# List of Michigan Wolverines football All-Americans

Michigan Wolverines football All-Americans are collegiate football players who have been named as All-Americans while playing for the University of Michigan football team.

## Overview

Since 1898, 145 Michigan Wolverines football players have earned first-team All-American honors recognized by the NCAA (including 76 consensus All-Americans on 89 separate selections).
There are two players who have earned the distinction three times: Bennie Oosterbaan (1925–1927) and Anthony Carter (1980–1982).
There are twenty-four others who have earned the distinction twice: Willie Heston, Albert Benbrook, Benny Friedman, Chuck Bernard, Ted Petoskey, Tom Harmon, Alvin Wistert, Robert Wahl, Ron Kramer, Bill Yearby, Dave Brown, Mark Donahue, Jumbo Elliott, Mark Messner, Tripp Welborne, Greg Skrepenak, Charles Woodson, Steve Hutchinson, Marlin Jackson, Jake Long, Taylor Lewan, Jake Butt, Jourdan Lewis, and Blake Corum.
Twenty-seven Michigan players have been unanimous All-American selections: Bennie Oosterbaan, Harry Newman, Chuck Bernard, Ralph Heikkinen, Tom Harmon, Bill Daley, Bob Chappuis, Ron Kramer, Jack Clancy, Jim Mandich, Mike Taylor, Dave Brown, Mark Donahue, Anthony Carter, Mark Messner, Tripp Welborne, Desmond Howard, Greg Skrepenak, Charles Woodson, Steve Hutchinson, Braylon Edwards, Jake Long, Jabrill Peppers, Aidan Hutchinson, Blake Corum, Zak Zinter, and Mason Graham.
Two players have been selected as unanimous All-Americans twice: Anthony Carter and Tripp Welborne (two of eleven players in Big Ten Conference history).
William Cunningham was the first All-American in 1898, based on a performance that led Louis Elbel to write "The Victors". Neil Snow was the second in 1901, based on his role on the 1901 team that outscored its opponents 550–0. Willie Heston was the first Michigan All-American selected by Walter Camp in 1903. Since then the Wolverines have had 85 players selected by the Walter Camp Football Foundation; the most storied of any collegiate program.

## Sortable chart of Michigan's All-Americans

| Player | Position | Year | Unanimous | Consensus | Selectors |
| William Cunningham | C | 1898 | No | Yes | CW-1 |
| Allen Steckle | T | 1898 | No | No | WC-2 |
| John McLean | HB | 1899 | No | No | PI |
| Richard France | G | 1899 | No | No | PI |
| Neil Snow | E | 1899 | No | No | PI |
| Neil Snow | E | 1901 | No | Yes | |
| Joe Maddock | T | 1902 | No | No | NA |
| Boss Weeks | QB | 1902 | No | No | NA |
| Willie Heston | HB | 1902 | No | No | NA; CW-2 |
| Willie Heston | HB | 1903 | No | Yes | WC-1; CW-1; FY-1; SA-1 |
| Herb Graver | HB | 1903 | No | No | WC-3 |
| Joe Maddock | T | 1903 | No | No | WC-3; CW-2; FY-1; SA-1 |
| Curtis Redden | E | 1903 | No | No | WC-3 |
| Willie Heston | HB | 1904 | No | Yes | WC-1, NYET, FL |
| Joe Curtis | T | 1904 | No | No | WC-2, FL |
| Joe Curtis | T | 1905 | No | No | WC-2 |
| Thomas Hammond | HB | 1905 | No | No | WC-3 |
| Henry Schulte | G | 1905 | No | No | WC-2 |
| John Garrels | FB | 1906 | No | No | WC-3 |
| Germany Schulz | C | 1907 | No | Yes | WC-1; CW-2; FY-1 |
| Walter Rheinschild | T | 1907 | No | No | FY-1 |
| Germany Schulz | C | 1908 | No | No | CON-2 [9]; NYW; PI; FY; TT; CSM; NYET; BSU; BP; PD; NHR; TJ; KCJ; PP; PT; PES |
| William Casey | T | 1909 | No | No | |
| Albert Benbrook | G | 1909 | No | Yes | WC-1 |
| Dave Allerdice | HB | 1909 | No | No | WC-2; NYT-1; TC-1 |
| Joe Magidsohn | HB | 1909 | No | No | WC-2 |
| Albert Benbrook | G | 1910 | No | Yes | WC–1; TC-1; OUT; ES; LES; TEL |
| Stanfield Wells | E | 1910 | No | Yes | WC-1; OUT |
| Joe Magidsohn | HB | 1910 | No | No | LES-2; TC-1; CP; OUT; TEL; PP-2; WT; PD; NYG; NYMT; PT; ALS; PL; Penn |
| Stanfield Wells | E | 1911 | No | No | WC-3 [hb]; NYG-1; HW-1; HL |
| Miller Pontius | T | 1912 | No | No | ASH-1 |
| Miller Pontius | T | 1913 | No | Yes | NS-1; MFP-2; FY-1; PHD-1; TT-1 |
| James Craig | HB | 1913 | No | Yes | WC–1; HW-1; INS-1; MFP-1; FY-1; TT-1; TET-1 |
| Bubbles Paterson | C | 1913 | No | No | WC–3; MFP-1 |
| Tommy Hughitt | QB | 1913 | No | No | MFP-2; FY-1 |
| John Maulbetsch | HB | 1914 | No | Yes | WC–1; VF [fb]; PHD; WE–1; FM-1; MO-1; PGT [fb]; BN; AC; PS; DD; PET; SLT; MD; NES; DN; PPL; BP; AW; PI; OUT |
| John Maulbetsch | HB | 1915 | No | No | WE-2; MON-2; TC-1 |
| Cliff Sparks | QB | 1916 | No | No | MON-1 |
| John Maulbetsch | HB | 1916 | No | No | FY-1 |
| Cedrick "Pat" Smith | FB | 1917 | No | No | |
| Ernest Allmendinger | G | 1917 | No | No | |
| Frank Culver | G | 1917 | No | No | WC–1; NEA; JV-2; PP-1 |
| Oscar Lambert | C | 1917 | No | No | WE-2 |
| Archie Weston | QB | 1917 | No | No | WE-1 |
| Frank Steketee | FB | 1918 | No | No | WC-1; BM-2 |
| Angus Goetz | T | 1918 | No | No | WC-3 |
| Angus Goetz | T | 1920 | No | No | WC-2 |
| Tad Wieman | T | 1920 | No | No | LP-2 |
| Ernie Vick | C | 1921 | No | No | FW-3; WC-1; WE-3; MM-2 |
| Paul Goebel | E | 1921 | No | No | LP-1 |
| Robert J. Dunne | G | 1921 | No | No | NB-1 |
| Franklin Cappon | T | 1921 | No | No | NB-2 |
| Paul Goebel | E | 1922 | No | No | NYT-1; NB-1; AW-1; LP-1; BE; RO-1 |
| Bernard Kirk | E | 1922 | No | No | WC-2; NYT-1; WE-1; NB-2; LP-2; BE; FH-1; RO-2 |
| Irwin Uteritz | QB | 1922 | No | No | WC-3; WE-3; FM-1; RO-5 |
| Harry Kipke | HB | 1922 | No | Yes | WC-1; NYT-2; AW-1; WE-1; NB-1; LP-1 [qb]; BE; RO-2 |
| Stanley Muirhead | T | 1922 | No | No | LP-2; RO-4 |
| Franklin Cappon | FB | 1922 | No | No | WE-3; NYT-2 [hb]; FH-2; RO-5 [hb] |
| Edliff Slaughter | G | 1923 | No | No | LP-1 |
| Jack Blott | C | 1923 | No | Yes | AW-1; WC-1; NB-1; DW-1 |
| Harry Kipke | HB | 1923 | No | No | AW-2; LP-1; TT-3 |
| Stanley Muirhead | T | 1923 | No | No | AW-2; LP-2; NB-2 |
| Edliff Slaughter | G | 1924 | No | No | WC-1; LP-1; BE-2; NB-1 |
| Harry Hawkins | G | 1925 | No | No | JRW-3; WE-3 |
| Robert J. Brown | C | 1925 | No | No | AP-2; COL-2; A&S-1; Sun–2; BE-1; NB-1 |
| Tom Edwards | T | 1925 | No | No | AP-2; COL-2; A&S-1; Sun–2; BE-1; NB-1 |
| Benny Friedman | QB | 1925 | No | Yes | UP-1; AP-2; COL-2; JRW-1; Sun–1; WE–2; BE-2 |
| Bennie Oosterbaan | E | 1925 | No | Yes | UP-1; AP-1; COL-1; A&S-1; JRW-1; Sun-1; WC; WE–1; BE-1; NB-1 |
| Benny Friedman | QB | 1926 | No | Yes | AP-1; COL-1; CP-1; NYS-1; BE-1; RWJ-2; RG-1; DW-1; ES-1 |
| Bennie Oosterbaan | E | 1926 | No | Yes | AP-3; COL-1; CP-1; WC-1; BE-1; RWJ-1; RG-2; ES-1 |
| Bennie Oosterbaan | E | 1927 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; COL-1; CP-1; HE-1; DJW-1; NYS-1; BE-1; LP-1 |
| Otto Pommerening | T | 1928 | No | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; CO-1 |
| Harry Newman | QB | 1930 | No | No | INS-3 |
| Maynard Morrison | C | 1931 | No | No | AP–3; COL–1; NEA-1; CP–3 |
| Bill Hewitt | E | 1931 | No | No | NEA-3 |
| Harry Newman | QB | 1932 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; AAB-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; NYT-1; WC-1; TR-1 |
| Chuck Bernard | C | 1932 | No | No | AP-3; NEA-1; INS-1 |
| Ted Petoskey | E | 1932 | No | No | WC-1; AAB-1; INS-3; NYS-2 |
| Chuck Bernard | C | 1933 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; WC-1; DJW-1; WD-1 |
| Ted Petoskey | E | 1933 | No | No | AP-2; UP-2; CO-2; INS-1; CP-1 |
| Francis Wistert | T | 1933 | No | Yes | UP-1; CO-1; INS-2; CP-2; NYS-1; WC-1; DJW-1; WD-1 |
| Herman Everhardus | HB | 1933 | No | No | COL-3; NEA-2; INS-2 |
| Matt Patanelli | E | 1936 | No | No | AP-3; CP-2 |
| Ralph Heikkinen | G | 1938 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; CP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; NYS-1; WC-1 |
| Tom Harmon | HB | 1939 | No | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; CO-1; CP-1; INS-1; NEA-3; NYS-1 [fb]; WC-1; NW-1 (2nd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Tom Harmon | HB | 1940 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; HE-1; CP-1; CO-1; NEA-1; NYS-1; WC-1 (Heisman Trophy winner) |
| Ed Frutig | E | 1940 | No | No | AP-3; UP-3; HE-1; CP-3 |
| Bob Westfall | FB | 1941 | No | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; AAB-1; CO-1; NEA-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1; WC-1 |
| Julius Franks | G | 1942 | No | Yes | AP-2; SN-3; INS-1; CP-1; NEA-2; CO-1; NYS-2 |
| Al Wistert | T | 1942 | No | Yes | AP-2; UP-1; SN-2; CP-3; NEA-3; LK-1; NYS-1; WC-1; MS-1 |
| Julius Franks | G | 1942 | Yes | Yes | AP-2; CO-1; INS-1; NEA-2; NW; SN-3; CP-1; NYS-2 |
| Merv Pregulman | T | 1942 | No | No | SN-3; NEA-1; MS-1 [4-way tie] |
| Merv Pregulman | T | 1943 | No | No | CO-1; SS-1 [tackle] |
| Bill Daley | FB | 1943 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-; CO-1; SS-1; INS-1; CP-1; NYS-1 |
| Milan Lazetich | T | 1944 | No | No | AP-2; UP-3; FWAA-2; INS-2; CP-2 |
| Elmer Madar | E | 1946 | No | No | AP-1; INS-2; CP-3 |
| Bob Chappuis | HB | 1947 | Yes | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; PO-1; CO-1; NEA-1; CP-1; INS-1; WC-1; FW-1 (2nd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| J.T. White | C | 1947 | No | No | FWAA-2 |
| Bump Elliott | HB | 1947 | No | No | AP-2; UP-2; PO-1; NEA-3; CP-2; INS-3; FW-2 |
| Pete Elliott | QB | 1948 | No | No | INS-1 [defense] |
| Dick Rifenburg | E | 1948 | No | Yes | AP-1; UP-1; NEA-1; CP-1; INS-1 [offense]; WC-1; FW-1 |
| Alvin Wistert | T | 1948 | No | Yes | UP-1; CO-1; NEA-2; CP-1; WC-1; FW-2 |
| Dick Kempthorn | FB | 1949 | No | No | AP-2; UP-2; FWAA-3 |
| Chuck Ortmann | HB | 1949 | No | No | FWAA-2 |
| Robert Wahl | T | 1949 | No | No | NEA-1 (offense); FWAA-1 |
| Alvin Wistert | T | 1949 | No | Yes | WC-1; AP-3; UP-1; TSN; INS-1 (defense) |
| Robert Wahl | T | 1950 | No | No | AAB; AP (defense)-1; UP-2; INS (offense)-1; CP-2 |
| Chuck Ortmann | HB | 1950 | No | No | CP-3 |
| Tom Johnson | T | 1951 | No | No | CT |
| Lowell Perry | E | 1951 | No | No | UP-3; CP-2 |
| Lowell Perry | E | 1952 | No | No | NEA |
| Art Walker | T | 1954 | No | No | AAB, FWAA |
| Ron Kramer | E | 1954 | No | No | AP-3; UP-3; CP-1; INS-2 |
| Ron Kramer | E | 1955 | No | Yes | AAB, AFCA, FWAA, INS, NEA, SN, UP, WC |
| Tom Maentz | E | 1955 | No | No | AP-2; UP-2; CP-3 |
| Ron Kramer | E | 1956 | Yes | Yes | AP, UP, CP, NEA, INS, TSN, AFCA, WC, FWAA (6th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Jim Pace | HB | 1957 | No | No | AAB, AP-1, INS-2, UP-2 |
| Jim Van Pelt | QB | 1957 | No | No | INS-2 |
| Bennie McRae | HB | 1961 | No | No | AP-3 |
| Bob Timberlake | QB | 1964 | No | No | AP-1, FWAA, FN [RB], NEA-2 [RB]) (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Bill Yearby | DT | 1964 | No | No | AFCA-3, AP-2, CP-1, FN, NEA-1 |
| Tom Mack | OT | 1965 | No | No | UPI-2, NEA-2 |
| Bill Yearby | DT | 1965 | No | Yes | AFCA, AP-2, CP-1, UPI-1, Time, TSN, WC |
| Jack Clancy | E | 1966 | Yes | Yes | AFCA, AP-1, CP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, UPI-1, Time, TSN, WC |
| Rick Volk | DB | 1966 | No | No | Time, TSN |
| Joe Dayton | C | 1967 | No | No | CP-3 |
| Ron Johnson | HB | 1967 | No | No | CP-2 |
| Ray Phillips | OG | 1967 | No | No | CP-3, UPI-2 |
| Tom Curtis | DB | 1968 | No | No | AP-2, UPI-2 |
| Ron Johnson | HB | 1968 | No | No | FWAA, FN, AP-2, CP-2, NEA-2, UPI-2 |
| Tom Curtis | DB | 1969 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, WC, CP, FN |
| Jim Mandich | TE | 1969 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, CP, Time, FN |
| Marty Huff | LB | 1970 | No | No | AFCA |
| Dan Dierdorf | OT | 1970 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, FWAA, WC, AFCA, Time, PFW, FN |
| Henry Hill | G | 1970 | No | No | CP |
| Reggie McKenzie | OG | 1971 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, TSN, Time, FN |
| Thom Darden | DB | 1971 | No | No | AFCA, TSN |
| Billy Taylor | RB | 1971 | No | No | FN |
| Mike Taylor | LB | 1971 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, Time, FN |
| Paul Seymour | OT | 1972 | No | Yes | NEA, FWAA, AFCA, TSN, Time |
| Randy Logan | DB | 1972 | No | Yes | UPI, WC, AFCA, FN |
| Dave Gallagher | DT | 1973 | No | Yes | AP, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, Time |
| Dave Brown | DB | 1973 | No | Yes | UPI, AFCA, FWAA |
| Mike Lantry | PK | 1973 | No | No | FN |
| Dave Brown | DB | 1974 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, FN, Time |
| Don Dufek | DB | 1975 | No | No | WC, FWAA, FN |
| Rob Lytle | RB | 1976 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FN, CFN (3rd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Calvin O'Neal | LB | 1976 | No | No | UPI, WC, TSN, CFN |
| Jim Smith | WR | 1976 | No | No | AP, TSN, FN, FWAA |
| Mark Donahue | OG | 1976 | No | Yes | UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, FN |
| Mark Donahue | OG | 1977 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, FN |
| John Anderson | LB | 1977 | No | No | FWAA |
| Walt Downing | C | 1977 | No | No | AFCA, TSN, FN |
| Rick Leach | QB | 1978 | No | No | AFCA-t (3rd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Ron Simpkins | LB | 1979 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, WC, FWAA |
| Curtis Greer | DT | 1979 | No | No | NEA, AFCA, FWAA |
| George Lilja | C | 1980 | No | No | WC |
| Anthony Carter | WR | 1980 | No | No | AP, TSN |
| Anthony Carter | WR | 1981 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN |
| Ed Muransky | OT | 1981 | No | Yes | AP, UPI |
| Bubba Paris | OT | 1981 | No | No | WC |
| Kurt Becker | OG | 1981 | No | Yes | AP, NEA, AFCA |
| Butch Woolfolk | RB | 1981 | No | No | FN |
| Anthony Carter | WR | 1982 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Tom Dixon | C | 1983 | No | No | AP, AFCA, TSN |
| Stefan Humphries | OG | 1983 | No | No | UPI, FWAA, TSN |
| Brad Cochran | DB | 1985 | No | Yes | UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA |
| Mike Hammerstein | DT | 1985 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, AFCA |
| Jim Harbaugh | QB | 1986 | No | No | UPI-2 (3rd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Garland Rivers | DB | 1986 | No | Yes | NEA, WC, AFCA |
| Jumbo Elliott | OT | 1986 | No | No | AFCA |
| Jumbo Elliott | OT | 1987 | No | Yes | UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA |
| Mark Messner | DT | 1987 | No | No | TSN |
| Mark Messner | DT | 1988 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN |
| John Vitale | C | 1988 | No | Yes | UPI, WC |
| Tripp Welborne | DB | 1989 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, FN |
| Tripp Welborne | DB | 1990 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, SH, TSN, FN |
| Dean Dingman | OG | 1990 | No | No | AFCA, TSN |
| Greg Skrepenak | OT | 1990 | No | No | WC |
| Greg Skrepenak | OT | 1991 | No | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, FWAA, SH, TSN, FN |
| Erick Anderson | LB | 1991 | No | No | UPI |
| Desmond Howard | WR | 1991 | Yes | Yes | AP, UPI, NEA, WC, AFCA, SH, TSN, FN (Heisman Trophy winner) |
| Chris Hutchinson | DT | 1992 | No | No | AFCA, FWAA, SH, FN |
| Tyrone Wheatley | RB | 1993 | No | No | SH |
| Remy Hamilton | PK | 1994 | No | No | WC |
| Ty Law | DB | 1994 | No | No | WC |
| Jason Horn | DT | 1995 | No | No | AFCA |
| Jarrett Irons | LB | 1996 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, WC |
| Rod Payne | C | 1996 | No | No | AFCA |
| Charles Woodson | DB | 1996 | No | No | AP, FWAA |
| Charles Woodson | DB | 1997 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, FN (Heisman Trophy winner) |
| Jerame Tuman | TE | 1997 | No | No | FN |
| Glen Steele | DT | 1997 | No | No | AFCA |
| Jon Jansen | OT | 1998 | No | No | AFCA |
| Rob Renes | DT | 1999 | No | No | TSN |
| Steve Hutchinson | OG | 1999 | No | No | PFW, CNNSI |
| Steve Hutchinson | OG | 2000 | Yes | Yes | AP, WC, AFCA, FWAA, PFW, FN, CNNSI, Rivals |
| David Terrell | WR | 2000 | No | No | PFW, CNNSI, Rivals |
| Larry Foote | LB | 2001 | No | No | FN |
| Marquise Walker | WR | 2001 | No | No | AFCA |
| Bennie Joppru | TE | 2002 | No | No | PFW |
| Marlin Jackson | DB | 2002 | No | No | PFW |
| Chris Perry | RB | 2003 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, WC, TSN, PFW, SI, ESPN, Rivals (4th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Marlin Jackson | DB | 2004 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, ESPN |
| Braylon Edwards | WR | 2004 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com |
| David Baas | C | 2004 | No | Yes | AP, FWAA, WC, CBS |
| Ernest Shazor | DB | 2004 | No | Yes | AP, FWAA, WC, SI, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com |
| Mike Hart | RB | 2006 | No | No | CFN, Rivals.com |
| Alan Branch | DT | 2006 | No | No | SI, PFW, ESPN, Scout.com |
| LaMarr Woodley | LB | 2006 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, ESPN, CBS, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
| Leon Hall | DB | 2006 | No | Yes | AP, FWAA, AFCA, WC, PFW, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
| Jake Long | OT | 2006 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
| Jake Long | OT | 2007 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, WC, TSN, SI, PFW, ESPN, CBS, CFN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
| Brandon Graham | DE | 2009 | No | No | ESPN, Rivals.com, Scout.com |
| Denard Robinson | QB | 2010 | No | No | FWAA (6th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| David Molk | C | 2011 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, SI |
| Taylor Lewan | OT | 2012 | No | No | WC, ESPN, AP, SI |
| Taylor Lewan | OT | 2013 | No | No | TSN |
| Jake Butt | TE | 2015 | No | No | CBS, SI |
| Jourdan Lewis | CB | 2015 | No | No | SI, USAT |
| Jourdan Lewis | CB | 2016 | No | Yes | AFCA, AP, WCFF, TSN, SI, ESPN, CBS |
| Jake Butt | TE | 2016 | No | Yes | AFCA, WCFF |
| Jabrill Peppers | LB | 2016 | Yes | Yes | AFCA, FWAA, AP, WCFF, TSN, SI, USAT, ESPN, FOX, CBS (5th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Chris Wormley | DE | 2016 | No | No | TSN-2 |
| Maurice Hurst | DT | 2017 | No | Yes | AP, TSN, USAT, ESPN, CBS |
| Devin Bush | LB | 2018 | No | Yes | AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, SI, USAT, CFN, CBS |
| Chase Winovich | DE | 2018 | No | No | WCFF-2, AFCA-2, CFN-2 |
| Ben Bredeson | G | 2019 | No | No | WCFF-2 |
| Aidan Hutchinson | DE | 2021 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, ESPN, CBS, Athletic, USAT (2nd in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Jake Moody | K | 2021 | No | Yes | AP, AFCA, WCFF, CBS |
| Hassan Haskins | RB | 2021 | No | No | AFCA-2 |
| Andrew Stueber | G | 2021 | No | No | AFCA-2 |
| David Ojabo | DE | 2021 | No | No | AP-2, CBS-2 |
| Blake Corum | RB | 2022 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, ESPN, CBS, Athletic, USAT (7th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Olusegun Oluwatimi | C | 2022 | No | Yes | AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, ESPN, Athletic, USAT |
| Mike Morris | DE | 2022 | No | No | FWAA-2, AFCA-2 |
| Zak Zinter | G | 2023 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, ESPN, Athletic, USAT, SI, FOX |
| Blake Corum | RB | 2023 | No | No | AFCA (9th in Heisman Trophy voting) |
| Mike Sainristil | CB | 2023 | No | No | TSN, ESPN, FOX |
| Will Johnson | CB | 2023 | No | No | SI |
| Mason Graham | DT | 2023 | No | No | TSN-2 |
| Kris Jenkins | DT | 2023 | No | No | FWAA-2, AFCA-2 |
| Mason Graham | DT | 2024 | Yes | Yes | AP, AFCA, FWAA, TSN, WCFF, USAT, CBS, Athletic, PFF, SI, ESPN |
| Dominic Zvada | K | 2024 | No | No | TSN, Athletic, ESPN |
| Will Johnson | CB | 2024 | No | No | AFCA-2, WCFF-2, CBS-2 |
| Colston Loveland | TE | 2024 | No | No | FWAA-2 |
| Kenneth Grant | DT | 2024 | No | No | AP-3 |