# The Voice of Romance: The Columbia Original Album Collection

The Voice of Romance: The Columbia Original Album Collection is a 68-disc box set by American pop singer Johnny Mathis that was released on December 8, 2017, by Legacy Recordings, a division of Sony Music Entertainment. The packaging noted that it includes 67 albums that have been remastered, several of which were being made available on CD for the first time. Two of those, I Love My Lady and The Island, were debuting in their entirety for the first time anywhere, and 38 of the bonus tracks included had also previously gone unreleased.

## Background

Johnny Mathis was surprised when Columbia Records notified him that they would be releasing a box set of everything he had recorded for the label. Regarding the songs on the albums included, he explained that his early success gave him the freedom to choose what to record, saying, "[M]ost of the stuff I ever wanted to do, from the time I was a little kid growing up in San Francisco, I've been fortunate to be able to put them into recordings." Upon receiving his own copy of the box set, he described it as "the greatest feeling I've ever had in my musical life." He told The Arizona Republic, "I saw all of the years and years of dedication and working hard and learning and trying to improve… It's hard to explain to even the most devoted fans what you've gone through in your life."

## Critical reception

In his review of the box set for The Second Disc, Joe Marchese asserted, "What it reveals is that the history of Johnny Mathis is, put simply, the history of American music in the second half of the twentieth century." In summation he wrote that Mathis's "consistence of quality and variation of style" were the most compelling reasons he had to recommend it. Elmore Magazine's Suzanne Cadgène admired many qualities of the release, including the organization and labeling of the discs, the album cover reproductions, the extensive liner notes, and the "delicious" music. In addition to noting how "handsomely designed" it was, Mikael Wood of The Los Angeles Times praised the box set for its inclusion of the two previously unreleased Mathis albums, stating, "Both demonstrate how nimble a singer Mathis has always been — and how curious a mind." Brenda Nelson-Strauss of Black Grooves recommended the collection "if you're interested in a complete career retrospective with plenty of tempting bonus material and you have a large budget". Michael P. Coleman of Sac Cultural Hub wrote, "We all know the hits, but the album cuts are equally breathtaking … [T]hese albums are bonafide masterpieces."

## Contents

Recording dates and release information taken from the liner notes.
| Disc # | Album | Year | Bonus tracks |
| 1 | Johnny Mathis | 1956 | "Out of This World" (Harold Arlen, Johnny Mercer) – 2:43 recorded 3/14/56; previously unreleased "I'm Glad There Is You" (Jimmy Dorsey, Paul Madeira) – 3:43 rec. 3/19/56 |
| 2 | Wonderful Wonderful | 1957 | |
| 3 | Warm | 1957 | |
| 4 | Good Night, Dear Lord | 1958 | |
| 5 | Swing Softly | 1958 | |
| 6 | Merry Christmas | 1958 | |
| 7 | Open Fire, Two Guitars | 1959 | |
| 8 | Heavenly | 1959 | |
| 9 | Faithfully | 1959 | |
| 10 | The Ballads of Broadway | 1960 | |
| 11 | The Rhythms of Broadway | 1960 | |
| 12 | Johnny's Mood | 1960 | |
| 13 | I'll Buy You a Star | 1961 | "Wherever You Are It's Spring" (Arthur Hamilton) – 2:33 rec. 2/8/61 |
| 14 | Live It Up! | 1961 | |
| 15 | Rapture | 1962 | |
| 16 | Johnny | 1963 | |
| 17 | Romantically | 1963 | |
| 18 | Up, Up and Away | 1967 | |
| 19 | Love Is Blue | 1968 | |
| 20 | Those Were the Days | 1968 | "Gentle on My Mind" (John Hartford) – 2:44 "Like to Get to Know You" (Stuart Scharf) – 2:33 above two rec. 7/10/68; both previously unreleased |
| 21 | Johnny Mathis Sings the Music of Bert Kaempfert | 1968 | "It Makes No Difference" (Milt Gabler, Bert Kaempfert, Herbert Rehbein) – 2:32 rec. 10/21-23/68; previously unreleased in the U.S. |
| 22 | Love Theme from "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time for Us) | 1969 | "The Way of Love" (Jacques Dieval, Al Stillman) – 2:51 rec. 6/5/69; previously unreleased |
| 23 | Give Me Your Love for Christmas | 1969 | |
| 24 | Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head | 1970 | |
| 25 | Close to You | 1970 | "Caroline" (Bodie Chandler) – 2:44 rec. 5/13/70; previously unreleased |
| 26 | Love Story | 1971 | Medley – 2:47 a. "Goin' Out of My Head" (Teddy Randazzo, Bobby Weinstein) b. "Can't Take My Eyes Off You" (Bob Crewe, Bob Gaudio) rec. 1/4/71; previously unreleased |
| 27 | You've Got a Friend | 1971 | "Reach Out I'll Be There" (Holland–Dozier–Holland) – 4:03 rec. 5/5/71; previously unreleased "So Much in Love" (George Williams, Billy Jackson, Roy Straigis) – 4:02 rec. 5/7/71; previously unreleased; songwriters erroneously credited as Marjorie Goetschius, Jascha Heifetz "I Only Have Eyes for You" from Dames (Al Dubin, Harry Warren) – 3:43 "Golden Slumbers" (John Lennon, Paul McCartney) – 3:30 above two rec. 5/11/71; both previously unreleased |
| 28 | Johnny Mathis in Person: Recorded Live at Las Vegas | 1972 | |
| 29 | The First Time Ever (I Saw Your Face) | 1972 | "Remember the Good" (Mickey Newbury) – 3:06 rec. 1/27/72; previously unreleased |
| 30 | Song Sung Blue | 1972 | "Morning Has Broken" (Eleanor Farjeon, Cat Stevens) – 3:40 rec. 6/7/72; previously unreleased "I'm on the Outside Looking In" (Teddy Randazzo, Bobby Weinstein) – 3:05 rec. 7/24/72; previously unreleased |
| 31 | Me and Mrs. Jones | 1973 | "Pieces of April" (Dave Loggins) – 3:17 rec. 10/2/72; previously unreleased |
| 32 | Killing Me Softly with Her Song | 1973 | |
| 33 | I'm Coming Home | 1973 | |
| 34 | The Heart of a Woman | 1974 | "Fifty Fifty" (Jerry Fuller) – 3:22 "Nothing in This Whole World" (unknown) – 4:14 above two rec. 5/28-29/74; both previously unreleased |
| 35 | When Will I See You Again | 1975 | |
| 36 | Feelings | 1975 | "Crazy Little Love Makin' Ways" (Rose McCoy, Robert Mersey) – 2:56 "Let's Go On From Here" (Kenneth Crouch) – 2:54 above two rec. 3/25/75; both previously unreleased |
| 37 | I Only Have Eyes for You | 1976 | |
| 38 | Mathis Is... | 1977 | |
| 39 | Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me | 1977 | "Experience" (unknown) – 4:17 rec. 9/30/77; previously unreleased "If It's Magic" (Stevie Wonder) – 3:36 rec. 6/14/77 |
| 40 | You Light Up My Life | 1978 | |
| 41 | That's What Friends Are For | 1978 | "Comme ci, comme ça" performed with Deniece Williams (J. S. Stewart) – 2:58 rec. 4/26/78; previously unreleased "Without Us" from Family Ties; performed with Deniece Williams (Jeff Barry, Tom Scott) – 4:02 rec. 10/21/82 "So Deep in Love" performed with Deniece Williams (Barry, Bruce Roberts) – 4:32 rec. 10/21/82; previously unreleased |
| 42 | The Best Days of My Life | 1979 | "I Never Said I Love You" (Hal David, Archie Jordan) – 3:38 rec. 8/23/78 |
| 43 | Mathis Magic | 1979 | |
| 44 | Different Kinda Different | 1980 | "In Love with Love" (Jimmy Scott) – 3:19 "Time for Love" (Don Ferris, Jack Lloyd) – 4:23 "Wondering Why" (Ainsworth Prasad, Tamra Smith) – 3:38 above three rec. 11/27/79; all three previously unreleased "When Am I Going to Get Over You" (unknown) – 3:30 rec. 12/6/79; previously unreleased "Three Times a Lady" (Lionel Richie) – 4:15 rec. 3/5/80 |
| 45 | Friends in Love | 1982 | "We Kiss in a Shadow" (Oscar Hammerstein II, Richard Rodgers) – 3:37 "Cryin' for the Night" (unknown) – 4:43 "Goodbye for Now" from Reds (Stephen Sondheim) – 3:22 above three rec. 9/1/81; all three previously unreleased "The One and Only" from The One and Only (Alan and Marilyn Bergman, Patrick Williams) – 3:17 rec. 9/2/81; previously unreleased "Here's to You" (Bob Geldof) – 5:05 "As If" (Shelly Peiken, Guy Roche) – 4:17 above two rec. 10/21/81; both previously unreleased |
| 46 | I Love My Lady | 1981 | |
| 47 | A Special Part of Me | 1984 | "Simple" (Vocal Version) (Marvin Morrow, Keith Stegall) – 5:55 "Simple" (Instrumental Version) (Morrow, Stegall) – 4:52 above two rec. 4/13/83 |
| 48 | Unforgettable – A Musical Tribute to Nat King Cole | 1983 | |
| 49 | Live | 1984 | |
| 50 | Right from the Heart | 1985 | |
| 51 | The Hollywood Musicals | 1986 | "I'll Take Romance" from I'll Take Romance (Oscar Hammerstein II, Ben Oakland) – 3:06 previously unreleased "Baía (Na Baixa do Sapateiro)" from The Three Caballeros (Ary Barroso, Ray Gilbert) – 4:08 "Brazil (Aquarela do Brasil)" from Saludos Amigos (Barroso, Bob Russell) – 4:15 above three rec. 4/6/86 |
| 52 | Christmas Eve with Johnny Mathis | 1986 | |
| 53 | Once in a While | 1988 | |
| 54 | In the Still of the Night | 1989 | |
| 55 | The Island | 1989 | |
| 56 | In a Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington | 1990 | |
| 57 | Better Together: The Duet Album | 1991 | |
| 58 | How Do You Keep the Music Playing? | 1993 | |
| 59 | All About Love | 1996 | |
| 60 | Because You Loved Me: The Songs of Diane Warren | 1998 | |
| 61 | Mathis on Broadway | 2000 | |
| 62 | The Christmas Album | 2002 | |
| 63 | Isn't It Romantic: The Standards Album | 2005 | |
| 64 | A Night to Remember | 2008 | |
| 65 | Let It Be Me: Mathis in Nashville | 2010 | |
| 66 | Sending You a Little Christmas | 2013 | |
| 67 | Odds and Ends: That’s What Makes the Music Play | 2017 | |
| 68 | Johnny Mathis Sings the Great New American Songbook | 2017 | |

## Odds and Ends: That’s What Makes the Music Play
### Track listing

Recording dates and release information taken from the liner notes.
* "Teacher, Teacher" (Alternate Version) performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 2:37
** recorded 6/16/57
* "Wild Is the Wind" (Alternate Version) from Wild Is the Wind (1957); performed with Ray Ellis & His Orchestra (Dimitri Tiomkin, Ned Washington) – 2:33
** rec. 10/31/57
* "Now That You've Gone (Puisque tu pars)" (Petula Clark, Norman Newell, Hubert Ballay) – 3:01
** rec. 11/2/67; previously unreleased
* "What to Do About Love" (Leon Carr, Paul Vance) – 2:28
** rec. 5/31/60
* "Each Time We Kiss" (Clyde Otis, Colin Towns) – 2:39
** rec. 3/4/61
* "My Favorite Dream" (Lee Pockriss, Vance) – 2:55
** rec. 10/9/61
* "A Clock Without Hands" (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:58
* "The Joy of Loving You" (Bart Howard) – 3:05
** above two rec. 3/29/62; above five from the album I'll Search My Heart and Other Great Hits
* "You Are There" (Johnny Mandel, Dave Frishberg) – 3:06
* "Fifty Fifty" (Jerry Fuller) – 3:19
** above two rec. 9/22/76; both previously unreleased
* "That's What Makes the Music Play" (Will Jennings, Roger Nichols) – 3:11
* "Let Me Be the One" (Nichols, Paul Williams) – 3:31
** above two rec. 9/27/76; both previously unreleased
* "El Amar y el Querer" (Manuel Alejandro, Ana Magdalena) – 4:13
* "Cosas Pequeñas" (Alejandro, Magdalena) – 3:11
* "Cuando Vuelvas a Casa" (Alejandro, Magdalena) – 4:00
** above three rec. 2/11/83; all three from his CBS Discos album Cuando Vuelvas a Casa
* Medley performed with Barbra Streisand – 4:43 a. "I Have a Love" from West Side Story (Leonard Bernstein, Stephen Sondheim) b. "One Hand, One Heart" from West Side Story (Bernstein, Sondheim)
** rec. 11/30/92; from the Barbra Streisand album Back to Broadway
* "The Shadow of Your Smile" performed with Dave Koz and Chris Botti (Johnny Mandel, Paul Francis Webster) – 5:22
** rec. 5/6/06; from the 2006 Mathis compilation Gold: A 50th Anniversary Celebration

### Personnel

Credits taken from the liner notes.
* Mitch Miller – producer (tracks 1, 2, 4)
* Robert Mersey – producer (track 3)
* Frank DeVol – producer (track 5)
* Irving Townsend – producer (tracks 6–8)
* Jerry Fuller – producer (tracks 9, 10)
* Roger Nichols – producer (tracks 11, 12)
* Jack Gold – producer (tracks 13–15)
* Barbra Streisand – producer (track 16)
* Phil Ramone – producer (track 17)

## Box set personnel

Credits taken from the liner notes.
* Johnny Mathis – executive producer; vocals
* Adam Block – executive producer
* John Jackson – executive producer
* Didier C. Deutsch – compilation producer
* Mike Piacentini – compilation producer; mastering engineer
* Timothy J. Smith – A&R coordination
* Mark Neuman – product direction
* Jeremy Holiday – product direction
* William McKinney – project direction
* Tom Cording – press coordination
* Gabby Gibb – press coordination
* Matt Kelly – tape research
* Michael Kull – tape research
* Tina Ibañez – art direction & design
* James Ritz – liner notes
Images courtesy of Rojon Productions & Sony Music Photo Archives:
* CRPS
* Bob Cato
* Jeff Dunas
* Becky Fluke
* Don Hunstein
* Urve Kuusik
* Art Maillett
* Aaron Mollin
* Fred Mollin
* Ricky Robinson
* Rick Shaw
* Sandy Speiser
* David Vance
Chart positions courtesy of Joel Whitburn & Billboard Publications