by ryan29 | 2026-03-12 23:14:08+00:00
I think this is going on my list of things I want to try. I have some feedback, but need to qualify it with a warning that I've barely used any AI beyond simple chat bots. This is going to be the opposite of the feedback that silentsvn gave you, meaning I have no idea what I'm talking about :-)

TLDR; You need a "how to use it" section that explains how to get information in and out of the context. That's assuming I'm not completely misunderstanding the purpose.

I started using Claude Code about a week ago, but my goal is to get something running locally that can help me get things accomplished. I'm skeptical of the claims that AI can do the work for us, but I'm interested in the idea that we can offload a bunch of cognitive load onto it freeing up brain space for the actual problems we're trying to solve. Some kind of memory system is the starting point IMO.

So here's my feedback. I skimmed the repo. You explain what it does and how it does it, but I have no idea what it does or how it does it. I think your explanations are too technical for people to understand why they'd want something like this and the example makes it look like a simple search engine. I think you need more of an explain-it-like-I'm-five approach. I might know enough to be the 5 year old in the conversation, so I'll explain a few issues I've been having and maybe you can tell me if / how your tool helps.

Most of this is in the context of using Claude Code.

I noticed the amnesia problem immediately, but expected it. I figured I'd need to take a couple of days to configure the system to remember things and adhere to my preferences, but now I realize that was wildly optimistic. Regardless, I started making a very naive system that uses markdown files with the goal of getting a better understanding of managing memory and context together. It tries to limit the current context, but it's naive. It walks a hierarchy and dumps things into the context. It's just for me to learn. I'll be happy if it helps me understand enough to pick a good tool that already exists.

The first big problem I hit was that I want what you describe as compounds, mainly chat exports, especially as I'm starting out and just want to "dump" information somewhere. I want all my chat history as I'm learning something. I had a big ah-ha moment when I asked Claude to write our conversation to a markdown file and it told me it couldn't, but offered to output a summary. I'm losing information in real time as I chat. I don't know if it's valuable or not because I don't know enough to know what I don't know.

I've been getting the most value from chatting with the AI to learn and plan things. That involves a lot of ideas, right or wrong, and I want to be able to save and retrieve those chats verbatim so I can get back to the exact same context in the future. I don't know if that's a good or bad idea, but I figure that, if I can retrieve the original context, I can always have the AI summarize it or have it help me create something more well structured once I understand the topic a bit better. I also think there's probably some value in having a future model re-evaluate that old context. For example, in the future I can start it with the current refined context (how I implemented things) and have it walk through all that old context to see if there are any novel ideas that might help to solve existing issues.

I'm assuming your spec documents are followed by the AI when working on the project. Is that right? If so, I wonder if you're underselling that by not giving an ELI5 example of how that works. For me, that's a hard problem to solve. I want a semantic search for rules the model needs to apply but I don't really want it to be semantic because they're rules that must be applied. I need to be able to ask "why isn't the tool following my docker compose spec" and need a deterministic way to answer that. I think your project does that.

Maybe I'm simply lacking knowledge and should be able to understand why I need this kind of tool and, more importantly, how it maps to context management (assuming that's what it does).

I'll give you an analogy, at least that applies to me. Your "how it works" section is like going to driver training and having the instructor start explaining how the car's engine and transmission are built. People like me need it dumbed down; "Push the gas and turn the wheel. It's faster than your bicycle."

Maybe I'm not the target audience yet, but maybe I am. I'm already convinced that AI with good memory management is useful. I'm also unwilling to build that memory using a commercial system like Claude or ChatGPT. It's vendor lock-in on the level of getting a lobotomy if you lose access to that system and I don't think people are doing a good job of assessing that risk.

I'm going to finish building my own crappy memory system and then yours is going to be the first real system I try. Thanks for sharing it.