Changes in cortical and sub-cortical patterns of activity associated with aging during the performance of a lexical set-shifting task

As the one’s brain is structurally altered by the passage of time, cognition does not have to suffer the same faith, at least not to the same extent. Indeed, age-related compensatory mechanisms allow for some cognitive preservation. The elderly can therefore use new compensatory neuronal networks (neural compensation) or flexible pathways that are less susceptible to disruption (neural reserve) in order to maintain high levels of performance (cognitive reserve) during cognitive tasks. However, how these mechanisms affect cortical and striatal activity during set-shifting as well as during semantic and phonological processing has not been extensively explored.  The purpose of this thesis was therefore to investigate how aging affects patterns of neural activity related to executive processes on the one hand and the use of lexical rules on the other. To this end we used functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) during the performance of a lexical analogue of the Wisconsin Card-Sorting Test. This task has been shown to strongly depend on fronto-striatal activity during set-shifting as well as on regions associated with semantic and phonological processing during semantic and phonological decisions, respectively. Two groups participated in our fMRI protocol: young individuals (18 to 35 years old) and older individuals (55 to 75 years old). Both younger and older individuals revealed significant fronto-striatal loop activity associated with planning and execution of set-shifts. However, while the younger group showed the involvement of a “cognitive loop” (including the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, the caudate nucleus and the thalamus) when instructed that a set-shift would be required on following trial, and the involvement of a “motor loop” (including the posterior prefrontal cortex and the putamen) when the set-shift had to be performed, the older participants showed significant activation of both loops during the execution of the set-shift  (matching periods) only. Young adults tended to present increased activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, the fusiform gyrus, the ventral temporal lobe and the caudate nucleus during semantic decisions and in the posterior Broca’s area, the temporoparietal junction and the motor cortical regions during phonological decisions, older individuals showed increased activity in the lateral prefrontal cortex and motor cortical regions during both semantic and phonological decisions. Furthermore, when semantic and phonological decisions were contrasted with each other, younger individuals showed significant brain activity differences in several regions while older individuals did not. In conclusion, our first study showed an age-related delayed cerebral activation phenomenon during set-shifting (previously observed only in few memory and language tasks). Based on those findings, we conceptualised the Temporal Hypothesis of Compensation (third manuscript) which is the existence of a compensatory mechanism characterised by age-related delayed cerebral activation allowing for cognitive performance to be preserved at the expense of speed processing. Regarding language processing (second study), semantic and phonological routes seem to merge into a single pathway in the elderly; these findings represent most probably neural reserve/compensation mechanisms on which the elderly rely to maintain an adequate level of performance.

Keyphrases: Striatum, Prefrontal cortex, Set-shifting, Semantic, Phonology, Aging, Compensatory mechanisms, Cognitive reserve, fMRI