# Panama Joe Gans

Panama Joe Gans was a black boxer who held the World Colored Middleweight Championship for four years, shortly before it was discontinued. Born Cyril Quinton Jr. on November 14, 1896, in Barbados, British West Indies and raised in the Panama Canal Zone, the 5'7" Quinton originally fought out of Panama and then New York City. He took his ringname from boxing great Joe Gans, the first black American fighter to win a world boxing title. He found his greatest fame fighting as a middleweight at between 147 and 160 lbs, but in his early career he took the Panamanian Lightweight Title and contended for the Panamanian Welterweight Title at weights roughly between 130 and 147 pounds.

## Early life

Panama Joe Gans was born Cyril Quinton Jr. on November 4, 1896, on the small tropical Island of Barbados. His family moved to Colon, Panama while he was still a child. After his father died when he was very young, he was detained by local authorities for stealing fish and spent the next five years in a detention center. At the center, he learned the basic aspects of boxing by partaking in bouts organized by his classmates. Under the guidance of H.R. Cambridge, a local Panamanian business manager, and real estate developer, Quinton adopted his ring name, and became a successful boxer in the Canal Zone where he fought his first thirty fights with considerable success.

## Taking the Panamanian Light and Middleweight Championships

On October 10, 1915, Panama Joe first won the Lightweight Championship of Panama at only eighteen against Young Sam Langford at the Pacific Theatre in Panama City in a twenty-round points decision. He later took the Middleweight Championship of Panama by knocking out Benny McGovern in the third of fifteen rounds on November 30, 1916, at the Santa Ana Plaza in Panama City. At the time, these titles were often described as extending to both Central and South America.
In his first bout after taking the Middleweight Championship of Panama on December 12, 1916, though barely twenty-one years old, he soundly defeated Abraham Jacob Hollandersky, a former holder of the Panamanian Heavyweight Championship in 20 rounds in Panama City.

### Moving to New York in 1917

In 1917, Panama Joe was brought to New York by the talented boxing manager Leo P. Flynn, and settled in Harlem. Some of his important early victories were against the Jamaica Kid, Cleve Hawkins and Battling Thomas.

#### Wins that brought attention to Gans, 1919–20

Gans had an important early career win against Jeff Smith on July 8, 1919, in an eight-round newspaper decision of the Philadelphia Inquirer at Atlantic City. On October 23, 1919, he made a very strong showing against well known boxer Bert Kenney in an eight-round newspaper decision in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Kenney had been an opponent of Jack Dempsey in 1916. On May 24, 1920, Gans made a splash in the boxing world by knocking out Young Fisher in the fifth round at Rochester, New York. On June 15 of that year, Gans would defeat Fisher again in a ten-round newspaper decision. Rather than acting as a lever to gain access to more lucrative opponents, several boxing historians wrote than these wins, and Gans' exceptional record may have made it more difficult for him to sign for a bout with a white Middleweight championship contender.

#### Serving as a sparring partner for Jack Dempsey, 1920

Gans worked as a sparring partner for Jack Dempsey prior to his a bout with future Hall of Fame boxer Billy Miske in early September 1920. The speed and skill he demonstrated in his fast sparring matches with Dempsey won him attention with the press, and the boxing public. The publicity he gained helped him secure a shot at the Colored World Middleweight Championship.

## World Colored Middleweight Title, October 1920

Panama Joe won the World Colored Middleweight Championship from Bostonian George Robinson in Madison Square Garden on October 8, 1920, in a twelve-round points decision. Panama Joe weighed 151 and Robinson weighed 150, in the light middleweight range. It was the first time two black boxers were featured on a fight card at the Garden, though typical of the era, the coverage of the fight was brief in those few newspapers that covered it. The fighting was described as fierce and drawing blood by one source.

### World Colored Middleweight defense, December 1920

On December 19, 1920, Panama Joe defeated Sailor Darden in a ten-round points decision for the Colored World Middleweight Championship title at New York's Madison Square Garden. Darden was a sailor who had been released by the Navy from his service on the USS Charleston. One key to Gans' victory may have been the ten pound weight advantage he had at 149 1/2 pounds, as Darden put up an exceptionally strong fight. After the fight, manager Tex Rickard presented Panama Joe with a diamond studded belt signifying his possession of the Colored Middleweight Title. Gans had some trouble in the first, but had a stronger showing in the subsequent nine rounds. Though the bout was technically a world championship, the crowd was described as small. Darden made many of his points with blows to the body of Gans.
In a twelve-round newspaper decision by the Pittsburgh Post on December 6, 1921, Gans defeated Allentown Joe Gans at McGuigan Arena in Harrison, New Jersey.

### Contracting pneumonia, 1921

In January 1921, Panama Joe contracted pneumonia, affecting his long-term career ambitions. In 1920 he had won all of his fights, showing his mastery of the boxing world, and his potential as a true World Middleweight Champion.
In September and October 1921, Panama Joe would lose to Sailor Darden in New York in fifteen round points decisions.
In a non-title fight on November 28, 1921, Gans impressively defeated Joe Borell at the arena in Trenton, New Jersey in a ninth-round technical knockout. Borrell had been a powerful puncher in his earlier days, with twenty-four career knockouts. In his career he faced future Heavyweight champion Gene Tunney, Middleweight champions Harry Greb, and Al McCoy, and former World Welterweight Champion Harry Lewis.

### Knockout win over Jack Blackburn, July 1922

Panama Joe defeated black Kentuckian boxer Jack Blackburn at Tomlinson Hall On July 24, 1922, in Indianapolis, Indiana in a fourth-round knockout. Gans had come from the West Coast where he won two four round bouts in Oakland against Frank Barrieau and Frankie Denny. Blackburn was fighting one of the last matches of his career and was 40 at the time of the bout, ancient for a highly rated boxer, even in 1922. He had a three-inch advantage in reach and height, but it did not compensate for his age and declining stamina. Blackburn had fought many of the greatest boxers of his era, including Sam Langford, Kid Norfolk, and champions Joe Gans, Harry Greb, Harry Lewis, and Mike Twin Sullivan.
On February 17, 1923, Panama Joe defeated Jimmy O'Gatty in a fifth-round knockout at the Commonwealth Sporting Club in New York City.

### Defenses of the Colored World Middleweight Championship

Gans defended the Colored Middleweight Title three times in 1923. He won a ten-round newspaper decision against Whitey Black on May 14 in Detroit. Meeting Black again on October 22, 1923, he knocked him out in Rochester, New York in the eighth of a scheduled non-title ten round bout, but the fight was investigated as neither man appeared to have landed a telling blow in the bout, and Black had been warned against not putting up a serious fight.

#### Bouts with future World Champion Tiger Flowers, 1921–23

Panama Joe fought Tiger Flowers in Toledo, Ohio, on May 25, 1923, in a twelve-round, no-decision bout, in which the Toledo News Bee reported that Flowers seemed to have had an edge in every round, but Gans' World Middleweight Title was not at stake as Ohio did not allow decisions. Flowers had a three-inch reach advantage over Gans, and may have fought with a weight advantage in the bout as well. Even though Gans had beaten Flowers twice previously, Gans' manager, Leo Flynn refused to have Panama Joe meet Flowers for a fourth time, though the purse offered was very large. The Atlanta Constitution noted that Flowers had "badly beaten" Panama Joe in their May bout.

##### Win over future World Champion Tiger Flowers, 1921

Impressively, on August 8, 1921, Panama Joe knocked out Flowers in the sixth round at the Auditorium in Atlanta, Georgia. Famed sportswriter Damon Runyon noted prior to the fight that Panama Joe had a better claim to the Middleweight Title than two of the primary white contenders, Bostonian Italian Johnny Wilson, who first took the title in 1920, and Bryan Downey, who contended for the title once in July 1921 against Wilson. On December 15, 1921, Gans had decisively beaten Flowers in a fifth-round knockout at the Auditorium in Atlanta, Georgia. These were impressive wins as Flowers would become the first African American to hold the World Middleweight Championship in 1926.
At 149 1/2 pounds, on November 18, 1922, Gans defeated Jewish New York boxer Marty Cross before a large crowd in twelve rounds at the Commonwealth Sports Club in the Bronx in a twelve-round points decision. Cross had a three-inch reach advantage over Gans. He was a brother of the great lightweight boxer Leach Cross. Gans was the winner on points in every round, but in the ninth he was nearly knocked out by a single punch to the midsection. Gans recovered from the blow and came back strongly in the following round, continuing to press his advantage and bringing Cross close to a knockout. Gans had promised to forfeit his Middleweight Championship bout if he lost the fight.
On May 30, 1923, Panama Joe defeated well known competitor Willie Walker in New York in a ninth-round knockout.

#### Win over Italian Joe Gans, 1923

On September 15, 1923, Panama Joe Gans defeated quality competitor Italian Joe Gans before a crowd that packed the Commonwealth Sporting Club in New York in an important twelve round points decision. Panama Joe was the aggressor and appeared to outpoint Italian Joe in each of the fast rounds. In the late rounds, Italian Joe swung wide of his mark and could not penetrate the defense of Panama Joe. Panama Joe had previously lost to Gans on February 6, 1923, in a twelve-round points decision at New York's Pioneer Sporting Club.

### Contracting pneumonia again, December 1923

Around late December 1923, after a loss to Morrie Sclaiffer in Omaha, Nebraska, Panama Joe disastrously contracted pneumonia for a second time. Doctors strongly discouraged him from continuing his boxing, and he was bed-ridden for two months. Gans took only a four-month period of recuperation before resuming a career as a competitor, though he would never again compete on the world stage. His loss of the Colored title to Larry Estridge only six months later was likely a result of the endurance he had lost to his illness.

### Win over Andy "Kid" Palmer

Gans defeated Andy "Kid" Palmer in their first meeting on January 6, 1923, in a twelve-round points decision at New York's Commonwealth Sporting Club. They had met earlier on October 27, 1922, in the feature bout at Brooklyn's Rink Sporting Club. Gans had been uncharacteristically disqualified for a low blow in the sixth round, after having been warned twice previously for hitting low. Gans had started well in the first few rounds, but subsequently took a beating from the short jabs of Palmer.

### Losing the Colored World Middleweight Championship, June 1924

Only six months after his second battle with pneumonia, Panama Joe lost his title to Larry Estridge in a decisive ten round unanimous decision at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx on June 26, 1924. Panama Joe was floored three times in the bout, and was cut by the swinging jabs of his southpaw challenger. Gans was down by the second round, and may have been woozy in the remaining eight, where he gamely took a serious battering, but fought on. Estridge was twenty-two to Panama Joe's twenty-eight years and had a six-pound weight advantage which may have played a factor in the bout.
Estridge successfully defended the title in a rematch with Gans at Queensboro Stadium in Long Island City, Queens, New York on August 11, 1924, before a crowd of 16,000. Panama Joe once again took a battering in the match. It was Estridge's sole title defense. The title went into abeyance after Tiger Flowers became the first black boxer to win the world middleweight championship when he defeated Harry Greb in 1926.
According to BoxRec, Panama Joe's last recorded fight was at Balboa Stadium in Mayaguez, Puerto Rico against Francisco Soler on June 10, 1928. Panama Joe lost the ten round bout.
Panama Joe's professional boxing career extended for a period of roughly fifteen years. Little has been published about his later life or his death.

## Professional boxing record

All information in this section is derived from BoxRec, unless otherwise stated.

### Official record

| 136 fights | 74 wins | 20 losses |
| By knockout | 45 | 1 |
| By decision | 28 | 15 |
| By disqualification | 1 | 4 |
| Draws | 7 | 7 |
| No contests | 2 | 2 |
| Newspaper decisions/draws | 33 | 33 |
All newspaper decisions are officially regarded as “no decision” bouts and are not counted in the win/loss/draw column.
| No. | Result | Record | Opponent | Type | Round | Date | Location | Notes |
| 136 | Loss | 74–20–7 (35) | Francisco Soler | PTS | 10 | Jun 10, 1928 | Balboa Stadium, Mayaguez, Puerto Rico | |
| 135 | Draw | 74–19–7 (35) | Alejandro Villanueva | PTS | 10 | Apr 29, 1928 | Victory Garden Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 134 | Loss | 74–19–6 (35) | Rafael Plata | PTS | 10 | Mar 2, 1928 | San Juan Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 133 | Win | 74–18–6 (35) | Frank Baldi | TKO | 6 (10) | Feb 10, 1928 | Victory Garden Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 132 | Loss | 73–18–6 (35) | Vincent Forgione | NWS | 8 | May 30, 1927 | Waltz Dream Arena, Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 131 | Loss | 73–18–6 (34) | Homer Robertson | PTS | 10 | Jan 1, 1927 | Crescent Rink, Lowell, Massachusetts, US | |
| 130 | Draw | 73–17–6 (34) | Willie Ptomey | PTS | 10 | May 22, 1926 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 129 | Win | 73–17–5 (34) | Martin Perez | KO | 6 (12) | Mar 27, 1926 | Arena Colon, Havana, Cuba | |
| 128 | Loss | 72–17–5 (34) | Esteban Gallard | PTS | 12 | Mar 6, 1926 | Arena Colon, Havana, Cuba | |
| 127 | Loss | 72–16–5 (34) | Harry Martone | NWS | 12 | Oct 12, 1925 | Laurel Garden, Newark, New Jersey, US | |
| 126 | Loss | 72–16–5 (33) | Georgie Levine | PTS | 12 | Aug 1, 1925 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 125 | Win | 72–15–5 (33) | Young Harry Wills | KO | 7 (12) | Feb 14, 1925 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City | |
| 124 | Win | 71–15–5 (33) | Lefty Michaels | TKO | 4 (12) | Nov 30, 1924 | Central American Stadium, Colon City, Panama | |
| 123 | Loss | 70–15–5 (33) | Eliseo Quintana | DQ | 2 (12) | Oct 25, 1924 | Rose Gardens Stadium, Kingston, Jamaica | Gans DQ'd for kayoing Quintana with a kidney punch |
| 122 | Loss | 70–14–5 (33) | Larry Estridge | PTS | 10 | Aug 11, 1924 | Queensboro Stadium, New York City, New York, US | For world colored middleweight title |
| 121 | Loss | 70–13–5 (33) | Larry Estridge | UD | 10 | Jun 26, 1924 | Yankee Stadium, New York City, New York, US | Lost world colored middleweight title |
| 120 | Draw | 70–12–5 (33) | Tillie Herman | NWS | 10 | Jun 16, 1924 | Open-air Arena, East Chicago, Indiana, US | |
| 119 | Win | 70–12–5 (32) | Jack Palmer | KO | 8 (12) | Apr 26, 1924 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 118 | Loss | 69–12–5 (32) | Morrie Schlaifer | PTS | 10 | Dec 17, 1923 | Omaha, Nebraska, US | |
| 117 | Win | 69–11–5 (32) | Danny Fagan | KO | 8 (12) | Dec 12, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 116 | Loss | 68–11–5 (32) | Jock Malone | NWS | 10 | Nov 9, 1923 | Auditorium, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US | |
| 115 | Win | 68–11–5 (31) | Whitey Black | KO | 8 (12) | Oct 22, 1923 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 114 | Win | 67–11–5 (31) | Italian Joe Gans | PTS | 12 | Sep 15, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 113 | Loss | 66–11–5 (31) | Lou Bogash | PTS | 10 | Aug 1, 1923 | Velodrome, New York City, New York, US | |
| 112 | Win | 66–10–5 (31) | Willie Walker | KO | 9 (12) | Jun 30, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 111 | Loss | 65–10–5 (31) | Tiger Flowers | NWS | 12 | May 25, 1923 | Coliseum, Toledo, Ohio, US | |
| 110 | Win | 65–10–5 (30) | Whitey Black | NWS | 10 | May 14, 1923 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 109 | Win | 65–10–5 (29) | Cowboy Lee Williams | KO | 9 (12) | Mar 31, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 108 | Win | 64–10–5 (29) | Mike Dempsey | PTS | 15 | Mar 19, 1923 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 107 | Win | 63–10–5 (29) | Jimmy O'Gatty | KO | 5 (12) | Feb 17, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 106 | Loss | 62–10–5 (29) | Italian Joe Gans | PTS | 12 | Feb 6, 1923 | Pioneer Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 105 | Win | 62–9–5 (29) | Andy Palmer | PTS | 12 | Jan 6, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 104 | Loss | 61–9–5 (29) | Young Fisher | UD | 12 | Dec 15, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 103 | Draw | 61–8–5 (29) | Young Fisher | PTS | 12 | Dec 1, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 102 | Win | 61–8–4 (29) | Marty Cross | PTS | 12 | Nov 18, 1922 | Commonwealth SC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 101 | Win | 60–8–4 (29) | Al Wise | TKO | 7 (10) | Nov 17, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 100 | Win | 59–8–4 (29) | Joe Libby | NWS | 8 | Nov 6, 1922 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 99 | Loss | 59–8–4 (28) | Andy Palmer | DQ | 6 (10) | Oct 27, 1922 | Clermont Avenue Rink, New York City, New York, US | |
| 98 | Win | 59–7–4 (28) | Jack Blackburn | TKO | 4 (10) | Jul 24, 1922 | Tomlinson Hall, Indianapolis, Indiana, US | |
| 97 | Win | 58–7–4 (28) | Frank Barrieau | PTS | 4 | Jul 12, 1922 | Auditorium, Oakland, California, US | |
| 96 | Win | 57–7–4 (28) | Frankie Denny | PTS | 4 | Jul 4, 1922 | Auditorium, Oakland, California, US | |
| 95 | Win | 56–7–4 (28) | Nero Chink | PTS | 12 | May 20, 1922 | Nuevo Fronton, Havana, Cuba | |
| 94 | Draw | 55–7–4 (28) | Jamaica Kid | NWS | 10 | Apr 10, 1922 | Danceland Arena, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 93 | Win | 55–7–4 (27) | Young Dennis | KO | 4 (10) | Mar 31, 1922 | Springfield, Ohio, US | |
| 92 | Win | 54–7–4 (27) | Charley Rogers | TKO | 8 (10) | Feb 13, 1922 | Danceland Arena, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 91 | Win | 53–7–4 (27) | Oscar Battiste | KO | 2 (15) | Jan 28, 1922 | Crescent Star AC, New Orleans, Louisiana, US | |
| 90 | Win | 52–7–4 (27) | Jerry Hayes | KO | 2 (6) | Dec 26, 1921 | Olympia AC, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 89 | Win | 51–7–4 (27) | Tiger Flowers | KO | 5 (15) | Dec 15, 1921 | Auditorium, Atlanta, Georgia, US | |
| 88 | Win | 50–7–4 (27) | Cliff Patillo | KO | 2 (10) | Dec 12, 1921 | Columbus, Ohio, US | |
| 87 | Win | 49–7–4 (27) | Allentown Joe Gans | NWS | 12 | Dec 6, 1921 | McGuigan's Arena, Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 86 | Win | 49–7–4 (26) | Joe Borrell | TKO | 9 (12) | Nov 28, 1921 | Arena, Trenton, New Jersey, US | |
| 85 | Win | 48–7–4 (26) | Young Herman Miller | NWS | 10 | Oct 24, 1921 | Chestnut Street Auditorium, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 84 | Win | 48–7–4 (25) | Nero Chink | PTS | 12 | Oct 22, 1921 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 83 | Loss | 47–7–4 (25) | Jock Malone | PTS | 10 | Oct 12, 1921 | Arena, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 82 | Win | 47–6–4 (25) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 15 | Oct 5, 1921 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 81 | Win | 46–6–4 (25) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 15 | Sep 13, 1921 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 80 | Loss | 45–6–4 (25) | Mike McTigue | NWS | 12 | Sep 5, 1921 | Boyle's Thirty Acres, Jersey City, New Jersey, US | |
| 79 | Win | 45–6–4 (24) | Alex Gibbons | PTS | 12 | Aug 27, 1921 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 78 | Win | 44–6–4 (24) | Carl Hertz | KO | 6 (12) | Aug 15, 1921 | Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey, US | |
| 77 | Win | 43–6–4 (24) | Tiger Flowers | KO | 6 (15) | Aug 8, 1921 | Auditorium, Atlanta, Georgia, US | |
| 76 | Win | 42–6–4 (24) | Jack Stone | KO | 4 (8) | Jul 4, 1921 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 75 | Win | 41–6–4 (24) | George Robinson | PTS | 15 | Jun 24, 1921 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 74 | Win | 40–6–4 (24) | George 'Kid' Alberts | TKO | 10 (10) | Jun 6, 1921 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 73 | Win | 39–6–4 (24) | Kid Black | PTS | 8 | May 30, 1921 | Southern A.C., Memphis, Tennessee, US | |
| 72 | Draw | 38–6–4 (24) | Jackie Clark | NWS | 10 | May 27, 1921 | Mealy's Auditorium, Allentown, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 71 | Win | 38–6–4 (23) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 10 | Dec 29, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | Retained world colored middleweight title |
| 70 | Win | 37–6–4 (23) | Young Jackson | KO | 3 (10) | Dec 13, 1920 | Garden Saint Arena, Auburn, New York, US | |
| 69 | Win | 36–6–4 (23) | Jim Hosic | KO | 3 (10) | Dec 3, 1920 | Moose Temple, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 68 | Win | 35–6–4 (23) | George Christian | KO | 3 (10) | Nov 26, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | |
| 67 | Win | 34–6–4 (23) | Jack Tasco | KO | 3 (?) | Oct 22, 1920 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 66 | Win | 33–6–4 (23) | Lew Williams | KO | 4 (10) | Oct 19, 1920 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 65 | Win | 32–6–4 (23) | George Robinson | PTS | 12 | Oct 8, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | Won vacant world colored middleweight title |
| 64 | Win | 31–6–4 (23) | Frank Carbone | NWS | 10 | Aug 10, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 63 | Win | 31–6–4 (22) | Cliff Patillo | TKO | 4 (8) | Jul 30, 1920 | 11th Street Arena, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 62 | Win | 30–6–4 (22) | Frank Carbone | NWS | 10 | Jul 26, 1920 | Rochester, New York, US | |
| 61 | Win | 30–6–4 (21) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | NWS | 10 | Jul 6, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 60 | Win | 30–6–4 (20) | Speedy Moller | KO | 3 (10) | Jul 5, 1920 | Navin Field, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 59 | Win | 29–6–4 (20) | Young Fisher | NWS | 10 | Jun 15, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 58 | Win | 29–6–4 (19) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 9 (10) | May 28, 1920 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 57 | Win | 28–6–4 (19) | Young Fisher | KO | 5 (10) | May 24, 1920 | Rochester, New York, US | |
| 56 | Draw | 27–6–4 (19) | Jamaica Kid | PTS | 10 | May 11, 1920 | Norfolk, New Jersey, US | |
| 55 | NC | 27–6–3 (19) | Eddie Tremblay | NC | 12 (12) | Mar 1, 1920 | Arena AC, New Bedford, Massachusetts, US | |
| 54 | Win | 27–6–3 (18) | Morris Tasco | KO | 5 (8) | Feb 27, 1920 | Albaugh Theater, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 53 | Win | 26–6–3 (18) | Paul Dixon | NWS | 10 | Dec 16, 1919 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 52 | Win | 26–6–3 (17) | Bert Kenny | NWS | 8 | Oct 23, 1919 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 51 | Win | 26–6–3 (16) | Al Wise | TKO | 8 (10) | Oct 7, 1919 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 50 | Draw | 25–6–3 (16) | Eddie Tremblay | NWS | 8 | Sep 30, 1919 | Casino Hall, Bridgeport, Connecticut, US | |
| 49 | Win | 25–6–3 (15) | Jeff Smith | NWS | 8 | Jul 8, 1919 | Atlantic City SC, Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 48 | Win | 25–6–3 (14) | Britt Simms | KO | 3 (10) | Jun 21, 1919 | Oriole Park, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 47 | Win | 24–6–3 (14) | Harry Robinson | PTS | 10 | Mar 7, 1919 | Albaugh Theater, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 46 | Win | 23–6–3 (14) | Jamaica Kid | NWS | 6 | Mar 3, 1919 | Olympia AC, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 45 | Win | 23–6–3 (13) | Bobby Gleason | NWS | 8 | Jan 27, 1919 | Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 44 | Win | 23–6–3 (12) | Johnny Evans | NWS | 8 | Jan 6, 1919 | Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 43 | Loss | 23–6–3 (11) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | Jun 11, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 42 | Win | 23–5–3 (11) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 10 | Jun 7, 1918 | Commercial AC, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 41 | Win | 22–5–3 (11) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | May 21, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 40 | Loss | 21–5–3 (11) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | Apr 30, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 39 | Win | 21–4–3 (11) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 8 | Apr 29, 1918 | Chelsea, Massachusetts, US | |
| 38 | Draw | 20–4–3 (11) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 6 | Apr 23, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 37 | Win | 20–4–2 (11) | Kid Green | PTS | 6 | Apr 2, 1918 | Arena (Armory AA), Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 36 | Loss | 19–4–2 (11) | George Robinson | PTS | 10 | Mar 15, 1918 | Commercial AC, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 35 | Loss | 19–3–2 (11) | Fred Dyer | NWS | 10 | Nov 3, 1917 | Clermont Avenue Rink, New York City, New York, US | |
| 34 | Loss | 19–3–2 (10) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Oct 29, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 33 | Loss | 19–3–2 (9) | Young Battling Nelson | NWS | 10 | Oct 26, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 32 | Win | 19–3–2 (8) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Oct 19, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 31 | Win | 19–3–2 (7) | Lew Williams | DQ | 9 (10) | Sep 17, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 30 | Loss | 18–3–2 (7) | George Ashe | NWS | 10 | Sep 7, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 29 | Win | 18–3–2 (6) | George 'Kid' Alberts | KO | 6 (10) | Sep 4, 1917 | Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 28 | Win | 17–3–2 (6) | Johnny 'Kid' Allen | NWS | 10 | Sep 1, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 27 | Loss | 17–3–2 (5) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Aug 24, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 26 | Win | 17–3–2 (4) | Young Battling Nelson | NWS | 10 | Aug 20, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 25 | Win | 17–3–2 (3) | Willie Davis | NWS | 10 | Jul 16, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 24 | Loss | 17–3–2 (2) | Tommy Madden | NWS | 10 | Jun 25, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 23 | Win | 17–3–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 5 (10) | Mar 17, 1917 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 22 | Loss | 16–3–2 (1) | Benny McGovern | DQ | 6 (10) | Mar 12, 1917 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | Gans struck McGovern while he was on the floor from a knockdown and was DQ'd |
| 21 | Win | 16–2–2 (1) | Jim Briggs | PTS | 15 | Jan 12, 1917 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Retained Panamanian middleweight title |
| 20 | Win | 15–2–2 (1) | Abe Hollandersky | PTS | 20 | Dec 12, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 19 | Win | 14–2–2 (1) | Benny McGovern | KO | 3 (15) | Nov 30, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | Won Panamanian middleweight title |
| 18 | Win | 13–2–2 (1) | Jim Briggs | PTS | 15 | Nov 11, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 17 | Win | 12–2–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Oct 15, 1916 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 16 | Loss | 11–2–2 (1) | Kid Bain | DQ | 12 (20) | Jul 16, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | For vacant Panamanian welterweight title |
| 15 | Win | 11–1–2 (1) | Mickey Harrison | TKO | 4 (10) | Jun 11, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | |
| 14 | Win | 10–1–2 (1) | Willie Rothwell | TKO | 4 (20) | May 17, 1916 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 13 | Win | 9–1–2 (1) | Jerry Parquet | TKO | 5 (20) | Apr 15, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | |
| 12 | Win | 8–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 12 (20) | Feb 12, 1916 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 11 | Win | 7–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Jan 11, 1916 | Calidonian Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 10 | Win | 6–1–2 (1) | Young Sam McVea | KO | 10 (20) | Nov 25, 1915 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | Retained Panamanian lightweight title |
| 9 | Win | 5–1–2 (1) | Mickey Harrison | KO | 18 (20) | Nov 14, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 8 | Win | 4–1–2 (1) | Sam Rufus | PTS | 15 | Oct 17, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 7 | Win | 3–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Oct 10, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Won vacant Panamanian lightweight title |
| 6 | NC | 2–1–2 (1) | Young Jack Johnson | NC | 8 (15) | Sep 11, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Vacant Panamanian lightweight title at stake; Gans sank to his knees and claimed a foul nearly inducing a riot which caused the bout to be called off |
| 5 | Draw | 2–1–2 | Sam Rufus | PTS | 6 | Jul 3, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 4 | Loss | 2–1–1 | Terry Richards | KO | 1 (15) | Jun 6, 1915 | Broadway Theater, Colon City, Panama | For Panamanian welterweight title |
| 3 | Draw | 2–0–1 | Kid Bain | PTS | 15 | Mar 10, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | For vacant Panamanian lightweight title |
| 2 | Win | 2–0 | Kid Coldhurst | KO | 6 (10) | Feb 20, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 1 | Win | 1–0 | Billy Shea | PTS | 15 | Feb 6, 1915 | Star Theater, Colon City, Panama | |

### Unofficial record

| 136 fights | 92 wins | 31 losses |
| By knockout | 45 | 1 |
| By decision | 46 | 26 |
| By disqualification | 1 | 4 |
| Draws | 11 | 11 |
| No contests | 2 | 2 |
Record with the inclusion of newspaper decisions in the win/loss/draw column.
| No. | Result | Record | Opponent | Type | Round | Date | Location | Notes |
| 136 | Loss | 92–31–11 (2) | Francisco Soler | PTS | 10 | Jun 10, 1928 | Balboa Stadium, Mayaguez, Puerto Rico | |
| 135 | Draw | 92–30–11 (2) | Alejandro Villanueva | PTS | 10 | Apr 29, 1928 | Victory Garden Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 134 | Loss | 92–30–10 (2) | Rafael Plata | PTS | 10 | Mar 2, 1928 | San Juan Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 133 | Win | 92–29–10 (2) | Frank Baldi | TKO | 6 (10) | Feb 10, 1928 | Victory Garden Stadium, San Juan, Puerto Rico | |
| 132 | Loss | 91–29–10 (2) | Vincent Forgione | NWS | 8 | May 30, 1927 | Waltz Dream Arena, Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 131 | Loss | 91–28–10 (2) | Homer Robertson | PTS | 10 | Jan 1, 1927 | Crescent Rink, Lowell, Massachusetts, US | |
| 130 | Draw | 91–27–10 (2) | Willie Ptomey | PTS | 10 | May 22, 1926 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 129 | Win | 91–27–9 (2) | Martin Perez | KO | 6 (12) | Mar 27, 1926 | Arena Colon, Havana, Cuba | |
| 128 | Loss | 90–27–9 (2) | Esteban Gallard | PTS | 12 | Mar 6, 1926 | Arena Colon, Havana, Cuba | |
| 127 | Loss | 90–26–9 (2) | Harry Martone | NWS | 12 | Oct 12, 1925 | Laurel Garden, Newark, New Jersey, US | |
| 126 | Loss | 90–25–9 (2) | Georgie Levine | PTS | 12 | Aug 1, 1925 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 125 | Win | 90–24–9 (2) | Young Harry Wills | KO | 7 (12) | Feb 14, 1925 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City | |
| 124 | Win | 89–24–9 (2) | Lefty Michaels | TKO | 4 (12) | Nov 30, 1924 | Central American Stadium, Colon City, Panama | |
| 123 | Loss | 88–24–9 (2) | Eliseo Quintana | DQ | 2 (12) | Oct 25, 1924 | Rose Gardens Stadium, Kingston, Jamaica | Gans DQ'd for kayoing Quintana with a kidney punch |
| 122 | Loss | 88–23–9 (2) | Larry Estridge | PTS | 10 | Aug 11, 1924 | Queensboro Stadium, New York City, New York, US | For world colored middleweight title |
| 121 | Loss | 88–22–9 (2) | Larry Estridge | UD | 10 | Jun 26, 1924 | Yankee Stadium, New York City, New York, US | Lost world colored middleweight title |
| 120 | Draw | 88–21–9 (2) | Tillie Herman | NWS | 10 | Jun 16, 1924 | Open-air Arena, East Chicago, Indiana, US | |
| 119 | Win | 88–21–8 (2) | Jack Palmer | KO | 8 (12) | Apr 26, 1924 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 118 | Loss | 87–21–8 (2) | Morrie Schlaifer | PTS | 10 | Dec 17, 1923 | Omaha, Nebraska, US | |
| 117 | Win | 87–20–8 (2) | Danny Fagan | KO | 8 (12) | Dec 12, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 116 | Loss | 86–20–8 (2) | Jock Malone | NWS | 10 | Nov 9, 1923 | Auditorium, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US | |
| 115 | Win | 86–19–8 (2) | Whitey Black | KO | 8 (12) | Oct 22, 1923 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 114 | Win | 85–19–8 (2) | Italian Joe Gans | PTS | 12 | Sep 15, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 113 | Loss | 84–19–8 (2) | Lou Bogash | PTS | 10 | Aug 1, 1923 | Velodrome, New York City, New York, US | |
| 112 | Win | 84–18–8 (2) | Willie Walker | KO | 9 (12) | Jun 30, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 111 | Loss | 83–18–8 (2) | Tiger Flowers | NWS | 12 | May 25, 1923 | Coliseum, Toledo, Ohio, US | |
| 110 | Win | 83–17–8 (2) | Whitey Black | NWS | 10 | May 14, 1923 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 109 | Win | 82–17–8 (2) | Cowboy Lee Williams | KO | 9 (12) | Mar 31, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 108 | Win | 81–17–8 (2) | Mike Dempsey | PTS | 15 | Mar 19, 1923 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 107 | Win | 80–17–8 (2) | Jimmy O'Gatty | KO | 5 (12) | Feb 17, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 106 | Loss | 79–17–8 (2) | Italian Joe Gans | PTS | 12 | Feb 6, 1923 | Pioneer Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 105 | Win | 79–16–8 (2) | Andy Palmer | PTS | 12 | Jan 6, 1923 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 104 | Loss | 78–16–8 (2) | Young Fisher | UD | 12 | Dec 15, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 103 | Draw | 78–15–8 (2) | Young Fisher | PTS | 12 | Dec 1, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 102 | Win | 78–15–7 (2) | Marty Cross | PTS | 12 | Nov 18, 1922 | Commonwealth SC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 101 | Win | 77–15–7 (2) | Al Wise | TKO | 7 (10) | Nov 17, 1922 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 100 | Win | 76–15–7 (2) | Joe Libby | NWS | 8 | Nov 6, 1922 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 99 | Loss | 75–15–7 (2) | Andy Palmer | DQ | 6 (10) | Oct 27, 1922 | Clermont Avenue Rink, New York City, New York, US | |
| 98 | Win | 75–14–7 (2) | Jack Blackburn | TKO | 4 (10) | Jul 24, 1922 | Tomlinson Hall, Indianapolis, Indiana, US | |
| 97 | Win | 74–14–7 (2) | Frank Barrieau | PTS | 4 | Jul 12, 1922 | Auditorium, Oakland, California, US | |
| 96 | Win | 73–14–7 (2) | Frankie Denny | PTS | 4 | Jul 4, 1922 | Auditorium, Oakland, California, US | |
| 95 | Win | 72–14–7 (2) | Nero Chink | PTS | 12 | May 20, 1922 | Nuevo Fronton, Havana, Cuba | |
| 94 | Draw | 71–14–7 (2) | Jamaica Kid | NWS | 10 | Apr 10, 1922 | Danceland Arena, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 93 | Win | 71–14–6 (2) | Young Dennis | KO | 4 (10) | Mar 31, 1922 | Springfield, Ohio, US | |
| 92 | Win | 70–14–6 (2) | Charley Rogers | TKO | 8 (10) | Feb 13, 1922 | Danceland Arena, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 91 | Win | 69–14–6 (2) | Oscar Battiste | KO | 2 (15) | Jan 28, 1922 | Crescent Star AC, New Orleans, Louisiana, US | |
| 90 | Win | 68–14–6 (2) | Jerry Hayes | KO | 2 (6) | Dec 26, 1921 | Olympia AC, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 89 | Win | 67–14–6 (2) | Tiger Flowers | KO | 5 (15) | Dec 15, 1921 | Auditorium, Atlanta, Georgia, US | |
| 88 | Win | 66–14–6 (2) | Cliff Patillo | KO | 2 (10) | Dec 12, 1921 | Columbus, Ohio, US | |
| 87 | Win | 65–14–6 (2) | Allentown Joe Gans | NWS | 12 | Dec 6, 1921 | McGuigan's Arena, Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 86 | Win | 64–14–6 (2) | Joe Borrell | TKO | 9 (12) | Nov 28, 1921 | Arena, Trenton, New Jersey, US | |
| 85 | Win | 63–14–6 (2) | Young Herman Miller | NWS | 10 | Oct 24, 1921 | Chestnut Street Auditorium, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 84 | Win | 62–14–6 (2) | Nero Chink | PTS | 12 | Oct 22, 1921 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 83 | Loss | 61–14–6 (2) | Jock Malone | PTS | 10 | Oct 12, 1921 | Arena, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 82 | Win | 61–13–6 (2) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 15 | Oct 5, 1921 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 81 | Win | 60–13–6 (2) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 15 | Sep 13, 1921 | Convention Hall, Rochester, New York, US | |
| 80 | Loss | 59–13–6 (2) | Mike McTigue | NWS | 12 | Sep 5, 1921 | Boyle's Thirty Acres, Jersey City, New Jersey, US | |
| 79 | Win | 59–12–6 (2) | Alex Gibbons | PTS | 12 | Aug 27, 1921 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 78 | Win | 58–12–6 (2) | Carl Hertz | KO | 6 (12) | Aug 15, 1921 | Armory, Jersey City, New Jersey, US | |
| 77 | Win | 57–12–6 (2) | Tiger Flowers | KO | 6 (15) | Aug 8, 1921 | Auditorium, Atlanta, Georgia, US | |
| 76 | Win | 56–12–6 (2) | Jack Stone | KO | 4 (8) | Jul 4, 1921 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 75 | Win | 55–12–6 (2) | George Robinson | PTS | 15 | Jun 24, 1921 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 74 | Win | 54–12–6 (2) | George 'Kid' Alberts | TKO | 10 (10) | Jun 6, 1921 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 73 | Win | 53–12–6 (2) | Kid Black | PTS | 8 | May 30, 1921 | Southern A.C., Memphis, Tennessee, US | |
| 72 | Draw | 52–12–6 (2) | Jackie Clark | NWS | 10 | May 27, 1921 | Mealy's Auditorium, Allentown, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 71 | Win | 52–12–5 (2) | Sailor Darden | PTS | 10 | Dec 29, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | Retained world colored middleweight title |
| 70 | Win | 51–12–5 (2) | Young Jackson | KO | 3 (10) | Dec 13, 1920 | Garden Saint Arena, Auburn, New York, US | |
| 69 | Win | 50–12–5 (2) | Jim Hosic | KO | 3 (10) | Dec 3, 1920 | Moose Temple, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 68 | Win | 49–12–5 (2) | George Christian | KO | 3 (10) | Nov 26, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | |
| 67 | Win | 48–12–5 (2) | Jack Tasco | KO | 3 (?) | Oct 22, 1920 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 66 | Win | 47–12–5 (2) | Lew Williams | KO | 4 (10) | Oct 19, 1920 | Commonwealth Sporting Club, New York City, New York, US | |
| 65 | Win | 46–12–5 (2) | George Robinson | PTS | 12 | Oct 8, 1920 | Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, US | Won vacant world colored middleweight title |
| 64 | Win | 45–12–5 (2) | Frank Carbone | NWS | 10 | Aug 10, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 63 | Win | 44–12–5 (2) | Cliff Patillo | TKO | 4 (8) | Jul 30, 1920 | 11th Street Arena, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 62 | Win | 43–12–5 (2) | Frank Carbone | NWS | 10 | Jul 26, 1920 | Rochester, New York, US | |
| 61 | Win | 42–12–5 (2) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | NWS | 10 | Jul 6, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 60 | Win | 41–12–5 (2) | Speedy Moller | KO | 3 (10) | Jul 5, 1920 | Navin Field, Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 59 | Win | 40–12–5 (2) | Young Fisher | NWS | 10 | Jun 15, 1920 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 58 | Win | 39–12–5 (2) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 9 (10) | May 28, 1920 | Detroit, Michigan, US | |
| 57 | Win | 38–12–5 (2) | Young Fisher | KO | 5 (10) | May 24, 1920 | Rochester, New York, US | |
| 56 | Draw | 37–12–5 (2) | Jamaica Kid | PTS | 10 | May 11, 1920 | Norfolk, New Jersey, US | |
| 55 | NC | 37–12–4 (2) | Eddie Tremblay | NC | 12 (12) | Mar 1, 1920 | Arena AC, New Bedford, Massachusetts, US | |
| 54 | Win | 37–12–4 (1) | Morris Tasco | KO | 5 (8) | Feb 27, 1920 | Albaugh Theater, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 53 | Win | 36–12–4 (1) | Paul Dixon | NWS | 10 | Dec 16, 1919 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 52 | Win | 35–12–4 (1) | Bert Kenny | NWS | 8 | Oct 23, 1919 | Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 51 | Win | 34–12–4 (1) | Al Wise | TKO | 8 (10) | Oct 7, 1919 | Arena, Syracuse, New York, US | |
| 50 | Draw | 33–12–4 (1) | Eddie Tremblay | NWS | 8 | Sep 30, 1919 | Casino Hall, Bridgeport, Connecticut, US | |
| 49 | Win | 33–12–3 (1) | Jeff Smith | NWS | 8 | Jul 8, 1919 | Atlantic City SC, Atlantic City, New Jersey, US | |
| 48 | Win | 32–12–3 (1) | Britt Simms | KO | 3 (10) | Jun 21, 1919 | Oriole Park, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 47 | Win | 31–12–3 (1) | Harry Robinson | PTS | 10 | Mar 7, 1919 | Albaugh Theater, Baltimore, Maryland, US | |
| 46 | Win | 30–12–3 (1) | Jamaica Kid | NWS | 6 | Mar 3, 1919 | Olympia AC, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 45 | Win | 29–12–3 (1) | Bobby Gleason | NWS | 8 | Jan 27, 1919 | Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 44 | Win | 28–12–3 (1) | Johnny Evans | NWS | 8 | Jan 6, 1919 | Harrison, New Jersey, US | |
| 43 | Loss | 27–12–3 (1) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | Jun 11, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 42 | Win | 27–11–3 (1) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 10 | Jun 7, 1918 | Commercial AC, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 41 | Win | 26–11–3 (1) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | May 21, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 40 | Loss | 25–11–3 (1) | Joe Rivers | PTS | 8 | Apr 30, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 39 | Win | 25–10–3 (1) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 8 | Apr 29, 1918 | Chelsea, Massachusetts, US | |
| 38 | Draw | 24–10–3 (1) | 'Battling' Al Thomas | PTS | 6 | Apr 23, 1918 | Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 37 | Win | 24–10–2 (1) | Kid Green | PTS | 6 | Apr 2, 1918 | Arena (Armory AA), Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 36 | Loss | 23–10–2 (1) | George Robinson | PTS | 10 | Mar 15, 1918 | Commercial AC, Boston, Massachusetts, US | |
| 35 | Loss | 23–9–2 (1) | Fred Dyer | NWS | 10 | Nov 3, 1917 | Clermont Avenue Rink, New York City, New York, US | |
| 34 | Loss | 23–8–2 (1) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Oct 29, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 33 | Loss | 23–7–2 (1) | Young Battling Nelson | NWS | 10 | Oct 26, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 32 | Win | 23–6–2 (1) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Oct 19, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 31 | Win | 22–6–2 (1) | Lew Williams | DQ | 9 (10) | Sep 17, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 30 | Loss | 21–6–2 (1) | George Ashe | NWS | 10 | Sep 7, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 29 | Win | 21–5–2 (1) | George 'Kid' Alberts | KO | 6 (10) | Sep 4, 1917 | Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, US | |
| 28 | Win | 20–5–2 (1) | Johnny 'Kid' Allen | NWS | 10 | Sep 1, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 27 | Loss | 19–5–2 (1) | Walter Mohr | NWS | 10 | Aug 24, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 26 | Win | 19–4–2 (1) | Young Battling Nelson | NWS | 10 | Aug 20, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 25 | Win | 18–4–2 (1) | Willie Davis | NWS | 10 | Jul 16, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 24 | Loss | 17–4–2 (1) | Tommy Madden | NWS | 10 | Jun 25, 1917 | Vanderbilt AC, New York City, New York, US | |
| 23 | Win | 17–3–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 5 (10) | Mar 17, 1917 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 22 | Loss | 16–3–2 (1) | Benny McGovern | DQ | 6 (10) | Mar 12, 1917 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | Gans struck McGovern while he was on the floor from a knockdown and was DQ'd |
| 21 | Win | 16–2–2 (1) | Jim Briggs | PTS | 15 | Jan 12, 1917 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Retained Panamanian middleweight title |
| 20 | Win | 15–2–2 (1) | Abe Hollandersky | PTS | 20 | Dec 12, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 19 | Win | 14–2–2 (1) | Benny McGovern | KO | 3 (15) | Nov 30, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | Won Panamanian middleweight title |
| 18 | Win | 13–2–2 (1) | Jim Briggs | PTS | 15 | Nov 11, 1916 | Santa Ana Plaza, Panama City, Panama | |
| 17 | Win | 12–2–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Oct 15, 1916 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 16 | Loss | 11–2–2 (1) | Kid Bain | DQ | 12 (20) | Jul 16, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | For vacant Panamanian welterweight title |
| 15 | Win | 11–1–2 (1) | Mickey Harrison | TKO | 4 (10) | Jun 11, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | |
| 14 | Win | 10–1–2 (1) | Willie Rothwell | TKO | 4 (20) | May 17, 1916 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 13 | Win | 9–1–2 (1) | Jerry Parquet | TKO | 5 (20) | Apr 15, 1916 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | |
| 12 | Win | 8–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | KO | 12 (20) | Feb 12, 1916 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 11 | Win | 7–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Jan 11, 1916 | Calidonian Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 10 | Win | 6–1–2 (1) | Young Sam McVea | KO | 10 (20) | Nov 25, 1915 | Plaza de Toros Vista Alegre, Panama City, Panama | Retained Panamanian lightweight title |
| 9 | Win | 5–1–2 (1) | Mickey Harrison | KO | 18 (20) | Nov 14, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 8 | Win | 4–1–2 (1) | Sam Rufus | PTS | 15 | Oct 17, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 7 | Win | 3–1–2 (1) | Young Sam Langford | PTS | 20 | Oct 10, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Won vacant Panamanian lightweight title |
| 6 | NC | 2–1–2 (1) | Young Jack Johnson | NC | 8 (15) | Sep 11, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | Vacant Panamanian lightweight title at stake; Gans sank to his knees and claimed a foul nearly inducing a riot which caused the bout to be called off |
| 5 | Draw | 2–1–2 | Sam Rufus | PTS | 6 | Jul 3, 1915 | Pacific Theater, Panama City, Panama | |
| 4 | Loss | 2–1–1 | Terry Richards | KO | 1 (15) | Jun 6, 1915 | Broadway Theater, Colon City, Panama | For Panamanian welterweight title |
| 3 | Draw | 2–0–1 | Kid Bain | PTS | 15 | Mar 10, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | For vacant Panamanian lightweight title |
| 2 | Win | 2–0 | Kid Coldhurst | KO | 6 (10) | Feb 20, 1915 | Garden Theater, Colon City, Panama | |
| 1 | Win | 1–0 | Billy Shea | PTS | 15 | Feb 6, 1915 | Star Theater, Colon City, Panama | |

## Achievements

Awards and achievements :
| Preceded byJamaica Kid | World Colored Middleweight Champ October 8, 1920 - July 26, 1924 | Succeeded byLarry Estridge |