# Miss New Jersey

The Miss New Jersey competition is an annual pageant held to select the representative for the state of New Jersey in the Miss America pageant.
Two Miss New Jersey winners have gone on to hold the title of Miss America: Bette Cooper who won in 1937 and Suzette Charles who did not win, but took over the title for the last 7 weeks of Vanessa Williams's reign in 1984. They also have one unofficial Miss America: Dorothy Hann (1932).
In the fall of 2018, the Miss America Organization terminated the Miss New Jersey organization's license as well as licenses from Florida, Georgia, New York, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and West Virginia. On December 26, 2018; MAO reinstated the license for the Miss New Jersey organization for one year, contingent on leadership changes and the recruitment of new sponsors and board members.
Elizabeth Mendel was crowned Miss New Jersey 2024 on June 8, 2024, at the Superstar Theater in the Resorts Casino Hotel in Atlantic City, New Jersey. She will compete for the title of Miss America 2025.

## Gallery of past titleholders

* Suzette Charles, Miss New Jersey 1983 and Miss America 1984-B
* Toni Georgiana, Miss New Jersey 1985
* Ashley Fairfield, Miss New Jersey 2008, at the 2008 Montclair 4th of July Parade
* Lindsey Petrosh, Miss New Jersey 2012, at the 2012 Philadelphia Thanksgiving Day Parade
* Cierra Kaler-Jones, Miss New Jersey 2014

## Results summary

The following is a visual summary of the past results of Miss New Jersey titleholders at the national Miss America pageants/competitions. The year in parentheses indicates the year of the national competition during which a placement and/or award was garnered, not the year attached to the contestant's state title.

### Placements

* Miss America: Bette Cooper (1937)
* 1st runners-up: Kathryn M. Gearon (1921), Suzette Charles (1984)
* 2nd runners-up: Cheryl Carter (1970), Suzanne Plummer (1974), Therese Hanley (1981), Jennifer Makris (1995), Kaitlyn Schoeffel (2018)
* 3rd runners-up: Ruth Brady (1938), Madeline Layton (1942), Mary D'Arcy (1978)
* Top 10: Emerita Monsch (1924), Emily Borbach (1924), Kathleen Harris (1943), Betty Jane Crowley (1949), Michele Sexton (1994), Victoria Paige (2000), Jill Horner (2001)
* Top 12: Mary Dillinger (1935), Elizabeth Koehler (1935)
* Top 15: Edith Becker (1924), Helen Corcoran (1925), Frances M. Glowaski (1925), Evelynne Jeanne Crowell (1926), Mildred Morlock (1926), Carolyn Pierson (1927), Margo Lundgren (1939), Delores Mendes (1947), Jennifer Farrell (2004), Jade Glab (2020)
* Top 16: June Stephens (1951)
* Top 18: Gertrude Christman (1933)

### Awards
#### Preliminary awards

* Preliminary Evening Wear: Alicia Luciano (2003)
* Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness: Suzanne Plummer (1974), Kathy Nejat (1998)
* Preliminary On Stage Interview: Jade Glab (2020)
* Preliminary Talent: Ruth E. Brady (1938), Suzette Charles (1984), Heather Hertling (1993)

#### Non-finalist awards

* Non-finalist Talent: Marilyn Beryl Rockafellow (1959), Georgia Malick (1963), Linda Gialanella (1973), Debra Naley (1982), Patricia La Terra (1985), Patricia Bowman (1989), Laura Murray (1990), Heather Hertling (1993), Dena Querubin (1996), Kathy Nejat (1998), Stephanie Ferrari (1999), Erica Scanlon (2005), Amy Polumbo (2008)

#### Other awards

* Miss Congeniality: Betty Jane Crowley (1949) (tie), Patricia Condon (1954)
* Amateur Beauty Award: Kathryn M. Gearon (1921)
* Amateur Beauty Award Second Prize: Mary Elizabeth Edwards (1922)
* Amateur Beauty Award Third Prize: Estelle Marks (1922)
* Jean Bartel Social Impact Initiative 2nd runner-up: Alyssa Sullivan (2022)
* Overall Elegance and Lifestyle Award: Alicia Luciano (2003)
* Quality of Life Award Winners: Dena Querubin (1996), Lindsey Gianinni (2016)
* Quality of Life Award 2nd runners-up: Jill Horner (2001), Ashleigh Udalovas (2011)
* Quality of Life Award Finalists: Jaime Gialloreto (2019)

## Winners

* Declared as winner
* Ended as a runner-up
* Ended as a finalist or semi-finalist
| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title | Miss America Talent | Placement at Miss America | Special scholarships at Miss America | Notes |
| 2024 | Elizabeth Mendel | | 22 | Miss South Jersey | | | | |
| 2023 | Victoria Mozitis | Northfield | 22 | Miss Cape Shores | Musical Theater Vocal | | | |
| 2022 | Augostina Mallous | Cape May Court House | 20 | Miss Southern Maritime | Acrobatic Dance | | Miss America Scholarship Foundation For Fundraising 2nd Runner up. | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2017 |
| 2021 | Alyssa Marie Sullivan | Cape May Court House | 25 | Miss Seashore Line | Vocal | | Jean Bartel Social Impact Initiative 2nd runner-up | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2013 |
| 2019–20 | Jade Glab | Belmar | 19 | Miss Central Jersey Beaches | Classical Vocal, "O mio babbino caro" from Gianni Schicchi | Top 15 | Preliminary On Stage Interview Award | Later Miss DC World America 2023 (2RU at Miss World America 2023) |
| 2018 | Jaime Gialloreto | Woolwich Township | 18 | Miss South Shore | Contemporary Jazz Dance, "Natural Woman" | | Quality of Life Award Finalist | Later Philadelphia Eagles Cheerleader |
| 2017 | Kaitlyn Schoeffel | Egg Harbor Township | 24 | Miss Eastern Shore | Dance, "SHUT UP + DANCE" | 2nd runner-up | | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2007 |
| 2016 | Brenna Weick | Mantua Township | 22 | Miss Seashore Line | Vocal | | | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2009 1st runner-up at Miss America's Outstanding Teen 2010 pageant Top 10 at National Sweetheart 2013 pageant |
| 2015 | Lindsey Giannini | Hammonton | 21 | Miss Central Coast | Jazz Dance, "Celebrate" by Pitbull | | Quality of Life Award | |
| 2014 | Cierra Kaler-Jones | Galloway | 21 | Miss Coastal Shore | Dance, "Listen" by Beyoncé | | | |
| 2013 | Cara McCollum | Princeton | 21 | Miss Island Resort | Piano, "White Water Chopsticks" | | | Died on February 22, 2016, after being in a single-vehicle accident a week prior |
| 2012 | Lindsey Petrosh | Egg Harbor City | 23 | Miss Atlantic County | Vocal, "Battle Hymn of the Republic" | | | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2006 |
| 2011 | Katharyn Nicolle | Wenonah | 20 | Miss Coastal Shore | Ballet en Pointe, "Theme from Superman" | | | Previously Miss New Jersey's Outstanding Teen 2008 |
| 2010 | Ashleigh Udalovas | Millville | 22 | Miss All State | Tap Dance, "Star Dancer" | | Quality of Life Award 2nd runner-up | Contestant at National Sweetheart 2007 & 2008 pageants |
| 2009 | Ashley Shaffer | Perrineville | 23 | Miss Columbus Day | Classical Vocal, "Nessun dorma" | | | |
| 2008 | Ashley Fairfield | Egg Harbor Township | 22 | Miss Columbus Day | Jazz Dance, "Man of La Mancha" | | | |
| 2007 | Amy Polumbo | Howell | 23 | Miss Seashore Line | Vocal, "Astonishing" from Little Women | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 2006 | Georgine DiMaria | Lodi | 22 | Miss All State | Violin, "Csárdás" by Vittorio Monti | | | Contestant at National Sweetheart 2004 pageant. Georgine M. DiMaria died at home in Lodi, N.J. at age 37 on August 28, 2021. |
| 2005 | Julie Robenhymer | Moorestown | 24 | Miss Burlington County | Dance, "Hit Me With a Hot Note" from Sophisticated Ladies | | | |
| 2004 | Erica Scanlon | Pitman | 22 | Miss Brigantine Resort | Vocal, "Glitter & Be Gay" from Candide | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 2003 | Jennifer Farrell | Margate | 19 | Miss Atlantic County | Ballet en Pointe, "Via Dolorosa" | Top 15 | | |
| 2002 | Alicia Luciano | Stanhope | 19 | Miss Tri County | Lyrical Dance, "The Prayer" | | Overall Elegance and Lifestyle Award Preliminary Evening Wear Award | Former Radio City Rockette |
| 2001 | Julie Barber | Vineland | 24 | Miss Union County | Ballet en Pointe, "Do You Wanna Dance?" | | | |
| 2000 | Jill Horner | Gloucester Township | 21 | Miss Monmouth County Area | Vocal, "You're Gonna Hear From Me" from Inside Daisy Clover | Top 10 | Quality of Life Award 2nd runner-up | |
| 1999 | Victoria Paige | Sparta | 20 | Miss Watchung Valley | Classical Vocal, "Non so più cosa son" from The Marriage of Figaro | Top 10 | | |
| 1998 | Stephanie Ferrari | Glen Rock | 24 | Miss Bergen County | Vocal, "My Heart Will Go On" | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1997 | Kathy Nejat | Voorhees | 21 | Miss Central Coast | Classical Ballet en Pointe, "The Dying Swan" | | Non-finalist Talent Award Preliminary Swimsuit Award | |
| 1996 | Melanie Bell | Vernon | 20 | Miss Northern Lights | Dance, "They Can't Take That Away From Me" | | | |
| 1995 | Dena Querubin | Waterford | 23 | Miss Spring Lake Heights | Classical Piano | | Non-finalist Talent Award Quality of Life Award | Now known as Dena Blizzard, comedienne and often host of Miss America preliminary competition |
| 1994 | Jennifer Makris | Cherry Hill | 21 | Miss Essex County | Jazz Vocal, "The Man that Got Away" | 2nd runner-up | | Later Miss New Jersey USA 1997 Top 10 at Miss USA 1997 pageant |
| 1993 | Michele Sexton | Spring Lake Heights | 24 | Miss Central Coast | Classical Vocal, "Vissi d'arte" | Top 10 | | |
| 1992 | Heather Hertling | Randolph | 24 | Miss Morris County | Classical Vocal, "Ernani Involami" | | Non-finalist Talent Award Preliminary Talent Award | Judge at the Miss America 1997 pageant |
| 1991 | Amy Fissel | Ocean City | 24 | Miss Shore Resort | Comedic Monologue, "Mountaineer's Motorcycle" | | | Later Miss New Jersey USA 1993 Top 6 at Miss USA 1993 pageant |
| 1990 | Lynette Falls | Ridgewood | 25 | Miss Camden County | Classical Piano, "4th Movement of Piano Sonata No. 1, Op. 22" by Alberto Ginastera | | | Mother of Miss Louisiana 2017, Laryssa Bonacquisti |
| 1989 | Laura Murray | Livingston | 25 | Miss Shore Resort | Popular Vocal, "With One More Look At You" from A Star Is Born | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1988 | Patricia Bowman | Ocean City | 19 | Miss Cape May County | Vocal, "Wind Beneath My Wings" | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1987 | Robin Lange | Medford | 22 | Miss Burlington County | Dramatic Monologue | | | |
| 1986 | Karyn Zosche | Pine Brook | 25 | Miss Passaic County | Piano, Rhapsody in Blue | | | |
| 1985 | Toni Georgiana | Cherry Hill | 21 | Miss Mercer County | Acrobatic Dance, "Slaughter on Tenth Avenue" | | | |
| 1984 | Patricia La Terra | West New York | 24 | Miss Bergen County | Dramatic Monologue | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1983 | Suzette Charles | Mays Landing | 20 | Miss Columbus Day | Popular Vocal, "Kiss Me In the Rain" | 1st runner-up | Preliminary Talent Award | Named Miss America when Vanessa Williams relinquished title |
| 1982 | Christina Criscione | Pequannock | 22 | Miss Dover-Morris | Classical Vocal, "Non Piu Mesta" from La Cenerentola | | | |
| 1981 | Debra Naley | Rockaway | 26 | Miss Greater Dover-West Morris | Violin Medley, "Csárdás" & "Orange Blossom Special" | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1980 | Therese Hanley | Jersey City | 17 | Miss Bergen County | Popular Vocal, "Starting Here, Starting Now" | 2nd runner-up (tie) | |
| 1979 | Mary McGinnis | Somers Point | 22 | Miss Collegiate | Clarinet, "Hora" | | | |
| 1978 | Laurie Berchtold | Ocean City | 21 | Miss Glassboro State College | Vocal, "Money, Money" from Cabaret | | | |
| 1977 | Mary D'Arcy | Yardville | 21 | Miss Glassboro State College | Semi-classical Vocal, "Summertime" | 3rd runner-up | | Judge at the Miss America 1991 pageant |
| 1976 | Lori Johnson | Medford | 19 | Miss Burlington County | Acrobatic Dance, "Love Is the Answer" | | | |
| 1975 | Nancy Craig | Trenton | 25 | Miss Trenton State College | Classical Ballet en Pointe, Swan Lake | | | |
| 1974 | Elizabeth Bracken | Mahwah | 21 | Miss Bergen County | Dramatic monologue, "Elizabeth Umpstead" by Carl Sandburg | | | |
| 1973 | Suzanne Plummer | Wildwood | 21 | Miss Cape May County | Piano, "Stardust" | 2nd runner-up | Preliminary Swimsuit Award | Previously Miss District of Columbia USA 1971 Top 12 at Miss USA 1971 pageant Former leader of Nevada State Republican Party and 2010 Senate Candidate |
| 1972 | Linda Gialanella | Maplewood | 22 | Miss Fanwood-Scotch Plains | Sketching Presentation, "Teaching the World to Draw" | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1971 | Lynn Hackerman | Mount Laurel | 18 | Miss Greater Moorestown & Miss Burlington County | Pantomime Dance | | | Formerly served on the Miss America board of directors with Sam Haskell |
| 1970 | Hela Yungst | Hillside | 20 | Miss Fanwood-Scotch Plains | Dramatic Vocal, "Aldonza" from Man of La Mancha | | | |
| 1969 | Cheryl Carter | Matawan | 19 | Miss Monmouth County | Piano, Theme from An Affair to Remember | 2nd runner-up (tie) | | |
| 1968 | Jeannette Phillipuk | Laurel Springs | 20 | Miss Glassboro State College | Vocal Medley, "The Sweetest Sounds" & "Nobody Told Me" from No Strings | | | |
| 1967 | Linda Ann Wilmer | Laurel Springs | 18 | Miss Glassboro State College | Classical Vocal, "Quando m'en vò" from La bohème | | | |
| 1966 | Christine Ebright | Rahway | 19 | Miss Newark State College | Operatic Vocal, "Un bel di vedremo" | | | |
| 1965 | Kathleen Holmes | Toms River | 19 | Miss Toms River | Vocal / Tap Dance, "Steppin' Out with My Baby" | | | |
| 1964 | Susan Krasnomowitz | Fair Lawn | 19 | Miss Paterson | Jazz Dance | | | |
| 1963 | Janet Bryan Adams | Hopatcong | | Miss Pequannock | Dramatic Monologue | | | |
| 1962 | Georgia Malick | Cherry Hill | 18 | Miss Cherry Hill | Piano, "Deep Purple" | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1961 | Marilyn Haufler | Watchung | 18 | Miss Fanwood-Scotch Plains | Comedic Monologue | | | |
| 1960 | Ann Barber | Westfield | 18 | Miss Fanwood-Scotch Plains | | | | |
| 1959 | Beverly Ann Domareki | Mountainside | 20 | | Original Dramatic Interpretation of a Beatnik | | | |
| 1958 | Marilyn Beryl Rockafellow | New Monmouth | 19 | | Vocal | | Non-finalist Talent Award | |
| 1957 | Janet Ressler | Union | | | Vocal | | | |
| 1956 | Beverly Cass | Fair Lawn | | | Piano | | | |
| 1955 | Patricia Campbell | Camden | | | Dance | | | |
| 1954 | Sally Joan Waller | West Orange | | | Vocal / Dance, "Singin' in the Rain" | | | Sally Joan "Joni" Waller Jaeger died at age 87 on March 16, 2024. |
| 1953 | Patricia Condon | Maplewood | | | Vocal | | Miss Congeniality | |
| 1952 | Mary Parker | Gibbsboro | | | Drama | | | |
| 1951 | Bernice Massi | Camden | | | | | | |
| 1950 | June Stephens | Ship Bottom | | | Comic Sketch, "The Older Set" | Top 16 | | |
| 1949 | Betty Jane Crowley | Green Bank | | | Poetry Recitation & Vocal, "Might Like a Rose" | Top 15 | Miss Congeniality (tie) | |
| 1948 | Barbara Anderson | Bloomfield | | | | | | |
| 1947 | Delores Mendes | Newark | | | Vocal & Guitar medley, "I Close My Eyes" & "Siboney" | Top 15 | | |
| 1946 | Helen Sprinitis | Kearny | | | | | | |
| 1945 | Matilda Agin | New Brunswick | | | | | | |
| 1944 | Janice Hansen | Union City | | | | | | |
| 1943 | Kathleen Harris | Newark | | | Vocal, "Gianni Mio" | Top 10 | | |
| 1942 | Madeline Layton | Maywood | | | Vocal, "Saturday Night" | 3rd runner-up | | |
| 1941 | Marjorie Eleanor Jennings | Dover | | | | | | |
| 1940 | Mildred Marie Selko | Kearny | | | | | | |
| 1939 | Kathleen Kirkland | Maplewood | | | | N/A | N/A | |
| 1939 | Margo Lundgren | Harrison | | | Whistling Tunes Vocal, "Don't Worry About Me" | Top 15 | | |
| 1938 | Ruth E. Brady | Asbury Park | | Miss Asbury Park | Vocal & Tap Dance | 3rd runner-up | Preliminary Talent Award | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1938 | Ruth Joan Sada | Burlington | | Miss Burlington | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1938 | Gloria Martha Riley | Paterson | | Miss New Jersey | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1938 | Dorothy Kathryn Powers | Riverside | | Miss Riverside | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1937 | Bette Cooper | Hackettstown | 17 | Miss Bertrand Island | Vocal, "When the Poppies Bloom Again" | Winner | Evening Gown Award | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1937 | Helen Frances Murphy | Riverside | | Miss Riverside | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1937 | Margaret Julia Jardon | Burlington | | Miss South Jersey | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1936 | Thelma Bieber | Camden | | Miss Camden | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1936 | Evelyn Pierce | Riverside | | Miss South Jersey | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Mildred Hughes | | | Miss Bloomfield | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Geraldine Hester | Bridgeton | | Miss Bridgeton | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Mary Dillinger | Burlington | | Miss Burlington | Vocal, "Every Little Moment" | Top 12 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Lena Melamed | Camden | | Miss Camden | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Dorothy Wainwright | Hillside | | Miss Hillside | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Ann Golden | | | Miss Lake Hopatcong | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Esther Moore | Mount Holly | | Miss Mount Holly | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Ann Harvey | Newark | | Miss Newark | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Norine Hughes | Glen Ridge | | Miss New Jersey | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Elizabeth Koehler | Penns Grove | | Miss Penns Grove | Vocal Medley, "Without a Song" & "Roll Out of Bed with a Smile" | Top 12 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Othelia March | Riverside | | Miss Riverside | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Ann Halko | West Orange | | Miss West Orange | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1935 | Thelma Fouks | Woodbury | | Miss Woodbury | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1934 | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held | No national pageant was held |
| 1933 | Gertrude Christman | | 15 | | | Top 18 | | |
| 1932 | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held |
| 1931 | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held |
| 1930 | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held |
| 1929 | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held |
| 1928 | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held | No national pageants were held |
| 1927 | Helen Mankus | | | Miss Elizabeth | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1927 | Eunice Geiser | | | Miss Jersey City | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1927 | Carolyn Pierson | | | Miss Newark | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1927 | Harriet Rita Shelby | | | Miss Passaic | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1927 | Sue Hoch | | | Miss Union City | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Mary Mavretic | | | Miss Brigantine Beach | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Name not known | | | Miss Canarsie | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Lucy Taylor | | | Miss Elizabeth | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Anita Limbacker | | | Miss Hoboken | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Mildred Morlock | | | Miss Newark | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Evelynne Jeanne Crowell | | | Miss Orange | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Elizabeth Welch | | | Miss Union City | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1926 | Kathleen Coyle | | | Miss Wildwood Gables | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1925 | Lee Bartlett | | | | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1925 | Frances M. Glowaski | | | Miss Jersey City | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1925 | Helen Corcoran | | | Miss Newark | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Edith Wright | | | Miss Bradley Beach | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Emily Borbach | | | Miss Cape May | | Top 10 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Helen Mankus | | | Miss Elizabeth | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Alice Kind | | | Miss Hammonton | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Emerita Monsch | | | Miss Hoboken | | Top 10 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Bonnie Blair | | | Miss Jersey City | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Name not known | | | Miss Kearny | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Name not known | | | Miss Long Beach | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Myrtle Marshall | | | Miss Margate City | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Edith Becker | | | Miss Newark | | Top 15 | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Gertrude McDonough | | | Miss Pleasantville | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1924 | Ethel Sipps | | | Miss Somers Point | | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1923 | Alice Kind | Hammonton | | Miss Hammonton | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Mildred McCann | Cape May | | Miss Cape May | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Florence Nurock | Camden | | Miss Camden | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Elene Hicks | Long Branch | 19 | Miss Long Branch | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Grace Taylor | Philadelphia | | Miss Ocean City | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Alma D. DeCone | Trenton | | Miss Trenton | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Mary E. Edwards | Vineland | | Miss Vineland | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1923 | Eleanor Addis | Wildwood | | Miss Wildwood | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at national pageant |
| 1922 | Estelle Marks | Atlantic City | | Miss Atlantic City | N/A | | Amateur Beauty Award Third Prize | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1922 | Sarah Alice Bell | Bridgeton | | Miss Bridgeton | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1922 | Eleanor Lindley | Greater Camden | | Miss Greater Camden | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1922 | Marion Steelman | Ocean City | | Miss Ocean City | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1922 | Mary Elizabeth Edwards | Vineland | 18 | Miss Vineland | N/A | | Amateur Beauty Award Second Prize | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1921 | Kathryn M. Gearon | Camden | | Miss Camden | N/A | 1st runner-up | Amateur Beauty Award | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |
| 1921 | Margaret Bates | Newark | | Miss Newark | N/A | | | Multiple New Jersey representatives Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant |

## Popular culture

In Philip Roth's Pulitzer Prize winning novel, "American Pastoral", the central character Seymour "Swede" Levov marries Dawn Dwyer, an Irish Catholic winner of Miss New Jersey 1949, from nearby Elizabeth, whom he met at Upsala College in East Orange, New Jersey.
In the Drake & Josh episode "Vicious Tiberius", the boys find out their teacher, Mrs. Hayfer, was the winner of Miss New Jersey 1976 while house sitting for her. The winner of the 1957 pageant is mentioned by title in the Martin Scorsese film Taxi Driver.