# NHL All-Star team

The National Hockey League All-Star teams were first named at the end of the 1930–31 NHL season, to honor the best performers over the season at each position.
Representatives of the Professional Hockey Writers' Association vote for the all-star team at the end of the regular season.
The career leader in selections is Gordie Howe, who was named to a total of 21 all-star teams (12 first, 9 second), all with the Detroit Red Wings. Alexander Ovechkin is the only player in history to be named to both all-star teams in the same season (as a left and right winger respectively) because of a voting error. The career leader for the most selections as a player without being inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame is John LeClair, who was named to a total of 5 all-star teams (2 first, 3 second).

## Selections

| ^ | Denotes players who are still active in the NHL |
| * | Denotes players inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame |
| † | Denotes inactive players not yet eligible for Hockey Hall of Fame consideration |
| Player (X) | Denotes the number of times a player has been selected |
| Player (in bold text) | Denotes players who won the Hart Memorial Trophy as the NHL's Most Valuable Player in the same year |

### Early years (1930–31 to 1941–42)

| Season | Position | First Team | First Team | Second Team | Second Team |
| Season | Position | Player | Team | Player | Team |
| 1930–31 | C | Howie Morenz* | Montreal Canadiens | Frank Boucher* | New York Rangers |
| 1930–31 | LW | Aurele Joliat* | Montreal Canadiens | Bun Cook* | New York Rangers |
| 1930–31 | RW | Bill Cook* | New York Rangers | Dit Clapper* | Boston Bruins |
| 1930–31 | D | Eddie Shore* | Boston Bruins | Sylvio Mantha* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1930–31 | D | King Clancy* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Ching Johnson* | New York Rangers |
| 1930–31 | G | Charlie Gardiner* | Chicago Black Hawks | Tiny Thompson* | Boston Bruins |
| 1930–31 | Coach | Lester Patrick* | New York Rangers | Dick Irvin* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1931–32 | C | Howie Morenz* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Hooley Smith* | Montreal Maroons |
| 1931–32 | LW | Busher Jackson* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Aurele Joliat* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1931–32 | RW | Bill Cook* (2) | New York Rangers | Charlie Conacher* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1931–32 | D | Eddie Shore* (2) | Boston Bruins | Sylvio Mantha* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1931–32 | D | Ching Johnson* (2) | New York Rangers | King Clancy* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1931–32 | G | Charlie Gardiner* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Roy Worters* | New York Americans |
| 1931–32 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (2) | New York Rangers | Dick Irvin* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1932–33 | C | Frank Boucher* (2) | New York Rangers | Howie Morenz* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1932–33 | LW | Baldy Northcott | Montreal Maroons | Busher Jackson* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1932–33 | RW | Bill Cook* (3) | New York Rangers | Charlie Conacher* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1932–33 | D | Eddie Shore* (3) | Boston Bruins | King Clancy* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1932–33 | D | Ching Johnson* (2) | New York Rangers | Lionel Conacher* | Montreal Maroons |
| 1932–33 | G | John Roach | Detroit Red Wings | Charlie Gardiner* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1932–33 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (3) | New York Rangers | Dick Irvin* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1933–34 | C | Frank Boucher* (3) | New York Rangers | Joe Primeau* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1933–34 | LW | Busher Jackson* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Aurele Joliat* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1933–34 | RW | Charlie Conacher* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Bill Cook* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1933–34 | D | King Clancy* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Eddie Shore* (4) | Boston Bruins |
| 1933–34 | D | Lionel Conacher* (2) | Montreal Maroons | Ching Johnson* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1933–34 | G | Charlie Gardiner* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks | Roy Worters* (2) | New York Americans |
| 1933–34 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (4) | New York Rangers | Dick Irvin* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1934–35 | C | Frank Boucher* (4) | New York Rangers | Cooney Weiland* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1934–35 | LW | Busher Jackson* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Aurele Joliat* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1934–35 | RW | Charlie Conacher* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Dit Clapper* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1934–35 | D | Eddie Shore* (5) | Boston Bruins | Cy Wentworth | Montreal Maroons |
| 1934–35 | D | Earl Seibert* | New York Rangers | Art Coulter* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1934–35 | G | Lorne Chabot | Chicago Black Hawks | Tiny Thompson* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1934–35 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (5) | New York Rangers | Dick Irvin* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1935–36 | C | Hooley Smith* (2) | Montreal Maroons | Bill Thoms | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1935–36 | LW | Sweeney Schriner* | New York Americans | Paul Thompson | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1935–36 | RW | Charlie Conacher* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Cecil Dillon | New York Rangers |
| 1935–36 | D | Eddie Shore* (6) | Boston Bruins | Earl Seibert* (2) | New York Rangers Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1935–36 | D | Babe Siebert* | Boston Bruins | Ebbie Goodfellow* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1935–36 | G | Tiny Thompson* (3) | Boston Bruins | Wilf Cude | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1935–36 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (6) | New York Rangers | Tommy Gorman* | Montreal Maroons |
| 1936–37 | C | Marty Barry* | Detroit Red Wings | Art Chapman | New York Americans |
| 1936–37 | LW | Busher Jackson* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Sweeney Schriner* (2) | New York Americans |
| 1936–37 | RW | Larry Aurie | Detroit Red Wings | Cecil Dillon (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1936–37 | D | Babe Siebert* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Earl Seibert* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1936–37 | D | Ebbie Goodfellow* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Lionel Conacher* (3) | Montreal Maroons |
| 1936–37 | G | Normie Smith | Detroit Red Wings | Wilf Cude (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1936–37 | Coach | Jack Adams* | Detroit Red Wings | Cecil Hart | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1937–38 | C | Bill Cowley* | Boston Bruins | Syl Apps* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1937–38 | LW | Paul Thompson (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Toe Blake* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1937–38 | RW | Gord Drillon* | Toronto Maple Leafs | No Second Team selection in 1937–38 | No Second Team selection in 1937–38 |
| 1937–38 | RW | Cecil Dillon (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1937–38 | D | Eddie Shore* (7) | Boston Bruins | Art Coulter* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1937–38 | D | Babe Siebert* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Earl Seibert* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1937–38 | G | Tiny Thompson* (4) | Boston Bruins | Dave Kerr | New York Rangers |
| 1937–38 | Coach | Lester Patrick* (7) | New York Rangers | Art Ross* | Boston Bruins |
| 1938–39 | C | Syl Apps* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Neil Colville* | New York Rangers |
| 1938–39 | LW | Toe Blake* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Johnny Gottselig | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1938–39 | RW | Gord Drillon* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Bobby Bauer* | Boston Bruins |
| 1938–39 | D | Eddie Shore* (8) | Boston Bruins | Earl Seibert* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1938–39 | D | Dit Clapper* (3) | Boston Bruins | Art Coulter* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1938–39 | G | Frank Brimsek* | Boston Bruins | Earl Robertson | New York Americans |
| 1938–39 | Coach | Art Ross* (2) | Boston Bruins | Red Dutton* | New York Americans |
| 1939–40 | C | Milt Schmidt* | Boston Bruins | Neil Colville* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1939–40 | LW | Toe Blake* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Woody Dumart* | Boston Bruins |
| 1939–40 | RW | Bryan Hextall* | New York Rangers | Bobby Bauer* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1939–40 | D | Dit Clapper* (4) | Boston Bruins | Art Coulter* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1939–40 | D | Ebbie Goodfellow* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Earl Seibert* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1939–40 | G | Dave Kerr (2) | New York Rangers | Frank Brimsek* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1939–40 | Coach | Paul Thompson (3) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Boucher* (5) | New York Rangers |
| 1940–41 | C | Bill Cowley* (2) | Boston Bruins | Syl Apps* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1940–41 | LW | Sweeney Schriner* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Woody Dumart* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1940–41 | RW | Bryan Hextall* (2) | New York Rangers | Bobby Bauer* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1940–41 | D | Dit Clapper* (5) | Boston Bruins | Ott Heller | New York Rangers |
| 1940–41 | D | Wally Stanowski | Toronto Maple Leafs | Earl Seibert* (7) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1940–41 | G | Turk Broda* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Frank Brimsek* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1940–41 | Coach | Cooney Weiland* | Boston Bruins | Dick Irvin* (6) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1941–42 | C | Syl Apps* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Phil Watson | New York Rangers |
| 1941–42 | LW | Lynn Patrick* | New York Rangers | Sid Abel* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1941–42 | RW | Bryan Hextall* (3) | New York Rangers | Gord Drillon* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1941–42 | D | Earl Seibert* (8) | Chicago Black Hawks | Pat Egan | Brooklyn Americans |
| 1941–42 | D | Tommy Anderson | Brooklyn Americans | Bucko McDonald | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1941–42 | G | Frank Brimsek* (4) | Boston Bruins | Turk Broda* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1941–42 | Coach | Frank Boucher (6) | New York Rangers* | Paul Thompson (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |

### Original Six era (1942–43 to 1966–67)

| Season | Position | First Team | First Team | Second Team | Second Team |
| Season | Position | Player | Team | Player | Team |
| 1942–43 | C | Bill Cowley* (3) | Boston Bruins | Syl Apps* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1942–43 | LW | Doug Bentley* | Chicago Black Hawks | Lynn Patrick* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1942–43 | RW | Lorne Carr | Toronto Maple Leafs | Bryan Hextall* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1942–43 | D | Earl Seibert* (9) | Chicago Black Hawks | Jack Crawford | Boston Bruins |
| 1942–43 | D | Jack Stewart* | Detroit Red Wings | Flash Hollett | Boston Bruins |
| 1942–43 | G | Johnny Mowers | Detroit Red Wings | Frank Brimsek* (5) | Boston Bruins |
| 1942–43 | Coach | Jack Adams* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Art Ross* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1943–44 | C | Bill Cowley* (4) | Boston Bruins | Elmer Lach* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1943–44 | LW | Doug Bentley* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Herb Cain | Boston Bruins |
| 1943–44 | RW | Lorne Carr (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Maurice Richard* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1943–44 | D | Earl Seibert* (10) | Chicago Black Hawks | Emile Bouchard* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1943–44 | D | Babe Pratt* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Dit Clapper* (6) | Boston Bruins |
| 1943–44 | G | Bill Durnan* | Montreal Canadiens | Paul Bibeault | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1943–44 | Coach | Dick Irvin* (7) | Montreal Canadiens | Hap Day* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1944–45 | C | Elmer Lach* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Cowley* (5) | Boston Bruins |
| 1944–45 | LW | Toe Blake* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Syd Howe* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1944–45 | RW | Maurice Richard* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Mosienko* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1944–45 | D | Emile Bouchard* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Glen Harmon | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1944–45 | D | Flash Hollett (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Babe Pratt* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1944–45 | G | Bill Durnan* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Mike Karakas | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1944–45 | Coach | Dick Irvin* (8) | Montreal Canadiens | Jack Adams* (3) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1945–46 | C | Max Bentley* | Chicago Black Hawks | Elmer Lach* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1945–46 | LW | Gaye Stewart | Toronto Maple Leafs | Toe Blake* (5) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1945–46 | RW | Maurice Richard* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Mosienko* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1945–46 | D | Jack Crawford (2) | Boston Bruins | Ken Reardon* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1945–46 | D | Emile Bouchard* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Jack Stewart* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1945–46 | G | Bill Durnan* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Frank Brimsek* (6) | Boston Bruins |
| 1945–46 | Coach | Dick Irvin* (9) | Montreal Canadiens | Johnny Gottselig (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1946–47 | C | Milt Schmidt* (2) | Boston Bruins | Max Bentley* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1946–47 | LW | Doug Bentley* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks | Woody Dumart* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1946–47 | RW | Maurice Richard* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Bobby Bauer* (4) | Boston Bruins |
| 1946–47 | D | Ken Reardon* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Jack Stewart* (3) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1946–47 | D | Emile Bouchard* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Quackenbush* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1946–47 | G | Bill Durnan* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Frank Brimsek* (7) | Boston Bruins |
| 1947–48 | C | Elmer Lach* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Buddy O'Connor* | New York Rangers |
| 1947–48 | LW | Ted Lindsay* | Detroit Red Wings | Gaye Stewart (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1947–48 | RW | Maurice Richard* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Bud Poile* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1947–48 | D | Bill Quackenbush* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Ken Reardon* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1947–48 | D | Jack Stewart* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Neil Colville* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1947–48 | G | Turk Broda* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Frank Brimsek* (8) | Boston Bruins |
| 1948–49 | C | Sid Abel* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Doug Bentley* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1948–49 | LW | Roy Conacher* | Chicago Black Hawks | Ted Lindsay* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1948–49 | RW | Maurice Richard* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Gordie Howe* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1948–49 | D | Bill Quackenbush* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Glen Harmon (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1948–49 | D | Jack Stewart* (5) | Detroit Red Wings | Ken Reardon* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1948–49 | G | Bill Durnan* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Chuck Rayner* | New York Rangers |
| 1949–50 | C | Sid Abel* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Ted Kennedy* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1949–50 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Tony Leswick | New York Rangers |
| 1949–50 | RW | Maurice Richard* (7) | Montreal Canadiens | Gordie Howe* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1949–50 | D | Gus Mortson | Toronto Maple Leafs | Leo Reise Jr. | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1949–50 | D | Ken Reardon* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Red Kelly* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1949–50 | G | Bill Durnan* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Chuck Rayner* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1950–51 | C | Milt Schmidt* (3) | Boston Bruins | Sid Abel* (4) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1950–51 | C | Milt Schmidt* (3) | Boston Bruins | Ted Kennedy* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1950–51 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Sid Smith | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1950–51 | RW | Gordie Howe* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Maurice Richard* (8) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1950–51 | D | Red Kelly* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Jimmy Thomson | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1950–51 | D | Bill Quackenbush* (4) | Boston Bruins | Leo Reise Jr. (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1950–51 | G | Terry Sawchuk* | Detroit Red Wings | Chuck Rayner* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1951–52 | C | Elmer Lach* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Milt Schmidt* (4) | Boston Bruins |
| 1951–52 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (5) | Detroit Red Wings | Sid Smith (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1951–52 | RW | Gordie Howe* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Maurice Richard* (9) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1951–52 | D | Red Kelly* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Hy Buller | New York Rangers |
| 1951–52 | D | Doug Harvey* | Montreal Canadiens | Jimmy Thomson (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1951–52 | G | Terry Sawchuk* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Jim Henry | Boston Bruins |
| 1952–53 | C | Fleming Mackell | Boston Bruins | Alex Delvecchio* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1952–53 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (6) | Detroit Red Wings | Bert Olmstead* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1952–53 | RW | Gordie Howe* (5) | Detroit Red Wings | Maurice Richard* (10) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1952–53 | D | Red Kelly* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Bill Quackenbush* (5) | Boston Bruins |
| 1952–53 | D | Doug Harvey* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Bill Gadsby* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1952–53 | G | Terry Sawchuk* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Gerry McNeil | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1953–54 | C | Ken Mosdell | Montreal Canadiens | Ted Kennedy* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1953–54 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (7) | Detroit Red Wings | Ed Sandford | Boston Bruins |
| 1953–54 | RW | Gordie Howe* (6) | Detroit Red Wings | Maurice Richard* (11) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1953–54 | D | Red Kelly* (5) | Detroit Red Wings | Bill Gadsby* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1953–54 | D | Doug Harvey* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Tim Horton* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1953–54 | G | Harry Lumley* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Terry Sawchuk* (4) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1954–55 | C | Jean Beliveau* | Montreal Canadiens | Ken Mosdell (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1954–55 | LW | Sid Smith (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Danny Lewicki | New York Rangers |
| 1954–55 | RW | Maurice Richard* (12) | Montreal Canadiens | Bernie Geoffrion* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1954–55 | D | Doug Harvey* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Bob Goldham | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1954–55 | D | Red Kelly* (6) | Detroit Red Wings | Fernie Flaman* | Boston Bruins |
| 1954–55 | G | Harry Lumley* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Terry Sawchuk* (5) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1955–56 | C | Jean Beliveau* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Tod Sloan | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1955–56 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (8) | Detroit Red Wings | Bert Olmstead* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1955–56 | RW | Maurice Richard* (13) | Montreal Canadiens | Gordie Howe* (7) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1955–56 | D | Doug Harvey* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Red Kelly* (7) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1955–56 | D | Bill Gadsby* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks | Tom Johnson* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1955–56 | G | Jacques Plante* | Montreal Canadiens | Glenn Hall* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1956–57 | C | Jean Beliveau* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Ed Litzenberger | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1956–57 | LW | Ted Lindsay* (9) | Detroit Red Wings | Real Chevrefils | Boston Bruins |
| 1956–57 | RW | Gordie Howe* (8) | Detroit Red Wings | Maurice Richard* (14) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1956–57 | D | Doug Harvey* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Fernie Flaman* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1956–57 | D | Red Kelly* (8) | Detroit Red Wings | Bill Gadsby* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1956–57 | G | Glenn Hall* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Jacques Plante* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1957–58 | C | Henri Richard* | Montreal Canadiens | Jean Beliveau* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1957–58 | LW | Dickie Moore* | Montreal Canadiens | Camille Henry | New York Rangers |
| 1957–58 | RW | Gordie Howe* (9) | Detroit Red Wings | Andy Bathgate* | New York Rangers |
| 1957–58 | D | Doug Harvey* (7) | Montreal Canadiens | Fernie Flaman* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1957–58 | D | Bill Gadsby* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks | Marcel Pronovost* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1957–58 | G | Glenn Hall* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks | Jacques Plante* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1958–59 | C | Jean Beliveau* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Henri Richard* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1958–59 | LW | Dickie Moore* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Alex Delvecchio* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1958–59 | RW | Andy Bathgate* (2) | New York Rangers | Gordie Howe* (10) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1958–59 | D | Tom Johnson* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Marcel Pronovost* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1958–59 | D | Bill Gadsby* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks | Doug Harvey* (8) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1958–59 | G | Jacques Plante* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Terry Sawchuk* (6) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1959–60 | C | Jean Beliveau* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Bronco Horvath | Boston Bruins |
| 1959–60 | LW | Bobby Hull* | Chicago Black Hawks | Dean Prentice | New York Rangers |
| 1959–60 | RW | Gordie Howe* (11) | Detroit Red Wings | Bernie Geoffrion* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1959–60 | D | Doug Harvey* (9) | Montreal Canadiens | Allan Stanley* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1959–60 | D | Marcel Pronovost* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Pierre Pilote* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1959–60 | G | Glenn Hall* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks | Jacques Plante* (5) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1960–61 | C | Jean Beliveau* (7) | Montreal Canadiens | Henri Richard* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1960–61 | LW | Frank Mahovlich* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Dickie Moore* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1960–61 | RW | Bernie Geoffrion* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Gordie Howe* (12) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1960–61 | D | Doug Harvey* (10) | Montreal Canadiens | Allan Stanley* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1960–61 | D | Marcel Pronovost* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Pierre Pilote* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1960–61 | G | Johnny Bower* | Toronto Maple Leafs | Glenn Hall* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1961–62 | C | Stan Mikita* | Chicago Black Hawks | Dave Keon* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1961–62 | LW | Bobby Hull* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1961–62 | RW | Andy Bathgate* (3) | New York Rangers | Gordie Howe* (13) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1961–62 | D | Doug Harvey* (11) | New York Rangers | Carl Brewer | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1961–62 | D | Jean-Guy Talbot | Montreal Canadiens | Pierre Pilote* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1961–62 | G | Jacques Plante* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Glenn Hall* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1962–63 | C | Stan Mikita* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Henri Richard* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1962–63 | LW | Frank Mahovlich* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Bobby Hull* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1962–63 | RW | Gordie Howe* (14) | Detroit Red Wings | Andy Bathgate* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1962–63 | D | Pierre Pilote* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks | Tim Horton* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1962–63 | D | Carl Brewer (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Elmer Vasko | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1962–63 | G | Glenn Hall* (7) | Chicago Black Hawks | Terry Sawchuk* (7) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1963–64 | C | Stan Mikita* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks | Jean Beliveau* (8) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1963–64 | LW | Bobby Hull* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1963–64 | RW | Kenny Wharram | Chicago Black Hawks | Gordie Howe* (15) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1963–64 | D | Pierre Pilote* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks | Elmer Vasko (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1963–64 | D | Tim Horton* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Jacques Laperriere* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1963–64 | G | Glenn Hall* (8) | Chicago Black Hawks | Charlie Hodge | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1964–65 | C | Norm Ullman* | Detroit Red Wings | Stan Mikita* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1964–65 | LW | Bobby Hull* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1964–65 | RW | Claude Provost | Montreal Canadiens | Gordie Howe* (16) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1964–65 | D | Pierre Pilote* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks | Bill Gadsby* (7) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1964–65 | D | Jacques Laperriere* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Carl Brewer (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1964–65 | G | Roger Crozier | Detroit Red Wings | Charlie Hodge (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1965–66 | C | Stan Mikita* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks | Jean Beliveau* (9) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1965–66 | LW | Bobby Hull* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (6) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1965–66 | RW | Gordie Howe* (17) | Detroit Red Wings | Bobby Rousseau | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1965–66 | D | Jacques Laperriere* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Allan Stanley* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1965–66 | D | Pierre Pilote* (7) | Chicago Black Hawks | Pat Stapleton | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1965–66 | G | Glenn Hall* (9) | Chicago Black Hawks | Gump Worsley* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1966–67 | C | Stan Mikita* (6) | Chicago Black Hawks | Norm Ullman* (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1966–67 | LW | Bobby Hull* (7) | Chicago Black Hawks | Don Marshall | New York Rangers |
| 1966–67 | RW | Kenny Wharram (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Gordie Howe* (18) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1966–67 | D | Pierre Pilote* (8) | Chicago Black Hawks | Tim Horton* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1966–67 | D | Harry Howell* | New York Rangers | Bobby Orr* | Boston Bruins |
| 1966–67 | G | Eddie Giacomin* | New York Rangers | Glenn Hall* (10) | Chicago Black Hawks |

### Expansion era (1967–68 to 2004–05)

| Season | Position | First Team | First Team | Second Team | Second Team |
| Season | Position | Player | Team | Player | Team |
| 1967–68 | C | Stan Mikita* (7) | Chicago Black Hawks | Phil Esposito* | Boston Bruins |
| 1967–68 | LW | Bobby Hull* (8) | Chicago Black Hawks | Johnny Bucyk* | Boston Bruins |
| 1967–68 | RW | Gordie Howe* (19) | Detroit Red Wings | Rod Gilbert* | New York Rangers |
| 1967–68 | D | Bobby Orr* (2) | Boston Bruins | J. C. Tremblay | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1967–68 | D | Tim Horton* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Jim Neilson | New York Rangers |
| 1967–68 | G | Gump Worsley* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Eddie Giacomin* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1968–69 | C | Phil Esposito* (2) | Boston Bruins | Jean Beliveau* (10) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1968–69 | LW | Bobby Hull* (9) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (7) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1968–69 | RW | Gordie Howe* (20) | Detroit Red Wings | Yvan Cournoyer* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1968–69 | D | Bobby Orr* (3) | Boston Bruins | Ted Green | Boston Bruins |
| 1968–69 | D | Tim Horton* (6) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Ted Harris | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1968–69 | G | Glenn Hall* (11) | St. Louis Blues | Eddie Giacomin* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1969–70 | C | Phil Esposito* (3) | Boston Bruins | Stan Mikita* (8) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1969–70 | LW | Bobby Hull* (10) | Chicago Black Hawks | Frank Mahovlich* (8) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1969–70 | RW | Gordie Howe* (21) | Detroit Red Wings | John McKenzie | Boston Bruins |
| 1969–70 | D | Bobby Orr* (4) | Boston Bruins | Carl Brewer (4) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1969–70 | D | Brad Park* | New York Rangers | Jacques Laperriere* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1969–70 | G | Tony Esposito* | Chicago Black Hawks | Eddie Giacomin* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1970–71 | C | Phil Esposito* (4) | Boston Bruins | Dave Keon* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1970–71 | LW | Johnny Bucyk* (2) | Boston Bruins | Bobby Hull* (11) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1970–71 | RW | Ken Hodge | Boston Bruins | Yvan Cournoyer* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1970–71 | D | Bobby Orr* (5) | Boston Bruins | Pat Stapleton (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1970–71 | D | J. C. Tremblay (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Brad Park* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 1970–71 | G | Eddie Giacomin* (5) | New York Rangers | Jacques Plante* (7) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1971–72 | C | Phil Esposito* (5) | Boston Bruins | Jean Ratelle* | New York Rangers |
| 1971–72 | LW | Bobby Hull* (12) | Chicago Black Hawks | Vic Hadfield | New York Rangers |
| 1971–72 | RW | Rod Gilbert* (2) | New York Rangers | Yvan Cournoyer* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1971–72 | D | Bobby Orr* (6) | Boston Bruins | Bill White | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1971–72 | D | Brad Park* (3) | New York Rangers | Pat Stapleton (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1971–72 | G | Tony Esposito* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks | Ken Dryden* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1972–73 | C | Phil Esposito* (6) | Boston Bruins | Bobby Clarke* | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1972–73 | LW | Frank Mahovlich* (9) | Montreal Canadiens | Dennis Hull | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1972–73 | RW | Mickey Redmond | Detroit Red Wings | Yvan Cournoyer* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1972–73 | D | Bobby Orr* (7) | Boston Bruins | Brad Park* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1972–73 | D | Guy Lapointe* | Montreal Canadiens | Bill White (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1972–73 | G | Ken Dryden* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Tony Esposito* (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1973–74 | C | Phil Esposito* (7) | Boston Bruins | Bobby Clarke* (2) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1973–74 | LW | Rick Martin | Buffalo Sabres | Wayne Cashman | Boston Bruins |
| 1973–74 | RW | Ken Hodge (2) | Boston Bruins | Mickey Redmond (2) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1973–74 | D | Bobby Orr* (8) | Boston Bruins | Bill White (3) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1973–74 | D | Brad Park* (5) | New York Rangers | Barry Ashbee | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1973–74 | G | Bernie Parent* | Philadelphia Flyers | Tony Esposito* (4) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1974–75 | C | Bobby Clarke* (3) | Philadelphia Flyers | Phil Esposito* (8) | Boston Bruins |
| 1974–75 | LW | Rick Martin (2) | Buffalo Sabres | Steve Vickers | New York Rangers |
| 1974–75 | RW | Guy Lafleur* | Montreal Canadiens | Rene Robert | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1974–75 | D | Bobby Orr* (9) | Boston Bruins | Guy Lapointe* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1974–75 | D | Denis Potvin* | New York Islanders | Borje Salming* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1974–75 | G | Bernie Parent* (2) | Philadelphia Flyers | Rogie Vachon* | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1975–76 | C | Bobby Clarke* (4) | Philadelphia Flyers | Gilbert Perreault* | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1975–76 | LW | Bill Barber* | Philadelphia Flyers | Rick Martin (3) | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1975–76 | RW | Guy Lafleur* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Reggie Leach | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1975–76 | D | Denis Potvin* (2) | New York Islanders | Borje Salming* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1975–76 | D | Brad Park* (6) | New York Rangers Boston Bruins | Guy Lapointe* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1975–76 | G | Ken Dryden* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Glenn Resch | New York Islanders |
| 1976–77 | C | Marcel Dionne* | Los Angeles Kings | Gilbert Perreault* (2) | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1976–77 | LW | Steve Shutt* | Montreal Canadiens | Rick Martin (4) | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1976–77 | RW | Guy Lafleur* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Lanny McDonald* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1976–77 | D | Larry Robinson* | Montreal Canadiens | Denis Potvin* (3) | New York Islanders |
| 1976–77 | D | Borje Salming* (3) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Guy Lapointe* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1976–77 | G | Ken Dryden* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Rogie Vachon* (2) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1977–78 | C | Bryan Trottier* | New York Islanders | Darryl Sittler* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1977–78 | LW | Clark Gillies* | New York Islanders | Steve Shutt* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1977–78 | RW | Guy Lafleur* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Mike Bossy* | New York Islanders |
| 1977–78 | D | Denis Potvin* (4) | New York Islanders | Larry Robinson* (2) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1977–78 | D | Brad Park* (7) | Boston Bruins | Borje Salming* (4) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1977–78 | G | Ken Dryden* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Don Edwards | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1978–79 | C | Bryan Trottier* (2) | New York Islanders | Marcel Dionne* (2) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1978–79 | LW | Clark Gillies* (2) | New York Islanders | Bill Barber* (2) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1978–79 | RW | Guy Lafleur* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Mike Bossy* (2) | New York Islanders |
| 1978–79 | D | Denis Potvin* (5) | New York Islanders | Borje Salming* (5) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1978–79 | D | Larry Robinson* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Serge Savard* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1978–79 | G | Ken Dryden* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Glenn Resch (2) | New York Islanders |
| 1979–80 | C | Marcel Dionne* (3) | Los Angeles Kings | Wayne Gretzky* | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1979–80 | LW | Charlie Simmer | Los Angeles Kings | Steve Shutt* (3) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1979–80 | RW | Guy Lafleur* (6) | Montreal Canadiens | Danny Gare | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1979–80 | D | Larry Robinson* (4) | Montreal Canadiens | Borje Salming* (6) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 1979–80 | D | Ray Bourque* | Boston Bruins | Jim Schoenfeld | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1979–80 | G | Tony Esposito* (5) | Chicago Black Hawks | Don Edwards (2) | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1980–81 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (2) | Edmonton Oilers | Marcel Dionne* (4) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1980–81 | LW | Charlie Simmer (2) | Los Angeles Kings | Bill Barber* (3) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1980–81 | RW | Mike Bossy* (3) | New York Islanders | Dave Taylor | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1980–81 | D | Denis Potvin* (6) | New York Islanders | Larry Robinson* (5) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1980–81 | D | Randy Carlyle | Pittsburgh Penguins | Ray Bourque* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1980–81 | G | Mike Liut | St. Louis Blues | Mario Lessard | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1981–82 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (3) | Edmonton Oilers | Bryan Trottier* (3) | New York Islanders |
| 1981–82 | LW | Mark Messier* | Edmonton Oilers | John Tonelli | New York Islanders |
| 1981–82 | RW | Mike Bossy* (4) | New York Islanders | Rick Middleton | Boston Bruins |
| 1981–82 | D | Doug Wilson* | Chicago Black Hawks | Paul Coffey* | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1981–82 | D | Ray Bourque* (3) | Boston Bruins | Brian Engblom | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1981–82 | G | Billy Smith* | New York Islanders | Grant Fuhr* | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1982–83 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (4) | Edmonton Oilers | Denis Savard* | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1982–83 | LW | Mark Messier* (2) | Edmonton Oilers | Michel Goulet* | Quebec Nordiques |
| 1982–83 | RW | Mike Bossy* (5) | New York Islanders | Lanny McDonald* (2) | Calgary Flames |
| 1982–83 | D | Mark Howe* | Philadelphia Flyers | Paul Coffey* (2) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1982–83 | D | Rod Langway* | Washington Capitals | Ray Bourque* (4) | Boston Bruins |
| 1982–83 | G | Pete Peeters | Boston Bruins | Roland Melanson | New York Islanders |
| 1983–84 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (5) | Edmonton Oilers | Bryan Trottier* (4) | New York Islanders |
| 1983–84 | LW | Michel Goulet* (2) | Quebec Nordiques | Mark Messier* (3) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1983–84 | RW | Mike Bossy* (6) | New York Islanders | Jari Kurri* | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1983–84 | D | Rod Langway* (2) | Washington Capitals | Paul Coffey* (3) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1983–84 | D | Ray Bourque* (5) | Boston Bruins | Denis Potvin* (7) | New York Islanders |
| 1983–84 | G | Tom Barrasso* | Buffalo Sabres | Pat Riggin | Washington Capitals |
| 1984–85 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (6) | Edmonton Oilers | Dale Hawerchuk* | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1984–85 | LW | John Ogrodnick | Detroit Red Wings | John Tonelli (2) | New York Islanders |
| 1984–85 | RW | Jari Kurri* (2) | Edmonton Oilers | Mike Bossy* (7) | New York Islanders |
| 1984–85 | D | Paul Coffey* (4) | Edmonton Oilers | Rod Langway* (3) | Washington Capitals |
| 1984–85 | D | Ray Bourque* (6) | Boston Bruins | Doug Wilson* (2) | Chicago Black Hawks |
| 1984–85 | G | Pelle Lindbergh | Philadelphia Flyers | Tom Barrasso* (2) | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1985–86 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (7) | Edmonton Oilers | Mario Lemieux* | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1985–86 | LW | Michel Goulet* (3) | Quebec Nordiques | Mats Naslund | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1985–86 | RW | Mike Bossy* (8) | New York Islanders | Jari Kurri* (3) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1985–86 | D | Paul Coffey* (5) | Edmonton Oilers | Larry Robinson* (6) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1985–86 | D | Mark Howe* (2) | Philadelphia Flyers | Ray Bourque* (7) | Boston Bruins |
| 1985–86 | G | John Vanbiesbrouck | New York Rangers | Bob Froese | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1986–87 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (8) | Edmonton Oilers | Mario Lemieux* (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1986–87 | LW | Michel Goulet* (4) | Quebec Nordiques | Luc Robitaille* | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1986–87 | RW | Jari Kurri* (4) | Edmonton Oilers | Tim Kerr | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1986–87 | D | Ray Bourque* (8) | Boston Bruins | Larry Murphy* | Washington Capitals |
| 1986–87 | D | Mark Howe* (3) | Philadelphia Flyers | Al MacInnis* | Calgary Flames |
| 1986–87 | G | Ron Hextall | Philadelphia Flyers | Mike Liut (2) | Hartford Whalers |
| 1987–88 | C | Mario Lemieux* (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Wayne Gretzky* (9) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1987–88 | LW | Luc Robitaille* (2) | Los Angeles Kings | Michel Goulet* (5) | Quebec Nordiques |
| 1987–88 | RW | Haakon Loob | Calgary Flames | Cam Neely* | Boston Bruins |
| 1987–88 | D | Ray Bourque* (9) | Boston Bruins | Gary Suter | Calgary Flames |
| 1987–88 | D | Scott Stevens* | Washington Capitals | Brad McCrimmon | Calgary Flames |
| 1987–88 | G | Grant Fuhr* (2) | Edmonton Oilers | Patrick Roy* | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1988–89 | C | Mario Lemieux* (4) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Wayne Gretzky* (10) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1988–89 | LW | Luc Robitaille* (3) | Los Angeles Kings | Gerard Gallant | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1988–89 | RW | Joe Mullen* | Calgary Flames | Jari Kurri* (5) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 1988–89 | D | Chris Chelios* | Montreal Canadiens | Al MacInnis* (2) | Calgary Flames |
| 1988–89 | D | Paul Coffey* (6) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Ray Bourque* (10) | Boston Bruins |
| 1988–89 | G | Patrick Roy* (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Mike Vernon* | Calgary Flames |
| 1989–90 | C | Mark Messier* (4) | Edmonton Oilers | Wayne Gretzky* (11) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1989–90 | LW | Luc Robitaille* (4) | Los Angeles Kings | Brian Bellows | Minnesota North Stars |
| 1989–90 | RW | Brett Hull* | St. Louis Blues | Cam Neely* (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 1989–90 | D | Ray Bourque* (11) | Boston Bruins | Paul Coffey* (7) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1989–90 | D | Al MacInnis* (3) | Calgary Flames | Doug Wilson* (3) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 1989–90 | G | Patrick Roy* (3) | Montreal Canadiens | Daren Puppa | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1990–91 | C | Wayne Gretzky* (12) | Los Angeles Kings | Adam Oates* | St. Louis Blues |
| 1990–91 | LW | Luc Robitaille* (5) | Los Angeles Kings | Kevin Stevens | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1990–91 | RW | Brett Hull* (2) | St. Louis Blues | Cam Neely* (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 1990–91 | D | Ray Bourque* (12) | Boston Bruins | Chris Chelios* (2) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 1990–91 | D | Al MacInnis* (4) | Calgary Flames | Brian Leetch* | New York Rangers |
| 1990–91 | G | Ed Belfour* | Chicago Blackhawks | Patrick Roy* (4) | Montreal Canadiens |
| 1991–92 | C | Mark Messier* (5) | New York Rangers | Mario Lemieux* (5) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1991–92 | LW | Kevin Stevens (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Luc Robitaille* (6) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1991–92 | RW | Brett Hull* (3) | St. Louis Blues | Mark Recchi* | Pittsburgh Penguins Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1991–92 | D | Brian Leetch* (2) | New York Rangers | Phil Housley* | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1991–92 | D | Ray Bourque* (13) | Boston Bruins | Scott Stevens* (2) | New Jersey Devils |
| 1991–92 | G | Patrick Roy* (5) | Montreal Canadiens | Kirk McLean | Vancouver Canucks |
| 1992–93 | C | Mario Lemieux* (6) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Pat LaFontaine* | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1992–93 | LW | Luc Robitaille* (7) | Los Angeles Kings | Kevin Stevens (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1992–93 | RW | Teemu Selanne* | Winnipeg Jets | Alexander Mogilny | Buffalo Sabres |
| 1992–93 | D | Chris Chelios* (3) | Chicago Blackhawks | Larry Murphy* (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1992–93 | D | Ray Bourque* (14) | Boston Bruins | Al Iafrate | Washington Capitals |
| 1992–93 | G | Ed Belfour* (2) | Chicago Blackhawks | Tom Barrasso* (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1993–94 | C | Sergei Fedorov* | Detroit Red Wings | Wayne Gretzky* (13) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1993–94 | LW | Brendan Shanahan* | St. Louis Blues | Adam Graves | New York Rangers |
| 1993–94 | RW | Pavel Bure* | Vancouver Canucks | Cam Neely* (4) | Boston Bruins |
| 1993–94 | D | Ray Bourque* (15) | Boston Bruins | Al MacInnis* (5) | Calgary Flames |
| 1993–94 | D | Scott Stevens* (3) | New Jersey Devils | Brian Leetch* (3) | New York Rangers |
| 1993–94 | G | Dominik Hasek* | Buffalo Sabres | John Vanbiesbrouck (2) | Florida Panthers |
| 1994–95 | C | Eric Lindros* | Philadelphia Flyers | Alexei Zhamnov | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1994–95 | LW | John LeClair | Montreal Canadiens Philadelphia Flyers | Keith Tkachuk | Winnipeg Jets |
| 1994–95 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ | Pittsburgh Penguins | Theoren Fleury | Calgary Flames |
| 1994–95 | D | Paul Coffey* (8) | Detroit Red Wings | Ray Bourque* (16) | Boston Bruins |
| 1994–95 | D | Chris Chelios* (4) | Chicago Blackhawks | Larry Murphy* (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1994–95 | G | Dominik Hasek* (2) | Buffalo Sabres | Ed Belfour* (3) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 1995–96 | C | Mario Lemieux* (7) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Eric Lindros* (2) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1995–96 | LW | Paul Kariya* | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim | John LeClair (2) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1995–96 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Alexander Mogilny (2) | Vancouver Canucks |
| 1995–96 | D | Chris Chelios* (5) | Chicago Blackhawks | Brian Leetch* (4) | New York Rangers |
| 1995–96 | D | Ray Bourque* (17) | Boston Bruins | Vladimir Konstantinov | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1995–96 | G | Jim Carey | Washington Capitals | Chris Osgood | Detroit Red Wings |
| 1996–97 | C | Mario Lemieux* (8) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Wayne Gretzky* (14) | New York Rangers |
| 1996–97 | LW | Paul Kariya* (2) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim | John LeClair (3) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1996–97 | RW | Teemu Selanne* (2) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 1996–97 | D | Brian Leetch* (5) | New York Rangers | Chris Chelios* (6) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 1996–97 | D | Sandis Ozolinsh | Colorado Avalanche | Scott Stevens* (4) | New Jersey Devils |
| 1996–97 | G | Dominik Hasek* (3) | Buffalo Sabres | Martin Brodeur* | New Jersey Devils |
| 1997–98 | C | Peter Forsberg* | Colorado Avalanche | Wayne Gretzky* (15) | New York Rangers |
| 1997–98 | LW | John LeClair (4) | Philadelphia Flyers | Keith Tkachuk (2) | Phoenix Coyotes |
| 1997–98 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (4) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Temmu Selanne* (3) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim |
| 1997–98 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* | Detroit Red Wings | Chris Pronger* | St. Louis Blues |
| 1997–98 | D | Rob Blake* | Los Angeles Kings | Scott Niedermayer* | New Jersey Devils |
| 1997–98 | G | Dominik Hasek* (4) | Buffalo Sabres | Martin Brodeur* (2) | New Jersey Devils |
| 1998–99 | C | Peter Forsberg* (2) | Colorado Avalanche | Alexei Yashin | Ottawa Senators |
| 1998–99 | LW | Paul Kariya* (3) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim | John LeClair (5) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1998–99 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (5) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Teemu Selanne* (4) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim |
| 1998–99 | D | Al MacInnis* (6) | St. Louis Blues | Ray Bourque* (18) | Boston Bruins |
| 1998–99 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Eric Desjardins | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1998–99 | G | Dominik Hasek* (5) | Buffalo Sabres | Byron Dafoe | Boston Bruins |
| 1999–2000 | C | Steve Yzerman* | Detroit Red Wings | Mike Modano* | Dallas Stars |
| 1999–2000 | LW | Brendan Shanahan* (2) | Detroit Red Wings | Paul Kariya* (4) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim |
| 1999–2000 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (6) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Pavel Bure* (2) | Florida Panthers |
| 1999–2000 | D | Chris Pronger* (2) | St. Louis Blues | Rob Blake* (2) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 1999–2000 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (3) | Detroit Red Wings | Eric Desjardins (2) | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 1999–2000 | G | Olaf Kolzig | Washington Capitals | Roman Turek | St. Louis Blues |
| 2000–01 | C | Joe Sakic* | Colorado Avalanche | Mario Lemieux* (9) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2000–01 | LW | Patrik Elias | New Jersey Devils | Luc Robitaille* (8) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 2000–01 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (7) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Pavel Bure* (3) | Florida Panthers |
| 2000–01 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (4) | Detroit Red Wings | Rob Blake* (3) | Los Angeles Kings Colorado Avalanche |
| 2000–01 | D | Ray Bourque* (19) | Colorado Avalanche | Scott Stevens* (5) | New Jersey Devils |
| 2000–01 | G | Dominik Hasek* (6) | Buffalo Sabres | Roman Cechmanek | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 2001–02 | C | Joe Sakic* (2) | Colorado Avalanche | Mats Sundin* | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 2001–02 | LW | Markus Naslund | Vancouver Canucks | Brendan Shanahan* (3) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2001–02 | RW | Jarome Iginla* | Calgary Flames | Bill Guerin | Boston Bruins |
| 2001–02 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (5) | Detroit Red Wings | Rob Blake* (4) | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2001–02 | D | Chris Chelios* (7) | Detroit Red Wings | Sergei Gonchar | Washington Capitals |
| 2001–02 | G | Patrick Roy* (6) | Colorado Avalanche | Jose Theodore | Montreal Canadiens |
| 2002–03 | C | Peter Forsberg* (3) | Colorado Avalanche | Joe Thornton$^†$ | Boston Bruins |
| 2002–03 | LW | Markus Naslund (2) | Vancouver Canucks | Paul Kariya* (5) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim |
| 2002–03 | RW | Todd Bertuzzi | Vancouver Canucks | Milan Hejduk | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2002–03 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (6) | Detroit Red Wings | Sergei Gonchar (2) | Washington Capitals |
| 2002–03 | D | Al MacInnis* (7) | St. Louis Blues | Derian Hatcher | Dallas Stars |
| 2002–03 | G | Martin Brodeur* (3) | New Jersey Devils | Marty Turco | Dallas Stars |
| 2003–04 | C | Joe Sakic* (3) | Colorado Avalanche | Mats Sundin* (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 2003–04 | LW | Markus Naslund (3) | Vancouver Canucks | Ilya Kovalchuk$^†$ | Atlanta Thrashers |
| 2003–04 | RW | Martin St. Louis* | Tampa Bay Lightning | Jarome Iginla* (2) | Calgary Flames |
| 2003–04 | D | Scott Niedermayer* (2) | New Jersey Devils | Chris Pronger* (3) | St. Louis Blues |
| 2003–04 | D | Zdeno Chara$^†$ | Ottawa Senators | Bryan McCabe | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 2003–04 | G | Martin Brodeur* (4) | New Jersey Devils | Roberto Luongo* | Florida Panthers |
| 2004–05 | Season cancelled due to the 2004–05 NHL lockout | Season cancelled due to the 2004–05 NHL lockout | Season cancelled due to the 2004–05 NHL lockout | Season cancelled due to the 2004–05 NHL lockout | Season cancelled due to the 2004–05 NHL lockout |

### Post-lockout era (2005–06 to present)

| Season | Position | First Team | First Team | Second Team | Second Team |
| Season | Position | Player | Team | Player | Team |
| 2005–06 | C | Joe Thornton$^†$ (2) | Boston Bruins San Jose Sharks | Eric Staal$^†$ | Carolina Hurricanes |
| 2005–06 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ | Washington Capitals | Dany Heatley | Ottawa Senators |
| 2005–06 | RW | Jaromir Jagr$^†$ (8) | New York Rangers | Daniel Alfredsson* | Ottawa Senators |
| 2005–06 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (7) | Detroit Red Wings | Sergei Zubov* | Dallas Stars |
| 2005–06 | D | Scott Niedermayer* (3) | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (2) | Ottawa Senators |
| 2005–06 | G | Miikka Kiprusoff | Calgary Flames | Martin Brodeur* (5) | New Jersey Devils |
| 2006–07 | C | Sidney Crosby^ | Pittsburgh Penguins | Vincent Lecavalier | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2006–07 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (2) | Washington Capitals | Thomas Vanek | Buffalo Sabres |
| 2006–07 | RW | Dany Heatley (2) | Ottawa Senators | Martin St. Louis* (2) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2006–07 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (8) | Detroit Red Wings | Chris Pronger* (4) | Anaheim Ducks |
| 2006–07 | D | Scott Niedermayer* (4) | Anaheim Ducks | Dan Boyle | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2006–07 | G | Martin Brodeur* (6) | New Jersey Devils | Roberto Luongo* (2) | Vancouver Canucks |
| 2007–08 | C | Evgeni Malkin^ | Pittsburgh Penguins | Joe Thornton$^†$ (3) | San Jose Sharks |
| 2007–08 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (3) | Washington Capitals | Henrik Zetterberg | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2007–08 | RW | Jarome Iginla* (3) | Calgary Flames | Alexei Kovalev | Montreal Canadiens |
| 2007–08 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (9) | Detroit Red Wings | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 2007–08 | D | Dion Phaneuf | Calgary Flames | Brian Campbell | Buffalo Sabres San Jose Sharks |
| 2007–08 | G | Evgeni Nabokov | San Jose Sharks | Martin Brodeur* (7) | New Jersey Devils |
| 2008–09 | C | Evgeni Malkin^ (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Pavel Datsyuk* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2008–09 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (4) | Washington Capitals | Zach Parise$^†$ | New Jersey Devils |
| 2008–09 | RW | Jarome Iginla* (4) | Calgary Flames | Marian Hossa* | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2008–09 | D | Mike Green | Washington Capitals | Nicklas Lidstrom* (10) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2008–09 | D | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (4) | Boston Bruins | Dan Boyle (2) | San Jose Sharks |
| 2008–09 | G | Tim Thomas | Boston Bruins | Steve Mason | Columbus Blue Jackets |
| 2009–10 | C | Henrik Sedin* | Vancouver Canucks | Sidney Crosby^ (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2009–10 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (5) | Washington Capitals | Daniel Sedin* | Vancouver Canucks |
| 2009–10 | RW | Patrick Kane^ | Chicago Blackhawks | Martin St. Louis* (3) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2009–10 | D | Duncan Keith$^†$ | Chicago Blackhawks | Drew Doughty^ | Los Angeles Kings |
| 2009–10 | D | Mike Green (2) | Washington Capitals | Nicklas Lidstrom* (11) | Detroit Red Wings |
| 2009–10 | G | Ryan Miller | Buffalo Sabres | Ilya Bryzgalov | Phoenix Coyotes |
| 2010–11 | C | Henrik Sedin* (2) | Vancouver Canucks | Steven Stamkos^ | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2010–11 | LW | Daniel Sedin* (2) | Vancouver Canucks | Alexander Ovechkin^ (6) | Washington Capitals |
| 2010–11 | RW | Corey Perry^ | Anaheim Ducks | Martin St. Louis* (4) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2010–11 | D | Nicklas Lidstrom* (12) | Detroit Red Wings | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (5) | Boston Bruins |
| 2010–11 | D | Shea Weber* | Nashville Predators | Lubomir Visnovsky | Anaheim Ducks |
| 2010–11 | G | Tim Thomas (2) | Boston Bruins | Pekka Rinne | Nashville Predators |
| 2011–12 | C | Evgeni Malkin^ (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Steven Stamkos^ (2) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2011–12 | LW | Ilya Kovalchuk$^†$ (2) | New Jersey Devils | Ray Whitney | Phoenix Coyotes |
| 2011–12 | RW | James Neal$^†$ | Pittsburgh Penguins | Marian Gaborik | New York Rangers |
| 2011–12 | D | Erik Karlsson^ | Ottawa Senators | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (6) | Boston Bruins |
| 2011–12 | D | Shea Weber* (2) | Nashville Predators | Alex Pietrangelo^ | St. Louis Blues |
| 2011–12 | G | Henrik Lundqvist* | New York Rangers | Jonathan Quick^ | Los Angeles Kings |
| 2012–13 | C | Sidney Crosby^ (3) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Jonathan Toews$^†$ | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 2012–13 | LW | Chris Kunitz | Pittsburgh Penguins | Alexander Ovechkin^ (8) | Washington Capitals |
| 2012–13 | RW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (7) | Washington Capitals | Martin St. Louis* (5) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2012–13 | D | P. K. Subban$^†$ | Montreal Canadiens | Kris Letang^ | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2012–13 | D | Ryan Suter^ | Minnesota Wild | Francois Beauchemin | Anaheim Ducks |
| 2012–13 | G | Sergei Bobrovsky^ | Columbus Blue Jackets | Henrik Lundqvist* (2) | New York Rangers |
| 2013–14 | C | Sidney Crosby^ (4) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Ryan Getzlaf$^†$ | Anaheim Ducks |
| 2013–14 | LW | Jamie Benn^ | Dallas Stars | Joe Pavelski$^†$ | San Jose Sharks |
| 2013–14 | RW | Corey Perry^ (2) | Anaheim Ducks | Alexander Ovechkin^ (9) | Washington Capitals |
| 2013–14 | D | Duncan Keith$^†$ (2) | Chicago Blackhawks | Shea Weber* (3) | Nashville Predators |
| 2013–14 | D | Zdeno Chara$^†$ (7) | Boston Bruins | Alex Pietrangelo^ (2) | St. Louis Blues |
| 2013–14 | G | Tuukka Rask$^†$ | Boston Bruins | Semyon Varlamov^ | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2014–15 | C | John Tavares^ | New York Islanders | Sidney Crosby^ (5) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2014–15 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (10) | Washington Capitals | Jamie Benn^ (2) | Dallas Stars |
| 2014–15 | RW | Jakub Voracek$^†$ | Philadelphia Flyers | Vladimir Tarasenko^ | St. Louis Blues |
| 2014–15 | D | Erik Karlsson^ (2) | Ottawa Senators | Drew Doughty^ (2) | Los Angeles Kings |
| 2014–15 | D | P. K. Subban$^†$ (2) | Montreal Canadiens | Shea Weber* (4) | Nashville Predators |
| 2014–15 | G | Carey Price$^†$ | Montreal Canadiens | Devan Dubnyk$^†$ | Arizona Coyotes Minnesota Wild |
| 2015–16 | C | Sidney Crosby^ (6) | Pittsburgh Penguins | Joe Thornton$^†$ (4) | San Jose Sharks |
| 2015–16 | LW | Jamie Benn^ (3) | Dallas Stars | Alexander Ovechkin^ (11) | Washington Capitals |
| 2015–16 | RW | Patrick Kane^ (2) | Chicago Blackhawks | Vladimir Tarasenko^ (2) | St. Louis Blues |
| 2015–16 | D | Drew Doughty^ (3) | Los Angeles Kings | Brent Burns^ | San Jose Sharks |
| 2015–16 | D | Erik Karlsson^ (3) | Ottawa Senators | Kris Letang^ (2) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2015–16 | G | Braden Holtby$^†$ | Washington Capitals | Ben Bishop$^†$ | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2016–17 | C | Connor McDavid^ | Edmonton Oilers | Sidney Crosby^ (7) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2016–17 | LW | Brad Marchand^ | Boston Bruins | Artemi Panarin^ | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 2016–17 | RW | Patrick Kane^ (3) | Chicago Blackhawks | Nikita Kucherov^ | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2016–17 | D | Brent Burns^ (2) | San Jose Sharks | Victor Hedman^ | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2016–17 | D | Erik Karlsson^ (4) | Ottawa Senators | Duncan Keith$^†$ (3) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 2016–17 | G | Sergei Bobrovsky^ (2) | Columbus Blue Jackets | Braden Holtby$^†$ (2) | Washington Capitals |
| 2017–18 | C | Connor McDavid^ (2) | Edmonton Oilers | Nathan MacKinnon^ | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2017–18 | LW | Taylor Hall^ | New Jersey Devils | Claude Giroux^ | Philadelphia Flyers |
| 2017–18 | RW | Nikita Kucherov^ (2) | Tampa Bay Lightning | Blake Wheeler^ | Winnipeg Jets |
| 2017–18 | D | Victor Hedman^ (2) | Tampa Bay Lightning | P. K. Subban$^†$ (3) | Nashville Predators |
| 2017–18 | D | Drew Doughty^ (4) | Los Angeles Kings | Seth Jones^ | Columbus Blue Jackets |
| 2017–18 | G | Pekka Rinne (2) | Nashville Predators | Connor Hellebuyck^ | Winnipeg Jets |
| 2018–19 | C | Connor McDavid^ (3) | Edmonton Oilers | Sidney Crosby^ (8) | Pittsburgh Penguins |
| 2018–19 | LW | Alexander Ovechkin^ (12) | Washington Capitals | Brad Marchand^ (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 2018–19 | RW | Nikita Kucherov^ (3) | Tampa Bay Lightning | Patrick Kane^ (4) | Chicago Blackhawks |
| 2018–19 | D | Mark Giordano^ | Calgary Flames | John Carlson^ | Washington Capitals |
| 2018–19 | D | Brent Burns^ (3) | San Jose Sharks | Victor Hedman^ (3) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2018–19 | G | Andrei Vasilevskiy^ | Tampa Bay Lightning | Ben Bishop$^†$ (2) | Dallas Stars |
| 2019–20 | C | Leon Draisaitl^ | Edmonton Oilers | Nathan MacKinnon^ (2) | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2019–20 | LW | Artemi Panarin^ (2) | New York Rangers | Brad Marchand^ (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 2019–20 | RW | David Pastrnak^ | Boston Bruins | Nikita Kucherov^ (4) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2019–20 | D | Roman Josi^ | Nashville Predators | Victor Hedman^ (4) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2019–20 | D | John Carlson^ (2) | Washington Capitals | Alex Pietrangelo^ (3) | St. Louis Blues |
| 2019–20 | G | Connor Hellebuyck^ (2) | Winnipeg Jets | Tuukka Rask$^†$ (2) | Boston Bruins |
| 2020–21 | C | Connor McDavid^ (4) | Edmonton Oilers | Auston Matthews^ | Toronto Maple Leafs |
| 2020–21 | LW | Brad Marchand^ (4) | Boston Bruins | Jonathan Huberdeau^ | Florida Panthers |
| 2020–21 | RW | Mitch Marner^ | Toronto Maple Leafs | Mikko Rantanen^ | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2020–21 | D | Adam Fox^ | New York Rangers | Victor Hedman^ (5) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2020–21 | D | Cale Makar^ | Colorado Avalanche | Dougie Hamilton^ | Carolina Hurricanes |
| 2020–21 | G | Andrei Vasilevskiy^ (2) | Tampa Bay Lightning | Marc-Andre Fleury^ | Vegas Golden Knights |
| 2021–22 | C | Auston Matthews^ (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Connor McDavid^ (5) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 2021–22 | LW | Johnny Gaudreau$^†$ | Calgary Flames | Jonathan Huberdeau^ (2) | Florida Panthers |
| 2021–22 | RW | Mitch Marner^ (2) | Toronto Maple Leafs | Matthew Tkachuk^ | Calgary Flames |
| 2021–22 | D | Cale Makar^ (2) | Colorado Avalanche | Victor Hedman^ (6) | Tampa Bay Lightning |
| 2021–22 | D | Roman Josi^ (2) | Nashville Predators | Charlie McAvoy^ | Boston Bruins |
| 2021–22 | G | Igor Shesterkin^ | New York Rangers | Jacob Markstrom^ | Calgary Flames |
| 2022–23 | C | Connor McDavid^ (6) | Edmonton Oilers | Leon Draisaitl^ (2) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 2022–23 | LW | Jason Robertson^ | Dallas Stars | Artemi Panarin^ (3) | New York Rangers |
| 2022–23 | RW | David Pastrnak^ (2) | Boston Bruins | Matthew Tkachuk^ (2) | Florida Panthers |
| 2022–23 | D | Erik Karlsson^ (5) | San Jose Sharks | Cale Makar^ (3) | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2022–23 | D | Adam Fox^ (2) | New York Rangers | Hampus Lindholm^ | Boston Bruins |
| 2022–23 | G | Linus Ullmark^ | Boston Bruins | Ilya Sorokin^ | New York Islanders |
| 2023–24 | C | Nathan MacKinnon^ (3) | Colorado Avalanche | Connor McDavid^ (7) | Edmonton Oilers |
| 2023–24 | LW | Artemi Panarin^ (4) | New York Rangers | Filip Forsberg^ | Nashville Predators |
| 2023–24 | RW | Nikita Kucherov^ (5) | Tampa Bay Lightning | David Pastrnak^ (3) | Boston Bruins |
| 2023–24 | D | Quinn Hughes^ | Vancouver Canucks | Cale Makar^ (4) | Colorado Avalanche |
| 2023–24 | D | Roman Josi^ (3) | Nashville Predators | Adam Fox^ (3) | New York Rangers |
| 2023–24 | G | Connor Hellebuyck^ (3) | Winnipeg Jets | Thatcher Demko^ | Vancouver Canucks |

## Most selections

The following table only lists players with at least eight total selections.
| ^ | Denotes players who are still active in the NHL |
| * | Denotes players inducted to the Hockey Hall of Fame |
| † | Denotes inactive players not yet eligible for Hockey Hall of Fame consideration |
| Player | Position | Total | First team | Second team | MVP (Hart) | Seasons |
| Gordie Howe* | RW | 21 | 12 | 9 | 6 | 26 |
| Ray Bourque* | D | 19 | 13 | 6 | 0 | 22 |
| Wayne Gretzky* | C | 15 | 8 | 7 | 9 | 20 |
| Maurice Richard* | RW | 14 | 8 | 6 | 1 | 18 |
| Bobby Hull* | LW | 12 | 10 | 2 | 2 | 16 |
| Nicklas Lidstrom* | D | 12 | 10 | 2 | 0 | 20 |
| Alexander Ovechkin^ | LW/RW | 12 | 8 | 4 | 3 | 19 |
| Doug Harvey* | D | 11 | 10 | 1 | 0 | 20 |
| Glenn Hall* | G | 11 | 7 | 4 | 0 | 18 |
| Jean Beliveau* | C | 10 | 6 | 4 | 2 | 20 |
| Earl Seibert* | D | 10 | 4 | 6 | 0 | 15 |
| Bobby Orr* | D | 9 | 8 | 1 | 3 | 12 |
| Ted Lindsay* | LW | 9 | 8 | 1 | 0 | 17 |
| Mario Lemieux* | C | 9 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 17 |
| Frank Mahovlich* | LW | 9 | 3 | 6 | 0 | 18 |
| Eddie Shore* | D | 8 | 7 | 1 | 4 | 14 |
| Jaromir Jagr$^†$ | RW | 8 | 7 | 1 | 1 | 24 |
| Phil Esposito* | C | 8 | 6 | 2 | 2 | 18 |
| Red Kelly* | D | 8 | 6 | 2 | 0 | 20 |
| Stan Mikita* | C | 8 | 6 | 2 | 2 | 22 |
| Mike Bossy* | RW | 8 | 5 | 3 | 0 | 10 |
| Pierre Pilote* | D | 8 | 5 | 3 | 0 | 14 |
| Luc Robitaille* | LW | 8 | 5 | 3 | 0 | 19 |
| Sidney Crosby^ | C | 8 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 19 |
| Paul Coffey* | D | 8 | 4 | 4 | 0 | 21 |
| Frank Brimsek* | G | 8 | 2 | 6 | 0 | 10 |