# 2021 College Baseball All-America Team

This is a list of college baseball players named first team All-Americans for the 2021 NCAA Division I baseball season. The NCAA recognizes four different All-America selectors for baseball: the American Baseball Coaches Association (since 1947), Baseball America (since 1981), Collegiate Baseball (since 1991), and the National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association (since 2001).

## Key

| ABCA | American Baseball Coaches Association |
| BA | Baseball America |
| CB | Collegiate Baseball |
| NCBWA | National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association |
| | Consensus All-American (selected by 3 or more selectors) |
| † | Awarded the Golden Spikes Award or Dick Howser Trophy as national Player of the Year |

## All-Americans

| Position | Name | School | ABCA | BA | CB | NCBWA | Notes |
| Starting pitcher | Brendan Beck | Stanford | Y | — | — | — | |
| Starting pitcher | Johnathan Lavallee | Long Beach State | — | — | Y | — | |
| Starting pitcher | Jack Leiter | Vanderbilt | Y | Y | Y | Y | Southeastern Conference Newcomer of the Year |
| Starting pitcher | Matt Mikulski | Fordham | Y | — | — | — | |
| Starting pitcher | Doug Nikhazy | Ole Miss | Y | Y | — | Y | |
| Starting pitcher | Kumar Rocker | Vanderbilt | Y | Y | — | Y | |
| Starting pitcher | Nicholas Sinacola | Maine | — | — | Y | — | America East Conference Pitcher of the Year |
| Starting pitcher | Andrew Taylor | Central Michigan | — | — | — | Y | |
| Starting pitcher | Gavin Williams | East Carolina | Y | Y | Y | Y | American Athletic Conference Player of the Year |
| Relief pitcher | Taylor Broadway | Ole Miss | — | — | — | Y | |
| Relief pitcher | Nick Jones | Georgia Southern | — | — | — | Y | |
| Relief pitcher | Kevin Kopps$^†$ | Arkansas | Y | Y | Y | Y | Southeastern Conference Pitcher of the Year Dick Howser Trophy winner Stopper of the Year Award winner National Pitcher of the Year Award winner Golden Spikes Award winner |
| Relief pitcher | Carson Palmquist | Miami | — | — | — | Y | |
| Relief pitcher | Landon Sims | Mississippi State | — | Y | — | Y | |
| Catcher | Henry Davis | Louisville | Y | Y | — | — | |
| Catcher | Matheu Nelson | Florida State | Y | Y | Y | Y | Atlantic Coast Conference Player of the Year |
| First baseman | Will Frizzell | Texas A&M | Y | — | — | — | |
| First baseman | Tyler Hardman | Oklahoma | Y | — | — | Y | |
| First baseman | Niko Kavadas | Notre Dame | — | Y | — | — | |
| Second baseman | Jace Jung | Texas Tech | — | — | Y | Y | Big 12 Conference Player of the Year |
| Second baseman | Connor Norby | East Carolina | Y | Y | — | — | |
| Third baseman | Christian Encarnacion-Strand | Oklahoma State | — | — | — | Y | |
| Third baseman | Austin Knight | Charlotte | — | — | Y | — | Conference USA Player of the Year |
| Third baseman | Tyler Locklear | VCU | Y | — | — | — | Atlantic 10 Conference Player of the Year |
| Third baseman | Hunter Wells | Louisiana Tech | Y | Y | — | — | |
| Shortstop | Ryan Bliss | Auburn | — | — | — | Y | |
| Shortstop | Brooks Lee | Cal Poly | — | — | Y | — | |
| Shortstop | Trey Sweeney | Eastern Illinois | Y | Y | — | — | |
| Outfielder | Tanner Allen | Mississippi State | Y | Y | Y | Y | Southeastern Conference Player of the Year |
| Outfielder | Enrique Bradfield | Vanderbilt | Y | — | — | Y | |
| Outfielder | Colton Cowser | Sam Houston State | — | Y | — | — | |
| Outfielder | Kyler Fedko | UConn | — | — | — | Y | |
| Outfielder | Quincy Hamilton | Wright State | Y | — | Y | — | Horizon League Player of the Year |
| Outfielder | Mason McWhorter | Georgia Southern | — | — | Y | Y | Sun Belt Conference Player of the Year |
| Outfielder | Donta Williams | Arizona | Y | — | — | — | |
| Outfielder | Aaron Zavala | Oregon | Y | Y | — | Y | |
| Designated hitter | Jacob Berry | Arizona | Y | — | — | Y | |
| Utility player | Spencer Schwellenbach | Nebraska | Y | — | — | — | Big Ten Conference Player of the Year John Olerud Award winner |
| Utility player | Paul Skenes | Air Force | — | Y | — | Y | |