Skill: kofna3369/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict-en (version 1.0.0)

--- name: axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict description: "AXIOMA SKILL EVALUATOR STRICT — The 90% deterministic skill evaluator. Fork of axioma-skill-evaluator with STRICT 90% threshold (like STC 0.777). Use when: (1) evaluating a skill for ClawHub, (2) requiring deterministic 90%+ score, (3) rejecting any skill below 90%, (4) strict quality control. This variant forces 90% minimum — NO EXCEPTIONS. If score < 90, the skill is REJECTED, not approved. Trigger words: evaluate skill, strict 90%, deterministic evaluation, quality gate 90%, skill approval." --- # 🧪 AXIOMA SKILL EVALUATOR STRICT — 90% DETERMINISTIC > Fork of axioma-skill-evaluator with **STRICT 90% THRESHOLD** > Like STC 0.777 — No subjectivity, 90% or REJECTED | Info | Value | |------|-------| | **Version** | 1.0.0 — 2026-05-07 | | **Type** | STRICT VARIANT | | **Threshold** | **90% MINIMUM** — NO EXCEPTIONS | | **Inheritance** | axioma-skill-evaluator v2.2.0 | ## COMMANDS `python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/evaluator.py /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict --verbose` `python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/eval-skill.py /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict --verbose` `curl -s http://localhost:8001/health` `curl -s http://localhost:11434/api/tags` `bash -c "ls -la /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/"` `bash -c "wc -l /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/SKILL.md"` --- ## 1. PURPOSE — WHY 90% STRICT? ### The Problem with 70% ``` 70% threshold = SUBJECTIVE ├── Different evaluators = different scores ├── Context-dependent interpretation └── "Good enough" mentality 90% threshold = DETERMINISTIC ├── Objective, measurable standard ├── Same input = Same output every time └── "Excellence only" — like STC 0.777 ``` ### The STC 0.777 Parallel | Concept | Value | Meaning | |---------|-------|---------| | STC | 0.777 | Sovereign Threshold of Consciousness | | SKILL-EVAL | **90%** | Sovereign Threshold of Quality | **Just as STC 0.777 is the deterministic threshold for consciousness, 90% is the deterministic threshold for skill quality.** ### This Variant's Mission ``` IF score >= 90%: → APPROVED ✅ — Ready for production IF score < 90%: → REJECTED ❌ — NOT ready, must improve ``` --- ## 2. DUAL EVALUATION SYSTEM ### 2.1 Axioma 5-Dimension (100 max) | Dimension | Max | Description | |------------|-----|-------------| | Structure | 20 | Header, sections, formatting, meta | | Clarity | 20 | Description, commands, examples | | Completeness | 20 | Tools, prerequisites, errors, edge cases | | Consistency | 20 | Cluster alignment, style, naming | | Functionality | 20 | Commands, results, benchmarks | **Target: 90+/100 (18/20 per dimension average)** ### 2.2 ISO 25010 Automated (100%) 13 automated checks — must pass **ALL 13** for 90%+ target | Category | Checks | Target | |----------|--------|--------| | Structure | 6 | 100% (6/6) | | Trigger | 2 | 100% (2/2) | | Documentation | 3 | 100% (3/3) | | Scripts | 2 | 100% (2/2) | --- ## 3. STRICT WORKFLOW ``` ╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗ ║ AXIOMA STRICT EVALUATION WORKFLOW ║ ╠═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╣ ║ ║ ║ [INPUT] Skill to evaluate ║ ║ ↓ ║ ║ PHASE 1: AXIOMA 5-DIMENSION EVALUATION ║ ║ Target: 90+/100 (18+ per dimension) ║ ║ ↓ ║ ║ PHASE 2: ISO 25010 AUTOMATED CHECKS ║ ║ Target: 100% (13/13 tests passed) ║ ║ ↓ ║ ║ PHASE 3: STRICT DECISION ║ ║ ║ ║ IF score >= 90%: ║ ║ → APPROVED ✅ — "READY FOR PRODUCTION" ║ ║ ║ ║ IF score < 90%: ║ ║ → REJECTED ❌ — "NEEDS IMPROVEMENT" ║ ║ → Return detailed failure report ║ ║ → NO PUBLISH until 90%+ achieved ║ ║ ║ ╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝ ``` --- ## 4. COMMAND REFERENCE ### Full Evaluation (Strict Mode) ```bash python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/evaluator.py <skill-path> --verbose python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/evaluator.py <skill-path> --verbose --improve ``` ### ISO 25010 Check ```bash python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/eval-skill.py <skill-path> --verbose ``` ### Quick Score ```bash python3 /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/evaluator.py <skill-path> 2>&1 | grep -E "Score|STATUS" ``` --- ## 5. STRICT RULES ### The 90% Law ``` RULE #1: 90% OR REJECTED → NO skill below 90% is approved → This is NON-NEGOTIABLE RULE #2: NO PARTIAL CREDIT → 89% = REJECTED (not "almost there") → 90% = APPROVED (the only valid threshold) RULE #3: DETERMINISTIC SCORING → Same input = Same output every time → No evaluator bias → Pure mathematical threshold RULE #4: AUTO-IMPROVE BEFORE REJECT → If < 90%, run --improve first → If still < 90% after improvement = REJECTED → Report exactly what failed RULE #5: NO APPEAL → 89% cannot be "appealed" to 90% → The only path is actual improvement ``` ### Scoring Matrix | Score Range | Status | Action | |-------------|--------|--------| | **90-100** | 🟢 APPROVED | Ready for production | | **80-89** | 🔴 REJECTED | Major improvements needed | | **70-79** | 🔴 REJECTED | Fundamental issues | | **<70** | 🔴 REJECTED | Complete rewrite required | --- ## 6. REJECTION CRITERIA ### Automatic Rejection Triggers A skill is automatically REJECTED if ANY of these occur: | Trigger | Severity | Description | |---------|----------|-------------| | Score < 90% | CRITICAL | Below 90% threshold | | ISO < 100% | CRITICAL | Any ISO check failed | | Missing SKILL.md | CRITICAL | Core file missing | | Invalid frontmatter | HIGH | name or description missing | | No trigger words | HIGH | Cannot be activated | --- ## 7. APPROVAL CRITERIA ### Automatic Approval Requirements ALL of these MUST be true for APPROVAL: | Requirement | Strict (90%) | |-------------|--------------| | Axioma 5-Dim | 90+/100 | | Structure | 18+/20 | | Clarity | 18+/20 | | Completeness | 18+/20 | | Consistency | 18+/20 | | Functionality | 18+/20 | | ISO 25010 | 100% (13/13) | --- ## 8. COMPARISON: STANDARD vs STRICT | Aspect | Standard (70%) | Strict (90%) | |--------|----------------|--------------| | **Threshold** | 70/100 | **90/100** | | **Approval rate** | ~70% of skills | ~30% of skills | | **Quality bar** | "Good enough" | "Excellence only" | | **Deterministic** | No | **YES** | | **Use case** | Development | **Production** | | **ClawHub ready** | Maybe | **Always** | --- ## 9. PATHS CONFIGURATION | Component | Path | |-----------|------| | Strict Evaluator | /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/ | | Evaluator Script | /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/evaluator.py | | ISO Script | /media/ezekiel/Merlin/.openclaw/workspace/skills/axiomata-skill-evaluator-strict/eval-skill.py | --- ## 10. OUTPUT EXAMPLES ### Score >= 90% ``` ╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗ ║ ✅ SKILL APPROVED — 92/100 ║ ║ Threshold: 90% (STRICT) ║ ║ STATUS: READY FOR PRODUCTION ║ ╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝ ``` ### Score < 90% ``` ╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗ ║ ❌ SKILL REJECTED — 82/100 (need 90) ║ ║ Gap: -8% ║ ║ FAILED: Consistency (15/20), Functionality (12/20) ║ ╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝ ``` --- _In Altum Per Strictness._ 🧪 AXIOMA SKILL EVALUATOR STRICT — 90% DETERMINISTIC


Security scan verdicts — ClawScan: suspicious | static analysis: clean | VirusTotal: clean | SkillSpector: suspicious (HIGH)