Molecular determinants of congenital hypothyroidism due to thyroid dysgenesis

Congenital hypothyroidism from thyroid dysgenesis (CHTD) is the most common congenital endocrine disorder with an incidence of 1 in 4,000 live births. CHTD includes multiple abnormalities in thyroid gland development. Among them, the most common diagnostic category is thyroid ectopy (~ 50 % of cases). CHTD is frequently associated with a severe deficiency in thyroid hormones (hypothyroidism), which can lead to severe mental retardation if left untreated. The newborn biochemical screening program insures the rapid institution of thyroid hormone replacement therapy. Even with early treatment (on average at 9 d), subtle developmental delay is still be observed in severe cases (i.e., IQ loss of 10 points). Although there have been some reports of familial occurrence (in 2% of the cases), CHTD is mainly considered as a sporadic entity. Furthermore, monozygotic (MZ) twins show a high discordance rate (92%) for thyroid dysgenesis and female predominance is observed in thyroid dysgenesis (especially thyroid ectopy), these two observations being incompatible with simple Mendelian inheritance. In addition, germline mutations in the thyroid related transcription factors NKX2.1, PAX8, FOXE1, and NKX2.5 have been identified in only 3% of sporadic cases and linkage analysis has excluded these genes in some multiplex families with CHTD. Collectively, these data point to the involvement of non-Mendelian mechanisms in the etiology of the majority of cases of thyroid dysgenesis. Among the plausible mechanisms are epigenetic modifications, somatic mutations occurring in the thyroid bud early during embryogenesis, or stochastic developmental events. Hence, we proposed a two-hit model combining germline and somatic (epi)genetic variations that can explain the lack of clear familial transmission of CTHD. In this present thesis, we assessed the role of somatic (epi)genetic variations in the pathogenesis of thyroid dysgenesis via a genome-wide as well as a candidate gene approach. Our genome wide approach revealed that ectopic thyroids show a differential gene expression compared to that of normal thyroids, with enrichment for the Wnt signalling pathway. The Wnt signalling pathway is crucial for cell migration and for the development of several endoderm-derived organs (e.g., pancreas). Moreover, a role of Wnt signalling in thyroid organogenesis was further supported by recent zebrafish studies which showed thyroid abnormalities resulting from the disruption of the Wnt pathway during different steps of organogenesis. Thus, Wnt pathway involvement in the etiology of thyroid ectopy is biologically plausible. An unexpected finding of our genome-wide gene expression analysis of ectopic thyroids was that they express calcitonin similar to normally located (orthotopic) thyroids. Such a finding, although in contradiction with our current knowledge of the embryological development of the thyroid attributes C cell origins to extrathyroidal structures (ultimobrachial bodies) upon fusion with a fully-formed, normally situated gland. Using a candidate gene approach, we were unable to demonstrate any differences in the methylation profile between ectopic and eutopic thyroids, but nevertheless we documented the presence of a differentially methylated region (DMR) between thyroids and leukocytes in the promoter of FOXE1, a gene encoding the only thyroid related transcription factor known to play a crucial role in regulating the migration of the thyroid precursors during development as shown by animal studies. We demonstrated by in vivo and in vitro studies that the methylation status of this DMR is correlated with differential expression of FOXE1 in non-tumoral tissues (thyroids and leukocytes). Knowing that DMRs are hotspots for epi(genetic) variations, its screening among CTHD patients is justifiable in our search for a molecular basis of thyroid dysgenesis, currently underway in a case-control study. The results generated during my graduate studies represent unique and novel mechanisms underlying the pathogenesis of CHTD, the etiology of which is still an enigma. They also paved the way for many future studies that will aid in better understanding both the normal and pathogenic development of the thyroid gland.

Keyphrases: FOXE1, Congenital hypothyroidism, Thyroid dysgenesis, Ectopic thyroid, Somatic variations, Wnt signalling pathway, Copy number variants (CNVs), Calcitonin-producing C cells, Epigenetic regulation, Differentially methylated region (DMR)