gutterguard-and-coingrinder-simulation-results-

# GutterGuard and CoinGrinder Simulation results

murch | 2023-12-21 22:22:05 UTC | #1

This post compares results of coin selection simulations on `master`, GutterGuard ([#28977](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/28977)) and CoinGrinder ([#27877](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/27877)) branches.

# Status Quo

Bitcoin Core currently uses multiple coin selection algorithms to generate input set candidates, and then uses the _[waste metric](https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/q/113622/5406)_ to select the input set candidate with the best (lowest) waste score. The algorithms in use are _Knapsack_, _Single Random Draw (SRD)_, and _Branch and Bound (BnB)_.

### Knapsack
Generally will produce an input set that causes the transaction to have a change output. It uses a subprocess that performs a multitude of random walks over the wallet’s UTXO pool and keeps the input set that minimizes the overshoot past `selection_target plus minimum_change`. Knapsack will return a changeless input set if it finds an input set that matches the `selection_target` to the satoshi.

- [+] Always finds a solution if there are sufficient funds
- [-] Very slow for large UTXO pools due to iterating over entire set multiple times
- [-] Optimizes for subordinate goal "minimal funds-in-flight"
- [-] Convoluted approach that gives an undeserved impression of sophistication
- [-] Almost always creates change
- [±] Aggressively selects UTXOs with small amounts

### SRD
Picks random entries from the UTXO pool until it can fund the transaction.

- [+] Always finds a solution if there are sufficient funds
- [+] Fast
- [+] Simple to understand
- [±] Unpredictable input set size
- [-] Always creates Change

### BnB
Deterministically searches the entire combination space of the UTXO pool for input sets that avoid creation of change. Keeps input set with best waste score if multiple input sets are found.

- [++] Avoids change output
- [+] Prefers least wasteful solution if there are multiple solutions
- [+] Efficient search algorithm with iteration limit works well even on large UTXO pool
- [-] Does not always find a solution

### Selection from input set candidates
The above algorithms are run separately on each type of UTXOs the wallet has. E.g. if you have P2PKH and P2WPKH inputs, each algorithm is run for each of the types. (If neither type of output can raise sufficient funds, a later back-off step allows combination of types.) The overarching function later picks the least wasteful input set across all candidates which usually results in reasonably thrifty input sets for high feerates, and somewhat heavier input sets at low feerates.

### Failure Scenarios

Users have raised issues when the above coin selection process produced extremely wasteful transactions. E.g. in one case, this resulted in a [transaction with 856 inputs at 46 s/vB that paid 0.036 ₿ in fees](https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/q/100437/5406) when the wallet contained a single input with sufficient funds, in another case, a user describes that their wallet built a [75 kB transaction with over 500 inputs](https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/q/120408/5406) when it had some single UTXOs with sufficient funds. While the single input in the latter case may have had fewer than 6 confirmations (the description is a bit light on details), these outcomes could e.g. occur on wallets with a large UTXO pool, when:

- The best BnB solution has a huge input count, or none exist at all
- Knapsack finds a combination with a huge input count that has a smaller overshoot than any UTXO that is larger than `target+min_change`
- The SRD selection on the large UTXO pool takes a lot of random picks before hitting a UTXO with a large amount

The outcome is more likely, if the wallet sports only a single type of UTXOs as otherwise more input set candidates are generated across the different output types. The likelihood of the above outcome is especially concerning in light of the extreme feerates in the recent months.

# Behavior of newly proposed algorithms

I propose that we add a coin selection algorithm that explicitly searches for an input set with low weight and always finds a solution to guard against the above outcome.

### Gutter Guard

_… prevents completely fumbling the coin selection._  
Gutter Guard determines the minimum necessary input count ___c___ per a "largest first" selection (sort UTXO set by descending effective value, pick from front). It then shuffles the UTXO pool and selects random UTXOs into a heap. The heap is limited to ___c+3___ UTXOs. If the heap’s limit is exceeded, the UTXO with the lowest effective value is discarded, otherwise return the content of the heap if it’s sufficient to fund the transaction.

- [++] Bounds the worst-case outcome
- [+] Simple to understand
- [+] Always finds a solution if one exists
- [+] Fast/computationally cheap
- [-] Input fees can still be multiple of necessary fees
- [±] Slightly consolidatory on fragmented wallets

### CoinGrinder

Uses a similar strategy as BnB to deterministically search the powerset of the UTXO pool to find the ___input set with the lowest weight___. In its current implementation, CoinGrinder is only used if the feerate is at least `3×long_term_feerate_estimate` (3×10 s/vB by default).

- [+++] Minimizes input weight for high feerate transactions
- [+] Will always find a solution if there is one
- [+] Computational effort bounded by iteration limit and search optimizations
- [-] Always minimizing the input set may grind UTXO set to dust (but that can be offset by using other strategies to produce larger input sets at low feerates)

# Simulation

These are some simulation results for running a scenario with 15'000 payment operations on a wallet. The wallet receives 9995 payments and sends payments 5005 times. This represents a merchant or service scenario. Generally, a scenario in which more payments are performed than deposits are received leads to the UTXO pool remaining lean by itself and therefore shows fewer pathological cases and is less interesting to analyze.  
The feerates used in the scenario are the [Peak and Tail feerate scenario](https://github.com/achow101/coin-selection-simulation/tree/main/feerates) which used the 25th percentile curve from https://transactionfee.info/charts/fees-package-feerates/ from 2021-05–2022-04.

![pat|690x309](upload://x4ZusQv9Of3uZBDFrq9Oo8imC5q.png)

Each deposit or payment in the payment scenario is paired with a feerate from the feerate scenario. The feerate scenario is repeated several times because it only has 365 elements, while there are over 15'000 payment operations.

The simulation is run on three different branches `master`, `GutterGuard`, and `CoinGrinder`. We observe that `GutterGuard` reduces the total fees by approximately 3%, and `CoinGrinder` reduces the total fees by approximately 4%, while the final UTXO counts are both 23 on `GutterGuard` and `CoinGrinder` and 21 on `master`.

# **Scenario: bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail**

## Branch: `master`

| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.19419586 | 22.7820000000 | 25 | 267 | 459 | 233 | 1 | 217 | bnb: **16** ; Total: **16** | 0.00056511 | 4.99881736 | 0.228053825023 | 0.854152856529 | 0.00466381 | 0.0000200163519313 | 0.000170000000 | 0.004833810000 | 1 | 14 | 1.96995708155 | 1.72305575036 | knapsack: **169** ; srd: **48** ; bnb: **16** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.92691954 | 27.5130000000 | 31 | 594 | 925 | 406 | 1 | 362 | bnb: **44** ; Total: **44** | 0.00050957 | 4.99881736 | 0.206918252265 | 0.808490086229 | 0.00840463 | 0.0000207010591133 | 0.000210800000 | 0.008615430000 | 1 | 14 | 2.27832512315 | 2.08673012629 | knapsack: **287** ; srd: **75** ; bnb: **44** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28261036 | 33.0313333333 | 79 | 961 | 1354 | 539 | 3 | 472 | bnb: **67** ; Total: **67** | 0.00050188 | 8.80296782 | 0.248608347352 | 0.953551575367 | 0.01199464 | 0.0000222535064935 | 0.000537200000 | 0.012531840000 | 1 | 18 | 2.51205936920 | 2.47315385470 | knapsack: **361** ; srd: **111** ; bnb: **67** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.66701132 | 35.1275000000 | 13 | 1316 | 1896 | 684 | 5 | 593 | bnb: **91** ; Total: **91** | 0.00050188 | 9.99976287 | 0.281526978196 | 1.15062483454 | 0.01481283 | 0.0000216561842105 | 0.0000884000000 | 0.0149012300000 | 1 | 51 | 2.77192982456 | 3.38942050801 | knapsack: **455** ; srd: **138** ; bnb: **91** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.29673767 | 35.0408000000 | 47 | 1682 | 2342 | 818 | 5 | 707 | bnb: **111** ; Total: **111** | 0.00050188 | 9.99976287 | 0.291498209943 | 1.18985835223 | 0.01762336 | 0.0000215444498778 | 0.000319600000 | 0.017942960000 | 1 | 51 | 2.86308068460 | 3.42620491125 | knapsack: **550** ; srd: **157** ; bnb: **111** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.38050601 | 34.4813333333 | 34 | 2008 | 2838 | 992 | 5 | 864 | bnb: **128** ; Total: **128** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.307026118785 | 1.20476934217 | 0.02230146 | 0.0000224813104839 | 0.000231200000 | 0.022532660000 | 1 | 51 | 2.86088709677 | 3.31933187497 | knapsack: **662** ; srd: **202** ; bnb: **128** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.40385369 | 35.8111428571 | 48 | 2415 | 3307 | 1085 | 5 | 940 | bnb: **145** ; Total: **145** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.287066056085 | 1.15820198974 | 0.02453685 | 0.0000226146082949 | 0.000326400000 | 0.024863250000 | 1 | 51 | 3.04792626728 | 3.62640834509 | knapsack: **724** ; srd: **216** ; bnb: **145** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.47153385 | 37.0072500000 | 43 | 2818 | 3792 | 1182 | 5 | 1017 | bnb: **165** ; Total: **165** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.271586021013 | 1.11655032300 | 0.02745202 | 0.0000232250592217 | 0.000292400000 | 0.027744420000 | 1 | 51 | 3.20812182741 | 3.87689502219 | knapsack: **792** ; srd: **225** ; bnb: **165** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.35500229 | 38.1991111111 | 22 | 3213 | 4294 | 1287 | 5 | 1103 | bnb: **184** ; Total: **184** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.260504905993 | 1.07536520580 | 0.03116165 | 0.0000242126262626 | 0.000149600000 | 0.031311250000 | 1 | 51 | 3.33644133644 | 4.08457639284 | knapsack: **852** ; srd: **251** ; bnb: **184** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.77899272 | 38.1484000000 | 21 | 3571 | 4777 | 1429 | 5 | 1227 | bnb: **202** ; Total: **202** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.246151725493 | 1.02439257811 | 0.03404379 | 0.0000238235059482 | 0.000142800000 | 0.034186590000 | 1 | 51 | 3.34289713086 | 4.03798321040 | knapsack: **954** ; srd: **273** ; bnb: **202** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 22.01558261 | 37.3441818182 | 42 | 3938 | 5243 | 1562 | 5 | 1347 | bnb: **215** ; Total: **215** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.266423447120 | 1.07171156401 | 0.03738510 | 0.0000239341229193 | 0.000285600000 | 0.037670700000 | 1 | 51 | 3.35659411012 | 4.04889851288 | knapsack: **1057** ; srd: **290** ; bnb: **215** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.44290411 | 36.6181666667 | 25 | 4278 | 5746 | 1722 | 5 | 1493 | bnb: **229** ; Total: **229** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.254736266062 | 1.02328797602 | 0.04075953 | 0.0000236698780488 | 0.000170000000 | 0.040929530000 | 1 | 51 | 3.33681765389 | 3.95402440351 | knapsack: **1174** ; srd: **319** ; bnb: **229** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.92125064 | 36.5747692308 | 31 | 4650 | 6223 | 1850 | 7 | 1604 | bnb: **246** ; Total: **246** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.249097912375 | 1.00029121318 | 0.04375394 | 0.0000236507783784 | 0.000210800000 | 0.043964740000 | 1 | 51 | 3.36378378378 | 3.97668798502 | knapsack: **1263** ; srd: **341** ; bnb: **246** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28216083 | 36.0924285714 | 58 | 4990 | 6689 | 2010 | 7 | 1757 | bnb: **253** ; Total: **253** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.255264399943 | 1.00205277345 | 0.04751686 | 0.0000236402288557 | 0.000394400000 | 0.047911260000 | 1 | 51 | 3.32786069652 | 3.90561489089 | knapsack: **1385** ; srd: **372** ; bnb: **253** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 16.99699907 | 35.6008000000 | 21 | 5335 | 7210 | 2165 | 7 | 1896 | bnb: **269** ; Total: **269** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.247115150949 | 0.975393525296 | 0.05043371 | 0.0000232950161663 | 0.000142800000 | 0.050576510000 | 1 | 51 | 3.33025404157 | 3.86383705213 | knapsack: **1500** ; srd: **396** ; bnb: **269** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.91722623 | 34.6768750000 | 24 | 5654 | 7698 | 2346 | 7 | 2068 | bnb: **278** ; Total: **278** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.253771793221 | 0.966933037743 | 0.05394153 | 0.0000229929795396 | 0.000163200000 | 0.054104730000 | 1 | 51 | 3.28132992327 | 3.79317770765 | knapsack: **1631** ; srd: **437** ; bnb: **278** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.62363839 | 34.2548235294 | 35 | 5963 | 8175 | 2537 | 7 | 2247 | bnb: **290** ; Total: **290** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.258910528549 | 0.968225800863 | 0.05837272 | 0.0000230085612929 | 0.000238000000 | 0.058610720000 | 1 | 51 | 3.22230981474 | 3.71408231447 | knapsack: **1770** ; srd: **477** ; bnb: **290** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.61014178 | 34.2111111111 | 24 | 6278 | 8673 | 2722 | 7 | 2419 | bnb: **303** ; Total: **303** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.250668723468 | 0.938254479864 | 0.06201412 | 0.0000227825569434 | 0.000163200000 | 0.062177320000 | 1 | 51 | 3.18626010287 | 3.65251853260 | knapsack: **1911** ; srd: **508** ; bnb: **303** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.57915619 | 33.8978947368 | 30 | 6573 | 9155 | 2927 | 7 | 2612 | bnb: **315** ; Total: **315** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.242217126076 | 0.908122883486 | 0.06576946 | 0.0000224699214213 | 0.000204000000 | 0.065973460000 | 1 | 51 | 3.12777587974 | 3.57892230048 | knapsack: **2072** ; srd: **540** ; bnb: **315** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.43008467 | 33.8402000000 | 22 | 6892 | 9646 | 3108 | 7 | 2776 | bnb: **332** ; Total: **332** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.238874281333 | 0.890080472149 | 0.06979755 | 0.0000224573841699 | 0.000149600000 | 0.069947150000 | 1 | 51 | 3.10360360360 | 3.53649598826 | knapsack: **2198** ; srd: **578** ; bnb: **332** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.07045818 | 33.0619047619 | 41 | 7193 | 10120 | 3307 | 7 | 2968 | bnb: **339** ; Total: **339** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.282442173827 | 1.04196410792 | 0.07340969 | 0.0000221982733595 | 0.000278800000 | 0.073688490000 | 1 | 51 | 3.06017538555 | 3.49076324597 | knapsack: **2352** ; srd: **616** ; bnb: **339** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.20613199 | 32.6075454545 | 34 | 7533 | 10617 | 3467 | 7 | 3118 | bnb: **349** ; Total: **349** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.289737562245 | 1.04846720407 | 0.07789287 | 0.0000224669368330 | 0.000231200000 | 0.078124070000 | 1 | 51 | 3.06230170176 | 3.46154135625 | knapsack: **2461** ; srd: **657** ; bnb: **349** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.27160929 | 32.7314782609 | 46 | 7877 | 11090 | 3623 | 7 | 3259 | bnb: **364** ; Total: **364** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.289352779340 | 1.04715216460 | 0.08115264 | 0.0000223992934033 | 0.000312800000 | 0.081465440000 | 1 | 51 | 3.06099917196 | 3.43760022425 | knapsack: **2577** ; srd: **682** ; bnb: **364** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.42905067 | 32.4147500000 | 23 | 8204 | 11602 | 3796 | 7 | 3421 | bnb: **375** ; Total: **375** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.287716742955 | 1.03874755318 | 0.08440292 | 0.0000222346996839 | 0.000156400000 | 0.084559320000 | 1 | 51 | 3.05637513172 | 3.42300731957 | knapsack: **2712** ; srd: **709** ; bnb: **375** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 24.52438410 | 32.7368000000 | 48 | 8541 | 12061 | 3959 | 7 | 3568 | bnb: **391** ; Total: **391** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.283425222601 | 1.02516182616 | 0.08854173 | 0.0000223646703713 | 0.000326400000 | 0.088868130000 | 1 | 51 | 3.04647638292 | 3.40545620616 | knapsack: **2823** ; srd: **745** ; bnb: **391** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.82292463 | 32.9331538462 | 28 | 8875 | 12567 | 4125 | 7 | 3720 | bnb: **405** ; Total: **405** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.276098031347 | 1.00701695832 | 0.09116036 | 0.0000220994812121 | 0.000190400000 | 0.091350760000 | 1 | 51 | 3.04654545455 | 3.38934340370 | knapsack: **2959** ; srd: **761** ; bnb: **405** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 14.89464301 | 32.7240000000 | 22 | 9156 | 13063 | 4344 | 7 | 3929 | bnb: **415** ; Total: **415** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.272766670109 | 0.987036689844 | 0.09469712 | 0.0000217995211786 | 0.000149600000 | 0.094846720000 | 1 | 51 | 3.00713627993 | 3.33986239447 | knapsack: **3135** ; srd: **794** ; bnb: **415** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 21.57619619 | 32.8532142857 | 30 | 9452 | 13541 | 4548 | 8 | 4119 | bnb: **429** ; Total: **429** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.271003455424 | 0.972727219723 | 0.09900938 | 0.0000217698724714 | 0.000204000000 | 0.099213380000 | 1 | 51 | 2.97735268250 | 3.30631970880 | knapsack: **3282** ; srd: **837** ; bnb: **429** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 17.76620172 | 32.8332413793 | 28 | 9756 | 14033 | 4744 | 8 | 4305 | bnb: **439** ; Total: **439** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.267172026012 | 0.957755985258 | 0.10228758 | 0.0000215614629005 | 0.000190400000 | 0.102477980000 | 1 | 51 | 2.95805227656 | 3.26955597749 | knapsack: **3438** ; srd: **867** ; bnb: **439** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.08772833 | 32.7158666667 | 36 | 10038 | 14518 | 4962 | 8 | 4516 | bnb: **446** ; Total: **446** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.263565464174 | 0.941036484558 | 0.10698328 | 0.0000215605159210 | 0.000244800000 | 0.107228080000 | 1 | 51 | 2.92583635631 | 3.22978440656 | knapsack: **3608** ; srd: **908** ; bnb: **446** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.02725944 | 32.7013460646 | 21 | 10076 | 14611 | 5005 | 8 | 4556 | bnb: **449** ; Total: **449** | 0.00050064 | 9.99976287 | 0.262789893604 | 0.937577735068 | 0.10775743 | 0.0000215299560440 | 0.000142800000 | 0.107900230000 | 1 | 51 | 2.91928071928 | 3.22297499647 | knapsack: **3636** ; srd: **920** ; bnb: **449** |

## Branch: `GutterGuard`

| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.19430334 | 23.5620000000 | 24 | 267 | 461 | 233 | 2 | 218 | bnb: **15** ; Total: **15** | 0.00054546 | 4.99672484 | 0.298585808073 | 1.00194346096 | 0.00455633 | 0.0000195550643777 | 0.000163200000 | 0.004719530000 | 1 | 13 | 1.97854077253 | 1.71817453233 | gg: **15** ; knapsack: **157** ; srd: **46** ; bnb: **15** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.92725331 | 29.8560000000 | 33 | 594 | 926 | 406 | 2 | 365 | bnb: **41** ; Total: **41** | 0.00051533 | 4.99672484 | 0.270893302384 | 0.939331395424 | 0.00807086 | 0.0000198789655172 | 0.000224400000 | 0.008295260000 | 1 | 16 | 2.28078817734 | 2.22665676854 | gg: **28** ; knapsack: **268** ; srd: **69** ; bnb: **41** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28304281 | 35.2366666667 | 76 | 961 | 1359 | 539 | 4 | 474 | bnb: **65** ; Total: **65** | 0.00050188 | 8.82013238 | 0.312688293734 | 1.11248686432 | 0.01156219 | 0.0000214511873840 | 0.000516800000 | 0.012078990000 | 1 | 16 | 2.52133580705 | 2.59270661285 | gg: **41** ; knapsack: **337** ; srd: **96** ; bnb: **65** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.66739760 | 39.1975000000 | 19 | 1316 | 1888 | 684 | 6 | 591 | bnb: **93** ; Total: **93** | 0.00050188 | 9.97571681 | 0.306767983604 | 1.11191502798 | 0.01442655 | 0.0000210914473684 | 0.000129200000 | 0.014555750000 | 1 | 38 | 2.76023391813 | 3.13966695424 | gg: **55** ; knapsack: **419** ; srd: **117** ; bnb: **93** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.29717662 | 37.9712000000 | 50 | 1682 | 2339 | 818 | 6 | 707 | bnb: **111** ; Total: **111** | 0.00050188 | 9.97571681 | 0.321645700424 | 1.18781375162 | 0.01718441 | 0.0000210078361858 | 0.000340000000 | 0.017524410000 | 1 | 38 | 2.85941320293 | 3.23892190050 | gg: **67** ; knapsack: **508** ; srd: **132** ; bnb: **111** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.38123719 | 38.2236666667 | 27 | 2008 | 2841 | 992 | 6 | 860 | bnb: **132** ; Total: **132** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.336216955849 | 1.20189174029 | 0.02157028 | 0.0000217442338710 | 0.000183600000 | 0.021753880000 | 1 | 38 | 2.86391129032 | 3.19444333779 | gg: **80** ; knapsack: **612** ; srd: **168** ; bnb: **132** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.40456675 | 38.7282857143 | 44 | 2415 | 3307 | 1085 | 6 | 936 | bnb: **149** ; Total: **149** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.332251860459 | 1.18043675287 | 0.02382379 | 0.0000219574101382 | 0.000299200000 | 0.024122990000 | 1 | 54 | 3.04792626728 | 3.71437665604 | gg: **84** ; knapsack: **670** ; srd: **182** ; bnb: **149** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.47233915 | 39.7077500000 | 42 | 2818 | 3786 | 1182 | 6 | 1010 | bnb: **172** ; Total: **172** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.313064794891 | 1.13976651486 | 0.02664672 | 0.0000225437563452 | 0.000285600000 | 0.026932320000 | 1 | 54 | 3.20304568528 | 3.87629075337 | gg: **85** ; knapsack: **736** ; srd: **189** ; bnb: **172** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.35581055 | 40.8080000000 | 27 | 3213 | 4285 | 1287 | 6 | 1099 | bnb: **188** ; Total: **188** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.298209298499 | 1.09605489492 | 0.03035339 | 0.0000235846076146 | 0.000183600000 | 0.030536990000 | 1 | 54 | 3.32944832945 | 4.07495040074 | gg: **97** ; knapsack: **792** ; srd: **210** ; bnb: **188** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.77976281 | 40.5986000000 | 22 | 3571 | 4768 | 1429 | 6 | 1219 | bnb: **210** ; Total: **210** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.278818182034 | 1.04456910788 | 0.03327370 | 0.0000232846046186 | 0.000149600000 | 0.033423300000 | 1 | 54 | 3.33659902029 | 4.03339490004 | gg: **107** ; knapsack: **885** ; srd: **227** ; bnb: **210** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 22.01645287 | 39.7229090909 | 41 | 3938 | 5232 | 1562 | 6 | 1335 | bnb: **227** ; Total: **227** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.283910468 | 1.04434621676 | 0.03651484 | 0.0000233769782330 | 0.000278800000 | 0.036793640000 | 1 | 54 | 3.34955185659 | 4.05654655420 | gg: **121** ; knapsack: **972** ; srd: **242** ; bnb: **227** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.44388530 | 38.9678333333 | 30 | 4278 | 5730 | 1722 | 6 | 1482 | bnb: **240** ; Total: **240** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.287627587598 | 1.03183700454 | 0.03977834 | 0.0000231000813008 | 0.000204000000 | 0.039982340000 | 1 | 54 | 3.32752613240 | 3.95906386300 | gg: **134** ; knapsack: **1081** ; srd: **267** ; bnb: **240** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.92240718 | 39.1370769231 | 37 | 4650 | 6204 | 1850 | 6 | 1591 | bnb: **259** ; Total: **259** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.279290940302 | 1.00423163071 | 0.04259740 | 0.0000230256216216 | 0.000251600000 | 0.042849000000 | 1 | 54 | 3.35351351351 | 3.96897119861 | gg: **140** ; knapsack: **1165** ; srd: **286** ; bnb: **259** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28348714 | 39.0191428571 | 70 | 4990 | 6659 | 2010 | 6 | 1739 | bnb: **271** ; Total: **271** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.266482287964 | 0.964605357130 | 0.04619055 | 0.0000229803731343 | 0.000476000000 | 0.046666550000 | 1 | 54 | 3.31293532338 | 3.92843925540 | gg: **153** ; knapsack: **1280** ; srd: **306** ; bnb: **271** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 16.99836590 | 38.3654666667 | 19 | 5335 | 7196 | 2165 | 6 | 1880 | bnb: **285** ; Total: **285** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.270032736947 | 0.961723015189 | 0.04906688 | 0.0000226636859122 | 0.000129200000 | 0.049196080000 | 1 | 54 | 3.32378752887 | 3.90731486992 | gg: **162** ; knapsack: **1390** ; srd: **328** ; bnb: **285** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.91856779 | 37.1357500000 | 21 | 5654 | 7686 | 2346 | 6 | 2053 | bnb: **293** ; Total: **293** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.295200466800 | 1.00879296085 | 0.05259997 | 0.0000224211295823 | 0.000142800000 | 0.052742770000 | 1 | 54 | 3.27621483376 | 3.81764575350 | gg: **187** ; knapsack: **1501** ; srd: **365** ; bnb: **293** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.62512596 | 36.6556470588 | 41 | 5963 | 8157 | 2537 | 6 | 2235 | bnb: **302** ; Total: **302** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.292620577311 | 1.00666131363 | 0.05688515 | 0.0000224222112732 | 0.000278800000 | 0.057163950000 | 1 | 54 | 3.21521482065 | 3.74031307774 | gg: **196** ; knapsack: **1641** ; srd: **398** ; bnb: **302** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.61167589 | 36.7653333333 | 29 | 6278 | 8651 | 2722 | 6 | 2402 | bnb: **320** ; Total: **320** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.282398838605 | 0.981592827956 | 0.06048001 | 0.0000222189603233 | 0.000197200000 | 0.060677210000 | 1 | 54 | 3.17817781043 | 3.68278092288 | gg: **200** ; knapsack: **1779** ; srd: **423** ; bnb: **320** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.58069370 | 36.3942105263 | 33 | 6573 | 9135 | 2927 | 6 | 2595 | bnb: **332** ; Total: **332** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.271198170933 | 0.950188145904 | 0.06423195 | 0.0000219446361462 | 0.000224400000 | 0.064456350000 | 1 | 54 | 3.12094294499 | 3.60086504177 | gg: **209** ; knapsack: **1938** ; srd: **448** ; bnb: **332** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.43188571 | 36.4597000000 | 27 | 6892 | 9627 | 3108 | 6 | 2762 | bnb: **346** ; Total: **346** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.268944178660 | 0.927562557419 | 0.06799651 | 0.0000218778989704 | 0.000183600000 | 0.068180110000 | 1 | 54 | 3.09749034749 | 3.56291832703 | gg: **219** ; knapsack: **2061** ; srd: **482** ; bnb: **346** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.07234952 | 35.6579047619 | 42 | 7193 | 10107 | 3307 | 6 | 2956 | bnb: **351** ; Total: **351** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.314953503048 | 1.06304013164 | 0.07151835 | 0.0000216263531902 | 0.000285600000 | 0.071803950000 | 1 | 54 | 3.05624433021 | 3.51513616534 | gg: **248** ; knapsack: **2201** ; srd: **507** ; bnb: **351** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.20861893 | 35.2531818182 | 43 | 7533 | 10592 | 3467 | 6 | 3102 | bnb: **365** ; Total: **365** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.312388762231 | 1.05049513605 | 0.07540593 | 0.0000217496192674 | 0.000292400000 | 0.075698330000 | 1 | 54 | 3.05509085665 | 3.47874917191 | gg: **259** ; knapsack: **2308** ; srd: **535** ; bnb: **365** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.27430214 | 35.3700869565 | 52 | 7877 | 11067 | 3623 | 6 | 3242 | bnb: **381** ; Total: **381** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.305419908442 | 1.03222719750 | 0.07845979 | 0.0000216560281535 | 0.000353600000 | 0.078813390000 | 1 | 54 | 3.05465084184 | 3.46311235640 | gg: **269** ; knapsack: **2419** ; srd: **554** ; bnb: **381** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.43191777 | 35.1097500000 | 20 | 8204 | 11586 | 3796 | 6 | 3402 | bnb: **394** ; Total: **394** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.313492289730 | 1.05066680206 | 0.08153582 | 0.0000214794046365 | 0.000136000000 | 0.081671820000 | 1 | 54 | 3.05216016860 | 3.45662649735 | gg: **284** ; knapsack: **2543** ; srd: **575** ; bnb: **394** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 24.52740182 | 35.2355200000 | 44 | 8541 | 12044 | 3959 | 6 | 3547 | bnb: **412** ; Total: **412** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.312901519563 | 1.05089155294 | 0.08552401 | 0.0000216024273807 | 0.000299200000 | 0.085823210000 | 1 | 54 | 3.04218236929 | 3.43862507132 | gg: **293** ; knapsack: **2649** ; srd: **605** ; bnb: **412** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.82594980 | 35.4110000000 | 30 | 8875 | 12547 | 4125 | 6 | 3702 | bnb: **423** ; Total: **423** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.304994560994 | 1.03138432544 | 0.08813519 | 0.0000213661066667 | 0.000204000000 | 0.088339190000 | 1 | 54 | 3.04169696970 | 3.42066905020 | gg: **300** ; knapsack: **2782** ; srd: **620** ; bnb: **423** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 14.89774309 | 35.2946666667 | 21 | 9156 | 13044 | 4344 | 6 | 3909 | bnb: **435** ; Total: **435** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.297958449749 | 1.00921949671 | 0.09159704 | 0.0000210858747698 | 0.000142800000 | 0.091739840000 | 1 | 54 | 3.00276243094 | 3.37249124233 | gg: **310** ; knapsack: **2952** ; srd: **647** ; bnb: **435** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 21.57946355 | 35.5185000000 | 31 | 9452 | 13517 | 4548 | 7 | 4096 | bnb: **452** ; Total: **452** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.294115539553 | 0.992684868518 | 0.09574202 | 0.0000210514555849 | 0.000210800000 | 0.095952820000 | 1 | 54 | 2.97207563764 | 3.33976756934 | gg: **325** ; knapsack: **3093** ; srd: **678** ; bnb: **452** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 17.76946241 | 35.4881379310 | 29 | 9756 | 14006 | 4744 | 7 | 4279 | bnb: **465** ; Total: **465** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.289182516579 | 0.976953342325 | 0.09902689 | 0.0000208741336425 | 0.000197200000 | 0.099224090000 | 1 | 54 | 2.95236087690 | 3.30516987679 | gg: **337** ; knapsack: **3242** ; srd: **700** ; bnb: **465** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.09103521 | 35.3356666667 | 30 | 10038 | 14496 | 4962 | 7 | 4488 | bnb: **474** ; Total: **474** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.285577224213 | 0.959134947640 | 0.10367640 | 0.0000208940749698 | 0.000204000000 | 0.103880400000 | 1 | 54 | 2.92140266022 | 3.26925619813 | gg: **351** ; knapsack: **3400** ; srd: **737** ; bnb: **474** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.03060711 | 35.3121145813 | 23 | 10076 | 14582 | 5005 | 7 | 4529 | bnb: **476** ; Total: **476** | 0.00050120 | 9.97571681 | 0.286605997779 | 0.956804193304 | 0.10440976 | 0.0000208610909091 | 0.000156400000 | 0.104566160000 | 1 | 54 | 2.91348651349 | 3.26603342797 | gg: **353** ; knapsack: **3424** ; srd: **752** ; bnb: **476** |

## Branch: `CoinGrinder`

| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.19431007 | 23.8480000000 | 22 | 267 | 464 | 233 | 2 | 219 | bnb: **14** ; Total: **14** | 0.00051685 | 4.99597564 | 0.168985573607 | 0.679673163816 | 0.00454960 | 0.0000195261802575 | 0.000149600000 | 0.004699200000 | 1 | 13 | 1.99141630901 | 1.67123590523 | cg: **21** ; knapsack: **165** ; srd: **33** ; bnb: **14** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.92726978 | 29.1980000000 | 33 | 594 | 925 | 406 | 2 | 364 | bnb: **42** ; Total: **42** | 0.00050308 | 4.99597564 | 0.144475909643 | 0.610946105027 | 0.00805439 | 0.0000198383990148 | 0.000224400000 | 0.008278790000 | 1 | 15 | 2.27832512315 | 2.16797639109 | cg: **35** ; knapsack: **282** ; srd: **47** ; bnb: **42** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28307178 | 34.2546666667 | 79 | 961 | 1356 | 539 | 3 | 474 | bnb: **65** ; Total: **65** | 0.00050188 | 4.99597564 | 0.128045802384 | 0.556617469511 | 0.01153322 | 0.0000213974397032 | 0.000537200000 | 0.012070420000 | 1 | 16 | 2.51576994434 | 2.58412941323 | cg: **57** ; knapsack: **356** ; srd: **61** ; bnb: **65** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.66739756 | 35.8575000000 | 14 | 1316 | 1899 | 684 | 5 | 597 | bnb: **87** ; Total: **87** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.183721836801 | 0.963651079172 | 0.01442659 | 0.0000210915058480 | 0.0000952000000 | 0.0145217900000 | 1 | 56 | 2.77631578947 | 3.52169106104 | cg: **67** ; knapsack: **453** ; srd: **77** ; bnb: **87** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.29724434 | 35.7344000000 | 51 | 1682 | 2340 | 818 | 5 | 709 | bnb: **109** ; Total: **109** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.200968485233 | 1.04753105765 | 0.01711669 | 0.0000209250488998 | 0.000346800000 | 0.017463490000 | 1 | 56 | 2.86063569682 | 3.52298146055 | cg: **77** ; knapsack: **547** ; srd: **85** ; bnb: **109** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.38145545 | 35.9136666667 | 29 | 2008 | 2841 | 992 | 5 | 862 | bnb: **130** ; Total: **130** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.227307114130 | 1.12133776363 | 0.02135202 | 0.0000215242137097 | 0.000197200000 | 0.021549220000 | 1 | 56 | 2.86391129032 | 3.41342810781 | cg: **98** ; knapsack: **652** ; srd: **112** ; bnb: **130** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.40480015 | 37.4480000000 | 48 | 2415 | 3307 | 1085 | 5 | 940 | bnb: **145** ; Total: **145** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.220479130457 | 1.08579016177 | 0.02359039 | 0.0000217422949309 | 0.000326400000 | 0.023916790000 | 1 | 56 | 3.04792626728 | 3.77717800053 | cg: **103** ; knapsack: **712** ; srd: **125** ; bnb: **145** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 23.47260037 | 38.7750000000 | 42 | 2818 | 3798 | 1182 | 5 | 1022 | bnb: **160** ; Total: **160** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.206872748151 | 1.04348216983 | 0.02638550 | 0.0000223227580372 | 0.000285600000 | 0.026671100000 | 1 | 56 | 3.21319796954 | 3.96686894231 | cg: **107** ; knapsack: **784** ; srd: **131** ; bnb: **160** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.35615672 | 39.6480000000 | 22 | 3213 | 4300 | 1287 | 5 | 1109 | bnb: **178** ; Total: **178** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.203870829522 | 1.00559062564 | 0.03000722 | 0.0000233156332556 | 0.000149600000 | 0.030156820000 | 1 | 56 | 3.34110334110 | 4.14898061580 | cg: **116** ; knapsack: **843** ; srd: **150** ; bnb: **178** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.78017875 | 39.6076000000 | 34 | 3571 | 4772 | 1429 | 5 | 1235 | bnb: **194** ; Total: **194** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.193004885474 | 0.955815690739 | 0.03285776 | 0.0000229935339398 | 0.000231200000 | 0.033088960000 | 1 | 56 | 3.33939818055 | 4.10168304958 | cg: **127** ; knapsack: **944** ; srd: **164** ; bnb: **194** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 22.01728937 | 38.6205454545 | 44 | 3938 | 5249 | 1562 | 5 | 1355 | bnb: **207** ; Total: **207** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.195981470052 | 0.951182116078 | 0.03567834 | 0.0000228414468630 | 0.000299200000 | 0.035977540000 | 1 | 56 | 3.36043533931 | 4.15167856608 | cg: **139** ; knapsack: **1045** ; srd: **171** ; bnb: **207** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.44464388 | 37.8906666667 | 27 | 4278 | 5747 | 1722 | 5 | 1496 | bnb: **226** ; Total: **226** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.188362870481 | 0.911149689949 | 0.03901976 | 0.0000226595586527 | 0.000183600000 | 0.039203360000 | 1 | 56 | 3.33739837398 | 4.04556927563 | cg: **150** ; knapsack: **1157** ; srd: **189** ; bnb: **226** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.92316834 | 37.9698461538 | 38 | 4650 | 6215 | 1850 | 5 | 1603 | bnb: **247** ; Total: **247** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.183975313481 | 0.883705979157 | 0.04183624 | 0.0000226141837838 | 0.000258400000 | 0.042094640000 | 1 | 56 | 3.35945945946 | 4.06278200898 | cg: **161** ; knapsack: **1242** ; srd: **200** ; bnb: **247** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.28430041 | 37.8664285714 | 72 | 4990 | 6668 | 2010 | 5 | 1750 | bnb: **260** ; Total: **260** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.177473687057 | 0.848859219835 | 0.04537728 | 0.0000225757611940 | 0.000489600000 | 0.045866880000 | 1 | 56 | 3.31741293532 | 4.01648485569 | cg: **174** ; knapsack: **1359** ; srd: **217** ; bnb: **260** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 16.99924857 | 37.4724000000 | 24 | 5335 | 7196 | 2165 | 5 | 1885 | bnb: **280** ; Total: **280** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.177391064403 | 0.843234149889 | 0.04818421 | 0.0000222559861432 | 0.000163200000 | 0.048347410000 | 1 | 56 | 3.32378752887 | 3.98576631937 | cg: **178** ; knapsack: **1472** ; srd: **235** ; bnb: **280** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.91955473 | 36.4260000000 | 23 | 5654 | 7687 | 2346 | 5 | 2056 | bnb: **290** ; Total: **290** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.193400275963 | 0.876458633010 | 0.05161303 | 0.0000220004390452 | 0.000156400000 | 0.051769430000 | 1 | 56 | 3.27664109122 | 3.90622814334 | cg: **189** ; knapsack: **1605** ; srd: **262** ; bnb: **290** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 26.62606905 | 36.0403529412 | 35 | 5963 | 8164 | 2537 | 5 | 2236 | bnb: **301** ; Total: **301** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.192812385640 | 0.870479296081 | 0.05594206 | 0.0000220504769413 | 0.000238000000 | 0.056180060000 | 1 | 56 | 3.21797398502 | 3.82928593235 | cg: **210** ; knapsack: **1742** ; srd: **284** ; bnb: **301** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.61256262 | 36.0920000000 | 28 | 6278 | 8656 | 2722 | 5 | 2406 | bnb: **316** ; Total: **316** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.184131431850 | 0.841978063836 | 0.05959328 | 0.0000218931961793 | 0.000190400000 | 0.059783680000 | 1 | 56 | 3.18001469508 | 3.77099867645 | cg: **223** ; knapsack: **1883** ; srd: **300** ; bnb: **316** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 19.58161842 | 35.7968421053 | 35 | 6573 | 9138 | 2927 | 5 | 2600 | bnb: **327** ; Total: **327** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.177131851981 | 0.813559033907 | 0.06330723 | 0.0000216287085753 | 0.000238000000 | 0.063545230000 | 1 | 56 | 3.12196788521 | 3.68354571639 | cg: **241** ; knapsack: **2041** ; srd: **318** ; bnb: **327** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.43288840 | 35.8227000000 | 26 | 6892 | 9630 | 3108 | 5 | 2764 | bnb: **344** ; Total: **344** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.175901789258 | 0.794930663393 | 0.06699382 | 0.0000215552831403 | 0.000176800000 | 0.067170620000 | 1 | 56 | 3.09845559846 | 3.63899917037 | cg: **254** ; knapsack: **2165** ; srd: **345** ; bnb: **344** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 13.07353548 | 35.0930476190 | 41 | 7193 | 10109 | 3307 | 5 | 2957 | bnb: **350** ; Total: **350** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.199681650183 | 0.868166694510 | 0.07033239 | 0.0000212677320835 | 0.000278800000 | 0.070611190000 | 1 | 56 | 3.05684910795 | 3.58448766707 | cg: **264** ; knapsack: **2321** ; srd: **372** ; bnb: **350** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 12.20992629 | 34.6953636364 | 42 | 7533 | 10598 | 3467 | 5 | 3107 | bnb: **360** ; Total: **360** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.195061106501 | 0.850538636883 | 0.07409857 | 0.0000213725324488 | 0.000285600000 | 0.074384170000 | 1 | 56 | 3.05682145948 | 3.55955862963 | cg: **282** ; knapsack: **2436** ; srd: **389** ; bnb: **360** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 27.27557467 | 34.8666956522 | 46 | 7877 | 11073 | 3623 | 5 | 3242 | bnb: **381** ; Total: **381** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.194723731783 | 0.845497044809 | 0.07718726 | 0.0000213047916092 | 0.000312800000 | 0.077500060000 | 1 | 56 | 3.05630692796 | 3.54308159924 | cg: **291** ; knapsack: **2543** ; srd: **408** ; bnb: **381** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.43327304 | 34.7681666667 | 22 | 8204 | 11580 | 3796 | 5 | 3398 | bnb: **398** ; Total: **398** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.194726944123 | 0.838401581678 | 0.08018055 | 0.0000211223788198 | 0.000149600000 | 0.080330150000 | 1 | 56 | 3.05057955743 | 3.51987725580 | cg: **297** ; knapsack: **2671** ; srd: **430** ; bnb: **398** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 24.52869452 | 34.8472000000 | 45 | 8541 | 12044 | 3959 | 5 | 3548 | bnb: **411** ; Total: **411** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.191581752049 | 0.824176340524 | 0.08423131 | 0.0000212759055317 | 0.000306000000 | 0.084537310000 | 1 | 56 | 3.04218236929 | 3.49546575364 | cg: **313** ; knapsack: **2786** ; srd: **449** ; bnb: **411** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 20.82722998 | 34.8699230769 | 28 | 8875 | 12548 | 4125 | 5 | 3701 | bnb: **424** ; Total: **424** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.187581044696 | 0.810098196171 | 0.08685501 | 0.00002105576 | 0.000190400000 | 0.087045410000 | 1 | 56 | 3.04193939394 | 3.47283152463 | cg: **319** ; knapsack: **2922** ; srd: **460** ; bnb: **424** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 14.89897305 | 34.6282962963 | 19 | 9156 | 13050 | 4344 | 5 | 3913 | bnb: **431** ; Total: **431** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.183598327498 | 0.792459161390 | 0.09036708 | 0.0000208027348066 | 0.000129200000 | 0.090496280000 | 1 | 56 | 3.00414364641 | 3.41597355038 | cg: **331** ; knapsack: **3107** ; srd: **475** ; bnb: **431** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 21.58068710 | 34.7263571429 | 25 | 9452 | 13527 | 4548 | 6 | 4100 | bnb: **448** ; Total: **448** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.182674596534 | 0.782311884138 | 0.09451847 | 0.0000207824252419 | 0.000170000000 | 0.094688470000 | 1 | 56 | 2.97427440633 | 3.38283712343 | cg: **353** ; knapsack: **3250** ; srd: **497** ; bnb: **448** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 17.77059990 | 34.5476551724 | 28 | 9756 | 14017 | 4744 | 6 | 4289 | bnb: **455** ; Total: **455** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.180617859419 | 0.771229915193 | 0.09788940 | 0.0000206343591906 | 0.000190400000 | 0.098079800000 | 1 | 56 | 2.95467959528 | 3.34763711902 | cg: **363** ; knapsack: **3409** ; srd: **517** ; bnb: **455** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 18.09223050 | 34.3252666667 | 36 | 10038 | 14499 | 4962 | 6 | 4497 | bnb: **465** ; Total: **465** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.178702173851 | 0.758088445077 | 0.10248111 | 0.0000206531862152 | 0.000244800000 | 0.102725910000 | 1 | 56 | 2.92200725514 | 3.30919619261 | cg: **388** ; knapsack: **3566** ; srd: **543** ; bnb: **465** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_peak-and-tail | 15.03174881 | 34.3089317685 | 23 | 10076 | 14591 | 5005 | 6 | 4538 | bnb: **467** ; Total: **467** | 0.00050188 | 9.84521291 | 0.178563130670 | 0.755523891709 | 0.10326806 | 0.0000206329790210 | 0.000156400000 | 0.103424460000 | 1 | 56 | 2.91528471528 | 3.31017376335 | cg: **391** ; knapsack: **3593** ; srd: **554** ; bnb: **467** |

-------------------------

murch | 2023-12-12 22:05:25 UTC | #2

This is a second simulation with the same payment scenario (bustabit tiny hot wallet) but the feerates from 2023 at 6h intervals. Other than in the _Peak and Tail_ feerate sequence, the 6h-YTD-2023 feerates are above the _Long Term Feerate Estimate_ of 10 s/vB most of the sequence, often magnitudes above. Given this, all branches end with significantly more UTXOs. `master` has 116 in the end, `GutterGuard` ends up with 183, and `CoinGrinder` has 188. On the other hand, the thriftiness of the additional algorithms pays off with reduced total fees: `master` pays a total of 0.44500219 ₿, `GutterGuard pays `0.43080706 (3.2% less), and `CoinGrinder` pays 0.40248296 (9.5% less).

![6h-2023|690x311](upload://i3cYg5sJbkYTKYEpZ1uRuoYNmUA.png)

**master:**

Scenario: bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023
| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---| --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 0E-8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0E-66 | 0E-66 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.19080850 | 38.4780000000 | 57 | 267 | 400 | 233 | 0 | 190 | bnb: **43** ; Total: **43** | 0.00054782 | 4.99898138 | 0.618820541053 | 1.31120853325 | 0.00805117 | 0.0000345543776824 | 0.000387600000 | 0.008438770000 | 1 | 13 | 1.71673819742 | 1.39163870322 | knapsack: **78** ; srd: **112** ; bnb: **43** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.90971831 | 68.6630000000 | 98 | 594 | 781 | 406 | 0 | 285 | bnb: **121** ; Total: **121** | 0.00054782 | 4.99898138 | 0.555064412316 | 1.24776165092 | 0.02560586 | 0.0000630686206897 | 0.000666400000 | 0.026272260000 | 1 | 16 | 1.92364532020 | 1.68554713609 | knapsack: **86** ; srd: **199** ; bnb: **121** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.25715472 | 99.6166666667 | 183 | 961 | 1117 | 539 | 0 | 339 | bnb: **200** ; Total: **200** | 0.00054782 | 8.76967429 | 0.539623828407 | 1.26768971902 | 0.03745028 | 0.0000694810389610 | 0.00124440000 | 0.03869468000 | 1 | 16 | 2.07235621521 | 1.80775801688 | knapsack: **88** ; srd: **251** ; bnb: **200** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.62699988 | 134.221000000 | 277 | 1316 | 1441 | 684 | 0 | 402 | bnb: **282** ; Total: **282** | 0.00054782 | 9.97296517 | 0.514016606169 | 1.35078596639 | 0.05482427 | 0.0000801524415205 | 0.00188360000 | 0.05670787000 | 1 | 16 | 2.10672514620 | 1.81389184024 | knapsack: **95** ; srd: **307** ; bnb: **282** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.25347065 | 170.292000000 | 345 | 1682 | 1793 | 818 | 3 | 456 | bnb: **362** ; Total: **362** | 0.00050897 | 9.97296517 | 0.459734783202 | 1.27740531644 | 0.06089038 | 0.0000744381173594 | 0.00234600000 | 0.06323638000 | 1 | 16 | 2.19193154034 | 1.89144396673 | knapsack: **100** ; srd: **356** ; bnb: **362** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 18.32272302 | 185.778666667 | 181 | 2008 | 2359 | 992 | 3 | 532 | bnb: **460** ; Total: **460** | 0.00050897 | 9.97296517 | 0.404900422180 | 1.19310092252 | 0.08008445 | 0.0000807302923387 | 0.00123080000 | 0.08131525000 | 1 | 40 | 2.37802419355 | 2.54985425820 | knapsack: **116** ; srd: **416** ; bnb: **460** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.33617924 | 197.484571429 | 359 | 2415 | 2623 | 1085 | 3 | 567 | bnb: **518** ; Total: **518** | 0.00050897 | 9.97296517 | 0.405150519295 | 1.19354999083 | 0.09221130 | 0.0000849873732719 | 0.00244120000 | 0.09465250000 | 1 | 40 | 2.41751152074 | 2.53933397744 | knapsack: **118** ; srd: **449** ; bnb: **518** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.39785811 | 220.885750000 | 414 | 2818 | 3004 | 1182 | 3 | 600 | bnb: **582** ; Total: **582** | 0.00050397 | 9.97296517 | 0.387368525017 | 1.16352859191 | 0.10112776 | 0.0000855564805415 | 0.00281520000 | 0.10394296000 | 1 | 40 | 2.54145516074 | 2.74447620076 | knapsack: **129** ; srd: **471** ; bnb: **582** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.26691330 | 236.793777778 | 276 | 3213 | 3582 | 1287 | 3 | 645 | bnb: **642** ; Total: **642** | 0.00050397 | 9.97296517 | 0.362959797767 | 1.12586367075 | 0.11925064 | 0.0000926578399378 | 0.00187680000 | 0.12112744000 | 1 | 40 | 2.78321678322 | 3.33608825170 | knapsack: **146** ; srd: **499** ; bnb: **642** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.67561789 | 241.068200000 | 260 | 3571 | 4016 | 1429 | 3 | 705 | bnb: **724** ; Total: **724** | 0.00050397 | 9.97296517 | 0.343437091972 | 1.08166101981 | 0.13741862 | 0.0000961641847446 | 0.00176800000 | 0.13918662000 | 1 | 40 | 2.81035689293 | 3.33469230540 | knapsack: **161** ; srd: **544** ; bnb: **724** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.89821718 | 229.856363636 | 40 | 3938 | 4680 | 1562 | 3 | 782 | bnb: **780** ; Total: **780** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.376709317455 | 1.16251654794 | 0.15475053 | 0.0000990720422535 | 0.000272000000 | 0.155022530000 | 1 | 64 | 2.99615877081 | 4.19037493813 | knapsack: **182** ; srd: **600** ; bnb: **780** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.31778343 | 215.854166667 | 114 | 4278 | 5064 | 1722 | 3 | 900 | bnb: **822** ; Total: **822** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.381760010478 | 1.11298783817 | 0.16588021 | 0.0000963299709640 | 0.000775200000 | 0.166655410000 | 1 | 64 | 2.94076655052 | 4.05940477229 | knapsack: **209** ; srd: **691** ; bnb: **822** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.79039820 | 209.924769231 | 143 | 4650 | 5466 | 1850 | 3 | 959 | bnb: **890** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **891** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.370546484390 | 1.08116729229 | 0.17460638 | 0.0000943818270270 | 0.000972400000 | 0.175578780000 | 1 | 64 | 2.95459459459 | 3.99026573433 | knapsack: **221** ; srd: **739** ; bnb: **890** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.13873623 | 205.075571429 | 114 | 4990 | 5933 | 2010 | 3 | 1057 | bnb: **951** ; knapsack: **2** ; Total: **953** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.349083059868 | 1.03653572022 | 0.19094146 | 0.0000949957512438 | 0.000775200000 | 0.191716660000 | 1 | 64 | 2.95174129353 | 3.92223555639 | knapsack: **252** ; srd: **807** ; bnb: **951** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 16.83635908 | 200.784800000 | 171 | 5335 | 6314 | 2165 | 3 | 1150 | bnb: **1012** ; knapsack: **3** ; Total: **1015** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.344275522904 | 1.02210000315 | 0.21107370 | 0.0000974936258661 | 0.00116280000 | 0.21223650000 | 1 | 64 | 2.91639722864 | 3.85479679924 | knapsack: **257** ; srd: **896** ; bnb: **1012** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.75089057 | 192.730125000 | 57 | 5654 | 6863 | 2346 | 3 | 1266 | bnb: **1076** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1080** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.395621164755 | 1.15039657510 | 0.22027719 | 0.0000938947953964 | 0.000387600000 | 0.220664790000 | 1 | 64 | 2.92540494459 | 3.85758996901 | knapsack: **277** ; srd: **993** ; bnb: **1076** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.44299196 | 184.668352941 | 92 | 5963 | 7292 | 2537 | 3 | 1421 | bnb: **1112** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1116** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.405519812491 | 1.17402298835 | 0.23901915 | 0.0000942133031139 | 0.000625600000 | 0.239644750000 | 1 | 64 | 2.87426093812 | 3.79901662309 | knapsack: **317** ; srd: **1108** ; bnb: **1112** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.41711613 | 182.277666667 | 152 | 6278 | 7664 | 2722 | 3 | 1538 | bnb: **1180** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1184** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.397619956873 | 1.14257788570 | 0.25503977 | 0.0000936957274063 | 0.00103360000 | 0.25607337000 | 1 | 64 | 2.81557678178 | 3.69984750644 | knapsack: **322** ; srd: **1220** ; bnb: **1180** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.37191649 | 180.120526316 | 163 | 6573 | 8089 | 2927 | 3 | 1679 | bnb: **1244** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1248** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.378736005539 | 1.09813223059 | 0.27300916 | 0.0000932726887598 | 0.00110840000 | 0.27411756000 | 1 | 64 | 2.76358045781 | 3.60594925358 | knapsack: **344** ; srd: **1339** ; bnb: **1244** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 13.21728511 | 177.016500000 | 113 | 6892 | 8578 | 3108 | 3 | 1799 | bnb: **1305** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1309** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.364315644258 | 1.06382579568 | 0.28259711 | 0.0000909257110682 | 0.000768400000 | 0.283365510000 | 1 | 64 | 2.75997425997 | 3.56776960860 | knapsack: **374** ; srd: **1429** ; bnb: **1305** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.83118230 | 172.042761905 | 44 | 7193 | 9093 | 3307 | 3 | 1944 | bnb: **1359** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1363** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.403045736003 | 1.16478155662 | 0.31268557 | 0.0000945526368310 | 0.000299200000 | 0.312984770000 | 1 | 64 | 2.74962201391 | 3.58825666762 | knapsack: **405** ; srd: **1543** ; bnb: **1359** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 11.95541547 | 168.000181818 | 65 | 7533 | 9509 | 3467 | 3 | 2041 | bnb: **1422** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1426** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.405492928300 | 1.15759844428 | 0.32860939 | 0.0000947820565330 | 0.000442000000 | 0.329051390000 | 1 | 64 | 2.74271704644 | 3.55114732423 | knapsack: **419** ; srd: **1626** ; bnb: **1422** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.00965195 | 164.879826087 | 186 | 7877 | 9846 | 3623 | 3 | 2155 | bnb: **1464** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1468** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.413007810260 | 1.17060018910 | 0.34310998 | 0.0000947032790505 | 0.00126480000 | 0.34437478000 | 1 | 64 | 2.71763731714 | 3.50585780116 | knapsack: **432** ; srd: **1727** ; bnb: **1464** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.16110863 | 165.217333333 | 88 | 8204 | 10363 | 3796 | 3 | 2247 | bnb: **1545** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1549** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.402915824780 | 1.15035416512 | 0.35234496 | 0.0000928200632244 | 0.000598400000 | 0.352943360000 | 1 | 64 | 2.72997892518 | 3.57756986872 | knapsack: **449** ; srd: **1802** ; bnb: **1545** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 24.24713454 | 164.176160000 | 142 | 8541 | 10748 | 3959 | 3 | 2349 | bnb: **1606** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1610** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.396452292878 | 1.13203565247 | 0.36579129 | 0.0000923948699166 | 0.000965600000 | 0.366756890000 | 1 | 64 | 2.71482697651 | 3.53810698324 | knapsack: **468** ; srd: **1885** ; bnb: **1606** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.53137457 | 165.000923077 | 223 | 8875 | 11090 | 4125 | 3 | 2438 | bnb: **1683** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1687** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.390861587170 | 1.11413973786 | 0.38271042 | 0.0000927782836364 | 0.00151640000 | 0.38422682000 | 1 | 64 | 2.68848484848 | 3.48039761566 | knapsack: **471** ; srd: **1971** ; bnb: **1683** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.59832262 | 164.723629630 | 130 | 9156 | 11608 | 4344 | 3 | 2582 | bnb: **1758** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1762** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.377131626479 | 1.08603265455 | 0.39101751 | 0.0000900132389503 | 0.000884000000 | 0.391901510000 | 1 | 64 | 2.67219152855 | 3.44808545210 | knapsack: **507** ; srd: **2079** ; bnb: **1758** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.26945036 | 164.359500000 | 144 | 9452 | 12028 | 4548 | 3 | 2720 | bnb: **1824** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1828** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.364809865085 | 1.06189928247 | 0.40575521 | 0.0000892161851363 | 0.000979200000 | 0.406734410000 | 1 | 64 | 2.64467897977 | 3.39308736060 | knapsack: **552** ; srd: **2172** ; bnb: **1824** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.44162396 | 165.541241379 | 187 | 9756 | 12410 | 4744 | 3 | 2841 | bnb: **1899** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1903** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.355652335906 | 1.04122858826 | 0.42686534 | 0.0000899800463744 | 0.00127160000 | 0.42813694000 | 1 | 64 | 2.61593591906 | 3.33637543804 | knapsack: **568** ; srd: **2277** ; bnb: **1899** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.75045552 | 165.475000000 | 192 | 10038 | 12840 | 4962 | 3 | 2994 | bnb: **1964** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1968** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.345271022198 | 1.01854427786 | 0.44425609 | 0.0000895316586054 | 0.00130560000 | 0.44556169000 | 1 | 64 | 2.58766626360 | 3.28491096185 | knapsack: **587** ; srd: **2411** ; bnb: **1964** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.69001468 | 165.364498375 | 116 | 10076 | 12980 | 5005 | 4 | 3020 | bnb: **1981** ; knapsack: **4** ; Total: **1985** | 0.00050397 | 9.99852353 | 0.342486914556 | 1.01460323562 | 0.44500219 | 0.0000889115264735 | 0.000788800000 | 0.445790990000 | 1 | 64 | 2.59340659341 | 3.28214845562 | knapsack: **610** ; srd: **2414** ; bnb: **1981** |

**GutterGuard:**

| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---| --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 0E-8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0E-66 | 0E-66 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.19118315 | 45.3360000000 | 81 | 267 | 380 | 233 | 1 | 194 | bnb: **39** ; Total: **39** | 0.00053696 | 4.99752527 | 0.744316989639 | 1.41083678304 | 0.00767652 | 0.0000329464377682 | 0.000550800000 | 0.008227320000 | 1 | 13 | 1.63090128755 | 1.32654839704 | srd: **96** ; knapsack: **60** ; gg: **38** ; bnb: **39** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.91117510 | 92.3390000000 | 145 | 594 | 738 | 406 | 1 | 289 | bnb: **117** ; Total: **117** | 0.00053696 | 4.99752527 | 0.572772754671 | 1.25482114672 | 0.02414907 | 0.0000594804679803 | 0.000986000000 | 0.025135070000 | 1 | 13 | 1.81773399015 | 1.57175086399 | srd: **154** ; knapsack: **68** ; gg: **67** ; bnb: **117** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.25921052 | 136.858000000 | 264 | 961 | 1049 | 539 | 1 | 352 | bnb: **187** ; Total: **187** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.593205722131 | 1.43110733215 | 0.03539448 | 0.0000656669387755 | 0.00179520000 | 0.03718968000 | 1 | 13 | 1.94619666048 | 1.71340641122 | srd: **195** ; knapsack: **71** ; gg: **86** ; bnb: **187** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.63001968 | 186.246500000 | 400 | 1316 | 1337 | 684 | 1 | 421 | bnb: **263** ; Total: **263** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.528103610048 | 1.36668779037 | 0.05180447 | 0.0000757375292398 | 0.00272000000 | 0.05452447000 | 1 | 13 | 1.95467836257 | 1.68169676100 | srd: **239** ; knapsack: **75** ; gg: **107** ; bnb: **263** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.25676100 | 236.781200000 | 478 | 1682 | 1673 | 818 | 4 | 469 | bnb: **349** ; Total: **349** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.507136783156 | 1.36086793374 | 0.05760003 | 0.0000704156845966 | 0.00325040000 | 0.06085043000 | 1 | 13 | 2.04523227384 | 1.71155136806 | srd: **270** ; knapsack: **79** ; gg: **120** ; bnb: **349** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 18.32606459 | 259.215333333 | 235 | 2008 | 2313 | 992 | 4 | 540 | bnb: **452** ; Total: **452** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.449414700759 | 1.27807276542 | 0.07674288 | 0.0000773617741935 | 0.00159800000 | 0.07834088000 | 1 | 57 | 2.33165322581 | 3.12114724579 | srd: **317** ; knapsack: **94** ; gg: **129** ; bnb: **452** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.33928804 | 270.739142857 | 435 | 2415 | 2562 | 1085 | 4 | 582 | bnb: **503** ; Total: **503** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.440715144107 | 1.25726101205 | 0.08910250 | 0.0000821221198157 | 0.00295800000 | 0.09206050000 | 1 | 57 | 2.36129032258 | 3.06966682591 | srd: **344** ; knapsack: **96** ; gg: **142** ; bnb: **503** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.40075480 | 292.470500000 | 465 | 2818 | 2967 | 1182 | 4 | 614 | bnb: **568** ; Total: **568** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.422812117508 | 1.22702772558 | 0.09823107 | 0.0000831058121827 | 0.00316200000 | 0.10139307000 | 1 | 57 | 2.51015228426 | 3.29849710121 | srd: **366** ; knapsack: **100** ; gg: **148** ; bnb: **568** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.27080011 | 307.611777778 | 401 | 3213 | 3473 | 1287 | 4 | 661 | bnb: **626** ; Total: **626** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.402197593873 | 1.18692022743 | 0.11536383 | 0.0000896377855478 | 0.00272680000 | 0.11809063000 | 1 | 57 | 2.69852369852 | 3.51988653799 | srd: **390** ; knapsack: **115** ; gg: **156** ; bnb: **626** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.67973146 | 317.316200000 | 361 | 3571 | 3926 | 1429 | 4 | 716 | bnb: **713** ; Total: **713** | 0.00051952 | 8.52092428 | 0.400730531215 | 1.19034383774 | 0.13330505 | 0.0000932855493352 | 0.00245480000 | 0.13575985000 | 1 | 57 | 2.74737578726 | 3.66276237186 | srd: **422** ; knapsack: **121** ; gg: **173** ; bnb: **713** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.90382090 | 316.295454545 | 143 | 3938 | 4576 | 1562 | 4 | 781 | bnb: **781** ; Total: **781** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.422893455723 | 1.26139101177 | 0.14914681 | 0.0000954845134443 | 0.000972400000 | 0.150119210000 | 1 | 122 | 2.92957746479 | 5.22205527742 | srd: **458** ; knapsack: **136** ; gg: **187** ; bnb: **781** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.32323705 | 299.086166667 | 155 | 4278 | 5003 | 1722 | 4 | 880 | bnb: **842** ; Total: **842** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.409300495 | 1.21785928890 | 0.16042659 | 0.0000931629442509 | 0.00105400000 | 0.16148059000 | 1 | 122 | 2.90534262485 | 5.01592877314 | srd: **518** ; knapsack: **152** ; gg: **210** ; bnb: **842** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.79608439 | 290.275538462 | 183 | 4650 | 5406 | 1850 | 6 | 939 | bnb: **911** ; Total: **911** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.390830585378 | 1.18213116698 | 0.16892019 | 0.0000913082108108 | 0.00124440000 | 0.17016459000 | 1 | 122 | 2.92216216216 | 4.90112024321 | srd: **549** ; knapsack: **164** ; gg: **226** ; bnb: **911** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.14437293 | 281.857857143 | 121 | 4990 | 5904 | 2010 | 6 | 1035 | bnb: **975** ; Total: **975** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.370580340435 | 1.13130526808 | 0.18530476 | 0.0000921914228856 | 0.000822800000 | 0.186127560000 | 1 | 122 | 2.93731343284 | 4.79993474593 | srd: **610** ; knapsack: **180** ; gg: **245** ; bnb: **975** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 16.84246229 | 272.930266667 | 187 | 5335 | 6276 | 2165 | 6 | 1128 | bnb: **1037** ; Total: **1037** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.356713032199 | 1.09582258385 | 0.20497049 | 0.0000946745912240 | 0.00127160000 | 0.20624209000 | 1 | 122 | 2.89884526559 | 4.67595251662 | srd: **671** ; knapsack: **184** ; gg: **273** ; bnb: **1037** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.75758447 | 261.686875000 | 67 | 5654 | 6824 | 2346 | 6 | 1237 | bnb: **1109** ; Total: **1109** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.402210045659 | 1.17118492977 | 0.21358329 | 0.0000910414705882 | 0.000455600000 | 0.214038890000 | 1 | 122 | 2.90878090367 | 4.61362028772 | srd: **729** ; knapsack: **201** ; gg: **307** ; bnb: **1109** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.45043956 | 250.511058824 | 112 | 5963 | 7240 | 2537 | 6 | 1389 | bnb: **1148** ; Total: **1148** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.397151808503 | 1.14622444757 | 0.23157155 | 0.0000912777098936 | 0.000761600000 | 0.232333150000 | 1 | 122 | 2.85376428853 | 4.50125931166 | srd: **812** ; knapsack: **231** ; gg: **346** ; bnb: **1148** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.42470665 | 246.235111111 | 181 | 6278 | 7602 | 2722 | 6 | 1505 | bnb: **1217** ; Total: **1217** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.387069949362 | 1.11324394960 | 0.24744925 | 0.0000909071454813 | 0.00123080000 | 0.24868005000 | 1 | 122 | 2.79279941220 | 4.37875743487 | srd: **894** ; knapsack: **232** ; gg: **379** ; bnb: **1217** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.38019463 | 241.924105263 | 189 | 6573 | 8032 | 2927 | 6 | 1648 | bnb: **1279** ; Total: **1279** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.363755682888 | 1.06987653527 | 0.26473102 | 0.0000904444892381 | 0.00128520000 | 0.26601622000 | 1 | 122 | 2.74410659378 | 4.25580444121 | srd: **987** ; knapsack: **254** ; gg: **407** ; bnb: **1279** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 13.22561179 | 237.414200000 | 115 | 6892 | 8536 | 3108 | 6 | 1759 | bnb: **1349** ; Total: **1349** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.352030499119 | 1.04241321302 | 0.27427043 | 0.0000882465990991 | 0.000782000000 | 0.275052430000 | 1 | 122 | 2.74646074646 | 4.24681902837 | srd: **1052** ; knapsack: **280** ; gg: **427** ; bnb: **1349** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.84174729 | 231.206857143 | 52 | 7193 | 9041 | 3307 | 6 | 1900 | bnb: **1407** ; Total: **1407** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.4002381271 | 1.15712415714 | 0.30212058 | 0.0000913579014212 | 0.000353600000 | 0.302474180000 | 1 | 122 | 2.73389779256 | 4.20143977776 | srd: **1126** ; knapsack: **308** ; gg: **466** ; bnb: **1407** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 11.96730220 | 225.229909091 | 83 | 7533 | 9457 | 3467 | 6 | 2007 | bnb: **1460** ; Total: **1460** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.405482504933 | 1.14391728417 | 0.31672266 | 0.0000913535217768 | 0.000564400000 | 0.317287060000 | 1 | 122 | 2.72771848861 | 4.16006091594 | srd: **1190** ; knapsack: **321** ; gg: **496** ; bnb: **1460** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.02139916 | 220.725043478 | 228 | 7877 | 9776 | 3623 | 6 | 2127 | bnb: **1496** ; Total: **1496** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.397838035980 | 1.13058074103 | 0.33136277 | 0.0000914608804858 | 0.00155040000 | 0.33291317000 | 1 | 122 | 2.69831631245 | 4.10031781941 | srd: **1264** ; knapsack: **335** ; gg: **528** ; bnb: **1496** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.17273665 | 219.946083333 | 92 | 8204 | 10341 | 3796 | 6 | 2229 | bnb: **1567** ; Total: **1567** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.398929923585 | 1.13528469548 | 0.34071694 | 0.0000897568335090 | 0.000625600000 | 0.341342540000 | 1 | 122 | 2.72418335090 | 4.20596915583 | srd: **1326** ; knapsack: **350** ; gg: **553** ; bnb: **1567** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 24.25921379 | 216.572800000 | 130 | 8541 | 10744 | 3959 | 6 | 2333 | bnb: **1626** ; Total: **1626** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.397814256125 | 1.13009106135 | 0.35371204 | 0.0000893437837838 | 0.000884000000 | 0.354596040000 | 1 | 122 | 2.71381662036 | 4.16519525334 | srd: **1395** ; knapsack: **369** ; gg: **569** ; bnb: **1626** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.54505133 | 216.240923077 | 281 | 8875 | 11037 | 4125 | 6 | 2443 | bnb: **1682** ; Total: **1682** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.392749041969 | 1.10813302392 | 0.36903366 | 0.0000894627054545 | 0.00191080000 | 0.37094446000 | 1 | 122 | 2.67563636364 | 4.09146166408 | srd: **1468** ; knapsack: **370** ; gg: **605** ; bnb: **1682** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.61220912 | 216.219925926 | 183 | 9156 | 11548 | 4344 | 6 | 2575 | bnb: **1769** ; Total: **1769** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.378791525192 | 1.08196299908 | 0.37713101 | 0.0000868165308471 | 0.00124440000 | 0.37837541000 | 1 | 122 | 2.65837937385 | 4.03287877469 | srd: **1545** ; knapsack: **407** ; gg: **623** ; bnb: **1769** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.28328366 | 215.781000000 | 195 | 9452 | 11966 | 4548 | 6 | 2709 | bnb: **1839** ; Total: **1839** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.366942609332 | 1.06069651677 | 0.39192191 | 0.0000861745624450 | 0.00132600000 | 0.39324791000 | 1 | 122 | 2.63104661390 | 3.96062920879 | srd: **1614** ; knapsack: **451** ; gg: **644** ; bnb: **1839** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.45521655 | 216.925310345 | 242 | 9756 | 12339 | 4744 | 6 | 2825 | bnb: **1919** ; Total: **1919** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.357791264234 | 1.04232841026 | 0.41327275 | 0.0000871148292580 | 0.00164560000 | 0.41491835000 | 1 | 122 | 2.60096964587 | 3.89103196833 | srd: **1694** ; knapsack: **455** ; gg: **676** ; bnb: **1919** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.76463743 | 217.231733333 | 258 | 10038 | 12756 | 4962 | 6 | 2976 | bnb: **1986** ; Total: **1986** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.345997955262 | 1.01807807486 | 0.43007418 | 0.0000866735550181 | 0.00175440000 | 0.43182858000 | 1 | 122 | 2.57073760580 | 3.81854266852 | srd: **1782** ; knapsack: **479** ; gg: **715** ; bnb: **1986** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.70420981 | 217.200119355 | 183 | 10076 | 12895 | 5005 | 6 | 3002 | bnb: **2003** ; Total: **2003** | 0.00051952 | 8.80733267 | 0.343201483068 | 1.01411700773 | 0.43080706 | 0.0000860753366633 | 0.00124440000 | 0.43205146000 | 1 | 122 | 2.57642357642 | 3.81250251882 | srd: **1785** ; knapsack: **501** ; gg: **716** ; bnb: **2003** |

**CoinGrinder:**

| Scenario File | Current Balance | Mean #UTXO | Current #UTXO | #Deposits | #Inputs Spent | #Withdraws | #Uneconomical outputs spent | #Change Created | #Changeless | Min Change Value | Max Change Value | Mean Change Value | Std. Dev. of Change Value | Total Fees | Mean Fees per Withdraw | Cost to Empty (10 sat/vB) | Total Cost | Min Input Size | Max Input Size | Mean Input Size | Std. Dev. of Input Size | Usage |
|  --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---| --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- |--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 0E-8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Total: **0** | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0E-66 | 0E-66 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |  |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.19132132 | 41.5520000000 | 82 | 267 | 377 | 233 | 0 | 192 | bnb: **41** ; Total: **41** | 0.00056094 | 4.99693990 | 0.623982837969 | 1.35047741271 | 0.00753835 | 0.0000323534334764 | 0.000557600000 | 0.008095950000 | 1 | 13 | 1.61802575107 | 1.30813814098 | knapsack: **71** ; bnb: **41** ; srd: **96** ; cg: **25** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.91267006 | 95.9050000000 | 149 | 594 | 736 | 406 | 0 | 291 | bnb: **115** ; Total: **115** | 0.00050005 | 4.99693990 | 0.453797352131 | 1.14213144768 | 0.02265411 | 0.0000557983004926 | 0.00101320000 | 0.02366731000 | 1 | 16 | 1.81280788177 | 1.71109191837 | knapsack: **79** ; bnb: **115** ; srd: **126** ; cg: **86** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.26139099 | 139.078666667 | 272 | 961 | 1042 | 539 | 0 | 353 | bnb: **186** ; Total: **186** | 0.00050005 | 4.99693990 | 0.384915890538 | 1.05102526981 | 0.03321401 | 0.0000616215398887 | 0.00184960000 | 0.03506361000 | 1 | 16 | 1.93320964750 | 1.77319757552 | knapsack: **83** ; bnb: **186** ; srd: **148** ; cg: **122** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.63452421 | 190.328500000 | 445 | 1316 | 1304 | 684 | 0 | 433 | bnb: **251** ; Total: **251** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.372520674758 | 1.12084593688 | 0.04729994 | 0.0000691519590643 | 0.00302600000 | 0.05032594000 | 1 | 16 | 1.90643274854 | 1.72400657664 | knapsack: **86** ; bnb: **251** ; srd: **163** ; cg: **184** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.26152510 | 250.734800000 | 534 | 1682 | 1630 | 818 | 3 | 482 | bnb: **336** ; Total: **336** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.339629060207 | 1.06772167819 | 0.05283593 | 0.0000645916014670 | 0.00363120000 | 0.05646713000 | 1 | 16 | 1.99266503667 | 1.76736219929 | knapsack: **91** ; bnb: **336** ; srd: **182** ; cg: **209** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 18.33155379 | 280.650000000 | 282 | 2008 | 2291 | 992 | 3 | 565 | bnb: **427** ; Total: **427** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.296057988053 | 0.992420318575 | 0.07125368 | 0.0000718283064516 | 0.00191760000 | 0.07317128000 | 1 | 68 | 2.30947580645 | 3.62884382343 | knapsack: **103** ; bnb: **427** ; srd: **211** ; cg: **251** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.34484158 | 295.944000000 | 497 | 2415 | 2533 | 1085 | 3 | 615 | bnb: **470** ; Total: **470** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.301033089561 | 1.00396217082 | 0.08354896 | 0.0000770036497696 | 0.00337960000 | 0.08692856000 | 1 | 68 | 2.33456221198 | 3.54771818942 | knapsack: **106** ; bnb: **470** ; srd: **221** ; cg: **288** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 23.40685064 | 321.172750000 | 522 | 2818 | 2947 | 1182 | 3 | 651 | bnb: **531** ; Total: **531** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.287157889601 | 0.977740948544 | 0.09213523 | 0.0000779485871404 | 0.00354960000 | 0.09568483000 | 1 | 68 | 2.49323181049 | 3.76213203809 | knapsack: **111** ; bnb: **531** ; srd: **230** ; cg: **310** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.27722359 | 339.373555556 | 362 | 3213 | 3554 | 1287 | 3 | 703 | bnb: **584** ; Total: **584** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.271071994011 | 0.943740278451 | 0.10894035 | 0.0000846467365967 | 0.00246160000 | 0.11140195000 | 1 | 68 | 2.76146076146 | 4.27038778818 | knapsack: **124** ; bnb: **584** ; srd: **240** ; cg: **339** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.68972959 | 346.311400000 | 338 | 3571 | 4013 | 1429 | 3 | 780 | bnb: **649** ; Total: **649** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.260421651859 | 0.931312931704 | 0.12330692 | 0.0000862889573128 | 0.00229840000 | 0.12560532000 | 1 | 68 | 2.80825752274 | 4.51603605228 | knapsack: **128** ; bnb: **649** ; srd: **251** ; cg: **401** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.91471596 | 336.786000000 | 128 | 3938 | 4660 | 1562 | 3 | 850 | bnb: **712** ; Total: **712** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.288234402494 | 1.01494195839 | 0.13825175 | 0.0000885094430218 | 0.000870400000 | 0.139122150000 | 1 | 93 | 2.98335467350 | 5.35334241066 | knapsack: **139** ; bnb: **712** ; srd: **279** ; cg: **432** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.33460103 | 315.198000000 | 136 | 4278 | 5099 | 1722 | 3 | 957 | bnb: **765** ; Total: **765** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.297627968892 | 1.00386252310 | 0.14906261 | 0.0000865636527294 | 0.000924800000 | 0.149987410000 | 1 | 93 | 2.96109175377 | 5.16741191808 | knapsack: **156** ; bnb: **765** ; srd: **340** ; cg: **461** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.80829124 | 305.963230769 | 192 | 4650 | 5479 | 1850 | 3 | 1021 | bnb: **828** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **829** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.286942750392 | 0.974262801548 | 0.15671334 | 0.0000847099135135 | 0.00130560000 | 0.15801894000 | 1 | 93 | 2.96162162162 | 5.04089684085 | knapsack: **166** ; bnb: **828** ; srd: **362** ; cg: **494** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.15795622 | 297.497714286 | 128 | 4990 | 5981 | 2010 | 3 | 1119 | bnb: **890** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **891** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.268203352806 | 0.934307055742 | 0.17172147 | 0.0000854335671642 | 0.000870400000 | 0.172591870000 | 1 | 93 | 2.97562189055 | 4.93944442582 | knapsack: **186** ; bnb: **890** ; srd: **387** ; cg: **547** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 16.85821784 | 289.089333333 | 261 | 5335 | 6304 | 2165 | 3 | 1230 | bnb: **934** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **935** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.263149622317 | 0.912339284650 | 0.18921494 | 0.0000873972009238 | 0.00177480000 | 0.19098974000 | 1 | 93 | 2.91177829099 | 4.80652233495 | knapsack: **188** ; bnb: **934** ; srd: **432** ; cg: **611** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.77225916 | 277.434125000 | 52 | 5654 | 6939 | 2346 | 3 | 1337 | bnb: **1008** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1009** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.293228898549 | 0.983960310643 | 0.19890860 | 0.0000847862745098 | 0.000353600000 | 0.199262200000 | 1 | 93 | 2.95780051151 | 4.89544508935 | knapsack: **207** ; bnb: **1008** ; srd: **501** ; cg: **630** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 26.46618688 | 265.148470588 | 111 | 5963 | 7343 | 2537 | 3 | 1491 | bnb: **1045** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1046** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.288366364735 | 0.972127060772 | 0.21582423 | 0.0000850706464328 | 0.000754800000 | 0.216579030000 | 1 | 93 | 2.89436342136 | 4.76496850368 | knapsack: **238** ; bnb: **1045** ; srd: **559** ; cg: **695** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.44127335 | 260.461666667 | 181 | 6278 | 7698 | 2722 | 3 | 1601 | bnb: **1120** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1121** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.272923193210 | 0.940972137535 | 0.23088255 | 0.0000848209221161 | 0.00123080000 | 0.23211335000 | 1 | 93 | 2.82806759735 | 4.62609823410 | knapsack: **239** ; bnb: **1120** ; srd: **593** ; cg: **770** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 19.39774696 | 254.855368421 | 196 | 6573 | 8122 | 2927 | 3 | 1745 | bnb: **1181** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1182** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.258861722653 | 0.904744271874 | 0.24717869 | 0.0000844477929621 | 0.00133280000 | 0.24851149000 | 1 | 93 | 2.77485480014 | 4.49563581622 | knapsack: **262** ; bnb: **1181** ; srd: **659** ; cg: **825** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 13.24350003 | 249.937900000 | 141 | 6892 | 8610 | 3108 | 3 | 1859 | bnb: **1248** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1249** | 0.00050005 | 8.99972093 | 0.250384759333 | 0.881788647427 | 0.25638219 | 0.0000824910521236 | 0.000958800000 | 0.257340990000 | 1 | 93 | 2.77027027027 | 4.42008658560 | knapsack: **293** ; bnb: **1248** ; srd: **716** ; cg: **851** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 12.86220801 | 243.836571429 | 50 | 7193 | 9163 | 3307 | 3 | 2020 | bnb: **1286** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1287** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.308799488535 | 1.05657485993 | 0.28165986 | 0.0000851708073783 | 0.000340000000 | 0.281999860000 | 1 | 93 | 2.77078923496 | 4.65228505935 | knapsack: **324** ; bnb: **1286** ; srd: **775** ; cg: **922** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 11.98903214 | 236.785818182 | 91 | 7533 | 9567 | 3467 | 3 | 2125 | bnb: **1341** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1342** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.306216955144 | 1.04354401456 | 0.29499272 | 0.0000850858725123 | 0.000618800000 | 0.295611520000 | 1 | 93 | 2.75944620710 | 4.58117079281 | knapsack: **337** ; bnb: **1341** ; srd: **818** ; cg: **971** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 27.04496050 | 232.355304348 | 259 | 7877 | 9866 | 3623 | 3 | 2248 | bnb: **1374** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1375** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.304456446530 | 1.03785627472 | 0.30780143 | 0.0000849576124758 | 0.00176120000 | 0.30956263000 | 1 | 93 | 2.72315760420 | 4.50269344134 | knapsack: **353** ; bnb: **1374** ; srd: **878** ; cg: **1018** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 15.19652615 | 232.517333333 | 124 | 8204 | 10416 | 3796 | 3 | 2336 | bnb: **1459** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1460** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.302783163489 | 1.03419376135 | 0.31692744 | 0.0000834898419389 | 0.000843200000 | 0.317770640000 | 1 | 93 | 2.74394099052 | 4.55304298606 | knapsack: **365** ; bnb: **1459** ; srd: **911** ; cg: **1061** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 24.28376881 | 230.030880000 | 157 | 8541 | 10825 | 3959 | 3 | 2441 | bnb: **1517** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1518** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.294409770459 | 1.01446013114 | 0.32915702 | 0.0000831414549129 | 0.00106760000 | 0.33022462000 | 1 | 93 | 2.73427633241 | 4.50485277337 | knapsack: **387** ; bnb: **1517** ; srd: **954** ; cg: **1101** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 20.57080787 | 230.536384615 | 345 | 8875 | 11091 | 4125 | 3 | 2561 | bnb: **1563** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1564** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.285567840449 | 0.993496387579 | 0.34327712 | 0.0000832186957576 | 0.00234600000 | 0.34562312000 | 1 | 93 | 2.68872727273 | 4.42439247168 | knapsack: **391** ; bnb: **1563** ; srd: **994** ; cg: **1177** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.63766153 | 230.698888889 | 177 | 9156 | 11656 | 4344 | 3 | 2677 | bnb: **1666** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1667** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.279953263496 | 0.974355036268 | 0.35167860 | 0.0000809573204420 | 0.00120360000 | 0.35288220000 | 1 | 93 | 2.68324125230 | 4.39627403738 | knapsack: **422** ; bnb: **1666** ; srd: **1064** ; cg: **1192** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 21.30922579 | 229.831785714 | 207 | 9452 | 12063 | 4548 | 3 | 2818 | bnb: **1729** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1730** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.269480742956 | 0.951948003836 | 0.36597978 | 0.0000804704881266 | 0.00140760000 | 0.36738738000 | 1 | 93 | 2.65237467018 | 4.31346530339 | knapsack: **473** ; bnb: **1729** ; srd: **1109** ; cg: **1237** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.48259680 | 231.010275862 | 243 | 9756 | 12445 | 4744 | 3 | 2932 | bnb: **1811** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1812** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.260890875849 | 0.935058393028 | 0.38589250 | 0.0000813432757167 | 0.00165240000 | 0.38754490000 | 1 | 93 | 2.62331365936 | 4.24040039017 | knapsack: **477** ; bnb: **1811** ; srd: **1138** ; cg: **1318** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 17.79298599 | 230.726133333 | 276 | 10038 | 12849 | 4962 | 3 | 3087 | bnb: **1874** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1875** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.251013131079 | 0.912751515855 | 0.40172562 | 0.0000809604232164 | 0.00187680000 | 0.40360242000 | 1 | 93 | 2.58948004837 | 4.16236608733 | knapsack: **501** ; bnb: **1874** ; srd: **1205** ; cg: **1382** |
| bustabit-tiny-hot-wallet_6h-YTD-2023 | 14.73253391 | 230.678403289 | 188 | 10076 | 12998 | 5005 | 3 | 3110 | bnb: **1894** ; knapsack: **1** ; Total: **1895** | 0.00050005 | 9.49925129 | 0.249207142897 | 0.909610046449 | 0.40248296 | 0.0000804161758242 | 0.00127840000 | 0.40376136000 | 1 | 93 | 2.59700299700 | 4.15295477730 | knapsack: **520** ; bnb: **1894** ; srd: **1209** ; cg: **1382** |

-------------------------

murch | 2023-12-10 01:39:35 UTC | #3

Here are Scatter Plots for 

**BHWt 2023-6h master:**

![image|600x371](upload://9TxliLzUUobVjNUaP69uH27KvJU.png)

also see
 [Interactive Sheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSE5nVRzAO1w3uN0hRjeZzNpqE-MxwIIuZo9pu7yUbdokWGni0ie1mQeilW7GRjvy2FlfgKH2noW_I6/pubchart?oid=1320697158&format=interactive)

**BHWt 2023-6h GutterGuard:**

![BHWt 2023-6h GutterGuard|600x371](upload://qHOc856zotmpVTPLyg8zLhTsMdV.png)

also see [Interactive site](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSE5nVRzAO1w3uN0hRjeZzNpqE-MxwIIuZo9pu7yUbdokWGni0ie1mQeilW7GRjvy2FlfgKH2noW_I6/pubchart?oid=1124220351&format=interactive)

**BHWt 2023-6h CoinGrinder:**

![BHWt 2023-6h CoinGrinder|600x371](upload://dgt9FYkRgQqCmmInAwWuNU2UkgN.png)

also see [Interactive site](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSE5nVRzAO1w3uN0hRjeZzNpqE-MxwIIuZo9pu7yUbdokWGni0ie1mQeilW7GRjvy2FlfgKH2noW_I6/pubchart?oid=878438197&format=interactive)

-------------------------

murch | 2023-12-10 02:23:36 UTC | #4

![Total Fees and UTXO count|600x371](upload://tT3cbnAZ56G2lIzC10UnjPSgirR.png)

also see: [interactive sheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vSE5nVRzAO1w3uN0hRjeZzNpqE-MxwIIuZo9pu7yUbdokWGni0ie1mQeilW7GRjvy2FlfgKH2noW_I6/pubchart?oid=182199409&format=interactive)

Bigger image:

![image|690x228](upload://y5Fix0zG2o7ADZU6M0Z79l6wMOt.png)

-------------------------