# List of All-ECAC Hockey Teams

The All-ECAC Hockey Teams are composed of players at all positions from teams that are members of ECAC Hockey, an NCAA Division I hockey-only conference. Each year, from 1961–62 onward, at the conclusion of the ECAC Hockey regular season the head coaches of each member team vote for players to be placed on each all-conference team. The First Team and Second Team have been named in each ECAC Hockey season with a Third team added in 2005–06; a Rookie Team was added starting in 1987–88.
The all-conference teams are composed of one goaltender, two defensemen and three forwards. If a tie occurred for the final selection at any position, both players were included as part of the greater all-conference team; if a tie resulted in an increase in the number of superior all-stars, the inferior team would not be reduced in number (as happened in 1965–66 and 1983–84) until 2005–06, after which the inferior team will be reduced accordingly (as happened in 2006–07). Players may only appear once per year on any of the first, second, or third teams but freshman may appear on both the rookie team and one of the other all-conference teams. Jack Leetch is so far the only player to appear on the All-Star teams in two different positions (forward and defense).
In the first three years ECAC Hockey's all-conference teams were double in size for goaltenders and defensemen and triple for forwards, reflecting the 28-29 teams in the conference. After the 1963–64 season the ECAC split their conference into Division I and NCAA Division III classifications and subsequently reduced the team size to a standard (and current) format.
Due to two thirds of league members cancelling their seasons due to the COVID-19 pandemic, ECAC Hockey did not name a second- or third-team all-conference in 2020–21.

## All-conference teams

Source:

### First Team
#### 1960s

1961–62 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Glen Eberly | G | Boston University |
| Frank Stephenson | G | Colby |
| Arlie Parker | D | St. Lawrence |
| David Johnston | D | Harvard |
| Don Young | D | Colby |
| Jack Leetch | D | Boston College |
| Cal Wagner | D | Clarkson |
| Ron Ryan | F | Colby |
| Bill Hogan | F | Boston College |
| Dates Fryberger | F | Middlebury |
| Gene Kinasewich | F | Harvard |
| Ron Mason | F | St. Lawrence |
| Bob Brinkworth | F | Rensselaer |
| Tim Taylor | F | Harvard |
| Dave Grannis | F | Harvard |
| Hal Pettersen | F | Clarkson |
| Corby Adams | F | Clarkson |
1962–63 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richie Broadbelt | G | St. Lawrence |
| Tom Apprille | G | Boston College |
| David Johnston | D | Harvard |
| Cal Wagner | D | Clarkson |
| Pat Brophy | D | Clarkson |
| Jack Callahan | D | Boston College |
| Larry Kish | D | Providence |
| Jack Leetch | F | Boston College |
| Bob Brinkworth | F | Rensselaer |
| Bill Hogan | F | Boston College |
| Dates Fryberger | F | Middlebury |
| Leo Dupere | F | Northeastern |
| Corby Adams | F | Clarkson |
| Ron Mason | F | St. Lawrence |
| Tom Roe | F | Williams |
| Gene Kinasewich | F | Harvard |
| Tim Taylor | F | Harvard |
1963–64 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Perani | G | St. Lawrence |
| Bill Sack | G | Rensselaer |
| Larry Kish | D | Providence |
| Jim Salfi | D | St. Lawrence |
| Richie Green | D | Boston University |
| Fred Kitchen | D | Rensselaer |
| John Mechem | D | Colby |
| Bob Brinkworth | F | Rensselaer |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
| Corby Adams | F | Clarkson |
| Gene Kinasewich | F | Harvard |
| Grant Heffernan | F | Providence |
| Ray Mooney | F | Providence |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Ike Ikauniks | F | Harvard |
| Mike Thompson | F | Army |
| Leo Dupere | F | Northeastern |
| Leon Bryant | F | Brown |
1964–65 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack Ferreira | G | Boston University |
| Tom Ross | D | Boston University |
| Robert Gaudreau | D | Brown |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Grant Heffernan | F | Providence |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
1965–66 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack Ferreira | G | Boston University |
| Robert Gaudreau | D | Brown |
| Peter McLachlan | D | Boston University |
| Harry Orr | D | Cornell |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| Bruce Fennie | F | Boston University |
| Fred Bassi | F | Boston University |
1966–67 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Harry Orr | D | Cornell |
| Peter McLachlan | D | Boston University |
| John Morrison | F | Yale |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| Wayne Small | F | Brown |
1967–68 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Skip Stanowski | D | Cornell |
| Bruce Pattison | D | Cornell |
| Wayne Small | F | Brown |
| Peter Tufford | F | Cornell |
| Gary Croteau | F | St. Lawrence |
1968–69 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Dryden | G | Cornell |
| Paul Hurley | D | Boston College |
| Bruce Pattison | D | Cornell |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| Herb Wakabayashi | F | Boston University |

#### 1970s

1969–70 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Cropper | G | Cornell |
| Mike Hyndman | D | Boston University |
| Dan Lodboa | D | Cornell |
| Tommy Earl | F | Colgate |
| Curt Bennett | F | Brown |
| Tim Sheehy | F | Boston College |
1970–71 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Bullock | G | Clarkson |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Steve Warr | D | Clarkson |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| John Danby | F | Boston University |
| Steve Stirling | F | Boston University |
1971–72 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Brady | G | Boston University |
| Bob Brown | D | Boston University |
| Steve Warr | D | Clarkson |
| Gordie Clark | F | New Hampshire |
| Larry Fullan | F | Cornell |
| Guy Smith | F | New Hampshire |
1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ned Yetten | G | Boston College |
| Tom Mellor | D | Boston College |
| Vic Stanfield | D | Boston University |
| Gordie Clark | F | New Hampshire |
| Bob McManama | F | Harvard |
| Carlo Ugolini | F | Cornell |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ed Walsh | G | Boston University |
| Vic Stanfield | D | Boston University |
| George Kuzmicz | D | Cornell |
| Bill Burlington | F | Boston University |
| Gordie Clark | F | New Hampshire |
| Randy Roth | F | Harvard |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Petrovek | G | Harvard |
| Brian Durocher | G | Boston University |
| Vic Stanfield | D | Boston University |
| Ron Wilson | D | Providence |
| Mike Eruzione | F | Boston University |
| Tim O'Connell | F | Vermont |
| Jamie Hislop | F | New Hampshire |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Shields | G | Clarkson |
| Ron Wilson | D | Providence |
| Peter Brown | D | Boston University |
| Jamie Hislop | F | New Hampshire |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Mike Eruzione | F | Boston University |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Shields | G | Clarkson |
| Jack Hughes | D | Harvard |
| Tim Bothwell | D | Brown |
| Dave Taylor | F | Clarkson |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
| Bob Miller | F | New Hampshire |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Laycock | G | Brown |
| Peter Shier | D | Cornell |
| Jack O'Callahan | D | Boston University |
| Lance Nethery | F | Cornell |
| Joe Mullen | F | Boston College |
| Ralph Cox | F | New Hampshire |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Craig | G | Boston University |
| Louis Cote | D | Vermont |
| Jack O'Callahan | D | Boston University |
| Joe Mullen | F | Boston College |
| Lance Nethery | F | Cornell |
| Ralph Cox | F | New Hampshire |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Doug Ellis | G | Boston College |
| Louis Cote | D | Vermont |
| Andre Aubut | D | Maine |
| Craig Homola | F | Vermont |
| Ross Brownridge | F | Dartmouth |
| Mike Prestidge | F | Clarkson |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don Sylvestri | G | Clarkson |
| Ed Small | D | Clarkson |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Bryan Cleaver | F | Clarkson |
| Gary Conn | F | Maine |
| Sandy Beadle | F | Northeastern |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Hayward | G | Cornell |
| Chris Renaud | D | Colgate |
| Scot Kleinendorst | D | Providence |
| Steve Cruickshank | F | Clarkson |
| Kirk McCaskill | F | Vermont |
| Andy Brickley | F | New Hampshire |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Darren Eliot | G | Cornell |
| Randy Velischek | D | Providence |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Kurt Kleinendorst | F | Providence |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Bob Brooke | F | Yale |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cleon Daskalakis | G | Boston University |
| Jim Chisholm | D | Boston College |
| T. J. Connolly | D | Boston University |
| Bob Armstrong | D | Clarkson |
| Gaetano Orlando | F | Providence |
| Steve Smith | F | Colgate |
| Kevin Foster | F | Vermont |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Cooper | G | Colgate |
| Dave Fretz | D | Clarkson |
| Ken Hammond | D | Rensselaer |
| John Carter | F | Rensselaer |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Draper | G | Vermont |
| Mike Dark | D | Rensselaer |
| Cliff Abrecht | D | Princeton |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F | Cornell |
| Randy Wood | F | Yale |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike O'Neill | G | Yale |
| Randy Taylor | D | Harvard |
| Mark Benning | D | Harvard |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F | Cornell |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard |
| Bob Kudelski | F | Yale |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Fletcher | G | Clarkson |
| Brian McColgan | D | St. Lawrence |
| Don Sweeney | D | Harvard |
| Pete Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
| Réjean Boivin | F | Colgate |
| John Messuri | F | Princeton |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike O'Neill | G | Yale |
| Dave Williams | D | Dartmouth |
| Mike Hurlbut | D | St. Lawrence |
| Scott Young | D | Colgate |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard |
| Kyle McDonough | F | Vermont |
| Jarmo Kekäläinen | F | Clarkson |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dave Gagnon | G | Colgate |
| Dan Ratushny | D | Cornell |
| Mike Brewer | D | Brown |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer |
| C. J. Young | F | Harvard |
| Mike Vukonich | F | Harvard |
| Joel Gardner | F | Colgate |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Les Kuntar | G | St. Lawrence |
| Dan Ratushny | D | Cornell |
| Dave Tretowicz | D | Clarkson |
| Peter Ciavaglia | F | Harvard |
| Ted Donato | F | Harvard |
| Andy Pritchard | F | St. Lawrence |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Christian Soucy | G | Vermont |
| Mike Brewer | D | Brown |
| Daniel Laperrière | D | St. Lawrence |
| Dale Band | F | Colgate |
| Mark Kaufmann | F | Yale |
| Mike Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Neil Little | G | Rensselaer |
| Jack Duffy | D | Yale |
| Aaron Miller | D | Vermont |
| Ted Drury | F | Harvard |
| Mark Kaufmann | F | Yale |
| Marko Tuomainen | F | Clarkson |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Geoff Finch | G | Brown |
| Sean McCann | D | Harvard |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson |
| Craig Conroy | F | Clarkson |
| Brian Farrell | F | Harvard |
| Steve Martins | F | Harvard |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Thomas | G | Vermont |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson |
| Mike Traggio | D | Brown |
| Éric Perrin | F | Vermont |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| Marko Tuomainen | F | Clarkson |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Thomas | G | Vermont |
| Steve Wilson | D | Cornell |
| Brad Dexter | D | Colgate |
| Éric Perrin | F | Vermont |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| Burke Murphy | F | St. Lawrence |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Trevor Koenig | G | Union |
| Matt Pagnutti | D | Clarkson |
| Steve Wilson | D | Cornell |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| Todd White | F | Clarkson |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Westlund | G | Yale |
| Ray Giroux | D | Yale |
| Steve Shirreffs | D | Princeton |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer |
| Damian Prescott | F | Brown |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Heffler | G | St. Lawrence |
| Jeff Burgoyne | D | Cornell |
| Willie Mitchell | D | Clarkson |
| Dan Riva | F | Rensselaer |
| Erik Cole | F | Clarkson |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joel Laing | G | Rensselaer |
| Cory Murphy | D | Colgate |
| Kent Huskins | D | Clarkson |
| Andy McDonald | F | Colgate |
| Brad Tapper | F | Rensselaer |
| Brandon Dietrich | F | St. Lawrence |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Oliver Jonas | G | Harvard |
| Matt Desrosiers | D | St. Lawrence |
| Kent Huskins | D | Clarkson |
| Erik Anderson | F | St. Lawrence |
| Mike Gellard | F | St. Lawrence |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Underhill | G | Cornell |
| Kerry Ellis-Toddington | D | Clarkson |
| Douglas Murray | D | Cornell |
| Marc Cavosie | F | Rensselaer |
| Mike Maturo | F | Dartmouth |
| Matt Murley | F | Rensselaer |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David LeNeveu | G | Cornell |
| Douglas Murray | D | Cornell |
| Randy Jones | D | Clarkson |
| Dominic Moore | F | Harvard |
| Tim Pettit | F | Harvard |
| Chris Higgins | F | Yale |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown |
| Grant Lewis | D | Dartmouth |
| Ryan Glenn | D | St. Lawrence |
| Brady Leisenring | F | Vermont |
| Lee Stempniak | F | Dartmouth |
| Jon Smyth | F | Colgate |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David McKee | G | Cornell |
| Luc Paquin | D | Princeton |
| Noah Welch | D | Harvard |
| Matt Moulson | F | Cornell |
| Lee Stempniak | F | Dartmouth |
| T. J. Trevelyan | F | St. Lawrence |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mark Dekanich | G | Colgate |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Mike Madill | D | St. Lawrence |
| T. J. Trevelyan | F | St. Lawrence |
| Tyler Burton | F | Colgate |
| Mike Ouellette | F | Dartmouth |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David Leggio | G | Clarkson |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac |
| Drew Bagnall | D | St. Lawrence |
| David Jones | F | Dartmouth |
| Kyle Rank | F | St. Lawrence |
| Nick Dodge | F | Clarkson |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Richter | G | Harvard |
| Grant Clitsome | D | Clarkson |
| Mike Moore | D | Princeton |
| Nick Johnson | F | Dartmouth |
| Lee Jubinville | F | Princeton |
| Steve Zalewski | F | Clarkson |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zane Kalemba | G | Princeton |
| Lane Caffaro | D | Union |
| Zach Miskovic | D | St. Lawrence |
| Mark Arcobello | F | Yale |
| Riley Nash | F | Cornell |
| David McIntyre | F | Colgate |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ben Scrivens | G | Cornell |
| Mike Schreiber | D | Union |
| Brendon Nash | D | Cornell |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer |
| Broc Little | F | Yale |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keith Kinkaid | G | Union |
| Nick Bailen | D | Rensselaer |
| Taylor Fedun | D | Princeton |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer |
| Brian O'Neill | F | Yale |
| Andrew Miller | F | Yale |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Troy Grosenick | G | Union |
| Danny Biega | D | Harvard |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Alex Killorn | F | Harvard |
| Brian O'Neill | F | Yale |
| Austin Smith | F | Colgate |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Hartzell | G | Quinnipiac |
| Nick Bailen | D | Rensselaer |
| George Hughes | D | St. Lawrence |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
| Kyle Flanagan | F | St. Lawrence |
| Andrew Miller | F | Yale |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Colin Stevens | G | Union |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| Ryan Haggerty | F | Rensselaer |
| Daniel Carr | F | Union |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Lyon | G | Yale |
| Joakim Ryan | D | Cornell |
| Rob O'Gara | D | Yale |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard |
| Daniel Ciampini | F | Union |
| Matthew Peca | F | Quinnipiac |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Lyon | G | Yale |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Rob O'Gara | D | Yale |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
| Nick Lappin | F | Brown |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Hayton | G | St. Lawrence |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Spencer Foo | F | Union |
| Alexander Kerfoot | F | Harvard |
| Mike Vecchione | F | Union |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell |
| Kelly Summers | D | Clarkson |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Ryan Donato | F | Harvard |
| Sheldon Rempal | F | Clarkson |
| Max Véronneau | F | Princeton |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andrew Shortridge | G | Quinnipiac |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Chase Priskie | D | Quinnipiac |
| Morgan Barron | F | Cornell |
| Ryan Kuffner | F | Princeton |
| Joe Snively | F | Yale |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Frank Marotte | G | Clarkson |
| Yanni Kaldis | D | Cornell |
| Jack Rathbone | D | Harvard |
| Nick Abruzzese | F | Harvard |
| Morgan Barron | F | Cornell |
| Drew O'Connor | F | Dartmouth |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keith Petruzelli | G | Quinnipiac |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Connor McCarthy | D | Clarkson |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
| Zach Tsekos | F | Clarkson |
| Cameron Buhl | F | St. Lawrence |
| Josh McKechney | F | Colgate |
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Sam Malinski | D | Cornell |
| Alex Campbell | F | Clarkson |
| Mathieu Gosselin | F | Clarkson |
| Nick Abruzzese | F | Harvard |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac |
| Henry Thrun | D | Harvard |
| Sam Malinski | D | Cornell |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac |
| Sean Farrell | F | Harvard |
| Alex Young | F | Colgate |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ian Shane | G | Cornell |
| John Prokop | D | Union |
| Jayden Lee | D | Quinnipiac |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac |
| Luke Haymes | F | Dartmouth |
| Gabriel Seger | F | Cornell |

### Second Team
#### 1960s

1961–62 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richie Broadbelt | G | St. Lawrence |
| Wayne Gibbons | G | Clarkson |
| Laing Kennedy | G | Cornell |
| Brian Robins | D | Rensselaer |
| Joe McGeough | D | Providence |
| Harry Howell | D | Harvard |
| Tom McMahon | D | Rensselaer |
| Pat Brophy | D | Clarkson |
| Jim Josephson | F | Rensselaer |
| Rollie Anderson | F | St. Lawrence |
| Tom Roe | F | Williams |
| Dave Leighton | F | Dartmouth |
| Marsh Tschida | F | Providence |
| John Cook | F | Princeton |
| Roger Purdie | F | Clarkson |
| Ron Famigletti | F | Bowdoin |
| Dave Sveden | F | Colby |
1962–63 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Godfrey Wood | G | Harvard |
| Laing Kennedy | G | Cornell |
| Richie Green | D | Boston University |
| John Weekes | D | Middlebury |
| Brian Pryce | D | Rensselaer |
| Harry Howell | D | Harvard |
| Leon Bryant | F | Brown |
| Ike Ikauniks | F | Harvard |
| John Cook | F | Princeton |
| Lou Lamoriello | F | Providence |
| Roger Purdie | F | Clarkson |
| Bill Lamarche | F | Harvard |
| Jerry Knightley | F | Rensselaer |
| Mike Denihan | F | Boston University |
| Brian Wilkinson | F | Clarkson |
| Steve Riggs | F | Colgate |
1963–64 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack Ferriera | G | Boston University |
| Neil Mieras | G | Army |
| Dick Peterson | D | Army |
| Bill Grisdale | D | Rensselaer |
| Mike Petterson | D | Harvard |
| Robert Gaudreau | D | Brown |
| Ron Butterfield | D | Army |
| Brian Wilkinson | F | Clarkson |
| Terry Chapman | F | Brown |
| Roger Purdie | F | Clarkson |
| John Keough | F | Providence |
| Arnie O'Reilly | F | St. Lawrence |
| Bruce Fennie | F | Boston University |
| Steve Riggs | F | Colgate |
| Dave Ross | F | St. Lawrence |
| Phil Dyer | F | Boston College |
| Bruce Davey | F | Colby |
| Larry Bone | F | Northeastern |
1964–65 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Yurkiewicz | G | Clarkson |
| Don Turcotte | D | Northeastern |
| Ralph Toran | D | Boston College |
| Doug Ferguson | F | Cornell |
| Dean Matthews | F | Dartmouth |
| Terry Chapman | F | Brown |
1965–66 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Terry Yurkiewicz | G | Clarkson |
| Gary Petterson | D | Clarkson |
| Tom Ross | D | Boston University |
| Tom Hurley | F | Clarkson |
| John Cunniff | F | Boston College |
| Mike Doran | F | Cornell |
1966–67 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wayne Ryan | G | Boston University |
| Don Turcotte | D | Northeastern |
| Brian Gilmour | D | Boston University |
| Dennis Macks | F | Brown |
| Jerry York | F | Boston College |
| Mike Doran | F | Cornell |
1967–68 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Leu | G | Northeastern |
| Thomas Rawls | D | Princeton |
| Bob Carr | D | Harvard |
| Mike Hyndman | F | Boston University |
| Brian Cornell | F | Cornell |
| Herb Wakabayashi | F | Boston University |
| John McLennan | F | Clarkson |
| Dale Watson | F | Rensselaer |
1968–69 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Metzer | G | New Hampshire |
| Curt Bennett | D | Brown |
| Chris Gurry | D | Harvard |
| Mike Hyndman | F | Boston University |
| Tim Sheehy | F | Boston College |
| Peter Tufford | F | Cornell |

#### 1970s

1969–70 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don McGinnis | G | Brown |
| Tom Mellor | D | Boston College |
| Wayne LaChance | D | Clarkson |
| Joe Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| John Hughes | F | Cornell |
| David Poile | F | Northeastern |
1970–71 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Cropper | G | Cornell |
| Tom Mellor | D | Boston College |
| Ric Jordan | D | Boston University |
| Jerry Kemp | F | Clarkson |
| Brian McCutcheon | F | Cornell |
| Kevin Pettit | F | Cornell |
1971–72 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don Cutts | G | Rensselaer |
| Ric Jordan | D | Boston University |
| Jim Higgs | D | Cornell |
| John Danby | F | Boston University |
| Dave Hynes | F | Harvard |
| Bob McManama | F | Harvard |
1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Don Cutts | G | Rensselaer |
| Bill Murray | D | Cornell |
| Keith Smith | D | Brown |
| Bill Corkery | F | Harvard |
| Steve Dolloff | F | Boston University |
| Dave Wisener | F | Boston University |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cap Raeder | G | New Hampshire |
| Levy Byrd | D | Harvard |
| Peter Brown | D | Boston University |
| Bob Goodenow | F | Harvard |
| Tom Fleming | F | Dartmouth |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom McNamara | G | Vermont |
| John Glynne | D | Vermont |
| Peter Brown | D | Boston University |
| Jim Thomas | F | Harvard |
| Dave Peace | F | Cornell |
| Randy Roth | F | Harvard |
| Rick Meagher | F | Boston University |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Skidmore | G | Boston College |
| Kevin McCabe | G | Brown |
| Bill Blackwood | D | Clarkson |
| Tim Burke | D | New Hampshire |
| Cliff Cox | F | New Hampshire |
| Richie Smith | F | Boston College |
| Bill Gilligan | F | Brown |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Skidmore | G | Boston College |
| Ron Wilson | D | Providence |
| Bill Blackwood | D | Clarkson |
| Tim Burke | D | New Hampshire |
| Mike Eruzione | F | Boston University |
| Lance Nethery | F | Cornell |
| Bob Ferriter | F | Boston College |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ian Harrison | G | Rensselaer |
| Bill Blackwood | D | Clarkson |
| Jack Hughes | D | Harvard |
| Dick Lamby | D | Boston University |
| Dave Silk | F | Boston University |
| Marty McNally | F | Clarkson |
| Kevin Zappia | F | Clarkson |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Greg Moffett | G | New Hampshire |
| Jim Korn | D | Providence |
| Mike Mastrullo | D | Brown |
| Bob Gould | F | New Hampshire |
| Brock Tredway | F | Cornell |
| Colin Ahern | F | Providence |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Sylvain Turcotte | G | Vermont |
| Ed Small | D | Clarkson |
| Scot Kleinendorst | D | Providence |
| Bill Army | F | Boston College |
| Steve Cruickshank | F | Clarkson |
| Billy O'Dwyer | F | Boston College |
| Steve O'Neill | F | Providence |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Nord | G | Maine |
| Chris Renaud | D | Colgate |
| Andre Aubut | D | Maine |
| Billy O'Dwyer | F | Boston College |
| Steve Cruickshank | F | Clarkson |
| Dan Fridgen | F | Colgate |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob O'Connor | G | Boston College |
| Randy Velischek | D | Providence |
| Mark Fusco | D | Harvard |
| Dan Poliziani | F | Yale |
| Kurt Kleinendorst | F | Providence |
| Billy O'Dwyer | F | Boston College |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cleon Daskalakis | G | Boston University |
| Gray Weicker | G | St. Lawrence |
| Kent Carlson | D | St. Lawrence |
| Dave Fretz | D | Clarkson |
| Colin Patterson | F | Clarkson |
| Paul Guay | F | Providence |
| Normand Lacombe | F | New Hampshire |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bruce Gillies | G | New Hampshire |
| Peter Taglianetti | D | Providence |
| Brian Byrnes | D | New Hampshire |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer |
| John Carter | F | Rensselaer |
| Marty Dallman | F | Rensselaer |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Grant Blair | G | Harvard |
| Peter Sawkins | D | Yale |
| Steve Tuite | D | St. Lawrence |
| Duanne Moeser | F | Cornell |
| Peter Natyshak | F | Cornell |
| Randy Wood | F | Yale |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Doug Dadswell | G | Cornell |
| Randy Taylor | D | Harvard |
| Mark Benning | D | Harvard |
| Chris Norton | D | Cornell |
| Gerard Waslen | F | Colgate |
| Bob Logan | F | Yale |
| Tim Smith | F | Harvard |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Yearwood | G | St. Lawrence |
| Wayne Crowley | G | Colgate |
| Hank Lammens | D | St. Lawrence |
| Dave Baseggio | D | Yale |
| Tim Barakett | F | Harvard |
| Pete Lappin | F | St. Lawrence |
| John Messuri | F | Princeton |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Laurin | G | Dartmouth |
| Chris Norton | D | Cornell |
| Hank Lammens | D | St. Lawrence |
| Luciano Borsato | F | Clarkson |
| Ian Boyce | F | Vermont |
| Kyle McDonough | F | Vermont |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Cohen | G | Colgate |
| Dave Baseggio | D | Yale |
| Mike Bishop | D | St. Lawrence |
| C. J. Young | F | Harvard |
| Allen Bourbeau | F | Harvard |
| Peter Ciavaglia | F | Harvard |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Harvey | G | Brown |
| Dave Tretowicz | D | Clarkson |
| Mike McKee | D | Princeton |
| Joe Day | F | St. Lawrence |
| Andre Faust | F | Princeton |
| Greg Polaski | F | Princeton |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Rogles | G | Clarkson |
| Mike Brewer | D | Brown |
| Daniel Laperrière | D | St. Lawrence |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer |
| John LeClair | F | Vermont |
| Mike Vukonich | F | Harvard |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Parris Duffus | G | Cornell |
| Stephane Robitaille | D | Rensselaer |
| Jack Duffy | D | Yale |
| Derek Chauvette | F | Brown |
| Andre Faust | F | Princeton |
| Hugo Belanger | F | Clarkson |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Christian Soucy | G | Vermont |
| Ted Beattie | D | St. Lawrence |
| Brad Layzell | D | Rensselaer |
| Scott Fraser | F | Dartmouth |
| Scott Hanley | F | Brown |
| Todd Marchant | F | Clarkson |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Currie | G | Clarkson |
| Sean O'Brien | D | Princeton |
| Derek Maguire | D | Harvard |
| Ron Pasco | F | Rensselaer |
| Chris Kaban | F | Brown |
| Bruce Gardiner | F | Colgate |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Todd Sullivan | G | Yale |
| Adam Bartell | D | Rensselaer |
| Brad Dexter | D | Colgate |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate |
| Burke Murphy | F | St. Lawrence |
| Patrice Robitaille | F | Clarkson |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Brenzavich | G | Colgate |
| Jeff Kungle | D | St. Lawrence |
| Patrick Rochon | D | Rensselaer |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate |
| Chris DeProfio | F | Colgate |
| Todd White | F | Clarkson |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Murphy | G | Clarkson |
| Ray Giroux | D | Yale |
| Andrew Will | D | Union |
| Paul DiFrancesco | F | St. Lawrence |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer |
| Éric Perrin | F | Vermont |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Elliott | G | Cornell |
| Willie Mitchell | D | Clarkson |
| Jimmy Andersson | D | Brown |
| Paul DiFrancesco | F | St. Lawrence |
| Jeff Halpern | F | Princeton |
| Chris Clark | F | Clarkson |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Westlund | G | Yale |
| Steve Shirreffs | D | Princeton |
| Jason Reid | D | Vermont |
| Andy McDonald | F | Colgate |
| Jeff Halpern | F | Princeton |
| Bob Prier | F | St. Lawrence |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Derek Gustafson | G | St. Lawrence |
| Justin Harney | D | St. Lawrence |
| Brian Pothier | D | Rensselaer |
| Erik Anderson | F | St. Lawrence |
| Erik Cole | F | Clarkson |
| Kirk Lamb | F | Princeton |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Walsh | G | Clarkson |
| Trevor Byrne | D | Dartmouth |
| Cory Murphy | D | Colgate |
| Dominic Moore | F | Harvard |
| Sean Nolan | F | Colgate |
| Matt Poapst | F | Clarkson |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown |
| Trevor Byrne | D | Dartmouth |
| Mark McRae | D | Cornell |
| Stephen Baby | F | Cornell |
| Chris Higgins | F | Yale |
| Brett Nowak | F | Harvard |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown |
| Noah Welch | D | Harvard |
| Trevor Byrne | D | Dartmouth |
| Scooter Smith | F | Colgate |
| Stephen Baby | F | Cornell |
| Ryan Vesce | F | Cornell |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nathan Marsters | G | Rensselaer |
| Scott Basiuk | D | Rensselaer |
| Rob Brown | D | Colgate |
| Joe Zappala | F | Yale |
| Hugh Jessiman | F | Dartmouth |
| Kevin Croxton | F | Rensselaer |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dov Grumet-Morris | G | Harvard |
| Charlie Cook | D | Cornell |
| Jaime Sifers | D | Vermont |
| Dustin Sproat | F | Princeton |
| Tom Cavanagh | F | Harvard |
| Scott Misfud | F | Vermont |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kris Mayotte | G | Union |
| Grant Lewis | D | Dartmouth |
| Dylan Reese | D | Harvard |
| Kyle Wilson | F | Colgate |
| David Jones | F | Dartmouth |
| Matt Moulson | F | Cornell |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mark Dekanich | G | Colgate |
| Alex Petizian | G | St. Lawrence |
| Sean Hurley | D | Brown |
| Dylan Reese | D | Harvard |
| Tyler Burton | F | Colgate |
| Jeff Prough | F | Brown |
| Jesse Winchester | F | Colgate |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David Leggio | G | Clarkson |
| Lane Caffaro | D | Union |
| Sean Hurley | D | Brown |
| Tyler Burton | F | Colgate |
| Colin Greening | F | Cornell |
| Brett Wilson | F | Princeton |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ben Scrivens | G | Cornell |
| Tom Dignard | D | Yale |
| Brendon Nash | D | Cornell |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
| Bryan Leitch | F | Quinnipiac |
| Colin Greening | F | Cornell |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Allen York | G | Rensselaer |
| Tom Dignard | D | Yale |
| Taylor Fedun | D | Princeton |
| Mario Valery-Trabucco | F | Union |
| David McIntyre | F | Colgate |
| Colin Greening | F | Cornell |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| James Mello | G | Dartmouth |
| Brock Matheson | D | Union |
| Danny Biega | D | Harvard |
| Jack Maclellan | F | Brown |
| Joe Devin | F | Cornell |
| Kelly Zajac | F | Union |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andy Iles | G | Cornell |
| Nick D'Agostino | D | Cornell |
| Michael Sdao | D | Princeton |
| Jack Maclellan | F | Brown |
| Chris Wagner | F | Colgate |
| Jeremy Welsh | F | Union |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Kasdorf | G | Rensselaer |
| Mike Keenan | D | Dartmouth |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| Kenny Agostino | F | Yale |
| Andrew Calof | F | Princeton |
| Matt Lorito | F | Brown |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andy Iles | G | Cornell |
| Joakim Ryan | D | Cornell |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Jesse Root | F | Yale |
| Kellen Jones | F | Quinnipiac |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Hayton | G | St. Lawrence |
| Eric Sweetman | D | St. Lawrence |
| Patrick McNally | D | Harvard |
| Kyle Criscuolo | F | Harvard |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
| Eric Neiley | F | Dartmouth |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Kasdorf | G | Rensselaer |
| Devon Toews | D | Quinnipiac |
| Eric Sweetman | D | St. Lawrence |
| Kyle Criscuolo | F | Harvard |
| Tim Clifton | F | Quinnipiac |
| Travis St. Denis | F | Quinnipiac |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Sakellaropoulos | G | Union |
| James De Haas | D | Clarkson |
| Jeff Taylor | D | Union |
| Ryan Donato | F | Harvard |
| Max Véronneau | F | Princeton |
| John Hayden | F | Yale |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Colton Point | G | Colgate |
| Chase Priskie | D | Quinnipiac |
| Terrance Amorosa | D | Clarkson |
| Anthony Angello | F | Cornell |
| Joe Snively | F | Yale |
| Ryan Kuffner | F | Princeton |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jake Kielly | G | Clarkson |
| Yanni Kaldis | D | Cornell |
| Aaron Thow | D | Clarkson |
| Haralds Egle | F | Clarkson |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
| Max Véronneau | F | Princeton |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Owen Savory | G | Rensselaer |
| Connor McCarthy | D | Clarkson |
| Will Reilly | D | Rensselaer |
| Jack Drury | F | Harvard |
| Curtis Hall | F | Yale |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
2020–21 :
* No team named
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mitchell Gibson | G | Harvard |
| Noah Beck | D | Clarkson |
| Henry Thrun | D | Harvard |
| Zach Tsekos | F | Clarkson |
| Ture Linden | F | Rensselaer |
| Matt Stienburg | F | Cornell |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mitchell Gibson | G | Harvard |
| Zach Metsa | D | Quinnipiac |
| Luc Salem | D | St. Lawrence |
| Matthew Coronato | F | Harvard |
| Alex Laferriere | F | Harvard |
| Ethan de Jong | F | Quinnipiac |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cooper Black | G | Dartmouth |
| Trey Taylor | D | Clarkson |
| Tommy Bergsland | D | Colgate |
| Jacob Quillan | F | Quinnipiac |
| Sam Lipkin | F | Quinnipiac |
| Liam Robertson | F | Union |

### Third Team
#### 2000s

2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Leroux | G | Princeton |
| Ryan O'Byrne | D | Cornell |
| Keith McWilliams | D | Rensselaer |
| Nick Dodge | F | Clarkson |
| Grant Goeckner-Zoeller | F | Princeton |
| Kevin Croxton | F | Rensselaer |
| Kevin Du | F | Harvard |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| | G | |
| Ben Lovejoy | D | Dartmouth |
| Jake Luthise | D | Rensselaer |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
| Byron Bitz | F | Cornell |
| Brandon Wong | F | Quinnipiac |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mark Dekanich | G | Colgate |
| Alex Biega | D | Harvard |
| Evan Stephens | D | Dartmouth |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
| Matt Beca | F | Clarkson |
| Jesse Winchester | F | Colgate |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alec Richards | G | Yale |
| Alex Biega | D | Harvard |
| Jody Peterson | D | Princeton |
| Brock McBride | F | St. Lawrence |
| Broc Little | F | Yale |
| Adam Presizniuk | F | Union |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keith Kinkaid | G | Union |
| Derek Keller | D | St. Lawrence |
| Evan Stephens | D | Dartmouth |
| Riley Nash | F | Cornell |
| Aaron Volpatti | F | Brown |
| Travis Vermeulen | F | St. Lawrence |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Allen York | G | Rensselaer |
| Mike Devin | D | Cornell |
| Joe Stejskal | D | Dartmouth |
| Andrew Calof | F | Princeton |
| Chris Cahill | F | Yale |
| Jeremy Welsh | F | Union |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Karpowich | G | Clarkson |
| Thomas Larkin | D | Colgate |
| Patrick McNally | D | Harvard |
| Connor Jones | F | Quinnipiac |
| Kyle Flanagan | F | St. Lawrence |
| Kelly Zajac | F | Union |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Anthony Borelli | G | Brown |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Zach Davies | D | Quinnipiac |
| Daniel Carr | F | Union |
| Jeremy Langlois | F | Quinnipiac |
| Greg Miller | F | Cornell |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charlie Finn | G | Colgate |
| Dennis Robertson | D | Brown |
| Spiro Goulakos | D | Colgate |
| Brian Ferlin | F | Cornell |
| Daniel Ciampini | F | Union |
| Kenny Agostino | F | Yale |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Garteig | G | Quinnipiac |
| Jeff Taylor | D | Union |
| Danny Federico | D | Quinnipiac |
| Cole Bardreau | F | Cornell |
| Tyson Spink | F | Colgate |
| Kyle Baun | F | Colgate |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Garteig | G | Quinnipiac |
| Joakim Ryan | D | Cornell |
| James De Haas | D | Clarkson |
| Alexander Kerfoot | F | Harvard |
| Mike Vecchione | F | Union |
| Tyson Spink | F | Colgate |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Merrick Madsen | G | Harvard |
| Chase Priskie | D | Quinnipiac |
| Jake Kulevich | D | Colgate |
| Sam Vineault | F | Clarkson |
| Sam Lafferty | F | Brown |
| Troy Crema | F | Dartmouth |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jake Kupsky | G | Union |
| Jake Kielly | G | Clarkson |
| Yanni Kaldis | D | Cornell |
| Josh Teves | D | Princeton |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
| Nico Sturm | F | Clarkson |
| Ryan Scarfo | F | Union |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell |
| Josh Teves | D | Princeton |
| Reilly Walsh | D | Harvard |
| Cam Donaldson | F | Cornell |
| Cole Maier | F | Union |
| Bobby McMann | F | Colgate |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell |
| Peter DiLiberatore | D | Quinnipiac |
| Alex Green | D | Cornell |
| Devin Brosseau | F | Clarkson |
| Josh Dunne | F | Clarkson |
| Haralds Egle | F | Clarkson |
2020–21 :
* No team named
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Clay Stevenson | G | Dartmouth |
| Brandon Estes | D | Union |
| Lukas Kälble | D | Clarkson |
| Alex Laferriere | F | Harvard |
| Max Andreev | F | Cornell |
| Wyatt Bongiovanni | F | Quinnipiac |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mathieu Caron | G | Brown |
| Noah Beck | D | Clarkson |
| Tanner Palocsik | D | Dartmouth |
| Ayrton Martino | F | Clarkson |
| Mathieu Gosselin | F | Clarkson |
| Skyler Brind'Amour | F | Quinnipiac |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Vinny Duplessis | G | Quinnipiac |
| Ben Robertson | D | Cornell |
| C. J. Foley | D | Dartmouth |
| Dalton Bancroft | F | Clarkson |
| Joe Miller | F | Harvard |
| Mathieu Gosselin | F | Clarkson |

### Rookie Team
#### 1980s

1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Corrie D'Alessio | G | Cornell |
| Mark Salsbury | G | Princeton |
| Andy Cesarski | D | Princeton |
| Steve Poapst | D | Colgate |
| Dave Tretowicz | D | Clarkson |
| Stephane Venne | D | Vermont |
| Trent Andison | F | Cornell |
| Peter Ciavaglia | F | Harvard |
| Bruce Coles | F | Rensselaer |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer |
| John LeClair | F | Vermont |
| Rob Tobin | F | Army |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chuckie Hughes | G | Harvard |
| Allain Roy | G | Harvard |
| Mike McKee | D | Princeton |
| Dan Ratushny | D | Cornell |
| Shawn Rivers | D | St. Lawrence |
| Kevin Sneddon | D | Harvard |
| Dale Band | F | Colgate |
| Jeff Blaeser | F | Yale |
| Jamie Cooke | F | Colgate |
| Andre Faust | F | Princeton |
| Craig Ferguson | F | Yale |
| Jim Larkin | F | Vermont |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Haddock | D | Colgate |
| Allen Kummu | D | Rensselaer |
| Aaron Miller | D | Vermont |
| Mike Ross | F | Brown |
| Hugo Belanger | F | Clarkson |
| Scott Thomas | F | Clarkson |
| Ryan Hughes | F | Cornell |
| Kent Manderville | F | Cornell |
| Ted Drury | F | Harvard |
| Francois Cadoret | F | Rensselaer |
| Greg Carvel | F | St. Lawrence |
| Mark Kaufmann | F | Yale |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Geoff Finch | G | Brown |
| Mike Bracco | G | Dartmouth |
| Neil Little | G | Rensselaer |
| Ed Henrich | D | Clarkson |
| Derek Maguire | D | Harvard |
| Sean McCann | D | Harvard |
| Mike McCourt | D | St. Lawrence |
| Craig Conroy | F | Clarkson |
| Tony DelCarmine | F | Dartmouth |
| Scott Fraser | F | Dartmouth |
| Rob Laferriere | F | Princeton |
| Eric Lacroix | F | St. Lawrence |
| Martin Leroux | F | Yale |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Christian Soucy | G | Vermont |
| Luigi Villa | G | Union |
| Brad Dexter | D | Colgate |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson |
| Mike Traggio | F | Brown |
| Wayne Clarke | F | Rensselaer |
| Ben Coughlin | F | Harvard |
| Dominique Ducharme | F | Vermont |
| Ron Fogarty | F | Colgate |
| Craig Hamelin | F | Rensselaer |
| Brad Konik | F | Harvard |
| Todd Marchant | F | Clarkson |
| Steve Martins | F | Harvard |
| Patrice Robitaille | F | Clarkson |
| Marko Tuomainen | F | Clarkson |
| Pat Turcotte | F | Dartmouth |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aaron Israel | G | Harvard |
| Tripp Tracy | G | Harvard |
| Dan Brierley | D | Yale |
| Jeff Kungle | D | St. Lawrence |
| Reid Simonton | D | Union |
| Jason Smith | D | Princeton |
| Matt Johnson | F | Vermont |
| Bill Kelleher | F | Dartmouth |
| Ryan Mulhern | F | Brown |
| Burke Murphy | F | St. Lawrence |
| Tim Regan | F | Rensselaer |
| Bryan Richardson | F | Rensselaer |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tim Thomas | G | Vermont |
| Troy Creurer | D | St. Lawrence |
| Ashlin Halfnight | D | Harvard |
| Adam Wiesel | D | Clarkson |
| Steve Wilson | D | Cornell |
| Vince Auger | F | Cornell |
| Chris Ford | F | Union |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate |
| Jean-Francois Houle | F | Clarkson |
| Éric Perrin | F | Vermont |
| Martin St. Louis | F | Vermont |
| Troy Stevens | F | Union |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Brenzavich | G | Colgate |
| Trevor Koenig | G | Union |
| Dan Murphy | G | Clarkson |
| Jimmy Andersson | D | Brown |
| Chris Clark | F | Clarkson |
| Paul DiFrancesco | F | St. Lawrence |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer |
| Tim Loftsgard | F | Colgate |
| Casson Masters | F | Princeton |
| Ryan Smart | F | Cornell |
| David Whitworth | F | Dartmouth |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Leeor Shtrom | G | Union |
| Jan Kloboucek | D | Vermont |
| Mikko Ollila | D | Clarkson |
| John Poapst | D | St. Lawrence |
| Ben Storey | D | Harvard |
| Craig Adams | F | Harvard |
| Matt Garver | F | Rensselaer |
| Kyle Knopp | F | Cornell |
| Craig MacDonald | F | Harvard |
| Brent Ozarowski | F | Union |
| Alain St. Hilaire | F | Rensselaer |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| J. R. Prestifilippo | G | Harvard |
| Dominique Auger | D | Princeton |
| Ryan Campbell | F | Union |
| Pete Gardiner | F | Rensselaer |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale |
| Ryan Moynihan | F | Cornell |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andrew Allen | G | Vermont |
| Cory Murphy | D | Colgate |
| Andreas Moborg | D | Vermont |
| Willie Mitchell | D | Clarkson |
| Steve Moore | F | Harvard |
| Erik Cole | F | Clarkson |
| Chris Bala | F | Harvard |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Shawn Grant | G | Clarkson |
| Kerry Ellis-Toddington | D | Clarkson |
| Ray DiLauro | D | St. Lawrence |
| Denis Ladouceur | F | Cornell |
| Jamie Herrington | F | Dartmouth |
| Matt Murley | F | Rensselaer |
| Brandon Dietrich | F | St. Lawrence |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Derek Gustafson | G | St. Lawrence |
| Trevor Byrne | D | Dartmouth |
| Mark McRae | D | Cornell |
| Dominic Moore | F | Harvard |
| Marc Cavosie | F | Rensselaer |
| Matt McRae | F | Cornell |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nathan Marsters | G | Rensselaer |
| Jeff Dwyer | D | Yale |
| Rob Brown | D | Colgate |
| Patrick Sharp | F | Vermont |
| Rob McFeeters | F | Clarkson |
| Tim Pettit | F | Harvard |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David LeNeveu | G | Cornell |
| Randy Jones | D | Clarkson |
| Noah Welch | D | Harvard |
| Chris Higgins | F | Yale |
| Jordan Webb | F | Union |
| Lee Stempniak | F | Dartmouth |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kris Mayotte | G | Union |
| Sean Offers | D | Dartmouth |
| Jaime Sifers | D | Vermont |
| Kevin Croxton | F | Rensselaer |
| Hugh Jessiman | F | Dartmouth |
| John Zeiler | F | St. Lawrence |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| David McKee | G | Cornell |
| Grant Lewis | D | Dartmouth |
| Mike Campaner | D | Colgate |
| Brian Ihnacak | F | Brown |
| Kyle Rank | F | St. Lawrence |
| Oren Eizenman | F | Rensselaer |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Fallon | G | Vermont |
| Sean Hurley | D | Brown |
| Sasha Pokulok | D | Cornell |
| Tyler Burton | F | Colgate |
| Nick Johnson | F | Dartmouth |
| Torrey Mitchell | F | Vermont |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mathias Lange | G | Rensselaer |
| Matt Generous | D | St. Lawrence |
| Nick St. Pierre | D | Colgate |
| Bryan Leitch | F | Quinnipiac |
| Shea Guthrie | F | Clarkson |
| Brett Wilson | F | Princeton |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Petizian | G | St. Lawrence |
| Alex Biega | D | Harvard |
| Brendon Nash | D | Cornell |
| Sean Backman | F | Yale |
| TJ Galiardi | F | Dartmouth |
| Brandon Wong | F | Quinnipiac |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Corey Milan | G | Union |
| Mike Devin | D | Cornell |
| Evan Stephens | D | Dartmouth |
| Riley Nash | F | Cornell |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer |
| Adam Presizniuk | F | Union |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jody O'Neill | G | Dartmouth |
| Jeff Buvinow | D | Brown |
| Keir Ross | D | Cornell |
| Patrick Cullen | F | Rensselaer |
| Doug Jones | F | Dartmouth |
| Brian O'Neill | F | Yale |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Keith Kinkaid | G | Union |
| George Hughes | D | St. Lawrence |
| Nick D'Agostino | D | Cornell |
| Jerry D'Amigo | F | Rensselaer |
| Brandon Pirri | F | Rensselaer |
| Louis Leblanc | F | Harvard |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Andy Iles | G | Cornell |
| Mathew Bodie | D | Union |
| Dennis Robertson | D | Brown |
| Andrew Calof | F | Princeton |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
| Daniel Carr | F | Union |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve Michalek | G | Harvard |
| Patrick McNally | D | Harvard |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union |
| Matthew Peca | F | Quinnipiac |
| Brian Ferlin | F | Cornell |
| Chris Martin | F | St. Lawrence |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jason Kasdorf | G | Rensselaer |
| Paul Geiger | D | Clarkson |
| Ryan Obuchowski | D | Yale |
| Kyle Baun | F | Colgate |
| Tylor Spink | F | Colgate |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Charlie Finn | G | Colgate |
| James de Haas | D | Clarkson |
| Gavin Bayreuther | D | St. Lawrence |
| Mike Vecchione | F | Union |
| Matt Carey | F | St. Lawrence |
| Sam Anas | F | Quinnipiac |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kyle Hayton | G | St. Lawrence |
| Kyle Summers | D | Clarkson |
| Nolan Gluchowski | D | St. Lawrence |
| Spencer Foo | F | Union |
| Drew Melanson | F | Rensselaer |
| Landon Smith | F | Quinnipiac |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cam Hackett | G | Rensselaer |
| Chase Priskie | D | Quinnipiac |
| Max Gottlieb | D | Brown |
| Ryan Kuffner | F | Princeton |
| Tommy Marchin | F | Brown |
| Joe Snively | F | Yale |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jake Kielly | G | Clarkson |
| Yanni Kaldis | D | Cornell |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard |
| Jackson Cressey | F | Princeton |
| Sheldon Rempal | F | Clarkson |
| Nico Sturm | F | Clarkson |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell |
| Nick Austin | D | Colgate |
| Reilly Walsh | D | Harvard |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac |
| Jack Jacome | F | Clarkson |
| Jack Baldini | F | Harvard |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Owen Savory | G | Rensselaer |
| Peter DiLiberatore | D | Quinnipiac |
| Jack Rathbone | D | Harvard |
| Wyatt Bongiovanni | F | Quinnipiac |
| Casey Dornbach | F | Harvard |
| Jack Drury | F | Harvard |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mitchell Gibson | G | Harvard |
| Dylan Anhorn | D | Union |
| Henry Thrun | D | Harvard |
| Nick Abruzzese | F | Harvard |
| John Farinacci | F | Harvard |
| Gabriel Seger | F | Union |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ethan Haider | G | Clarkson |
| Pierson Brandon | D | Colgate |
| Luc Salem | D | St. Lawrence |
| Ty Smilanic | F | Quinnipiac |
| Alex Young | F | Colgate |
| Greg Lapointe | F | St. Lawrence |
2021–22 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Clay Stevenson | G | Dartmouth |
| Ian Moore | D | Harvard |
| Hank Kempf | D | Cornell |
| Alex Laferriere | F | Harvard |
| Ayrton Martino | F | Clarkson |
| Matthew Coronato | F | Harvard |
2022–23 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cooper Black | G | Dartmouth |
| John Prokop | D | Union |
| Ryan Healey | D | Harvard |
| Sam Lipkin | F | Quinnipiac |
| Joe Miller | F | Harvard |
| Sutter Muzzatti | F | Rensselaer |
2023–24 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack Stark | G | Yale |
| C. J. Foley | D | Dartmouth |
| Ben Robertson | D | Cornell |
| Mason Marcellus | F | Quinnipiac |
| Jonathan Castagna | F | Cornell |
| Jake Schneider | F | Colgate |

#### Rookie Team players by school

| School | Winners |
| Harvard | 42 |
| Clarkson | 30 |
| Cornell | 28 |
| Rensselaer | 28 |
| St. Lawrence | 25 |
| Union | 21 |
| Colgate | 20 |
| Dartmouth | 20 |
| Vermont | 17 |
| Yale | 13 |
| Princeton | 12 |
| Quinnipiac | 12 |
| Brown | 11 |
| Army | 1 |