# Bellaire Goblet Company

The Bellaire Goblet Company was the largest manufacturer of goblets (glass stemware) in the United States during the 1880s. Its original glass plant was located in Bellaire, Ohio, a town that earned the nickname "Glass City" because of its many glass factories. Bellaire Goblet Company was part of Ohio's "Glass City" on the east side of the state, and later moved to the other side of the state to participate in Northwest Ohio's "Gas Boom". It also became part of a large glass trust.
The company was incorporated on July 31, 1876, by experienced glass makers from the Belmont Glass Company, which was Bellaire's first glass manufacturer. Operations for Bellaire Goblet started later in the year. By 1879 the company was exporting goods to Europe, South America, and Australia, and it expanded production capacity by leasing an additional glass works in town. Bellaire had what glass companies and other manufacturers needed: a good transportation infrastructure, a good labor supply, and plenty of coal for fuel.
In 1886 Northwest Ohio began a "gas boom" with the discovery of natural gas near the small community of Findlay. Local businessmen used incentives such as free land, cash, and low-cost natural gas to lure energy–intensive manufacturers to set up operations there. Bellaire Goblet Company moved to Findlay in 1888. The company kept the name "Bellaire" because of the brand recognition already associated with that name. During the next few years Northwest Ohio began having gas shortages in addition to the country's economic recession, and this put financial hardship on companies that relied on large quantities of fuel for their manufacturing process. In 1891 Bellaire Goblet Company was sold to a glass trust named United States Glass Company and became known as the trust's "Factory M". The Factory M plant was closed permanently in January 1893 when it had no fuel for its furnaces after the town stopped providing natural gas. The plant was sold to a non–glass company in 1894.

## Background

Glass is made by starting with a batch of ingredients, melting it together, forming the glass product, and gradually cooling it. The batch of ingredients is dominated by sand, which contains silica. The batch is placed inside a pot or tank that is heated by a furnace to roughly 3090 °F (1700 °C). The melted batch is typically shaped into the glass product (other than plate and window glass) by either a blowing or pressing it into a mold. The glass product must then be cooled gradually (annealed), or else it could easily break. An oven used for annealing is called a lehr. Because most glass plants melted their ingredients in a pot during the 1880s, a plant's number of pots was often used to describe capacity. One of the major expenses for the glass factories is fuel for the furnace. Wood and coal have long been used as fuel for glassmaking. An alternative fuel, natural gas, became a desirable fuel for making glass because it is clean, gives a uniform heat, is easier to control, and melts the batch of ingredients faster.

### Glass City

Belmont County, Ohio, is located in the Ohio coal belt on the eastern side of the state. One of the county's Ohio River communities is Bellaire. At one time, steamships traveling down the Ohio River knew Bellaire as the last stop for coal until Cincinnati. Bellaire had ten coal mines in the hills adjacent to the town. An 1873 map shows the Central Ohio Railroad entering Bellaire from the west, and the Cleveland and Pittsburgh Railroad entering Bellaire from the north. The Central Ohio Railroad was Bellaire's first, and it connected Bellaire with Columbus, Ohio. The line began being operated by the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad in 1865. The Cleveland and Pittsburgh Railroad eventually became controlled by the Pennsylvania Railroad. In addition to its railroads, the National Road ran through Bellaire. A few miles upriver was the city of Wheeling, West Virginia, which was an early glass producing center in what was at that time, the American "west". Glass was first made in Wheeling in the 1820s, and one of the larger glass works in the United States, J. H. Hobbs, Brockunier and Company, was still operating there in the 1880s.
Given Bellaire's transportation resources, fuel resource, and experienced workforce nearby, the town was an excellent location for a glass manufacturing plant. The Belmont Glass Company, founded in 1866, was Bellaire's first of many glass plants and the second in Belmont County. For the period of 1870 to 1885, Bellaire's nickname was "Glass City" because of its numerous glass factories and the large amount of capital invested in them. By 1880, Belmont County ranked sixth in the value of glass produced among the nation's counties, and the state of Ohio ranked fourth. Glass manufacturers inspected in Bellaire in 1888 (includes makers of bottles, fruit jars, glassware, lantern globes and window glass) were: Rodefer Brothers, Aetna Glass Manufacturing, Bellaire Fruit Jar, Union Window Glass Works, Crystal Window Glass, Lantern Globe, Bellaire Bottle, Belmont Glass Works, Bellaire Window Glass Works, Enterprise Window Glass, and Bridgeport Glass. Partially caused by the gas boom in Northwest Ohio, Bellaire had only three glass furnaces in 1891 after a peak of 17 in 1884.

### Northwest Ohio gas boom

In early 1886, a major discovery of natural gas occurred in Northwest Ohio near the small village of Findlay. Although small natural gas wells had been drilled in the area earlier, the well drilled on property owned by Louis Karg was much more productive than those drilled before. Soon, many more wells were drilled, and the area experienced an economic boom as gas workers, businesses, and factories were drawn to the area. In 1888, Findlay community leaders, assuming the supply of natural gas was unlimited, started a campaign to lure more manufacturing plants to the area. Incentives to relocate to Findlay included free natural gas, free land, and cash. These incentives were especially attractive to glass manufacturers, since the glass manufacturing process is energy-intensive.
The gas boom in Northwest Ohio enabled the state to improve its national ranking as a manufacturer of glass (based on value of product) from 4th in 1880 to 2nd in 1890. Over 70 glass companies operated in northwest Ohio between 1880 and the early 20th century. However, Northwest Ohio’s gas boom lasted less than five years. By 1890, the region was experiencing difficulty with its gas supply, and many manufacturers were already shutting down, using alternative fuels, or considering relocating.

## Production in Bellaire

The Bellaire Goblet Company (sometimes mislabeled as Bellaire Goblet Works) received its charter from the state of Ohio on July 31, 1876. It was organized in the fall by E. G. Morgan, Charles Henry Over, Henry Carr, John Robinson, Melvin L. Blackburn, and William A. Gorby. Morgan was president, Gorby was secretary and treasurer, and Over was manager. Most of the founders were experienced glass men from the Belmont Glass Company with exception of Morgan, who provided capital. Robinson and Over had also worked at the J. H. Hobbs, Brockunier and Company before being involved with the Belmont Glass startup. The company's original glass product was exclusively goblets (glass stemware). Production was conducted using a workforce of about 100 employees working a 10–pot furnace. The company would eventually expand its products to include tableware and pressed stemware.
During the 1870s, deflation was an economic issue for manufacturers. One source estimates that consumer prices decreased for seven years in that decade, while they remained unchanged for the other three. To combat falling prices, manufacturers of similar products formed trade associations, typically known as holding companies or trusts. (The Sherman Antitrust Act was not passed until 1890.) During February 1877, a cartel named Pittsburgh and Wheeling Goblet Company was formed with the objective of limiting the sale of goblets below prices determined by the "partnership". Eighteen manufacturers of goblets were part of the trust, and this included a non-union manufacturer: Bellaire Goblet Company. Competitive pressures prevailed, and the group disbanded on September 11, 1877.
During March 1879, Bellaire Goblet leased (and eventually purchased) an additional glass plant that had an 8–pot furnace. That plant was expanded with the addition of a 14–pot gas furnace. In September, the company's two factories had a capacity of 7,500 dozen goblets per week—and two months–worth of unfilled orders. They exported to South America, Germany, and Australia. Domestically, half of their product was sold in the eastern United States, especially Boston and New York. St. Louis, Chicago, Cincinnati, and San Francisco were major destinations for goblets in the west. The company's employee count was about 150.
In 1880, Bellaire Goblet Company had three furnaces with a total capacity of 29 pots. This meant the company had 10 percent of Ohio's glassmaking capacity. It was also the largest of Bellaire's six glass manufacturers, and third largest of the 19 in the state. By 1885, the employee count grew to 175 men and boys. A report for 1887 listed Bellaire Goblet as having 285 employees and as one of eleven glass companies in Bellaire. During March 1888, a newspaper noted that there was a "strong probability" that the company would move to Findlay, Ohio.

## Production in Findlay

The management of Bellaire Goblet Company decided in March 1888 to move to Findlay, Ohio. A major reason for the move was the incentives: free natural gas for five years (important for the furnaces), free land, and $15,000 cash (equivalent to $508,667 in 2023). Construction of the glass works began in late April. The new plant had two 15-pot furnaces, and equipment from the Bellaire works was shipped by rail to Findlay. The plant's location in Findlay was on Bolton Avenue (between Davis and College streets) near a switching track from the Cincinnati, Hamilton and Dayton Railway.
When Bellaire Goblet Company moved to Findlay, it leased its two Bellaire glass works to another glass company. Charles Henry Over and company president E. G. Morgan decided to not move to Findlay. Melvin L. Blackburn became president while William Gorby continued as secretary and treasurer. John Robinson became plant manager, replacing Over. Some of the Bellaire plant's 300 workers chose to remain in Bellaire and work for the company leasing the Bellaire glass works.
Production in the new Findlay glass works began on August 13. The only problems were not factory–related: workers were difficult to find, and housing for the workers was scarce. An inspector's report for 1888 listed the company as employing 250 males, 12 females, and 50 boys. Production at the new plant went well and continued into the next year with no major problems.

### Fire and gas

Early in the morning of May 9, 1889, the Bellaire Goblet plant was destroyed by fire in what was called the "most destructive fire in the history of Findlay". The fire destroyed everything except the building's brick walls and furnaces. The total loss was estimated at over $100,000 (equivalent to $3,391,111 in 2023), and insurance covered about $65,000 (equivalent to $2,204,222 in 2023). Although some newspapers said the glass works would be rebuilt at once, management was concerned about the availability of natural gas. Even though the company had signed a contract for five years of free gas, the contract was nullified by Findlay's gas producer. Bellaire Goblet was offered a new contract, contingent on the company rebuilding the glass works as soon as possible, for gas at $400 (equivalent to $13,564 in 2023) per year for five years, which would be available if the city had a sufficient supply. The company signed the contract on June 9, 1889, and the rebuild of the glass works began. The company's glassmakers were used as a construction workforce, and the plant resumed full production on August 18, 1889. The Bellaire Goblet Company had a capacity of 30 pots, making it second in capacity among Findlay's twelve glass companies.
In December 1890, gas rates were raised from $400 per year to $3,600 (equivalent to $122,080 in 2023), and the company was notified that if it did not pay at the new rate its gas would be shut off. The company claimed it already had an agreement to pay $400 per year, but the city said the contract was illegal. On top of this potential huge increase in fuel costs, the domestic economy had been in recession since July 1890. The company sued over the gas price increase—and lost. The unfavorable decision was made in late June 1891, but management was focused on something else. On July 1, 1891, the Bellaire Goblet Company ceased to exist as it became Factory M of the United States Glass Company.

## Factory M

The objective of the U.S. Glass Company trust was to lower production costs. Two ways to lower costs were to get concessions from the unions and to use more mechanization. U.S. Glass preferred to produce glass using the most modern equipment with relatively unskilled workers. It began construction of large glass works at Gas City, Indiana, and Glassport, Pennsylvania, which would be highly automated. As fuel is another important cost in glassmaking, Gas City was participating in East Central Indiana's Gas Boom, and Glassport had a coal mine.
Factory M began operations during August 1891, and it produced many of the original products made when it was Bellaire Goblet Company. U.S. Glass management signed an agreement to pay $2,700 (equivalent to $91,560 in 2023) per year for the plant's natural gas fuel. Factory M produced glass through December 8, 1892, before going on a holiday stop effective December 10. Findlay's gas supply was very low, and all glass factories in town had switched to other fuel sources with the exception of two factories owned by U.S. Glass—Factory J and Factory M. Factory J was in the process of switching to oil, but was still using gas. Findlay gas trustees warned Factory M that it should immediately convert to oil for its fuel source., and then raised its gas price to $5,040 (equivalent to $170,912 in 2023) per year. On January 12, 1893, after gas was cut off, U.S. Glass announced that it was shutting down Factory J and Factory M permanently. Equipment from Factory M was stored at the empty Factory J, and eventually equipment from both factories was sent to the Gas City plant (Factory U). The Factory M property was sold to a non–glass manufacturer in May 1894, and the Factory J land was sold in 1910.

## Aftermath

Charles Henry Over, who did not move to Findlay, started the C. H. Over Glass Company in 1889. The plant was located in Muncie, Indiana, and employed 175 people. William A. Gorby was a trustee for United States Glass Company. After Bellaire Goblet became Factory M, Gorby became a purchasing agent for U.S. Glass in Pittsburgh. John Robinson resigned as plant manager and started the Robinson Glass Company in Zanesville, Ohio. M. L. Blackburn joined Robinson Glass in 1892.
During the Economic depression of 1893 (Panic of 1893), United States Glass Company negotiated with the union to change restrictive work rules and equalize wages in unionized and nonunion glass works. The union refused to make concessions, and a "lockout–strike" lasted from October 12, 1893, until January 1897. During much of that time glass was still made at the two large plants in Gas City and Glassport, and the company did not suffer from significant financial difficulties. In 1896, the company was operating six plants: three in Pittsburgh (Factories B, F, and K), and three more in Tiffin, Gas City, and Glassport. Some of the other plants were closed permanently during the strike, including four that were destroyed by fire. The company experienced more strikes in 1913, including at Gas City and Glassport, and reached a settlement where all of its plants became unionized. More plants were closed during the Great Depression in the 1930s. The company filed for bankruptcy in 1962.