Le circuit cérébral de la peur : analyse spectrale et imagerie cérébrale en trouble du cauchemar

Nightmares are defined as highly dysphoric dreams that are well-remembered upon awakening, frequently involving threats to survival, security or physical integrity. They are thought to happen most frequently during rapid eye movement sleep. For most people, nightmares are a rare occurrence and are mostly benign. However, research shows that nightmares are linked to psychopathology. Many psychiatric populations have an elevated nightmare frequency compared to the general population. In addition to being associated with psychopathology, nightmares can for example predict the development of post-traumatic stress disorder, be a risk factor for suicide, or diminish emotional regulation capabilities. Therefore, nightmares can be relevant to clinical practice. However, research about their pathophysiology is lacking. More specifically, there is a lack of research on the neural correlates of nightmares.  According to the neurocognitive model of nightmares, nightmares are a breakdown of the normal function of dreams. Dreams are thought to help emotional regulation by combining emotionally negative memories with more neutral memories, thereby extinguishing these negative memories. The function of dreams, and therefore the occurrence of nightmares, is thought to be supported by a limbic-prefrontal circuit comprising medial prefrontal and anterior cingulate cortices, hippocampus, and amygdala.  The aim of this dissertation is to study brain mechanisms involved in nightmares, thereby testing the neurocognitive model of nightmares.  In study 1, we used spectral analysis to compare EEG activity in wake and sleep between 18 frequent nightmare recallers and 15 control participants. The results show higher 2-5Hz activity during wake, non-REM and REM sleep, mainly for central and frontal derivations, for frequent nightmare recallers compared to controls. Differences were most apparent for REM sleep. These results partly replicate past work showing heightened 3-4Hz activity in frequent nightmare recallers compared to controls. It improves upon past work by demonstrating cross-state alterations of EEG activity, thereby supporting the cross-state continuity assumption of the neurocognitive model of nightmares.  In study 2, we used single photon emission tomography to obtain regional cerebral blood flow (an indirect measure of neuronal activity) from 18 frequent nightmare recallers while they were viewing pictures with a negative or neutral emotional valence. Results demonstrate that the severity of nightmares is negatively associated with brain regions included (medial prefrontal and anterior cingulate cortices) and not included (frontal, temporal and insular regions) in the neurocognitive model of nightmares.  In sum, this dissertation offers partial support to the neurocognitive model of nightmares, while also highlighting limits of the model and proposing ideas for future investigations on the neural correlates of nightmares. This dissertation also discusses some clinical implications of the study of the neural correlates of nightmares, most importantly providing a better understanding of nightmare-reducing treatments (pharmacological or non-pharmacological).

Keyphrases: Parasomnies, EEG, Nightmares, Brain imaging, Spectral analysis, Rapid eye movement sleep, Pathophysiology