# List of Arizona Coyotes award winners

This is a list of Arizona Coyotes award winners. It also includes players and data from the previous incarnation of the franchise, the original Winnipeg Jets (1972–1996).

## League awards
### Team trophies

The Arizona Coyotes have not won any of the team trophies the National Hockey League (NHL) awards annually — the Stanley Cup as league champions, the Clarence S. Campbell Bowl as Western Conference playoff champions and the Presidents' Trophy as the team with the most regular season points.
Team trophies awarded to the Arizona Coyotes franchise :
| Award | Description | Times won | Seasons | References |
| Avco World Trophy (WHA) | WHA championship | 3 | 1975–76, 1977–78, 1978–79 | |

### Individual awards

Individual awards won by Arizona Coyotes franchise players and staff :
| Award | Description | Winner | Season |
| Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy | Perseverance, sportsmanship and dedication to hockey | Connor Ingram | 2023–24 |
| Calder Memorial Trophy | Rookie of the year | Dale Hawerchuk | 1981–82 |
| Calder Memorial Trophy | Rookie of the year | Teemu Selanne | 1992–93 |
| Dennis A. Murphy Trophy (WHA) | Top defenseman | Lars-Erik Sjoberg | 1977–78 |
| General Manager of the Year Award | Top general manager | Don Maloney | 2009–10 |
| Gordie Howe Trophy (WHA) | Most valuable player | Bobby Hull | 1972–73 |
| Gordie Howe Trophy (WHA) | Most valuable player | Bobby Hull | 1974–75 |
| Howard Baldwin Trophy (WHA) | Coach of the year | Bobby Kromm | 1975–76 |
| Jack Adams Award | Top coach during the regular season | Tom Watt | 1981–82 |
| Jack Adams Award | Top coach during the regular season | Bob Murdoch | 1989–90 |
| Jack Adams Award | Top coach during the regular season | Bobby Francis | 2001–02 |
| Jack Adams Award | Top coach during the regular season | Dave Tippett | 2009–10 |
| King Clancy Memorial Trophy | Leadership qualities on and off the ice and humanitarian contributions within their community | Kris King | 1995–96 |
| King Clancy Memorial Trophy | Leadership qualities on and off the ice and humanitarian contributions within their community | Shane Doan | 2009–10 |
| Lou Kaplan Trophy (WHA) | Rookie of the year | Anders Hedberg | 1974–75 |
| Lou Kaplan Trophy (WHA) | Rookie of the year | Kent Nilsson | 1977–78 |
| Mark Messier Leadership Award | Player who exemplifies leadership on and off the ice | Shane Doan | 2011–12 |
| Paul Deneau Trophy (WHA) | Most gentlemanly player | Kent Nilsson | 1978–79 |
| WHA Playoff MVP (WHA) | Most valuable player of the playoffs | Ulf Nilsson | 1975–76 |
| WHA Playoff MVP (WHA) | Most valuable player of the playoffs | Robert Guindon | 1977–78 |
| WHA Playoff MVP (WHA) | Most valuable player of the playoffs | Rich Preston | 1978–79 |

## All-Stars
### WHA First, Second and Third Team All-Stars

Winnipeg Jets selected to the WHA First, Second and Third Team All-Stars :
| Player | Position | Selections | Season | Team |
| Norm Beaudin | Right wing | 1 | 1972–73 | 3rd |
| Christian Bordeleau | Center | 1 | 1972–73 | 3rd |
| Joe Daley | Goaltender | 2 | 1975–76 | 1st |
| Joe Daley | Goaltender | 2 | 1976–77 | 2nd |
| Anders Hedberg | Right wing | 4 | 1974–75 | 2nd |
| Anders Hedberg | Right wing | 4 | 1975–76 | 1st |
| Anders Hedberg | Right wing | 4 | 1976–77 | 1st |
| Anders Hedberg | Right wing | 4 | 1977–78 | 1st |
| Larry Hornung | Defense | 1 | 1972–73 | 2nd |
| Bobby Hull | Left wing | 5 | 1972–73 | 1st |
| Bobby Hull | Left wing | 5 | 1973–74 | 1st |
| Bobby Hull | Left wing | 5 | 1974–75 | 1st |
| Bobby Hull | Left wing | 5 | 1975–76 | 2nd |
| Bobby Hull | Left wing | 5 | 1977–78 | 2nd |
| Barry Long | Defense | 1 | 1977–78 | 2nd |
| Morris Lukowich | Left wing | 1 | 1978–79 | 2nd |
| Ulf Nilsson | Center | 3 | 1975–76 | 1st |
| Ulf Nilsson | Center | 3 | 1976–77 | 2nd |
| Ulf Nilsson | Center | 3 | 1977–78 | 1st |
| Lars-Erik Sjoberg | Defense | 1 | 1977–78 | 1st |

### NHL first and second team All-Stars

The NHL first and second team All-Stars are the top players at each position as voted on by the Professional Hockey Writers' Association.
Arizona Coyotes franchise players selected to the NHL First and Second Team All-Stars :
| Player | Position | Selections | Season | Team |
| Ilya Bryzgalov | Goaltender | 1 | 2009–10 | 2nd |
| Dale Hawerchuk | Center | 1 | 1984–85 | 2nd |
| Phil Housley | Defense | 1 | 1991–92 | 2nd |
| Teemu Selanne | Right wing | 1 | 1992–93 | 1st |
| Keith Tkachuk | Left wing | 1 | 1994–95 | 2nd |
| Ray Whitney | Left wing | 1 | 2011–12 | 2nd |
| Alexei Zhamnov | Center | 1 | 1994–95 | 2nd |

### NHL All-Rookie Team

The NHL All-Rookie Team consists of the top rookies at each position as voted on by the Professional Hockey Writers' Association.
Arizona Coyotes franchise players selected to the NHL All-Rookie Team :
| Player | Position | Season |
| Logan Cooley | Forward | 2023–24 |
| Iain Duncan | Forward | 1987–88 |
| Bob Essensa | Goaltender | 1989–90 |
| Clayton Keller | Forward | 2017–18 |
| Matias Maccelli | Forward | 2022–23 |
| Boris Mironov | Defense | 1993–94 |
| Teemu Selanne | Forward | 1992–93 |

### All-Star Game selections

Arizona Coyotes franchise players and coaches have participated in the WHA All-Star Game and the NHL All-Star Game.

#### WHA All-Star Game selections

The World Hockey Association all-star game was a mid-season exhibition game, pitting one team of WHA stars against another, held from 1973 to 1978. In 1979, a team of WHA stars played a three-game mid-season series against Dynamo Moscow in lieu of an all-star game.
Winnipeg Jets players and coaches selected to the WHA All-Star Game :
| Game | Year | Name | Position |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Norm Beaudin | Right wing |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Chris Bordeleau | Center |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Larry Hornung | Defense |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Bobby Hull | Left wing & Head coach |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Nick Mickoski | Assistant coach |
| 1972–73 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1973 | Ernie Wakely | Goaltender |
| 1973–74 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1974 | Larry Hornung (Did not play) | Defense |
| 1973–74 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1974 | Fran Huck | Center |
| 1973–74 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1974 | Bobby Hull | Left wing & Head coach |
| 1973–74 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1974 | Nick Mickoski | Assistant coach |
| 1973–74 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1974 | Ernie Wakely | Goaltender |
| 1974–75 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1975 | Joe Daley | Goaltender |
| 1974–75 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1975 | Bobby Hull | Left wing |
| 1974–75 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1975 | Ulf Nilsson | Center |
| 1974–75 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1975 | Lars-Erik Sjoberg | Defense |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Thommie Bergman | Defense |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Joe Daley (Did not play) | Goaltender |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Anders Hedberg | Right wing |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Larry Hornung | Defense |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Bobby Hull | Left wing |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Ulf Nilsson | Center |
| 1975–76 Canadian Division vs. United States Divisions | 1976 | Lars-Erik Sjoberg | Defense |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Thommie Bergman | Defense |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Joe Daley | Goaltender |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Anders Hedberg | Right wing |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Bobby Hull | Left wing |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Bobby Kromm | Head Coach |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Willy Lindström | Right wing |
| 1976–77 Western Disivison vs. Eastern Division | 1977 | Ulf Nilsson | Center |
| 1977–78 WHA All-Stars vs. Quebec Nordiques | 1978 | Anders Hedberg | Right wing |
| 1977–78 WHA All-Stars vs. Quebec Nordiques | 1978 | Bobby Hull | Left wing |
| 1977–78 WHA All-Stars vs. Quebec Nordiques | 1978 | Barry Long | Defense |
| 1977–78 WHA All-Stars vs. Quebec Nordiques | 1978 | Ulf Nilsson | Center |
| 1977–78 WHA All-Stars vs. Quebec Nordiques | 1978 | Lars-Erik Sjoberg | Defense |
| 1978–79 WHA All-Stars vs. Moscow Dynamo | 1979 | Larry Hillman | Head Coach |
| 1978–79 WHA All-Stars vs. Moscow Dynamo | 1979 | Barry Long | Defense |
| 1978–79 WHA All-Stars vs. Moscow Dynamo | 1979 | Morris Lukowich | Left wing |
| 1978–79 WHA All-Stars vs. Moscow Dynamo | 1979 | Markus Mattsson | Goaltender |
| 1978–79 WHA All-Stars vs. Moscow Dynamo | 1979 | Peter Sullivan | Center |

#### NHL All-Star Game selections

The National Hockey League All-Star Game is a mid-season exhibition game held annually between many of the top players of each season. Thirty-three All-Star Games have been held since the Arizona Coyotes entered the NHL as the Winnipeg Jets in 1979, with at least one player chosen to represent the Coyotes in each year except 2003. The All-Star game has not been held in various years: 1979 and 1987 due to the 1979 Challenge Cup and Rendez-vous '87 series between the NHL and the Soviet national team, respectively, 1995, 2005, and 2013 as a result of labor stoppages, 2006, 2010, and 2014 because of the Winter Olympic Games, and 2021 as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The franchise has yet to host one of the games.
* † Selected by fan vote
* ‡ Selected by Commissioner
* ↑ All-Star Game Most Valuable Player
Arizona Coyotes franchise players and coaches selected to the NHL All-Star Game :
| Game | Year | Name | Position |
| 32nd | 1980 | Morris Lukowich | Left wing |
| 33rd | 1981 | Morris Lukowich | Left wing |
| 34th | 1982 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center |
| 35th | 1983 | Dave Babych | Defense |
| 36th | 1984 | Dave Babych | Defense |
| 37th | 1985 | Randy Carlyle | Defense |
| 37th | 1985 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center |
| 37th | 1985 | Paul MacLean | Right wing |
| 38th | 1986 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center |
| 39th | 1988 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center |
| 40th | 1989 | David Ellett | Defense |
| 41st | 1990 | Doug Smail | Left wing |
| 41st | 1990 | Thomas Steen (Did not play) | Center |
| 42nd | 1991 | Phil Housley | Defense |
| 43rd | 1992 | Phil Housley | Defense |
| 44th | 1993 | Randy Carlyle‡ | Defense |
| 44th | 1993 | Phil Housley | Defense |
| 44th | 1993 | Teemu Selanne | Right wing |
| 45th | 1994 | Teemu Selanne | Right wing |
| 46th | 1996 | Teemu Selanne | Right wing |
| 47th | 1997 | Keith Tkachuk | Left wing |
| 47th | 1997 | Oleg Tverdovsky | Defense |
| 48th | 1998 | Nikolai Khabibulin | Goaltender |
| 48th | 1998 | Keith Tkachuk | Left wing |
| 49th | 1999 | Nikolai Khabibulin | Goaltender |
| 49th | 1999 | Teppo Numminen | Defense |
| 49th | 1999 | Jeremy Roenick | Center |
| 49th | 1999 | Jim Schoenfeld | Assistant coach |
| 49th | 1999 | Keith Tkachuk | Left wing |
| 50th | 2000 | Teppo Numminen | Defense |
| 50th | 2000 | Jeremy Roenick | Center |
| 51st | 2001 | Sean Burke | Goaltender |
| 51st | 2001 | Teppo Numminen | Defense |
| 52nd | 2002 | Sean Burke | Goaltender |
| 53rd | 2003 | No Coyotes selected | — |
| 54th | 2004 | Shane Doan | Right wing |
| 55th | 2007 | Ed Jovanovski | Defense |
| 55th | 2007 | Yanic Perreault | Center |
| 56th | 2008 | Ed Jovanovski | Defense |
| 57th | 2009 | Shane Doan | Left wing |
| 58th | 2011 | Keith Yandle | Defense |
| 59th | 2012 | Keith Yandle | Defense |
| 60th | 2015 | Oliver Ekman-Larsson | Defense |
| 61st | 2016 | John Scott†↑ | Left wing |
| 62nd | 2017 | Mike Smith | Goaltender |
| 63rd | 2018 | Oliver Ekman-Larsson | Defense |
| 64th | 2019 | Clayton Keller | Center |
| 65th | 2020 | Darcy Kuemper (Did not play) | Goaltender |
| 65th | 2020 | Rick Tocchet | Head Coach |
| 66th | 2022 | Clayton Keller | Center |
| 67th | 2023 | Clayton Keller | Center |
| 68th | 2024 | Clayton Keller | Center |

### All-Star Game replacement events

Winnipeg Jets players and coaches selected to All-Star Game replacement events :
| Event | Year | Name | Position | References |
| Rendez-vous '87 | 1987 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center | |

## Career achievements
### Hockey Hall of Fame

The following is a list of Arizona Coyotes who have been enshrined in the Hockey Hall of Fame.
Arizona Coyotes franchise players and personnel inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame :
| Individual | Category | Year inducted | Years with Coyotes franchise in category |
| Cliff Fletcher | Builder | 2004 | 2000–2007 |
| Mike Gartner | Player | 2001 | 1996–1998 |
| Dale Hawerchuk | Player | 2001 | 1981–1990 |
| Phil Housley | Player | 2015 | 1990–1993 |
| Bobby Hull | Player | 1983 | 1972–1980 |
| Brett Hull | Player | 2009 | 2005 |
| Serge Savard | Player | 1986 | 1981–1983 |
| Teemu Selanne | Player | 2017 | 1992–1996 |

### Foster Hewitt Memorial Award

One member of the Coyotes organization has been honored with the Foster Hewitt Memorial Award. The award is presented by the Hockey Hall of Fame to members of the radio and television industry who make outstanding contributions to their profession and the game of ice hockey during their broadcasting career.
Members of the Arizona Coyotes honored with the Foster Hewitt Memorial Award :
| Individual | Year honored | Years with Coyotes as broadcaster | References |
| Dave Strader | 2017 | 2007–2011 | |

### Lester Patrick Trophy

The Lester Patrick Trophy has been presented by the National Hockey League and USA Hockey since 1966 to honor a recipient's contribution to ice hockey in the United States. This list includes all personnel who have ever been employed by the Arizona Coyotes in any capacity and have also received the Lester Patrick Trophy.
Members of the Arizona Coyotes franchise honored with the Lester Patrick Trophy :
| Individual | Year honored | Years with Coyotes | References |
| Wayne Gretzky | 1994 | 2000–2009 | |
| Brian Mullen | 1995 | 1982–1987 | |

### United States Hockey Hall of Fame

Members of the Arizona Coyotes franchise inducted into the United States Hockey Hall of Fame :
| Individual | Year inducted | Years with franchise |
| Tony Amonte | 2009 | 2002–2003 |
| Aaron Broten | 2007 | 1991–1992 |
| Dave Christian | 2001 | 1979–1983 |
| Phil Housley | 2004 | 1990–1993 |
| Craig Janney | 2016 | 1996–1998 |
| Ed Olczyk | 2012 | 1990–1992, 1995–1996 |
| Jeremy Roenick | 2010 | 1996–2001, 2006–2007 |
| Mathieu Schneider | 2015 | 2010 |
| Keith Tkachuk | 2011 | 1992–2001 |

### Retired numbers

The Arizona Coyotes have retired one of their jersey numbers. Bobby Hull's number 9 (February 19, 1989) and Thomas Steen's number 25 (May 6, 1995) were retired while the franchise was in Winnipeg. Hull's number was un-retired by his request prior to the 2005–06 season so his son Brett could wear it. Both numbers were returned to circulation during the 2014–15 season. Also out of circulation is the number 99 which was retired league-wide for Wayne Gretzky on February 6, 2000. Gretzky did not play for the Coyotes franchise during his 20-year NHL career and the only player in franchise history to wear the number prior to its league-wide retirement was Rick Dudley during the 1980–81 season.
Arizona Coyotes retired numbers :
| Number | Player | Position | Years with Coyotes franchise as a player | Date of ceremony | References |
| 19 | Shane Doan | Right wing | 1995–2017 | February 24, 2019 | |

### Coyotes' Ring of Honor

Seven numbers are honored via the induction of players into the Coyotes' Ring of Honor. Bobby Hull and Wayne Gretzky, then entering his first season as head coach of the Coyotes, were the first two players inducted into the Coyotes' Ring of Honor on October 8, 2005.
Arizona Coyotes' Ring of Honor :
| Number | Player | Position | Years with Coyotes franchise as a player | Date of ceremony |
| 7 | Keith Tkachuk | Left wing | 1992–2001 | December 23, 2011 |
| 9 | Bobby Hull | Left wing | 1972–1980 | October 8, 2005 |
| 10 | Dale Hawerchuk | Center | 1981–1990 | April 5, 2007 |
| 25 | Thomas Steen | Center | 1981–1995 | January 21, 2006 |
| 27 | Teppo Numminen | Defense | 1988–2003 | January 30, 2010 |
| 97 | Jeremy Roenick | Center | 1996–2001, 2006–2007 | February 11, 2012 |
| 99 | Wayne Gretzky | Center | — | October 8, 2005 |

## Team awards
### Beth Champie Memorial Award

The Beth Champie Memorial Award was an annual award given to the player "who demonstrates the most dedication to the fans throughout the season." It was last awarded in 2011.
* 2007–08 – Derek Morris
* 2008–09 – Shane Doan
* 2009–10 – Keith Yandle
* 2010–11 – Paul Bissonnette

### Jukka Nieminen Memorial Trophy

The Jukka Nieminen Memorial Trophy was an annual award given to the hardest working player as determined by the fans.
* 1996–97 – Dallas Drake
* 1997–98 – Dallas Drake
* 1998–99 – Rick Tocchet
* 1999–00 – Shane Doan
* 2000–01 – Mike Sullivan
* 2001–02 – Shane Doan
* 2002–03 – Shane Doan
* 2003–04 – Cale Hulse
* 2005–06 – Keith Ballard
* 2006–07 – Keith Ballard
* 2007–08 – Shane Doan
* 2008–09 – Zbynek Michalek
* 2009–10 – Vernon Fiddler
* 2010–11 – Lauri Korpikoski
* 2011–12 – Shane Doan
* 2012–13 – Boyd Gordon
* 2013–14 – Antoine Vermette
* 2014–15 – Tobias Rieder
* 2015–16 – Jordan Martinook
* 2016–17 – Jordan Martinook
* 2017–18 – Nick Cousins
* 2018–19 – Niklas Hjalmarsson
* 2019–20 – Conor Garland
* 2020–21 – Conor Garland
* 2021–22 – Liam O'Brien
* 2022–23 – Jack McBain
* 2023–24 – J.J. Moser

### Leading Scorer Award

The Leading Scorer Award was an annual award given to the team's leading scorer during the regular season.
* 1996–97 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1997–98 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1998–99 – Jeremy Roenick
* 1999–00 – Jeremy Roenick
* 2000–01 – Jeremy Roenick
* 2001–02 – Daymond Langkow
* 2002–03 – Mike Johnson
* 2003–04 – Shane Doan
* 2005–06 – Shane Doan
* 2006–07 – Shane Doan
* 2007–08 – Shane Doan
* 2008–09 – Shane Doan
* 2009–10 – Wojtek Wolski
* 2010–11 – Shane Doan
* 2011–12 – Ray Whitney
* 2012–13 – Keith Yandle
* 2013–14 – Keith Yandle
* 2014–15 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2015–16 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2016–17 – Radim Vrbata
* 2017–18 – Clayton Keller
* 2018–19 – Clayton Keller
* 2019–20 – Nick Schmaltz
* 2020–21 – Phil Kessel
* 2021–22 – Clayton Keller
* 2022–23 – Clayton Keller
* 2023–24 – Clayton Keller

### Man of the Year Award

The Man of the Year Award was an annual award given for a player's "dedication, commitment and passion for bettering the lives of those in the community."
* 1996–97 – Kris King
* 1997–98 – Jim McKenzie
* 1998–99 – Jeremy Roenick
* 1999–00 – Jeremy Roenick
* 2000–01 – Brad May
* 2001–02 – Landon Wilson
* 2002–03 – Landon Wilson
* 2003–04 – Shane Doan and Tyson Nash
* 2005–06 – Keith Ballard and Fredrik Sjostrom
* 2006–07 – Josh Gratton
* 2007–08 – Derek Morris
* 2008–09 – Kurt Sauer
* 2009–10 – Jim Vandermeer
* 2010–11 – Vernon Fiddler
* 2011–12 – Jason LaBarbera
* 2012–13 – Paul Bissonnette
* 2013–14 – David Moss
* 2014–15 – Michael Stone
* 2015–16 – Michael Stone
* 2016–17 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2017–18 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2018–19 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2019–20 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2020–21 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2021–22 – Lawson Crouse
* 2022–23 – Travis Boyd
* 2023–24 – Nick Bjugstad

### Team MVP Award

The Team MVP Award was an annual award given to the team's Most Valuable Player as determined by Coyotes broadcast media and beat writers from The Arizona Republic and FoxSportsArizona.com.
* 1996–97 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1997–98 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1998–99 – Nikolai Khabibulin
* 1999–00 – Jeremy Roenick
* 2000–01 – Sean Burke
* 2001–02 – Sean Burke
* 2002–03 – Mike Johnson
* 2003–04 – Shane Doan
* 2005–06 – Curtis Joseph
* 2006–07 – Shane Doan
* 2007–08 – Shane Doan
* 2008–09 – Shane Doan
* 2009–10 – Ilya Bryzgalov
* 2010–11 – Ilya Bryzgalov
* 2011–12 – Mike Smith
* 2012–13 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2013–14 – Antoine Vermette
* 2014–15 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2015–16 – Oliver Ekman-Larsson
* 2016–17 – Radim Vrbata
* 2017–18 – Clayton Keller
* 2018–19 – Darcy Kuemper
* 2019–20 – Darcy Kuemper
* 2020–21 – Jakob Chychrun
* 2021–22 – Clayton Keller
* 2022–23 – Clayton Keller
* 2023–24 – Clayton Keller

### Three-Star Award

The Three-Star Award was an annual award given to the player who earned the most points from Star of the game selections throughout the regular season.
* 1996–97 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1997–98 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1998–99 – Keith Tkachuk
* 1999–00 – Keith Tkachuk
* 2000–01 – Sean Burke
* 2001–02 – Sean Burke
* 2002–03 – Ladislav Nagy
* 2003–04 – Shane Doan
* 2005–06 – Curtis Joseph
* 2006–07 – Shane Doan
* 2007–08 – Ilya Bryzgalov
* 2008–09 – Shane Doan
* 2009–10 – Ilya Bryzgalov
* 2010–11 – Ilya Bryzgalov
* 2011–12 – Mike Smith
* 2012–13 – Mike Smith
* 2013–14 – Mike Smith
* 2014–15 – Mike Smith
* 2015–16 – Shane Doan
* 2016–17 – Mike Smith
* 2017–18 – Clayton Keller
* 2018–19 – Darcy Kuemper
* 2019–20 – Darcy Kuemper
* 2020–21 – Phil Kessel
* 2021–22 – Karel Vejmelka
* 2022–23 – Clayton Keller
* 2023–24 – Connor Ingram