# Real World/Road Rules Challenge: The Island

Real World/Road Rules Challenge: The Island is the 16th season of the MTV reality game show, The Challenge (at the time known as Real World/Road Rules Challenge).
Like previous seasons of The Challenge, The Island featured cast members from various past seasons of The Real World and Road Rules, competing along with several cast members from the Fresh Meat season of The Challenge. This season featured the contestants "stranded" on an island off the coast of Panama, where the cast competed for a buried treasure chest filled with $300,000 in gold. Unlike in previous seasons, the cast was not housed in a luxurious dwelling, but was "forced" to improvise and "work" for the basic necessities of food and shelter, as on the TV series Survivor. There were no predetermined teams. Instead, the cast members had to forge their own alliances. Of the twenty cast members, there were only four winners. The Island premiered on September 10, 2008, and concluded on October 29, 2008.

## Format

The contestants are "stranded" on an island, the objective of the challenge is to construct two boats that they are eventually going to be used to reach a nearby island where the buried treasure of $300,000 is hidden. Once the boats are complete, only eight key-holders are allowed to board and compete in a 4-on-4 race to get to the buried treasure.
At the beginning of each episode, materials to build the boats, food, information about the boats and some luxury are air-dropped, it's up to the contestants to decide how the food is divided and to assemble the pieces and make sure their vessels are seaworthy.
They then have to choose 3 contestants to go into a face-off. In order to get one of the keys to be in the final race and have a shot for the money, contestants must risk it all in this three-way face-offs. After each face-off, the winner receives a key, the losers get a chance to speak in front of every contestant as should why they should stay in the island, the contestants (except for the winner of the face-off) vote on who should leave the island. In the case of a tie, the winner of the face-off decides who leaves and who stays.
However, the rules of the challenge are given to the competitors as the challenge advances, and the way to get the keys can change at any moment. At the end of the season, the eight key-holders have to divide themselves into two teams of four, build their boats and race to the island where the buried treasure of $300,000 is hidden. The final eliminated contestants can help.

## Contestants

| Contestants | Original season | Finish |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | Winner |
| Evelyn Smith | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Winner |
| Johnny Devenanzio | The Real World: Key West | Winner |
| Kenny Santucci | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Winner |
| Jenn Grijalva | The Real World: Denver | Runner-up |
| Paula Meronek | The Real World: Key West | Runner-up |
| Robin Hibbard | The Real World: San Diego | Runner-up |
| Ryan Kehoe | Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Fresh Meat | Runner-up |
| Dunbar Merrill | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 8 |
| Johanna Botta | The Real World: Austin | Episode 8 |
| KellyAnne Judd | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 8 |
| Dan Walsh | Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge | Episode 8 |
| Colie Edison | The Real World: Denver | Episode 7 |
| Cohutta Grindstaff | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 6 |
| Tyrie Ballard | The Real World: Denver | Episode 5 |
| Ashli Robson | The Real World: Sydney | Episode 4 |
| Rachel Robinson | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | Episode 3 |
| Abram Boise | Road Rules: South Pacific | Episode 2 |
| Dave Malinosky | The Real World: Hollywood | Episode 2 |
| Tonya Cooley | The Real World: Chicago | Episode 1 |

## Face-offs

* Leaning Tower: Contestants must swim out to retrieve 12 pegs that will help them climb a telephone pole with a bell at the top. The first to the climb to the top and ring the bell wins.
** Played by: Abram vs. Kenny vs. Tonya
* Ring Wrestle: Contestants must all hold onto a ring and wrestle it out of the other's hands. The last person remaining wins.
** Played by: Abram vs. Derrick vs. Johnny
* The Rack: Contestants must sit on two parallel bars situated over water and never lose contact with both bars. The last person remaining wins.
** Played by: KellyAnne vs. Rachel vs. Robin
* Ball Buster: Contestants get to pick a partner and they all must fight to push a 9-foot-tall (2.7 m) ball into their goal twice. The first person to do so wins.
** Played by: Ashli vs. Jenn vs. Paula
* Bridge It: Contestants must walk back and forth across a bridge. After every time they walk across, they must remove one of the planks, making it more difficult for the next person to walk across. The only person who does not fall from the bridge wins.
** Played by: Dan vs. Evelyn vs. Tyrie
* Rat in a Cage: Contestants are each be locked in their own cage and each has four locks. Four keys are scattered that they have to untie. The first out of the cage wins.
** Played by: Johnny vs. Cohutta vs. Derrick
* Timbur: Contestants must stand on a stump and hold two heavy tree trunks up with each arm. Whoever holds the two tree trunks the longest wins.
** Played by: Johanna vs. Colie vs. Ryan
* Water Bound: Contestants are shackled at the ankles and dropped in a tank of water with a weight. They must continuously bounce up and sink back down with the weight. The person who holds the weight the longest wins.
** Played by: Dan vs. Evelyn vs. KellyAnne vs. Johanna

## Game summary

| Episode | Episode | Face-off participants | Face-off outcome | Face-off outcome | Face-off outcome | Face-off outcome | Face-off outcome |
| # | Face-off | Face-off participants | Winner | Key Stolen | Saved | Eliminated | Vote |
| 1 | Leaning Tower | Abram | Abram | — | Kenny | Tonya | 14-3 |
| 1 | Leaning Tower | Kenny | Abram | — | Kenny | Tonya | 14-3 |
| 1 | Leaning Tower | Tonya | Abram | — | Kenny | Tonya | 14-3 |
| 2 | Ring Wrestle | Abram | Derrick | — | Johnny | Abram | 9-6 |
| 2 | Ring Wrestle | Derrick | Derrick | — | Johnny | Abram | 9-6 |
| 2 | Ring Wrestle | Johnny | Derrick | — | Johnny | Abram | 9-6 |
| 3 | The Rack | KellyAnne | KellyAnne | — | Robin | Rachel | 8-6 |
| 3 | The Rack | Rachel | KellyAnne | — | Robin | Rachel | 8-6 |
| 3 | The Rack | Robin | KellyAnne | — | Robin | Rachel | 8-6 |
| 4 | Ball Buster | Ashli | Paula | — | Jenn | Ashli | 7-0 |
| 4 | Ball Buster | Jenn | Paula | — | Jenn | Ashli | 7-0 |
| 4 | Ball Buster | Paula | Paula | — | Jenn | Ashli | 7-0 |
| 5 | Bridge It | Dan | Evelyn | Johnny | Dan | Tyrie | 9-2 |
| 5 | Bridge It | Evelyn | Evelyn | Johnny | Dan | Tyrie | 9-2 |
| 5 | Bridge It | Tyrie | Evelyn | Johnny | Dan | Tyrie | 9-2 |
| 6 | Rat in a Cage | Cohutta | Johnny | Evelyn | Derrick | Cohutta | 10-1 |
| 6 | Rat in a Cage | Derrick | Johnny | Evelyn | Derrick | Cohutta | 10-1 |
| 6 | Rat in a Cage | Johnny | Johnny | Evelyn | Derrick | Cohutta | 10-1 |
| 7 | Timber | Colie | Ryan | KellyAnne | Johanna | Colie | 10-0 |
| 7 | Timber | Johanna | Ryan | KellyAnne | Johanna | Colie | 10-0 |
| 7 | Timber | Ryan | Ryan | KellyAnne | Johanna | Colie | 10-0 |
| 8 | Water Bound | Dan | Evelyn | Dunbar | — | Dan | — |
| 8 | Water Bound | Evelyn | Evelyn | Dunbar | — | Dunbar | — |
| 8 | Water Bound | Johanna | Evelyn | Dunbar | — | Johanna | — |
| 8 | Water Bound | KellyAnne | Evelyn | Dunbar | — | KellyAnne | — |
| 8 | Final Challenge | Winners: Derrick, Evelyn, Johnny, Kenny | Winners: Derrick, Evelyn, Johnny, Kenny | Winners: Derrick, Evelyn, Johnny, Kenny | 2nd place: Jenn, Paula, Robin, Ryan | 2nd place: Jenn, Paula, Robin, Ryan | 2nd place: Jenn, Paula, Robin, Ryan |
    Red Boat
    Blue Boat

### Face-off progress

| Contestants | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes |
| Contestants | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Finale | Finale | Finale |
| Derrick | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | | WINNER |
| Evelyn | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | WON | LOSE | SAFE | WON | | WINNER |
| Johnny | SAFE | SAVE | SAFE | SAFE | LOSE | WON | SAFE | SAFE | | WINNER |
| Kenny | SAVE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | | WINNER |
| Jenn | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAVE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | | LOSER |
| Paula | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | | LOSER |
| Robin | SAFE | SAFE | SAVE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | | LOSER |
| Ryan | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | WON | SAFE | | LOSER |
| Dunbar | SAFE | KEY | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | LOST | | |
| Johanna | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | LAST | | |
| KellyAnne | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | LOSE | LAST | | |
| Dan | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | RISK | SAFE | SAFE | LAST | | |
| Colie | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | |
| Cohutta | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | |
| Tyrie | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | |
| Ashli | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | |
| Rachel | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | | | | | | | |
| Abram | WIN | OUT | | | | | | | | |
| Dave | SAFE | QUIT | | | | | | | | |
| Tonya | OUT | | | | | | | | | |

#### Competition

    The contestant won the competition
    The contestant made it to the end of the challenge, but lost in the final
    The contestant won the face-off and a key
    The contestant won the face-off and took the key of another contestant
    The contestant lost the face-off, but was not eliminated and received a key
    The contestant lost the face-off, but was not eliminated
    The contestant had their key stolen by the face-off winner
    The contestant had their key stolen by the face-off winner and was automatically eliminated
    The contestant lost the face-off and was automatically eliminated
    The contestant lost the face-off and was voted out
    The contestant quit the competition
    The contestant was given a key by an eliminated player

## Voting progress

| Voted Out | Voted Out | Tonya 14 of 17 votes | Abram 9 of 15 votes | Rachel 8 of 14 votes | Ashli 7 of 13 votes | Tyrie 9 of 11 votes | Cohutta 10 of 11 votes | Colie 10 of 10 votes | No Vote |
| Players | Players | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes | Episodes |
| Players | Players | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| | Derrick | Kenny | | Rachel | Ashli | Tyrie | | Colie | |
| | Evelyn | Tonya | Johnny | Robin | Ashli | | Cohutta | Colie | |
| | Johnny | Tonya | | Rachel | Ashli | Tyrie | | Colie | |
| | Kenny | | Abram | Rachel | Not Shown | Tyrie | Cohutta | Colie | |
| | Jenn | Kenny | Johnny | Robin | | Dan | Cohutta | Colie | |
| | Paula | Tonya | Abram | Rachel | | Tyrie | Cohutta | Colie | |
| | Robin | Tonya | Johnny | | Not Shown | Tyrie | Cohutta | Colie | |
| | Ryan | Kenny | Abram | Rachel | Not Shown | Tyrie | Cohutta | | |
| Dunbar | Dunbar | Tonya | Abram | Rachel | Not Shown | Tyrie | Cohutta | Colie | |
| Johanna | Johanna | Tonya | Abram | Rachel | Not Shown | Not Shown | Cohutta | | |
| KellyAnne | KellyAnne | Tonya | Johnny | | Ashli | Tyrie | Derrick | Colie | |
| Dan | Dan | Tonya | Abram | Rachel | Ashli | | Cohutta | Colie | |
| Colie | Colie | Tonya | Abram | Robin | Not Shown | Dan | Cohutta | | |
| Cohutta | Cohutta | Tonya | Abram | Robin | Ashli | Tyrie | | | |
| Tyrie | Tyrie | Tonya | Abram | Robin | Ashli | | | | |
| Ashli | Ashli | Tonya | Johnny | Robin | | | | | |
| Rachel | Rachel | Tonya | Johnny | | | | | | |
| Abram | Abram | | | | | | | | |
| Dave | Dave | Tonya | | | | | | | |
| Tonya | Tonya | | | | | | | | |

## Key holders

| Key | Episode | Episode | Episode | Episode | Episode | Episode | Episode | Episode |
| Key | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 1 | Abram | Dunbar | Dunbar | Dunbar | Dunbar | Dunbar | Dunbar | Evelyn |
| 2 | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny | Kenny |
| 3 | | Derrick | Derrick | Derrick | Derrick | Derrick | Derrick | Derrick |
| 4 | | Johnny | Johnny | Johnny | Evelyn | Johnny | Johnny | Johnny |
| 5 | | | KellyAnne | KellyAnne | KellyAnne | KellyAnne | Ryan | Ryan |
| 6 | | | Robin | Robin | Robin | Robin | Robin | Robin |
| 7 | | | | Paula | Paula | Paula | Paula | Paula |
| 8 | | | | Jenn | Jenn | Jenn | Jenn | Jenn |
* Key holder at the end of each episode

## Episodes

| No. overall | No. in season | Title | Original release date |
| 213 | 1 | "Welcome to the Island" | September 10, 2008 (2008-09-10) |
| 214 | 2 | "Calling It Quits" | September 17, 2008 (2008-09-17) |
| 215 | 3 | "Girl Fight" | September 24, 2008 (2008-09-24) |
| 216 | 4 | "Are You a Quitter?" | October 1, 2008 (2008-10-01) |
| 217 | 5 | "Ev vs. The Island" | October 8, 2008 (2008-10-08) |
| 218 | 6 | "Island King" | October 15, 2008 (2008-10-15) |
| 219 | 7 | "Down to the Wire" | October 22, 2008 (2008-10-22) |
| 220 | 8 | "Sailing to Victory" | October 29, 2008 (2008-10-29) |

### Reunion special

The Island Reunion: The Final Face Off aired on November 5, 2008 and was hosted by Carlos Santos from MTV Tres. The cast members who attended were: Johanna, Paula, Kenny, Derrick, Johnny, Evelyn, Ryan, Jenn, KellyAnne and Robin. A promo from the upcoming The Real World: Brooklyn season is shown.

## Controversy

The season sparked controversy for production's poor respect of the local environment. Panamanian locals criticised MTV for clearing a small patch of forest for construction, developing an access road through the forest and installing generators and lighting on the beach.