# Real World/Road Rules Challenge: The Ruins

Real World Road Rules Challenge: The Ruins is the 18th season of the MTV reality television game show, The Challenge (at the time known as Real World/Road Rules Challenge). This is the last season to use Real World/Road Rules in the on-screen title, before being shortened to The Challenge in the 19th season.
The Ruins took place in Phuket, Thailand, with cast members from The Real World, Road Rules and The Challenge competing. This season was played in the format of two teams — Champions and Challengers; players on the Champions team had won at least one previous challenge, while players on the Challengers team had never won a challenge or made their Challenge debut.
The season premiered on September 30, 2009 and concluded with the "S#!t They Should Have Shown" special on December 23, 2009.

## Format

This season of the Real World/Road Rules Challenge puts the Champions against the Challengers. The two teams compete in numerous missions, typically called challenges, in order to win cash, prizes and advance in the overall game. The winning team in each challenge receives a cash prize of $20,000, which is split evenly among the team members and placed in their individual bank accounts, as well as a bonus prize for each member of the team.
Before every challenge however, the Champions and the Challengers each select three players of each gender within their team to be nominated for elimination. After the challenge, the six nominees from the winning team pick one guy and one girl among themselves, as well as a male-female pair from the losing team's nominees to battle against in the Ruins.
In the Ruins, there are two events — one battle for each gender. The winners from each event get to stay in Phuket, and have a chance to compete for a share of $120,000 in the final challenge. The losers are eliminated from the game, and lose all of their prize money in their individual bank accounts to the event winners, though their bonus prizes are not affected.

## Contestants

| Champions | Original season | Finish |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | Winner |
| Evan Starkman | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Winner |
| Johnny Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | Winner |
| Kenny Santucci | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Winner |
| Susie Meister | Road Rules: Down Under | Winner |
| Darrell Taylor | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | Episode 8 |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | Episode 7 |
| Veronica Portillo | Road Rules: Semester at Sea | Episode 6 |
| Syrus Yarbrough | The Real World: Boston | Episode 6 |
| Ibis Nieves | Road Rules: X-Treme | Episode 5 |
| Wes Bergmann | The Real World: Austin | Episode 5 |
| Katie Doyle | Road Rules: The Quest | Episode 4 |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | Episode 4 |
| Evelyn Smith | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Episode 2 |
| Challengers | Original season | Finish |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | Runner-up |
| Sarah Rice | The Real World: Brooklyn | Runner-up |
| Casey Cooper | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Episode 9 |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 8/9 |
| Kimberly Alexander | The Real World: Hollywood | Episode 8/9 |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego | Episode 8 |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 7 |
| Danny Jamieson | The Real World: Austin | Episode 4 |
| Adam King | The Real World: Paris | Episode 3 |
| Brianna Taylor | The Real World: Hollywood | Episode 3 |
| Nick Brown | The Real World: Hollywood | Episode 2 |
| Shauvon Torres | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 2 |
| Diem Brown | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Episode 1 |
| Chet Cannon | The Real World: Brooklyn | Episode 1 |

### Champion of

* 1 2 3 4 The Inferno 3
* 1 2 3 4 The Island
* ↑ The Duel II
* 1 2 The Gauntlet 2
* 1 2 The Gauntlet
* 1 2 3 The Inferno
* ↑ The Inferno II
* ↑ Fresh Meat
* ↑ The Gauntlet III
* ↑ Challenge 2000
* ↑ Extreme Challenge
* ↑ The Duel

## Gameplay
### Challenge games

* Chain Gang: Each team is connected to a 30-foot rope that is hanging from a platform suspended high above water. The bottom person has to unclip himself/herself and climb to the top. Once that person climbs up and rings the gong, the next person at the bottom can unhook themself and climb up. If someone unhooks before it is their turn, everyone under them is disqualified along with anybody who falls. The team that sends the most players to the top of the platform wins, unless there is a tie, in which the team with the fastest time wins.
** Winners: Champions
* Swing on By: Players from each team have to swing by a rope from one platform to another in a 180° circle. A fence is located in between both platforms that is suspended high above water. One by one, each player has to swing from a launch pad, around the fence, and onto the landing platform. Once a player lands on the landing pad, that player must remain on the pad, and if that player falls into the water, he/she must return to the launch pad and swing again. The team with the fastest time wins. (Note: The Champions team had to sit out two players.)
** Winners: Champions
* Repo Race: Each team must advance from one end of an obstacle course to another. However, they must do so by forming a human bridge resulting in lying face down in the sand, with their backs as the planks. The last person at the back of the "bridge" must advance to and reposition to the front of the bridge, but if a runner steps in the sand or falls off the "bridge," the entire team must reset to their previous position. At the last obstacle, the designated runner from each team must carry a bag through their respective "bridges" to the finish line, without dropping it in the sand. The team that advances to the end of the obstacle course first wins.
** Winners: Challengers
* Burning Bridge: A raft is located in the middle of a lake, and each team has to build a floating bridge from the raft to the shore. Players from each team have to swim toward the raft, then release bridge pieces that are attached to anchors below water. Once the bridge is complete, one player from each team must run across it with a torch in their hand, then light the raft on fire. The first team to light their team raft on fire wins.
** Winners: Champions
* Block Party: Two guys and two girls from each team will wrap around a pole. The remaining players from each team will then need to pull the other team's players off the pole and drag them back to the starting area to eliminate them. When a player is eliminated, they can join their teammates in trying to pull the opposing team's players from the pole. Once the opposing team's four players wrapped around the pole are eliminated, the team can then begin carrying cinder blocks to the pole to build steps high enough to ring the gong. The first team to ring a gong wins.
** Winners: Champions
* Fruits of Your Labor: Teams have to transfer Thai fruit from one end of an obstacle course to another. The challenge begins with players loading up as much fruit into a basket as possible, then running toward a wall and tossing all the fruit over the wall, where two teammates will try to catch the fruit into a sack, then those players will transfer baskets of fruit to a table, where the next set of teammates will deliver the fruit from the table to a weight scale, using bamboo poles but not their hands. The team that transfers as much fruit into the weight scale wins.
** Winners: Champions
* Rotary Club: Players from each team roll down an obstacle course while curled up inside of a giant tractor tire. If a tire stops short of the finish line with a player inside of it, one player designated as a tracker must push that tire across the finish line, and once that player has crossed the finish line, he/she has to push the tire uphill to a white line near the end zone, where teammates can help push the tire back to the beginning of the course. The process continues until each player has ridden inside of the tire down to the end zone and advanced the tire back to the beginning of the course, where the team that completes the challenge first wins.
** Winners: Champions
* On the Fence: Players from each team have to maneuver across a series of three chain-link fences that are suspended from a structure above a 20-story building and ring a gong at the end of the last chain-link fence. One player per team races against an opposing player on opposite sides, and if a player falls, a 15-minute penalty will be added to their team's overall score. The team that advances each player to the end to ring a gong in the fastest time wins.
** Winners: Champions
* Wall Walker: Players from each team have to run up a circular ramp that is attached to a platform suspended atop a 20-story building, and collect up to three flowers that are inside three vases atop the ramp. Each player has to collect as much flowers as possible, and transfer them to a vase at the other side of the runway. (Note: Since the Challengers team had two fewer players than the Champions, two players from the Challengers team had to go up the ramp twice.) The team that transfers the most flowers into the vase on the opposite side of the runway wins.
** Winners: Champions

### Ruins games

* Shoots and Ladders: Players build a ladder with bamboo poles in front of them. Once their ladder is 100% percent, they race to the top and hit their gong. The first person to do so wins.
** Played By: Chet vs. Wes & Diem vs. Tonya
* Shadow Fighter: Standing in two separate platforms and tied together by a series of ropes by the feet and hands, the challengers must use the ropes to make the opponent fall off the platform. The first to three points wins.
** Played By: Nick vs. Wes & KellyAnne vs. Evelyn
* Burnout: Players extinguish a fire by steering water from a center pipe, with a wheel, into the opponent's barrel. Once the barrel becomes full, it spills into a gutter, leading to a pot filled with burning cigars. The first person to extinguish their opponent's fire wins.
** Played By: Adam vs. Syrus & Brianna vs. Susie
* Oh Ring: A player from each team tries to wrestle a ring away from their opponent, while suspended above the ground from their feet. The first player to wrestle the ring away from their opponent twice wins.
** Played By: Danny vs. Darrell & Sarah vs. Katie
* Spool: Players weave a rope through an obstacle course, under and over bamboo poles. The first player to weave their rope through the obstacle course and ring their gong wins.
** Played By: Cohutta vs. Wes & Kimberly vs. Ibis
* Hog Tie: While suspended from carabiners by their wrists and feet under a large bamboo pole, players try to shimmy their way from one end of the pole to the other, grab a key halfway through, then unlock the carabiners with the key, while laying on a platform. Once a player has unlocked the carabiners, he/she can return to the ground, then race back to the beginning side of the pole to ring a gong.
** Played By: Cohutta vs. Syrus & KellyAnne vs. Veronica
* Crunch: Players are hanging upside down in a crunch position by their legs from bamboo poles, with their heads partially submerged in separate water tanks. The players try to maintain 40-lb. weights on their chests by using their ab muscles, while trying to keep their heads above water. The opponent wins if a player surrenders by pulling an emergency lever inside the tank, which releases all the water.
** Played By: Cohutta vs. Darrell & Johanna vs. Sarah
* Rag Doll: Within a circle, the player who wrestles a rope away from their opponent wins.
** Played By: Dunbar vs. Johnny & Kimberly vs. Susie
* Muay Thai: Players "karate-kick" the bottoms of bamboo poles that are hanging in a vertical row of an obstacle course. The first player to kick and break every bamboo pole and ring their gong wins.
** Played By: Casey vs. Susie

### Final challenge

Each team begins by racing to the first checkpoint, "Bizarre Buffet," where each player must completely eat a series of five bizarre foods—beetles, fried frog legs, stinky Thai fruit, red chilies and crickets & grasshoppers—in order to collect a Thai artifact and advance to the second checkpoint. At "Junction," teams are faced with choosing one of four different colored paths, collecting an artifact at the end of each path and placing each artifact into their team stone that will open a secret door. The other checkpoints consist of a jigsaw puzzle, crawling through a mud pit and back, walk through an "Shortcut" obstacle course with bamboo poles and solving a difficult Building Blocks puzzle. If any player falls of the bamboo poles while trying to complete the Shortcut course, the entire team must restart the Shortcut course. If a team does not complete the Building Blocks puzzle within a 30-minute time limit, each player must carry a block with them to the Junction. The team that makes it to the finish line first after opening the secret door with all five artifacts wins an additional $160,000 to be split amongst their team members.
* Winners: Champions

## Game summary
### Elimination chart

| Episode | Episode | Winners | Winners | Ruins contestants | Ruins contestants | Ruins contestants | Ruins contestants | Ruins contestants | Ruins contestants | Ruins game | Ruins outcome | Ruins outcome | Ruins outcome | Ruins outcome |
| # | Challenge | Winners | Winners | Champions | Champions | Champions | Challengers | Challengers | Challengers | Ruins game | Winner | Winner | Eliminated | Eliminated |
| 1 | Chain Gang | | Champions | Darrell | Kenny | Wes | Chet | Cohutta | Nick | Shoots and Ladders | | Wes | | Chet |
| 1 | Chain Gang | | Champions | Johanna | Susie | Tonya | Diem | Sarah | Shauvon | Shoots and Ladders | | Tonya | | Diem |
| 2 | Swing on By | | Champions | Derrick | Johnny | Wes | Cohutta | Danny | Nick | Shadow Fighter | | Wes | | Nick |
| 2 | Swing on By | | Champions | Evelyn | Katie | Susie | Casey | KellyAnne | Shauvon | Shadow Fighter | | KellyAnne | | Evelyn |
| 3 | Repo Race | | Challengers | Ibis | Susie | Veronica | Brianna | Casey | Kimberly | Burnout | | Susie | | Brianna |
| 3 | Repo Race | | Challengers | Evan | Kenny | Syrus | Adam | Brad | Danny | Burnout | | Syrus | | Adam |
| 4 | Burning Bridge | | Champions | Katie | Susie | Tonya | Casey | Kimberly | Sarah | Oh Ring | | Sarah | | Katie |
| 4 | Burning Bridge | | Champions | Darrell | Derrick | Johnny | Cohutta | Danny | Dunbar | Oh Ring | | Darrell | | Danny |
| 5 | Block Party | | Champions | Evan | Kenny | Wes | Brad | Cohutta | Dunbar | Spool | | Cohutta | | Wes |
| 5 | Block Party | | Champions | Ibis | Johanna | Veronica | Casey | KellyAnne | Kimberly | Spool | | Kimberly | | Ibis |
| 6 | Fruits of Your Labor | | Champions | Derrick | Johnny | Syrus | Brad | Cohutta | Dunbar | Hog Tie | | Cohutta | | Syrus |
| 6 | Fruits of Your Labor | | Champions | Johanna | Susie | Veronica | Casey | KellyAnne | Sarah | Hog Tie | | KellyAnne | | Veronica |
| 7 | Rotary Club | | Champions | Johanna | Susie | — | Casey | Kimberly | Sarah | Crunch | | Sarah | | Johanna |
| 7 | Rotary Club | | Champions | Darrell | Evan | Kenny | Brad | Cohutta | Dunbar | Crunch | | Darrell | | Cohutta |
| 8/9 | On the Fence | | Champions | Susie | — | — | Casey | KellyAnne | Kimberly | Rag Doll | | Susie | | Kimberly |
| 8/9 | On the Fence | | Champions | Derrick | Johnny | Kenny | Dunbar | — | — | Rag Doll | | Johnny | | Dunbar |
| 9 | Wall Walker | | Champions | Susie | — | — | Casey | KellyAnne | Sarah | Muay Thai | | Susie | | Casey |
| 10 | Final Challenge | | Champions | | | | | | | | | | | |

### Ruin progress

| Contestants | Contestants | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges | Challenges |
| Contestants | Contestants | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8/9 | 9 | Finale |
| | Derrick | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | WINNER |
| | Evan | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | WINNER |
| | Johnny | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | ELIM | SAFE | WINNER |
| | Kenny | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | RISK | SAFE | WINNER |
| | Susie | RISK | RISK | ELIM | RISK | SAFE | RISK | RISK | ELIM | ELIM | WINNER |
| | KellyAnne | SAFE | ELIM | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | ELIM | SAFE | RISK | RISK | LOSER |
| | Sarah | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | SAFE | RISK | ELIM | SAFE | RISK | LOSER |
| | Casey | SAFE | RISK | RISK | RISK | RISK | RISK | RISK | RISK | OUT | |
| | Dunbar | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | RISK | RISK | RISK | OUT | | |
| | Kimberly | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | RISK | ELIM | SAFE | RISK | OUT | | |
| | Brad | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | RISK | RISK | DQ | | |
| | Darrell | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | DQ | | |
| | Cohutta | RISK | RISK | SAFE | RISK | ELIM | ELIM | OUT | | | |
| | Johanna | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | RISK | OUT | | | |
| | Veronica | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | RISK | OUT | | | | |
| | Syrus | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | |
| | Ibis | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | OUT | | | | | |
| | Wes | ELIM | ELIM | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | |
| | Danny | SAFE | RISK | RISK | OUT | | | | | | |
| | Katie | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | |
| | Tonya | ELIM | SAFE | SAFE | DQ | | | | | | |
| | Adam | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | | |
| | Brianna | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | | |
| | Evelyn | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | | | |
| | Nick | RISK | OUT | | | | | | | | |
| | Shauvon | RISK | QUIT | | | | | | | | |
| | Diem | OUT | | | | | | | | | |
| | Chet | OUT | | | | | | | | | |

#### Teams

    The contestant is on the Challengers team
    The contestant is on the Champions team

#### Competition

    The contestant's team won the final challenge
    The contestant's team lost the final challenge
    The contestant was safe from the Ruins
    The contestant was nominated for the Ruins, but was not chosen to go in and was safe
    The contestant was put into the Ruins and won
    The contestant was put into the Ruins and was eliminated
    The contestant was disqualified from the competition due to disciplinary reasons
    The contestant withdrew from the competition due to medical reasons

### Bank progress

| Player | Player | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes |
| Player | Player | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8/9 | 9 | 10 |
| | Derrick | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | $11,300 | $15,300 | $19,300 | $50,970 |
| | Evan | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | $11,300 | $15,300 | $19,300 | $50,970 |
| | Johnny | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | $11,300 | $17,300 | $21,300 | $52,970 |
| | Kenny | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | $11,300 | $15,300 | $19,300 | $50,970 |
| | Susie | $1,400 | $2,800 | $4,800 | $6,400 | $8,220 | $10,440 | $13,300 | $25,520 | $31,520 | $63,190 |
| | KellyAnne | $0 | $2,800 | $4,800 | $4,800 | $4,800 | $13,300 | $13,300 | $13,300 | $13,300 | $13,300 |
| | Sarah | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $6,400 | $6,400 | $6,400 | $17,700 | $17,700 | $17,700 | $17,700 |
| | Casey | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | |
| | Dunbar | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | | |
| | Kimberly | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $8,220 | $8,220 | $8,220 | $8,220 | | |
| | Darrell | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $6,400 | $8,220 | $10,440 | $31,960 | $31,960 | | |
| | Brad | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 | | |
| | Cohutta | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | $8,220 | $18,660 | $18,660 | | | |
| | Johanna | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | $11,300 | | | |
| | Veronica | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | $8,440 | | | | |
| | Syrus | $1,400 | $2,800 | $4,800 | $6,400 | $8,220 | $10,440 | | | | |
| | Ibis | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | | | | | |
| | Wes | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | $6,220 | | | | | |
| | Danny | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | $2,000 | | | | | | |
| | Katie | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | | | | | | |
| | Tonya | $1,400 | $2,800 | $2,800 | $4,400 | | | | | | |
| | Brianna | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | | | | | | | |
| | Adam | $0 | $0 | $2,000 | | | | | | | |
| | Evelyn | $1,400 | $2,800 | | | | | | | | |
| | Nick | $0 | $0 | | | | | | | | |
| | Shauvon | $0 | $0 | | | | | | | | |
| | Diem | $0 | | | | | | | | | |
| | Chet | $0 | | | | | | | | | |
Final Prize: $158,350

## Episodes

| No. overall | No. in season | Title | Original release date | US viewers (millions) |
| 231 | 1 | "Wes Side Story" | September 30, 2009 (2009-09-30) | 1.699 |
| 232 | 2 | "The Booby Trap" | October 7, 2009 (2009-10-07) | N/A |
| 233 | 3 | "The Road to Ruins" | October 14, 2009 (2009-10-14) | N/A |
| 234 | 4 | "Girls Gone Wild" | October 21, 2009 (2009-10-21) | N/A |
| 235 | 5 | "Reversal of Fortune" | October 28, 2009 (2009-10-28) | N/A |
| 236 | 6 | "Ruining On Empty" | November 4, 2009 (2009-11-04) | N/A |
| 237 | 7 | "Silence of the Ruins" | November 11, 2009 (2009-11-11) | N/A |
| 238 | 8 | "Thai Me Up! Thai Me Down!" | November 18, 2009 (2009-11-18) | N/A |
| 239 | 9 | "Muay So-Called Ruins?" | December 2, 2009 (2009-12-02) | N/A |
| 240 | 10 | "Good Thai and Good Luck" | December 9, 2009 (2009-12-09) | N/A |

### Reunion special

The reunion aired on December 16, 2009 and it was hosted by Maria Menounos. Cast members that attended were: Wes, KellyAnne, Brad, Sarah, Evan, Dunbar, Kenny, Johanna, Johnny, Veronica, Susie & Katie. First topic was the weather in Thailand, how hot it was and how it affected the competition. Next topic was the final challenge, Sarah and KellyAnne said that until the final puzzle they thought they had a shot at the money, Susie said that she considered making a deal with the Challengers but at the end it's better to win the money yourself than get it from a deal, Evan then added that he had no doubt about Susie's performance in the final challenge because the night before she told him "nothing funny" was going to happen but Johnny said he had doubts. Susie was pointed to be as manipulative as Kenny and Evan.
The Brad/Darrell fight was shown and Brad talked about his trip to the hospital and his recovery process. Brad talked about how Tori reacted to the fight and their upcoming wedding, and he added he probably would not come back for another Challenge without Tori. Footage of Wes' multiple fights with the cast was shown. The love pentagon (Cohutta, KellyAnne, Wes, Johanna & Kenny) was also discussed, Johanna explained her side on the story and why she felt so down during the season. KellyAnne and Evelyn's elimination round was discussed next, Wes said he now understands that putting KellyAnne against Evelyn was the smartest decision for the Champions team and that it was not a personal attack, but KellyAnne said she still doesn't understand why her teammates wanted her out. Sarah then talked about how Kenny, Evan and Johnny made her feel and why she cried after Johnny's comments. Johanna said she exploited with Johnny's comments and not with Kenny's because they both had a "third grade crush" on each other but Sarah explained it was because Kenny and Evan make fun of so many people that it's normal, Wes said that it was time for the "I'm mean to everyone so I can be mean to you" excuse Kenny uses ends, Johanna added she was in Sarah's position with Kenny and Evan a while ago but it eventually gets better. Johnny and Katie talked about the fight with Sarah.
Maria Menounos commented on how this season broke the record of challengers being disqualified and the Veronica/Tonya fight was shown, Veronica said that up until the day of the fight she and Tonya were good on the challenge, that she didn't walk away because she did not think Tonya would hit her. Veronica said Tonya shouldn't have been on the show because she's not stable enough. Some footage of "The S#it They Should Have Shown" is played, as well as a preview for The Real World: D.C.

## Sexual assault controversy

In October 2011, two years after The Ruins season aired, contestant Tonya Cooley filed a lawsuit against fellow contestants Kenny Santucci and Evan Starkman, MTV, and Bunim/Murray Productions, claiming that she was sexually assaulted during filming. Cooley claimed in the lawsuit that Santucci and Starkman inserted a toothbrush into her vaginal canal while she was passed out from heavy drinking, and stated that she was subjected to an environment in which degrading and harassing behavior was directed at female contestants, including bathing suits stripped off their bodies. The lawsuit was settled out of court one year later.