# Macalester Plymouth United Church Hymn Contest

The Macalester Plymouth United Church Hymn Contest is an annual global competition for new hymns. Hosted by a Saint Paul, Minnesota, congregation that is part of both the United Church of Christ and the Presbyterian Church (USA), the competition focuses on generating new hymns on religiously liberal themes for Mainline Protestant churches. The head of the Hymn Society in the United States and Canada has referred to it as "one of the most respected competitions" in hymnwriting.

## History

The contest was founded in 1996 by the Rev. Roger Grussing, senior pastor of Macalester Plymouth United Church (MPUC), and Curt Oliver, MPUC's music director. It is funded by an endowment from A.A. "Al" Heckman, a Minnesota foundation executive who died in 1994. The purpose of the contest was to generate new hymn texts that "can motivate the church to be more actively involved in social reform."
The contest describes itself as the longest-running hymn contest in the English language and attracts entries from across the United States, as well as from Great Britain, Canada, and Australia. According to the St. Paul Pioneer Press, "the social justice hymn contest has acquired an 'American Idol' or Sundance Film Festival or Oprah's Book Club sort of clout, capable of elevating a previously unknown artist to national prominence."

## Format

The contest focuses on new and unpublished texts for hymns, with a different theme announced each year. While it welcomes new tunes, it "strongly encourage[s] the use of familiar meters which may be sung to familiar tunes." As of 2006, the contest offered a $500 cash prize for the winner or winners, should multiple hymns be recognized. An anonymous panel judges the contest.
The hymnwriters retain the copyright to their texts, although MPUC retains a perpetual license to use the winning hymn or hymns in worship. Describing itself as a "a liberal and inclusive church with a history of active involvement in contemporary social issues," MPUC advises entrants to avoid the use of archaic language such as "thee" and "thou" and to use inclusive language (for example, "siblings" instead of "brothers").

## Table of contests and winners

| Year | Theme | Winning hymn(s) | Winning hymnwriter(s) | Publication history |
| 1996 | Hymns that call the church to work for social justice | Who Will Speak a Word of Warning | Richard Leach | Selah Publishing, 2000; Voices Together (Mennonite Church USA hymnal), 2020 |
| 1997 | Hymns that call the church to nurture and care for children everywhere | Gentle Jesus, Loving Shepherd | Lurline DuPre |
| 1998 | Hymns that speak to the role and ministry of the church in addressing social concerns faced by our communities, our nation and our world as we enter a new century | How Long Ago the World Was Taught | Richard Leach | |
| 1999 | Hymns which address environmental stewardship at a time of conflicting national / tribal interests | The Garden Needs Our Tending Now | Mary Louise Bringle | GIA Publications, 2002; Voices Together, 2020 |
| 2000 | Hymns based on the Hebrew prophets’ calls for justice | As the Bear That Roams the Timber | John Core | |
| 2001 | Hymns which call the church to greater inclusivity | O God, By Whose Guidance | Robert Gardiner | |
| 2002 | Hymns which call the church to affirm gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender persons and to celebrate their gifts and ministries | Faces and Facets (co-winner) In the Desert Where They’d Wandered (co-winner) The Love That Goes Unspoken (co-winner) | Alan J. Hommerding Richard Spalding Mary Louise Bringle | |
| 2003 | Hymns which call the church and its people to work for peace | O God of Peace, Who Gave Us Breath and Birth | Timothy Dudley-Smith | |
| 2004 | Hymns which celebrate religious diversity and encourage interfaith cooperation, with the understanding that many of the world’s social problems are rooted in religious intolerance | Creator of the Intertwined | Jacque B. Jones | GIA Publications, 2004; Hymns for a Pilgrim People (National Association of Congregational Christian Churches hymnal), 2007; Worship, fourth edition (Roman Catholic hymnal), 2011; Community of Christ Sings (Community of Christ hymnal), 2013 |
| 2005 | Hymns which call the church and its people to greater awareness of the plight of the homeless, and to the need for affordable housing for all people | The Church of Christ Cannot be Bound | Adam M. L. Tice | GIA Publications, 2005; Celebrating Grace (Baptist hymnal), 2010; Worship, fourth edition, 2011; Lead Me, Guide Me, second edition (Roman Catholic hymnal), 2011; Total Praise (National Baptist Convention hymnal), 2011; Glory to God (Presbyterian Church (USA) hymnal), 2013; Community of Christ Sings, 2013; Lift Up Your Hearts (Christian Reformed Church in North America and Reformed Church in America hymnal), 2013; Worship in the City (United Church of Canada songbook), 2015; One Lord, One Faith, One Baptism (African-American ecumenical hymnal), 2018; RitualSong, second edition (Roman Catholic hymnal), 2018; Voices Together, 2020 |
| 2006 | Hymns that call the church and its people to practice the forgiveness of enemies and to commend to the nations as practical politics the search for cooperation and peace | Disarming Presence, Win Us (co-winner) To Dream of It Is Wondrous (co-winner) | Dorothy Fulton John Core | |
| 2007 | New hymns to use on Mother's Day, sensitive to the changing nature of family life, and affirming feminist calls for equality | Thank You, God, For Mother | Nathan Crabtree | |
| 2008 | Hymns which will enable the church and its people to lament, to cry out in anger and frustration to God | When Brutal Forces Crush Out Love (co-winner) Earth Is Aching (co-winner) Can We Curse Without Blaspheming? (co-winner) | R. Frederick Crider Jr. David Gambrell William Allen Pasch | When Brutal Forces Crush Out Love: Wayne Leupold Editions, 2008; Discipleship Ministries Collection (United Methodist Church) |
| 2009 | Hymns to be sung on Labor Day, with words that especially address the plight of the unemployed | God Bless the Work Your People Do | John A. Dalles | Voices Together, 2020 |
| 2010 | Hymns giving thanks for the nation's many blessings and calling the church to work for social reform. | Unknown | John A. Dalles | |
| 2011 | Hymns that express dismay over the growing gap between rich and poor and call the church to action to work for greater economic equality | Seek the Welfare of the City (co-winner) We Learned the First Part Long Ago (co-winner) Now Hear the Words of Jesus (co-winner) | Norman J. Goreham (co-winner) John Core (co-winner) Howard Maple (co-winner) | Seek the Welfare of the City: Worship in the City (United Church of Canada songbook), 2015 |
| 2012 | Hymns that address the scriptural call to speak out loudly and clearly against injustice, and to unite with others working for change | Now Is the Time to Speak | John A. Dalles | |
| 2013 | A new Advent or Christmas carol | Unknown | John A. Dalles | |
| 2014 | Unknown | Unknown | Jacque B. Jones | |
| 2015 | Hymns which celebrate God's presence in current social changes and changes in the church | A Hymn for Peace | Christopher L. Webber | |