Le rôle de l’insula dans la prise de décision risquée : apports de l’évaluation clinique suite à une résection focale unilatérale et de la neuroimagerie fonctionnelle 

The insula has long been considered primarily as part of the « visceral brain » because of its role in the treatment of physiological and visceral responses. However, since the advent of functional brain imaging, its involvement in various aspects of neuropsychological functioning has become well established. More and more studies suggest that the insular cortex plays a key role in the circuits responsible for risky decision-making. The somatic marker hypothesis suggests that emotions influence our decisions by means of internal and visceral physiological changes. It has been proposed that the insula participates in risky decision-making by representing the somatic states of the emotionally charged situation and projecting this information to the ventromedian prefrontal cortex, thus constituting a key structure in the circuits responsible for decision. Current theories argue that the insula would be more involved in risk taking when the individual faces a potential loss rather than a gain. However, although several studies support a role in the decision-making process, the specific contribution of the insular cortex remains enigmatic. The studies that make up this thesis aim to better understand how the insula participates in risk taking with neuropsychological tasks of gambling that can simulate decision-making situations of everyday life. The first neurobehavioral study examines the consequences of insular cortex resections on the ability to make decisions about potential risk in drug-refractory epileptic patients who have undergone unilateral resection of this region. Their performance in two gambling tasks is compared to a group of patients who had surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy (sparing the insula) and a group of healthy control. The results highlight an alteration of risk taking in patients with insular resection, which results in difficulty in adjusting their choice according to the expected value (EV) (i.e. the ratio between the magnitude and probabilities of possible outcomes) of the risky option in the loss condition. This study supports the idea that risky decision making involves different neural processes depending on whether the risk involves a potential gain or loss. The second aim of this thesis deals with the specific assessment of the valence, magnitude, probability and EV of the risky option to insula activity during a decision-making process. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging, the brain activity of healthy individuals was recorded as they completed a gambling task. The results of the study suggest a predominant role of the insula in adjusting risky decisions based on EV. In addition, the activity of the insular cortex during decision-making was influenced by the participants' sensitivity to punishment. In sum, the data from this thesis contribute to a better understanding of the specific role of the insula in risky decision-making and lead to a reflection on the neuropsychological evaluation of insular lesions.

Keyphrases: Insula, gambling, expected value, risky decision making, emotions, epilepsy, functional magnetic resonance imaging