by jeroenhd | 2025-07-04 16:12:12+00:00
> Modern developers debug through seventeen layers of frameworks to discover that their problem is a missing semicolon in a configuration file generated by a tool that abstracts away another tool that was created to simplify a process that was perfectly straightforward twenty years ago.

But it wasn't straightforward twenty years ago. Maybe it was to you, but it wasn't to others. There's a reason the world moved away from command line interfaces and it's not just to bully the nerds.

Same reason many Americans don't know how to use a clutch, and why chopping down trees for your own house has fallen out of fashion. As society specialises and technology advances, responsibilities are divided.

> The VHS player in my basement could be fixed with a screwdriver and a service manual (OK, sometimes an oscilloscope). Meanwhile, my Wi-Fi router requires a PhD in reverse engineering just to figure out why it won’t connect to the internet. We’ve mistaken complexity for sophistication and abstraction for advancement.

A VHS player is built on top of tons of abstractions. There's a component somewhere in the middle that will take electric pulses and turn them into subtitles you can turn on or off. Just like that WiFi router still has its analog pins you could hook your oscilloscope up to if you want to troubleshoot it.

We have lost service manuals for many electronics indeed, but that's because servicing these devices no longer earns anyone a living. Electronics as complex as VHS players have dropped in price from a month or two's wage for a whole family to the price of eating out. Spending half a year teaching yourself electrical engineering to maintain your TV isn't worth the time investment anymore, unless you're doing it out of personal interest.

You can repair the failed electronics on WiFi routers. You don't need to, though, because the electronics no longer constantly fail like they used to. The skills electrical engineers from the last century have proudly honed just aren't as relevant as they used to be. The "old man yells at cloud" complaint that kids these days don't even know assembly is just as relevant as it was in the days when assembly was commonplace, when kids those days didn't even know how to program spinning drums or knit magnetic core memory without the help of an assembler.

Billions of people drive cars every day. Most of those people have no idea how their car works beyond the ignition, yet the world relies on that technology and it's working just fine. Cars do break down sometimes, and that's when you call in the experts. The people who know the ins and outs of assembly, machine code, and CPU microcode, still exist. The difference between back then and now is that, like cars, you don't need years of education before you can comfortably use the devices anymore.

I too lament the overly complex software ecosystem of today, the simple apps that have grown to hundreds of megabytes, the Javascriptification of our world, but that's not a failure of society. It's what you get when you go for the cost-optimised computing approach that has lead to supercomputers in our pocket rather than the quality-over-features approach that you needed back when people spent more than a year's worth of meals on relatively simple electronic devices.