Comparison of congenital cardiac surgery techniques through the development of national and international cohorts

Outstanding technical advances have made possible for a growing number of infants with complex heart disease to survive into adulthood. Consequently, more patients are now living long enough to experience late complications related to their underlying pathology or sequelae from past interventions. However, due to the inherent challenges of carrying research in adult congenital heart disease, important knowledge gaps prevent further optimization of care. Waiting on broad linkage of pediatric and adult databases to facilitate access to data, stand-alone multicenter research initiatives remain essential. The current body of work presents two multicenter cohort studies which were designed to help improving the long-term health of patients with complex heart disease through a comparison of common operative techniques.  The first study sought to evaluate the chronic impact of Fontan surgery type on the thromboembolic risk. This North American cohort enrolled 522 patients with univentricular palliation consisting of an atriopulmonary connection (21.4%), lateral tunnel (41.8%) or extracardiac conduit (36.8%). In multivariable analyses stratified by surgical decade and controlling for the time-varying effects of atrial arrhythmias and thromboprophylaxis, extracardiac conduits were independently associated with a lower risk of systemic (hazard ratio [HR]: 0.20 vs. lateral tunnel; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.04-0.97) and combined (HR: 0.34 vs. lateral tunnel; 95% CI: 0.13-0.91) thromboembolic events. These results cast doubt on the widely held notion that extracardiac conduits are potentially more thrombogenic than lateral tunnels by virtue of greater exposure to synthetic material and relative flow restriction through a fixed pathway.  The second study investigated, in patients with repaired tetralogy of Fallot or equivalent disease undergoing a first pulmonary valve implant, the early effectiveness and safety of concomitant tricuspid valve intervention. This pan-Canadian cohort included 542 patients who underwent isolated pulmonary valve replacement (66.8%) or combined pulmonary and tricuspid valve surgery (33.2%). In multivariable analyses, combined surgery was associated with a greater reduction in tricuspid regurgitation grade than isolated pulmonary valve replacement (odds ratio [OR]: 0.44; 95% CI: 0.25-0.77) without an increase in early adverse events (OR: 0.85; 95% CI: 0.46-1.57) or hospitalization time (incidence rate ratio: 1.17; 95% CI: 0.93-1.46). These results strongly question the appropriateness of conservative management of severe tricuspid regurgitation at the time of pulmonary reintervention. Furthermore, they confirm that concomitant tricuspid valve intervention can safely improve moderate insufficiency beyond the effect of right ventricular offloading – a strategy likely worthwhile to adopt in a population of young adults already at high risk of right heart failure.  In conclusion, with higher statistical power than previously published studies, the presented body of work allowed for a valid comparison of common surgical techniques used in congenital cardiac care, which will likely impact current practices. Ultimately, this thesis underlines the importance of fostering collaboration in order to meet the emerging health needs of patients with complex heart disease.

Keyphrases: congenital cardiac surgery, Fontan procedure, thromboembolism, atrial arrhythmia, thromboprophylaxis, tetralogy of Fallot, tricuspid regurgitation, tricuspid valve repair, tricuspid valve replacement