# List of Division I AHCA All-American Teams

The Division I AHCA All-American Teams are an annual honor bestowed by the American Hockey Coaches Association to the college hockey players judged to be the top performers in their division. Each team is composed of at least one goaltender, two defensemen and three forwards on ice hockey programs. At least one all-star team has been named by the since the start of NCAA tournament play in 1947–48 after the conclusion of either the regular season or the conference tournaments.
Initially the All-American teams weren't named by ACHA. in the first ten years of the teams the players were selected by some combination of media members and team officials. In some years only players from teams that participated in the NCAA tournament were eligible. In each of the first ten years two teams worth of players were voted on and usually assorted into a first- and second-team. In some years, however, no distinction was made and the players were all considered to have received first-team honors. The format was changed for the 1957–58 season, creating an All-American team for both the East and West regions. In the early years of this format the All-American teams were dominated by two conferences (the WCHA in the west and the ECAC in the east) as there were only two major conferences competing in NCAA hockey (the WCHA began play in 1959–60 followed by the ECAC two years later). While the CCHA began play in 1971–72 it would only provide one player to the All-American teams until a conference realignment in 1981–82 when it became considered on par with the major conferences. The ECAC would continue to dominate the eastern teams until an internal schism split the conference and Hockey East was formed in 1984–85. Due in part to an influx of member teams to fill the rolls of the four major conferences as well as increased inter-conference competition for recognition, the AHCA began to name two teams for each region (first- and second-teams) which it has continued to do since 1983–84.
As of 2013–14 the conferences that comprise the east region are Atlantic Hockey, the ECAC and Hockey East while the western region contains the Big Ten, NCHC and the WCHA.

## All-American teams

Sources:

### First Team
#### 1940s

1947–48 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ian Watson | G | California |
| Ross Smith | D | Michigan |
| Butch Songin | D | Boston College |
| Pat Finnegan | F | California |
| Bill Riley | F | Dartmouth |
| Joe Slattery | F | Colorado College |
1948–49 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dick Desmond | G | Dartmouth |
| Ian Watson | G | California |
| Connie Hill | D | Michigan |
| Butch Songin | D | Boston College |
| Jim Starrak | D | Colorado College |
| Dick Starrak | D | Michigan |
| Wally Gacek | F | Michigan |
| Wally Grant | F | Michigan |
| Bill Riley | F | Dartmouth |
| Joe Riley | F | Dartmouth |
| Dick Rowell | F | Colorado College |
| Joe Slattery | F | Colorado College |

#### 1950s

1949–50 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ralph Bevins | G | Boston University |
| Ross Smith | D | Michigan |
| Jim Starrak | D | Colorado College |
| Jack Garrity | F | Boston University |
| Warren Lewis | F | Boston College |
| Arnold Oss | F | Dartmouth |
1950–51 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Larry Ross | G | Minnesota |
| Donald Whiston | G | Brown |
| Joe deBastiani | D | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Heathcott | D | Michigan |
| John Noah | D | North Dakota |
| Jim Starrak | D | Colorado College |
| Gil Burford | F | Michigan |
| Neil Celley | F | Michigan |
| Tony Frasca | F | Colorado College |
| Jack Garrity | F | Boston University |
| Clifford Harrison | F | Dartmouth |
| John McKennell | F | Michigan |
| Gordon Watters | F | Minnesota |
1951–52 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ray Picard | G | Northeastern |
| John Grocott | D | Dartmouth |
| Eddie Miller | D | Denver |
| Tony Frasca | F | Colorado College |
| Ron Hartwell | F | Colorado College |
| Bob Wheeler | F | Brown |
1952–53 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mattson | G | Minnesota |
| Ray Picard | G | Northeastern |
| Doug Binning | D | Middlebury |
| Herb LaFontaine | D | Rensselaer |
| Alex MacLellan | D | Michigan |
| Bob Monahan | D | Michigan Tech |
| Hank Bothfeld | F | Princeton |
| Wellington Burtnett | F | Boston College |
| Ben Cherski | F | North Dakota |
| Frank Chiarelli | F | Rensselaer |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| Richard Rodenhiser | F | Boston University |
1953–54 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Spike Schultz | G | North Dakota |
| Bob Kiley | D | Boston College |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Ben Cherski | F | North Dakota |
| Richard Dougherty | F | Minnesota |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
1954–55 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Sloan | G | St. Lawrence |
| Doug Silverberg | D | Colorado College |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Bill Cleary | F | Harvard |
| Bill Reichart | F | North Dakota |
| Clare Smith | F | Colorado College |
1955–56 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lorne Howes | G | Michigan |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Doug Silverberg | D | Colorado College |
| Garry Kearns | F | Rensselaer |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Ed Rowe | F | Clarkson |
1956–57 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack McCartan | G | Minnesota |
| Don Wishart | D | Colorado College |
| Pat Presley | D | St. Lawrence |
| Bill Hay | F | Colorado College |
| Bill Reichart | F | North Dakota |
| Ed Rowe | F | Clarkson |
1957–58 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie MacDonald | G | Clarkson |
| Bob Dupuis | D | Boston University |
| Don MacLeod | D | Boston University |
| Bob Cleary | F | Harvard |
| Bob Marquis | F | Boston University |
| Paul Midghall | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack McCartan | G | Minnesota |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Ed Zemrau | D | Denver |
| Bill Hay | F | Colorado College |
| Dick Burg | F | Minnesota |
| Bob McCusker | F | Colorado College |
| Bob White | F | Michigan |
1958–59 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gerry Jones | G | Yale |
| Joe Jangro | D | Boston College |
| Pat Presley | D | St. Lawrence |
| Bob Marquis | F | Boston University |
| Paul Midghall | F | Rensselaer |
| Phil Latreille | F | Middlebury |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Selinger | G | Michigan State |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Watt | D | Michigan |
| John Kosiancic | F | Michigan Tech |
| Bob White | F | Michigan |
| Murray Williamson | F | Minnesota |

#### 1960s

1959–60 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Wahman | G | Dartmouth |
| Red Martin | D | Boston College |
| Rusty Ingersoll | D | Dartmouth |
| Terry Slater | F | St. Lawrence |
| Phil Latreille | F | Middlebury |
| Art Chisholm | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Cuculick | G | Michigan Tech |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| George Konik | D | Denver |
| Paul Coppo | F | Michigan Tech |
| Reg Morelli | F | North Dakota |
| Bill Masterton | F | Denver |
1960–61 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rod Blackburn | G | New Hampshire |
| Arlie Parker | D | St. Lawrence |
| Red Martin | D | Boston College |
| Terry Slater | F | St. Lawrence |
| Phil Latreille | F | Middlebury |
| Art Chisholm | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Kirkwood | G | Denver |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| Grant Munro | D | Denver |
| Red Berenson | F | Michigan |
| Bill Masterton | F | Denver |
| Jerry Walker | F | Denver |
1961–62 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Stephenson | G | Colby |
| David Johnston | D | Harvard |
| Arlie Parker | D | St. Lawrence |
| Bill Hogan | F | Boston College |
| Ron Ryan | F | Colby |
| Dates Fryberger | F | Middlebury |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Chandik | G | Michigan State |
| Henry Akervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Elov Seger | D | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Angotti | F | Michigan Tech |
| Red Berenson | F | Michigan |
| Jerry Sullivan | F | Michigan Tech |
1962–63 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richie Broadbelt | G | St. Lawrence |
| Pat Brophy | D | Clarkson |
| David Johnston | D | Harvard |
| Cal Wagner | D | Clarkson |
| Bob Brinkworth | F | Rensselaer |
| Jack Leetch | F | Boston College |
| Dates Fryberger | F | Middlebury |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Nanne | D | Minnesota |
| Don Ross | D | North Dakota |
| George Hill | F | Michigan Tech |
| Al McLean | F | North Dakota |
| Dave Merrifield | F | North Dakota |
| Bill Staub | F | Denver |
1963–64 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Perani | G | St. Lawrence |
| Richie Green | D | Boston University |
| Larry Kish | D | Providence |
| Cal Wagner | D | Clarkson |
| Corby Adams | F | Clarkson |
| Bob Brinkworth | F | Rensselaer |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Carl Lackey | D | Michigan State |
| Tom Polanic | D | Michigan |
| Craig Falkman | F | Minnesota |
| John Simus | F | Colorado College |
| Gordon Wilkie | F | Michigan |
1964–65 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Yurkiewicz | G | Clarkson |
| Jack Ferreira | G | Boston University |
| Robert Gaudreau | D | Brown |
| Tom Ross | D | Boston University |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Grant Heffernan | F | Providence |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Don Ross | D | North Dakota |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Doug Roberts | F | Michigan State |
| Mel Wakabayashi | F | Michigan |
| Doug Woog | F | Minnesota |
1965–66 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Yurkiewicz | G | Clarkson |
| Robert Gaudreau | D | Brown |
| Tom Ross | D | Boston University |
| Fred Bassi | F | Boston University |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Hill | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Bruce Riutta | D | Michigan Tech |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Terry Casey | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Lindberg | F | Colorado College |
| Doug Volmar | F | Michigan State |
1966–67 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Brian Gilmour | D | Boston University |
| Harry Orr | D | Cornell |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| John Morrison | F | Yale |
| Jerry York | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Rick Best | G | Michigan Tech |
| Jerry Lafond | D | North Dakota |
| Bruce Riutta | D | Michigan Tech |
| Keith Christiansen | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Bob Lindberg | F | Colorado College |
| Gary Milroy | F | Michigan Tech |
| Jim Wiste | F | Denver |
1967–68 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Bruce Pattison | D | Cornell |
| Skip Stanowski | D | Cornell |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Wayne Small | F | Brown |
| Herb Wakabayashi | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Keough | G | Michigan |
| Terry Abram | D | North Dakota |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Gary Gambucci | F | Minnesota |
| Bob Munro | F | North Dakota |
| Jim Wiste | F | Denver |
1968–69 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Paul Hurley | D | Boston College |
| Bruce Pattison | D | Cornell |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Tim Sheehy | F | Boston College |
| Peter Tufford | F | Cornell |
| Herb Wakabayashi | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Duffett | G | Michigan State |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| John Marks | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Collyard | F | Colorado College |
| Al Karlander | F | Michigan Tech |
| George Morrison | F | Denver |
| Bob Munro | F | North Dakota |

#### 1970s

1969–70 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Bullock | G | Clarkson |
| Dan Lodboa | D | Cornell |
| Mike Hyndman | D | Boston University |
| Curt Bennett | F | Brown |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| Tommy Earl | F | Colgate |
| Tim Sheehy | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Murray McLachlan | G | Minnesota |
| Ron Busniuk | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| John Jagger | D | Wisconsin |
| John Marks | D | North Dakota |
| Wally Olds | D | Minnesota |
| Bob Collyard | F | Colorado College |
| Murray Keogan | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| George Morrison | F | Denver |
1970–71 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Bullock | G | Clarkson |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Steve Warr | D | Clarkson |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| Kevin Pettit | F | Cornell |
| Steve Stirling | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Morris Trewin | G | Michigan Tech |
| Mike Christie | D | Denver |
| Bob Murray | D | Michigan Tech |
| Walt Ledingham | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Don Thompson | F | Michigan State |
| Vic Venasky | F | Denver |
1971–72 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Brady | G | Boston University |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Steve Warr | D | Clarkson |
| John Danby | F | Boston University |
| Larry Fullan | F | Cornell |
| Dave Hynes | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Watt | G | Michigan State |
| Jeff Rotsch | D | Wisconsin |
| Alan Hangsleben | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Winograd | F | Colorado College |
| Walt Ledingham | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Doug Palazzari | F | Colorado College |
| Tom Peluso | F | Denver |
1972–73 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ed Walsh | G | Boston University |
| Tom Mellor | D | Boston College |
| Keith Smith | D | Brown |
| Gordie Clark | F | New Hampshire |
| Steve Dolloff | F | Boston University |
| Bob McManama | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Grahame | G | Denver |
| Bob Boyd | D | Michigan State |
| Bill Nyrop | D | Notre Dame |
| Pat Boutette | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Eddie Bumbacco | F | Notre Dame |
| Rob Palmer | F | Denver |
1973–74 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cap Raeder | G | New Hampshire |
| George Kuzmicz | D | Cornell |
| Vic Stanfield | D | Boston University |
| Bill Burlington | F | Boston University |
| Gordie Clark | F | New Hampshire |
| Randy Roth | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Robbie Moore | G | Michigan |
| Norm Barnes | D | Michigan State |
| Jim Nahrgang | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Colp | F | Michigan State |
| Doug Palazzari | F | Colorado College |
| Mike Zuke | F | Michigan Tech |
1974–75 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Petrovek | G | Harvard |
| Vic Stanfield | D | Boston University |
| Ron Wilson | D | Providence |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Tim O'Connell | F | Vermont |
| Randy Roth | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie Mio | G | Colorado College |
| Les Auge | D | Minnesota |
| Brian Engblom | D | Wisconsin |
| Bob D'Alvise | F | Michigan Tech |
| Mike Polich | F | Minnesota |
| Tom Ross | F | Michigan State |
1975–76 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Shields | G | Clarkson |
| Peter Brown | D | Boston University |
| Ron Wilson | D | Providence |
| Cliff Cox | F | New Hampshire |
| Jamie Hislop | F | New Hampshire |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Bill Gilligan | F | Brown |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie Mio | G | Colorado College |
| Jack Brownschidle | D | Notre Dame |
| Craig Norwich | D | Wisconsin |
| Tom Ross | F | Michigan State |
| Mike Eaves | F | Wisconsin |
| Mike Zuke | F | Michigan Tech |
1976–77 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Shields | G | Clarkson |
| Bill Blackwood | D | Clarkson |
| Tim Burke | D | New Hampshire |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Bob Miller | F | New Hampshire |
| Dave Taylor | F | Clarkson |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Julian Baretta | G | Wisconsin |
| Jack Brownschidle | D | Notre Dame |
| Craig Norwich | D | Wisconsin |
| Dave Debol | F | Michigan |
| Mike Eaves | F | Wisconsin |
| Brian Walsh | F | Notre Dame |
1977–78 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Laycock | G | Brown |
| Bill Blackwood | D | Clarkson |
| Peter Shier | D | Cornell |
| Ralph Cox | F | New Hampshire |
| Joe Mullen | F | Boston College |
| Lance Nethery | F | Cornell |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ernie Glanville | G | Denver |
| Curt Giles | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Ken Morrow | D | Bowling Green |
| Doug Berry | F | Denver |
| Mike Eaves | F | Wisconsin |
| Mark Johnson | F | Wisconsin |
1978–79 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Craig | G | Boston University |
| Louis Cote | D | Vermont |
| Jack O'Callahan | D | Boston University |
| Ralph Cox | F | New Hampshire |
| Joe Mullen | F | Boston College |
| Lance Nethery | F | Cornell |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Iwabuchi | G | North Dakota |
| Bill Baker | D | Minnesota |
| Curt Giles | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Mark Johnson | F | Wisconsin |
| Kevin Maxwell | F | North Dakota |
| Mark Pavelich | F | Minnesota–Duluth |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mark Holden | G | Brown |
| Andre Aubut | D | Maine |
| Louis Cote | D | Vermont |
| Bill Army | F | Boston College |
| Ross Brownridge | F | Dartmouth |
| Craig Homola | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Roy Schultz | G | Wisconsin |
| Dave Feamster | D | Colorado College |
| Howard Walker | D | North Dakota |
| Theran Welsh | D | Wisconsin |
| Murray Eaves | F | Michigan |
| Tim Harrer | F | Minnesota |
| Greg Meredith | F | Notre Dame |
| Mark Taylor | F | North Dakota |
1980–81 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don Sylvestri | G | Clarkson |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Ed Small | D | Clarkson |
| Sandy Beadle | F | Northeastern |
| Bryan Cleaver | F | Clarkson |
| Gary Conn | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Fricker | G | Michigan |
| Marc Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Tim Watters | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Bozek | F | Northern Michigan |
| Neal Broten | F | Minnesota |
| Aaron Broten | F | Minnesota |
1981–82 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Hayward | G | Cornell |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Chris Renaud | D | Colgate |
| Andy Brickley | F | New Hampshire |
| Steve Cruickshank | F | Clarkson |
| Kirk McCaskill | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State |
| Bruce Driver | D | Wisconsin |
| Brian MacLellan | D | Bowling Green |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green |
| George McPhee | F | Bowling Green |
| John Newberry | F | Wisconsin |
1982–83 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darren Eliot | G | Cornell |
| Gray Weicker | G | St. Lawrence |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Randy Velischek | D | Providence |
| Bob Brooke | F | Yale |
| Kurt Kleinendorst | F | Providence |
| Colin Patterson | F | Clarkson |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State |
| Doug Lidster | D | Colorado College |
| James Patrick | D | North Dakota |
| Kirt Bjork | F | Notre Dame |
| Patrick Flatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green |
1983–84 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cleon Daskalakis | G | Boston University |
| Bob Armstrong | D | Clarkson |
| Dave Fretz | D | Clarkson |
| John Carter | F | Rensselaer |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer |
| Steve Smith | F | Colgate |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Casey | G | North Dakota |
| Garry Galley | D | Bowling Green |
| Tom Kurvers | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Dan Kane | F | Bowling Green |
| Paul Pooley | F | Ohio State |
| Bill Watson | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
1984–85 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Terreri | G | Providence |
| Dave Fretz | D | Clarkson |
| Ken Hammond | D | Rensselaer |
| Tim Army | F | Providence |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Kosti | G | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Norm Maciver | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Dan McFall | D | Michigan State |
| Pat Micheletti | F | Minnesota |
| Kelly Miller | F | Michigan State |
| Craig Simpson | F | Michigan State |
| Bill Watson | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
1985–86 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Doug Dadswell | G | Cornell |
| Cliff Abrecht | D | Princeton |
| Mike Dark | D | Rensselaer |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Scott Harlow | F | Boston College |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F | Cornell |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gary Kruzich | G | Bowling Green |
| Wayne Gagné | D | Western Michigan |
| Norm Maciver | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Dallas Gaume | F | Denver |
| Mike Donnelly | F | Michigan State |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan |
1986–87 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Racine | G | Northeastern |
| Mark Benning | D | Harvard |
| Brian Leetch | D | Boston College |
| Craig Janney | F | Boston College |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F | Cornell |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gary Kruzich | G | Bowling Green |
| Wayne Gagné | D | Western Michigan |
| Ian Kidd | D | North Dakota |
| Tony Hrkac | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Joyce | F | North Dakota |
| Mitch Messier | F | Michigan State |
1987–88 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Racine | G | Northeastern |
| Jack Capuano | D | Maine |
| Brian McColgan | D | St. Lawrence |
| Réjean Boivin | F | Colgate |
| Dave Capuano | F | Maine |
| Pete Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Robb Stauber | G | Minnesota |
| Scott Paluch | D | Bowling Green |
| Paul Stanton | D | Wisconsin |
| Steve Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Paul Ranheim | F | Wisconsin |
| Mark Vermette | F | Lake Superior State |
1988–89 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike O'Neill | G | Yale |
| Greg Brown | D | Boston College |
| Mike Hurlbut | D | St. Lawrence |
| Dave Capuano | F | Maine |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard |
| Kyle McDonough | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Hoffort | G | Lake Superior State |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Myles O'Connor | D | Michigan |
| Kip Miller | F | Michigan State |
| Greg Parks | F | Bowling Green |
| Bobby Reynolds | F | Michigan State |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dave Gagnon | G | Colgate |
| Greg Brown | D | Boston College |
| Rob Cowie | D | Northeastern |
| David Emma | F | Boston College |
| Steve Heinze | F | Boston College |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Erickson | G | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Rob Blake | D | Bowling Green |
| Russ Parent | D | North Dakota |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green |
| Kip Miller | F | Michigan State |
| Gary Shuchuk | F | Wisconsin |
1990–91 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Les Kuntar | G | St. Lawrence |
| Keith Carney | D | Maine |
| Dan Ratushny | D | Cornell |
| David Emma | F | Boston College |
| Shawn McEachern | F | Boston University |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Brad Werenka | D | Northern Michigan |
| Jason Woolley | D | Michigan State |
| Scott Beattie | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jim Dowd | F | Lake Superior State |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
1991–92 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Parris Duffus | G | Cornell |
| Mike Brewer | D | Brown |
| Daniel Laperrière | D | St. Lawrence |
| Scott Pellerin | F | Maine |
| David Sacco | F | Boston University |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State |
| Mark Astley | D | Lake Superior State |
| Joby Messier | D | Michigan State |
| Dallas Drake | F | Northern Michigan |
| Denny Felsner | F | Michigan |
| Dwayne Norris | F | Michigan State |
1992–93 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Dunham | G | Maine |
| Chris Imes | D | Maine |
| Jack Duffy | D | Yale |
| David Sacco | F | Boston University |
| Ted Drury | F | Harvard |
| Paul Kariya | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech |
| Barry Richter | D | Wisconsin |
| Brett Hauer | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Bryan Smolinski | F | Michigan State |
| Derek Plante | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
1993–94 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dwayne Roloson | G | UMass Lowell |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson |
| Sean McCann | D | Harvard |
| Mike Pomichter | F | Boston University |
| Craig Conroy | F | Clarkson |
| Steve Martins | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech |
| Shawn Reid | D | Colorado College |
| John Gruden | D | Ferris State |
| David Oliver | F | Michigan |
| Brian Wiseman | F | Michigan |
| Chris Marinucci | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
1994–95 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blair Allison | G | Maine |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson |
| Chris Imes | D | Maine |
| Mike Grier | F | Boston University |
| Greg Bullock | F | UMass Lowell |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chuck Thuss | G | Miami |
| Kelly Perrault | D | Bowling Green |
| Brian Rafalski | D | Wisconsin |
| Brian Holzinger | F | Bowling Green |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| Brian Bonin | F | Minnesota |
1995–96 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Thomas | G | Vermont |
| Jeff Tory | D | Maine |
| Dan McGillis | D | Northeastern |
| Jay Pandolfo | F | Boston University |
| Éric Perrin | F | Vermont |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bach | G | Colorado College |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Crowley | D | Minnesota |
| Peter Geronazzo | F | Colorado College |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| Brian Bonin | F | Minnesota |
1996–97 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Trevor Koenig | G | Union |
| Jon Coleman | D | Boston University |
| Matt Pagnutti | D | Clarkson |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University |
| Todd White | F | Clarkson |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marty Turco | G | Michigan |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami |
| Mike Crowley | D | Minnesota |
| Randy Robitaille | F | Miami |
| Brendan Morrison | F | Michigan |
| John Madden | F | Michigan |
1997–98 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Robitaille | G | Northeastern |
| Ray Giroux | D | Yale |
| Tom Poti | D | Boston University |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University |
| Mark Mowers | F | New Hampshire |
| Marty Reasoner | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Alban | G | Michigan State |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami |
| Curtis Murphy | D | North Dakota |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State |
| Bill Muckalt | F | Michigan |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State |
1998–99 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Heffler | G | St. Lawrence |
| David Cullen | D | Maine |
| Mike Mottau | D | Boston College |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College |
| Steve Kariya | F | Maine |
| Jason Krog | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Blackburn | G | Michigan State |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Brad Williamson | D | North Dakota |
| Jason Blake | F | North Dakota |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joel Laing | G | Rensselaer |
| Justin Harney | D | St. Lawrence |
| Mike Mottau | D | Boston College |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College |
| Andy McDonald | F | Colgate |
| Jeff Farkas | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Jeff Dessner | D | Wisconsin |
| Jeff Jillson | D | Michigan |
| Shawn Horcoff | F | Michigan State |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |
| Steven Reinprecht | F | Wisconsin |
2000–01 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ty Conklin | G | New Hampshire |
| Bobby Allen | D | Boston College |
| Kent Huskins | D | Clarkson |
| Erik Anderson | F | St. Lawrence |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Travis Roche | D | North Dakota |
| Dany Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Andy Hilbert | F | Michigan |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |
2001–02 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Underhill | G | Cornell |
| Jim Fahey | D | Northeastern |
| Douglas Murray | D | Cornell |
| Marc Cavosie | F | Rensselaer |
| Darren Haydar | F | New Hampshire |
| Colin Hemingway | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State |
| Mike Komisarek | D | Michigan |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Mike Cammalleri | F | Michigan |
| Mark Hartigan | F | St. Cloud State |
| John Pohl | F | Minnesota |
2002–03 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David LeNeveu | G | Cornell |
| Freddy Meyer | D | Boston University |
| Douglas Murray | D | Cornell |
| Ben Eaves | F | Boston College |
| Chris Higgins | F | Yale |
| Dominic Moore | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Brown | G | Ferris State |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State |
| Tom Preissing | D | Colorado College |
| Noah Clarke | F | Colorado College |
| Chris Kunitz | F | Ferris State |
| Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College |
2003–04 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown |
| Andrew Alberts | D | Boston College |
| Thomas Pöck | D | Massachusetts |
| Steve Saviano | F | New Hampshire |
| Lee Stempniak | F | Dartmouth |
| Tony Voce | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernd Brückler | G | Wisconsin |
| Keith Ballard | D | Minnesota |
| Ryan Caldwell | D | Denver |
| Brandon Bochenski | F | North Dakota |
| Junior Lessard | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Zach Parise | F | North Dakota |
2004–05 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David McKee | G | Cornell |
| Andrew Alberts | D | Boston College |
| Noah Welch | D | Harvard |
| Sean Collins | F | New Hampshire |
| Patrick Eaves | F | Boston College |
| Jason Guerriero | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis McElhinney | G | Colorado College |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Mark Stuart | D | Colorado College |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Marty Sertich | F | Colorado College |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College |
2005–06 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cory Schneider | G | Boston College |
| Peter Harrold | D | Boston College |
| Dan Spang | D | Boston University |
| Chris Collins | F | Boston College |
| Greg Moore | F | Maine |
| T. J. Trevelyan | F | St. Lawrence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Elliott | G | Wisconsin |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| Scott Parse | F | Omaha |
| Ryan Potulny | F | Minnesota |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College |
2006–07 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Curry | G | Boston University |
| Drew Bagnall | D | St. Lawrence |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Brian Boyle | F | Boston College |
| David Jones | F | Dartmouth |
| Michel Léveillé | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David Brown | G | Notre Dame |
| Alex Goligoski | D | Minnesota |
| Jack Johnson | D | Michigan |
| Ryan Duncan | F | North Dakota |
| T. J. Hensick | F | Michigan |
| Jonathan Toews | F | North Dakota |
2007–08 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kevin Regan | G | New Hampshire |
| Matt Gilroy | D | Boston University |
| Mike Moore | D | Princeton |
| Nathan Gerbe | F | Boston College |
| Lee Jubinville | F | Princeton |
| Mike Radja | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richard Bachman | G | Colorado College |
| Tyler Eckford | D | Alaska |
| Jack Hillen | D | Colorado College |
| Ryan Jones | F | Miami |
| T. J. Oshie | F | North Dakota |
| Kevin Porter | F | Michigan |
2008–09 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Thiessen | G | Northeastern |
| Matt Gilroy | D | Boston University |
| Zach Miskovic | D | St. Lawrence |
| David McIntyre | F | Colgate |
| Viktor Stålberg | F | Vermont |
| Colin Wilson | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Stalock | G | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Ian Cole | D | Notre Dame |
| Jamie McBain | D | Wisconsin |
| Louie Caporusso | F | Michigan |
| Aaron Palushaj | F | Michigan |
| Ryan Stoa | F | Minnesota |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ben Scrivens | G | Cornell |
| Colby Cohen | D | Boston University |
| Brendon Nash | D | Cornell |
| Bobby Butler | F | New Hampshire |
| Gustav Nyquist | F | Maine |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Cheverie | G | Denver |
| Brendan Smith | D | Wisconsin |
| Patrick Wiercioch | D | Denver |
| Blake Geoffrion | F | Wisconsin |
| Mark Olver | F | Northern Michigan |
| Rhett Rakhshani | F | Denver |
2010–11 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keith Kinkaid | G | Union |
| Brian Dumoulin | D | Boston College |
| Blake Kessel | D | New Hampshire |
| Cam Atkinson | F | Boston College |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer |
| Paul Thompson | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Pat Nagle | G | Ferris State |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Justin Schultz | D | Wisconsin |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Matt Frattin | F | North Dakota |
| Andy Miele | F | Miami |
2011–12 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Troy Grosenick | G | Union |
| Danny Biega | D | Harvard |
| Brian Dumoulin | D | Boston College |
| Spencer Abbott | F | Maine |
| Alex Killorn | F | Harvard |
| Austin Smith | F | Colgate |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Taylor Nelson | G | Ferris State |
| Torey Krug | D | Michigan State |
| Justin Schultz | D | Wisconsin |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Jaden Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
| Reilly Smith | F | Miami |
2012–13 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Hartzell | G | Quinnipiac |
| Nick Bailen | D | Rensselaer |
| Chad Ruhwedel | D | UMass Lowell |
| Trevor van Riemsdyk | D | New Hampshire |
| Kyle Flanagan | F | St. Lawrence |
| Johnny Gaudreau | F | Boston College |
| Steven Whitney | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brady Hjelle | G | Ohio State |
| Nick Jensen | D | St. Cloud State |
| Jacob Trouba | D | Michigan |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami |
| Danny Kristo | F | North Dakota |
| Drew LeBlanc | F | St. Cloud State |
2013–14 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Connor Hellebuyck | G | UMass Lowell |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
| Johnny Gaudreau | F | Boston College |
| Kevin Hayes | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Sam Brittain | G | Denver |
| Jake McCabe | D | Wisconsin |
| Mike Reilly | D | Minnesota |
| Josh Archibald | F | Omaha |
| Nic Dowd | F | St. Cloud State |
| Ryan Dzingel | F | Ohio State |
2014–15 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Lyon | G | Yale |
| Matt Grzelcyk | D | Boston University |
| Rob O'Gara | D | Yale |
| Daniel Ciampini | F | Union |
| Jack Eichel | F | Boston University |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jake Hildebrand | G | Michigan State |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | Denver |
| Mike Reilly | D | Minnesota |
| Zach Hyman | F | Michigan |
| Tanner Kero | F | Michigan Tech |
| Matt Leitner | F | Minnesota State |
2015–16 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Lyon | G | Yale |
| Matt Grzelcyk | D | Boston University |
| Jake Walman | D | Providence |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
| Andrew Poturalski | F | New Hampshire |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charlie Lindgren | G | St. Cloud State |
| Ethan Prow | D | St. Cloud State |
| Zach Werenski | D | Michigan |
| Brock Boeser | F | North Dakota |
| Kyle Connor | F | Michigan |
| Tyler Motte | F | Michigan |
2016–17 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charles Williams | G | Canisius |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Charlie McAvoy | D | Boston University |
| Zach Aston-Reese | F | Northeastern |
| Spencer Foo | F | Union |
| Mike Vecchione | F | Union |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Bitzer | G | Bemidji State |
| Will Butcher | D | Denver |
| Tucker Poolman | D | North Dakota |
| Henrik Borgström | F | Denver |
| Alex Iafallo | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Tyler Sheehy | F | Minnesota |
2017–18 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell |
| Jérémy Davies | D | Northeastern |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Ryan Donato | F | Harvard |
| Adam Gaudette | F | Northeastern |
| Dylan Sikura | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cale Morris | G | Notre Dame |
| Scott Perunovich | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Jimmy Schuldt | D | St. Cloud State |
| Henrik Borgström | F | Denver |
| C. J. Suess | F | Minnesota State |
| Troy Terry | F | Denver |
2018–19 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cayden Primeau | G | Northeastern |
| Cale Makar | D | Massachusetts |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Mitchell Chaffee | F | Massachusetts |
| Ryan Kuffner | F | Princeton |
| Nico Sturm | F | Clarkson |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Hunter Shepard | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Quinn Hughes | D | Michigan |
| Jimmy Schuldt | D | St. Cloud State |
| Taro Hirose | F | Michigan State |
| Patrick Newell | F | St. Cloud State |
| Rem Pitlick | F | Minnesota |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeremy Swayman | G | Maine |
| David Farrance | D | Boston University |
| Jack Rathbone | D | Harvard |
| Morgan Barron | F | Cornell |
| Jack Dugan | F | Providence |
| John Leonard | F | Massachusetts |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Ian Mitchell | D | Denver |
| Scott Perunovich | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Jordan Kawaguchi | F | North Dakota |
| Hugh McGing | F | Western Michigan |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
2020–21 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Spencer Knight | G | Boston College |
| David Farrance | D | Boston University |
| Brennan Kapcheck | D | American International |
| Matthew Boldy | F | Boston College |
| Bobby Trivigno | F | Massachusetts |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack LaFontaine | G | Minnesota |
| Ronnie Attard | D | Western Michigan |
| Cam York | D | Michigan |
| Cole Caufield | F | Wisconsin |
| Shane Pinto | F | North Dakota |
| Sampo Ranta | F | Minnesota |
2021–22 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Devon Levi | G | Northeastern |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Scott Morrow | D | Massachusetts |
| Nick Abruzzese | F | Harvard |
| Aidan McDonough | F | Northeastern |
| Bobby Trivigno | F | Massachusetts |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Ronnie Attard | D | Western Michigan |
| Jake Sanderson | D | North Dakota |
| Matty Beniers | F | Michigan |
| Bobby Brink | F | Denver |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State |
2022–23 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Devon Levi | G | Northeastern |
| Lane Hutson | D | Boston University |
| Henry Thrun | D | Harvard |
| Sean Farrell | F | Harvard |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac |
| Aidan McDonough | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Blake Pietila | G | Michigan Tech |
| Brock Faber | D | Minnesota |
| Luke Hughes | D | Michigan |
| Logan Cooley | F | Minnesota |
| Adam Fantilli | F | Michigan |
| Matthew Knies | F | Minnesota |
2023–24 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jacob Fowler | G | Boston College |
| Lane Hutson | D | Boston University |
| Ryan Ufko | D | Massachusetts |
| Macklin Celebrini | F | Boston University |
| Cutter Gauthier | F | Boston College |
| Will Smith | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kaidan Mbereko | G | Colorado College |
| Zeev Buium | D | Denver |
| Seamus Casey | D | Michigan |
| Jackson Blake | F | North Dakota |
| Gavin Brindley | F | Michigan |
| Jack Devine | F | Denver |

### Second Team
#### 1940s

1947–48 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernie Burke | G | Boston College |
| Connie Hill | D | Michigan |
| George Pulliam | D | Dartmouth |
| Jim Bell | F | Northeastern |
| Roland DePaul | F | Minnesota |
| Wally Gacek | F | Michigan |

#### 1950s

1949–50 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack McDonald | G | Michigan |
| Joe McCusker | D | Boston College |
| Daniel McKinnon | D | North Dakota |
| Len Ceglarski | F | Boston College |
| Buzz Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Chris Ray | F | Colorado College |
1951–52 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Kinsley | G | Colorado College |
| Joe deBastiani | D | Michigan Tech |
| Jim Haas | D | Michigan |
| Omer Brandt | F | Colorado College |
| Frank Chiarelli | F | Rensselaer |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
1953–54 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Sloan | G | St. Lawrence |
| Doug Binning | D | Middlebury |
| Jim Haas | D | Michigan |
| Frank Chiarelli | F | Rensselaer |
| Wally Kilrea Jr. | F | Yale |
| Abbie Moore | F | Rensselaer |
1954–55 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lorne Howes | G | Michigan |
| Phil Hilton | D | Colorado College |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Jack McManus | F | Michigan Tech |
1955–56 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Sloan | G | St. Lawrence |
| Chuck Lundberg | D | St. Lawrence |
| Art Smith | D | Clarkson |
| Jack McManus | F | Michigan Tech |
| Ken Yackel | F | Minnesota |
| Ed Zifcak | F | St. Lawrence |
1956–57 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie MacDonald | G | Clarkson |
| John Petroske | D | Minnesota |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Cleary | F | Harvard |
| Joe McLean | F | St. Lawrence |
| Bob McCusker | F | Colorado College |

#### 1980s

1983–84 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Daren Puppa | G | Rensselaer |
| Peter Taglianetti | D | Providence |
| T. J. Connolly | D | Boston University |
| Kevin Foster | F | Vermont |
| Ken Manchurek | F | Northeastern |
| Gaetano Orlando | F | Providence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Kosti | G | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Dan McFall | D | Michigan State |
| Bill Schafhauser | D | Northern Michigan |
| Perry Pooley | F | Ohio State |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan |
| Bob Lakso | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
1984–85 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Cooper | G | Colgate |
| Jim Averill | D | Northeastern |
| Peter Taglianetti | D | Providence |
| Doug Brown | F | Boston College |
| John Carter | F | Rensselaer |
| Bob Sweeney | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Glenn Healy | G | Western Michigan |
| Gary Haight | D | Michigan State |
| Tim Thomas | D | Wisconsin |
| Tony Granato | F | Wisconsin |
| Steve Moria | F | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Ray Staszak | F | Illinois-Chicago |
1985–86 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Grant Blair | G | Harvard |
| Chris Terreri | G | Providence |
| Mark Benning | D | Harvard |
| Jay Octeau | D | Boston University |
| Andy Otto | D | Clarkson |
| Doug Brown | F | Boston College |
| John Cullen | F | Boston University |
| Clark Donatelli | F | Boston University |
| Randy Wood | F | Yale |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Horn | G | Western Michigan |
| Chris Olson | G | Denver |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Scott Sandelin | D | North Dakota |
| Jim Smith | D | Denver |
| Matt Christensen | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Dwight Mathiasen | F | Denver |
| Corey Millen | F | Minnesota |
| Jamie Wansbrough | F | Bowling Green |
1986–87 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Yearwood | G | St. Lawrence |
| Hank Lammens | D | Harvard |
| Eric Weinrich | D | Maine |
| Pete Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
| Jon Morris | F | UMass Lowell |
| Kevin Stevens | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ed Belfour | G | North Dakota |
| Rob Doyle | D | Colorado College |
| Donald McSween | D | Michigan State |
| Gary Emmons | F | Northern Michigan |
| Tony Granato | F | Wisconsin |
| Brad Jones | F | Michigan |
1987–88 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Fletcher | G | Clarkson |
| Brian Dowd | D | Northeastern |
| Don Sweeney | D | Harvard |
| Luciano Borsato | F | Clarkson |
| Gord Cruickshank | F | Providence |
| Mike Golden | F | Maine |
| Mike McHugh | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dean Anderson | G | Wisconsin |
| Mike DeAngelis | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Randy Skarda | D | Minnesota |
| Phil Berger | F | Northern Michigan |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green |
| Steve Tuttle | F | Wisconsin |
1988–89 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David Littman | G | Boston College |
| Bob Beers | D | Maine |
| Dave Williams | D | Dartmouth |
| Rick Bennett | F | Providence |
| Tim Sweeney | F | Boston College |
| C. J. Young | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis Joseph | G | Wisconsin |
| Darryl Olsen | D | Northern Michigan |
| Todd Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Sheldon Gorski | F | Illinois-Chicago |
| Daryn McBride | F | Denver |
| Dave Snuggerud | F | Minnesota |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Harvey | G | Brown |
| Keith Carney | D | Maine |
| Dan Ratushny | D | Cornell |
| Joel Gardner | F | Colgate |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | Maine |
| C. J. Young | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Muzzatti | G | Michigan State |
| Kord Cernich | D | Lake Superior State |
| Kip Noble | D | Michigan Tech |
| Lee Davidson | F | North Dakota |
| Jim Dowd | F | Lake Superior State |
| Dave Shields | F | Denver |
1990–91 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Levy | G | New Hampshire |
| Peter Ahola | D | Boston University |
| Ted Crowley | D | Boston College |
| Peter Ciavaglia | F | Harvard |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer |
| Jim Montgomery | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Pye | G | Northern Michigan |
| Sean Hill | D | Wisconsin |
| Karl Johnston | D | Lake Superior State |
| Denny Felsner | F | Michigan |
| David Roberts | F | Michigan |
| Doug Weight | F | Lake Superior State |
1991–92 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott LaGrand | G | Boston College |
| Christian Soucy | G | Vermont |
| Tom Dion | D | Boston University |
| Rob Gaudreau | D | Providence |
| Domenic Amodeo | F | New Hampshire |
| Dale Band | F | Colgate |
| Mike Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Duane Derksen | G | Wisconsin |
| Chris Hynnes | D | Colorado College |
| Doug Zmolek | D | Michigan State |
| Jim Hiller | F | Northern Michigan |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Larry Olimb | F | Minnesota |
1992–93 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Neil Little | G | Rensselaer |
| Aaron Miller | D | Vermont |
| Kaj Linna | D | Boston University |
| Cal Ingraham | F | Maine |
| Jim Montgomery | F | Maine |
| Mark Kaufmann | F | Yale |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Shields | G | Michigan |
| Bob Marshall | D | Miami |
| Michael Smith | D | Lake Superior State |
| Fred Knipscheer | F | St. Cloud State |
| Brian Savage | F | Miami |
| Brian Rolston | F | Lake Superior State |
1993–94 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| J. P. McKersie | G | Boston University |
| Rich Brennan | D | Boston University |
| Derek Maguire | D | Harvard |
| Jacques Joubert | F | Boston University |
| Shane Henry | F | UMass Lowell |
| Chad Quenneville | F | Providence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Shields | G | Michigan |
| Jeff Wells | D | Bowling Green |
| Chris McAlpine | D | Minnesota |
| Dean Fedorchuk | F | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Clayton Beddoes | F | Lake Superior State |
| Steve Guolla | F | Michigan State |
1994–95 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Thomas | G | Vermont |
| Kaj Linna | D | Boston University |
| Jeff Tory | D | Maine |
| Chris O'Sullivan | F | Boston University |
| Marko Tuomainen | F | Clarkson |
| Chad Quenneville | F | Providence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bach | G | Colorado College |
| Kent Fearns | D | Colorado College |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College |
| Mike Knuble | F | Michigan |
| Anson Carter | F | Michigan State |
1995–96 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Murphy | G | Clarkson |
| Jon Coleman | D | Boston University |
| Brad Dexter | D | Colgate |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University |
| Todd White | F | Clarkson |
| Burke Murphy | F | St. Lawrence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Magliarditi | G | Western Michigan |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Dan Trebil | D | Minnesota |
| Sean Tallaire | F | Lake Superior State |
| Kevin Hilton | F | Michigan |
| Teeder Wynne | F | North Dakota |
1996–97 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Murphy | G | Clarkson |
| Chris Kelleher | D | Boston University |
| Tim Murray | D | New Hampshire |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer |
| Jason Krog | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kirk Daubenspeck | G | Wisconsin |
| Andy Roach | D | Ferris State |
| Curtis Murphy | D | North Dakota |
| Jason Botterill | F | Michigan |
| David Hoogsteen | F | North Dakota |
| Mark Parrish | F | St. Cloud State |
1997–98 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Westlund | G | Yale |
| Chris Kelleher | D | Boston University |
| Mike Mottau | D | Boston College |
| Steve Shirreffs | D | Princeton |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Calvin Elfring | D | Colorado College |
| Tyler Harlton | D | Michigan State |
| Sean Berens | F | Michigan State |
| Jason Blake | F | North Dakota |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
1998–99 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michel Larocque | G | Boston University |
| Jayme Filipowicz | D | New Hampshire |
| Willie Mitchell | D | Clarkson |
| Erik Cole | F | Clarkson |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
| Rejean Stringer | F | Merrimack |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Maund | G | Ohio State |
| Benoit Cotnoir | D | Notre Dame |
| Mike Weaver | D | Michigan State |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State |
| Paul Comrie | F | Denver |
| Jay Panzer | F | North Dakota |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ty Conklin | G | New Hampshire |
| Chris Dyment | D | Boston University |
| Brian Pothier | D | Rensselaer |
| Brandon Dietrich | F | St. Lawrence |
| Cory Larose | F | Maine |
| Brad Tapper | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jayme Platt | G | Lake Superior State |
| Mike Pudlick | D | St. Cloud State |
| Mike Weaver | D | Michigan State |
| Mike Comrie | F | Michigan |
| Lee Goren | F | North Dakota |
| Dany Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
2000–01 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nolan Schaefer | G | Providence |
| Matt Desrosiers | D | St. Lawrence |
| Ron Hainsey | D | UMass Lowell |
| Carl Corazzini | F | Boston University |
| Krys Kolanos | F | Boston College |
| Devin Rask | F | Providence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Meyer | G | St. Cloud State |
| Jeff Jillson | D | Michigan |
| Greg Zanon | D | Omaha |
| Mike Bishai | F | Western Michigan |
| Mike Cammalleri | F | Michigan |
| Mark Cullen | F | Colorado College |
| Bryan Lundbohm | F | North Dakota |
2001–02 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown |
| Chris Dyment | D | Boston University |
| Peter Metcalf | D | Maine |
| Niko Dimitrakos | F | Maine |
| Ben Eaves | F | Boston College |
| Matt Murley | F | Rensselaer |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wade Dubielewicz | G | Denver |
| Andrew Hutchinson | D | Michigan State |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State |
| Greg Zanon | D | Omaha |
| Rob Collins | F | Ferris State |
| Mark Cullen | F | Colorado College |
| Jeff Hoggan | F | Omaha |
2002–03 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Ayers | G | New Hampshire |
| J. D. Forrest | D | Boston College |
| Noah Welch | D | Harvard |
| Stephen Baby | F | Cornell |
| Lanny Gare | F | New Hampshire |
| Colin Hemingway | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis McElhinney | G | Colorado College |
| Brad Fast | D | Michigan State |
| Paul Martin | D | Minnesota |
| Shane Joseph | F | Minnesota State |
| Grant Stevenson | F | Minnesota State |
| R. J. Umberger | F | Ohio State |
2003–04 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jimmy Howard | G | Maine |
| Prestin Ryan | D | Maine |
| Stephen Wood | D | Providence |
| Patrick Eaves | F | Boston College |
| Todd Jackson | F | Maine |
| Ryan Shannon | F | Boston College |
| Colin Shields | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Al Montoya | G | Michigan |
| Beau Geisler | D | Minnesota–Duluth |
| A. J. Thelen | D | Michigan State |
| Derek Edwardson | F | Miami |
| Jim Slater | F | Michigan State |
| Thomas Vanek | F | Minnesota |
2004–05 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dov Grumet-Morris | G | Harvard |
| Charlie Cook | D | Cornell |
| Brian Yandle | D | New Hampshire |
| Matt Moulson | F | Cornell |
| Ryan Shannon | F | Boston College |
| Lee Stempniak | F | Dartmouth |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tuomas Tarkki | G | Northern Michigan |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami |
| Brett Skinner | D | Denver |
| Gabe Gauthier | F | Colorado College |
| Colin Murphy | F | Michigan Tech |
| Jeff Tambellini | F | Michigan |
2005–06 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Curry | G | Boston University |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Brian Yandle | D | New Hampshire |
| Brian Boyle | F | Boston College |
| Michel Léveillé | F | Maine |
| Mike Ouellette | F | Dartmouth |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bobby Goepfert | G | St. Cloud State |
| Tom Gilbert | D | Wisconsin |
| Nathan Oystrick | D | Northern Michigan |
| David Backes | F | Minnesota State |
| Joe Pavelski | F | Wisconsin |
| Paul Stastny | F | Denver |
2006–07 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jonathan Quick | G | Massachusetts |
| Matt Gilroy | D | Boston University |
| Sean Sullivan | D | Boston University |
| Nick Dodge | F | Clarkson |
| Eric Ehn | F | Air Force |
| Trevor Smith | F | New Hampshire |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bobby Goepfert | G | St. Cloud State |
| Taylor Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Matt Hunwick | D | Michigan |
| Nathan Davis | F | Miami |
| Scott Parse | F | Omaha |
| Mike Santorelli | F | Northern Michigan |
2007–08 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Kassel | G | Army |
| Grant Clitsome | D | Clarkson |
| Brad Flaishans | D | New Hampshire |
| Bryan Ewing | F | Boston University |
| Matt Fornataro | F | New Hampshire |
| Pete MacArthur | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State |
| Chris Butler | D | Denver |
| Alec Martinez | D | Miami |
| Chad Kolarik | F | Michigan |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State |
| Chad Rau | F | Colorado College |
2008–09 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zane Kalemba | G | Princeton |
| Maury Edwards | D | UMass Lowell |
| Kevin Shattenkirk | D | Boston University |
| Mark Arcobello | F | Yale |
| Jacques Lamoureux | F | Air Force |
| James Marcou | F | Massachusetts |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Johnson | G | Alaska |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Erik Gustafsson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami |
| Erik Condra | F | Notre Dame |
| Chad Rau | F | Colorado College |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Foster | G | New Hampshire |
| Justin Braun | D | Massachusetts |
| Blake Kessel | D | New Hampshire |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
| Nick Johnson | F | Sacred Heart |
| Broc Little | F | Yale |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cody Reichard | G | Miami |
| Erik Gustafsson | D | Northern Michigan |
| Jeff Petry | D | Michigan State |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Zac Dalpe | F | Ohio State |
| Matt Read | F | Bemidji State |
2010–11 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Muse | G | Boston College |
| Nick Bailen | D | Rensselaer |
| Taylor Fedun | D | Princeton |
| Stéphane Da Costa | F | Merrimack |
| Gustav Nyquist | F | Maine |
| Paul Zanette | F | Niagara |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aaron Dell | G | North Dakota |
| Jake Gardiner | D | Wisconsin |
| Zach Redmond | D | Ferris State |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami |
| Mike Connolly | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Carl Hagelin | F | Michigan |
2011–12 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Cannata | G | Merrimack |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Tim Kirby | D | Air Force |
| Barry Almeida | F | Boston College |
| Brian O'Neill | F | Yale |
| Jeremy Welsh | F | Union |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kent Patterson | G | Minnesota |
| Chad Billins | D | Ferris State |
| Danny DeKeyser | D | Western Michigan |
| Nick Bjugstad | F | Minnesota |
| J. T. Brown | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Jason Zucker | F | Denver |
2012–13 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Gillies | G | Providence |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| George Hughes | D | St. Lawrence |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
| Mike Collins | F | Merrimack |
| Andrew Miller | F | Yale |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Juho Olkinuora | G | Denver |
| Danny DeKeyser | D | Western Michigan |
| Nate Schmidt | D | Minnesota |
| Corban Knight | F | North Dakota |
| Anders Lee | F | Notre Dame |
| Ryan Walters | F | Omaha |
2013–14 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Colin Stevens | G | Union |
| Ben Hutton | D | Maine |
| Mike Matheson | D | Boston College |
| Daniel Carr | F | Union |
| Ryan Haggerty | F | Rensselaer |
| Devin Shore | F | Maine |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Wilcox | G | Minnesota |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | Denver |
| Colton Parayko | D | Alaska |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami |
| Cody Kunyk | F | Alaska |
| Michael Mersch | F | Wisconsin |
| Kyle Rau | F | Minnesota |
2014–15 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Gillies | G | Providence |
| Mike Paliotta | D | Vermont |
| Robbie Russo | D | Notre Dame |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
| Matt Garbowsky | F | RIT |
| Kevin Roy | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zane McIntyre | G | North Dakota |
| Zach Palmquist | D | Minnesota State |
| Colton Parayko | D | Alaska |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami |
| Dylan Larkin | F | Michigan |
| Michael Mersch | F | Wisconsin |
| Trevor Moore | F | Denver |
2015–16 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Thatcher Demko | G | Boston College |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Rob O'Gara | D | Yale |
| Ryan Fitzgerald | F | Boston College |
| Mark Jankowski | F | Providence |
| Danny O'Regan | F | Boston University |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cam Johnson | G | North Dakota |
| Will Butcher | D | Denver |
| Troy Stecher | D | North Dakota |
| Drake Caggiula | F | North Dakota |
| J. T. Compher | F | Michigan |
| Alex Petan | F | Michigan Tech |
2016–17 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Hayton | G | St. Lawrence |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Jake Walman | D | Providence |
| Dylan Zink | D | UMass Lowell |
| Anders Bjork | F | Notre Dame |
| Tyler Kelleher | F | New Hampshire |
| Alexander Kerfoot | F | Harvard |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tanner Jaillet | G | Denver |
| Daniel Brickley | D | Minnesota State |
| Luc Snuggerud | D | Omaha |
| Mason Jobst | F | Ohio State |
| Luke Kunin | F | Wisconsin |
| Austin Ortega | F | Omaha |
2017–18 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Colton Point | G | Colgate |
| Jacob Bryson | D | Providence |
| Kelly Summers | D | Clarkson |
| Ryan Kuffner | F | Princeton |
| Sheldon Rempal | F | Clarkson |
| Max Véronneau | F | Princeton |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tanner Jaillet | G | Denver |
| Philip Beaulieu | D | Northern Michigan |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| Nick Halloran | F | Colorado College |
| Tanner Laczynski | F | Ohio State |
| Cooper Marody | F | Michigan |
2018–19 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andrew Shortridge | G | Quinnipiac |
| Jérémy Davies | D | Northeastern |
| Joseph Duszak | D | Mercyhurst |
| Blake Christensen | F | American International |
| David Cotton | F | Boston College |
| Josh Wilkins | F | Providence |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joey Daccord | G | Arizona State |
| Jack Ahcan | D | St. Cloud State |
| Bobby Nardella | D | Notre Dame |
| Scott Perunovich | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mason Jobst | F | Ohio State |
| Blake Lizotte | F | St. Cloud State |
| Troy Loggins | F | Northern Michigan |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Marotte | G | Clarkson |
| Yanni Kaldis | D | Cornell |
| Mike Lee | D | Sacred Heart |
| Nick Abruzzese | F | Harvard |
| Jason Cotton | F | Sacred Heart |
| Tyler Madden | F | Northeastern |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Hunter Shepard | G | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Cole Hults | D | Penn State |
| Connor Mackey | D | Minnesota State |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| Noah Cates | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Cole Koepke | F | Minnesota–Duluth |
| Nate Sucese | F | Penn State |
2020–21 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Trevin Kozlowski | G | Army |
| Drew Helleson | D | Boston College |
| Zac Jones | D | Massachusetts |
| Colin Bilek | F | Army |
| Will Calverley | F | RIT |
| Jonny Evans | F | Connecticut |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Matt Kiersted | D | North Dakota |
| Jackson LaCombe | D | Minnesota |
| Dylan Holloway | F | Wisconsin |
| Jordan Kawaguchi | F | North Dakota |
| Linus Weissbach | F | Wisconsin |
2021–22 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac |
| Jordan Harris | D | Northeastern |
| Henry Thrun | D | Harvard |
| Colin Bilek | F | Army |
| Jack McBain | F | Boston College |
| Ryan Tverberg | F | Connecticut |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Fanti | G | Minnesota Duluth |
| Luke Hughes | D | Michigan |
| Owen Power | D | Michigan |
| Ethen Frank | F | Western Michigan |
| Brian Halonen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Ben Meyers | F | Minnesota |
2022–23 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac |
| Sam Malinski | D | Cornell |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Matt Brown | F | Boston University |
| Matthew Coronato | F | Harvard |
| Alex Jefferies | F | Merrimack |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bischel | G | Notre Dame |
| Michael Benning | D | Denver |
| Jake Livingstone | D | Minnesota State |
| Carter Mazur | F | Denver |
| Jason Polin | F | Western Michigan |
| Massimo Rizzo | F | Denver |
2023–24 :
| East |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ian Shane | G | Cornell |
| Gianfranco Cassaro | D | RIT |
| John Prokop | D | Union |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac |
| Ryan Leonard | F | Boston College |
| Liam McLinskey | F | Holy Cross |
| Gabe Perreault | F | Boston College |
| West |||
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle McClellan | G | Wisconsin |
| Dylan Anhorn | D | St. Cloud State |
| Artyom Levshunov | D | Michigan State |
| Noah Laba | F | Colorado College |
| Rutger McGroarty | F | Michigan |
| Massimo Rizzo | F | Denver |