UESPWiki:Archive/CP Task List

Task List

I'd like to create a useful Task List page for the entire community to use.  My impression is that a lot of new editors would like to contribute, but don't know what needs to be done (other than spellchecking and cleanup, which isn't everyone's favorite job).  On the other hand, I'm pretty sure that most of the experienced editors have lengthy lists of jobs that they think could be done (or at least, I know I do!).  It seems like there should be some easy way to share that information.  I've tried to reorganize the Task List page so that it can fulfill that purpose.

One reason I'm bringing this up now is that the huge interest in adding pages describing Shivering Isles seems to confirm that there were a lot of editors who wanted to add to the site, but just didn't know what needed to be done.  And I'm guessing in a few weeks some of the Shivering Isles momentum will wane, once the obvious red links and empty quest pages have been filled in.  I think having an idea list in place at that time will be useful, so that some of the new editors can find other things to work on if they're interested.  Also, it will be worthwhile having a way to start to keep track of remaining Shivering Isles-related tasks.

For the Task List page to work, though, it really needs to be something that editors other than just me find useful ;)  So I'd really like to get feedback from everyone on how to make this as useful as possible.
Does anyone else think that a Task List page is worthwhile?  In particular, are there really editors who'd like ideas on what needs to be done?  If I've misjudged the situation, then it's probably not worth pursuing this idea.
Are the types of ideas that are currently listed on the page useful?  Is there enough info for editors to get a basic idea of whether or not it's something interesting?  Are these ideas the types of projects that editors would like to know about?  Or should the page be taken in some other direction?
How detailed should the tasks be?  This is one that I've struggled with somewhat: I don't want it to be an hour-long task just to add an idea to the page, because most editors won't want to put that type of time into writing up an idea, especially if they're not sure anyone else will want to follow through on it.  But it also needs to be possible for someone else to figure out what actually needs to be done.  So I've tried to compromise: allow the descriptions to be brief, and then encourage people to ask for more details.  When someone asks, anyone with ideas about the details can step in and answer the question.  I know from my point of view, I'm much more willing to spend the time on details if I know someone is interested in hearing about them.
Do other editors have ideas that they'd like to add to the page?  Is it fairly straightforward to add an idea?
I see the current page just as a starting point to give everyone some idea what I'm talking about.  Any ideas about how to improve it are welcome! --Nephele 18:32, 3 April 2007 (EDT)

:This page looks like a good way to get people involved in the site and should point editors in the right direction. However, I think many will find themselves lost when it comes to actually do the edits, as there isn't a clear procedure on how to proceed or project organisation for most of the tasks. What I mean is that we lack the organisation of projects like the Morrowind Redesign Project, which takes editors almost step by step on what needs to be done on certain pages. If more of these projects were created, I beleive it will be clearer to editors what to do. --DrPhoton 03:21, 4 April 2007 (EDT)

::Good point.  A few of the tasks could be fleshed out more so that it's easier for any editor to pick them up.  In particular, the Tamriel:Books and Tamriel:Dictionary suggestions really amount to converting those pages to a standard format.  A style guide describing the format really needs to be written, in which case those tasks could basically just link to the style guide.  And I think having more projects would be great... if someone is willing to take the time to provide the detailed procedures.

::But then the question that comes to mind is, should the Task List page be limited to only those tasks that include clear instructions on what needs to be done?  My feeling is that no, it shouldn't.  I think if it's limited to only be fully-fleshed out projects then basically nobody will ever want to add tasks to the page.  For example, a couple of the tasks that I added are suggestions made on talk pages (Sigil Stones, House Upgrades).  While I'm patrolling recent edits, it's not a big deal to add a one-line description of any such suggestions with a link.  But if I have to fully research what needs to be done and write it all out, I know I basically won't want to go to the trouble: if I spend that much time on it, I might as well just do the whole thing myself.  For a lot of shorter tasks, I don't think they lend themselves to being turned into full projects.  But having a central list of such tasks is still useful, I think, even if the number of editors who might know how to pick them up is more limited.  --Nephele 16:57, 5 April 2007 (EDT)