Genetic Landscape of Joubert syndrome in French Canadians

Joubert syndrome (JBTS) is a primarily autosomal recessive disorder characterized by a distinctive mid-hindbrain/cerebellum malformation, eye movement abnormalities (oculomotor apraxia), irregular breathing, developmental delay, and ataxia. Over the past decade, over 20 causal genes have been identified, all of which have an important role in the structure and function of the primary cilia.  Thus, JBTS joins an expanding category of diseases termed “ciliopathies”.  Though JBTS was first described in affected siblings of a French Canadian (FC) family in 1969, the underlying genesis basis of the disorder was unknown in the overwhelming majority of FC cases at the onset of this doctoral project in 2010.   We identified a total of 43 FC individuals with JBTS from 35 families.  We observed a clustering of the affected families in the Lower Saint-Lawrence region of the province of Quebec, suggesting the presence of a founder effect. The aim of this doctoral project was to characterize the genetic landscape of JBTS in the FC population, and we hypothesized the presence of a founder effect in novel JBTS gene(s).  Therefore, we initially used a homozygosity mapping approach.  However, we did not identify any shared regions of homozygosity amongst affected individuals, suggesting the presence of genetic and/or allelic heterogeneity. We therefore primarily used a whole exome sequencing approach in our JBTS patients, a strategy that is better suited for the study of genetically heterogeneous conditions.   Our work has resulted in the identification of two novel JBTS genes: C5orf42 and TMEM231. In total, we have identified causal mutations in C5orf42 in 14 families (including the original JBTS family described in 1969), and TMEM231 in 2 families.  Though the function and cellular localization of C5orf42 was not known at the time of the publication of our manuscript, our genetic findings combined with subsequent animal and cellular work establish the important role of C5orf42 in ciliary structure and function, particularly at the ciliary transition zone.  TMEM231 had been previously shown to localize to the ciliary transition zone and interact with several JBTS gene products. We also identified deleterious rare variants in one JBTS patient in the ciliary gene CEP104, implicating CEP104 as a strong candidate JBTS gene. We identified causal mutations in 10 JBTS genes, including CC2D2A in 9 families and NPHP1 in 3 families. Definite causal mutations were identified in 32 of 35 families (91% of cases). We documented a complex founder effect in the FC population with multiple recurrent mutations in 4 different genes (C5orf42, CC2D2A, TMEM231, NPHP1).   Prior to the start of this research endeavor, the underlying genetic etiology of Joubert syndrome was unknown in all 35 families.  Now, a definite molecular diagnosis has been identified in 32 families, and a probable molecular diagnosis in the remaining 3. Therefore, our work has resulted in the unraveling of the genetic basis of JBTS in the French-Canadian population using WES, and reveals the presence of a complex founder effect with substantial locus and allelic heterogeneity.

Keyphrases: Cil, Ciliopathie, C5orf42, TMEM231, CEP104, Joubert syndrome, Cilia, Ciliary transition zone, Founder effect, Molar tooth sign, French Canadians, Whole exome sequencing