# The Languages of Africa

The Languages of Africa is a 1963 book of essays by the linguist Joseph Greenberg, in which the author sets forth a genetic classification of African languages that, with some changes, continues to be the most commonly used one today. It is an expanded and extensively revised version of his 1955 work Studies in African Linguistic Classification, which was itself a compilation of eight articles which Greenberg had published in the Southwestern Journal of Anthropology between 1949 and 1954. It was first published in 1963 as Part II of the International Journal of American Linguistics, Vol. 29, No. 1; however, its second edition of 1966, in which it was published (by Indiana University, Bloomington: Mouton & Co., The Hague) as an independent work, is more commonly cited.
Its author describes it as based on three fundamentals of method:
* "The sole relevance in comparison of resemblances involving both sound and meaning in specific forms."
* "Mass comparison as against isolated comparisons between pairs of languages."
* "Only linguistic evidence is relevant in drawing conclusions about classification."

## Innovations

Greenberg's Niger–Congo family was substantially foreshadowed by Westermann's "Western Sudanic", but he changed the subclassification, including Fulani (as West Atlantic) and the newly postulated Adamawa–Eastern, excluding Songhai, and classifying Bantu as merely a subfamily of Benue–Congo (previously termed "Semi-Bantu").
Semitic, Berber, Egyptian and Cushitic had been generally accepted as members of a "Hamito-Semitic" family, while Chadic, Fulani, "Nilo-Hamitic" and Hottentot had all been controversially proposed as members. He accepted Chadic (while changing its membership), and rejected the other three, establishing to most linguists' satisfaction that they had been classified as "Hamitic" for purely typological reasons. This demonstration also led to the rejection (by him and by linguistics as a whole) of the term Hamitic as having no coherent meaning in historical linguistics; as a result, he renamed the newly reclassified family "Afroasiatic".
Following Schapera and rejecting Meinhof, he classified Hottentot as a member of the Central Khoisan languages. To Khoisan he also added the much more northerly Hadza (Hatsa) and Sandawe.
His most revolutionary step was the postulation of the Nilo-Saharan family. This is still controversial, because so far attempts to reconstruct this family have been unsuccessful, but it holds promise and it is widely used. Prior linguists had noticed an apparent relationship between the majority of the languages, but had never formally proposed a family. These languages – the Eastern Sudanic, Central Sudanic, Kunama and Berta branches – Greenberg placed into a core group he called Chari–Nile, to which he added all the remaining unclassified languages of Africa that did not have noun classes. The distinction between Chari–Nile and the peripheral branches has since been abandoned. On a lower level, he placed "Nilo-Hamitic" firmly within Nilotic, following a suggestion of Köhler, and placed Eastern Sudanic on a firmer foundation.
Finally, he assigned the unclassified languages of the Nuba Hills of South Kordofan to the Niger–Congo family, calling the result Congo–Kordofanian. The relationship has been accepted, with the exception of the "Tumtum" group, though the Kordofanian languages are no longer seen as being a primary branch, and the name 'Congo–Kordofanian' is no longer used.
Greenberg's four families became the dominant conception of African languages, though his subclassification did not fare as well. Niger−Congo and Afroasiatic are nearly universally accepted, with no significant support for Hamitic or the independence of Bantu. Nilo-Saharan is still considered provisional. Khoisan is now rejected by specialists, except as a term of convenience, though it may be retained in less specialized literature.

## Classification

The book classifies Africa's languages into four stocks not presumed to be related to each other, as follows:

### I. Congo–Kordofanian

    I.A Niger–Congo
    I.A.1 West Atlantic
    I.A.1.a Northern: Wolof, Serer-Sin, Fulani, Serer-Non, Konyagi, Basari, Biafada, Badyara (Pajade), Dyola, Mandyak, Balante, Banyun, Nalu, Cobiana, Cassanga, Bidyogo
    I.A.1.b Southern: Temne, Baga, Landoma, Kissi, Bulom, Limba, Gola
    I.A.2 Mande
    I.A.2.a Western
    I.A.2.a.1 Malinke, Bambara, Dyula, Mandinka, Numu, Ligbi, Huela, Vai, Kono, Koranko, Khasonke Bobo
    I.A.2.a.3 Mende, Loko, Gbandi, Loma, Kpelle (Guerze)
    I.A.2.a.4 Susu, Dyalonke
    I.A.2.a.5 Soninke, Bozo
    I.A.2.a.6 Duun, Dzuun, Jo, Seenku (Sembla), Kpan, Banka
    I.A.2.b Eastern
    I.A.2.b.1 Mano, Dan (Gio), Guro (Kweni), Mwa, Nwa, Beng, Gban, Tura (Wen), Yaure
    I.A.2.b.2 Samo, Bisa, Busa, Kyenga, Shanga
    I.A.3 Voltaic
    I.A.3.a Senoufo: Minianka, Tagba, Foro, Tagwana (Takponin), Dyimini, Nafana
    I.A.3.b. Lobi-Dogon: Lobi, Dyan, Puguli, Gan, Gouin, Turuka, Doghosie, Doghosie-Fing, Kyan, Tara, Bwamu, Wara, Natioro, Dogon, Kulango
    I.A.3.c Grusi: Awuna, Kasena, Nunuma, Lyele, Tamprusi, Kanjaga (Bulea) (moved to group d), Degha, Siti, Kurumba (Fulse), Sisala
    I.A.3.d Mossi, Dagomba, Kusasi, Nankanse, Talensi, Mamprusi, Wala, Dagari, Birifo, Namnam, Kanjaga (Bulea) (moved from group c)
    I.A.3.e Tem, Kabre, Delo, Chala
    I.A.3.f Bargu (Bariba)
    I.A.3.g Gurma, Tobote (Basari), Kasele (Chamba), Moba
    I.A.3.x Dogon
    I.A.4 Kwa
    I.A.4.a Kru: Bete, Bakwe, Grebo, Bassa, De, Kru (Krawi)
    I.A.4.b Avatime, Nyangbo, Tafi, Logba, Likpe, Ahlo, Akposo, Lefana, Bowili, Akpafu, Santrokofi, Adele, Kebu, Anyimere, Ewe, Aladian, Avikam, Gwa, Kyama, Akye, Ari, Abe, Adyukru, Akan (Twi, Anyi, Baule, Guang, Metyibo, Abure), Ga, Adangme
    I.A.4.c Yoruba, Igala
    I.A.4.d Nupe, Gbari, Igbira, Gade
    I.A.4.e Bini, Ishan, Kukuruku, Sobo
    I.A.4.f Idoma, Agatu, Iyala
    I.A.4.g Ibo
    I.A.4.h Ijo
    I.A.5 Benue–Congo
    I.A.5.A Plateau
    I.A.5.A.1
    I.A.5.A.1.a Kambari, Dukawa, Dakakari, Basa, Kamuku, Reshe
    I.A.5.A.1.b Piti, Janji, Kurama, Chawai, Anaguta, Buji, Amap, Gure, Kahugu, Ribina, Butawa, Kudawa
    I.A.5.A.2 Afusare, Irigwe, Katab, Kagoro, Kaje, Kachicheri, Morwa, Jaba, Kamantan, Kadara, Koro, Afo
    I.A.5.A.3 Birom, Ganawuri (Aten)
    I.A.5.A.4 Rukuba, Ninzam, Ayu, Mada, Kaninkwom
    I.A.5.A.5 Eggon, Nungu, Yeskwa
    I.A.5.A.6 Kaleri, Pyem, Pai
    I.A.5.A.7 Yergam, Basherawa
    I.A.5.B Jukunoid: Jukun, Kentu, Nyidu, Tigong, Eregba, Mbembe, Zumper (Kutev, Mbarike), Boritsu
    I.A.5.C Cross-River
    I.A.5.C.1 Boki, Gayi (Uge), Yakoro
    I.A.5.C.2 Ibibio, Efik, Ogoni (Kana), Andoni, Akoiyang, Ododop, Korop
    I.A.5.C.3 Akunakuna, Abine, Yako, Asiga, Ekuri, Ukelle, Okpoto-Mteze, Olulomo
    I.A.5.D Bantoid: Tiv, Bitare, Batu, Ndoro, Mambila, Bute, Bantu
    I.A.6 Adamawa–Eastern
    I.A.6.A Adamawa
    I.A.6.A.1 Tula, Dadiya, Waja, Cham, Kamu
    I.A.6.A.2 Chamba, Donga, Lekon, Wom, Mumbake
    I.A.6.A.3 Daka, Taram
    I.A.6.A.4 Vere, Namshi, Kolbila, Pape, Sari, Sewe, Woko, Kotopo, Kutin, Durru
    I.A.6.A.5 Mumuye, Kumba, Gengle, Teme, Waka, Yendang, Zinna
    I.A.6.A.6 Dama, Mono, Mbere, Mundang, Yasing, Mangbei, Mbum, Kpere, Lakka, Dek
    I.A.6.A.7 Yungur, Mboi, Libo, Roba
    I.A.6.A.8 Kam
    I.A.6.A.9 Jen, Munga
    I.A.6.A.10 Longuda
    I.A.6.A.11 Fali
    I.A.6.A.12 Nimbari
    I.A.6.A.13 Bua, Nielim, Koke
    I.A.6.A.14 Masa
    I.A.6.B Eastern
    I.A.6.B.1 Gbaya, Manja, Mbaka
    I.A.6.B.2 Banda
    I.A.6.B.3 Ngbandi, Sango, Yakoma
    I.A.6.B.4 Zande, Nzakara, Barambo, Pambia
    I.A.6.B.5 Bwaka, Monjombo, Gbanziri, Mundu, Mayogo, Bangba
    I.A.6.B.6 Ndogo, Bai, Bviri, Golo, Sere, Tagbo, Feroge, Indri, Mangaya, Togoyo
    I.A.6.B.7 Amadi (Madyo, Ma)
    I.A.6.B.8 Mondunga, Mba (Bamanga)
    I.B Kordofanian
    I.B.1 Koalib: Koalib, Kanderma, Heiban, Laro, Otoro, Kawama, Shwai, Tira, Moro, Fungor
    I.B.2 Tegali: Tegali, Rashad, Tagoi, Tumale
    I.B.3 Talodi: Talodi, Lafofa, Eliri, Masakin, Tacho, Lumun, El Amira
    I.B.4 Tumtum: Tumtum, Tuleshi, Keiga, Karondi, Krongo, Miri, Kadugli, Katcha
    I.B.5 Katla: Katla, Tima

### II. Nilo-Saharan

    II.A Songhai
    II.B Saharan
    II.B.a Kanuri, Kanembu
    II.B.b Teda, Daza
    II.B.c Zaghawa, Berti
    II.C Maban: Maba, Runga, Mimi of Nachtigal, Mimi of Gaudefroy-Demombynes
    II.D. Fur
    II.E. Chari–Nile
    II.E.1 Eastern Sudanic
    II.E.1.1 Nubian
    II.E.1.1.a Nile Nubian (Mahas-Fadidja and Kenuzi-Dongola)
    II.E.1.1.b Kordofanian Nubian: Dair, Dilling, Gulfan, Garko, Kadero, Kundugr
    II.E.1.1.c Midob
    II.E.1.1.d Birked
    II.E.1.2 Murle (Beir), Longarim, Didinga, Suri, Mekan, Murzu, Surma (including Tirma and Zulmanu), Masongo
    II.E.1.3 Barea
    II.E.1.4 Ingassana (Tabi)
    II.E.1.5 Nyima, Afitti
    II.E.1.6 Temein, Teis-um-Danab
    II.E.1.7 Merarit, Tama, Sungor
    II.E.1.8 Dagu of Darfur, Baygo, Sila, Dagu of Dar Dagu (Wadai), Dagu of Western Kordofan, Njalgulgule, Shatt, Liguri
    II.E.1.9 Nilotic
    II.E.1.9.a Western
    II.E.1.9.a.1 Burun
    II.E.1.9.a.2 Shilluk, Anuak, Acholi, Lango, Alur, Luo, Jur, Bor
    II.E.1.9.a.3 Dinka, Nuer
    II.E.1.9.b Eastern
    II.E.1.9.b.1 Bari, Fajulu, Kakwa, Mondari
    II.E.1.9.b.2a Jie, Dodoth, Karamojong, Teso, Topotha, Turkana
    II.E.1.9.b.2b Masai
    II.E.1.9.b.3 Southern: Nandi, Suk, Tatoga
    II.E.1.10 Nyangiya, Teuso
    II.E.2 Central Sudanic
    II.E.2.1 Bongo, Baka, Morokodo, Beli, Gberi, Sara dialects (Madjinngay, Gulai, Mbai, Gamba, Kaba, Dendje, Laka), Vale, Nduka, Tana, Horo, Bagirmi, Kuka, Kenga, Disa, Bubalia
    II.E.2.2 Kreish
    II.E.2.3 Binga, Yulu, Kara [= Tar Gula]
    II.E.2.4 Moru, Avukaya, Logo, Keliko, Lugbara, Madi
    II.E.2.5 Mangbetu, Lombi, Popoi, Makere, Meje, Asua
    II.E.2.6 Mangbutu, Mamvu, Lese, Mvuba, Efe
    II.E.2.7 Lendu
    II.E.3 Berta
    II.E.4 Kunama
    II.F Koman/Coman: Komo, Ganza, Uduk, Gule, Gumuz, Mao

### III. Afroasiatic

    III.A Semitic
    III.B Egyptian
    III.C Berber
    III.D Cushitic
    III.D.1 Northern Cushitic: Beja (Bedauye)
    III.D.2 Central Cushitic: Bogo (Bilin), Kamir, Khamta, Awiya, Damot, Kemant, Kayla, Quara
    III.D.3 Eastern Cushitic: Saho-Afar, Somali, Galla, Konso, Geleba, Marille, (Reshiat, Arbore), Gardula, Gidole, Gowaze, Burji, Sidamo, Darasa, Kambata, Alaba, Hadya, Tambaro, Mogogodo (added 1966)
    III.D.4 Western Cushitic: Janjero, Wolamo, Zala, Gofa, Basketo, Baditu, Haruro, Zaysse, Chara, Gimira, Benesho, Nao, Kaba, Shako, She, Maji, Kafa, Garo, Mocha, Anfillo (Mao), Shinasha, Bako, Amar, Bana, Dime, Gayi, Kerre, Tsamai, Doko, Dollo
    III.D.5 Southern Cushitic: Burungi (Mbulungu), Goroa (Fiome), Alawa (Uwassi), Iraqw, Mbugu, Sanye [= Dahalo], Ngomvia (added 1966)
    III.E Chad
    III.E.1
    III.E.1.a Hausa, Gwandara
    III.E.1.b Ngizim, Mober [= Kanuri, not Chadic], Auyokawa, Shirawa, Bede
    III.E.1.c
    III.E.1.c.i Warjawa, Afawa, Diryawa, Miyawa, Sirawa
    III.E.1.c.ii Gezawa, Sayawa, Barawa of Dass
    III.E.1.d
    III.E.1.d.i Bolewa, Karekare, Ngamo, Gerawa, Gerumawa, Kirifawa, Dera (Kanakuru), Tangale, Pia, Pero, Chongee, Maha (added 1966)
    III.E.1.d.ii Angas, Ankwe, Bwol, Chip, Dimuk, Goram, Jorto, Kwolla, Miriam, Montol, Sura, Tal, Gerka
    III.E.1.d.iii Ron
    III.E.2 Kotoko group: Logone, Ngala [= Mpade?], Buduma, Kuri, Gulfei, Affade, Shoe, Kuseri
    III.E.3 Bata–Margi group
    III.E.3.a Bachama, Demsa, Gudo, Malabu, Njei (Kobochi, Nzangi, Zany), Zumu (Jimo), Holma, Kapsiki, Baza, Hiji, Gude (Cheke), Fali of Mubi, Fali of Kiria, Fali of Jilbu, Margi, Chibak, Kilba, Sukur, Vizik, Vemgo, Woga, Tur, Bura, Pabir, Podokwo
    III.E.3.b Gabin, Hona, Tera, Jera, Hinna (Hina)
    III.E.4
    III.E.4.a Hina, Daba, Musgoi, Gauar
    III.E.4.b Gisiga, Balda, Muturua, Mofu, Matakam
    III.E.5 Gidder
    III.E.6 Mandara, Gamergu
    III.E.7 Musgu
    III.E.8 Bana, Banana (Masa), Lame, Kulung
    III.E.9
    III.E.9.a Somrai, Tumak, Ndam, Miltu, Sarwa, Gulei [= Tumak?]
    III.E.9.b Gabere, Chiri, Dormo, Nangire
    III.E.9.c Sokoro (Bedanga), Barein
    III.E.9.d Modgel
    III.E.9.e Tuburi
    III.E.9.f Mubi, Karbo, (added 1966: Jegu, Jonkor, Wadai-Birgid)

### IV Khoisan

    IV.A South African Khoisan
    IV.A.1 Northern South African Khoisan
    IV.A.2 Central South African Khoisan
    IV.A.3 Southern South African Khoisan
    IV.B Sandawe
    IV.C Hatsa