# List of men's All-WCHA Hockey Teams

The All-WCHA Hockey Teams are composed of players at all positions from teams that are members of the Western Collegiate Hockey Association (WCHA), an NCAA Division I hockey-only conference. Each year, from 1959–60 onward, at the conclusion of the WCHA regular season, the head coaches of each member team vote for players to be placed on each all-sir team. The First Team and Second Team have been named in each WCHA Hockey season with a Third Team added in 1995–96; a Rookie Team was added starting in 1990–91.
The all-conference teams are composed of one goaltender, two defensemen, and three forwards. If a tie occurred for the final selection at any position, both players were included as part of the greater all-conference team; if a tie resulted in an increase in the number of superior all-stars, the inferior team would not be reduced in number (as happened in 1963–64). Players may only appear once per year on any of the first, second, or third teams but a freshman may appear on both the rookie team and one of the other all-conference teams.
In 1951–52, the Midwest Collegiate Hockey League (MCHL) formed as a conference. Two years later, it changed its name to the Western Intercollegiate Hockey League (WIHL). By 1957–58, however, a major disagreement over recruiting caused the dissolution of the conference with all member teams becoming independent schools for the following season. After one season without a formalized conference, all of the schools involved in the spat discovered that not being in a conference was worse than the alternative so the WCHA was formed. Because all of the WCHA founding teams played in the WIHL/MCHL, the former league's all-star teams (1951–1958) are included in this list.
After the Big Ten formed a college hockey conference starting in 2013–14, the WCHA lost 8 of its member teams from the previous season (Colorado College, Denver, Minnesota, Minnesota-Duluth, Nebraska-Omaha, North Dakota, St. Cloud State and Wisconsin), leaving Michigan Tech as the only founding member remaining in the WCHA.

## All-conference teams

    See footnotes.
    Note: There were no all-conference teams for the 1958–1959 season, because the original conference dissolved in 1958.

### First Team
#### 1950s

1951–52 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ken Kinsley | G | Colorado College |
| Don Burgess | D | Denver |
| Eddie Miller | D | Denver |
| Tony Frasca | F | Colorado College |
| Ron Hartwell | F | Colorado College |
| Omer Brandt | F | Colorado College |
1952–53 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mattson | G | Minnesota |
| Tom Wegleitner | D | Minnesota |
| Eddie Miller | D | Denver |
| Ben Cherski | F | North Dakota |
| Richard Dougherty | F | Minnesota |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
1953–54 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mattson | G | Minnesota |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Jim Haas | D | Michigan |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| Richard Dougherty | F | Minnesota |
| Ben Cherski | F | North Dakota |
1954–55 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob McManus | G | Michigan Tech |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Phil Hilton | D | Colorado College |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| Bill Reichart | F | North Dakota |
| Clare Smith | F | Colorado College |
1955–56 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lorne Howes | G | Michigan |
| Ken Yackel | D | Minnesota |
| Doug Silverberg | D | Colorado College |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Bill Reichart | F | North Dakota |
| Jack McManus | F | Michigan Tech |
1956–57 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack McCartan | G | Minnesota |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Don Wishart | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Hay | F | Colorado College |
| Bill Reichart | F | North Dakota |
| Bob McCusker | F | Colorado College |
1957–58 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jack McCartan | G | Minnesota |
| Bill Steenson | D | North Dakota |
| Ed Zemrau | D | Denver |
| Bill Hay | F | Colorado College |
| Ike Scott | F | Colorado College |
| Bob McCusker | F | Colorado College |

#### 1960s

1959–60 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Kirkwood | G | Denver |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| Henry Åkervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Reg Morelli | F | North Dakota |
| Bill Masterton | F | Denver |
| John Kosiancic | F | Michigan Tech |
1960–61 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Kirkwood | G | Denver |
| Marty Howe | D | Denver |
| George Konik | D | Denver |
| Red Berenson | F | Michigan |
| Bill Masterton | F | Denver |
| Jerry Walker | F | Denver |
1961–62 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Henry Åkervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Jack Wilson | D | Denver |
| Red Berenson | F | Michigan |
| Jerry Sullivan | F | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Angotti | F | Michigan Tech |
1962–63 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Nanne | D | Minnesota |
| Don Ross | D | North Dakota |
| Bill Staub | F | Denver |
| Dave Merrifield | F | North Dakota |
| Gary Butler | F | Michigan |
| George Hill | F | Michigan Tech |
1963–64 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Garry Bauman | G | Michigan Tech |
| Norm Wimmer | D | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Polanic | D | Michigan |
| Bill Staub | F | Denver |
| Gordon Wilkie | F | Michigan |
| Gary Butler | F | Michigan |
| John Simus | F | Colorado College |
1964–65 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Don Ross | D | North Dakota |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Gerry Kell | F | North Dakota |
| Mel Wakabayashi | F | Michigan |
| Doug Woog | F | Minnesota |
1965–66 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Bruce Riutta | D | Michigan Tech |
| Doug Volmar | F | Michigan State |
| Terry Casey | F | North Dakota |
| Dennis Hextall | F | North Dakota |
1966–67 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tony Esposito | G | Michigan Tech |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Jerry Lafond | D | North Dakota |
| Keith Christiansen | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jim Wiste | F | Denver |
| Tom Mikkola | F | Michigan State |
1967–68 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Curran | G | North Dakota |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Terry Abram | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Munro | F | North Dakota |
| Jim Wiste | F | Denver |
| Gary Gambucci | F | Minnesota |
1968–69 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Murray McLachlan | G | Minnesota |
| Keith Magnuson | D | Denver |
| Terry Abram | D | North Dakota |
| George Morrison | F | Denver |
| Bob Munro | F | North Dakota |
| Al Karlander | F | Michigan Tech |

#### 1970s

1969–70 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Murray McLachlan | G | Minnesota |
| John Marks | D | North Dakota |
| Ron Busniuk | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| George Morrison | F | Denver |
| Murray Keogan | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bob Collyard | F | Colorado College |
1970–71 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Morris Trewin | G | Michigan Tech |
| Mike Christie | D | Denver |
| Bob Murray | D | Michigan Tech |
| Walt Ledingham | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Don Thompson | F | Michigan State |
| Bob Collyard | F | Colorado College |
1971–72 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Watt | G | Michigan State |
| Alan Hangsleben | D | North Dakota |
| Bob Winograd | D | Colorado College |
| Jim Cahoon | F | North Dakota |
| Doug Palazzari | F | Colorado College |
| Tom Peluso | F | Denver |
1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Grahame | G | Denver |
| Bob Boyd | D | Michigan State |
| Bruce Affleck | D | Denver |
| Rob Palmer | F | Denver |
| Eddie Bumbacco | F | Notre Dame |
| Peter McNab | F | Denver |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Shelstad | G | Minnesota |
| Jim Nahrgang | D | Michigan Tech |
| Norm Barnes | D | Michigan State |
| Doug Palazzari | F | Colorado College |
| Steve Colp | F | Michigan State |
| Mike Zuke | F | Michigan Tech |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Warden | G | Michigan Tech |
| Brian Engblom | G | Wisconsin |
| Gord McDonald | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Tom Ross | F | Michigan State |
| Bob D'Alvise | F | Michigan Tech |
| Mike Polich | F | Minnesota |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie Mio | G | Colorado College |
| Jack Brownschidle | D | Notre Dame |
| Reed Larson | D | Minnesota |
| Tom Ross | F | Michigan State |
| George Lyle | F | Michigan Tech |
| Mike Zuke | F | Michigan Tech |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Julian Baretta | G | Wisconsin |
| Jack Brownschidle | D | Notre Dame |
| Craig Norwich | D | Wisconsin |
| Brian Walsh | F | Notre Dame |
| Dave Debol | F | Michigan |
| Kris Manery | F | Michigan |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ernie Glanville | G | Denver |
| Curt Giles | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bill Himmelright | D | North Dakota |
| Doug Berry | F | Denver |
| Mark Johnson | F | Wisconsin |
| Mike Eaves | F | Wisconsin |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Iwabuchi | G | North Dakota |
| Curt Giles | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bill Baker | D | Minnesota |
| Mark Pavelich | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mark Johnson | F | Wisconsin |
| Kevin Maxwell | F | North Dakota |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Roy Schultz | G | Wisconsin |
| Dave Feamster | D | Colorado College |
| Howard Walker | D | North Dakota |
| Tim Harrer | F | Minnesota |
| Mark Taylor | F | North Dakota |
| Greg Meredith | F | Notre Dame |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State |
| Marc Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Tim Watters | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steve Ulseth | F | Minnesota |
| Neal Broten | F | Minnesota |
| Aaron Broten | F | Minnesota |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Casey | G | North Dakota |
| Doug Lidster | D | Colorado College |
| Bruce Driver | D | Wisconsin |
| Ed Beers | F | Denver |
| Phil Sykes | F | North Dakota |
| John Newberry | F | Wisconsin |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Mason | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| James Patrick | D | North Dakota |
| Doug Lidster | D | Colorado College |
| Scott Bjugstad | F | Minnesota |
| Bryan Erickson | F | Minnesota |
| Patrick Flatley | F | Wisconsin |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Casey | G | North Dakota |
| Tom Kurvers | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jim Leavins | D | Denver |
| Bill Watson | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Dan Brennan | F | North Dakota |
| Tom Rothstein | F | Minnesota |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Kosti | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Tim Thomas | D | Wisconsin |
| Norm Maciver | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bill Watson | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Pat Micheletti | F | Minnesota |
| Jim Archibald | F | North Dakota |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Blue | G | Minnesota |
| Norm Maciver | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Scott Sandelin | D | North Dakota |
| Dallas Gaume | F | Denver |
| Gary Emmons | F | Northern Michigan |
| Brett Hull | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ed Belfour | G | North Dakota |
| Rob Doyle | D | Colorado College |
| Ian Kidd | D | North Dakota |
| Tony Hrkac | F | North Dakota |
| Bob Joyce | F | North Dakota |
| Gary Emmons | F | Northern Michigan |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Robb Stauber | G | Minnesota |
| Mike DeAngelis | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Randy Skarda | D | Minnesota |
| Phil Berger | F | Northern Michigan |
| Paul Ranheim | F | Wisconsin |
| Steve Johnson | F | North Dakota |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis Joseph | G | Wisconsin |
| Paul Stanton | D | Wisconsin |
| Darryl Olsen | D | Northern Michigan |
| Daryn McBride | F | Denver |
| Shawn Harrison | F | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Chorske | F | Minnesota |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chad Erickson | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Kip Noble | D | Michigan Tech |
| Russ Parent | D | North Dakota |
| Peter Hakinson | F | Minnesota |
| Gary Shuchuk | F | Wisconsin |
| Dave Shields | F | Denver |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Pye | G | Northern Michigan |
| Bret Hedican | D | St. Cloud State |
| Brad Werenka | D | Northern Michigan |
| Russ Romaniuk | F | North Dakota |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Scott Beattie | F | Northern Michigan |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Duane Derksen | G | Wisconsin |
| Greg Andrusak | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Chris Hynnes | D | Colorado College |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Larry Olimb | F | Minnesota |
| Dallas Drake | F | Northern Michigan |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech |
| Barry Richter | D | Wisconsin |
| Brett Hauer | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Fred Knipscheer | F | St. Cloud State |
| Greg Johnson | F | North Dakota |
| Derek Plante | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech |
| Chris McAlpine | D | Minnesota |
| Shawn Reid | D | Colorado College |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College |
| Kelly Fairchild | F | Wisconsin |
| Chris Marinucci | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bach | G | Colorado College |
| Nick Naumenko | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Rafalski | D | Wisconsin |
| Greg Hadden | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College |
| Brian Bonin | F | Minnesota |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bach | G | Colorado College |
| Mike Crowley | D | Minnesota |
| Nick Naumenko | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Bonin | F | Minnesota |
| Peter Geronazzo | F | Colorado College |
| Teeder Wynne | F | North Dakota |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve DeBus | G | Minnesota |
| Mike Crowley | D | Minnesota |
| Curtis Murphy | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Jason Blake | F | North Dakota |
| David Hoogsteen | F | North Dakota |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Craig Anderson | D | Wisconsin |
| Curtis Murphy | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Jason Blake | F | North Dakota |
| Andre Savage | F | Michigan Tech |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gregg Naumenko | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Brad Williamson | D | North Dakota |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Jason Blake | F | North Dakota |
| Paul Comrie | F | Denver |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Mike Pudlick | D | St. Cloud State |
| Jeff Dessner | D | Wisconsin |
| Dany Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |
| Steven Reinprecht | F | Wisconsin |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Meyer | G | St. Cloud State |
| Travis Roche | D | North Dakota |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |
| Bryan Lundbohm | F | North Dakota |
| Mark Cullen | F | Colorado College |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wade Dubielewicz | G | Denver |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Andy Reierson | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mark Hartigan | F | St. Cloud State |
| John Pohl | F | Minnesota |
| Mark Cullen | F | Colorado College |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis McElhinney | G | Colorado College |
| Tom Preissing | D | Colorado College |
| Aaron MacKenzie | D | Denver |
| Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College |
| Shane Joseph | F | Minnesota State |
| Grant Stevenson | F | Minnesota State |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernd Brückler | G | Wisconsin |
| Keith Ballard | D | Minnesota |
| Beau Geisler | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Junior Lessard | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Brandon Bochenski | F | North Dakota |
| Zach Parise | F | North Dakota |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Curtis McElhinney | G | Colorado College |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Brett Skinner | D | Denver |
| Marty Sertich | F | Colorado College |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College |
| Colin Murphy | F | Michigan Tech |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bobby Goepfert | G | St. Cloud State |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Tom Gilbert | D | Wisconsin |
| Ryan Potulny | F | Minnesota |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College |
| Paul Stastny | F | Denver |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bobby Goepfert | G | St. Cloud State |
| Alex Goligoski | D | Minnesota |
| Matt Niskanen | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ryan Duncan | F | North Dakota |
| Mason Raymond | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Andrew Gordon | F | St. Cloud State |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richard Bachman | G | Colorado College |
| Jack Hillen | D | Colorado College |
| Taylor Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Chad Rau | F | Colorado College |
| T. J. Oshie | F | North Dakota |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Stalock | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jamie McBain | D | Wisconsin |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Ryan Stoa | F | Minnesota |
| Chad Rau | F | Colorado College |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Cheverie | G | Denver |
| Brendan Smith | D | Wisconsin |
| Patrick Wiercioch | D | Denver |
| Rhett Rakhshani | F | Denver |
| Blake Geoffrion | F | Wisconsin |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Aaron Dell | G | North Dakota |
| Justin Schultz | D | Wisconsin |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Matt Frattin | F | North Dakota |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mike Connolly | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kent Patterson | G | Minnesota |
| Justin Schultz | D | Wisconsin |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | Denver |
| Jack Connolly | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Nick Bjugstad | F | Minnesota |
| J. T. Brown | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Stephon Williams | G | Minnesota State |
| Nate Schmidt | D | Minnesota |
| Nick Jensen | D | St. Cloud State |
| Ryan Walters | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Drew LeBlanc | F | St. Cloud State |
| Danny Kristo | F | North Dakota |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| C. J. Motte | G | Ferris State |
| Zach Palmquist | D | Minnesota State |
| Colton Parayko | D | Alaska |
| Matt Leitner | F | Minnesota State |
| Matt Bailey | F | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Cody Kunyk | F | Alaska |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Philips | G | Michigan Tech |
| Colton Parayko | D | Alaska |
| Zach Palmquist | D | Minnesota State |
| Tanner Kero | F | Michigan Tech |
| Matt Leitner | F | Minnesota State |
| Tyler Morley | F | Alaska |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris Nell | G | Bowling Green |
| Casey Nelson | D | Minnesota State |
| Mark Friedman | D | Bowling Green |
| Alex Petan | F | Michigan Tech |
| Teodors Bļugers | F | Minnesota State |
| Tyler Morley | F | Alaska |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Bitzer | G | Bemidji State |
| Daniel Brickley | D | Minnesota State |
| Matt Roy | D | Michigan Tech |
| Gerald Mayhew | F | Ferris State |
| Mitchell McLain | F | Bowling Green |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Atte Tolvanen | G | Northern Michigan |
| Zach Frye | D | Alaska |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| C. J. Suess | F | Minnesota State |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
| Troy Loggins | F | Northern Michigan |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Atte Tolvanen | G | Northern Michigan |
| Philip Beaulieu | D | Northern Michigan |
| Cooper Zech | D | Ferris State |
| Diego Cuglietta | F | Lake Superior State |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
| Troy Loggins | F | Northern Michigan |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Connor Mackey | D | Minnesota State |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
| Adam Brady | F | Bemidji State |
| Chris Jandric | F | Alaska |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Will Cullen | D | Bowling Green |
| Elias Rosén | D | Bemidji State |
| Brandon Kruse | F | Bowling Green |
| Julian Napravnik | F | Minnesota State |
| Connor Ford | F | Bowling Green |

### Second Team
#### 1950s

1951–52 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Willard Ikola | G | Michigan |
| Joe deBastiani | D | Michigan Tech |
| Elwood Shell | D | North Dakota |
| John Mayasich | F | Minnesota |
| John McKennell | F | Michigan |
| Bill Abbott | F | Denver |
1952–53 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Willard Ikola | G | Michigan |
| Alex MacLellan | D | Michigan |
| Elwood Shell | D | North Dakota |
| Gene Campbell | F | Minnesota |
| John Matchefts | F | Michigan |
| Bill Abbott | F | Denver |
| Joe deBastiani | F | Michigan Tech |
1953–54 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Spike Schultz | G | North Dakota |
| Phil Hilton | D | Colorado College |
| Bill Abbott | D | Denver |
| Doug Mullen | F | Michigan |
| George Chin | F | Michigan |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Jack Smith | F | Denver |
1954–55 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Simus | G | Colorado College |
| Doug Silverberg | D | Colorado College |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Bill Abbott | D | Denver |
| Jack McManus | F | Michigan Tech |
| Bunt Hubchik | F | Colorado College |
| Bill MacFarland | F | Michigan |
| Jack Smith | F | Denver |
1955–56 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob McManus | G | Michigan Tech |
| Ed Zemrau | D | Denver |
| Bob Pitts | D | Michigan |
| John Andrews | F | Colorado College |
| Tom Rendall | F | Michigan |
| Clare Smith | F | Colorado College |
1956–57 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Yurkovich | G | North Dakota |
| Bob Pitts | D | Michigan |
| Bob Schiller | D | Michigan |
| Jack McManus | F | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Rendall | F | Michigan |
| Tom Kennedy | F | Michigan Tech |
1957–58 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Selinger | G | Michigan State |
| Bob Watt | D | Michigan |
| Mike Pearson | D | Minnesota |
| Dick Burg | F | Minnesota |
| Jim Ridley | F | North Dakota |
| Murray Massier | F | Denver |

#### 1960s

1959–60 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| George Cuculick | G | Michigan Tech |
| Guy LaFrance | D | North Dakota |
| George Konik | D | Denver |
| Gerald Fabbro | F | Michigan Tech |
| John MacMillan | F | Denver |
| Paul Coppo | F | Michigan Tech |
1960–61 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bill Rowe | G | Michigan Tech |
| John Palenstein | D | Michigan |
| Henry Åkervall | D | Michigan Tech |
| Lou Angotti | F | Michigan Tech |
| Bill Colpitts | F | North Dakota |
| Jerry Sullivan | F | Michigan Tech |
1961–62 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bob Gray | G | Michigan |
| Elov Seger | D | Michigan Tech |
| Don Rodgers | D | Michigan |
| Gene Rebellato | F | Michigan Tech |
| Trent Beatty | F | Denver |
| Gordon Wilkie | F | Michigan |
1962–63 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Lech | G | North Dakota |
| Gary Begg | D | Michigan Tech |
| Jack Wilson | D | Denver |
| Dominic Fragomeni | F | Denver |
| John Ivanitz | F | Michigan Tech |
| Al McLean | F | North Dakota |
1963–64 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Buddy Blom | G | Denver |
| Wayne Smith | D | Denver |
| Jim Kenning | D | Denver |
| Carl Lackey | D | Michigan State |
| Craig Falkman | F | Minnesota |
| Scott Watson | F | Michigan Tech |
| George Hill | F | Michigan Tech |
1964–65 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Lech | G | North Dakota |
| Dennis Huculak | D | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Polanic | D | Michigan |
| Gary Milroy | F | Michigan Tech |
| Doug Roberts | F | Michigan State |
| Dennis Hextall | F | North Dakota |
1965–66 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Lothrop | G | Minnesota |
| Dennis Huculak | D | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Hill | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Wayne Weller | F | Michigan Tech |
| Mel Wakabayashi | F | Michigan |
| Gary Gambucci | F | Minnesota |
1966–67 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Best | G | Michigan Tech |
| Paul Domm | D | Michigan |
| Bruce Riutta | D | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Toothill | F | Michigan Tech |
| Gary Milroy | F | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Lindberg | F | Colorado College |
1967–68 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gerry Powers | G | Denver |
| Dick Paradise | D | Minnesota |
| Dick Sieradzki | D | Michigan Tech |
| Bill Klatt | F | Minnesota |
| Cliff Koroll | F | Denver |
| Al Karlander | F | Michigan Tech |
1968–69 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gerry Powers | G | Denver |
| Paul Domm | D | Michigan |
| John Marks | D | North Dakota |
| Dave Kartio | F | North Dakota |
| Tom Miller | F | Denver |
| Bob Collyard | F | Colorado College |

#### 1970s

1969–70 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wayne Thomas | G | Wisconsin |
| John Jagger | D | Wisconsin |
| Wally Olds | D | Minnesota |
| Bernie Gagnon | F | Michigan |
| Murray Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Tom Gilmore | F | Denver |
1970–71 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chico Resch | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| John Jagger | D | Wisconsin |
| Wally Olds | D | Minnesota |
| Murray Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Vic Venasky | F | Denver |
| Mike Usitalo | F | Michigan Tech |
1971–72 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Makey | G | Wisconsin |
| Bob Boyd | D | Michigan State |
| Rick Wilson | D | North Dakota |
| Walt Ledingham | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bernie Gagnon | F | Michigan |
| Don Thompson | F | Michigan State |
1972–73 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Makey | G | Wisconsin |
| Bill Nyrop | D | Notre Dame |
| Jim Nahrgang | D | Michigan Tech |
| Ian Williams | F | Notre Dame |
| Norm Cherrey | F | Wisconsin |
| Pat Boutette | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1973–74 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Quance | G | Michigan Tech |
| Gord McDonald | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bruce Affleck | D | Denver |
| Lorne Stamler | F | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Ross | F | Michigan State |
| Ray Delorenzi | F | Notre Dame |
1974–75 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eddie Mio | G | Colorado College |
| Bob Lorimer | G | Michigan Tech |
| Les Auge | D | Minnesota |
| Mike Zuke | F | Michigan Tech |
| Jim Warner | F | Colorado College |
| Thomas Milani | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1975–76 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Robbie Moore | G | Michigan |
| Dave Langevin | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Craig Norwich | D | Wisconsin |
| Dave Debol | F | Michigan |
| Thomas Milani | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Steve Colp | F | Michigan State |
1976–77 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Peterson | G | Notre Dame |
| Greg Woods | D | Denver |
| John Taft | D | Wisconsin |
| Dan Lempe | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Roger Lamoureux | F | North Dakota |
| Mike Eaves | F | Wisconsin |
1977–78 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Julian Baretta | G | Wisconsin |
| Greg Woods | D | Denver |
| Lex Hudson | D | Denver |
| Greg Whyte | F | Colorado College |
| Steve Christoff | F | Minnesota |
| Dave Delich | F | Colorado College |
| Perry Schnarr | F | Denver |
1978–79 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Rockwell | G | Michigan Tech |
| Bob Suter | D | Wisconsin |
| Dave Feamster | D | Colorado College |
| Gord Salt | F | Michigan Tech |
| Dave Delich | F | Colorado College |
| Steve Christoff | F | Minnesota |

#### 1980s

1979–80 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Frame | G | Colorado College |
| Theran Welsh | D | Wisconsin |
| Marc Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Doug Smail | F | North Dakota |
| Murray Eaves | F | Michigan |
| Dan Lempe | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1980–81 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Paul Fricker | G | Michigan |
| John Blum | D | Michigan |
| Theran Welsh | D | Wisconsin |
| Ken Berry | F | Denver |
| Bruce Aikens | F | Colorado College |
| Troy Murray | F | North Dakota |
1981–82 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Behrend | G | Wisconsin |
| James Patrick | D | North Dakota |
| Craig Ludwig | D | North Dakota |
| Bryan Erickson | F | Minnesota |
| Gregg Moore | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Troy Murray | F | North Dakota |
1982–83 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jon Casey | G | North Dakota |
| Bruce Driver | D | Wisconsin |
| Chris Chelios | D | Wisconsin |
| Paul Houck | F | Wisconsin |
| Dave Tippett | F | North Dakota |
| Gregg Moore | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1983–84 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rick Kosti | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Tony Kellin | D | Minnesota |
| Rick Zombo | D | North Dakota |
| Norm Maciver | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Tom Herzig | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Bob Lakso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Matt Christensen | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1984–85 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Blue | G | Minnesota |
| Rob Doyle | D | Colorado College |
| Doug Clarke | D | Colorado College |
| Matt Christensen | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Corey Millen | F | Minnesota |
| Tony Granato | F | Wisconsin |
1985–86 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Tom Allen | G | Denver |
| Marty Wiitala | D | Wisconsin |
| Rob Doyle | D | Colorado College |
| Corey Millen | F | Minnesota |
| Pat Micheletti | F | Minnesota |
| Dwight Mathiasen | F | Denver |
1986–87 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mike Richter | G | Wisconsin |
| Todd Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Guy Gosselin | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Rick Boh | F | Colorado College |
| Paul Ranheim | F | Wisconsin |
| Corey Millen | F | Minnesota |
| Tony Granato | F | Wisconsin |
1987–88 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dean Anderson | G | Wisconsin |
| Todd Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Paul Stanton | D | Wisconsin |
| Steve Tuttle | F | Wisconsin |
| John Archibald | F | Michigan Tech |
| Daryn McBride | F | Denver |
1988–89 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Robb Stauber | G | Minnesota |
| Todd Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Russ Parent | D | North Dakota |
| Dave Snuggerud | F | Minnesota |
| John Byce | F | Wisconsin |
| Phil Berger | F | Northern Michigan |

#### 1990s

1989–90 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Duane Derksen | G | Wisconsin |
| Sean Hill | D | Wisconsin |
| Jason Herter | D | North Dakota |
| John Byce | F | Wisconsin |
| Lee Davidson | F | North Dakota |
| Eric Murano | F | Denver |
1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Duane Derksen | G | Wisconsin |
| Jason Herter | D | North Dakota |
| Sean Hill | D | Wisconsin |
| Larry Olimb | F | Minnesota |
| Kelly Hurd | F | Michigan Tech |
| Dixon Ward | F | North Dakota |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jeff Stolp | G | Minnesota |
| Travis Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Doug Zmolek | D | Minnesota |
| Dixon Ward | F | North Dakota |
| Derek Plante | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jim Hiller | F | Northern Michigan |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Carey | G | Wisconsin |
| Jon Rohloff | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Travis Richards | D | Minnesota |
| Joe Frederick | F | Northern Michigan |
| John Young | F | Michigan Tech |
| Chris Marinucci | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Lee Schill | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Kelly Hultgren | D | St. Cloud State |
| Kent Fearns | D | Colorado College |
| Mike Harding | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jeff Nielsen | F | Minnesota |
| Andrew Shier | F | Wisconsin |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Sinuhe Wallinheimo | G | Denver |
| Kent Fearns | D | Colorado College |
| Kelly Hultgren | D | St. Cloud State |
| Brad Federenko | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Peter Geronazzo | F | Colorado College |
| Colin Schmidt | F | Colorado College |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Judd Lambert | G | Colorado College |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Dan Trebil | D | Minnesota |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Colin Schmidt | F | Colorado College |
| Antti Laaksonen | F | Denver |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kirk Daubenspeck | G | Wisconsin |
| Eric Rud | D | Colorado College |
| Rick Mrozik | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Dave Paradise | F | St. Cloud State |
| Matt Cullen | F | St. Cloud State |
| Mike Peluso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Leitza | G | St. Cloud State |
| Calvin Elfring | D | Colorado College |
| Andy Sutton | D | Michigan Tech |
| Steven Reinprecht | F | Wisconsin |
| Reggie Berg | F | Minnesota |
| David Hoogsteen | F | North Dakota |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Dan Peters | D | Colorado College |
| Trevor Hammer | D | North Dakota |
| Jay Panzer | F | North Dakota |
| Darren Clark | F | Colorado College |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Scott Meyer | G | St. Cloud State |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Dylan Mills | D | Minnesota |
| Tyler Arnason | F | St. Cloud State |
| John Pohl | F | Minnesota |
| Lee Goren | F | North Dakota |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wade Dubielewicz | G | Denver |
| Duvie Wescott | D | St. Cloud State |
| Paul Manning | D | Colorado College |
| Eric Westrum | F | Minnesota |
| Dany Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Ryan Bayda | F | North Dakota |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dean Weasler | G | St. Cloud State |
| Matt Shasby | D | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Paul Martin | D | Minnesota |
| Ryan Bayda | F | North Dakota |
| Nate DiCasmirro | F | St. Cloud State |
| Judd Medak | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Wade Dubielewicz | G | Denver |
| Paul Martin | D | Minnesota |
| Keith Ballard | D | Minnesota |
| Noah Clarke | F | Colorado College |
| Thomas Vanek | F | Minnesota |
| Brandon Bochenski | F | North Dakota |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Isaac Reichmuth | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ryan Caldwell | D | Denver |
| Matt Jones | D | North Dakota |
| Chris Conner | F | Michigan Tech |
| Thomas Vanek | F | Minnesota |
| Evan Schwabe | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernd Brückler | G | Wisconsin |
| Lars Helminen | D | Michigan Tech |
| Mark Stuart | D | Colorado College |
| Gabe Gauthier | F | Denver |
| Evan Schwabe | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Robbie Earl | F | Wisconsin |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Elliott | G | Wisconsin |
| Alex Goligoski | D | Minnesota |
| Brian Salcido | D | Colorado College |
| Joe Pavelski | F | Wisconsin |
| Marty Sertich | F | Colorado College |
| David Backes | F | Minnesota State |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Elliott | G | Wisconsin |
| Mike Vanelli | D | Minnesota |
| Taylor Chorney | D | North Dakota |
| Jonathan Toews | F | North Dakota |
| Travis Morin | F | Minnesota State |
| Kyle Okposo | F | Minnesota |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jean-Philippe Lamoureux | G | North Dakota |
| Chris Butler | D | Denver |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Andreas Nödl | F | St. Cloud State |
| Ryan Duncan | F | North Dakota |
| Garrett Roe | F | St. Cloud State |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Marc Cheverie | G | Denver |
| Patrick Wiercioch | D | Denver |
| Garrett Raboin | D | St. Cloud State |
| Ryan Duncan | F | North Dakota |
| Jordan Schroeder | F | Minnesota |
| Justin Fontaine | F | Minnesota-Duluth |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Eidsness | G | North Dakota |
| Ryan McDonagh | D | Wisconsin |
| Nate Prosser | D | Colorado College |
| Justin Fontaine | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State |
| Tyler Ruegsegger | F | Denver |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kent Patterson | G | Minnesota |
| Jake Gardiner | D | Wisconsin |
| Matt Donovan | D | Denver |
| Jason Zucker | F | Denver |
| Drew Shore | F | Denver |
| Justin Fontaine | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kenny Reiter | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Gabe Guentzel | D | Colorado College |
| Nate Schmidt | D | Minnesota |
| Jaden Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
| Drew Shore | F | Denver |
| Jason Zucker | F | Denver |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Juho Olkinuora | G | Denver |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | Denver |
| Mike Boivin | D | Colorado College |
| Corban Knight | F | North Dakota |
| Erik Haula | F | Minnesota |
| Rylan Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cole Huggins | G | Minnesota State |
| Kevin Czuczman | D | Lake Superior State |
| Scott Czarnowczan | D | Ferris State |
| Garrett Thompson | F | Ferris State |
| Colton Beck | F | Alaska |
| Jean-Paul Lafontaine | F | Minnesota State |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Stephon Williams | G | Minnesota State |
| Matt Prapavessis | D | Bemidji State |
| Casey Nelson | D | Minnesota State |
| Bryce Gervais | F | Minnesota State |
| Alex Petan | F | Michigan Tech |
| Malcolm Gould | F | Michigan Tech |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Phillips | G | Michigan Tech |
| Matt Roy | D | Michigan Tech |
| Sean Walker | D | Bowling Green |
| Gerald Mayhew | F | Ferris State |
| Darren Nowick | F | Northern Michigan |
| Dominik Shine | F | Northern Michigan |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Atte Tolvanen | G | Northern Michigan |
| Shane Hanna | D | Michigan Tech |
| Sean Walker | D | Bowling Green |
| C. J. Franklin | F | Minnesota State |
| Mitch Hults | F | Lake Superior State |
| Phillip Marinaccio | F | Bemidji State |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Bitzer | G | Bemidji State |
| Daniel Brickley | D | Minnesota State |
| Philip Beaulieu | D | Northern Michigan |
| Mitchell McLain | F | Bowling Green |
| Adam Rockwood | F | Northern Michigan |
| Josh Kestner | F | Alabama–Huntsville |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Justin Baudry | D | Bemidji State |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| Brandon Kruse | F | Bowling Green |
| Adam Rockwood | F | Northern Michigan |
| Parker Tuomie | F | Minnesota State |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zach Driscoll | G | Bemidji State |
| Tommy Muck | D | Bemidji State |
| Philip Beaulieu | D | Northern Michigan |
| Griffin Loughran | F | Northern Michigan |
| Parker Tuomie | F | Minnesota State |
| Max Humitz | F | Lake Superior State |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Mareks Mitens | G | Lake Superior State |
| Colin Swoyer | D | Michigan Tech |
| Will Riedell | D | Lake Superior State |
| Joseph Nardi | F | Northern Michigan |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State |
| Ashton Calder | F | Lake Superior State |

### Third Team
#### 1990s

1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Teras Lendzyk | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Taj Melson | D | St. Cloud State |
| Eric Rud | D | Colorado College |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College |
| David Vallieres | F | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Mike Peluso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Mullin | G | Denver |
| Dane Litke | D | North Dakota |
| Calvin Elfring | D | Colorado College |
| Sacha Molin | F | St. Cloud State |
| Ryan Kraft | F | Minnesota |
| Andre Savage | F | Michigan Tech |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Doug Taskey | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Josh DeWolf | D | St. Cloud State |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Mike Peluso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Wyatt Smith | F | Minnesota |
| Paul Comrie | F | Denver |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Graham Melanson | G | Wisconsin |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| Jeff Dessner | D | Wisconsin |
| Wyatt Smith | F | Minnesota |
| James Patterson | F | Denver |
| Lee Goren | F | North Dakota |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Graham Melanson | G | Wisconsin |
| Alex Brooks | D | Wisconsin |
| Paul Manning | D | Colorado College |
| Aaron Fox | F | Minnesota State |
| Jason Ulmer | F | North Dakota |
| Erik Westrum | F | Minnesota |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Hauser | G | Minnesota |
| Ben Christopherson | D | Minnesota State |
| Tom Preissing | D | Colorado College |
| Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College |
| Mark Hartigan | F | St. Cloud State |
| Brandon Sampair | F | St. Cloud State |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Berkhoel | G | Denver |
| Tom Preissing | D | Colorado College |
| Aaron MacKenzie | D | Denver |
| Jeff Taffe | F | Minnesota |
| Connor James | F | Denver |
| Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Isaac Reichmuth | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Andy Schneider | D | North Dakota |
| David Hale | D | North Dakota |
| Zach Parise | F | North Dakota |
| Kevin Doell | F | Denver |
| Troy Riddle | F | Minnesota |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Berkhoel | G | Denver |
| Mark Stuart | D | Colorado College |
| Ryan Suter | D | Wisconsin |
| Shane Joseph | F | Minnesota State |
| Brady Murray | F | North Dakota |
| Gabe Gauthier | F | Denver |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cam Ellsworth | G | Michigan Tech |
| Tom Gilbert | D | Wisconsin |
| Matt Jones | D | North Dakota |
| David Backes | F | Minnesota State |
| Ryan Potulny | F | Minnesota |
| Danny Irmen | F | Minnesota |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jordan Parise | G | North Dakota |
| Chris Harrington | D | Minnesota |
| Matt Smaby | D | North Dakota |
| Drew Stafford | F | North Dakota |
| Ryan Dingle | F | Denver |
| Danny Irmen | F | Minnesota |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael-Lee Teslak | G | Michigan Tech |
| Lee Sweatt | D | Colorado College |
| Steve Wagner | D | Minnesota State |
| Andreas Nödl | F | St. Cloud State |
| T. J. Oshie | F | North Dakota |
| Ryan Dingle | F | Denver |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Peter Mannino | G | Denver |
| Robbie Bina | D | North Dakota |
| Jamie McBain | D | Wisconsin |
| Tyler Bozak | F | Denver |
| Blake Wheeler | F | Minnesota |
| Kyle Turris | F | Wisconsin |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Eidsness | G | North Dakota |
| Josh Meyers | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Kurt Davis | D | Minnesota State |
| Garrett Roe | F | St. Cloud State |
| Anthony Maiani | F | Denver |
| Rhett Rakhshani | F | Denver |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Dunn | G | St. Cloud State |
| Garrett Raboin | D | St. Cloud State |
| Chay Genoway | D | North Dakota |
| Michael Davies | F | Wisconsin |
| Joe Colborne | F | Denver |
| Garrett Roe | F | St. Cloud State |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Faulkner | G | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Kurt Davis | D | Minnesota State |
| Justin Faulk | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Jason Gregoire | F | North Dakota |
| Jaden Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
| Drew LeBlanc | F | St. Cloud State |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Josh Thorimbert | G | Colorado College |
| Nick Jensen | D | St. Cloud State |
| Ben Blood | D | North Dakota |
| Mark Zengerle | F | Wisconsin |
| Brock Nelson | F | North Dakota |
| Travis Oleksuk | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Adam Wilcox | G | Minnesota |
| Andrej Šustr | D | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Jake McCabe | D | Wisconsin |
| Matt Leitner | F | Minnesota State |
| Nick Bjugstad | F | Minnesota |
| Eriah Hayes | F | Minnesota State |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Kevin Kapalka | G | Lake Superior State |
| Jason Binkley | D | Ferris State |
| Matt Prapevessis | D | Bemidji State |
| Johnny McInnis | F | Minnesota State |
| Zach Lehrke | F | Minnesota State |
| Tyler Morley | F | Alaska |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| C. J. Motte | G | Ferris State |
| Shane Hanna | D | Michigan Tech |
| Brock Maschmeyer | D | Northern Michigan |
| Blake Pietila | F | Michigan Tech |
| Marcus Basara | F | Alaska |
| Brendan Harms | F | Bemidji State |
| Blake Tatchell | F | Alaska-Anchorage |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gordon Defiel | G | Lake Superior State |
| Brandon Anselmini | D | Ferris State |
| Shane Hanna | D | Michigan Tech |
| Mark Cooper | F | Bowling Green |
| Bryce Gervais | F | Minnesota State |
| Malcolm Gould | F | Michigan Tech |
| Tyler Heinonen | F | Michigan Tech |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Justin Kapelmaster | G | Ferris State |
| Mark Friedman | D | Bowling Green |
| Kurt Gosselin | D | Alabama–Huntsville |
| Brad McClure | F | Minnesota State |
| Dominik Shine | F | Northern Michigan |
| Gerry Fitzgerald | F | Bemidji State |
| Tyler Heinonen | F | Michigan Tech |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Connor LaCouvee | G | Minnesota State |
| Ian Scheid | D | Minnesota State |
| Ryker Killins | D | Ferris State |
| Mitch Reinke | D | Michigan Tech |
| Zeb Knutson | F | Minnesota State |
| Darien Craighead | F | Northern Michigan |
| Robbie Payne | F | Northern Michigan |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Ryan Bednard | G | Bowling Green |
| Connor Mackey | D | Minnesota State |
| Ian Scheid | D | Minnesota State |
| Max Humitz | F | Lake Superior State |
| Steven Jandric | F | Alaska |
| Anthony Nellis | F | Lake Superior State |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Jurusik | G | Michigan Tech |
| Elias Rosén | D | Bemidji State |
| Ian Scheid | D | Minnesota State |
| Connor Ford | F | Bowling Green |
| Owen Sillinger | F | Bemidji State |
| Darien Craighead | F | Northern Michigan |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Zach Driscoll | G | Bemidji State |
| Akito Hirose | D | Minnesota State |
| Riese Zmolek | D | Minnesota State |
| Trenton Bliss | F | Michigan Tech |
| André Ghantous | F | Northern Michigan |
| Pete Veillette | F | Lake Superior State |

### Rookie Team
#### 1990s

1990–91 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech |
| Chris McAlpine | D | Minnesota |
| Shawn Reid | D | Colorado College |
| Tony Szabo | F | Northern Michigan |
| Jason Zent | F | Wisconsin |
| Craig Johnson | F | Minnesota |
1991–92 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Corwin Saurdiff | G | Northern Michigan |
| Jason Helr | D | Northern Michigan |
| Kent Fearns | D | Colorado College |
| Brian Rafalski | D | Wisconsin |
| Sandy Gasseau | F | St. Cloud State |
| Steve Magnusson | F | Minnesota |
| Darby Hendrickson | F | Minnesota |
1992–93 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Jim Carey | G | Wisconsin |
| Jason Wright | D | Michigan Tech |
| Nick Naumenko | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Bonin | F | Minnesota |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College |
| Pat Mikesch | F | Michigan Tech |
1993–94 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Toby Kvalevog | G | North Dakota |
| Todd Bethard | D | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Eric Rud | D | Colorado College |
| Brad Federenko | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Landon Wilson | F | North Dakota |
| Dean Seymour | F | Northern Michigan |
1994–95 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brian Leitza | G | St. Cloud State |
| Mike Crowley | D | Minnesota |
| Calvin Elfring | D | Colorado College |
| Joe Bianchi | F | Wisconsin |
| Mike Peluso | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ryan Kraft | F | Minnesota |
1995–96 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Steve DeBus | G | Minnesota |
| Scott Swanson | D | Colorado College |
| Darrin Bradley | D | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College |
| Matt Cullen | F | St. Cloud State |
| Erik Rasmussen | F | Minnesota |
1996–97 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brant Nicklin | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Ben Clymer | D | Minnesota |
| Curtis Doell | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Buddy Smith | F | Northern Michigan |
| Dave Spehar | F | Minnesota |
| Toby Petersen | F | Colorado College |
1997–98 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Karl Goehring | G | North Dakota |
| Trevor Hammer | D | North Dakota |
| Ryan Coole | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Paul Manning | D | Colorado College |
| Kevin Granato | F | Wisconsin |
| Mark Rycroft | F | Denver |
| Jeff Panzer | F | North Dakota |
1998–99 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Gregg Naumenko | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Jordan Leopold | D | Minnesota |
| David Tanabe | D | Wisconsin |
| Steve Cygan | F | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Jesse Heerema | F | Colorado College |
| Tyler Arnason | F | St. Cloud State |

#### 2000s

1999–00 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Corey McEachern | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Travis Roche | D | North Dakota |
| Brian Fahey | D | Wisconsin |
| Dany Heatley | F | Wisconsin |
| Noah Clarke | F | Colorado College |
| Ryan Bayda | F | North Dakota |
2000–01 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Chris King | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Ryan Caldwell | D | Denver |
| Paul Martin | D | Minnesota |
| Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College |
| Grant Potulny | F | Minnesota |
| Troy Riddle | F | Minnesota |
2001–02 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Bernd Brückler | G | Wisconsin |
| Keith Ballard | D | Minnesota |
| Matt Gens | D | St. Cloud State |
| Mike Doyle | F | St. Cloud State |
| Brandon Bochenski | F | North Dakota |
| Peter Szabo | F | St. Cloud State |
2002–03 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Isaac Reichmuth | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Mark Stuart | D | Colorado College |
| Chris Harrington | D | Minnesota |
| Thomas Vanek | F | Minnesota |
| Zach Parise | F | North Dakota |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College |
2003–04 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Matt Zaba | G | Colorado College |
| Ryan Suter | D | Wisconsin |
| Matt Carle | D | Denver |
| Brady Murray | F | North Dakota |
| David Backes | F | Minnesota State |
| Robbie Earl | F | Wisconsin |
2004–05 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Nathan Lawson | G | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Alex Goligoski | D | Minnesota |
| Kyle Klubertanz | D | Wisconsin |
| Joe Pavelski | F | Wisconsin |
| Paul Stastny | F | Denver |
| Travis Zajac | F | North Dakota |
2005–06 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dan Tormey | G | Minnesota State |
| Chris Butler | D | Denver |
| Brian Lee | D | North Dakota |
| Phil Kessel | F | Minnesota |
| T. J. Oshie | F | North Dakota |
| Mason Raymond | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2006–07 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Alex Stalock | G | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Erik Johnson | D | Minnesota |
| Jamie McBain | D | Wisconsin |
| Andreas Nödl | F | St. Cloud State |
| Kyle Okposo | F | Minnesota |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State |
2007–08 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Richard Bachman | G | Colorado College |
| Ryan McDonagh | D | Wisconsin |
| Cade Fairchild | D | Minnesota |
| Kyle Turris | F | Wisconsin |
| Tyler Bozak | F | Denver |
| Garrett Roe | F | St. Cloud State |
2008–09 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Brad Eidsness | G | North Dakota |
| Patrick Wiercioch | D | Denver |
| Jake Gardiner | D | Wisconsin |
| Jordan Schroeder | F | Minnesota |
| Joe Colborne | F | Denver |
| Mike Connolly | F | Minnesota-Duluth |

#### 2010s

2009–10 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Joe Howe | G | Colorado College |
| Matt Donovan | D | Denver |
| Justin Schultz | D | Wisconsin |
| Danny Kristo | F | North Dakota |
| Craig Smith | F | Wisconsin |
| Rylan Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
2010–11 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Sam Brittain | G | Denver |
| Justin Faulk | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| David Makowski | D | Denver |
| Jason Zucker | F | Denver |
| Jaden Schwartz | F | Colorado College |
| J. T. Brown | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
2011–12 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Juho Olkinuora | G | Denver |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | Denver |
| Andrew Prochno | D | St. Cloud State |
| Kyle Rau | F | Minnesota |
| Jean-Paul Lafontaine | F | Minnesota State |
| Jayson Megna | F | Nebraska-Omaha |
2012–13 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Stephin Williams | G | Minnesota State |
| Nolan Zajac | D | Denver |
| Andy Welinski | D | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Tony Cameranesi | F | Minnesota-Duluth |
| Alex Petan | F | Michigan Tech |
| Rocco Grimaldi | F | North Dakota |
2013–14 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Cole Huggins | G | Minnesota State |
| Sean Flanagan | D | Minnesota State |
| Ruslan Pedan | D | Bemidji State |
| Shane Hanna | D | Michigan Tech |
| Kyle Schempp | F | Ferris State |
| Marcus Basara | F | Alaska |
| Alex Globke | F | Lake Superior State |
2014–15 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Michael Bitzer | G | Bemidji State |
| Mark Friedman | D | Bowling Green |
| Nolan Valleau | D | Bowling Green |
| Brandon Hawkins | F | Bowling Green |
| C. J. Franklin | F | Minnesota State |
| Max McHugh | F | Alabama-Huntsville |
2015–16 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Atte Tolvanen | G | Northern Michigan |
| Wyatt Ege | D | Alaska Anchorage |
| Daniel Brickley | D | Minnesota State |
| Corey Mackin | F | Ferris State |
| Max Coatta | F | Minnesota State |
| Jake Lucchini | F | Michigan Tech |
2016–17 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Angus Redmond | G | Michigan Tech |
| Ian Scheid | D | Minnesota State |
| Alec Rauhauser | D | Bowling Green |
| Mitch Reinke | D | Michigan Tech |
| Zach Whitecloud | D | Bemidji State |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State |
| Darien Craighead | F | Northern Michigan |
| Max Humitz | F | Lake Superior State |
2017–18 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Eric Dop | G | Bowling Green |
| Connor Mackey | D | Minnesota State |
| Eric Sinclair | D | Alaska Anchorage |
| Jake Jaremko | F | Minnesota State |
| Brandon Kruse | F | Bowling Green |
| Steven Jandric | F | Alaska |
| Max Johnson | F | Bowling Green |
| Reggie Lutz | F | Minnesota State |
2018–19 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State |
| Chris Jandric | D | Alaska |
| Cooper Zech | D | Ferris State |
| Ashton Calder | F | Minnesota State |
| Brian Halonen | F | Michigan Tech |
| Julian Napravnik | F | Minnesota State |
| Owen Sillinger | F | Bemidji State |

#### 2020s

2019–20 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| John Hawthorne | G | Northern Michigan |
| Elias Rosén | D | Bemidji State |
| Jake Willets | D | Ferris State |
| Lucas Sowder | F | Minnesota State |
| Louis Boudon | F | Lake Superior State |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State |
2020–21 :
| Player | Pos | Team |
| Rico DiMatteo | G | Northern Michigan |
| Akito Hirose | D | Minnesota State |
| Jake Livingstone | D | Minnesota State |
| Arvid Caderoth | F | Michigan Tech |
| Lukas Sillinger | F | Bemidji State |
| Tyrone Bronte | F | Alabama–Huntsville |

#### Rookie Team players by school

| School | Winners |
| Minnesota State | 21 |
| Michigan Tech | 10 |
| Alaska-Anchorage | 9 |
| Northern Michigan | 9 |
| Bowling Green | 7 |
| Bemidji State | 6 |
| Ferris State | 4 |
| Alaska | 3 |
| Lake Superior State | 3 |
| Alabama–Huntsville | 2 |
| School | Winners |
| Minnesota | 25 |
| Colorado College | 19 |
| Wisconsin | 19 |
| North Dakota | 17 |
| Denver | 15 |
| Minnesota-Duluth | 13 |
| St. Cloud State | 11 |