Impact of the ego-dystonic nature of obsessions on treatment outcome in eating disorders

There is a widely held assumption that both ego-dystonicity and ego-syntonicity characterize obsessions in eating disorders (EDs), and these factors are clinically relevant to the conceptualization and treatment of EDs; however, empirical findings on this subject are scarce. Given the recognized overlap between EDs, particularly anorexia and bulimia nervosa (BN), and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) in phenomenology and psychological characteristics, a 24-week cognitive inference-based therapy (IBT) program shown to be effective in treating OCD was adapted to treat EDs. OCD research has suggested that the transformation of intrusive thoughts into obsessions is linked to the degree to which intrusive thoughts threaten core perceptions of the self. The present thesis aims to examine the relationship between ego-dystonicity and EDs.  To do so, we explored the link between the ego-dystonic nature of obsessions in patients suffering from an ED and fear of self concept. We also investigated the relationship between ED symptom severity and ego-dystonicity in obsessions. Moreover, we studied differences between non-clinical and eating-disordered individuals in the presence of ego-dystonic thoughts and extent of fear of self. Finally, we compared the degree of ego-dystonicity in individuals with EDs’ thoughts to those suffering from OCD. Ego-dystonicity in thoughts was measured by the Ego Dystonicity Questionnaire (EDQ) and degree of feared self was measured by the Fear of Self Questionnaire (FSQ) in both a clinical sample (n = 57 women with EDs) and a non-clinical female sample (n = 45). Ego-dystonicity and fear of self were highly correlated in both clinical and non-clinical samples. EDQ scores were not significantly correlated to overall ED symptom severity with the exception of the EDQ Irrationality subscale, which was related strongly to ED compulsion (ritual) severity. Participants suffering from an ED had significantly higher EDQ scores and FSQ scores compared to controls.   Next, a case study describes the application of IBT treatment for a 35-year-old woman diagnosed with BN. ED pathology significantly decreased from pre-IBT to six-month follow-up. This case study highlights the importance of addressing overvalued ideas, fear of self and self-doubt in psychological treatment for EDs via a focus on self-cognitions and reasoning about self.  Furthermore, the final objective of this thesis was to examine the change in (1) ED symptom severity, (2) the degree of ego-dystonicity in obsessions, and (3) fear of self, motivational, mood and anxiety measures from pre-IBT to six-month follow-up. Ego-dystonicity, fear of self, ED symptoms and motivational stage were assessed in 15 women with BN over the course of IBT and at follow-up. Eighty percent of the sample demonstrated a clinically significant reduction in ED symptoms and 53% ceased their compensatory behaviors at six-month follow-up. Clinical implications relevant to the treatment of EDs are discussed.

Keyphrases: Ego-dystonicity, Ego-syntonicity, Eating disorders, Anorexia nervosa, Bulimia nervosa, Obsessive-compulsive disorder, Fear of self, Inference-based therapy, Cognitive therapy