# List of FIS Alpine Ski World Cup winners of women's discipline titles

This is a complete list of FIS Alpine Ski World Cup winners of women's discipline titles, the list is completed by the second and third classified.

## Podiums standings

| # | Skier | Period | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 1 | Lindsey Vonn | 2000–2019 | 16 | 5 | 6 |
| 2 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | 1969–1980 | 12 | 5 | 5 |
| 3 | Vreni Schneider | 1984–1995 | 11 | 5 | 3 |
| 4 | Renate Götschl | 1993–2009 | 10 | 9 | 3 |
| 5 | Mikaela Shiffrin | 2011–active | 10 | 6 | 5 |
| 6 | Katja Seizinger | 1989–1999 | 9 | 5 | 2 |
| 7 | Hanni Wenzel | 1972–1984 | 7 | 6 | 4 |
| 8 | Janica Kostelić | 1998–2007 | 7 | 2 | 2 |
| 9 | Erika Hess | 1977–1987 | 6 | 3 | 4 |
| 10 | Michela Figini | 1983–1990 | 6 | 1 | 2 |

## Season-end podiums
### Slalom

In the following table ladies's slalom World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 1967.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 1967 | Marielle Goitschel Annie Famose | | Nancy Greene |
| 1968 | Marielle Goitschel | Florence Steurer Gertrude Gabl | |
| 1969 | Gertrude Gabl | Kiki Cutter | Ingrid Lafforgue |
| 1970 | Ingrid Lafforgue | Michèle Jacot Barbara Cochran | |
| 1971 | Britt Lafforgue Betsy Clifford | | Annemarie Pröll Barbara Cochran |
| 1972 | Britt Lafforgue | Florence Steurer Françoise Macchi | |
| 1973 | Patricia Emonet | Rosi Mittermaier | Monika Kaserer |
| 1974 | Christa Zechmeister | Rosi Mittermaier | Fabienne Serrat |
| 1975 | Lise-Marie Morerod | Hanni Wenzel | Christa Zechmeister |
| 1976 | Rosi Mittermaier | Lise-Marie Morerod | Danièle Debernard |
| 1977 | Lise-Marie Morerod | Perrine Pelen | Claudia Giordani |
| 1978 | Hanni Wenzel | Perrine Pelen | Fabienne Serrat |
| 1979 | Regina Sackl | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Lea Sölkner |
| 1980 | Perrine Pelen | Hanni Wenzel | Annemarie Moser-Pröll |
| 1981 | Erika Hess | Christin Cooper | Perrine Pelen Daniela Zini |
| 1982 | Erika Hess | Ursula Konzett | Christin Cooper |
| 1983 | Erika Hess | Tamara McKinney | Maria Rosa Quario |
| 1984 | Tamara McKinney | Roswitha Steiner | Perrine Pelen |
| 1985 | Erika Hess | Tamara McKinney | Perrine Pelen |
| 1986 | Roswitha Steiner | Erika Hess | Perrine Pelen |
| 1987 | Corinne Schmidhauser | Tamara McKinney | Erika Hess |
| 1988 | Roswitha Steiner | Vreni Schneider | Anita Wachter |
| 1989 | Vreni Schneider | Monika Maierhofer | Tamara McKinney |
| 1990 | Vreni Schneider | Claudia Strobl | Ida Ladstätter |
| 1991 | Petra Kronberger | Pernilla Wiberg | Blanca Fernandez Ochoa |
| 1992 | Vreni Schneider | Pernilla Wiberg | Blanca Fernandez Ochoa |
| 1993 | Vreni Schneider | Annelise Coberger | Patricia Chauvet |
| 1994 | Vreni Schneider | Pernilla Wiberg | Urška Hrovat |
| 1995 | Vreni Schneider | Pernilla Wiberg | Martina Ertl |
| 1996 | Elfi Eder | Urška Hrovat | Pernilla Wiberg |
| 1997 | Pernilla Wiberg | Claudia Riegler | Deborah Compagnoni |
| 1998 | Ylva Nowén | Kristina Koznick | Hilde Gerg |
| 1999 | Sabine Egger | Pernilla Wiberg | Anja Pärson |
| 2000 | Špela Pretnar | Christel Pascal | Anja Pärson |
| 2001 | Janica Kostelić | Sonja Nef | Martina Ertl-Renz |
| 2002 | Laure Pequegnot | Kristina Koznick | Anja Pärson |
| 2003 | Janica Kostelić | Anja Pärson | Tanja Poutiainen |
| 2004 | Anja Pärson | Marlies Schild | Monika Bergmann |
| 2005 | Tanja Poutiainen | Janica Kostelić | Marlies Schild |
| 2006 | Janica Kostelić | Marlies Schild | Anja Pärson |
| 2007 | Marlies Schild | Nicole Hosp | Sarka Záhrobská |
| 2008 | Marlies Schild | Nicole Hosp | Veronika Zuzulová |
| 2009 | Maria Riesch | Sarka Záhrobská | Lindsey Vonn |
| 2010 | Maria Riesch | Kathrin Zettel | Marlies Schild |
| 2011 | Marlies Schild | Tanja Poutiainen | Maria Riesch |
| 2012 | Marlies Schild | Michaela Kirchgasser | Tina Maze |
| 2013 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Tina Maze | Veronika Velez-Zuzulová |
| 2014 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Frida Hansdotter | Marlies Schild |
| 2015 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Frida Hansdotter | Tina Maze |
| 2016 | Frida Hansdotter | Veronika Velez-Zuzulová | Wendy Holdener |
| 2017 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Veronika Velez-Zuzulová | Wendy Holdener |
| 2018 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Wendy Holdener | Frida Hansdotter |
| 2019 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Petra Vlhová | Wendy Holdener |
| 2020 | Petra Vlhová | Mikaela Shiffrin | Katharina Liensberger |
| 2021 | Katharina Liensberger | Mikaela Shiffrin | Petra Vlhová |
| 2022 | Petra Vlhová | Mikaela Shiffrin | Lena Dürr |
| 2023 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Wendy Holdener | Petra Vlhová |
| 2024 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Lena Dürr | Petra Vlhová |

### Downhill

In the following table ladies's downhill World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 1967.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 1967 | Marielle Goitschel | Isabelle Mir | Giustina Demetz |
| 1968 | Isabelle Mir Olga Pall | | Christl Haas |
| 1969 | Wiltrud Drexel | Isabelle Mir | Olga Pall |
| 1970 | Isabelle Mir | Annie Famose | Florence Steurer |
| 1971 | Annemarie Pröll | Wiltrud Drexel | Françoise Macchi |
| 1972 | Annemarie Pröll | Wiltrud Drexel | Marie-Theres Nadig |
| 1973 | Annemarie Pröll | Wiltrud Drexel | Jacqueline Rouvier |
| 1974 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Marie-Theres Nadig | Wiltrud Drexel |
| 1975 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Bernadette Zurbriggen | Marie-Theres Nadig |
| 1976 | Brigitte Totschnig | Bernadette Zurbriggen | Nicola Spiess |
| 1977 | Brigitte Totschnig | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Marie-Theres Nadig |
| 1978 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Cindy Nelson | Marie-Theres Nadig |
| 1979 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Bernadette Zurbriggen | Marie-Theres Nadig |
| 1980 | Marie-Theres Nadig | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Hanni Wenzel |
| 1981 | Marie-Theres Nadig | Doris de Agostini | Cornelia Pröll |
| 1982 | M.-C. Gros-Gaudenier | Holly Flanders Doris de Agostini | |
| 1983 | Doris de Agostini | Maria Walliser | Elisabeth Kirchler |
| 1984 | Maria Walliser | Irene Epple | Hanni Wenzel |
| 1985 | Michela Figini | Maria Walliser | Brigitte Örtli |
| 1986 | Maria Walliser | Katharina Gutensohn | Laurie Graham |
| 1987 | Michela Figini | Maria Walliser | Laurie Graham |
| 1988 | Michela Figini | Brigitte Örtli | Maria Walliser |
| 1989 | Michela Figini | Maria Walliser | Michaela Gerg-Leitner |
| 1990 | Katharina Gutensohn | Petra Kronberger | Michaela Gerg-Leitner Michela Figini |
| 1991 | Chantal Bournissen | Sabine Ginther | Petra Kronberger |
| 1992 | Katja Seizinger | Petra Kronberger | Miriam Vogt |
| 1993 | Katja Seizinger | Regina Häusl | Kerrin Lee-Gartner |
| 1994 | Katja Seizinger | Kate Pace | Mélanie Suchet |
| 1995 | Picabo Street | Hilary Lindh | Katja Seizinger |
| 1996 | Picabo Street | Katja Seizinger | Isolde Kostner Heidi Zurbriggen |
| 1997 | Renate Götschl | Heidi Zurbriggen | Varvara Zelenskaya |
| 1998 | Katja Seizinger | Renate Götschl | Isolde Kostner |
| 1999 | Renate Götschl | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Michaela Dorfmeister |
| 2000 | Regina Häusl | Renate Götschl | Isolde Kostner |
| 2001 | Isolde Kostner | Renate Götschl | Régine Cavagnoud |
| 2002 | Isolde Kostner | Michaela Dorfmeister | Corinne Rey-Bellet |
| 2003 | Michaela Dorfmeister | Renate Götschl | Kirsten Clark |
| 2004 | Renate Götschl | Hilde Gerg | Carole Montillet |
| 2005 | Renate Götschl | Hilde Gerg | Michaela Dorfmeister |
| 2006 | Michaela Dorfmeister | Lindsey Kildow | Renate Götschl |
| 2007 | Renate Götschl | Julia Mancuso | Lindsey Kildow |
| 2008 | Lindsey Vonn | Renate Götschl | Britt Janyk |
| 2009 | Lindsey Vonn | Andrea Fischbacher | Maria Riesch |
| 2010 | Lindsey Vonn | Maria Riesch | Anja Pärson |
| 2011 | Lindsey Vonn | Maria Riesch | Julia Mancuso |
| 2012 | Lindsey Vonn | Tina Weirather | Elisabeth Görgl |
| 2013 | Lindsey Vonn | Tina Maze | Maria Höfl-Riesch |
| 2014 | Maria Höfl-Riesch | Anna Fenninger | Tina Maze |
| 2015 | Lindsey Vonn | Anna Fenninger | Tina Maze |
| 2016 | Lindsey Vonn | Fabienne Suter | Larisa Yurkiw |
| 2017 | Ilka Štuhec | Sofia Goggia | Lara Gut |
| 2018 | Sofia Goggia | Lindsey Vonn | Tina Weirather |
| 2019 | Nicole Schmidhofer | Stephanie Venier | Ramona Siebenhofer |
| 2020 | Corinne Suter | Ester Ledecka | Federica Brignone |
| 2021 | Sofia Goggia | Corinne Suter | Lara Gut-Behrami |
| 2022 | Sofia Goggia | Corinne Suter | Ester Ledecká |
| 2023 | Sofia Goggia | Ilka Štuhec | Corinne Suter |
| 2024 | Cornelia Hütter | Lara Gut-Behrami | Sofia Goggia |

### Giant slalom

In the following table ladies's giant slalom World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 1967.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 1967 | Nancy Greene | Erika Schinegger | Annie Famose |
| 1968 | Nancy Greene | Fernande Bochatay | Florence Steurer |
| 1969 | Marilyn Cochran | Michèle Jacot | Gertrude Gabl |
| 1970 | Françoise Macchi Michèle Jacot | | Annemarie Pröll |
| 1971 | Annemarie Pröll | Michèle Jacot | Françoise Macchi |
| 1972 | Annemarie Pröll | Monika Kaserer | Britt Lafforgue |
| 1973 | Monika Kaserer | Annemarie Pröll | Hanni Wenzel |
| 1974 | Hanni Wenzel | Fabienne Serrat | Monika Kaserer |
| 1975 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Fabienne Serrat | Monika Kaserer |
| 1976 | Lise-Marie Morerod | Monika Kaserer | Rosi Mittermaier |
| 1977 | Lise-Marie Morerod | Monika Kaserer | Annemarie Moser-Pröll |
| 1978 | Lise-Marie Morerod | Hanni Wenzel | Maria Epple |
| 1979 | Christa Kinshofer | Hanni Wenzel | Irene Epple |
| 1980 | Hanni Wenzel | Marie-Theres Nadig Perrine Pelen | |
| 1981 | Tamara McKinney | Marie-Theres Nadig | Erika Hess Hanni Wenzel Irene Epple |
| 1982 | Irene Epple | Maria Epple | Erika Hess |
| 1983 | Tamara McKinney | Cindy Nelson | Maria Epple |
| 1984 | Erika Hess | Christin Cooper | Tamara McKinney |
| 1985 | Marina Kiehl Michela Figini | | Vreni Schneider |
| 1986 | Vreni Schneider | Traudl Hächer | Mateja Svet |
| 1987 | Maria Walliser Vreni Schneider | | Blanca Fernandez Ochoa |
| 1988 | Mateja Svet | Catherine Quittet | Vreni Schneider |
| 1989 | Vreni Schneider | Mateja Svet | Maria Walliser |
| 1990 | Anita Wachter | Mateja Svet | Petra Kronberger |
| 1991 | Vreni Schneider | Anita Wachter | Pernilla Wiberg |
| 1992 | Carole Merle | Vreni Schneider | Diann Roffe |
| 1993 | Carole Merle | Anita Wachter | Martina Ertl |
| 1994 | Anita Wachter | Vreni Schneider | Deborah Compagnoni |
| 1995 | Vreni Schneider | Heidi Zeller-Bähler | Špela Pretnar |
| 1996 | Martina Ertl | Katja Seizinger | Anita Wachter |
| 1997 | Deborah Compagnoni | Katja Seizinger | Anita Wachter |
| 1998 | Martina Ertl | Deborah Compagnoni | Alexandra Meissnitzer |
| 1999 | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Anita Wachter | Andrine Flemmen |
| 2000 | Michaela Dorfmeister | Sonja Nef | Anita Wachter |
| 2001 | Sonja Nef | Anja Pärson | Michaela Dorfmeister |
| 2002 | Sonja Nef | Michaela Dorfmeister | Anja Pärson |
| 2003 | Anja Pärson | Karen Putzer | Janica Kostelic |
| 2004 | Anja Pärson | Denise Karbon | María José Rienda |
| 2005 | Tanja Poutiainen | Anja Pärson | María José Rienda |
| 2006 | Anja Pärson | María José Rienda | Janica Kostelic |
| 2007 | Nicole Hosp | Tanja Poutiainen | Michaela Kirchgasser |
| 2008 | Denise Karbon | Elisabeth Görgl | Manuela Mölgg |
| 2009 | Tanja Poutiainen | Kathrin Zettel | Tina Maze |
| 2010 | Kathrin Hölzl | Kathrin Zettel | Tina Maze |
| 2011 | Viktoria Rebensburg | Tessa Worley | Tanja Poutiainen |
| 2012 | Viktoria Rebensburg | Lindsey Vonn | Tessa Worley |
| 2013 | Tina Maze | Anna Fenninger | Viktoria Rebensburg |
| 2014 | Anna Fenninger | Jessica Lindell-Vikarby | Maria Pietilä Holmner |
| 2015 | Anna Fenninger | Eva-Maria Brem | Mikaela Shiffrin |
| 2016 | Eva-Maria Brem | Viktoria Rebensburg | Lara Gut |
| 2017 | Tessa Worley | Mikaela Shiffrin | Sofia Goggia |
| 2018 | Viktoria Rebensburg | Tessa Worley | Mikaela Shiffrin |
| 2019 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Petra Vlhová | Tessa Worley |
| 2020 | Federica Brignone | Petra Vlhová | Mikaela Shiffrin |
| 2021 | Marta Bassino | Mikaela Shiffrin | Tessa Worley |
| 2022 | Tessa Worley | Sara Hector | Mikaela Shiffrin |
| 2023 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Lara Gut-Behrami | Marta Bassino |
| 2024 | Lara Gut-Behrami | Federica Brignone | Sara Hector |

### Super G

In the following table ladies's Super-G World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 1986.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 1986 | Marina Kiehl | Liisa Savijarvi | Michaela Marzola |
| 1987 | Maria Walliser | Catherine Quittet | Marina Kiehl |
| 1988 | Michela Figini | Sylvia Eder | Regine Mösenlechner Blanca Fernández Ochoa |
| 1989 | Carole Merle | Sigrid Wolf | Anita Wachter |
| 1990 | Carole Merle | Michaela Gerg-Leitner | Sigrid Wolf |
| 1991 | Carole Merle | Petra Kronberger | Michaela Gerg-Leitner |
| 1992 | Carole Merle | Merete Fjeldavlie | Katja Seizinger |
| 1993 | Katja Seizinger | Ulrike Maier | Carole Merle |
| 1994 | Katja Seizinger | Bibiana Perez | Hilde Gerg |
| 1995 | Katja Seizinger | Heidi Zeller-Bähler | Heidi Zurbriggen |
| 1996 | Katja Seizinger | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Martina Ertl |
| 1997 | Hilde Gerg | Katja Seizinger | Pernilla Wiberg |
| 1998 | Katja Seizinger | Renate Götschl | Isolde Kostner |
| 1999 | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Michaela Dorfmeister | Martina Ertl |
| 2000 | Renate Götschl | Mélanie Turgeon | Mojca Suhadolc |
| 2001 | Régine Cavagnoud | Renate Götschl | Carole Montillet |
| 2002 | Hilde Gerg | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Michaela Dorfmeister |
| 2003 | Carole Montillet | Renate Götschl | Karen Putzer |
| 2004 | Renate Götschl | Carole Montillet | Michaela Dorfmeister |
| 2005 | Michaela Dorfmeister | Renate Götschl | Lindsey Kildow |
| 2006 | Michaela Dorfmeister | Alexandra Meissnitzer | Nadia Styger |
| 2007 | Renate Götschl | Nicole Hosp | Lindsey Kildow |
| 2008 | Maria Riesch | Elisabeth Görgl | Fabienne Suter |
| 2009 | Lindsey Vonn | Nadia Fanchini | Fabienne Suter |
| 2010 | Lindsey Vonn | Elisabeth Görgl | Nadia Styger |
| 2011 | Lindsey Vonn | Maria Riesch | Julia Mancuso |
| 2012 | Lindsey Vonn | Julia Mancuso | Anna Fenninger |
| 2013 | Tina Maze | Julia Mancuso | Anna Fenninger |
| 2014 | Lara Gut | Anna Fenninger | Tina Weirather |
| 2015 | Lindsey Vonn | Anna Fenninger | Tina Maze |
| 2016 | Lara Gut | Tina Weirather | Lindsey Vonn |
| 2017 | Tina Weirather | Ilka Štuhec | Lara Gut |
| 2018 | Tina Weirather | Lara Gut | Anna Veith |
| 2019 | Mikaela Shiffrin | Nicole Schmidhofer | Tina Weirather |
| 2020 | Corinne Suter | Federica Brignone | Nicole Schmidhofer |
| 2021 | Lara Gut-Behrami | Federica Brignone | Corinne Suter |
| 2022 | Federica Brignone | Elena Curtoni | Mikaela Shiffrin |
| 2023 | Lara Gut-Behrami | Federica Brignone | Ragnhild Mowinckel |
| 2024 | Lara Gut-Behrami | Federica Brignone | Cornelia Hütter |

### Combined

In the following table ladies's combined World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 1975.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| Classic Combined ||||
| 1975 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Hanni Wenzel | Rosi Mittermaier |
| 1976 | Rosi Mittermaier | Bernadette Zurbriggen | Cindy Nelson |
| 1977 | Hanni Wenzel | Lise-Marie Morerod | Annemarie Moser-Pröll |
| 1978 | not held | not held | not held |
| 1979 | Annemarie Moser-Pröll Hanni Wenzel | | Cindy Nelson |
| 1980 | Hanni Wenzel | Annemarie Moser-Pröll | Cindy Nelson |
| 1981 | Marie-Theres Nadig | Hanni Wenzel | Christa Kinshofer |
| 1982 | Irene Epple | Erika Hess | Cindy Nelson |
| 1983 | Hanni Wenzel | Elisabeth Kirchler | Irene Epple |
| 1984 | Erika Hess | Irene Epple | Olga Charvátová |
| 1985 | Brigitte Örtli | Michela Figini | Maria Walliser |
| 1986 | Maria Walliser | Erika Hess | Michela Figini |
| 1987 | Brigitte Örtli | Vreni Schneider | Erika Hess |
| 1988 | Brigitte Örtli | Anita Wachter | Karen Percy Petra Kronberger |
| 1989 | Brigitte Örtli | Ulrike Maier | Vreni Schneider |
| 1990 | Anita Wachter | Michaela Gerg-Leitner | Petra Kronberger Brigitte Örtli |
| 1991 | Sabine Ginther Florence Masnada | | Ingrid Stöckl |
| 1992 | Sabine Ginther | Miriam Vogt | Anita Wachter |
| 1993 | Anita Wachter | Miriam Vogt | Morena Gallizio |
| 1994 | Pernilla Wiberg | Bibiana Perez | Renate Götschl |
| 1995 | Pernilla Wiberg | Vreni Schneider | Martina Ertl |
| 1996 | Anita Wachter | Ingeborg Helen Marken | Hilde Gerg |
| 1997 | Pernilla Wiberg | Hilde Gerg | Anita Wachter |
| 1998 | Hilde Gerg | Katja Seizinger Martina Ertl | |
| 1999 | Hilde Gerg | Janica Kostelic | Trude Gimle |
| 2000 | Renate Götschl | Caroline Lalive | Andrine Flemmen |
| 2001 | Janica Kostelic | Caroline Lalive | Renate Götschl |
| 2002 | Renate Götschl | Michaela Dorfmeister | Brigitte Obermoser |
| 2003 | Janica Kostelic | Martina Ertl | Maria Riesch |
| 2004 | not held | not held | not held |
| Super Combined ||||
| 2005 | Janica Kostelic | Anja Pärson | Emily Brydon |
| 2006 | Janica Kostelic | Anja Pärson | Lindsey Kildow |
| 2007 | Marlies Schild | Julia Mancuso | Nicole Hosp |
| 2008 | Maria Riesch | Lindsey Vonn | Anja Pärson |
| 2009 | Anja Pärson | Lindsey Vonn | Kathrin Zettel |
| 2010 | Lindsey Vonn | Anja Pärson | Michaela Kirchgasser |
| 2011 | Lindsey Vonn | Tina Maze | Maria Riesch |
| 2012 | Lindsey Vonn | Tina Maze | Nicole Hosp |
| 2013 | Tina Maze | Nicole Hosp | Michaela Kirchgasser |
| 2014 | Marie-Michèle Gagnon | Michaela Kirchgasser | Maria Höfl-Riesch |
| Alpine Combined ||||
| 2015 | Anna Fenninger | Tina Maze | Kathrin Zettel |
| 2016 | Wendy Holdener | Lara Gut | Michaela Kirchgasser |
| 2017 | Ilka Štuhec | Federica Brignone | Wendy Holdener |
| 2018 | Wendy Holdener | Michelle Gisin | Federica Brignone |
| 2019 | Federica Brignone | Roni Remme | Wendy Holdener |
| 2020 | Federica Brignone | Wendy Holdener | Ester Ledecka |
| 2021 | not held | not held | not held |
| 2022 | not held | not held | not held |
| 2023 | not held | not held | not held |

### Parallel

In the following table ladies's Parallel World Cup season-end podiums since first season in 2020.
| Season | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| 2020 | Petra Vlhová | Clara Direz | Federica Brignone |
| 2021 | Petra Vlhová | Paula Moltzan | Lara Gut-Behrami |
| 2022 | Andreja Slokar | Thea Louise Stjernesund | Kristin Lysdahl |
| 2023 | not held | not held | not held |