beast Beauty and the Beast The Wiz |
| Best Supporting Actress | Hannah Belmonte Katie Esswein Maddie Georgi Barbara Johnson Arielle Katcher Teressa LaGamba | Mrs. Potts Joan Little Red Andrea Mayzie Sylvia | Woodland Hills North Hills Hampton Winchester Thurston Pine-Richland Schenley | Beauty and the Beast Dames at Sea Into the Woods Once on This Island Seussical All Shook Up |
| Best Actor | Jaron Frand Cody Hoellerman Jeff Markanich Kian McCollum Bobby Neumeyer Dylan Putas | Adam/Noah Cat in the Hat Joseph Chad Beast Cat in the Hat | CAPA Pine-Richland Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Chartiers Valley Central Catholic Bishop Canevin | Children of Eden Seussical Joseph and the Amazing   Technicolor Dreamcoat All Shook Up Beauty and the Beast Seussical |
| Best Actress | Sarah Chybrzynski Lauren Gigliotti Jane Jeffries Sarah Jane Kirkland Yin Yin Ou Ally Scalo | Belle Gertrude Belle Natalie Ti Moune Gertrude | Woodland Hills Pine-Richland Central Catholic Schenley Winchester Thurston North Catholic | Beauty and the Beast Seussical Beauty and the Beast All Shook Up Once on This Island Seussical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Perry Traditional Academy Schenley | Children of Eden Urinetown All Shook Up |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Hampton North Catholic | Beauty and the Beast Into the Woods Seussical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Dames at Sea Seussical Beauty and the Beast |

### 2007 nominees and winners

The award winners from each category are bolded.
| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Chartiers Valley Pine-Richland Plum South Park Woodland Hills | Bye, Bye, Birdie Sweet Charity Cats The Wizard of Oz Jesus Christ Superstar Les Misérables |
| Best Costume Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Catholic Pine-Richland Plum Robinson Township   Christian St. Joseph Woodland Hills | Pippin Cats The Wizard of Oz The Music Man A Year With Frog and Toad Les Misérables |
| Best Lighting Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Pine-Richland Plum Woodland Hills | Grease Sweet Charity Oklahoma! Cats The Wizard of Oz Les Misérables |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Allderdice Baldwin North Allegheny Pine-Richland Plum Shaler | Bye, Bye, Birdie Bye, Bye, Birdie Oklahoma! Cats The Wizard of Oz Grease |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin North Catholic North Hills Plum Vincentian Academy Winchester Thurston | The Boyfriend Pippin Thoroughly Modern Millie The Wizard of Oz Guys & Dolls Urinetown |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Hills Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Riverview Serra Catholic Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Working Cats The Wizard of Oz The King and I Les Misérables |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley McKeesport North Catholic Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Sweet Charity Crazy for You Pippin Working Urinetown Les Misérables |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Catholic North Hills Plum Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Sweet Charity Pippin Thoroughly Modern Millie The Wizard of Oz Urinetown Les Misérables |
| Best Supporting Actor | Gerard Michael D'Emilio Phil Franks Jeff Markovich Vincent Myers Peter Randolph Francesco Salpietro | Officer Lockstock Moonface Martin Tom Patrick Marius King Charles Munkustrap | Winchester Thurston Keystone Oaks Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Woodland Hills North Catholic Pine-Richland | Urinetown Anything Goes Working Les Misérables Pippin Cats |
| Best Supporting Actress | Anne Arezina Emily Bull Teressa Lagamba Samanta Lerda Jennifer Machen Natalie Schaefer | Berthe Maggie Darlene Love Bombalurina Little Sally Grizabella | North Catholic Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Schenley Pine-Richland Winchester Thurston Pine-Richland | Pippin Working Leader of the Pack Cats Urinetown Cats |
| Best Actor | Justin Fortunato Kurt Giammatti Tim Morgan Connor Mrozowski Corey O'Connor Brad Pietryga | Albert Peterson Fred Graham Jesus Bobby Strong Oscar Scarecrow | Baldwin Hampton South Park Winchester Thurston Chartiers Valley Plum | Bye, Bye, Birdie Kiss Me, Kate Jesus Christ Superstar Urinetown Sweet Charity The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Actress | Christina Bordini Maggie Carr Nicole Dohoda Alix Keil Sarah Jane Kirkland Madison Micucci | Nickie Lilli Vanessi Millie Charity Ellie Laurie | Chartiers Valley Hampton North Hills Chartiers Valley Schenley North Allegheny | Sweet Charity Kiss Me, Kate Thoroughly Modern Millie Sweet Charity Leader of the Pack Oklahoma! |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes St. Joseph South Park | 42nd Street A Year With Frog and Toad Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Plum Winchester Thurston | Sweet Charity The Wizard of Oz Urinetown |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Hills Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Thoroughly Modern Millie Cats Les Misérables |

### 2006 nominees and winners

The award winners from each category are bolded.
| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Hampton McKeesport Pine-Richland Robinson Township Christian Winchester Thurston | My One and Only Oliver Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance The Sound Of Music Hot Mikado |
| Best Costume Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Catholic Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Perry Traditional Pine-Richland Schenley Winchester Thurston | The Wiz Seussical Beauty And The Beast Pirates of Penzance Joseph Hot Mikado |
| Best Lighting Design | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Pine-Richland Serra Catholic Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Damn Yankees Guys & Dolls Pirates of Penzance Children of Eden Hot Mikado Pippin |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton North Allegheny Perry Pine-Richland Plum Schenley | Oliver Guys & Dolls Beauty and the Beast Pirates of Penzance Hello Dolly Joseph |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | McKeesport North Allegheny North Catholic Schenley Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Guys and Dolls The Wiz Joseph Hot Mikado Pippin |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | Hampton McKeesport North Catholic Perry Pine-Richland South Park | Oliver Anything Goes The Wiz Beauty and the Beast Pirates of Penzance Pippin |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Allegheny North Catholic Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Schenley Winchester Thurston | Guys & Dolls The Wiz Seussical Piratez of Penzance Joseph Hot Mikado |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | North Catholic Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Riverview Schenley Winchester Thurston | The Wiz Seussical Pirates of Penzance The King and I Joseph Hot Mikado |
| Best Supporting Actor | Aaron Bova Michael D'Emilio Brad Glasser Jeff Hahn Peter Randolph Mike Washabaugh | Moonface Martin Mikado Charlemagne Nicely Nicely Johnson The Wiz Cogsworth | McKeesport Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills North Allegheny North Catholic Perry | Anything Goes Hot Mikado Pippin Guys & Dolls The Wiz Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Supporting Actress | Christina Bordini Ellen Caparosa Phallon DePante Sarah Jane Kirkland Jennifer Machen Sarah Wahl | Meg Catherine Katisha Narrator Pitti-Sing Lina LeMont | Chartiers Valley Woodland Hills Winchester Thurston Schenley Winchester Thurston Keystone Oaks | Damn Yankees Pippin Hot Mikado Joseph Hot Mikado Singin' In The Rain |
| Best Actor | Christopher Devita Zachary Drylie Justin Fortunato Billy Hepfinger Noah Levin Nathan Sudie | KoKo The King Billy Buck Chandler Sky Masterson Nanki-Poo Father | Winchester Thurston Riverview Baldwin North Allegheny Winchester Thurston Serra Catholic | Hot Mikado The King and I My One and Only Guys & Dolls Hot Mikado Children of Eden |
| Best Actress | Nicole Dohoda Alexandra Jahn Alix Keil Mary Lamb Lindsay Machen Mallory Praskovich | Ruth Miss Adelaide Lola Dorothy Yum-Yum Gertrude | North Hills Penn Hills Chartiers Valley North Catholic Winchester Thurston Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart | Wonderful Town Guys & Dolls Damn Yankees The Wiz Hot Mikado Seussical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the   Sacred Heart Robinson Township Christian Winchester Thurston | Seussical The Sound Of Music Hot Mikado |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Catholic Schenley | Damn Yankees The Wiz Joseph |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Hampton North Allegheny Pine-Richland | Oliver Guys & Dolls Pirates of Penzance |

### 2005 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry St .Joseph Winchester Thurston | Seussical Man of La Mancha Pippin |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Plum Quaker Valley Riverview | Annie Oklahoma Oklahoma |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Once Upon A Mattress Crazy for You Seussical |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Bye Bye Birdie Man of La Mancha Pippin |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Northgate Plum Riverview | Copacabana Annie Oklahoma |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Seussical |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Perry Winchester Thurston | The Pajama Game Seussical Pippin |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Plum Quaker Valley Riverview | Annie Oklahoma Oklahoma |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Seussical |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Plum Taylor Allderdice Winchester Thurston | The Pajama Game Titanic Annie Seussical Pippin |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Chartiers Valley Riverview Schenley Winchester Thurston | 42nd Street Beauty and the Beast Oklahoma Grease Pippin |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Perry Plum Quaker Valley Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Seussical Annie Oklahoma Pippin Seussical |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Schenley Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Grease Pippin Seussical |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny St. Joseph Winchester Thurston Quaker Valley | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Man of La Mancha Pippin Seussical |
| Best Supporting Actor | Ankit Dhir Justin Fortunato Sam Griffin John Ladd Corey O'Connor | J. Bruce Ismay Vernon Hines Ali Hakem Minstrel Cogsworth | North Allegheny Baldwin Riverview Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley | Titanic The Pajama Game Oklahoma Once Upon A Mattress Beauty and the Beast |
| Best Supporting Actress | Jordan DeVaughn Alex Knell Mallory Praskovich Pam Savitz Ilana Toeplitz | Mayzie Alice Beane Ursula JoJo Berthe | Perry North Allegheny Our Lady of Sacred Heart Taylor Allderdice Winchester Thurston | Seussical Titanic Bye Bye Birdie Seussical Pippin |
| Best Actor | Dustin Giffin Billy Hepfinger Ben Johnson Nathan Sudie Tony Venni | The Beast Thomas Andrews Pippin Fagin Tony | Chartiers Valley West Allegheny Winchester Thurston Serra Catholic Penn Hills | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Pippin Oliver Copacabana |
| Best Actress | Heather Hamm Kala Kelly Jeanette Lundel Leigh Michelow Amy Platt | Lola Gertrude Peggy Sawyer Gertrude Cat in the Hat | Penn Hills Perry Central Catholic Taylor Allderdice Woodland Hills | Copacabana Seussical 42nd Street Seussical Seussical |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Serra Catholic Winchester Thurston | Bye Bye Birdie Oliver Pippin |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Quaker Valley Riverview Schenley | Oklahoma Oklahoma Grease |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Woodland Hills | Beauty and the Beast Titanic Seussical |

### 2004 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry Riverview Winchester Thurston | Copacabana Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Elizabeth Forward Our Lady of the Sacred Heart | How To Succeed Oliver Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Joseph Anything Goes |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Copacabana Children Of Eden Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Elizabeth Forward Northgate | How To Succeed Oliver Lil Abner |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | The Music Man Joseph Anything Goes |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Perry Winchester Thurston | Joseph Copacabana Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Schenley South Park | How To Succeed Smokey Joe's Cafe Into The Woods |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Pine-Richland | Anything Goes The Music Man Joseph |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Plum Pine-Richland Schenley Taylor Allderdice | Anything Goes Bye Bye Birdie Joseph Smokey Joe's Cafe Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Schenley Winchester Thurston | Anything Goes Joseph Pirates of Penzance Smokey Joe's Cafe Pirate Of Penzance |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Chartiers Valley North Catholic Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Pippin Footloose Joseph Anything Goes |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Central Catholic Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Schenley | Anything Goes Crazy For You Joseph Pirates of Penzance Smokey Joe's Cafe |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Schenley Winchester Thurston | Anything Goes Joseph Pirates of Penzance Smokey Joe's Cafe Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Supporting Actor | Justin Fortunato Mark Frechione Phil Giammattei John Ladd Eric Ojerholm | Moonface Martin Major General Willard Bud Frump Marcellus | Baldwin Winchester Thurston North Catholic Bishop Canevin North Allegheny | Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance Footloose How to Succeed... The Music Man |
| Best Supporting Actress | Molly Donovan Jenny Fetchko Amy Platt Lara Miller Mallory Mousseau | Portia Bullfrog Erma Ruth Mae Peterson | Brentwood Vincentian Woodland Hills Winchester Thurston Plum | Cinderella Honk Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Lead Actor | Jordan DeBona Phil Duprey Billy Hepfinger Dan Joyner Ben Reed | Leading Player Pirate King Harold Hill Pirate King Joseph | Chartiers Valley Quaker Valley North Allegheny Winchester Thurston Pine-Richland | Pippin Pirates of Penzance The Music Man Pirates of Penzance Joseph |
| Best Lead Actress | Tori Brady Dana Lundquist Katie Maloney Caroline Nicolian Karen Sealy | Rose Alverez Mabel Marian Paroo Lola Princess Winnifred | Plum Quaker Valley North Allegheny Perry Our Lady of the Sacred Heart | Bye Bye Birdie Pirates of Penzance The Music Man Copacabana Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Catholic Perry Winchester Thurston | Footloose Copacabana Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Schenley South Park | How to Succeed Smokey Joe's Cafe Into The Woods |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Quaker Valley | Anything Goes Joseph Pirates of Penzance |

### 2003 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Steel Valley | Oliver The Sound of Music Grease |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley Riverview | Kiss Me Kate West Side Story Guys & Dolls |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | West Side Story Guys & Dolls Hello Dolly |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Northgate South Allegheny Trinity Christian | The Pajama Game Cinderella Fiddler on the Roof |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Brentwood Riverview Seton-La Salle | Smile Guys & Dolls Damn Yankees |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Montour North Allegheny Woodland Hills | Joseph Les Miserables Hello Dolly |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Oliver Honk Joseph |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Chartiers Valley Riverview | Kiss Me Kate West Side Story Guys & Dolls |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | West Side Story Guys & Dolls Hello Dolly |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Perry Pine-Richland Schenley Springdale Winchester Thurston | Once Upon A Mattress Guys & Dolls Lucky In The Rain Godspell Joseph |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Chartiers Valley Riverview Schenley Woodland Hills | West Side Story West Side Story Guys & Dolls Lucky In The Rain Hello Dolly |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Bishop Canevin Pine-Richland Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | West Side Story Kiss Me, Kate Guys & Dolls Damn Yankees Hello Dolly |
| Best Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Riverview Quaker Valley Schenley | West Side Story Les Misérables Guys & Dolls Smile Lucky In The Rain |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Northgate Riverview Woodland Hills | West Side Story Les Miserables The Pajama Game Guys & Dolls Hello Dolly |
| Best Supporting Actor | Joe Balestrino John Graham Dan Joyner Christian Ortiz Ben Reed | Willard Bernardo Pharaoh Thenardier Benny Southstreet | Central Catholic Baldwin Winchester Thurston North Allegheny Pine-Richland | Footloose West Side Story Joseph Les Misérables Guys & Dolls |
| Best Supporting Actress | Jaimie Finseth Kaleigh King Emily McGill Deana Muraco Jenna Noel | Gertrude Stine Eponine Gladys Anita Fantine | Schenley North Allegheny Northgate Baldwin North Allegheny | Lucky In The Rain Les Miserables The Pajama Game West Side Story Les Miserables |
| Best Lead Actor | Trey Compton Alex DiClaudio Ryan Kofford Ryan Ogrondy Quinn Shannon | Javert Sky Masterson Harold Hill Sid Fred/Petrucio | North Allegheny Riverview Plum McKeesport Bishop Canevin | Les Miserables Guys & Dolls The Music Man The Pajama Game Kiss Me, Kate |
| Best Lead Actress | Ashley Gaines Elise Hindmarsh Carolina Nicolian Krystal Prosky Carrie Zosack | Dolly Sarah Brown Princess Winifred Miss Adelaide Babe | Woodland Hills Riverview Perry Riverview McKeesport | Hello Dolly Guys & Dolls Once Upon A Mistake Guys & Dolls The Pajama Game |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Northgate Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Winchester Thurston | The Pajama Game The Sound of Music Joseph |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bishop Canevin Riverview Schenley | Kiss Me, Kate Guys & Dolls Lucky In The Rain |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Woodland Hills | West Side Story Les Miserables Hello Dolly |

### 2002 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Perry Winchester Thurston | Once Upon A Mattress The Bakers Wife Hello Dolly |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Schenley Seton-La Salle | My Favorite Year The Melody Lingers On Miss Liberty |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Pine-Richland Springdale | The Music Man Fiddler On The Roof Peter Pan |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Winchester Thurston | Once Upon A Mattress Godspell Hello Dolly |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Schenley Steel Valley | My Favorite Year The Melody Lingers On Oliver |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Montour Pine-Richland | The Music Man The Will Rogers Follies Fiddler On The Roof |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Winchester Thurston | Where Mystery Lies Once Upon A Mattress Hello Dolly |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Chartiers Valley Schenley | My Favorite Year Footloose The Melody Lingers On |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | How To Succeed... Fiddler On The Roof Evita |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | North Catholic Pine-Richland Plum Schenley South Allegheny | Annie Get Your Gun Fiddler On The Roof Fiddler On The Roof The Melody Lingers On Footloose |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Pine-Richland Schenley | The Music Man Footloose How To Succeed... Fiddler On The Roof The Melody Lingers On |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin Canevin Catholic Chartiers Valley Pine-Richland Springdale | The Music Man My Favorite Year Footloose Fiddler On The Roof Peter Pan |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Chartiers Valley Deer Lakes Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Schenley | Where Mystery Lies Footloose Once Upon A Mattress Godspell The Melody Lingers On |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Pine-Richland Schenley Winchester Thurston | Footloose How To Succeed... Fiddler On The Roof The Melody Lingers On Hello Dolly |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jim DuBois Howard Frankel Matt Gromley Mike Milburn Mike Wilson | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Woodland Hills Schenley Chartiers Valley Schenley | Footloose Evita The Melody Lingers On Footloose The Melody Lingers On |
| Best Supporting Actress | Ashley Gaines Elise Hindmarsh Kaleigh King Angela Machi Katelyn Wood | --- --- --- --- --- | Woodland Hills Riverview North Allegheny Schenley Seton-La Salle | Evita Joseph How To Succeed... The Melody Lingers On Miss Liberty |
| Best Lead Actor | Benjamin Bruni Trey Compton Bernard Eyth Quinn Shannon Benjamin Shaw | --- --- --- --- --- | St. Joseph North Allegheny CAPA Canevin Catholic CAPA | Godspell How To Succeed... Where Mystery Lies How To Succeed... Where Mystery Lies |
| Best Lead Actress | Annie Claffey Kate Dorman Caitlin Reilly Kate Rogal Brittany Taylor | --- --- --- --- --- | North Catholic Perry Seton-La Salle Wichester Thurston Woodland Hills | Annie Get Your Gun The Baker's Wife Miss Liberty Hello Dolly Evita |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Winchester Thurston | Where Mystery Lies Once Upon A Mattress Hello Dolly |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Catholic Schenley | Footloose Annie Get Your Gun The Melody Lingers On |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny Pine-Richland | The Music Man How To Succeed... Fiddler on the Roof |

### 2001 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry South Allegheny Winchester Thurston | Into The Woods Bye Bye Birdie Into The Woods |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Catholic Schenley | The Wiz The Pajama Game Once On This Island |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Montour Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Once On This Island My One and Only On the 20th Century |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry St. Joseph Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods The Music Man The Wizard of Oz |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley Schenley Seton-La Salle | The Wiz Once On This Island Oklahoma |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Montour Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Once On This Island My One and Only On the 20th Century |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Perry | ...Forum Anything Goes Into The Woods |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Chartiers Valley Schenley | Pippin The Wiz Once On This Island |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Plum Springdale Woodland Hills | Annie Get Your Gun The Wizard of Oz On the 20th Century |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA North Catholic Perry Pine-Richland Serra Catholic | ...Forum The Pajama Game Into The Woods My One and Only Joseph |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin CAPA Chartiers Valley Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Schenley | Crazy For You ...Forum The Wiz Anything Goes Once On This Island |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | McKeesport North Allegheny Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Oklahoma Crazy For You Anything Goes Oklahoma On the 20th Century |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA North Allegheny Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Schenley Steel Valley | ...Forum Crazy For You Anything Goes Once On This Island How To Succeed... |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Chartiers Valley North Allegheny Pine-Richland Schenley | ...Forum The Wiz Crazy For You My One and Only Once On This Island |
| Best Supporting Actor | Eric Cheski Ryan Giovengo Boody Ben Reed Cisco Rios Derek Steele | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley CAPA Pine-Richland Woodland Hills Schenley | The Wiz ...Forum My One and Only On the 20th Century Once On This Island |
| Best Supporting Actress | Jenna Noel Caitlin Reilly Megan Rowles Brittany Taylor Enka Taylor | --- --- --- --- --- | North Allegheny Seton-La Salle Serra Catholic Woodland Hills Schenley | Crazy For You Oklahoma Joseph... On the 20th Century Once On This Island |
| Best Lead Actor | Christopher Conte William Hittinger Brendan Murnane Chris Peluso Joshua Reed | --- --- --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Quaker Valley Woodland Hills North Allegheny Perry | Grease Anything Goes On the 20th Century Crazy For You Into The Woods |
| Best Lead Actress | Lindsey Carothers Kate Dorman Jessica Hortert Natalie Nicolian Chelsey Shannon | --- --- --- --- --- | North Allegheny Perry Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Perry Canevin Catholic | Crazy For You Into The Woods Anything Goes Into The Woods Pippin |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Perry | ...Forum Anything Goes Into The Woods |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley North Catholic Schenley | The Wiz The Pajama Game Once On This Island |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Crazy For You My One and Only On the 20th Century |

### 2000 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Winchester Thurston | Secret Garden Lil Abner Grease |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic McKeesport Steel Valley | My Fair Lady Bye Bye Birdie My Favorite Year |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | My Favorite Year Grease The King and I |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Secret Garden Joseph... Grease |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Perry Schenley | My Fair Lady Joseph... Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | My Favorite Year Grease The King and I |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes St. Joseph | Secret Garden Lil Abner Joseph... |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Allderdice North Catholic Steel Valley | Pippin Guys and Dolls My Favorite Year |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Plum Seton-La Salle | My Favorite Year Joseph... Grease |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Plum Schenley South Allegheny Steel Valley | My Favorite Year Joseph... Once Upon A Mattress The Wizard of Oz My Favorite Year |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA North Allegheny Quaker Valley Schenley Thomas Jefferson | Secret Garden West Side Story Grease Once Upon A Mattress State Fair |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Quaker Valley Springdale Steel Valley Woodland Hills | My Fair Lady Grease Annie My Favorite Year The King and I |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic CAPA Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Schenley | My Fair Lady Secret Garden My Favorite Year Grease Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | My Fair Lady Secret Garden Working Grease The King and I |
| Best Supporting Actor | Matthew Bonner-Davis Charles Moneypenny Zach Nadolski Steven Stoyanoff III Vince Ventura | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Quaker Valley North Allegheny Baldwin Canevin Catholic | Secret Garden Grease West Side Story Guys and Dolls My Fair Lady |
| Best Supporting Actress | Tammi Christian Elise Hindmarsh Lucy Spardy Nicole Spardy Sarrah Strmel | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Riverview Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Our Lady of the Sacred Heart North Allegheny | Secret Garden My Fair Lady Working Working West Side Story |
| Best Lead Actor | Andrew Birnie Larry Dailey Chris Gardner Josh Maszle Michael Rizzi | --- --- --- --- --- | Quaker Valley Pine-Richland CAPA Steel Valley Canevin Catholic | Grease My Favorite Year Secret Garden My Favorite Year My Fair Lady |
| Best Lead Actress | Lydia Burns Emily Kramer Ashley Liebmann Angela Machi Chelsey Shannon | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills Schenley Canevin Catholic | Secret Garden Grease The King and I Once Upon A Mattress My Fair Lady |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart St. Joseph | Secret Garden Working Joseph... |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Schenley Steel Valley | My Fair Lady Once Upon A Mattress My Favorite Year |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | My Favorite Year Grease The King and I |

### 1999 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes St. Joseph Steel Valley | How To Succeed... Cinderella Anything Goes |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Into the Woods Hello Dolly |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Hello Dolly Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Steel Valley Winchester Thurston | Mame Anything Goes Anyone Can Whistle |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Into the Woods Hello Dolly |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Hello Dolly Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Perry St. Joseph Steel Valley | Lil Abner Cinderella Anything Goes |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic North Catholic Penn Hills | Into The Woods The Music Man Mame |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Montour Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | South Pacific Hello Dolly Pirates of Penzance |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Pine-Richland Plum Schenley South Allegheny | Into The Woods Hello Dolly My Favorite Year The Wiz Hello Dolly |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | North Allegheny Plum Springdale Steel Valley Woodland Hills | 42nd Street My Favorite Year Grease Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Baldwin North Allegheny South Park Steel Valley Woodland Hills | Oklahoma 42nd Street Oklahoma Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic North Allegheny Plum Steel Valley Woodland Hills | Into The Woods 42nd Street My Favorite Year Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic North Allegheny Plum Steel Valley Woodland Hills | Into The Woods 42nd Street My Favorite Year Anything Goes Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Supporting Actor | Justin Bidula Matt Bolish Justin Gargis Matthew Hydzik Matt Laughery | --- --- --- --- --- | Steel Valley Bethel Park CAPA Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Anything Goes Violet Fiddler on the Roof Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Supporting Actress | Lydia Burns Katie Campbell Karen Clawson Megan Elk Amanda Gillespie | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Seton-La Salle Plum Woodland Hills Quaker Valley | Violet Mack and Mabel My Favorite Year Pirates of Penzance Fiddler On The Roof |
| Best Lead Actor | Liam Bonner Stephen Esper Jason Kaminski Scott Pearson Leo Posteraro | --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Woodland Hills North Catholic Woodland Hills Plum | Into The Woods Pirates of Penzance The Music Man Pirates of Penzance My Favorite Year |
| Best Lead Actress | Lisa Graham Lori Marinacci Courtney Mazza Chelsey Shannon Sarah Strimel | --- --- --- --- --- | Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle CAPA Canevin Catholic North Allegheny | Fiddler On The Roof Mack and Mabel Violet Into The Woods 42nd Street |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | South Allegheny Steel Valley Winchester Thurston | Hello Dolly Anything Goes Anyone Can Whistle |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Into the Woods Hello Dolly |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny Plum Woodland Hills | 42nd Street My Favorite Year Pirates of Penzance |

### 1998 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | South Park St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Makin It Children of Eden Runaways |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Quaker Valley Steel Valley | Crazy For You Pippin Crazy For You |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bethel Park Carlynton Woodland Hills | Pippin Mack and Mabel Man of La Mancha |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes St. Joseph | Children of Eden The Wizard of Oz Children of Eden |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Plum Schenley | Crazy For You Guys and Dolls Anything Goes |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin Bethel Park Carlynton | Barnum Pippin Mack and Mabel |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Perry St. Joseph | Children of Eden The Pajama Game Children of Eden |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Catholic Pine-Richland Seton-La Salle | Godspell Crazy For You Mame |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bethel Park Carlynton Woodland Hills | Pippin Mack and Mabel Man of La Mancha |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park Clairton North Catholic Pine-Richland Steel Valley | Pippin You're A Good Man Charlie Brown Godspell Crazy For You Crazy For You |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Pine-Richland Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Children of Eden Mack and Mabel Crazy For You Mame Man of La Mancha |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park South Allegheny Seton-La Salle South Park Steel Valley | Pippin Annie Mame Anything Goes Crazy For You |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park CAPA Our Lady of the Sacred Heart Pine-Richland Woodland Hills | Pippin Children of Eden Bye Bye Birdie Crazy For You Man of La Mancha |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park CAPA Pine-Richland St. Joseph Woodland Hills | Pippin Children of Eden Crazy For You Children of Eden Man of La Mancha |
| Best Supporting Actor | Dominic Atwater Chris Byers Joel Hayden Chris Moward Scott Pearson | Dominic Tom Thumb Van Buren Cain Padre | North Catholic Central Catholic Thomas Jefferson CAPA Woodland Hills | Godspell Barnum Damn Yankees Children of Eden Man of La Mancha |
| Best Supporting Actress | Kristen Cannon Dominique Dobson Danielle Foanio Charlotte Robinson Paula Taggart | Meg Joice Heth Berthe Mama Noah North Catholic | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Bethel Park CAPA Quaker Valley | Damn Yankees Barnum Pippin Children of Eden Godspell |
| Best Lead Actor | Liam Bonner Kevin Haden Tim Marquette John Sloan Damian Vanore | Barnum Leading Player Bobby Adam/Japeth Applegate | Central Catholic Bethel Park Pine-Richland CAPA Thomas Jefferson | Barnum Pippin Crazy For You Children of Eden Damn Yankees |
| Best Lead Actress | Tonilyn Longo Courtney Mazza Meghan Ott Audrey Pernell Danielle Vetter | Lola Eve Polly Mabel Mame | Canevin Catholic CAPA Pine-Richland Carlynton Seton-La Salle | Damn Yankees Children of Eden Crazy For You Mack and Mabel Mame |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA St. Joseph Winchester Thurston | Children of Eden Children of Eden Runaways |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Catholic Pine-Richland Seton-La Salle | Godspell Crazy For You Mame |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Bethel Park Montour Woodland Hills | Pippin The Wizard of Oz Man of La Mancha |

### 1997 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes South Park | Chess Fiddler On The Roof The Boy Friend |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Schenley Seton-La Salle | Pirates of Penzance Leader of the Pack How To Succeed... |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Baldwin West Mifflin Woodland Hills | Singin In The Rain The Wizard of Oz The Music Man |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Brashear Deer Lakes St. Joseph | Hello Dolly Fiddler On The Roof Fiddler On The Roof |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Pine-Richland | Working Joseph... Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Wiz Guys and Dolls The Music Man |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes St. Joseph | Chess Fiddler On The Roof Fiddler On The Roof |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Elizabeth Forward Schenley Seton-La Salle | Guys and Dolls Leader of the Pack How To Succeed... |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Wiz Guys and Dolls The Music Man |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park CAPA Central Catholic Pine-Richland South Park | Oliver Chess Joseph... Pirates of Penzance The Boy Friend |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Pine-Richland Schenley Woodland Hills | Chess The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Leader of the Pack The Music Man |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Schenley West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Chess The Wiz Leader of the Pack Guys and Dolls The Music Man |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Pine-Richland Schenley Winchester Thurston Woodland Hills | Chess The Wiz Pirates of Penzance Leader of the Pack Guys and Dolls The Music Man |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Montour Pine-Richland Schenley West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Grease Pirates of Penzance Leader of the Pack Guys and Dolls The Music Man |
| Best Actor in a supporting role | Andy Barnes Brian Carothers David Hughey Brent Montone Andy Place | --- --- --- --- --- | Montour Montour CAPA Seton-La Salle Schenley | Grease Grease Chess How To Succeed... Leader of the Pack |
| Best Actress in a supporting role | Christiana Craig Kadia Givner Michelle Johnson Kaaren Terpack Danielle Vetter | --- --- --- --- --- | Seton-La Salle Schenley CAPA Peabody Seton-La Salle | How to Succeed... Leader of the Pack Chess The Wiz How to Succeed... |
| Best Actor in a lead role | Nick Lowery Tim Marquette Jordan Mueller Jacob Ming-Trent Bob Zinsmeister | --- --- --- --- --- | West Allegheny Pine-Richland Carlynton CAPA Montour | Guys and Dolls Pirates of Penzance The Wiz Chess Grease |
| Best Actress in a lead role | Shani Alexander Lydia Burns Nicole Geving Natalie Hatcher Genevieve McHoes | --- --- --- --- --- | Schenley CAPA West Allegheny Carlynton Central Catholic | Leader of the Pack Chess Guys and Dolls The Wiz Joseph... |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes St. Joseph | Chess Fiddler On The Roof Fiddler On The Roof |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Pine-Richland Schenley Seton-La Salle | Pirates of Penzance Leader of the Pack How To Succeed... |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Montour West Allegheny Woodland Hills | The Wiz Grease Guys and Dolls The Music Man |

### 1996 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Montour St. Joseph | Shenandoah Guys and Dolls Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Peabody | Weird Romance Little Shop Of Horrors Hello Dolly |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Woodland Hills | Oklahoma My One and Only The Mystery of Edwin Drood |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | St. Joseph Schenley Shadyside Academy | Jesus Christ Superstar West Side Story City of Angels |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Peabody | Weird Romance Little Shop Of Horrors Hello Dolly |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Woodland Hills | Oklahoma My One and Only The Mystery of Edwin Drood |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Montour St. Joseph Schenley | Guys and Dolls Jesus Christ Superstar West Side Story |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Peabody | Weird Romance Little Shop Of Horrors Hello Dolly |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Oklahoma West Side Story The Mystery of Edwin Drood |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic Pine-Richland Plum Riverview St. Joseph | Little Shop of Horrors Bye Bye Birdie Brigadoon Fiddler on the Roof Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Central Catholic Schenley Seton-La Salle | Weird Romance My One and Only Little Shop of Horrors West Side Story West Side Story |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Central Catholic St. Joseph Woodland Hills | Oklahoma My One and Only Little Shop of Horrors Jesus Christ Superstar The Mystery of Edwin Drood |
| Best Vocal Ensemble | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Moon Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle | Weird Romance Little Shop of Horrors Secret Garden West Side Story West Side Story |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic CAPA Central Catholic Quaker Valley St. Joseph | Oklahoma Weird Romance Little Shop of Horrors West Side Story Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Actor in a supporting role | Andy Artz Damien Lavara John Sloan Matt Smouse Jacen Wilkerson | --- Daniel Gaddis Paul --- Joe Hopkins | Peabody CAPA CAPA Pine-Richland CAPA | Hello Dolly Weird Romance Weird Romance Bye Bye Birdie Weird Romance |
| Best Actress in a supporting role | Rachell Abell Charlyn Booker Jessika Harper Ginny Keyes Danielle Vetter | --- Carol Drayton Nola --- --- | Quaker Valley CAPA CAPA Peabody Seton-La Salle | West Side Story Weird Romance Weird Romance Hello Dolly West Side Story |
| Best Actor in a leading role | Chris Byers Dave Crawford Dave English Jordan Mueller Jacob Ming-Trent | --- --- --- --- Kevin Drayton | Central Catholic Quaker Valley Riverview Carlynton CAPA | Little Shop of Horrors West Side Story Fiddler on the Roof My One and Only Weird Romance |
| Best Actress in a leading role | Chelsea Boyd Jessica Green Courtney Mazza Jennifer O'Loughlin Erin Rhodes | Delphie --- P. Burke --- --- | CAPA Shadyside Academy CAPA Quaker Valley Central Catholic | Weird Romance City of Angels Weird Romance West Side Story Little Shop of Horrors |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | St. Joseph Schenley Shadyside Academy | Jesus Christ Superstar West Side Story City of Angels |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Peabody | Weird Romance Little Shop Of Horrors Hello Dolly |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle | My One and Only West Side Story West Side Story |

### 1995 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Schenley | Once On This Island Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Ain't Misbehavin |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic East Allegheny | Guys and Dolls 1776 Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- | Moon Riverview West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Hello Dolly Once Upon A Mattress Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Shadyside Academy | Once On This Island Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Big River |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Central Catholic East Allegheny Plum Quaker Valley Thomas Jefferson | 1776 Bye Bye Birdie Cinderella Into the Woods Secret Garden |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton West Allegheny Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Steel Valley Shadyside Academy | Once On This Island Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Oklahoma Big River |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic East Allegheny | Guys and Dolls 1776 Bye Bye Birdie |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton West Allegheny Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Bethel Park CAPA Central Catholic Moon St. Joseph | South Pacific Once On This Island 1776 Fiddler on the Roof Cotton Patch Gospel |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Carlynton Seton-La Salle West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Once On This Island 42nd Street Smile Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Schenley Seton-La Salle Shadyside Academy Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Aint Misbehavin Smile Big River Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | CAPA Central Catholic Shadyside Academy West Allegheny Woodland Hills | Once On This Island 1776 Big River Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Actor in a supporting role | Jacob Ming-Trent Justin Morris Michael Casey David Crawford Austin Ireland | Ton-Ton Billy John Dickinson Cinderella's Prince Mana | CAPA Carlynton Central Catholic Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle | Once On This Island 42nd Street 1776 Into The Woods Smile |
| Best Actress in a supporting role | Tanika Harris Rebecca Lee Catherine Craig Katherine Kennedy Danielle Vetter | Mama Maggie Robin Brenda Maria | CAPA Carlynton Seton-La Salle Seton-La Salle Seton-La Salle | Once On This Island 42nd Street Smile Smile Smile |
| Best Actor in a lead role | Shelby Shannon Jason Notaro Zachary Quinto Vince Ponder Eric Rieger | Nathan Julian John Adams Jim Billy | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Central Catholic Shadyside Academy West Allegheny | Guys and Dolls 42nd Street 1776 Big River Carousel |
| Best Actress in a lead role | Jackie Urso Jennifer O-Loughlin Molly Sander Bianca Lucente Courtney D'Ono | Peggy Cinderella Doria Julie Judas | Carlynton Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle West Allegheny Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Into The Woods Smile Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Shadyside Academy | Once On This Island Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Big River |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic East Allegheny Quaker Valley | Guys and Dolls Bye Bye Birdie Into the Woods |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Seton-La Salle West Allegheny Woodland Hills | 42nd Street Smile Carousel Jesus Christ Superstar |

### 1994 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Schenley Shadyside Academy | Pirates of Penzance Once On This Island Once On This Island |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Elizabeth Forward Quaker Valley | Me and My Girl Oliver Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton North Hills Woodland Hills | Joseph... Oliver Annie Get Your Gun |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Moon Shadyside Academy | Pirates of Penzance Joseph... Once On This Island |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Pine-Richland Quaker Valley | Me and My Girl The Music Man Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Joseph... My Favorite Year Annie Get Your Gun |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Schenley Shadyside Academy | Pirates of Penzance Once On This Island Once On This Island |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Pine-Richland Shaler | Me and My Girl The Music Man Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Joseph... My Favorite Year Annie Get Your Gun |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic North Catholic Winchester Thurston | Pirates of Penzance The Boy Friend Joseph... |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Schenley Seton-La Salle Shadyside Academy Woodland Hills | Joseph... Once On This Island My Favorite Year Once On This Island Annie Get Your Gun |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Deer Parks Quaker Valley Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Joseph... Annie Get Your Gun Once Upon A Mattress My Favorite Year Annie Get Your Gun |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Central Catholic Carlynton Schenley Shadyside Academy | Me and My Girl Pirates of Penzance Joseph... Once On This Island Once On This Island |
| Best Supporting Actor | Kevin Finn Justin Morris Zachary Quinto Shelby Shannon Jeff Waag | Artful Dodger Pharaoh Major General Stanley Sir John Lord Brockhurst | North Hills Carlynton Central Catholic Canevin Catholic North Catholic | Oliver Joseph... Pirates of Penzance Me and My Girl The Boy Friend |
| Best Supporting Actress | Dana Greco Meighan Lloyd Brigid Ryan Julie Vara Jamie Wick | Artful Dodger Belle Mae Carroca Queen Aggravain Alice Miller Lady Jacqueline | Elizabeth Forward Seton-La Salle Shaler Seton-La Salle Canevin Catholic | Oliver My Favorite Year Once Upon A Mattress My Favorite Year Me and My Girl |
| Best Lead Actor | Christopher Eccher Michael Martin Michael McGurk Jason Notaro Dan Zitelli | Bill Snibson Fagan Benjy Stone Joseph Pirate King | Canevin Catholic North Hills Seton-La Salle Carlynton Central Catholic | Me and My Girl Oliver My Favorite Year Joseph... Pirates of Penzance |
| Best Lead Actress | Sabrina Gutierrez Jeanne Kim Erin McAdams Jackie Urso Courtney Zilweger | Ti-Moune Ti-Moune Nancy Narrator Marian | Schenley Shadyside Academy Elizabeth Forward Carlynton Pine-Richland | Once On This Island Once On This Island Oliver Joseph... The Music Man |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Schenley Shadyside Academy | Pirates of Penzance Once On This Island Once On This Island |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Quaker Valley Shaler | Me and My Girl Once Upon A Mattress Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Carlynton Seton-La Salle Woodland Hills | Joseph... My Favorite Year Annie Get Your Gun |

### 1993 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Deer Lakes Winchester Thurston | Once Upon A Mattress Oklahoma Little Mary Sunshine |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Peabody | Sound of Music Godspell Into the Woods |
| Best Scenic Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway North Hills Woodland Hills | West Side Story Guys and Dolls Peter Pan |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Central Catholic Deer Lakes Schenley | Once Upon A Mattress Oklahoma Guys and Dolls |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Peabody | Sound of Music Godspell Into the Woods |
| Best Costume Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway West Allegheny Woodland Hills | West Side Story Oklahoma Peter Pan |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | St. Joseph Schenley Winchester Thurston | Jesus Christ Superstar Guys and Dolls Little Mary Sunshine |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Peabody | Sound of Music Godspell Into the Woods |
| Best Lighting Design   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway West Allegheny Woodland Hills | West Side Story Oklahoma Peter Pan |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic North Allegheny North Catholic | Sound of Music Hello Dolly Pippin |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Carlynton Gateway St. Joseph Schenley Woodland Hills | Godspell West Side Story Jesus Christ Superstar Guys and Dolls Peter Pan |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Gateway Seton-La Salle Shaler Woodland Hills | Sound of Music West Side Story Guys and Dolls The Music Man Peter Pan |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Gateway Peabody Woodland Hills | Sound of Music Godspell West Side Story Into The Woods Peter Pan |
| Best Actor in a supporting role | John Bard Kevin Hunt Michael McGurk Don Mudrick Yarone Zober | --- --- --- --- --- | Plum Gateway Seton-La Salle West Alegheny Peabody | Oklahoma West Side Story Guys and Dolls Oklahoma Into The Woods |
| Best Actress in a supporting role | Maddie Carver Sylvia Cosnotti Danielle Garner Melanie Moore Brigid Ryan | --- --- --- --- --- | Riverview Plum Gateway Peabody Shaler | Bye Bye Birdie Oklahoma West Side Story Into The Woods The Music Man |
| Best Actor in a lead role | Mark Cadungog Kevin Hanrahan Jeff Hornak Eric Rieger Brian Salter | --- --- --- --- --- | St. Joseph Shaler Woodland Hills West Allegheny Schenley | Jesus Christ Superstar The Music Man Peter Pan Oklahoma Guys and Dolls |
| Best Actress in a lead role | Katie Byrd Gretchen Cleevely Lisa Marinacci Lyn Philistine Rosie Renn | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Woodland Hills Seton-La Salle Seton-La Salle Gateway | Sound of Music Peter Pan Guys and Dolls Guys and Dolls West Side Story |
| Best Musical   Budget Category I | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | St. Joseph Schenley Winchester Thurston | Jesus Christ Superstar Guys and Dolls Little Mary Sunshine |
| Best Musical   Budget Category II | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Carlynton Peabody | Sound of Music Godspell Into the Woods |
| Best Musical   Budget Category III | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway West Allegheny Woodland Hills | West Side Story Oklahoma Peter Pan |

### 1992 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Schenley Shadyside Academy | The Wizard of Oz Aint Misbehavin Pippin |
| Best Scenic Design   Middle Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Shaler Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Sound of Music Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Scenic Design   Highest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway Keystone Oaks Woodland Hills | The Boy Friend The Wizard of Oz Lil Abner |
| Best Costume Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Schenley Shadyside Academy | The Wizard of Oz Aint Misbehavin Pippin |
| Best Costume Design   Middle Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Quaker Valley Plum Canevin Catholic | The Boy Friend Camelot Into The Woods |
| Best Costume Design   Highest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway Keystone Oaks Woodland Hills | The Boy Friend The Wizard of Oz Lil Abner |
| Best Lighting Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | CAPA Deer Lakes Shadyside Academy | Anything Goes The Wizard of Oz Pippin |
| Best Lighting Design   Middle Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Shaler Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Sound of Music Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Lighting Design   Highest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | East Allegheny Gateway Woodland Hills | 42nd Street The Boy Friend Lil Abner |
| Best All-Student Orchestra | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | North Allegheny North Catholic Thomas Jefferson | Annie Get Your Gun Grease Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Choreography | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | East Allegheny Gateway Schenley Shadyside Academy Woodland Hills | 42nd Street The Boy Friend Aint Misbehavin Pippin Lil Abner |
| Best Crew/   Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | North Hills Deer Lakes Gateway Thomas Jefferson Woodland Hills | South Pacific The Wizard of Oz The Boy Friend Once Upon A Mattress Lil Abner |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Deer Lakes Gateway Shadyside Academy Woodland Hills | Into The Woods The Wizard of Oz The Boy Friend Pippin Lil Abner |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jamie Caridi Chris DeMarco Kevin Hanrahan Michael Keating Brian Thomas | Roger Pappy Yokum Max Scarecrow Evil Eye Fleagle | North Catholic Woodland Hills Shaler Keystone Oaks Woodland Hills | Grease Lil Abner Sound of Music The Wizard of Oz Lil Abner |
| Best Supporting Actress | Melissa Cardello Gretchen Cleevely Danielle Garner Jennifer Halterlein Merica Paris | Bonnie Mammy Yokum Maisie Meg Catherine | CAPA Woodland Hills Gateway Penn Hills Shadyside Academy | Anything Goes Lil Abner The Boy Friend Brigadoon Pippin |
| Best Lead Actor | Wayne Chiaramonte J. Alex Cordaro Bruce Harris Vincent Ponder Jr Eric Watts | Emile Pippin Lead Singer Leading Player Mr. Applegate | North Hills Shadyside Academy Schenley Shadyside Academy Allderdice | South Pacific Pippin Aint Misbehavin Pippin Damn Yankees |
| Best Lead Actress | Emily Belo Erin Locante Christina McCann Meagan Schu Amy Bogel | Annie Sandy Polly Nellie Princess Winnifred | North Allegheny North Catholic Gateway North Hills Thomas Jefferson | Annie Grease The Boy Friend South Pacific Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Musical   Lowest | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Deer Lakes Schenley Shadyside Academy | The Wizard of Oz Aint Misbehavin Pippin |
| Best Musical   Middle Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Canevin Catholic Shaler Thomas Jefferson | Into The Woods Sound of Music Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Musical   Highest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Gateway Keystone Oaks Woodland Hills | The Boy Friend The Wizard of Oz Lil Abner |

### 1991 nominees and winners

| Category | Nominee | Role | School | Musical |
| Best Scenic Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | East Allegheny North Allegheny Penn Hills | Annie My Fair Lady Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Scenic Design   Medium Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Fox Chapel North Hills Shaler | Bye Bye Birdie The Pajama Game Annie |
| Best Scenic Design   High Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Keystone Oaks Upper St. Clair Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Oklahoma Guys and Dolls |
| Best Costume Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley East Allegheny Shaler Area | Chicago Annie Annie |
| Best Costume Design   Medium Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Fox Chapel North Allegheny Penn Hills | Bye Bye Birdie My Fair Lady Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Costume Design   Highest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Keystone Oaks Upper St. Clair Woodland Hills | Anything Goes Oklahoma Guys and Dolls |
| Best Lighting Design   Lowest Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Charties Valley Fox Chapel Plum | Chicago Bye Bye Birdie Fiddler On The Roof'' |
| Best Lighting Design   Medium Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | East Allegheny Keystone Oaks North Hills | Annie Anything Goes The Pajama Game |
| Best Lighting Design   High Budget | --- --- --- | --- --- --- | Shaler Upper St. Clair Woodland Hills | Annie Aint Misbehavin Guys and Dolls |
| Best Choreographer | Renee Ann Keil --- --- --- Tiffany Ellis | --- --- --- --- --- | Chartiers Valley East Allegheny Fox Chapel Plum Schenley | Chicago Annie Bye Bye Birdie Fiddler On The Roof The All Night Strut |
| Best Crew/Technical Execution | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | East Allegheny Fox Chapel Keystone Oaks North Hills Woodland Hills | Annie Bye Bye Birdie Anything Goes The Pajama Game Guys and Dolls |
| Best Direction | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | East Allegheny Fox Chapel Keystone Oaks Plum Woodland Hills | Annie Bye Bye Birdie Anything Goes Fiddler On The Roof Guys and Dolls |
| Best Supporting Actor | Kevin Hanrahan Mike Keating Tony Loverti Josh Reed Richard Wooley | --- --- --- --- Nicely Nicely Johnson | Shaler Keystone Oaks North Allegheny Quaker Valley Woodland Hills | Annie Anything Goes My Fair Lady Working Guys and Dolls |
| Best Supporting Actress | Megan McCarthy Melissa Richtar Tracy Saula Amy Smith Melissa Yankello | --- --- --- --- Dolores | Fox Chapel Keystone Oaks East Allegheny Quaker Valley Quaker Valley | Bye Bye Birdie Anything Goes Annie Working Working |
| Best Lead Actor | Dan Brown Gregory Esper Chris Lynch John McCarthy Jason Nairn Eric Watts | Daddy Warbucks Sky Masterson Henry Higgins Albert Tevye Prince Dauntless | East Allegheny Woodland Hills North Allegheny Fox Chapel Plum Penn Hills | Annie Guys and Dolls My Fair Lady Bye Bye Birdie Fiddler On The Roof Once Upon A Mattress |
| Best Lead Actress | Kristen Arnold Sonya Duree Gaelen Gilliland Ellen Patalski Amanda Temple | Eliza Doolittle Annie Rosie Golde Miss Adelaide | North Allegheny East Allegheny Fox Chapel Plum Woodland Hills | My Fair Lady Annie Bye Bye Birdie Fiddler On The Roof Guys and Dolls |
| Best Musical | --- --- --- --- --- | --- --- --- --- --- | East Allegheny Fox Chapel Keystone Oaks Schenley Woodland Hills | Annie Bye Bye Birdie Anything Goes The All Night Strut Guys and Dolls |